Interpretation & Doctrine

Luke 2:43 Douay-Rheims

And having fulfilled the days, when they returned, the child Jesus remained in Jerusalem; and his parents knew it not.

A.D. 253 – 1871 · 8 witnesses

‹ Luke 2 Read Luke 2 ›

  1. Patristic before A.D. 750

  2. 253

    Origen

    Patristic
    But as when the Jews plotted against Him He escaped from the midst of them, and was not seen; so now it seems that the Child Jesus remained, and His parents knew not where He was. As it follows, And not finding him, they returned to Jerusalem, seeking for him. (John 10:29.)

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 2:42-50

  3. 735

    Bede

    Patristic
    But some one will ask, how was it that the Son of God, brought up by His parents with such care, could be left behind from forgetfulness? To which it is answered, that the custom of the children of Israel while assembling at Jerusalem on the feast days, or returning to their homes, was for the women and men to go separately, and the infants or children to go with either parent indiscriminately. And so both Mary and Joseph each thought in turn that the Child Jesus, whom they saw not with them, was returning with the other parent. Hence it follows, But they, supposing him to have been in the company, &c.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 2:42-50

  4. Reformation c. 1500 – 1650

  5. 1637

    Cornelius a Lapide

    Catholic
    And when they had fulfilled the days , as they returned the child fesus tarried behind in ferusalem. In the Greek, after they had finished , or gone through , the days — namely, of the Passover ; for this feast was kept for seven days, and S. Luke here implies that Mary and Joseph kept all these days at Jerusalem, though they were not bound by the law to remain so long — tarried behind in Jerusalem, there to shed some little ray of His wisdom and Divinity, as though longing to begin the ministry for which His Father had sent Him. For at the age of twelve childhood ends, and youth and perfect judgment begin. So says Bede. And Joseph and his mother knew not of it , because Jesus asked leave of His parents, who were lingering a little in Jerusalem from motives of devotion or business, to visit His relations, as if he were about to go on with them, and, having obtained permission, went to them, but soon withdrew quietly to the Temple — God so directing —in order that His parents, though at other times always solicitous about Him, should be unaware of this, and think that He was in the company of His kinsfolk

    Source Luke 2:43

  6. Post-Reformation c. 1650 – 1900

  7. 1771

    John Gill

    Reformed
    And when they had fulfilled the days,.... The seven days of the fear of unleavened bread, for so many days that feast was observed; and though it was not absolutely necessary, and obligatory upon them to stay all that time at Jerusalem, yet Mary and Joseph seem so to have done, as did the more religious and devout persons: as they returned; at the time when they were going from Jerusalem home again: the child Jesus tarried behind in Jerusalem; being desirous of hearing the discourses of the doctors about the sense of the Scriptures, the meaning of the laws, and the traditions of the elders, and of conversing with them: and Joseph, and his mother, knew not of it; of his intention to tarry longer, nor of his design in so doing: he did not ask leave of them, since his stay was about an affair of his heavenly Father's; and therefore this action of Christ is not to be drawn into an example, or precedent for children, to act without consulting, or asking leave of their parents. They had no notion at all of his staying behind them, nor any suspicion of it; nor did they miss him for a considerable time; which might be owing to the large numbers that went in company together, so that they could not tell but that he was in the crowd, though they did not see him; or to the men and women travelling in separate companies, as is thought; so that Joseph might think he was with Mary, and Mary might conclude he was with Joseph, till they came to the end of their first day's journey, when they came together, and then missed him.

    Source Luke 2:43

  8. 1832

    Adam Clarke

    Methodist
    Had fulfilled the days - Eight days in the whole: one was the passover, and the other seven, the days of unleavened bread. See on Mat 26:2 (note).

    Source Luke 2:43

  9. 1863
  10. 1871

    Jamieson, Fausset & Brown

    Reformed
    as they returned--If the duties of life must give place to worship, worship, in its turn, must give place to them. Jerusalem is good, but Nazareth is good, too; let him who neglects the one, on pretext of attending to the other, ponder this scene. tarried behind . . . Joseph and his mother knew not--Accustomed to the discretion and obedience of the lad [OLSHAUSEN], they might be thrown off their guard.

    Source Luke 2:43

  11. Undated date unknown

  12. Greek Expositor (anonymous)

    Patristic date unknown
    (Metaphrastes vel Geometer.) The feast having been celebrated, while the rest returned, Jesus secretly tarried behind. As it follows, And when they had fulfilled the days, as they returned, the child Jesus tarried behind in Jerusalem; and his parents knew not of it. It is said, When the days were accomplished, because the feast lasted seven days. But the reason of His tarrying behind in secret was, that His parents might not be a hindrance to His carrying on the discussion with the lawyers; or perhaps to avoid appearing to despise his parents by not obeying their commands. He remains therefore secretly, that he might neither be kept away nor be disobedient.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 2:42-50

On Luke 2:42–50

  1. Glossa Ordinaria

    Medieval date unknown
    (ordin.) Or they feared lest Herod who sought Him in His infancy, now that He was advanced to boyhood might find an opportunity of putting Him to death.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 2:42-50

  2. Greek Expositor (anonymous)

    Patristic date unknown
    (Geometer) His indication of wisdom did not exceed the measure of His age, but at the time that with us the powers of discernment are generally perfected, the wisdom of Christ shews itself.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Luke 2:42-50