Thomas Aquinas, on Job 4:7

“Remember, I pray thee, who ever perished being innocent? or when were the just destroyed?”

“After Eliphaz accused Job of impatience taking his opportunity from what Job had said, "Before I eat, I sigh," (3:24), he intends now to accuse him of presumption from the fact that he said he was innocent. To show him that he is not innocent, he takes his argument from the premise of his adversity saying, "Remember, I implore you, who that was innocent has ever perished; or when have the upright been destroyed?" Consider here again that Eliphaz and the other two friends were of the opinion that the misfortunes of this world do not happen to someone except as a punishment for sin and on the other hand prosperity comes as a reward for justice. So according to his opinion, it would not seem fitting that anyone innocent should perish temporally or that anyone who was upright, i.e. just according to virtue, should be destroyed by the loss of temporal glory, which he thought was a reward for justice. He believed this opinion to be so true that even Job could not disagree with it. Yet he thought that Job had, as it were, forgotten the truth which he knew at one time, because his spirit was troubled. So he says, "Remember."”

Imported from an open dataset — not yet checked against the printed edition.