The interpretation timeline

Luke 9:32

How this passage has been read — the sources, oldest to newest.

From the early Church Fathers to now.

21 Patristic witnesses · 4 Orthodox witnesses

View
Patristic before A.D. 750
Origen · c. A.D. 184–253 A.D. 253
“(in Matt. tom. 12.) Now His disciples being unable to bear this, fell down, humbled under the mighty hand of God, greatly afraid since they knew what was said to Moses, No man shall see my face, and lice. Hence it follows, And they feared as they entered into the cloud.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Origen · c. A.D. 184–253 A.D. 253
“(ubi sup.) Now Jesus wishes not those things which relate to His glory to be spoken of before His passion. Hence it follows, And they kept it close. For men would have been offended, especially the multitude, if they saw Him crucified Who had been so glorified.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Basil of Caesarea · c. A.D. 330–379 A.D. 379
“(in Esai. c. 4. 5.) For the obscurity of the Law had passed away; for as smoke is caused by the fire, so the cloud by light; but because a cloud is the sign of calmness, the rest of the future state is signified by the covering of a cloud.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Ambrose of Milan · A.D. 339–397 A.D. 397
“For the incomprehensible brightness of the Divine nature oppresses our bodily senses. For if the sight of the body is unable to contain the sun’s ray when opposite to the eyes which behold it, how can the corruption of our fleshly members endure the glory of God? And perhaps they were oppressed with sleep, that after their rest they might behold the sight of the resurrection. Therefore when they were awake they saw His glory. For no one, except he is watching, sees the glory of Christ. Peter was delighted, and as the allurements of this world enticed him not, was carried away by the glory of the resurrection. Hence it follows, And it came to pass as they departed, &c.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Ambrose of Milan · A.D. 339–397 A.D. 397
“But Peter distinguished not only by earnest feeling, but also by devout deeds, wishing like a zealous workman to build three tabernacles, offers the service of their united labour; for it follows, Let us make three tabernacles, one for thee, &c.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Ambrose of Milan · A.D. 339–397 A.D. 397
“Nor does the condition of man in this corruptible body allow of making a tabernacle to God, whether in the soul or in the body, or in any other place; and although he knew not what he said, yet a service was offered which not by any deliberate forwardness, but its premature devotion, receives in abundance the fruits of piety. For his ignorance was part of his condition, his offer of devotion.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Ambrose of Milan · A.D. 339–397 A.D. 397
“Now observe, that the cloud was not black from the darkness of condensed air, and such as to overcast the sky with a horrible gloom, but a shining cloud, from which we were not moistened with rain, but as the voice of Almighty God came forth the dew of faith was shed upon the hearts of men. For it follows, And there came a voice out of the cloud, saying, This is my beloved Son: hear ye him. Elias was not His Son. Moses was not. But this is the Son whom you see alone.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Ambrose of Milan · A.D. 339–397 A.D. 397
“They then departed, when our Lord’s manifestation had begun. There are three seen at the beginning, one at the end; for faith being made perfect, they are one. Therefore are they also received into the body of Christ, because we also shall be one in Christ Jesus; or perhaps, because the Law and the Prophets came out from the Word.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
John Chrysostom · A.D. 347–407 A.D. 407
“(ubi sup.) Or else Peter heard that it was necessary Christ must die, and on the third day rise again, but he saw around him a very remote and solitary place; he supposed therefore that the place had some great protection. For this reason he said, It is good for us to be here. (Exod. 24:15, 2 Kings 1:12.) Moses, too was present, who entered into the cloud. Elias, who on the mount brought down fire from heaven. The Evangelist then, to indicate the confusion of mind in which he utters this, added, Not knowing what he said.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Augustine of Hippo · A.D. 354–430 A.D. 430
“(de Con. Ev. l. ii. c. 56.) Now in what Luke here says of Moses and Elias, And it came to pass as they departed from him, Peter said unto Jesus, Master, it is good for us to be here, he must not be thought contrary to Matthew and Mark, who have so connected Peter’s suggestion of this, as if Moses and Elias were still speaking with our Lord. For they did not expressly state that Peter said it then, but rather were silent about what Luke added, that as they departed, Peter suggested this to our Lord.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Cyril of Alexandria · A.D. 376–444 A.D. 444
“He knew not what he said, for neither was the time come for the end of the world, or for the Saints’ enjoyment of their promised hope. And when the dispensation was now commencing, how was it fitting that Christ should abandon His love of the world, Who was willing to suffer for it?”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Cyril of Alexandria · A.D. 376–444 A.D. 444
“(in Thes. lib. 12. c. 14.) How then should men suppose Him who is really the Son to be made or created, when God the Father thundered from above, This is my beloved Son! as if He said, Not one of My sons, but He who is truly and by nature My Son, according to whose example the others are adopted, He ordered them then to obey Him, when He added, Hear ye him. And to obey Him more than Moses and Elias, for Christ is the end of the Law and the Prophets. Hence the Evangelist adds significantly, And when the voice was past, Jesus was found alone.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
291 years pass — nothing from this stretch is hosted yet
Bede the Venerable · c. A.D. 672–735 A.D. 735
“And mark, that as when our Lord was baptized in Jordan, so also when He was glorified on the Mount, the mystery of the whole Trinity is declared; for His glory which we confess at baptism, we shall see at the resurrection. Nor in vain does the Holy Spirit appear here in the cloud, there in the form of a dove, seeing that he who now preserves with a simple heart the faith which he receives, shall then in the light of open vision look upon those things which he believed.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
John of Damascus · A.D. 676–749 A.D. 749
“(Orat. de Trans. fig.) It were not good for thee, Peter, that Christ should abide there, for if He had remained, the promise made to thee would never receive its accomplishment. For neither wouldest thou have obtained the keys of the kingdom, nor the tyranny of death been abolished. Seek not bliss before its time, as Adam did to be made a God. The time shall come when thou shalt enjoy the sight without ceasing, and dwell together with Him who is light and life.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
John of Damascus · A.D. 676–749 A.D. 749
“(ubi sup.) But the Lord ordained thee not the builder of tabernacles, but of the universal Church. Thy words have been brought to pass by thy disciples, by thy sheep, in building a tabernacle, not only for Christ, but also for His servants. But Peter said not this deliberately, but through the inspiration of the Spirit revealing things to come, as it follows, not knowing what he said.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
John of Damascus · A.D. 676–749 A.D. 749
“(ubi sup.) This also our Lord commands, since He knew His disciples to be imperfect, seeing that they had not yet received the full measure of the Spirit, lest the hearts of others who had not seen should be prostrated by sorrow, and lest the traitor should be stirred up to a frantic hatred.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
358 years pass — nothing from this stretch is hosted yet
Scholastic c. 1100 – 1500
Theophylact of Ohrid · c. 1055–1107 1107
“While Christ is engaged in prayer, Peter is heavy with sleep, for he was weak, and did what was natural to man; as it is said, But Peter and they that were with him were heavy with sleep. But when they awake, they behold His glory, and the two men with Him; as it follows, And when they were awake, they saw his glory, and the two men, that stood with him.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Theophylact of Ohrid · c. 1055–1107 1107
“But while Peter spake, our Lord builds a tabernacle not made with hands, and enters into it with the Prophets. Hence it is added, While he thus spake there came a cloud and overshadowed them, to shew that He was not inferior to the Father. For as in the Old Testament it was said, the Lord dwelt in the cloud, so now also a cloud received our Lord, not a dark cloud, but bright and shining.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗
Theophylact of Ohrid · c. 1055–1107 1107
“Now those things which began from the Word, end in the Word. For by this he implies that up to a certain time the Law and the Prophets appear, as here Moses and Elias; but afterwards, at their departure, Jesus is alone. For now abideth the Gospel, legal things having passed away.”
Catena Aurea: Gospel of Luke, as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 9:32-36 PD · J. H. Newman (Oxford, 1843) ↗

The reader meets the sources first; chronology and attribution do the work. Provenance is shown on every quotation — solid for hosted public domain, dashed for link-out.