Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Corporeal nature was brought into being in six days, such that in the beginning, before every day, "God created heaven and earth." Since things flow from the first and most perfect principle, and such a principle is most omnipotent, most wise, and most benevolent: therefore it was necessary that they be brought into being in such a way that in their production the aforesaid threefold nobility and excellence would shine forth. And therefore the divine operation for producing the world-machine was threefold, namely creation, which is appropriately attributed to omnipotence; distinction, which corresponds to wisdom, and adornment, which corresponds to the most generous goodness. And since creation is from nothing, therefore it was in the beginning, before every day, as the foundation of all things and all times.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To intimate the order of nature, Scripture determines, according to what was fitting for God to work: that in the beginning, before the course of time, that threefold nature was brought from non-being into being, when it says: "In the beginning God created heaven and earth" and "the Spirit of God moved over the waters." Where by the name of heaven the luminous nature is intimated; by the name of earth, the opaque; by the name of water, the pervious or transparent, whether subject to contrariety or elevated above contrariety. Where also the eternal Trinity is intimated, namely the Father in the name of God creating, the Son in the name of the beginning, the Holy Spirit in the name of the Spirit of God. And thus is to be understood that which is said: "He who lives forever created all things simultaneously": not because He created them in a chaos of every kind of confusion, as the poets imagined, since He brought forth this threefold nature, the highest in the highest place, the middle in the middle, and the lowest in the lowest: nor indeed into a being of every kind of distinction, since heaven was perfect, and the earth unformed, and the middle nature, as it were holding a middle position, had not yet been brought to perfect distinction.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Three errors are to be guarded against in the sciences, which destroy sacred Scripture and the Christian faith and all wisdom. The error against the cause of being concerns the eternity of the world, namely to posit that the world is eternal. This first error is refuted by what is written: "In the beginning God created heaven and earth." For you hold that God is the cause of all things either in part or in whole. If in part: then you take away from God his primacy of causing. If in whole: then God is the cause of every other thing; therefore he produces it not from himself, not from something else, because nothing else exists; therefore from nothing. Likewise, it follows according to this error that a thing had being and non-being simultaneously, and that being was before non-being; and many other absurdities. Whence it is certain that God created all things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is manifest that a beginning should be made from the One from whom the two greatest Wise Men began: Moses, the originator of wisdom, and John, its consummator. The former said: "In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth," and, in Augustine's opinion, this means the Son. And John said: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God; and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things were made through Him." If, therefore, it is impossible to understand a creature except through that by which it was made, it is necessary that the true Word go before thee.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These, then, are the mysteries concerned with the Tree of Life, that is, Holy Scripture, because it begins with eternity and ends in the direction of eternity. Hence, "in the beginning God created the heavens and the earth"; and at the end, "I saw a new heaven and a new earth." These are the forty-eight boards of the dwelling — twenty on one side, and twenty on the other, and eight in the back — within which is placed the Ark, that is, Christ, containing in Himself "all the treasures of wisdom and of knowledge," upon whom the Cherubim gaze.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To intimate the order of nature, Scripture determines, according to what was fitting for God to work: that in the beginning, before the course of time, that threefold nature was brought from non-being into being, when it says: "In the beginning God created heaven and earth" and "the Spirit of God moved over the waters." Where by the name of heaven the luminous nature is intimated; by the name of earth, the opaque; by the name of water, the pervious or transparent, whether subject to contrariety or elevated above contrariety. Where also the eternal Trinity is intimated, namely the Father in the name of God creating, the Son in the name of the beginning, the Holy Spirit in the name of the Spirit of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the distinction of the bodies of the world is considered according to a threefold mode, therefore it was accomplished over three days. For there is the distinction of luminous nature from transparent and opaque, and this was made on the first day in the division of light from darkness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Things have being in a threefold way, namely in matter or their proper nature, in created intelligence, and in the eternal art; in accordance with which three things Scripture says: "God said: let it be made: He made, and it was made."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now rightly the whole of time, which runs its course according to a threefold law, namely the law implanted within, the law given from without, and the law infused from above, runs through seven ages and is consummated at the end of the sixth; so that the course of the world may correspond to its origin, and the course of the greater world may correspond to the course of life of the lesser world, namely man, for whose sake it was made. For the first age of the world, in which the formation of the world itself took place, the fall of the demons and the confirmation of the Angels, rightly corresponds to the first day, on which light was made and was distinguished from darkness. Now the first age is called infancy, because, just as infancy is entirely erased by forgetfulness, so that first age was consumed by the flood.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the work of virtue, six things are required corresponding to the works of the six days. The first is understood in the work of the first day, when God said: Let there be light: and light was made: this is provident circumspection.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Of the central Person, it is said in Genesis: "The Lord God made to grow out of the ground all kinds of trees pleasant to the sight and good for food, the tree of life also in the midst of the garden." In reference to which Augustine writes that of all the things that were made, it was said: "Let there be, He made it," and so it was--excepting light, of which God said "Let there be light," and there was light--for they were produced first in all eternity from Eternal Art, second in the intelligent creature, and third in the material world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And yet Scriptures say: "God said, 'Let there be light.'" And again, "God said," that is, He begot the Word in whom He disposed all things, and, disposing them, made them. Hence Augustine writes in his Confessions: "Whatever You make, you make through your Word coeternal with You, nor do you make anything by any other mode than by expressing it; and yet You do not eternally make what You eternally express."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is a vision through that understanding which is given by nature, and a vision through that understanding which is lifted up by faith, taught by Scripture, exalted by contemplation, enlightened by prophecy, absorbed by rapture in God. Through the first vision, we understand that to which our intelligence reaches by its own power. This corresponds to the first day on which light was made. Without this light which is given within, a man has nothing, neither faith nor grace nor the illumination of wisdom. For this reason also light was separated from darkness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“God saw that the light was good. God separated the light from the darkness, etc. After every one of the works of the six days, with the exception of the second, it is said: God saw that it was good. And at the end: God saw that all He had made was very good. God is said to see, because He makes us see. The first vision of the soul is by means of understanding naturally given. Hence in the Psalm: The light of Thy countenance, O Lord, is signed upon us. And here all the difficulties of philosophy could be explained. The philosophers have offered nine sciences and promised a tenth: contemplation. But many philosophers, while attempting to avoid the darkness of error, have themselves become involved in major errors. While professing to be wise, they have become fools. Because they boasted of their knowledge, these philosophers have become the likes of Lucifer. With the Egyptians was the densest darkness, but with Your saints was the greatest light. All those who properly followed the Law of Nature, the patriarchs, the prophets, and the philosophers, were the sons of light. Truth is the light of the soul. This light never fails. Indeed, it shines so powerfully upon the soul that this soul cannot possibly believe it to be non-existing, or abstain from expressing it, without an inner contradiction. For if truth does not exist, it is true that truth does not exist: and so something is true. And if something is true, it is true that truth exists. Hence if truth does not exist, truth exists!”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It has been said that truth is intellectual light radiating over intelligence either human or angelical; and that it shines forth in a manner that cannot be stopped, for it cannot be thought of as non-existing. Now a thing may shine forth in three different ways: as the truth of an object, as the truth of an expression, or as proper behavior. As the truth of an object, it consists in conformity of existence with essence; as the truth of an expression, it is conformity of essence with thought; as proper behavior, it is righteous living. And this is clear on the part of the principle which sends forth light, of the subject which receives this light, and of the objective towards which it enlightens. As a cause of being, this light is powerful; as a reason of understanding, this light is clear; as an ordering of life, this light is good. And that is the reason why it is written: God saw that the light was good. As a powerful light, it irradiates for the sake of understanding substances or essences, the quantities and natures of the world; as a clear light, it irradiates for the sake of understanding rational expressions, reasonings and proofs; as a good light, it suffuses the intelligence, or demonstrates matters of propriety, activity, or justice. As a means of understanding propriety, it points to the practice of good habits; as a means of understanding activity, it points to intellectual speculation; as a means of understanding justice, it points to political laws. First, it is necessary that propriety be acquired, then activity investigated, and finally justice exercised. And here is shown how a prelate should behave: being perfect in both action and contemplation, he must accept the laws. Where? On the Mountain of Contemplation, with Moses, so that he may act with propriety and industry, and not as a beast, for a beast cannot go up into the Mountain: a beast that touches the Mountain must be stoned.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“God saw the light that it was good; and He divided the light from the darkness. This passage is quoted to explain the vision of intelligence which is infused by nature. Concerning the fact that it was good, it makes us see, both through scientific consideration and through the contemplation of wisdom. Through scientific consideration, it makes us see in so far as it illumines as light, that is, as the truth of things, the truth of expression, and the truth of behavior. Through the contemplation of wisdom, it makes us see in so far as it illumines by means of the influx of a radiation from the eternal light into the soul. It procures the vision of this same light in itself, as in a mirror; in a separate intelligence, as in a medium somewhat removed; in the eternal light, as in the original subject. It is also written that He divided the light from the darkness; and that some philosophers attacked ideas, as a result of which the threefold understanding of truth was hidden: that is, the truth of eternal art, the truth of divine providence, and the truth of the fall of the angels—which follows if angels only have their perfection from motion. The consequence of this is a threefold blindness: concerning the eternity of the world, the unity of the intellect, and the question of punishment and glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These philosophers had the wings of ostriches, for their affective powers were not cleansed or ordained or straightened: for this can be obtained only through faith. Hence they proposed a false circle of beatitude, second a false sufficiency of merits in the present world, third an eternal soundness of internal powers. In these three instances, they fell into darkness.
But faith, brushing away these obscurities, indicates the disease, its cause, Physician, and medicine; it heals the soul by placing the roots of merits in God who must be satisfied. And so the soul goes forth through faith into assured hope by means of the merits of Christ, and not in a presumptuous fashion. And so faith heals, straightens and ordains: in this manner the soul may be changed, straightened and ordained. The philosophers did not know these roots. Faith alone, then, divides the light from the darkness. Hence, the Apostle says: You were once darkness, but now you are light in the Lord. For faith, that has hope and charity together with good works, heals the soul, and once it has been healed, cleanses and lifts it up and makes it into the likeness of God. Now we are in the true light: not like those who sleep and take the false for the true, an idol for God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"God saw the light that it was good; and He divided the light from the darkness." The passage, "God saw the light," is quoted on account of the first vision of the intelligence, which is infused by nature. It means that God made it possible to see. This has been covered in the two preceding collations by considering the sciences, in that the light shines as the truth of things, the truth of words, and the truth of moral acts. And nine parts were distinguished in the doctrine, of which the three principal are radiations proceeding, according to Augustine, from the decree of the eternal light. It was also established that "God saw," that is, made it possible to see, through wisdom-procuring contemplation, through the enlightenment of the soul seen in itself as in a mirror, seen in the intelligence and in a conveying medium, and in the uncreated light as in its fountainhead, in accordance with the six conditions which this light impresses upon the mind. And in accordance with these, the soul rises up in the said light by means of reasoning, testing, and understanding, as it has been said. And the philosophers — at least the most worthy among them — and the ancients have come to this point: that there exists a beginning and an end and an exemplary reason.
"God divided the light from the darkness" in order that what had been said of the angels could also be said of the philosophers. But why have some of them followed darkness? Because of this: although all could see the first cause as the universal principle and universal end, they had different opinions concerning the means. For some denied that exemplars of things existed in this cause: the leader of these seems to have been Aristotle who, in the beginning and the end of his Metaphysics, and in many other places, strongly condemns the ideas of Plato. Wherefore he says that God knows only Himself, and does not need the knowledge of any other thing, and produces as the desired and loved. But this supposes that He knows nothing, or no particular thing. Therefore Aristotle is the principal assailant of Platonic ideas in his "Ethics" where he says that the supreme good cannot be an Idea. And the reasons he adduces are worthless, and the commentator answers them.
Upon this error, there follows another, that is, that God has neither foreknowledge nor providence, since He does not have within Himself a rational justification of things by which He could know them. They also say that there are no truths concerning the future except that of necessary things. And from this it follows that all things come about either by chance or by necessity. And since it is impossible that things come about by chance, the Arabs conclude to absolute necessity, that is, that these substances that move the globe are the necessary causes of all things. From this it follows that truth is hidden, that is, the truth of government of worldly things in terms of pain and glory. If, indeed, these substances are inerrant movers, nothing is supposed concerning hell or the existence of the devil: neither did Aristotle ever suppose the existence of the devil, nor happiness after this life, as it appears. Here, then, there is a threefold error: a concealment of exemplarity, of divine providence and of world government.
From this follows a threefold blindness or darkness, that is, concerning the eternity of the world, which seems to be Aristotle's thesis according to all the Greek doctors, for instance Gregory of Nyssa, Gregory Nazianzen, the Damascene, Basil, and the commentators of all the Arabs, who say that Aristotle holds this opinion, and his words are seen to mean it. Never will you find that he said that the world had a principle or a beginning: he even argues against Plato who seems to have been the only one to suppose that time began. And this is contrary to the light of truth. From this follows blindness concerning the existence of a single intellect, for if the world is supposed to be eternal, one of these hypotheses must be true: that souls are infinite in number since there would be an infinite number of men; or that the soul is corruptible; or that it is transmitted from body to body; or that there is only one single intellect in all, an error attributed to Aristotle by his commentator. From these two propositions it may be concluded that after this life there is neither happiness nor pain.
These men, then, fell into error and were not separated from darkness: and these are the worst errors. And they are not yet closed by the key of the bottomless pit. These are the obscurities of Egypt: although a great light had been seen in these things through earlier forms of knowledge, yet all light was put out by these errors. And some men, seeing that Aristotle had been so great in other matters and had expressed the truth so well, could not believe that in this he had not said the truth.
But I say that the eternal light is the exemplar of all things, and that the mind, once lifted up as was the mind of others among the noble philosophers of antiquity, is able to reach it. And in the same light, the first thing to come to the mind is the exemplar of the virtues. As Plotinus writes, "it is absurd that the exemplars of other things be in God, and not the exemplars of the virtues."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is the distinction of transparent nature from transparent, and this was made on the second day in the division of waters from waters.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is rightly said that the firmament was made in the midst of the waters, not because the waters above the heavens are fluid, cold, heavy, and corruptible waters, but because they are subtle and incorruptible, pervious and raised above all contrariety, and on this account are of celestial nature and to be placed among the celestial things by reason of the nobility of their form. They are also placed there by reason of power and influence. For since every bodily action in lower things takes its rule, origin, and vigor from celestial nature, and since there are two active qualities, namely the hot and the cold, and some heaven is principally influencing the hot, namely the sidereal heaven by reason of its luminosity: it was fitting that some heaven should influence the cold, and thus the crystalline. And just as the sidereal heaven, although it influences toward heat, is nevertheless not formally hot: so also the heaven that is called watery or crystalline is not essentially cold. Hence what the Saints say, that the waters are placed there to restrain the heat of the higher bodies and other similar things, are to be understood not according to formal predication, but according to efficacy and influence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second age, in which through the ark and the flood the good were saved and the wicked destroyed, corresponds to the second day, on which through the firmament the separation of waters from waters was made. The second age is called childhood; for just as in childhood we begin to speak, so in the second age the distinction of tongues was made.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the work of virtue, six things are required corresponding to the works of the six days. It is necessary that a man set for himself a right end in God; and this is indicated when he says: Let there be a firmament in the midst of the waters. And God called the firmament heaven; because it is necessary that a man be drawn upward, so that he may have a right intention toward God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second vision is understood of the second day, when a firmament was made in the midst, and this firmament is faith which divides the waters. Faith is the origin of wisdom and the origin of knowledge, whether of eternal or of temporal things, in so far as neither knowledge nor wisdom disagrees with faith.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wisdom refers to the understanding of the eternal God, knowledge to the knowing of God made man. Wherefore the firmament was made in the midst of the waters, that is, faith, in order that the soul may know those things that are above the firmament and those that are below it. And such wisdom concerns divine things, and such knowledge, human things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second time corresponds to the second day and to the age of childhood: for then there was made "a firmament in the midst of the waters." At this time, a covenant was made by means of the rainbow, lest man be wiped out by the waters from below; and by means of the ark, lest he perish later in the flood. And as in childhood infants speak and learn to speak, so in the second time tongues were divided. And this extends from Noah to Abraham.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the work of virtue, six things are required corresponding to the works of the six days. It is necessary that a man set for himself a right end in God; and this is indicated when he says: Let there be a firmament in the midst of the waters. And God called the firmament heaven; because it is necessary that a man be drawn upward, so that he may have a right intention toward God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“GOD called the firmament heaven. The loftiness and firmness of faith have been explained. Now we must speak of its splendor. Heaven is called caelum, because engraved (caelatum), that is, sculptured with stars. Genesis explains how splendid is this faith: "Look at the heavens and, if you can, count the stars. So shall your posterity be." The promise of a bodily posterity was made to Abraham, for it is written: "So shall your posterity be." The promise of a spiritual posterity was also made to him, for through faith he was to be the father of a multitude. The flesh of Abraham gave forth offspring and was thus multiplied. All the more so would his spiritual begetting be fruitful: for he begot spiritually through his fruitful mind. Now, the great number of thoughts arising out of faith transcend in clarity the light of the stars.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“GOD called the firmament heaven. It has been said that the scope of faith consists in two things, the extreme of loftiness and the extreme of depth. The scope of faith has been discussed: its firmness now remains to be covered. But if faith is lofty, how can it be certain? For the higher a thing is, the less it is known; and the less it is known, the more doubtful it must necessarily be. Wherefore we should understand that the firmness of this faith is threefold. It consists first in the witness of truth expressed through the uncreated Word; second, in the witness of truth expressed through the incarnate Word; third, in the witness of truth expressed through the inspired Word.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There now follows the work of the second day, which is the second vision of understanding, lifted up by faith: and of this it is not said that God "saw" but that He "called" it. Literally speaking, this heaven is lofty, stable, and visible: it is lofty as regards its position, stable as regards its form, and visible as regards its clarity. It is lofty: hence in Proverbs, "The heaven above and the earth beneath." By the very fact that the heaven is noble, it holds the highest place in the order of the universe, and the earth the lowest. It is also stable as regards its form, for it moves without changing place, but within its place, around a center. Hence in Job: "Do you spread out with Him the firmament of the skies, hard as a brazen mirror?" It is finally visible as regards the multitude of its adornments. Hence, in Job, "His spirit hath adorned the heavens." And, in Ecclesiasticus, "The beauty, the glory of the heavens are the stars, that rise to adorn the heights of God." Because of the latter quality, heaven is called caelum, from caelando, "by engraving," and not "by concealing": by carving, since it is written with the diphthong ae, for it is adorned and so to speak engraved with lights.
Firmament means a vision of faith. For faith makes the soul or intelligence lofty, since it goes beyond every reason and investigation of the mind. It makes it stable, because it excludes doubt and vacillation; it makes it visible, because it displays its multiformed light. And so, the solidity of faith is also called heaven, because it makes understanding lofty through investigation, stable when it establishes the truth, and visible when it fills it with a manifold light. Hence in Daniel: "The wise shall shine brightly like the splendor of the firmament." But no one is wise unless he is taught by God, for "No one comes to the Father but through Me," says the Saviour. And in John: "They all shall be taught of God." No one is taught in matters of faith except through God; and because it comes about through God's voice, it is said: "God called the firmament heaven." It is not said, God saw the firmament, but called it, because the solidity of faith consists rather in belief than in contemplation. For belief is through the ear, because, as the Apostle wrote to the Romans, "faith depends on hearing," and, before that, "with the heart a man believes unto justice."
Now faith consists more precisely in the confession of truth than in the communication of light. Hence, "with the mouth profession of faith is made unto salvation." Therefore in a certain sense faith sees, and in another it does not see. The merit of faith is founded on non-seeing, the light of faith on believing. There exists therefore a firmament-heaven, "the substance of things to be hoped for." And it consists in light, because it is "the evidence of things that are not seen." Wherefore it has both light and clouds. "God called the firmament heaven." In Ecclesiasticus it is written: "The firmament on high is His beauty, the beauty of heaven with its glorious shew." And here, three things are touched upon: loftiness, stability, and beauty. For this vision of faith is lofty, stable and beautiful. This faith is most noble, most solid and most splendid. Many possess it, however, without knowing it, for the face of faith is covered: it wears a kind of dark veil. It turns sinful souls into the most exalted. Hence, in the Acts, "He cleansed their hearts by faith."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is the distinction of transparent nature from opaque, and this was made on the third day in the division of waters from the earth. In these, moreover, the distinction of celestial and elemental things is implicitly given to be understood.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third age, in which Abraham was called, and the synagogue was begun, which was to bear fruit and generate offspring for the worship of God, corresponds to the third day, on which the earth appeared and brought forth green plants. The third age is called adolescence, because, just as the generative power then begins to pass into its act, so then Abraham was called, and circumcision was given to him, and the promise concerning the seed was made.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the work of virtue, six things are required corresponding to the works of the six days. Pure affection is required; and this is understood in the third work, when God divided the land from the waters, that is, secular affections from divine ones.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third vision is understood of the third day, when the waters were gathered together and dry land appeared. The land is Scriptures which have spiritual meanings and refer to angelical and divine hierarchies which have often been marvelously described by the saints: and from these Scriptures spring forth vegetation and the tree of life. But let everyone beware of the tree of inquisitive knowledge.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such is the third vision, of understanding instructed by Scriptures, which is figured in the work of the third day. And as in the work of the days, there is added a second to the first and a third to both of them, so also out of the first and second visions there comes forth a third, and this vision is more noble and greater than the preceding two. And although such adaptation and comparison to the work of the third day may not seem properly fitting since the earth is the lowest of the elements, while the Scriptures are most high, yet the relationship is excellently pointed out: for whatever the heavens contain in any measure of excellence, the earth holds or receives or possesses in some measure of liveliness. Wherefore it receives the influences of heaven and brings forth the most beautiful swarms of beings.
Now this vision is concerned with three things, the spiritual meanings of the senses, the sacramental symbols, and the manifold interpretations that are drawn from them. All of Scriptures may be reduced to these three. The first are offered to our understanding by means of the gathering of the waters, that is, the spiritual meanings.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The sacramental symbols are represented by the swarming of beings on earth, in this passage: "Let the earth bring forth vegetation." The manifold interpretations are signified by the seed, in this passage: "...containing their seed," etc. Who can know the infinity of seeds, when in a single one are contained forests of forests and thence seeds in infinite number? Likewise, out of Scriptures may be drawn an infinite number of interpretations which none but God can comprehend. For as new seeds come forth from plants, so also from Scriptures come forth new interpretations and new meanings, and thereby are Sacred Scriptures distinct from everything else. Hence, in relation to the interpretations yet to be drawn, we may compare to a single drop from the sea all those that have been drawn so far.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Let the earth bring forth vegetation: seed-bearing plants," etc. It has been explained how, by the gathering of waters, spiritual meanings should be understood. Now it remains to explain how the sacramental figures are symbolized by the vegetation of the earth. For it is not without reason that the vegetation of the earth is seen to point to Sacred Scriptures, in the sense that it has a great number of figures that grow and produce a multiplication of thoughts in the soul.
Vegetation on earth is alive, generous, and lovely. Alive, that is, having strength: wherefore it produces the green herb. And by this it is shown that the sacraments of Scripture, which externally seem arid, are yet alive within.
Some people believe that these sacraments and these Scriptures were so composed that the man who wrote them merely placed one sentence after another. It is not so, for Scripture is supremely orderly, and its order is similar to that of nature in the development of vegetation on earth. First there was a fixing of roots; then the production of green foliage; third, a multiplication of fresh flowers; fourth, an abundance of restoring fruit. Likewise, in Scripture there is first a fixing of the roots of virtue, as in the Patriarchs who are in a sense the roots of all that is said in Scripture. Hence in their calling there is a first planting. But later, in the establishment of commands and sacrifices, there is a production of green foliage. Later still, in the manifestation of the prophetical visions, there is a multiplication of flowers. Finally, in the diffusion of spiritual charisms, there is an abundance of restoring fruit. And so, here there was first one Patriarch as a single root, that is, Abraham, then another, Isaac, and a third, Jacob. And he begot twelve patriarchs from whom came the Twelve Tribes. After this plantation there followed the Law as a production of green foliage, that gave shade. And because foliage is not to last forever, but is to be followed by flowers, there followed prophecy with both fragrance and beauty. And because it was fitting that the heavens distil dew, there followed in the fourth place a Fruit in Christ, because Christ is the fruit of the Law and its fulfillment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The earth brought forth vegetation, every kind of seed-bearing plant and all kinds of trees that bear fruit containing their seed," etc. Concerning this vision of the intelligence taught by Scripture, we have said of the spiritual interpretation that it was understood by means of the gathering of waters. Likewise, of the sacramental figure, that it was understood through the germination of the earth. We have spoken also of the theories that were understood both through the seed and through the fruit. For these theories reproduce in a manner related to seed, and they sustain in a manner related to food: wherefore they are understood partly under the aspect of seed and partly under the aspect of the germination of fruits. In terms of seed, they consist in correlations of times, by which times follow one another; in terms of the fruit of a tree they consist also in correlations of times, by which times correspond to one another. In the order of comparison of a tree or a seed to the seed, the times follow one another; in the order of comparison of the germ to the germinating, they correspond to each other.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, this vegetation is lovely. Wherefore Genesis continues: "Each one according to its kind." Even exterior roughness that gives nature a reputation of malformation is yet what makes it most beautiful. Hence the bride says: "I am as dark — but lovely." That is, lovely because dark.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There follows a reference to seeds and fruits. "The earth brought forth vegetation, every kind of seed-bearing plant." As in the gathering of the waters, there was a symbol of the many forms of intelligent beings, and in the germination of the earth, a symbol of the multiplicity of sacramental images, so also in the seeds is shown a kind of infinity in the heavenly theories that are pointed to by these same seeds. For the principal intelligences and figures exist in certain determined numbers, while the theories are almost infinite. For as the reflection of light-rays and images from a mirror comes about in almost infinite ways, so it is from the mirror of Scriptures. Who can know how many are the intermediate angles between the right and the obtuse, between the obtuse and the acute? Hence, as in the seeds there is multiplication to infinity, so also are the theories multiplied. Wherefore in Daniel: "Many shall pass over, and knowledge shall be manifold," for one man and another look differently into the mirror.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The earth brought forth vegetation, every kind of seed-bearing plant and all kinds of trees that bear fruit containing their seed," etc. Concerning this vision of the intelligence taught by Scripture, we have said of the spiritual interpretation that it was understood by means of the gathering of waters. Likewise, of the sacramental figure, that it was understood through the germination of the earth. We have spoken also of the theories that were understood both through the seed and through the fruit. For these theories reproduce in a manner related to seed, and they sustain in a manner related to food: wherefore they are understood partly under the aspect of seed and partly under the aspect of the germination of fruits. In terms of seed, they consist in correlations of times, by which times follow one another; in terms of the fruit of a tree they consist also in correlations of times, by which times correspond to one another. In the order of comparison of a tree or a seed to the seed, the times follow one another; in the order of comparison of the germ to the germinating, they correspond to each other.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since adornment corresponds to distinction, therefore it likewise had to be completed in three days. There is the adornment of luminous nature, and this was accomplished on the fourth day in the formation of the stars, the sun, and the moon.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The heavenly bodies influence terrestrial and elemental things as regards the distinctive signification of times, namely of days, months, and years. For thus Scripture says that they are for signs and times and days and years. They also influence as regards the effective production of things generable and corruptible, namely minerals, plants, sensible creatures, and human bodies. Yet they are signs of times and the governance of operations in such a way that they are not certain signs of future contingent events, nor do they influence free will through the force of constellations, which certain philosophers called fate. The heavenly bodies through light and motion serve for the distinctions of times, namely of the day, according to the light of the sun and the motion of the firmament; of the month, according to the motion of the moon in its oblique circle; of the year, according to the motion of the sun in the same circle; and of the seasons, according to the varied motion, distance and conjunction, ascent and descent, retrogradation and station of the planets, from which arises diversity in the seasons.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth age, in which the kingdom and the priesthood flourished, because King David expanded the divine worship, corresponds to the fourth day, on which the formation of the luminaries and stars was made. The fourth age is called youth, because, just as in youth the age of man flourishes, so in the fourth age the synagogue flourished under kings.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the work of virtue, six things are required corresponding to the works of the six days. Just or right election is required, so that all our works may be done in an orderly manner, according as they ought: and this is indicated in the fourth work, when he says: Let there be luminaries in the firmament of heaven, that is, let our works be ordered.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth vision is understood of the fourth day, when it was said, "Let there be lights," that is, the sun, moon and stars. A man who does not have contemplation cannot yet enjoy the adornment of sun, moon and stars. Contemplation of the super-heavenly hierarchy is represented by the sun, contemplation of the sub-heavenly hierarchy, by the moon, and contemplation of the heavenly hierarchy, by the stars.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth allegory, concerning Sacred Scripture, is shown in Genesis: "God made the two great lights, the smaller light to rule the night," that is, the Old Testament, "and the greater one to rule the day," that is, the New Testament. As the moon receives its light from the sun, so does the Old Testament from the New. And so when the sun stands in the east, and the moon on the opposite side in the west — "Stand still, O sun, at Gabaon, O moon, in the valley of Aialon!" said Josue — then is the Old Testament lighted up: it cannot shine, except by means of the New.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“So let us say of Christ that He is the Tree of Life in the midst of Paradise, who is symbolized in four instances found in the first mystery, beginning with the words: "In the beginning God created," to the words: "The earth was corrupt." He is symbolized by the greater light, the Tree of Life, Adam's marriage, and most of all, the murder of Abel; for Christ was killed by His brothers.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“GOD made the two great lights, etc. It has been said that contemplation consists in the delicious consideration of the heavenly Monarchy, the delicious consideration of the Church Militant, and the delicious consideration of the hierarchized human mind, or of [that mind] ordained in a hierarchical manner. The first is understood through the sun, the second through the moon, and the third through the stars. We should speak first of the sun.
The Eternal Sun, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, is alive, resplendent and warming. The Father is supremely alive, the Son supremely resplendent, and the Holy Spirit supremely warming. The Father is the most lively light, the Son the most beautiful and bright splendor, the Holy Spirit the most ardent heat. As the real sun imparts life, light, and heat to all things, so do these three. Liveliness, splendor, and heat are one sun, and yet they have distinction although they are not three suns. Likewise, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are one God. And as liveliness is resplendent and warming, and splendor is quickening and warming, and heat is quickening and resplendent in this visible sun: so also the Father is in Himself and in the Son and in the Holy Spirit; and the Son is in the Father and in Himself and in the Holy Spirit; and the Holy Spirit is in the Father and in the Son and in Himself, by reason of circumincession which is characterized by identity with distinction.
In this consideration, there is a certain reason of divine exemplarity in relation to all enlightenments. But a certain enlightenment pertains to the Father, as He exists in Himself, another as He exists in the Son, and yet another as He exists in the Holy Spirit. And there is another [enlightenment] that pertains to the Son as He exists in Himself, another as He exists in the Father, and yet another as He exists in the Holy Spirit. And [there is another enlightenment that pertains] to the Holy Spirit as He exists in Himself, another as He exists in the Father, and yet another as He exists in the Son. And it is proper to enlightenments to correspond to this ninefold series. These enlightenments consist in considering the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit as they are in Themselves, and [as such] they are three in number. Other enlightenments [consist in considering] them as related to each other, and they are six in number. And so there are nine. And because of this number six, six times the Lord said "Let there be," and so it was, in the work of the six days.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“GOD made the two great lights, the greater light to rule the day and the smaller one to rule the night, and He made the stars. It has been explained how the soul is hierarchized in relation to the light of the Sun, in that this Sun is alive, shining, and warm. The Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit are the origin of all illuminations or irradiations by reason of excellence, influence, and pre-eminence; and in that the soul is assimilated to the Sun through conformity and by reason of the fullness of the hierarchical disposition, and because of a threefold aspect. And there are three considerations. It is hierarchized also in relation to the Church Militant, in which there is a distinction by reason of processes, of ascents, and of practices, for this is how the Church is seen, and in no other way: in it, there is one head, one body, and one food. Paul speaks much of this, for he was well versed in this consideration. Likewise, the Psalter speaks much of it. And sometimes it speaks in the name of such a person [the Church], and at other times, in the name of another. Hence in the Psalm: "The Lord is King, in splendor robed," it refers to the Church's head and to its four orders. After that, it was explained how the soul is hierarchized in the contemplation of itself according to ascent, descent and renewed ascent. And when the soul has achieved this, some marvelous theories are in existence in it and produce in it. For it has twelve series of nine: three exemplars in the sun, three exemplated in the heavenly hierarchy, three in the sub-heavenly, and three in itself. These are twelve illustrations to which are added twelve considerations, like twelve stars, that is, the bodily natures, etc., so that the soul is in the light at all times, for it cannot remain [statically] in any one, and in the final one, there is repose, that is, in the exemplary reason in the fatherland. These things do not occur simultaneously on the way, but in the fatherland, all things will be seen together at a single glance. But all twelve of these considerations are free, and they have an infinite number of branches, out of which an immense book could be made.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is the adornment of transparent nature, and this was accomplished on the fifth day, on which fish and birds were made from the waters for the adornment of water and air.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fifth age, in which those in exile lived among many peoples and were afflicted, corresponds to the fifth day, on which the formation of fish from the waters was made. The fifth age is called old age, because just as in old age strength diminishes and beauty fades, so also in the exile it happened concerning the priesthood of the Jews.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the work of virtue, six things are required corresponding to the works of the six days. Vigorous prosecution is required, which is signified in the fifth work, when God brought forth living soul in the waters, as swimming creatures, and in the air flying creatures.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fifth vision, which comes about through understanding enlightened by prophecy, is still higher than the preceding ones, in that contingent things are seen infallibly, which comes about through a certain kind of sight looking into the Eternal Mirror. The contingent is changing and varied: if then a prophet sees with infallibility and certainty, everything he sees must be considered within infallible Truth. This vision is understood to refer to the fifth day when the fishes of the waters were made together with the birds, for the soul is carried up to God on the breeze by means of pinions and a great number of feathers.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is the adornment of opaque nature, namely the earth, and this was accomplished on the sixth day, on which beasts were made, and creeping things were made, and also for the consummation of all things human nature was made.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To this vision of rapture corresponds the work of the sixth day: "God said, 'Let us make mankind in Our image and likeness,'" for it is of such great worth that it must "have dominion over the fish of the sea, the birds of the air, and every creature that crawls on earth." The higher a man is lifted up, the humbler he is, as is the case with Paul, who lowered himself through humility when it came to determining the nature of the union.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the New Testament, after the universal scripture and the course of time, Christ was formed, as was man on the sixth day, that He may "have dominion over the fish of the sea," and "the birds of the air." As the Psalm says, "what is man that You should be mindful of him, or the son of man that You should care for him? You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor. You have given him rule over the works of your hands, putting all things under his feet: all sheep and oxen, yes, and the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, the fishes of the sea," etc. And in order that it be understood of Christ, the Apostle says: "You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor." And there follows: "But we do see Him who was made 'a little lower than the angels,' namely, Jesus, crowned with glory and honor because of His having suffered death." Man was created out of a virgin soil that had never received blood, which signifies Christ born of the Virgin; and as Eve was formed out of Adam's side, so also the Church, out of the side of Christ. But since Christ never sinned, how can Adam's transgression correspond to Him? There must be transference from the head to the body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Genesis 1: Let us make man in our image and likeness, and let him have dominion over the fish of the sea, etc.; on which words Augustine says in the nineteenth book of the City of God: "God did not will that rational man, made in the image of God, should have dominion except over irrational creatures"; but it belongs to the dictate of nature that man should preserve the divine institution: therefore it accords with natural right that man should not command man, nor that one should be subject to another by obeying. To which it must be said that in those words Augustine does not intend to exclude subjection and obedience, but coerced servitude, which indeed neither existed nor ought to have existed except through the intervention of the guilt of sin as a disease contrary to nature itself.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The rational soul is a form having being, living, understanding, and exercising freedom. It has in the mind the image of the Trinity according to memory, intelligence, and will. A form that is understanding not only created essence, but also the creative essence, to whose image it was made through memory, understanding, and will. Because the form capable of beatitude is capable of God through memory, understanding, and will: and this is to be in the image of the Trinity on account of unity in essence and trinity in powers: therefore it was necessary that the soul be understanding God and all things, and through this be marked with the image of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The creation of the world is as it were a certain book, in which the fabricating Trinity shines forth, is represented, and is read according to a threefold degree of expression, namely by way of vestige, image, and similitude, such that the character of vestige is found in all creatures, the character of image in intellectual beings alone or rational spirits, the character of similitude in deiform beings alone: from which, as though by certain stairlike degrees, the human intellect is naturally suited to ascend step by step to the supreme principle, which is God. Every creature is compared to Him in a threefold way: either as to a creative principle, or as to a motive object, or as to an indwelling gift. And since a creature cannot have God as its principle without being configured to Him according to unity, truth, and goodness; nor God as its object without apprehending Him through memory, intelligence, and will; nor God as an infused gift without being configured to Him through faith, hope, and charity: hence it is that the first is called a vestige of the Trinity, the second an image, and the third a similitude.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The sixth age, in which Christ was born in human form, who is truly the image of God, corresponds to the sixth day, on which the first man was formed. The sixth age is called decrepitude, because, just as that is the age which is joined with death, yet possessing a great light of wisdom; so the sixth age of the world is terminated with the day of judgment, and in it wisdom flourishes through the teaching of Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the work of virtue, six things are required corresponding to the works of the six days. Charitable formation is required, so that the works may be complete, clothed over with all circumstances, according to what the law of divine charity demands. For charity is the perfective form of all things; and he who has charity has all these six. The sixth work of virtue, therefore, is the formation of charity: which is signified when it says: God made man in his image and likeness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this consideration, moreover, lies the perfection of the mind's illumination, when, as on the sixth day, it sees man made in the image of God. For if an image is an expressive likeness, when our mind contemplates in Christ the Son of God, who is the image of the invisible God by nature, our humanity so wonderfully exalted, so ineffably united, seeing at once in one the first and the last, the highest and the lowest, the circumference and the center, the Alpha and the Omega, the caused and the cause, the Creator and the creature, the book, that is, written within and without: it has now arrived at a certain perfect reality, so that with God it may reach the perfection of its illuminations in the sixth stage, as on the sixth day; nor does anything further remain except the day of rest, in which through the ecstasy of the mind the keenness of the human mind may rest from every work which it had accomplished.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Conjugal chastity is consonant with the law of nature by reason of created nature itself. It accords with the law of nature by reason of created nature, which was formed in the distinction of the sexes, according to that passage of Genesis 1: God created man in His image and likeness; male and female He created them. From this the union of man and woman is natural; and all of this belongs to it according to the state of the law of nature, from which the act and exercise of conjugal chastity itself first draws its origin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A twofold precept was given to man, namely of nature and of discipline; the precept of nature: "Increase and multiply"; the precept of discipline: "Of the tree of knowledge of good and evil thou shalt not eat." A twofold good was prepared for man: one visible, the other invisible; one temporal, the other eternal; one for the flesh, the other for the spirit. Of these goods, God gave one and promised the other, so that one might be possessed freely, and the other sought through merit. And because a good is given in vain unless it is preserved, and is promised in vain unless one attains to it, therefore a twofold precept was given to man: one of nature for preserving the good given, the other of discipline for meriting the good promised.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That which accords with divine precepts is a work of virtue and consonant with the law of God: but the conjugal act is of this kind: therefore it is a work of virtue. The minor is proved: Genesis 1: Increase and multiply, etc.: but this is accomplished through the conjugal act: therefore the conjugal act is a work of virtue.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Conjugal chastity accords with the law of nature by reason of the superadded precept, while the law of nature still remained, according to that passage of Genesis 1: God blessed them and said: Increase and multiply and fill the earth: which indeed is not done legitimately except through the exercise of conjugal chastity. From this it is moral; and all of this belongs to it according to the state of the law of nature, from which the act and exercise of conjugal chastity itself first draws its origin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against the vowing of widowed continence it is objected: everything that is repugnant to a divine precept is to be condemned; but to vow continence is repugnant to a divine precept, namely Genesis 1: Increase and multiply: therefore continence is not to be vowed.
To this it must be said that the precept of nature is twofold: one which regards the common state; another which regards the state of a singular person. The first does not bind anyone per se and determinately, so long as there is another who fulfills or can fulfill that command. And since there are many who devote themselves to carnal generation, as much as suffices for nature, the observance of continence in a singular person is not repugnant to that precept. For that precept does not descend to any determinate person, except in a case in which nature could not subsist unless that person devoted himself to generation, as was the case with Adam, or with the sons of Noah, to whom it was expressly said: Increase and multiply and fill the earth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On the seventh day God rested, not from labor nor from work, since He works even until now, but from the establishment of new species: because He had made all things either in likeness, as those things which are propagated, or in seminal reason, as those things which are brought into being by other modes. To the six days of works there is added a seventh of rest, which day is not written as having an evening — not because that day did not have a succeeding night, but to prefigure the rest of souls, which shall never have an end.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The seventh age, which is the rest of souls having no end, corresponds to the seventh day, on which God rested from all the work that He had done. And thus these seven ages are distinguished on account of the notable events that occurred at their beginnings, by reason of which they correspond to the days of the formation of the world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since, moreover, each of the aforesaid modes is doubled, inasmuch as it happens that one considers God as the Alpha and the Omega, or inasmuch as it happens that one sees God in each of the aforesaid modes as through a mirror and as in a mirror, or because each of these considerations must be mingled with the other conjoined to it and must be considered in its purity: hence it is necessary that these three principal stages ascend to the number six, so that, just as God completed the whole world in six days and rested on the seventh, so the lesser world may be led in most orderly fashion through six stages of successive illuminations to the repose of contemplation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this consideration, moreover, lies the perfection of the mind's illumination, when, as on the sixth day, it sees man made in the image of God. For if an image is an expressive likeness, when our mind contemplates in Christ the Son of God, who is the image of the invisible God by nature, our humanity so wonderfully exalted, so ineffably united, seeing at once in one the first and the last, the highest and the lowest, the circumference and the center, the Alpha and the Omega, the caused and the cause, the Creator and the creature, the book, that is, written within and without: it has now arrived at a certain perfect reality, so that with God it may reach the perfection of its illuminations in the sixth stage, as on the sixth day; nor does anything further remain except the day of rest, in which through the ecstasy of the mind the keenness of the human mind may rest from every work which it had accomplished.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These six considerations having therefore been traversed, as if they were the six steps of the throne of the true Solomon, by which one arrives at peace, where the true peaceful one rests in a peaceful mind as in an interior Jerusalem; and as if also the six wings of the Cherub, by which the mind of the true contemplative, filled with the illumination of supernal wisdom, may be borne upward; and as if also the first six days, in which the mind must be exercised, so that it may at last arrive at the sabbath of rest; after our mind has contemplated God outside itself through vestiges and in the vestiges, within itself through the image and in the image, above itself through the similitude of the divine light shining upon us and in that light itself, insofar as is possible according to the state of wayfaring and the exercise of our mind; when at last in the sixth step it has arrived at this point, that it contemplates in the first and highest principle and the mediator of God and men, Jesus Christ, those things whose likenesses can in no way be found in creatures, and which exceed all keenness of the human intellect: it remains that, in contemplating these things, it should transcend and pass beyond not only this sensible world, but also itself; in which passing over, Christ is the way and the door, Christ is the ladder and the vehicle, as it were the mercy seat placed upon the ark of God and the mystery hidden from the ages.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By means of diffusion, as of brightness out of light, of heat out of fire, of a river out of its headspring, of rain out of a full or humid cloud. In the first diffusion, equality is lacking, for brightness is not the same as light. In the second, closeness is lacking, for heat is not close to fire, since it is the principle neither of its form nor of its origin, but is merely an accident. In the third, simultaneity is lacking, for a spring diffuses itself by flowing, and not all at once. In the fourth, fullness is lacking, for not all of the rain is drawn out of a cloud, but only successive drops. Now, join these four conditions to a single diffusion, one of splendor having equality, of heat having closeness and substantiality, of a river or fountain having simultaneity, and of rain having fullness: and in this way, you will have a trace of the eternal generation.
Hence, the Son is sometimes compared to brightness: "Being the brightness of His glory," etc.; at other times, to a flame, as in Moses' bush which represented the person of the Son; or again, as a river or spring: "But a spring rose out of the earth. A river rose in Eden." Again, He is sometimes compared to rain: "For just as from the heavens the rain and snow come down and do not return there till they have watered the earth," etc. And, later: "So shall my word be that goes forth from my mouth," that is, from the Father's heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The body of the first man was so fashioned and from the slime of the earth formed, that nevertheless it was subject to the soul and in its own way proportionate, proportionate, I say, with respect to an equal temperament, with respect to a most beautiful and manifold organization, and with respect to uprightness of stature. In order that the power of God might be manifested in man, He made him from natures most greatly distant, conjoined into one person and nature — such as are the body and the soul, of which one is a corporeal substance, while the other, namely the soul, is a spiritual and incorporeal substance, which in the genus of substance are most greatly distant. In order that the wisdom of God might be manifested therein, He made such a body that it would have proportion in its own way to the soul. In order that it might be conformed to the vivifying soul, it had an equal temperament, not from weight or mass, but from the equality of natural justice, which disposes toward the most noble mode of life. In order that it might be conformed to the soul as moving through the manifold variety of powers, it had a manifold variety of organs with the highest beauty and artfulness and flexibility; as is evident in the face and in the hand, which is the "instrument of instruments." In order that it might be conformed to the soul as tending upward toward heaven, it had uprightness of stature and the head raised upward, so that bodily uprightness might bear witness to mental uprightness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“So that the goodness and benevolence of God might be manifested in man, He made man without any stain or fault and without any punishment or misery. For since the First Principle is at once most good and most just; because most good, He ought not to have made man other than good, and thereby innocent and upright; because most just, He ought not to have inflicted punishment on one who had absolutely no sin: and thereby He constituted for that rational soul such a body as would be so obedient to it that there would be in it no struggle of rebellion, no proneness to concupiscence, no diminution of vigor, no corruption of death: so also it would be so conformed to the soul that, just as the soul was innocent and yet could fall into fault, so the body would be impassible and yet could fall into punishment; and therefore it was able not to die, and it was able to die; it was able to have sufficiency, and it was able to have want; it was able to obey the soul, and it was also able to have rebellion and struggle against it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the New Testament, after the universal scripture and the course of time, Christ was formed, as was man on the sixth day, that He may "have dominion over the fish of the sea," and "the birds of the air." As the Psalm says, "what is man that You should be mindful of him, or the son of man that You should care for him? You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor. You have given him rule over the works of your hands, putting all things under his feet: all sheep and oxen, yes, and the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, the fishes of the sea," etc. And in order that it be understood of Christ, the Apostle says: "You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor." And there follows: "But we do see Him who was made 'a little lower than the angels,' namely, Jesus, crowned with glory and honor because of His having suffered death." Man was created out of a virgin soil that had never received blood, which signifies Christ born of the Virgin; and as Eve was formed out of Adam's side, so also the Church, out of the side of Christ. But since Christ never sinned, how can Adam's transgression correspond to Him? There must be transference from the head to the body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It should be noted that as a fruit delights both sight and taste, it delights the sense of sight mostly by its excellence and beauty, but the sense of taste, by its sweetness and flavor. Likewise, these theories sustain the intellect by their beauty, and the affective dispositions by their sweetness. This is what Scripture suggests when it says: The Lord God planted a garden in Eden, to the east, and He put there the man He had formed, etc. This is said as a recapitulation on the seventh day, since the planting was done on the third day.
There follows: The Lord God made to grow out of the ground all kinds of trees pleasant to the sight and good for food, the tree of life also in the midst of the garden, and the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, so that it would sustain the intellect by its beauty and the affective dispositions by its sweetness. But consummation was to come about in the tree of life, provided caution was exercised in regard to the tree of knowledge. The soil, therefore, is Scripture which brings forth all kinds of trees pleasant to the sight, as regards the intellect, and good for food as regards the affective dispositions, that is, the manifold theories both delighting and sustaining. In the heavenly paradise, there is no planting, except of eternal reasons, and although there is sustainment in the fact of the predestination of all the saints, I will rejoice rather over my own. And this is what the Lord suggests: "Rejoice rather in this, that your names are written in heaven." Paul could speak of the heavenly paradise, because he was caught up to the third heaven. We do not know, but we speak of the earthly paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The tree of life was also given for continual nourishment, and finally for perfect transformation through perpetual immortality. There would be a consumption of nutrimental moisture through the action of heat: there would also nonetheless be a restoration through the nourishment of the trees of paradise, restored through the tree of life, that is, with the radical moisture preserved: which tree indeed had this virtue, on account of which, as Augustine says, it was not only for food but also as a Sacrament. The incorruption and immortality of Adam's body came principally from the soul as from that which contains and influences, from the body's good and balanced constitution as from that which disposes and receives, from the tree of life as from that which vivifies and assists, and from the governance of divine providence as from that which conserves inwardly and protects outwardly.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Of this central Person, it is said in Genesis: "The Lord God made to grow out of the ground all kinds of trees pleasant to the sight and good for food, the tree of life also in the midst of the garden." In reference to which Augustine writes that of all the things that were made, it was said: "Let there be, He made it," and so it was--excepting light, of which God said "Let there be light," and there was light--for they were produced first in all eternity from Eternal Art, second in the intelligent creature, and third in the material world.
The Word expresses the Father and the things He made, and principally leads us to union with the Father who brings all things together; and in this regard He is the Tree of Life, for by this means we return to the very fountain of life and are revived in it. But if we stoop to a knowledge of things acquired by experimenting them, investigating beyond what is conceded to us, we fall from true contemplation and taste of the forbidden tree of the knowledge of good and evil, as did Lucifer. For if Lucifer, in contemplating this Truth, had been led back from the knowledge of creatures to the unity of the Father, he would have turned dusk into dawn and would have enjoyed daylight. But because he fell for the love and desire of his own excellence, he lost the day. And Adam did the same. Now, this Center is one that produces knowledge, it is the Truth, that is, the Tree of Life, while the other truth is an occasion of death, when a man falls for the love of created beauty.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third mode of generation is by means of propagation, and this in a fourfold way: as of a growth coming from a seed, a tree from a root, a conceived offspring from the belly or womb of the mother, or children from a begetting father. In the first mode of generation, formal beauty is lacking, for in the seed the form is vague and hidden. It is not so in the case of the Son. In the second, conformity is lacking, for although there is a single root, it is different in shape from the branches even though they produce a single tree. In the third, actuality is lacking, for although the mother is in a certain sense the active principle of the offspring, yet she is much more of a passive principle. In the fourth, eternal coexistence is lacking.
Now, take away these defects and suppose first formal beauty. In this sense, there is Isaiah: "The branch of the Lord will be luster and glory, and the fruit of the earth will be honor and splendor." Second, suppose conformity: The Son conforms to the Father to the point that He is "the tree of life... in the midst of the garden." Hence, in Proverbs: "She is a tree of life to those who grasp her." Third, suppose actuality: in this sense, you have the Psalm: "With Thee is the principality in the day of Thy strength, in the brightness of the saints: from the womb before the day star I begot Thee. From the womb," says the Psalmist, which is in relation to the warmth of the Father's bosom, from which He does not withdraw. Fourth, suppose eternal coexistence. In this sense, there is the Psalm: "This day I have begotten You," that is in eternity, or in My eternal today.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The Lord God planted a garden in Eden, to the East, and He put there the man He had formed. The Lord God made to grow out of the ground all kinds of trees pleasant to the sight and good for food, the tree of life also in the midst of the garden, and the tree of the knowledge of good and evil." The trees pleasant and good represent the sacraments of Scripture which have great beauty. Yet they are not seen as beautiful except through the conformity of the symbol with the thing represented. For these trees are beautiful because ordained.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is true that in this regard there comes the danger of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, so that, after dismissing the tree of life by reason of the sweetness of emotions, the soul may wander around other sciences and go so far that it can no longer come back but is excluded from the delights of paradise and loses the flavor of the tree of life. To eat of the tree of life by means of these enlightenments is to be sustained, so that a man seeks nothing but the intelligence of truth, the mood of piety, and the enjoyment of sweetness, that is, the solace of contemplation. But when a man forgets these things and delights in the pursuit of inquisitiveness, he only wants to know; and out of this is born the arrogance of vanity when he looks down upon other men. And upon this there follows the conflict of lawsuits, because he considers himself dishonored when someone stands up to him: and he is always ready to fight any opponent. And in such a way true life is taken away from man, as occurred with Adam, or rather, with the woman who was inquisitive and wanted to be like God. Therefore, they made themselves coverings and blamed another for their sin, Adam blaming God for having given him such a wife, and the woman blaming the serpent. Hence these enlightenments must enter the affective dispositions in order that the intellect be straightened.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And so, progressing little by little, Scripture explains how the Antichrist will be, first, most filthy, etc. Hence, next to the tree of life was the tree of the knowledge of good and evil: for the latter promised good and rendered evil, wherefore it will turn into a serpent, a dragon and a beast. In all these mysteries, there is some relationship with the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit, for the Trinity must shine forth mostly through their works.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It should be noted that as a fruit delights both sight and taste, it delights the sense of sight mostly by its excellence and beauty, but the sense of taste, by its sweetness and flavor. Likewise, these theories sustain the intellect by their beauty, and the affective dispositions by their sweetness. This is what Scripture suggests when it says: The Lord God planted a garden in Eden, to the east, and He put there the man He had formed, etc. This is said as a recapitulation on the seventh day, since the planting was done on the third day.
There follows: The Lord God made to grow out of the ground all kinds of trees pleasant to the sight and good for food, the tree of life also in the midst of the garden, and the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, so that it would sustain the intellect by its beauty and the affective dispositions by its sweetness. But consummation was to come about in the tree of life, provided caution was exercised in regard to the tree of knowledge. The soil, therefore, is Scripture which brings forth all kinds of trees pleasant to the sight, as regards the intellect, and good for food as regards the affective dispositions, that is, the manifold theories both delighting and sustaining. In the heavenly paradise, there is no planting, except of eternal reasons, and although there is sustainment in the fact of the predestination of all the saints, I will rejoice rather over my own. And this is what the Lord suggests: "Rejoice rather in this, that your names are written in heaven." Paul could speak of the heavenly paradise, because he was caught up to the third heaven. We do not know, but we speak of the earthly paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because outside the unity of faith and charity, which makes us children and members of the Church, no one can be saved: therefore, if the Sacraments are received outside her, they are not received unto salvation, although they are true Sacraments; but they can become useful if one returns to holy mother Church.
Whence Augustine against the Donatists writes: "The Church, compared to paradise, shows us that people can indeed receive her baptism even outside, but that no one can either obtain or retain the salvation of blessedness outside her. For the rivers from the fountain of paradise, as Scripture testifies, also flowed abundantly outward: for they are mentioned by name, and through which lands they flow, and that they are situated outside paradise, is known to all; nor yet in Mesopotamia or in Egypt, where those rivers reached, is there the happiness of life that is spoken of in paradise. Thus it happens that, although the water of paradise is outside paradise, blessedness nevertheless is not found except within paradise. So therefore the baptism of the Church can exist outside the Church, but the gift of the blessed life is found only within the Church."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The four cardinal virtues are symbolized by the four rivers of paradise, in so far as they are originated by faith. A river stands for the grace of the Holy Spirit poured out into these four virtues: Phison corresponds to temperance, Gehon to prudence, Tigris to fortitude, and Euphrates to justice. Phison represents the rational power, Gehon the concupiscible, Tigris the irascible, and Euphrates the whole soul.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By means of diffusion, as of brightness out of light, of heat out of fire, of a river out of its headspring, of rain out of a full or humid cloud. In the first diffusion, equality is lacking, for brightness is not the same as light. In the second, closeness is lacking, for heat is not close to fire, since it is the principle neither of its form nor of its origin, but is merely an accident. In the third, simultaneity is lacking, for a spring diffuses itself by flowing, and not all at once. In the fourth, fullness is lacking, for not all of the rain is drawn out of a cloud, but only successive drops. Now, join these four conditions to a single diffusion, one of splendor having equality, of heat having closeness and substantiality, of a river or fountain having simultaneity, and of rain having fullness: and in this way, you will have a trace of the eternal generation.
Hence, the Son is sometimes compared to brightness: "Being the brightness of His glory," etc.; at other times, to a flame, as in Moses' bush which represented the person of the Son; or again, as a river or spring: "But a spring rose out of the earth. A river rose in Eden." Again, He is sometimes compared to rain: "For just as from the heavens the rain and snow come down and do not return there till they have watered the earth," etc. And, later: "So shall my word be that goes forth from my mouth," that is, from the Father's heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It should be noted that the Church was placed in paradise, like the first man, "to till it," in such a way that no one would say "that anything he possessed" was "his own." For it began in a state of great perfection that is observed today in the religious life, for the love of Christ was still recent, and in those days "a large number also of the priests accepted the faith." This Church, meaning the one that began with the Jews, because they were converted at one time by the three thousand, and at another, by the five thousand, possessed the "tree of life," that is, faith, because "My just one lives by faith." It also had the "tree of knowledge," that is, the Law, which remained with them for seeing and reading, and not for eating. Much more: for "the day you eat of it, you must die." And so you may see the tree of knowledge, but not eat of it, or else you would destroy what Christ had done; and death would necessarily come in, for "the letter kills." Hence Paul says: "I, Paul, tell you that if you be circumcised, Christ will be of no advantage to you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“According to others, time is divided into five: and this is established by Christ who referred to five summonses: "The kingdom of heaven is like a householder who went out early in the morning to hire laborers for his vineyard." The five summonses were in the morning, and at the third, sixth, ninth and eleventh hours. The morning saw the beginning of the creature, for God placed man in Paradise and commanded him "to till it and to keep it." But man had as yet neither mattock nor hoe: but he was able to make them out of the trees that were obedient to him. The second summons was under the scourge, until Noah who preached that man be more careful; the third, under Abraham who was a worshiper of God and a builder of altars, and it lasted until Moses; the fourth, under Moses through the Law and the prodigies, and it lasted until Christ; the fifth, under Christ and through Christ by means of penance—and He called all men to it and also to the wedding feast.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is fitting to work within sacred Scripture and to train the mind. As Seneca says, "Many have I found who trained their body, but few their mind." In Genesis it is said that "the Lord God took the man and placed him in the garden of Eden to till it and to keep it." Such a training is a spiritual disposition towards devotedness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For according to the first institution of nature, man was created fit for the repose of contemplation, and therefore God placed him in a paradise of delights. But turning away from the true light toward a changeable good, he was bent over by his own fault, and his entire race by original sin, which infected human nature in a twofold manner, namely the mind with ignorance, and the flesh with concupiscence; so that man, blinded and bent over, sits in darkness and does not see the light of heaven, unless grace with justice comes to his aid against concupiscence, and knowledge with wisdom against ignorance.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Genesis 2: God placed man in paradise, that he might work: likewise, in chapter 3 of the same it was said to man sinning: In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat thy bread, etc. Therefore the precept concerning labor regards man according to nature as instituted and according to nature as fallen, therefore according to all times; but it especially regards the man who is able by himself and cannot supply through another; but such is the able-bodied poor man: therefore such a one is bound to labor manually.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A twofold precept was given to man, namely of nature and of discipline; the precept of discipline: "Of the tree of knowledge of good and evil thou shalt not eat." Obedience is pure when a precept obliges of itself alone, not from any other cause; and such is called a precept of discipline, because through it one learns how great is the virtue of obedience, which by its merit leads to heaven, but by its contrary casts one down into hell. Therefore that commandment was not given to man on account of any need that God had for human service, but to provide a way of meriting the crown through pure and voluntary obedience.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is said in Genesis: "Of every tree that is in paradise, you shall eat; but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in whatever hour you eat of it, you shall die the death." Adam with his wife contracted the vice of curiosity, when the devil said to them: "You shall be as gods, knowing good and evil": he also contracted the vice of carnality, when he ate of the fruit: he also contracted the vice of vanity, when he wished to be as gods.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It should be noted that the Church was placed in paradise, like the first man, "to till it," in such a way that no one would say "that anything he possessed" was "his own." For it began in a state of great perfection that is observed today in the religious life, for the love of Christ was still recent, and in those days "a large number also of the priests accepted the faith." This Church, meaning the one that began with the Jews, because they were converted at one time by the three thousand, and at another, by the five thousand, possessed the "tree of life," that is, faith, because "My just one lives by faith." It also had the "tree of knowledge," that is, the Law, which remained with them for seeing and reading, and not for eating. Much more: for "the day you eat of it, you must die." And so you may see the tree of knowledge, but not eat of it, or else you would destroy what Christ had done; and death would necessarily come in, for "the letter kills." Hence Paul says: "I, Paul, tell you that if you be circumcised, Christ will be of no advantage to you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In Genesis: "The Lord cast a deep sleep upon Adam, and when he had fallen asleep, he took one of his ribs" and made a woman "and brought her to Adam." And why, while he slept, did He take one of his ribs? Could He not have done this while he was awake? This is mystical. Was not the Church formed from the side of Christ, when Christ fell asleep on the cross? And from His side flowed forth blood and water, that is, the Sacraments, through which the Church is reborn. From the rib of Adam, Eve was formed, who was joined to him in marriage. Just as man was formed from virgin earth, so Christ from the glorious Virgin. And just as from the side of the sleeping Adam woman was formed, so the Church from Christ hanging on the cross. And just as from Adam and Eve, Abel and his successors were formed, so from Christ and the Church the whole Christian people. And just as Eve is the mother of Abel and of all of us, so the Christian people has the Virgin as mother.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the New Testament, after the universal scripture and the course of time, Christ was formed, as was man on the sixth day, that He may "have dominion over the fish of the sea," and "the birds of the air." As the Psalm says, "what is man that You should be mindful of him, or the son of man that You should care for him? You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor. You have given him rule over the works of your hands, putting all things under his feet: all sheep and oxen, yes, and the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, the fishes of the sea," etc. And in order that it be understood of Christ, the Apostle says: "You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor." And there follows: "But we do see Him who was made 'a little lower than the angels,' namely, Jesus, crowned with glory and honor because of His having suffered death." Man was created out of a virgin soil that had never received blood, which signifies Christ born of the Virgin; and as Eve was formed out of Adam's side, so also the Church, out of the side of Christ. But since Christ never sinned, how can Adam's transgression correspond to Him? There must be transference from the head to the body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The woman was formed from the side of the man as a companion and help for immaculate propagation. In that state the body was such that from it there would be a seminal separation for the propagation of offspring through the assistance of the female sex equally co-principiating.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The Lord cast a deep sleep upon Adam, and when he had fallen asleep, he took one of his ribs" and made a woman "and brought her to Adam." And why, while he slept, did He take one of his ribs? Could He not have done this while he was awake? This is mystical. Was not the Church formed from the side of Christ, when Christ fell asleep on the cross? And from His side flowed forth blood and water, that is, the Sacraments, through which the Church is reborn. From the rib of Adam, Eve was formed, who was joined to him in marriage. Just as man was formed from virgin earth, so Christ from the glorious Virgin. And just as from the side of the sleeping Adam woman was formed, so the Church from Christ hanging on the cross.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Adam said that she was "woman, because she was taken from man. This," he said, "is bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh." And why, while he slept, did He take one of his ribs? Could He not have done this while he was awake? This is mystical. Was not the Church formed from the side of Christ, when Christ fell asleep on the cross? And from His side flowed forth blood and water, that is, the Sacraments, through which the Church is reborn. Just as man was formed from virgin earth, so Christ from the glorious Virgin. And just as from the side of the sleeping Adam woman was formed, so the Church from Christ hanging on the cross.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Conjugal chastity accords with the law of nature by reason of the revelation shown from above. For Adam prophetically said after his deep sleep: This now is bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh. Wherefore a man shall leave his father and mother and shall cleave to his wife, and the two shall be in one flesh. This word is said to have been spoken by God in Matthew 19, because Adam said it while illuminated by the divine Spirit. From this the union is sacramental; and all of this belongs to it according to the state of the law of nature, from which the act and exercise of conjugal chastity itself first draws its origin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since each of the spiritual unions signified in the Sacrament of matrimony is a union of one as agent and infuser, and of the other as patient and receiver; and this by the bond of love, which proceeds from pure will: hence it is that matrimony must be a joining of two persons, differing according to the relation of agent and patient, namely of the male sex and the female, and this from the pure consent of the will. And because consent before commingling does not make a full union, because they are not yet one flesh: hence it is that by words regarding the future, matrimony is said to be initiated, by words regarding the present confirmed, but in carnal union consummated, because then they are one flesh and become one body: and through this it fully signifies that union which is between us and Christ. For then the body of one is fully transferred to the body of the other according to the power of one's spouse for the procreation of offspring.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the Lord said: "For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and shall cleave to his wife." And the Apostle said: "This is a great sacrament; but I speak in Christ and in the Church." Was not the Church formed from the side of Christ, when Christ fell asleep on the cross? And from His side flowed forth blood and water, that is, the Sacraments, through which the Church is reborn. From the rib of Adam, Eve was formed, who was joined to him in marriage. Just as man was formed from virgin earth, so Christ from the glorious Virgin. And just as from the side of the sleeping Adam woman was formed, so the Church from Christ hanging on the cross. And just as from Adam and Eve, Abel and his successors were formed, so from Christ and the Church the whole Christian people.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Conjugal chastity accords with the law of nature by reason of the revelation shown from above. For Adam prophetically said after his deep sleep: This now is bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh. Wherefore a man shall leave his father and mother and shall cleave to his wife, and the two shall be in one flesh. This word is said to have been spoken by God in Matthew 19, because Adam said it while illuminated by the divine Spirit. From this the union is sacramental; and all of this belongs to it according to the state of the law of nature, from which the act and exercise of conjugal chastity itself first draws its origin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When God had established man in the happiness of paradise in both sexes, namely male and female, the devil, envying man, having assumed the form of a serpent, attacked the woman—first by questioning: Why has God commanded you not to eat? Since the devil, who formerly was knowing and upright, by falling through pride became crafty and envious—and therefore through envy wished to tempt and through cunning knew how—he therefore tempted insofar as he was able, and God permitted it. That he assumed the serpentine form in tempting was of divine dispensation, so that not only could his craftiness be detected, but also from that figure the diabolical craftiness in tempting might become known to all the children of Adam. Again, that he tempted concerning the precept of discipline was likewise of divine dispensation, so that whether he conquered or was conquered, the merit of obedience or the demerit of disobedience might become known to all. But that he began with the woman was of his own craftiness, because it is easier to cast down the less strong; whence the cunning of the enemy attacks the city from its weaker side. Similarly, the manner in which he proceeded in the temptation was of great cunning, because he proceeded by testing, impelling, and enticing. For he conducted his test through questioning, he impelled through assurance, and he enticed through promise. For first he questioned about the reason for the commandment, so that he might lead reason into doubt.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The manner in which the devil proceeded in the temptation was of great cunning, because he proceeded by testing, impelling, and enticing. For he conducted his test through questioning, he impelled through assurance, and he enticed through promise. For first he questioned about the reason for the commandment, so that he might lead reason into doubt; second, doubt having been established—Lest perhaps we die—he gave assurance, so that he might lead the irascible power into contempt; third, he promised, so that he might lead the concupiscible power into desire, and thus by these three modes might draw the freedom of choice to consent, which faculty belongs to reason and will, embracing nonetheless the three aforesaid powers: the rational, the irascible, and the concupiscible.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The devil attacked the woman—first by questioning: Why has God commanded you not to eat? second by asserting: You shall not die at all: third by promising: You shall be as gods, knowing good and evil: wishing by this temptation to cast down the weaker woman and through her afterwards to overthrow the male sex. For first he questioned about the reason for the commandment, so that he might lead reason into doubt; second, doubt having been established, he gave assurance: You shall not die at all, so that he might lead the irascible power into contempt; third, he promised, so that he might lead the concupiscible power into desire, and thus by these three modes might draw the freedom of choice to consent.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, the devil promised: You shall be as gods, knowing good and evil, so that he might lead the concupiscible power into desire, and thus by these three modes might draw the freedom of choice to consent, which faculty belongs to reason and will, embracing nonetheless the three aforesaid powers: the rational, the irascible, and the concupiscible; with respect to which the devil enticed the woman through a threefold desirable object, namely through knowledge, which is desirable to the rational power; through excellence after the manner of God, which is desirable to the irascible power; through the sweetness of the tree, which is desirable to the concupiscible power. And thus he tempted everything that was temptable in the woman, through everything by which she could be led into temptation, which is the threefold desirable object of the world, namely the concupiscence of the flesh, the concupiscence of the eyes, and the pride of life; according to which three things the origin of every temptation is discerned, whether from the world, or from the flesh, or from the devil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Adam with his wife contracted the vice of curiosity, when the devil said to them: "You shall be as gods, knowing good and evil": he also contracted the vice of carnality, when he ate of the fruit: he also contracted the vice of vanity, when he wished to be as gods.
Hear, brothers: those who have the knowledge of the Saints, namely clerics, let them take heed for themselves, lest they have anything of vice mixed in; because if a man mixes in anything of vice, he loses the knowledge of discerning between good and evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The reasoning of the devil leads to hell: it is a fallacy, a sophistic and destructive reasoning. For the devil deceived the first man and assumed the existence in the heart of man of a kind of self-evident proposition such as this: the rational creature must needs desire to be the same as its Creator since He is its likeness--and, said he, "When you eat, you will be like God." Hence it is good to eat of the forbidden fruit in order to become like Him. And by this syllogism all men sin, for as Dionysius says, "No one commits evil with evil as a goal: every man intends good and desires good. But he is deceived because he takes for true what is only a likeness of good." By means of this same fallacy, the devil made man fall into the sufferings of nature, the needs of indigence, and mortality of life.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“One should consider with fear what Job says of Behemoth-Leviathan: "He shall strew gold under him like mire." Through knowledge, temptation easily leads to ruin. "You will be like God, knowing good and evil." Wherefore some men want to search beyond the way of nature, that is, beyond contingent matters. Concerning the levels of pride, blessed Bernard says that the primary vice is inquisitiveness which brought about the fall of Lucifer. By this, too, Adam fell. The hunger for knowledge must be changed: wisdom and holiness must be preferred to it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The woman, consenting to the diabolic temptation, desired knowledge and excellence after the manner of God, and desired no less to experience the sweetness of the forbidden tree; and at length she fell into transgression of the precept. Nor content with this, by offering the fruit of the forbidden tree, she led the man, who, unwilling to grieve his delights, did not correct the woman, but rather gave consent to her evil persuasion; and by tasting the offered fruit, he became a transgressor of the divine commandment.
Since from the first principle there had been given to man a twofold sense and appetite with respect to the twofold book and with respect to the twofold good, so that according to the freedom of the will man could turn to either, the woman, having heard the exterior suggestion of the serpent, did not have recourse to the interior book, which renders itself legible to the right judgment of reason, but kept her sense fixed upon the exterior book and began to occupy herself with the exterior good. And because her sense did not approach the infallible truth, her appetite began to turn toward the mutable good. She therefore desired what the devil promised, and thus she consented to do what he suggested. By desiring excellent knowledge, therefore, she was raised up into pride; and raised up into pride, by this very thing she was enticed to gluttony; and through this she was thirdly cast down by disobedience. The first was in the mind, the second in sensuality, the third in action.
And just as the temptation, beginning from the lower part, reached all the way to the highest, since from hearing through desire it came to consent, so conversely the disorder, beginning from the higher part, reached all the way to the lowest and produced one consummated sin, which in human nature is the beginning of all sin and the origin of evils.
For the woman, having been enticed, enticed the man, who, similarly turned toward the exterior book and toward the mutable good, esteeming too highly the companionship of the woman and the solace of her society, was unwilling either to correct the woman or to grieve his own delights. And since he ought to have corrected her and did not correct her, therefore the sin of the woman is imputed to him. But because he was unwilling to grieve his own delights by repelling the woman from himself, he began to love himself excessively, and through this, withdrawing from divine friendship, he fell into gluttony and disobedience.
The transgression of the precept was therefore common to both, although from different causes; in both, however, namely in the man and the woman, there was a disordering from the highest to the lowest, because first in the mind or in reason, then in sensuality, and lastly in deed. For each was prostrated through disobedience and enticed through gluttony, because each was raised up in pride: the woman indeed by desiring and pursuing what she had not yet received, the man by excessively loving and prizing what he already had; whence the woman believed she would be exalted by eating, but Adam, thinking himself something great and dear to God, believed he would be punished less severely. For he had not yet experienced the rigor of divine severity.
And thus each, while inordinately raising himself above himself, fell miserably below himself, from the state of innocence and grace to the state of guilt and misery.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The man and the woman immediately after their fault felt the penalty of rebellion and shame in the flesh; and therefore to cover their shameful parts they made for themselves loincloths. Since each parent, by being proud in mind and tasting in the flesh, was disobedient to their superior, by the just judgment of God it came about that their inferior became disobedient to them, especially with respect to those parts according to which there is the union of both sexes, which are the members serving the generative power. And because this was in them not from nature but from their own fault, therefore they were ashamed and covered themselves.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The blessed Virgin possesses that price, because she is strong and valiant as one valiantly fighting. In Genesis: "The Lord said to the serpent: I will put enmities between you and the woman, and your seed and her seed; she shall crush your head, and you shall lie in wait for her heel." Bernard says of the glorious Virgin: "She crushed the head of the ancient serpent, when she reduced to nothing every suggestion of the evil one, both regarding the allurement of the flesh and the pride of the mind."
Do not allow the serpent to enter into your heart through suggestion; for Gregory says that when the head of the serpent has entered into any opening, then the whole body easily enters.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the woman the punishment was doubled, because there was inflicted upon her the penalty of manifold hardships in conception, the penalty of pains in childbirth, and also the penalty of subjection to the man in married life. Since from the woman sin took its beginning, therefore her punishment is doubled. For because she was proud in mind, she incurred subjection; because she saw and desired the tree as sweet to eat, she incurred pain; finally, because she broke the yoke of obedience, she incurred the bond and burden of manifold hardship. And thus it is clear with what order the manifold punishments were inflicted by divine providence upon the man and doubled in the woman, so that "the disgrace of sin would not be without the beauty of justice."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By divine judgment, the man incurred the penalty of labor and anguish, the penalty of hunger and want, the penalty of death and dissolution into dust, as Scripture says: Cursed is the earth in your work. Because the man, having despised the supreme delectable, sought to delight in the flesh, therefore by the just judgment of God there was inflicted upon him labor and the want of hunger and thirst. Since the First Principle is most provident in governing and most upright in presiding, it leaves nothing whatsoever disordered in the universe; and since fault is rightly ordered through punishment, therefore immediately in the first parents the disgrace of sin was followed by the dignity of judgment, so that what was disordered by falling from the order of nature might fall immediately into the order of justice. For this twofold order so embraces all things that what falls from the one relapses into the other.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because on account of the good of the flesh man chose to be separated from the good of the mind, therefore by the just judgment of God the soul is unwillingly separated from the flesh through death and incineration—and through this, just as God had given to man according to the order of nature a body subject to the soul, capable of propagation without lust, capable of sustenance without failing, incapable of change without death intervening, so, when man sinned, according to the order of justice it came about that He withdrew all the aforesaid and inflicted their opposites: so that fault might not remain unpunished and disordered, which divine providence ought in no way to permit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As to the objection that man from his original condition was ordained to this work, it must be said that no man ought to be without labor in this life, lest perhaps what is said of the reprobate in the Psalm be said of him: They are not in the labor of men, and with men they shall not be scourged: but from this it does not follow that one must be occupied with manual labor, and especially that which is lucrative. And through this the response to the objection about the example of Adam is clear, because it is certain that not all are obligated to the work of agriculture. Nor was that which is said: In the sweat of your face, etc., said then as a precept of life, but as a punishment for sin committed, as is clear from the following text.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That remedy ought to have had efficacy first upon those who believed in Christ, and by believing hoped, and by hoping loved; and on this account He ought to have descended to the nether regions immediately for their liberation. Whence, when the gate of heaven was opened through the passion of Christ—who by making satisfaction removed the flaming sword, by changing the divine sentence—He snatched from hell all His members.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ is symbolized most of all by the murder of Abel; for Christ was killed by His brothers; and an inscription was placed among the Jews, that they be not killed, but become errant and fugitive on the earth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ is symbolized most of all by the murder of Abel; for Christ was killed by His brothers; and an inscription was placed among the Jews, that they be not killed, but become errant and fugitive on the earth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now Adam, in the act of making fruitful, represents those doctors who, falling upon the law as lovers upon their spouse, consumed the tree of the knowledge in order to observe the Law, and consented to the Serpent who persuaded them to do so, whence arose the heresy of the Ebionites, who taught that the Law was to be observed together with the Gospels. And so great was the zeal for the Law that Peter fell into that fallacy, but the grace of God delivered him. And thereupon follows the expulsion from Paradise, God withdrawing Himself from them. And they were dispersed, and cursed in their work, and devoured as by two bears, Titus and Vespasian. Thus did Cain, the murderer of his brother, that is, the Jewish people, receive a sign.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first mystery is that of the creation of beings, and there the Antichrist is represented by Lamech who was the first to introduce bigamy and was a transgressor of the natural law and given to extreme lust. Then "the sons of God saw that the daughters of men were fair, and they took wives for themselves, as many as they wished." Because of this came the Flood. And hence it is possible to surmise what the Antichrist will be like: he is the filthiest one. And his symbolic meaning is shown in this, that he would kill the one to whom a token had been given, that is, the Jews represented by Cain. Wherefore Lamech "shall be avenged seventy times sevenfold," for his sin will be greater than the sin of the Jews.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first mystery is that of the creation of beings, and there the Antichrist is represented by Lamech who was the first to introduce bigamy and was a transgressor of the natural law and given to extreme lust. Then "the sons of God saw that the daughters of men were fair, and they took wives for themselves, as many as they wished." Because of this came the Flood. And hence it is possible to surmise what the Antichrist will be like: he is the filthiest one. And his symbolic meaning is shown in this, that he would kill the one to whom a token had been given, that is, the Jews represented by Cain. Wherefore Lamech "shall be avenged seventy times sevenfold," for his sin will be greater than the sin of the Jews.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The manner in which sacrifice was introduced is seen in the fact that Abel offered a sacrifice by faith, and so did Noah, of whose offering it is said: The Lord smelled the sweet odor. And these sacrifices represented that which Christ offered on the cross. Hence it is said, the Lord smelled: God was appeased by the death of His only Son. By contrast, the demons, because of their pride, seek to be worshiped as God Himself, in order to obtain on earth the honor they could not have in heaven, and because men are farthest removed from God. A man who makes such sacrifices offers the blood of Christ, in that it was shed in order to appease the Father.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of the cleansing of crimes, Christ is symbolized by the bow in the clouds, which is the sign of the covenant.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of the cleansing of crimes, Christ is symbolized by Noah who lay naked in his tent in a state of drunkenness: for Christ was drunk with love for His spouse and was naked on the cross — where the very wicked Cham derided Him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the order of hope, concerning what we should expect, there is anagogy, and this in two ways: one in the skies, as in this passage: "Abram, look at the heavens and, if you can, count the stars." And that means the heavenly intelligences.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Heaven is called caelum, because engraved (caelatum), that is, sculptured with stars. Genesis explains how splendid is this faith: "Look at the heavens and, if you can, count the stars. So shall your posterity be." The promise of a bodily posterity was made to Abraham, for it is written: "So shall your posterity be." The promise of a spiritual posterity was also made to him, for through faith he was to be the father of a multitude. The flesh of Abraham gave forth offspring and was thus multiplied. All the more so would his spiritual begetting be fruitful: for he begot spiritually through his fruitful mind. Now, the great number of thoughts arising out of faith transcend in clarity the light of the stars.
These thoughts of faith are compared to the stars and also to twelve pearls. Although these stars are countless, there are twelve signs through which the sun runs its course. These twelve signs are merely clusters of stars which have divers influences because of their different configurations and lights. And the sun, in combination with these, affects the course of life on earth at different times and according to the different influences. These thoughts also, arising from the considerations of faith, are compared to the clarity of pearls because they are bright, vivifying and joyful in the manner of pearls. For pearls have brightness or refulgence, while they also comfort through their efficacy, and rejoice the heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We have spoken of the second vision, that is, of understanding lifted up by faith, as expressed through the words "heaven," or "firmament," meaning lofty, firm, and beautiful. Of this, it was said to Abraham, that is, to the believer: "Look at the heavens and, if you can, count the stars." And by the twelve signs through which the sun of understanding runs as it traverses the hemisphere of our intelligence, producing the day and the year of faith; and by the twelve gates, each one made of a single pearl, may be understood the twelve principal ideas to which the others may then be retraced, and according to which the others are ruled and directed: and these twelve principal ideas are bright, vivifying, and joyful. The first of these ideas was to consider God as the first Being; the second, to consider Him as triune.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The promise of a bodily posterity was made to Abraham, for it is written: "So shall your posterity be." The promise of a spiritual posterity was also made to him, for through faith he was to be the father of a multitude. The flesh of Abraham gave forth offspring and was thus multiplied. All the more so would his spiritual begetting be fruitful: for he begot spiritually through his fruitful mind. Now, the great number of thoughts arising out of faith transcend in clarity the light of the stars.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Conjugal chastity accords with the written law by reason of the divine promise: because the Lord promised to Abraham, Genesis 17: You shall be the father of many nations; and I will make you increase most exceedingly, and I will establish you among nations, and kings shall come forth from you. Since therefore the Lord as a benefit promised that He would give offspring to Abraham through the way of marriage, it is evident that conjugal chastity accords with the written law.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The other way of anagogy is above the skies, as in the case of Abraham who saw three men and worshiped one, for the Trinity appeared in these three; and in the case of the two angels who were sent to Sodom, the Son and the Holy Spirit who are sent by the Father; and because the Father is never sent, He was not seen there, but He was seen in the case of the three men, for here He appeared and was not sent.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For testimony is given in the Old Testament concerning the Trinity both in figures and in words. Among the figures, however, that one was especially authoritative which was shown to the father of our faith, Abraham: of whom it is said in Genesis eighteen, that when three men appeared to him, he indeed saw three, but adored one, whence he spoke to the three as to one, in this understanding in himself and intimating to others the mystery of the Trinity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Conjugal chastity accords with the written law by reason of the divine miracle, according to that passage of Genesis 21: The Lord visited Sarah, as He had promised, and fulfilled what He had spoken, and she conceived and bore a son in her old age, at the time which God had foretold to her. Since therefore the Lord as a benefit promised that He would give offspring to Abraham through the way of marriage, and miraculously made fruitful the dead womb of Sarah, and also gave laws according to which marriage is to be contracted: it is evident that conjugal chastity accords with the written law.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of the calling, Christ is symbolized by the sacrifice of Isaac, because Abraham is a proper representation of God the Father. Christ is represented by Isaac who carried his own wood on his neck, like the wood of the Cross.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This dew is the influence of the Holy Spirit's grace which visits the Scriptures and in which it is sweetly found. Hence, in Genesis: "The fragrance of my son is like the fragrance of a field which the Lord has blessed! God give you dew from heaven, and fruitfulness of the earth, abundance of grain and wine." Jacob, that spiritual man, is well learned in the Sacred Scriptures. Out of him comes forth an odor that abounds throughout the Scriptures in their threefold meaning: the grain referring to allegory, the wine to tropology, and the oil to anagogy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The spiritual senses denote mental perceptions concerning the truth to be contemplated. This contemplation indeed was in the Prophets through revelation with respect to the threefold vision, namely corporeal, imaginative, and intellectual; in other just persons, however, it is found through speculation, which begins from sense and arrives at imagination, and from imagination to reason, from reason to understanding, from understanding to intelligence; from intelligence, however, to wisdom or ecstatic knowledge, which begins here on the way but is consummated in everlasting glory.
And in these degrees consists the ladder of Jacob, whose summit reaches heaven: and the throne of Solomon, upon which sits the most wise King, truly peaceful and loving as the most beautiful bridegroom and wholly desirable: upon whom the Angels desire to gaze, and toward whom the desire of holy souls sighs, as the hart longs for the fountains of waters.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The hierarchical levels are disposed in the soul in a threefold manner: in relation to ascent, to descent, and to the return to God. Then the soul sees "angels of God ascending and descending" upon it; as Jacob saw in his mind.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since therefore one must first ascend before descending on the ladder of Jacob, let us place the first step of ascent at the bottom, setting this entire sensible world before us as a mirror, through which we may pass over to God, the supreme Artificer, so that we may be true Hebrews passing over from Egypt to the land promised to the Fathers, and also Christians passing over with Christ from this world to the Father, and also lovers of wisdom, who calls and says: Pass over to me, all you who desire me, and be filled from my generations. For from the greatness of the beauty and of the creature, the Creator of these things can be knowably seen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These six considerations having therefore been traversed, as if they were the six steps of the throne of the true Solomon, by which one arrives at peace, where the true peaceful one rests in a peaceful mind as in an interior Jerusalem; and as if also the six wings of the Cherub, by which the mind of the true contemplative, filled with the illumination of supernal wisdom, may be borne upward; and as if also the first six days, in which the mind must be exercised, so that it may at last arrive at the sabbath of rest; after our mind has contemplated God outside itself through vestiges and in the vestiges, within itself through the image and in the image, above itself through the similitude of the divine light shining upon us and in that light itself, insofar as is possible according to the state of wayfaring and the exercise of our mind; when at last in the sixth step it has arrived at this point, that it contemplates in the first and highest principle and the mediator of God and men, Jesus Christ, those things whose likenesses can in no way be found in creatures, and which exceed all keenness of the human intellect: it remains that, in contemplating these things, it should transcend and pass beyond not only this sensible world, but also itself; in which passing over, Christ is the way and the door, Christ is the ladder and the vehicle, as it were the mercy seat placed upon the ark of God and the mystery hidden from the ages.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is therefore a right order; man should study first Sacred Scripture, in the letter and the spirit; then the original writings of the saints, giving priority to Sacred Scripture over them. It is the same with the writings of the masters and those of the philosophers: one should scan them stealthily as if it were not good to tarry. How much was Rachel enriched for having stolen her father's household idols? The only thing she gained was to have lied and to have simulated weakness after having put them in the camel's saddle and sat on them. The same thing happens when the notebooks of the philosophers are concealed. Our waters should not go down to the Dead Sea, but up to their first point of origin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is therefore a right order; man should study first Sacred Scripture, in the letter and the spirit; then the original writings of the saints, giving priority to Sacred Scripture over them. It is the same with the writings of the masters and those of the philosophers: one should scan them stealthily as if it were not good to tarry. How much was Rachel enriched for having stolen her father's household idols? The only thing she gained was to have lied and to have simulated weakness after having put them in the camel's saddle and sat on them. The same thing happens when the notebooks of the philosophers are concealed. Our waters should not go down to the Dead Sea, but up to their first point of origin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens in a circle, as, for instance, when it advises us not to flee, because we have protection all around. For we have the Lord and angels about us, wherefore the Psalm: Mountains are round about Jerusalem; so the Lord is round about His people. To the servant of Eliseus who cried out because of the Syrian robbers who sought to capture him, Eliseus said: "Lord, open his eyes, that he may see." And the Lord opened the eyes of the servant, and he saw. And behold the mountain was full of horses, and chariots of fire round about Eliseus. Jacob too, afraid of his brother, saw the angels and said: "This is the encampment of God." Wherefore the Psalm says: The Lord is my light and my salvation; whom should I fear? And in another passage: Had not the Lord been with us, let Israel say, etc., until the end.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This was also shown to blessed Francis, when in the rapture of contemplation on the lofty mountain — where I pondered in my mind these things which have been written — there appeared a Seraph with six wings affixed to a cross, as I and many others heard from his companion who was then with him there; where he passed over into God through the rapture of contemplation, and was set forth as an example of perfect contemplation, just as he had previously been of action, as another Jacob and Israel, so that through him God might invite all truly spiritual men to this kind of passing over and rapture of the mind, more by example than by word.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Sin against nature is the most wicked and is to be fled above all others. And concerning this crime, "Joseph accused his brothers before their father of a most grievous crime."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Of these twelve modes of generation, it is said in Genesis: "I had another dream," he said. "The sun, the moon and eleven stars were worshiping me." Now, this One is the most comely Joseph whom all things worship: temporal beings cry out by means of the moon, and spiritual beings, by means of the sun and the eleven stars. The modes of generation of creatures correspond to eleven of the conditions, while the twelfth is lacking: it came about in the generation of the Son of God. Wherefore there are here eleven stars, a quantity short of twelve which is a rising number, for all beings are defective in relation to the mode of generation of this One, and tend toward the generation of the Word: for all beings point to the generation of the Word.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, they are compared two by two: in the Old Testament, there are the times before the Law and under the Law; in the New, the times of the calling of the Gentiles and of the calling of the Israelites that shall be at the end. And these times are symbolized by the two sons of Juda, Zara and Phares. Now, Zara "put out a hand. The midwife took a scarlet thread," and "tied it on his hand. But he drew back his hand," and Phares was born, who opened the breach. The Jews believed at first, but they immediately drew back their hand at the time of the early Church; but after all of the Gentiles have come in, then Zara will be born and the Jewish people will be converted.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, they are compared two by two: in the Old Testament, there are the times before the Law and under the Law; in the New, the times of the calling of the Gentiles and of the calling of the Israelites that shall be at the end. And these times are symbolized by the two sons of Juda, Zara and Phares. Now, Zara "put out a hand. The midwife took a scarlet thread," and "tied it on his hand. But he drew back his hand," and Phares was born, who opened the breach. The Jews believed at first, but they immediately drew back their hand at the time of the early Church; but after all of the Gentiles have come in, then Zara will be born and the Jewish people will be converted.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Carnal concupiscence took from us our noble generation, by which we would all be born innocent and heirs of paradise, and it makes us be born in death and guilt and the loss of the birthright. This was prefigured in Reuben, who lost the right of the firstborn, because he went up to his father's bed and defiled his couch; and Joseph, on account of his chastity, was made prince over his brothers.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of the calling, Christ is symbolized by the two sons of Judah, Zarah and Phares, for of him many things are said in happy remembrance, such as this: "A lion's whelp is Judah; from the prey you have gone up, my son. He crouches and couches as a lion; as a lioness, and who will disturb him?" Hence the lawgiver also placed here this figure of the two sons of Judah born of Thamar.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the third mystery, that of the calling of the fathers, the Antichrist is represented by Dan. And some commentators choose to say that he will literally belong to the tribe of Dan. I would not dare to assert that it will be so. And yet in the Apocalypse the tribe of Dan is not designated. It is said in Genesis of this same Dan: "Dan shall be a serpent by the road, a viper by the path," that hides itself in the sand in order to catch the birds flying around; and in this it is shown that he was extremely deceitful. "Biting at the hoofs of the horse, so that the rider tumbles backward": certainly, the horse is a symbol for the preacher of truth, and the hoof points to evangelical perfection, which the Antichrist will fight. For a horse is worthless unless it has a steady hoof. Joseph, therefore, accompanied the sons of the servant-girls who sold their brother; but Dan was the first-born of the sons of the servant-girls.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, there must be the clear view of wise judgment, so that, as the dove staying over water can see the bird of prey, man too may see in Scriptures. And this pertains to Joseph, which is understood to mean "growing." "Joseph is a growing son," a most handsome son, the savior of Egypt, the leader of his brothers, meaning that he has that judgment by which a man is guide and instructor to others: and this pertains to wisdom. And he is in the eleventh place, so that he can gather the wheat, not the leaves, but the documents of truth in Holy Scripture, and that he can pour it out again later for the salvation of the people. This is the sixth angel, [the one] of Philadelphia, "saving the inheritance." This one provides wheat against future famine.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of the diffusion of grace, Christ is indicated as the pious distributor in Paul, in whom the Acts of the Apostles are consummated — and there is no wonder, since he himself was a Benjamin and a predatory wolf, the last of the apostles, through whom the future was signified.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That the Holy Spirit prompted such a move may be seen in Moses, whom the fire led "to the inner parts of the desert," where he received enlightenment. The inner parts are the form of wisdom; the enlightenment is mental ecstasy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is said in Exodus: "That the bush burned and was not consumed," that is, the glorious Virgin, bringing forth the Son of God and light, gave light to the world through the fire of divine love and was not corrupted. The love of charity preserves from corruption.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A figure preceded in the bush and fire, which Moses saw; a figure in the rod and flower of Aaron; a figure in the fleece and dew of Gideon. Whence Bernard says: "What was shown to Moses in the bush and fire, to Aaron in the rod and flower, to Gideon in the fleece and dew: this Solomon clearly foresaw in the strong woman and her price; more clearly Jeremiah foretold concerning the woman and the man; most clearly Isaiah declared concerning the Virgin and her son; and at last Gabriel made it manifest by greeting the Virgin."
Who brought it about that the Virgin conceived? Certainly the Holy Spirit, who is a love fervent, fruitful, undefiled, virile, incorrupt, and deifying. That he is a fervent love is signified to us in the bush and fire.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence Moses, after he had led the flock across the desert, saw a bush which, though on fire, was not consumed. "I must go over," he said, "to look at this remarkable sight, and see why the bush is not burned." And there he was enlightened. The spiny bush is the flesh liable to suffering; the flame is the soul of Christ full of light and of the fire of love; the light itself is the Godhead; the light joined to the bush by means of the flame is the Godhead joined to flesh by means of the spirit or soul. And so, in order that He be able to quicken the dead and to make sons of God out of mere men, He had to be preeminent.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By means of diffusion, as of brightness out of light, of heat out of fire, of a river out of its headspring, of rain out of a full or humid cloud. In the first diffusion, equality is lacking, for brightness is not the same as light. In the second, closeness is lacking, for heat is not close to fire, since it is the principle neither of its form nor of its origin, but is merely an accident. In the third, simultaneity is lacking, for a spring diffuses itself by flowing, and not all at once. In the fourth, fullness is lacking, for not all of the rain is drawn out of a cloud, but only successive drops. Now, join these four conditions to a single diffusion, one of splendor having equality, of heat having closeness and substantiality, of a river or fountain having simultaneity, and of rain having fullness: and in this way, you will have a trace of the eternal generation.
Hence, the Son is sometimes compared to brightness: "Being the brightness of His glory," etc.; at other times, to a flame, as in Moses' bush which represented the person of the Son; or again, as a river or spring: "But a spring rose out of the earth. A river rose in Eden." Again, He is sometimes compared to rain: "For just as from the heavens the rain and snow come down and do not return there till they have watered the earth," etc. And, later: "So shall my word be that goes forth from my mouth," that is, from the Father's heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first object of speculation is the fact that God is. The first name of God is "To Be" which is most manifest and most perfect — and therefore, first. Hence nothing is more manifest, for anything said of God is retraced to being: this then is truly God's proper name. God would not have said to Moses, that is to the Giver of the Law, "I am who am," unless He were First. Later, He said: "The God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, the God of Jacob," by which He expressed the mystery of the Trinity. Thirdly, He said: "Who gives one man speech?" by which He explains that He is the Exemplar.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“You know to whom the first noble knowledge of the commandments was given? Certainly to Moses, who wrote through the Holy Spirit. But when did he have this knowledge? Certainly, when the Lord appeared to him. And in what manner did He appear to him? Certainly, in the fire of the flame of the burning bush. And then Moses said: Who are you, Lord? And the Lord answered him: I am who I am. And then the Lord gave him two lights, namely the light of eternal essence and the light of eternal truth. The bush was burning and was not consumed, in which the mystery of the incarnation is signified to us.
These are the two lights and the principal foundations of faith, namely the light of eternal essence and the light of eternal truth, and together with this also the mystery of the incarnation of our Savior.
And when we make the cross on our forehead in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, we acknowledge the Trinity and together with this our Redeemer. By saying: In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, man acknowledges the Trinity; by making the cross on the forehead, he acknowledges the Redeemer.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As related to pre-existent truth, in three ways: as regards essence, as regards excellence, or as regards refulgence. The divine essence is the first thing that comes to the mind. When Moses inquired about God's name, he was told: "I am who am," that is, every kind of goodness and power. As regards excellence: God is one, triune, and true. As regards refulgence, He is the Exemplar of all things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first object of speculation is the fact that God is. The first name of God is "To Be" which is most manifest and most perfect — and therefore, first. Hence nothing is more manifest, for anything said of God is retraced to being: this then is truly God's proper name. God would not have said to Moses, that is to the Giver of the Law, "I am who am," unless He were First. Later, He said: "The God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, the God of Jacob," by which He expressed the mystery of the Trinity. Thirdly, He said: "Who gives one man speech?" by which He explains that He is the Exemplar.
The fact that God is first is most manifest because from every proposition, both affirmative and negative, it follows that God is. Even if you say: "God is not," it follows that God is, for every proposition implies itself as both affirmative and negative.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now this is the most manifest and perfect name of God, for all things depending upon God are comprised within this name: "I am who am." This name is properly His, and it was said of it in what manner all things represent Him by way of order, origin and fulfillment, or immediate relationship. This name written in the soul gives it light so that it may see.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first mode first and principally fixes its gaze upon being itself, saying that He Who Is is the primary name of God. The second mode fixes its gaze upon the good itself, saying that this is the primary name of God. The first pertains especially to the Old Testament, which above all proclaims the unity of the divine essence; whence it was said to Moses: I am who I am; the second pertains to the New, which determines the plurality of persons, baptizing in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Therefore our master Christ, wishing to raise the young man who had kept the Law to evangelical perfection, principally and precisely attributed the name of goodness to God. No one, he said, is good but God alone. Damascene therefore, following Moses, says that He Who Is is the primary name of God; Dionysius, following Christ, says that the good is the primary name of God.
Whoever wishes therefore to contemplate the invisible things of God with regard to the unity of essence, let him first fix his gaze upon being itself and let him see that being itself is so certain in itself that it cannot be thought not to be, because being most pure does not present itself except in the full flight from non-being, just as nothingness presents itself in the full flight from being. Just as therefore absolute nothingness has nothing of being nor of its conditions, so conversely being itself has nothing of non-being, neither in act nor in potency, neither according to the truth of the thing nor according to our estimation. Since, however, non-being is the privation of being, it does not fall into the intellect except through being; but being does not fall through another, because everything that is understood is understood either as non-being, or as being in potency, or as being in act. If therefore non-being cannot be understood except through being, and being in potency only through being in act; and being names the pure act itself of a being: being therefore is what first falls into the intellect, and that being is what is pure act. But this is not particular being, which is contracted being, because it is mixed with potency; nor analogous being, because it has the least of act, since it has the least of being. It remains therefore that that being is divine being.
Wondrous therefore is the blindness of the intellect, which does not consider that which it sees first and without which it can know nothing. But just as the eye, intent upon the various differences of colors, does not see the light by which it sees the rest, and if it sees it, does not attend to it: so the eye of our mind, intent upon particular and universal beings, does not attend to being itself beyond every genus, although it first presents itself to the mind, and through it all other things. Whence it most truly appears that "as the eye of the bat is to the light, so is the eye of our mind to the most manifest things of nature"; because, accustomed to the darkness of beings and the phantasms of sensible things, when it gazes upon the very light of supreme being, it seems to itself to see nothing: not understanding that this very darkness is the supreme illumination of our mind, just as when the eye sees pure light, it seems to itself to see nothing.
See therefore being most pure itself, if you can, and it will present itself to you that it cannot be thought as received from another: and thereby it is necessarily thought as in every way first, which can be neither from nothing nor from something. For what is through itself, if being itself is not through itself nor from itself? It also presents itself to you as entirely lacking non-being, and thereby as never beginning, never ending, but eternal. It also presents itself to you as in no way having in itself anything except what is being itself, and thereby as composed with nothing, but most simple. It presents itself to you as having nothing of potentiality, because every possible thing in some way has something of non-being, and hence as supremely most actual. It presents itself as having nothing of defectibility, and hence as most perfect. It presents itself lastly as having nothing of diversification, and hence as supremely one. Being therefore, which is being pure and being simply and being absolute, is being primary, eternal, most simple, most actual, most perfect, and supremely one.
And these things are so certain that the opposite of them cannot be thought by one understanding being itself, and one of them necessarily implies the other. For because it is simply being, therefore it is simply first: because it is simply first, therefore it is not made by another, nor could it have been made by itself, therefore it is eternal. Likewise, because it is first and eternal; therefore it is not from others, therefore it is most simple. Likewise, because it is first, eternal, and most simple: therefore there is nothing of potentiality mixed with act in it, and therefore it is most actual. Likewise, because it is first, eternal, most simple, most actual; therefore it is most perfect: to such a being absolutely nothing is lacking, nor can any addition be made. Because it is first, eternal, most simple, most actual, most perfect: therefore it is supremely one. For what is said through every manner of superabundance with respect to all things. "What also is said simply through superabundance, it is impossible that it should belong to any but one alone." Whence if God names being primary, eternal, most simple, most actual, most perfect: it is impossible for him to be thought not to be, nor to be anything but one alone. Hear therefore, O Israel, your God is one God. If you see this in the pure simplicity of the mind, you will be in some measure flooded with the illumination of eternal light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first object of speculation is the fact that God is. The first name of God is "To Be" which is most manifest and most perfect — and therefore, first. Hence nothing is more manifest, for anything said of God is retraced to being: this then is truly God's proper name. God would not have said to Moses, that is to the Giver of the Law, "I am who am," unless He were First. Later, He said: "The God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, the God of Jacob," by which He expressed the mystery of the Trinity. Thirdly, He said: "Who gives one man speech?" by which He explains that He is the Exemplar.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first object of speculation is the fact that God is. The first name of God is "To Be" which is most manifest and most perfect — and therefore, first. Hence nothing is more manifest, for anything said of God is retraced to being: this then is truly God's proper name. God would not have said to Moses, that is to the Giver of the Law, "I am who am," unless He were First. Later, He said: "The God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, the God of Jacob," by which He expressed the mystery of the Trinity. Thirdly, He said: "Who gives one man speech?" by which He explains that He is the Exemplar.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“What else is this than what was signified by the taskmasters of Pharaoh, of whom it is said in Exodus 1, that they hated the children of Israel and brought them to bitterness, afflicting them with hard labors of clay and brick, and with every kind of servitude? And hear what the Gloss says on that passage of Exodus 5: Why, Moses and Aaron, do you disturb the people from their works? Go to your burdens: "Today if Moses and Aaron, that is, the prophetic and priestly word, should urge a soul to the service of God, to go out from the world, to renounce all that one possesses, to attend to the law and the word of God; immediately you will hear the unanimous friends of Pharaoh saying: See how men are seduced, and young people are perverted, so that they neither labor, nor serve in the military, nor do anything profitable, and having abandoned necessary affairs, they pursue idleness and leisure! What is it to serve God? They do not wish to labor and they seek occasions for idleness. These were then the words of Pharaoh, these also his friends now speak, and they persecute not only with words, but also with blows."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"For in her is a spirit intelligent, holy, unique, manifold, subtle." This spirit lifts up the soul and teaches unforeseen things. "This is the finger of God" which the Pharaoh's magician cannot touch, that is, our mind. Many wise men possess the first faces of wisdom, but only a few have this one.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whoever looks upon this mercy seat with full turning of the countenance, gazing upon him who hangs upon the cross through faith, hope, and charity, devotion, admiration, exultation, appreciation, praise, and jubilation, makes the Passover, that is, the passing over, with him, so as to pass through the Red Sea by the rod of the cross, entering the desert from Egypt, where he may taste the hidden manna, and may rest with Christ in the tomb as though outwardly dead, yet sensing, insofar as is possible according to the state of wayfaring, what was said on the cross to the thief clinging to Christ: Today you shall be with me in paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Theft is the handling of another's property, against the owner's will, out of greed. If it is done not out of greed, as the children of Israel by the Lord's command carried with them from Egypt vessels of silver and gold, or when someone takes a sword from another lest he do harm, then he is not said to commit theft.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whoever looks upon this mercy seat with full turning of the countenance, gazing upon him who hangs upon the cross through faith, hope, and charity, devotion, admiration, exultation, appreciation, praise, and jubilation, makes the Passover, that is, the passing over, with him, so as to pass through the Red Sea by the rod of the cross, entering the desert from Egypt, where he may taste the hidden manna, and may rest with Christ in the tomb as though outwardly dead, yet sensing, insofar as is possible according to the state of wayfaring, what was said on the cross to the thief clinging to Christ: Today you shall be with me in paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That the divine being is eternal, the authority of Scripture demonstrates this, Exodus 15: The Lord shall reign forever and ever; and Romans 1: His eternal power also and divinity. The truth of the faith also demonstrates this: "Eternal the Father," it says in the Athanasian Creed, "eternal the Son, eternal the Holy Spirit." Likewise, the necessity of reason concludes this same thing. For everything that is its own being is eternal; for being cannot not be, therefore it can neither begin nor cease, and thus it lacks a beginning and an end: if therefore God, since he is most simple, is his own being, indeed is simply being itself; therefore he is altogether eternal.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, you can multiply the four cardinal virtues by the three theological, and then there are twelve: for prudence must be faithful, trusting, and loving; and so it is with the others. And they are represented by the twelve springs, the twelve gems in the High Priest's vestment, and the twelve doors of the City. First, the twelve springs, for as they flow into each other, they make the soul clean. Second, the twelve gems, for they adorn the soul with all the virtues carried in the heart, as these gems were carried on the High Priest's chest. Third, the twelve doors, in so far as they lead in: for in the east, there is the sincerity of temperance; in the south, the serenity of prudence; in the north, the stability of constancy; and in the west, the sweetness of justice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And here is shown how a prelate should behave: being perfect in both action and contemplation, he must accept the laws. Where? On the Mountain of Contemplation, with Moses, so that he may act with propriety and industry, and not as a beast, for a beast cannot go up into the Mountain: a beast that touches the Mountain must be stoned.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For knowing the Creator, he says: I am the Lord your God. In that he says Lord, he intimates the power of the Father. In that he says God, he intimates the wisdom of the Son. In that he says your, he intimates the benevolence or goodness of the Holy Spirit. Moreover, in that he says I, he denotes the identity of essence, and in this he intimates God as triune and one, Creator of all things.
There follows: Who brought you out of the land of Egypt; here he intimates the gift of restoration through the incarnate Word. The Lord speaks to all to whom he gave the commandment, and he gave the commandments to all, although he first gave them to the children of Israel. From the house of servitude, that is, of sin; for all of us have been led out from the servitude of sin who have been redeemed through the blood of the Lamb.
The whole Trinity speaks these words. He says therefore I, namely, the one whom you ought to obey and whom you ought to love and adore. Or he says I, who made you in the being of nature and in the being of grace. We ought therefore also to say: Lord, you are the one whom we ought to adore, whom we ought to serve; you are the one who created me; you are the one who redeemed me.
These two things, therefore, namely the knowledge of the Creator and the Restorer, are set forth first, without which we can understand nothing, because these are the foundations of our faith.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is necessary that certain moral precepts order us toward God: and certain toward our neighbor according to the twofold precept of charity; which the Holy Spirit willed to intimate through the mystery of the two tablets, and therefore they are said to be written by the finger of God.
And because God is triune, namely Father and Son and Holy Spirit, to whom belongs the highest majesty to be adored, truth to be professed, and charity to be embraced, according to the irascible, rational, and concupiscible powers, through the act of deed, of mouth, and of heart: therefore the commandment of the first tablet is threefold, corresponding to the three aforesaid, namely subjective adoration, truthful oath-taking, and sacred sabbath-observance.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Note that latria is worship owed to God alone and is rendered in such a way that it is owed to no other. God prohibits the worship of others in the negative, and by this he implied the worship of God in the affirmative, which is made explicit in the New Testament, when the Lord says: Thou shalt adore the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve.
It is asked: why did the Lord prohibit the worship of others in the negative and not make explicit the worship of God in the affirmative? Certainly, because he wished to give us the commandments in the easiest manner he could; and therefore in the negative he called us back from the worship of others, so as to imply his own worship in the affirmative. And it should be noted that he called us back from all idolatry. Now everything that is adored other than God is either an intellectual creature, such as angels and demons; or a corporeal creature, such as heaven and earth and water and the like; or it is a figment of the human mind. And the Lord prohibits adoring these three.
Sacred Scripture places the intellectual creature at the highest level, the figment in the middle, and corporeal nature at the lowest; and accordingly it first prohibits idolatry with respect to the intellectual creature, when it says: You shall not have strange gods.
We Christians ought to see beyond that Jewish people to whom these commandments were given, because the truth has been made manifest to us. In the first word: You shall not have strange gods before me, all profane pacts with demons are prohibited, whether they be made through incantations of words, or through inscriptions of characters or images, or through immolations of sacrifices. In these three consist all the parts of the magical art. And thus by prohibiting these three, all things are prohibited from which all profane pacts with demons arise, whether they be made for the transmutation of natures, as the magicians of Pharaoh did; or for the deception of the senses, as illusionists do; or for the investigation of future contingencies. All these Augustine calls pacts with demons, because in such things there is attributed to the creature what ought to be attributed to the Creator; and therefore such persons sin against the first word of the commandment: You shall not have strange gods before me.
We have an example of this in a certain learned man, who had long studied how he might become rich, and had made his tongue available for hire for a long time, and yet was always in want. But he thought thus: since I cannot be made rich through God, I will be made rich through the devil. He sought a magician among Jews and Christians and found none. At length he thought: I myself will try whether I can become rich through the devil. He went by a certain shady, rocky path alongside a torrent and said: Where are you, demon, who always seek to deceive men? I am here to give you my soul. The first and second time the demon did not come nor respond, because the Lord did not yet permit it. But the third time the devil came and said: What do you seek from me? He answered: That you make me rich. The devil said to him: It is necessary that you first adore me. And then he bowed down and adored him. And immediately the devil had power over him and deceived him: he made all those stones appear to him to be gold. And the demon said to him: Take as much gold as you wish. And then he, rejoicing, loaded himself with stones, and when he came home he placed the stones in a certain corner of the house; and the stones caught fire, and the house was burned along with whatever was in it, so that he himself barely escaped. He thought again to return to the former place, saying: I will go and take enough gold. And when he came to the place, then he saw that there was nothing there but stones: and so he was made a fool.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Jews sometimes reproach us and say that we do not properly observe the first commandment. Concerning the first statement, namely: "You shall not have strange gods," they say that the Lord says: "Hear, O Israel, the Lord your God is one;" and you posit a Trinity, namely the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit.
To this objection, that we worship three gods, I say that if we worshipped three persons such that we said there were three gods and a threefold essence, it would necessarily follow that we worshipped three gods. But we worship the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, one God and one essence, but three persons. Whence, just as we see that in man there is a plurality of natures, namely intellectual and corporeal, and yet there is but one person, so conversely in the divine there is unity of essence and plurality of persons.
God the Father has a Word and the Holy Spirit: indeed He has a Word, through which He made all things; and He has the Holy Spirit, through whom He preserves all things. The Word flows forth from the one who speaks and is God from God. Likewise the Holy Spirit is spirated from the Father and the Son and is God and in God. The Holy Spirit alone is the one who searches the depths of hearts, and He is God.
Hence the person who wishes to understand these things and to speak about them must have the most elevated thoughts, not earthbound ones: for otherwise he cannot understand the most exalted things concerning God. For when we posit the Trinity, we do not posit Christ as a mere man, but God with man.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the first tablet are contained the commandments ordering us toward God: but God is the Trinity, Father and Son and Holy Spirit. To the Father is attributed majesty, to the Son truth, and to the Holy Spirit goodness. In the Father there is supreme majesty to be humbly adored; in the Son there is supreme truth to be faithfully asserted; in the Holy Spirit there is supreme goodness to be sincerely loved. In the first commandment is commanded the humble adoration of divine majesty, when it is said: "Thou shalt not have strange gods."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first plague was of blood, by which idolaters were struck, because the Psalm says of them: "They poured out innocent blood, the blood of their sons and of their daughters, whom they sacrificed to the idols of Canaan."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And from this fact, that He is the pious worshiper of Himself, the true witness to Himself, and the holy lover of Himself, there comes down from heaven a threefold radiation in the mind, according to the three commandments of the first tablet. For the creature must behave in relation to God in a manner that is pious, true, and holy. This consists in worshiping God piously, hence, the first commandment, You shall not have other gods besides Me, but only one; in witnessing to God: You shall not take the name of the Lord, your God, in vain; in loving God in a holy manner: Remember to keep holy the Sabbath day. These three imprint the Sun in the higher portion of the soul.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the first, we proceed as follows and it is shown that the divine being is supremely one. And that this is so, faith and divine Scripture sufficiently proclaim, Exodus twenty: Your God is one God; and Deuteronomy thirty-two: See therefore that I alone am, and there is no other God besides me; and David in the Psalm: There shall not be in you a new god, nor shall you adore a foreign god: and divine Scripture sufficiently preaches this.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It must be said that this truth, that God is one, is a truth not only believable, but also intelligible: since it is necessary and certain not only from the testimony of Scripture and the illumination of grace, which is found in faith; but it is also certain from itself and from the testimony of creatures.
From itself, therefore: because the divine being, on account of its singular sublimity and sublime singularity, possesses unity in every way. For since God has every perfection in himself, and this in the highest degree and most excellently, he is shown to be one not only from the sublimity of nature and wisdom, power and goodness and influence and causality, but indeed from all his conditions and noble properties that are attributed to him in the highest degree. Hence all conditions attest to the unity of the supreme essence.
From the testimony of creatures also: because every creature, just as it has natural goodness, so also is shown to have unity. "For nothing can exist unless it is one," as Boethius and Augustine say, and as sense and intellect teach. Therefore, just as every creature by its goodness proclaims that in God there is true and supreme goodness, so by its unity it proclaims that the cause of all things is one in itself.
Nor does the diversity of things stand against this testimony. For every diversity of things is comprehended within one universe, which in itself is indeed finite and limited and perfect. But this would not be so unless that plurality were reduced to something in which there would be a stopping point: and therefore it is necessary that all things be reduced to one ultimate end and one first principle, otherwise there would be a regress to infinity. Therefore the very universe of things testifies that God is one: whence, just as it is impossible for one circumference to have, nor can one rationally conceive, any but one center, from which lines flow and to which they are reduced as to a terminus: so in one universe one cannot posit or understand anything but one God alone.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the second word: You shall not make a graven image, all false and superstitious inventions of errors are prohibited. And it should be noted here that every error is nothing other than a fiction of the mind. For imagination produces error by clouding reason and making what is not appear to be. Now all false and superstitious inventions of errors arise either from the wicked audacity of philosophical investigation, or from a perverse understanding of Sacred Scripture, or from a disordered affection of human carnality.
From the wicked audacity of philosophical investigation proceed errors among philosophers, such as positing that the world is eternal and that there is one intellect in all men. For to posit that the world is eternal is to pervert all of Sacred Scripture and to say that the Son of God was not incarnate. To posit, moreover, that there is one intellect in all men is to say that there is no truth of faith, nor salvation of souls, nor observance of the commandments; and this is to say that the worst man is saved and the best is damned. And whoever fabricates or defends or imitates this, or proceeds according to it, errs most gravely, because he acts against the second word of the commandment: You shall not make a graven image: whence the fabricator, the defender, and the imitator alike are all prohibited here.
Second, errors arise in some from a perverse understanding of Sacred Scripture, as among heretics, who hold wrongly concerning the Trinity and the Holy Spirit. Such are the Arians, the Sabellians, the Donatists, the Pelagians, and the like.
Third, errors are prohibited which arise from a perverse affection of human carnality, such as the errors of the Epicureans, who say that there is no other life than this one; and the Nicolaitans, who say that it is lawful for anyone to act shamefully with anyone. The Saracens likewise do not have what they say from Sacred Scripture nor from the height of divine wisdom. Therefore all errors, in whatever manner they proceed, ought to be abominated as graven images, because they sin against this word of the commandment: You shall not make a graven image.
We must therefore stand upon what the lights of faith dictate, and whatever is opposed to this, we ought to abominate entirely as a graven image.
In the third word: Neither shall you make a likeness of those things that are in the heavens, etc., all perverse valuations of worldly natures are prohibited. Now every perverse valuation of creatures proceeds either by reason of sublimity, or by reason of sufficiency, or by reason of delight. In the first way it is the idolatry of the proud; in the second way it is the idolatry of the avaricious; in the third way it is the idolatry of the lascivious.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the command "You shall not make a graven image," the Jews object that we make graven images, because we have many images in our churches. I say that it is impossible for the Divinity to be carved; but we make an effigy of Christ — of Christ, I say, incarnate, and we adore that effigy.
But it must be understood that there is a twofold adoration: one which is called dulia, another which is called latria. With the adoration of dulia we can adore all those in whom there is power, wisdom, and holiness: and thus we adore princes, prelates, and masters as those in whom there is power and wisdom; likewise those who have the excellence of prophecy, as those in whom there is wisdom: and thus that captain of fifty adored Elijah.
Likewise, we thus adore the Saints who are in the homeland, as those in whom there is eminent holiness.
Similarly, the adoration of dulia is to be shown to images, not insofar as it is an image or painting, but by reason of that which is signified through it. But to God alone is the adoration of latria to be shown.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the third clause of the first commandment, in which God prohibits worshipping corporeal nature, the Jews say that we worship a morsel of bread; and this seems to them most absurd. But it must be understood that at the utterance of the word of the priest and the intention of the one speaking, the substance of the bread is immediately converted into the true Body of Christ, which has a soul united with the Divinity. But the Jew says: how can this be? I say that He who can separate substance from accidents can bring it about that the substance which is under alien accidents does not appear to our senses. Hence I say that we adore the true Body of Christ and God, three and one; and in this the virtue, power, wisdom, and goodness of God are manifested. But the Jew errs who believes he can judge of this in an earthbound manner.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There are certain things which avail for the observance of the commandments, and these must be subjoined. It should be noted here that all commandments are either affirmative or negative. Affirmative ones indeed are that man should do good; negative ones, that man should avoid evil. But it is impossible for man to avoid evil except through fear, and to do good except through love; and on account of this, two things are necessary for the observance of the commandments, namely fear and love.
A bird cannot fly without two wings, nor can a man walk without two feet. Similarly, no one can be a perfect observer of the commandments of God unless he is filled with fear and love. But man is not filled with fear except from the consideration of divine severity, nor is he filled with love except from the consideration of divine goodness.
This twofold consideration is therefore necessary for man. And on account of this He says: I am the Lord your God, strong and jealous, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of those who hate me.
A mighty zealot, that is, having the strongest zeal, namely against those who hate me. Visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children, not that he punishes the children on account of the actual sins of the fathers, but when the children are imitators of their fathers' crimes, then the Lord punishes the sins of the fathers together with their own sins unto the third and fourth generation, namely of those who hate me. He says this so that we may fear, and through fear turn away from evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Together with fear one must also love him, because he says of himself: And showing mercy unto thousands to those who love me; in which he shows us that the mercy and kindness of God transcends the punishment of iniquities. When the heart is enlarged through love, then man easily keeps the commandments of God. I have run the way of thy commandments, when thou didst enlarge my heart. I have seen an end of all perfection; thy commandment is exceedingly broad. He says that the way of God's commandments is broad, yet to some it seems to be narrow. Certainly to those who love, it is broad; but to those who do not love, it seems to be narrow.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because God is triune, namely Father and Son and Holy Spirit, to whom belongs the highest majesty to be adored, truth to be professed, and charity to be embraced, according to the irascible, rational, and concupiscible powers, through the act of deed, of mouth, and of heart: therefore the commandment of the first tablet is threefold, corresponding to the three aforesaid, namely subjective adoration, truthful oath-taking, and sacred sabbath-observance.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Just as in the first commandment humble adoration of the supreme majesty is commanded, so in this second commandment faithful confession of the supreme truth is commanded, and the denial of truth is forbidden. In the Old Testament it is said that he who swears in the name of God should swear and not perjure himself. For to perjure is the same as to forswear, and this is to take the name of God in vain.
Jeremiah says: "And you shall swear: the Lord lives, in truth and in judgment and in justice;" and the Gloss says there that "an oath ought to have three companions: truth, judgment, and justice."
First, I say, an oath ought to be made with truth; whence he says: "You shall not take the name of the Lord your God in vain," that is, without truth. Now it must be understood that there is a twofold oath, namely assertory and promissory, such that there is a certain oath given as testimony and a certain oath given as a promise. An assertory oath is made thus: I assert this to you and testify to it by the witness of divine truth.
Now this assertory oath must first possess truth. Truth is present in an assertory oath when a man does not deny what is true, nor affirm what is false, nor knowingly assert what is doubtful; for speech is indicative of those things which are in the heart. But do you know what it means when a man testifies to something false by the witness of divine truth? It is to say that he lies and that divine truth lies along with him. And this is the first way of taking the name of God in vain, namely, when we deny the truth.
Second, an assertory oath must be made with justice. It is made with justice when it is not made against a commandment of the divine law, nor against a precept of holy Mother Church, nor to the detriment of one's own salvation or that of another. And he who swears against these three swears rashly and sins in a twofold manner: both because he swears and because he keeps the oath.
Third, it is necessary that judgment accompany an assertory oath, so that there be in the mind a discernment of truth and justice, namely, whether the oath is true or false, just or unjust, fruitful or unfruitful. Whence, if I swear without judgment, not discerning among these three, I swear rashly. These three companions ought to be present in an assertory oath.
But the Manichaeans assail us and say that we ought not to swear at all, because it is said in the New Testament, namely in Matthew: "You shall not swear falsely;" and it follows: "But I say to you, not to swear at all. But let your speech be: yes yes, no no." I certainly say that in certain cases or for certain reasons it is quite lawful to swear. But the heretics do not rightly attend to the force of the words. For it is one thing to say: "not to swear at all," and another to say: "at all not to swear" — just as it is one thing to say: "a certain man does not run," and another: "not a certain man runs." "At all not to swear" is the same as "in no way to swear," and "not to swear at all" is the same as not "to swear in every way," but for certain reasons.
Second, the name of God ought not to be taken in vain in a promissory oath. Now a promissory oath is made in three ways, namely for promoting good, for preserving fidelity, and for entering into mutual peace. In the first way, inferiors swear to superiors; in the second way, equals to equals; in the third way, superiors to inferiors. By the first oath the Apostle swore, saying in Romans: "God is my witness, whom I serve in my spirit." In the second way, Laban swore fidelity to Jacob. In the third way, superiors swear to protect the people. From the first oath a threefold benefit results: faith in the intellect, love in the affections, and peace in effect. For these three reasons an oath is made for promoting good.
In the second way, a promissory oath is made for preserving fidelity, and this is done in three ways, namely for restraining malice, for settling controversy, and for clearing away infamy. First, I say, it is made for restraining malice, so that a man may neither deny the true nor affirm the false; and this is the reason for the usefulness of the oath. Second, it is made for settling controversy. Whence the Apostle says to the Hebrews: "The end of all controversy is an oath." Third, it is made for clearing away infamy. Whence in Deuteronomy it is said that the elders had to clear themselves by oath when a dead body was found. For these three reasons an oath is made for preserving fidelity.
In the third way, a promissory oath is made for entering into mutual peace: and in this is understood the restraint of all mortal sins; because "every true oath is dangerous, a false one is pernicious, and no oath is safe." And for this reason it is said in Ecclesiasticus: "Let not your mouth become accustomed to swearing." This is the literal understanding of the words.
But the spiritual understanding of this precept is this: that we take the name of God not in vain in three ways, namely for effecting, for promising, and for expressing. First, I say, we take up the name of God not in vain for effecting, as in the Sacraments, when it is said in baptism: "I baptize you in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit." Second, we take up the name of our God not in vain for promising, as when I promise to go to Saint James, or to enter religious life, by an oath. Third, we take up the name of God not in vain for expressing, as when we speak with an oath.
Conversely, we take up the name of God in vain in three ways: first, through frustration of a Sacrament received; second, through breaking of a vow made; third, through uttering of blasphemous speech.
First, we take up the name of God in vain through frustration of a Sacrament received; and according to this there is a threefold degree of taking the name of God in vain. The first is when someone does not believe in the Sacrament, like a heretic. Second, when one believes but does not dispose himself for the Sacrament, like a usurer. Third, when someone does not preserve the grace received in the Sacrament, like one who afterward sins. Hear, you who are marked with the Christian name: the character is then imprinted upon you through the power of the name of God; and when you afterward sin, you empty out the power of the Sacrament. Of such persons the Apostle says to Titus: "They profess to know God, but by their deeds they deny Him;" and thus "you trample upon the Son of God" and "treat as polluted the blood" of the covenant, you who were washed in the blood of Christ!
The second mode of taking the name of God in vain is through breaking of a vow made. And here there is likewise a threefold degree. The first is through irrational delay, as when I promise to go to Saint James by an oath and do not assign myself a fixed term, and thus always procrastinate. In the second way, breaking of a vow occurs through a contrary will, as when someone promises something to God and afterward repents of it. Against such persons it is said in Deuteronomy: "If anything has proceeded from your lips, you shall not make it void." In the third way, breaking of a vow occurs through apostatic rebellion, as when a man apostatizes from religious life. The first of these modes is evil, the second worse, the third worst, because it is said: "An apostate man is a worthless man;" on account of which it is said in Ecclesiastes: "If you have vowed anything to God, do not delay to pay it; for an unfaithful and foolish promise displeases God." And this is so when time and hour and day and year were calling out.
In the third way, we take up the name of God in vain through uttering of blasphemous speech; and this occurs in three ways: first, when someone, speaking of God, uses cursing speech, as when he curses God. The second mode is through mendacious speech, when someone denies what is true of God, or affirms what is false; because Anselm says that the nobler part of every contradiction is to be attributed to God. The third mode is through reproachful speech, such as when someone speaks of the lower members of Christ, he blasphemes most wickedly, even if he speaks the truth, and despises Christ in that He was humble and assumed our nature. And such persons have been destroyed by divine judgment. For Gregory narrates that a certain boy of six years was accustomed to blaspheme the name of the Lord. One day, when he was blaspheming and was in the lap of his father, he was seized by demons and carried into hell. On account of which it is said in Leviticus: "Whoever shall have blasphemed the name of the Lord, let him surely die."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“God is the Trinity, Father and Son and Holy Spirit. To the Father is attributed majesty, to the Son truth, and to the Holy Spirit goodness. In the Son there is supreme truth to be faithfully asserted. In the second commandment is commanded the faithful assertion of divine truth, when it is said: "Thou shalt not take the name of thy God in vain."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second plague was of frogs, by which blasphemers and perjurers were struck, who are compared to frogs. For the frog is a noisy animal and consumes itself by its croaking. Similarly does a man when he loses the stability of truth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And from this fact, that He is the pious worshiper of Himself, the true witness to Himself, and the holy lover of Himself, there comes down from heaven a threefold radiation in the mind, according to the three commandments of the first tablet. For the creature must behave in relation to God in a manner that is pious, true, and holy. This consists in worshiping God piously, hence, the first commandment, You shall not have other gods besides Me, but only one; in witnessing to God: You shall not take the name of the Lord, your God, in vain; in loving God in a holy manner: Remember to keep holy the Sabbath day. These three imprint the Sun in the higher portion of the soul.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because God is triune, namely Father and Son and Holy Spirit, to whom belongs the highest majesty to be adored, truth to be professed, and charity to be embraced, according to the irascible, rational, and concupiscible powers, through the act of deed, of mouth, and of heart: therefore the commandment of the first tablet is threefold, corresponding to the three aforesaid, namely subjective adoration, truthful oath-taking, and sacred sabbath-observance.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the first tablet are contained three commandments ordering us to God according to three things appropriated to the three divine Persons. In the first commandment is commanded the humble adoration of the divine majesty; in the second, the faithful confession of the supreme truth; in the third, the sincere love of the supreme goodness.
See that in these words the Holy Spirit wrote the tablets: for by the finger of God the Holy Spirit is understood, who inscribed all the precepts with the utmost diligence, signifying the integrity and consummation of the commandment. In this commandment, however, the Lawgiver commands something, permits something, and prohibits something. He commands to sanctify the Sabbath day, where it says: Remember to sanctify the Sabbath day. For sanctification is that which turns the soul toward the holy God, toward the true God, and toward God who is to be loved above all. He permits something in this commandment, where it says: Six days you shall labor and do all your work. He truly prohibits something, namely servile work, where it says: You shall do no work on it. This is the perfect rest, which has joined to it good work and the prohibition of servile work.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the Jews mock us and say: you hold the Decalogue, and the Decalogue contained only moral precepts; but a moral precept has binding force for all time. But the seventh day, on which it is not permitted to work, counting from the first day on which it is permitted to work, is the Sabbath day, which is called the day of Saturn; and you rest on the Lord's Day instead of the Sabbath day. Likewise it is said: You shall do no work on it: and you do many works, and thus you destroy the whole thing.
See, dearly beloved: it must be understood that that precept contains something that is purely moral, and something that is purely ceremonial, and something that is mixed from the moral and the ceremonial. That the Lord commands sanctification, that is, rest for the sake of loving, this is a purely moral precept. Whence blessed Peter says: But sanctify the Lord Christ in your hearts, that is, love him. For he sanctifies or makes holy the Sabbath who loves God above all things for his own sake, not for the sake of something else.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But you will say: why did he confuse and mix together moral and ceremonial precepts? - I say that this commandment: Remember to keep holy the Sabbath day, is about charity: and whatever is manifest and hidden in the other commandments is consummated in this one. And therefore he mixed together the ceremonial and the moral, so that we might better recall them to memory: lest, if he had set them out separately, our memory would be burdened.
Now there are three things that are required for perfect love. The first is divine leisure, converting the soul to God. The second is the imitation of Christ in good works. The third is cessation from every servile work, which renders the heart pure and clean. Now the conversion to God takes place according to seven works, without which the soul is not converted to perfect leisure in God; of which three are intrinsic, which are done by meditating, praying, and exulting: and from these three results contemplation. The other four are extrinsic, which are done by reading, chanting psalms, offering sacrifice, and fulfilling the divine law; and this is done either by hearing, or by teaching, or by conferring with others.
And this is what he says: Remember to keep holy the Sabbath day. The Lord therefore first commands leisure converting the soul to himself.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“God is the Trinity, Father and Son and Holy Spirit. To the Father is attributed majesty, to the Son truth, and to the Holy Spirit goodness. In the Holy Spirit there is supreme goodness to be sincerely loved. In the third commandment is commanded the sincere love of divine goodness, when it is said: "Remember to keep holy the Sabbath day."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third was the plague of gnats, by which the undevout were struck, who did not keep the Sabbath day, which is the day of devotion. Gnats are small flies, and they greatly disturb and vex men. Similarly the undevout are disturbed. In this sign the magicians of Pharaoh failed, as a sign that we cannot escape the restlessness of thoughts except through devotion. Of blessed Gregory it is read that scarcely in an entire day did he have a single thought about earthly things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And from this fact, that He is the pious worshiper of Himself, the true witness to Himself, and the holy lover of Himself, there comes down from heaven a threefold radiation in the mind, according to the three commandments of the first tablet. For the creature must behave in relation to God in a manner that is pious, true, and holy. This consists in worshiping God piously, hence, the first commandment, You shall not have other gods besides Me, but only one; in witnessing to God: You shall not take the name of the Lord, your God, in vain; in loving God in a holy manner: Remember to keep holy the Sabbath day. These three imprint the Sun in the higher portion of the soul.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He commands imitation of himself, when he says: Six days you shall labor. Concerning this imitation the Apostle says: Be imitators of God, as most beloved children: and in Luke it is said: Be merciful, even as your Father is merciful. Now there are six works of mercy, namely: feeding the hungry, giving drink to the thirsty, clothing the naked, gathering in strangers, visiting the sick, and ransoming captives. Moreover, the work of perfect virtue cannot exist unless the creature is conformed to Christ in these things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now for the work of virtue, six things are required corresponding to the works of the six days, which are provident circumspection, right intention, pure affection, just or right election, vigorous prosecution, and charitable formation.
The first, then, is understood in the work of the first day, when God said: Let there be light: and light was made: this is provident circumspection.
Second, it is necessary that a man set for himself a right end in God; and this is indicated when he says: Let there be a firmament in the midst of the waters. And God called the firmament heaven; because it is necessary that a man be drawn upward, so that he may have a right intention toward God.
Third, pure affection is required; and this is understood in the third work, when God divided the land from the waters, that is, secular affections from divine ones.
Fourth, just or right election is required, so that all our works may be done in an orderly manner, according as they ought: and this is indicated in the fourth work, when he says: Let there be luminaries in the firmament of heaven, that is, let our works be ordered.
Fifth, vigorous prosecution is required, which is signified in the fifth work, when God brought forth living soul in the waters, as swimming creatures, and in the air flying creatures.
Sixth, charitable formation is required, so that the works may be complete, clothed over with all circumstances, according to what the law of divine charity demands. For charity is the perfective form of all things; and he who has charity has all these six. The sixth work of virtue, therefore, is the formation of charity: which is signified when it says: God made man in his image and likeness.
When the work of man is made complete from these six, then man is said to live rightly.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is in the precept something figurative, such as the signification of the seventh day. For the seventh day signifies the rest of souls and the rest of the Lord in the tomb and the cessation from all servile work with leisure and contemplation of God. On the seventh day, however, he rested and called the intellectual creature back to himself, and on the seventh day he led the souls existing in limbo back to the rest of paradise. The signification, therefore, of the seventh day is the figurative rest of souls. Thus in this commandment there is contained something that is purely moral, namely, that God should be loved above all things, and something that is purely ceremonial, such as the signification of the seventh day.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is contained in the precept something that is partly moral and partly ceremonial, such as the cessation from works. And here certain things are to be understood generally, and certain things specifically. If we understand it generally, as the Jews do, who say that there ought to be a universal cessation from every servile work, so it is suggested to the Christian that he ought to abstain from all sin. But if we understand it specifically, that we ought to abstain from some things and not from others, then it is moral, not as in a precept, but as in well-being, and it has remained, as it is commanded in ecclesiastical institution.
Now I call servile works mechanical works, which are seven, namely: agriculture, which comprehends every manner of cultivating the earth; wool-working, which consists in every work and kind of garments; fabrication, whether it be in iron material, or metallic, or stone, or wood; hunting, which comprehends every work of bakers and cooks and every manner of preparing food; medicine, which consists in the art of preparing ointments or syrups and things of this kind; navigation, which comprehends every work of sailors on the sea or every work of commerce; and theatrics, which comprehends every manner of play or amusement.
Now among all of these there are some things that are of pure servility; some that are of continual necessity; and some that are of pure enjoyment. Those that are of pure servility are prohibited by the Church; but those that are of continual necessity, such as those that pertain to the preservation of life or health, are permitted insofar as they are of necessity, but are prohibited insofar as they are of servility. But those that are of pure enjoyment are permitted, not prohibited, because on account of our inclination they are allowed by the Church.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It does not suffice to do the work of virtue unless man guards himself from vicious work; and this is touched upon when it says: You shall do no work in it, that is, no sin.
Now man can commit sin in five ways: first, when he perpetrates sin against the commandment; second, when he incites another to sin; third, when he defends the sinner; fourth, when he accepts the sinner; fifth, when he overlooks the sinner and neither rebukes nor punishes, and this is the greatest danger, when someone neglects to correct another.
The first sin is touched upon when it says: You shall do no work in it, that is, you shall perpetrate no sin.
The second sin is touched upon when it says: nor your son nor your daughter, that is, you shall not be the father of sin by instigating another to sin either by word or deed or example. The third sin is touched upon when it says: nor your manservant nor your maidservant. He who commits sin is the servant of sin: but he who defends sin is the master of sin, by providing harbor to the one committing sin. The fourth sin is when someone accepts the sinner: which is touched upon when it says: nor your beast of burden. A beast of burden, when it was tied, was not led to work except by the acceptance of its master, and this acceptance is a binding.
The fifth sin is when someone neglects to correct another: which is touched upon when it says: nor the stranger who is within your gates. One considers a man a stranger when he sees a man sinning and says: what is his sin to me? And thus, when a man does not punish the sin of another, he becomes a partaker of that sin.
In many other ways also a man becomes a partaker of the sin of another; and on account of this the Psalm says: From my hidden sins cleanse me, O Lord, and from the sins of others spare your servant.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The reason for the precept is added, where it says: In six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea and all things that are in them, and he rested on the seventh day. Therefore the Lord blessed and sanctified it. But why does he command rest? Certainly, because he blessed and sanctified it. Therefore you also, creature of God, who are an imitator of Christ, ought to do this.
For God wrought all things in six days, not because he could not have made them in one day: but it must be understood here that the world has something in the eternal art, namely eternal being, which is the eternity of life and one possession, in which nothing is prior or posterior: and this God impressed upon the angelic minds. Likewise, the world has something in the created intelligence, namely a priority and posteriority by nature, though it exists simultaneously according to duration. But it has a before and after according to duration, not according to nature, insofar as it is in matter, not on account of a defect of the worker, but on account of his condescension, so that he might fit all things together and designate all things in the first works. And just as he produced the roots of all operations in the first works, so also he fully produced the seeds of all works and their rest.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But because the neighbor is an image of the Trinity, and to him, insofar as he bears the image of the Father, piety is owed: insofar as he bears the image of the Son, truthfulness is owed, insofar as he bears the image of the Holy Spirit, benignity is owed: hence it is that there are seven commandments which pertain to the second tablet. For with respect to piety there are two: one which commands piety, namely concerning honoring one's father: the other which forbids impiety, namely concerning not killing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The precepts are ordered according to their nobility; and beneficence is better than innocence: therefore the commandment of beneficence is placed before the commandment of innocence; and it was handed down to the Jews synecdochically thus: Honor your father and your mother. And here is set forth first the form of the commandment, when he says: Honor, etc. Second, the promise is added, where it says: That you may be long-lived upon the earth.
Understand according to the literal sense that father designates the person of the one who begets, the person of the one who instructs, and the person of the one who rears, because a father, having a son, begets him, instructs and nourishes him, and it belongs to the father to bequeath his goods to his son: and according to these three things, the father in relation to the son holds the character of origin, the character of governance, and the character of benefactor. And accordingly a threefold honor is owed to the father: the honor of reverence, the honor of obedience, and the honor of beneficence.
First, I say, to the father, insofar as he holds the character of origin, the honor of reverence is owed; whence in Ecclesiasticus: He who fears God will honor his father and his mother, and will serve as masters those who begot him.
Second, by reason of governance, the honor of obedience is owed to the father; whence the Apostle to the Ephesians: Children, obey your parents, for this is just. Honor your father and your mother: which is the first commandment with a promise, that it may be well with you, and that you may be long-lived upon the earth.
Third, the honor of beneficence is owed to the father, because he holds the character of benefactor: whence in Ecclesiasticus: Son, support your father in his old age, and do not grieve him in his life.
It is therefore commanded that a threefold honor be rendered to parents, namely the honor of reverence, obedience, and beneficence. And this is the first commandment that you must keep on account of the promise, namely that it may be well with you, and that you may be long-lived upon the earth.
But is it always true that they live longer? For we see that this sometimes fails: therefore God is deceitful in his promise. I say that long life is considered not only according to the length of passing days, but according to their value. And according as there is a threefold honor which is shown to parents, so there corresponds to this threefold honor a threefold reward: because to the one who honors his father with the honor of reverence is owed a glorious or honorable life; to the one who honors his father with the honor of obedience is owed a joyful life; to the one who honors his father with the honor of beneficence is owed an abundant life.
First, I say, to the one who honors his father with the honor of reverence is granted a glorious or honorable life; whence in Ecclesiasticus: The glory of a man is from the honor of his father; likewise in the same place: Glory not in the dishonor of your father, for his shame is not glory to you. For it is natural that a son should love his father most ardently, and that he should be indignant when someone does injury to his father.
Second, to the one who honors his father with the honor of obedience is granted a joyful life; whence in Ecclesiasticus: He who honors his father shall find joy in his children, and in the day of his prayer he shall be heard. He who honors his father shall live a longer life; and he who obeys his father shall bring comfort to his mother. The highest joy is that a man not be rebellious toward his superior; because he who is rebellious toward his superior will find his inferior rebellious toward him, and the despiser of higher powers will be despised by those beneath him: just as Adam, when he was disobedient to his superior, found all the lower creatures which had been subject to him turned against him.
Third, to the one who honors his father with the honor of beneficence is granted an abundant life; whence in Ecclesiasticus: Honor your father and your mother, and blessing shall come upon you, and your blessing shall remain to the last. This blessing is called the multiplication of goods. Behold, the precept, and behold the promise.
We are obliged to obey our parents as long as we make use of their goods; and we ought to comply with them in the exercise of virtuous or salutary acts, in the dispensation of temporal goods, and in the rendering of services: because we ought to live according to their counsel and spend according to their command and, when they require it, render service. If, however, parents should wish, say, or command something that is against the advancement of our salvation, piety is not to be shown to them in such matters. And this is what the Lord says in the Gospel: He who does not hate his father and mother and wife and children and brothers, and even his own soul, cannot be my disciple. The Lord wills that on account of paternal affection a man should not cease to do what pertains to his salvation. And this is what the Lord says: Let the dead bury their dead; but you go and proclaim the kingdom of God. And Jerome says: 'If your father should lie across the threshold, if your mother should bare the breasts with which she nursed you, trample over your father, trample over your mother, and fly to the standard of the cross. For the only kind of piety in this matter is to be cruel.'”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Beneficence toward every kind of person is commanded. Father names the person in whom there is a preeminent character of authority, seniority, and amiability. In natural being, the son is not coequal with the father.
First I say, in the father there is authority: and in this commandment a precept is given that the father be obeyed, because he has authority. Moreover, everyone who presides over public affairs, or political affairs, or monastic affairs has authority.
First I say that he who presides over public affairs is called father by reason of authority, such as a prince, baron, count, and the like, and is called father by guardianship or defense; and we ought to honor him as a father. Whence blessed Peter: Fear God, honor the king.
Second, he who presides over political or ecclesiastical affairs is called father by reason of authority. And we ought to honor him according to what the ecclesiastical ordering requires, and the people ought to obey him: whence the Apostle to the Hebrews: Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they keep watch as those who will render an account for your souls.
Third, he who presides over monastic affairs is called father by reason of authority. And we ought to honor him and obey him, according to the rule and the promise that has been made. Whence Jerome: 'Love the superior of the monastery as a father, fear him as a lord, hear him as a master, believe that whatever he says to you is salutary.' It is clear, therefore, that we ought to obey these according to what authority requires.
Second, in the father is understood old age and frailty; for the elderly become weakened. And he who honors his father by reason of old age and frailty honors every person who is in need of assistance, or who lacks understanding, or strength, or who is harassed by another. And on account of this we ought to help another through instruction, or through sustenance, or through protection. And for this purpose prelates especially exist: if a person lacks understanding, they ought to help him through instruction: if he lacks strength, they ought to help him through sustenance: if he is harassed by another, they ought to help him through protection.
Third, in the father is understood the notion of friendliness: and in this we understand that by reason of origin every person is lovable and ought to be loved, and every person is bound to honor another. Whence the Apostle: In honor anticipating one another; and again: Render to all what is owed; to whom honor, honor. Owe no one anything, except to love one another. For a person ought to love another, willing good to each one with respect to affection, with respect to deed, and with respect to outward expression.
Moreover, this love has an order, because we ought to love according to the reason of proximity, according to the reason of likeness, and according to the reason of obligation.
First, I say, we ought to love according to the reason of proximity; and according to this we owe greater love to those of our household than to strangers, and ought to serve friends more than enemies.
Second, this love has an order according to the reason of likeness, because to some we owe by reason of likeness greater love than to others: thus by reason of likeness in specific form we are bound to love a human being; yet according to likeness by reason of agreement in faith we ought to love a Christian more than a Saracen; likewise by reason of profession in a community a religious is more bound to love a brother of his order, and one canon another canon.
Third, we ought to love by reason of obligation: and thus we are more bound to some than to others. For I am bound to love another and to honor him by reason of precept; yet I am more bound by reason of precept and benefit, if I have received a benefit; I am most bound to love another and to honor him by reason of precept and by reason of benefit and by reason of promise, that is, him concerning whom there is a precept for me, and from whom I have received a benefit, and to whom I have made a promise—such a one I ought to love and honor more.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“So that you may better retain this in mind, I shall tell you two examples: one good, about a man who honored his mother, and another evil and cruel, about a man who did not honor his father.
There was a certain great and famous master at Paris, known and beloved by many. His mother, hearing of this, who was a poor woman, resolved to go to her son; she took a staff and in a little tunic of coarse cloth came to Paris and inquired of certain ladies about this master. Those matrons said: what do you want from him? She replied: I am his mother. Then those matrons brought her into their house and refreshed her. Afterward they considered that the good man would be ashamed if he saw her in such a state; and they clothed her well and gave her a mantle and brought her to the master. Then she said: I am your mother. The master replied: I do not believe it, because my mother was a poor woman and was not accustomed to wear anything but a little tunic of coarse cloth. And since the master would not accept her words, the matrons brought her back to their house and returned to her the little tunic and the staff. Then she approached her son in the assembly of many people; and he recognized his mother in such garb, and removing his hood, he embraced her saying: now I know well that you are my mother. This was spread throughout the city and was reckoned to him as a great good. And afterward he was made Bishop of Paris.
I saw the man who knew him to whom this happened. There was a certain poor man who through his own industry had acquired many goods, and he had an only son. Certain nobles, seeing this, arranged that the son should contract marriage with the daughter of a certain nobleman. And then she, who was young, beautiful, and noble, began to abhor the father of her husband and prevailed so much upon her husband that the father was driven from the table and from the house; and he had nothing to eat but bad beans. One day he was famished and came to the house of his son and asked for food, and bad beans were given to him, and he was driven from the house. Then she said to her husband: now we can eat in peace. Go to the chest and take out the cooked capon. And when he opened the chest, the capon was changed into a toad. Which, suddenly leaping onto his face, placed two feet on his chin and two on his forehead and covered his entire face, and there was no physician who knew how to remove it. At length a certain smith came who tried to remove it with his pincers. Then the toad looked at him with so horrible a countenance that he fell to the ground and dared do nothing more; and there was no one who knew how to give counsel; but that man died an evil death.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the second tablet are contained seven commandments ordering us toward neighbor, which are signified by two precepts of the natural law, namely: do to another what you wish to be done to you; do not do to another what you do not wish to be done to you. And according to these two precepts of the natural law a twofold justice is received, of which one is of innocence, the other of beneficence. The commandment of beneficence is: "Honor thy father and thy mother." This commandment, however, is not only one of reverence, but is also one of service and obedience; and it pertains not only to one's father, but indeed to all who proceed from one's father.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth plague was of dog-flies, by which the impious were struck, who have among themselves dog-flies, that is, carnal affections.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And because the lower portion of the soul is informed by the higher and is given to it as a help, it is necessary that the lower have commandments by which it would be conformed to the higher, so that it behave piously, truly and holily. Piously toward superiors, most of all parents, hence, Honor your father and your mother. Truly and justly toward equals, hence: You shall not kill, which precludes any harm. Holily toward inferiors, hence, You shall not commit adultery, which forbids any act of impudicity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But because the neighbor is an image of the Trinity, and to him, insofar as he bears the image of the Father, piety is owed: insofar as he bears the image of the Son, truthfulness is owed, insofar as he bears the image of the Holy Spirit, benignity is owed: hence it is that there are seven commandments which pertain to the second tablet. For with respect to piety there are two: one which commands piety, namely concerning honoring one's father: the other which forbids impiety, namely concerning not killing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The commandment which pertains to innocence must necessarily be multiplied, because it consists in this: that a man guard against giving offense to his neighbor. Now it happens that one offends his neighbor in three ways, namely in mind, word, and deed. Offense in deed occurs in three ways, because a man can offend his neighbor through an act either against his own person, or against a person joined to him, or against his earthly possessions. And accordingly there are three commandments: "Thou shalt not kill; thou shalt not commit adultery; thou shalt not steal."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this commandment: "You shall not kill," anger breaking forth into injuries destructive of natural or substantial life and of sound life and of honorable life is prohibited. For nature desires what is better, and therefore it does not suffice for it to have mere existing life; rather, beyond this it desires a healthy and sound and honorable life; and accordingly the Lawgiver in this commandment: "You shall not kill," first prohibits anger breaking forth into injuries destructive of natural life; second, of sound life, namely, when injury is done through beatings or wounds; third, of honorable life, such as the injury done through open or hidden insult, such as that which is done through a gesture.
Hence in the Gospel: "You have heard that it was said to the ancients: You shall not kill; and whoever kills shall be liable to judgment. But I say to you that everyone who is angry with his brother shall be liable to judgment. And whoever says to his brother: Raca, shall be liable to the council. And whoever says: You fool, shall be liable to the fire of Gehenna." Therefore it is plain that in three ways a man acts against that commandment: "You shall not kill," namely when someone is angry with his brother, or when he says: Raca, or when he says: You fool. And when he does this from deliberation of mind, then he says that he is liable to the fire of Gehenna. And because natural life is the foundation of the others, therefore under this form: "You shall not kill," the Lawgiver expressed the commandment.
Now the Manichaeans object to us and say that the Lawgiver contradicts himself. For he says: "You shall not kill," and elsewhere he says: "You shall not suffer sorcerers to live." And this is against rulers in Christian law, who kill others through judicial sentence. Likewise they object that the Lord says: "All who take up the sword shall perish by the sword"; therefore it is not lawful to take up the sword. And similarly they say that it is not lawful for a priest to be a slayer. And this is against the Church and ecclesiastical persons, who by executing judgment and commanding take up the sword. Likewise they object that it is said "But I say to you, not to resist evil," and this is against the Lawgiver.
We ought to understand that what is prohibited here is the slaying of man, not of beasts or plants, as the ancient Manichaeans said, who refused to eat from the fruits of trees. Now the slaying of man can be by law, or by man in truth, or interpretively. The slaying of man by man as by man, not as by law, is prohibited: but God, who is the founder of nature and the preserver of nature and of law, can deprive a man of life whenever He wills. Law however slays a man when the minister of the law slays, and this with a just order having been observed, a just cause, and a just intention.
It is necessary that there be a just order and a just cause, that is, that one be slain from a just cause, because the law says: "That which is just you shall justly pursue." Likewise, it is necessary to have a just intention, so that the man who is the minister of the law slays a man by law, not from the desire for vengeance, but from the love of justice. Whence the Apostle to the Romans, speaking to rulers, says that "the ruler does not bear the sword without cause. For he is the minister of God, an avenger unto wrath against him who does evil."
What therefore the Lord says to Peter: "All who take up the sword shall perish by the sword": this refers only to this, that he who is not a minister of the law ought not to slay. And what is said, that it is not lawful for a priest to be a slayer, this does not refer to rulers. The first thing, therefore, that the Lord says: "You shall not kill," is true, as man, but as minister of the law. The second, that the Lord says: "All who take up the sword shall perish by the sword," is true, if one does not preside over the commonwealth. The third, that the Lord says: "But I say to you, not to resist evil," is true, from the desire for vengeance: but from the love of justice it is well lawful to resist evil. It is now clear how the law slays a man.
Likewise, a man is slain by man as by man, and this happens in three ways: either by chance, or by necessity, or by will. If a man slays a man by chance, either he applies his effort to a lawful matter and exercises due diligence; and then he is excused from so much and from the whole. If however the homicide is accidental, and the man applies his effort to an unlawful matter and does not exercise due diligence: then he is excused from so much, not from the whole.
If however the homicide was committed out of necessity, this is twofold: either out of avoidable necessity, or unavoidable. The necessity is avoidable if I can flee but refrain on account of shame or some other cause: and in this case the person is excused from so much, not from the whole, because it would have been better for him to flee. If however the necessity is unavoidable, namely such that a man kills another not from the desire for revenge but from the love of preserving life and soul, so that he does not slay him out of cruelty but rather prevents him from destroying his own life and soul, and if this is done with the moderation of blameless self-defense; then it is conceded to imperfect persons, not to perfect ones — and Augustine says this in On Free Will — and such a person is excused both from the whole and from so much.
In a third way homicide is committed by a man willfully, and this is twofold: either from the desire for revenge, as when someone kills another's father; or from cruelty of spirit, as when robbers or the wrathful kill others: and both of these are prohibited, and the first is graver than the second.
Likewise homicide is committed interpretively, and this occurs in three ways: first, by omitting in deed: whence Ambrose says: "Feed the one dying of hunger: if you have not fed him, you have killed him." In the second way it occurs when someone kills another by counseling, or accusing, or disparaging, when he does this from malice of spirit. In the third way homicide is committed interpretively by hating in the soul: whence in the epistle of John: "He who hates his brother is a murderer." I say therefore that according to the principal meaning, what is prohibited here is killing — not that which is by law, but that which is by man — and that which is done willfully or interpretively: and this is what it says: "You shall not kill."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fifth plague was the death of livestock, by which murderers were struck; because everyone who kills by the sword is guilty of death. Such men die like beasts, because they are worthy of neither divine nor human protection; because he who kills another destroys himself and does not perceive his own brutishness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And because the lower portion of the soul is informed by the higher and is given to it as a help, it is necessary that the lower have commandments by which it would be conformed to the higher, so that it behave piously, truly and holily. Piously toward superiors, most of all parents, hence, Honor your father and your mother. Truly and justly toward equals, hence: You shall not kill, which precludes any harm. Holily toward inferiors, hence, You shall not commit adultery, which forbids any act of impudicity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But because the neighbor is an image of the Trinity, and to him, insofar as he bears the image of the Holy Spirit, benignity is owed: with respect to benignity, to which cupidity and concupiscence are opposed, each of which can be in deed or in heart, four are taken, namely thou shalt not commit adultery, thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's wife, thou shalt not steal, and thou shalt not covet another's goods. And these are to be ordered according to greater or lesser injuries by which justice can be violated.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The commandment which pertains to innocence must necessarily be multiplied, because it consists in this: that a man guard against giving offense to his neighbor. Now it happens that one offends his neighbor in three ways, namely in mind, word, and deed. Offense in deed occurs in three ways, because a man can offend his neighbor through an act either against his own person, or against a person joined to him, or against his earthly possessions. And accordingly there are three commandments: "Thou shalt not kill; thou shalt not commit adultery; thou shalt not steal."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here it is commanded that no one violate the wife of his neighbor. And blessed Augustine says that here is prohibited every illicit use of the generative members, which is done for the pursuit of lust with an assault upon chastity. And this occurs in seven ways, namely through adultery, fornication, prostitution, defilement, sacrilege, incest, and the sin against nature.
It should be noted that there is conjugal, common, and privileged modesty. Accordingly I say that one can be an assailant of conjugal modesty, and this is called adultery: or one is an assailant of common chastity, and this is done either with an unattached woman simply, and is called fornication, or with an unattached woman who is vagrant and prostituted, and is called prostitution. If however someone is an assailant of privileged modesty, that is, of virginity, this is twofold: either it is done with an attached condition, which is deflowering, and thus it is called defilement: or it is done with a woman consecrated to God, and thus it is called sacrilege, namely when someone violates a woman consecrated to the Lord.
But if it is done against the foundation of all these, then it is called sin against nature: and this is done in two ways: either against the dictate of natural reason, namely against that "which nature has taught all animals," and thus it is properly called sin against nature: or it is done against the instinct of nature, and in this way it is incest, namely when someone sins with a person related to him. Sin against nature is the most wicked and is to be fled above all others. And concerning this crime, "Joseph accused his brothers before their father of a most grievous crime."
It is clear, first, how here all adultery with a neighbor's wife is prohibited; and according to Augustine, all illicit use of the generative members is prohibited, which is done for the procurement of lust with an assault upon chastity. It is also clear on what basis the seven transgressions of this commandment are understood: "You shall not commit adultery": and that sin against nature is to be fled above all others.
Peter Damian relates that two men were together in the desert who performed the harshest penance. One of them was unlearned and, on account of his sins, was deceived by the devil, who told him that the sin of pollution against nature was no greater a sin than blowing mucus from one's nose. And then that wretched man practiced that shameful act. At death the devil carried away his soul. Seeing this, the other was amazed that a man of such great vigils and sufferings should be lost. And then an Angel of the Lord appeared, who related to him that he had defiled everything through such a sin.
Every act, therefore, that consists in the experience of lust, in whatever way a man may devise the sin itself, is prohibited, unless it is done in the form of marriage of the Church. In sleep a man sometimes suffers pollutions without fault and without cause. A certain foolish priest said to one confessing to him about nocturnal pollution: can you not give a coin to fulfill your lust? It is now clear how all illicit use of the body and of lust, procured outside the form of marriage, is here prohibited.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The sixth plague was of swelling blisters, by which adulterers are struck, who have swelling blisters, that is, infected flesh. Blisters arise from a humor causing itching, and when a man scratches himself, afterward he suffers pain. Similarly, he who indulges in lust first takes pleasure, afterward suffers pain.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And because the lower portion of the soul is informed by the higher and is given to it as a help, it is necessary that the lower have commandments by which it would be conformed to the higher, so that it behave piously, truly and holily. Piously toward superiors, most of all parents, hence, Honor your father and your mother. Truly and justly toward equals, hence: You shall not kill, which precludes any harm. Holily toward inferiors, hence, You shall not commit adultery, which forbids any act of impudicity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But because the neighbor is an image of the Trinity, and to him, insofar as he bears the image of the Holy Spirit, benignity is owed: with respect to benignity, to which cupidity and concupiscence are opposed, each of which can be in deed or in heart, four are taken, namely thou shalt not commit adultery, thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's wife, thou shalt not steal, and thou shalt not covet another's goods. And these are to be ordered according to greater or lesser injuries by which justice can be violated.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The commandment which pertains to innocence must necessarily be multiplied, because it consists in this: that a man guard against giving offense to his neighbor. Now it happens that one offends his neighbor in three ways, namely in mind, word, and deed. Offense in deed occurs in three ways, because a man can offend his neighbor through an act either against his own person, or against a person joined to him, or against his earthly possessions. And accordingly there are three commandments: "Thou shalt not kill; thou shalt not commit adultery; thou shalt not steal."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Theft is the handling of another's property, against the owner's will, out of greed. If it is done not out of greed, as the children of Israel by the Lord's command carried with them from Egypt vessels of silver and gold, or when someone takes a sword from another lest he do harm, then he is not said to commit theft.
Theft, moreover, is divided into parts, because theft is the handling of another's property, against the owner's will: and this is done either through mere fraud, or through violence, or through circumvention. If it is done through mere fraud and furtively, then it is called theft. If it is done through violence, either that violence is open, and thus it is called robbery: or it is hidden, and thus it is called brigandage.
If indeed the handling of another's property occurs through circumvention, this can happen with an attached agreement, and this in three ways: either with a fraudulent agreement, or an unjust one, or a profane one. The first way occurs in business transactions, and this happens in three ways, namely either in weight, or in number, or in measure: and from this merchants very rarely escape. If however it is done with an unjust agreement, thus it is usury, in which that which is sold is common, namely time. If however it is done with a profane agreement, in which what is proper to God is sold, thus it is simony.
But it is asked: why, if I lend you a garment or a horse or a house for money, is it not usury, as it is with money? I say that in a garment or a horse or a house, the use is drawn from the thing, not from money: and therefore it is not called usury. Some believe that usury is evil because it is prohibited: but certainly it is prohibited because it is evil. In a loan, what is mine becomes yours; and if you acquire something through your own industry from that loan, and I demand something back from it, I sell time, which is common, and which it is not lawful to sell. But in a loan for use, my property does not pass into yours, as in a loan my money becomes yours; and the money is not diminished nor deteriorated, as happens with a house or a garment or a horse, because one must return the money whole and entire. And therefore, when through usury a man seeks something, there is a perversion of order and an appropriation of what is common: and everyone ought to guard himself against this.
If however circumvention occurs with a profane agreement, it is called simony, in which he who buys acquires nothing, nor does he who sells possess anything, but they only handle another's property: and this happens when a spiritual thing is sold as though it were a cheap thing. Against whom the Lord says: "Do not make my Father's house a house of trade." But some make it a den of thieves; whence: "Her princes judged for bribes, and her priests taught for hire, and her prophets divined for money."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The seventh plague was the destruction of temporal goods, by which thieves are struck, because he who takes what belongs to others deserves to lose what is his own. This was the plague of hail, which destroyed everything. It is remarkable that he who commits fornication, if he repents, can be reconciled to God; but he who seizes what belongs to others cannot be reconciled to God unless he restores what belongs to others.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But we cannot possess these three in relation to others unless we have them first in relation to ourselves. Wherefore there are three more commandments: one that straightens all deeds, another that straightens all speech, and yet another that straightens all affective dispositions. That which straightens deeds is as follows: You shall not steal, which not only prohibits stealing from others, but commands to give from one's own goods. And this is how the Apostle understands it: He who was wont to steal, let him steal no longer; but rather let him labor, working with his hands, that he may have something to share with him who suffers need.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But because the neighbor is an image of the Trinity, and to him, insofar as he bears the image of the Father, piety is owed: insofar as he bears the image of the Son, truthfulness is owed, insofar as he bears the image of the Holy Spirit, benignity is owed: hence it is that there are seven commandments which pertain to the second tablet. With respect to truthfulness, which principally consists in word, one is taken, namely concerning not bearing false testimony.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“One offends his neighbor in word, against which there is one commandment, namely: "Thou shalt not bear false witness." By false witness are signified all things that a man can say against his neighbor.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here is prohibited the lie that is harmful to one's neighbor. And according to the general understanding, every pernicious lie is here prohibited: and it is to be understood that every lie is evil. Augustine distinguishes and says that there is the officious, jocose, and pernicious lie. A lie is called officious that harms no one and benefits someone. The jocose lie is one that is made not with the will to harm but with the desire to lie, and sometimes it harms, but does not benefit. The pernicious lie is one that is made with the intention of lying, and this in order to harm; and it benefits no one but harms all. And Augustine says that "in the first lie there is minimal fault, in the second moderate, in the third grave."
The officious lie occurs in three ways: either for defending someone's temporal goods, or for protecting life, or for preserving chastity. The jocose lie occurs in two ways: either from the sheer desire of lying, or of pleasing. The pernicious lie occurs in three ways: either in the doctrine of religion against sacred Scripture, or in the imputation of a false crime: and in these two ways it benefits no one, but harms all. In the third way, a pernicious lie occurs in the case of someone; and thus it benefits one person and harms another.
Thus it is clear that there are eight kinds of lying. And Augustine says that God can make it so that theft is not a sin; but He cannot make it so that lying is not a sin. And this is on account of the nobility of truth: because a lie is a false utterance of speech with the intention of deceiving, and God cannot depart from truth, because He is truth itself; but with theft He can well dispense, so that it is not a sin. Whence it is most necessary for man that he keep faith and have truth in speech, because Seneca says: "He who loses faith has nothing more to lose."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The eighth plague was of locusts devouring all green vegetation, by which liars are struck, who trample the truth with their teeth and lips.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But we cannot possess these three in relation to others unless we have them first in relation to ourselves. Wherefore there are three more commandments: one that straightens all deeds, another that straightens all speech, and yet another that straightens all affective dispositions. That which straightens speech is as follows: You shall not bear false witness, which prohibits all falsity either in oneself or in relation to another. Speak truth each one with his neighbor.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But because the neighbor is an image of the Trinity, and to him, insofar as he bears the image of the Holy Spirit, benignity is owed: with respect to benignity, to which cupidity and concupiscence are opposed, each of which can be in deed or in heart, four are taken, namely thou shalt not commit adultery, thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's wife, thou shalt not steal, and thou shalt not covet another's goods. And these are to be ordered according to greater or lesser injuries by which justice can be violated. And thus the rules pertaining to the necessity of justice ought to be contained in the ten precepts.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Offense in the mind has two roots according to the twofold concupiscence, namely of the flesh and of the eyes. Against the concupiscence of the flesh there is one commandment: "Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's wife." Against the concupiscence of the eyes there is another commandment: "nor his field, nor any other thing."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"You shall not covet your neighbor's goods, nor shall you desire his wife;" in which He prohibits the twofold concupiscence, namely of the eyes and of the flesh, which are the kindling of all evils and the root of all sins: because when the concupiscible power is infected and corrupted, it corrupts all the other powers of the soul. In the preceding commandments: "You shall not kill, you shall not commit adultery, you shall not steal, you shall not speak false testimony," every illicit exterior act committed against one's neighbor is prohibited. In these two: "You shall not covet your neighbor's goods, nor shall you desire his wife," the illicit interior act is prohibited, and here the concupiscence of the eyes, or covetousness, is prohibited, which "is the root of all evils"; the concupiscence of the flesh is also prohibited, which is the kindling of all sins. Through this twofold concupiscence occurs the transmission of all evils and sins; and therefore the divine law prohibits it, and in this prohibits all evils and all sins. This is the fever by which all the children of Adam are feverish, and which generates all evils.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The ninth plague was of darkness, by which the covetous and avaricious are struck, because nothing so blinds a man as covetousness. Whence the Prophet: "Gifts and presents blind the eyes of the prudent and change the words of the just;" Solomon: "Nothing is more wicked than the avaricious man. For he has even his own soul for sale, because in his life he has cast away his inmost parts."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The tenth plague was the death of the firstborn, by which the carnal are struck, like Esau. For the Apostle says: "Lest anyone among you be a fornicator, like Esau, and lose his birthright." Carnal concupiscence took from us our noble generation, by which we would all be born innocent and heirs of paradise, and it makes us be born in death and guilt and the loss of the birthright. This was prefigured in Reuben, who lost the right of the firstborn, because he went up to his father's bed and defiled his couch; and Joseph, on account of his chastity, was made prince over his brothers.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That which straightens all affective dispositions is as follows: You shall not covet your neighbor's wife, etc. As Augustine writes, "The law is good, for while prohibiting concupiscence, it also prohibits any evil." But concupiscence is twofold, of the flesh and of cupidity, and the latter is the root of all evil. Hence, in this commandment, the Lawgiver Himself went down to details such as the ass, the slave, the female servant, etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because the written law was a law of rigor, it not only approves the threefold obedience, but also punishes its transgressors. It punishes the rebellious servant, Exodus 21: He who strikes his servant or handmaid with a rod, if he survive for a day or two, he shall not be subject to penalty, because he is his property.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In contemplation, there is admiration, expansion, a transference and restoration of one's self. Hence, "after gazing on God, they could still eat and drink."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Lord spoke that word to Moses, and Moses, having heard the word, ascended the mountain and received two tablets of stone and the Law and the commandments. In this it is signified that if we wish to arrive at an understanding of the commandments of God, we must ascend the mountain, that is, to the eminence of the mind, because according to the impression of the eternal light the law of nature has been given to us, and according to that light we have received the teachings of the divine law.
Being of itself first falls upon the soul. Now being is twofold, namely created and uncreated, and accordingly justice is twofold: one, by which we are ordered to uncreated being, and another, by which we are ordered to created being. And according to this twofold justice a twofold tablet was given to Moses, namely the first and the second. In the first tablet are contained the commandments by which we are ordered to uncreated being, that is, God. In the second tablet are contained the commandments by which we are ordered to created being, namely our neighbor.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Just as God completed the whole world in six days and rested on the seventh, so the lesser world may be led in most orderly fashion through six stages of successive illuminations to the repose of contemplation. As a figure of this, one ascended by six steps to the throne of Solomon; the Seraphim that Isaiah saw had six wings; after six days the Lord called Moses from the midst of the cloud, and Christ after six days, as is said in Matthew, led the disciples up the mountain and was transfigured before them.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ was such a Center in His ascension. It is written in Exodus: "Moses passed into the midst of the cloud, and there he stayed for forty days and forty nights." And this is what Christ was in His ascension.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For if you are a Cherub contemplating the essential attributes of God, and you wonder that the divine being is at once the first and the last, eternal and most present, most simple and greatest, that is, uncircumscribed, wholly everywhere and nowhere comprehended, most actual and never moved, most perfect and having nothing superfluous nor diminished, and yet immense and infinite without limit, supremely one, and yet all-inclusive, as having all things in itself, as all power, all truth, all good: look upon the mercy seat and wonder that in it the first beginning is joined with the last, God with man formed on the sixth day, the eternal is joined with temporal man, born of the Virgin in the fullness of time, the most simple with the supremely composite, the most actual with one who supremely suffered and died, the most perfect and immense with the small, the supremely one and all-inclusive with a composite individual distinct from all others, namely the man Jesus Christ.
But if you are the other Cherub contemplating the proper attributes of the persons, and you wonder that communicability coexists with propriety, consubstantiality with plurality, configurability with personality, coequality with order, coeternity with production, cointimacy with sending forth, because the Son was sent by the Father, and the Holy Spirit by both, who nevertheless is always with them and never departs from them: look upon the mercy seat and wonder that in Christ there stands personal union with a trinity of substances and a duality of natures; there stands complete agreement with a plurality of wills; there stands the co-predication of God and man with a plurality of properties; there stands co-adoration with a plurality of nobilities; there stands co-exaltation above all things with a plurality of dignities; there stands co-dominion with a plurality of powers.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As a sign of Him, there are the two Cherubim turned toward each other, but with their faces looking toward the propitiatory. The two Cherubim are the two Testaments whose gaze is directed upon Christ. He opened their minds when they understood the Scriptures, meaning that the book of Scriptures is understood precisely through that key, the Incarnate Word, the one eminently concerned with the works of restoration. For unless you understand the order and origin of restoration, you cannot understand Scriptures.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the Cherubim also designate this, who looked upon one another. Nor is it without mystery that they looked upon one another with their faces turned toward the mercy seat, so that what the Lord says in John may be verified: "This is eternal life, that they may know thee, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom thou hast sent." For we ought to admire not only the essential and personal conditions of God in themselves, but also by comparison to the superadmirable union of God and man in the unity of the person of Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These six considerations having therefore been traversed, as if they were the six steps of the throne of the true Solomon, by which one arrives at peace, where the true peaceful one rests in a peaceful mind as in an interior Jerusalem; and as if also the six wings of the Cherub, by which the mind of the true contemplative, filled with the illumination of supernal wisdom, may be borne upward; and as if also the first six days, in which the mind must be exercised, so that it may at last arrive at the sabbath of rest; after our mind has contemplated God outside itself through vestiges and in the vestiges, within itself through the image and in the image, above itself through the similitude of the divine light shining upon us and in that light itself, insofar as is possible according to the state of wayfaring and the exercise of our mind; when at last in the sixth step it has arrived at this point, that it contemplates in the first and highest principle and the mediator of God and men, Jesus Christ, those things whose likenesses can in no way be found in creatures, and which exceed all keenness of the human intellect: it remains that, in contemplating these things, it should transcend and pass beyond not only this sensible world, but also itself; in which passing over, Christ is the way and the door, Christ is the ladder and the vehicle, as it were the mercy seat placed upon the ark of God and the mystery hidden from the ages.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whoever looks upon this mercy seat with full turning of the countenance, gazing upon him who hangs upon the cross through faith, hope, and charity, devotion, admiration, exultation, appreciation, praise, and jubilation, makes the Passover, that is, the passing over, with him, so as to pass through the Red Sea by the rod of the cross, entering the desert from Egypt, where he may taste the hidden manna, and may rest with Christ in the tomb as though outwardly dead, yet sensing, insofar as is possible according to the state of wayfaring, what was said on the cross to the thief clinging to Christ: Today you shall be with me in paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In so far as the cardinal virtues receive their form from charity, they are represented by the four ornaments of the tabernacle, the four sheets, skins of violet, curtains of goat hair, and rams' skins dyed red. The sheets correspond to temperance, the purple skins to the heavenly colors of prudence, the curtains of goat hair to justice, the rams' skins dyed red to fortitude. Or again, in the ornaments of the Dwelling, there are four colors: linen-white, in which there is temperance; violet revealing prudence; purple, the color of royal clothing, meaning justice; and red, that is, the color of fire, fortitude. And in this manner they adorn the Dwelling on all four sides. Likewise, they stabilize, and lead in through the door, through the four sides of the city, stabilized by hope to an equal rule.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As a symbol of this, the High Priest had two stones on his ephod: one on the right side and the other on the left. And on these were written the twelve names of the sons of Israel: six names on one stone and six names on the other—and they were made of lucid and ardent onyx, through which faith in the humanity and divinity is expressed. And they are likewise expressed in the Creed composed by the twelve apostles. And a sacrifice made in such faith as this is pleasing to God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As a symbol of this, the High Priest had two stones on his ephod: one on the right side and the other on the left. And on these were written the twelve names of the sons of Israel: six names on one stone and six names on the other—and they were made of lucid and ardent onyx, through which faith in the humanity and divinity is expressed. And they are likewise expressed in the Creed composed by the twelve apostles. And a sacrifice made in such faith as this is pleasing to God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, you can multiply the four cardinal virtues by the three theological, and then there are twelve: for prudence must be faithful, trusting, and loving; and so it is with the others. And they are represented by the twelve springs, the twelve gems in the High Priest's vestment, and the twelve doors of the City. First, the twelve springs, for as they flow into each other, they make the soul clean. Second, the twelve gems, for they adorn the soul with all the virtues carried in the heart, as these gems were carried on the High Priest's chest. Third, the twelve doors, in so far as they lead in: for in the east, there is the sincerity of temperance; in the south, the serenity of prudence; in the north, the stability of constancy; and in the west, the sweetness of justice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the rules pertaining to the necessity of justice are contained in the divine precepts, and it belongs to justice to "render to each one his due": it is necessary that certain moral precepts order us toward God: and certain toward our neighbor according to the twofold precept of charity; which the Holy Spirit willed to intimate through the mystery of the two tablets, and therefore they are said to be written by the finger of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The exercise of the gift of piety consists in the abundance of interior compassion. Of this it is said in Ecclesiasticus: "These are men of mercy, whose acts of piety have not failed; with their seed good things endure." How great was the piety of Moses! Who loved the people provoking the Lord and prayed to the Lord for them saying: "Hear me, Lord, this people has sinned: either forgive this people this offense, or if you do not, blot me out of your book which you have written." Bernard gives the example of a woman who has her little child and is outside the house. If it were said to her: leave your little child outside the house, and you enter the house; she would not want to enter the house, such that the child would remain outside. So Moses willed that the Lord would forgive the people their sin, or that He would blot him from the book of life.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens from outside through extrinsic examples, of which all of Scripture is full. If you seek an example of patience, behold Job and Tobias; of magnanimity, behold David fighting Goliath, and Judas Macchabee. As an example of faith, behold Abraham and the glorious Virgin, whose faith surpasses that of Abraham. For Abraham believed that he could have a son from a sterile old woman, but Mary believed that although a virgin, she would conceive of the Holy Spirit: nor would she have conceived had she not believed. If you seek an example of love, behold Moses who said: "If You would only forgive their sin! If You will not, then strike me out of the book that You have written!"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Turning back again, let us say: because therefore the most pure and absolute being, which is simply being, is the first and the last, therefore it is the origin and consummating end of all things.
Because eternal and most present, therefore it encompasses and enters all durations, existing as it were simultaneously as their center and circumference.
Because most simple and greatest, therefore it is wholly within all things and wholly beyond all things, and therefore "it is an intelligible sphere whose center is everywhere and whose circumference is nowhere."
Because most actual and most immutable, therefore "remaining stable, it gives motion to all things."
Because most perfect and immense, therefore it is within all things, not enclosed; beyond all things, not excluded; above all things, not elevated; below all things, not cast down.
Because indeed it is supremely one and all-encompassing, therefore it is all things in all, although all things are many and it itself is nothing but one; and this because through most simple unity, most serene truth, and most sincere goodness there is in it all power, all exemplarity, and all communicability; and therefore from him and through him and in him are all things, and this because he is omnipotent, omniscient, and in every way good, which to see perfectly is to be blessed, as was said to Moses: I will show you all good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such love divides, puts to sleep, and lifts up. It divides, since it cuts away from any other love because of the single love for the Spouse; it puts to sleep and appeases all the powers and imposes silence; it lifts up, since it leads to God. And so man is as dead, wherefore it is said: "Love is strong as death," because it cuts away from all things. Man, then, must die of this love in order to be lifted up. Hence "no man sees Me and still lives."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But if you ask how these things come about, ask grace, not doctrine; desire, not understanding; the groaning of prayer, not the study of reading; the Bridegroom, not the master; God, not man; darkness, not clarity; not light, but the fire that wholly inflames and carries into God through ecstatic anointings and most ardent affections. Which fire is indeed God, and his furnace is in Jerusalem, and Christ kindles this in the fervor of his most ardent passion, which only he truly perceives who says: My soul has chosen hanging, and my bones death. Whoever loves this death can see God, because it is indubitably true: No man shall see me and live. Let us die, therefore, and enter into the darkness; let us impose silence upon our cares, concupiscences, and phantasms; let us pass over with Christ crucified from this world to the Father, so that, when the Father is shown to us, we may say with Philip: It suffices us; let us hear with Paul: My grace suffices for you; let us exult with David, saying: My flesh and my heart have failed, God of my heart and God my portion forever. Blessed be the Lord forever, and let all the people say: So be it, so be it. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This wisdom results from many mysteries of the Scriptures, as out of many mirrors there results a multiplication of light rays and fires. These are the "mirrors of the women" out of which "the bronze laver" was made; this is Scriptures, "with faces unveiled, reflecting as in a mirror the glory of the Lord, being transformed into His very image from glory to glory": from the clarity of allegory to the clarity of anagogy, and again to that of tropology.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Gratuitous knowledge is called the knowledge of the Saints, because it has nothing of vice mixed in, nothing of carnality, nothing of curiosity, and nothing of vanity. Whence in Leviticus: "The Lord also said to Aaron: You and your sons shall not drink wine or anything that can intoxicate, so that you may have the knowledge of discerning between the holy and the profane." He who has the knowledge of discerning between the holy and the profane will abstain from everything that can intoxicate, that is, from every superfluous delight in creatures: this is the intoxicating wine. Whether someone on account of vanity, or on account of curiosity, or carnality inclines toward superfluous delight, which is in creatures: he does not have the knowledge of the Saints.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Conjugal chastity accords with the written law by reason of the divine statute, Leviticus 18. For the Lord established laws according to which legitimacy is observed in the persons who contract marriage. For He says: I am the Lord your God: keep my laws and judgments, which if a man do, he shall live in them. No man shall approach to her that is near of kin to him, etc. Since therefore the Lord as a benefit promised that He would give offspring to Abraham through the way of marriage, and miraculously made fruitful the dead womb of Sarah, and also gave laws according to which marriage is to be contracted: it is evident that conjugal chastity accords with the written law.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To be sanctified is to be drawn away from any love that sullies and corrupts and may lead the soul to ruin. In this must the creature resemble the Creator: "You shall be holy," He said, "because I am holy." This holiness makes one God-conformed. That is why the Seraphic spirits cried out: "Holy, holy, holy."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We take up the name of God in vain through uttering of blasphemous speech; and this occurs in three ways: first, when someone, speaking of God, uses cursing speech, as when he curses God. The second mode is through mendacious speech, when someone denies what is true of God, or affirms what is false; because Anselm says that the nobler part of every contradiction is to be attributed to God. The third mode is through reproachful speech, such as when someone speaks of the lower members of Christ, he blasphemes most wickedly, even if he speaks the truth, and despises Christ in that He was humble and assumed our nature.
And such persons have been destroyed by divine judgment. For Gregory narrates that a certain boy of six years was accustomed to blaspheme the name of the Lord. One day, when he was blaspheming and was in the lap of his father, he was seized by demons and carried into hell. On account of which it is said in Leviticus: "Whoever shall have blasphemed the name of the Lord, let him surely die."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The danger of transgression ought to move us to the observance of the commandments, because the transgressor of the commandments falls into many dangers: first, because he loses many goods; second, because he rushes into abominable crimes; third, because he merits eternal punishments. Transgressors lose many goods; whence in Leviticus: "If you will not hear my voice and will not do all my commandments, I will visit you with want and burning heat, which shall consume your eyes and consume your souls." He says: "I will visit you with want": behold, the privation of all goods; "and with burning heat, which shall consume your eyes and consume your souls," because it blinds the intellect of the true and takes away the affection for the good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The purely intellectual vision existed in the minds of the angels and of the Lawmaker. Moses was raised up to this vision more completely than any other prophet, for it is written: Should there be a prophet among you, in visions will I reveal Myself to him, in dreams will I speak to him; not so with my servant Moses! Throughout My house he bears My trust: face to face I speak to him, plainly and not in riddles. The presence of the Lord he beholds.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A figure preceded in the rod and flower of Aaron. The history is in the rod of Aaron, which, cut off and dry, in the space of a single night put forth leaves, flowered, and brought forth fruit. Who brought it about that the Virgin conceived? Certainly the Holy Spirit, who is a love fervent, fruitful, undefiled, virile, incorrupt, and deifying. That he is a fruitful love is signified in the rod of Aaron, which in the space of a night put forth leaves, flowered, and brought forth fruit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the production of foliage, it is said in the Book of Numbers: "How goodly are your tents, O Jacob; your encampments, O Israel! They are like gardens beside a stream." These are the mysteries of Scripture. Who can conceive the charm of the mysteries of Sacred Scriptures?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“One is said to be superior to another either with respect to the origin of nature, or with respect to the dominion of power or presidency, or with respect to the governance of providence. The first superiority belongs to nature itself by reason of itself, because "nature is a force implanted in things, producing like from like"; the second by reason of vice, because, as Ambrose says, servitude is the punishment of sin; but the third belongs by reason of remedy, according to that passage in Numbers twenty-seven: Let the God of the spirits of all flesh provide a man who may be over this multitude, lest they be as sheep without a shepherd. To the first superiority is owed filial obedience, to the second servile obedience, and to the third jurisdictional obedience, which regards the dignity of prelacy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Jews sometimes reproach us and say that we do not properly observe the first commandment. Concerning the first statement, namely: "You shall not have strange gods," they say that the Lord says: "Hear, O Israel, the Lord your God is one;" and you posit a Trinity, namely the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit.
To this objection, that we worship three gods, I say that if we worshipped three persons such that we said there were three gods and a threefold essence, it would necessarily follow that we worshipped three gods. But we worship the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, one God and one essence, but three persons. Whence, just as we see that in man there is a plurality of natures, namely intellectual and corporeal, and yet there is but one person, so conversely in the divine there is unity of essence and plurality of persons.
God the Father has a Word and the Holy Spirit: indeed He has a Word, through which He made all things; and He has the Holy Spirit, through whom He preserves all things. The Word flows forth from the one who speaks and is God from God. Likewise the Holy Spirit is spirated from the Father and the Son and is God and in God. The Holy Spirit alone is the one who searches the depths of hearts, and He is God.
Hence the person who wishes to understand these things and to speak about them must have the most elevated thoughts, not earthbound ones: for otherwise he cannot understand the most exalted things concerning God. For when we posit the Trinity, we do not posit Christ as a mere man, but God with man.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And these things are so certain that the opposite of them cannot be thought by one understanding being itself, and one of them necessarily implies the other. For because it is simply being, therefore it is simply first: because it is simply first, therefore it is not made by another, nor could it have been made by itself, therefore it is eternal. Likewise, because it is first and eternal; therefore it is not from others, therefore it is most simple. Likewise, because it is first, eternal, and most simple: therefore there is nothing of potentiality mixed with act in it, and therefore it is most actual. Likewise, because it is first, eternal, most simple, most actual; therefore it is most perfect: to such a being absolutely nothing is lacking, nor can any addition be made. Because it is first, eternal, most simple, most actual, most perfect: therefore it is supremely one. For what is said through every manner of superabundance with respect to all things. "What also is said simply through superabundance, it is impossible that it should belong to any but one alone." Whence if God names being primary, eternal, most simple, most actual, most perfect: it is impossible for him to be thought not to be, nor to be anything but one alone. Hear therefore, O Israel, your God is one God. If you see this in the pure simplicity of the mind, you will be in some measure flooded with the illumination of eternal light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To the objection that if we are bound to believe this, it is either because it is true, or because it is a truth falling under a precept, it must be said that it is because it is a truth falling under a precept. And if you ask: under which precept? I say that under the first, in which indeed it is said: Hear, O Israel, the Lord your God is one God. You shall adore the Lord your God and Him alone shall you serve. In this precept indeed we are obligated expressly to believe that God is one, but implicitly to believe that God is triune. And this is evident as follows: because by this precept we are bound to worship God with the worship of latria, which is there called service. Now to worship in spiritual matters is according to a transumption from material things: in material things, however, to cultivate a field is to bring forth the shoots proceeding originally from the earth itself. In this same manner, to worship God is to profess by heart and mouth and deed that He is the principle, such that He is not perfectly worshipped unless we confess that He is the principiating principle not only effective in creation, but also restorative in redemption and perfective in glorification: nor yet perfectly, if He is believed to be a principle from time, unless He is believed to be a principiating principle from eternity: nor yet, unless He is believed to be a principle principiating one who eternally principiates: which we believe when we believe that the Father eternally generates the Son, who together with Him spirates the Holy Spirit, so that eternally in God there is a principle from a principle, and a principle not from a principle.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The authority of the one commanding ought to move us to observe the commandments of God. He is of great authority, because by His munificent benevolence He saves us. "And now, Israel, what does the Lord your God ask of you, except that you fear the Lord your God and walk in His ways and love Him and serve the Lord your God with your whole heart and with your whole soul, and keep the commandments of the Lord?" Lord, who created you; God, who governs you; your own, who saves you.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And in Deuteronomy it is said: "And now, Israel, what does the Lord your God ask of you, except that you fear him and keep all his commandments and walk in his ways?" And Solomon says: "Fear God and observe his commandments: this is the whole man," that is, the perfect man. Therefore if you wish to be perfect, fear God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The authority of the one commanding ought to move us to observe the commandments of God, because by His great power He creates us. "Your eyes have seen all the great works of God, which He did, that you might keep His commandments."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now Sacred Scripture is generous in that God conveys His influence to it, producing the most abundant multiplications. Hence, in Deuteronomy: "The land which you are to enter and occupy is not like the land of Egypt," which is irrigated, but "a land... that drinks in rain from the heavens." For it is not like the other sciences, since God visits it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Behold, the wondrous benefit of observance and the wondrous calamity of transgression. Whence the Lord through Moses: "Behold, I set before thee blessing and curse: blessing, if thou shalt keep My commandments: curse, if thou shalt not keep them." The Lord places us in the middle and works with us wonderfully.
When someone wishes to demonstrate something to another, he proceeds against him by a twofold way, namely by ostensive reasoning and by reasoning leading to an impossibility. Thus does the Lord: He places man in the middle between heaven and hell: in heaven is eternal glory, in hell are eternal punishments. And when the Lord shows man the glory of paradise, which he can merit by keeping the commandments, then He inclines him to the observance of the commandments by ostensive reasoning. But when He shows him the punishments of hell, into which he will fall if he transgresses the commandments, then He inclines him by reasoning leading to an impossibility.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Just as that law, Deuteronomy 15: There shall be no needy person or beggar among you, was not given against the mendicancy of the poor, but against the tightfistedness of the rich — which is clear from the fact that in the same chapter it is added: The poor shall not be wanting in the land of your habitation; therefore I command you to open your hand to your needy and poor brother — so also this law is given to bishops who have abundance for the sustenance of poor clerics, especially those who are not in want voluntarily but by compulsion, lest on account of their indigence they become slack in divine service.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The ninth plague was of darkness, by which the covetous and avaricious are struck, because nothing so blinds a man as covetousness. Whence the Prophet: "Gifts and presents blind the eyes of the prudent and change the words of the just."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Just as mercy is a friend of wisdom, so avarice is its enemy. The avaricious deride all who do not love money. "Gifts blind the eyes of the wise and alter the words of the just." They blind the eyes, not bodily, but spiritual; therefore they take away the light of wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Law slays a man when the minister of the law slays, and this with a just order having been observed, a just cause, and a just intention. It is necessary that there be a just order and a just cause, that is, that one be slain from a just cause, because the law says: "That which is just you shall justly pursue."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because the written law was a law of rigor, it not only approves this threefold obedience, but also punishes transgressors of this obedience. It punishes the rebellious son, the rebellious servant, and also the disobedient subject, Deuteronomy 17: He who acts proudly, refusing to obey the command of the priest, that man shall die.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Deuteronomy 17: If you perceive that the judgment before you is difficult and ambiguous, and you see the words of the judges to vary: arise and go up to the place which the Lord your God has chosen. But the man who acts proudly, refusing to obey the command of the priest, that man shall die: there the Gloss says: "Here he grants the faculty of appeal." From this text and Gloss it is gathered that in the old law there was a supreme Pontiff, to whom recourse was to be had in judgments, and whom all were bound to obey. If therefore this was so in the law of the figure, much more does it seem that it ought to be so in the law of grace. And this for a threefold reason: first, because there is greater unity now than then: therefore much more ought there be one Pontiff. Likewise, the pontificate is now more worthy and lofty: therefore much more ought all now be subject to one Pontiff than in the time of the law of Moses. Finally, because here there ought to be a greater obedience and a more ordered hierarchy. From all of which it is gathered that if one supreme Pontiff was to be obeyed in the time of the law of Moses, much more so in the time of the law of Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because the written law was a law of rigor, it not only approves this threefold obedience, but also punishes transgressors of this obedience. For it punishes the rebellious son, Deuteronomy 21: If a man beget a rebellious and insolent son, who does not heed his father's command, and when corrected scorns to obey: they shall seize him and bring him to the elders, etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second mode of breaking a vow occurs through a contrary will, as when someone promises something to God and afterward repents of it. Against such persons it is said in Deuteronomy: "If anything has proceeded from your lips, you shall not make it void."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From the second consideration comes forth that fruit of justice which consists in fleeing evil, that is, by means of distinguishing judgments. No one, indeed, wants to reap cockle or tares, for as it is said in Deuteronomy: "According to the measure of the sin shall the measure also of the stripes be." Thus the consideration of the judgments will make one flee from evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The commandments of God are irreproachable, because they contain nothing impossible. To one having charity the commandments of God are easy and sweet, but to one not having charity they seem difficult. Augustine gives the example of a bird having feathers and a bird without feathers: for a bird having feathers it is easy to fly, but for a bird not having feathers it is difficult. Similarly, to a man of perverse will the commandments seem difficult, which to one having charity are easy. Whence it is said in Deuteronomy: "This commandment which I command you today is not above you nor placed far off nor set in heaven nor placed beyond the sea, but the word is very near to you, in your mouth and in your heart, that you may do it."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is now clear that there are ten precepts of the sacred decalogue. In the first three, right ordering toward God is commanded; in the fourth, right ordering and beneficence toward parents; in the other six, right ordering and innocence toward one's neighbor is commanded.
Although certain precepts are called affirmative and certain negative, nevertheless all contain both affirmation and negation within themselves. When God prohibits something in a certain commandment, He commands its contrary; and conversely, when He commands something, He prohibits its contrary. For in the first commandment, humble adoration of the divine majesty is commanded, and idolatry is prohibited. In the second, faithful assertion of the divine truth is commanded, and perjury is prohibited. In the third, devout love of the divine goodness is commanded, and lack of devotion is prohibited. In the fourth, piety toward parents is commanded, and dishonor is prohibited. In the fifth, meekness is commanded, and wrath is prohibited. In the sixth, chastity is commanded, and adultery is prohibited. In the seventh, generosity is commanded, and theft is prohibited. In the eighth, truthfulness is commanded, and lying is prohibited. In the ninth, liberality of heart is commanded, and concupiscence for temporal things is prohibited. In the tenth, purity of mind is commanded, and concupiscence of the flesh is prohibited.
See that all the precepts contain within themselves affirmation and negation, and that in every precept there is life and good, death and evil. In the observance of the commandments there is life and good, and in transgression there is death and evil. And from the observance of the law follows blessing, and from transgression, cursing. For from the observance of the law a man becomes reverent, faithful, devout, pious, meek, chaste, generous, truthful, content with his own possessions — that is, liberal in heart and undefiled in mind. On the contrary, from the transgression of the law a man becomes an idolater, a blasphemer, undevout, impious, a murderer, an adulterer, a thief, a liar, covetous, and carnal. Therefore the transgressor of the law and the observer are more distant from one another than hell is from paradise, because the one is at the center and the other is at the circumference; nor can the God of heaven do otherwise, because He is just and "cannot deny Himself."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Give ear, O heavens, while I speak; let the earth hearken to the words of my mouth! May my instruction soak in like the rain, and my discourse permeate like the dew, like a downpour upon the grass, like a shower upon the crops." This dew is the influence of the Holy Spirit's grace which visits the Scriptures and in which it is sweetly found.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the first word: You shall not have strange gods before me, all profane pacts with demons are prohibited, whether they be made through incantations of words, or through inscriptions of characters or images, or through immolations of sacrifices. All these Augustine calls pacts with demons, because in such things there is attributed to the creature what ought to be attributed to the Creator; and therefore such persons sin against the first word of the commandment: You shall not have strange gods before me. Concerning such persons it is said in the canticle of Deuteronomy: They provoked him with strange gods, and stirred him to anger with him who was not God. Whence such persons fall into the hands of demons.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We see some who have been exalted by God, who nonetheless raise themselves up against God, saying: "Our hand is exalted, and God has not done all these things." Such men lose both the land of the living and the grace of the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"It is a nation without counsel and without prudence: would that they were wise and understood and foresaw their last things." He touches upon the three parts of intelligence, namely memory of things past, understanding of things present, and circumspection regarding things future. Whoever does not have this understanding cannot be set right. This understanding is the rule of moral circumspections with desire of heart and pursuit of work, so that a person may consider what is to be avoided, what is to be done, and what is to be awaited. For God gives this understanding, and it is a gift of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"It is a nation without counsel and without prudence: would that they were wise and understood and foresaw their last things." He touches upon the three parts of intelligence, namely memory of things past, understanding of things present, and circumspection regarding things future. Whoever does not have this understanding cannot be set right. This understanding is the rule of moral circumspections with desire of heart and pursuit of work, so that a person may consider what is to be avoided, what is to be done, and what is to be awaited. For God gives this understanding, and it is a gift of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the first, we proceed as follows and it is shown that the divine being is supremely one. And that this is so, faith and divine Scripture sufficiently proclaim, Exodus twenty: Your God is one God; and Deuteronomy thirty-two: See therefore that I alone am, and there is no other God besides me; and David in the Psalm: There shall not be in you a new god, nor shall you adore a foreign god: and divine Scripture sufficiently preaches this.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It must be said that this truth, that God is one, is a truth not only believable, but also intelligible: since it is necessary and certain not only from the testimony of Scripture and the illumination of grace, which is found in faith; but it is also certain from itself and from the testimony of creatures.
From itself, therefore: because the divine being, on account of its singular sublimity and sublime singularity, possesses unity in every way. For since God has every perfection in himself, and this in the highest degree and most excellently, he is shown to be one not only from the sublimity of nature and wisdom, power and goodness and influence and causality, but indeed from all his conditions and noble properties that are attributed to him in the highest degree. Hence all conditions attest to the unity of the supreme essence.
From the testimony of creatures also: because every creature, just as it has natural goodness, so also is shown to have unity. "For nothing can exist unless it is one," as Boethius and Augustine say, and as sense and intellect teach. Therefore, just as every creature by its goodness proclaims that in God there is true and supreme goodness, so by its unity it proclaims that the cause of all things is one in itself.
Nor does the diversity of things stand against this testimony. For every diversity of things is comprehended within one universe, which in itself is indeed finite and limited and perfect. But this would not be so unless that plurality were reduced to something in which there would be a stopping point: and therefore it is necessary that all things be reduced to one ultimate end and one first principle, otherwise there would be a regress to infinity. Therefore the very universe of things testifies that God is one: whence, just as it is impossible for one circumference to have, nor can one rationally conceive, any but one center, from which lines flow and to which they are reduced as to a terminus: so in one universe one cannot posit or understand anything but one God alone.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Finally, there is the ecstatic taste of sweet contemplation. It is written: "Of the tribe of Benjamin, twelve thousand sealed." Benjamin, "the son of the right hand, the son of pain," in giving birth to whom Rachel died, and yet, Benjamin, "the best beloved of the Lord, as in a bride chamber shall he abide all the day." And this signifies the ecstatic excess of contemplation. The son of Jacob is not born to anything beyond this. Here is sleep with excess. No one attains this sealing unless he has gone through all the preceding ones.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, there arises from these twelve enlightenments a threefold fruit. From the first four comes forth the fruit of grace, from the intermediate four, the fruit of righteousness, from the last four, the fruit of wisdom. These fruits are referred to in Deuteronomy: "To Joseph also he said: Of the blessing of the Lord be his land, of the fruits of heaven, and of the dew, and of the deep that lieth beneath. Of the fruits brought forth by the sun and the moon. Of the tops of the ancient mountains, of the fruits of the everlasting hills, and of the fruits of the earth, and of the fullness thereof." And so these fruits come forth from Christ, blessed by Joseph who produced fruit of heaven, and of the dew, and of the deep that lieth beneath, that is, the charismatic gifts of the graces, by means of dew on humble hearts. The fruits of the sun and the moon and the tops of the mountains refer to the exercise of perfect righteousness which consists in this, that man trains himself to fulfill God's commands, according to his condition of being a subject, a prelate, or a contemplative. By the fruits of the everlasting hills, wisdom is understood, or the fruit of wisdom, which consist in the contemplation of eternal reasons and the consideration of lofty heavenly spirits. The fruits of the earth refer to the consideration of the divine condescensions in the orders of the Churches. Their fullness is seen as the conjunction of both Churches, the militant and the triumphant.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence, if charity is patient, long-suffering and good, then it "shall suck as milk the abundance of the sea." In this way did Lawrence rejoice over the glowing embers as if they had been flowers. These fruits are in the spirit, not in the flesh.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Do not turn aside from the law; so that you may understand all that you do." Prudential understanding teaches what is to be carried out, namely every good, according to the way of interior thought and exterior action. God wills that we do all things reasonably. And blessed Ambrose says that we ought neither to do nor to speak anything about that for which we cannot give a reason.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because the Holy Spirit brought together these articles of faith, contained in the depths of the Scriptures, into one through the twelve Apostles as through the most steadfast witnesses: hence it is that the aforesaid articles were collected into the one Creed of the Apostles. And therefore, according to the Apostles who composed it, they can be called twelve articles, because each Apostle, for the building up of the faith, set down one article as one living stone: which the Holy Spirit rightly prefigured in the twelve men who drew twelve stones from the bed of the Jordan for the construction of the altar of the Lord.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"God made the two great lights, the smaller light to rule the night," that is, the Old Testament, "and the greater one to rule the day," that is, the New Testament. As the moon receives its light from the sun, so does the Old Testament from the New. And so when the sun stands in the east, and the moon on the opposite side in the west — "Stand still, O sun, at Gabaon, O moon, in the valley of Aialon!" said Josue — then is the Old Testament lighted up: it cannot shine, except by means of the New.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A figure preceded in the fleece and dew of Gideon. The history is that Gideon asked of the Lord that the dew falling would be entirely on the fleece, and the threshing floor would remain dry; and he filled a basin with dew. Who brought it about that the Virgin conceived? Certainly the Holy Spirit, who is a love fervent, fruitful, undefiled, virile, incorrupt, and deifying. That he is an undefiled love is signified in the completed fleece, because the dew did not soil the fleece but cleansed it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This was marked in the case of Gedeon where those who were tested by the water, that is, those who lapped it like dogs, fought the battle and won, while those who bent their knee to drink were turned away. And those who had won the test were given trumpets and pitchers and lanterns, and they obtained the victory by means of blaring horns and clanging vessels. These are the preachers of the Church who in their preaching make a blaring of horns. The vessels are the bodies, the lanterns are the miracles. Indeed, every time they died for the sake of truth, they repelled and overcame the enemy by means of miracles. But those who drink by lapping with their tongues like dogs, who draw only a little water with their tongues, are those who take little from philosophy; while those who bent their knee to drink are those who inclined themselves totally to it: and the same are inclined to an infinite number of errors.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This was marked in the case of Gedeon where those who were tested by the water, that is, those who lapped it like dogs, fought the battle and won, while those who bent their knee to drink were turned away. And those who had won the test were given trumpets and pitchers and lanterns, and they obtained the victory by means of blaring horns and clanging vessels. These are the preachers of the Church who in their preaching make a blaring of horns. The vessels are the bodies, the lanterns are the miracles. Indeed, every time they died for the sake of truth, they repelled and overcame the enemy by means of miracles. But those who drink by lapping with their tongues like dogs, who draw only a little water with their tongues, are those who take little from philosophy; while those who bent their knee to drink are those who inclined themselves totally to it: and the same are inclined to an infinite number of errors.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is said that Samson, according to the instruction of the Angel, did not permit a razor to come upon his head; but his hair grew, and he became the strongest of men. It was a wondrous thing that with his hair he was strong, and without hair he became weak. Delilah the harlot deceived him: she asked him where his strength lay. Four times she asked him, and the fourth time he told her the truth, but the first three times he concealed the truth from her. The first time he said: "If I am bound with seven cords of sinew," I shall be like other men; and when he was bound and the Philistines came upon him to seize him, he immediately broke the cords. Again she asked him where his strength lay, and he said: "If I am bound with seven new ropes that have not yet been put to use," I shall be like other men. The third time he said to her: "If you fasten seven locks of my hair into the ground with a pin," I shall be like other men. The fourth time he revealed the truth to her and said: "If you shave the seven locks of hair that are on my head, I shall be like other men"; and then the Philistines seized him. What does this mean? — I say that the shaving of the hair signifies the withdrawal of the sevenfold grace of the Holy Spirit. Concerning all the Saints it is clear that, as long as the grace of the Holy Spirit remained with them, they were strong. — Why did he not tell her where his strength lay? See, in the loss of the Holy Spirit there is this progression; by this path the Holy Spirit is lost. There are four enticements of the senses, namely preoccupation, cogitation, the bending of the interior affections, and the assault upon the divine laws. In the last the Holy Spirit is lost, but in the others a man is disposed toward this. First the devil offers sensory pleasures; and this is to be bound with "seven cords of sinew." Afterward, when a man lingers in thoughts upon the pleasure offered, then he is bound with "seven new ropes that have not yet been put to use." Next follows the bending of the affections: just as from a multitude of rays heat is generated, so when there is manifold cogitation in the soul, the soul is bent toward that thing; and this is signified by the binding of the hair with a pin in the ground. Still the man does not lose the Holy Spirit. But fourthly follows the assault upon the divine laws, when the hair of the head is shaved off, that is, when the grace of the Holy Spirit is withdrawn.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is said that Samson, according to the instruction of the Angel, did not permit a razor to come upon his head; but his hair grew, and he became the strongest of men. It was a wondrous thing that with his hair he was strong, and without hair he became weak. Delilah the harlot deceived him: she asked him where his strength lay. Four times she asked him, and the fourth time he told her the truth, but the first three times he concealed the truth from her. The first time he said: "If I am bound with seven cords of sinew," I shall be like other men; and when he was bound and the Philistines came upon him to seize him, he immediately broke the cords. Again she asked him where his strength lay, and he said: "If I am bound with seven new ropes that have not yet been put to use," I shall be like other men. The third time he said to her: "If you fasten seven locks of my hair into the ground with a pin," I shall be like other men. The fourth time he revealed the truth to her and said: "If you shave the seven locks of hair that are on my head, I shall be like other men"; and then the Philistines seized him. What does this mean? — I say that the shaving of the hair signifies the withdrawal of the sevenfold grace of the Holy Spirit. Concerning all the Saints it is clear that, as long as the grace of the Holy Spirit remained with them, they were strong. — Why did he not tell her where his strength lay? See, in the loss of the Holy Spirit there is this progression; by this path the Holy Spirit is lost. There are four enticements of the senses, namely preoccupation, cogitation, the bending of the interior affections, and the assault upon the divine laws. In the last the Holy Spirit is lost, but in the others a man is disposed toward this. First the devil offers sensory pleasures; and this is to be bound with "seven cords of sinew." Afterward, when a man lingers in thoughts upon the pleasure offered, then he is bound with "seven new ropes that have not yet been put to use." Next follows the bending of the affections: just as from a multitude of rays heat is generated, so when there is manifold cogitation in the soul, the soul is bent toward that thing; and this is signified by the binding of the hair with a pin in the ground. Still the man does not lose the Holy Spirit. But fourthly follows the assault upon the divine laws, when the hair of the head is shaved off, that is, when the grace of the Holy Spirit is withdrawn.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is said that Samson, according to the instruction of the Angel, did not permit a razor to come upon his head; but his hair grew, and he became the strongest of men. It was a wondrous thing that with his hair he was strong, and without hair he became weak. Delilah the harlot deceived him: she asked him where his strength lay. Four times she asked him, and the fourth time he told her the truth, but the first three times he concealed the truth from her. The first time he said: "If I am bound with seven cords of sinew," I shall be like other men; and when he was bound and the Philistines came upon him to seize him, he immediately broke the cords. Again she asked him where his strength lay, and he said: "If I am bound with seven new ropes that have not yet been put to use," I shall be like other men. The third time he said to her: "If you fasten seven locks of my hair into the ground with a pin," I shall be like other men. The fourth time he revealed the truth to her and said: "If you shave the seven locks of hair that are on my head, I shall be like other men"; and then the Philistines seized him. What does this mean? — I say that the shaving of the hair signifies the withdrawal of the sevenfold grace of the Holy Spirit. Concerning all the Saints it is clear that, as long as the grace of the Holy Spirit remained with them, they were strong. — Why did he not tell her where his strength lay? See, in the loss of the Holy Spirit there is this progression; by this path the Holy Spirit is lost. There are four enticements of the senses, namely preoccupation, cogitation, the bending of the interior affections, and the assault upon the divine laws. In the last the Holy Spirit is lost, but in the others a man is disposed toward this. First the devil offers sensory pleasures; and this is to be bound with "seven cords of sinew." Afterward, when a man lingers in thoughts upon the pleasure offered, then he is bound with "seven new ropes that have not yet been put to use." Next follows the bending of the affections: just as from a multitude of rays heat is generated, so when there is manifold cogitation in the soul, the soul is bent toward that thing; and this is signified by the binding of the hair with a pin in the ground. Still the man does not lose the Holy Spirit. But fourthly follows the assault upon the divine laws, when the hair of the head is shaved off, that is, when the grace of the Holy Spirit is withdrawn.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is said that Samson, according to the instruction of the Angel, did not permit a razor to come upon his head; but his hair grew, and he became the strongest of men. It was a wondrous thing that with his hair he was strong, and without hair he became weak. Delilah the harlot deceived him: she asked him where his strength lay. Four times she asked him, and the fourth time he told her the truth, but the first three times he concealed the truth from her. The first time he said: "If I am bound with seven cords of sinew," I shall be like other men; and when he was bound and the Philistines came upon him to seize him, he immediately broke the cords. Again she asked him where his strength lay, and he said: "If I am bound with seven new ropes that have not yet been put to use," I shall be like other men. The third time he said to her: "If you fasten seven locks of my hair into the ground with a pin," I shall be like other men. The fourth time he revealed the truth to her and said: "If you shave the seven locks of hair that are on my head, I shall be like other men"; and then the Philistines seized him. What does this mean? — I say that the shaving of the hair signifies the withdrawal of the sevenfold grace of the Holy Spirit. Concerning all the Saints it is clear that, as long as the grace of the Holy Spirit remained with them, they were strong. — Why did he not tell her where his strength lay? See, in the loss of the Holy Spirit there is this progression; by this path the Holy Spirit is lost. There are four enticements of the senses, namely preoccupation, cogitation, the bending of the interior affections, and the assault upon the divine laws. In the last the Holy Spirit is lost, but in the others a man is disposed toward this. First the devil offers sensory pleasures; and this is to be bound with "seven cords of sinew." Afterward, when a man lingers in thoughts upon the pleasure offered, then he is bound with "seven new ropes that have not yet been put to use." Next follows the bending of the affections: just as from a multitude of rays heat is generated, so when there is manifold cogitation in the soul, the soul is bent toward that thing; and this is signified by the binding of the hair with a pin in the ground. Still the man does not lose the Holy Spirit. But fourthly follows the assault upon the divine laws, when the hair of the head is shaved off, that is, when the grace of the Holy Spirit is withdrawn.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“After the judgment of binding follows another judgment, namely the judgment of blinding, which is figured in the book of Judges, where it is said that the Philistines, when they had captured Samson, gouged out his eyes and made him grind at the mill. For from sin man has darkness in his mind, such that he considers nothing to be sin; he thinks light to be darkness and darkness to be light, because his spiritual eyes have been blinded.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The blessed Virgin is venerative and restorative of the honor taken from God, and a mother consenting that Christ be offered as the price. Therefore "she shall be praised." Anna was praised because she offered Samuel: whence it is said of her: "The woman went her way and ate, and her countenance was no longer changed." She offered her son to serve: but the blessed Virgin offered her son to be sacrificed. Abraham, you wished to offer your son, but you offered a ram! But the glorious Virgin offered her own son.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the Canticle of Anna it is said in the book of Kings: "Let the old things depart from your mouth, for the Lord is the God of sciences, and to Him thoughts are prepared;" not foolish thoughts, which are scattered along the ways of errors, but good thoughts are prepared for the Lord along the ways of truth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The exercise of the gift of piety consists in the abundance of interior compassion. Of this it is said in Ecclesiasticus: "These are men of mercy, whose acts of piety have not failed." So it was with Samuel, when the people sought a king; afterwards the people recognized that Samuel had governed the people well, and when the people had sinned, they feared that Samuel would not want to pray to the Lord for them. And the people asked him to pray for them, and Samuel said: "Far be it from me that I should cease to pray for you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The exercise of the gift of piety consists in the abundance of interior compassion. Of this it is said in Ecclesiasticus: "These are men of mercy, whose acts of piety have not failed." Of how great piety was David, king of Israel! Saul was seeking to kill him, and David had Saul in his hand: he could have killed him, with God not prohibiting it, because God said to him: "I will deliver him into your hands." He could have killed him, with no man prohibiting it, nor the law prohibiting it; and yet he spared him and his house. These therefore are men of mercy, whose acts of piety did not fail.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On 2 Kings 6, upon the text: Michal, the daughter of Saul, looking out, saw King David leaping and dancing, and she despised him in her heart; Gregory says: "Behold, the one whom the Lord singularly preferred above all others despises himself before the Lord by making himself equal to the least and by exhibiting what is abject. The power of kingship is not recalled to memory; he does not fear to become vile in the eyes of his subjects by dancing. What others may think of these deeds, I do not know; I am more amazed at David dancing than at David fighting: by fighting he conquered his enemy, but by dancing before the Lord he conquered himself." If, therefore, to conquer oneself is a work of perfect virtue, and this is accomplished through self-abasement: therefore self-abasement is a work of perfect virtue.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A little further on in the same place: I will play and become yet more vile, etc.; upon which Gregory says: "As if he were openly saying: I desire to become vile before men, because I seek to keep myself noble before God through humility." If, therefore, to be noble before God is nothing other than to be perfect, and self-abasement makes one noble before God: therefore it is an act of perfect virtue.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Bernard calls this humiliation the vilification of oneself; whence he adds: "I will play and become yet more vile, I will play, that is, so that I may be mocked. A good game, at which Michal grows angry, but God is delighted; a good game, which provides a laughingstock indeed to men, but a spectacle to the Angels; a good game, I say, in which we are made a reproach to the affluent and a contempt to the proud. With this chaste and devout game he was playing who said: We are made a spectacle to this world and to Angels and to men. With this game let us also play in the meantime, that we may be mocked and confounded and humbled, until he comes who casts down the mighty and exalts the humble, who will make us glad, exalt us, and glorify us for eternity."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The same is seen also in the example of Solomon who asked, not for gold and silver, but for an understanding heart: and so it was given to him. Hence James: "If any of you is wanting in wisdom, let him ask it of God, who gives abundantly to all men, and does not reproach; and it will be given to him. But let him ask with faith, without hesitation." For one who hesitates is not disciplined.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All men want to be wise and knowing. Yet, soon it happens that the woman deceives the man. But wisdom is the higher, being noble, while knowing is the lower: yet she seems beautiful to man, and he seeks to be joined to her, and his spirit tends to the things that can be known and experienced, and he wills to know them, and to experience the things he knows, and consequently to be united to them. And in this way he is weakened like Solomon who sought to know all things, "and he treated about trees from the cedar that is in Libanus, unto hyssop." And he forgets about the most important, and thus turns to the vain. Therefore passing from knowing to wisdom is not assured: a means must be placed in between, that is, holiness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is yet another distinction based upon the elevation and the different levels of ecclesiastics. Now, it is fitting that this distinction be ordained "with three rows of polished stones." Indeed, among the levels, some are cleansing, others enlightening, and others again uniting.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, Third Kings, chapter eight: If heaven and the heavens of heavens cannot contain you, how much more this house which I have built? If therefore the being of God can be contained by nothing and circumscribed by nothing, it must be acknowledged that it has entirely the character of the infinite.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the beauty of Wisdom is wondrous, and no one looks upon her without admiration and ecstasy, as it is said of Esther and of Solomon, for "all the earth desired to see Solomon's face"; and the Queen of Sheba "came from the ends of the earth to hear the wisdom of Solomon"; and when she saw "the order of his ministers, and their apparel, and the cupbearers, and the holocausts, which he offered in the house of the Lord: she had no longer any spirit in her."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the beauty of Wisdom is wondrous, and no one looks upon her without admiration and ecstasy, as it is said of Esther and of Solomon, for "all the earth desired to see Solomon's face"; and the Queen of Sheba "came from the ends of the earth to hear the wisdom of Solomon"; and when she saw "the order of his ministers, and their apparel, and the cupbearers, and the holocausts, which he offered in the house of the Lord: she had no longer any spirit in her."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There are seven orders arranged by degrees up to the priesthood, in which is the standing of the orders, because it belongs to the priesthood to consecrate the Sacrament of the body of Christ, in which is the fullness of all graces; whence the other six are as it were subordinate and like certain steps by which one ascends to the throne of Solomon; and they are six on account of the perfection of the number, because six is the first perfect number, and because the perfection and sufficiency of the office of ministering so requires. For it is necessary that some minister as if from a more remote position, some from a nearer, and some from the nearest, so that nothing is lacking in the ordered ministry.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The seventh and last column of wisdom is simplicity in intention. Concerning this it is said that "King Solomon made a great throne of ivory," and he made in it "six steps." The other columns are round about, but this one is the most principal and at the summit. The Apostle speaks saying: "Seek the things that are above;" and in Ecclesiastes: "What has the wise man more than the fool, and what has the poor man, except to go thither where life is?" Surely, where Christ is, and when Christ shall appear, life shall appear.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Just as God completed the whole world in six days and rested on the seventh, so the lesser world may be led in most orderly fashion through six stages of successive illuminations to the repose of contemplation. As a figure of this, one ascended by six steps to the throne of Solomon; the Seraphim that Isaiah saw had six wings; after six days the Lord called Moses from the midst of the cloud, and Christ after six days, as is said in Matthew, led the disciples up the mountain and was transfigured before them.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These six considerations having therefore been traversed, as if they were the six steps of the throne of the true Solomon, by which one arrives at peace, where the true peaceful one rests in a peaceful mind as in an interior Jerusalem; and as if also the six wings of the Cherub, by which the mind of the true contemplative, filled with the illumination of supernal wisdom, may be borne upward; and as if also the first six days, in which the mind must be exercised, so that it may at last arrive at the sabbath of rest; after our mind has contemplated God outside itself through vestiges and in the vestiges, within itself through the image and in the image, above itself through the similitude of the divine light shining upon us and in that light itself, insofar as is possible according to the state of wayfaring and the exercise of our mind; when at last in the sixth step it has arrived at this point, that it contemplates in the first and highest principle and the mediator of God and men, Jesus Christ, those things whose likenesses can in no way be found in creatures, and which exceed all keenness of the human intellect: it remains that, in contemplating these things, it should transcend and pass beyond not only this sensible world, but also itself; in which passing over, Christ is the way and the door, Christ is the ladder and the vehicle, as it were the mercy seat placed upon the ark of God and the mystery hidden from the ages.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the beauty of Wisdom is wondrous, and no one looks upon her without admiration and ecstasy, as it is said of Esther and of Solomon, for "all the earth desired to see Solomon's face"; and the Queen of Sheba "came from the ends of the earth to hear the wisdom of Solomon"; and when she saw "the order of his ministers, and their apparel, and the cupbearers, and the holocausts, which he offered in the house of the Lord: she had no longer any spirit in her."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He affirms that this ascent comes about through the power and the strongest motion of the Holy Spirit, as it is said of Elias: "A great and strong wind overthrowing the mountains, and breaking the rocks in pieces." It is not for us to have this fire within our power; but if God gives it from above, it is the priest's duty to nourish it and to throw wood on it by means of prayer.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second flow from the light of faith is the zeal of truth, so that a man be aroused with indignation against anything evil or false and be immediately attracted to anything good. Let him despise every wickedness, like Elias, who foretold about Achab and Jezabel that hounds would devour them. Achab said: "Hast thou found me thy enemy?" And Elias replied: "I have found thee because thou art sold, to do evil in the sight of the Lord," as if he were saying, "Anyone who is against God is against me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning this oil of piety it is said in the fourth book of Kings that a certain woman came to Elisha and said that her creditors wished to take her children; and she said: "My husband was a man who feared God." And Elisha said that she should bring all the vessels of her neighbors and pour some of that oil into each one, until all were filled. Why did he command her to bring the vessels of her neighbors? Could he not have multiplied the oil and filled a single jar, so that the woman would not have labored so much? I say that the woman holds the type of the Church, and Elisha holds the type of Christ. When the Church is poor in merits and it is necessary that she repay the debt: by what means will she repay? She must fill the vessels of her neighbors. Do you wish the piety of mother Church to descend upon you? Fill the vessels of your neighbors. This oil of piety ought to be possessed by all.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of prophetical revelation, Christ is symbolized by sign, as with Eliseus and Giezi who laid the staff on the child, who did not rise, and then Eliseus himself lay upon him. According to Gregory, this points to the Law and to Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such cupidity must be tamed by munificence, which includes generosity and magnificence. It is the fountain which pours out water: for the fountain does not keep water within. According to the Philosopher, it is hard to be completely cured from cupidity, for cupidity is delightful in that it makes a man imagine himself to be great, and makes others believe that he is. If a man indulges in excesses, his brain suffers: but a man rejoices in riches because they lead to presumption and reputation. And so, such cupidity infected Giezi, and he became a leper because he ran after Naaman. Even today those who practice simony consider it quite the right thing. Simon came to Peter and said to him: "Accept some money: I have enough. Grant that I may give the Holy Spirit through the laying of hands." But Peter did not consider it right, nor did he have any patience: "Thy money," he said, "go to destruction with thee."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens in a circle, as, for instance, when it advises us not to flee, because we have protection all around. For we have the Lord and angels about us, wherefore the Psalm: Mountains are round about Jerusalem; so the Lord is round about His people. To the servant of Eliseus who cried out because of the Syrian robbers who sought to capture him, Eliseus said: "Lord, open his eyes, that he may see." And the Lord opened the eyes of the servant, and he saw. And behold the mountain was full of horses, and chariots of fire round about Eliseus. Jacob too, afraid of his brother, saw the angels and said: "This is the encampment of God." Wherefore the Psalm says: The Lord is my light and my salvation; whom should I fear? And in another passage: Had not the Lord been with us, let Israel say, etc., until the end.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the sixth time, three events came about: the height of victory, of teaching, and of prophecy. The height of victory occurred with Sennacherib who rose against Jerusalem, and "an angel of the Lord slew a hundred and eighty-five thousand." Yet Ezechias was healed in a manner that opposed the laws of nature, and the sun went backwards. Likewise, in the time from Hadrian through that of Charlemagne who miraculously brought about triumphal victories as if he were an angel sent by the Lord, and the sun, to wit, the tide of tribulations, receded, and there came about the peace of the Church which was later to set up archbishops, bishops and the religious way of life.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But who will deliver us from these plagues? Certainly there is one alone who came to deliver us, namely Christ, who made ten condescensions against the ten plagues. This is prefigured in the book of Kings, where it is said that the sun went back ten degrees, by which are signified the ten condescensions that the Lord made for the sake of man.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the sixth time, three events came about: the height of victory, of teaching, and of prophecy. The height of victory occurred with Sennacherib who rose against Jerusalem, and "an angel of the Lord slew a hundred and eighty-five thousand." Yet Ezechias was healed in a manner that opposed the laws of nature, and the sun went backwards. Likewise, in the time from Hadrian through that of Charlemagne who miraculously brought about triumphal victories as if he were an angel sent by the Lord, and the sun, to wit, the tide of tribulations, receded, and there came about the peace of the Church which was later to set up archbishops, bishops and the religious way of life.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The soul is disposed to the gift of fortitude through the unconquerable shield of faith. If we loved truth, we would not fear the devil, because it is written: "The eyes of the Lord behold the whole earth and give fortitude to those who believe in him with a perfect heart."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Another particle of the perfection of the fear of the Lord consists in perfect promptitude of obedience. Hence in the book of Chronicles: "Let the fear of the Lord be with you, and do all things with diligence": as if to say: do not be sluggish or negligent, because it is written in Ecclesiastes: "He who fears God neglects nothing." If I believed that a thief was going to enter my chamber and carry off my treasure, I would not leave the window open. You must always fear God, because he who "keeps the whole law but offends in one point has become guilty of all."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third evil counselor is he who leads what is certain into doubt. Whence it is said in Ezra that certain ones who were from across the river came to the Jews and said: 'Who gave you counsel to build this house and restore its walls?' The Jews had the counsels of God and of the prophets; yet those from across the river came to give counsel, though they did not know what was being done in Jerusalem. Some do not know what is done in religious life, and yet they wish to give counsel and say to one wishing to enter: 'What do you wish to do? Attend to the divine good pleasure: It is better to be in the will of God than in the hand of counsel.' By this way, if you wish to wait until the Lord reveals it to you, and you do not wish to do what Holy Scripture and holy men tell you, and what Christ inspires in you, you will always be able to be at a crossroads.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The blessed Virgin possesses that price, because she is strong and valiant, sublimely reigning. Whence in Esther it is said that Esther found grace before Ahasuerus above all women, and he placed a diadem upon her head and made her queen. The blessed Virgin on account of her sanctity, piety, and sublimity had a crown of precious stone. Who is this stone? Certainly Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the tropological sense, the sun has four faces. The first is the grace of the Holy Spirit, as in Esther: "The light and the sun rose up: and the humble were exalted," that is, when God lives in us through grace. Hence, as the sun sheds its light continuously, so must the soul continuously receive illuminations from the grace of the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is a reading in the Book of Esther: "The little fountain grew into a river, and was turned into a light, and into the sun, and abounded into many waters." Scripture was a "little fountain" at the time of the giving of the Law, for the book containing the commandments of the Law is small; but later it grew into an immense river in the books of Josue, Judges, Kings, Esdras, Judith, Tobias, Esther and the Macchabees. Then, it was "turned into light," that is, the light of the Prophets, for prophecy is light; then again, "into the sun," that is, in the Gospels. And many interpretations were drawn from it, and in that sense, it may be said that it "abounded into many waters."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And in Esther it is said: "I saw you, Lord, as an Angel of God, and my heart was troubled by fear of your glory; for you are exceedingly wonderful, Lord, and your face is full of graces." An Angel sees and surveys all things, approves the good and rejects the evil; likewise, an Angel loves the good and hates the evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third middle way is fortitude, which is concerned with fears and acts of valor. A man needs it in order to be neither fainthearted nor rash, but that he be able to bear frightful trials and even death. For some men do fall into cowardice and faintheartedness. Hence, in Job: "Have I the strength of stones, or is my flesh of bronze?" And so, fortitude is in the soul, not in the flesh. Better is the patient spirit than the lofty spirit. And Proverbs say: A patient man is better than a warrior, and he that rules his temper, than he who takes a city. Hence a spiritual man must take great care to avoid dejection.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, Gregory, in the Moralia, on that passage of Job: I have numbered for myself laborious nights: "The elect serve the Creator of all things and are often straitened by want of things; they cling to God through love, and yet they lack the supports of the present life." To lack the supports of the present life, therefore, is fitting to the perfection of the Saints.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But if you ask how these things come about, ask grace, not doctrine; desire, not understanding; the groaning of prayer, not the study of reading; the Bridegroom, not the master; God, not man; darkness, not clarity; not light, but the fire that wholly inflames and carries into God through ecstatic anointings and most ardent affections. Which fire is indeed God, and his furnace is in Jerusalem, and Christ kindles this in the fervor of his most ardent passion, which only he truly perceives who says: My soul has chosen hanging, and my bones death. Whoever loves this death can see God, because it is indubitably true: No man shall see me and live. Let us die, therefore, and enter into the darkness; let us impose silence upon our cares, concupiscences, and phantasms; let us pass over with Christ crucified from this world to the Father, so that, when the Father is shown to us, we may say with Philip: It suffices us; let us hear with Paul: My grace suffices for you; let us exult with David, saying: My flesh and my heart have failed, God of my heart and God my portion forever. Blessed be the Lord forever, and let all the people say: So be it, so be it. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Anyone who wishes to obtain advantages from his studies should be holy and should work for a life that is reverent, pure, religious, and edifying. Now the reverent life of the saints consists in this, that in anything they do, they be always in a state of fear, whether going to Mass or to table, whether walking or standing still, for in anything there is a possibility of sin. "Then I am in dread of all my pains; I know that you will not hold me innocent." The best sign is fear, and the worst, temerity, for such is never corrected.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Friendship with God man could not recover except through a fitting mediator, who could lay his hand upon both and be conformed to each party and a friend to each, and therefore, as he is like God through his Divinity, so like man through his humanity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The authority of the one commanding ought to move us to observe the commandments of God: because it is God who commands that the precepts be observed. For He is of great authority, which is evident from three things: first, because He Himself by His great power creates us; second, because by His wondrous wisdom He rules and governs us; third, because by His munificent benevolence He saves us.
He who commands that the commandments of God be observed is of great authority, because by His great power He creates us. "Your hands have made me and fashioned me wholly round about."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The height of faith consists in understanding the eternal God, its depth, in knowing God made man. Of the first, it is written: "It is higher than the heavens; what can you do?" Concerning the second, there is added: "It is deeper than the nether world; what can you know?" The depth of God made man, that is, the humility, is such that reason fails. The height of God is beyond investigation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Who will have the gift of fortitude? All now flee for a trifle, for the loss of some small temporal thing, or some slight advantage; and why? Because they do not have fortitude. But Job himself says: "The just man will hold to his way." The way of Christ himself is that a man walk purely and with fortitude.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is necessary that a judge have clarity of knowledge. How would I judge well concerning an unknown matter? Hence when the friends of Job argued against him that he was not just, saying: A just God does not punish the just, and yet He punishes you, therefore you are not just—they wished to judge concerning hidden things. Job, hearing these things, responded to them saying: "Turn back and come, and I shall not find among you any wise man."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of the Lord arises in us from the consideration of the perspicacity of divine wisdom. Whence Job: "For he alone is, and no one can turn away his thoughts. And therefore I am troubled at his presence, and when I consider him, I am made fearful with dread." He alone is, that is, from himself alone he has being, and all other things are from him. And just as all things flow from the first being, so God is the cause of all things. Therefore, if God is the cause of all things, there is no creature that is not naked in his eyes, because he himself sees and beholds the thoughts of men. Therefore Job, in the person of a man considering the divine wisdom that weighs all things, says: "Considering him, I am troubled with fear." Therefore man ought greatly to consider what he thinks, what he speaks, and what he does, because God sees all things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of the Lord arises in us from the consideration of the perspicacity of divine wisdom. "And therefore I am troubled at his presence, and when I consider him, I am made fearful with dread." If God is the cause of all things, there is no creature that is not naked in his eyes, because he himself sees and beholds the thoughts of men. Therefore Job, in the person of a man considering the divine wisdom that weighs all things, says: "Considering him, I am troubled with fear." Therefore man ought greatly to consider what he thinks, what he speaks, and what he does, because God sees all things. Whence Boethius in the book On the Consolation says: "A great necessity of uprightness is imposed upon you, if you are unwilling to dissemble, since you do all things in the sight of a judge who discerns all things."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Job raises the question of where wisdom may be found; and he answers negatively, that it is not found by a man living in a merely human manner, saying: 'Man does not know its price, nor is it found in the land of those who live pleasantly.' That last statement gives the reason: this is the cause why the carnal man does not know the price of wisdom, because the carnal man does not perceive the savor of wisdom; nor can a man know wisdom unless he finds its savor; and he does not find savor in it if he lives delicately, because carnal delights cannot coexist with wisdom. Who can say: 'I am more than a man?' It is true that wisdom is drawn from the hidden things of mysteries. It happens that a preacher pours out wisdom to others and tastes it and makes others taste it; but sometimes he is like a channel, making others taste it, and he himself does not know what it is: it profits him little, and those who hear him, unless they are of good disposition.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Job raises the question of where wisdom may be found; and he answers negatively, that it is not found by a man living in a merely human manner, saying: 'Man does not know its price, nor is it found in the land of those who live pleasantly.' That last statement gives the reason: this is the cause why the carnal man does not know the price of wisdom, because the carnal man does not perceive the savor of wisdom; nor can a man know wisdom unless he finds its savor; and he does not find savor in it if he lives delicately, because carnal delights cannot coexist with wisdom. Who can say: 'I am more than a man?' It is true that wisdom is drawn from the hidden things of mysteries. It happens that a preacher pours out wisdom to others and tastes it and makes others taste it; but sometimes he is like a channel, making others taste it, and he himself does not know what it is: it profits him little, and those who hear him, unless they are of good disposition.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That piety is the worship of God, Job says: "Behold, piety itself is wisdom." Another translation has: "Behold, fear, that itself is wisdom"; but in the Septuagint translation it reads: "Behold, piety itself is wisdom." And Augustine says that piety in Greek is the same as theosebia, which is the same as the worship of God. The worship of God, moreover, consists chiefly in reverence for God, which is not had without fear. For it is necessary for a worshiper of God to think of God most loftily, most devoutly, with reverence and fear.
If you think diminishingly of the power of God, namely that he cannot create all things from nothing: you do not think most highly. Similarly, if you think diminishingly of the wisdom of God, namely that through his wisdom he cannot penetrate the innermost things: you do not think most highly. Just as we have the testimony of light, that it not only shines in itself but can illuminate many other bodies, so God sees and illuminates all things, because he himself is light. If you think of God's power and of God's wisdom that he cannot restore bodies, whether badly or well: then you think wrongly of God and do not think most highly. Likewise, if you do not believe in the divine condescensions and mercies, through which God fills the creature serving him with grace, pardon, and beatitude: you are not a worshiper of God.
I say therefore that piety is nothing other than a pious sense, pious affection, and pious service toward the pious, first, and highest origin. The highest good cannot be possessed nor worshiped without piety. Naturally every thing tends toward its origin: a stone downward, and fire upward, and rivers run to the sea, a tree is joined to its root, and other things have continuity with their root. The rational creature is deiform, which can return upon its origin through memory, understanding, and will; and it is not pious unless it pours itself back upon its origin. Therefore I said that piety is nothing other than a pious sense, pious affection, and pious service toward the pious, first, and highest origin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Behold, the fear of the Lord is wisdom, and to depart from evil is prudence." Prudential understanding teaches what is to be avoided, namely every evil. Every person who wishes to be directed toward the good must fear God, so as to avoid every evil. Therefore prudential understanding teaches first what is to be avoided.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fear produces these three things in us, because "the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom," and "the root of wisdom is to fear God," and "the fullness of wisdom is to fear God": "Behold, the fear of the Lord, that itself is wisdom." He who does not fear God knows nothing. And because the fear of the Lord avails for these three things, namely for obtaining the influx of divine wisdom, for introducing the rectitude of divine justice, and for attaining the illumination of divine wisdom; therefore Ecclesiasticus says: "The fear of the Lord is like a paradise of blessing."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Gather together, then, these three considerations, namely the consideration of the sublimity of divine power, the consideration of the perspicacity of divine wisdom, and the consideration of the severity of divine vengeance. And who will there be who will not fear? Whence Job says: "I always feared God as though waves were swelling over me, and I could not bear his weight." If you were in a small ship, when waves were surging over the ship from every side, you could not flee, because the waves would be on every side; you could not hide, because you could not conceal yourself, as a man hides himself against lightning; you could not even resist, because you would have nothing that you could set against the wave. Gather these three together; if it were so for you, you would fear greatly.
And Job says: "I always feared God as though waves were swelling over me." And why? I cannot flee on account of the sublimity of divine power, because "if I ascend into heaven, thou art there; if I descend into hell, thou art present; if I take my wings at dawn and dwell in the uttermost parts of the sea, even there thy hand shall lead me, and thy right hand shall hold me." Likewise, I cannot hide on account of the perspicacity of divine wisdom, because God sees all things. Likewise, I cannot resist on account of the severity of divine vengeance, because he who sins is punished by eternal judgment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second mode of generation is by means of expression: as in the case of the species coming out of the object, the imprint out of the seal, the speech out of the speaker, or the concept or thought out of the mind. And in these, there is deficiency. In the first, the reality of the object is lacking, for the species in the eye or in the soul is not the reality of the thing. In the second, simplicity is lacking, for the image or figure does not consist in a point or in something simple, but has parts. In the third, permanence is lacking, for speech passes away and does not remain. In the fourth, substance is lacking, for the concept of the mind is neither a substance nor a hypostasis. Take away such defects, and suppose an expression like the species deriving from the object but having reality, like the imprint produced by the seal but having simplicity, like the word coming forth from the speaker but having permanence, like the concept proceeding from the mind but having substance: and then you have the first part of the mirror.
The Psalm refers to the first manner of expression: "My heart overflows with a goodly theme." And there follows: "Fairer in beauty are you than the sons of men." Wisdom refers to the second: "For she is the refulgence of eternal light, the spotless mirror of the power of God, the image of His goodness." And the Apostle: "He is the image of the invisible God." Job refers to the third: "God speaketh once, and repeateth not the selfsame thing the second time." Understand this as meaning "in the Son," in the sense that He always is, and will never cease to be nor even be changed. In the fourth manner of expression, suppose substantiality, for the concept of the eternal mind is a hypostasis, and this mental concept is most noble and perfect. Hence, in Proverbs: "When there were no depths I was brought forth." And so He is sometimes called the Word, the Species, the Image, the Word remaining forever, the Concept—not as existing within a mind, but as being substantial: a hypostasis. And in this way we have the other part of the mirror.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Do you know the paths of the clouds, the great paths and perfect sciences?" He says "great paths," that is, philosophical and theological knowledge, which are called "great paths," because they comprehend many sciences; he says "perfect paths" with respect to gratuitous and glorious knowledge. The "paths of the clouds" are the sciences of perfect men, because, just as clouds are drawn upward by the power of heat, so perfect men are elevated in the abstraction of the mind.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, there are in angels some virtues related to rational souls through which they govern men. Indeed, they are the conveyors of light and the uplifters of intelligences so that illuminations may be received. And so there is in them a conveying power, because they are a certain light and a certain transparency, and they temper the divine light within themselves for our sake, so that it may be proportioned to us. Secondly, there is in them an uplifting power through which they make us able, by condescending to us and raising us up, to receive this particular radiation, and yet not as achieving it themselves. Finally, there is in them a supreme power through which they turn themselves to God in the act of receiving splendors, and the eternal light they love; and all things lead back to this light in order that they may tend toward God through love and praise. Hence in Job: Where were you while the morning stars sang in chorus and all the sons of God shouted for joy? And all this corresponds with the philosophers' opinions. Again, by this very fact, the angels are to give thanks. When the soul sees all this, it becomes interior to the angels, and it enters their world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, there are in angels some virtues related to rational souls through which they govern men. Indeed, they are the conveyors of light and the uplifters of intelligences so that illuminations may be received. And so there is in them a conveying power, because they are a certain light and a certain transparency, and they temper the divine light within themselves for our sake, so that it may be proportioned to us. Secondly, there is in them an uplifting power through which they make us able, by condescending to us and raising us up, to receive this particular radiation, and yet not as achieving it themselves. Finally, there is in them a supreme power through which they turn themselves to God in the act of receiving splendors, and the eternal light they love; and all things lead back to this light in order that they may tend toward God through love and praise. Hence in Job: Where were you while the morning stars sang in chorus and all the sons of God shouted for joy? And all this corresponds with the philosophers' opinions. Again, by this very fact, the angels are to give thanks. When the soul sees all this, it becomes interior to the angels, and it enters their world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But by what way does grace descend into men? Job asks, saying: "By what way is light spread, and heat divided upon the earth?" I respond and say that grace descends upon rational minds through the Word incarnate, through the Word crucified, and through the Word inspired.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When the three virtues of faith, hope and love are included, they rise up to a series of seven symbolized by the seven stars, the seven women, and the seven loaves of the gospel: and this, in so far as they are resplendent, fecund and strengthening. Their luminosity is represented by the seven stars. Hence, in Job: Have you fitted a curb to the Pleiades, or loosened the bonds of Orion? The Pleiades are those seven stars joined together, commonly known as the Hen and its Chicks. These virtues bring about a stable orbit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the order of hope, concerning what we should expect, there is anagogy, and this in two ways: one in the skies, as in this passage: "Abram, look at the heavens and, if you can, count the stars." And that means the heavenly intelligences. Again, in Job: "Do you know the ordinances of the heavens; can you put into effect their plan on the earth?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third firmness of faith is found in the writings of the doctors and of those who were wise with the knowledge of things worldly or divine: Dionysius, Gregory Nazianzen, Gregory of Nyssa, the Damascene, Basil, Athanasius, Chrysostom. Among the Latins, Hilarion, Gregory, Augustine, Ambrose, Jerome. The writings of all these are in accord: they say the same thing, they have the same flavor. It is of these that Job says: Who can declare the order of the heavens? Or who can make the harmony of heaven to sleep? Such is the accord between Scriptures, the councils and the doctors.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence in Job: "Does the eagle fly up at your command to pass the night at his lofty nest?" And later: "Where the slain are, there is he." First, he speaks wonders of the eagle, and then humble things; and so it is with rapture. For the man ravished to the greatest height is also the most humble. And it must be so, for had he been proud, he could have lost grace and fallen into a reprobate sense.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence in Job: "Does the eagle fly up at your command to pass the night at his lofty nest?" And later: "Where the slain are, there is he." First, he speaks wonders of the eagle, and then humble things; and so it is with rapture. For the man ravished to the greatest height is also the most humble. And it must be so, for had he been proud, he could have lost grace and fallen into a reprobate sense.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the twelfth mystery, the opening of scriptures, the Antichrist is symbolized by the beast from the depth, the one that comes up out of the abyss, who will crush all things. For he will be consummate in every form of malice; he will have seven heads, that is, every kind of temptation and every method, working at times through riches, at other times through false miracles, at others again through fear. Hence in Job: "He carries his tail like a cedar," for in him every form of malice will be inflated. And as Christ enjoyed every charismatic gift in order that He be able to receive the assumed human nature, so also this one possessed every form of malice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When the devil saw Christ suffering, he believed His argument had little weight. But Christ ridiculed him: "Can you play with him as with a bird? Can you put him in leash for your maidens?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third judgment of God is the judgment of obstinacy, namely when the heart of man can be softened neither by promises nor by threats nor by scourges nor by torments. Of such a one it is said: "His heart shall be hardened as a stone." The wife of Lot was turned into stone. I would rather that my heart were turned into stone than that it should be so hardened.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“One should consider with fear what Job says of Behemoth-Leviathan: "He shall strew gold under him like mire." Through knowledge, temptation easily leads to ruin. "You will be like God, knowing good and evil." Wherefore some men want to search beyond the way of nature, that is, beyond contingent matters. Concerning the levels of pride, blessed Bernard says that the primary vice is inquisitiveness which brought about the fall of Lucifer. By this, too, Adam fell. The hunger for knowledge must be changed: wisdom and holiness must be preferred to it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Piety avails for avoiding all evils. Praise God and be angry against sin, and do not defend sin, because to defend sin is a twofold sin. It is noteworthy what the Psalm says: "Blessed is the man who has not walked in the counsel of the impious," by consenting to sin; "and has not stood in the way of sinners," by persisting in sin; "and has not sat in the chair of pestilence," by defending his sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence, meditation on the Law is supremely necessary. The Psalm reads: Happy the man who follows not the counsel of the wicked, but delights in the Law of the Lord. He is like a tree planted near running water. And Ecclesiasticus: The things that God hath commanded thee, think on them always, and in many of His works be not curious.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence, meditation on the Law is supremely necessary. The Psalm reads: Happy the man who follows not the counsel of the wicked, but delights in the Law of the Lord. He is like a tree planted near running water. And Ecclesiasticus: The things that God hath commanded thee, think on them always, and in many of His works be not curious.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence, meditation on the Law is supremely necessary. The Psalm reads: Happy the man who follows not the counsel of the wicked, but delights in the Law of the Lord. He is like a tree planted near running water. And Ecclesiasticus: The things that God hath commanded thee, think on them always, and in many of His works be not curious.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third mode of generation is by means of propagation, and this in a fourfold way: as of a growth coming from a seed, a tree from a root, a conceived offspring from the belly or womb of the mother, or children from a begetting father. In the first mode of generation, formal beauty is lacking, for in the seed the form is vague and hidden. It is not so in the case of the Son. In the second, conformity is lacking, for although there is a single root, it is different in shape from the branches even though they produce a single tree. In the third, actuality is lacking, for although the mother is in a certain sense the active principle of the offspring, yet she is much more of a passive principle. In the fourth, eternal coexistence is lacking.
Now, take away these defects and suppose first formal beauty. In this sense, there is Isaiah: "The branch of the Lord will be luster and glory, and the fruit of the earth will be honor and splendor." Second, suppose conformity: The Son conforms to the Father to the point that He is "the tree of life... in the midst of the garden." Hence, in Proverbs: "She is a tree of life to those who grasp her." Third, suppose actuality: in this sense, you have the Psalm: "With Thee is the principality in the day of Thy strength, in the brightness of the saints: from the womb before the day star I begot Thee. From the womb," says the Psalmist, which is in relation to the warmth of the Father's bosom, from which He does not withdraw. Fourth, suppose eternal coexistence. In this sense, there is the Psalm: "This day I have begotten You," that is in eternity, or in My eternal today.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of God avails for introducing the rectitude of divine justice. "The fear of the Lord drives out sin. For he who is without fear cannot be justified." Injustice does not enter the soul except through sin: but the first justification of the soul is that it be subject to the divine majesty. "If you do not hold yourself steadfastly in the fear of the Lord, your house will quickly be overturned." Consider David, who says: "Serve the Lord in fear, and rejoice in him with trembling."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"O sons of men, how long will you be heavy of heart? Why do you love vanity and seek after falsehood? And know that the Lord has made His Holy One wonderful: the Lord will hear me when I cry to Him. Be angry, and do not sin: for what you say in your hearts, upon your beds be moved to compunction." He who has true knowledge and knows God and sees that he does not walk rightly or perfectly is in continual sorrow, because he sees that his affections and thoughts are scattered. Augustine: "Knowledge begets mourning."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“God is said to see, because He makes us see. The first vision of the soul is by means of understanding naturally given. Hence in the Psalm: The light of Thy countenance, O Lord, is signed upon us. And here all the difficulties of philosophy could be explained.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Through the first vision, we understand that to which our intelligence reaches by its own power. This corresponds to the first day on which light was made. Hence in the Psalm: "The light of thy countenance, O Lord, is signed upon us." Without this light which is given within, a man has nothing, neither faith nor grace nor the illumination of wisdom. For this reason also light was separated from darkness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Another help for rising to the exemplary principles is that provided by the spiritual creature, which resembles light, a mirror, an image, "a scroll written within." Every spiritual substance is light. Hence, the Psalm: "The light of Thy countenance, O Lord, is signed upon us." At the same time, it is a mirror, for it receives and represents all things; and it has the nature of light, so that it may even pass judgment on things. For the whole world is described in the soul.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since it is possible to contemplate God not only outside us and within us, but also above us: outside through his vestige, within through his image, and above through the light that is sealed upon our mind, which is the light of eternal Truth, since "our mind itself is immediately formed by Truth itself"; those who have been exercised in the first mode have already entered into the court before the tabernacle; those in the second have entered into the holy place: but those in the third enter with the High Priest into the holy of holies; where above the ark are the Cherubim of glory overshadowing the mercy seat; by which we understand two modes or degrees of contemplating the invisible and eternal things of God, of which one is concerned with the essential attributes of God, and the other with what is proper to the persons.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning this hierarch, then, and the ecclesiastical hierarchy, the whole of sacred Scripture exists, through which we are taught to be purged, illumined, and perfected, and this according to the threefold law handed down in it, namely of nature, of Scripture, and of grace; or rather according to its threefold principal part, namely the Mosaic law which purges, the prophetic revelation which illumines, and the evangelical teaching which perfects; or most especially according to its threefold spiritual understanding: the tropological, which purges unto uprightness of life; the allegorical, which illumines unto clarity of understanding; the anagogical, which perfects through mental ecstasies and the sweetest perceptions of wisdom, according to the three aforesaid theological virtues and the reformed spiritual senses and the three above-mentioned ecstasies and the hierarchical acts of the mind, by which our mind returns to its interior, so that there it may contemplate God in the splendors of the Saints and in them as in resting-places may sleep in peace and rest, the Bridegroom adjuring that it not be awakened until it proceed of His will.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The seventh age runs concurrently with the sixth, that is, the repose of the souls after Christ's passion. After that comes the eighth age, the resurrection, of which the Psalmist says: "At dawn I bring my plea expectantly before You. For You, O God, delight not in wickedness." And it is a return to the first, for after the seventh day, there is a return to the first. These, then, are the seeds scattered throughout for the understanding of Scripture, and they are produced from these trees in so far as they accord with common interpretation, and in this way time is divided into seven ages.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Join seven ages, five callings, and three times, and you have fifteen, a number that contains a mystery: through the descent of the Holy Spirit upon the hundred and twenty who believed. In relation to them, the sun goes up fifteen degrees in an hour in our hemisphere; for if the natural day has twenty-four hours and every sign of the Zodiac has thirty degrees, and twelve signs move around each day, it is necessary that each hour the sun rise by fifteen degrees in our hemisphere. And this is the dawn of the resurrection, when we shall be at the end of time, as it is written "At dawn I bring my plea expectantly before You."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The impious man is he who defends his own impiety, namely sin. Of such the Psalm says: "Their throat is an open sepulchre; with their tongues they acted deceitfully: judge them, O God. Let them fall from their own counsels: according to the multitude of their impieties, cast them out, for they have provoked you, O Lord."
Do you wish to be freed from evil? Hear David, who says: "I said: I will confess against myself my injustice to the Lord, and you have forgiven the impiety of my sin." Praise God and be angry against sin, and do not defend sin, because to defend sin is a twofold sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The eighth plague was of locusts devouring all green vegetation, by which liars are struck, who trample the truth with their teeth and lips. The Psalm: "Their heart is vain; their throat is an open sepulchre; with their tongues they dealt deceitfully."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Where there is no fear, there is neither wisdom nor justice nor grace. "Their throat is an open sepulchre, the poison of asps is under their lips, with their tongues they acted deceitfully, their feet are swift to shed blood: whose mouth is full of cursing and bitterness, destruction and unhappiness are in their ways"; "there is no fear of God before their eyes." When a man does not have the fear of God, then his sense is turned to malice and goes forth like the poison of asps. When a man is disordered in affection with respect to thought, in speech with respect to utterance, and in deed with respect to effect; then he has nothing good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The impious man is he who defends his own impiety, namely sin. Of such the Psalm says: "Their throat is an open sepulchre; with their tongues they acted deceitfully: judge them, O God. Let them fall from their own counsels: according to the multitude of their impieties, cast them out, for they have provoked you, O Lord."
Do you wish to be freed from evil? Hear David, who says: "I said: I will confess against myself my injustice to the Lord, and you have forgiven the impiety of my sin." Praise God and be angry against sin, and do not defend sin, because to defend sin is a twofold sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since Scripture conceals a manifold understanding beneath a single letter, the expositor ought to bring hidden things forth into the light and make manifest what has been drawn forth through another, more open passage of Scripture, as if I were to expound that verse of the Psalm: Take hold of arms and shield, and rise up to help me, and wished to explain what the divine arms are; I would say that they are his truth and good will: and that this is so must be proved through open Scripture. For it is also written elsewhere: With the shield of your good will you have crowned us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens a posteriori through strict judgments. For God always imposes strict judgments upon transgressions of the precepts, as in the cases of Lucifer, Adam and his wife, the depraved upon whom came the flood, the prideful who built the tower of Babel, the Chananeans and Israel. Likewise, the New Testament is full of judgments. Now, the judgment follows the act, while the command precedes it. The judgment is related to the command: if you transgress it, you shall be punished. Unless you follow the guiding light, a sword shall pierce you. Hence the Psalm: Unless they be converted, God will sharpen His sword; He will bend and aim His bow, prepare His deadly weapons against them, and use fiery darts for arrows. The bow is the judgment of Scripture; the hardness of the wood, the Old Testament; the cord that bends the wood, the New Testament; the judgments, light or harsh, are the arrows. Hence again in the Psalm: The Law of the Lord is perfect, refreshing the soul; the decree of the Lord is trustworthy, giving wisdom to the simple. The ordinances of the Lord are true, all of them just.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens a posteriori through strict judgments. For God always imposes strict judgments upon transgressions of the precepts, as in the cases of Lucifer, Adam and his wife, the depraved upon whom came the flood, the prideful who built the tower of Babel, the Chananeans and Israel. Likewise, the New Testament is full of judgments. Now, the judgment follows the act, while the command precedes it. The judgment is related to the command: if you transgress it, you shall be punished. Unless you follow the guiding light, a sword shall pierce you. Hence the Psalm: Unless they be converted, God will sharpen His sword; He will bend and aim His bow, prepare His deadly weapons against them, and use fiery darts for arrows. The bow is the judgment of Scripture; the hardness of the wood, the Old Testament; the cord that bends the wood, the New Testament; the judgments, light or harsh, are the arrows. Hence again in the Psalm: The Law of the Lord is perfect, refreshing the soul; the decree of the Lord is trustworthy, giving wisdom to the simple. The ordinances of the Lord are true, all of them just.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These are the two knowledges of faith illuminating and inflaming in a threefold manner while being retraced to unity. They are said to cry, out of admiration, because both forms of knowledge are admirable. Wherefore in the Psalm: "O Lord, our Lord, how glorious is Your name over all the earth!" And in truth this name is admirable in so far as it refers to the eternal God, for it implies a true distinction of Persons together with unity of essence, through which they are supremely conforming to each other, supremely in accord, supremely coequal, coeternal, consubstantial, and coessential. Likewise, it is admirable in so far as it refers to God made man, because the three natures are conjoined: the highest with the lowest, without debasement; the first with the last, without alteration; the simple with the composite, without composition.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When I behold Your heavens, the work of Your fingers, that is, the heavenly men in whom we see this threefold light, the work of God's fingers. The magicians of Pharaoh lacked this third finger, that is, the miracles.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the New Testament, after the universal scripture and the course of time, Christ was formed, as was man on the sixth day, that He may "have dominion over the fish of the sea," and "the birds of the air." As the Psalm says, "what is man that You should be mindful of him, or the son of man that You should care for him? You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor. You have given him rule over the works of your hands, putting all things under his feet: all sheep and oxen, yes, and the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, the fishes of the sea," etc. And in order that it be understood of Christ, the Apostle says: "You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor." And there follows: "But we do see Him who was made 'a little lower than the angels,' namely, Jesus, crowned with glory and honor because of His having suffered death." Man was created out of a virgin soil that had never received blood, which signifies Christ born of the Virgin; and as Eve was formed out of Adam's side, so also the Church, out of the side of Christ. But since Christ never sinned, how can Adam's transgression correspond to Him? There must be transference from the head to the body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"O Lord, our Lord, how glorious is Your name over all the earth! You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor." And in truth this name is admirable in so far as it refers to the eternal God, for it implies a true distinction of Persons together with unity of essence. Likewise, it is admirable in so far as it refers to God made man, because the three natures are conjoined: the highest with the lowest, without debasement; the first with the last, without alteration; the simple with the composite, without composition.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the New Testament, after the universal scripture and the course of time, Christ was formed, as was man on the sixth day, that He may "have dominion over the fish of the sea," and "the birds of the air." As the Psalm says, "what is man that You should be mindful of him, or the son of man that You should care for him? You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor. You have given him rule over the works of your hands, putting all things under his feet: all sheep and oxen, yes, and the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, the fishes of the sea," etc. And in order that it be understood of Christ, the Apostle says: "You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor." And there follows: "But we do see Him who was made 'a little lower than the angels,' namely, Jesus, crowned with glory and honor because of His having suffered death." Man was created out of a virgin soil that had never received blood, which signifies Christ born of the Virgin; and as Eve was formed out of Adam's side, so also the Church, out of the side of Christ. But since Christ never sinned, how can Adam's transgression correspond to Him? There must be transference from the head to the body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the New Testament, after the universal scripture and the course of time, Christ was formed, as was man on the sixth day, that He may "have dominion over the fish of the sea," and "the birds of the air." As the Psalm says, "what is man that You should be mindful of him, or the son of man that You should care for him? You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor. You have given him rule over the works of your hands, putting all things under his feet: all sheep and oxen, yes, and the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, the fishes of the sea," etc. And in order that it be understood of Christ, the Apostle says: "You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor." And there follows: "But we do see Him who was made 'a little lower than the angels,' namely, Jesus, crowned with glory and honor because of His having suffered death." Man was created out of a virgin soil that had never received blood, which signifies Christ born of the Virgin; and as Eve was formed out of Adam's side, so also the Church, out of the side of Christ. But since Christ never sinned, how can Adam's transgression correspond to Him? There must be transference from the head to the body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, Scripture enlightens from below by showing forth the torments of hell. In the Psalm: He rains upon the wicked fiery coals and brimstone; a burning blast is their allotted cup. In the Apocalypse: Their portion shall be in the pool that burns with fire and brimstone. And the smoke of their torments goes up forever and ever. Scripture proposes this from the very beginning where it is said that darkness covered the abyss, until the end. And so Scripture offers internal spectacles, external examples, heavenly promises, and the tortures of hell.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Psalm says: The fool has said in his heart: there is no God; but to say in the heart is to think: therefore that God does not exist can be thought, at least by the fool.
To that which is objected to the contrary from the Psalm and from Damascene, the response is already clear: because it proceeds from doubt which comes from a deficiency of reason, of the kind that exists in the foolish intellect, which, darkened by its own dimness, neither sufficiently resolves nor rightly compares nor fully apprehends the meaning of this name God. For the intellect itself has within itself sufficient light from its own condition, by which it could drive this doubt far away and free itself from foolishness. Hence in this defective consideration of the foolish intellect, it falls short voluntarily rather than by compulsion, not on account of a deficiency on the part of the object known, but on account of a deficiency on its own part.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Scripture shut up all things under sin, the first through ignorance, the second through weakness, and the third through malice, so that when Christ came, He could have mercy on them all. And the Apostle wonders at this, and quotes the authority of the Psalm: "All alike have gone astray; they have become perverse; there is not one that does good, not even one."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All our merits are rooted in the merit of Christ, whether satisfactory for punishment or meritorious of eternal life, because we are worthy neither to be absolved from offense against the highest good, nor to gain the immensity of the eternal reward, which is God, except through the merit of the God-man, to whom we can and ought to say: "All our works you have wrought in us, O Lord." He, I say, is the Lord, to whom the Prophet says: "I said to the Lord: You are my God, for you have no need of my goods."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Grace cannot be given to man unless he first acknowledge his blindness, weakness, and malice. And so, there was a time in which blindness prevailed, as in the period before the Law. At a later point, the illuminating Law was given, and yet "their infirmities were multiplied," and there was an opportunity for a greater transgression of the Law. And therefore man had to be convicted of weakness or impotency.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The orders are preceded by a certain distinction in the tonsure and crown, by which is understood the cutting away of temporal desires and the elevation of the mind to eternal things, so that the cleric may be shown to be wholly appointed to divine worship; and therefore he says at the reception of the crown: The Lord is the portion of my inheritance.
And because such a one ought to be instructed in the divine praises, which chiefly consist in the Psalms: therefore the psalmistrate, as a preamble, precedes the other orders.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This brief word belongs to David himself, who through the Holy Spirit unfolds to us the very gift of understanding given to us by the Holy Spirit, and he unfolds it to us with respect to the humble gratitude of the recipient and with respect to the liberal diffusion of the giver. The humble gratitude of the recipient is noted when he says: "I will bless the Lord"; the liberal diffusion of the giver is noted when he adds: "Who has bestowed upon me understanding." This gift requires that man be grateful to God, and brings it about that man recognizes himself and the gift and the source of the gift: and by understanding the source of the gift man recognizes himself, and so gives thanks. And then he blesses God and pours back the beauty of the gift upon the very author of the gift, and praises him, and does not assail the giver. Moreover, we dispose ourselves to receive this gift through three things: first, through holiness of life; second, through the docility of meekness; and third, through the captivation of the understanding, so that we may bless the author of this gift.
All radiance of intelligence comes from that fountain of intelligence. And although the radiance of intelligence is manifold, understanding is the rule of moral circumspections, the gateway of scientific considerations, and the key of heavenly contemplations; and this is a gift.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If you take a straight look at the leaders of the city, the foremost chief is Christ. In terms of the fight, although the angels and the saints help, yet the principal contender is Christ. Hence, in the Psalm: "I set the Lord ever before me; with Him at my right hand I shall not be disturbed." And again, in the Acts: "Behold, I see the heavens opened, and the Son of Man standing at the right hand of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But grace which lifts up is obtained through hope. Therefore "our present light affliction which is for the moment, prepares for us an eternal weight of glory." For the Lord rejoices in the right. "The delights at your right hand forever." At the left are passing riches, glories and consolations. We must indeed adhere to the right. As the Psalm says, "Your right hand upholds me," Lord. Hence the rewards dispose towards the third act of grace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens from above by means of divine promises, for its teaching is concerned with things above. Hence the Apostle writes: For we know that if the earthly house in which we dwell be destroyed, we have a building from God, a house not made by human hands, eternal in the heavens. And: "In My Father's house there are many mansions," says the Lord. In the Psalms, it is said: The children of men take refuge in the shadow of Your wings. They have their fill of the prime gifts of Your house; from Your delightful stream You give them to drink. For with You is the fountain of life, and in Your light we see light. And in the Apocalypse: For the Lamb who is in the midst of the throne will shepherd them, and will guide them to the fountains of the waters of life. And in a Psalm: The delights at Your right hand forever. And so Scripture offers us the divine promises.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A saint's life must be pure, that is, everything must be done out of love for God, and not out of love for something else, since all love is suspect if it is not addressed to God. "Keep me as the apple of your eye." The apple of the eye is not kept clean when there is mist or dust or liquid on it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If long and healthful life: there is sound eternity and eternal soundness, because the just shall live forever, and: The salvation of the just is from the Lord. If fullness: they shall be satisfied, when the glory of God shall appear. If inebriation: they shall be inebriated with the plenty of the house of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I will love you, O Lord, my fortitude; the Lord is my firmament and my refuge and my deliverer." Catherine and Lucy were strong through the love of God. If we are not bound to the Lord through charity, we easily lose our fortitude.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I will love you, O Lord, my fortitude; the Lord is my firmament and my refuge and my deliverer." Catherine and Lucy were strong through the love of God. If we are not bound to the Lord through charity, we easily lose our fortitude.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And so, first of all there is the heavenly form. For Scripture makes use of all the heavens and the stars. Hence the Psalm: The heavens declare the glory of God, and the firmament proclaims His handiwork. And Ecclesiasticus: The clear vault of the sky shines forth like heaven itself, a vision of glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In relation to unity, there are two testaments, the one giving birth into slavery and, the other, into freedom; the one of fear and the other of love, the one literal and the other spiritual, the one figurative and the other actual: and so these two times are distinguished as are the night and the day. Hence, in the Psalm: "Day pours out the word to day, and night to night imparts knowledge." During that night, the Law was like the moon, and according to Gregory the Fathers were like the stars. But when the Sun came, the day was light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the second allegory, about the blessed Virgin Mary, it is said in the Psalm: "He has pitched a tent there for the sun." Wherefore she is "as beautiful as the moon, as resplendent as the sun, as awe-inspiring as bannered troops." Hence she is a vessel able to contain light: "The sun, an admirable instrument, the work of the most High — shining gloriously in the firmament of heaven."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens a posteriori through strict judgments. For God always imposes strict judgments upon transgressions of the precepts, as in the cases of Lucifer, Adam and his wife, the depraved upon whom came the flood, the prideful who built the tower of Babel, the Chananeans and Israel. Likewise, the New Testament is full of judgments. Now, the judgment follows the act, while the command precedes it. The judgment is related to the command: if you transgress it, you shall be punished. Unless you follow the guiding light, a sword shall pierce you. Hence the Psalm: Unless they be converted, God will sharpen His sword; He will bend and aim His bow, prepare His deadly weapons against them, and use fiery darts for arrows. The bow is the judgment of Scripture; the hardness of the wood, the Old Testament; the cord that bends the wood, the New Testament; the judgments, light or harsh, are the arrows. Hence again in the Psalm: The Law of the Lord is perfect, refreshing the soul; the decree of the Lord is trustworthy, giving wisdom to the simple. The ordinances of the Lord are true, all of them just.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens a posteriori through strict judgments. For God always imposes strict judgments upon transgressions of the precepts, as in the cases of Lucifer, Adam and his wife, the depraved upon whom came the flood, the prideful who built the tower of Babel, the Chananeans and Israel. Likewise, the New Testament is full of judgments. Now, the judgment follows the act, while the command precedes it. The judgment is related to the command: if you transgress it, you shall be punished. Unless you follow the guiding light, a sword shall pierce you. Hence the Psalm: Unless they be converted, God will sharpen His sword; He will bend and aim His bow, prepare His deadly weapons against them, and use fiery darts for arrows. The bow is the judgment of Scripture; the hardness of the wood, the Old Testament; the cord that bends the wood, the New Testament; the judgments, light or harsh, are the arrows. Hence again in the Psalm: The Law of the Lord is perfect, refreshing the soul; the decree of the Lord is trustworthy, giving wisdom to the simple. The ordinances of the Lord are true, all of them just.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The commandments of God are irreproachable, because they contain nothing burdensome, but rather they are sweet. "More to be desired than gold and much precious stone, and sweeter than honey and the honeycomb." But we see that to an infected palate sweet food seems bitter; similarly, to a man of perverse will the commandments of God, which are easy and sweet, seem difficult.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In many other ways also a man becomes a partaker of the sin of another; and on account of this the Psalm says: From my hidden sins cleanse me, O Lord, and from the sins of others spare your servant.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third counsel is that by which we are made ready to pursue what is lawful, what is fitting, and what is expedient according to the exercise of virtuous operation. What you have well conceived in mind, you may bring to completion in deed. The Psalm says: 'May he grant you according to your heart and confirm all your counsel.' That counsel adds over and above readiness for action. There is a threefold operation, namely to discern rightly, to choose well, and to pursue readily.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Another evil counselor is one who turns good things into evil. The Psalm says: 'For they turned evils against you; they devised counsels which they were unable to establish; for you shall make them turn their back.' It is evil when someone says something by which the counsel of Christ could be considered evil — as when someone condemns the counsel of entering holy religious life. It is foolish, dangerous, pernicious, and reckless to turn into evil that which Christ declared good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The brothers should be spoken to, hence, the Psalm: "I will proclaim your name to my brethren; in the midst of the assembly I will praise you"; and spiritual men also, in order that they may be drawn from worldly knowledge to Christian knowledge.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We should speak of the Church of rational men united in harmonious and uniform concelebration of divine praise, according to the Psalm, "with Thee is my praise in a great Church." As a sweet chant results from a great number of voices united in a certain proportion and harmony, so also a spiritual harmony pleasing to the Most High comes forth from the harmony of the love of many.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Psalm says: "Upon the seas he founded it"; and elsewhere: "Who founded the earth upon its own stability."
Some mocked David because he said that God founded the earth upon the waters. The earth, since it is dry, unless there were moisture penetrating it, would be reduced to dust; and just as the human body receives moisture through its veins, so it is necessary that fresh waters come from the sea and hold the earth together. He says that he founded the earth upon the waters on account of the mystery. The earth which the Spirit has filled is the ecclesiastical hierarchy; he "who weighs the mass of the earth with three fingers," because he founded the holy Church upon the divine utterances. The sacred utterances are for its stability.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He overcame the world, despoiled Hades, and restored Paradise. Hence in the Psalm: "Lift up, O gates, your lintels; reach up, you ancient portals, that the King of Glory may come in! Who is this King of glory? The Lord, strong and mighty." We want to hear this: "Lift up, O gates, your lintels! Who is this King of Glory? The Lord, strong and mighty!" He, then, is the Strong One.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He overcame the world, despoiled Hades, and restored Paradise. Hence in the Psalm: "Lift up, O gates, your lintels; reach up, you ancient portals, that the King of Glory may come in! Who is this King of glory? The Lord, strong and mighty." We want to hear this: "Lift up, O gates, your lintels! Who is this King of Glory? The Lord, strong and mighty!" He, then, is the Strong One.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He overcame the world, despoiled Hades, and restored Paradise. Hence in the Psalm: "Lift up, O gates, your lintels; reach up, you ancient portals, that the King of Glory may come in! Who is this King of glory? The Lord, strong and mighty." We want to hear this: "Lift up, O gates, your lintels! Who is this King of Glory? The Lord, strong and mighty!" He, then, is the Strong One.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He overcame the world, despoiled Hades, and restored Paradise. Hence in the Psalm: "Lift up, O gates, your lintels; reach up, you ancient portals, that the King of Glory may come in! Who is this King of glory? The Lord, strong and mighty." We want to hear this: "Lift up, O gates, your lintels! Who is this King of Glory? The Lord, strong and mighty!" He, then, is the Strong One.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the first principle does all things from itself and according to itself and for itself, it is necessary that it be most good and most upright, and thereby most merciful and most just: and hence it is that all his ways are mercy and truth, or judgment. But if God had from the beginning created man in such great miseries, there would be neither mercy nor justice, namely that he would oppress his own work with such great misery, with no preceding fault. If therefore it is most certain that the first principle is most upright and most clement both in producing and in providing: it is necessary that he so made the human race that from the beginning there was in it neither fault nor misery; it is also necessary that he so governs that he does not permit misery to be in us except on account of some preceding fault.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the remission of sin is accomplished by God through penitential grace within ecclesiastical unity, the differences of the sin against the Holy Spirit are taken according as they directly assail those three things. If in relation to the unity of the Church: since the unity of the Church consists in faith and charity, that is, in grace and truth, there is thus a twofold sin, namely envy of fraternal grace and assailing of acknowledged truth. If in relation to God who gives: since all His ways with respect to justification are especially mercy and truth, there is thus a twofold sin: one which assails mercy, and this is despair; another which assails justice, and this is presumption of impunity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since indeed a perfect advance in good is considered according to divine imitation, and all the ways of the Lord are mercy and truth: hence it is that there is a twofold beatitude according to these two ways, namely hunger or zeal for justice, and the affection of mercy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I will love you, O Lord, my fortitude; the Lord is my firmament and my refuge and my deliverer. The protector of my life, of whom shall I be afraid?" Catherine and Lucy were strong through the love of God. If we are not bound to the Lord through charity, we easily lose our fortitude.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Thoughts about God must be the highest in the order of truth, for He Himself is the Truth ruling all things, illuminating all things, straightening all things, disposing all things. Wherefore, in the Psalm: The Lord is my light and my salvation; whom should I fear? The power of government should not in any way be attributed to the constellations of heaven.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens in a circle, as, for instance, when it advises us not to flee, because we have protection all around. For we have the Lord and angels about us, wherefore the Psalm: Mountains are round about Jerusalem; so the Lord is round about His people. To the servant of Eliseus who cried out because of the Syrian robbers who sought to capture him, Eliseus said: "Lord, open his eyes, that he may see." And the Lord opened the eyes of the servant, and he saw. And behold the mountain was full of horses, and chariots of fire round about Eliseus. Jacob too, afraid of his brother, saw the angels and said: "This is the encampment of God." Wherefore the Psalm says: The Lord is my light and my salvation; whom should I fear? And in another passage: Had not the Lord been with us, let Israel say, etc., until the end.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is good to have the sign of Zabulon, which is "a dwelling of fortitude," which implies the first stability. "Because Thou, O Lord, art my hope." Hence, "the name of the Lord is a strong tower; the just man runs to it and is safe." He alone is at peace who fixes himself upon that "with which there is no change, no shadow of alteration." Hence, "in Thee, O Lord, have I hoped, let me never be confounded."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He who does not fear God must fear everywhere; and he who truly fears God has what no one can take from him. But he who fears something other than God has what ought to be taken from him. He who fears God cannot lose God. It is not so with money. If a man has money, he fears lest he lose it, and yet he is certain that he will lose it. But he who fears God is secure everywhere. "How great is the multitude of your sweetness, O Lord, which you have hidden for those who fear you"; there follows: "You have perfected it for those who hope in you." Therefore the fear of God ought to be perfect, because "it shall be well with those who fear God," because they shall come to the blessing of glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He who fears God cannot lose God. But he who fears something other than God has what ought to be taken from him. But he who fears God is secure everywhere. "How great is the multitude of your sweetness, O Lord, which you have hidden for those who fear you; you have perfected it for those who hope in you." Therefore the fear of God ought to be perfect, because "it shall be well with those who fear God," because they shall come to the blessing of glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Piety avails for avoiding all evils. Do you wish to be freed from evil? Hear David, who says: "I said: I will confess against myself my injustice to the Lord, and you have forgiven the impiety of my sin." Praise God and be angry against sin, and do not defend sin, because to defend sin is a twofold sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I will give you understanding and I will instruct you in this way in which you shall walk; I will fix my eyes upon you." The Lord promises us this understanding and shows us how we ought to receive it. "I will fix my eyes upon you": the divine good pleasure accepts what we do, approving in the present and rewarding in the future. If you wish to be regulated according to this rule, take care that you be not bestial but well-ordered: that you be directed not according to the impulse of sense, but according to the judgment of reason; not according to bestial phantasms, but according to intellectual judgments. Otherwise what happened to Adam will happen to you, who, having despised the rule of truth, followed the instinct of the woman, and the woman followed the instinct of the serpent.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Do not become like the horse and the mule, which have no understanding." It is necessary that you be well-ordered in conduct, if you wish to have the gift of understanding. If you wish to be regulated according to the divine rule, take care that you be not bestial but well-ordered: that you be directed not according to the impulse of sense, but according to the judgment of reason; not according to bestial phantasms, but according to intellectual judgments.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By the word of the Lord the heavens were established; and all the power of them by the spirit of His mouth. The heavens, that is the heavenly beings, were confirmed through faith by the Word of God; and through this same Word, both the heavenly and the sub-heavenly beings were confirmed, and hence it is said: And all the power of them by the spirit of His mouth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In words, that appears especially efficacious for testifying which David, the most excellent of the Prophets, said in the Psalm: By the Word of the Lord the heavens were established, and by the Spirit of His mouth all their power, where the trinity of persons is simultaneously intimated, such that two persons are named explicitly under the name of Spirit and Word, and one implicitly under the name of Lord. Moreover in many places, indeed in nearly all places of the Old Testament, although implicitly, nevertheless through figures and words testimony is rendered to the eternal Trinity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the gathering of waters, the Psalm says: "He gathers the waters of the sea as in a flask." He gathers the waters of the sea in a flask when He brings together in the skin of Scriptures the totality of the spiritual meanings. Now there are three reasons why these meanings are compared to waters gathered in a wine-bag — to wit, because of the primitive origination of these spiritual meanings, because of their most profound depth, and because of their abundantly flowing multiformity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And so it is clear that possible things come forth from the most actual, changing things from the most stable, and the lowest things from the most sublime. And as the sun by shining brings forth a variety and number of colors, so out of this Word there comes forth a variety of things. Hence there is no understanding except through the Word. And this is the most noble key of the soul cleansed by faith, and it is needed because "the low sensitivity of our mind is not touched in such outstanding light, except when it is cleansed by the justifying power of faith." Hence all those who lack this faith have their hand cut off. Wherefore the Psalm says: "He spoke, and they were made: He commanded, and they were created."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Ecclesiasticus says: 'Before all works let a true word precede you, and before every act a stable counsel.' The true word, which can neither be deceived nor deceive, is the only-begotten Son of God and his doctrine and his life. Let this word precede you and this stable counsel. Stable counsel is none other than that of my God; 'the counsel of the Lord remains forever.'”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Passing over is an endeavor: the endeavor to pass from the study of the sciences to the study of holiness and from the study of holiness to that of wisdom. It is said of this in the Psalm: "Teach me goodness and discipline and knowledge." The endeavor begins from the top because it wants to "taste and see how good the Lord is." But it is not possible to reach wisdom except through discipline, nor discipline except through knowledge — wherefore the last should not be placed before the first. It would be a poor merchant who would prefer tin to gold. The man who chooses knowledge over holiness will never prosper.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By the authority of the Psalm: Fear the Lord, all you his saints, for there is no want to those who fear him: therefore being in want and fearing God do not stand together.
To that which is first objected to the contrary, that there is no want to those who fear God — it must be said that want is twofold, namely bodily and spiritual: but that word is understood not of any want whatsoever, but of spiritual want. And that this is true appears from what immediately follows: The rich have wanted and have hungered: it is clear that this is not understood of a lack of material riches; it remains therefore that it is understood of a want of spiritual goods, which although it exists in the rich, nevertheless does not exist in those who fear God, because fear is the beginning of wisdom, of which it is said in Wisdom 7: All good things came to me together with her, etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Come, children, hear me: I will teach you the fear of the Lord." These words are of the Prophet David, in which he invites the children of the grace of God and the children of adoption to learn this lesson: and he invites not only the little ones, but also the advanced and the aged and the decrepit. This is a lesson that ought to be taught in youth and never abandoned. This lesson, therefore, is for all. It is true that Sacred Scripture speaks of the fear of the Lord; and the fear of the Lord is handed down in Sacred Scripture. The preacher does as a man who is in a meadow and gathers flowers: he cannot gather them all, but he gathers some and makes from them a garland. I wish to make for you a garland from the flowers that I have gathered, which for the present I wish to set before you. It seems to me that the fear of the Lord is a most beautiful tree planted in the heart of the holy man, which God waters continually: and when the tree is brought to perfection, then the man is worthy of eternal glory. I wish to describe for you the root of this tree and its branching together with its fruit.
And what is the root of the fear of the Lord? For it is necessary to go to the original principle, so that we may know by what way the fear of God arises in us. Now the fear of God arises in us first from the consideration of the sublimity of divine power, second, from the consideration of the perspicacity of divine wisdom, third, from the consideration of the severity of divine vengeance.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the same manner, there are four acts of justice: to do good, to flee evil, to beware of prosperity, and to withstand misfortune. Of the first two, the Psalm says: "Turn from evil, and do good. The Lord has eyes for the just. The Lord confronts the evildoers."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since Scripture conceals a manifold understanding beneath a single letter, the expositor ought to bring hidden things forth into the light and make manifest what has been drawn forth through another, more open passage of Scripture, as if I were to expound that verse of the Psalm: Take hold of arms and shield, and rise up to help me, and wished to explain what the divine arms are; I would say that they are his truth and good will: and that this is so must be proved through open Scripture. For it is also written elsewhere: With the shield of your good will you have crowned us; and again: His truth shall compass you about with a shield. To this no one can easily attain unless through habitual reading he commits the text and letter of the Bible to memory; otherwise he will never be able to be proficient in the exposition of the Scriptures.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Where there is no fear, there is neither wisdom nor justice nor grace. When a man does not have the fear of God, then his sense is turned to malice and goes forth like the poison of asps. When a man is disordered in affection with respect to thought, in speech with respect to utterance, and in deed with respect to effect; then he has nothing good. "Destruction and unhappiness are in their ways, and the way of peace they have not known," namely the way of the grace of the Holy Spirit. And why? Because "there is no fear of God before their eyes."
If you wish to strive to have grace, justice, and wisdom, and these cannot be had without fear: therefore the fear of God is necessary for you. Likewise, where there is no fear, there is foolishness, malice, and iniquity, destruction and unhappiness: but these are to be fled as the worst things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This Hierarch is the most generous because He gives us whatever we ask. He swears to it and asserts it with complete truthfulness. Hence in the Psalm: "Man and beast You save, O Lord. They shall be inebriated with the plenty of Thy house."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens from above by means of divine promises, for its teaching is concerned with things above. Hence the Apostle writes: For we know that if the earthly house in which we dwell be destroyed, we have a building from God, a house not made by human hands, eternal in the heavens. And: "In My Father's house there are many mansions," says the Lord. In the Psalms, it is said: The children of men take refuge in the shadow of Your wings. They have their fill of the prime gifts of Your house; from Your delightful stream You give them to drink. For with You is the fountain of life, and in Your light we see light. And in the Apocalypse: For the Lamb who is in the midst of the throne will shepherd them, and will guide them to the fountains of the waters of life. And in a Psalm: The delights at Your right hand forever. And so Scripture offers us the divine promises.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If fullness: they shall be satisfied, when the glory of God shall appear. If inebriation: they shall be inebriated with the plenty of the house of God. If melody: there the choirs of Angels sing together praising God without end. If any pleasure, not impure but pure: you shall give them to drink of the torrent of your pleasure, O God. If wisdom: the very wisdom of God shall show itself to them. If friendship: they shall love God more than themselves and one another as themselves, and God shall love them more than they love themselves, because they love Him and themselves and one another through Him, and He loves Himself and them through Himself.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This Hierarch is the most generous because He gives us whatever we ask. He swears to it and asserts it with complete truthfulness. Hence in the Psalm: "Man and beast You save, O Lord. They shall be inebriated with the plenty of Thy house."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens from above by means of divine promises, for its teaching is concerned with things above. Hence the Apostle writes: For we know that if the earthly house in which we dwell be destroyed, we have a building from God, a house not made by human hands, eternal in the heavens. And: "In My Father's house there are many mansions," says the Lord. In the Psalms, it is said: The children of men take refuge in the shadow of Your wings. They have their fill of the prime gifts of Your house; from Your delightful stream You give them to drink. For with You is the fountain of life, and in Your light we see light. And in the Apocalypse: For the Lamb who is in the midst of the throne will shepherd them, and will guide them to the fountains of the waters of life. And in a Psalm: The delights at Your right hand forever. And so Scripture offers us the divine promises.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens from above by means of divine promises, for its teaching is concerned with things above. Hence the Apostle writes: For we know that if the earthly house in which we dwell be destroyed, we have a building from God, a house not made by human hands, eternal in the heavens. And: "In My Father's house there are many mansions," says the Lord. In the Psalms, it is said: The children of men take refuge in the shadow of Your wings. They have their fill of the prime gifts of Your house; from Your delightful stream You give them to drink. For with You is the fountain of life, and in Your light we see light. And in the Apocalypse: For the Lamb who is in the midst of the throne will shepherd them, and will guide them to the fountains of the waters of life. And in a Psalm: The delights at Your right hand forever. And so Scripture offers us the divine promises.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This fountainhead, however, is in a certain way the origin of another totality. For since the Father produces the Son, and through the Son and with the Son produces the Holy Spirit, therefore God the Father, through the Son with the Holy Spirit, is the principle of all created things: for unless He produced them from eternity, He could not produce through them in time: and therefore by reason of that production in the Trinity He is rightly said to be the fountain of life. For just as He has life in Himself, so He gives the Son to have life in Himself, etc. Hence it is that eternal life is this alone, that the rational spirit, which flows from the most blessed Trinity and is the image of the Trinity, returns by way of a certain intelligible circle through memory, understanding, and will, through the deiformity of glory into the most blessed Trinity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Isaac, treating that verse of the Psalm, *In your light we shall see light,* says: "Just as from the sun proceeds that by which the sun can be seen, and yet what shows the sun does not leave the sun: so in God the light which proceeds from God irradiates the mind, so that it first sees the very radiance itself, without which it would not see, and in that radiance sees all other things." Therefore according to this, all things are seen in the divine light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore, however much one may be illuminated by the light of nature and acquired knowledge, one cannot enter into oneself so as within oneself to delight in the Lord, except through the mediation of Christ, who says: I am the door. If anyone enters through me, he shall be saved, and shall go in and go out, and shall find pastures. But to this door we do not draw near unless we believe in him, hope in him, and love him. It is necessary, therefore, if we wish to re-enter into the enjoyment of Truth as into paradise, that we enter through faith, hope, and charity in the mediator of God and men, Jesus Christ, who is as the tree of life in the midst of paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“However much knowledge a man may have of the New and Old Testament, it is still necessary that he consult the Lord. The Psalm says: 'Reveal your way to the Lord, and he himself will give you the petitions of your heart. Be subject to the Lord.' I do not say that he should have a special conversation with him, but it is necessary that the Lord bring forth truth for him as light. In this are reproved certain ones who wish to be governed by their own knowledge.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Psalm: I have not seen the just man forsaken, nor his seed seeking bread: therefore he who seeks bread is neither just nor the seed of the just.
To that which is objected from the Psalm: I have not seen the just man forsaken, etc.; it must be said that bread is twofold, namely bodily and spiritual; but that word is not understood of bodily bread, but of spiritual bread. And that this is true appears from the Gloss on the same passage: Nor his seed seeking bread, the Gloss says: "spiritual bread, that is, to lack the bread of the word of God, because the word of God is always with him." The text can also be construed so that it is understood: I have not seen the just man forsaken, nor his seed seeking bread have I seen forsaken: because, according to what is said in the last chapter of Hebrews on that text: I will not leave you nor forsake you, the Gloss says: "He would be forsaken who perished from hunger." The Prophet therefore means to say that he saw neither the just man nor the seed of the just man dead from hunger, and this does not call one back from poverty, but rather invites to it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The mouth of the just shall meditate wisdom, and his tongue shall speak judgment." A just judge is one who is moved by just zeal, approves all good things and condemns evil things: but he who does not have right zeal cannot judge well. Love and hatred pervert judgment. If you hate me, you cannot judge me rightly: and why? Because it seems to you that all things that are in me are evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If long and healthful life: there is sound eternity and eternal soundness, because the just shall live forever, and: The salvation of the just is from the Lord. If fullness: they shall be satisfied, when the glory of God shall appear.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For no one is in any way disposed to divine contemplations, which lead to mental transports, unless with Daniel he be a man of desires. But desires are inflamed in us in a twofold manner, namely through the cry of prayer, which makes one roar from the groaning of the heart, and through the brilliance of speculation, by which the mind turns itself most directly and most intensely toward the rays of light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When the soul does what it can, grace lifts it up easily and God works in it, so that there be a worthy admission of divine matters, corresponding to the Thrones. "O Lord, all my desire is before You; from You my groaning is not hid." Later, when the soul is lifted up, it must not be idle, but should look around. Then, indeed, the soul must be fixed, and standing, and expecting.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The danger of transgression ought to move us to keep God's commandments, because transgressors lose many goods. Transgression blinds the intellect of the true and takes away the affection for the good: and on account of this, in the person of the transgressor the Psalmist says: "My strength has forsaken me, and the light of my eyes, and it itself is not with me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“No virtue is in the true perfection of virtue unless it approves each thing according as it is to be approved: but, as is said in the Psalm, every living man is altogether vanity: therefore no one is of perfect virtue unless he considers himself vain and useless, and wills to be so considered by everyone.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Adam passed over from truth to vanity. Hence in the Psalm: "A phantom only, man goes his ways; like vapor only are his restless pursuits; he heaps up stores, and knows not who will use them." For as long as vain, transitory, passing good is loved, man is "passing over." And such passing over Wisdom reproves. This passing over is the cause of every evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, this same thing is shown by the example of Christ. Psalm: But I am a beggar and poor: Gloss: "Christ says this of Himself: I am a beggar in the form of a servant. A beggar is one who asks from another, a pauper is one who does not suffice for himself." But it is certain that this is not understood of Christ with respect to spiritual gifts or goods, because He was a comprehensor and full of all grace: therefore it is understood with respect to temporal goods, and thus with respect to those He was a beggar and asked from another.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And in these degrees consists the ladder of Jacob, whose summit reaches heaven: and the throne of Solomon, upon which sits the most wise King, truly peaceful and loving as the most beautiful bridegroom and wholly desirable: upon whom the Angels desire to gaze, and toward whom the desire of holy souls sighs, as the hart longs for the fountains of waters. By which most fervent desire, in the manner of fire, our spirit is not only made agile for ascent, but also by a certain learned ignorance is rapt above itself into darkness and ecstasy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, wisdom is not obtained except by the man who thirsts. Hence, the Psalm: "My soul hath thirsted after the strong living God"; and: "As the hind longs for the running waters, so my soul longs for You, O God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The gift of understanding is solid food, like bread which is obtained through much labor. And so it is with the gift of understanding: to prepare understanding is a difficult task in itself. Likewise, wisdom is not obtained except by the man who thirsts. Hence, the Psalm: "My soul hath thirsted after the strong living God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The whole of Scripture is the heart of God, the mouth of God, the tongue of God, the pen of God, "a scroll written within and without." Hence, in the Psalm: "My heart overflows with a goodly theme; as I sing my ode to the King, my tongue is nimble as the pen of a skillful scribe." The heart is of God, the mouth of the Father, the tongue of the Son, the pen of the Holy Spirit. For the Father speaks through the Son or Tongue, but that which fulfills and commits to memory is the Pen of the Scribe.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second mode of generation is by means of expression: as in the case of the species coming out of the object, the imprint out of the seal, the speech out of the speaker, or the concept or thought out of the mind. And in these, there is deficiency. In the first, the reality of the object is lacking, for the species in the eye or in the soul is not the reality of the thing. In the second, simplicity is lacking, for the image or figure does not consist in a point or in something simple, but has parts. In the third, permanence is lacking, for speech passes away and does not remain. In the fourth, substance is lacking, for the concept of the mind is neither a substance nor a hypostasis. Take away such defects, and suppose an expression like the species deriving from the object but having reality, like the imprint produced by the seal but having simplicity, like the word coming forth from the speaker but having permanence, like the concept proceeding from the mind but having substance: and then you have the first part of the mirror.
The Psalm refers to the first manner of expression: "My heart overflows with a goodly theme." And there follows: "Fairer in beauty are you than the sons of men." Wisdom refers to the second: "For she is the refulgence of eternal light, the spotless mirror of the power of God, the image of His goodness." And the Apostle: "He is the image of the invisible God." Job refers to the third: "God speaketh once, and repeateth not the selfsame thing the second time." Understand this as meaning "in the Son," in the sense that He always is, and will never cease to be nor even be changed. In the fourth manner of expression, suppose substantiality, for the concept of the eternal mind is a hypostasis, and this mental concept is most noble and perfect. Hence, in Proverbs: "When there were no depths I was brought forth." And so He is sometimes called the Word, the Species, the Image, the Word remaining forever, the Concept—not as existing within a mind, but as being substantial: a hypostasis. And in this way we have the other part of the mirror.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Grace is poured forth upon your lips; therefore God has blessed you forever." This word is directed to our Lord Jesus Christ, as is apparent in the Psalm from the preceding and subsequent text. For in the Psalm where these words are written, there is set before them: "Beautiful in form above the sons of men:" and there follows: "Your throne, O God, is forever and ever," etc. Therefore it speaks of Christ, who is blessed, in whom all the nations of the earth are blessed. "In your seed shall all nations be blessed," was said to Abraham; and because Christ is the Word, through whom all things are blessed, and he who is blessed by God the Father is blessed by Christ, therefore all things are blessed through Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To Him are referred all the eloquent sayings of Scriptural wisdom, as for instance those of Solomon and others. And yet the Jews understand as applying to Solomon what is said of Christ in the Psalm: "Fairer in beauty are you than the sons of men; grace is poured out upon your lips." Solomon was not like that.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second mode of generation is by means of expression: as in the case of the species coming out of the object, the imprint out of the seal, the speech out of the speaker, or the concept or thought out of the mind. And in these, there is deficiency. In the first, the reality of the object is lacking, for the species in the eye or in the soul is not the reality of the thing. In the second, simplicity is lacking, for the image or figure does not consist in a point or in something simple, but has parts. In the third, permanence is lacking, for speech passes away and does not remain. In the fourth, substance is lacking, for the concept of the mind is neither a substance nor a hypostasis. Take away such defects, and suppose an expression like the species deriving from the object but having reality, like the imprint produced by the seal but having simplicity, like the word coming forth from the speaker but having permanence, like the concept proceeding from the mind but having substance: and then you have the first part of the mirror.
The Psalm refers to the first manner of expression: "My heart overflows with a goodly theme." And there follows: "Fairer in beauty are you than the sons of men." Wisdom refers to the second: "For she is the refulgence of eternal light, the spotless mirror of the power of God, the image of His goodness." And the Apostle: "He is the image of the invisible God." Job refers to the third: "God speaketh once, and repeateth not the selfsame thing the second time." Understand this as meaning "in the Son," in the sense that He always is, and will never cease to be nor even be changed. In the fourth manner of expression, suppose substantiality, for the concept of the eternal mind is a hypostasis, and this mental concept is most noble and perfect. Hence, in Proverbs: "When there were no depths I was brought forth." And so He is sometimes called the Word, the Species, the Image, the Word remaining forever, the Concept—not as existing within a mind, but as being substantial: a hypostasis. And in this way we have the other part of the mirror.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To those who have been forestalled by divine grace — the humble and pious, the contrite and devout, those anointed with the oil of gladness, lovers of divine wisdom and inflamed with desire for it, who wish to devote themselves to magnifying, admiring, and even tasting God — I propose the speculations that follow, suggesting that the mirror set before us externally is of little or no avail unless the mirror of our own mind has been cleansed and polished.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence, it is fitting that there be contempt for all things. Wherefore there follows: "Of the tribe of Manasses, twelve thousand sealed." Manasses is understood to mean "oblivion." For some men despise earthly things, but do not give them up. Others give them up, but do not despise them. Others again despise them and give them up, but do not forget them. When the soul gives up and forgets, then there is perfection, and this is indicated in the sixth place. "Forget your people and your father's house." As Augustine writes, "He loves you less if, besides You, he loves something else not on account of You."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The patriarchs were the ancestors of the apostles according to the flesh and according to the promise. These apostles are the children of them that have been shaken. And, in another place: "The place of your fathers your sons shall have." Wherefore the apostles correspond to the Seraphim, because the apostolic order is conformed to Christ, and before this, there was the illuminative order, that of the prophets, and before that, the stabilizing order, that of the patriarchs.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Psalm: He established them as princes over all the earth: it is established that this was said of the Apostles: therefore all the earth is under the principate of the Apostles: but this principate is a stable principate, according to that word of the Psalm: Their principate has been exceedingly strengthened: but it is not stable unless it is united, because every kingdom divided against itself shall be brought to desolation; nor is it united unless it has one principal prince: therefore according to the prophetic testimony all the earth ought to be subject to one who is the prince of all. Whence Bernard says in the third book to Eugenius: "Your forebears were sent forth, not to subdue certain regions, but the world itself: and indeed their sound went forth into all the earth." And afterwards: "Their principate has been exceedingly strengthened: they have been established as princes over all the earth. You have succeeded to his inheritance, thus you are the heir, and the world is the inheritance."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"There is a stream whose runlets gladden the city of God," that is, the one "coming forth from the throne of God and of the Lamb," the Holy Spirit. And there will be no inner defect, since "they shall neither hunger nor thirst" through lack of sustainment by which life is lost; "neither shall the sun strike them" through any external harm.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If you wish to be regulated according to the divine rule, take care that you be not bestial but well-ordered: that you be directed not according to the impulse of sense, but according to the judgment of reason; not according to bestial phantasms, but according to intellectual judgments. Otherwise what happened to Adam will happen to you, who, having despised the rule of truth, followed the instinct of the woman, and the woman followed the instinct of the serpent. "Man, when he was in honor, did not understand; he was compared to the senseless beasts and was made like unto them." Man became brutish and subject to the passions.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the sacrifice of praise imposes upon the heart something naturally related to judgment: it is concerned with a command of nature; and in this all true philosophers agree. Hence he says that "whoever doubts whether parents are to be honored and God is to be venerated, is deserving of punishment."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the Lord rejoices in the right. "The delights at your right hand forever." At the left are passing riches, glories and consolations. We must indeed adhere to the right. As the Psalm says, "Your right hand upholds me," Lord. Hence the rewards dispose towards the third act of grace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, vegetation is generous. Hence in the Psalm: "You have visited the land and watered it; greatly have you enriched it. God's watercourses are filled; you have prepared the grain," and "the valleys are blanketed with grain." This land is alive and awake, it abounds. Now Sacred Scripture is generous in that God conveys His influence to it, producing the most abundant multiplications. For it is not like the other sciences, since God visits it, as shown in the Psalm: "God's watercourses are filled; you have prepared the grain."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whatever is said in the Bible of the sun shedding light, or of other diffusions, or of banquets, is said of His bounty. Hence, in the Psalm: "The household shall divide the spoils." And in Isaiah: "They rejoice before You as men make merry when dividing spoils." These are the gifts of Christ's lavishness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As a sweet chant results from a great number of voices united in a certain proportion and harmony, so also a spiritual harmony pleasing to the Most High comes forth from the harmony of the love of many. Hence the Psalm: "Bless the Lord, you of Israel's wellspring!" To such observers of divine Law, to such lovers of divine peace, to such singers of divine praise, and to no others, is this speech to be addressed: and such are men of the Church. As for the man who has been snatched away from this Church, this speech does not have to be addressed to him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If we wish to describe fortitude rightly, we must note that it is from heaven. "God is wonderful in his saints; the God of Israel, he himself shall give power and strength to his people." Therefore fortitude is a gift of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The honor taken from God through pride and disobedience with respect to a thing to which man was bound is in no way better restored than through humiliation and obedience to that thing to which one was in no way obligated. Since therefore Christ Jesus, insofar as he was God, was equal to the Father in the form of God; insofar as he was an innocent man, he was in no way a debtor of death: when he emptied himself and became obedient unto death, he paid back to God what he had not stolen through the homage of perfect satisfaction, and offered a sacrifice of supreme sweetness for the perfect placation of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“So does the man who sees God in all things, who tastes God in them through his three powers. "Pleasing to Him be my theme; I will be glad in the Lord." And elsewhere: "For you make me glad, O Lord, by Your deeds." Again: "I will glorify Him with thanksgiving." In all things there is taste and restoration for the intellective and the affective powers. Out of all these fruits there arises the fruit of love and charity which covers them all. For all of Scripture is ordained towards charity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth judgment of God is the judgment of abandonment, namely when God abandons man and exposes him to every temptation and sin. "When my strength shall fail, do not forsake me, O Lord. Depart not from me." It is a great peril when a father exposes his son in the midst of wolves.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To Him are referred all the eloquent sayings of Scriptural wisdom, as for instance those of Solomon and others. And yet the Jews understand as applying to Solomon what is said of Christ in the Psalm: "Fairer in beauty are you than the sons of men; grace is poured out upon your lips." Solomon was not like that. And again, "May his name be blessed forever."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But grace which lifts up is obtained through hope. The Psalm reads: "For what have I in heaven? And besides Thee what do I desire upon earth?" And elsewhere: "I say, You are my refuge, my portion in the land of the living," so that a man be kept whole in view of this fatherland. Therefore "our present light affliction which is for the moment, prepares for us an eternal weight of glory."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But if you ask how these things come about, ask grace, not doctrine; desire, not understanding; the groaning of prayer, not the study of reading; the Bridegroom, not the master; God, not man; darkness, not clarity; not light, but the fire that wholly inflames and carries into God through ecstatic anointings and most ardent affections. Which fire is indeed God, and his furnace is in Jerusalem, and Christ kindles this in the fervor of his most ardent passion, which only he truly perceives who says: My soul has chosen hanging, and my bones death. Whoever loves this death can see God, because it is indubitably true: No man shall see me and live. Let us die, therefore, and enter into the darkness; let us impose silence upon our cares, concupiscences, and phantasms; let us pass over with Christ crucified from this world to the Father, so that, when the Father is shown to us, we may say with Philip: It suffices us; let us hear with Paul: My grace suffices for you; let us exult with David, saying: My flesh and my heart have failed, God of my heart and God my portion forever. Blessed be the Lord forever, and let all the people say: So be it, so be it. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Augustine shows that in this word: "But it is good for me to adhere to God," the whole of what is said is contained: "You shall love the Lord your God with your whole heart and with your whole soul and with your whole mind." For we ought to love God, because this is just, holy, easy, and sweet. Whence Augustine: "Lord, who are you to me? And who am I to you, that you command me to love you, and if I do not love you, you threaten me with immense miseries?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ was such a Center in His crucifixion. "God is our king before ages; He has wrought salvation in the midst of the earth." The earth is clearly the center, and hence it is the lowest, and of modest size; and because the lowest and of modest size, it receives all the heavenly influences, and brings forth a marvelous multiplication of beings. Likewise the Son of God, the very small and poor and humble One, assuming our earth, and made of earth, not only came upon the surface of the earth, but indeed to the depth of its center, that is, "He has wrought salvation in the midst of the earth," for after His crucifixion, His soul went down into hell and re-established the heavenly thrones.
Such a Center has a saving power: and anyone who draws away from it is condemned, as drawing away from the means of humility. In such a center "He has wrought salvation," that is, in the humility of the cross.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Which peace our Lord Jesus Christ proclaimed and gave; of whose preaching our father Francis was a renewer, announcing peace at the beginning and end of every sermon, wishing peace in every greeting, sighing for ecstatic peace in every contemplation, like a citizen of that Jerusalem, of which that man of peace speaks, who was peaceable with those who hated peace: Pray for the things that are for the peace of Jerusalem. For he knew that the throne of Solomon was only in peace, since it is written: In peace is his place made, and his dwelling in Sion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such art is both one and manifold. How this can occur cannot be seen unless there come about an illumination "from the everlasting mountains," and when "despoiled are the stouthearted," that is, the foolish. For it is fitting to think of God in the highest way. Speculation is also manifold, for it represents many things distinctly and certainly. Hence I will see myself better in God than in myself. And yet it is supremely one.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By the fruits of the everlasting hills, wisdom is understood, or the fruit of wisdom, which consist in the contemplation of eternal reasons and the consideration of lofty heavenly spirits. "Thou enlightenest wonderfully from the everlasting hills. All the foolish of heart were troubled."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All these sciences, moreover, have certain and infallible rules, like lights and rays descending from the eternal law into our mind. And therefore our mind, irradiated and suffused with such great splendors, unless it be blind, can be led through itself to the contemplation of that eternal light. The irradiation and consideration of this light suspends the wise in admiration, and on the contrary leads the foolish, who do not believe so that they may understand, into perturbation, so that that prophetic word may be fulfilled: Thou dost illumine wondrously from the eternal mountains; all the foolish of heart are troubled.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such art is both one and manifold. How this can occur cannot be seen unless there come about an illumination "from the everlasting mountains," and when "despoiled are the stouthearted," that is, the foolish. For it is fitting to think of God in the highest way. Speculation is also manifold, for it represents many things distinctly and certainly. Hence I will see myself better in God than in myself. And yet it is supremely one.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the second place, a saint's life must be pure, that is, everything must be done out of love for God, and not out of love for something else, since all love is suspect if it is not addressed to God. That is why Augustine — and also Bernard in a letter to a certain monk — write that the apostles' love for the bodily Christ prevented the coming of the Spirit. What of other forms of love addressed to creatures? "My soul refuses comfort."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All perverse valuations of worldly natures are prohibited. Now every perverse valuation of creatures proceeds either by reason of sublimity, or by reason of sufficiency, or by reason of delight. In the first way it is the idolatry of the proud; in the second way it is the idolatry of the avaricious; in the third way it is the idolatry of the lascivious. Against the first the Prophet says: There shall be no new god in you, nor shall you adore a strange god.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the first, we proceed as follows and it is shown that the divine being is supremely one. And that this is so, faith and divine Scripture sufficiently proclaim, Exodus twenty: Your God is one God; and Deuteronomy thirty-two: See therefore that I alone am, and there is no other God besides me; and David in the Psalm: There shall not be in you a new god, nor shall you adore a foreign god: and divine Scripture sufficiently preaches this.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It must be said that this truth, that God is one, is a truth not only believable, but also intelligible: since it is necessary and certain not only from the testimony of Scripture and the illumination of grace, which is found in faith; but it is also certain from itself and from the testimony of creatures.
From itself, therefore: because the divine being, on account of its singular sublimity and sublime singularity, possesses unity in every way. For since God has every perfection in himself, and this in the highest degree and most excellently, he is shown to be one not only from the sublimity of nature and wisdom, power and goodness and influence and causality, but indeed from all his conditions and noble properties that are attributed to him in the highest degree. Hence all conditions attest to the unity of the supreme essence.
From the testimony of creatures also: because every creature, just as it has natural goodness, so also is shown to have unity. "For nothing can exist unless it is one," as Boethius and Augustine say, and as sense and intellect teach. Therefore, just as every creature by its goodness proclaims that in God there is true and supreme goodness, so by its unity it proclaims that the cause of all things is one in itself.
Nor does the diversity of things stand against this testimony. For every diversity of things is comprehended within one universe, which in itself is indeed finite and limited and perfect. But this would not be so unless that plurality were reduced to something in which there would be a stopping point: and therefore it is necessary that all things be reduced to one ultimate end and one first principle, otherwise there would be a regress to infinity. Therefore the very universe of things testifies that God is one: whence, just as it is impossible for one circumference to have, nor can one rationally conceive, any but one center, from which lines flow and to which they are reduced as to a terminus: so in one universe one cannot posit or understand anything but one God alone.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The door to wisdom is a yearning for it and a powerful desire. Hence the Psalm: "Open wide your mouth, and I will fill it." That is the road by which wisdom comes within me, by which I go into wisdom, and wisdom comes into me, and likewise charity. Such wisdom cannot be obtained without supreme mutual pleasure, but where there is supreme mutual pleasure, supreme yearning must have come first.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Transgressors of the commandments plunge into abominable crimes. Of such transgressors the Psalm says: "My people did not hear My voice, and Israel did not attend to Me, and I dismissed them according to the desires of their hearts." For the Lord delivers such transgressors into the hands of demons.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As inducing strength, the seven virtues are represented by the seven loaves of the gospel, from which the whole body of the elect is fed. For the philosophers, these four virtues became stones, but they are actually seven breads of life. Moses' five loaves were made of barley, but the seven loaves of wheat of the evangelical teaching were made out of the fat of the wheat.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All true philosophers worshiped a single God. That is why even Socrates was killed: in his reverence for one God, he forbade sacrifices to Apollo. It is true that Plato argued with him to flee. "May it never happen," answered Socrates, "that I deny a truth I have asserted!" And so Plato did not interfere with his execution: he even blushed for having suggested flight. The worship of God is the dutiful expression of faith. Hence Tullius says that propriety consists in the cult of the gods. It is not fitting that he say "of the gods." The angels are not called gods in Scriptures, lest they be venerated as gods, but men are called gods: God hath stood in the congregation of gods, that is, of men, not of angels. Now, the worship of God consists in praise and sacrifice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Where sacred Scripture is lacking, it is necessary that the earth, that is, the Church, be shaken: "They neither knew nor understood, they walk in darkness; all the foundations of the earth shall be moved." Arius, who wished to take away the foundation of the Trinity; Nestorius, who wished to destroy the unity of person; and Eutyches, who wished to confuse the natures in Christ: these men shook the foundations of the Church.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If honor and riches: God shall set His good and faithful servants over many things, indeed sons of God and gods they shall be called and shall be, and where His Son shall be, there shall they be also, heirs indeed of God, and co-heirs with Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Blessed is the man whose help is from You; he has disposed ascents in his heart, in the valley of tears, in the place which he has appointed. Since blessedness is nothing other than the enjoyment of the highest good, and the highest good is above us, no one can be made blessed unless he ascends above himself, not by a bodily ascent, but by one of the heart. But we cannot be raised above ourselves except by a higher power lifting us up. For however much the interior steps may be disposed, nothing is accomplished unless divine help accompanies them. But divine help accompanies those who seek it from a humble and devout heart; and this is to sigh toward Him in this valley of tears, which is done through fervent prayer. Prayer, therefore, is the mother and origin of the upward-lifting. Therefore Dionysius, in his book On Mystical Theology, wishing to instruct us in mental ecstasies, first sets forth prayer. Let us therefore pray and say to the Lord our God: Lead me, O Lord, in Your way, and I shall walk in Your truth; let my heart rejoice, that it may fear Your name.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It was fitting for the perfect Leader to show himself when there was opportunity to run toward the prize: and this is in the end of times, yet before the terminus, and in the approach to the final judgment, so that, spurred by the fear of judgment and drawn by the hope of reward and animated by the perfection of his example, we might vigorously and perfectly follow the Leader from virtue to virtue, until we arrive at the prize of eternal happiness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ was such a Center in His ascension. Likewise the Christian must rise "from strength to strength," and not stand still at the terminal point of virtue, for by so doing he would cease to be virtuous.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whoever therefore wishes to ascend to God must, having avoided the fault that deforms nature, exercise the aforementioned natural powers toward reforming grace, and this through prayer; toward purifying justice, and this in conduct of life; toward illuminating knowledge, and this in meditation; toward perfecting wisdom, and this in contemplation. Just as therefore no one comes to wisdom except through grace, justice, and knowledge, so one does not arrive at contemplation except through clear meditation, holy conduct, and devout prayer. Just as therefore grace is the foundation of uprightness of the will and of clear illumination of reason, so first we must pray, then live in holiness, third attend to the spectacles of truth, and by attending ascend step by step, until one arrives at the lofty mountain, where the God of gods is seen in Sion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And so, concerning the fruit of grace, it is written in the Psalm: "For the Lord will give goodness: and our earth shall yield her fruit." And so these fruits come forth from Christ, blessed by Joseph who produced fruit of heaven, and of the dew, and of the deep that lieth beneath, that is, the charismatic gifts of the graces, by means of dew on humble hearts.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Lead me, O Lord, in Your way, and I shall walk in Your truth; let my heart rejoice, that it may fear Your name. In praying this prayer, we are illuminated to know the stages of the divine ascent. For since, according to the state of our condition, the universe of things is itself a ladder for ascending into God, and among things some are vestiges, some are images, some are corporeal, some spiritual, some temporal, some aeviternal, and accordingly some are outside us, some within us: in order that we may arrive at the consideration of the First Principle, which is most spiritual and eternal and above us, we must pass through the vestige, which is corporeal and temporal and outside us, and this is to be led in the way of God: we must enter into our own mind, which is the image of God, aeviternal, spiritual and within us, and this is to walk in the truth of God: we must transcend to the eternal, most spiritual, and above us, looking toward the First Principle, and this is to rejoice in the knowledge of God and in the reverence of His majesty.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Furthermore, this charity gives to the soul a fire. Hence, in the Canticle, "Set me as a seal on your heart... for stern as death is love," when it loves to such a degree that it is totally carried up to the supremely desirable, and sees prosperity as nothing, and adversity as nothing, since all things are like a single straw in a furnace. "If a man should give all the substance of his house for love, he shall despise it as nothing." Now, the fourth seal consists in this, that the soul perceives an incomprehensible consolation that grows so much within it that it is unable both to comprehend it and to explain it to others. The Canticle says of this: "Eat, friends; drink! Drink freely of love!" And this inebriated soul says: The king "brought me into the cellar of wine." And earlier: "The king hath brought me into his storerooms." This occurs when the soul is beside itself, like a drunken man who does not know what he is doing. Hence, Paul did not know whether he was in the body or out of the body. Of this seal, the Psalm says: "Shew me a token for good, that they who hate me may see, and be confounded."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Church had to be founded: therefore it was necessary to lay the foundations, namely the commandments of God, and it was necessary that they be placed in some person. This could not be except in the glorious Virgin; as the Psalm says: "His foundations are in the holy mountains: a man is born in her, and the Most High himself has founded her."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The heavens proclaim your wonders, that is, the marvels of the soul which they feel within them. Such experiences make faith most secure. When the soul considers the Most High in a manner that is most pious, true, and good, then it is lifted up by zeal and the rapture of love to the third heaven.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This counsel has been confirmed by the twelve Apostles and by the counsels of the Saints. If you want the testimony of the Saints concerning these counsels, seek Anthony, Paphnutius, and Macarius, who all resolved to observe these counsels. Seek the bishops Basil, Augustine, Martin, and Gregory; all were monks and resolved to observe the counsels and kept them. Seek also Benedict, who was an abbot; seek Dominic, seek Francis, who resolved that all these counsels must be observed. From the Lamb proceed torches, and they are illuminations for manifesting the counsels. It is written: 'God who is glorified in the counsel of the saints.' Therefore we ought to choose a good counselor.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The spiritual throne is indicated: that of doctrine, of superiorship, or of judgment. Hence the Psalm: "And his throne shall be like the sun before me; like the moon which remains forever." A superior is the sun as regards the documents of truth, the moon as regards the example of virtue; or he is the sun of wisdom and the moon of knowledge; or again, he is the sun in the act of judgment and the moon in that of mercy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The spiritual throne is indicated: that of doctrine, of superiorship, or of judgment. Hence the Psalm: "And his throne shall be like the sun before me; like the moon which remains forever." A superior is the sun as regards the documents of truth, the moon as regards the example of virtue; or he is the sun of wisdom and the moon of knowledge; or again, he is the sun in the act of judgment and the moon in that of mercy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But if you ask how these things come about, ask grace, not doctrine; desire, not understanding; the groaning of prayer, not the study of reading; the Bridegroom, not the master; God, not man; darkness, not clarity; not light, but the fire that wholly inflames and carries into God through ecstatic anointings and most ardent affections. Which fire is indeed God, and his furnace is in Jerusalem, and Christ kindles this in the fervor of his most ardent passion, which only he truly perceives who says: My soul has chosen hanging, and my bones death. Whoever loves this death can see God, because it is indubitably true: No man shall see me and live. Let us die, therefore, and enter into the darkness; let us impose silence upon our cares, concupiscences, and phantasms; let us pass over with Christ crucified from this world to the Father, so that, when the Father is shown to us, we may say with Philip: It suffices us; let us hear with Paul: My grace suffices for you; let us exult with David, saying: My flesh and my heart have failed, God of my heart and God my portion forever. Blessed be the Lord forever, and let all the people say: So be it, so be it. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Adam passed over from truth to vanity. "A phantom only, man goes his ways; like vapor only are his restless pursuits; he heaps up stores, and knows not who will use them. — The next morning they are like the changing grass, which at dawn springs up anew, but by evening wilts and fades." For as long as vain, transitory, passing good is loved, man is "passing over." And such passing over Wisdom reproves. This passing over is the cause of every evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since Scripture conceals a manifold understanding beneath a single letter, the expositor ought to bring hidden things forth into the light and make manifest what has been drawn forth through another, more open passage of Scripture, as if I were to expound that verse of the Psalm: Take hold of arms and shield, and rise up to help me, and wished to explain what the divine arms are; I would say that they are his truth and good will: and that this is so must be proved through open Scripture. For it is also written elsewhere: With the shield of your good will you have crowned us; and again: His truth shall compass you about with a shield.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The soul is disposed to the gift of fortitude through the unconquerable shield of faith. The devil draws man to the concupiscence of the flesh, to the concupiscence of the eyes, and to the pride of life. What is the means of resisting these? Through truth. "His truth shall encompass you with a shield," namely through faith dwelling within, "you shall not fear the terror of the night." And blessed Peter said: "Your adversary as a roaring lion goes about seeking whom he may devour: whom resist, strong in faith." If we loved truth, we would not fear the devil, because it is written: "The eyes of the Lord behold the whole earth and give fortitude to those who believe in him with a perfect heart."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third part of the perfection of the fear of the Lord consists in the perfect firmness of confidence: because the fear of the Lord is a tower of firmness and confidence, because it renders a person secure from every other fear. "His truth shall encompass you with a shield; you shall not fear the terror of the night, nor the arrow that flies by day, nor the pestilence that walks in darkness, nor the assault and the noonday devil." He who does not fear God must fear everywhere; and he who truly fears God has what no one can take from him. But he who fears something other than God has what ought to be taken from him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this garden, there is much walking about, for if one is not happy to remain in the first, he goes to the second, and likewise with the others. And so man is compassed about with apples. Hence, in the Canticle: "Stay me up with flowers, compass me about with apples." And in the Psalm: "His truth shall compass thee with a shield." And so, as the intellect is ordained toward the affective dispositions, and faith is the way to charity, so also these enlightenments must pass over into the affective dispositions, in order that the intellect pass from the speculative to the practical.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third part of the perfection of the fear of the Lord consists in the perfect firmness of confidence: because the fear of the Lord is a tower of firmness and confidence, because it renders a person secure from every other fear. "His truth shall encompass you with a shield; you shall not fear the terror of the night, nor the arrow that flies by day, nor the pestilence that walks in darkness, nor the assault and the noonday devil." He who does not fear God must fear everywhere; and he who truly fears God has what no one can take from him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The soul is disposed to the gift of fortitude through the unconquerable shield of faith. The devil draws man to the concupiscence of the flesh, to the concupiscence of the eyes, and to the pride of life. What is the means of resisting these? Through truth. "His truth shall encompass you with a shield," namely through faith dwelling within, "you shall not fear the terror of the night." If we loved truth, we would not fear the devil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third part of the perfection of the fear of the Lord consists in the perfect firmness of confidence: because the fear of the Lord is a tower of firmness and confidence, because it renders a person secure from every other fear. "His truth shall encompass you with a shield; you shall not fear the terror of the night, nor the arrow that flies by day, nor the pestilence that walks in darkness, nor the assault and the noonday devil." He who does not fear God must fear everywhere; and he who truly fears God has what no one can take from him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens from the right by means of dangerous satisfactions. Nor is it without reason that satisfactions are called dangerous and punishments benign, for satisfactions entail serious risk. Behold Adam, Saul, Solomon, the idolater Jeroboam, and the Prince of Angels, to all of whom temporal satisfactions and a state of high eminence were occasions of ruin. For they are occasions of ruin when they please. When they do not please, man is not taken up by them. Wherefore Christ did not want to have any temporal satisfaction, because a thousand fall at your side, ten thousand at your right. And one should always prefer to be on that side on which less are falling.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence, when one considers brightness as coming from light, the mind must be transferred to the consideration of the eternal generation—and so with the other examples. And in this there is a great pleasure of which it is said in the Psalm: "For You make me glad, O Lord, by Your deeds; at the work of Your hands, I rejoice." Wherefore the Apostle says: "We all, with faces unveiled, reflecting as in a mirror the glory of the Lord."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“So does the man who sees God in all things, who tastes God in them through his three powers. "Pleasing to Him be my theme; I will be glad in the Lord." And elsewhere: "For you make me glad, O Lord, by Your deeds." Again: "I will glorify Him with thanksgiving." In all things there is taste and restoration for the intellective and the affective powers. Out of all these fruits there arises the fruit of love and charity which covers them all. For all of Scripture is ordained towards charity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He therefore who is not illumined by such great splendors of created things is blind; he who is not awakened by such great cries is deaf; he who does not praise God on account of all these effects is mute; he who from such great signs does not advert to the first principle is a fool. Open therefore your eyes, bring near your spiritual ears, loose your lips, and apply your heart, that in all creatures you may see, hear, praise, love, and worship, magnify and honor your God, lest perchance the whole world rise up against you. For on this account the whole world shall fight against the senseless, and conversely for the wise it shall be matter of glory, who according to the Prophet can say: Thou hast given me delight, O Lord, in thy making, and in the works of thy hands I shall rejoice. How great are thy works, O Lord! Thou hast made all things in wisdom, the earth is filled with thy possession.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is hierarchized also in relation to the Church Militant, in which there is a distinction by reason of processes, of ascents, and of practices, for this is how the Church is seen, and in no other way: in it, there is one head, one body, and one food. Paul speaks much of this, for he was well versed in this consideration. Likewise, the Psalter speaks much of it. And sometimes it speaks in the name of such a person [the Church], and at other times, in the name of another. Hence in the Psalm: "The Lord is King, in splendor robed," it refers to the Church's head and to its four orders.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The spiritual meanings are called rivers — and also those men who understand in a spiritual manner — because they have their origin from the Scriptures and are confirmed by the Scriptures, and because, from these spiritual meanings, other meanings are derived. Hence in the Psalm: "The floods lift up, O Lord, the floods lift up their voice; the floods lift up their tumult. More powerful than the roar of many waters." Why? Because "powerful on high is the Lord," God's voice had to be loud.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The spiritual meanings are called rivers — and also those men who understand in a spiritual manner — because they have their origin from the Scriptures and are confirmed by the Scriptures, and because, from these spiritual meanings, other meanings are derived. Hence in the Psalm: "The floods lift up, O Lord, the floods lift up their voice; the floods lift up their tumult. More powerful than the roar of many waters." Why? Because "powerful on high is the Lord," God's voice had to be loud.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"He who chastises the nations, shall he not rebuke, he who teaches man knowledge?" The Psalm of David says that the great teacher of knowledge is God. You know that if someone must draw water, he more willingly draws it from its original source than from a rivulet. Therefore, if the Lord is the great teacher and giver of the gift about which we intend to speak, it is necessary that we have recourse to that font in order to obtain illumination. Thus did the Psalmist, thus did Solomon, and he became a great scholar. In the beginning it is necessary that we lift up our souls and beseech the bestower of gifts, because we do not seek temporal things, but the benefit and salvation of our soul; and this is pleasing to God, just as Solomon did, who sought wisdom from the Lord. Let us therefore beseech the Lord, that he himself may open the eyes of our mind and grant me the light of knowledge, so that I may be able to say something concerning the gift of knowledge, which may be to the honor of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We ought to say: Lord, you are the one whom we ought to adore, whom we ought to serve; you are the one who created me; you are the one who redeemed me. Come, let us adore and fall down and weep before the Lord who made us, for he is the Lord our God, and we are the people of his pasture and the sheep of his hand.
These two things, therefore, namely the knowledge of the Creator and the Restorer, are set forth first, without which we can understand nothing, because these are the foundations of our faith.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Everything that is adored other than God is either an intellectual creature, such as angels and demons; or a corporeal creature, such as heaven and earth and water and the like; or it is a figment of the human mind. And the Lord prohibits adoring these three. Sacred Scripture places the intellectual creature at the highest level, the figment in the middle, and corporeal nature at the lowest; and accordingly it first prohibits idolatry with respect to the intellectual creature, when it says: You shall not have strange gods. Concerning idolatry with respect to the spiritual creature, it is said in the Psalm: For all the gods of the nations are demons, but the Lord made the heavens.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fire will precede the face of the Judge, by which the face of the earth will be burned up, so that the figure of this world will perish by the conflagration of worldly fires, just as the flood came about by the inundation of waters.
Since in the final judgment, on account of the severity of the judge to be displayed, it is necessary that the hearts of all be terrified, and especially of sinners, who despised the Lord of all things, so that every creature may receive divine zeal and be conformed to its Author, and also conformed to its inhabitant: it is necessary that the foundations of the entire world be most horribly shaken. And because nothing more intensely and swiftly and horribly in its action moves the other elements than fire rushing together from here and there on every side: hence it is that fire must precede the face of the judge himself, not from one side only, but from every part of the world, so that there may be a convergence of elemental and terrestrial fire, of purgatorial and also infernal fire, so that by infernal fire the reprobate may be burned, by purgatorial fire the just may be purged, by terrestrial fire these things born of the earth may be consumed, by elemental fire the elements may be refined and disposed toward the face of renewal, and together with this all other things may be disturbed, so that not only men and demons, but even the Angels beholding may be terrified.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Why did the Lord place the figment of the human mind among idolatry, since a figment is nothing in reality? An idol is nothing; rather, it is referred to that which exists in estimation. Concerning idolatry with respect to the figment of the human mind, it is said in the Psalm: Let all be confounded who adore graven things, and who glory in their idols. That man is inclined to adore his own figment and thus to glory in adoring it — this is the supreme perversion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The whole Trinity speaks these words: I am the Lord your God. He says therefore I, namely, the one whom you ought to obey and whom you ought to love and adore. Or he says I, who made you in the being of nature and in the being of grace. We ought therefore also to say: Lord, you are the one whom we ought to adore, whom we ought to serve; you are the one who created me; you are the one who redeemed me. Know that the Lord himself is God; He made us, and not we ourselves.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That the divine being is immutable is shown by authority. The Psalm: You shall change them, and they shall be changed, but You are the selfsame; the Gloss says: "immutable."
For inasmuch as it is simple, it is immutable from itself: for it has nothing that is not its own essential being, which indeed "is not an accident, but a subsistent truth," as Hilary says. Inasmuch as it is immense, it is not mutable in another or by another: for nothing else can transfer it, since it is everywhere whole. Moreover, inasmuch as it is eternal, it is not mutable with another, because it itself remains fixed, while other things succeed one another.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Although God possesses all the most noble properties, He is nevertheless most excellent in this property, namely that of piety. He is pious and merciful, because He spares and protects. The Lord says: "As a father has mercy on his children, so have I had mercy on you."
Search all the works of God from the beginning to the end, and you will always find operations of mercy that are great, greater, and greatest. The great operations of divine mercy are the operations of nature; the greater operations of divine mercy are the operations of grace; but the greatest operations are the operations of glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We need divine mercy pardoning our offenses, and divine justice recompensing our merits. But the fear of God makes one find mercy, and the observance of the commandments, justice. The consideration of the magnificence of God leads to fearing; the consideration of the divine law leads to the observance of the commandments. And for this reason it is suggested to us that we should always meditate on the divine law. Whence the Jews on the Sabbath day were accustomed always to dispute concerning the law of God, because this is the work of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We cannot have the grace of God except through the fear of God, because "the mercy of the Lord is from eternity and unto eternity upon those who fear him." No one receives the grace of God unless he fears God. Bernard says: "In truth I have learned that nothing is equally efficacious for meriting, preserving, and multiplying the grace of God as if at all times you are found before God not to be wise in lofty things, but to fear."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From the midst of the rocks they shall give forth their voices. That is, from the midst of the two cherubim of which the Lord speaks, meaning from the space between them, that is, from the midst of the Two Testaments. The third firmness of faith consists in the full accord of the witnesses, and is found in three things: in the words of Scriptures, in the decrees of the councils, and in the writings of the saints.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the fourth part, the refreshment of eternal strength is sought, and this through the gift of strength or fortitude, when he says: "Give us this day our daily bread." "Bread strengthens the heart of man."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He therefore who is not illumined by such great splendors of created things is blind; he who is not awakened by such great cries is deaf; he who does not praise God on account of all these effects is mute; he who from such great signs does not advert to the first principle is a fool. Open therefore your eyes, bring near your spiritual ears, loose your lips, and apply your heart, that in all creatures you may see, hear, praise, love, and worship, magnify and honor your God, lest perchance the whole world rise up against you. For on this account the whole world shall fight against the senseless, and conversely for the wise it shall be matter of glory, who according to the Prophet can say: Thou hast given me delight, O Lord, in thy making, and in the works of thy hands I shall rejoice. How great are thy works, O Lord! Thou hast made all things in wisdom, the earth is filled with thy possession.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On that verse of the Psalm: "He who looks upon the earth and makes it tremble," the Gloss says: "Then God looks upon the earth and makes it tremble, when he illumines the earthly man by the regard of his grace and converts him to his original principle, through which all things are begun and governed. And then man trembles." Therefore man ought greatly to consider what he thinks, what he speaks, and what he does, because God sees all things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For all creatures declare God. What shall I do? I shall sing with them all. The thick cord in the zither does not give forth a pleasant sound if struck alone, but there is harmony in consonance with others. So does the man who sees God in all things, who tastes God in them through his three powers. "Pleasing to Him be my theme; I will be glad in the Lord." And elsewhere: "For you make me glad, O Lord, by Your deeds." Again: "I will glorify Him with thanksgiving." In all things there is taste and restoration for the intellective and the affective powers.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first plague was of blood, by which idolaters were struck, because the Psalm says of them: "They poured out innocent blood, the blood of their sons and of their daughters, whom they sacrificed to the idols of Canaan."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But if you ask how these things come about, ask grace, not doctrine; desire, not understanding; the groaning of prayer, not the study of reading; the Bridegroom, not the master; God, not man; darkness, not clarity; not light, but the fire that wholly inflames and carries into God through ecstatic anointings and most ardent affections. Which fire is indeed God, and his furnace is in Jerusalem, and Christ kindles this in the fervor of his most ardent passion, which only he truly perceives who says: My soul has chosen hanging, and my bones death. Whoever loves this death can see God, because it is indubitably true: No man shall see me and live. Let us die, therefore, and enter into the darkness; let us impose silence upon our cares, concupiscences, and phantasms; let us pass over with Christ crucified from this world to the Father, so that, when the Father is shown to us, we may say with Philip: It suffices us; let us hear with Paul: My grace suffices for you; let us exult with David, saying: My flesh and my heart have failed, God of my heart and God my portion forever. Blessed be the Lord forever, and let all the people say: So be it, so be it. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In relation to the most profound depth of spiritual meanings, the Psalm reads: "They who sailed the sea in ships, trading on the deep waters." The man goes down to the sea in ships who approaches the Scriptures in a spirit of extreme reverence in order to explain them. He goes down with ships who takes as support the wood of the cross: for anyone who seeks to enter the sea of Scriptures without this wood is submerged, for he sinks into the greatest errors. Unless he is Peter himself, he founders.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Psalm: Let his children be carried about vagabonds and beg: but nothing that the Psalmist, speaking in the Spirit of God, imprecates as a punishment pertains to evangelical perfection or perfect justice; begging is of this kind: therefore, etc.
To that which is objected, that begging is an evil which the Psalmist imprecates, speaking in the Spirit of God: it must be said that there is voluntary begging and compelled begging, which is accompanied by murmuring and impatience. The first is meritorious, the second is demeritorious and afflictive; and the Psalm is understood of the second, not of the first. And that this is true appears from the text, because it says: Let them be carried about wandering and be cast out, and all these things seem to connote compulsion and violence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, Psalm: He persecuted the needy and begging man: Gloss: "namely Christ. To persecute the poor is sheer cruelty. Others indeed sometimes suffer such things on account of riches and honors." Either, therefore, Christ is called a beggar because He begged from the Father, or because He begged from man. If because He begged from the Father: then all men are beggars, the rich as well as the poor: therefore to persecute Christ in this way would not have been the height of cruelty; if because He begged from men, we have what was proposed: therefore etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Behold, He sets before us curse and blessing; let us leave to Judas the traitor the curse and the snares, of whom it is said that he "did not will blessing, and it shall be far from him"; and let us with blessed Matthias receive the blessing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Under the Law in the mystery of the giving of the Law, Christ is symbolized by Moses' staff with which he chastised the Egyptians and dried up the sea, and which is the scepter of power which the Lord stretched forth from Sion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third mode of generation is by means of propagation, and this in a fourfold way: as of a growth coming from a seed, a tree from a root, a conceived offspring from the belly or womb of the mother, or children from a begetting father. In the first mode of generation, formal beauty is lacking, for in the seed the form is vague and hidden. It is not so in the case of the Son. In the second, conformity is lacking, for although there is a single root, it is different in shape from the branches even though they produce a single tree. In the third, actuality is lacking, for although the mother is in a certain sense the active principle of the offspring, yet she is much more of a passive principle. In the fourth, eternal coexistence is lacking.
Now, take away these defects and suppose first formal beauty. In this sense, there is Isaiah: "The branch of the Lord will be luster and glory, and the fruit of the earth will be honor and splendor." Second, suppose conformity: The Son conforms to the Father to the point that He is "the tree of life... in the midst of the garden." Hence, in Proverbs: "She is a tree of life to those who grasp her." Third, suppose actuality: in this sense, you have the Psalm: "With Thee is the principality in the day of Thy strength, in the brightness of the saints: from the womb before the day star I begot Thee. From the womb," says the Psalmist, which is in relation to the warmth of the Father's bosom, from which He does not withdraw. Fourth, suppose eternal coexistence. In this sense, there is the Psalm: "This day I have begotten You," that is in eternity, or in My eternal today.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning this hierarch, then, and the ecclesiastical hierarchy, the whole of sacred Scripture exists, through which we are taught to be purged, illumined, and perfected, and this according to the threefold law handed down in it, namely of nature, of Scripture, and of grace; or rather according to its threefold principal part, namely the Mosaic law which purges, the prophetic revelation which illumines, and the evangelical teaching which perfects; or most especially according to its threefold spiritual understanding: the tropological, which purges unto uprightness of life; the allegorical, which illumines unto clarity of understanding; the anagogical, which perfects through mental ecstasies and the sweetest perceptions of wisdom, according to the three aforesaid theological virtues and the reformed spiritual senses and the three above-mentioned ecstasies and the hierarchical acts of the mind, by which our mind returns to its interior, so that there it may contemplate God in the splendors of the Saints and in them as in resting-places may sleep in peace and rest, the Bridegroom adjuring that it not be awakened until it proceed of His will.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This counsel has been confirmed by the twelve Apostles and by the counsels of the Saints. From the Lamb proceed torches, and they are illuminations for manifesting the counsels. It is written: 'God who is glorified in the counsel of the saints.' The Psalm says: 'I will confess to you, O Lord, with my whole heart, in the counsel of the just and in the congregation.' Therefore we ought to choose a good counselor.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of God avails for obtaining the illumination of divine wisdom, because "the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom." For the fear of the Lord is the extrinsic principle of wisdom and the intrinsic principle and the complement of wisdom; because there is servile fear, and this is the initiator of wisdom, because, just as the needle introduces the thread and does not remain with the thread, so servile fear introduces wisdom and does not remain with wisdom. Another is the fear of punishment and of offending God; and this is the intrinsic beginning of wisdom and the root of wisdom. The third is the fear of filial reverence: and this is the complement of wisdom, because "the fullness of wisdom is to fear God."
Fear produces these three things in us, because "the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom," and "the root of wisdom is to fear God," and "the fullness of wisdom is to fear God": Job: "Behold, the fear of the Lord, that itself is wisdom." He who does not fear God knows nothing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Holy and terrible is his name; the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom; a good understanding have all who practice it." Prudential understanding teaches what is to be avoided, namely every evil. For every person who wishes to be directed toward the good must fear God, so as to avoid every evil. Therefore prudential understanding teaches first what is to be avoided, namely every evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If, now, it is considered as fulfilling or perfecting, this again is threefold: it may be seen as vital food for the militant and triumphant Church, as the punishment of crimes, and as the final reward. It is fitting that God be first; hence He is credible and understandable, and this in terms of influence by reason of the laws of mercy, justice and peace; in relation to the first, as Virtue; in relation to the second, as Truth; in relation to the third, as Equity. These are the twelve gates that are mentioned in the psalm: "Open to me the gates of justice," for "He who is just lives by faith."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wherefore the Psalm reads: Happy are they whose way is blameless. And: Instruct me, O Lord, in the way of Your statutes, etc. In every verse there is a reference to commands, indicated as law, or witnessing, or declarations, or some other equivalent name. Also, in the Hebrew, every verse of each octave begins with the same letter—which cannot be rendered in our language—so that the twenty-two letters correspond to the twenty-two octaves, and each octave contains eight verses. Augustine was moved by so great a correspondence: that there be here so much knowledge and so great a variety. For Augustine himself once saw a very beautiful tree that had twenty-two branches, and each one had eight twigs, and from these the most sweet drops were running. And he understood that this tree was the Psalm: Happy are they whose way is blameless. Hence, meditation on the Law is supremely necessary.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Then I shall not be confounded, when I shall have regard to all your commandments." Blessed James says: "Whoever shall keep the whole law, yet offend in one point, is become guilty of all": not that for one transgression he is punished with as much punishment of sense as for the transgression of all; but he will be punished with as much punishment of loss, yet not as severely for one as for all. Therefore, if anyone wishes to attain to true life, it is necessary that he have regard to all the commandments of God in heart, mouth, and deed. And therefore he says: "When I shall have regarded," that is, perfectly looked upon and considered and acted accordingly, I shall not fear to be confounded. It is no great thing to be confounded in the present, but to be confounded eternally. Such confusion is greatly to be abhorred. But we cannot escape that confusion unless we have regard to all the commandments of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In these twelve mysteries is the whole of Scripture. In each of these there are twelve lights of scriptural interpretation, that is, the allegorical, the anagogical, and the tropological. And twelve times twelve are one hundred and forty-four, and this corresponds to the number of those marked with the sign, and to that of the City. Hence in the Psalm: "Open my eyes, that I may consider the wonders of your law."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Transgressors of the commandments merit eternal punishments. The Psalm: "Cursed are they who decline from Thy commandments": cursed, because it shall be said to them: "Depart, ye cursed, into everlasting fire."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“'For your testimonies are my meditation, and your justifications are my counsel'; which counsel is found in the testaments and testimonies. In designation of this it is said in Exodus that when Moses was to enter the oracle, he entered through the midst of the two Cherubim. He went through the midst, because Christ must have regard for both testaments.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The sacraments of Scripture, which externally seem arid, are yet alive within. No other Scripture besides this one is able to give life. Hence, in the Psalm: "For the sake of Your promise, give me life."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Together with fear one must also love God. When the heart is enlarged through love, then man easily keeps the commandments of God. I have run the way of thy commandments, when thou didst enlarge my heart. He says that the way of God's commandments is broad, yet to some it seems to be narrow. Certainly to those who love, it is broad; but to those who do not love, it seems to be narrow.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wherefore the Psalm reads: Happy are they whose way is blameless. And: Instruct me, O Lord, in the way of Your statutes, etc. In every verse there is a reference to commands, indicated as law, or witnessing, or declarations, or some other equivalent name. Also, in the Hebrew, every verse of each octave begins with the same letter—which cannot be rendered in our language—so that the twenty-two letters correspond to the twenty-two octaves, and each octave contains eight verses. Augustine was moved by so great a correspondence: that there be here so much knowledge and so great a variety. For Augustine himself once saw a very beautiful tree that had twenty-two branches, and each one had eight twigs, and from these the most sweet drops were running. And he understood that this tree was the Psalm: Happy are they whose way is blameless. Hence, meditation on the Law is supremely necessary.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, civil war is the temptation of the world. Indeed, every creature is a trap. Hence the saying: Vanity of vanities! All things are vanity! What profit has man from all the labor which he toils at under the sun? Vain and worthless is anything of which nothing remains to man after death: wherefore all things are vanity. The Psalm reads: Turn away my eyes from seeing what is vain.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scholastic discipline without personal discipline is insufficient for wisdom: for a man becomes wise not merely by listening: he must also conform. Hence the Psalm on wisdom reads: "Teach me goodness and discipline and knowledge." For there is no knowledge without precedent discipline, nor discipline without precedent goodness. Hence it is through goodness and discipline that knowledge dwells within us. A sick man is not healed by listening to a physician: he must follow his prescription. But few walk along that way of wisdom, hence few ever reach it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Passing over is an endeavor: the endeavor to pass from the study of the sciences to the study of holiness and from the study of holiness to that of wisdom. It is said of this in the Psalm: "Teach me goodness and discipline and knowledge." The endeavor begins from the top because it wants to "taste and see how good the Lord is." But it is not possible to reach wisdom except through discipline, nor discipline except through knowledge — wherefore the last should not be placed before the first. It would be a poor merchant who would prefer tin to gold. The man who chooses knowledge over holiness will never prosper.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, we ought to speak of the commandments of God, that we may better know them. For the more frequently a man walks along a certain way, the better he knows it. Whence Gregory says that a man comes to know the way by walking it more frequently. But the way of going to the fatherland is through the observance of the commandments; but a man cannot keep the commandments of God unless he knows them, and he does not know them except by hearing discourse about them. Therefore David says: "Give me understanding, and I shall learn thy commandments."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On that verse of the Psalm, *Your hands have made me and formed me; give me understanding,* the Gloss says: "God alone gives understanding: for God through himself, who *is light,* illuminates devout minds."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scriptures, explaining the mystery of the heavenly and sub-heavenly hierarchies, say: Your word, O Lord, endures forever; it is firm as the heavens; that is, the word of the Trinity. Through all generations your truth endures; You have established the earth and it stands firm. The Church, represented by the name "earth," was founded upon this Word.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scriptures, explaining the mystery of the heavenly and sub-heavenly hierarchies, say: Your word, O Lord, endures forever; it is firm as the heavens; that is, the word of the Trinity. Through all generations your truth endures; You have established the earth and it stands firm. The Church, represented by the name "earth," was founded upon this Word.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When the heart is enlarged through love, then man easily keeps the commandments of God. I have seen an end of all perfection; thy commandment is exceedingly broad. He says that the way of God's commandments is broad, yet to some it seems to be narrow. Certainly to those who love, it is broad; but to those who do not love, it seems to be narrow.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second benefit of keeping the commandments of God is the understanding of the sacred Scriptures; the Psalm: "I have understood above the ancients, because I have sought your commandments." But how we may arrive at the understanding of the sacred Scriptures, Gregory shows: whence concerning the passage that the disciples, when they saw Jesus, did not understand him, but when they heard him speaking, then they understood him, Gregory says there that "by hearing God's precepts the disciples were not illuminated, but by doing them they were illuminated"; because not the hearers of the law only, but the doers shall be justified.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Sacred Scripture is a tongue, hence: "Sweetmeats and milk are under your tongue — How sweet to my palate are your promises, sweeter than honey to my mouth!" This tongue enjoys the taste of food, wherefore these same Scriptures are compared to loaves of bread that nourish and are pleasant to the taste.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Note that an animal that does not ruminate is impure. Now, rumination consists in this, that an animal has two stomachs. It brings food to its mouth, then ruminates it, then makes it pass into the second stomach. The Psalm reads: "How sweet to my palate are your promises, sweeter than honey to my mouth!" Do not love the harlot and dismiss your wife.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is read that blessed Gregory, who was Pope and Doctor of the Church, had the custom that whenever he went to the study of the divine law, he always spoke these words: Depart from me, ye evildoers, and I will search the commandments of my God. It was asked of him why he did this; and he replied to Peter, to whom he was accustomed to tell his secrets, that he had learned by experience that whenever he wished to meditate on the law of God, he felt demons always opposing him. But in other subtleties the demons do not provoke, because in them they see no harm to themselves: indeed, they expect advantage from them. But when mention is made of the teachings of truth, by which demons are put to flight, then the prince of darkness rushes forth armed, now through earthly occupations, now through phantastic illusions, and strives to call back the minds of men from the study of truth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third origin of the fear of the Lord is from the consideration of the severity of divine vengeance, because the judgments of God are many. Whence the Psalm: "Pierce my flesh with your fear, for I have feared your judgments." For there are seven judgments of God: six are in the present life, and the seventh is at death, and that one shall be doubled. The first judgment of God is that of binding; the second is that of blinding; the third is that of obstinacy; the fourth is that of abandonment; the fifth is that of scattering; the sixth is that of despair, and the seventh is that of condemnation. All the judgments of God David feared; whence he said: "For I have feared because of thy judgments."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I am thy servant: give me understanding, that I may know thy testimonies." Gratuitous knowledge teaches to know and the manner of knowing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Prophet David shows for what reason we ought to speak of the commandments of God, and this he shows through a threefold reason. The first is that we may be inflamed to the love of the divine commandments; for nothing is so necessary as to love the law of God and his commandments. And on account of this he said: "Therefore I have loved thy commandments above gold and topaz."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, we ought to speak of the commandments of God, that we may hate iniquity. Therefore it is said in the Psalm: "Therefore I was directed toward all thy commandments; every wicked way I have hated." For when a man begins to know iniquity or sin and the disorders of sin which are against God, then he begins to detest sin. We ought therefore to speak of the commandments, that we may love and understand them and be directed on the way to the fatherland and hate iniquity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That the simple profit by hearing the word of God is clear, because it is said in the Psalm: "The declaration of your words illuminates and gives understanding to the little ones." "Little one" is the name given here to one who on account of the smallness of his knowledge is called a little one, just as one who knows few things is said to have a small soul, and likewise one who knows many things is said to be of great understanding. "Little one" is also said of one who conducts himself humbly, even if he knows many things and is very understanding.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On account of which it should be noted that sacred Scripture sets before us a sevenfold septenary for consideration, namely of the capital vices, of the Sacraments, of the virtues, of the gifts, of the beatitudes, of the petitions, and of the glorious endowments, three spiritual and four corporal: the septenary of vices as the first, from which we ought to withdraw; the septenary of the Sacraments as the second, through which we ought to advance; the septenary of the endowments as the last, which we ought to desire; the septenary of the petitions as the penultimate, by which we ought to ask: and the threefold intermediate septenary of the virtues, the gifts, and the beatitudes, through which we ought to pass: so that, praising the name of the Lord and praying seven times a day, we may obtain the sevenfold grace of the virtues, gifts, and beatitudes, by which we may overcome the sevenfold battle of the capital vices and arrive at the sevenfold crown of the glorious endowments, with the aid nonetheless of the sevenfold medicine of the Sacraments divinely established for the restoration of the human race.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The authority of the one commanding ought to move us to observe the commandments of God. He is of great authority, because by His wondrous wisdom He governs us. "I have kept your commandments and your testimonies, because all my ways are in your sight."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Which peace our Lord Jesus Christ proclaimed and gave; of whose preaching our father Francis was a renewer, announcing peace at the beginning and end of every sermon, wishing peace in every greeting, sighing for ecstatic peace in every contemplation, like a citizen of that Jerusalem, of which that man of peace speaks, who was peaceable with those who hated peace: Pray for the things that are for the peace of Jerusalem. For he knew that the throne of Solomon was only in peace, since it is written: In peace is his place made, and his dwelling in Sion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If you take a straight look at the leaders of the city, the foremost chief is Christ. In terms of the fight, although the angels and the saints help—"I lift up my eyes toward the mountains; whence shall help come to me"—yet the principal contender is Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Which peace our Lord Jesus Christ proclaimed and gave; of whose preaching our father Francis was a renewer, announcing peace at the beginning and end of every sermon, wishing peace in every greeting, sighing for ecstatic peace in every contemplation, like a citizen of that Jerusalem, of which that man of peace speaks, who was peaceable with those who hated peace: Pray for the things that are for the peace of Jerusalem. For he knew that the throne of Solomon was only in peace, since it is written: In peace is his place made, and his dwelling in Sion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens in a circle, as, for instance, when it advises us not to flee, because we have protection all around. For we have the Lord and angels about us, wherefore the Psalm: Mountains are round about Jerusalem; so the Lord is round about His people. To the servant of Eliseus who cried out because of the Syrian robbers who sought to capture him, Eliseus said: "Lord, open his eyes, that he may see." And the Lord opened the eyes of the servant, and he saw. And behold the mountain was full of horses, and chariots of fire round about Eliseus. Jacob too, afraid of his brother, saw the angels and said: "This is the encampment of God." Wherefore the Psalm says: The Lord is my light and my salvation; whom should I fear? And in another passage: Had not the Lord been with us, let Israel say, etc., until the end.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens in a circle, as, for instance, when it advises us not to flee, because we have protection all around. For we have the Lord and angels about us, wherefore the Psalm: Mountains are round about Jerusalem; so the Lord is round about His people. To the servant of Eliseus who cried out because of the Syrian robbers who sought to capture him, Eliseus said: "Lord, open his eyes, that he may see." And the Lord opened the eyes of the servant, and he saw. And behold the mountain was full of horses, and chariots of fire round about Eliseus. Jacob too, afraid of his brother, saw the angels and said: "This is the encampment of God." Wherefore the Psalm says: The Lord is my light and my salvation; whom should I fear? And in another passage: Had not the Lord been with us, let Israel say, etc., until the end.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These apostles are the children of them that have been shaken. The Psalm reads: "As arrows in the hand of the mighty, so the children of them that have been shaken." The apostolical order corresponds to the Father as He is in the Holy Spirit. In the patriarchs, there was stability of faith, in the prophets, clarity of knowledge, and in the apostles, the warmth of love. If, then, the birth in the New Testament was to be out of the most noble origin, it had to be out of the most noble Principles. Wherefore the apostles correspond to the Seraphim, because the apostolic order is conformed to Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As a figure of this it is written in the Psalm: "Behold, how good and how pleasant it is for brethren to dwell together in unity. Like ointment upon the head, which descended upon the beard, the beard of Aaron." We have one Father, one sacrifice, one Sacrament, and one reward. First there is the ointment of piety upon the head; afterwards it descends upon all others who draw near to the head. First there ought to be piety in prelates and superiors, and afterwards in the common people; whence he says: "which descended to the hem of his garment."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As a figure of this it is written in the Psalm: "Behold, how good and how pleasant it is for brethren to dwell together in unity. Like ointment upon the head, which descended upon the beard, the beard of Aaron." We have one Father, one sacrifice, one Sacrament, and one reward. He says: "Like ointment upon the head." First there is the ointment of piety upon the head; afterwards it descends upon all others who draw near to the head. First there ought to be piety in prelates and superiors, and afterwards in the common people; whence he says: "which descended to the hem of his garment." Concerning this oil of piety it is said in the fourth book of Kings that a certain woman came to Elisha and said that her creditors wished to take her children; and she said: "My husband was a man who feared God." And Elisha said that she should bring all the vessels of her neighbors and pour some of that oil into each one, until all were filled. Why did he command her to bring the vessels of her neighbors? Could he not have multiplied the oil and filled a single jar, so that the woman would not have labored so much? I say that the woman holds the type of the Church, and Elisha holds the type of Christ. When the Church is poor in merits and it is necessary that she repay the debt: by what means will she repay? She must fill the vessels of her neighbors. Do you wish the piety of mother Church to descend upon you? Fill the vessels of your neighbors. This oil of piety ought to be possessed by all. Whence in the Song of Songs: "Your name is oil poured out."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And this entirely through that one hierarch, Jesus Christ, who by reason of the human nature assumed is not only hierarch in the ecclesiastical hierarchy, but also in the angelic, and the middle Person in that supercelestial hierarchy of the most blessed Trinity; so that through Him from God the supreme head, the grace of anointing descends not only upon the beard, but also upon the hem of the garment, because not only upon the heavenly Jerusalem, but even unto the Church Militant.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since therefore through these four properties the body is made conformed to the spirit and also subject to it, hence it is that in these four it is said to be especially endowed, by reason of which it has the aptitude to follow the spirit and to be placed in the celestial region, which is the region of the Blessed. For in these properties it is made like to the celestial bodies, through which the celestial body is, as it were, gradually distant from the four elements: and thus the fourfold dowry of bodies renders the body both perfect in itself and conformed to the celestial habitation and to the blessed Spirit, through whom from the supreme head, God, even unto the hem of the garment, namely the body, the fullness of sweetness and the inebriation of beatitude overflows and, insofar as is possible, is derived.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And so, in descending order, out of charity which is an ointment flowing from the head over the beard upon the collar of the robe, there is the cleaving to God, to self, to the neighbor and to one's body. Hence, as there are twelve fruits in the twelve examples of ascent towards charity, so also there are twelve fruits in the descent. And this is what is said in the Apocalypse: "On both sides of the river, was the tree of life, bearing twelve fruits, yielding its fruit according to each month." On the one side of the river, the intellectual fruits; on the other, the affective; or on the one side the ascending fruits, and on the other the descending.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is a hierarchizing of the soul in the order of descent, that is, by way of going down. For it is fitting that "the ointment upon the head" of the hierarchy on high run down "over the beard" in the intermediate hierarchy, and upon the "robe," that is, the lowest hierarchy. Now, these things come about according to the powers of the soul, and Dionysius says they are three: the powers of receiving, preserving, and distributing, so that a soul may receive abundantly, preserve attentively, and pour out again generously.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Do not allow the serpent to enter into your heart through suggestion; for Gregory says that when the head of the serpent has entered into any opening, then the whole body easily enters. For this reason the Psalm says: "Blessed is he who shall seize and dash his little ones against the rock," that is, the first movements against Christ: and then he shall have peace. He who wishes to defend his land fears for himself, lest the enemy enter his land: for he who holds the borders of his land in strength possesses the interior more securely.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Sacred Scripture possesses in its progression a sublimity, which consists in the description of hierarchies arranged in graduated order, which are the ecclesiastical, angelic, and divine hierarchy; such that it describes the first openly, the second somewhat more hiddenly, and the third still more hiddenly. From its description of the ecclesiastical hierarchy it is lofty; from its description of the angelic, loftier; from its description of the divine, loftiest, so that we may say that word of the Prophet: Your knowledge is become wonderful to me; it is strengthened, and I cannot reach unto it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here it must be noted that there is a clarity of philosophical knowledge, of theological knowledge, of gratuitous knowledge, and a clarity of glorious knowledge. The clarity of philosophical knowledge is great according to the opinion of worldly men, yet it is small in comparison to the clarity of Christian knowledge. The clarity of theological knowledge indeed seems small according to the opinion of worldly men, but according to truth it is great. The clarity of gratuitous knowledge is greater, but the clarity of glorious knowledge is the greatest: there lies the final state. "Your knowledge is become wonderful beyond me; it is fortified, and I cannot attain to it," namely in this life.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The height of God is beyond investigation. Hence, "such knowledge is too wonderful for me; too lofty for me to attain."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Although the intellect and the affection of the rational soul never rest except in God and in the infinite good, this is not because it comprehends that good, but because nothing suffices for the soul unless it exceeds its capacity. Whence it is true that both the affection and the intellect of the rational soul itself are borne toward the infinite good and true, and toward it as infinite; but to be borne toward it can be in six modes, namely by believing, by reasoning, by wondering, by gazing, by exceeding and by comprehending. The first mode is of imperfection and of the way; the last mode is of the highest perfection and is proper to the eternal and infinite Trinity; the second and third modes pertain to the progress of the way; the fourth and fifth to the consummation of the fatherland. For on the way we can contemplate the divine immensity by reasoning and by wondering: but in the fatherland by gazing, when we shall have been made deiform, and by exceeding, when we shall be wholly inebriated: on account of which inebriation Anselm says at the end of the Proslogion that we shall enter more into the divine joy than the divine joy shall enter into our heart.
And since that soul united to the Word is both more made deiform and more inebriated on account of a grace not merely sufficient, but also superexcellent: therefore it gazes upon the divine wisdom and by gazing exceeds into it, although it does not comprehend it. And for this reason wonder has a place not only on the way, but also in the fatherland: not only in the Angels, but also in the soul assumed by God, so that it says: Your knowledge is become wonderful from me; it is strengthened, and I cannot reach unto it, as the Gloss expounds concerning the man assumed by the Word, that "he cannot be made equal to Him in wisdom nor in anything else."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Psalm: Your knowledge has become wonderful, etc.; the Gloss: "The assumed man cannot be made equal to the divine substance in substance nor in anything else." Therefore the soul of Christ does not comprehend all things that are comprehended by the eternal wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Job says: "I always feared God as though waves were swelling over me." And why? I cannot flee on account of the sublimity of divine power, because "if I ascend into heaven, thou art there; if I descend into hell, thou art present; if I take my wings at dawn and dwell in the uttermost parts of the sea, even there thy hand shall lead me, and thy right hand shall hold me." Likewise, I cannot hide on account of the perspicacity of divine wisdom, because God sees all things. Likewise, I cannot resist on account of the severity of divine vengeance, because he who sins is punished by eternal judgment. It is necessary, therefore, that we fear God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Job says: "I always feared God as though waves were swelling over me." And why? I cannot flee on account of the sublimity of divine power, because "if I ascend into heaven, thou art there; if I descend into hell, thou art present; if I take my wings at dawn and dwell in the uttermost parts of the sea, even there thy hand shall lead me, and thy right hand shall hold me." Likewise, I cannot hide on account of the perspicacity of divine wisdom, because God sees all things. Likewise, I cannot resist on account of the severity of divine vengeance, because he who sins is punished by eternal judgment. It is necessary, therefore, that we fear God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Job says: "I always feared God as though waves were swelling over me." And why? I cannot flee on account of the sublimity of divine power, because "if I ascend into heaven, thou art there; if I descend into hell, thou art present; if I take my wings at dawn and dwell in the uttermost parts of the sea, even there thy hand shall lead me, and thy right hand shall hold me." Likewise, I cannot hide on account of the perspicacity of divine wisdom, because God sees all things. Likewise, I cannot resist on account of the severity of divine vengeance, because he who sins is punished by eternal judgment. It is necessary, therefore, that we fear God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By which most fervent desire, in the manner of fire, our spirit is not only made agile for ascent, but also by a certain learned ignorance is rapt above itself into darkness and ecstasy, so that not only does it say with the bride: We will run in the fragrance of your ointments, but also sings with the Prophet: And the night is my illumination in my delights. Which nocturnal and delightful illumination no one knows except he who experiences it, nor does anyone experience it except through grace divinely given, nor is it given to anyone except to him who exercises himself toward it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Your eyes have seen my actions; in Your book they are all written." In other words, that which had been written earlier is now made manifest: it is not written anew. In this book are inscribed all the eternal laws. And so God is the eternal Exemplar, and this is a matter of faith which believes that God is the creator of all things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But grace which lifts up is obtained through hope. The Psalm reads: "For what have I in heaven? And besides Thee what do I desire upon earth?" And elsewhere: "I say, You are my refuge, my portion in the land of the living," so that a man be kept whole in view of this fatherland. Therefore "our present light affliction which is for the moment, prepares for us an eternal weight of glory."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of prophetical revelation, Christ is symbolized through harmonious singing "with a ten-stringed lyre," as in the psalm where David learns how to prophesy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This Hierarch is the most generous because He gives us whatever we ask. He swears to it and asserts it with complete truthfulness. Hence in the Psalm: "You open Your hand and satisfy the desire of every living thing."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“God by the knowledge of simple intelligence knows and comprehends infinite things.
I respond: For the understanding of the foregoing, it must be noted that according to the ancient doctors we are compelled to hold that God knows infinite things, as the Prophet David says in the Psalm: "Great is our Lord and great is his power, and of his wisdom there is no number"; and as Augustine not only asserts this but also proves it in the twelfth book of the City of God, the eighteenth chapter, where he speaks thus: "Therefore, as for that which certain ones, namely the philosophers, say—that not even by God's knowledge can infinite things be comprehended—it remains for them to dare to say, and to plunge themselves into this abyss of impiety, that God does not know all numbers. For it is most certain that they are infinite, since in whatever number you may think the end should be placed, that same number—I do not say can be increased by adding one—but however great it may be and however vast a multitude it may contain, it can by the very theory and science of numbers not only be doubled but even multiplied. Indeed, each number is so bounded by its own properties that none of them can be equal to any other: therefore they are both unequal among themselves and diverse, and each one individually is finite, and all together are infinite. Does God then not know all numbers on account of their infinity, and does the knowledge of God reach up to a certain sum of numbers and remain ignorant of the rest? Who, even the most demented, would say this?" And a little further on: "The infinity of number, therefore, although there is no number of infinite numbers, is nevertheless not incomprehensible to him whose understanding has no number. Wherefore, if whatever is comprehended by knowledge is made finite by the comprehension of the knower, then assuredly all infinity is in some ineffable manner made finite to God, because it is not incomprehensible to his knowledge. Therefore, if the infinity of numbers cannot be infinite to the knowledge of God by which it is comprehended, who are we, mere little men, to presume to fix a limit to his knowledge?"
By these testimonies, therefore, as by the most certain witnesses, we are compelled to say or to hold that God knows infinite things.
The manner of this position, however, is assigned by the more modern doctors, who have said that there is a threefold mode of divine cognition, not on account of a diversity of divine knowledge in itself, but in its connotation. For in God there is a knowledge of approbation, of vision, and of intelligence. The knowledge of approbation is of good things only, and of finite things. The knowledge of vision is of evil things and good things, but of finite things, inasmuch as it concerns time: for it is only of those things which were, are, and will be. But the knowledge of intelligence is of infinite things, inasmuch as God understands not only future things but also possible things: and the things possible to God are not finite but infinite.
The reason for this position, namely why we hold that God knows infinite things and does not make or will or dispose them, is that the divine knowing according to the third mode of understanding is an intrinsic act of God. By intrinsic I mean not only because it proceeds from what is intrinsic, but also because it is toward what is intrinsic and through what is intrinsic and according to an intrinsic mode. Toward what is intrinsic, I say, because the divine gaze in knowing does not leap outside itself, but by beholding itself as truth knows every truth. Through what is intrinsic, because through the eternal reasons, which are identical with himself, he knows whatever he knows. According to an intrinsic mode, because the divine knowing not only abstracts from the notion of actual cause, but also from that of cause absolutely. For he knows evils, of which he is not the cause; he also knows future things, which he does not yet bring about; he also knows possible things, which he will never bring about. And therefore, because knowing itself neither involves nor connotes anything actual outside, it signifies there an act in the mode of a habit, an act, I say, commensurate with the power itself — for whatever God can know, he knows — it also signifies an act in no way restricted, neither with respect to itself nor with respect to what is connoted, therefore universal with respect to places, with respect to times, and with respect to objects. For whatever he knew somewhere he knows everywhere, and whatever he knows once he knows always, and just as he knows one thing, so he knows all knowable things. Whence, because knowable things are not only beings in act, but also in potency: since it is not unfitting to hold that there are infinite things in potency, it is not unfitting to hold that infinite things are actually known by God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“However powerful, rich, learned, and strong a man may be, unless he fears God, nothing avails him. Whence the Psalm: "He shall not take pleasure in the strength of the horse, nor shall he be well pleased with the legs of a man: the Lord is well pleased with those who fear him, and with those who hope in his mercy."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“However powerful, rich, learned, and strong a man may be, unless he fears God, nothing avails him. Whence the Psalm: "He shall not take pleasure in the strength of the horse, nor shall he be well pleased with the legs of a man: the Lord is well pleased with those who fear him, and with those who hope in his mercy."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fruits of the earth refer to the consideration of the divine condescensions in the orders of the Churches. Their fullness is seen as the conjunction of both Churches, the militant and the triumphant. It is in this manner that God "has granted peace in your borders"; that is, as He shall declare, peace is like a river.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the fourth place, that is, from afar, there is born in us the praise of God in all things. For all creatures declare God. What shall I do? I shall sing with them all. The thick cord in the zither does not give forth a pleasant sound if struck alone, but there is harmony in consonance with others. Symbolic figures are received by all creatures in the Scriptures for the sake of praising God, as is evident in the Psalms: "Praise the Lord from the heavens," and "Bless the Lord, all you works of the Lord," from above and below. So does the man who sees God in all things, who tastes God in them through his three powers.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture tends to lead back to the first beginning by means of reformation, or it describes eternal things, as in the Laws and Gospels. Hence in the Psalm: "He gave them a duty which shall not pass away." For it is not to be understood that the Law or the Commandments will pass away, but rather that they will be better served in the fatherland. For they are not served in the same manner under the Old Testament and under the New Testament: they are served better under the New Testament, and yet better still in the fatherland. God indeed lives by these very Laws which He Himself has given.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The wise man hearing shall be wiser, and the one who understands shall possess counsels." In the second word Solomon shows that it is useful to hear the word of God; and the reason is that in the hearing of the word of God both he who understands profits, and likewise he who does not understand: therefore both the wise and the simple ought to go to hear the word of God. That the wise profit by hearing the word of God is clear, because he says that the wise man hearing wisdom shall be wiser.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This wisdom has been made manifest, hence "wisdom cries aloud in the street, in the open squares she raises her voice." And yet we do not find her, resembling the unlettered man who owns a book and has no concern for it. And so with us: the Scriptures were given to us in Greek, in the vernacular and in Hebrew, and yet they are unknown as a source.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against those who speak against the counsels of God, it is said in Proverbs: 'I have called and you refused; you have despised all my counsel and neglected my reproofs; therefore I will laugh at your destruction.' A dog, when it lies in the straw and does not wish to eat, does not permit another to eat. So these men do not wish to enter religious life nor do they permit others to enter.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"If you call upon wisdom and incline your heart to prudence and seek her as money and dig for her as for treasures, then you will understand the fear of the Lord and find the knowledge of God." Prudential understanding teaches what is to be avoided, namely every evil. Whoever wishes to have this understanding must seek it with desire of heart and diligence of effort; and what then will you find? Certainly, the fear of the Lord and the knowledge of God. For every person who wishes to be directed toward the good must fear God, so as to avoid every evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third mode of generation is by means of propagation, and this in a fourfold way: as of a growth coming from a seed, a tree from a root, a conceived offspring from the belly or womb of the mother, or children from a begetting father. In the first mode of generation, formal beauty is lacking, for in the seed the form is vague and hidden. It is not so in the case of the Son. In the second, conformity is lacking, for although there is a single root, it is different in shape from the branches even though they produce a single tree. In the third, actuality is lacking, for although the mother is in a certain sense the active principle of the offspring, yet she is much more of a passive principle. In the fourth, eternal coexistence is lacking.
Now, take away these defects and suppose first formal beauty. In this sense, there is Isaiah: "The branch of the Lord will be luster and glory, and the fruit of the earth will be honor and splendor." Second, suppose conformity: The Son conforms to the Father to the point that He is "the tree of life... in the midst of the garden." Hence, in Proverbs: "She is a tree of life to those who grasp her." Third, suppose actuality: in this sense, you have the Psalm: "With Thee is the principality in the day of Thy strength, in the brightness of the saints: from the womb before the day star I begot Thee. From the womb," says the Psalmist, which is in relation to the warmth of the Father's bosom, from which He does not withdraw. Fourth, suppose eternal coexistence. In this sense, there is the Psalm: "This day I have begotten You," that is in eternity, or in My eternal today.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first counsel is regulated according to the dictate of divinely instituted laws. Whence in Proverbs: 'Keep the law and counsel, and you will have grace for your mouth and life for your soul.' What is this law? Surely the law written outwardly and the law divinely inspired.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is certain that as long as man stood up, he had the knowledge of created things and through their significance, was carried up to God, to praise, worship, and love Him. This is what creatures are for, and this is how they are led back to God. But when man had fallen, since he had lost knowledge, there was no longer any one to lead creatures back to God. Hence this book, the world, became as dead and deleted. And it was necessary that there be another book through which this one would be lighted up, so that it could receive the symbols of things. Such a book is Scripture which establishes the likenesses, the properties, and the symbolism of things written down in the book of the world. And so, Scripture has the power to restore the whole world toward the knowledge, praise, and love of God. Hence, if you ask what is the meaning of the serpent to you, or what is its use — it is more useful to you than the whole world because it teaches you how to be prudent, as the ant teaches you how to be wise. Solomon says: "Go to the ant, O sluggard, study her ways and learn wisdom."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third and worst mode of breaking a vow occurs through apostatic rebellion, as when a man apostatizes from religious life. The first mode of breaking a vow is evil, the second worse, the third worst, because it is said: "An apostate man is a worthless man."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens a priori by means of directive precepts. It is fitting to have light before oneself. For the bidding is a lamp, and the teaching a light; and this leads to heaven. Hence, "If thou wilt enter into life, keep the commandments." And to the commandments are added the counsels. And this is what Scripture teaches us everywhere.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Just as by following the glorious Virgin we become precious and holy, so by following Eve we become wicked and worthless. Whence in Proverbs: "The price of a harlot is scarcely one loaf of bread; but a woman captures the precious soul of a man." O foolish Eve, for the eating of one fruit you sold yourself and your husband and all of us! O son of Eve! Beware, lest you be an imitator of Eve; but for whatever pleasure you give your soul, you are an imitator of Eve.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She is a net to those who lust and consent. Whence in Ecclesiasticus: "On account of the beauty of a woman many have perished." It is difficult "to carry fire in one's bosom without one's garments being burned."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third benefit of the observance of God's commandments is the attainment of heavenly rewards. Whence it is said in Proverbs: "Keep my commandments, and you shall live; and my law as the pupil of the eye." This is the reason why God gave the observance of commandments to man when he was in paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first counsel is that by which we are instructed to discern what is lawful, what is fitting, and what is expedient according to the judgment of right reason. Whence in Proverbs: 'I, wisdom, dwell in counsel and am present among learned thoughts.' 'I dwell in counsel,' namely that by which a man is instructed to discern what is lawful, what is fitting, and what is expedient according to the judgment of right reason. First a man ought to consider whether it is lawful, whether it is fitting: many things are lawful that are not fitting. Afterward he ought to consider whether it is expedient, because the Apostle says: 'All things are lawful for me, but not all things are expedient.' Once this threefold consideration has been attained, thoughts are instructed, and wisdom dwells in the counsel of man.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fruit of wisdom is mentioned in Proverbs: "Her fruit is better than the choicest and the purest gold." Hence this fruit comes from Christ in a threefold manner, because Jesus Christ is the Son of God. Because He is Jesus, from Him comes the fruit of grace; because He is Christ, from Him comes the fruit of righteousness; because He is the Son of God, from Him comes the fruit of wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second mode of generation is by means of expression: as in the case of the species coming out of the object, the imprint out of the seal, the speech out of the speaker, or the concept or thought out of the mind. And in these, there is deficiency. In the first, the reality of the object is lacking, for the species in the eye or in the soul is not the reality of the thing. In the second, simplicity is lacking, for the image or figure does not consist in a point or in something simple, but has parts. In the third, permanence is lacking, for speech passes away and does not remain. In the fourth, substance is lacking, for the concept of the mind is neither a substance nor a hypostasis. Take away such defects, and suppose an expression like the species deriving from the object but having reality, like the imprint produced by the seal but having simplicity, like the word coming forth from the speaker but having permanence, like the concept proceeding from the mind but having substance: and then you have the first part of the mirror.
The Psalm refers to the first manner of expression: "My heart overflows with a goodly theme." And there follows: "Fairer in beauty are you than the sons of men." Wisdom refers to the second: "For she is the refulgence of eternal light, the spotless mirror of the power of God, the image of His goodness." And the Apostle: "He is the image of the invisible God." Job refers to the third: "God speaketh once, and repeateth not the selfsame thing the second time." Understand this as meaning "in the Son," in the sense that He always is, and will never cease to be nor even be changed. In the fourth manner of expression, suppose substantiality, for the concept of the eternal mind is a hypostasis, and this mental concept is most noble and perfect. Hence, in Proverbs: "When there were no depths I was brought forth." And so He is sometimes called the Word, the Species, the Image, the Word remaining forever, the Concept—not as existing within a mind, but as being substantial: a hypostasis. And in this way we have the other part of the mirror.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“According to this same manner one may also find in the illumination of rational philosophy, whose principal concern turns upon discourse. In which there are three things to consider according to the threefold consideration of discourse itself, namely with respect to the speaker, by reason of the utterance, and with respect to the hearer or by reason of the end.
If we consider speech in relation to the speaker, we see that every speech signifies a concept of the mind, and that interior concept is the word of the mind and its offspring, which is known even to the one conceiving it. But in order that it may become known to the hearer, it puts on the form of voice, and the intelligible word by means of that garment becomes sensible and is heard outwardly and is received in the ear of the hearer's heart, and yet does not depart from the mind of the one uttering it.
According to this mode we see in the eternal Word that the Father eternally conceived it by generating, according to that passage of Proverbs eight: The depths did not yet exist, and I was already conceived. But in order that it might become knowable to sense-bound man, it put on the form of flesh, and the Word was made flesh and dwelt among us, and yet remained in the bosom of the Father.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is certain that wisdom delights to be with men: whence she says: "My delights are to be with the children of men." But that wisdom does not dwell with us is not a defect on her part, but on ours. If we wish that the aforesaid light dwell in us, we must have seven pillars: chastity in the flesh, innocence in the mind, moderation in speech, persuadability in affection, liberality in effect, maturity in judgment, and simplicity in intention.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If we consider the fruit, we shall find the union of God and the soul. For every artisan who makes some work either makes it so that through it he may be praised, or so that through it something may be procured or gained for himself, or so that he may delight in it, according to the three things that are among desirable goods, namely the honorable good, the useful, and the delectable. For these three reasons God made the rational soul: that it might praise Him, that it might serve Him, that it might delight and rest in Him; and this is through charity, in which he who abides, abides in God, and God in him, so that there is a certain wondrous union, and from that union a wondrous delight; for, as it is said in Proverbs, my delights are to be with the children of men. Behold how the illumination of mechanical art is a path to the illumination of Sacred Scripture, and there is nothing in it that does not proclaim true wisdom. And therefore Sacred Scripture quite rightly makes frequent use of such similitudes.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Wisdom has built herself a house, she has hewn out seven pillars." This house is principally built by wisdom, and thus wisdom builds the Church and the soul, so that it may be a dwelling place of God: a house pleasant, a house beautiful, and a house strong. It is certain that wisdom delights to be with men: whence she says: "My delights are to be with the children of men." But that wisdom does not dwell with us is not a defect on her part, but on ours. If we wish that the aforesaid light dwell in us, we must have seven pillars.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Do not rebuke a scoffer, lest he hate you: rebuke a wise man, and he will love you." It is better to be corrected by a wise man than to be deceived by the flattery of fools. A fool, when he is corrected, does not withdraw from evil nor is he led to good. He who recognizes his faults, and they displease him, is wise. He who rebukes a person and calls him back from evil renders him a greater service than if he gave him the whole world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of God avails for obtaining the illumination of divine wisdom, because "the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom." For the fear of the Lord is the extrinsic principle of wisdom and the intrinsic principle and the complement of wisdom; because there is servile fear, and this is the initiator of wisdom, because, just as the needle introduces the thread and does not remain with the thread, so servile fear introduces wisdom and does not remain with wisdom. Another is the fear of punishment and of offending God; and this is the intrinsic beginning of wisdom and the root of wisdom. The third is the fear of filial reverence: and this is the complement of wisdom, because "the fullness of wisdom is to fear God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The gift of fortitude is given for accomplishing manly deeds; whence in Proverbs: "The slack hand works poverty, but the hand of the strong prepares riches."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Gregory of Nazianzus was a most pure youth. It happened that he was studying at Athens. One night, while he slept, there came to him a most beautiful lady, having two handmaidens as if they were virgins; he began to repel her. And the lady said: "Do not flee from me, for I have not come to corrupt you. I am Wisdom, and the two handmaidens are humility and chastity. If you desire me, who am Wisdom, keep these handmaidens, namely humility and chastity, for where there has been pride, there will be disgrace; but where there is humility, there is wisdom." True virginity is that in which wisdom is joined as a companion. Humility with modesty is the principal pillar of wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He is truly wise who truthfully recognizes his own and others' nothingness and the sublimity of the first principle. But no one arrives at full knowledge of God except through true and right knowledge of oneself; nor does he rightly know himself who does not attend to his own nothingness; but to know one's own nothingness is to humble oneself: therefore humility is the gateway of wisdom. And this the Wise Man says in Proverbs eleven: Where there is humility, there is also wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He who follows counsel will have joy. Whence in Proverbs: 'Those who enter upon counsels of peace, joy follows them forever.'”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The wisdom of the shrewd is to understand his way, and the imprudence of fools is erring." Prudential understanding teaches what is to be carried out, namely every good, according to the way of interior thought and exterior action. God wills that we do all things reasonably.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third part of the perfection of the fear of the Lord consists in the perfect firmness of confidence: because the fear of the Lord is a tower of firmness and confidence, because it renders a person secure from every other fear. "His truth shall encompass you with a shield; you shall not fear the terror of the night, nor the arrow that flies by day, nor the pestilence that walks in darkness, nor the assault and the noonday devil." And in Proverbs: "The fear of the Lord is a tower of strength." He who does not fear God must fear everywhere; and he who truly fears God has what no one can take from him. But he who fears something other than God has what ought to be taken from him. He who fears God cannot lose God. It is not so with money. If a man has money, he fears lest he lose it, and yet he is certain that he will lose it. But he who fears God is secure everywhere.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And Solomon in Proverbs: "The fear of the Lord is a fountain of life, that they may turn aside from the ruin of death." If you do not fear God, you have lost grace, you have lost justice, and you have lost true wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second pillar of the house of wisdom is innocence in the mind, which is noted when James says: "then peaceable." Augustine says that "peace is the tranquility of order," namely, when one humbly subjects himself to a superior, conducts himself equably toward an equal, and discreetly governs an inferior. All who are children of wisdom maintain this order. Whence comes war? If you loved peace, you would obey your superior and govern your inferior in an orderly manner; you would have peace. He who disturbs this peace destroys the house of wisdom. "He who is patient is governed by much wisdom; he who is impatient exalts his own folly," and thus he overturns the house of wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the third place, it is fitting that there be a victorious bearing of worldly tribulations. Indeed, the man who assumes them must prepare himself for suffering. Wherefore Christ overturned the tables in His zeal. Later, when they sought Him, He showed Himself. Hence, "the patient man shows much good sense." There is no doubt that those whose tables He overturned were then clamoring: "Crucify Him!"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If you seek an example of justice, fortitude, prudence, purity, Scripture proposes becoming examples of every virtue. For virtue consists in concrete doings, wherefore interior guidelines are not enough unless they are accompanied by a concrete example. Hence Scripture gives both. As a rule against anger, it offers: A mild answer calms wrath. Consider Abigail who broke David's wrath.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third middle way is fortitude, which is concerned with fears and acts of valor. A man needs it in order to be neither fainthearted nor rash, but that he be able to bear frightful trials and even death. For some men do fall into cowardice and faintheartedness. Hence, in Job: "Have I the strength of stones, or is my flesh of bronze?" And so, fortitude is in the soul, not in the flesh. Better is the patient spirit than the lofty spirit. And Proverbs say: A patient man is better than a warrior, and he that rules his temper, than he who takes a city. Hence a spiritual man must take great care to avoid dejection.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The expectation of the one who waits is a most precious gem; wherever he turns, he understands prudently." Prudential understanding instructs what is to be awaited, namely the highest good. In all things that direct our understanding in what is to be done and what is to be avoided, a person must employ the counsel of the end. For it is necessary that a person expect something in what he does. If you aim at temporal advantage, you expect a worthless reward. A pleasing, indeed a most pleasing gem is the eternal good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“So great is the closeness between silence and wisdom that "the fool, if he keeps silent, will be reputed wise:" and the wise man who speaks much is reputed a fool. In a single word one can utter a detraction; for this reason one must "make a balance for one's words." Immoderation of speech is to be guarded against in the highest degree.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The impious are those who do not acknowledge divine piety. "But the impious man, when he has come into the depth of sins, shows contempt." The impious man is he who defends his own impiety, namely sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The gift of fortitude is given by God protecting. For God protects us according to hierarchical ordering, fortifying us within and without. It is written in Proverbs: "The name of the Lord is a most strong tower; the just man runs to it and shall be exalted." Fortitude is, as from a solid, sublime, and strong principle, from God; and the eternal God is the origin of fortitude in all things, because nothing is powerful nor strong except through the fortitude of the first principle. Therefore this fortitude descends from God protecting us as from the first principle according to hierarchical dispositions; which fortitude renders every man rich and secure and powerful and confident.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is good to have the sign of Zabulon, which is "a dwelling of fortitude," which implies the first stability. "Because Thou, O Lord, art my hope." Hence, "the name of the Lord is a strong tower; the just man runs to it and is safe." He alone is at peace who fixes himself upon that "with which there is no change, no shadow of alteration." Hence, "in Thee, O Lord, have I hoped, let me never be confounded."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The gift of fortitude is given by God protecting. For God protects us according to hierarchical ordering, fortifying us within and without. "The substance of the rich man is a city of strength and like a strong wall surrounding him." Fortitude is, as from a solid, sublime, and strong principle, from God; and the eternal God is the origin of fortitude in all things, because nothing is powerful nor strong except through the fortitude of the first principle.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Death and life are in the power of the tongue." If the woman had kept silent when the devil said to her: "Why has God commanded you not to eat of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil?" the devil would not have had the occasion to tempt her further. And the philosophers also taught their disciples to be silent; Cato: "I consider the first of virtues to be to restrain the tongue." I believe that the sins of the tongue are so great that the world would have enough to answer for on account of those alone, if God were to rise up to judge them.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Wine is a luxurious thing, and drunkenness is tumultuous; whoever delights in these will not be wise." And elsewhere: "Wine and women make the wise to fall away and will reprove the sensible." You have a ready example in that Solomon, who fell away on account of women even to the worship of idolatry, who nevertheless was filled with wisdom like a river. If there were a tavern in which wine were sold that would induce forgetfulness of all wisdom, I believe no one would be so foolish as to buy that wine. I believe that the eternal God, by the most high dispensation of his counsel, permitted Solomon to fall, so that he might teach all men to flee from women.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the perfection of prelacy, two things are necessarily required, namely zeal for justice and the affection of mercy: for mercy and truth preserve the king. According to these two, the governance of prelacy in the Church militant ought to be ordered.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The commandments of God contain nothing burdensome, but rather they are sweet. "It is joy to the just to do judgment," that is, justice. But we see that to an infected palate sweet food seems bitter; similarly, to a man of perverse will the commandments of God, which are easy and sweet, seem difficult.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Philosophical knowledge is a certain knowledge of truth as investigable. Concerning this knowledge it is said in Proverbs: "Behold, I have described it for you in a threefold manner, in thoughts and knowledge, that I might show you the firmness and the words of truth." That word can be the word of Solomon and the word of God. I say that it can be the word of God. For He Himself describes philosophical knowledge in a threefold manner, that is, He describes it according to a threefold account: as natural, as rational, and as moral, namely insofar as it is the "cause of being, the ground of understanding," and the "order of living." Insofar as it is the cause of being, it designates natural science; insofar as it is the ground of understanding, it signifies rational science; insofar as it is the order of living, it describes moral science.
Nor is that word only of God, indeed it is also of Solomon, who disputed from the cedar of Lebanon down to the hyssop. He himself says: "Behold, I have described it to you in a threefold manner, that I might show you firmness," that is, solid and firm truth, "and the words of truth": he himself describes it in a threefold manner, namely insofar as it is the truth of things, the truth of words and the truth of morals, according as it is the undividedness of being from existence, and the undividedness of being in relation to existence, and of being from its end. The truth of things is the undividedness of being from existence: the truth of words is the undividedness of being in relation to existence: the truth of morals is the undividedness of being from its end. The truth of morals is rectitude, according to which a man lives well within and without according to the dictate of law, because law is the rule of rectitude; the truth of words is the adequation of voice and intellect; the truth of things is "the adequation of intellect and thing." And because philosophical science teaches the words of truth; and truth is threefold: therefore he says that he described it in a threefold manner.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The devil draws man to the concupiscence of the flesh, to the concupiscence of the eyes, and to the pride of life. The concupiscence of the eyes, which is the fuel of concupiscence and pride, makes men strong, because men endure many things in order to acquire temporal goods. In wine, which makes a man drunk and renders him bold, is signified the concupiscence of the eyes. It is written: "Do not gaze upon wine when it grows golden" in the cup. What is the means of resisting these? Through truth, namely through faith dwelling within.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the same manner, there are four acts of justice: to do good, to flee evil, to beware of prosperity, and to withstand misfortune. Hence the just is warned not to fall. If he does fall, he is advised to rise again. For "the just man falls seven times and rises again."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This happens when a man has good intentions but does not fulfill them: then it is that the thistles of malice and the nettles of cupidity come to grow. The stone wall of the virtues is destroyed because of the dissipation of thoughts. Hence, in the same text: "complete your outdoor tasks, and arrange your work in the field."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In Proverbs: "I passed by the field of the sluggard, by the vineyard of the man without sense; and behold! it was all overgrown with thistles; its surface was covered with nettles, and its stone wall broken down." This happens when a man has good intentions but does not fulfill them: then it is that the thistles of malice and the nettles of cupidity come to grow. The stone wall of the virtues is destroyed because of the dissipation of thoughts.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In Proverbs: "I passed by the field of the sluggard, by the vineyard of the man without sense; and behold! it was all overgrown with thistles; its surface was covered with nettles, and its stone wall broken down." This happens when a man has good intentions but does not fulfill them: then it is that the thistles of malice and the nettles of cupidity come to grow. The stone wall of the virtues is destroyed because of the dissipation of thoughts.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth column of the house of wisdom is persuadability in the affections. There is no one who is persuadable to good unless he is benign: and this also accords with wisdom. It is written: "The spirit of wisdom is benign, and will not free the evil-speaker from his lips." Good persuadability causes one to esteem and love good things and to consent to them: and the wiser a person is, the more persuadable he is to good things. "A golden earring and a shining pearl is he who rebukes the wise and the obedient ear." Just as an earring adorns the ear, and a pearl in a crown adorns the face, so a good word adorns the wise person. When a wise person is rebuked, he conducts himself as if he were being adorned. For if I correct myself at the word of good admonition, what else do I do than adorn myself with that word? If, however, this pearl is set before a fool, he tramples it like a dog.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth need is good measure, so that a man seek not to savor beyond his means, but that he do so according to moderation. Hence, the Wise Man says: "If you find honey, eat only what you need, lest you become glutted with it and vomit it up." Do not extend yourself beyond the point your intelligence can reach; but neither remain short of it. Wherefore, in order to make this point, as Dionysius says, the Seraphim flew with their intermediate wings, showing that man should not remain short of his possibilities nor rise beyond them. Likewise, those who sing beyond their range never produce harmony.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the same manner, there are four acts of justice: to do good, to flee evil, to beware of prosperity, and to withstand misfortune. The fourth is referred to in Proverbs: "The just man, like a lion, feels sure of himself." There is also this: "Blessed are they who suffer persecution for justice' sake." And again: "Strive for justice for thy soul, and even unto death fight for justice."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the same manner, there are four acts of justice: to do good, to flee evil, to beware of prosperity, and to withstand misfortune. Of the third: "Happy the man who is always on his guard" when things go well with him. Hence the just is warned not to fall. If he does fall, he is advised to rise again. For "the just man falls seven times and rises again."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Solomon in Proverbs says: "I am the most foolish of men, and the wisdom of men is not with me. I have not learned wisdom, and I have not known the wisdom of the Saints." Christ was foolish in outward appearance, when he departed from the desire of the foolish; more foolish, when he willed to be afflicted; most foolish indeed, when he chose the death of the cross and died by the most shameful death. This is the wisdom of the Saints.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Furthermore, Proverbs thirty: Give me neither riches nor beggary; and afterward: Lest compelled by want I steal and perjure the name of my God; but nothing pertains to evangelical perfection which the Wise Man wisely refuses: therefore etc.
It can be said that those things were said in the time of the written law, which promised temporal things, not eternal, in which poverty was despised. Whence Chrysostom, in the eighteenth homily on the Epistle to the Hebrews, treating the aforesaid word: Riches and beggary etc., says: "These things were said in the Old Testament, where much account was made of riches, where there was very great contempt for poverty, where this indeed was a curse, namely poverty, but that was a blessing, namely riches. But now it is by no means so. But if you wish to hear the praise of poverty, Christ Himself professed it and said: But the Son of man has not where to lay His head; and again He said to the disciples: Do not possess gold." From which it is apparent that the authority is not contrary to those who assume voluntary poverty, since that was said in the time of the written law, but this in the time of the law of grace. Nor was that said in the person of a perfect man, but rather of a weak one, as is clear from the word of Chrysostom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Most incomprehensible is wisdom that travels along roads that are beyond investigation. Concerning this, it is said in Proverbs: "Three things are too wonderful for me, yes, four I cannot understand: the way of an eagle in the air, the way of a serpent upon a rock, the way of a ship on the high seas, and the way of a man with a maiden." "The way of an eagle in the air" came about in the ascension of Christ; "the way of a serpent upon the rock," in the resurrection, for a serpent is renewed upon the rock where it sheds its old skin; "the way of a ship on the high seas," in the passion; "the way of a man with a maiden," in the incarnation, which the author says he cannot understand. And it is true in terms of human reason, but not so in terms of faith.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Most incomprehensible is wisdom that travels along roads that are beyond investigation. Concerning this, it is said in Proverbs: "Three things are too wonderful for me, yes, four I cannot understand: the way of an eagle in the air, the way of a serpent upon a rock, the way of a ship on the high seas, and the way of a man with a maiden." "The way of an eagle in the air" came about in the ascension of Christ; "the way of a serpent upon the rock," in the resurrection, for a serpent is renewed upon the rock where it sheds its old skin; "the way of a ship on the high seas," in the passion; "the way of a man with a maiden," in the incarnation, which the author says he cannot understand. And it is true in terms of human reason, but not so in terms of faith.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Who shall find a valiant woman?" This word is written in Proverbs: without doubt it was said in commendation of mother Church, and specially in commendation of the glorious Virgin. In which word she is commended for three things: first, for the strengthening of spiritual fortitude; second, for the fruitfulness of supernatural conception; and third, for the discretion of salutary counsel.
She is commended for the strength of spiritual fortitude, when he says: "Who shall find a valiant woman?" He asks not in despair, but in confidence. Who then shall find her? Certainly he who "reaches from end to end"; he himself shall find her and sent to her a bridesman, that is, Gabriel the Archangel. Gabriel is interpreted as "the strength of God," and he himself was sent to find the "valiant woman." Without doubt Solomon wished to rest in her as in a secure place; but this could not be unless she were strong, because it is said in the Canticle that "sixty valiant ones surround the bed of Solomon."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Who shall find a valiant woman?" This is Solomon's word applied to the glorious Virgin, in which he commends her for three things: first, for the strength of spiritual fortitude; second, for the fruitfulness of supernatural conception; and third, for the discernment of salutary counsel.
And rightly are these three joined together: because the strength of spiritual fortitude was the beginning of the supernatural conception, and the gift of counsel was as it were the complement, because that Virgin, who was to conceive Christ, the Son of God, the power of God and the wisdom of God, had to be strong and prudent: strong in virtue and prudent through wisdom. And therefore the Wise Man, wishing to explain the conception of the Virgin, sets forth first the spirit of fortitude and then adds the gift of counsel; because she, upon whom the spirit of wisdom and understanding, the spirit of counsel and fortitude, the spirit of knowledge and piety and the spirit of the fear of the Lord was to rest, had to be filled with the sevenfold spirit of the gifts of the Holy Spirit, but especially with the spirit of fortitude and counsel.
Moreover, in that he says: "Her price is from afar and from the uttermost boundaries," the glorious Virgin is understood to be commended for the supernatural fecundity of her conception. This I do not have from myself, but Bernard says: "If our salvation and that of all, if the restoration of innocence is placed in the hand of a woman: it is necessary that a strong woman be sought, who is needed for so great a work"; and he adds: "Not from the earth, not from the nearby heaven, but from the highest heaven is his going forth."
"Far off and from the uttermost boundaries is her price"; and whose is this price? The price of this woman, the blessed Virgin, is that by which we may be able to obtain the kingdom of heaven; or it is hers, that is, taken from her, paid through her, and possessed by her: taken from her in the incarnation of the Word; paid through her in the redemption of the human race; and possessed by her in the attainment of the glory of paradise. She herself brought forth that price, paid it, and possessed it: therefore it is hers as originating, as paying, and as possessing. This woman brought forth that price as strong and holy; paid it as strong and compassionate; and possessed it as strong and vigorous.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The most blessed glorious Virgin is commended in these words first for the strength of spiritual fortitude; second, for the fruitfulness of supernatural conception; and third, for the discretion of salutary counsel. The first is noted there: 'Who shall find a valiant woman?' the second there: 'Her price is as from afar and from the uttermost boundaries'; the third there: 'She hath sought wool and flax and hath wrought by the counsel of her hands.'”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Holy Spirit here describes the gift of counsel with respect to the preliminary act, and this with respect to the intrinsic act and the extrinsic act, and with respect to the proper act. The first and second are noted when it says: 'She sought wool and flax'; and the third there: 'She worked by the counsel of her hands.'
There is a counsel by which we are instructed to discern what is lawful, what is fitting, and what is expedient for salvation according to the judgment of right reason; another is a counsel by which we are instructed to choose what is lawful, what is fitting, and what is expedient according to the command of a good will. The third is a counsel by which we are instructed to pursue what is lawful, what is fitting, and what is expedient according to the exercise of virtuous operation. And of this counsel it is said: 'She has worked by the counsel of her hands.'”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“'She sought wool and flax.' Wool is that from which coarse garment is made; flax is that from which fine garment is made. From wool is made a warm garment, from flax a delicate garment. Likewise, from wool is made an outer garment, while from flax is made an inner garment. According to this threefold property there are three senses, namely the allegorical, anagogical, and tropological.
According to allegory, by wool and flax are signified the New and Old Testaments. According to anagogy, by wool, from which a warm garment is made, is signified the revelation of prayer, because prayer is like heat; by flax, from which a delicate garment is made, are signified delights. According to tropology, by wool are given to be understood outward things, and by flax the experiences of just men.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is a threefold operation, namely to discern rightly, to choose well, and to pursue readily. Therefore it says: 'She has worked by the counsel of her hands.' She not only decreed and chose, but carried it through. It does not suffice to have a good will, unless a man wills to carry it out in deed, from the intellective power to the affective and from the affective to operation. The Philosopher says that three things are necessary for virtue, namely 'to know, to will, and to act unwaveringly.'”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Who shall find a valiant woman?" Without doubt it was said in commendation of mother Church, and specially in commendation of the glorious Virgin. In which word she is commended for three things: first, for the strengthening of spiritual fortitude; second, for the fruitfulness of supernatural conception; and third, for the discretion of salutary counsel. The third is noted when it adds: "She hath sought wool and flax, and hath wrought by the counsel of her hands."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The way of Christ himself is that a man walk purely and with fortitude. "She girded," he says, "her loins with strength."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Of the valiant woman it is said: "She put her hand to strong things, and her fingers grasped the spindle." He speaks of the Church and of her members. First it is necessary to put the hand to strong things before the fingers grasp the spindle, that is, it is necessary first to act with fortitude before a man can teach with perspicacity. In the spindle, by which thread is drawn from tow, is signified the diligence by which men receive doctrine and unfold it. He who wishes to teach well must put his hand to strong things. If the arm is weak, even if the sword be strong and good, the blow will not be good. Some are full of words and have little of works.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fifth column of the house of wisdom is liberality in effect. Wisdom wills to have mercy not only in affection, but also in effect. "She opened her hand to the needy and stretched out her palms to the poor. She opened her mouth to wisdom, and the law of clemency is on her tongue. From the fruit of her hands she gave to the needy." Wisdom teaches that a person should perform works not frivolous but fruitful, because "the fruit of good labors is glorious." Among all fruitful works, the works of mercy are most fruitful. Give therefore from the fruits of your hands.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Strength and beauty are her clothing." Just as the body is adorned by its garment, so the soul is adorned by fortitude; therefore it is called the clothing of the soul; nor is fortitude only the clothing of the soul, or of the glorious Virgin, but indeed of Mother Church. Whence Isaiah says: "Arise, arise, O daughter of Sion; put on the garments of thy glory."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Good is the grace that makes a man good; but "grace is deceitful and beauty is vain," as is said in Proverbs. Grace freely given can coexist with mortal sin. This grace Ecclesiasticus regards as of little account, but the grace that makes one pleasing he highly esteems.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She paid this price as strong and devout with the devotion of divine veneration. Whence in Proverbs: "Charm is deceitful and beauty is vain; the woman who fears the Lord, she shall be praised." But there is no one who could restore the honor taken from God except Christ. And the blessed Virgin is venerative and restorative of the honor taken from God, and a mother consenting that Christ be offered as the price. Therefore "she shall be praised." Anna was praised because she offered Samuel: whence it is said of her: "The woman went her way and ate, and her countenance was no longer changed." She offered her son to serve: but the blessed Virgin offered her son to be sacrificed. Abraham, you wished to offer your son, but you offered a ram! But the glorious Virgin offered her own son.
The poor widow is praised because she offered all that she had: but this woman, namely the glorious Virgin, most merciful, devout, and devoted to God, offered her whole substance. In this the impiety of men is rebuked, who do not render thanks to God for what they have received. You have received so many good things from God, namely prebends and other things; if you do anything for God, it seems great to you. But if you give yourself and everything you have for God, it is nothing. Devotion principally consists in the worship of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This entire book is divided into three parts: into the title or proem and the treatise, which begins there: "Vanity of vanities" etc.; and the epilogue, which begins there: "And since Ecclesiastes was most wise."
In the title the efficient cause is made manifest, in the treatise the material and formal causes, in the epilogue the final cause.
In the title, therefore, the author is made manifest with respect to wisdom, with respect to goodness, and with respect to royal power.
By reason of wisdom he says: "The words of Ecclesiastes," supply: what follows are the words of Ecclesiastes; because Ecclesiastes means "preacher," and one cannot be a preacher unless he is wise, because it is said in Proverbs twenty-six: "As if a thorn should grow in the hand of a drunkard, so unfitting is a parable in the mouth of fools"; whence Proverbs seventeen: "Eloquent words do not befit a fool."
With respect to goodness it is made manifest when it says: "Son of David." For David was holy, and sons by imitation are holy; whence in Scripture it is a name of kindness and gentleness: Matthew fifteen: "Have mercy on me, Son of David."
With respect to royal power, when it says: "King of Jerusalem," because Jerusalem was the most noble city and the capital of the whole kingdom, below: "I, Ecclesiastes, was king of Israel in Jerusalem," because there he chiefly dwelt.
Here a question arises: since Solomon composed three books, why is it that he prefixes a title to the book of Proverbs and to this one, in which his name is expressed, but does not prefix one in the Song of Songs?
I respond: it must be said that in the book of Proverbs Solomon himself is introduced speaking as a wise man to a disciple, whence he calls his hearer "son": similarly here he is introduced as a man who has experienced various things; but in the Song of Songs it is the bride and bridegroom who speak. Lest therefore it should seem that they were the words of Solomon to his wife, but rather they are of Christ to the Church, he does not prefix his name there. But here, because he was for the most part speaking in his own person, and in the book of Proverbs, therefore he prefixes a title in which his name is specified and disclosed.
Likewise it is asked why in the book of Proverbs he says "parables," but here he says "words."
If you say that there he speaks parabolically and figuratively, but here openly: then I ask, why here and there he employs a different manner of proceeding.
I respond: it must be said that there is a certain mode of speaking that is proper and open, and another that is parabolic: and this latter is twofold: one through parables and open similitudes, another through hidden and profound ones. Since therefore Solomon in the book of Proverbs speaks to the little ones and the unlearned, he therefore speaks parabolically and openly: but since in Ecclesiastes he speaks to those who are advancing, therefore openly and properly: but in the Song of Songs, since he speaks to the perfect, whose food is solid food, therefore parabolically and hiddenly.
The question is: why in the title of Proverbs does he call himself by his own name, but here he calls himself Ecclesiastes?
I respond: it must be said that, as Jerome says, Solomon had three names, which indeed suited him according to the threefold scripture which he produced. For he was called Solomon, called Ecclesiastes, and Jedidiah. Solomon, the peaceful one, because he possessed the entire kingdom in peace: whence he also handed down the teaching of proverbs to all. Ecclesiastes, the preacher, because he speaks in the persons of various people. Jedidiah means the same as beloved of the Lord.
Therefore he calls himself Ecclesiastes, because in this book he brings forward the opinions of various persons and accordingly persuades in diverse ways. He was called Jedidiah in the title of the Psalm Eructavit, which is about him according to the literal sense.
Likewise it is asked: why here does he call himself "son of David" and "king of Jerusalem," but in Proverbs he calls himself "king of Israel"?
I respond: one reason is taken from the side of the author, because, according to what the Hebrews believe, this book was written by Solomon when he was doing penance and humbling himself. And therefore in Proverbs he does not name himself from another, but rather manifests the power of his entire kingdom: here however he humbles himself: therefore, naming himself from another, he indicates not the whole power but a part.
Another reason was from the side of the work, because in Proverbs he leads to the knowledge of things to be done, but here to the contempt of present things. And because very many are those who wish more to be wise than to despise present things: therefore there he calls himself king of Israel, but here king of Jerusalem, because despisers of the world are citizens of the heavenly Jerusalem, who do not have here an abiding city, but seek the future one.
And from this the solution to that question which can be raised is clear: why here he does not express the end, as in Proverbs. Because the end of Proverbs is wisdom, which attracts one to listen: the end of this book is contempt of the world, about which few wish to hear.
From these things it is clear why he said "words," why he said "Ecclesiastes," why "of the son of David," why "king of Jerusalem," and why he also did not add anything about the usefulness of the teaching of this book, as in Proverbs.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the efficient cause: it has been said that the efficient cause was Solomon. That it is not fitting, however, for such a person to be the author, appears from the following:
Because he was a sinner and carnal: but when a carnal man preaches spirituality, he causes scandal rather than edification: therefore this book is more apt to generate scandal than edification.
Likewise, in the Psalm it is said: "But to the sinner God said: Why do you declare my justices?" Therefore if Solomon was a sinner, then he was sinning by declaring the divine justice.
Furthermore, a good author produces credibility, whence the argument from authority has its force; therefore a bad author produces no credibility: but the books of Sacred Scripture are for generating faith.
To this it must be responded that, as Jerome says, according to the tradition of the Hebrews, this book was written by Solomon while doing penance: and because God does not reject the penitent, but rather accepts them, accordingly Solomon was not in a blameworthy state when he wrote this book.
It can also be responded otherwise, that the Holy Spirit speaks true and good things not only through the good, but indeed also through the wicked: whence the Lord himself says in the Gospel: "Do what they say, but do not do what they do": whence also through Balaam he prophesied most expressly, and so also through Solomon, even though carnal, he said many good things.
As to what is objected, therefore, that he was sinning: it must be responded that to him the gift of wisdom was entrusted most especially among all others: and because he was bound not to hide the talent of the Lord, he was obliged to teach the people of the Lord both by word and by writing, especially since he was appointed to their governance. Whence he was not sinning in this, that he taught, but in this, that he did not duly dispose himself.
As to what is objected, that the book is not to be believed, since the author is not worthy of credence: I respond: just as we believe the Prophets, that they spoke not of themselves but through the Holy Spirit: so also in all the books of Scripture, that they were produced at the dictation of the Holy Spirit: whence the goodness of the person does not contribute to greater or lesser credibility, presupposing that he spoke through the Spirit. And because it is established for us that Solomon was filled with the spirit of wisdom, as is clear from 3 Kings 3; therefore the Church without doubt receives his books.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wisdom and love are the principal fruits. And that which is most opposed to them is vanity. For this reason, the Canticle speaks of a loving wisdom. No one, indeed, can say that the words of the Canticle are without wisdom and love, nor that they are not far removed from vanity. Wherefore before this book there comes Ecclesiastes where vanity is shown in these words: "Vanity of vanities! All things are vanity!" This proposition is true and is proved by the whole book. It is fitting, then, to pass over from all things into truth, so that there be no other pleasure than in God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, civil war is the temptation of the world. Indeed, every creature is a trap. Hence the saying: Vanity of vanities! All things are vanity! What profit has man from all the labor which he toils at under the sun? Vain and worthless is anything of which nothing remains to man after death: wherefore all things are vanity. The Psalm reads: Turn away my eyes from seeing what is vain.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here begins the treatise: and because "the end imposes necessity upon those things which are ordered to the end," since the end of this book is the contempt of all things and the fear of God alone, therefore in all things he intends to show vanity. And because he proceeds as a preacher by persuading and proving, therefore this treatise has three parts: because first he proposes what he intends to prove, namely that there is vanity in all things; second he proves it, there: "What more does man have from his labor," etc.; third he concludes it as proven near the end: "Vanity of vanities," etc.
He therefore proposes a threefold vanity in things, namely of penality, of iniquity, of mutability. As to the vanity of penality: "Vanity of vanities, said Ecclesiastes," that is, he proposed. Concerning this, below in the second chapter: "All his days are full of labors, nor does his mind rest at night: and is this not vanity?" As to the vanity of iniquity he says again: "Vanity of vanities"; whence Jeremiah 10: "Their works are vain and worthy of ridicule: in the day of their visitation they shall perish."
As to the vanity of mutability he says: "and all is vanity," because all things are subject to mutability; Romans 8: "The creature was made subject to vanity, not willingly"; and below in the third chapter: "All things are subject to vanity, and all go to one place." Therefore it is not a repetition of words when he says "vanity" three times, but a wondrous distinction of intelligible things.
And it should be noted that this threefold vanity follows in sequence, and one arises from another: because the vanity of iniquity arises from the vanity of mutability, although that is not the whole cause; but the vanity of penality arises from the vanity of iniquity. He therefore arranges these vanities in a reverse resolutory order, and pursues them in the opposite order in what follows. And because that twofold vanity has its origin from another vanity, but the third does not, therefore he says "vanity of vanities" twice, and afterwards only "vanity."
It should also be noted that this threefold vanity is found in man, because he is the one upon whom falls punishment and fault: and on account of this it is said in the Psalm: "Every living man is altogether vanity." For there is in him the vanity of nature, the vanity of fault, and the vanity of punishment. Concerning the vanity of nature, in the Psalm: "Man is made like unto vanity; his days pass away like a shadow." Concerning the vanity of fault, likewise in the Psalm: "The Lord knows the thoughts of men, that they are vain." Concerning the vanity of punishment, Job 14: "Man born of a woman, living for a short time, is filled with many miseries."
It should also be noted that Solomon himself speaks of himself as if of another, just as John, in the twenty-first chapter: "This is that disciple who bears witness concerning these things"; and similarly Moses. Now a threefold reason can be assigned for this: one is on the part of the first efficient cause, because the Holy Spirit himself is the author of Scripture, not Solomon or another; therefore, when he is introduced in sacred Scripture, Scripture ought to speak of him as if of another, just as Balaam said in Numbers, the twenty-fourth chapter: "The hearer of the words of God said," etc.
Another reason is taken from the part of the immediate efficient cause: because Scripture shuns all pride and displays humility; and therefore no teacher in it ought to speak of himself as of himself, but for the sake of humility, as if of another. The third reason: when Scripture intimates great and wondrous things, it ought to show them as if from afar; whence Hugh says: "This manner of speaking, as often as it is employed in Scripture, is done either for the sake of humility or of wonder. For we ought both to remove great things from ourselves on account of humility, and to show wondrous things as if from afar on account of wonder." An example is found in Paul and John.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the purpose of the book of Ecclesiastes: it is said that the purpose of the book is contempt of the world. That it is so determined, is proved by that which is said in James 4: "The friendship of this world is enmity with God": but everything that is hostile to God, it is good to despise. Likewise, 1 John 2: "Do not love the world, nor the things that are in the world."
But on the contrary: Praise of the work redounds to the craftsman, therefore contempt of the work also redounds to the same, therefore whoever despises the world despises God: therefore either this world was not made by God, or it is not to be despised. Likewise, Proverbs 16: "The Lord has made all things for himself," therefore all things are ordered to God; but what is ordered to an end is not to be despised, but to be accepted and loved: therefore this world, and the things that are in it, are to be loved.
I respond: it must be said that, as Augustine and Hugh maintain, this world is like a certain ring given by the bridegroom to the soul itself: but the bride can love the ring bestowed upon her by the bridegroom in two ways, namely, with chaste love and with adulterous love. Chaste love is that by which she loves the ring in memory of the bridegroom and on account of love for the bridegroom: adulterous, that by which she loves the ring more than the bridegroom: and the bridegroom cannot but regard this as evil. For just as love is twofold, so hatred or contempt is twofold, because "as often as one of the opposites is spoken of, so also the other." Contempt of the ring, as though it were a small and worthless gift, redounds to the bridegroom: but contempt of the ring, as though it be reckoned as nothing in comparison with the love of the bridegroom, this is to the glory of the bridegroom: and concerning this contempt it is said in Song of Songs, the last chapter: "If a man should give all the substance of his house for love, he shall despise it as nothing." Of this contempt is the discourse here: and thus the objections are resolved.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the subject matter of the book of Ecclesiastes: it is said that here the treatment is of vanity.
But on the contrary: Every science treats of the good and the true: but the vain is deprived of goodness and truth: therefore there is no science of it. Furthermore, it seems that there is no vanity in things, because it is said in Genesis 1: "God saw all things that he had made, and they were very good": therefore if all things are very good, nothing is vain. Furthermore, that is vain and futile which is not ordered to an end, just as, if someone were to bathe himself so that the sun might be eclipsed, he would labor in vain, because the former is not orderable to the latter: but all creatures tend toward the highest good in their own way, as Dionysius says, and Boethius, that all things desire the good, and also the Philosopher: therefore nothing vain is found among all things. Furthermore, if vanity is found, and this science is founded upon it as upon its subject: and what is founded upon the vain is vain: therefore this science is vain.
I respond: for the understanding of the foregoing, it can be said in one way thus, that vain is said in two ways: in one way absolutely, and thus it deprives of the true and the good, and such a thing does not exist in the universe. In another way something is vain by comparison to its initial origin, because it is from nothing: and thus it is not incompatible with the good; indeed one and the same thing is both good and vain: but good, because from the good and toward the good; vain, because from nothing and left to itself it tends toward nothing; and such vanity possesses goodness subject to knowledge, and therefore concerning such there can be knowledge and doctrine. And by this all objections can be resolved, because they proceed as if they were about the vain absolutely.
But this solution does not resolve the matter, because Ecclesiastes does not treat of things insofar as they are from nothing, but rather insofar as they are desired by men: and moreover it treats of the vanity of fault, which is a privation: therefore it is necessary to speak otherwise.
One must therefore respond otherwise and say that just as the true is said in three ways, so also the vain, which is opposed to it, by the rule stated above. In one way the true is said insofar as it is convertible with being, and thus it is said that every being is true; and thus the vain, opposed to the true, is called non-being, just as we say that a chimera is a non-being.
In another way the true is said insofar as beyond entity it adds an ordering to operation and end, just as true wine is said to be that which has the true operation of wine, so a true man is one who has the operation proper to man, and this is the operation of virtue; and thus the vain is said through privation of ordering to an end, and thus all sins and abuses are vain.
In another way the true is said insofar as it adds above being a freedom from admixture with non-being, which in no way has potency toward that: and thus that is said to have true being which has immutable being: and in this way the vain, opposed to the true, is that which is mutable and changeable. And thus every creature is vain, because subject to vanity, that is, to mutability.
Thus therefore, with the vain being said in three ways: in one way through privation of being absolutely, in another way through privation of ordered being, in a third way through privation of unchangeable being: concerning the first, there is in no way knowledge or doctrine, unless perhaps it has being in a cause and according to that can be known and taught: and thus it is not vain: but insofar as it is vain, there is knowledge of it neither per se nor per accidens.
Concerning the second way, there is no knowledge per se, but per accidens. For just as medicine is the knowledge of the healthy and the sick, of the healthy indeed per se, but of the sick per accidens, as the Philosopher holds; so concerning fault or sin there is theoretical knowledge, but by reason of virtue.
Concerning the third way, namely concerning the mutability of the creature, there is knowledge per se, as is evident concerning the motion of the sun and the spheres and other things.
In this book, therefore, the subject treated is the vanity of mutability or of nature, because it is fair and fitting, and the vanity of fault: the other vanity, namely that of total privation, is not treated, because of that there is neither knowledge nor doctrine.
To the first objection, therefore, that every science concerns the good and the true: this is true per se, but there can also be science of the vain by reason of the true; and he who knows true principles also knows false ones: and it is similar with the sick and the healthy, and likewise in the matter at hand.
To the objection that creatures are not vain, because they are very good and ordered to an end: it must be answered that they are not called vain through a defect of goodness or order, but through a defect of immutable being: and thus every creature is vain, yet it is not so vain that it lacks truth and goodness; and therefore knowledge and doctrine concerning it is true.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, civil war is the temptation of the world. Indeed, every creature is a trap. Hence the saying: Vanity of vanities! All things are vanity! What profit has man from all the labor which he toils at under the sun? Vain and worthless is anything of which nothing remains to man after death: wherefore all things are vanity. The Psalm reads: Turn away my eyes from seeing what is vain.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Above he proposed what he intends to prove; here he begins to prove it. And just as a threefold vanity was proposed to exist in things, so also a threefold vanity is proved to exist. Whence this part has three parts. For first he shows there to be in things the vanity of mutability; second, the vanity of iniquity; third, the vanity of punishment. "The first is natural and fitting, as Hugh says; the second is culpable, because perverse; the third is penal and miserable."
Now mutability in things is considered in two ways: in one way by reason of change, in another way in comparison to the measure of a definite time.
Therefore mutability is first shown in the existence of creatures. And because creatures have a threefold being, namely in the Word, by reason of exemplarity; in the universe, by mode of materiality; in the human mind, by mode of abstraction—the first being is unfailing and immutable, whence it has no vanity; but in the others there is vanity.
Therefore, as to the rational creature, namely man, he shows there to be mutability, from which one can be delivered by no labor; on account of which he says: "What more does man have from all his labor, with which he labors under the sun?" Supply: except vanity and mutability, as if to say: nothing. Concerning this labor it is said in Job 5: "A bird is born to fly, and man to labor"; and Genesis 3: "Cursed is the earth in your work; in labor you shall eat from it all the days of your life."
Here a question arises concerning what he says: "What more does man have," etc.
This seems to be a heretical opinion and to agree with that which says that "vain is" everyone "who serves God."
Likewise in the Psalm it is said: "The patience of the poor shall not perish in the end": therefore something remains.
Likewise Proverbs chapter twelve: "He who works his land shall be satisfied with bread": therefore it is good to work and to labor.
I respond: as Hugh says, emphasis must be placed on this, that he says: "In which he labors under the sun": "for it is the same as if he were to say: under time."
On account of which it should be noted that certain things come to be with time, such as those whose origin time did not precede, as the angelic nature and prime matter. Certain things come to be in time, which began after the origin of time but do not have their setting in time, such as the soul of Peter. Certain things come to be in time and under time, which begin after the origin of time and are terminated in time, of which kind are mutable things. And such things are twofold: for some come to be for time and under time, and such things pass away in act and in fruit; some for eternity, and such things pass away in act but remain in root and in fruit, because the good will remains to be rewarded for eternity.
When therefore he says that man has nothing but vanity from all his labor with which he labors under the sun: this is understood insofar as labor is under time with respect to act and intention; and then it has no place among good things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And that he has nothing more than vanity, he shows when he adds: "A generation passes away, and a generation comes." Therefore there is change and succession both in man and in his works. Sirach 14: "Some things are generated, and others are cast down; so is the generation of flesh and blood: one ends, and another is born," according to what is said in James 4: "What is your life but a vapor appearing for a little while"? But when they are corrupted, they do not pass into nothing, but into something, because into earth; whence it was said to Adam: "You are dust, and to dust you shall return." Therefore he adds: "But the earth stands forever," as it were the matter into which dissolution takes place. Psalm: "Who founded the earth upon its stability"; and Proverbs 8: "When he was weighing the foundations of the earth."
Likewise, there is a question concerning what he says: "The earth stands forever."
To the contrary: Matthew twenty-four: "Heaven and earth shall pass away": therefore the earth does not stand.
Likewise, Apocalypse twenty-one: "I saw a new heaven and a new earth," therefore the earth grows old: therefore it does not stand.
I respond: it must be said that "the earth standing" is twofold: either with respect to substance, or with respect to figure or disposition; I say that the earth stands forever with respect to substance, but passes away with respect to figure: First Corinthians seven: "The figure of this world passes away." But men are generated and corrupted with respect to substance, so that they are rightly called not "men" but "the dead."
Or "eternal" is said in multiple ways: in one way, that which does not have an end prescribed in Scripture: thus the land of promise was given to the children of Israel as an eternal possession. In another way, that which has an end, but not in time: thus "time" is said to be eternal. In the third way, that whose signification is never ended. In the fourth way, that whose substance is never ended. In the fifth way, that whose substance neither ends nor began.
In this last way, God alone; in the fourth way it applies to the earth with respect to substance, in the third way with respect to signification, in the first two ways with respect to figure.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the allegorical sense, the sun signifies Christ. "The sun rises and the sun goes down." It rises in the nativity, it goes down in death; it orbits through noon in the ascension; it is inclined to the north in the judgment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Ecclesiastes shows these four when he says: "The sun riseth, and goeth down, and returneth to his place: and there rising again, maketh his round by the south, and turneth again to the north." Marvelous was the origin: how the supersubstantial radiation was united to humanity in the womb, came forth from the womb; how He dwelled in the world, alive, shining and inflaming; how in death He condescended to die; how later He rose from the nether world, first into [His] body and then into heaven; and how He shall come back for the judgment. There was a marvelous duration of eternity in the union of the Godhead with humanity. For it is impossible to have a greater separation, short of the denial of God's existence: since it would be easier to separate an angel from its essence. The breadth of charity came about in death; the marvelous sublimity of power, in the ascension; the marvelous depth of wisdom will come about in the judgment. These are wondrous [realities] by which the soul is placed, so to speak, outside of itself.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here secondly he shows mutability in the celestial nature, as is evident in the sun, which never rests, but when it rises, it tends toward setting, whence it does not remain in its rising. Therefore he says: "The sun rises and sets," so that it does not remain in the place of rising nor even in the place of setting; thence he adds: "And it returns to its place." Nor does it remain there, whence he also adds: "And there being born again it circles through the south." Nor does it remain even in the middle place; therefore he adds: "And it bends toward the north."
This can be explained with respect to the diurnal motion, or also the annual. With respect to the diurnal, Hugh says: "The sun rises daily, when it is presented to human sight. It sets when, descending to the lower parts, it withdraws itself from our eyes. It returns to its place, because, driven by the rotation beneath, it again returns to its place. But rising again it circles through the south, because by an oblique course it ascends from the east to the meridian line; then it turns toward the north, because, descending toward the west, it again inclines toward the north by an oblique progression."
With respect to the annual motion, thus: "The sun rises when through the vernal equinox it ascends to our pole. It sets when, passing through the autumnal equinox, it descends to the lower regions. It circles through the south when it lingers in the winter signs. It turns toward the north when it revolves in the summer signs, which are nearer to the northern pole." And thus the sun does not stand still by nature, but only by miracle, as is read in Joshua 10: "Sun, stand still over Gibeon, and moon, over the valley of Ajalon."
Spiritually, this sun is Christ, concerning whom Malachi four: "The Sun of Justice shall rise upon you who fear my name." This sun rises in the nativity to illuminate: Isaiah sixty: "Arise, be illuminated, Jerusalem": and John one: "He was the true light, which illuminates every man." This sun sets in the passion to redeem: Amos eight: "The sun shall set at midday," that is, in the vehement love of charity. This sun returns to its place in the ascension: Luke nineteen: "A certain man went into a far country." This sun circles through the south, that is, in the fervent love of the Saints: Song of Songs one: "Show me, O you whom my soul loves, where you feed, where you lie down at midday": and John fourteen: "If anyone loves me," afterwards: "We will come to him and make our abode with him." This sun turns to the north in the final judgment: Jeremiah one: "From the north shall all evil be spread."
Likewise it is asked, since other luminaries likewise rise, why he speaks more of the sun than of others.
I respond: it must be said that once mutability has been established in the sun, which is the noblest and most luminous among the heavenly bodies, it is sufficiently given to be understood in the others.
Likewise, he seems to proceed in a disordered manner, because he says that it sets before he says that it circles through the south: for it circles before it sets.
I respond: it must be said that he does not arrange them according to progression, but according to dimensions or the limits of dimensions. Therefore, because east and west are opposites, they are immediately ordered together; likewise, because south and north are opposites, they are similarly placed immediately in the manner of a cross.
But there is a doubt about what he says: "It returns to its place," because in the firmament no one place of the sun is more its place than another.
If you say that it returns to the place from which it began its course: this is manifestly false, because the sun is always moved by its own motion either ascending or descending; therefore it never returns to the same place.
Likewise, what does he mean when he says: "Turning toward the north." For if the sun is moved by diurnal motion with the motion of the firmament, and the firmament moves uniformly and similarly, then it does not turn more toward the arctic pole than toward the antarctic, or conversely.
If you say that this is understood of its proper motion: but the sun according to its proper motion ascends and descends in the zodiac, and when it ascends, it approaches the north; when it descends, it draws near to the south; therefore it does not turn more toward the north than toward the south.
I respond: it must be said that one can speak of the motion of the sun as diurnal and annual. If we speak of the annual motion, it is true that the sun returns to its place, because it began to move from there. But if we understand this of the diurnal motion, it does not return to its place from which it began to move according to the truth, but according to our estimation, since it does not make a sphere but a spiral.
To the second it must similarly be said that if we speak of the annual motion, it holds true according to the four seasons, as was said above, because it rises in spring, sets in autumn, circles through the south in winter, and turns toward the north in summer. But if you understand this of the diurnal motion, this does not hold true except according to our estimation. For we see the firmament moving, and we imagine its poles to the right and to the left; but it is not so, rather one pole is as if above our heads, namely the northern; the other as if beneath our feet. When therefore the sun revolves according to the poles of the firmament, it does not go directly above our heads and beneath our feet, but as if transversally; and because we see according to the level plane, it seems to us that by day it inclines toward the south and by night toward the north.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Ecclesiastes shows these four when he says: "The sun riseth, and goeth down, and returneth to his place: and there rising again, maketh his round by the south, and turneth again to the north." Marvelous was the origin: how the supersubstantial radiation was united to humanity in the womb, came forth from the womb; how He dwelled in the world, alive, shining and inflaming; how in death He condescended to die; how later He rose from the nether world, first into [His] body and then into heaven; and how He shall come back for the judgment. There was a marvelous duration of eternity in the union of the Godhead with humanity. For it is impossible to have a greater separation, short of the denial of God's existence: since it would be easier to separate an angel from its essence. The breadth of charity came about in death; the marvelous sublimity of power, in the ascension; the marvelous depth of wisdom will come about in the judgment. These are wondrous [realities] by which the soul is placed, so to speak, outside of itself.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here is touched upon the mutability in elemental nature, and first with respect to air. With respect to air, he touches upon the mutability in spirit or in wind, which is either the motion of air according to some philosophers, or according to Aristotle the motion of vapor in the air, by whose motion the air is also moved. On account of which he says: "Surveying all things, the spirit goes about in a circuit," that is, the wind circuits by surveying all things. "Spirit" is said to mean "wind": Exodus 15: "Your spirit blew, O Lord, and the sea covered them"; and in the Psalm: "Fire, hail, snow, ice, the spirit of storms."
This "goes about in a circuit," because it arises from the four regions of the earth: Zechariah 2: "Flee from the land of the north, for I have scattered you to the four winds of heaven"; and Ezekiel 37: "Come from the four winds, O spirit." For there are four principal winds and eight collateral ones.
And "it returns to its circuits," because the wind ceases when that vapor comes to rest and returns to the earth whence it arose. And because that cause is hidden, therefore it is said in the Psalm: "Who brings forth winds from his treasuries," that is, from hidden places.
Or, as the Gloss explains, this can be understood of the sun with respect to the annual motion, which surveys all things and returns in the circles of the zodiac; and the sun is called "spirit" because it is the principle and cause of all life, whence it causes all other things to breathe.
Spiritually, this surveying spirit is the Holy Spirit, who is therefore said to survey, because he makes us search all things: First Corinthians two: "The Spirit searches all things, even the deep things of God."
He is said to go in a circuit, because he makes us go around: whence Wisdom chapter seven: "The spirit of wisdom is mobile"; likewise also going around, because he makes us consider the circuit of misery: Job chapter one: "Naked I came forth from my mother's womb, and naked shall I return thither." Likewise the circuit of grace, concerning which John chapter sixteen: "I came forth from the Father and came into the world, and again I leave the world and go to the Father." Likewise of glory, Ezekiel chapter one: "This was the appearance of splendor round about, and this was the likeness of the glory of the Lord." The Spirit of God makes one consider this: Second Corinthians chapter three: "We with unveiled face shall behold the glory of the Lord."
This circuit consists in the consideration that all things are from God and unto God. And Dionysius says that the Angels are moved circularly around the throne.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On that passage of Ecclesiastes: "To the place whence the rivers go forth, they return:" Bernard says that "the origin of fountains is the sea; the origin of virtues and knowledge is Christ." He says therefore: "To the place whence the rivers go forth," namely of graces, "they return, that they may flow again." For just as a fountain has no duration unless it maintains a continuous connection with its source, nor indeed does light, so the grace of the Holy Spirit cannot flourish in the soul except through its return to its original principle.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is written in Ecclesiastes: "All rivers go to the sea, yet never does the sea become full. To the place where they go, the rivers keep on going:" and it is the same with all the spiritual meanings that flow from divine Scripture. The spiritual meanings are called rivers — and also those men who understand in a spiritual manner — because they have their origin from the Scriptures and are confirmed by the Scriptures, and because, from these spiritual meanings, other meanings are derived.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here mutability is touched upon with respect to visible elemental nature, namely water, because there is no stability there: for all waters move toward the sea; whence he says: "All the rivers enter into the sea," namely the great ocean, concerning which it is said in Job thirty-eight: "Who shut up the sea with doors, when it burst forth, as if proceeding from a womb"? And this motion is not terminated, because the sea is not filled: therefore he adds: "And the sea does not overflow." And because this seems wonderful, therefore he gives the cause of this: "To the place whence they go forth, the rivers return," not so that they may rest there, but "so that they may flow again." The rivers go forth secretly, they return openly, because they go forth through subterranean channels and certain filtrations. And thus all things are carried in a circuit and are subject to vanity. Hugh: "Behold how all things are carried in a circuit and are subject to vanity: and we know that a circle has no end: those things therefore that run in a circuit run indeed, but do not arrive at an end. What rest therefore can be hoped for, where there can be no stability? And therefore it is said of the impious: 'The head of their circuit'; and again: 'The impious walk in a circuit'; and again: 'My God, make them like a wheel.'"
Spiritually, these are the rivers of graces, concerning which John chapter seven: "He who believes in me, as the Scripture says, rivers shall flow from his belly."
The sea, from which the rivers have their origin, is the immensity of divine generosity, which is neither increased nor diminished: "For great is our Lord and great is his power, and of his wisdom there is no number."
To this sea the rivers of thanksgiving return, so that they may flow again: John chapter four: "Whoever drinks of this water which I shall give him, it shall become in him a fountain of water springing up unto eternal life." From this they go forth: James chapter one: "Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above." And just as rivers cease to exist and dry up when they cease to flow and are still, so also with the gifts of graces: the Psalm: "You broke open fountains and torrents," through generosity; "you dried up the rivers of Ethan," through the severity of judgment.
It is asked about what he says: "The rivers go forth from the sea."
Against: The sea is bitter, and rivers are sweet; but contraries do not have their origin from one principle, nor one from another; therefore neither does the sea come from rivers, nor rivers from the sea.
I respond: it must be said that all water by nature is sweet or tasteless, as the Philosopher says; but it becomes bitter accidentally, either through the evaporation of the subtle parts, with the earthly parts remaining, or through the admixture of earthly parts. Conversely, that water, just as it was accidentally made bitter, can return to sweetness through refinement, as is shown by the experiment of an earthen vessel placed in the sea. Since therefore rivers, even though they return to the sea in great abundance, nevertheless flow out secretly and underground and through a certain filtration, the water is refined and turned to sweetness.
As to the objection, then, that one of two contraries does not have its origin from the other: it must be said that water is not contrary to water; and if it has a contrary disposition, it has this not by nature but by accident, as is evident in hot and cold water. Nor is the origin of rivers from the sea by reason of property, because sweetness is prior by nature in water, but with respect to outflow, as the drawing of wine from a cask: because that place contains an abundance of waters, from which emanation ceaselessly occurs.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Above, the vanity in things was determined according to the being which they have in the universe: here vanity is determined according to the being which they have in the human intellect: and vanity is shown in them in three ways: first, because they are not evident; second, because they do not satisfy; third, because they do not endure. They are not evident for interpreting or teaching; they do not satisfy so as to refresh and quiet the learner; they do not endure for remembering. And these three correspond to a threefold power in us: the interpretive, the cognitive, and the memorative.
First, therefore, it is noted that they are not evident for explaining; thus he says: "All things are difficult," namely for discovering their reason; whence Wisdom 9: "With difficulty we estimate the things that are on earth, and we find with labor the things that are before us"; below in chapter 8: "I understood that man can find no reason for the works of God"; and therefore, because they are difficult, "man cannot explain them in speech": Job 38: "Who shall declare the reason of the heavens"? Sirach 43: "We shall say much and shall fall short in words: the consummation of words is he himself."
Here in the second place it is touched upon that they do not fill so as to refresh the learner; and because we learn most by two senses, namely sight and hearing, he shows that in neither is there satiety; and therefore he says: "The eye is not satisfied with seeing": Proverbs twenty-seven: "For the eyes of men are insatiable." "Nor is the ear filled with hearing," since there is an itching to hear new and curious things: Second Timothy four: "They will heap up to themselves teachers according to their own desires, having itching ears." And the reason for this is that that in which there is true satiety, neither has the eye seen nor has the ear perceived: First Corinthians two: "Neither has the eye seen, nor has the ear heard."
It is asked concerning what he says: "All things are difficult."
On the contrary: There are many things whose knowledge is common to us and to brutes; therefore it is not difficult for man to know what a beast knows.
Likewise, there are certain things in which it does not happen to err, as in the knowledge of sensible things, because the sense is not deceived regarding its proper object, and of intelligible principles, such as axioms, and such things are easy to know.
Likewise, what does he mean when he says: "Man cannot explain them in speech"? It is easier for man to speak than for any creature to operate easily; therefore if it is easy for any creature to operate, then it is easy for man to explain its operation.
I respond: it must be said that there is knowing incompletely, as when something is known according to its accidents, or according to some operation. There is again knowing perfectly, and he knows perfectly who fully knows the substance, power, and operation, and the causes and reasons of these. And because power is hidden, and substance is remote from the senses, therefore all things are difficult for us.
As to the objection that we know some things in common with brute animals, this is true in a certain way, as that this is bitter; but a brute animal knows nothing fully.
Similarly the second is clear: because insofar as something is sensible, it is manifest.
Through this the following is also clear: because to "say" something and to "explain" it differ: for to "explain" is to draw out hidden reasons that are inwardly wrapped up; and no one can do this unless he understands; and this is arduous and belongs to few.
Likewise, there is a question about what he says: "The eye is not satisfied with seeing."
It is asked why he does not adduce the other senses, since it is similarly possible to know through them.
Likewise, what does he mean when he says: "Is not satisfied"? For one is said to be "satisfied" when he no longer desires more of what he was desiring; but it sometimes happens that a man does not want to see or hear more, but rather to rest.
Likewise, if it is not satisfied, then their desire never rests; therefore since a desire that has no rest is frustrated of its end, and every such thing is vain, therefore the desire of sight is vain.
I respond: it must be said that he mentions only these two senses because he speaks of the senses insofar as they are a way into knowledge and are referred to sensual delight. And the word by which we recognize all things is twofold: namely the divine word and the human word. The divine word is every creature, because it speaks God: this word the eye perceives. The human word is the uttered voice, and this the ear perceives.
Or because knowledge is twofold: through discovery and teaching; for the first regards sight, while the second regards hearing.
As to the objection about satisfaction: I say that he speaks of the satisfaction of these insofar as they are organs of the heart and of the will or appetite; and because the heart is not satisfied, neither are these two senses. Hence Hugh: "All beauty, all delight, all sweetness of created things can affect the human heart, but cannot satisfy it—only that sweetness alone, for which it was made, can satisfy it."
As to the objection about being frustrated: this is false, because it is terminated elsewhere.
As to the objection that one does not want more: this is because one grows weary and is disgusted, not because one is satisfied.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If moreover we consider the delight, we shall perceive the union of God and the soul. For every sense seeks its fitting sensible object with desire, finds it with joy, and returns to it without weariness, because the eye is not satisfied with seeing, nor is the ear filled with hearing. In this manner also, the sense of our heart, whether it be the beautiful, the harmonious, the fragrant, the sweet, or the soothing, ought to seek with desire, find with joy, and return to without ceasing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The times of origin consist in the first seven days; the times of symbolism, in the span between the beginning of the world and Christ, when a new time begins, although Solomon said: "Nothing is new under the sun" — which is true in the order of nature, but this is above nature. The times of grace then come later. Moses began from the times of origin, and he was bound to do so, for Scripture, like a germinating soil, had to bring forth the seeds at first, then the symbolic trees, and finally the fruit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And that one cannot be refreshed in these earthly things, he shows, because the eye and ear wish to perceive new things; but nothing remains in newness; therefore the ear and eye are filled by nothing. He supposes the major premise, and it is made manifest in Acts seventeen: "The Athenians spent their time in nothing else but either saying or hearing something new"; but here he proposes the minor, because nothing has newness, neither with respect to being nor with respect to becoming. Therefore he says: "What is it that has been?" He asks and he himself responds: "The same that shall be"; therefore by simple conversion: what shall be has been. Similarly it follows: "What is it that has been done?" He responds: "The same that is to be done"; therefore by simple conversion: what is to be done has been done. And from this he concludes: "Nothing is new under the sun, nor can anyone say: Behold this is recent"; therefore neither to say nor to hear anything new. And he repeats the proof: "For they have already gone before in the ages that were before us": Second Peter three: "Since our fathers fell asleep, all things continue as they are."
Likewise, there is a question about what he says: "Nothing is new under the sun."
The contrary seems to be the case: Jeremiah thirty-one: "The Lord will make a new thing upon the earth."
Likewise, Apocalypse twenty-one: "I saw a new heaven and a new earth."
Likewise, from this statement the error seems to be confirmed that there is a circulation in things according to procession, such that the same things exist which formerly existed, and this through the following text: it has "already preceded in the ages that were before us"; and thus that error seems to be verified which posits that after the great year, which contains fifteen thousand years, all things are renewed.
I respond: it must be said that there is an operation of creation, of conservation, of reparation, and of glorification. Each of these operations is above nature, and therefore will not be under the sun or under time, but above it, except for propagation; hence he understands only of this.
On this it should be noted that he calls "new" that whose likeness has not preceded; and thus there is nothing new according to propagation, because there always like comes from like. But the objector objects as if he were speaking of the numerically same thing; and that is impossible to understand in this way, because if every form that is corrupted and generated again differs numerically, it cannot be understood of the numerically same thing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He shows that nothing remains in newness, neither with respect to being nor with respect to becoming. Therefore he says: "What is it that has been?" He asks and he himself responds: "The same that shall be." Similarly it follows: "What is it that has been done?" He responds: "The same that is to be done." And from this he concludes: "Nothing is new under the sun, nor can anyone say: Behold this is recent"; therefore neither to say nor to hear anything new. And he repeats the proof: "For they have already gone before in the ages that were before us": Second Peter three: "Since our fathers fell asleep, all things continue as they are."
On this it should be noted that he calls "new" that whose likeness has not preceded; and thus there is nothing new according to propagation, because there always like comes from like.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the third place it is touched upon here that things do not endure so as to be remembered, because all things are delivered to oblivion; whence he says: "There is no remembrance of former things," namely among us who come after: Wisdom two: "Our name shall receive oblivion through time, and no one shall have remembrance of our works." And so it is in things past and in things future; whence he adds: "But neither indeed shall there be remembrance of those things that are to come hereafter among those who shall be in the last time," that is: later generations shall not be mindful of former things, and this on account of time, which brings on oblivion; below in chapter two: "Future times shall cover all things with oblivion."
Likewise, there is a question about what he says: "There is no remembrance of former things."
On the contrary: It is said in the Psalm: "I remembered your works, O Lord."
I respond: to this some say that it is understood of evil things, not of good things.
But this is still false, because many evil things are also in memory.
And therefore it must be said that this proposition is not to be understood as universally true, but as true in most cases, because there is more forgetfulness than remembrance; nevertheless, very many of the things that have been done are in our memory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here from the consideration of the mutability of things he reproves his own curiosity. And first he manifests his curiosity; second, he reproves his curiosity on account of vanity, in the second chapter.
First he manifests his curiosity, first indeed in the works of prudence or philosophy; second, of the curiosity of opulence or mechanical art, at: "I magnified my works."
Therefore the suitability of the one considering is noted, when he says: "I, Ecclesiastes": because in him there was wisdom, therefore he calls himself Ecclesiastes, that is, a preacher; there was also power, whence he says: "I was king"; there was also peace, whence he adds: "in Jerusalem," which is interpreted as "vision of peace": Ecclesiasticus forty-seven: "Solomon reigned in days of peace": First Chronicles twenty-two: "The son who shall be born to you shall be a peaceful man"; and because he possessed this, therefore nothing held him back from consideration.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here curiosity itself is touched upon, because he wished to know all things and to investigate them subtly. Therefore he says: "And I proposed in my mind to seek," namely from another, "and to investigate wisely," by myself; and this is curiosity; Romans twelve: "Not to be wise more than it behooves one to be wise, but to be wise unto sobriety"; whence Proverbs twenty-five: "You have found honey; eat what is sufficient for you, lest perhaps being sated you vomit it up." "Concerning all things that are done under the sun." Behold, a greater curiosity, because concerning all things: Ecclesiasticus three: "Do not search into superfluous things in many ways, and do not be curious about his many works; for many things beyond the understanding of men have been shown to you."
"This most wretched occupation." Here the severity of divine judgment is touched upon: because by divine judgment, on account of the sin of the first parent, it came about that our rational faculty so readily indulges itself in the knowledge of earthly things. On account of which he says: "This most wretched occupation," because it is not only blameworthy but also penal; "God gave to the sons of men," that is, he permitted it to be given; or by reason of its penal character he gave it in a just manner; "that they might be occupied in it," and thereby be forgetful of their salvation.
Whence it should be noted that there is an evil occupation, which is from weakness: concerning this, Ecclesiasticus forty: "A great occupation is created for all men, and a heavy yoke upon the sons of Adam, from the day of their going out of their mother's womb even to the day of their burial into the mother of all."
There is a worse occupation, which is from ignorance, concerning which Job three: "Let darkness and the shadow of death obscure it; let a mist occupy it, and let it be wrapped in bitterness."
The third is from curiosity, and this is the worst, and of this he speaks here.
And it should be noted that "occupation, as Hugh says, is a distraction of the mind which turns away and distracts and ensnares the soul, so that it cannot think about the things that pertain to salvation." Curiosity, however, is the lustful prostitution of the human intellect, indiscriminately embracing any truth whatsoever and committing adultery with it, because the First Truth alone is the spouse.
But here it is asked concerning what he says: "This most wretched occupation."
Against: This is sin: therefore God gave sin.
If you say: "He gave," that is, He permitted it to be given; but similarly He permitted stealing: therefore it would be rightly said that God steals.
I respond: "Sins that are midway between the first apostasy and the final punishment are both punishment and fault"; but some express more the character of fault, and some more the character of punishment: those which express more the character of punishment are attributed to the just judgment of God, and such is occupation and blindness of this kind.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here is touched upon the discovered vanity, because he profited nothing more, except that in his consideration he found vanity. And therefore he says: "I saw all things that are done under the sun," that is, I considered all things. "And behold, all is vanity," that is, vanity openly appears in them, because, as the Apostle says in Romans 8, "the creature was made subject to vanity, not willingly"; and not only vanity, but indeed also "affliction of spirit."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But because not all see this, and because they thus labor in vain and do not perceive their affliction: to this tacit question he responds saying: "The perverse are corrected with difficulty": whence Proverbs 18: "A fool does not receive words of prudence, unless you say those things which revolve in his heart." "And the number of fools is infinite," namely on account of their multitude: and to consider this is not only vanity, but indeed also affliction: whence it is said in the Psalm: "I saw the transgressors, and I pined away"; and again: "My zeal has made me pine away." Man is perverted through evil thought: Wisdom 1: "Perverse thoughts separate from God: but proven virtue corrects the foolish." Through evil affection: Proverbs 17: "He who is of a perverse heart shall not find good, and he who turns his tongue shall fall into evil." Through evil speech: Proverbs 10: "The lips of the just consider what is pleasing, and the mouth of the wicked, perverse things"; Proverbs 2: "That you may be delivered from the man who speaks perverse things." Through wicked action: Proverbs 2: "They rejoice when they have done evil, and exult in the worst things"; Isaiah 1: "Cease to act perversely."
Likewise, there is a question concerning what he says: "The perverse are corrected with difficulty": because it is easy for someone to become perverted; but perversion is against nature; therefore, if it is most easy to return to nature, since vice is against nature, it is most easy to be corrected.
I respond: the reason is taken both from the side of the evil work, because "good exists in one way, but evil in every way"; and from the side of the operating power, which is rendered weak through fault, and therefore cannot engage in strenuous work; and from the side of the opposition of good to evil according to privation, because it is most easy to recede from a habit to privation, but difficult, or altogether impossible, to return.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here he similarly shows his curiosity in the consideration of moral matters. For first is noted his transition from natural things to moral matters; second, the discovery of affliction; third, the turning to the enjoyment of delightful things; fourth, the return to the consideration of evils.
First, therefore, his transition to considering moral matters is intimated, and this after he had considered the natures of things. On account of which he says: "I have spoken in my heart," namely through thought, "saying: Behold, I have become great," in fame, "and I have surpassed all in wisdom who were before me in Jerusalem"; Third Kings, chapter four: "And the wisdom of Solomon surpassed the wisdom of all the Orientals and the Egyptians, and he was wiser than all men"; Ecclesiasticus, chapter forty-seven: "He was instructed in his youth, and was filled with wisdom as with a river." And he had this knowledge partly through revelation; whence he says: "My mind has contemplated many things wisely," namely illuminated by God; and partly also through his own diligence; whence he adds: "And I have learned"; Proverbs, chapter four: "I was a tender son of my father and an only one in the sight of my mother, and he taught me"; Proverbs, the last chapter: "The vision with which his mother instructed him."
Considering therefore that he had this wisdom in the investigation of natural things, because "he discoursed from the cedar of Lebanon to the hyssop," according to what is said in Third Kings, chapter four, he wished to transfer himself to moral matters.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whence he says: "And I gave my heart to know prudence," with respect to things to be done, "and learning," with respect to things to be known, "and errors," against prudence, "and folly," against learning; because nothing is known perfectly unless its opposite is known. And it is useful to know these things when they are investigated in the proper manner; whence Proverbs, chapter eight: "Receive instruction and not money; choose learning rather than gold."
Here the discovery of spiritual affliction in the consideration thereof is touched upon: because the better a man knows good and evil, the more he is afflicted when he errs. On account of which he says: "And I knew that in these things also there was labor and affliction of spirit," that is, in the knowledge of useful things: "labor," namely in acquiring; Psalm: "I thought that I might know this, it is labor before me"; "affliction of spirit," after acquisition, either on account of the detestation of fault, or because it is an occasion of pride and impatience, since "knowledge puffs up."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, gratuitous knowledge is called the knowledge of the Saints, because it has a zeal for all holiness.
Whence in the book of Ecclesiastes: "In much wisdom there will be indignation; he who adds knowledge adds sorrow." A man knowing his own defects has the sorrow of compunction for himself, the sorrow of compassion for his neighbors, and the sorrow of zeal for the honor of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Because in much wisdom there is much indignation," either of contrition, against fault, or of impatience from pride, because great clerics, when they do not have what they want, are most easily indignant: whence it is said in Job thirty-two that Elihu was indignant, and this because he considered himself wise. And therefore it follows: "He who adds knowledge adds also sorrow," because an impatient man sustains many sorrows, since there is no one for whom all things turn out according to his wish. And with this exposition agrees another translation of Jerome: "I knew that in these things there was a feeding on wind," and therefore rightly there is labor and affliction of spirit. Whence Hugh: "Curiosity drove it to inquiry, pride to ostentation: and therefore it was fitting that labor should press down the swollen, and occupation dissipate the curious."
It can also be understood of the affliction of contrition, because even where there is much wisdom, there is much indignation against sin: Jeremiah thirty-one: "After you showed me, I struck my thigh." "And he who adds knowledge adds also sorrow," namely of penance: Job last chapter: "Now my eye sees you: therefore I reprove myself and do penance in dust and ashes."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I said in my heart" etc. Here the third point is touched upon, namely the turning to pleasure on account of the weariness of contemplation. For since in contemplating there was labor and affliction, he therefore thought to abandon this and turn himself to delights, in which there is pleasure. On account of which he says: "I said in my heart," that is, I came to this consideration on account of the spiritual affliction in contemplating. Whence the word is a consideration not of wisdom, but of sloth, which, not finding rest within, seeks it without. "I said" therefore: "I will go and abound in delights and enjoy good things." "I will go," by withdrawing from the true good: Psalm: "Man has become a spirit going forth and not returning." "I will abound in delights," as regards the multitude of pleasures, namely carnal ones as opposed to spiritual: Song of Songs 7: "How beautiful you are, dearest, in delights." From these he departed to carnal ones: Isaiah 22: "The Lord called to weeping and mourning" etc., and after: "Behold joy and gladness, slaughtering rams" etc. "And I will enjoy good things," as regards rest: for one enjoys that in which the appetite finds rest: Wisdom 2: "Come, let us enjoy the good things that are, and let us use creation as in youth swiftly"; and Proverbs 7: "Come, let us enjoy the desired embraces." But because this consideration was blameworthy and reprehensible, he therefore rebuked himself, because present pleasure is not true pleasure, but deception: therefore he adds: "And I saw that this also was vanity:" because it neither endures nor refreshes, but fails and deceives.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The world also, by displaying sweetness, inflames to lust, just as wine by its sweetness draws to gluttony and through this to lust: whence in 3 Esdras 3: Wine, which prevails over all who drink it, seduces the mind. Likewise of the king and of the orphan it makes the mind vain, and this by inflaming to lust, according to that passage in Ephesians 5: Be not drunk with wine, wherein is lust. To this vanity the world drew Solomon; Ecclesiastes 2: I said: I will go and abound in delights and enjoy good things; and I saw that this also was vanity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On account of which he says: "I counted laughter an error," because it leads man astray: "and to joy I said: why are you vainly deceived?" because namely the one rejoicing in it is deceived. Laughter is outward, and joy is inward. Laughter deceives, because it offers good and in the end evil; Proverbs 14: "Laughter shall be mingled with sorrow, and mourning takes hold of the ends of joy": and James 4: "Let your laughter be turned into mourning," because Luke 6: "Woe to you who laugh, for you shall weep."
This laughter is the laughter of the frenzied, because it is erroneous and momentary. Likewise also inward joy deceives: Job 21: "They rejoice at the sound of the organ: they spend their days in good things and in a moment they descend to hell": and Job 20: "The joy of the hypocrite is but for a moment."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I thought in my heart" etc. Here the fourth point is touched upon, namely the return to the consideration of useful things, and this by returning from pleasure to sobriety. On account of which he says: "I thought in my heart to withdraw my flesh from wine," because it inclines in a wondrous manner toward pleasure; whence Ephesians 5: "Be not drunk with wine, wherein is luxury"; and Proverbs 20: "Wine is a luxurious thing, and drunkenness tumultuous: whoever delights in these things shall not be wise." Therefore he thought to abandon the incitement to pleasure, "that I might transfer my mind to wisdom," that is, to the consideration of wise things, and that I might abandon the consideration of foolish things, such as was the preceding consideration; whence he says: "And that I might avoid foolishness:" and this toward the exhortation of wisdom; Proverbs 1: "How long, O little ones, will you love childishness, and fools desire those things that are harmful?" And this not only on account of one's own benefit, but the common benefit; therefore he says: "That I might see what is useful for the children of men:" and this in the present life, whence he also adds: "What deed is needful," that is, what is opportune to do, "under the sun during the number of the days of their life." This he saw and declared at the end of the book: "Fear God and keep his commandments: this is the whole of man."
This is useful: to keep the commandments of God, because it is said below in chapter eight: "He who keeps the commandment shall experience no evil"; and Proverbs 19: "He who keeps the commandment keeps his soul; but he who neglects his way shall die."
The remission of iniquity: 2 Timothy 2: "If anyone shall cleanse himself from these, he shall be a sanctified vessel, useful to the Lord, prepared for every good work." The instruction of truth: 2 Timothy 3: "All doctrine divinely inspired is useful for instructing in justice," so that man may be just.
The exercise of piety: 1 Timothy 4: "Exercise yourself unto piety: for bodily exercise is profitable for little, but piety is profitable for all things."
Useless things: the proud transgression of the law of God: 2 Chronicles 24: "Why do you transgress the commandment of the Lord, which will not profit you?" Wisdom without teaching: Ecclesiasticus 20: "Hidden wisdom and an unseen treasure, what profit is there in both?" Teaching without life: Luke 14: "Salt is good; but if the salt lose its savor, wherewith shall it be seasoned" etc. Contentious disputation: 2 Timothy 2: "Do not contend in words: for it is profitable for nothing."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He expresses his curiosity with respect to the possession of stable things, namely houses for dwelling, vineyards and gardens for eating, and pools for irrigating. Therefore he says: "I made my works great," that is, I made great things: 3 Kings 10: "King Solomon was made great above all the kings of the whole earth." And he expresses individually: "I built myself houses," because he built many: whence 3 Kings 9: "After Solomon had built two houses: the house of the Lord and the house of the king," he built a house for the daughter of Pharaoh; and that was of curiosity and reprehensible: whence Isaiah 5: "Woe to you who join house to house." "I planted vineyards," namely for drink: Genesis 9: "Noah planted a vineyard, and drinking the wine was made drunk."
Spiritually this Solomon, who magnified his works, is Christ the Lord, who is the peaceful king, whose works are great; whence in the Psalm: "How magnificent are your works, O Lord; you have made all things in wisdom," etc. Christ, moreover, magnifies his spiritual works, inasmuch as he makes servants great and many, both with respect to the active life and with respect to the contemplative life.
For contemplatives, that they may be great in their state, have many things conferred upon them by Christ the Lord: houses, namely quiet consciences; Proverbs 24: "Do not lie in wait and seek wickedness in the house of the just, nor lay waste his rest." In this house one must rest, not in another's; since on the contrary, Ecclesiasticus 21: "The foot of the fool is quick into the house of his neighbor."
Vineyards, that is, affections of devotion, from which wine is drawn; Judges 9: "Can I forsake my wine?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I made gardens and orchards and planted them with trees of every kind," for food: Song of Songs 6: "I went down into my garden to see the fruits of the valleys and to look whether the vineyard had flourished and the pomegranates had budded."
Spiritually, gardens, that is, exterior enclosures; Song of Songs 4: "A garden enclosed, a fountain sealed, my sister, my spouse."
Orchards, that is, honorable and renowned works: Job 9: "My days have passed like ships carrying fruit," which, namely, leave behind a good fragrance: 2 Corinthians 2: "We are the good fragrance of Christ to God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And because these things needed to be irrigated, he therefore adds: "And I built for myself pools of water," that is, places in which there is a collection of waters; and this, so that "I might irrigate the forest of sprouting trees," namely through irrigation, because it is said in Job 12: "If he withholds the waters, all things will be dried up." Such pools were necessary in the land of promise on account of the scarcity of water; Deuteronomy 11: "The land which you shall enter to possess is mountainous and level, awaiting rains from heaven."
Spiritually, forests, that is, various virtues: Numbers 24: "How beautiful are your tabernacles, O Jacob, like wooded valleys."
Pools, that is, many tears: Song of Songs 7: "Your eyes are like the pools in Heshbon"; Jeremiah 9: "Who will give water to my head and a fountain of tears to my eyes?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I possessed servants." Here is touched upon secondly the curiosity regarding the multitude of those serving, because in both sexes; whence he says: "I possessed servants and handmaids;" and also in every age; whence: "And I had a great household;" 3 Kings 10: "The queen of Sheba, seeing the wisdom of Solomon and the foods of his table, the dwellings of his servants and the ranks of his ministers, had no more spirit in her."
"Herds also." Here is touched upon thirdly the curiosity regarding the gathering of livestock and animals, both great and small, when he says: "Herds also and great flocks of sheep," supply: I had; "beyond all who were before me in Jerusalem." And that he had many is evident, because he consumed many; whence 3 Kings 4: "The food of Solomon for each day was ten fat oxen and twenty pasture oxen and a hundred rams, besides the hunting of stags, roe deer," etc.
Just as Christ magnified his works in contemplatives, so also in actives, for whom more things are necessary: menservants and maidservants, through humility; Luke 17: "When you have done all that was commanded you, say: we are unprofitable servants."
Herds of oxen, through the vigor of works, because it is not for oxen to rest but to plow: Job 1: "The oxen were plowing": Sirach 7: "Do not hate laborious works."
Sheep, through simplicity of intention: Matthew 10: "Behold, I send you as sheep in the midst of wolves"; 1 Peter 2: "As newborn infants, desire milk."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I heaped up for myself." Here is touched upon fourthly the curiosity regarding the heaping up of minerals, when he says: "I heaped up for myself gold and silver," as regards metals, "and the wealth of kings and provinces," as regards precious stones and gems; 3 Kings 10: "Each one brought gifts to Solomon: vessels of silver and gold, garments and weapons of war," and afterwards: "And he made it so that there was as great an abundance of silver in Jerusalem as of stones."
He shows his excessive diligence in preparing such delectable things, both with respect to hearing and with respect to sight. By reason of hearing he says: "I made me singers, men and women," that is, of both sexes, and this for the sake of delights: whence he says: "And the delights of the sons of men," and this with respect to hearing. With respect to sight he also made beautiful vessels: whence he says: "cups and pitchers, for pouring wines," that is, "I made," and this for the sake of delights. Whence he was very diligent, and this is reprehensible; whence Amos 6: "Woe to you who are wealthy in Zion"; and afterwards: "You who sing to the sound of the psaltery, drinking wine in bowls."
Spiritually, gold, through charity; Daniel 2 says of that statue that "its head was of the finest gold," because charity is the head of the virtues. Silver, through the sweetness of speech, because it has a sweet sound; whence in the Psalm: "The words of the Lord are pure words, silver tried by fire"; and Sirach 6: "A sweet word multiplies friends and appeases enemies." The treasures of kings, through the generosity of munificence: Sirach 13: "Good is the substance to which there is no sin in conscience."
It is asked, since to take such delight in these songs is a sin, to what genus of sin is it reduced? If you say that it is reduced to lust, it is asked: since hearing is one sense, just as taste and touch, it seems that there ought to be a capital sin pertaining to hearing, just as there is pertaining to touch; or if not, I ask the reason. Likewise I ask whether to take delight in songs of this kind is a sin. That it is not, seems evident: because the Saints instituted singing for the glory of God. But that it is a sin: Augustine in the Confessions: "As often as the singing pleased me more than the words, I confess that I have sinned gravely."
I respond: it must be said that to take delight in songs of this kind is either on account of interior devotion, and this seeks nothing but upright singing and the words; or on account of interior pleasure and wantonness; or on account of a certain curiosity. In the first way it is not a sin, but a merit; in the second way it is a sin connected to lust proximately; in the third way it is a sin of curiosity connected to lust remotely.
As for what is asked, namely why there is not a capital sin pertaining to this sense, as there is pertaining to touch and taste: I respond, because the corruption and the delight are not so great.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"And I surpassed in riches" etc. Here the second point is touched upon, namely the power to accomplish, because a poor man, even if he could begin such artful delights, could not however bring them to completion: but he himself could, being rich. Therefore he says: "And I surpassed in riches all who were before me in Jerusalem." For he exceeded all: 3 Kings 3: "I have given you riches and glory, so that no one among all kings in days past has been like you."
"Wisdom also" etc. Here the third point is touched upon, namely prudence for ordering, when he says: "Wisdom also persevered with me," by which, that is, he ordered those things which he had made; 3 Kings 10: "The queen of Sheba, seeing the wisdom of Solomon and the ranks of those serving, their garments also and the cupbearers etc., had no more spirit in her"; and 3 Kings 4: "The wisdom of Solomon surpassed the wisdom of all the Orientals and the Egyptians, and he was wiser than all men."
It is asked concerning what he says: "And I surpassed in riches all who were before me in Jerusalem." What does this mean? What he says seems to be no great distinction, because before him none reigned except only his father, since he himself went up and captured it and expelled the Jebusite. To this some say that he speaks not only with respect to the kings of Israel, namely David and Saul, but also with respect to the judges. But this was not a great thing. On account of this it is said that before him there were kings in Jerusalem from Canaan, and they indeed were wealthy and great, and he speaks with respect to them. Or the text can be read such that the qualification "in Jerusalem" refers to the riches which he possessed in Jerusalem, not to the kings, so that the sense would be: "I surpassed in riches in Jerusalem all who were before me," because none before him was like him.
Likewise it is asked concerning what he says: "Wisdom also persevered with me." On the contrary: "The wisdom of doctrine is according to his name," Ecclesiasticus 6: therefore no one is wise except he to whom things are savory as they ought to be; but they were not savory to Solomon, because he despised eternal goods and loved temporal ones; therefore he was not wise, but foolish.
I respond: it must be said that wisdom in one way denotes cognition alone, and thus it is called "wisdom, the knowledge of things divine and human"; in another way it denotes taste and the savor of the affections and order, and thus wisdom is said to derive from savor. In the first way, to be wise belongs to the good and the wicked alike, who have an intellect illuminated to see many truths about God and creatures; in the second way it belongs only to the good. In the first way he persevered, because he did not lose his understanding; in the second way he lost it, when he sinned and became foolish.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"And all things which they desired" etc. Here the fourth point is touched upon, namely his pleasure in fully enjoying those delectable things which he had prepared; and because there is a certain pleasure which has its origin from without, and a certain one from interior conception, he notes both in himself. With respect to the first he says: "And all things which my eyes desired," that is, seeing outwardly, "I did not deny them," nay rather, he indulged them to his own fault; whence Lamentations 3: "My eye has despoiled my soul"; and Jeremiah 9: "Death has climbed through my windows."
As for interior pleasure he says: "Nor did I forbid my heart," that is, the concupiscence of the heart, from "enjoying every pleasure and delighting itself in those things which I had prepared;" against that passage of Sirach 18: "Son, go not after your concupiscences, and turn away from your own will." And because affection often perverts the judgment of reason, a perverted judgment follows; whence he adds: "And I reckoned this my portion," that is, I judged it to be better for me "if I should enjoy my labor," namely in the present. And this is the judgment of the Epicureans, who expect no other good nor any other portion; on the contrary, the Saints do not have their portion in the present, but in the future; whence in the Psalm: "My portion, O Lord, let it be in the land of the living"; and again: "The Lord is the portion of my inheritance and of my cup," etc.
Here the question is raised concerning what he says: "And I considered this my portion, if I should enjoy my labor." Therefore it seems that Solomon held the opinion of the Epicureans, who hold that there is no other joy except in the present; and this is heretical. Likewise, if he was wise and understanding and held this position, then it should be presumed that this was true.
I respond: it must be said that there is a twofold judgment in us: one of reason deliberating and comparing, another of estimation. I say that Solomon by the judgment of reason deliberating and comparing never considered this nor held this opinion, but only by estimation, just as every sinner estimates that it is good for him to sin; hence there is not there an error of infidelity, but rather an error of deviation from the good. The Epicureans, however, not only estimate this, but assert with certitude that there is no other good; and therefore they are heretics and infidels.
To the objection that he was wise, etc.: it must be said that, although he was wise, nevertheless in this he acted unwisely, and therefore he is not to be imitated, just as David was good, yet he did not act well when he had Uriah killed; nor does he say this for imitation, but for reproof.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He reproves his own curiosity on account of the vanity he discovered, which consists in mutability. He found therefore vanity and affliction in the works which he had done with curiosity, on account of diligent consideration; for which reason he says: "And when I turned to all the works which my hands had made," that is, had diligently considered, according to that word of the Apostle in Galatians 6: "But let each one prove his own work." "And to the labors in which I had sweated in vain," therefore in vain, because he had not done them for God, and therefore had labored to no purpose; Wisdom 3: "Their hope is empty, and their labor without fruit." "I saw in all things vanity and affliction of spirit, and that nothing endures under the sun:" therefore they were vain and afflictive, because unstable. For by the fact that they do not endure, they are vain; by the fact that they are lost and do not endure, they are afflictive: Sirach 40: "The substance of the ungodly shall dry up like a river, and shall resound like a great thunder in rain"; whence 1 John 2: "The world passes away and its concupiscence": and therefore: "Her grace is deceitful, and beauty is vain."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He indicates the diligence of his consideration in treating those things in which he had studied. For this reason he says: "I passed over to contemplate wisdom," as regards things to be chosen: "and errors and folly," as regards things to be avoided. "I passed over," I say, from pleasure: whence Sirach 24: "Come over to me, all you who desire me," etc.; but although there was in him diligence, there was nevertheless not sufficiency: whence he adds: "What, I say, is man, that he could follow the King, his maker?" As if to say: he is insufficient for considering and seeing those things which the Lord foresees. "What is man?" As if to say: something small and insufficient: the Psalm: "What is man, that you are mindful of him?" "That he could follow the King, his maker," that is, God the creator: Isaiah 64: "And now, O Lord, you are our father, and we indeed are clay; and you are our maker, and we are all the works of your hands." Him no one can follow; Job 11: "Can you perhaps comprehend the footsteps of God, and find the Almighty unto perfection?"
It is asked: "What is man, that he can follow God?" On the contrary: Ecclesiasticus 23: "It is a great glory to follow the Lord." Likewise, Job 23: "My foot has followed his steps."
I respond: it must be said that there is a following by equality, and this has been given to no creature; and because Satan wanted this, he fell. There is again a following by subjection and obedience, and this indeed man can do, but not just anyone—only those to whom it has been given by God through grace, and whom he himself draws; and therefore no one can do it by himself without God's help.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I saw that wisdom excels folly as much as light differs from darkness." Therefore wisdom is light: light, I say, descending from above from the Father of lights, from whom is every best gift and every perfect gift. This light descends to illuminate our cognitive power, to gladden our affective power, and to strengthen our operative power. It descends from the most high God into the intellect, from the intellect into the affection, and even to the lowest, namely operation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here the second point is noted, namely the discovered preeminence of wisdom over folly, because it surpasses it, as it were, beyond all proportion. For which reason he says: "And I saw that wisdom so far exceeded folly," that is, was nobler, "as light differs from darkness." And this comparison is fitting, since wisdom illuminates, and folly blinds or darkens. That wisdom indeed illuminates, Wisdom 6: "Love the light of wisdom, all you who rule over peoples"; whence also Christ, the wisdom of God, calls himself light; John 8: "I am the light of the world."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The eyes of the wise man are in his head," that is, in Christ: "the fool walks in darkness." In Christ is the consummation of every good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth aspect of the zeal of wisdom is the elevation of desire. This gives worth to other endeavors, so that forgetting what is behind, we strain forward to what is before. "The wise man has eyes in his head. — The heart of a wise man is in his right hand." Now, the zeal of wisdom consists in this, that our endeavor be directed toward nothing but God who is "all delight."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The eyes of the wise man are in his head," namely for directing: "the fool walks in darkness," as though he had no eyes in his head. That wisdom indeed illuminates, Wisdom 6: "Love the light of wisdom, all you who rule over peoples"; whence also Christ, the wisdom of God, calls himself light; John 8: "I am the light of the world." On the contrary, folly is darkness: Isaiah 5: "Woe to you who call good evil and evil good, who put darkness for light and light for darkness"; whence John 1: "The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not comprehend it"; therefore, because they neither knew nor understood, therefore they walk in darkness; John 3: "For they loved darkness more than light."
Here the third point is touched upon: the equality of the wise man and the fool both in death and after death. As regards the equality in dying, he says: "And I learned that the destruction of both was one:" one, that is, alike, because no one escapes the sentence of death on account of his wisdom: whence 2 Kings 14: "We all die, and like waters that flow down into the earth, which do not return." Just as the fool takes nothing away, so neither does the wise man: Job 1: "Naked I came forth from my mother's womb, and naked I shall return."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And on account of this equality he despised wisdom; therefore he says: "And I said in my heart: if one and the same downfall shall befall both the fool and me, what does it profit me that I have devoted greater effort to wisdom?" as if to say: nothing, as regards death: Ecclesiasticus 40: "The Day of Union, that is, of death, from the one who sits" etc.
"And I spoke with my mind," that is, I considered inwardly, and "I perceived that this also was vanity," namely, to devote greater effort to wisdom than the fool.
There is a question about what he says: "What does it profit me, that I devoted greater effort to wisdom?" Because according to this it seems that he dissuades from study, the contrary of which he often urges; and Proverbs 27: "Apply yourself to wisdom, my son," etc.
I respond: it must be said that devoting effort to wisdom can be in two ways: for the advantage of the present life, or for the reward of eternal glory. For the advantage of the present life, wisdom profits before death, because it directs man in his works; but in death it profits nothing, because the learned man dies just as the unlearned, nor is his life prolonged. But if for the advantage of eternal life, thus he does not die, but rather lives.
It is useful for the working of good: Sirach 21: "Wise doctrine is a golden ornament," etc. It is useful for the avoidance of evil: Sirach 3: "A wise and understanding heart will abstain from sins." It is useful for the increase of grace: Proverbs 4: "She will give to your head increases of graces." It is useful for the increase of glory: Proverbs 3: "The wise shall possess glory."
Thus therefore he discourages studying wisdom for present advantage and curiosity, but rather for eternal salvation; and therefore he reproves himself, because he had labored for curiosity and worldly vanity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Not only is there equality in death, but also after death: whence he also adds: "And I spoke with my mind," that is, I considered inwardly, and "I perceived that this also was vanity," namely, to devote greater effort to wisdom than the fool, because there is no more memory of him than of the fool. Therefore he says: "For there shall not be memory of the wise man any more than of the fool forever;" and the reason is added: "And future times shall equally cover all things with oblivion." Whence above in the first chapter it was said: "There is no memory of former things, nor indeed of those things which shall be hereafter": Wisdom 2: "And our name shall receive oblivion through time, and no one shall have memory of our works"; Job 13: "And your memory shall be compared to ashes, and your necks shall be reduced to clay."
From this kind of equality discovered, he concludes vanity in his pursuit and reproof of himself; whence he repeats the equality, saying: "The learned dies similarly as the unlearned," and thus they are equal.
There is a question about what he says: "There will be no remembrance of the wise man like that of the fool." Against this: Proverbs 10: "The memory of the just is with praises, and the name of the wicked shall rot." Likewise, Sirach 39: "His memory shall not depart, and his name shall be sought out," etc.
I respond: to this some say that he speaks in the person of the carnal man, whence he says what is simply false, but true according to the estimation of carnal men. But this does not fully resolve the matter, because he ought not to assert the position of carnal men, but rather to refute it. Therefore it must be said that one can speak of the memory of the wise man and the fool either with respect to God, or with respect to men. If we speak with respect to God, there is certainly a remembrance of the good wise man, who devotes himself to wisdom for the glory of God; but with respect to men, the memory of both the good and the evil passes away, for the most part, because men remember few things.
But if of the evil wise man and vain one, there is no memory, neither with respect to God nor with respect to men, indeed his name passes away like the name of the fool: and therefore it is foolish to labor in wisdom for the sake of the fame of one's name. But Ecclesiastes speaks of the vain wise man, who has his eye on earthly things, and he speaks of human memory, not divine.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And from this he concludes: "Therefore I was weary of my life," as if he refused to live on account of weariness, as Job 10: "My soul is weary of my life": on account of occasions of sin: Genesis 27, Rebecca said: "I am weary of my life because of the daughters of Heth." On account of labors: Numbers 21: "The people began to be weary of the journey and the labor, and they spoke against the Lord" etc. On account of tribulations: 2 Corinthians 1: "We were burdened beyond measure, so that it wearied us even to live." On account of the delay of future glory: Job 10: "My soul is weary of my life." On account of impending temptation: Psalm: "My soul has slumbered from weariness, strengthen" etc. On account of the horror of impending death: Mark 14: "Jesus began to fear and to be weary."
"Seeing that all things under the sun are evil, and all is vanity and affliction of spirit:" Wisdom 9: "The body, which is corrupted, weighs down the soul, and the earthly habitation depresses the mind that thinks upon many things"; therefore frequent meditation of the flesh is affliction.
An inquiry is made concerning what he says: "My life wearied me as I beheld all evils under the sun." Against this: Genesis 1: "God saw all things that he had made, and they were very good:" therefore they are not evil; indeed, this is heretical.
I respond: it must be said that, as the Apostle says in Romans 7: "The law is holy, and the commandment holy," yet by occasion the commandment was deadly to those not having grace and wrought death: just as creatures are very good for the just and those who love God and "work together unto good" and are good in themselves, yet for the impious, sinners, and the foolish, all things are turned into evils by occasion: whence Wisdom 14: "The creatures of God are for a temptation and a snare to the feet of the unwise:" and Sirach 39: "All these things shall be turned into evils for the impious and sinners."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He reproves his own curiosity concerning the works of human industry directed toward wealth. He argues first that he was curious about acquiring earthly things on account of the uncertainty of good offspring, because he himself could not always possess those things and feared having a useless successor. Therefore he says: "Again I detested all my industry," that is, my curious diligence, "with which I most studiously labored under the sun," namely to increase these goods: Jeremiah 6: "From the least even to the greatest, all are given to avarice."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the reason for the loathing is introduced: "Who shall have an heir after me, whom I know not whether he will be wise or foolish." Literally, Solomon had as heir Rehoboam, a foolish son, who, following the counsel of the young men, caused the kingdom to be divided, 3 Kings 12. "And he shall have dominion over my labors, in which I toiled," as regards the body; "and was solicitous," as regards the soul. Concerning this toil, Genesis 3: "In the sweat of your face you shall eat your bread"; concerning solicitude, Matthew 6: "Be not solicitous for your soul, what you shall eat, or for your body, what you shall put on." And that is exceedingly vain; whence he says: "And is there anything so vain?" Supply: as to labor solicitously for a fool and an idler, as if to say: no.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From the consideration of this vanity, therefore, he ceased from curiosity; whence he says: "Wherefore I ceased, and my heart renounced laboring under the sun," that is, for temporal goods. "I ceased," in deed; "and my heart renounced," in will. But the miser does not cease on this account, below in chapter 4: "There is one alone, and he has not a second, and yet he does not cease to labor."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he repeats the reason why he ceased: "For when another labors in wisdom," in the heart; "and in doctrine," in the mouth; "and in solicitude," in deed; "he leaves what was acquired to an idle man." And from this he concludes vanity: "and this therefore is vanity and a great evil:" vanity indeed, because riches are left to a useless man, but a great evil; whence Hugh says: "It is a great evil that what one man is worn down by in labor, another should abuse idly and illicitly"; evil, because to a squanderer; Jeremiah 51: "Their works are vain," etc.; Deuteronomy 28: "Let there be no strength in your hand; let a people whom you know not eat the fruit of your land and all your labors."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"What does it profit a man of all his labor," in body, "and affliction of spirit," in mind, "by which he is tormented under the sun?" As if to say: nothing; whence Proverbs 23: "Labor not to become rich, but set bounds to your prudence." It does not profit, namely him who labors for the sake of possessing these visible things. Whence Bernard says: "With others are the fruits of riches, but to the rich fall only the name and the solicitude"; and therefore it does not profit; whence below in chapter 5: "What does it profit the possessor, except that he beholds riches with his eyes?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The world is vain also because it does not give rest to the one who labors, and therefore he who labors for worldly things labors in vain: Ecclesiastes 2: What does it profit a man from all his labor, by which he labors under the sun? All his days are full of labors and sorrows, nor does his mind rest at night: and is this not vanity? because he labors in vain, because he does not rest. This world cannot give rest, because it itself does not endure, but rather always revolves: therefore those who cling to it must needs go around in circles. Therefore it is said in the Psalm: The wicked walk round about.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Not only does it not profit, but rather it harms: whence he adds: "All his days are full of labors and sorrows," outwardly: "nor does his mind rest at night," inwardly. Therefore it is said in Job 7: "I have numbered empty months and wearisome nights for myself"; and Proverbs 15: "All the days of the poor are evil. A secure mind is like a continual feast." And from this he concludes that to labor thus is vain, because it is useless: therefore he says: "And is not this also vanity?" As if to say: indeed: below in chapter 5: "He who loves riches shall reap no fruit from them: and this therefore is vanity," because they harm. Whence in the same place: "There is another infirmity which I have seen under the sun, riches gathered up" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The world is vain also because it does not give rest to the one who labors, and therefore he who labors for worldly things labors in vain: Ecclesiastes 2: What does it profit a man from all his labor, by which he labors under the sun? All his days are full of labors and sorrows, nor does his mind rest at night: and is this not vanity? because he labors in vain, because he does not rest. This world cannot give rest, because it itself does not endure, but rather always revolves: therefore those who cling to it must needs go around in circles. Therefore it is said in the Psalm: The wicked walk round about.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Is it not better to eat and drink and to show his soul good things from his labors?" Supply: than to labor always continually: as if to say: it is better, that is, less evil, because the latter is an evil of guilt and punishment, the former is an evil of guilt, but has pleasantness: Isaiah 22: "Behold, joy and gladness, slaying rams" etc. And that it is better, he makes manifest: because this is a gift of God: whence he says: "And this is from the hand of God:" Jeremiah 5: "I filled them, and they committed adultery" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he proposes himself as an example of this to confirm it: "Who shall so devour," as regards concupiscence: "and abound in delights," as regards abundance: "as I?" As if to say: no one: 3 Kings 4: "Now the provision of Solomon for each day was thirty measures of fine flour and sixty measures of meal, ten fat oxen and twenty pasture oxen" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"To the good man" etc. Here he condemns solicitude through the equity of divine judgment, since such solicitude is not given to the good, but to the wicked, and this by divine judgment. Therefore he says: "To the man who is good in his sight," namely, who pleases him, not men, like a hypocrite: Psalm: "Let the just feast" etc. "God has given wisdom," as regards eternal things: "and knowledge," as regards the dispensing of temporal things: "and understanding," as regards things to be understood or considered: Job 38: "Who has placed wisdom in the inward parts of man, or who has given the cock understanding?" This according to the bounty of mercy. But according to the equity of justice he adds: "But to the sinner he has given affliction and superfluous care," that is, he permitted it to be given by just judgment: "that he may add and gather together and hand it over to him who has pleased God:" Proverbs 13: "The substance of the sinner is kept for the just": Proverbs 28: "He who gathers riches by usury and interest gathers them for him who is liberal to the poor." And from this he infers vanity: "But this also is vanity and a vain solicitude of mind," because Proverbs 11: "The expectation of solicitude shall perish."
Note that there is study for the acquisition of wisdom: Proverbs 27: "Apply yourself to wisdom, my son, that you may be able to answer a word to him who reproaches you." For the exercise of justice: Jeremiah 7: "Now make your ways and your pursuits good." For the fulfillment of concupiscence: Proverbs 23: "To whom is woe? To whose father is woe? Is it not to those who linger over wine and study to drain their cups?" For the dominion of avarice: Jeremiah 6: "From the least to the greatest, all are devoted to avarice."
The first two studies are good, the two following are evil, and in these the goodness of a man is discerned: whence Proverbs 20: "By his pursuits a youth is known, whether his works are clean and upright." Because therefore the Ecclesiast had not yet devoted himself to these, but to avarice and gluttony, therefore he was reproving his pursuits.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All things have their time, etc. Above he treated the vanity of things, showing that there is variability in them by reason of motion: here secondly he wishes to show vanity with respect to the determination and variety in time. And because he shows the mutability and variety of things not for contempt of them insofar as they are works of God, but insofar as they are loved by us: therefore in this part he shows first the variety of times: second he reproves our curiosity, there: What more has man: third he shows the perpetuity of the divine works, there: And I learned that the works of God.
Art. 1. On the variety and mutability of things in time, both generally and specifically.
The first part has two sections, because first he treats the variety and mutability of things in time generally, second specifically, by adducing and proving, there: A time to be born.
He proposes therefore generally, saying: All things have their time, that is, variety of time, because Romans 8: "The creature was made subject to vanity, not willingly." And all things pass away in their appointed intervals under the sun, with respect to the determination of the prefixed time; Wisdom 11: "You have disposed all things in number, weight, and measure"; 1 Corinthians 7: "The figure of this world passes away"; and especially in this span of time prefixed for it; Job 14: "You have appointed his bounds, which cannot be passed."
I. Here there is a question concerning what he says: All things have their time.
1. There is an objection: since spiritual substances, as Jerome says, are contained neither by place nor by time.
2. Likewise, everything that is in time and has time is corporeal; but spiritual substances are incorporeal: therefore they are not in time nor do they have time.
That they are in time, however, seems clear: 1. Because Augustine says to Dardanus: "Uncreated spiritual substance is moved neither through time nor through place; created spiritual substance is moved through time, but not through place; created corporeal substance through time and place."
2. Likewise, what is in place is in time; but "God alone is uncircumscribable," as Damascene says, therefore He alone is atemporal: therefore all other things have time.
I respond: it must be said to this that this distribution is accommodated, just as when it is said: the heaven covers all things, it is understood of those things which are under heaven; and therefore the objection concerning spiritual substance is not to be sustained.
If however we wish to extend the division, we shall say that time is spoken of in three ways: commonly and properly and more properly. Commonly, according as it denotes the measure of the passage from non-being to being: and in this way it is in all things, because all things had a beginning. And the text seems to suggest this, because he says that all things have their time, but not that all things pass away except under the sun.
In another way properly, insofar as it implies variation either in substance or in affection; and thus spiritual substance still has time with respect to the change of affections.
In a third way more properly, insofar as it is the preeminent measure: and thus it belongs to corruptible things, and not to all things.
As to what is asked, therefore, whether spiritual substances have time: it must be resolved that in the first way they have it with respect to substance: in the second way, with respect to certain affections: in the third way they do not have it. — And by this the contraries of both sides are resolved.
II. It is asked concerning the second part of the proposition: And all things pass away in their own times under the sun, whether the elements pass away.
It seems that they do.
1. Revelation 21: I saw a new heaven and a new earth: therefore the old had passed away.
2. Likewise, 1 John 2: The world passes away and its concupiscence: and Matthew 24: Heaven and earth shall pass away.
On the contrary: They are part of the constitution of the universe: therefore since the universe remains, it is manifest that the elements do also.
I respond: it must be said that for something to pass away in its own time is threefold: either with respect to corruption according to the whole substance, as brute animals are corrupted: or with respect to corruption of itself according to a part, as the elements are generated and corrupted at their boundaries, where they touch one another; or to pass away, that is, to be changed from the state of corruptibility to another state, and in this way this sensible world will be renewed.
What is said here, therefore, that they pass away in their own times, is understood according to one or another of these three ways.
2. As to what is again objected: The world passes away and its concupiscence, the qualification resolves it, namely the world insofar as it is an occasion of pleasure.
1. As to what is said: I saw a new heaven: the Gloss says: "that is, renewed."
2. As to what is said in Matthew: Heaven and earth shall pass away: the Gloss explains: they shall pass away, from a changeable form to an unchangeable one.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A time to be born. Above he set forth the general proposition; here he proves it by induction in particular cases, showing the diverse varieties of times in things. And this part has four parts. First is touched upon the variety of times which regards rise and decline. Second, that which regards state, at: A time to weep and a time to laugh. Third, that which regards use, at: A time to embrace. Fourth, that which regards the manner of proper conduct, at: A time to keep silence.
First, therefore, is introduced that variety which regards the rise of things and their decline under a fourfold distinction: first, of living things; second, of plants; third, of sentient beings; fourth, of artificial things.
As to the rise and decline of living things, he says there is variety when he says: A time to be born and a time to die, and this in all living things, because from birth one comes to death: Job 14: "Man, born of woman, living for a short time, is filled with many miseries"; Ecclesiasticus 40: "Great labor is created for all men, and a heavy yoke upon the sons of Adam, from the day of their coming out of their mother's womb until the day of their burial into the mother of all." And therefore Wisdom 5: "We, being born, immediately ceased to be"; Ecclesiasticus 14: "Some things are generated, and others are cast down; so is the generation of flesh and blood: one comes to an end, and another is born."
As to the rise of plants, he says: A time to plant; as to their decline, a time to uproot what has been planted: Genesis 2: "The Lord God had planted a paradise of pleasure from the beginning"; but a time to uproot the unfruitful: whence Luke 13: "Behold, it is three years since I have come seeking fruit on this fig tree and find none; cut it down therefore."
Spiritually, this fourfold variation is referred to the four states of men existing in the Church: the first with respect to the reborn; the second with respect to penitents; the third with respect to the just; the fourth with respect to prelates. — First, therefore, among the baptized there is a time of being born and of dying, for they are born to God: John 3: "Unless one is born again of water and the Holy Spirit," etc., just as they die to the world: Romans 6: "We are buried together with him through baptism into death."
Second, there is a time of planting and a time of uprooting, because virtues are planted in them: the Psalm: "Your children are like young olive plants"; but vices are uprooted; Wisdom 4: "Adulterous plantings shall not give deep roots," because, Matthew 15, "every plant which my heavenly Father has not planted shall be rooted up."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As to the rise and decline of sentient beings, he adds: A time to kill; and a time to kill is placed first, and a time to heal follows, on account of the state of corrupted nature, which has grown more prevalent, so that health does not have a place. Concerning this variation, Deuteronomy 32: "I will kill, and I will make to live"; and again, 2 Kings 8: "He measured two lines, one to put to death and one to keep alive."
As to the rise and decline of artificial things, he adds fourthly: A time to destroy, behold the decline; and a time to build, behold the restoration of what was destroyed. Things that are ruinous must be destroyed: Luke 19: "There shall not be left in you a stone upon a stone." A time to build, when there is abundance of resources: Luke 12: "I will destroy my barns and build greater ones"; Haggai 1: "Bring wood, build the house, and it shall be acceptable to me." And thus there is no permanence in the passing of things.
Spiritually, third, among the baptized there is a time of killing the movement of concupiscence: Colossians 3: "Mortify your members which are upon the earth"; and there is a time of healing the power of nature: Jeremiah 30: "I will close up your scar and heal you of your wounds."
Fourth, there is a time of destroying and of building among the baptized, because the dwelling of the devil is destroyed and a dwelling of Christ is made: 1 Peter 2: "Coming to him as to a living stone, be yourselves also built up into spiritual houses"; Jeremiah 1: "I have set you over nations and kingdoms, to uproot and to destroy and to scatter and to build and to plant."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A time for weeping etc. Having set forth the variety of times which regards the rise and fall of things, here is set forth the variety of times which regards their state, namely of prosperity and adversity. And this is considered according to a threefold distinction, namely of prosperity, joy, and security, and their opposites.
As regards therefore the time of prosperity, in which one should laugh, and of adversity, in which one should weep, he says: A time for weeping, in adversity: First Maccabees 1: "Every husband took up lamentation, and those who sat upon the marriage bed mourned"; and Lamentations 1: "Weeping she wept in the night, and her tears were on her cheeks." And a time for laughing, in prosperity: Esther 8: "A new light seemed to rise for the Jews, and joy and exultation." And he places weeping before laughter, either because it precedes according to fallen nature; Wisdom 7: "I uttered my first cry, like all others, weeping"; or because one must first grieve, because Luke 6: "Blessed are you who weep now, for you shall laugh"; conversely, concerning the wicked: Proverbs 14: "Laughter shall be mingled with sorrow."
As regards the state of joy and its opposite, he says: A time for mourning and a time for dancing. Mourning differs from weeping, laughter from dancing, because weeping is in tears, mourning in the voice, laughter in outward sign, and dancing in the elevation of the body. Concerning mourning, the last chapter of Genesis: "This is a great mourning for the Egyptians," in that place, that is, at funeral rites; but dancing belongs to splendid solemnities: Mark 6 says that on Herod's birthday the daughter of Herodias entered to dance.
Spiritually, the second variety of times pertains to penitents with respect to three things: namely, contrition, confession, and satisfaction. A time of weeping and a time of laughing, in contrition, in which there is joy and sorrow: Proverbs 14: "The heart that knows the bitterness of its own soul, in its joy no stranger shall intermeddle." — A time of mourning and a time of dancing, in confession, in which one ought to confess with lamentation: Job 10: "Let me alone, that I may lament my sorrow a little." One ought to confess nakedly and openly: 2 Kings 6: "David danced girded before the ark."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As regards the time of security and its opposite, he says: A time for scattering stones, namely when there is security: Micah 4: "No man shall take up the sword against another." A time for gathering, for the building of fortifications, namely when there is fear of enemies: Second Chronicles 32: "He built up every wall that had been broken down and erected towers."
A time for embracing etc. The variety of times which regards the rise and fall of things and also their state has been set forth; here is set forth the third, which regards use, and this under a fourfold distinction, namely as regards the use of wives, possessions, treasures, and garments.
As regards therefore the use of wives, which consists in carnal union for the generation of offspring, he says: A time for embracing and a time to be far from embraces: First Corinthians 7: "It remains that those who have wives should be as though they had none"; and again: "Do not defraud one another, unless perhaps by consent for a time, that you may devote yourselves to prayer, and return together again."
Spiritually, there is a time to scatter stones and a time to gather them, in satisfaction. Stones of offense are occasions of sin: Ecclesiasticus 21: "The way of the wicked is paved with stones, and at their end are the netherworld and darkness and punishments." These are gathered in consideration and scattered in cautious avoidance and mortification of the flesh. From these occasions few are freed, except those who are guarded by the Lord: Psalm: "In their hands they shall bear you up, lest you strike your foot against a stone."
The third variety regards the just with respect to their twofold state, namely that of actives and contemplatives. As to contemplatives: A time to embrace and a time to be far from embraces, because they ought to attend now to action, now to contemplation. Concerning which embrace, Proverbs 4: "You shall be glorified by her, when you have embraced her." They ought to be far from the embraces of the flesh, concerning which, Proverbs 7: "Come, let us be inebriated with desired embraces."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Regarding the use of possessions, he says: A time to acquire and a time to lose. We acquire through diligence, but lose through sloth; Proverbs 14: "The wise woman builds her house, but the foolish one tears down even what was built with her own hands."
Or a time to acquire in life, to lose in death: Job 20: "The riches which he gathered, he shall vomit up," etc.
Or a time to acquire, when we are joined to God; to lose, when we are separated: Psalm: "He blessed them, and they were multiplied"; and afterward: "And they were made few."
Regarding the use of treasures, he adds: A time to keep, when there is abundance; and a time to cast away, when there is need among the poor. The example is of Joseph, Genesis 41, who stored up in time of plenty and distributed in time of famine. For riches are to be kept for this purpose: that they may be distributed; hence in the Psalm: "He distributed, he gave to the poor."
Spiritually, as to actives, who ought to be exercised in works of piety, he adds: A time to acquire and a time to lose, that is, to distribute what has been acquired through almsgiving: Ecclesiasticus 29: "Lose your money for the sake of a brother and friend, and do not hide it under a stone." — This is said of perfect justice; but it is a work of supererogation to give everything, and with respect to this it is said: A time to keep and a time to cast away, as if to relinquish everything: Matthew 19: "If you wish to be perfect, go, sell what you have and give to the poor."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Regarding the use of garments, he adds: A time to rend, when they are worn out; and a time to sew, because our garments are daily worn out and are not renewed, unless perhaps by a divine miracle, as in Deuteronomy 8: "Your garment with which you were covered has in no way been consumed by age"; but ours are quickly consumed; therefore little care should be given to them: 1 Timothy 6: "Having food and clothing, let us be content with these."
Here is set forth the fourth variety of time, which regards the proper manner of conduct, which is considered according to the threefold alternation of acts, namely with respect to the act of the rational power, which is to speak; the concupiscible, which is to love; the irascible, whose act is to wage war; and with respect to their opposites.
Therefore, regarding the alternation of speech, he says: A time to be silent and a time to speak, because one should not always speak nor always be silent; Ecclesiasticus 20: "A wise man will be silent until the proper time, but the frivolous and imprudent will not observe the time." For the wise man is silent and speaks at the proper time; hence Proverbs 25: "Golden apples in settings of silver, he who speaks a word in its proper time." And he places silence before speech, because one should speak deliberately: Proverbs 13: "He who guards his mouth guards his soul; but he who is heedless in speaking shall experience evils."
Spiritually, again, as to actives: A time to rend and a time to sew, and this with respect to clothing: Job 31: "If I have let the poor go without covering, and if his sides have not blessed me."
The fourth variety is considered with respect to prelates, first in teaching, when he says: A time to be silent and a time to teach, because one must first learn and afterward teach; Ecclesiasticus 18: "Before you speak, learn"; Ecclesiasticus 32: "Listen in silence."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Regarding the alternation of the act of the concupiscible power, he says: A time of love, when a thing possesses goodness; and a time of hatred, when it turns to wickedness; Psalm: "I have hated and abhorred iniquity"; and Romans 12: "Hating evil, cleaving to good, loving one another with fraternal charity."
As for the alternation of the act of the irascible power, he says: A time of war, against assailing adversaries: 2 Kings 11: "And it came to pass, at the return of the year, at the time when kings go forth to war, David sent Joab," etc. And a time of peace, when those who rise up cease: 1 Maccabees 14: "The land of Judah was quiet in the days of Simon," etc.; and Micah 4: "Nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war any more."
Spiritually, A time of love and a time of hatred, in the correction of the wicked, which consists in hating vice and in loving nature: 2 Thessalonians, last chapter: "Do not esteem him as an enemy, but correct him as a brother"; and Psalm: "With a perfect hatred I hated them."
A time of war and a time of peace: of war, toward the incorrigible, who are to be struck with the sword of excommunication: Ecclesiasticus 7: "Do not seek to become a judge, unless you have the strength to break through iniquities." Of peace, toward those who return: Luke 10: "If there be a son of peace in that house, your peace shall rest upon him; but if not, it shall return to you."
The question concerns the number of these times. For it seems that he has insufficiently set forth the diversities of the variations of times, because there are many which are not reduced to these, such as the time for eating and fasting and similar things. — If you say that these are by way of example, then they are superfluous, because far fewer would have sufficed.
I respond: it must be said that, as Augustine says, although any change in the universe considered in itself is of imperfection, nevertheless in the whole of the universe there results a perfect song. Because therefore Solomon wished to narrate the variety in such a way as to show imperfection in individual things and perfection in the whole, he did so in such a number as comprehends universality and perfection. And therefore he enumerates twenty-eight times and fourteen variations: because twenty-eight is a perfect number and comprehends the sevenfold, which is the universality of time. Although the number six is perfect, it does not however comprehend the sevenfold: therefore he set down this many, not fewer, lest universality be lacking; not more, because one must stand in perfection and universality.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Art. 2. Our curiosity is reproved in two ways.
What more has man, etc. He showed above the variety of things according to diverse times; here secondly from this he reproves human curiosity: and he does this indeed in this order. First he suggests the uselessness of curiosity; second, in detestation of it, he commends present pleasure.
He reproves our curiosity on account of its uselessness, whence he says: What more has man? supply: except mutability and variety, and through this, affliction.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he shows that there is affliction: I have seen the affliction which God has given to the sons of men, that they may be occupied in it: he gave, that is, he permitted to be given, according to that passage in Romans 1: "God gave them over to a reprobate mind"; to the sons of men, that is, to sinners: above in chapter 2: "But to the sinner God has given affliction and superfluous care." That they may be occupied, namely with various cares; wherefore Ecclesiasticus 11: "My son, let not your occupations be in many things."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he explains what that affliction is, namely of consideration; whence he says: He has made all things good in their time; whence Ecclesiasticus 39: "All the works of the Lord are good, and in its hour he will supply every work. It is not to be said, this is worse than that: for all things in their time shall be approved." And although he made good things, nevertheless he did not give knowledge of these, but gave the capacity for inquiry; whence he says: And he has delivered the world to their disputation, namely for inquiring: Ecclesiasticus 17: "He gave them counsel and a tongue and eyes and ears and a heart for thinking," not for arriving at the answer; whence he adds: So that man may not find out the work that God has wrought, that is, so that he may not come to perfect knowledge: and this on account of doubt. From the beginning to the end, namely of his life: Job 36: "Remember that you are ignorant of his work, of which men have sung"; and below in chapter 8: "I understood that of the works of God I could find no reason."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here secondly, he commends present pleasure, and this in order to reprove curiosity; whence he says: And I knew that there was nothing better, supply: among these transitory goods, than to rejoice and to do good in one's life, namely to rejoice, in heart, to do good, in work.
Or: to rejoice, in enjoying; Wisdom 2: "Let us everywhere leave signs of our joy": to do good, in preparing delightful things; Luke 12: "My soul, you have many goods laid up for many years: rest, eat, drink, feast."
The Gloss expounds spiritually: And I knew that there was nothing better, that is, more useful, than to rejoice, namely with joy of mind; Ecclesiasticus 30: "Joyfulness of heart, this is the life of man and a treasure of holiness without failing"; and to do good in one's life, namely meritorious works; Galatians 6: "Therefore, while we have time, let us work good toward all."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he adds the reason; whence he says: For every man who eats and drinks sees good from his labor, and there is a surplus of meaning here, so that the sense is: he who eats and drinks sees good from his labor, because he immediately has his reward; whence he says: And this is the gift of God: below in chapter 5: "Every man to whom God has given riches and has granted him the power to eat from them, this is the gift of God."
For every man who eats and drinks: supply: from Scripture, eats the difficult things and drinks the easy things: in Proverbs 9, Wisdom says: "Come and eat my bread and drink the wine which I have mixed for you." And this is the gift of God, because the understanding of the Scriptures is given by God: Second Corinthians 3: "Not that we are sufficient to think anything of ourselves as of ourselves, but our sufficiency is from God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Art. 3. The immutability of the divine works is shown.
I have learned that all the works etc. He showed above the mutability of works, and from this reproved human curiosity. Here thirdly he shows the immutability of the divine works, because above he had shown their variability.
He says therefore: I have learned that all the works which God has made persevere forever. Behold the perpetuity, on account of which our consideration can change nothing: whence he says: We cannot add anything to them or take anything away, which God has made, that he may be feared, and thus they are not in our power: Proverbs 30: "Add nothing to his words, lest you be reproved and found a liar."
Here a question arises: since he intends to determine the vanity of mutability, why does he here determine perpetuity?
1. It seems outside his purpose.
2. Likewise, concerning this perpetuity itself a question is raised, because he says: The works which God has made persevere forever: but no corporeal things persevere forever: therefore God made no corporeal things: therefore this leads back to the heresy of Mani, who said that corruptible things were not created by the good God.
3. Likewise it seems that he contradicts himself, because immediately there follows: God restores what has passed away: therefore something of the works of God is corrupted and restored: therefore he speaks falsely when he says that all the works of God persevere forever.
But that all the works of God are incorruptible, as he says in the text, seems to be the case:
1. Because cause and effect are proportional, therefore the effect of an incorruptible cause ought to be incorruptible: but God endures forever and is incorruptible: therefore also the works of God.
2. Likewise, since all the works of God are very good, as is said in Genesis 1; and incorruptible things are better than corruptible things: it seems that these corruptible things were not created by the good God.
I respond: to the first point, why he here treats of perpetuity, it must be said that it is not for its own sake, but on the occasion of mutability; and indeed he does this for a threefold reason. The first is to remove error; for since above he had shown mutability in creatures, lest it be believed that the works of God were entirely defectible, he adds that in some way they are perpetual. Again, another reason is to restrain curiosity, which he had restrained, because we cannot investigate the mutability and cause and origin of things; he also wishes to restrain it because we can neither change nor increase the very substance of things. The third reason is to repress pride: for since he seemed to have diminished the works of the Lord through mutability, lest anyone on this account condemn God the author, he returns again to intimate perpetuity in them.
As to what is asked about permanence, it is answered that the being of things is threefold: namely, in their own genus, in the soul, and in divine foreknowledge; and above he showed that they are mutable in their own genus and insofar as they are in the soul: here he touches on their perpetuity in divine foreknowledge.
It can be answered otherwise, that one can speak of things according to their proper being in two ways: either according to common or individual being. According to individual being, many things are corruptible; according to common being, they are perpetual, because God continually preserves their being through generation; "for because they are far distant from the principle, God completed their being in another way, making generation continuous in them."
1. To the objection that they are incorruptible because they are proportional to their cause, it must be said that this is understood where there is univocal generation, where a cause produces something similar to itself. But this is not the case with the Creator and creature; rather, through infinite power he makes things great and small, corruptible and incorruptible.
2. To the objection about goodness, it must be said that all things are good in themselves, but very good in their order: and because where there is order, there is greater and lesser good, therefore some things are corruptible and some incorruptible. For this reason, goodness is in things not only according to more and less, but according to opposition and likeness; therefore the world is compared to a most beautiful poem; therefore it is fitting that some things are corruptible, and some the contrary.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he shows this, because not even God himself diminishes or adds: whence he says: What has been made, that itself remains. Neither does he add: whence he infers: The things that shall be have already been, because similar things have preceded: whence he also says: And God restores what has passed away, because "the corruption of one thing is the generation of another"; above in chapter one: "There is nothing new under the sun, nor can anyone say: this is recent"; Genesis 2: "God rested on the seventh day."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Part II. The vanity of fault is proved, then the remedy against it is set forth.
I saw under the sun, etc. He treated above of the vanity of nature; here of the vanity of fault: and because this is dangerous, therefore it needs a remedy. First, therefore, he sets forth the vanity; second, the remedy against it, below in chapter four: Guard your foot.
Now vanity is under a threefold distinction: first he treats of the vanity of malice; second, of avarice, at: I considered and found; third, of imprudence, at: Better is a child. Now vanity is in rulers and subjects. First, therefore, he treats of the vanity of malice in those who govern and judge; second, in subjects, at: I turned myself.
First, therefore, the vanity of malice, which is in rulers, is described in this order: first he introduces the consideration of this vanity; second, that from this one arrives at the premeditation of future judgment; third, at the consideration of the present condition; fourth, how one falls into erroneous opinion.
First, therefore, he introduces that he has considered the malice of judges, saying: I saw under the sun in the place of judgment wickedness, as regards the examination of the case; and in the place of justice iniquity, as regards the pronouncing of the sentence: Isaiah 1: "How is the faithful city become a harlot, full of judgment; justice dwelt in it of old, but now murderers; your princes are faithless, companions of thieves; they all love gifts, they pursue rewards, they do not judge for the orphan, and the cause of the widow does not come before them"; because it is said in the Psalm: "In whose hands are iniquities, their right hand is filled with bribes."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And I said in my heart: God shall judge the just and the wicked. Here, second, he shows how from this he arrives at the premeditation of future judgment. For which reason he adds: And I said in my heart: He shall judge the just, unto reward; the wicked, unto punishment: Job 34: "Far be wickedness from God, and iniquity from the Almighty. For he shall render to a man his work, and according to the ways of each one he shall restore to them. For truly God shall not condemn in vain, nor shall the Almighty overturn judgment." And therefore God shall judge them according to their works, which then shall be manifest; whence he adds: And the time of every thing shall then be, that is, the time of judgment of every person, who appears to be every thing, according to 2 Corinthians 5: "For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, that each one may receive the proper things of the body, whether it be good or evil."
Or: the time of every thing, that is, of the manifestation of every thing: 1 Corinthians 4: "Judge not before the time, until the Lord comes, who will both bring to light the hidden things of darkness and will make manifest the counsels of hearts."
Or: the time of every thing, that is, of the retribution of every thing: Romans 8: "Every creature groans," etc.
Ecclesiastes expected this time to be future from the sight of present iniquity: Isaiah 59: "Judgment is turned backward, and justice stood far off, because truth has fallen in the streets, and equity could not enter: and the Lord saw, and evil appeared in his eyes, because it is not manifest, and the just one was clothed with a breastplate and a helmet of salvation."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“I said in my heart concerning the sons of men etc. Here is touched upon thirdly how from this he arrived at a consideration of the present state, namely why the Lord willed men to be miserable in the present: for this purpose, namely that he might prove them, therefore he made the life of man similar to beasts.
On account of which he says: I said in my heart, that is, I knew: concerning the sons of men, as regards nature: that God might prove them and show them to be like beasts, that is, by likening them to beasts he might prove who they were, whether truly good or evil: because the evil, seeing their likeness to beasts in life, wish to be assimilated in habits and live bestially: but the good live spiritually: therefore in the Psalm it is said: "Man, when he was in honor, did not understand; he was compared to senseless beasts and was made like them." And he shows the likeness of men to beasts in death and life and in matter: the dissimilarity in spiritual substance is not manifest.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As regards death he says: And therefore one is the destruction of man and of beasts, and equal is the condition of both, namely for the proving of men, because, just as a beast does not always live, but rather sometimes dies, so also man: below in chapter nine: "There is no one who always lives and who has confidence of this matter"; and therefore he shows that the likeness is in death, whence: As man dies, so also do they die.
Nor is the likeness only in the end of life, but also in the act of living: therefore he adds: All things breathe alike, namely those that breathe: nor has man more than a beast, namely as regards the act of life: Wisdom 7: "One is the coming forth of men into life and like is the departure." Thus the likeness as regards life is clear.
I. It is asked concerning what he says: Man has nothing more than the beast, and that the destruction of both is equal. That this is false appears:
1. In Genesis two it is said: There was not found for Adam a helper like unto him, therefore no beast is like unto man: therefore he has something more than the beast.
2. Likewise, it is certain that man deliberates about future things and discerns past things and expresses his conceptions: but a beast does not: therefore etc.
3. Furthermore, man tames beasts, but no beast tames man: therefore man has something more than the beast.
That he does not have anything more, however, seems apparent: because he is born, lives, and dies and goes into the earth, just as a beast does.
I respond: some say that he says this in the person of the carnal man, who believes man has nothing more than a beast. — Otherwise it can be said that he speaks in his own person: and he speaks truly according to his own understanding. For he intends to show the uncertainty of the soul's recompense through a likeness to the beast. He posits and understands that likeness, however, with respect to visible things, which can be discerned by the senses: and through this he does not conclude a likeness regarding spiritual things, but rather a doubt: whence he says: Who knows, etc.
It must be said, therefore, that according to truth man possesses reason beyond the beasts, but shares with them in corruptibility, life, and respiration: and because reason is not something sensible but intelligible, and he speaks of sensible things, therefore there is in this no objection whatsoever.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he adds the likeness as regards matter: and therefore he says: All things are subject to vanity, namely, because they were made from nothing, therefore they are vain; Romans 8: "The creature was made subject to vanity." He does not say that nothing is the matter, but he means to say that they do not have uncreated matter nor essence, but they have created matter, which he understands by the name of earth.
Therefore he says: And all things go to one place, namely to the matter from which they were made. From earth they were made and to earth alike they return, alike, that is, conformably. And thus the likeness in matter is noted: Ecclesiasticus 40: "All things that were made from earth shall return to earth: likewise also all waters shall return to the sea."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But only in these things is the likeness apparent, but the difference in the soul does not appear. Who knows whether the spirit of the children of Adam ascends upward? to heaven, namely to recompense, or downward through corruption: just as conversely, whether the spirit of beasts descends downward? through corruption, or even upward, as also that of man, to the retribution of judgment. Few have known this: many have erred and held that the spirits of man and beast are uniform. The faithful have known this, in whose person it is said below in the twelfth chapter: "Let the body return to its earth, whence it was, and let the spirit return to God, who gave it." But the carnal do not know this, in whose person it is said below in the ninth chapter: "The dead know nothing more, nor have they any further reward."
II. There is a doubt concerning what he says: Who knows whether the spirit of the sons of Adam ascends upward? That it does, however, seems apparent:
1. First, through the disposition of the body, whose arrangement and organization is ordered according to a fittingness toward what is above. If therefore "he gave man an uplifted face and bade him gaze upon the heavens," and he looks upward: therefore the spirit is borne upward.
2. Likewise, all naturally desire happiness: but it is certain that no one can be happy in miseries, especially one to whom death comes unwillingly: therefore, if he cannot have happiness in this life, he is born to have it after this life as a separated spirit: therefore, etc.
3. Furthermore, our intellect is unmixed, whence it understands all things; therefore it does not depend on the body with respect to its act, therefore much less with respect to its being: therefore, when the body descends, it is possible for the spirit to ascend.
4. Likewise, by the reasoning of Ecclesiastes himself: because if some have good things and some have evil things, and we see that in the present evil things befall the good and good things befall the wicked: if therefore it is necessary to posit one ruler, it is necessary to posit another time and recompense, in which God judges the impious and the just. Since therefore our faith declares this, Ecclesiastes seems to have been a heretic who doubted this.
That it goes downward, however, seems apparent:
1. Through Scripture: because in Wisdom 9 it is said: The body which is corrupted weighs down the soul; therefore, if the soul is corrupted bodily, it is corrupted entirely.
2. Likewise, what suffers with the suffering dies with the dying: but the soul suffers with the body: therefore, etc.
3. Likewise, no substance is idle; therefore what takes away from something all operation takes away from it being and duration: but the soul loses all operation when the body is injured, which is evident because it loses the intellect, regarding which this seems less likely, as in the case of the mad: therefore, when the body is corrupted, it loses its substance.
I respond: it must be said that good souls ascend upward to reward, and that the souls of beasts descend downward into corruption — this our faith both declares and presupposes; and with this, reason and philosophy agree. Nevertheless, that reasoning and philosophy is both obscure and has many grounds for doubt; therefore almost no one, or very few, were able to attain true certitude concerning the immortality of the soul and its beatitude, unless faith had come to their aid. Whence even Plato, who held the soul to be immortal, nevertheless erred concerning beatitude, since he held that souls pass through the bodies of brute animals. — Ecclesiastes therefore neither denies nor doubts this, but says that this is difficult to demonstrate; and this is indeed true for the unbeliever.
2. 3. To what is objected concerning operation and co-suffering, it must be said that for something to be united to another, this occurs in two ways: either as a mover only, and then it can be separated with no change made in it; or as a mover and a perfection, and this again in two ways: either it does not have its own proper operation, as the soul of a brute animal, or it has its own proper operation, as the human soul. Since therefore the human soul is united to the body as perfection and mover, it suffers together with the suffering body; therefore it is also impeded when the body is impeded. But since it is joined separably, it is not necessary that it itself be corrupted: when every harmony is dissolved, the soul departs.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And I perceived etc. In the fourth place, on account of this likening, he subjoins how he fell into an erroneous commendation of pleasure, as if nothing were better than it.
On account of which he says: I perceived that there is nothing better than that a man should rejoice in his work, that is, to take delight in present things, as the carnal do, of whom Isaiah fifty-six says: "Come, let us take wine and be filled with drunkenness, and it shall be as today, so also tomorrow and much more." And this commendation is erroneous, because it posits no other recompense nor any other life: whence he adds: And that this is his portion, as if he should expect nothing else: whence in Isaiah twenty-two it is said in the person of such people: "Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we shall die"; and Wisdom two: "Everywhere let us leave signs of joy, for this is our portion, and this is our lot." And this erroneous opinion has its origin from the uncertainty of judgment: on account of which he says: For who shall bring him to know the things that shall be after him? that is, who will show him that there are any future goods which he ought to expect? as if to say: no one. And certainly no one will persuade him, unless he be raised to the contemplation of spiritual things: "while we look not at the things which are seen, but at the things which are not seen: for the things which are seen are temporal, but the things which are not seen are eternal," Second Corinthians four. But because the carnal man regards only visible things, therefore he does not expect eternal things: therefore First Corinthians two: "The natural man does not perceive the things that are of God." Therefore if he wishes to know future goods, it is necessary to put off carnality.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I turned myself to other things," etc. Above we treated the vanity of malice in prelates; here in subjects. The vanity of malice is touched upon here with regard to a threefold distinction: first, of calumny, in maliciously harming; second, of envy, in maliciously grieving, there: "Again I contemplated"; third, of sloth, in withdrawing from good work, and this is touched upon there: "The fool folds."
He therefore describes the emptiness of calumny; and with regard to the consideration of calumny he says: "I turned myself to other things," supply: to be considered; "and I saw the calumnies that are committed under the sun," that is, in this world: Ezekiel twenty-two: "The people of the land practiced extortion and seized by violence; they afflicted the needy and the poor and oppressed the stranger with calumny without justice." And calumny is called the violent extortion of goods, as if through justice, but through malice.
And he adds the aggravation of misery, on account of the calamity of the oppressed, because they are oppressed unjustly, inconsolably, irremediably.
Because unjustly, he says: "And the tears of the innocent," namely on account of such calumnies: Job thirty-five: "Because of the multitude of oppressors they will cry out, and they will wail because of the violence of the arm of tyrants."
Because inconsolably: "and no one to console them," which indeed aggravates the cruelty; whence Lamentations one: "There is none to comfort her among all her dear ones." On the contrary, Ecclesiasticus seven: "Do not fail those who weep in consolation, and walk with those who mourn."
Nor does he lack only consolation, but indeed a remedy; whence he also adds: "Nor able to resist their violence, destitute of all assistance," supply: I saw. Of this malice it is said in Proverbs twenty-two: "Do not do violence to the poor because he is poor, nor crush the needy at the gate." Therefore 2 Chronicles twenty: "In us there is not such great strength that we can resist this multitude that rushes upon us."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But with regard to the detestation of fault he adds: "And I praised the dead more than the living," namely because they do not see these evils and cruelties, which no good person can see and not grieve: 3 Kings nineteen, Elijah said: "It is enough for me, Lord; take my soul, for I am not better than my fathers."
The question is raised here concerning what he says: "I praised the dead more than the living."
Against: 1. Below in chapter nine: "A living dog is better than a dead lion."
2. Furthermore, this seems evident by reason: because a positive state is better than a privation, therefore life is better than death; therefore, from conjugates, the living are better off than the dead.
I respond: it must be said that to praise one thing more than another, or to prefer it, can be done in two ways: either absolutely, or with respect to some condition. Speaking absolutely, the living is preferred to the dead, unless the condition of blessedness is added; but with respect to something, the dead is preferred to the living: first, because he does not have so many occasions of sinning; whence the Apostle said in Romans 7: "Unhappy man that I am, who will deliver me from the servitude of this body?" Second, because he does not have so many occasions of sorrow, since he does not see so many evils; Jonah, last chapter: "It is better for me to die than to live." And with respect to this condition, the dead is preferred to the living, to emphasize present evils and miseries.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"And I judged happier than both," namely than the dead and the living, "him who has not yet been born nor seen the evils that are under the sun"; as though to see or to have seen these evils were a great misery: 1 Maccabees two: "Woe to me, said Mattathias, why was I born to see the destruction of my people and the destruction of the holy city, and to sit there?" — Thus therefore there is noted here the consideration of calumny, the aggravation of misery, because they are oppressed, desolate, destitute of assistance, and then the detestation of fault.
Likewise, there is a question about what is said: "I judged him who has not yet been born happier than both."
Against: 1. He has nothing good; therefore he is not happier.
2. Furthermore, everything that has in some way the character of happiness is to be desired; but no one can desire non-being, as Augustine says; therefore he who has not been born is in no way happy.
Likewise, it is asked whether anyone can will this, namely to prefer non-being to punishment, with a rightly ordered appetite.
That he can: Matthew 26: "It would have been better for him if he had not been born"; therefore if everything better is to be desired and preferred, so also is this.
That he cannot, it seems, because it takes away all good; therefore nothing is worse than that.
I respond: it must be said that happiness is in someone in two ways: truly and by estimation. Truly it is in one thing alone; by estimation it is in many things, according to diverse opinions and considerations and its conditions found in diverse things. For because it is the most delightful good, Epicurus therefore placed it in pleasures, and so with the others. Because, therefore, the happy person is troubled by no evil or misery, and this condition is found in him who has not yet been born, by reason of this condition he says: "I judged happier," etc. I say also that by reason of that condition, it is desired by many who are afflicted.
As to what is asked, whether it ought to be desired or preferred: it must be said that punishment is twofold, temporal and eternal. Neither punishment takes away the whole, but nevertheless eternal punishment always diminishes it; corruption into non-being, however, takes away the whole, but only once. If, therefore, such corruption into non-being is compared to temporal punishment, it is absolutely worse; but if compared to eternal punishment, they stand as mutually exceeding, because the former exceeds in what it takes away, the latter in its continuance. And because the latter is infinite in duration, while the former is momentary, in this respect it exceeds and can more reasonably be fled and spurned.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I again contemplated" etc. Here secondly is touched upon the vanity of envy, in grieving maliciously over the good and prosperity of one's neighbor, which he also saw; whence he adds: "I again contemplated." This contemplation is a free, penetrating, and fixed gaze. "I contemplated," I say, "all the labors and industries of men: labors," as regards the body; "and industries of men," as regards the soul.
Or: "labors and industries," that is, virtues; whence another translation: "Every virtue of work"; above in chapter two: "I detested all my industry, by which I most diligently labored under the sun." "And I observed," that is, I perceived in my mind, that they "lie open," that is, are exposed, to the "envy of one's neighbor," because the envious person, seeing good things, immediately grieves; Ecclesiasticus chapter fourteen: "Evil is the eye of the envious, turning away his face and despising his own soul." "And in this therefore is vanity," namely of malice; Proverbs chapter twenty-eight: "The man who hastens to become rich and envies others," etc. "And superfluous care," namely of punishment, because, when he ought to think about his own goods, he always thinks about those of others; whence Proverbs chapter twenty-three: "Do not eat with an envious man, and do not desire his foods, because like a diviner he reckons what he does not know."
Likewise, a question is raised about what he says: "I observed that all things are exposed to the envy of one's neighbor." I ask whether a man ought to cease from a good work on account of his neighbor's envy.
It seems that he should: because one's neighbor is to be loved more than any present advantage; therefore, if one's neighbor perishes through envying, that work ought to be omitted.
On the contrary: A good work provides a good example and stirs to good; therefore, if a good is to be made manifest for praise, a man ought not to conceal it on account of his neighbor's envy.
I respond: that work is either of necessity, or of utility. If of necessity, it is by no means to be abandoned. If of utility, either it can be done equally well in his absence as in his presence, or not: if so, a man ought to remove that work from his eyes, so as to take away the occasion, when he reasonably conjectures that the other envies; but if he cannot, he ought to do it, and he does not give the occasion, but the other takes it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The fool folds" etc. Here thirdly is touched upon the vanity of sloth, on account of which a man is rendered weary and lazy toward every good and thereby foolish. Therefore he says: "The fool folds his hands"; therefore a fool, because lazy; Proverbs chapter twelve: "He who pursues idleness is most foolish"; Proverbs chapter six: "Go to the ant, O sluggard, and learn wisdom." This fool "folds his hands," because he refuses to work; Proverbs chapter twenty-six: "The sluggard hides his hands under his armpit and finds it labor if he brings them to his mouth." And from this, that he refuses to work, he becomes poor and thin on account of the want of poverty; whence he says: "And he eats his own flesh," saying: this is said hyperbolically, because he becomes thin, not having food; Proverbs chapter twenty-one: "Desires kill the sluggard, for his hands refused to do anything."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But in this laziness of sloth he seems to himself to have an excuse of wisdom; whence he also adds, saying: "Better is a handful with rest than both hands full with labor and affliction of spirit." This is the maxim of the sluggard, by which he excuses himself; whence it is said in Proverbs chapter twenty-six: "The sluggard seems wiser to himself than seven men who speak maxims." — And thus is intimated in the sluggard the torpor of sloth, because he folds his hands; the endurance of penury, because he eats his flesh; the excuse of ignorance, because he praises rest.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Above he treated the vanity of malice; here he treats the vanity of avarice: and first is set forth the consideration of avarice; second, because the avaricious man does not wish to have a companion, in detestation of it is set forth the commendation of the fellowship of another, at the passage: "It is better therefore that two be together" etc.
In the consideration therefore of the vanity of avarice he says: "Considering, I found another vanity under the sun," namely another, because what was spoken above was of malice, but this is of avarice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whence he adds: "There is one alone, and he has not a second, neither son nor brother," and he ought to be content with little as one who is alone, because he does not even wish to have a companion: Ecclesiasticus 11: "I have found rest for myself, and now I will eat of my goods alone"; and yet he is wholly consumed by avarice both in deed and desire and understanding. In deed: whence he says: "And yet he does not cease to labor": Ecclesiasticus 31: "The rich man has labored in gathering substance." In desire: "His eyes are not satisfied with riches": Ecclesiasticus 14: "The insatiable eye of the covetous in a portion of iniquity shall not be satisfied." In understanding: whence he adds: "Nor does he reflect, saying: For whom do I labor and defraud my soul of good things?" Psalm 38: "He stores up treasures and knows not for whom he shall gather them." From these things therefore he infers vanity: "In this also there is vanity and a most grievous affliction": below in chapter 5: "Riches kept to the hurt of their owner: for they perish in a most grievous affliction."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The vanity of avarice renders one busied, and through this subject to many labors: Ecclesiastes 4: Considering, I found yet another vanity under the sun: there is one alone, and he has not a second, and yet he does not cease to labor, nor are his eyes satisfied with riches. For riches are foreign gods, concerning which, in Jeremiah 16: You shall serve foreign gods, who will give you no rest day or night.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"It is better, therefore, that two be together" etc. Here is touched upon secondly the commendation of the companionship of another, and this in detestation of the solicitude of avarice: on account of which he says: "It is better, therefore, that two be together," although the avaricious man would prefer otherwise: and he subjoins the reason: "For they have the advantage of mutual companionship": and therefore, in Luke 10, the Lord "sent the disciples two by two before his face."
And he shows a threefold advantage: namely in raising up, in preserving, and in defending.
Here it is asked concerning the solitary life, whether it should be preferred to companionship. That it should, it seems:
1. Because it is said in Lamentations 3 concerning the good youth: "He shall sit alone and keep silence": therefore it is good to be alone.
2. Furthermore, Bernard says: "As often as I have been among men, I returned less a man": therefore it is not good to be among men.
3. Likewise, whoever is in companionship must necessarily be anxious about how to conform himself to the companionship: but the Apostle says in 1 Corinthians 7 that it is good not to marry in order to avoid anxiety about pleasing a wife: therefore likewise it is good to flee all companionship.
On the contrary: 1. Genesis 2: "It is not good for man to be alone": therefore solitude is blameworthy, and by the opposite, companionship is praiseworthy.
2. Likewise, Matthew 18: "Where two or three are gathered in my name, there I am in the midst of them": he does not say: where one, but where two or three: therefore life in congregation is better than the solitary life.
3. Likewise, this is proved by this text, because companionship supports, warms, and defends, which are three goods of which the solitary are deprived.
I respond: it must be said that solitude is threefold: one through lack of love, as the miser does not wish to have a companion in riches, nor the envious in goods, nor the proud in great things: and this solitude is altogether evil. Another solitude is through want of consolation, as it is said in the Psalm: "I am alone and poor," and this is wretched. And there is another solitude through the quiet of contemplation, and this is praiseworthy and honorable.
Similarly, companionship exists in a threefold manner: one namely that disturbs and hinders, as the companionship of the wicked: another needing support and solace, as the companionship of wives and the infirm: and another that aids and advances, as the companionship of the perfect. The first is to be fled, the second to be tolerated, but the third to be sought: and this exists in religious life. When therefore Scripture commends companionship, it is understood of this kind: and this does not conflict with the solitude of contemplation, because Bernard says on the Canticles: "Among many a man can be entirely alone, if he flees curiosity." And thus the objections are answered.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On account of raising up he says: "If one falls, he will be supported by the other": Deuteronomy 22: "If you see the donkey of your brother fallen on the road, you shall not despise it, but shall lift it up with him." The solitary man lacks this benefit: therefore he adds: "Woe to him who is alone, because when he falls, he has no one to raise him up," and therefore he is wretched: whence in the Psalm: "Look upon me and have mercy on me, for I am alone and poor."
Spiritually here is noted the threefold effect of charity, namely mutual raising up, mutual consolation, and mutual defense. On account of raising up he says: "If one falls": Galatians, the last chapter: "If a man is overtaken in any fault, you who are spiritual, instruct such a one in the spirit of meekness": whence it is said in Ecclesiasticus 37: "Set the heart of good counsel with you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And since, where anyone has fallen, he must lie there, unless someone lends a hand and assists him to rise: our soul could not be perfectly raised from these sensible things to the contemplation of itself and of the eternal Truth in itself, unless the Truth, having assumed human form in Christ, had become for it a ladder repairing the prior ladder, which had been broken in Adam.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As for the advantage in preserving he adds: "And if two sleep together, they will warm each other," that is, they will be preserved from the cold: Ephesians 5: "No one has hated his own flesh, but nourishes and cherishes it." The solitary man lacks this benefit: whence he adds: "One alone," if he sleeps, "how will he be warmed?" An example of this: in 3 Kings 1 it is said that David had grown old and could not be warmed, and it is added that they sought Abishag the Shunammite, who slept in the bosom of the king and warmed him: by himself he could not be warmed, since he was alone.
Spiritually, on account of consolation he says: "They will warm each other": 1 Thessalonians 5: "Comfort the fainthearted": and in the same, chapter 2: "We became little ones in your midst, as if a nurse were to cherish her children."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As for the advantage in defending he adds: "And if anyone prevails against one, two will resist him," and thus it avails for defense: 2 Kings 10: "If the Syrians prevail against me, you shall be an aid to me: but if the sons of Ammon prevail against you, I will come to your aid." And this indeed he makes manifest by an example: "A threefold cord is not easily broken." Just as a cord joined to a cord is stronger, so also is a man: Proverbs 18: "A brother who is helped by a brother is like a strong city."
Spiritually, on account of defense he says: "Two will resist": Isaiah 50: "Let us stand together: who is my adversary?"
On account of this threefold effect of charity it is called a threefold cord: Hosea 11: "I will draw you with the cords of Adam, with the bonds of charity."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Better is a child," etc. He treated above of the vanity of malice and avarice: here he treats of the vanity of imprudence: and because the vanity of imprudence is culpable and detestable, therefore he inveighs against it in two ways: first, on account of present evil; second, on account of succeeding or consequent evil, at: "I saw all the living."
The present evil accompanying imprudence is that it subjects a rich and elderly king to a poor boy who possesses prudence, and this indeed is a great vanity. And therefore he says: "Better is a poor and wise boy than an old and foolish king," although the latter surpasses in power, surpasses in wealth, surpasses even in age; below in chapter ten: "More precious is wisdom and a little glory for a time than folly"; and Proverbs twelve: "Better is a poor man who is sufficient for himself than a boastful man who lacks bread." And he explains what he said: foolish, because he has a deficiency of foresight regarding the future, which is one part of prudence: whence he says: "Who does not know how to foresee for the future," namely the outcome of events: Deuteronomy thirty-two: "Would that they were wise and understood and foresaw the last things."
Spiritually, this can also be expounded concerning Christ. The poor and wise child is Christ, a child on account of innocence: whence Isaiah forty-two, according to another reading: "Behold, my child, my chosen one, my soul is well pleased in him." Poor, because he was made needy for us: Second Corinthians eight: "You know, brothers, the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that for your sake he became poor, though he was rich." Wise, indeed Wisdom itself, First Corinthians one: "We proclaim Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God"; and below in chapter nine: "There was found in it a poor and wise man."
The old and foolish king is the devil, who is old; Job forty: "He is the beginning of the ways of God": whence "he has grown old in evil days." A king, because he reigns among the wicked: whence Job forty-one: "He is king over all the children of pride." Foolish, because he undertook what he could not accomplish: whence Isaiah fourteen, he said: "I will ascend into heaven, I will exalt my throne above the stars of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"That from prison and chains sometimes one goes forth to a kingdom": Wisdom ten: "She did not abandon the just man who was sold into bondage, but freed him from sinners, until she brought him the scepter of the kingdom." "And another, born to a kingdom, is consumed by want," and this on account of his pride: Ecclesiasticus ten: "The Lord has destroyed the thrones of proud rulers and has made the meek to sit in their place."
Spiritually, although the devil is most cunning at deceiving, he nevertheless does not know how to foresee that one goes forth from prison to reign, so that Christ goes forth from the prison of the flesh and from the bonds of the Passion to the kingdom of heavenly glory: Hebrews one: "He sits at the right hand of the Majesty on high." Even the devil, born into the kingdom, that is, to possess the kingdom, is consumed by want, as it is said in Colossians two: "Despoiling principalities and powers, he led them away openly."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here is touched upon secondly the evil succeeding on account of his imprudence, because he himself is cast down and another is exalted: whence he says: "I saw all the living who walk under the sun," that is, many or innumerable, hyperbolically, "with the second youth," that is, who follows him in the kingdom: whence he says: "who shall rise up in his place." And so others follow the succeeding youth, despising the old man. The example is of David, who rose up to the kingdom of Saul, whom the children of Israel followed, having abandoned the house of Saul, as is said in Second Kings five, that all came to David.
Spiritually: "And I saw all the living under the sun with the second youth," that is, Christ: John twelve: "Behold, the whole world has gone after him." He rises up because he cast the devil out of the kingdom: John twelve: "Now is the judgment of the world, now shall the prince of this world be cast out."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the reason why they follow the youth, having abandoned the old man, is because the foolish old man did good to no one; and the following text implies this: "Infinite is the number of the people of all who were before him," that is, before the coming of the youth they were under the foolish king and adhered to him. "And those who shall be afterwards," supply: those adhering to the old man, "shall not rejoice in him," that is, in the foolish old man, because he did good to no one nor will he, because he does not know how: Ecclesiasticus twenty: "The fool shall have no friend, nor shall there be gratitude for his goods; for he does not distribute with right judgment what ought to be given." And from this he concludes vanity: whence he says: "But this also is vanity and affliction of spirit," that is, another vanity from those previously mentioned, above in chapter one: "I saw all things that are done under the sun, and behold, all is vanity"; and the reason is subjoined: "The perverse are corrected with difficulty, and the number of fools is infinite." And thus the section on the vanity of fault is concluded.
Spiritually: "The infinite number of men who were before him," that is, before the coming of Christ: and the faithful, "who shall come after, will not rejoice in him," that is, in the foolish king, that is, the devil, because they rejoiced only in Christ: whence the Apostle, the last chapter of Philippians: "Rejoice in the Lord always." One must rejoice in the Lord, not in the devil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the vanity of fault is deadly and pestilential, therefore here the remedy against that vanity is treated. And because a threefold vanity preceded, namely of malice, avarice, and imprudence, therefore here he sets forth three remedies. And first he gives the remedy against malice; second, against avarice, at the passage: "The covetous man shall not be satisfied"; third, against imprudence, at the passage: "What more has he" etc. But since the disease of malice is in itself irremediable and can further corrupt others, therefore the remedy is set forth here not against malice, but against the corruption of malice or the evil that follows in others from the sight of another's malice.
From this there arises a threefold disorder, namely: in deed, through the disobedience of transgression; in speech, through the foolishness of utterance; in the heart, through erroneous thought. Into all of which the incautious observer of another's malice rushes headlong. For when someone considers the wicked unpunished, he believes there is no providence: behold, erroneous thought; and through this he freely speaks foolish things, because he believes there is no one to reprove; and further he transgresses the commandments, because he does not believe there is one who punishes.
First, therefore, he gives the remedy against disobedience; second, against foolish speech, at the passage: "Do not rashly speak anything" etc.; third, against erroneous thought, at the passage: "If you see the oppressions of the poor" etc.
In the remedy against disobedience, an exhortation is introduced, and the reason for the exhortation is subjoined. He exhorts to diligent guarding of the feet, lest one transgress the divine commandments; therefore he says: "Guard your foot, lest perhaps it turn aside from the right way": Hebrews 12: "Make straight steps with your feet, that no one limping may go astray." "Entering the house of God," that is, into the Church, or into the service of God, into which a man ought to enter with fear; whence in the Psalm: "I will enter into your house, and I will worship toward your holy temple in your fear." Thus he ought to keep his foot from disobedience and have it ready for obedience; on account of which he says: "And draw near, that you may hear," that is, obey: "draw near," because Deuteronomy 33: "Those who draw near to his feet shall receive of his teaching"; "hear," by obeying: Jeremiah 17: "Hear the word of the Lord, all you who enter through these gates. Thus says the Lord: guard your souls."
And there is subjoined the reason for the exhortation: "For obedience is much better than the sacrifices of fools, who do not know what evil they do," who do not recognize their transgressions nor care to obey. Gregory: "Obedience is better than sacrifices, because in obedience one's own will is slain, in sacrifice the flesh of another." Improper is the comparison, because obedience is good, and therefore pleasing; whence Lamentations 3: "It is good for a man when he has borne the yoke from his youth"; but the sacrifices of fools displease: Proverbs 15: "The sacrifices of the wicked are abominable to the Lord"; whence Saul was rebuked, because out of love of offering he transgressed the divine command: 1 Kings 15: "Does the Lord desire holocausts or sacrifices, and not rather that he be obeyed? For obedience is better than sacrifices, and to hearken rather than to offer the fat of rams."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, a remedy is given against foolish speech, which occurs in a threefold manner.
"Do not rashly speak anything." Here he gives a remedy against foolish or disordered speech. Now speech is disordered either because it is inconsiderate; or because it is false, and this he prohibits there: "If you have vowed anything," etc.; or because it is erroneous, and this he prohibits there: "Do not give your mouth, so as to cause to sin," etc.
Regarding inconsiderate speech, he prohibits rashness and adds the reason and provides confirmation by example.
He therefore prohibits rashness; whence he says: "Do not rashly speak anything," that is, inconsiderately; Sirach 9: "He who is rash in his speech will be hateful"; and again Sirach 28: "Make a balance for your words and a bridle for your mouth." And because a man who is hasty cannot deliberate, therefore he adds: "Nor let your heart be hasty to utter a word," indeed one ought to deliberate at length; whence Proverbs 29: "Have you seen a man hasty in his speech? Folly is to be expected rather than his correction." Whence there ought to be a distance between mouth and heart; against which Sirach 21: "In the mouth of fools is their heart." Whence it is said in James 1: "Let every man be swift to hear and slow to speak"; and Seneca: "I want you to be slow of speech."
And the reason is added, namely the divine judgment, which sees all things; therefore he says: "For God is in heaven," supply: seeing all things; whence in the Psalm: "The Lord looked from heaven upon the earth"; "and you are upon earth," placed in plain sight before Him, so you do not escape His notice; Sirach 23: "The eyes of the Lord are far brighter than the sun, looking round about all the ways of men." "Therefore let your words be few," because namely you speak before God, because He Himself will demand an account of all things; Matthew 12: "Of every idle word that men shall have spoken, they shall render an account thereof on the day of judgment."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And it can scarcely be that he who speaks much does not displease God. Whence he makes this clear by example and similitude, saying: "Dreams follow many cares," and therefore it is foolish to attend to them; Sirach 34: "Dreams have led many astray." "And in many words folly is found"; Sirach 20: "He who uses many words injures his own soul"; and Proverbs 10: "In much speaking sin will not be lacking"; but on the contrary, below in chapter 10: "The fool multiplies words."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second mode of taking the name of God in vain is through breaking of a vow made. And here there is likewise a threefold degree. The first is through irrational delay, as when I promise to go to Saint James by an oath and do not assign myself a fixed term, and thus always procrastinate. In the second way, breaking of a vow occurs through a contrary will, as when someone promises something to God and afterward repents of it. In the third way, breaking of a vow occurs through apostatic rebellion, as when a man apostatizes from religious life. The first of these modes is evil, the second worse, the third worst, because it is said: "An apostate man is a worthless man;" on account of which it is said in Ecclesiastes: "If you have vowed anything to God, do not delay to pay it; for an unfaithful and foolish promise displeases God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"If you have vowed anything," etc. Here secondly he prohibits false speech, by which namely that is promised which is not fulfilled.
He therefore exhorts one to fulfill what has been promised: whence he says: "If you have vowed anything to God," that is, you have promised by a vow: "do not delay to render it:" whence in the Psalm: "Vow, and render to the Lord your God, all you who round about him bring gifts"; and the Gloss says: "To vow is voluntary, but to render is necessary," because otherwise a man is false in his promise; whence he adds: "For an unfaithful and foolish promise displeases God: unfaithful," in which there is no truth: "foolish," in which there is no judgment, because a foolish promise is not to be kept: whence Isidore says: "In evil promises, break faith; in a base vow, change your decree." Therefore he adds that truth is to be kept in a promise, when he says: "But whatever you have vowed, render it," without wavering; Leviticus twenty-seven: "A clean animal that can be sacrificed, if anyone has vowed it, shall be holy and cannot be changed, neither for better nor for worse."
Here a question arises concerning what he says: "Whatever you have vowed, pay it:" whether one who has vowed indiscreetly is bound, supposing that he intends to obligate himself: because, if not, then he gains an advantage from his own indiscretion. Likewise, one is bound to practice truth: but he who does not do what he promised does not practice truth, indeed he lies: therefore such a person is bound to do what he vowed. Likewise, Jephthah vowed indiscreetly and fulfilled it, and he is commended by the Apostle in Hebrews 11: therefore we ought to pay and fulfill indiscreet vows.
On the contrary: What is indiscreet to say is indiscreet to do: if therefore he who vows thus, by the very fact that he says it, is indiscreet, if he does it he is much more indiscreet and sins more greatly: therefore by omitting it he does well. Likewise, a preceding evil does not excuse a following one: therefore if someone vowed something foolish and does it, he is no less blameworthy than if he did it without a vow: nor is the vow less blameworthy than if he did not fulfill it. Likewise, Isidore says: "In evil promises break faith, in a shameful vow change your resolve."
I respond: it must be said that one is not bound: indeed, if he does it, he adds sin upon sin: whence Jephthah too, by fulfilling his vow, sinned more than if he had not fulfilled it; because in vowing he was foolish and in fulfilling he was impious, as Augustine says. To the objection that he is commended: it must be said that he is commended neither for his vow nor for the fulfillment of his vow, because the Apostle commends there faith, and commends the faith of Jephthah, namely that he believed he would triumph over his enemies by the Lord's help. To the objection that it brings advantage: I say that this is false; because immediately in the vow itself he sins and is worthy of punishment. To the objection concerning truth, it must be said that truth lays judgment beneath itself: because therefore he vowed without judgment, he cannot fulfill it with truth: and for this reason there cannot be truth in such a vow, and therefore there is no obligation.
It is also asked whether one can commute a vow. That one cannot seems to be shown by that passage in the last chapter of Leviticus: "It cannot be changed, neither for worse nor for better." But that one can seems to be shown: because it is permitted to make the Lord's portion better: therefore, even if it is not permitted to change for the worse, it is nevertheless permitted to change for the better.
I respond: it must be said that there is changing a vow entirely for the worse, and there is changing it for the better in a way that includes the original, as when one who vowed to enter a less perfect religious order enters a more perfect one that encloses the former within it. There is also changing it for the better in a way that does not include the original, as changing a pilgrimage to Rome into a journey overseas. The first is in no way permitted, but is prohibited: the second is permitted of itself: the third is permitted, but not without the authority of a superior. For because I am obligated to the Lord, I cannot change it except at his discretion: and because he does not speak to me except through his minister, who holds his place, I cannot change it without the authority of a superior, unless the Lord himself most certainly inspires it interiorly. And thus that passage is clear.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Otherwise it would have been better not to vow: therefore he says: "And it is much better not to vow," that is, it is less evil, because without fault: "than after a vow not to render what was promised:" Second Peter two: "It would have been better for them not to have known the way of truth than after knowing it to turn back"; because Luke nine: "No one putting his hand to the plow and looking back is fit for the kingdom of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Do not give your mouth" etc. Here thirdly he prohibits erroneous speech: and he dissuades from error of speech, and then adds the reason, and afterward reveals the root of the error.
He dissuades from error of speech, saying: "Do not give your mouth to cause your flesh to sin," that is, do not speak erroneous speech by which you may be cast headlong into sins. And he specifies what kind of speech he means, adding: "Neither say before the Angel: There is no providence," that is, do not say it, neither in secret nor in hidden places, because in hidden places the Angels hear, who are appointed for guardianship; whence below in chapter ten: "Do not detract from the king in your thought, and in the secret of your bedchamber do not curse the rich, for the birds of the sky will carry your voice." And the reason for the exhortation is added: "Lest perhaps the Lord, being angry, destroy your works," that is, render them useless: "angry," not through a disturbance of the soul, but through a rigid punishment of fault. So he was angry over the words of Rabshakeh and destroyed all the works of the kings of the Assyrians through an Angel by night: Isaiah thirty-seven: "If only the Lord your God would hear the words of Rabshakeh, whom the king of the Assyrians sent to blaspheme the living God"; Proverbs twenty: "A wise king scatters the wicked" etc.
It is also asked concerning what he says: "Do not say before the Angel: There is no providence." On the contrary: it seems that there is no providence. First, because providence gives due order to things; but this order does not exist in the world, below in the tenth chapter: "I saw servants on horses and princes walking upon the earth like servants." Likewise second: because providence gives due recompense, but this does not exist in the world, below in the ninth chapter: "The same things happen to all." Likewise third: because it gives due duration; but this simply does not exist in the world, below in the seventh chapter: "The impious man lives a long time in his impiety."
But that it is necessary to posit providence is shown: Because it belongs to the wise man to provide for his household; therefore much more so to the supremely wise. Likewise, it belongs to the wise artisan not only to make but also to preserve; thus God preserves and governs; but he is wise, and the wise man governs everything that he governs through providence; therefore, etc. Likewise, because God is supremely wise, he cannot fail to see our evils; therefore, since he is supremely just, he cannot fail to punish evils and reward good things; therefore there is recompense for all things, and therefore also providence.
Likewise it is asked who sins more: whether he who denies providence, or he who criticizes divine providence. It seems that he who denies sins more, because he who believes that providence exists, by the very fact that he believes, does well; therefore he has something of good; but he who simply denies has nothing; therefore he is more blameworthy. On the contrary: Jerome says that he who posits providence and accuses God sins more than he who simply denies providence.
I respond to the first point that providence exists. To what is objected concerning due order, the response is that order is twofold, namely particular and universal: something can be deprived of particular order, but not of universal order, as Boethius says. Universal order embraces all things; whence he who falls from the order of nature falls into the order of punishment; just as Augustine's example is of the cloud, in which there is a whirlwind and a turning that is disordered in itself, but ordered toward the breaking of the earth; so the wicked rule over the good for the exercise of the good and the punishment of the wicked. Similarly concerning recompense it must be said that in the present life good things come to the wicked in a just manner, so that they may be rewarded here and eternally tormented in the future; and evil things come to the good, so that they may be purified here and eternally rewarded. To what is objected concerning life, it must be said that the wicked live long for the aforesaid reason, but the good die; because it is said of Enoch that "he was taken away, lest wickedness should change his understanding." Since therefore the divine judgments are hidden in the present life for the testing of men, and since the simple and unlearned do not perceive hidden things, it seems that all things are disordered; and therefore Ecclesiastes teaches us to look to him under whom all things are ordered.
To what is asked, who sins more greatly: I respond that it must be said that to deny providence can be twofold: in one way, because we believe God to be ignorant, or because we believe that He does not care about the deeds of mortals. Likewise, to accuse is also twofold: either because He does not care, or because He perverts. In both ways, to accuse providence is worse, because one not only errs but indeed reviles and blasphemes God; and thus one sins more greatly absolutely speaking, and knowledge there does not excuse but rather aggravates.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the origin of this speech is added: because it does not arise from right reason, but from the illusion of dreams; on account of which he says: "Where there are many dreams, there are very many vanities," because a dream is vanity: Isaiah twenty-nine: "The hungry man dreams and eats, and afterwards, when he has awakened, his soul is empty." "And innumerable words," which follow upon dreams, because nothing certain can be known from them: because Ecclesiasticus thirty-four: "Divination of error and lying auguries and dreams of evildoers are vanity." And therefore one should not be concerned with such things, but with God: whence he adds: "But you, fear God," because he alone is the one who can destroy and save us, not dreams, not auguries: Luke twelve: "I will show you whom you should fear: fear him who, after he has killed, has the power to cast into hell."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, a remedy is given against erroneous thinking.
"If you see the oppressions," etc. Here thirdly he draws back from erroneous thinking, namely so that from seeing the malice of men one should not believe that providence is lacking: whence he says: "If you see the oppressions of the needy:" above in chapter four: "I saw the oppressions that are carried on under the sun, and the tears of the innocent." "And violent judgments," which he saw, above in chapter three: "I saw under the sun, in the place of judgment, wickedness." "And justice overturned in the province:" which he had similarly seen above in chapter three: "I saw in the place of justice, iniquity." From this consideration, I say, one should not wonder, as though there were no one who governs nor who corrects: whence he says: "Do not wonder at this matter," as though there were no one who governs, because there is one orderer of all things: whence he adds: "Because one higher than the high watches over, and there are others yet more eminent above these:" whence in Matthew eight the centurion said: "I am a man placed under authority, having soldiers under me, and I say to this one: Go, and he goes."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"And moreover the king of all the earth commands one who serves him:" although therefore they do not serve one another and are not ordered through themselves, they are nevertheless ordered by God, who knows how to use evils well: in Genesis forty-one it is signified: "I am Pharaoh; without your command no one shall move hand or foot in all the land of Egypt." Whence it is said in Revelation nineteen: "He had written on his garment and on his thigh: King of kings and Lord of lords." And he himself perverts nothing: whence it is said in Deuteronomy ten: "The Lord our God, he is the God of gods and Lord of lords, the Lord great, mighty, and terrible, who does not accept persons nor gifts: he executes judgment for the orphan and the widow"; and therefore, if he commands, justice is not perverted.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The covetous man shall not be filled with money." Above he set forth the remedy against the vanity of malice; here he adds secondly the remedy against the vanity of avarice. Now the remedy against avarice is contempt of earthly goods; therefore here he urges contempt of riches. And he does this indeed by a threefold reason: for first he shows that riches are not to be desired, because they do not enrich their possessors; second, because they are not frequently transmitted to posterity, at the passage: "There is another grievous evil"; third, because they frequently devolve to strangers, at the passage: "There is also another evil which I have seen under the sun," etc.
First, riches are to be despised because they do not enrich their possessors, and this for a threefold reason. First, therefore, he detests avarice, because the riches that are desired neither help nor enrich their possessors, because they do not suffice; second, because they do not profit; third, because they afflict.
Riches are therefore to be detested and spurned, because they do not suffice for the covetous man, and this is what the covetous man first desires, namely sufficiency. Therefore he says: "The covetous man shall not be filled with money:" Sirach 14: "The eye of the covetous man is insatiable." Whence Jerome: "The miser lacks both what he has and what he does not have"; and Seneca: "If you wish to make yourself rich, you must not add to your money but subtract from your desire."
Here secondly he dissuades from the love of riches, because they do not profit. Therefore he says: "And he who loves riches shall not reap fruit from them," and thus they do not profit: Sirach 10: "There is nothing more wicked than to love money. For such a one has his soul for sale"; and thus riches profit the miser nothing, because he gives his soul for money: whence Matthew 16: "What does it profit a man, if he gain the whole world, yet suffer the loss of his own soul"? as if to say: nothing. And from this he infers the vanity of loving them: "And this therefore is vanity," both of fault and of punishment: concerning the first, the Psalm: "Sons of men, how long will you be heavy of heart" etc.; concerning the second, the Psalm: "Their days were consumed in vanity" etc. The Psalm: "Behold the man who did not make God his helper, but trusted in the abundance of his riches and prevailed in his vanity."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The world with its things is vain, because it does not provide fullness to the one who possesses it: whence it is said in Ecclesiastes 5: The covetous man shall not be satisfied with money. And the reason for this is that all worldly things are vain, and vain things do not satisfy: whence it is said in Ecclesiasticus 34: Vain hope and falsehood to the senseless man, as one who grasps at a shadow and pursues the wind: so is he who attends to lying visions: whence just as the wind does not satisfy the stomach, nor does a shadow fill it, so neither do temporal things, which are the shadow of eternal things, for which the soul was created.
Vain also, because the world does not yield fruit to the one who loves it: whence it is said in Ecclesiastes 5: He who loves riches shall not reap fruit from them: and this therefore is vanity. He reaps no fruit, but rather loss, because by gaining the world he loses God and loses himself: and according to what is said in Matthew 16: What does it profit a man, if he gain the whole world, yet suffer the loss of his own soul?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he shows that riches profit the possessor nothing: because they are consumed, and the master has nothing more than the servant: therefore he says: "Where there are great riches, many also are those who consume them:" thus all things are consumed. Whence Seneca: "Wolves follow corpses, flies follow honey: that crowd follows the prey, not the man"; Job 39: "Its young ones lap up blood, and wherever there is a carcass, it is immediately present"; because, according to what is said in Proverbs 19, "many honor the person of the powerful and are friends of the one who gives gifts." "And what does it profit the possessor, except that he beholds his riches with his eyes?" as if to say: nothing more for himself than for others, because any one of the others eats as much as he alone: and thus he has no fruit above others, but rather loss, because he has more sin; whence Sirach 11: "If you are rich, you will not be free from sin. If you pursue it, you will not overtake it" etc.
But a question is raised concerning what he says, that riches do not profit the possessor. For below in chapter seven: "Wisdom is more useful with riches, and it profits more those who see the sun." Likewise, Proverbs thirteen: "The redemption of a man's soul is his riches:" therefore they avail for redeeming the soul.
On the contrary: Everything which it is simply better to relinquish than to retain is simply useless, because if the absence of something is useful, its presence is harmful: therefore if relinquishing riches is good, retaining them is useless. Likewise, all usefulness is measured according to its ordering toward the ultimate end: therefore what furnishes an impediment to arriving at the end is not useful but useless; but riches are of this kind, because it is impossible for one who loves riches to enter heaven, and it is difficult to have them and not love them: therefore the possession of riches impedes: therefore they do not profit but hinder.
I respond to this that, as Bernard says, "these temporal things are of themselves neither good nor evil, whose use is good, abuse evil, anxiety over them worse, and the pursuit of gain from them most base." If therefore it is asked whether riches are useful or useless, I say that to one using them well they are useful, but to one hoarding them they are useless, and to one using them badly they are harmful; whence it is said below in the same book: "Riches kept to the hurt of their owner;" but to one using them well they avail, namely when he distributes them in works of piety.
For thus they avail for the redemption of guilt: Daniel four: "Redeem your sins with almsgiving." They avail for the increase of grace: First Timothy four: "Exercise yourself unto piety," etc. They avail for the attainment of glory: Luke sixteen: "Make for yourselves friends from the mammon of iniquity, so that when you fail, they may receive you into eternal tabernacles."
To the objection that they are useless because it is good to relinquish them: it must be said that to relinquish is to give to God, and this is to use riches well; whence they are useful for relinquishing, for giving to the poor, for purchasing the kingdom. To the objection that it is difficult to have and not to love: I respond that from this it does not follow that they impede, because every virtue concerns what is difficult, and yet virtue does not impede but assists. Nevertheless, the more useful and safer practice is to relinquish everything at once rather than to give little by little, on account of avoiding the dangers that arise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here thirdly he shows that riches are to be spurned, because they afflict and do not permit a man to rest: whence they take away the sleep of quiet. Therefore he says: "Sweet is the sleep of the worker, whether he eats little or much." And thus the worker and laborer sometimes rests: Sirach 31: "The sleep of health is in a frugal man: he will sleep until morning, and his soul will delight in him." But on the contrary concerning the rich man: he does not rest: whence he adds: "But the fullness of the rich man does not permit him to sleep." Or, because he has many riches, he has many cares, which take away sleep: Job 15: "The sound of terror is always in his ears, and when there is peace, he suspects treachery"; whence above in chapter two: "All his days are full of labors and sorrows, nor does his mind rest through the night." Or also, because he eats and drinks much and does not labor, therefore he does not rest: whence Sirach 31: "Sleeplessness and bile and gripping pains are for the intemperate man," and thus on account of surfeit he does not rest.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, riches are to be despised because they are frequently not transmitted to posterity.
"There is also another infirmity," etc. Above he showed that riches do not enrich their possessors; here he adds secondly that they are to be despised because they are frequently not transmitted to posterity; and indeed he does this in the following order. First is noted the consideration of future poverty in one's offspring. Second, from this he denounces the toilsome anxiety of acquiring money. Third, in denunciation of this, he commends the enjoyment of present gladness, adding that this is a gift of divine generosity.
He considers therefore first the future destitution in the offspring of the rich man, because, when they are preserved for a long time by the father, they do not remain for the son. Therefore he says: "There is also another most grievous infirmity, which I saw under the sun," another, namely, from the aforementioned one, which, I say, is in the possession of riches: whence he says: "Riches kept to the hurt of their owner," because they cannot be gathered without the evil both of punishment and of fault: Ecclesiasticus thirty-one: "Blessed is the man who is found without blemish, and who has not gone after gold nor hoped in the treasures of money. Who is this? and we shall praise him: for he has done wonderful things in his life." Or: "to the hurt," for they make a man come into the evil of punishment; James five: "Come now, you rich, weep and howl in your miseries which shall come upon you." "Of their owner," nay rather in reality of their slave, because avarice makes the avaricious man a slave: whence Ephesians five: "Avarice, which is the service of idols."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"These, I say, perish in the worst affliction," because it is necessary that he relinquish them with sorrow: Job twenty-seven: "The rich man, when he shall sleep, shall take nothing with him." Nor are they only left behind by their owner, but they are also lost by the son, whence he adds: "He has begotten a son, who shall be in the utmost destitution." There is an utmost destitution, and this is of all goods, concerning which Proverbs six: "Want shall come upon you like a traveler" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And thus riches that are preserved are not left to the heir, nor can they be carried away by the possessor: whence he adds: "As he came forth naked from his mother's womb, so shall he return," not into the womb, but into the earth. "And he shall take nothing with him of his labor:" Job one: "Naked I came forth from my mother's womb, and naked shall I return thither."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And this is greatly to be lamented: whence he adds: "A most miserable infirmity indeed: as he came, so shall he return:" whence 1 Timothy last chapter: "We brought nothing into this world, and there is no doubt that neither can we carry anything away."
Here secondly he reproves the solicitude of increasing money by consideration of the destitution that is to come: whence he infers as if from the aforesaid things that it is vain to afflict oneself with such great labors in the acquisition of things. Therefore he says: "What then does it profit him," namely the avaricious rich man, "that he labored into the wind?" that is, in vain, if it is so that "as he came forth naked from the womb, naked shall he return," both he himself and his son, as if to say: nothing. Therefore in the Psalm: "O sons of men, how long will you be heavy of heart? Why do you love vanity and seek after lying?" Riches are compared to wind on account of their vanity: whence Ecclesiasticus thirty-four: "As one who grasps at a shadow and pursues the wind, so is he who attends to lying visions"; he labored therefore into the wind, when he labored for acquiring riches.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he adds the magnitude of the toil: "All the days of his life he eats in darkness," on account of loneliness; "and in many cares," on account of anxiety; "and in distress," on account of the scantiness of expenditures; "and sadness," on account of the necessity of expenditures. For he is saddened because he must eat something: Ecclesiasticus 14: "The wicked and envious eye will not be satisfied with bread, and the needy one will be in sadness at his own table." Riches cause a man to be in cares and distresses, because Matthew 13: "The anxiety of this world and the deceitfulness of riches chokes the word."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"This therefore seemed good to me." Here thirdly he commends the enjoyment of gladness in detestation of the affliction of avarice. For since the miser afflicts himself, and nothing profits him, therefore it seemed good to him to eat; and for this reason he says: "This therefore seemed good to me, that one should eat and drink," as regards exterior pleasantness; "and enjoy gladness from his toil, with which he has toiled under the sun:" "gladness," as regards interior pleasantness; and this, while he can; whence he also adds: "The number of the days of his life, which God has given him," as if he should not expect another time. "And this is his portion." Concerning all these things, Isaiah 22: "Behold joy and gladness, slaying rams, eating flesh and drinking wine; let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we shall die," as if that were one's portion.
But here a question arises first concerning what he says: "This seemed good to me, that one should eat." Against: Below in chapter 10: "Woe to you, O land, whose king is a child, and whose princes eat in the morning:" therefore he contradicts himself. Furthermore, he says: "And let him rejoice." On the contrary: Below in chapter seven: "It is better to go to the house of mourning than to the house of feasting," and again: "The heart of the wise is where sorrow is." Likewise, Truth itself says in Luke 6: "Woe to you who laugh now, for you shall weep;" therefore it is evil to rejoice, and all of Scripture condemns the joy of the flesh: what then does it mean that he commends it here?
To this one responds by means of the manner of proceeding in this book, which is singular among all the books of Sacred Scripture. For he speaks as a preacher weaving together his disputation, in which diverse opinions are brought forward according to diverse persons in whose character he speaks: whence he speaks one way in the person of the carnal man, as here, and another way in the person of the wise man, as below: "It is better to go," etc. But afterward he speaks in his own person, where he says: "Let us all hear together the end of the discourse," where he as it were renders judgment upon those whose case he had previously examined: "Fear God," and that God will judge all things. Whence whatever is read in the book that opposes that judgment is annulled by that judgment; and such are all the things said in commendation of present pleasure; and thus by one solution all objections are answered.
Otherwise it can be said that Ecclesiastes himself, whatever he says, says in his own person; but nevertheless, to understand the things he says, two things must be attended to, namely the reason for speaking and the manner. The manner of speaking varies in two ways: for some things he says truly, and some ironically; truly, as that passage: "Cast your bread upon the passing waters," below in chapter eleven; ironically, as that passage: "Rejoice therefore, O young man, in your youth." And this is clear from what follows: "And know that for all these things God will bring you into judgment," below in chapter eleven.
Another variation is noted in manner, because some things he says by way of approving: "Do not rashly speak anything," etc.; and some things by way of recounting that he himself did thus, as he said above in chapter two: "I did not restrain my heart from enjoying every pleasure," etc. This he does not approve, but recounts that he did thus, just as the Apostle also says of himself that he was a blasphemer. Similarly, some things he says by way of recounting that he thought thus, as when he said above in chapter two: "Is it not better to eat and drink," etc. And he uses this kind of speech frequently in this little book, as though narrating his temptations; whence this book was as it were a certain meditation of Solomon. And just as a man falls from one meditation into another according to diverse considerations, as when someone thinks this to be good and afterward falls into another estimation, so Solomon narrates in this book as well.
As for the reason for speaking, it should be noted that some things he says simply for their own approval, but certain things he says not in approval, but in comparison with and detestation of other things, just as one who wished to censure avarice would praise prodigality: so also in this book he praised the dead in comparison with the living, and pleasure in respect to avarice, because in avarice there is both punishment and guilt. He did this, however, in order to call back from the one, not to attract to the other.
Furthermore, as for the reason for speaking, it should be noted that some things he says to all, and some to certain persons who presuppose something, and from their presupposition he argues against them, as he said above, that there is no memory of the wise man as of the fool. He said this to those wise men who placed their entire reward in the praises of men.
This rule, therefore, is to be generally observed in his words: that what he says truly and approvingly, he says by commending in itself, he says to all—that is, truly and assertively, universally and absolutely—and these things are indeed to be adduced as authoritative. But what he says ironically and what he says by way of recitation, he says for the detestation of other things, or from some presupposition, or toward the contrary. That statement, therefore, was spoken not assertorily, but by way of recitation: for he recites his own trial, which he intends to narrate. Or it was said not absolutely, but for the detestation of avarice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he approves this consideration, as though it pleases God; whence he also adds: "And to every man to whom God has given substance and riches:" for these things are from God; whence Ecclesiasticus 11: "Good things and evil, life and death, poverty and honor are from God." "And has given him power to eat thereof," delighting outwardly; "and to enjoy his portion," resting in these things; "and to rejoice in his toil," joyfully expending what has been acquired. "This is the gift of God," for this power is from God, because John 15: "Without me you can do nothing." And he shows that it is a great gift, because the torment of cares and anxieties, which are great punishments, are tempered through delights. Therefore he adds: rightly do I say that "it is the gift of God," insofar as it frees from the torments of avarice.
Likewise, there is a question about what he says, that it is a "gift of God" that one should enjoy riches: but this is sin. I respond: it must be said that the goods of fortune, of nature, and also of grace are all gifts of God: but those of fortune are the least, those of nature are intermediate, and those of grace are the best. Among the gifts of nature are counted health and strength; among the goods of fortune, prosperity and tranquility. For God gives riches to some, to whom he does not give health or tranquility, and these do not enjoy their goods; to some he adds in addition tranquility and health, and such persons have the power of enjoying them; and because those things are gifts of God, so also is the power; but furthermore, the evil misuse of that power—this is not from God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"For he will not much remember the days of his life," that is, he will not be much afflicted by cares that pertain to life, "because God occupies his heart with delights," not spiritual ones, concerning which in Song of Songs 7: "How beautiful you are and how graceful, dearest, in delights!" but carnal ones, concerning which it was said above in chapter 2: "I made for myself singers, both men and women, and the delights of the sons of men."
Likewise, he says that "God occupies the heart with delights" in life: but this again is sin. As to the question that God is said to occupy his heart with delights: it must be answered that certain things God does mercifully, and certain things by just judgment in abandoning, just as he is said to hand over the wise of the world to a reprobate mind: so also he is said to occupy the heart with delights by permitting, through just judgment, it to be occupied and to forget eternal things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Thirdly, he denounces avarice, because riches are frequently transferred to strangers.
"There is also another evil," etc. Above he showed that riches are to be despised, both because they do not enrich their possessors, and because they are frequently not transmitted to posterity. Here thirdly he shows they are to be despised, because they are frequently transferred to strangers: this indeed he does in this order. First indeed is indicated the transfer of hoarded riches: second, the detestation of miserliness, at: "If anyone should beget," etc.; third is subjoined the reason for the detestation, at: "In vain therefore he came," etc.
First therefore Ecclesiastes considered the vanity attending the rich and proposes it, assumes it, and concludes. He proposes, saying: "There is also another evil, which I saw under the sun:" and he aggravates it from the circumstance: "And which is frequent among men," that is, among the weak lovers of the world and the rich, of whom the Psalm says: "O sons of men, how long will you be heavy of heart? Why do you love vanity and seek after falsehood?" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he assumes the vanity, which is observed in this, that one hoards riches and another devours them: therefore he says: "A man, to whom God has given riches," as regards movable goods; "and wealth," as regards immovable goods; "and honors," as regards exalted things. For all things are from God: riches are from God: Proverbs 3: "Length of days is in her right hand, and in her left hand riches and glory." And wealth is from God, especially that of which Sirach 13 says: "Good is the wealth for which there is no sin on the conscience." Likewise honor is from God: whence in Daniel 5, Daniel said to Belshazzar: "O king! The Most High God gave kingdom and magnificence and honor to your father." And to complete the perfect abundance of the goods of fortune, he subjoins: "And nothing is lacking to his soul of all that he desires," because he has sufficiently. He calls soul here the carnal life, of which John 12 says: "He who loves his soul shall lose it." Thus he has abundance for possessing, and yet he has avarice for retaining, which takes away from him the power of enjoying: therefore he subjoins: "Nor does God grant him the power to eat of it," because he continually hoards it, and in vain: whence Sirach 14: "For the covetous and miserly man, wealth is without purpose; and for the envious man, of what use is gold?" Neither does he himself use it, nor his posterity, but strangers: whence he adds: "But a stranger shall devour it:" whence Sirach 14: "He who heaps up unjustly from his own soul gathers for others, and another shall revel in his goods"; and Proverbs 13: "The wealth of the sinner is stored up for the just." And from this he infers vanity: "And this is vanity and a great misery:" vanity, because he himself does not rejoice; misery, because, when another takes it away, he is grieved: Isaiah 1: "Your land — strangers devour it before your face," etc.
There is a question concerning what he says: "God did not give him the power to enjoy good things."
To the contrary: This is free will; but He gave free will; therefore also the power.
I respond: it must be said that he has the capacity for enjoying, namely by which he can enjoy; but by the just judgment of God he is impeded by some punishment, because he has incurred superfluous anxiety and fear and sorrow. And because power denotes an unimpeded capacity, and this has been impeded by just judgment, therefore, etc.
Likewise, there is a question concerning what he says, that "nothing is lacking to his soul of all that it desires."
To the contrary: Above in the fifth chapter: "The covetous man shall not be filled with money;" and again Jerome: "The miser lacks both what he has and what he does not have." Therefore he speaks poorly when he says: "And nothing is lacking."
I respond: it must be said that for something to be lacking, this can be in two ways: either with respect to sufficiency according to reality and nature, or according to opinion. I say therefore that a miser can indeed be so wealthy that nothing is lacking to him according to reality and nature; but nevertheless never so wealthy that something is not lacking to him according to his own estimation, because he always desires to have more, and thus it is lacking to him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"If anyone should beget" etc. Here is noted the detestation of miserliness by reason of the aforementioned transfer, and he reproves miserliness itself, however much successive prosperity he may have. Therefore he adds: "If anyone should beget a hundred children," this is said hyperbolically, that is, many children, because the wicked frequently beget wicked children, in whom there is no joy, even if they are many: Sirach 16: "Do not rejoice in ungodly children; if they are multiplied, do not delight in them." To abound in children is temporal prosperity; and another temporal prosperity follows: "And should live many years," that is, for many years; "and should have more days of age," namely more than other men; and this indeed is temporal prosperity. The impious frequently have this prosperity; whence below in chapter seven: "For a long time the impious man lives in his impiety," if he has abounded in these prosperities. "And his soul does not enjoy the goods of his substance," that is, he has been miserly and greedy in life; "and lacks burial" in death, according to what is said of Joachim in Jeremiah chapter twenty-two: "Joachim shall be buried with the burial of an ass, rotting and cast forth beyond the gates of Jerusalem."
With these conditions of prosperity and miserliness having been set forth, he subjoins the detestation: "Concerning this I pronounce," as a judge of the earth, "that an abortive is better than he," on account of the great misery and vanity which the abortive lacks; whence it is said in Job chapter three: "Why did I not die in the womb? Why, having come forth from the womb, did I not immediately perish? Why was I received upon the knees? Why was I suckled at the breasts?" And again in chapter ten: "Why did you bring me forth from the womb?"
Likewise, concerning this it is asked why he prefers the stillborn to him. It seems that this is wrong:
1. Because the stillborn had knowledge of no things, but this man did; likewise, the miser, when he sins mortally, enjoys things that are meant to be used.
2. Likewise, how does he say that it did not know the difference between good and evil, unless it had fully enjoyed goods? Therefore it seems that the stillborn would be better than all who do not delight in present goods and who are not carnal: but this is heretical.
I respond: it must be said that according to that approach, if this is said in the person of the carnal man, the response is easy; maintaining nevertheless that he says this according to truth, I say that he prefers the stillborn to such a grasping rich man, because the former, although it did not experience goods, nevertheless did not endure evils; but the latter endured evils and did not taste goods; therefore the former is preferable, and it is in this respect that he means it.
To the objection based on reason, that he did not fully enjoy goods: it must be said that to enjoy in one way denotes love of something with rest in it; in another way, rest and delight. I say therefore that he who loves God possesses Him, as Augustine says in the book of Eighty-Three Questions, and therefore he who loves God delights in Him. But money or a temporal thing, when it is loved and not possessed according to one's desire, begets sorrow. Therefore there can be enjoyment of these things, that is, supreme love, and yet slight delight and great sorrow. Therefore it does not follow that, although such a miser sins, he rests in delight; but nevertheless he rests in love, because he loves for his own sake.
To the objection that it did not know the difference: it must be said that by simple knowledge, he who always has goods knows good and evil; similarly also he who always has evils; but not by knowledge of experience, unless he has both goods and evils. And because such a one always has evils, never goods; therefore, etc.
To the objection concerning the spiritual man, I say that he is not without spiritual delight, and therefore he sees the sun and knows the difference. But the grasping miser, because he is a sinner, does not have spiritual delight; because he is grasping, he does not have carnal delight; and therefore he does not know the difference between good and evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"For he comes in vain" etc. Here is subjoined thirdly the reason for the detestation, namely that an abortive is better than one who is miserly in this manner, because, just as an abortive comes in vain and goes to darkness, since it immediately dies, so also does he; therefore it is said: "For he comes in vain and goes to darkness," namely the miser himself: Job chapter three: "To a man whose way is hidden, and whom God has surrounded with darkness." And that in vain such a greedy and miserly man should come into this world, he shows both on account of the deletion of his name in death, and on account of the inexperience of good in life, and on account of the non-fulfillment of desire in both states. On account of the deletion of his name he says: "And his name shall be blotted out by oblivion," that is, he shall endure neither in reality nor in name, according to what the Lord threatens against Babylon in Isaiah chapter fourteen: "I will destroy the name and remnants and offspring and posterity of Babylon, says the Lord"; and in Wisdom chapter two, in the person of the wicked: "Our name shall receive oblivion in time, and no one shall be mindful of our works."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On account of the inexperience of good, he adds: "he does not see the sun," in which namely there is delight and experience of good, according to what is said below in the eleventh chapter: "The light is sweet, and it is delightful for the eyes to see the sun." The avaricious man has not seen this, because he errs: Wisdom 5: "We have erred from the way of truth, and the light of justice has not shone upon us, and the sun of understanding has not risen upon us," etc. And thus he has not seen the sun, that is, he has not had the light of knowledge; nor has he known the difference between good and evil, because namely he has not experienced it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore he says: "Even if he should live two thousand years," because we do not have knowledge through length of time, but through experience: Sirach 34: "He who has not been tested knows few things," according to what the Philosopher says: "Experience produced art, inexperience produced chance." On account of the incompleteness of desire, he adds: "Do not all things hasten to one place?" As if to say: on the part of the body, they will pass into the earth; Sirach 41: "All things that are made from the earth shall be converted into earth"; and above in the third chapter: "All things are subject to vanity, and all things go to one place." On the part of the body, therefore, there is reduction to ashes, but on the part of the soul, there is the incompleteness of its desire.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For this reason he says: "All the labor of man is in his mouth:" the mouth is called the initiation of desire; for he who desires, as it were, opens his mouth. Therefore, for labor to be in the mouth is to labor toward the completion of desire; whence Proverbs 16: "The soul of the laborer labors for himself, because his mouth has compelled him." And although he does this toward fulfilling his desire, it is nevertheless not fulfilled; therefore he says: "But his soul," namely that of the tenacious rich man, "will not be filled with good things," as was said above in the fifth chapter: "The covetous man shall not be filled with money"; whence Habakkuk 2: "He has enlarged his soul like hell, and he himself like death shall not be filled." Thus it is true of the avaricious regarding money; so also regarding knowledge: 2 Timothy 3: "Always learning, and never arriving at the knowledge of the truth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"What more does he have" etc. He set forth above the remedy against the vanity of malice and against the vanity of avarice: here thirdly he sets forth the remedy against the vanity of imprudence. Against this, however, the supreme remedy is the acquisition of wisdom; and because no one can acquire wisdom unless he has the proper method of learning: therefore this part has two sections. In the first he gives the method, in the second he unfolds the teachings of wisdom, at the passage: "Better is a good name" etc.
First the method of acquiring wisdom is explained by a threefold reasoning.
The method of considering or learning for one who wishes to be wise is handed down in this way. First, that he should learn useful things: second, that he should leave aside hidden things: third, that he should not inquire into lofty things.
First therefore he teaches to seek and consider useful things, and this is, how one may arrive at the life of glory. Therefore he asks: "What more does the wise man have than the fool, and what does the poor man?" He rightly joins these two: poor and wise. For one is called poor through contempt of present things: whence Matthew 5: "Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven"; wise, through the savor of eternal things and right estimation: concerning which Proverbs 3: "The wise shall possess glory: the exaltation of fools is disgrace." But the fool is called the worldly man, who on the contrary, despising eternal things, gapes after earthly things: concerning whom Job 5: "I saw the fool with a firm root, and I cursed his beauty at once." "What more does the wise and poor man have than the fool" in this life? supply: little. "Except that he may go there, where life is," namely eternal life, to which man ought to aspire, not to temporal things, which cannot be held: on account of which he has little here in mortal life, because "the learned dies equally with the unlearned," above in chapter two: but in eternal life he has much more, because he will obtain delightful, abundant, secure being, all things in the open vision and enjoyment of the highest good: concerning which life John 17: "This is eternal life, that they may know you, the only true God" etc. To this life the wise proceed, because they direct their eyes toward it, as is said above in chapter two: "The eyes of the wise man are in his head"; and therefore he follows Christ, the light, who, as is said in John 14, is "the way, the truth, and the life": but the fool does not proceed: whence below in chapter ten: "The labor of fools shall afflict them, because they do not know how to go to the city."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To this life one cannot rightly arrive without knowledge: therefore he adds: "It is better to see what you desire," that is, to know the life which you long for: "than to desire what you do not know," that is, to wish to arrive there in ignorance: and therefore one ought to direct one's consideration toward it: Proverbs 4: "Let your eyes look upon what is right, and let your eyelids go before your steps." And indeed this is good to know, but to desire what one does not know is foolish. Therefore he adds: "But this also is vanity and presumption of spirit," namely, to desire what man does not know, just as James and John desired and asked to sit at the right hand, and sought presumptuously: therefore it is said to them in Matthew 20: "You do not know what you ask."
It can also be expounded as a commendation of the knowledge of useful things, so that the sense is that it is better to know desirable and useful things than to desire to know hidden things, which indeed he forbids to consider, because this is presumption of spirit, namely, to wish to know what God has disposed in his providence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is asked concerning what he says: "It is better to see what you desire than to desire what you do not know." Therefore it does not involve a contradiction that someone can desire what he does not know.
On the contrary: Augustine says that "we can love things unseen, but things unknown in no way"; thus therefore, in order for something to be loved and desired, it is necessary that it be known. Furthermore, the affection follows the intellect; therefore where the intellect does not precede, the affection does not extend itself; but the intellect does not extend itself to those things which it does not know; therefore neither does the affection desire those things.
I respond: it must be said that there is a twofold knowledge, namely of certitude and of estimation; and so correspondingly there is a twofold ignorance: one through the privation of any certitude, and another through the privation of any estimation. I say therefore that in order for something to be desired, it is not necessary that knowledge of certitude precede: for desire follows estimation alone; but it is necessary that some knowledge of estimation precede. Here, however, he speaks of ignorance through the privation of certitude.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And indeed he forbids to scrutinize this, consequently saying: "He who is to be" etc. Here he calls back from scrutinizing hidden things, such as the divine disposition: on account of which he says: "He who is to be, his name has already been called," with respect to eternal election; Romans 4: "Who calls those things which are not, as though they were." "And it is known that he is man," with respect to the smallness of the duration of life: Genesis 3: "Dust you are, and to dust you shall return." "And he cannot contend in judgment against one stronger than himself," with respect to the condition of justice: for no one is so just that he can justify himself in judgment with God: Job 9: "I know that man is not justified when compared to God. If he should wish to contend with God, he cannot answer him one for a thousand"; therefore Job said: "How great then am I, that I should answer him"; and therefore it is added: because "stronger:" whence Job 9: "If strength is sought, he is most mighty; if equity of judgment, no one dares to bear witness for me." Therefore this hidden disposition is said not to be scrutinized by us; because in our words little truth is found, especially when we wish to discuss those things which are hidden from us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore he adds: "Words are very many," that is, few things are known: below, chapter 10: "The fool multiplies words." "And having much vanity in disputing," and little truth, above, chapter 3: "He has delivered the world to their disputation, so that man may not find the work which God has wrought from the beginning even to the end"; and therefore those who wish to scrutinize these things become vain, according to that word of the Apostle in First Corinthians 3: "God knows the thoughts of the wise, that they are vain."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here he calls back a third time from scrutinizing lofty things and inquiring into them, and this, since he has enough to do in knowing his own evils, or common ones. Therefore he says: "What need is there for a man to seek things greater than himself?" as if to say, there is no need: Sirach 3: "Seek not the things that are too high for thee, and search not into things above thy strength"; and Romans 11: "Be not high-minded, but fear." And he adds the reason why he ought not to seek greater things: "Since he does not know what is profitable for him in his life," that is, what is useful for him: Wisdom 9: "We can hardly guess at the things that are upon earth, and with labor do we find the things that are before us. But the things that are in heaven, who shall search out?" He is indeed ignorant of what is useful in this momentary life; whence he adds: "In the number of the days of his pilgrimage"; Genesis 47: "The days of the pilgrimage of my life are few and evil"; 2 Corinthians 5: "While we are in this body, we are pilgrims from the Lord." "And in the time which passes like a shadow"; 1 Chronicles, last chapter: "We are pilgrims before thee and strangers, as were all our fathers. Our days upon earth are as a shadow, and there is no delay." And so he cannot inquire by himself, nor even learn from another; therefore he adds: "Or who can tell him what shall come after him under the sun?" For man does not know future things, unless the Lord reveals them through grace. Therefore man ought not to extend his thought to this: Isaiah 48: "Before the day thou heardest them not, lest perhaps thou shouldst say: Behold, I knew them. Thou hast neither heard nor known, neither was thine ear opened from that time"; below in chapter 8: "Man is ignorant of things past, and things to come he can know by no messenger." Whence God alone knows and reveals future things.
The question is raised concerning what he says: "What need is there for a man to seek things greater than himself?" From this it seems that man ought not to investigate anything nor come to know by labor what is above him. This same point is proved by Ecclesiasticus 3: "Seek not things that are higher than yourself." Likewise, Romans 11: "Be not high-minded, but fear."
But to the contrary: Man stands in the middle between visible creatures and God; but Augustine says that the soul of man is darkened when it fixes its eye on these earthly and lowest things, but is illuminated when it turns to eternal goods: therefore it ought always to seek those things. But those things are higher: therefore, etc. Furthermore, the soul is never perfected with complete perfection except in those things which are higher than itself; but everything perfectible ought to tend toward and seek that in which it is perfected: therefore it ought to seek higher things.
If you say that he does not mean that one ought not to seek or consider things higher according to substance, but that one ought not to consider those things which exceed the possibility of one's consideration, it is objected then: because all things that belong to faith are above our intellect: therefore according to this our intellect ought not to raise itself to believing those things which belong to faith. Likewise, then those who wish to examine the articles of faith would be most blameworthy: therefore all who dispute about faith would be blameworthy.
I respond: it must be said that emphasis should be placed on what he says, "greater than himself," and on what he says, "to seek." "Greater than himself" he calls those things which exceed our consideration, insofar as they exceed it. "To seek" he calls to inquire into and examine, as if to say that it is foolish to wish to investigate those things which our inquiry cannot reach, with respect to those things for which our consideration does not suffice. For there are some things which are manifest to us concerning God, and those are not greater than us: hence he does not discourage the consideration of God. As to the objection concerning faith, it must be said that he does not dissuade from believing, but from seeking. Furthermore, even though the things of faith are above our intellect by itself when bare, they are nevertheless not above the intellect illuminated by the grace of faith: hence to seek those things and to believe and to investigate up to that point to which the light of faith extends is not to extend oneself to greater things; and such is every sober disputation concerning the articles themselves. But if one exceeds this, unless it be from God, then such excess is blameworthy.
The question is also raised concerning what he says: "Who can show him what shall come after him under the sun?" To the contrary: In our soul there is a power which is "to become all things" and "to make all things"; but the possible intellect can receive in itself all present things, all past things, and all future things: therefore if the agent intellect can reduce it to act, then man can of himself know future things.
I respond: it must be said that even if the agent can form or abstract cognition in the possible intellect, nevertheless its operation depends both on the certitude of the thing outside and internally on sense; because "when the thing is lacking, knowledge perishes"; and "when a sense is lacking, it is necessary that one science be lacking according to that sense." Because therefore future contingents do not generate a likeness of themselves in sense, neither through themselves nor through a determinate antecedent cause: and they do not have in themselves the stability that is required for cognition: therefore our intellect, which receives from things, cannot of itself come to the cognition of them, except through him whose cognition does not depend on things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The teachings of wisdom are set forth, through which a remedy is applied against the vanity of foolishness. And since, as is said in Wisdom 8, "wisdom teaches sobriety, prudence, justice, and virtue" or fortitude: in the first he sets forth teachings for having modesty: in the second, for having constancy; in the third, for having prudence; in the fourth, for having justice. For having modesty he provides five teachings. In the first he teaches to prefer the honorable to the pleasant: in the second, future life to the present: in the third, affliction to pleasure: in the fourth, sorrow to merriment: in the fifth, severity to softness or flattery.
He therefore sets forth the teaching in which he teaches to prefer the honorable, such as a good name, to the pleasant, such as ointment: therefore he says: "A good name is better," that is, a good reputation displayed by good men, concerning which Sirach 41: "Have care for a good name, for this shall remain with you more than a thousand precious and great treasures." "Than precious ointments," which indeed are very fragrant, according to what is said in John 12: "Mary took a pound of ointment of precious spikenard and anointed the feet of Jesus: and the house was filled with the odor of the ointment"; and although ointments are fragrant, nevertheless a good name is more so, therefore it is better: 2 Corinthians 2: "We are the good odor of Christ unto God in every place," namely as regards good reputation.
Here the second teaching is noted, in which he prefers future life to the present, and thus entrance into another life to entrance into this one. And therefore he says: "And the day of death," supply: is better "than the day of birth," because one dies to rest; Revelation 14: "Blessed are the dead who die in the Lord: henceforth, says the Spirit, that they may rest from their labors." But here one is born to labor: Job 5: "Man is born to labor, and a bird to flight"; and therefore death is better: whence Sirach 30: "Death is better than a bitter life, and eternal rest than persevering illness."
It is asked concerning what is said: "The day of death is better than the day of birth." On the contrary: Death is a privation, life is a possession; but a possession always has more of entity and goodness than a privation; therefore life is better than death; therefore the day of birth is better. Furthermore, it is a rule that "that whose corruption is good, its generation is bad." But death is the corruption of life; therefore that whose death is good, its life is bad. But the life of none is bad except a sinner's; therefore the death of none is better than life except a sinner's. But this is false, because a sinner by dying tends toward hell.
I respond: it must be said that something is preferred to another sometimes by reason of itself, sometimes by reason of what follows upon it. That is to be preferred to another by reason of itself which of itself bespeaks more of good, just as a man is better than a horse. In another way, by reason of what follows, and thus death is preferred to life, and that dissolution, namely death, upon which follows rest and being with Christ. And of this death he speaks here, because in life man is in danger, in labor and sorrow; after death he is immediately in joy, security, and tranquility. And the response to the first objection is clear, because death is not preferred by reason of itself. What is objected in the second place can be solved similarly. For death is said to be bad in two ways: either because it takes away a great good, namely the good life, as a good both true and useful; or because it leads to a bad end. In the first way the death of the just is bad, that is, harmful; but in the second way it is exceedingly good, and in this respect it is preferred.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"It is better to go to the house of mourning," where sins are mourned, because Matthew 5: "Blessed are those who mourn, for they shall be consoled"; "than to the house of feasting," where delights are found: Proverbs 23: "Do not be among the banquets of drunkards." And the reason for this is: because in banquets man forgets himself, in the house of mourning he remembers his judgment: and therefore he adds: "For in that," namely in the house of mourning, "the end of all men is brought to mind": Sirach 38: "Remember my judgment: for yours also shall be so. For me it is today, for you it shall be tomorrow." "And the living considers what shall come to pass." And this is most useful: whence Sirach 7: "Remember your last things, and you shall never sin"; and therefore it is said in Sirach 38: "Remember the last things and forget malice," because, as Jerome says, "he easily despises all things who always considers that he is going to die."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here he prefers sadness to merriment: because the former, namely sadness, corrects, and merriment deceives. And therefore he says: "Anger is better than laughter," anger namely, by which one is angered at the sins of others: Hebrews 12: "He scourges every son whom he receives"; and Revelation 3: "Those whom I love, I rebuke and chastise." This anger is better than the laughter of dissimulation: Sirach 30: "Play with your son, and he will bring you sorrow": and therefore: "Anger is better." And the reason is given: "Because by the sadness of the countenance the mind of the offender is corrected": Proverbs 25: "The north wind drives away rain, and a sad countenance a backbiting tongue."
It is asked concerning what he says: "Anger is better than laughter." On the contrary: Matthew 5: "Whoever is angry with his brother shall be liable to judgment": but whoever derides is not liable to any punishment: therefore it is worse to be angry than to laugh. Likewise, to laugh can be without fault: but to be angry, since it implies a disturbance of reason, is scarcely without venial fault, and is never without punishment: therefore it is far worse than laughter.
I respond: it must be said that there is to be angry at vice and to be angry by nature: the first is of virtue and good, the second of vice and evil. Similarly, there is to smile at the good and to deride sin: the first is good; the second, evil. And he speaks of anger and laughter insofar as evil is in view. But then similarly he could give another rule with respect to the good: laughter is better than anger. And it must be said that in the present life there are more evils than goods: therefore more people ought to grieve than to rejoice; therefore he prefers anger to laughter.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he confirms this lesson by the judgment of the wise: whence he says: "The heart of the wise is where sadness is": but on the contrary: "The heart of fools is where merriment is": the former seek sorrowful things in the present, the latter pleasant things: John 16: "You shall weep and lament, but the world shall rejoice." And that the former act wisely, and the latter foolishly, is clear from the outcome, because it is said to the sorrowful in Luke 6: "Blessed are you who weep now, for you shall laugh"; and on the contrary to those who rejoice: "Woe to you who laugh, for you shall weep."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"It is better to be corrected by a wise man than to be deceived by the flattery of fools." A fool, when he is corrected, does not withdraw from evil nor is he led to good. He who recognizes his faults, and they displease him, is wise. He who rebukes a person and calls him back from evil renders him a greater service than if he gave him the whole world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here is noted the fifth lesson, by which severity is preferred to softness, as for example harsh rebuke to flattery. On account of which he says: "It is better to be rebuked by a wise man than to be deceived by the flattery of fools." Proverbs 27: "Open rebuke is better than hidden love," because rebuke directs, but flattery deceives. Proverbs 16: "A wicked man entices his friend and leads him by a way that is not good." And Isaiah 3: "O my people, those who call you blessed, they themselves deceive you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he gives the reason by a similitude: because the flattery of a fool lasts but a short time and makes much noise, like thorns kindled under a pot. Therefore he says: "For as the crackling of thorns under a pot," it sounds loudly, "so is the laughter of a fool." Literally, a fool laughs loudly. Ecclesiasticus 21: "A fool lifts up his voice in laughter, but a wise man will scarcely laugh quietly." Or: loud laughter is when flattery is clamorous. Proverbs 27: "He who blesses his neighbor with a loud voice, rising early in the morning, shall be like one who curses." "But this also is vanity," namely such flattery. In the Psalm: "Vain are the sons of men, liars are the sons of men."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Instructions are set forth for having constancy: and since constancy is lost through oppression and through wrath, and is preserved through patience and through perseverance: therefore four instructions are set forth here. In the first is shown that oppression is to be avoided: in the second, that perseverance is to be loved: in the third, that patience is to be preserved: in the fourth, that wrath is to be fled.
In the first instruction, therefore, he shows that oppression is to be avoided, because by disturbing a man it renders him inconstant. For this reason he says: "Oppression disturbs the wise man." Oppression is a litigious accusation, and therefore one must withdraw from it; Isaiah 54: "Withdraw far from oppression, for you shall not fear." "And it shall destroy the strength of his heart," that is, the fortitude of charity: Matthew 24: "Because iniquity shall abound, the charity of many shall grow cold."
But there is a doubt about what he says: "Oppression disturbs the wise man." To the contrary: "Whatever happens shall not grieve the just man," as is held in Proverbs 12: therefore if the wise man is just, he is not disturbed by oppression. To this it is answered in one way, that there is a disturbance of impatience, and by this the just man is not disturbed: and of compassion, and by this he is disturbed, just as the Apostle said in 2 Corinthians 11: "Who is scandalized, and I am not on fire?" as if to say: no one. But the following text removes this exposition and adds: "And it will destroy the strength of his heart." Therefore it must be resolved, as is said in the Gloss, that there is a wise and just man who is perfect, and of him that passage in Proverbs is understood: and one who is imperfect, and of him this passage here is understood.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third middle way is fortitude, which is concerned with fears and acts of valor. A man needs it in order to be neither fainthearted nor rash, but that he be able to bear frightful trials and even death. For some men do fall into cowardice and faintheartedness. Hence, in Job: "Have I the strength of stones, or is my flesh of bronze?" And so, fortitude is in the soul, not in the flesh. Better is the patient spirit than the lofty spirit. And Proverbs say: A patient man is better than a warrior, and he that rules his temper, than he who takes a city. Hence a spiritual man must take great care to avoid dejection.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here the second instruction is noted, in which perseverance is preferred to justice merely begun. On account of this he says: "Better is the end of a speech than its beginning": it is better to persevere in good than merely to begin: Matthew 10: "He who shall persevere to the end, he shall be saved"; whence Bernard says: "Perseverance is the consummation of all virtues."
Here the third lesson is noted, in which patience is commended, because without it there cannot be constancy; therefore he says: "Better is the patient one than the arrogant": the comparison is improper, because the patient one is good, but the arrogant one is evil: Proverbs 16: "Better is the patient man than the mighty."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here the fourth lesson is touched upon, in which it is taught that anger is to be fled, because it does not stand well with constancy; therefore he says: "Be not swift to anger": James 1: "Let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, and slow to wrath." And the reason is added: "Because anger rests in the bosom of a fool"; Job 5: "Wrath kills the foolish man, and envy slays the little one." He well says "rests," on account of its duration: for the wise man, even if he grows angry, ought not to preserve it long: Ephesians 4: "Let not the sun go down upon your wrath": but not so the fool: Proverbs 27: "Heavy is the sand" in the bosom of the fool.
Likewise, what is it that he says here: "Be not swift to anger?" To the contrary: In the Psalm: "Be angry, and do not sin." I respond: it must be said that anger is manifold.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Having set down the lessons for modesty and constancy, here he sets down lessons for having prudence. And because it belongs to the prudent man to discern where one may err: therefore he sets down four lessons for having discretion. The first is for the discernment of useful things: the second, for the discernment of the divine works: the third, for the discernment of times: the fourth, for the discernment of the merits of men.
The first instruction, therefore, was given for the discernment of useful things: for in different times there are different advantages arising from different causes. Therefore he says: "Do not say: What do you think is the reason that former times," that is, of the ancients, "were better?" because, namely, in them there was want: "than they now are," when, namely, there is already an abundance of things: because this question arises from thoughtlessness: whence he adds: "For such an inquiry is foolish."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the reason for this is: because he does not consider the usefulness of wealth, therefore he teaches how to discern it, saying: "Wisdom is more useful with riches," because Proverbs 13: "The riches of a man are the redemption of his soul." "And it profits more those who see the sun," that is, those who have a right intention: because Sirach 13: "Good is substance where there is no sin on the conscience, and most wicked is poverty in the mouth of the ungodly."
It is asked concerning what he says: "Wisdom is more useful with riches." Therefore it is better to be a rich wise man than a poor wise man: therefore to be poor is not a more perfect state. Furthermore, "art and virtue concern difficult things"; but it is more difficult for a rich man to be saved than a poor man: therefore it is of greater virtue: therefore a more praiseworthy state. Against this is: because the Lord set the state of the poor man above both by deed and by word, Matthew 19.
I respond: it must be said that poverty is threefold: one from delight, another from endurance, another with impatience. The first is good and perfect, the second is imperfect, the third is blameworthy: Ecclesiasticus 13: "Most wretched is poverty in the mouth of the ungodly." When it is said that wisdom is better with riches than without, this is understood concerning poverty that is with endurance or impatience. To the objection about difficulty, it must be said that there is difficulty by reason of the kind of work, and this contributes to greater virtue; and there is difficulty by reason of the disorder of the will, just as the miser gives a gift with more difficulty than the generous person, and this counts for nothing; and so the rich person is saved with more difficulty. It is solved otherwise: because it is understood concerning superfluity and excessive want.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Furthermore, Ecclesiastes seven: Wisdom is more useful with riches: Gloss: "than alone"; but riches do not make a man perfect: therefore much less do poverty and want.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And that money is useful, he shows through its effect: "For as wisdom protects," namely from fault: Proverbs 2: "If wisdom shall enter your heart, and knowledge shall please your soul, counsel shall keep you, and prudence shall preserve you"; "so also does money protect," namely when well spent: Sirach 29: "The alms of a man is as a purse with him, and shall preserve the grace of a man as the apple of the eye." And although both are useful, yet wisdom is more useful: therefore he adds: "But wisdom and learning have this advantage besides, that they give life to their possessor": whence Proverbs 4: "Hear, my son, and receive my words, that the years of life may be multiplied to you": and Proverbs 3: "Wisdom is a tree of life to those who lay hold of her." But money without wisdom bestows death: James 5: "Come now, you rich, weep and howl in your miseries." And therefore wisdom is to be preferred to money: Proverbs 8: "Receive wisdom and not money; choose instruction rather than gold."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This is the second instruction, in which he teaches the discreet consideration of the divine works or judgments, because him whom He despises by the sign of reprobation, no one can bring back. Therefore he says: "Consider the works of God," that is, the divine judgments, "that no one can correct him whom He has despised," that is, whom He Himself has willed to visit by His own judgment. Whence it is said in 1 Kings 2 concerning the sons of Eli: "And they did not hear the voice of their father, because the Lord willed to slay them." These works and judgments are to be considered unto fear: Habakkuk 3: "I considered your works and was afraid."
It is asked concerning what he says: "That no one can correct him whom God has despised." But God despises every sinner, because "the Most High hates sinners," Ecclesiasticus 12; and: "Likewise the ungodly and his ungodliness are abominable to God." Likewise, if he cannot be corrected, then neither can he be saved: therefore it ought not to be imputed to him.
I respond: it must be said that just as love is twofold, namely eternal and according to present justice, so the despising of men is twofold: and he speaks here not of just any man, but of the reprobate, nor of just any despising, but of despising according to eternal reprobation, the sign of which is hardening in the present; and thus it does not apply to every sinner, but to the reprobate. To the objection that it ought not be imputed to him: it must be said that on the contrary it should, because God despises no one without cause. Whence also, although he cannot rise unless God extends His hand, nevertheless he is not excused, because it is his own fault that the hand is not extended to him. Whence Augustine says in the book On Correction and Grace that no one is corrected except willingly.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This is the third instruction, in which he teaches that discretion must be exercised regarding times: because God did not make all times uniformly, but diversely, and man ought to dispose himself according to the diverse times. Therefore he says: "In the good day, enjoy good things," that is, work good with joy: Ecclesiasticus 14: "Do not defraud yourself of a good day, and let not a portion of a good day pass you by," because in this day there is place and time for working. Whence John 9: "I must work while it is day"; similarly also we, whence the Apostle to the Galatians, last chapter: "Let us work good toward all, while we have time." "And guard against the evil day," namely that one of which Zephaniah 1 speaks: "A day of wrath, that day, a day of tribulation and distress, a day of calamity and misery." Whoever wishes to guard against this day must needs reflect upon that saying of Ecclesiasticus 11: "In the day of good things, be not unmindful of evil things." These days the Lord made and ordained in a just manner: therefore he says: "For as He made this one," that is the good, "so also that one," namely the evil, "God made": and this by just judgment: "So that man may not find just complaints against Him." Therefore He makes good things for the good, evil things against the evil, because in the Psalm: "The Lord is just in all His ways."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here is noted the fourth instruction, by which he teaches that diligent discretion must be exercised regarding merits, because they are very hidden. Therefore he says: "These things also I saw in the day of my birth," that is, after I was born, "I saw" this happen: "The just man perishes in his justice," because he is regarded as though he were impious: Isaiah 57: "The just man perishes, and no one considers it." "And the impious man lives a long time in his impiety," as if he were just: at which Jeremiah was indignant, chapter 12: "Why does the way of the impious prosper, it is well with all who transgress and act unjustly?" And below in chapter 8: "There are just men to whom evil things happen, as if they had done the works of the impious; and there are impious men who are so secure, as if they had the deeds of the just."
It is asked concerning what he says: "The just man perishes in his justice, and the wicked man lives a long time in his wickedness." But to the contrary: in the Psalm: "Men of blood and deceit shall not live out half their days." Likewise, concerning the good, Exodus 20: "Honor your father, that you may be long-lived upon the earth," and live a long time: therefore life is prolonged for one who observes the commandments.
I respond: it must be said that just as it is said in Wisdom 4 concerning the just man: "Being made perfect in a short time, he fulfilled a long time," and few days are reckoned as many; so conversely among the wicked, and likewise concerning the number of those to be saved and those to be damned: and the days of the good are longer because they are better, not because they live longer.
It should be noted, however, that the years of men are sometimes shortened lest they become evil: Wisdom 4: "He was taken away, lest wickedness should change his understanding"; sometimes lest they become worse: in the Psalm: "Men of blood and deceit shall not live out half their days." They are prolonged, however, for the purgation of the good: Sirach 2: "For gold is tested in fire"; for the wicked, for their correction: Romans 2: "Do you not know that the kindness of God leads you to repentance?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Above he set forth instructions for possessing modesty, constancy, and prudence; here in the fourth place he sets forth instructions for possessing justice: and because that is not true justice which exceeds in rigor and cruelty, but rather is to be scorned by piety: therefore he sets forth here four instructions. In the first he forbids the rigor of severity or the excess of justice: in the second, the headlong rush of impiety: in the third he commends the display of mercy: in the fourth, the overlooking of personal injury.
In the first instruction, therefore, he dissuades from excess of justice in punishing, when he says: "Be not just overmuch," that is, do not exceed in the rigor of justice, because it is a fault to prosecute every fault to its fullest: whence James 2: "Judgment without mercy shall be done to him who does not show mercy." Neither should you exceed in scrutinizing fault: therefore he says: "Neither be more wise than is necessary," because it is said in Proverbs 30: "He who blows the nose violently draws forth blood," therefore Romans 12: "Not to be wise beyond what is fitting to be wise, but to be wise unto sobriety."
It is asked concerning what he says: "Do not be excessively just." On the contrary: This is true per se: the just man is good, therefore the more just, the more good, therefore the most just, the most good: therefore in justice there is no excess. Likewise, whatever is said of God is said in the highest degree: but "just" is said of God: therefore God is supremely just. And it is evident that this is not evil: therefore if the summit of justice is not evil, therefore there is no excess therein.
I respond: it must be said that "just" in one way is the same as having such a virtue: and thus the increase of justice is measured by approach to the mean, and so there cannot be excess therein, because no one can be too virtuous nor approach the mean too closely. In another way "just" is said insofar as it names the act of that virtue, which is to punish: and thus its excess is not measured by approach to the mean, but rather to the extreme; then he is called "more just" who punishes more, and to punish in the highest degree is not good. And thus it is understood in the text. To the second objection, that whatever befits God is said in the highest degree: this is true of that which is said absolutely and which names after the manner of a habit: but that which denotes an effect is not said in the highest degree, just as God does not punish in the highest degree nor spare in the highest degree, but insofar as is fitting.
Likewise, there is a question about what is said: "Neither be more wise than is necessary." For he who loves more is more wise: but no one can love too much: therefore neither can one be too wise, insofar as love is referred to God. Furthermore, no one is too wise, therefore neither can anyone be so: therefore no one can be more wise than is necessary. But on the contrary: Virtue consists in the mean and is corrupted by excess just as by deficiency: therefore just as there can be sin in remitting too much, so also in punishing too much.
To the question about wisdom, it must be said that the habit of wisdom can in no way be excessive: but regarding the act, it should be noted that it is threefold, namely to taste, to know, and to investigate: to taste and to know no one can do too much, but to investigate thoroughly one certainly can do too much. And the reason for this is that excessive investigation leads to foolishness, but love cannot be excessive toward God, because He is to be loved in the highest degree.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here is noted the second instruction in which he forbids the headlong rush of impiety: for impiety renders a man stupefied in feeling and hardened. Therefore he says: "Be not stupefied": Jeremiah 31: "Everyone who eats a sour grape, his teeth shall be set on edge." It renders one cruel in deed: therefore he says: "Do not act impiously overmuch," that is, cruelly: Psalm: "I said to the wicked: Do not act wickedly": and Sirach 7: "Do not sow evil in the furrows of injustice, and you shall not reap it sevenfold." It also renders the intellect blind: therefore he says: "Be not foolish": Proverbs 24: "He who thinks to do evil shall be called a fool. The thought of the fool is sin." And because sin and folly hasten death: therefore the reason follows: "Lest you die before your time," that is, lest your death be hastened, because in the Psalm: "Men of blood and deceit shall not live out half their days": and again Luke 12: "Fool, this night they shall require your soul of you." The example of Dathan and Abiram, who went down alive into hell.
There is a question about what he says: "Do not be foolish, lest you die before your time." On the contrary: Job 14: "You have appointed his limits, which cannot be passed": therefore it seems that on account of goodness they cannot be increased: therefore neither on account of wickedness can they be diminished. If this is true, how does God promise long years in Scripture? Likewise, concerning Hezekiah, in 4 Kings 20, how did God add fifteen years to him? Likewise, He also shortens; in the Psalm: "Men of blood and deceit shall not live out half their days."
I respond: it must be said that to die in one's time is threefold: in one way, in the time of one's salvation, to which each person is ordained: thus all the good die in their time, and no wicked persons do, because they never arrive at this—I speak of those who are finally wicked. In the second way, to die in one's time, that is, by natural death, which indeed occurs through the consumption of the radical moisture, and thus the aged and decrepit die in their time. In the third way, to die in one's time is to die at the time predetermined for one by God, according to divine foreknowledge, which is never deceived. No one anticipates this, no one passes beyond it. In the first way, the wicked die in a time not their own; in the second way, both good and wicked who die by accidental death; in the third way, no one.
Therefore Ecclesiastes and Scripture speak here with regard to the first mode, but Job understands it with regard to the third. Similarly, concerning Hezekiah it is said that the Lord changed his counsel.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Let the fear of the Lord be with you, and do all things with diligence": as if to say: do not be sluggish or negligent, because it is written in Ecclesiastes: "He who fears God neglects nothing." If I believed that a thief was going to enter my chamber and carry off my treasure, I would not leave the window open. You must always fear God, because he who "keeps the whole law but offends in one point has become guilty of all."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here is noted the third instruction, in which he counsels the display of mercy: and he sets forth first the exhortation and then adds the reason. He exhorts, when he says: "It is good for you to support the just one," namely in justice: Proverbs 24: "Do not lie in wait nor seek wickedness in the house of the just, and do not lay waste to his rest"; because it is said in Proverbs 17: "It is not good to inflict harm upon the just, nor to strike the prince who judges rightly." Not only is the just one to be supported in a just cause, but also a hand is to be extended to him through almsgiving: whence he adds: "But also from him do not withdraw your hand": Sirach 12: "Do good to the just, and you will find great recompense: and if not from him, certainly from God." Having thus set forth the exhortation, he adds a threefold reason: and the first is the divine will, on account of which he says: "He who fears God neglects nothing," namely of those things which God wills to be done; Sirach 7: "Fear God with your whole soul, and purge yourself of your negligence with few."
Likewise, there is a question about what he says: "He who fears God neglects nothing." But whoever sins neglects something; therefore no one who sins fears God. But "there is no just person who does not sin"; therefore there is no just person who fears God. I respond: it must be said that negligence in one way implies contempt, and thus it is a mortal sin, and thus it is understood here; in another way, it implies any omission of circumstance whatsoever, and thus it is venial, and no one is without it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wisdom descends from above as a light to strengthen our operative power. "Wisdom has strengthened the wise man more than ten princes of the city." No sub-celestial power, neither earthly nor human, nor celestial or angelic, strengthens the soul as much as super-celestial wisdom. Whence in the book of Wisdom: "Wisdom entered into the soul of the servant of God and stood against kings. She gave him a strong contest, that he might overcome and know that wisdom is mightier than all things."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, the fruit of wisdom is born of the last four by contrast. Corresponding to this fruit, there are four acts, for wisdom is comforting, struggling, contemplating, and extolling. It comforts the good: "Wisdom is a better defense for the wise man than would be ten princes in the city." It is also struggling, against evil: "Better is wisdom than weapons of war." Again, Wisdom "gave him a strong conflict, that he might overcome and know that wisdom is mightier than all." It is also contemplating the Supreme Good: "For she is fairer than the sun." Wisdom makes the soul taste the Supreme Good and be united to it. It is also extolling God on account of all things. This fruit is united with glory: this is the work, this is the reward, this is the fruit, that we shall see, love, and praise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second reason is the dignity of the just, on account of which he says: "Wisdom has strengthened the wise man above ten princes of the city"; and so, Wisdom 6, "wisdom is better than strength, and a prudent man is better than a strong one."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third reason is human frailty, on account of which he says: "There is no just man on earth who does good and does not sin": and therefore one must have mercy on the sinner: Proverbs 24: "The just man falls seven times a day and rises again"; indeed, however perfect one may be, he sometimes sins: 1 John 1: "If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us."
Likewise, it is asked whether any just person can be without sin. That he cannot seems evident from what is said here and in 1 John 1: "If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves." That he can, however, seems evident from Job 17: "I have not sinned, and my eye dwells in bitterness." Likewise, if he cannot, and no one sins in that which he cannot avoid, therefore etc.
It must be said concerning sin that many are without mortal sin, but no one exercising free will is without venial sin except Christ, and this we also believe of the most blessed Virgin. To what is objected from Job, I respond: he does not deny that he sinned, but that he sinned so as to be punished in this way. Similarly, the heart reproves when sin has given pleasure; but when one does what one did not will, even if one sinned, the heart does not reprove. As to what is said about the impossibility of avoiding sin, it must be said that man has been brought to this by vice, and therefore he is not excused from sinning in some way. Furthermore, even if he cannot avoid it universally, he can nevertheless avoid any particular sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here the fourth instruction is touched upon, in which he exhorts to the overlooking of one's own injury: whence one ought not to inquire nor believe every one who reports. Therefore he says: "But also to all the words that are spoken, do not apply your heart," that is, do not give credence, because little trust is to be placed in words, since many speak much: because, Sirach 19, "he who believes quickly is light of heart"; and because it is difficult to hear and not believe: Sirach 28: "Hedge your ears with thorns, and do not listen to a wicked tongue"; whence one ought not to be anxious to hear what is said about oneself. And the reason is given: "Lest perhaps you hear your servant cursing you": just as Shimei cursed David, 2 Kings 16: whence Abishai says: "Why does this most wretched dog curse my lord the king? I will go and cut off his head."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And this indeed often happens, as a man can know from himself: "For your conscience knows that you have frequently cursed others," and so you ought not diligently heed nor punish: Sirach 31: "Know the things of your neighbor from yourself." And again, forgive: for as it is said in Matthew 18: "Ought you not then also to have had mercy on your fellow servant, as I also had mercy on you?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This wisdom is spread out among all things. For everything possesses a rule of wisdom and displays divine wisdom by reason of some characteristic; and the man who would know all characteristics would clearly see this wisdom. And it is to this study that the philosophers gave themselves, and Solomon himself. And so he speaks to himself, saying: "I will acquire wisdom"; but it was "beyond me." For when anyone, out of idle curiosity over creatures, gives himself to the search for this wisdom, it eludes him more than ever.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Above he treated the vanity of mutability and iniquity; in this part he intends to treat the vanity of penality. And because punishment is twofold: one kind, which is the occasion of sin, such as concupiscence; another kind, which is pure affliction, such as death and bodily infirmity: therefore he first treats the first penality, which is the occasion of sin. And because the vanity of the proneness of concupiscence is perilous, nor is anyone freed except by the aid of divine wisdom: therefore first the discovery of concupiscence is noted; second, the remedy of wisdom is subjoined.
The diligent inquiry into concupiscence, which was so diligent that it degenerated into curiosity, is described according to three aspects: the curiosity of his presumption, the loftiness of his inquiry, and the studiousness of his consideration. Therefore, as regards the curiosity of his presumption, he says: "I have tried all things in wisdom," that is, in inquiry—behold, the inquiry of curiosity: Ecclesiasticus 3: "Be not curious in many of his works." "I said: I shall become wise," behold, the elation of presumption: Isaiah 5: "Woe to you who are wise in your own eyes"; and 1 Corinthians 3: "If any of you seems to be wise in this world, let him become a fool, that he may be wise."
One may raise a doubt concerning what he says here: "I tried all things in wisdom": whether in this he was blameworthy. That he was, it seems from the text itself: "I said: I shall become wise, and it withdrew further from me." Likewise, from what is said in Ecclesiasticus 3: "Do not be curious about his many works." To the contrary: "The spiritual man judges all things, and he himself is judged by no one": therefore if Solomon had the spirit of wisdom, then it was his to judge concerning all things. Furthermore, in the last chapter of 1 Thessalonians the Apostle says: "Test all things: hold fast what is good": therefore it is good to test all things.
I respond: it must be said that to test something is twofold: in one way, to know through experience, as one knows and tests wine that one tastes; in another way, through examination and approval and disapproval. In the first way, only useful things are to be tested; but if one wishes to test more things, it is curiosity. But insofar as to test is the same as to examine, so Paul takes to prove, and thus all things are to be examined, not only good and useful things, but also useless things. Thus it is said that "the spiritual man judges all things": thus also it is said: "test all things," that is: examine all things, whether good or bad in our works, concerning which we can doubt; but in the works of God, concerning which we ought to suppose that they are well made, it is curiosity to prove or examine. Since therefore Solomon extended his examination beyond those things which pertain to salvation, therefore it was curiosity, and this must be conceded. Those two authorities are understood concerning those things which pertain to salvation and belong to oneself, but Solomon went beyond.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the depth of faith, there is in Ecclesiastes: "What exists is far-reaching: it is deep, very deep: who can find it out?" That is, by means of reason. For it goes beyond our powers of investigation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The man goes down to the sea in ships who approaches the Scriptures in a spirit of extreme reverence in order to explain them. He goes down with ships who takes as support the wood of the cross: for anyone who seeks to enter the sea of Scriptures without this wood is submerged, for he sinks into the greatest errors. Unless he is Peter himself, he founders. Hence, "it is very deep: who can find it out?" Wisdom is glorified, which penetrated the profound abyss and saw God's marvels in the deep.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As to the sublimity of the inquiry he says: "And she withdrew farther from me than she was before," because the question seemed to him more difficult the more he inquired, and this by the divine severity of judgment: Romans 1: "Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools" — and by the loftiness of the question: therefore he says: "And a deep profundity, who shall find it?" Deep is the profundity of the inquiry of wisdom: Sirach 24: "I dwelt in the highest places, and my throne was in a pillar of cloud." And therefore who can find it? Few sufficiently, but none perfectly: Sirach 43: "Labor not, for you shall not comprehend": and Romans 11: "O the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the third part of philosophy, namely moral philosophy, Solomon also says that he attained it. Whence in Ecclesiastes: "I surveyed all things with my mind, that I might know and consider and seek wisdom and reason, and that I might know the wickedness of the fool and the error of the imprudent." He says that he considered many things and ordered all things to morals. The wickedness of the fool consists in thinking wrongly about the cause of causes; the error of the imprudent concerns the governance of the monastic life, or the domestic life, or the political life, that is, concerning the governance of oneself, or of the family, or of the city. Great prudence is required for the governance of oneself, greater for the governance of a family, but the greatest for the governance of a city. It is impossible that the sun should illuminate bodies far from itself and not illuminate those near to it. No one can have a well-ordered family unless he himself is well-ordered. If someone wishes to have chaste servants, and he himself is not chaste, this cannot be. Similarly, unless a man governs his family well, he will not be able to govern a city well, because "as is the ruler of a city, so also are its inhabitants."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As to the diligence of consideration he adds: "I surveyed all things in my mind," that is, I went about and diligently considered from every side: Sirach 6: "As one who plows and one who sows, draw near to her." And the moving reason is touched upon: "That I might know," in habit: "and consider," in act: "wisdom," in the appetites: "reason," in operations. And conversely: "That I might know the wickedness of the fool," in things to be done: "and the error of prudence," in things to be believed: above in chapter 1: "I gave my heart to know prudence and learning, and errors and folly."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Solomon followed foolish women, therefore he laments and says in Ecclesiastes: "I found woman more bitter than death, who is the snare of hunters, and her heart is a net, her hands are bonds. He who pleases God shall escape from her, but he who is a sinner shall be captured by her." A snare to those who look upon her, a net to those who lust and consent, and bonds to those who touch her.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The vehement proneness of concupiscence itself is touched upon, because it leads to the greatest bitterness under the appearance of sweetness. Therefore he says: "I found a woman more bitter than death," and this after the perpetration of the wicked deed to which concupiscence drags one: whence Proverbs 5: "The lips of a harlot are as a dropping honeycomb, and her throat is smoother than oil." That concupiscence drags one to this, which had its origin from woman and has its fuel in woman, which by its beauty ensnares through desire: therefore he says: "It is the snare of hunters," that is, of demons, who hunt the souls of men. It ensnares by words and glances: Proverbs 7: "She entangled him with many words and drew him forth with the flatteries of her lips." It ensnares by the beauty of the face: Sirach 9: "On account of the beauty of a woman many have perished." It also ensnares by words: whence in the same place: "Her conversation burns like fire." Not only does it ensnare in desire, but it also swallows up in wicked deed: whence he says: "And her heart is a net," when according to her wish one consents to the wicked deed. This is the dragnet of the devil: Habakkuk 1: "He lifted up the whole with a hook; he drew it in his dragnet." But afterward it binds through affection: and therefore he says: "And her hands are bonds": Proverbs 7: "He follows her and does not know that the fool is drawn to bonds." From this inclination no one is delivered unless he is aided by the Lord, so great is it; therefore he says: "He who pleases God shall escape her," according to that passage in 1 Corinthians 6: "Flee fornication"; Wisdom 8: "I knew that I could not otherwise be continent unless God should grant it." "But he who is a sinner shall be captured by her": Proverbs 5: "His own iniquities capture the wicked man, and he is bound by the cords of his own sins."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here the second point is noted, namely the universality of concupiscence, the reason for which was difficult to discern; therefore he says: "Behold, this I have found, said Ecclesiastes, one thing," namely the inclination of concupiscence itself, "and another," namely its universality. "And I labored," supply, "to find the reason, which my soul still seeks"; this is the reason for the universality of concupiscence, why it is in all. "And I did not find it," namely by my own ingenuity; because the philosophers did not know how to discover this: but nevertheless by faith he knew the reason and by experience he knew the effect, namely its universality.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore he says: "One man out of a thousand I have found, and a woman out of all I have not found": it is a hyperbole, and he means to say that he found very few men in whom concupiscence did not reign: but he himself found no women: nor is this surprising, because Sirach 25: "All wickedness is short compared to the wickedness of a woman." We could, however, expound this of Christ, who alone escaped from the corruption of original concupiscence, who alone was "free among the dead."
Likewise there is a doubt concerning what he says: "One man among a thousand I have found." According to this he seems to confirm that heresy that no woman is saved; and heretics strive to prove this: because, if only that which Christ assumed is saved, and he assumed only the male sex, therefore that alone will be saved. And they endeavor to prove this by what is said in the last chapter of Mark: "He who shall believe and shall be baptized": it does not say: "she who shall be baptized." And the same is said in John chapter 3.
The contrary of this is shown by what is said in Matthew 21: "The harlots shall go before you into the kingdom of God." Likewise, this is shown because the Lord received both sexes, healed both bodily, called both through the Apostles. Solomon himself also praised both, and concerning the valiant woman in the last chapter of Proverbs: "She shall laugh on the last day."
I respond: it must be said that he speaks of the universality of concupiscence, and of this one may speak in two ways: in one way with respect to carnal propagation, because it is transmitted; in another way with respect to the pursuit through actual sin. If in the first way, the statement is true and proper, because Christ alone was conceived without sin and did not contract original sin. If in the second way, the statement is hyperbolic: and this is evident, because there is not only one good man to be saved, but indeed many: and this is said with respect to the rarity of those who in that time were found free from the act of concupiscence.
As to what the heretics object, that he assumed the male sex: I respond that even though he assumed the male sex, it must be noted that he assumed it from a woman: which he would not have done if it did not pertain to salvation. Moreover, man and woman are of one nature and one body. As to what they object from the Gospel, that it is in the masculine: it must be said that this masculine is generic and stands there for the nature, not for the sex: and frequently the masculine gender includes the feminine according to the manner of Scripture.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here the third thing is noted, namely the causality of concupiscence, which indeed was not from God, but from the first sin. Therefore he says: "Only this I have found, that God made man upright": Ecclesiasticus 17: "God created man from the earth, and made him according to his own image." And the sign of this is the uprightness of stature, which still remains in the body. "And he himself," namely by his own freedom, "entangled himself in infinite questions": because by withdrawing from the One he became inclined toward many and infinite things, because in them his concupiscence is neither ended nor satisfied; Proverbs 30: "Three things are insatiable, and the fourth, which never says enough: hell, and the mouth of the womb, and the earth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Above he described the vanity of concupiscence. Here against that vanity he intends to give the remedy of wisdom: for no one is rescued from concupiscence unless he walks with wisdom. He exhorts therefore in this part to adhere to wisdom from a fourfold consideration: first, from the consideration of its nobility; second, of its power; third, of its utility; fourth, of the opportuneness of time. He exhorts therefore to adhere to wisdom from the consideration of its nobility, which is weighed in this, that it renders a man noble and glorious both with respect to appearance and with respect to speech. And this he first proposes by questioning, then confirms by responding.
Who is such as the wise man? That is, who is so distinguished? Wisdom 8: "On account of her I shall have glory among the multitudes and honor among the elders and the young," he speaks of wisdom. Who is so distinguished in speech? Whence he says: And who knows the explanation of a word? Supply: except the wise man. Wisdom 8: "He knows the subtleties of speeches," etc. And therefore in doubtful matters the wise man is to be heard with reverence; thus Wisdom 8: "The faces of princes shall wonder at me; when I am silent they will wait for me, and when I speak they will look upon me, and when I discourse at greater length, they will lay their hand upon their mouth."
He proposed by questioning, now he confirms by responding; therefore he says: The wisdom of a man shines in his countenance. Proverbs 17: "Wisdom shines in the face of the prudent man," that is, it appears in his works. Sirach 19: "By his appearance a man is known, and by the meeting of his face a sensible person is recognized." For just as a good man is known by his countenance, so a wise man by his works. Nor is it a wonder if he is distinguished in appearance, because God does this; whence he says: And the Most Powerful shall change his face. This Most Powerful One is God; Job 36: "God does not cast away the mighty, since He Himself is mighty"; and afterwards: "Behold, God is exalted in His strength, and no one is like Him among lawgivers." He changes the face — the exterior — by first changing the interior, that is, by converting it to Himself. For the face of the soul is the higher portion of reason, by which it is naturally disposed to see God. This face God alone changes; Proverbs 21: "As the divisions of waters, so is the heart of the king in the hand of the Lord; whithersoever He wills, He shall incline it."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The wise person is admirable not only with respect to appearance, but also with respect to speech through wisdom: in whose person he says: I observe the mouth of the king, says wisdom. This King is God, of whom 1 Timothy at the end says: "The blessed and only Sovereign, the King of kings and Lord of lords." The mouth of this King is the Son of God, through whom He speaks to us: Hebrews 1: "In these last days He has spoken to us in His Son." To observe therefore the mouth of the king is to attend diligently to the word of the Son of God: Luke 11: "Blessed are those who hear the word of God and keep it." Wisdom therefore says: I observe, and I cause others to observe, according to that text of Deuteronomy 6: "Observe, that you may do what the Lord has commanded you, and it may be well with you." And he explains in what things he observes, namely in the commandments, therefore he says: And the precepts of the oath of God, which, namely, proceed from His mouth. And I observe, namely the precepts of the oath of God: precepts of the oath are so called because they are firm and inviolable; Matthew 24: "Heaven and earth shall pass away, but my words shall not pass away." Or: they are called precepts of the oath, because they were given with a covenant and an oath: Exodus 24: "Moses took the blood and sprinkled it upon the people, saying: This is the blood of the covenant of the Lord concerning all these words."
A question is raised concerning what he says: I observe the precepts of the oath of God: therefore God swears.
On the contrary: 1. Matthew 5: Let your speech be: yes, yes; no, no: therefore what is more than this is from evil. Therefore if it does not befit the perfect to swear, and nothing befits God except what is of the highest perfection, then to swear does not befit God.
2. Furthermore, it is shown that it would be superfluous: because God cannot lie, therefore the simple word of God is equally true as an oath.
3. Likewise, it seems that He cannot swear: because to swear is to call upon someone as witness and support: but God has no other by whom He could confirm: therefore neither can He swear.
I respond: it must be said that an oath is the end of every controversy, and is a pure and firm assertion, than which none can be firmer, and this for the purpose of producing certain belief. Thus therefore, when we wish to produce certain belief in the hearer, we swear: so God, condescending to our weakness, swears indeed, in order to render our faith solid.
1. As to the objection, therefore, that it is from evil: it is explained that it is from the evil of punishment, not of the one swearing, but of the one to whom the oath is made, that is, on account of his doubt.
Nevertheless, it must be said otherwise that the Lord does not there prohibit the oath as something evil: but because men are prone to speaking falsehood, He prohibits the proneness to swearing indiscriminately, lest at some point they fall simultaneously into lying and swearing to the contempt of God: and because God cannot lie, this reasoning has no place with respect to God.
2. As to the objection that He cannot lie: I say that although an oath in God does not add anything beyond a simple assertion according to the reality of the matter, it does nevertheless add according to our estimation, because our faith is made firmer thereby: and a wondrous condescension toward us is shown.
3. As to the objection that he cannot bring forward another witness: I say that just as he is his own witness, because he is his own truth, so he swears by himself; and this is the best testimony, because light manifests both itself and other things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here secondly he exhorts one to adhere to wisdom by consideration of His power, when he says: Do not hasten to depart from His face, that is, do not turn aside from His will: and this on account of the sin of the heart, as though you would hide yourself from Him. Concerning this departure, Deuteronomy 32: "He forsook God his maker, and departed from God his savior." Therefore do not depart from His face, wishing to hide in evil: Sirach 16: "Do not say: I shall be hidden from God, and from on high who will remember me"? As Cain, who said to the Lord: "Behold, you cast me out today from your face, and from your face I shall be hidden." And if it should happen that you depart, do not remain in evil: therefore he adds: Nor remain in an evil work: Sirach 5: "Do not delay to turn to the Lord, and do not defer from day to day." And the reason for this is the consideration of divine power, because He acts omnipotently: For whatever He wills, He shall do: the Psalm: "Whatever He willed, He did"; and Isaiah 46: "My counsel shall stand, and all my will shall be done."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He also acts easily; therefore he says: And His word is full of power, the Psalm: "The voice of the Lord in power, the voice of the Lord breaking the cedars": and Jeremiah 32: "No word shall be difficult for You, who show mercy unto thousands." He also acts irreproachably: Nor can anyone say to Him: Why do You act thus? Romans 9: "Who are you to answer back to God"?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here he thirdly exhorts us to cling to wisdom by consideration of our benefit. For there is great benefit in clinging to it and keeping its commandments. On account of which he says: He who keeps the commandment shall experience nothing evil: indeed he shall have many good things: Matthew 19: "If you wish to enter into life, keep the commandments"; and John 8: "If you abide in my word, you shall truly be my disciples, and you shall know the truth, and the truth shall set you free."
Here he fourthly exhorts us to keep the commandments of divine wisdom by consideration of the opportunity of time, which the wise man considers in his works. On account of which he says: The heart of the wise man understands the time and the response: he understands the time in which one ought to act: Ephesians 5: "See, brethren, how carefully you walk, not as unwise, but as wise, redeeming the time, because the days are evil." Not only the time, but also the response in its time: Colossians 4: "Walk in wisdom toward those who are outside, redeeming the time. Let your speech always be with grace, seasoned with salt, that you may know how you ought to respond to each one."
There is also a doubt about this, because he says: He who keeps the commandment will not experience anything evil. Against this: below in the same chapter: There are just men to whom evils befall as though they had done the works of the wicked.
I respond: there is experiencing evil that endures and evil that passes away; and he speaks here of the experience of evil that always remains, not of that which passes away.
There is also a question about what he says: He who keeps the commandment, etc.
1. Since there are many commandments to be kept, why does he say "commandment" in the singular?
2. Furthermore, it is possible for someone to keep the divine commandments out of fear, as the Jews kept them; and yet such persons are not saved.
I respond: it must be said that although the commandments are many by diversity of work, nevertheless they have unity both in relation to the one commanding, and in relation to the one observing, and in relation to the end. In relation to the one commanding, because he who commands is one; and therefore whoever transgresses one commandment cannot be obedient to the one commanding, because the one who commands is one. — In relation to the one observing there is unity, because he observes all things by one principle and rule, namely charity, which conquers all things. Whence, just as charity either loves all or none, so it observes all commandments or none. In relation to the end there is unity, because one reward is owed, and they are to be observed for one reward. Because therefore this threefold unity concurs in the due observance of the commandments, he rightly says: He who keeps the commandment, etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the wise man does well who considers the opportune time; which he proves when he brings forth: To every matter, that is, in every matter, there is a time and an opportunity, and much affliction of man, supply: in diligently considering these things; above, chapter 3: "All things have their time, and all things pass away in their own intervals under the sun." For there is an opportunity of time for studying: Sirach 38: "Write wisdom in a time of leisure." There is also an opportunity for praying: Psalm: "At midnight I arose to give praise to you." There is also an opportunity of time for doing good: Galatians 6: "While we have time, let us do good to all."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And this opportunity is in the present time; and he shows this to be in the present time, showing the future time to be perilous, because it cannot be foreseen: whence he said: He who is ignorant of things past, and things to come he can know by no messenger, because the future can be known far less than the past: above, chapter 7: "Who can tell him what shall be after him?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Neither can it be prevented, whence he says: Nor is it in man's dominion, that is, power, to prevent the spirit, namely from departing, because no one can prevent the time of death from coming. And he explains this by adding: Nor does he have power in the day of death; Job 14: "You have appointed his limits, which cannot be passed." It cannot be avoided: whence he says: Nor is one permitted to rest, when war presses in, namely on the day of judgment; Wisdom 5: "The whole world shall fight for him against the senseless." Which war the wicked shall not be able to avoid; whence in Apocalypse 6 they will say to the mountains: "Fall upon us," etc., because then "flight shall perish." Neither can it be dissembled, therefore he says: Wickedness shall not save the wicked, as though he could feign himself good: Job 36: "He does not save the wicked, and he grants judgment to the poor"; and Proverbs 11: "Treasures shall not profit in the day of vengeance: justice shall deliver from death": therefore Job 10: "If I be wicked, woe is me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He treated above of the vanity of proneness; here he treats of the vanity of false security. And since this vanity is dangerous, because it impels a man to sin or detains him once impelled, therefore first the vanity is set forth; second, the remedy of the vanity, at: He who digs a pit will fall into it, below in chapter ten.
First the vanity of false security is shown according to its twofold origin.
False security arises in two ways: first, from the appearance of a lack of just retribution; second, from the appearance of a lack of providential governance, and this second is touched upon at: I turned to other things and saw that the race is not to the swift, etc., below in chapter nine.
First, the first origin arises from the appearance of a lack of just retribution; which appearance is set forth by a threefold reason.
The retribution of justice, however, appears to fail on account of the exaltation of the wicked, on account of the depression of the good, on account of the indistinction of both: there are therefore three parts here. First it is shown how the vanity of security arises from the promotion of the wicked: second, how from the depression of the good, at the place: There is also another vanity which is done upon the earth, etc.; third, how it arises from the indistinction of these and those, at the place: And I applied my heart to know wisdom, etc.
First, concerning the exaltation of the wicked.
The origin, therefore, of security from the exaltation of the wicked is described in this order. First, the sublimity of the wicked is intimated: second, how from this there arises for the impious the vanity of security: third, how from this is elicited the advantage of the good.
First, therefore, the sublimity of the wicked is intimated, which Ecclesiastes considered with his diligent consideration. On account of which he says: All these things I considered, supply: which I said before. And I gave my heart to all the works that are done under the sun, that I might consider all things: above in chapter one, "I gave my heart to know prudence and learning, and errors and folly." And in this consideration he himself saw the elevation of the wicked both in power and in fame. As to the elevation in power, he says: Sometimes man rules over man to his own harm, namely when a wicked man presides, because a good man rules to his own good when he presides well: whence 1 Timothy 3: "If anyone desires the office of bishop, he desires a good work"; but a wicked man to his own harm: whence Sirach 7: "Do not bind upon yourself a double sin, for even in one you will not be free from guilt." A wicked prelate binds upon himself a double sin.
The question is raised here concerning what he says: Sometimes man has dominion over man: whether a man can justly have dominion over another man. That he can, appears as follows:
1. Because in Romans 13: "There is no power except from God": and the Apostle says that masters are to be served not only on account of fear, but also on account of conscience: therefore if everything that is from God is just, then for a man to have power over another man is just.
2. Furthermore, if conscience dictates to a man nothing but what is just, when it is right, and it dictates this, as the Apostle says: therefore it is just for a man to be subject to another man.
3. Likewise the Apostle says in Ephesians 6: Servants, obey your earthly masters: but the Apostle neither exhorts nor commands anything except what is just: therefore etc.
Against: 1. Men are equal by nature, therefore that one should be set over another is against nature: but everything that is against nature is sin: therefore etc.
2. Likewise, all men are free by nature, therefore when a man is made a slave, this is by usurpation; but everything usurped is sin: therefore it is sinful for one man to rule over another.
I respond: it must be said that one man can justly rule over another, which is evident because Noah by divine authority made his son Canaan a servant of his brothers; similarly Isaac did so regarding Esau and Jacob.
1. 2. As to what is objected regarding this, that it is against nature, and that every man is free: it must be understood that there is a twofold state, namely of nature destitute and of nature instituted. With respect to the state of nature instituted, although all would be free and equal, and it would not have been said to men that they should rule over anything except brute animals alone: nevertheless with respect to the state of nature corrupted it is otherwise. For because some are worse than others and wicked, therefore by the just judgment of God they become servants both in themselves and in their posterity.
There is also another reason for ruling, namely for the restraint of the wicked; for if there were no temporal power, everyone would do what seemed right in his own eyes, and thus there would be a rending by iniquity, and everyone would sin at will. And thus there can justly be dominion and servitude among men.
Whether, however, the wicked can justly rule over the good will be inquired below.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As for exaltation in fame he says: I saw the wicked buried, namely by the depth of despair: Proverbs 18: "When the wicked man comes into the depth of sins, he scorns." Or: buried, by the heap of flattery: Matthew 8: "Let the dead bury their dead"; Gregory: "The dead man buries the dead, when he overwhelms with the heap of flattery." Or: buried, by the continuation of transgression unto death, as if to say: those who were buried in wickedness and died in wickedness, according to what is frequently said; 3 Kings 16: "He died in the sins of Jeroboam, who made Israel to sin"; and according to what the Lord says to the Jews, John: "You shall die in your sin." Such wicked men he saw exalted in fame; therefore he says: Who also, while they were still living, supply: in their wickedness, were in the holy place, that is, in a position of dignity as if they were holy, just as also the Antichrist, about whom Matthew 24: "When you shall see the abomination of desolation standing in the holy place," etc. And they were praised in the city as if for works of the just. And thus they were great in fame: the Psalm: "For the sinner is praised in the desires of his soul"; and Proverbs 28: "Those who forsake the law praise the wicked; but those who keep it," etc.
But this also is vanity. Here the second point is touched upon, namely the vanity of security: because from the fact that the wicked are not punished, others are rendered secure; therefore he says: But this also is vanity, that is, a cause of vanity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he shows this: For because sentence is not speedily pronounced against the wicked, but they are kindly waited for, according to what is said in 2 Peter 3: "The Lord does not delay his promise, but deals patiently on your account, not willing that any should perish, but that all should return to repentance." And without any fear the sons of men perpetrate evils, and so they are secure, because they think of nothing and fear nothing concerning the future: Proverbs 28: "Evil men do not consider judgment," because, namely, they are not now punished: Isaiah 26: "Let us have mercy on the wicked, and he will not learn justice," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here the third point is touched upon, how from this is drawn the benefit for the good, because from this the good come to know divine mercy and are exercised in justice. Therefore he says: Yet the sinner, and the text should be construed thus: Yet from this, that the sinner a hundred times does evil, that is, many times, according to that passage of Jeremiah 2: "How exceedingly vile you have become, repeating your ways." And is sustained through patience, namely of God, according to that passage of Romans 2: "Do you not know that the kindness of God leads you to repentance?" Whence Lamentations 3: "It is the mercy of the Lord that we are not consumed." I have known that it shall be well with those who fear God, that is, with those who turn away from evil: Proverbs 16: "By the fear of the Lord one turns away from evil." Who reverence his face, and on account of reverence for him do not dare to sin, according to what Job 31 says of himself: "I always feared God as waves swelling over me, and I could not bear his weight."
It is asked concerning what he says: The wicked man sins a hundred times and is sustained: whether this is of kindness or of severity. That it is of kindness seems evident:
Lamentations 3: It is of the mercy of the Lord that we are not consumed.
Furthermore, the Apostle in Romans 2: Do you not know that the kindness of God leads you to repentance?
But on the contrary: The wicked man, the longer he lives, the more evils he commits, and the more evils he commits, the more sharply he will be tormented: therefore if he were to die sooner, it would be better for him: therefore that his days are prolonged is rather for evil than for good: therefore it is of severity.
I respond: it must be said that there are certain wicked men whom God foresaw would return to him: for such men the prolongation of life is an effect of great mercy, both manifest and hidden. Others there are whom he foresaw would multiply sins and die in them: and for such men to prolong life is of justice and of mercy: of mercy, because cruel punishment is deferred for them: but of hidden justice, because he who is filthy is permitted to become filthier still: for he thereby merited the prolongation of life, and as regards this it is of hidden severity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But this benefit of divine mercy and patience does not extend to the wicked; and therefore it is more profitable for them to die than to live. — Therefore he says: Let there not be good for the wicked: he says this not by way of wishing but by way of predicting, as that passage of the Psalm: "Let sinners be turned into hell." Let there not be good, namely of glory: Isaiah 26: "Let the wicked be taken away, lest he see the glory of God." Nor let there be the good of the present life either: therefore he adds: Nor let his days be prolonged, that is, they will not be prolonged: Proverbs 10: "The years of the wicked shall be shortened": and in the Psalm: "Men of blood and deceit shall not live out half their days." But let those who do not fear the face of the Lord pass away like a shadow. And indeed they pass away like a shadow: whence in the Psalm: "I saw the wicked highly exalted," and afterward: "I passed by, and behold, he was no more"; whence in the person of the wicked, Wisdom 5: "All these things have passed away like a shadow and like a messenger running ahead and like a ship that passes through the surging water."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Above he showed how security arises from the sight of the exaltation of the wicked: here secondly he shows how it arises from the sight of the adversity of the good. And indeed he does this in this order. First, the adversity of the good is set forth: second, from this the security of the wicked: third, vanity is concluded: fourth, pleasure is commended.
There is therefore proposed the adversity of the good, from which vanity arises; on account of which he says: There is also another vanity which is done upon the earth, another, namely, from the aforementioned, because it has a different cause: for the aforementioned came from the exaltation of the wicked, but this one from the adversity of the good. Therefore he says: There are just men, to whom evils befall, that is, adversities, as though they had done the works of the wicked, according to what is found in Hebrews 11: "The saints experienced mockeries and scourgings, and moreover chains and prisons: they were stoned, they were cut asunder, they were tempted." An example is Tobias, who was made blind, Tobit 2; an example is Job, who was so afflicted, Job 1. And the reason for this is given in Judith 8: "All who were pleasing to God passed through many tribulations as faithful ones."
And there are the wicked. Here the second point is noted, namely the security of the wicked. For because the wicked see that evils befall the good and good things befall themselves, they are therefore rendered secure. Therefore he says: And there are the wicked, who are rendered so secure as though they had the deeds of the just; and this because they are immune from tribulation. An example is that rich glutton, Luke 16, to whom it was said: "Remember that you received good things in your life, and Lazarus likewise evil things." And therefore the wicked are made secure because they prosper; whence Jeremiah 12: "Why does the way of the wicked prosper; it is well with all who transgress," etc.
But this also is most vain. Here thirdly vanity is concluded from this security of the wicked. Therefore he says: But this also I judge most vain. For it is vain when good things befall both the good and the wicked, because it is unworthy on account of the wicked; more vain when evil things befall both the good and the wicked, because it is unjust on account of the good; but most vain when evil things befall the good and good things befall the wicked, because it is equally unjust and unworthy. Whence he bears it so indignantly that he almost wishes to accuse God on this account: Habakkuk 1: "Why do you look upon those who act wickedly and are silent, while the wicked devours one more just than himself?"
It can be asked here which state is better and more useful: namely, whether the state of prosperity or of adversity. That the state of adversity is better seems to be the case:
1. Because it is said in Apocalypse 3: I rebuke and chastise those whom I love: therefore tribulation is a sign of divine love.
2. Likewise, it is said in Hebrews 12: He scourges every son whom he receives: therefore to be scourged is a sign of divine sonship.
3. Likewise, Tobit 12: Because you were acceptable to God, it was necessary that trial should prove you: therefore etc.
4. Likewise, Judith 8: All who have pleased God passed through many tribulations as faithful ones: therefore that state is better.
On the contrary: 1. The Church seeks peace: "Give peace, O Lord, in our days": therefore if the Church seeks what is better, the state of prosperity is better.
2. Likewise, the Apostle, in 1 Timothy 2, directs that prayer be made for those who are placed in high position, that we may lead a quiet and tranquil life: therefore the state of tranquility is better.
3. Likewise, if there were no sin, there would be no adversity, but complete tranquility and prosperity: therefore the state of prosperity is more consonant with the state of innocence and glory; but "what is more similar to the better is itself better": therefore etc.
I respond: it must be said that the states of prosperity and adversity can be compared in relation to the good or to the wicked. If in relation to the wicked, who are puffed up in prosperity and cast down in adversity, neither is useful unless divine grace assists interiorly, so that when he scourges exteriorly, he illumines interiorly: thus, when inspiration accompanies the scourge, which often happens, the state of adversity is more useful for the wicked. — But if we speak by comparison to the good: then it must be said that some good persons are perfect, of whom is said that verse of Proverbs 12: Whatever befalls the just man shall not make him sorrowful: thus for the perfect the state of adversity is better and more useful, because in it they are tested, as gold is proved in fire. But the state of prosperity is not useful for them, either because they do not advance, or because they grow tepid, or because their spirits fall, just as David, brave in battles, fell at the sight of a woman.
There are also others who are imperfect, who love God and are drawn by temporal benefits: and since they do not have perfect charity, they easily fall: for such persons prosperity is more useful. And because the Church has many who are tender and weak, more numerous than the strong, therefore she is compelled to pray for peace. That evils therefore befall the good in the present life is a gift of God, according to Philippians 1: It has been granted to you not only to believe in him, but also to suffer for his sake.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here fourthly, from this, pleasure is commended in detestation of so great a vanity, from the fact that good things befall the wicked and evil things befall the good; and this is the praise and word of a troubled man. Therefore he says: I praised therefore gladness, namely of the flesh, as though this alone were good; therefore he says: That there is no good for man under the sun except to eat and to drink, according to that passage in Isaiah 22: "Behold, joy and gladness, slaying rams, eating flesh and drinking wine," as though there were no other life nor any other reward. Therefore he adds: And this alone he carries away with him from his labor, as though nothing else were to be expected, but one should rejoice in the days of his life, which God gave him under the sun: Wisdom 2: "Let us everywhere leave signs of our gladness, for this is our portion."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It has been shown how the vanity of security arises from the exaltation of the wicked and also from the oppression of the good. Here it is shown thirdly how it arises from the indistinction of the one group and the other. For because the wicked cannot be distinguished from the good, therefore they are secure; and since this security has its origin from this kind of indistinction, and it itself is also the principle of pleasure, therefore this part has two parts. First it is shown how from indistinction arises security; second, how from security arises pleasure, at the passage: There is no one who lives forever, etc.
First it is shown how security is born from this.
The first point, therefore, is described in this order: first, therefore, is noted the vain solicitude of discerning; second, the uncertainty of discernment; third, the reason for the uncertainty; fourth, is noted from this the origin of vain security.
Therefore first is intimated the vain solicitude of discerning, which solicitude was diligent; whence he says: And I applied my heart, that is, I applied my intellect; that I might know wisdom, with respect to invisible things, and understand the distinction of those things which are occupied on earth, with respect to visible things, because Romans 1: "The invisible things of God are clearly seen from the creation of the world, being understood through those things which have been made." And this solicitude is vain, because however much a man may labor, he cannot find out; therefore he adds: There is a man who day and night takes no sleep with his eyes, but rather labors continually to inquire, above in chapter three: "I saw the affliction which God has given to the sons of men, that they might be occupied in it"; and he adds: "He made all things good and delivered the world to their disputation"; and although he labors so much, he profits nothing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore he adds: And I understood that man can find no reason for all the works of God, of those works, namely, which are done under the sun: Sirach 43: "Do not labor, for you will not comprehend." And the more he has labored to seek, the less he will find: whence in the Psalm: "Man shall approach to a deep heart, and God shall be exalted," that is, made distant; Augustine: "God is lofty; you raise yourself up, and He flees from you; you humble yourself, and He comes to you." Even if the wise man says that he knows, he will not be able to find out, that is, if he believes himself to know, he understands less, because it is said in Romans 1: "Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools"; above in chapter seven: "I said: I shall become wise, and it departed further from me." And he repeats the solicitude, adding that it was curious; for to apply solicitude where there is no utility is curiosity. Therefore he says: All these things I pondered in my heart, that I might understand with curiosity; and this is reproved in Sirach 3: "Do not search much into superfluous things, and do not be curious about the many works of His." And thus the solicitude of distinguishing is evident, which was diligent and vain, and therefore curious.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The security of salvation requires that the matter be so effected that it not fall into doubt; and there is no one who is certain of the goodness and faith of the minister, and even the same person is not certain concerning himself whether he is worthy of love or of hatred: therefore, if the Sacraments could be dispensed only by the good, no one would be certain of the reception of the Sacrament; and so it would be necessary always to repeat them, and the malice of one would prejudice the salvation of another; nor would there be any stability in the grades of the hierarchy of the Church militant, which consists especially in the dispensing of the Sacraments. And therefore it was fitting that the dispensation of the Sacraments be entrusted to man not by reason of holiness, which varies according to the will, but by reason of authority, which always remains.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"There are just and wise ones" etc. Here the second point is touched upon, namely the uncertainty of discernment. For a man does not know of himself whether he is a good man or an evil one, even the good man himself. Therefore he says: "There are just and wise ones," and thus good; "and their works are in the hand of God," that is, in the power of knowing, accepting, and rewarding. In his hand are merits and rewards. There are merits of good thoughts: Proverbs 21: "As the divisions of waters, so is the heart of the king in the hand of the Lord." There are merits of good affections: Psalm: "In his hand are all the ends of the earth." There are also merits of good speeches: Wisdom 7: "In his hand are both we and our words." There are also merits of good works, as in the passage at hand. There are also rewards in his hand: Wisdom 3: "The souls of the just are in the hand of God"; and since they are in the hand of God, they ought to be known. "And yet man does not know whether he is worthy of love" or of "hatred," and thus he does not know how to discern; 1 Corinthians 4: "I am conscious of nothing against myself, but I am not justified in this" etc.
There is a doubt about what he says: "Man does not know whether he is worthy of love or of hatred."
This seems false: 1. Because Romans 8: "Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? I am certain," etc.: therefore there is an objection against it there.
You will say that he knew by revelation; it is objected that man can know by himself, because the worthiness of divine love places in us sanctifying grace; but Augustine says that those things which are essentially in the soul are better known than those which are known according to species: therefore if we are certain of those things which we know according to species, as when something sweet is placed upon the tongue, much more so of grace.
2. Likewise, Augustine says that he who has faith is certain that he has faith. Therefore he who has love or charity is certain that he has it: therefore he who has grace is certain: therefore he is certain whether he is pleasing to God.
3. Likewise, concerning hatred one can be certain: indeed, he who has sinned and wills to sin is certain that he is worthy of hatred.
On the contrary: I. 1 Corinthians 4: "I am conscious of nothing against myself, yet I am not justified in this," etc.
2. Likewise, Job 9: If he comes to me, I shall not see him; and if he departs, I shall not perceive it; and in the same place: "If I am simple, my very soul shall be ignorant of this."
3. Likewise, Ecclesiasticus 5: "Concerning the forgiven sin, do not be without fear": therefore no one is certain.
To this some respond that the passage is understood concerning the hatred of predestination and reprobation, of which no one is certain; and thus there is no objection, because predestination does not place in us any effect through which it could be known. It must be answered otherwise, because this response does not satisfy the text: for the text says: "He does not know whether he is worthy of love"; but no one is worthy of or merits being predestined: therefore it is understood according to present justice.
On account of this, others respond that knowledge is twofold, namely necessary and infallible: and this we cannot have, because no one can know with certitude whether he has grace, except through revelation, as the Apostle did. There is another kind that is probable and through signs: and this indeed can be had and is had, because many know through probable signs that they are in grace.
To the objection, then, that the soul sees essentially: I say that habits in the soul are not known except through the fact that the soul sees itself disposed toward some act; and because the acts of unformed and formed faith and of gratuitous and natural love are so similar that a man can scarcely or never discern between them: therefore, even if he knows the habit, he nevertheless does not know whether it is gratuitous.
To the objection concerning hatred, I say that he speaks of the just, because they do not know whether they are worthy of love or hatred; not of the openly wicked.
Yet whatever the case may be concerning charity and faith—whether a man knows that he has them or not—he nevertheless does not know whether he is worthy of the love or hatred of God: for we can believe, but how do we know that the Lord hates the wicked and loves the good, when He bestows so many and such great goods upon the wicked as upon the good? Hence Ecclesiastes did not say that they do not know themselves to be just, but that they do not know themselves to be beloved by God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"But all things are reserved for the future." Here the third point is noted, namely the reason for uncertainty, which arises from this, that in the present, recompense is not made according to merits, but is reserved for the future. And therefore he says thus: "Man does not know... But all things are reserved uncertain for the future," so that they may be made certain; 1 Corinthians 4: "Do not judge before the time, until the Lord comes, who will both illuminate the hidden things of darkness and make manifest the counsels of hearts"; which indeed he does not do now, but reserves, according to that passage in Job 14: "You have sealed up my transgressions as in a bag"; and thus in the present all things are in hiddenness. And it is added: "Because all things equally befall the just and the impious" etc.: all things, good and evil, equally befall the just and the sinner, whom he describes under six differences. "The just and the impious," with regard to the belief of faith, which justifies the impious: Habakkuk 2: "The just man lives by his faith." "The good and the evil," with regard to the purity of love, because holy love makes one good: Matthew 7: "A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit." "The clean and the unclean," with regard to the uprightness of conduct: for that is observed in outward things, Tobit 4. "The one offering sacrifices and victims, and the one despising sacrifices," with regard to the devotion of religion — Exodus 12: "This is the religion of the Passover; no foreigner shall eat of it." "As the good, so also the sinner," with respect to the observance of the commandments, the observance of which makes the good, and the transgression makes sinners; Daniel 9: "We have sinned, we have committed iniquity, and we have departed and turned aside from your commandments and judgments." "As the perjurer, so also he who truly swears," with respect to the speaking of truth: "deterat," where "de-" intensifies, not diminishes; "deterat," that is, he truly swears, according to which signification it is taken in 1 Kings 20: "And Jonathan continued to swear to David, because he loved him." Equal things befall all these both with respect to the condition of nature, according to Wisdom 7: "Therefore there is one entrance for all into life, and a like departure"; and with respect to the condition of fault: Romans 3: "All have sinned and lack the glory of God"; and with respect to the condition of punishment: Ecclesiasticus 8: "Remember that we are all in corruption."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"This is the worst" etc. Here the fourth is touched upon, namely the origin of vain security, because great security arises from this lack of distinction, which is the occasion of many sins. Therefore he says: "And this is the worst among all things that are done under the sun, because the same things befall all." Therefore "the worst," because the occasion of many sins; for God does not seem to care about us. Whence arises that saying of Job 22: "The clouds are his hiding place, and he does not consider our affairs." And he shows that evils arise from this, because security arises, through which man falls into malice and contempt. Therefore he says: "Whence also the hearts of the children of men," that is, of the wicked and the carnal, "are filled with malice and contempt." In the filling, a multitude of vices is designated, so that malice is in the concupiscible, and contempt in the irascible, which are the two roots of sins; Genesis 6: "The earth was corrupted before God and filled with iniquity"; and this "in their life," that is, as long as they have a place for meriting: 1 Thessalonians 2: "That they may fill up their sins always." And because such are cast headlong into punishment, therefore he adds: "And after these things they shall be led down to hell": the Psalm: "But you, O God, shall lead them down into the pit of destruction"; and Job 21: "They spend their days in prosperity, and in a moment they descend to hell."
One may also raise a doubt about what he says: "This is the worst thing under the sun, that the same things happen to all."
On the contrary: 1. It is worse when good things happen to the wicked and bad things to the good than when the same things happen to both, because, as was said above, that is undue and unworthy.
2. Likewise, it was said above: "This I judge most vain," concerning the fact that the wicked are secure and evils befall the just; but "what is said by way of superabundance belongs to one alone": therefore, etc.
I respond: it must be said that increase and decrease in vanity or wickedness can be taken properly: and thus it is said intensively, in the way that one says: a pearl is whiter than a horse; and thus intensively the vanity is greater when the wicked are exalted and the good are cast down. Furthermore, more and less can be taken extensively, because it is the cause or occasion in more cases or for more people: and in this way the indistinction of the good from the wicked is a greater vanity, because it is the origin of more evils. For if bad things happened to the good and good things to the wicked, the good could be discerned from the wicked; but when the same things happen to both, they cannot be discerned.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Secondly, it is shown how pleasure arises from this.
"No one lives forever." He has now shown how the vanity of false security arises from indistinction; here secondly he shows how pleasure arises from security: and indeed he does this in the following order. First is noted the certainty of death; second, the worsening of one's state through death; third, the commendation of pleasure; fourth, the confirmation of the commendation.
First, therefore, the certainty of death is noted by the fact that no one escapes its judgment. Therefore he says: "There is no one who lives forever": therefore in the Psalm: "What man is there who shall live and not see death?" And into this condemnation Adam fell with his posterity, when it was said to him in Genesis 3: "Dust you are, and to dust you shall return." "And who has confidence in this matter," supply: no one; "in this matter," namely the hope of living forever: Job 7: "My days have passed more swiftly than a web is cut by the weaver, and they are consumed without any hope, for my life is wind, and it shall not return," etc.
"A living dog is better," etc. Here secondly it is shown that through death there is a deterioration of condition: and he proposes this under a metaphor: "A living dog is better than a dead lion." Although a lion surpasses a dog, nevertheless death renders it inferior, because a living dog can do something, a dead lion can do nothing, and yet when living it is more powerful than a dog: Proverbs 30: "The lion, the mightiest of animals, shall tremble at the approach of none." Thus metaphorically he means to say that any living person, however lowly, is better than a dead person, however good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he proves this first with regard to the act of cognition. "For the living know that they are to die": at least of this they are certain: 2 Kings 14: "We all die, and like waters that flow down into the earth, which do not return." Or: "to die," that is, given over to the necessity of death; Romans 8: "The body is dead because of sin." "For the dead know nothing further," because cognition presupposes life; and thus the living surpass the dead in the act of cognition: for they have neither motion nor sensation. With regard to the act of recollection he says: "Nor do they have any further reward," namely of fame in the memory of others: "because their memory has been handed over to oblivion": above in chapter 2: "There shall be no remembrance of the wise man, just as neither of the fool, forever and in times to come," etc. Or: because their memory does not have the act of recollection: Job 7: "He who descends to the netherworld shall not ascend, nor shall he return again to his house, nor shall his place know him anymore."
It can be asked concerning what he says: "The dead know nothing more." This seems to be false, because the soul separated from the body is freer; but a substance, the freer it is from the body, the more suited it is for cognition; therefore the dead are more apt for knowing; therefore either the soul perishes, or it knows.
Likewise there is a doubt concerning this, that "they have no further reward." This is manifestly heretical, because this removes divine justice.
If we wish to respond to these by saying that it is spoken in the person of Epicurus, then the response is clear; but if we wish to maintain that it is in his own person, it must be said that when he says that the dead do not know, it is understood with respect to those things which are in this world: because they do not know these worldly things, nor are they in the memory of the worldly, nor do they have affection for worldly things. And this is clear from the text, because he says: "Nor do they have a part in this age."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“With regard to the act of affection he says: "Love also and hatred and envy have likewise perished," because they are not affected as before in life. With regard to the act of exterior operation he says: "Nor do they have a part in this world," and he explains with respect to what: "and in the work that is done under the sun," because they cannot work, according to that saying in John 9: "The night comes, when no one can work."
Likewise concerning what he says, that "love and hatred have perished together." On the contrary: An evil will always remains; therefore if evil will exists through love and hatred, therefore etc.
If we wish to respond to these by saying that it is spoken in the person of Epicurus, then the response is clear; but if we wish to maintain that it is in his own person, it must be said that when he says that the dead do not know, it is understood with respect to those things which are in this world: because they do not know these worldly things, nor are they in the memory of the worldly, nor do they have affection for worldly things. And this is clear from the text, because he says: "Nor do they have a part in this age."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Go therefore and eat" etc. Here the third point is touched upon, namely the commendation of present delight, to the embracing of which he exhorts first according to taste; whence he says: "Go therefore and eat your bread with joy": by bread is understood everything that pertains to food. "And drink your wine with gladness": by wine, everything that pertains to drink. "Because God is pleased with your works": as if to say: you are not certain whether they displease; therefore presume that they please, and so eat and drink without care, according to that passage of Isaiah 22: "Behold, joy and gladness, to eat flesh and to drink wine: let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we shall die."
Moreover, this can be expounded spiritually, so that first it exhorts to the delight of contemplation; and second, to the urgency of action. For contemplative men, three things are necessary: meditation on Sacred Scripture, purity of conscience, and the embrace of interior devotion. With regard to meditation on Sacred Scripture he says: "Eat bread and drink wine": bread with respect to difficult matters, and wine with respect to easy matters. Proverbs 9, Wisdom says: "Come, eat my bread and drink the wine that I have mixed for you."
Concerning this exhortation: "Go therefore and eat your bread and drink your wine," etc. — if we wish to respond by saying that it is spoken in the person of Epicurus, then the response is clear; but if we wish to maintain that it is in his own person, it must be said that that exhortation is not stated absolutely, but is a conclusion drawn from the aforementioned vanity. Hence he says: "Go therefore," that is to say: if a man cannot discern whether in the present he ought to please God and in the future be rewarded — if this, I say, he cannot know, nor can he live forever — therefore he can rejoice without care. But that does not hold unless this is supposed: that the Lord does not reward differently in the future than in the present — which is the aforementioned vanity, which he will destroy below in chapter eleven.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Then according to sight he says: "At all times let your garments be white," so that you may appear comely in clothing; "and let not oil be lacking from your head," so that you may appear comely in appearance. In this manner those adorn themselves who wish to be pleasing in the sight of men. The example is of Judith, who, when she wished to please the eyes of Holofernes, adorned herself, according to what is said in Judith 10; but she did this for a good purpose, because otherwise it is reprehensible: Ecclesiasticus 11: "Never glory in your clothing."
Spiritually, with regard to purity of conscience he says: "At all times let your garments be white," that is, a clean conscience. Apocalypse 3: "They have not defiled their garments; they shall walk with me in white." On the contrary, it is said in Isaiah 9: "A garment mixed with blood shall be for burning and fuel for fire." And because interior joy follows upon cleanness of conscience, therefore he says: "And let oil not be lacking from your head": whence in the Psalm: "That he may make the face cheerful with oil"; Matthew 6: "But you, when you fast, anoint your head" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Then according to touch he says: "Enjoy life with the wife whom you love." This enjoyment is described in Proverbs 7: "Come, let us be inebriated with breasts and enjoy the desired embraces, until the day dawns." And this not only once, but "all the days of the life of your instability, which are given to you under the sun." Truly our life is unstable, according to that passage of Job 14: "He never remains in the same state." And for greater expression he says: "All the time of your vanity." Our life is a time of vanity; whence in the Psalm: "Man is made like unto vanity; his days pass away like a shadow."
"For this is the portion" etc. Here the fourth point is touched upon, namely the confirmation of the commendation, and the confirmation consists in this: that man expects no other reward nor has any other fruit, and therefore he ought to take what he can. Thus he says: "For this is your portion in life and in the labor with which you toil under the sun," namely, to delight in the present. Wisdom 2: "Let us everywhere leave signs of our joy, for this is our portion, and this is our lot."
Spiritually, with regard to the embrace of interior devotion he says: "Enjoy life with the wife whom you love." This wife is the religious life, in which one must devote oneself to contemplation. Proverbs 5: "Rejoice with the wife of your youth, a most dear hind" etc. This beloved wife was prefigured by Rachel, for whom "Jacob served seven years," Genesis 29.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And because no other reward is to be expected, man ought to take from this as much as he can. Thus he says: "Whatever your hand is able to do, work at it earnestly," that is, while you have time, do not wait for the future. And therefore it is added: "For neither work," in things to be done; "nor reason," in things to be deliberated; "nor knowledge," in things to be known; "nor wisdom," in things to be loved, "shall be in the netherworld, to which you hasten": these things are not there, because, as is said in Job 10, "that land is dark and covered with the shadow of death, where no order exists, but everlasting horror dwells." Thither sinners hasten, and all before the coming of Christ with respect to limbo. Job 17: "All my things shall descend into the deepest hell." Thither sinners hasten, drawing nearer day by day. Deuteronomy 32: "The day of destruction is near."
Spiritually, then as regards the active, he says: "Whatever your hand is able to do, do it earnestly." To work earnestly is to work swiftly, against negligence: Ecclesiasticus 31: "In all your works be swift, and no infirmity shall befall you"; fervently, Proverbs 18: "He who is soft and slack in his work is the brother of him who destroys his own works"; continuously, so that one does not grow lukewarm: Ecclesiasticus 27: "If you do not hold yourself earnestly in the fear of the Lord, your house will quickly be overthrown"; perseveringly: 2 Timothy 2: "He who strives in the contest will not be crowned unless he has strived lawfully," that is, perseveringly. And the reason is added why one must earnestly do good works in the present: because the time of merit is brief; whence: "In the underworld there is no work," for exercising oneself in piety: John 9: "I must work while it is day." And therefore it is said in the last chapter of Galatians: "Let us do good while we have time, to all, but especially to the household of the faith." "There is no reason," for inquiring and discerning what is good, what is evil: Job 12: "They shall grope as in darkness and not in light, and he shall make them stagger like drunkards"; Isaiah 19: "And the Lord has mingled in their midst a spirit of dizziness." "There is no wisdom and knowledge": knowledge, namely for contemplating God in his works, nor wisdom, for contemplating him in himself: concerning these, Isaiah 33: "The riches of salvation are wisdom and knowledge; the fear of the Lord is his treasure."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, carelessness arises from the appearance of a defect in the governance of providence; which appearance is shown in two ways.
"I turned to another thing" etc. As was said above, carelessness is found among the wicked: first, because the retribution of justice seems to be lacking; second, because the governance of providence seems to be lacking. The defect that appears to exist in the retribution of justice has been treated; here secondly is treated the defect that appears to exist concerning the governance of providence, for these things do not seem to be governed in an orderly fashion, but by chance. And this part has two sections, because first the defect of order is shown generally, and second specifically, at: "This wisdom also I have seen" etc., concerning the disorder of authority.
First the defect of order is shown in general.
Concerning the first he proceeds thus. First he shows the disorder and chance that seems to exist with respect to the conduct of life; second, that which seems to exist with respect to the termination of death, at: "Man does not know his own end."
Therefore, with respect to the conduct of life he shows the disorder, because things are not suited to those ends for which they have fitness. For which reason he says: "I turned to another thing," because above he considered retribution, here he turns to considering order. "And I saw under the sun," and he enumerates five gratuitously given gifts that are defrauded of their proper acts: "the race is not to the swift," though they are fitted for running: Amos 2: "Flight shall perish from the swift." "Nor the battle to the strong," though they are fitted for fighting: 2 Kings 1: "The mighty have fallen, and the weapons of war have perished." "Nor bread to the wise," though they are fitted for distributing provisions; Isaiah 3: "I am not a physician, and in my house there is no bread." "Nor riches to the learned," though they are fitted for possessing all gifts; below in the same chapter: "There was found in it a poor man." "Nor favor to the skilled," though they are fitted for doing pleasing works: Isaiah 20: "All who worked well were confounded." "But time and chance in all things," as though all things come by chance and temporal things are subject to change: above in chapter 3: "All things have their season and pass away in their appointed times." And the aforementioned gifts are distinguished, because the first two regard the body: agility, for attaining what is desired, and strength for resisting evil inflicted; the three following regard the soul, namely wisdom in the heart, learning in speech, and skill in work.
Spiritually, here is intimated the heavenly election of the good. Therefore, in order to attribute the entire operation of the good to God, he says first: "The race is not to the swift," because it is not from themselves that they run, but from God: Romans 9: "It is not of him who wills nor of him who runs, but of God who has mercy." "Nor the battle to the strong," because in the Psalm: "The king is not saved by great strength." "Nor bread to the wise," from themselves, but from God: John 6: "My Father gives you the true bread from heaven." "Nor riches to the learned," namely of wisdom and knowledge, from themselves, but from God: 1 Corinthians 1: "In all things you have been made rich in him," namely in Christ. "Nor favor to the skillful," from themselves, but from God: Psalm: "God loves mercy and truth; the Lord will give grace and glory."
A doubt can be raised about what he says, that "he saw time and chance in all things." Therefore according to this it seems that all things happen by chance.
But to the contrary. It seems that not all things happen by chance: because those things which happen according to purpose do not happen by chance; but many things are done from purpose; therefore not all things happen by chance.
2. Furthermore, it seems that in nothing is there chance, because as Plato says, "there is nothing apart from the first cause whose origin a legitimate cause has not preceded": therefore according to this nothing happens by chance, but all things proceed from a determinate cause.
3. Likewise, in every operation God is the principal agent; but whatever God does principally, He does both knowingly and by design, and nothing of such a kind happens by chance: therefore nothing at all happens by chance.
I respond: it must be said that chance and fortune are causes per accidens, not because they are other causes than causes per se, but because when nature and intellect do something to which they are directly ordered, they do this per se, and there is no chance there; but when from their operation something occurs to which they are not directly ordered, on account of the concurrence of another cause, there is chance: as is clear in the case of the creditor found in the marketplace and the stone falling upon one's head. I say therefore that if the outcomes of things are compared to the first cause, which is God: since God foresees all things, nothing is by chance according to the ordering of divine foreknowledge. But if we speak by comparison to created causes, either concerning immutable ones, as is the case with the motion of the higher bodies, or concerning mutable ones, as are the lower causes which are under the sun: in the disposition of these mutable causes, it is hardly possible that some unintended effect does not concur, indeed beyond intention: and therefore chance is found in all things, not because all things happen by chance, but because concerning every mutable creature something happens by chance.
As for what is objected concerning divine foreknowledge, the answer is already clear. For chance is not spoken of in comparison to divine foreknowledge.
As for what is objected secondly, that all things have a cause: it must be said that it is true that all things have a legitimate cause, namely nature or intellect, but nevertheless by this it is not excluded that they can do or do something beyond the intended order, God excepted.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Man does not know his end," etc. Here is touched upon the deficiency of governance with respect to the termination of death, because it is determined for no one, neither when nor how he must die. And it seems that such or such a death happens by chance. And therefore he says: "Man does not know his end," that is, the day of death: Matthew 24: "Watch therefore, for you do not know at what hour your Lord will come." And he gives an example of how there is disorder and a game of uncertainty, saying: "But as fish are caught by the hook," namely unknowingly, "and as birds are caught in the snare," namely by deceit; Ecclesiasticus 11: "As a partridge is lured into a cage, and as a roe deer into a snare, so also is the heart of the proud." "So are men caught in an evil time": 1 Thessalonians 5: "When they shall say: Peace and security, sudden destruction shall come upon them." "When it shall come upon them suddenly," that is, unexpectedly: Isaiah 30: "Suddenly, when it is not expected, its destruction shall come, and it shall be shattered like a potter's vessel."
Spiritually, as to the hidden damnation of the wicked, he says: "Man does not know his end," because "the way of the wicked is dark," etc. "As fish by the hook," that is, the pleasure-seekers, who are caught by the hook of pleasure: Habakkuk 1: "They lift up everything with the hook." And "as birds by the snare," that is, the ambitious by the snare of honor: 1 Timothy 3: "Not a neophyte, lest, puffed up with pride, he fall into the judgment of the devil." "So are men caught," that is, the avaricious, "in an evil time": Job 27: "The rich man, when he shall sleep, shall take nothing with him."
It is asked concerning what he says, "As fishes are caught with a hook": whether the catching of fish is by chance or not. That it is, seems as follows:
1. Because that this fish comes rather than another, this is not by nature nor by reason: therefore it is by chance.
2. Likewise, that one man catches and another does not: this is not by reason of nature or of art: therefore it is by chance.
But to the contrary: If someone intending to find gold were digging, it would not be chance: therefore since one who fishes intends to catch, there is no chance there.
I respond: it must be said that one can speak of the catching by comparison to those who catch, and thus it is not by chance: one can also speak by comparison to the fish, which go to the hook: and because they go on account of food, and something else occurs, with respect to them there is chance.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, the defect of order in the governance of providence is shown in particular, and this in three ways.
"This wisdom also I have seen under the sun." He determined above the deficiency of the governance of providence in general; here he intends to show in particular, namely concerning prelacy, because the wise are despised and fools are promoted. There are therefore in this part three parts. In the first he shows the abasement of the wise man; in the second he subjoins the commendation of the abased, there: "And I said that better" etc.; in the third he introduces the promotion of the fool, there: "If the spirit of him who has power" etc.
The abasement of the wise man is therefore described in this order. First is set forth the praise of wisdom; second is expressed the case in which there is a deficiency of power; third is noted the succor of wisdom; fourth, the contempt of the wise man.
There is therefore set forth the praise of wisdom, when he says: "This wisdom I have seen under the sun," that is, in worldly things I have known it by its effect: "and I judged it very great," that is, I approved and praised it as exceedingly great. For great is wisdom in conquering a lesser enemy: greater, in conquering an equal: greatest, in conquering the most powerful: whence it is said in Job 26 concerning the supremely wise One: "His prudence struck the proud one."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"A small city" etc. Here is noted the deficiency of power, and this with respect to resisting the assailant: therefore he says: "A small city, and few men in it." "The siege was completed." And because it was small and had few men, therefore it was weak for defending itself: whence Jehoshaphat said in 2 Chronicles 20: "In us there is not so great strength that we can resist this great multitude," because, namely, they were few. Especially then they cannot resist, when the assailant is strong: on account of which he says: "There came against it a great king," namely through power: "and surrounded it," through great malice: "and he built fortifications all around," for battle: "and the siege was completed," through the inability to resist. An example of this is found in Judith 7 concerning Bethulia, which was besieged by Holofernes. This also the Lord foretold to Jerusalem in Luke 19: "Your enemies will surround you with a rampart and press you in on every side."
Spiritually, the city is the Church: the Psalm: "Glorious things are said of you, O city of God." This city is small through humility, because in these the Lord alone dwells: the last chapter of Isaiah: "To whom shall I look, if not to the poor little one, contrite in spirit and trembling at my words"? "Few men in it," in comparison with the wicked: Matthew 20: "Many are called, but few are chosen." The great king is the devil, of whom it is said in the penultimate chapter of Job: "He is king over all the children of pride"; he is also great, according to what is said in the same place: "There is no power on earth that can be compared to him." This king comes against the city through temptations: he surrounds it, by offering manifold pleasures: he built fortifications, by procuring occasions of sin: and he perfectly besieges it, when he entangles them in transgressions of the commandments. Concerning these things, Luke 19: "Your enemies will surround you with a rampart and hem you in and dash you to the ground, and they will not leave a stone upon a stone."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"And there was found in it" etc. Here is noted the succor of wisdom, where there was a deficiency of power: therefore he says: "And there was found in it a poor man," and thus powerless: "and wise, and he delivered the city by his wisdom." An example of this, how a wise person delivered, is found concerning Judith in her book, how she delivered Bethulia from Holofernes by her wisdom, though she was weak. Another example is found in 2 Kings 20, where it is said that a wise person in Abel delivered the city from the assault of Joab. On the contrary, it is said in Baruch 3: "And because they did not have wisdom, they perished on account of their foolishness"; this is said concerning the mighty.
"And no one afterwards" etc. Here the fourth point is touched upon, namely the contempt of the wise deliverer, the sign of which is forgetfulness. Therefore he says: "No one afterwards remembered that poor man." Behold, contempt and ingratitude: against which it is said in Ecclesiasticus 29: "Do not forget the kindness of your surety, for he gave his life for you" etc.
Spiritually, "A poor and wise man," who is Christ, who is a man from the strength of virtue: Jeremiah 31: "A woman shall encompass a man." He is also poor: 2 Corinthians 8: "Though he was rich in all things, for your sake he became poor"; wise, indeed Wisdom itself: 1 Corinthians 1: "We preach Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God." He was found by those who seek: Matthew 7: "For everyone who asks receives, and he who seeks finds." He delivered the people, Isaiah 19: "They shall cry out to the Lord from the face of the oppressor, and he shall send them a savior and a defender, who shall deliver them"; he delivered them through his wisdom, though he could have done so through power: Job 26: "His prudence struck the proud one." — "And no one afterward remembered him," because poverty is despised: Proverbs 19: "The brothers of the poor man hated him; moreover, even his friends withdrew far from him." No one remembered him by having compassion, according to what is said in Lamentations 3: "Remember my poverty and my transgression, the wormwood and the gall"; but on the contrary, Amos 6: "They suffered nothing over the affliction of Joseph." By giving thanks: Luke 17: "And there was not found anyone who returned to give glory to God except this foreigner." By imitating in deed: Isaiah 17: "You shall be desolate, because you have forgotten the God of your salvation, and have not remembered your mighty helper." By confessing with the mouth: Genesis 40: "When prosperity followed, the butler forgot his interpreter."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The contempt and oblivion of the wise man has been shown; here is shown secondly the commendation of the despised one. He commends wisdom, however, by a threefold preeminence: first, by setting it above the strength of power; second, above the defense of armor; third, above the height of worldly glory.
He therefore first sets forth wisdom above strength by his own judgment. For this reason he says: "And I said that wisdom is better than strength"; Wisdom 6: "Wisdom is better than strength, and a prudent man is better than a strong one." And because it is better, therefore it ought not to be despised; and yet nonetheless it is despised. For this reason he says: "How then is the wisdom of the poor man despised?" as though it ought not to be despised; but on account of poverty it is held in contempt. Whence in Ecclesiasticus 13 it is said of the poor man: "The sensible man spoke, and no place was given to him; the rich man spoke, and all were silent, and they carry his word up to the clouds." And the sign of contempt for wisdom is added: "And his words were not heard"; and yet they are very much to be heard. Proverbs 8: "Now therefore, children, hear me: Blessed are they who keep my ways."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And that the words of the wise man are to be heard, he adds: "The words of the wise are heard in silence," that is, they are worthy to be heard in silence. Ecclesiasticus 32: "Listen in silence, and for your reverence good grace shall come to you"; whence it is also added: "And do not presume to speak in the midst of great men." "More than the cry of a prince among fools," and his speech is more clamorous, because however much a man may cry out, the fool does not pay attention. Ecclesiasticus 22: "He who tells wisdom to a fool speaks with one who is sleeping, and at the end of the narration he says: 'Who is this?'" That wisdom therefore is despised, this is on account of the foolishness of the hearers; therefore Matthew 7: "Do not give what is holy to dogs." And the reason for this is given by the Apostle in 1 Corinthians 2: "The natural man does not perceive the things that are of the Spirit of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, the fruit of wisdom is born of the last four by contrast. Corresponding to this fruit, there are four acts, for wisdom is comforting, struggling, contemplating, and extolling. It comforts the good: "Wisdom is a better defense for the wise man than would be ten princes in the city." It is also struggling, against evil: "Better is wisdom than weapons of war." Again, Wisdom "gave him a strong conflict, that he might overcome and know that wisdom is mightier than all."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Wisdom is better," etc. Here secondly he sets forth wisdom above the defense of armor, saying: "Wisdom is better than weapons of war," because weapons of war are for protection; likewise wisdom protects. Proverbs 2: "Counsel shall keep you, and prudence shall preserve you, that you may be delivered from the evil way and from the man who speaks perverse things." And that it protects better is clear, because he who loses wisdom through fault cannot defend himself by armor without losing many goods. Whence he says: "And he who shall sin in one thing," by departing from wisdom, according to what was said above in chapter 8: "Do not hasten to depart from his face, nor persist in an evil work." "Shall lose many good things"; for by sinning in one thing, he loses wisdom, and by losing it, he loses many good things. Wisdom 7: "All good things came to me together with her"; and therefore, when she is lost, many good things are lost. Or: "he who shall sin in one thing," against charity, "shall lose many good things," according to that saying in James 2: "He who sins in one thing is made guilty of all." And he makes this manifest through a metaphor, because the awareness of sin is compared to a dying fly, because it renders and produces abomination in the affection and in the conscience.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore he adds: dying flies, that is, the thoughts of sinners succeeding one another and inclining toward mortal sin, destroy the sweetness of the ointment, that is, they destroy the anointing, and thus many good things, because First John 2: "The anointing teaches you about all things." Or: the sweetness of the ointment, that is, interior devotion and the sweetness of wisdom: Proverbs 27: "The heart is delighted with ointment and various fragrances."
More precious is wisdom. Here, thirdly, wisdom is set above the height of worldly glory, or even above the foolishness that fools desire. Therefore he says: More precious is wisdom and a little glory, that is, with little glory, for a time, that is, temporally — better, I say, than foolishness, even with great glory: above in chapter 4: "Better is a poor and wise child than an old and foolish king." Or the sense can be that wisdom is better than foolishness; and also that a little glory, for a time, that is, bestowed at the proper time, is better than foolishness.
Question.
Here arises the question concerning what he says: He who shall offend in one thing, etc.
1. For if God always punishes less than what is deserved, then he who sins in one thing ought not to be punished except in one thing: therefore he ought not to lose many things, but one.
2. Likewise, from this it seems that there is a connection among the vices, just as among the virtues; because if vice is the privation of good, then if by one sin many good things are lost, then by one sin a man incurs many vices; but this is only through connection: therefore there is a connection among the vices.
3. Likewise, that there is a connection in vices with respect to all things is apparent; it is said in James 2: Whoever offends in one point is become guilty of all: therefore it seems that whoever perpetrates one vice is as guilty as if he perpetrated all of them.
But on the contrary: 1. Because some vices are contrary to each other: therefore if there were a connection in vices, then two contraries would exist simultaneously in the same subject, which is unlawful to say.
2. Likewise, vices are not from God, but acquired from our own work: but it is certain that temperance and justice are not acquired in us by the same act, when they are habitual: therefore similarly also in vices.
I respond: it must be said that one can speak of sin by reason of deformity and by reason of obligation to punishment. If by reason of deformity, that indeed regards three things, namely the privation of gratuitous good, the privation of natural good or natural aptitude, and furthermore the inclination to a disordered act, which is called a certain disposition. By reason of the first good there is indeed a connection in vices, because whoever sins in one sin loses grace and all the virtues, insofar as they are gratuitous. But by reason of the privation of aptitude there is no connection, but rather a distinction among them, because each vice deprives its own proper aptitude. By reason of the third, namely the inclination to act, there is neither complete distinction nor complete connection, but rather in some cases one inclines to another, and in some cases it inclines only sometimes, as the sin of gluttony to the sin of lust, and similarly in spiritual matters, pride to envy.
One can speak again of sins with respect to the obligation of punishment, and thus they obligate to a twofold punishment, namely the deprivation of the vision and the harshness of fire. With respect to the first there is a connection, because whoever sins in one sin loses the glory owed to all the virtues. But with respect to the second there is no connection, but distinction, because to each corresponds its own proper harshness.
This word of Ecclesiastes and of blessed James is therefore understood with respect to the loss of grace and glory.
To the objection, therefore, that one is punished beyond one's desert: I say that this is false, because whoever sins in one act sins against the grace of all the virtues, and therefore deserves to lose the whole.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth aspect of the zeal of wisdom is the elevation of desire. This gives worth to other endeavors, so that forgetting what is behind, we strain forward to what is before. "The wise man has eyes in his head. — The heart of a wise man is in his right hand." Now, the zeal of wisdom consists in this, that our endeavor be directed toward nothing but God who is "all delight."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The heart of the wise man is at his right hand, and the heart of the fool at his left; by the right hand good things are understood, by the left hand evil things: Matthew 25: "He shall set the sheep on his right hand, but the goats on his left." He means therefore to say that the wise think good things and the foolish think evil things: Proverbs 10: "The lips of the just consider what is pleasing, but the mouth of the wicked what is perverse." The right hand gives us to understand eternal goods, the left hand temporal things: whence Proverbs 3: "Length of days is in her right hand, and in her left hand riches and glory." He means therefore to say that the wise think upon and desire eternal goods, and the foolish temporal things: Song of Songs 2: "His left hand is under my head, and his right hand shall embrace me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fool therefore thinks vain things and knows not how to consider things with discernment, neither in himself nor in others, which is a greater disadvantage. Therefore he adds: But also the fool walking in the way, namely in that way which seems good to him: Proverbs 12: "The way of a fool is right in his own eyes." Since he himself is foolish, that is, since he walks foolishly, because in darkness; above in chapter 2: "The fool walks in darkness." He esteems all others to be fools, whence Proverbs 26: "The sluggard seems wiser to himself than seven men who speak wise sayings."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The contempt of the wise man has been set forth above, and conversely his just commendation: here is subjoined thirdly the promotion of fools. And because the authority of fools is burdensome, therefore the armor of patience is set forth first, and the disordered authority of fools is subjoined, at the text: There is an evil which I have seen, etc.
Therefore the armor of patience is set forth first, for the possession of which he says: If the spirit of him who has power, that is, the fury of a prelate: for spirit is called fury in Isaiah 2: "Cease from man, whose spirit is in his nostrils"; 3 Kings 19: "A great and strong spirit, overturning mountains and crushing," etc. Ascend upon you, namely to oppress: Jeremiah 4: "Behold, he shall ascend like a cloud, and his chariots like a tempest: woe to us, for we are laid waste." Do not leave your place, that is, the place of patience and constancy, in which the soul finds rest, according to that passage in Luke 21: "In your patience you shall possess your souls"; 1 Peter 2: "Servants, be subject in all fear to your masters, not only to the gentle, but also to the harsh: for this is grace, if for the sake of conscience toward God one endures," etc. And the reason for its usefulness is given: Because healing will cause the greatest sins to cease. Here healing is called the affliction of scourges, by which man is healed: Wisdom 6: "The care of discipline is love, and love is the keeping of the laws." The predication is causal in both cases, because if through many scourges one arrives at love, and through this the law is kept: therefore it causes sins to cease.
It is expounded otherwise: If the spirit of him who has power, that is, if the spirit of ambition, that is, the malice of the ambitious, ascend upon you, that is, if it comes into your mind that you wish to be a prelate: do not leave your place, namely the place of subjection and servitude, concerning which Luke 14: "When you are invited to the wedding, recline in the last place," and Sirach 11: "Trust in God, and remain in your place." And the reason is given: Because healing will cause the greatest sins to cease. The translation of Symmachus has: Because modesty: whence 1 Corinthians 9: "I chastise my body and bring it into subjection, lest perhaps, having preached to others, I myself should become a castaway."
It is expounded otherwise concerning the devil: If the spirit of him who has power, that is, of the devil: Job, the penultimate chapter: "There is no power on earth that can be compared to him"; ascend upon you, and this by tempting: Luke 11: "When the unclean spirit has gone out of a man, he walks through waterless places, seeking rest, and does not find it." Do not leave your place, namely the place of penitence: Ephesians 4: "Do not give place to the devil." Because healing will cause the greatest sins to cease: Origen's text has: salvation, which indeed is through the medicine of penitence: Sirach 11: "The malice of one hour causes forgetfulness of the greatest pleasure," that is, brief penitence for a great sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is an evil which I have seen etc. Here the second point is touched upon, namely the disordered promotion of fools, both on account of a defect of knowledge and on account of a defect of life, because the foolish and wicked are placed in authority, while the wise and those rich in good morals are cast down. On account of which he says: There is an evil which I have seen under the sun, that is, in the present state of men, as it were proceeding from error, not from error according to truth, but apparently from error, yet nevertheless according to just judgment: from the face of the prince, namely of him from whom is all power, who by just judgment sometimes gives wicked prelates: Hosea 13: "I will give you a king in my fury, and I will take him away in my indignation."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he expresses what that evil is with regard to the defect of knowledge: The fool set in high dignity: set, he rightly says, because there is nothing there but a false placing: Psalm: "You set them up, you cast them down when they were lifted up." Or: set as a useless stone: whence in Zechariah 11 it is said to the foolish prelate: "O shepherd and idol! abandoning the flock, a sword upon his arm and upon his right eye: his arm shall utterly wither, and his right eye shall be completely darkened": and therefore Proverbs 26: "As he who casts a stone into the heap of Mercury, so is he who gives honor to a fool." On the contrary: The rich sitting below: rich, namely in good morals and knowledge and grace, of whom in 1 Corinthians 1: "In all things you are made rich in him, so that nothing is wanting to you in any grace"; and Isaiah 33: "The riches of salvation are wisdom and knowledge."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“With regard to the defect of life he says: I have seen servants upon horses: servants, he calls sinners, of whom in John 8: "He who commits sin is the servant of sin"; upon horses, he says in the plural to express pomp: Deuteronomy 17: "When he shall have been established, he shall not multiply horses for himself." On the contrary: Princes walking as servants, namely those princes who rule themselves through a good life: Seneca: "If you shall have ruled yourself well, you will be a prince": these he saw as servants, but in the future it will be the contrary: Luke 14: "Everyone who humbles himself shall be exalted, and he who exalts himself shall be humbled."
Question.
It is asked here whether it is just that the wicked should rule over the good. That it is, it seems:
1. Because it is said in Romans 13: There is no power except from God: therefore wicked princes do not have power except from God.
2. Likewise, John 19: You would not have, Christ said to Pilate, any power against me unless it had been given to you from above. And Augustine expounds from above: that is, from God: therefore if Pilate was wicked and used his power wickedly, then that the wicked rule, this is from God.
3. Likewise, 1 Peter 2: Be subject not only to the good and gentle, but also to the froward, and he gives the reason: for conscience's sake: therefore if it is just to be subject to them, since everything just is from God, this also will be from him.
4. Likewise, Job 34: Who makes a hypocrite to reign on account of the sins of the people, etc.: therefore, etc.
On the contrary: 1. Hosea 8: They have reigned, but not by me; princes have arisen, and I knew it not: therefore it seems that the prelacy of the wicked is not from God.
2. Likewise, servitude is a punishment inflicted for sin, therefore it is rightly and justly inflicted on no one except a sinner: therefore by contraries, neither is dominion justly given except to the just. Therefore if dominion is given to a sinner, and servitude to the just, there is a defect of order and justice: therefore it is not from God.
3. Furthermore, if the power of the wicked is just and from God, because nothing from God is other than just; since no one ought to take away another's right: therefore no one ought to labor for the deposition of a wicked prelate: therefore whoever labors against this sins.
I respond: it must be said that a wicked or unjust prelate falls under a threefold distinction. One is unjust in himself, yet enters justly and exercises authority justly: and such a one can justly hold authority, nor does he sin in this, and it is just to be subject to such a one. There is also another, who enters unjustly and exercises authority unjustly: and such a one cannot justly hold authority, nor ought a man to be subject to such a one. There is also another, who is unjust, yet enters justly, but exercises authority unjustly, because he afflicts the good and promotes the wicked: it is just to be subject to such a one in those things that pertain to justice; but in those things that are against God, a man ought not to be subject: and "because he deserves to lose his privilege who abuses the power granted to him," even if he entered justly: nevertheless it is just that he be removed.
As to what is objected regarding the first part, whether it is just for the wicked to hold authority: it must be said that for the wicked who govern well to hold authority is not an evil to the commonwealth; but for those who govern wickedly, it is just that they hold authority, not by their own justice, but by divine justice, because he makes him to reign on account of the sins of the people. And thus the response to the first objections is clear, that the power of wicked men is from God.
1. To the first objection to the contrary, I say that it is understood with respect to those who enter illegitimately and by their own authority, not divine.
2. To the objection concerning order, I say that the punishment of sin remains even without sin for the purpose of discipline: so also I say concerning servitude among the good.
3. To the objection: if it is from God, therefore it is just that he have such power: it must be said that in comparison to his own merits it is not just, but rather iniquitous; in comparison to the merits of the wicked subjects it is just. And because from diverse causes it is lawful for us to will contrary things, where the divine will is not evident; and we do not know which of these may be more pleasing to God in the future: a man can justly labor for the removal of an unjust prelate.
Furthermore, he received such power from God, but its execution from himself: he held power justly, but exercises it unjustly: and therefore, as long as he holds power from God, he must be obeyed: but because he exercises it unjustly, one must work so that he no longer holds it. Thus that point is clear.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He set forth above the vanity of security: here secondly he intends to give a remedy against that vanity: and because security arose from a defect of just retribution and of the governance of providence, which appeared to exist: therefore there are here two parts. First he gives a remedy against the defect of the order of providence: second, against the defect of just retribution, below in chapter eleven: Cast your bread etc.
The disorder of governance comes from a threefold cause: either because a wicked man is placed in charge, or because a foolish one, or because a useless and lax one. First, therefore, he gives a remedy against a wicked prelate; second, against a foolish prelate, at: The words of the mouth of a wise man are grace: third, against a carnal and lax prelate, at: Woe to you, O land, whose king is a child.
As to the first point, then, he proceeds as follows. First he says that a good prelate is not to be removed: second, that a wicked one is not to be endured or promoted: third, he says that one who has been promoted is to be corrected: fourth, that one must not secretly detract from him.
First, therefore, he says that a good prelate is not to be removed, neither by fraud nor by violence. Not by fraud: whence he threatens: He who digs a pit, namely by preparing a snare for a good prelate, shall fall into it: the Psalm: "He opened a pit and dug it out, and he fell into the pit which he made." Nor is he to be removed by power; whence he threatens one who does the contrary: He who breaks down a hedge, that is, a good prelate, who guards his subjects like a hedge: Sirach thirty-six: "Where there is no hedge, the property will be plundered." A serpent shall bite him, that is, the devil with his demons, who are biting serpents: Jeremiah eight: "Behold, I will send among you the worst serpents, against which there is no charm, and they shall bite you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He who moves stones etc. Here he shows secondly that a harsh and useless prelate is not to be promoted; and he threatens those who promote a harsh one: whence he says: He who moves stones, that is, promotes the hard and wicked to a greater dignity; shall be afflicted by them, that is, through them, or on account of them: Proverbs 26: "As he who casts a stone into the heap of Mercury, so is he who gives honor to a fool"; and afterward: "He who rolls a stone, it shall return upon him"; and Sirach 27: "He who throws a stone on high, it shall fall upon his own head." Neither is one who is vain and useless to be promoted; therefore he says: He who cuts wood, another translation: He who hews: he hews, who wishes to place a useless prelate as a support for the edifice. A useless prelate is compared to wood, because just as unfruitful wood when cut is given over to fire, so also the prelate: Matthew 7: "Every tree that does not bear good fruit shall be cut down and cast into the fire." He shall be wounded by them, because, namely, the conscience is wounded: Sirach 27: "The deceitful blow of the deceitful man shall lay open wounds." Concerning these wounds, Isaiah 1: "Wound and bruise and swelling sore, it is not bound up nor fomented with oil."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If the iron has become blunt etc. Here he adds thirdly that the prelate who has in some way turned aside to evil is to be corrected, because he can be of value, although much labor is required. Therefore he says: If the iron has become blunt, that is, the edge of goodness and wisdom has been altered through fault in the prelate; and this not as before, supply "sharp," but has become dull, through fault; with much labor, namely of correction, it shall be sharpened, that is, it shall be restored to its former uprightness: Proverbs 27: "Iron is sharpened by iron, and a man sharpens the face of his friend." And through this likeness of corporeal things he draws a conclusion in spiritual matters: And after diligence, that is, the labor of diligence, wisdom shall follow, just as after the sharpening of iron there follows the straightness and fineness of the edge for cutting: Proverbs 15: "The ear that hears the reproofs of life shall dwell in the midst of the wise"; and Proverbs 2: "If you seek her as money and dig for her as for a treasure, then you shall understand the fear of the Lord and shall find knowledge."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If it bites etc. Here he shows fourthly that one ought not secretly detract from such a prelate, and he shows the magnitude of the fault of detraction through a comparison in bodily things. Therefore he says: If a serpent bites in silence, which is proper to the serpent itself, because it secretly infuses venom, he who secretly detracts has nothing less than it, because, just as that is fraudulent, so also is this, because this is to curse the deaf: Leviticus 19: "You shall not curse the deaf, nor place a stumbling block before the blind." Just as that is deadly, so also is this: Galatians 5: "If you bite and devour one another, take heed lest you be consumed by one another": Proverbs 26: "The words of a whisperer are as simple things, and they reach even to the innermost parts of the belly." Just as of old they were delivered by looking upon Christ, according to what is said in Wisdom 16: "He who turned was not healed by what he saw, but by you, O Lord, the Savior of all": so also now. Whence he himself said, John 15: "If they have kept my word, they will keep yours also."
Question.
It is asked whether to speak evil of someone secretly is detraction and sin, where it is established that what is said is true. That it is not, it seems:
1. Because, just as the good person is worthy of praise, so the evil person is worthy of blame: therefore just as it is just to praise the good, so it is just to blame the evil: therefore just as he who praises the good does not sin, neither does he who speaks evil of the evil.
2. Likewise, just as one ought to rejoice with the good, so one ought to have compassion on the evil: therefore just as someone can recount to another the good of another person while rejoicing together without sin, so also the evil while having compassion: therefore he who speaks evil of another secretly, if he has compassion, does not sin.
3. Moreover, the Lord says in Matthew 18 that when a neighbor sins, he is to be corrected before one or before two: and if he does not listen, it is to be told to the Church: therefore at least concerning the incorrigible, it seems that a person may speak evil to anyone.
On the contrary: 1. What you do not wish done to you, do not do to another: therefore what you do not wish said about you, you ought not say about another: but you ought not wish that anyone speak evil of you in your absence, because it will profit you nothing: therefore etc.
2. Likewise, he who speaks evil of another takes away his good name: therefore since a good name is better than many treasures, therefore since a person cannot take away another's treasures without sin, likewise etc.
3. Likewise, it is said in Leviticus 19: You shall not curse the deaf: but he who speaks evil behind one's back curses the deaf: therefore he acts against that precept.
4. Moreover, a sin committed in public causes scandal: therefore he who makes public some sin that is not public causes scandal: but he who speaks against another makes known a sin that is hidden: therefore he scandalizes the one with whom he speaks.
I respond: it must be said that he who speaks evil of another either speaks compelled by necessity, or induced by usefulness, or driven by the desire to detract. He is compelled by necessity when he is bound by a precept either human or divine: human, when he speaks to one who can command and does command him to speak; divine, when conscience dictates to a man that he is bound to accuse his neighbor so that he may be corrected, according to that precept of the Lord concerning fraternal correction.
He is induced by usefulness when he narrates the evil of another to someone who can benefit and not harm, and for whom it is beneficial to hear that evil and not harmful, as when someone narrates to a person who loves and who has compassion and has the will to correct him.
But when neither necessity nor usefulness is considered, even if there be truth, one is not excused from the desire to detract; indeed, one sins with the sin of detraction, even if one speaks the truth.
Therefore the arguments that prove it is a sin to speak evil of another in his absence must be conceded, unless necessity or usefulness intervenes: for then it is clear that they do not hold.
1. To what is objected to the contrary, that it is just to blame, etc.; it must be said that although they are worthy of blame, nevertheless a man ought not to blame them. Nor is the case similar with praise, because a good reputation excites to good, but an evil one to evil, and therefore evil is not to be made public as good is.
Moreover, it is not mine to judge.
2. To what is objected concerning compassion, it must be said that true compassion is that in which the one who has compassion is wounded, not that in which the wretched person is harmed. And because this person in such speaking harms the sinner in his reputation, therefore he ought not to accuse.
3. To what is objected concerning the Lord's command, it must be said that the Lord means that those are to be called who can and will be of benefit: and by the Church He does not mean the multitude, but He means the one who can be of benefit and ought to correct, and to such a one it is to be told.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The words of the mouth of a wise man are grace." Speech is the instrument for expressing wisdom, and therefore it ought to be governed according to the rule of wisdom. It is a wondrous thing that when men sit at table to refresh themselves spiritually, one devil speaks of temporal matters and of detractions and feeds all who are at table with that poison.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He gave above a remedy against the malice of a prelate; here he gives a remedy against the foolishness of a prelate, showing that a foolish prelate is not to be promoted, but rather is worthy of ruin: first, on account of the defect of discreet speech; second, on account of the defect of provident consideration; third, on account of the defect of fruitful action.
On account of the defect of discreet speech, the fool casts himself down, just as by antithesis the wise man exalts himself. Therefore he says: The words of a wise man's mouth are grace, because in them through discretion he acquires grace: Sirach 20: "A wise man makes himself lovable by his words"; but on the contrary: The lips of a fool will cast him down, that is, the words that proceed from the lips of a fool: Proverbs 18: "The mouth of a fool is his destruction, and his lips are the ruin of his soul."
Spiritually here by the wise man we understand Christ, by the foolish man the antichrist. The words of the mouth of the wise man are grace, because the words of Christ are gracious: the Psalm: "Grace is poured forth on your lips, therefore God has blessed you forever"; and Luke 2: "All who heard him were astonished at his understanding and his answers"; and others said, John 7: "Never has a man spoken thus." On the contrary, the fool is the antichrist, of whom it is said in the Psalm: "The fool has said in his heart: There is no God." His lips will cast him down, because on account of the malice of his teaching he will be plunged into the deep, Job 18: "The steps of his strength shall be straitened, and his own counsel shall cast him down."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the reason for precipitousness is indiscretion, because he indiscreetly inclines: whence he says: The beginning of his words is folly. And the reason for this is that he does not consider, whence Proverbs twenty-nine: "Have you seen a man swift to speak? Folly is more to be expected than his correction." He also indiscreetly concludes: whence he says: And the last thing of his mouth is the worst error, because folly in the end leads to an erroneous judgment; Proverbs fourteen: "The imprudence of fools errs"; because, as was said above in chapter two, "the eyes of the wise man are in his head, the fool walks in darkness."
Spiritually, his words will be words of blasphemy and pride: therefore foolish and erroneous. Whence it is said, Daniel 11: "He shall speak magnificent things against the God of gods, and shall prosper, until the wrath is accomplished"; and 2 Thessalonians 2: "The man of sin shall be revealed, the son of perdition, who opposes and exalts himself above all that is called God," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Furthermore, he perseveres in folly: therefore he adds: The fool multiplies words, thus by multiplying foolish words he becomes obstinate in malice: against which in the Psalm: "Incline not my heart to words of malice" etc.; and this is useless and vain, whence it is said in Proverbs nineteen: "But he who pursues words will have nothing"; and Proverbs fourteen: "Where words are most plentiful, there is frequently want."
Man knows not what has been before him, as one foolish and inconsiderate: James one: "He considered himself and went away and immediately forgot what he was like." And what shall be after him, who can tell him? As if to say: no one: above in chapter eight: "He who is ignorant of the past can know the future by no messenger," and this indeed is very harmful: whence Deuteronomy thirty-two: "Would that they were wise and understood and would foresee their last end."
Spiritually, this fool will not only be indiscreet in speaking, but also improvident, because he will not consider the ruin that is to follow him, according to what the Apostle says, 2 Thessalonians 2: "Whom the Lord Jesus shall slay with the spirit of his mouth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“How, then, should one strive for knowledge, wisdom and holiness? It is good to know in order to obtain the fruits of wisdom, in order that we may enter through the city doors. As Ecclesiastes writes, "the labor of fools shall afflict them that know not how to go to the city," that is, who do not know how to direct their endeavors properly.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The labor of fools etc. Here thirdly he shows that in the fool there is a defect of fruitful operation, because in his labor he is much afflicted and profits little. Therefore he says: The labor of fools shall afflict them, because they do not labor in good things: Jeremiah nine: "They have labored to act wickedly": whence Wisdom five: "We have wearied ourselves in the way of iniquity and perdition and have walked difficult paths: but the way of the Lord we have not known." And he gives the reason for this: Who know not how to go to the city, that is, they know not the right way to go to that city, of which Isaiah twenty-six says: "The city of our strength is Sion the Savior; a wall and a bulwark shall be set in it." To this city fools know not how to go: whence above in chapter six: "What has the wise man more than the fool? And what has the poor man, except to go thither where there is life?"
Spiritually, fools will follow this fool and will be afflicted: Who do not know how to go to the city, through true faith and love: 2 Thessalonians 2: "God shall send them the operation of error, who did not believe the truth, but consented to iniquity"; because they did not receive the love of truth: therefore the unknowing will be deceived: whence in the Psalm: "They knew not, nor did they understand, therefore they walk in darkness."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He gave the remedy against the disorder that arises from a wicked and foolish prelate: here thirdly he gives the remedy against the disorder that arises from a useless and lax prelate. He shows therefore that such a slothful and carnal person ought not to be set over others nor even tolerated. And this part has two sections: because first he denounces him, showing him unworthy of prelacy; second, he says that one ought not secretly to detract from him, at: In your thought, etc.
He shows, therefore, that the carnal and slothful man is unworthy of prelacy, first on account of the disorder of gluttony; second on account of the weakness or idleness of sloth; third on account of the unfittingness of merriment; fourth on account of the subversion of justice, through love of money. On account of the disorder of gluttony, the carnal and lax prelate is unworthy of prelacy, and woe to those who set him over themselves. Therefore he says: Woe to you, O land, whose king is a child, that is, a pursuer of passions; for children are pursuers of passions. Isaiah, penultimate chapter: "The child of a hundred years shall die." Therefore woe, because it is an occasion of eternal damnation and a sign of divine indignation. Isaiah 3: "I will give children to be their princes, and the effeminate shall rule over them." And because princes follow their leader, therefore he says: And whose princes eat in the morning, quickly seeking pleasurable things; and therefore they are always foolish, because it is said in Proverbs 20: "Wine is a luxurious thing, and drunkenness is tumultuous; whoever is delighted by these things shall not be wise."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And because "opposites placed next to each other shine forth more clearly," he commends the contrary, saying in detestation of the former: Blessed is the land whose king is noble, namely with nobility of character, because nobility alone is that which adorns the soul with good morals. Concerning which, Proverbs, last chapter: "Her husband is noble in the gates, when he sits among the senators of the land." And because princes follow their leader, therefore he adds: And whose princes eat at their proper time, that is, at the due hour after business has been dispatched, and this for refreshment, not for luxury. The Interlinear Gloss: "They eat only that they may live; they do not live that they may eat," as do those of whom 2 Peter 2 says: "Defilements and stains, abounding in delights, reveling in their feasts."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In slothfulness shall be brought low, etc. Here, secondly, it is shown that the lax prelate himself is unworthy on account of the idleness of sloth, which is followed by the destruction of the house that was built. On account of which he says: In slothfulness the roofing shall be brought low. The roofing is called the joining of timbers for covering a house. This is brought low in slothfulness, because, while its repair is neglected, it collapses; so also is the spiritual building destroyed through sloth. Proverbs 18: "He who is soft and slack in his work is the brother of him who wastes his own works." And because, where there is no goading fear of the Lord, sloth reigns, therefore it is said in Sirach 27: "If you do not hold yourself steadfastly in the fear of the Lord, your house shall quickly be overthrown." And in the weakness of hands the house shall leak. He says the same thing, but explains it further: the house leaks through, when it is rainy and does not defend against the showers, in which it is neither good nor safe to be: whence Proverbs twenty-seven: "A dripping roof on a day of cold and a quarrelsome woman are compared." This house leaks through when the hands are weak and slack: therefore Hebrews twelve: "Lift up your slack hands and loosened knees, and make straight steps with your feet."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In laughter they make bread etc. Here thirdly he shows the unworthiness of the slothful and carnal man on account of the unseemliness of merriment, in which the carnal always wish to be, and on account of which they do everything that they do. Therefore he says: In laughter they make bread and wine. The Gloss: Prelates in laughter, that is, in unseemly merriment; Luke twelve: "My soul, you have many good things for many years; eat, drink, be merry." And therefore he adds: That they may feast by drinking: for they act so that they may eat, not so that they may break bread for the hungry: James five: "You have feasted upon the earth and in luxuries have nourished your hearts." And for this they are rebuked in Isaiah five: "The harp and the lyre and wine are at your banquets, and the work of God you do not regard."
And all things obey money etc. Here fourthly it is touched upon that they are unworthy on account of the subversion of justice, which they subvert out of love of money. Therefore he says: And all things obey money, because all love money above all things: Isaiah one: "All love gifts, they pursue rewards," and thence follows the subversion of justice: "They do not judge for the orphan, and the cause of the widow does not come before them": and Jeremiah six: "From the least even to the greatest, all are devoted to avarice."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here he restrains subjects from secret detraction, should it happen that such a one is placed in authority: and first he sets forth the exhortation; second, he gives the reason.
He exhorts therefore that one should neither speak evil by diminishing reputation, nor call down a curse by wishing his misery. Therefore he says: In your thought do not detract from the king, that is, in secret: Exodus twenty-two: "You shall not detract from the gods, and you shall not curse the prince of your people." And in the secret of your chamber, that is, of your conscience, do not curse the rich man, and this by calling down evil: Romans twelve: "Bless those who persecute you, bless and do not curse"; and First Peter three: "Not curse for curse."
Because the birds of heaven etc. Here the reason for the exhortation is given: because what you said in secret will be made public by the Angels, because the birds of heaven will carry your voice. He calls the birds of heaven demons on account of their swiftness, because they are swift, or on account of their rapacity: whence Genesis fifteen: "The birds of heaven descended upon the carcasses, and Abraham drove them away"; and Matthew thirteen: "Another fell by the wayside, and the birds came and ate it up." And here heaven is called the murky air, in which demons dwell. These carry the voice, because they frequently make public what is hidden: Matthew ten: "Nothing is hidden that shall not be known." And he who has wings will announce the matter, that is, the devil will announce your evil speech, because he is the accuser: but he will at last be cast out, whence Revelation twelve: "The accuser of our brethren is cast out, who accused them day and night."
Questions.
I. But a doubt arises here, because he says that the birds of heaven, that is, demons, report the detraction of thought: therefore it seems that our will and thought are known to the devil.
But against this is: 1. Because of God alone is it said that He is searching hearts and reins: therefore He alone knows thoughts and affections.
2. Likewise, Augustine says that if the devil had known the patience of Job, he would never have tempted him, because he does not tempt anyone except to conquer, not to be conquered.
I respond: it must be said that neither demons nor even good Angels, except in the Word, can know our thoughts and hidden affections: and I call hidden, those which are not manifested through signs: but those which are manifested through signs, demons detect and know: and because there are few of which no signs appear, whether in deed, or in the face, or in speech, or in some other way: therefore he says that they hear.
II. Likewise, it is asked concerning what he says, that the birds of heaven will carry or announce.
I ask: how will they carry? If it is said, that to him about whom it is spoken: this is false, because then everyone would know all the hidden evils that are said about him: he understands therefore that they will carry them to God.
But against this: 1. God is more immediate and more present to us than demons, since He is not far from each one of us. If therefore to carry or to announce is done to one who is distant, it is evident that it is not the same.
2. Likewise, through whom is that carrying done? Either through good Angels or through evil ones: not through good ones, because good Angels procure our salvation, not therefore our damnation: therefore they do not bring evils. If through demons: against this: Demons do not see God nor do they speak to God any more than evil men do: therefore if evil men do not bring things to God, then neither do demons.
I respond: it must be said that birds here are called evil spirits or demons: these are said to carry to God evil and hidden deeds, while good Angels carry good deeds. But to carry is not to report to God by voice, or to notify Him as though He were ignorant, but to know our malice, and by knowing to remember it, and to be a witness. The good, however, add beyond knowledge, memory, and testimony, intercession; but the evil add the will to accuse.
And thus the response is clear, because they do not report as to one who is distant, but as to a judge. And to the second, because the evil by their office observe evil deeds and procure damnation: therefore it belongs to them.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, a remedy is given against the vanity of security arising from the failure of the retribution of justice.
Cast your bread etc. He set forth above a remedy against the fact that the governance of providence seemed to fail due to the disorder of prelacy: here secondly he sets forth a remedy against the fact that the retribution of justice seemed to fail, on account of which man became secure in evil and grew sluggish toward good. This remedy consists in the consideration of future retribution: and since God bestows good things upon those who do well and repays evil things upon those who do evil: therefore first, from the consideration of reward, he invites to good: second, from the consideration of punishment, he recalls from evil, at the passage: If a man shall have lived many years.
First, he invites to good by the consideration of reward.
The good to which he invites is the good of piety, which "is profitable for all things," and on account of which the just are especially saved, as is evident in Matthew twenty-five, where only works of mercy are enumerated. Therefore he exhorts here to works of mercy and the giving of alms on account of retribution.
And first he exhorts that they be done willingly: second, that they be done abundantly, at the passage: Give portions to seven: third, that they be done unceasingly, at the passage: He who observes the wind shall never etc.
When therefore he exhorts that they be done voluntarily and willingly, he sets forth the exhortation and adds the reason.
He exhorts therefore to giving alms willingly: therefore he says: Cast your bread, that is, give willingly and liberally, not by extortion and as if compelled: Second Corinthians nine: "Let each one give as he has determined in his heart, not from sadness or from necessity: for God loves a cheerful giver." Your bread, not another's; Ecclesiasticus thirty-four: "He who offers a sacrifice from the substance of the poor is as one who slays a son in the sight of his father." Upon the passing waters. Many waters are many peoples, Apocalypse seventeen: passing waters are those who pass from nation to nation and from kingdom to another people: such are pilgrims and strangers: to these alms are to be given; Isaiah fifty-eight: "Break your bread for the hungry, and bring the needy and wandering into your house." Or: waters are present tribulations, according to that verse of the Psalm: "The waters have come in even unto my soul": passing waters are the poor and afflicted, because through tribulations they pass to rest: to such alms are to be given: Luke fourteen: When you give alms, call the poor and the feeble, the blind, etc. And the reason is given: Because after many days you shall find it, that is, the retribution for it: therefore retribution does not fail, but is deferred: Ecclesiasticus twelve: "Do good to the just, and you shall find great recompense: and if not from him, certainly from the Lord": likewise Luke sixteen: "Make for yourselves friends from the mammon of iniquity" etc.
These things can also be briefly explained concerning spiritual almsgiving, which consists in the instruction of one's neighbor: to which he similarly exhorts, to give willingly or liberally, abundantly and unceasingly:
Willingly or liberally, when he says: Cast your bread etc., that is, give freely; Matthew 10: "Freely you have received, freely give"; bread, namely of doctrine, of which is said in Lamentations 4: "The little ones asked for bread, and there was no one to break it for them." Upon the passing waters, that is, those who despise temporal goods, to whom alone it should be given: Matthew 7: "Do not give what is holy to dogs." Or: upon those of whom it is said in the Psalm: "We passed through fire and water, and you led us out" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Give portions to seven etc. Here secondly he exhorts to giving abundantly: and he sets forth the exhortation and subjoins the reason. He exhorts therefore to abundance, saying: Give portions to seven and also to eight, that is, according to the capacity of your powers give alms, so that, whether you be poor or rich, you give a seventh and an eighth of your goods, that is, you make the portion of the poor generous: Second Corinthians 8: "That your abundance may supply their want"; and Luke 11: "Give alms of that which remains over". Therefore he says: Give portions to seven: for by the number seven we understand what suffices to supply one's own necessity; whatever is beyond that is called seven and eight: and this is to be distributed to the poor, not to be stored up in earthly treasures, but in heavenly ones: whence Matthew 6: "Lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither rust nor moth destroys"; and Tobit 4: "If you have much, give abundantly: if you have little, strive willingly to impart even that little". And the reason for this generosity is given, when it is added: Because you know not what evil etc. And a manifold reason is given, namely on account of caution against evil; whence he says: You know not what evil shall come upon the earth. Because therefore you are not certain, you must provide for yourself, lest you fall into peril: and the best remedy is abundant almsgiving: Ecclesiasticus 29: "Shut up alms in the bosom of the poor, and it shall pray for you and deliver you from all evil".
Abundantly it is also to be dispensed: therefore he says: Give seven portions: seven portions we understand as the doctrine of Christ of the Old Testament, because there the seventh day was commanded to be observed. By eight we understand the doctrine of the New Testament, because the eighth day is commanded to be observed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On account of the amplification of merit he says: If the clouds be full, supply: by God, they will pour out rain upon the earth, on account of which rain the earth bears fruit: Hosea 6: "He will come to us like the rain, the early and the latter rain to the earth"; and this for bearing fruit and multiplying the goods of the earth through the merit of almsgiving. For just as full clouds inebriate the earth with rain, so multiplied alms inebriate the soul with grace: Second Corinthians 9: "Now he who supplies seed to the sower will both provide bread for eating and will multiply your seed and increase the growth of the fruits of your righteousness". On account of the stability of the reward, which cannot be changed nor lost: on account of which he says: If a tree fall to the south: this tree is man: concerning which Job 14: "A tree has hope; if it be cut down, it will sprout again." And the south gives to understand the warmth of charity and the state of glory: Song of Songs 4: "Arise, O north wind, and come, O south wind: blow through my garden" etc. Therefore for the tree to fall toward the south is for a man to be brought into glory at death; and then there it shall be, that is, it can never be displaced; Revelation 3: "He who overcomes, I will make him a pillar in the temple of my God, and he shall go out no more." If it falls to the north, there it shall be, that is, if unto infernal punishment; Jeremiah 1: "From the north shall all evil be spread forth"; he who falls into hell, there he shall be, because from thence he shall never be freed. For rightly it is said in the last chapter of Isaiah: "Their fire shall not be extinguished, and their worm shall not die." In whatever place it falls, there it shall be, whether for good or for ill; Galatians 6: "What a man sows, that also shall he reap."
And because a man cannot abundantly communicate doctrine unless he is filled from above, he says: If the clouds are filled, they will pour out rain upon the earth. The clouds are good preachers, who fly to the heights through contemplation: Isaiah 60: "Who are these who fly like clouds and like doves to their windows"? These are filled by the Lord with knowledge: Isaiah 11: "The earth is filled with your knowledge, as the waters covering the sea": and this through the Holy Spirit: Wisdom 1: "The Spirit of the Lord has filled the whole world." These clouds, once filled, will pour out rain, that is, the doctrine of the divine word; Ecclesiasticus 39: "He himself like rain will send forth the words of his wisdom"; Isaiah 55: "As the rain and snow descend from heaven and water the earth and soak it: so shall my word be," upon the earth of the heart for bearing fruit; Hebrews 6: "The earth, drinking in the rain that comes upon it, and bringing forth fitting vegetation" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He who observes the wind etc. Here he exhorts to giving unceasingly: and first he teaches that times are not to be watched; second, that divine works are not to be scrutinized; third, that works of mercy are to be continued.
As to the first, he says: He who observes the wind does not sow, because frequently a wind comes that he does not want, and the wind that would please him does not come. And he who considers the clouds shall never reap: and therefore it is necessary that when it is time for reaping, he should reap, and for sowing, he should sow, and not wait. So also in the matter at hand, while he has time, let him do good; Ecclesiasticus 4: "Do not afflict the heart of the needy, and do not delay a gift to one in distress"; and Proverbs 3: "Do not say to your friend: Go and come back, tomorrow I will give to you, when you can give at once"; and thus he ought not to delay.
Unceasingly also must it be dispensed: therefore he says: He who observes the wind does not sow. To sow is to preach the word of God: Matthew thirteen: "The sower went out to sow his seed": and afterwards he explains: "The seed is the word of God." This wind is the wind of detraction, concerning which Job one says: "A wind came from the region of the desert and struck the four corners of the house." He who observes this wind of detraction never sows, because he who fears the words of detracting men does not preach unto fruit, but rather is tossed about like a reed: Matthew eleven: "What did you go out to see? A reed shaken by the wind"? And he who observes the clouds will never reap. The clouds, as the Gloss says, are the blandishment of flattery, which he who desires to have never reaps eternal life, because "he has received his reward," Matthew six: and he sows in the flesh, and therefore will reap corruption, Galatians last chapter: "He who sows in the flesh" etc. And therefore these things are to be despised, but one must preach morning and evening; Second Timothy four: "Preach the word, be instant in season, out of season"; Acts twenty: "For three years I did not cease day and night, admonishing each one of you with tears."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As you know not what is the way etc. Above he said that times are not to be observed; here, second, he teaches that divine works are not to be considered or scrutinized, because we cannot; therefore he says: As you know not what is the way of the spirit. The Spirit, who is God, because this we do not know; whence John 3: "The Spirit breathes where He wills, and you hear His voice, but you know not," etc.; and Job 9: "If He comes to me, I shall not see Him; if He departs, I shall not perceive it." The spirit, which is the soul or spiritual creature, whose way, that is, origin, is not known, nor indeed its end; above, in chapter 3: "Who knows whether the spirit of the sons of Adam ascends upward?" The spirit, which is the wind, whose way is not known, that is, its origin; whence in the Psalm: "Who brings forth the winds from His treasuries"; Exodus 15: "Your spirit blew, and the sea covered them." He says therefore: As you know not what is the way of the spirit, and by what reason the bones are joined together in the womb of a pregnant woman, that is, how they are fitted together and differentiated: because even Avicenna himself says that the formative power of the members is a divine power: 2 Maccabees 7: "I know not how you appeared in my womb; for I neither gave you spirit and soul, nor did I fashion the members of each of you": but He fashioned them, to whom it is said in Job 10: "You have knit me together with bones and sinews." Just as you are ignorant of these things, which are carnal, so you are ignorant of the works of the Lord, who is the maker of all things: works, that is, hidden judgments, concerning which it is said in the Psalm: "Great are the works of the Lord, sought out according to all His purposes." These works we do not know: Romans 11: "O the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How incomprehensible are His judgments, and how unsearchable His ways!"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the morning sow etc. Here thirdly he exhorts to doing good unceasingly: and first the exhortation is set forth; second, the reason for the exhortation is added; and third, the recompense.
He exhorts therefore to performing works of mercy unceasingly, for he says: In the morning sow your seed, that is, in the time of youth, because Lamentations 3: "It is good for a man when he has borne the yoke from his youth." And in the evening let not your hand cease, that is, in old age, as if to say that at every time and age good works are to be done without ceasing: Galatians 6: "And let us not grow weary in doing good, for in due time we shall reap, if we do not lose heart." Therefore one must sow continually, because, as it is said in 2 Corinthians 9, "he who sows sparingly shall also reap sparingly, and he who sows in blessings shall also reap from blessings."
Because you do not know etc. Here the second point is noted, namely the reason for the exhortation: because man does not know when and which works God accepts, just as he who sows does not know which seed bears fruit. Therefore he says: Because you do not know which may rather spring up: this one, that is, the evening sowing, or that one, that is, the morning sowing: above in chapter 9: "Man does not know whether he is worthy of love or of hatred." And if both together, it will be better, because "more goods are to be preferred over fewer"; Isaiah 32: "Blessed are you who sow beside all waters."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is indeed a beautiful wisdom, because it is light, but it is more beautiful than the sun, since the sun is unable to give birth to its radiance within itself, while the Eternal Sun begets the most beautiful Radiance within Himself. Likewise, eternal wisdom exerts its influence over all things. Hence in Ecclesiastes: "Light is sweet! and it is pleasant for the eyes to see the sun."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Sweet is the light etc. Here the third point is noted, namely the recompense: and this is the beholding of the eternal light and sun, in which there is the highest sweetness, and so great is the recompense. And therefore he says: Sweet is the light, to behold. Concerning this sweetness, in the Psalm: "How great is the multitude of Your sweetness, O Lord," etc. And it is delightful for the eyes to see the sun, that sun, of which Malachi 4 says: "The sun of justice shall rise upon you who fear God." This sun it is delightful to see: therefore 1 Peter 1: "Into whom the Angels desire to look." And because only those who shall be at the right hand will see that light, therefore in the Psalm: "Delights at Your right hand forevermore."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, he calls back from evil by consideration of future punishment.
If a man has lived many years etc. Above he exhorted to good by consideration of reward; here he intends to call back from evil by consideration of future punishment: and indeed he does this in this order. First he says that memory of the future time must be maintained: second, he reproves present joy; third, he exhorts to cast away all wickedness and abundance of malice.
He exhorts and admonishes to maintain the memory of future time, however much a man may abound in present prosperity. On account of which he says: If a man has lived many years, because in truth, even if they seem many, they nevertheless cannot be many, according to that passage in Ecclesiasticus 18: "The number of the days of man, at most are a hundred years." And in all these he shall have rejoiced, according to those of whom it is said in Job 21: "They hold the timbrel and rejoice at the sound of the organ; they spend their days in prosperity," etc. He ought to remember the time of darkness, that is, the day of judgment, which will be a dark time; Zephaniah 1: "That day is a day of wrath, a day of darkness and gloom"; and of many days. These are the days or years of eternity; in the Psalm: "One day in your courts is better than a thousand." He ought to remember the day of judgment, so that he may fear; he ought to remember glory, so that he may hope and rejoice, and this according to the alternation of works; whence Ecclesiasticus 11: "In the day of good things, be not unmindful of evil things, and in the day of evil things, be not unmindful of good things." Days, I say, many, which when they shall have come, past things will be convicted of vanity, that is, they will be manifestly shown to have been vain; whence Jerome: When the kingdom of Christ shall have come, the other kingdoms will vanish. Past things will be convicted, namely of the vanity of mutability: Wisdom 5: "What has pride profited us? Or what has the boasting of riches brought us? All these things have passed away like a shadow." They will be convicted of the vanity of iniquity: Ecclesiasticus 17: "What is more wicked than what flesh and blood has devised?" And these things will be convicted; Ephesians 5: "For the things that are convicted by the light are made manifest."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Rejoice therefore, O young man, etc. Here secondly he reproves present joy, asserting that man must be judged for it; whence speaking ironically he says: Rejoice therefore, O young man, in your youth, because that age is suited to joy; whence Wisdom 2: "Come, let us enjoy the creature as swiftly as in youth"; as if to say: do not rejoice in youth, lest you grieve in old age; whence Ecclesiasticus 5: "Do not follow the desire of your heart in your strength." And he explains this joy, so that it may be complete both in mind and in deed and in outward sign. As to the joy of delight in the mind he says: And let your heart be in what is good, as if to say: do not rejoice in heart, because above in chapter 7: "The heart of the fool is where joy is." As to delight in deed: And walk in the ways of your heart, that is, outwardly fulfill in deed what you desire in heart, as if to say: do not walk thus; Ecclesiasticus 18: "Son, do not go after your desires, and turn away from your own will." As to joy in outward sign he says: And in the sight of your eyes, so that the eye may gaze upon those things which the heart desires and your hand performs, according to what is said of those concerning whom 2 Peter 2 states: "Having eyes full of adultery and unceasing sin," as if to say: do not walk thus; Isaiah 3: "Because the daughters of Zion are lifted up and have walked with outstretched neck and wanton glances of the eyes," etc. And that this is spoken ironically is clear, because he threatens evil upon those who rejoice thus; whence he adds: And know that for all these things God will bring you into judgment. And therefore all these things are to be fled; Job 19: "Flee from the face of the sword, for the sword is the avenger of iniquity, and know that there is judgment."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Remove anger etc. Here thirdly he exhorts to cast away all wickedness, namely malice of heart and uncleanness of flesh. As to malice of heart he says: Remove anger from your heart, so that you may not be angry, because anger renders a man wicked; Matthew 5: "But I say to you that everyone who is angry with his brother shall be liable to judgment"; and if he is angry, he ought not to persist in it; whence Ephesians 4: "Let not the sun go down upon your wrath." As to uncleanness of flesh he says: And remove evil from your flesh, and thus he excludes all uncleanness of the flesh; James 1: "Casting away all uncleanness and abundance of malice, receive with meekness the engrafted word." He removes evil from the flesh who mortifies it; Colossians 3: "Mortify your members which are upon the earth." And the reason for this is given: For youth and pleasure are vain, because they pass away quickly; 1 John 2: "The world passes away and its desire," and therefore Wisdom 5: "What has pride profited us? Or what has the boasting of riches brought us? All these things have passed away like a shadow," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He describes punishment in general with respect to three things: first, with respect to the presence of what is harmful; second, with respect to the absence of what is pleasant; third, with respect to the lack of remedy; from the consideration of which he exhorts us to remember God.
Therefore, with respect to the presence of what is harmful, he says: "Remember your Creator," giving Him praise and confession, "in the days of your youth," that is, as long as you are young and healthy: Sirach 17: "You shall confess while living; alive and healthy you shall confess and praise the Lord, and you shall glory in His mercies." And the reason for this is that the time of old age should not be awaited, in which there is the presence of what is harmful; on account of which he says: "Before the time of affliction comes": Sirach 18: "Before sickness apply the remedy, and before judgment examine yourself." "And the years draw near of which you shall say: They do not please me." These are the years in which human nature is troubled by many afflictions; and these are in old age and draw near, because in the Psalm: "Our years shall be considered as a spider's web" etc.
Spiritually, he exhorts here that each one should remember the benefits of God and the benefactor himself, before man is handed over to a reprobate sense and falls into the blindness of error. Therefore they ought to remember God, because he is creator. First indeed he gave essence: Isaiah 45: "I made the earth and created man upon it"; therefore God must be remembered; against which, Deuteronomy 32: "You have forgotten God, your Creator." He gave power: Deuteronomy 8: "You shall remember the Lord your God, because he himself gave you strength, that he might fulfill his covenant." He gave good operation: Philippians 2: "God works in us both to will and to accomplish"; and Isaiah 26: "All our works you have wrought in us, O Lord"; and therefore he must be remembered; Psalm: "I was mindful of the works of the Lord, for I shall be mindful from the beginning of your wonders."
Because he was incarnate for us: Song of Songs 1: "We shall exult and rejoice in you, mindful of your breasts more than wine."
Because he is redeemer, who suffered for us: Lamentations 3: "Remember my poverty and transgression," etc.; who was given to us as food from heaven: Psalm: "The merciful and compassionate Lord made a memorial of his wonders; he gave food to those who fear him."
Because he is rewarder according to merit: Psalm: "You shall render to each one according to his works"; on account of this it is said elsewhere in the Psalm, "I was mindful of your judgments," etc. As to desire, Isaiah 26: "Your name and your memorial are in the desire of the soul," etc.; and therefore it is added, "My soul desired you in the night." Rewarding beyond desire: Isaiah 63: "I will remember the mercies of the Lord above all things that the Lord has rendered to us," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“With respect to the absence of what is pleasant, he says: "Before the sun grows dark," in whose sight there is great delight: above in chapter eleven: "The light is sweet, and it is delightful for the eyes to see the sun"; whence Tobit 5: "What joy shall be to me, who sit in darkness and do not see the light of heaven?" And to signify the complete absence, he excludes every heavenly light; whence he says: "Before the sun grows dark," so that it may not be seen in its circuit, "and the light," so that its influence may not be seen, and this during the day; "and the moon and the stars," during the night: Isaiah 13: "The stars of heaven and their splendor shall not spread forth their light; the sun is darkened in its rising, and the moon shall not shine with its light."
With respect to the lack of remedy, he says: "And let the clouds return after the rain." After rain the sky is accustomed to clear; when therefore after rain the turbulence of clouds returns, it is a sign that there is no return to exultation and gladness: Tobit 3: "After a storm You make calm, and after weeping and tears You pour in exultation." But those days shall be turned into darkness and shall not return to light: Job 3: "Let it expect light and not see it, nor the rising of the dawning aurora."
Spiritually, of this Creator we ought to be mindful both by giving thanks and by turning to him: "before the sun is darkened," namely the sun of justice, Christ, when man falls from faith: Amos 8: "The sun shall set for them at midday"; "and the light," of grace, when man falls from charity, for then he loses grace: Wisdom 5: "We have erred from the way of truth, and the light of justice did not shine upon us"; "and the moon," the understanding of Sacred Scripture, which receives its light from Christ: Revelation 12: "A woman clothed with the sun, and the moon under her feet." The woman clothed with the sun is the Church of the nations, to whom was given the full understanding of Sacred Scripture. "And the stars," the examples of the perfect: Baruch 3: "The stars gave light in their watches," namely at night, "and said: We are here." "And the clouds return," etc., that is, the teaching of the preachers ceases: Ezekiel 3: "Son of man, I will make your tongue cleave to your palate."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He shows the future weakening in old age with respect to six kinds of members. First, with respect to the shaking of the bones, which are ordered to protecting the body, when he says: "When the keepers of the house shall tremble." The house is the frame of the body: this is fragile, and therefore needs a keeper; and so the Philosopher says that nature made the bones hard for guarding the soft members, as the ribs for the belly, and the skull for the head. These are shaken when their joints become loose.
Likewise, with respect to the weakening of the legs for sustaining the weight of the body; whence he says: "And the strong men shall bow themselves": the strong men are the legs, because, as strong men bear the weight of war, so the legs bear the weight of the body. These strong men totter when the legs tremble and waver and do not securely support.
Third, with respect to the diminishing of the teeth for chewing food; whence he says: "And the grinders shall be idle, being few in number": the grinders are the two jaws, which after the manner of two millstones grind food. These, when the number of teeth is diminished, are idle, because they cannot grind food for chewing.
Fourth, with respect to the darkening of the eyes for seeing; therefore he says: "And they that look through the windows shall be darkened": they that look through the windows are the eyes, which are like two openings for seeing. These are darkened when the aged cannot see light, as Eli: 1 Kings 3, who "could not see. The lamp of God, before it was extinguished," etc. As also Isaac, of whom Genesis 27: "Isaac was old, and his eyes were dim," etc.
Spiritually, the final state of the Church before the judgment, which will be at the coming of the Antichrist, is described with regard to the diminution of faith with respect to four classes of persons. First, he foretells the shaking of the prelates, when he says: "When the keepers of the house shall be moved." This house is the Church, of which it is said in the Psalm: "Holiness becometh thy house," etc. The keepers are the prelates, to whom the care of the Lord's flock has been entrusted: Isaiah 62: "Upon thy walls, O Jerusalem, I have set watchmen." The keepers, therefore, shall be moved, when the prelates shall be shaken in faith; and this indeed will be at the coming of the Antichrist; whence Judith, last chapter: "The mountains shall be moved from their foundations."
Second, he foretells the wavering of the perfect, when he says: "And the strong men shall stagger": the strong men are the perfect in charity and hope, according to that passage of Isaiah 40: "They that hope in the Lord shall renew their strength." These shall waver: Matthew 24: "False prophets shall arise and shall show signs, so as to lead into error, if it be possible, even the elect"; and in the same place: "And unless those days had been shortened, no flesh would be saved; but for the sake of the elect those days shall be shortened."
Third, he foretells the fall of the simple, when he adds: "And the grinders shall be idle, their number being diminished," that is, the simple shall cease from good work, overcome by weariness on account of the great deception practiced upon them; whence he says: "their number being diminished," because they shall be greatly reduced: Matthew 24: "Two shall be at the mill; one shall be taken, and the other shall be left."
Fourth, he foretells the error of the wise, when he says: "And they that look through the holes shall be darkened," that is, the wise, who see with subtlety, shall be enveloped in the darkness of error: Job 12: "They shall grope as in darkness and not in light, and he shall make them stagger like drunkards."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fifth, with respect to the immobilization of the lips for speaking, when he says: "And the doors shall be shut in the street": the doors are the lips, by which the gate of the mouth is closed. These doors are shut in the street when a man on account of old age cannot speak loudly so as to be heard by many; therefore he says: "In the lowness of voice of the grinders," that is, of those speaking softly: he says grinding means speaking, because, as a man moves his jaws for grinding food, so he moves his jaws and lips for pronouncing formed words.
Sixth, regarding the deafness of the ears for hearing, he says: "They shall rise up at the voice of the bird," that is, the cock, because the elderly cannot hear high sounds, because they are easily disturbed and most easily startled. They cannot hear sonorous and harmonious sounds either: whence he says: "And all the daughters of song shall be brought low." The daughters of song, which hear harmonious sounds, are the ears: these grow deaf in the elderly, because they cannot hear sonorous voices; 2 Kings 19, Barzillai said to David: "I am eighty years old; are my senses still keen to discern sweet from bitter, or can I still hear the voices of singers, men and women?"
These therefore are the six defects that follow upon or accompany old age: because the elderly cannot repel harmful things, cannot sustain themselves, cannot eat, cannot see, cannot speak, cannot hear.
Spiritually, because those who fall from faith fall from faithful confession, therefore he says: "And they shall shut the doors in the street," that is, in public; "when the sound of the grinding is low," that is, murmuring. But true confession is in public; whence Matthew 10: "What you hear in the ear, preach upon the housetops."
Here there is noted the spreading of error after the diminution of faith. First, falsehood will be preached by the Antichrist, when he says: "They will rise up at the voice of the bird." The voice of the bird singing in the night is the preaching of the Antichrist preaching in the night of darkness and unbelief. At his voice, therefore, those who believe his preaching will rise up. For this reason it is said in Matthew 24, that they should not give credence: "If therefore they shall say to you: Behold, he is in the desert, do not believe." Nevertheless many will hear and believe; in John 5 it is said to the Jews: "If another shall come in his own name, him you will receive."
Second, he foretells that truth will be silenced, because there will be no one to hear; therefore he says: "All the daughters of song will grow deaf." Then the daughters of song grow deaf when they cannot hear the sound of truth, which is like a certain harmony. This will be in the time of the Antichrist, as was foretold: in Isaiah 30 it is foretold concerning that people who will cling to the Antichrist: "It is a people provoking to wrath, lying children, children unwilling to hear the law of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He adds the signs of debilitation, which are four: tremor of the body, whiteness of the head, swelling of the belly, and cooling of desire.
The first sign of infirmity in the old person is tremor of the body; on account of which he says: "They shall also fear the heights and be afraid in the way," that is, all the members of the body shall become tremulous: and this is a sign of the dissolution and diminution of the retentive power of the members, which is unable to hold the members steady: and therefore it is compelled to continually tremble; whence the wretched old person can say that word of the Psalm: "Fear and trembling came upon me" etc.
The second sign is whiteness of the head, regarding which he says: "The almond tree shall flourish," that is, the head and beard shall grow white: for the almond tree, when it blossoms, turns white, and this is a sign of weakness of power: for because in the old person the retentive power of the humors is weakened, therefore the humors putrefy and also grow cold, as a sign of which white superfluities proceed from the body of the old person: and therefore they grow white.
The third sign of senile infirmity is swelling of the belly or of other members of the body; regarding which he says: "The locust shall be fattened." The fattening of the locust even around its old age is rather swelling than true fatness, in which manner the fattening in the elderly occurs, and this is a sign of the weakness of the digestive heat. For because the digestive heat fails, phlegmatic, watery, and undigested humor abounds, which fills the body of the old person and appears to fatten it.
The fourth sign is the diminishing of desire: on account of which he says: "The caper shall be scattered." The caper is a certain herb which "benefits the kidneys," as the Gloss says, and strengthens the act of the generative power; and according to Jerome, in Hebrew it has a common name for both the herb and for lustful desire. In whichever signification therefore it is taken, the sense is correct: "the caper shall be scattered," that is, the ardor of desire shall diminish; and this is a sign of weakness in the old man. For in the act of generation, heat moves, and digested moisture supplies the material. Because therefore old age is cold and dry, heat and moisture fail, and therefore the ardor of desire is diminished.
The miseries preceding death have been described. Here is described the very misery of death both in the dying person and in those who mourn. In the dying person, when he says: "Because man shall go to the house of his eternity," that is, he shall die. For the house after death is eternal, because above in chapter eleven, "if a tree falls to the south, there it shall be; if to the north, there it shall be"; and thus the house after death is rightly called the house of eternity. As to the misery in those who mourn, he says: "And the mourners shall go about in the street: they go about," because on account of grief they know not how to rest: Psalm: "The head of their going about, the labor of their lips shall cover them." And they shall mourn over the dead as though unwilling to be consoled, but they ought not so: Sirach 22: "Mourning for the dead lasts seven days."
Spiritually, he foretells that the power of the Antichrist will be dreaded, when he says: "They will also fear the heights and be in dread," etc., that is, all, both small and great, will fear the power of the Antichrist and will worship out of terror; whence Revelation 13: "All the earth wondered after the beast, saying: Who is like to this beast, and who shall be able to fight with it?" And afterwards: "And power was given to it over every tribe and people and tongue, and all who dwell upon the earth shall worship it, whose names are not written in the book of life."
The manner of multiplying error will be by a threefold way, namely through miracles, through gifts, through torments. First, the manner of drawing to error through miracles, when he says: "The almond tree will blossom," so that just as the rod of Aaron wondrously blossomed and produced almonds, according to what is said in Numbers 17, so in emulation the Antichrist will make the rod blossom and wither, and perform many other miracles, through which the foolish will be turned to him: Revelation 13: "And the beast performed great signs and deceived the inhabitants of the earth on account of the signs which were given to it to perform in the sight of men."
Second, he foretells the manner of drawing through gifts, when he adds: "And the locust will be fattened." The locust is fattened when a greedy man is filled with money and through it is turned away from God: Deuteronomy 32: "The beloved grew fat and kicked back; grown fat, fattened, enlarged," etc. In this manner the Antichrist will turn many from the faith, which was signified in 2 Maccabees 7: "Antiochus, when there still remained the youngest, exhorted him not only with words, but also promised with an oath that he would make him rich and blessed, and that, having departed from the laws, he would hold him dear."
Third, he foretells that some will be drawn away through torments, when he says: "And the caper bush shall be scattered." The caper bush, as was said, is an herb that provokes lust. By this are understood the carnal, who carry out the care of the flesh in desires. These are scattered when through fear of torments they fall away from the faith: for they are among those of whom it is said in Luke 8: "They believe for a time, and in the time of temptation they fall away." The time of temptation will be at the coming of the Antichrist; whence Matthew 24: "There will be such tribulation as has not been from the beginning of the world until now."
As for the rewarding of the good, he says: "Man shall go into the house of his eternity," when, namely, it will be said to them: "Come, blessed of my Father, receive the kingdom which was prepared for you from the foundation of the world," Matthew 25. And then they will go into the house of eternal joy: Isaiah 35: "They shall come into Zion with praise, and everlasting joy shall be upon their heads: they shall obtain joy and gladness."
As for the wicked, he says: "And the mourners shall go about in the street," namely the wicked: whence Wisdom 5: "They shall say within themselves, repenting and groaning for anguish of spirit"; and Matthew 24: "They shall see the sign of the Son of Man in heaven: and then shall all the tribes of the earth mourn, and they shall see the Son of Man," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He touches on the miseries following death, which are the dissolution of the body and the migration of the spirit to God.
First is noted the dissolution of the sinews, when he says: "Before the silver cord is broken," and the phrase must be repeated: "Remember your Creator" etc. The intertwining of the sinews is rightly called a cord, because it encircles and binds the whole body, and silver, on account of their whiteness and translucency. The silver cord therefore is broken when the binding of the sinews is dissolved.
Second, the dissolution of the veins or arteries, when he says: "And the golden fillet runs back"; the intertwining of the veins is rightly called a fillet, because, just as a fillet is wound around, and by it the whole that is bound is preserved, so by the veins and arteries the whole mechanism of the body is surrounded and preserved. This intertwining of veins and arteries is rightly called golden, because gold is red and veins of this kind are red on account of the redness of the blood contained within them. Then therefore the golden fillet runs back when the intertwining of the veins and arteries does not endure.
Third, the breaking of the vessel of urine is noted, when he says: "And let the pitcher be shattered at the fountain." The pitcher is the receptacle of water drawn from a fountain, and the bladder is the receptacle of urine proceeding from the liver as from a fountain. For urine is the filtrate of the blood and other humors, which proceed from the liver into the whole body as from a fountain. The pitcher, therefore, is shattered at the fountain when the bladder ruptures and cannot receive the filtrate of the humors that proceeds from the liver.
Fourth, the destruction of the passage of impure waste is noted, when he says: "And let the wheel be broken at the cistern." The wheel is the instrument by which the drawing out of foul and muddy water from the cistern is accomplished: the cistern contains for the most part muddy water; and such is our belly. Therefore, for the wheel to be broken at the cistern is for the passage of impure waste exiting from the belly to be destroyed in death.
Spiritually, first is noted the emptying out of eloquence, when it is said: "Before the silver cord is broken." Silver is sonorous and signifies eloquence: the silver cord is the beautiful joining and binding together of words, which binds a man after the manner of a cord while it persuades, according to that which is said in Proverbs 7: "She ensnared him with many words, and drew him away with the flattery of her lips." Then therefore the silver cord will be broken, when after the day of judgment worldly eloquence will be silenced: Matthew 22: "Friend, how did you come in here not having a wedding garment? And he was speechless."
Second is noted the emptying out of prelacy or power, when he says: "And the golden fillet runs back." By the fillet, which was placed on the head of the priest, is understood the order of power and prelacy, by which the Church is bound together. This fillet runs back to its beginning, namely when Christ alone will reign, and all other power will be taken away; and this will be after the judgment: 1 Corinthians 15: "Then the end, when he shall have delivered up the kingdom to God and the Father, when he shall have abolished all rule and dominion and power."
Third is noted the emptying of worldly wisdom, when he says: "And the pitcher be broken at the fountain." This pitcher is the curiosity of the heart, which is brought to draw wisdom; concerning which figuratively in John 4: "A woman of Samaria came with a pitcher to draw water." The woman of Samaria is paganism, which comes with a pitcher, that is, with curiosity, to draw wisdom; whence it is said in Acts 17: "The Athenians spent their time in nothing else than either saying or hearing something new." The fountain moreover is worldly wisdom: whence in the Psalm: "You broke open the fountains and the torrents" etc. The pitcher therefore is broken at the fountain, when no place remains for curiously devoting oneself to worldly wisdom; Isaiah 30: "And it shall be broken as the potter's vessel with a most powerful crushing" etc.
Fourth is noted the removal of worldly wealth, when he adds: "And the wheel be broken at the cistern." By the cistern, which receives waters, is understood the accumulation of worldly wealth, according to that of Jeremiah 2: "They have forsaken me, the fountain of living water, and have dug for themselves broken cisterns" etc. The wheel signifies fickleness and changeableness in possessing; whence these are called goods of fortune. Then therefore the wheel is broken at the cistern, when every hope of having temporal goods is taken away: which was signified in Exodus 14: "The Lord looking upon the camp of the Egyptians overthrew the wheels of the chariots," because, Sirach 40, "the substance of the ungodly shall be dried up like a river."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fifth, the incineration of the whole body is noted, when it is said: "And let the dust return to its earth, whence it was," that is, let the body be reduced to ashes, according to that passage in Genesis 3: "You are dust, and to dust you shall return." "To its earth," because it is from it: Sirach 40: "All things that are made of earth shall return to earth."
Sixth, the return of the spirit or soul to God is touched upon: whence he says: "And let the spirit return to God, who gave it." The Lord himself gives the spirit, whence it is said in the Psalm: "He who fashioned their hearts one by one," etc.; and to him every spirit returns as to the recompenser; Romans 14: "We shall all stand before the judgment seat of Christ," etc.
Spiritually, fifth is noted how upon the wicked there shall be the infliction of punishment, when he says: "And the dust return to the earth." Dust is rightly said to be the impious and the sinner, according to that of the Psalm: "Not so the wicked, not so, but as the dust which the wind drives from the face of the earth." The earth is the depth of darkness, according to that of Proverbs 25: "The heaven above, and the earth beneath." Then therefore the dust returns to the earth, when the sinner is shut up in the lowest depth of infernal darkness; Revelation 20: "Whoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire."
Sixth indeed is noted how upon the just and the spiritual there shall be the conferral of glory, when he says: "The spirit return to God, who gave it." The spirit is the spiritual and good person, who is joined to God through grace: 1 Corinthians 6: "He who cleaves to the Lord is one spirit." This spirit returns to God, not because it was previously with him and afterwards departed, when it came to the body and in death returns again, as Origen held: but it is said to return because it is from him and through him and is finally ordered toward him: and this indeed shall be in glory after the judgment, according to what is said in Colossians 3: "When Christ, your life, shall appear, then you also shall appear with him in glory."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As was said from the beginning of the book, this entire book has an order directed toward proving one proposition, which he set forth at the beginning of the book, namely this: "Vanity of vanities" etc. This he proved throughout the entire book and now at the end concludes, saying: "Vanity of vanities, said Ecclesiastes." Above he similarly said, that is, proposed: but now: "Ecclesiastes said," that is, concluded. He said, I say: "Vanity of vanities." This statement is taken materially, and the act of saying passes over it, so that the sense is: Ecclesiastes said this statement: "Vanity of vanities": and in this statement that genitive designates origin, so that the sense is: "Vanity of vanities," that is, from vanities arises vanity. Ecclesiastes also said this, namely: "All is vanity," and the substantive verb is understood from the usage of speech, so that the sense is: "All things are vanity."
From this twofold statement such an argument is drawn: If from vanities arises vanity, and all things are vanity, then all created things do not make their lover blessed but make him vain, according to that passage in Jeremiah 2: "They walked after vanity, and became vain." If therefore all ought to desire beatitude and flee vanity, then all ought to despise earthly goods. And this is the conclusion of this book.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this epilogue, first the diligence of the writer is noted, because, since he was wise, he did not hide his wisdom but declared it to others. Therefore he says: "And since Ecclesiastes was most wise": 3 Kings 4: "The wisdom of Solomon surpassed the wisdom of all the Orientals; and he was wiser than all men." Since he was thus wise, he was not negligent but diligent. Whence "he taught the people": Sirach 24: "I will yet pour out doctrine as prophecy, and will leave it to those who seek wisdom"; and afterwards: "Look, for I have not labored for myself alone, but for all who seek truth." He explains his diligence through the multitude of writings and teachings: and three books are touched upon here, which he composed. First Ecclesiastes, when he says: "And he recounted the things he had done," supply: in this book of Ecclesiastes: above in the first and second chapters he narrated spiritual and carnal works, so that in evil things he might give an example of what to detest, and in good things an example of what to imitate.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, the book of Proverbs is touched upon, when he says: "And searching, he composed parables, which are useful words," that is, in Proverbs: at the beginning of Proverbs: "The parables of Solomon, son of David, king of Israel, for knowing wisdom and discipline, for understanding the words of prudence."
Third, the book of the Song of Songs is touched upon, when he says: "And he wrote discourses most upright and full of truth." He says this because those words which are spoken in the Song of Songs seem to be words of lasciviousness and lust: therefore he says: "Most upright discourses," that is, just and good: Proverbs 8: "All my words are just, there is nothing wicked or perverse in them." The words of the Song of Songs also seem to be false and playful, when it says: "Your nose is like a tower"; therefore he says: "And full of truth": for that is full which contains and holds something within: so also the words of the Song of Songs inwardly conceal and encompass truth: and this is necessary for all teaching: Sirach 37: "Before all works, let a truthful word precede you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This counsel has been confirmed by the twelve Apostles and by the counsels of the Saints. Whence it is said in Ecclesiastes: 'The words of the wise are like goads and like nails driven deep, which were given through the counsel of masters by one shepherd.' If you want the testimony of the Saints concerning these counsels, seek Anthony, Paphnutius, and Macarius, who all resolved to observe these counsels. Seek the bishops Basil, Augustine, Martin, and Gregory; all were monks and resolved to observe the counsels and kept them. Seek also Benedict, who was an abbot; seek Dominic, seek Francis, who resolved that all these counsels must be observed. From the Lamb proceed torches, and they are illuminations for manifesting the counsels.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The authority of his discourses is noted, because they were not lightly uttered, but rather uttered with counsel and inspired by God, and therefore they are firm and stable. And therefore he says: "The words of the wise are as goads," penetrating, namely, to the interior: "and as nails fixed deep," that is, into the depths, which are immovable, and therefore are not easily driven from the heart, but remain and lead to the good. Whence the word of God is compared to a sword, Ephesians 6: "And the sword of the spirit, which is the word of God." And therefore it pierces the heart, according to what is said in Acts 2: "When they heard these things, they were pierced in heart." Therefore the words of the wise are to be penetrated, because they were not lightly spoken: therefore he says: "Which through the counsel of masters," that is, through deliberate discussion and judgment, "were given by one shepherd," that is, by Christ, who is the shepherd, according to what is said in John 10: "I am the good shepherd." From this shepherd the words of the wise were given, because, as Augustine says, "he who teaches within has his chair in heaven"; whence Matthew 23: "One is your master, Christ." Yet they were given through the counsel of masters, that is, of the ministers of this supreme master, whom he himself sent and taught: whence it is said in 1 Peter 5: "Elders, feed the flock of God that is among you, so that when the prince of shepherds shall come, you may receive the unfading crown of glory." He himself sent these: Matthew, last chapter: "Going therefore, teach all nations."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The curiosity of the hearers is restrained, whom he addresses under the person of a son, saying: "More than these, my son, do not seek," so as to always wish to hear new things: for it suffices to know what is necessary: Sirach 3: "The things that God has commanded you, think upon them always, and in many of his works be not curious."
And a twofold reason is given for this admonition, because the inquiry of this curiosity is unending and laborious. It is unending; therefore he says: "Of making many books there is no end": because the curious never have so many that they do not wish to hear more, because they never wish to hear old things, but always new ones: whence Acts 17: "The Athenians spent their time in nothing else, but either to tell or to hear some new thing." Therefore it is said in Daniel 12: "Many times shall pass, and knowledge shall be manifold," because knowledge is always in a certain way renewed. Not only is curious inquiry unending, but it is also laborious: therefore he adds: "And much study is an affliction of the flesh": Sirach 31: "The watchfulness of honesty shall waste the flesh." It is, I say, a great affliction, and conversely the utility is small, according to what was said above in chapter eight: "There is a man who day and night takes no sleep with his eyes. And I understood that of all the works of God, man can find no reason for those things which are done under the sun."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A bird cannot fly without two wings, nor can a man walk without two feet. Similarly, no one can be a perfect observer of the commandments of God unless he is filled with fear and love. But man is not filled with fear except from the consideration of divine severity, nor is he filled with love except from the consideration of divine goodness. He says this so that we may fear, and through fear turn away from evil; whence: Fear God and keep his commandments; this is the whole of man, that is, for this is every man. Do you wish to merit, so as to arrive at the highest fulfillment? Fear God. But how shall I fear? Certainly by considering that the Lord is a most mighty zealot.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And Solomon says: "Fear God and observe his commandments: this is the whole man," that is, the perfect man. Therefore if you wish to be perfect, fear God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the method of treatment in Ecclesiastes: it has been said that he acts and speaks in diverse persons, namely that of the fool and that of the wise man.
But: As it is said in Sirach 20, "a parable from the mouth of a fool will be rejected": therefore a statement made in the person of a fool is not to be heeded: therefore if the meaning of the sacred books is to be heeded, he ought not to speak in the person of a fool. Likewise, what he says in the person of the fool and the carnal man is to be rejected: but it is not known, when he speaks, whether he says this in his own person or in another's: therefore it is not known what in this book is to be held and what is to be rejected: therefore this science is a path to error. But canonical books ought to purge error: therefore this book should be removed from the canon.
I respond: it must be said that to speak something in the person of a fool or a carnal man is twofold: either to approve it, or to reject it and show it to be vain. In the first way it does not befit the science of truth: in the second way it does, just as if someone wished to refute an error and first set it forth, then afterward destroyed it. And he speaks in this way, not in the first; and therefore he is not to be condemned, but rather to be commended, because he rejects what is to be rejected.
To the objection that it is not known when he speaks in his own person: it must be said that the other side of a disputation cannot be known until one arrives at the judgment and at the determination, because in the resolution it is known what is chosen and what is rejected. Thus I say that Ecclesiastes proceeds as if disputing up to the end of the book, and at the end gives his judgment, when he says: "Let us all hear together the end of the discourse: Fear God, and know that for every fault God will bring you to judgment." In which word he condemns all the opinions of the foolish, the carnal, and the worldly. Whence what accords with that judgment he says in his own person, and what disagrees he says in the person of others: and therefore this book cannot be understood unless it is heard in its entirety.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The conclusion of what has been said is touched upon. "The end of the discourse," that is, the terminus and consummation of the speech, "let us all hear together," as being useful and necessary to all.
And the conclusion of all that has been said consists in this, namely in the avoidance of evil or in the doing of good: to which all the doctrine and speech of Solomon is ordered, indeed all of Scripture. Therefore first, with respect to the avoidance of evil, he says: "Fear God": Proverbs 16: "In the fear of the Lord everyone turns away from evil." With respect to the doing of good, he says: "And keep his commandments": Deuteronomy 6: "Hear, O Israel, and observe, that you may do the things which the Lord has commanded." "This is the whole man," that is, the total and perfect man. For if he does good and does not turn away from evil, he is not a whole man, but half: again, if he turns away from evil and does not do good, he is only half: but if he turns away from evil through fear and does good through the observance of the commandments, then he is the whole man, that is, the complete just man. The Lord requires nothing more from man: Deuteronomy 10: "And now, Israel, what does the Lord require of you, except that you fear the Lord your God and walk in his ways, and serve the Lord with your whole heart and with your whole soul, and keep the commandments of the Lord your God?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the reason why God is to be feared and His commandments are to be observed is this: because He will demand an account of all things, whether of good or of evil. Therefore he adds: "And God will bring all things that are done into judgment for every error," because nothing will remain unexamined, neither what was done through malice nor what was done through error: Matthew 12: "For every idle word that men shall have spoken, they shall render an account." And not only will evil deeds be examined, but indeed also good ones: therefore he adds: "Whether it be good or whether it be evil," it will be brought into judgment: whence in the Psalm: "When I shall receive the appointed time, I will judge with justice"; and again, 2 Corinthians 5: "We must all be made manifest before the tribunal of Christ": therefore He will judge all things, because He beholds all things. And this is what ought greatly to exhort us to fear and to the observance of the commandments: and therefore he concludes with this, just as Boethius also does at the end of the Consolation: "A great necessity of uprightness is imposed upon us, since we do all things in the sight of a Judge who discerns all things."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third hierarchizing is that of grace above nature and diligence. When the soul is lifted higher than itself, and, having emptied itself out, receives divine illuminations, it looks above itself to what has been given to it. And out of this, it rises, or is lifted up, to divine concerns. These three acts are reception, revelation, and union beyond which the mind does not reach. And it is in this that the whole Canticle consists: the chaste, chaster, and chastest receiving; the chaste, chaster, and chastest speculation; the chaste, chaster, and chastest union. And then will it be possible to say with this Canticle: "Let Him kiss me with kisses of His mouth!" Reception corresponds to the Thrones, revelation to the Cherubim, and union to the Seraphim.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First there is the ointment of piety upon the head; afterwards it descends upon all others who draw near to the head. First there ought to be piety in prelates and superiors, and afterwards in the common people. Concerning this oil of piety it is said in the fourth book of Kings that a certain woman came to Elisha and said that her creditors wished to take her children. And Elisha said that she should bring all the vessels of her neighbors and pour some of that oil into each one, until all were filled. I say that the woman holds the type of the Church, and Elisha holds the type of Christ. When the Church is poor in merits and it is necessary that she repay the debt: by what means will she repay? She must fill the vessels of her neighbors. Do you wish the piety of mother Church to descend upon you? Fill the vessels of your neighbors. This oil of piety ought to be possessed by all. Whence in the Song of Songs: "Your name is oil poured out."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By which most fervent desire, in the manner of fire, our spirit is not only made agile for ascent, but also by a certain learned ignorance is rapt above itself into darkness and ecstasy, so that not only does it say with the bride: We will run in the fragrance of your ointments, but also sings with the Prophet: And the night is my illumination in my delights. Which nocturnal and delightful illumination no one knows except he who experiences it, nor does anyone experience it except through grace divinely given, nor is it given to anyone except to him who exercises himself toward it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, the fourth seal consists in this, that the soul perceives an incomprehensible consolation that grows so much within it that it is unable both to comprehend it and to explain it to others. The Canticle says of this: "Eat, friends; drink! Drink freely of love!" And this inebriated soul says: The king "brought me into the cellar of wine." And earlier: "The king hath brought me into his storerooms." This occurs when the soul is beside itself, like a drunken man who does not know what he is doing. Hence, Paul did not know whether he was in the body or out of the body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The vegetation of the earth symbolizing Sacred Scripture is lovely. Even exterior roughness that gives nature a reputation of malformation is yet what makes it most beautiful. Hence the bride says: "I am as dark — but lovely." That is, lovely because dark.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“God's wisdom appears most beautifully in the mysteries of Scripture, even more than in the first manner. For if, so to speak, I wish to praise the bride in that she is pretty and truthful: if I simply say that she is pretty and truthful, my heart is not affected very deeply. But if I say: "Thy cheeks are beautiful as the turtle dove's, thy neck as jewels," I praise her marvelously, if only I understand. I praise her not only as being chaste and good, but as being chaste and loving because of her love for her spouse. For the turtle dove is a chaste and loving bird, since out of love for its mate, as long as the mate lives, it consorts with no other, but only after it dies. Hence the bride is good, not merely because she is chaste, but because she is chaste out of love for her spouse. Hence the cheeks are beautiful, for they are prominent and beauty appears in them. "Thy neck as jewels": the neck, through which the voice is emitted, stands for truth; the jewels, that adorn the breast and bind it, stand for discretion, for if one tells the truth at the wrong time, for the wrong reason, in the wrong place or to the wrong people, this is not beautiful truth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, there arises from these twelve enlightenments a threefold fruit. From the first four comes forth the fruit of grace, from the intermediate four, the fruit of righteousness, from the last four, the fruit of wisdom. This fruit is beautiful in the measure in which the intellect is sustained by it, and it is tasty in the measure in which the affective dispositions are fed by it. It touches upon this threefold fruit, meaning these enlightenments, in the sense that they produce nourishing food, in that this threefold fruit is from Christ. Hence, in the Canticle: "As an apple tree among the trees of the woods, so is my lover among men. I delight to rest in his shadow, and his fruit is sweet to my mouth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Furthermore, this charity gives to the soul a fire. Hence, in the Canticle, "Set me as a seal on your heart... for stern as death is love," when it loves to such a degree that it is totally carried up to the supremely desirable, and sees prosperity as nothing, and adversity as nothing, since all things are like a single straw in a furnace. "If a man should give all the substance of his house for love, he shall despise it as nothing." Now, the fourth seal consists in this, that the soul perceives an incomprehensible consolation that grows so much within it that it is unable both to comprehend it and to explain it to others. The Canticle says of this: "Eat, friends; drink! Drink freely of love!" And this inebriated soul says: The king "brought me into the cellar of wine." And earlier: "The king hath brought me into his storerooms." This occurs when the soul is beside itself, like a drunken man who does not know what he is doing. Hence, Paul did not know whether he was in the body or out of the body. Of this seal, the Psalm says: "Shew me a token for good, that they who hate me may see, and be confounded."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this garden, there is much walking about, for if one is not happy to remain in the first, he goes to the second, and likewise with the others. And so man is compassed about with apples. Hence, in the Canticle: "Stay me up with flowers, compass me about with apples." And in the Psalm: "His truth shall compass thee with a shield." And so, as the intellect is ordained toward the affective dispositions, and faith is the way to charity, so also these enlightenments must pass over into the affective dispositions, in order that the intellect pass from the speculative to the practical.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When a worthy admission has come about together with a holy perception, then the soul is rapt in God, that is, in the beloved. Hence, in the Canticle: "His left hand is under my head and His right arm embraces me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Then, in this union, the power of the soul is recollected, and it becomes more unified, and enters in its intimate self, and consequently it rises up to its summit: for according to Augustine, the intimate self and the summit are the same. It is of this summit that the Canticle speaks: "I adjure you, O daughters of Jerusalem, that you stir not up nor awake my beloved, till she please."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, there is the production of prophets similar to the multiplication of flowers. It is said of them in the Canticle: "The flowers appear on the earth... and the song of the dove is heard." Flowers appeared when the prophet said: "A shoot shall sprout from the stump of Jesse, and from his roots a bud shall blossom." But the song of the dove was heard when it was said: "How lonely she is now, the once crowded city! Widowed is she who was mistress over nations." For the turtle moans instead of singing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is necessary to chastize the roots of the passions, so that the opposing powers are cut off and neutralized. It is fitting that a man have the three opposite virtues: that he be submissive, chaste, and poor. In this way will the roots of the passions be pulled out. "The time of pruning has come," for they abound every day.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When a worthy admission has come about together with a holy perception, then the soul is rapt in God, that is, in the beloved. "My Lover belongs to me and I to Him; He browses among the lilies," for the soul already feels the union and is made one spirit with God. And this is the highest thing in the soul: it makes it abide in heaven.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such are the three hierarchies which this Sun enlightens in a threefold manner. Hence, the sun, three times as much, burneth the mountains. These are the mountains of Bether, as explained in the Canticle: My lover, like a gazelle or a young stag, upon the mountains of Bether. And it is upon those very mountains that this Sun is sending out its first illuminations.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In order to reach such a summit, it is good for us to be carried above every sense, every rational operation related to the imagination, even to dismiss the angelical intelligences, so that it may be said: "The watchmen came upon me as they made their rounds of the city: I had hardly left them when I found Him whom my heart loves." And this is what Dionysius teaches, to dismiss sensible and intellectual things, beings and non-beings—and by non-beings, he means temporal things because they are in a constant state of flux—thus to enter into the radiance of darkness. It is called darkness because it does not bear upon the intelligence, and yet the soul is supremely flooded with light. And because this cannot be had without prayer, Dionysius begins with prayer.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In order to reach such a summit, it is good for us to be carried above every sense, every rational operation related to the imagination, even to dismiss the angelical intelligences, so that it may be said: "The watchmen came upon me as they made their rounds of the city: I had hardly left them when I found Him whom my heart loves." And this is what Dionysius teaches, to dismiss sensible and intellectual things, beings and non-beings—and by non-beings, he means temporal things because they are in a constant state of flux—thus to enter into the radiance of darkness. It is called darkness because it does not bear upon the intelligence, and yet the soul is supremely flooded with light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning this hierarch, then, and the ecclesiastical hierarchy, the whole of sacred Scripture exists, through which we are taught to be purged, illumined, and perfected, and this according to the threefold law handed down in it, namely of nature, of Scripture, and of grace; or rather according to its threefold principal part, namely the Mosaic law which purges, the prophetic revelation which illumines, and the evangelical teaching which perfects; or most especially according to its threefold spiritual understanding: the tropological, which purges unto uprightness of life; the allegorical, which illumines unto clarity of understanding; the anagogical, which perfects through mental ecstasies and the sweetest perceptions of wisdom, according to the three aforesaid theological virtues and the reformed spiritual senses and the three above-mentioned ecstasies and the hierarchical acts of the mind, by which our mind returns to its interior, so that there it may contemplate God in the splendors of the Saints and in them as in resting-places may sleep in peace and rest, the Bridegroom adjuring that it not be awakened until it proceed of His will.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Faith is a union of the Head with the body. The shining of light as related to faith is called allegory, and it is twofold, one directed to the Head and the other to the body. For there is one directed to the crucified Head, that was born, etc., and another directed to the body, that is, the Church, primitive, intermediate, and final. And Solomon praises the Church in this manner, according to its threefold state: "Who is she that cometh forth as the morning rising, fair as the moon, bright as the sun?" — "Who is she that goeth up by the desert, as a pillar of smoke of aromatic spices, of myrrh and frankincense?" — "Who is this that cometh up from the desert, flowing with delights, leaning upon her beloved?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third comparison between the Old and the New Testaments is related to a threefold division, for there is a time when the Synagogue was initiated, another when it was promoted, and yet another when it failed. Likewise, in the New Testament, there is a time when it was started, another when it was expanded, and yet another when it was consummated. Hence, in the Canticle the Church is praised three times, for it is one, nor is there nor can there be any other. The Church is praised when it was started: "What is this coming up from the desert, like a column of smoke?" When it was expanded: "Who is this that comes forth like the dawn, as beautiful as the moon, as resplendent as the sun?" When it was consummated: "Who is this coming up from the desert, flowing with delights, leaning upon her lover?" For it is necessary that Rachel give birth to her sons in the final Church. Hence, in the Apocalypse, Manasses is placed before his father, for he is in the sixth place, and Joseph in the twelfth, while Benjamin is in the last, and this is not without cause.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, there is a comparison of times three by three, as of the origin, promotion and fall of the Synagogue; and in the Church, the times of its beginning, expansion, and consummation. Hence, in the Canticle, there are three expressions of wonder: "Who is this," etc. in praise of the Church, and, by contrast, three expressions of sorrow in the Lamentations. Hence, it is not without reason that the alphabet is repeated so often.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When these senses have been recovered, while the soul sees and hears, smells, tastes, and embraces its spouse, it can sing as a bride the Song of Songs, which was composed for the exercise of contemplation according to this fourth degree, which no one grasps unless he receives it, because it consists more in affective experience than in rational consideration. For in this degree, when the interior senses have been restored to sense the supremely beautiful, to hear the supremely harmonious, to smell the supremely fragrant, to taste the supremely sweet, to apprehend the supremely delightful, the soul is disposed to mental transports, namely through devotion, admiration, and exultation, according to those three exclamations which are made in the Song of Songs. The first of these arises from the abundance of devotion, through which the soul becomes like a column of smoke from the aromatics of myrrh and frankincense; the second from the excellence of admiration, through which the soul becomes like the dawn, the moon, and the sun, according to the progression of illuminations that suspend the soul in admiration of the spouse contemplated; the third from the superabundance of exultation, through which the soul of most sweet pleasure, flowing with delights, leans entirely upon her beloved.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Without doubt Solomon wished to rest in her as in a secure place; but this could not be unless she were strong, because it is said in the Canticle that "sixty valiant ones surround the bed of Solomon." Solomon is interpreted as "the desirable king": sixty valiant ones surround his bed. The number sixty is perfect and arises from the multiplication of the number six by ten, and thus through it is signified the universality of works; or it arises from the multiplication of the number ten by the number six, and through it is signified the universality of the ten precepts of the decalogue. Insofar as one is strong and ready according to the dictates of the laws and precepts of the decalogue, then one is strong, such that one cannot be harmed from without.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he said: I have wanted to lead you to this "tree of life." "King Solomon hath made him a litter of the wood of Libanus. The pillars thereof he made of silver, the seat of gold, the going up of purple: the midst he covered with charity." The seat of gold is contemplative wisdom. And this no one has, except one who has the pillars of silver, which are the virtues buttressing the soul. The going up of purple is charity which makes [the soul] go up to the higher things and down to the lower.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he said: I have wanted to lead you to this "tree of life." "King Solomon hath made him a litter of the wood of Libanus. The pillars thereof he made of silver, the seat of gold, the going up of purple: the midst he covered with charity." The seat of gold is contemplative wisdom. And this no one has, except one who has the pillars of silver, which are the virtues buttressing the soul. The going up of purple is charity which makes [the soul] go up to the higher things and down to the lower.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The blessed Virgin was crowned with this stone in the flesh: seeing in the flesh the glorified body of Christ, seeing in spirit his glorified soul, and in mind his Divinity. Christ was crowned first, and she afterward. Whence in the Canticle: "Go forth, daughters of Sion, and see king Solomon in the diadem with which his mother crowned him on the day of his espousals and on the day of the gladness of his heart," that is, in flesh and mind, because he first put on flesh, suffered, and afterward was glorified: and the whole Church was crowned through him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Where the words of Scripture signify things of creation, or the conduct of the Israelite people, there one should seek from another passage of Scripture what each thing signifies, and then derive its signification through words plainly signifying the truth of faith, or the uprightness of morals as well; as for example if it is said: The sheep bring forth twin offspring, one should show that sheep there signify human beings, and twin offspring the twofold charity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Thy neck is as the tower of David, which is built with bulwarks: a thousand bucklers hang upon it, all the armor of valiant men." This was said to the bride or mother Church, whose neck is like the tower of David. It is called the neck, whence the doctrine of truth goes forth. The neck serves us for two things, namely, for receiving food and for expressing words. Thus mother Church is called the neck, because from her the doctrine of truth goes forth: whence it says: "a thousand bucklers hang upon it." Likewise, from her proceeds the universality of words for strengthening souls: whence it says: "all the armor of valiant men." There is nothing that avails for having spiritual fortitude that sacred Scripture does not set forth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is not the intellect that can go in there, but the heart. Hence again in the Canticle: "You have ravished my heart, my sister, my bride; you have ravished my heart with one glance of your eyes"—for the heart reaches down into the depths of Christ—"with one hair of thy neck"—for the hair refers to the height of mental thoughts. And he affirms that this ascent comes about through the power and the strongest motion of the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Sacred Scripture is a tongue, hence: "Sweetmeats and milk are under your tongue." This tongue enjoys the taste of food, wherefore these same Scriptures are compared to loaves of bread that nourish and are pleasant to the taste.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the soul is a paradise in which Scripture is planted, and it has marvelous aspects of sweetness and beauty. Hence in the Canticle: My sister, my spouse is a garden enclosed, a garden enclosed, a fountain sealed up. Thy plants are a paradise of pomegranates. The soul is a garden in which there are sacramental mysteries and spiritual meanings, where a fountain of spiritual outpourings gushes forth, but it is enclosed, and the fountain is sealed up, for they are not visible to the impure, but to those whom God knows to be His. Eternal wisdom loves this garden and dwells around it. Hence in Ecclesiasticus: I, like the river Doryx, flowed out of paradise. This garden is watered by the One who plants all things: and whatever he did not plant will be rooted up. "Every plant that My heavenly Father has not planted will be rooted up." And consequently, I said: I will water my garden of plants, and I will water abundantly the fruits of my meadow. For He waters by means of blood, with which He sprinkled the book and all the people; He also waters through the Holy Spirit flowing from Him. The Scripture has this flow and we find it there. Such are the trees beautiful to behold and sweet to feed upon because of the beauty and flavor of their fruits.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But it is fitting that the seal of truth be impressed upon the soul, by which also the soul becomes "an enclosed garden, a fountain sealed." The first seal consists in its having the indissoluble bond of charity, which occurs when the soul loves in such a way that it says: "Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? Shall tribulation, or distress, or persecution, or hunger," etc. Not that man could never fall away from charity, but when he does, that he never think of sinning. The second [seal] consists in this, that [the soul] has the irrevocable gift of divine charity, so that it loves everything God loves, both friends and enemies, both strangers and neighbors. Hence, "the charity of God is poured forth in our hearts." Through these means, then, the soul diffuses itself in order that it may love every good, and nothing but good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the soul is a paradise in which Scripture is planted, and it has marvelous aspects of sweetness and beauty. Hence in the Canticle: My sister, my spouse is a garden enclosed, a garden enclosed, a fountain sealed up. Thy plants are a paradise of pomegranates. The soul is a garden in which there are sacramental mysteries and spiritual meanings, where a fountain of spiritual outpourings gushes forth, but it is enclosed, and the fountain is sealed up, for they are not visible to the impure, but to those whom God knows to be His. Eternal wisdom loves this garden and dwells around it. Hence in Ecclesiasticus: I, like the river Doryx, flowed out of paradise. This garden is watered by the One who plants all things: and whatever he did not plant will be rooted up. "Every plant that My heavenly Father has not planted will be rooted up." And consequently, I said: I will water my garden of plants, and I will water abundantly the fruits of my meadow. For He waters by means of blood, with which He sprinkled the book and all the people; He also waters through the Holy Spirit flowing from Him. The Scripture has this flow and we find it there. Such are the trees beautiful to behold and sweet to feed upon because of the beauty and flavor of their fruits.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Furthermore, this charity gives to the soul a fire. Hence, in the Canticle, "Set me as a seal on your heart... for stern as death is love," when it loves to such a degree that it is totally carried up to the supremely desirable, and sees prosperity as nothing, and adversity as nothing, since all things are like a single straw in a furnace. "If a man should give all the substance of his house for love, he shall despise it as nothing." Now, the fourth seal consists in this, that the soul perceives an incomprehensible consolation that grows so much within it that it is unable both to comprehend it and to explain it to others. The Canticle says of this: "Eat, friends; drink! Drink freely of love!" And this inebriated soul says: The king "brought me into the cellar of wine." And earlier: "The king hath brought me into his storerooms." This occurs when the soul is beside itself, like a drunken man who does not know what he is doing. Hence, Paul did not know whether he was in the body or out of the body. Of this seal, the Psalm says: "Shew me a token for good, that they who hate me may see, and be confounded."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this union the mind is joined to God, wherefore in a certain sense it sleeps, while in another it keeps vigil: "I was sleeping, but my heart kept vigil." Only the affective power keeps vigil and imposes silence upon all the other powers; then man becomes foreign to his senses: he is in ecstasy and hears "secret words that man may not repeat," because they are only in the heart. Hence, because nothing can be expressed unless it is conceived, or conceived unless it is understood, and here the intelligence does not speak: it follows that a man can hardly speak or explain anything.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When this peace has been attained, there necessarily follows a superabundant spiritual delight, and then the person is fit for contemplation and for the gazes and embraces of the Bridegroom and the Bride, which take place according to the spiritual senses, by which is seen the supreme beauty of Christ the Bridegroom under the aspect of Splendor: is heard the supreme harmony under the aspect of the Word: is tasted the supreme sweetness under the aspect of Wisdom, which comprehends both, namely the Word and the Splendor: is smelled the supreme fragrance under the aspect of the Word inspired in the heart; is clasped the supreme gentleness under the aspect of the Word incarnate, dwelling among us bodily and rendering himself palpable, kissable, and embraceable to us through the most ardent charity, which causes our mind to pass over through ecstasy and rapture from this world to the Father.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth aspect of the zeal of wisdom is the elevation of desire. This gives worth to other endeavors, so that forgetting what is behind, we strain forward to what is before. "The wise man has eyes in his head. — The heart of a wise man is in his right hand." Now, the zeal of wisdom consists in this, that our endeavor be directed toward nothing but God who is "all delight." These four are difficult, unless they are preceded by a fourfold effort: then they are easy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since there can be no perfect cure without the conservation of the health that has been introduced; and the health that has been introduced cannot be conserved in the conflict of battle except in the battle-line of the Church, which is terrible as an army set in array; and this indeed comes about through the armor of sevenfold grace: hence it is that the Sacraments must be seven. For in order that this battle-line be perfectly and continuously fortified: since it consists of corruptible parts, it needs Sacraments that fortify, that raise up, and that renew: that fortify those who fight, that raise up those who fall, and that renew those who die. Now the Sacrament that fortifies either fortifies those entering, and thus it is baptism: or those standing firm, and thus it is confirmation: or those departing, and thus it is extreme unction. The Sacrament that raises up either raises up from a venial fall, and thus it is the Eucharist: or from a mortal fall, and thus it is penance.
The Sacrament that renews either renews in spiritual being, and thus it is orders, whose function is to administer the Sacraments: or in natural being, and thus it is matrimony. Whence, since baptism is for those entering, confirmation for those fighting, the Eucharist for those recovering strength, penance for those rising again, extreme unction for those departing, orders for those introducing new soldiers, and matrimony for those preparing new soldiers; the sufficiency and order of the sacramental remedies and arms is evident from these.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For it is necessary that the hierarchized soul have levels corresponding to the Jerusalem which is above. For the soul is something great: the whole universe may be described in it. The soul is called "as lovely as Jerusalem," for it is likened to Jerusalem through the disposition of the hierarchical levels. For they are disposed in the soul in a threefold manner: in relation to ascent, to descent, and to the return to God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The mind cannot see it with intellectual eyes, and so they must be turned away. Hence it is said in the Canticle: "Turn away thy eyes from me, for they have made me flee away." For Christ goes away when the mind attempts to behold this wisdom through intellectual eyes; since it is not the intellect that can go in there, but the heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Solomon represents Christ, except in the women in whom there is no good that can have symbolical meaning. Hence, when it is said in the Canticle: "There are sixty queens, eighty concubines, and maidens without number," this does not refer literally to wives: these women are placed here in a mysterious fashion, and they represent perfect and imperfect souls.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since there can be no perfect cure without the conservation of the health that has been introduced; and the health that has been introduced cannot be conserved in the conflict of battle except in the battle-line of the Church, which is terrible as an army set in array; and this indeed comes about through the armor of sevenfold grace: hence it is that the Sacraments must be seven. For in order that this battle-line be perfectly and continuously fortified: since it consists of corruptible parts, it needs Sacraments that fortify, that raise up, and that renew: that fortify those who fight, that raise up those who fall, and that renew those who die. Now the Sacrament that fortifies either fortifies those entering, and thus it is baptism: or those standing firm, and thus it is confirmation: or those departing, and thus it is extreme unction. The Sacrament that raises up either raises up from a venial fall, and thus it is the Eucharist: or from a mortal fall, and thus it is penance.
The Sacrament that renews either renews in spiritual being, and thus it is orders, whose function is to administer the Sacraments: or in natural being, and thus it is matrimony. Whence, since baptism is for those entering, confirmation for those fighting, the Eucharist for those recovering strength, penance for those rising again, extreme unction for those departing, orders for those introducing new soldiers, and matrimony for those preparing new soldiers; the sufficiency and order of the sacramental remedies and arms is evident from these.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Faith is a union of the Head with the body. The shining of light as related to faith is called allegory, and it is twofold, one directed to the Head and the other to the body. For there is one directed to the crucified Head, that was born, etc., and another directed to the body, that is, the Church, primitive, intermediate, and final. And Solomon praises the Church in this manner, according to its threefold state: "Who is she that cometh forth as the morning rising, fair as the moon, bright as the sun?" — "Who is she that goeth up by the desert, as a pillar of smoke of aromatic spices, of myrrh and frankincense?" — "Who is this that cometh up from the desert, flowing with delights, leaning upon her beloved?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the second allegory, about the blessed Virgin Mary, it is said in the Psalm: "He has pitched a tent there for the sun." Wherefore she is "as beautiful as the moon, as resplendent as the sun, as awe-inspiring as bannered troops." Hence she is a vessel able to contain light: "The sun, an admirable instrument, the work of the most High — shining gloriously in the firmament of heaven."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These four fruits come forth in an orderly manner. Consideration in a direct line through the help of the citizens of heaven disposes toward the first act of wisdom, seen to be "as awe-inspiring as bannered troops" and the "companies of the camps."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, there is a comparison of times three by three, as of the origin, promotion and fall of the Synagogue; and in the Church, the times of its beginning, expansion, and consummation. Hence, in the Canticle, there are three expressions of wonder: "Who is this," etc. in praise of the Church, and, by contrast, three expressions of sorrow in the Lamentations. Hence, it is not without reason that the alphabet is repeated so often.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third comparison between the Old and the New Testaments is related to a threefold division, for there is a time when the Synagogue was initiated, another when it was promoted, and yet another when it failed. Likewise, in the New Testament, there is a time when it was started, another when it was expanded, and yet another when it was consummated. Hence, in the Canticle the Church is praised three times, for it is one, nor is there nor can there be any other. The Church is praised when it was started: "What is this coming up from the desert, like a column of smoke?" When it was expanded: "Who is this that comes forth like the dawn, as beautiful as the moon, as resplendent as the sun?" When it was consummated: "Who is this coming up from the desert, flowing with delights, leaning upon her lover?" For it is necessary that Rachel give birth to her sons in the final Church. Hence, in the Apocalypse, Manasses is placed before his father, for he is in the sixth place, and Joseph in the twelfth, while Benjamin is in the last, and this is not without cause.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When these senses have been recovered, while the soul sees and hears, smells, tastes, and embraces its spouse, it can sing as a bride the Song of Songs, which was composed for the exercise of contemplation according to this fourth degree, which no one grasps unless he receives it, because it consists more in affective experience than in rational consideration. For in this degree, when the interior senses have been restored to sense the supremely beautiful, to hear the supremely harmonious, to smell the supremely fragrant, to taste the supremely sweet, to apprehend the supremely delightful, the soul is disposed to mental transports, namely through devotion, admiration, and exultation, according to those three exclamations which are made in the Song of Songs. The first of these arises from the abundance of devotion, through which the soul becomes like a column of smoke from the aromatics of myrrh and frankincense; the second from the excellence of admiration, through which the soul becomes like the dawn, the moon, and the sun, according to the progression of illuminations that suspend the soul in admiration of the spouse contemplated; the third from the superabundance of exultation, through which the soul of most sweet pleasure, flowing with delights, leans entirely upon her beloved.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These four fruits come forth in an orderly manner. Consideration in a direct line through the help of the citizens of heaven disposes toward the first act of wisdom, seen to be "as awe-inspiring as bannered troops" and the "companies of the camps."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Faith is a union of the Head with the body. The shining of light as related to faith is called allegory, and it is twofold, one directed to the Head and the other to the body. For there is one directed to the crucified Head, that was born, etc., and another directed to the body, that is, the Church, primitive, intermediate, and final. And Solomon praises the Church in this manner, according to its threefold state: "Who is she that cometh forth as the morning rising, fair as the moon, bright as the sun?" — "Who is she that goeth up by the desert, as a pillar of smoke of aromatic spices, of myrrh and frankincense?" — "Who is this that cometh up from the desert, flowing with delights, leaning upon her beloved?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third comparison between the Old and the New Testaments is related to a threefold division, for there is a time when the Synagogue was initiated, another when it was promoted, and yet another when it failed. Likewise, in the New Testament, there is a time when it was started, another when it was expanded, and yet another when it was consummated. Hence, in the Canticle the Church is praised three times, for it is one, nor is there nor can there be any other. The Church is praised when it was started: "What is this coming up from the desert, like a column of smoke?" When it was expanded: "Who is this that comes forth like the dawn, as beautiful as the moon, as resplendent as the sun?" When it was consummated: "Who is this coming up from the desert, flowing with delights, leaning upon her lover?" For it is necessary that Rachel give birth to her sons in the final Church. Hence, in the Apocalypse, Manasses is placed before his father, for he is in the sixth place, and Joseph in the twelfth, while Benjamin is in the last, and this is not without cause.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, there is a comparison of times three by three, as of the origin, promotion and fall of the Synagogue; and in the Church, the times of its beginning, expansion, and consummation. Hence, in the Canticle, there are three expressions of wonder: "Who is this," etc. in praise of the Church, and, by contrast, three expressions of sorrow in the Lamentations. Hence, it is not without reason that the alphabet is repeated so often.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When these senses have been recovered, while the soul sees and hears, smells, tastes, and embraces its spouse, it can sing as a bride the Song of Songs, which was composed for the exercise of contemplation according to this fourth degree, which no one grasps unless he receives it, because it consists more in affective experience than in rational consideration. For in this degree, when the interior senses have been restored to sense the supremely beautiful, to hear the supremely harmonious, to smell the supremely fragrant, to taste the supremely sweet, to apprehend the supremely delightful, the soul is disposed to mental transports, namely through devotion, admiration, and exultation, according to those three exclamations which are made in the Song of Songs. The first of these arises from the abundance of devotion, through which the soul becomes like a column of smoke from the aromatics of myrrh and frankincense; the second from the excellence of admiration, through which the soul becomes like the dawn, the moon, and the sun, according to the progression of illuminations that suspend the soul in admiration of the spouse contemplated; the third from the superabundance of exultation, through which the soul of most sweet pleasure, flowing with delights, leans entirely upon her beloved.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A person is disposed to the influx of the gift of fortitude through the inextinguishable fire of charity. Whence in the Song of Songs: "Set me as a seal upon your heart, as a seal upon your arm: for love is strong as death, jealousy is hard as hell; its lamps are lamps of fire and flames; many waters could not extinguish charity." Do you think you can extinguish a burning furnace with a drop of water? Every power is like a drop of water in comparison to the loving soul. "Love is strong as death": death conquers all, and likewise love conquers all things. "Jealousy is hard as hell": hell does not release what it holds, and so charity conquers all things and holds them fast. Paul, what do you say about charity? "Who," he says, "shall separate me from the charity of God?" He answers: "Tribulation? or distress? or hunger? or nakedness? or danger? or persecution? or the sword?" And he says: "I am certain that neither death nor life nor things present nor things to come shall be able to separate me from the charity which is in Christ Jesus." This charity draws us to a celestial nature and does not permit any foreign impression upon us: of itself, it is perpetual; unless I give a bill of divorce, God will not take away his charity from us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such love divides, puts to sleep, and lifts up. It divides, since it cuts away from any other love because of the single love for the Spouse; it puts to sleep and appeases all the powers and imposes silence; it lifts up, since it leads to God. And so man is as dead, wherefore it is said: "Love is strong as death," because it cuts away from all things. Man, then, must die of this love in order to be lifted up. Hence "no man sees Me and still lives." Then, in this union, the power of the soul is recollected, and it becomes more unified, and enters in its intimate self, and consequently it rises up to its summit: for according to Augustine, the intimate self and the summit are the same.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fortitude is comparable to the power of fire. Hence the author of the Canticle, speaking of fortitude, says: "For love is strong as death, jealousy as hard as hell. The lamps thereof are fire and flames."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Furthermore, this charity gives to the soul a fire. Hence, in the Canticle, "Set me as a seal on your heart... for stern as death is love," when it loves to such a degree that it is totally carried up to the supremely desirable, and sees prosperity as nothing, and adversity as nothing, since all things are like a single straw in a furnace. "If a man should give all the substance of his house for love, he shall despise it as nothing." Now, the fourth seal consists in this, that the soul perceives an incomprehensible consolation that grows so much within it that it is unable both to comprehend it and to explain it to others. The Canticle says of this: "Eat, friends; drink! Drink freely of love!" And this inebriated soul says: The king "brought me into the cellar of wine." And earlier: "The king hath brought me into his storerooms." This occurs when the soul is beside itself, like a drunken man who does not know what he is doing. Hence, Paul did not know whether he was in the body or out of the body. Of this seal, the Psalm says: "Shew me a token for good, that they who hate me may see, and be confounded."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A person is disposed to the influx of the gift of fortitude through the inextinguishable fire of charity. "Many waters could not extinguish charity." Do you think you can extinguish a burning furnace with a drop of water? Every power is like a drop of water in comparison to the loving soul. "Love is strong as death": death conquers all, and likewise love conquers all things. "Jealousy is hard as hell": hell does not release what it holds, and so charity conquers all things and holds them fast. This charity draws us to a celestial nature and does not permit any foreign impression upon us: of itself, it is perpetual; unless I give a bill of divorce, God will not take away his charity from us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Furthermore, this charity gives to the soul a fire. Hence, in the Canticle, "Set me as a seal on your heart... for stern as death is love," when it loves to such a degree that it is totally carried up to the supremely desirable, and sees prosperity as nothing, and adversity as nothing, since all things are like a single straw in a furnace. "If a man should give all the substance of his house for love, he shall despise it as nothing."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As Augustine and Hugh maintain, this world is like a certain ring given by the bridegroom to the soul itself: but the bride can love the ring bestowed upon her by the bridegroom in two ways, namely, with chaste love and with adulterous love. Chaste love is that by which she loves the ring in memory of the bridegroom and on account of love for the bridegroom: adulterous, that by which she loves the ring more than the bridegroom: and the bridegroom cannot but regard this as evil. For just as love is twofold, so hatred or contempt is twofold, because "as often as one of the opposites is spoken of, so also the other." Contempt of the ring, as though it were a small and worthless gift, redounds to the bridegroom: but contempt of the ring, as though it be reckoned as nothing in comparison with the love of the bridegroom, this is to the glory of the bridegroom: and concerning this contempt it is said in Song of Songs, the last chapter: "If a man should give all the substance of his house for love, he shall despise it as nothing."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence again in Isaiah: "An ox knows its owner, and an ass, its master's manger; but Israel does not know, My people has not understood." The ox represents the order of the apostles, wherefore Paul calls himself "a Hebrew of Hebrews": for they were oxen furrowing the earth. The ass was the gentile people.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Then came the time of the prophets who showed them clearly that they could not be saved through the Law. Hence, in Isaiah: "Your new moons and festivals I detest. — I have had enough of whole-burnt rams and fat of fatlings; in the blood of calves, lambs and goats I find no pleasure." And they killed them, and their followers too, and they received false prophets, thus revealing their malice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Then came the time of the prophets who showed them clearly that they could not be saved through the Law. Hence, in Isaiah: "Your new moons and festivals I detest. — I have had enough of whole-burnt rams and fat of fatlings; in the blood of calves, lambs and goats I find no pleasure." And they killed them, and their followers too, and they received false prophets, thus revealing their malice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Within the order of laymen, there is a threefold order, that is, of the holy people, the holy masters and the holy leaders. As Isaias writes, "I will restore your judges as at first." For good leaders have good masters. And good leaders together with good masters have good people, since they teach them. On the contrary, evil leaders have evil masters, and consequently, they teach the people improperly. Bad people choose bad leaders.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Another distinction is in relation to duality. The Old Testament comprises two times: before the Law, and under the Law. In the New Testament, likewise, there are two corresponding times: the time of the calling of the Gentiles that corresponds to the first, and the time of the calling of the Jews that corresponds to the second. This time is not yet, for then will be fulfilled these words of Isaiah: "One nation shall not raise the sword against another, nor shall they train for war again." For this is not yet fulfilled since both swords are still active: there are still disputes and heresies. Hence the Jews, who are waiting for this believe that Christ has not yet come.
The fact that the Jews will be converted is certain because of Isaiah and the Apostle who teaches authoritatively: "Though the number of the children of Israel are as the sands of the sea, the remnant shall be saved." And again: "A partial blindness only has befallen Israel, until the full number of the Gentiles should enter." Isaiah continues: "Come, let us climb the Lord's mountain, to the house of the God of Jacob." And later: "One nation shall not raise the sword against another, nor shall they train for war again." The Jews oppose to this the fact that none of it has come about as yet. But the prophet is not speaking of the first advent nor of the first calling, but of the last, when "the Lord will have His day against all that is arrogant." Nor should it be understood that in so doing, the Lord is dismissing these branches.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, their fecundity is represented by the seven women in Isaiah: Seven women will take hold of one man on that day. A man, because these virtues produce virility; and one, because they do not divide him, but make him stable and fruitful.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third mode of generation is by means of propagation, and this in a fourfold way: as of a growth coming from a seed, a tree from a root, a conceived offspring from the belly or womb of the mother, or children from a begetting father. In the first mode of generation, formal beauty is lacking, for in the seed the form is vague and hidden. It is not so in the case of the Son. In the second, conformity is lacking, for although there is a single root, it is different in shape from the branches even though they produce a single tree. In the third, actuality is lacking, for although the mother is in a certain sense the active principle of the offspring, yet she is much more of a passive principle. In the fourth, eternal coexistence is lacking.
Now, take away these defects and suppose first formal beauty. In this sense, there is Isaiah: "The branch of the Lord will be luster and glory, and the fruit of the earth will be honor and splendor." Second, suppose conformity: The Son conforms to the Father to the point that He is "the tree of life... in the midst of the garden." Hence, in Proverbs: "She is a tree of life to those who grasp her." Third, suppose actuality: in this sense, you have the Psalm: "With Thee is the principality in the day of Thy strength, in the brightness of the saints: from the womb before the day star I begot Thee. From the womb," says the Psalmist, which is in relation to the warmth of the Father's bosom, from which He does not withdraw. Fourth, suppose eternal coexistence. In this sense, there is the Psalm: "This day I have begotten You," that is in eternity, or in My eternal today.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fourth is the fullness of restoring fruits. Isaiah says: "The branch of the Lord will be luster and glory, and the fruit of the earth will be honor and splendor." And when was this? When the woman said: "Blessed art thou among women and blessed is the Fruit of thy womb!"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Therefore my people are led into captivity, because they did not have knowledge," namely neither in the head nor in the members.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Opposing adherence to peace, we have the spirit of malice and cruelty, of hatred and anger, and these two lead to complete perversion: the malicious man turns every good into evil, while the angry man turns every evil into good and considers good the actual rendering of evil. Hence they "change darkness into light, and light into darkness." Such as these are unqualified to listen to God's Law.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is a twofold dimension to the firmament: one concerned with the highest, the other with the lowest; one which makes known the eternal God, the other which reveals God made man. Of these two aspects, Isaiah says, in chapter six, in a vision which was the root of all his other visions: "I saw the Lord seated on a high and lofty throne, with the train of his garment filling the temple." And immediately there follows upon this the blinding of the Jews and the enlightenment of the Gentiles. Wherefore Isaiah says "I saw," that is, through the vision of understanding lifted up by faith and stabilized in the height of eternal wisdom, in which there is a twofold light, inflaming and seraphic.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of prophetical revelation, Christ is symbolized through prophetical visions, and this in different ways: for one saw Christ as "a branch of the watching-tree," another saw Him "seated on a high and lofty throne," while yet another saw Him "dressed."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Seraphim were stationed above; each of them had six wings: with two they veiled their faces, with two they veiled their feet, with two they hovered aloft." There are two Seraphim established in us through faith. Our intellect enlightened by faith is made to resemble a Seraph, that is, it is enlightened and inflamed through faith. Faith is both toward the eternal God and toward God made man. Faith toward the eternal God contains one explanation of the six wings: in reference to the distinction of the Persons, there are three articles—concerning the unbegotten Father, the only-begotten Son proceeding from the Father only, and the Holy Spirit breathed by both. These are the three wings on the right side, that is, in eternity. Likewise, on the left there are three wings inasmuch as there is diffusion into the creature out of a single essence, power and operation: the one God is the Creator, the Sanctifier and the Retributor.
The other Seraph is closer to us and also has six wings: three in the order of descent and three in the order of ascent. These are the three articles concerning the incarnation, crucifixion and descent into hell. Likewise, there are three in the order of ascent: resurrection out of hell into the world, ascension out of the world into heaven, and the coming out of heaven for the judgment. These six wings are the six perfect considerations of God in the three Persons and the three operations; the other six in the second series are the six considerations of God incarnate. In these things, therefore, are contained the twelve articles of faith, of which the twelve apostles were the preachers. For a wing lifts up in order to transcend every human reason. In the absence of this twofold consideration, there is no worshiper of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Just as God completed the whole world in six days and rested on the seventh, so the lesser world may be led in most orderly fashion through six stages of successive illuminations to the repose of contemplation. As a figure of this, one ascended by six steps to the throne of Solomon; the Seraphim that Isaiah saw had six wings; after six days the Lord called Moses from the midst of the cloud, and Christ after six days, as is said in Matthew, led the disciples up the mountain and was transfigured before them.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These six considerations having therefore been traversed, as if they were the six steps of the throne of the true Solomon, by which one arrives at peace, where the true peaceful one rests in a peaceful mind as in an interior Jerusalem; and as if also the six wings of the Cherub, by which the mind of the true contemplative, filled with the illumination of supernal wisdom, may be borne upward; and as if also the first six days, in which the mind must be exercised, so that it may at last arrive at the sabbath of rest; after our mind has contemplated God outside itself through vestiges and in the vestiges, within itself through the image and in the image, above itself through the similitude of the divine light shining upon us and in that light itself, insofar as is possible according to the state of wayfaring and the exercise of our mind; when at last in the sixth step it has arrived at this point, that it contemplates in the first and highest principle and the mediator of God and men, Jesus Christ, those things whose likenesses can in no way be found in creatures, and which exceed all keenness of the human intellect: it remains that, in contemplating these things, it should transcend and pass beyond not only this sensible world, but also itself; in which passing over, Christ is the way and the door, Christ is the ladder and the vehicle, as it were the mercy seat placed upon the ark of God and the mystery hidden from the ages.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To be sanctified is to be drawn away from any love that sullies and corrupts and may lead the soul to ruin. In this must the creature resemble the Creator: "You shall be holy," He said, "because I am holy." This holiness makes one God-conformed. That is why the Seraphic spirits cried out: "Holy, holy, holy."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Our intellect enlightened by faith cries out three times: "Holy, holy, holy." There are two Seraphim established in us through faith, and each one makes the triple exclamation, but refers only once to the Lord God. For the understanding of God is the understanding of three Persons with unity of essence. And so the intellect is made to resemble a Seraph, that is, it is enlightened and inflamed through faith, and cries out "Holy" three times. The other Seraph answers "Holy, holy, holy," for as in the eternal God there are trinity of Persons and oneness of essence, so also in God made man there are trinity of natures and unity of Person. And these are the two roots of faith, and a man who ignores them believes nothing: they refer to the body, the soul and the divinity. The holy Christ has a holy body, the holy Christ has a holy soul, the holy Christ has a holy divinity. He is holy without, holy within, and holy above.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This, indeed, is the Monarch who exerts power to the supreme degree, who is supremely wise in discerning the truth, supremely holy in loving the good, and supremely constant in distributing what is just. The Seraphim correspond to supreme holiness, for in them there is holy love, wherefore they cry out, Holy, Holy, Holy; the Cherubim, to wisdom, for in them there is the fullness of understanding; the Thrones, to constancy, for in them there is a high seat, open to receiving.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Isaiah according to the Septuagint translation says: "Unless you believe, you shall not understand." And Augustine says: "Unless a man captivates his understanding and follows through faith what he hears, he is not disposed to the gift of understanding." A man is disposed to receive worthily the gift of understanding through the captivation of the intelligence. He who wishes to search sacred Scripture according to the light of his own intelligence thinks the most false errors. In this life we are little ones, and "the learner must believe." For it is necessary to believe God, and especially in sublime matters that transcend our understanding. The first Angel erred because he presumed upon himself.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is no salvation except through wisdom. But wisdom is neither disclosed nor obtained except through faith. Hence: "Unless you believe, you shall not understand." For you should not "be more wise than it behooveth to be wise,... according as God hath divided to every one the measure of faith." For faith is not had except through the grace of the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Where shall that price be found? Certainly nowhere except in the womb of the glorious Virgin. Whence Isaiah: "Behold, a Virgin shall conceive and bear a son, and his name shall be called Emmanuel." Emmanuel is interpreted "God with us." It was not fitting for the Virgin to have a son unless he were God, nor for God to have a mother unless she were a Virgin. That price could not be found except in the Virgin. It is "from afar and from the uttermost boundaries," because in him the highest is joined with the lowest, and the first with the last. That price is "from afar," by which the entire human race is redeemed: because what is redeemed is the lowest, therefore it is the highest; because what is redeemed is the last, therefore it is the first. Man among creatures was created last.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The full accord of the witnesses is found in the words of Scriptures. Isaiah says: The virgin shall be with child; and Luke: Thou shalt conceive. One says: Christ shall be slain; and the Evangelist: Put Him to death. Whatever, then, had been foretold by the prophets was fulfilled through Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Going down to philosophy implies the greatest danger. Isaias says: "Because this people has rejected the waters of Siloe that flow gently, and melts with fear before the loftiness of Rasin and Romelia's son, therefore the Lord raises against them the waters of the River, great and mighty, the king of Assyria." We should no longer return to Egypt. Let the masters beware, then, not to commend or appreciate too highly the sayings of the philosophers, lest the people take it as a pretext to return to Egypt, or dismiss because of their example the waters of Siloe in which is supreme perfection, and go to the waters of the philosophers in which there is eternal deceit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Next to these mysteries are the mystery of the tree of life and the mystery of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. For he who seeks nothing but knowledge tastes of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. And this is pointed out in Isaias: Forasmuch as this people hath cast away the waters of Siloe, that go with silence, and hath rather taken Rasin and the son of Romelia: Therefore behold the Lord will bring upon them the waters of the river, strong and many. But as Jerome says, the waters of Siloe run with a great rumble: wherefore it is evident that the meaning here is different. The waters that go with silence are Holy Scripture which cannot be learned except in silence: and in that there is enlightenment. As a sign of this, it is said to the blind: "Go, wash in the pool of Siloe (which is interpreted 'sent')." For these waters are found through revelation. But it is fitting first to anoint the eyes with clay made of spittle and dust. Spittle is wisdom. Dust is Christ's flesh. Clay is faith concerning the mystery of the incarnation. But those who have taken Rasin and the son of Romelia are those who seek external sciences. Wherefore the prince of the Assyrians shall have power over them: the Lord willed it. And here it should be noted that the sons of Israel despoiled the Egyptians of their silver vessels: and after that, the Lord never wanted them to be returned.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Going down to philosophy implies the greatest danger. Isaias says: "Because this people has rejected the waters of Siloe that flow gently, and melts with fear before the loftiness of Rasin and Romelia's son, therefore the Lord raises against them the waters of the River, great and mighty, the king of Assyria." We should no longer return to Egypt. Let the masters beware, then, not to commend or appreciate too highly the sayings of the philosophers, lest the people take it as a pretext to return to Egypt, or dismiss because of their example the waters of Siloe in which is supreme perfection, and go to the waters of the philosophers in which there is eternal deceit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Next to these mysteries are the mystery of the tree of life and the mystery of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. For he who seeks nothing but knowledge tastes of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. And this is pointed out in Isaias: Forasmuch as this people hath cast away the waters of Siloe, that go with silence, and hath rather taken Rasin and the son of Romelia: Therefore behold the Lord will bring upon them the waters of the river, strong and many. But as Jerome says, the waters of Siloe run with a great rumble: wherefore it is evident that the meaning here is different. The waters that go with silence are Holy Scripture which cannot be learned except in silence: and in that there is enlightenment. As a sign of this, it is said to the blind: "Go, wash in the pool of Siloe (which is interpreted 'sent')." For these waters are found through revelation. But it is fitting first to anoint the eyes with clay made of spittle and dust. Spittle is wisdom. Dust is Christ's flesh. Clay is faith concerning the mystery of the incarnation. But those who have taken Rasin and the son of Romelia are those who seek external sciences. Wherefore the prince of the Assyrians shall have power over them: the Lord willed it. And here it should be noted that the sons of Israel despoiled the Egyptians of their silver vessels: and after that, the Lord never wanted them to be returned.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the first petition of the Lord's Prayer, our sanctification is sought, and this through the gift of fear, when he says: "Our Father, who art in heaven; hallowed be thy name." Isaiah: "Sanctify the Lord of hosts, and let him be your dread and your fear."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whatever is said in the Bible of the sun shedding light, or of other diffusions, or of banquets, is said of His bounty. Hence, in the Psalm: "The household shall divide the spoils." And in Isaiah: "They rejoice before You as men make merry when dividing spoils." These are the gifts of Christ's lavishness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of the establishment of judges, Christ is symbolized by Gedeon, of whom Isaiah speaks: "As on the day of Madian."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But who is the good counselor? Certainly that one of whom it is said: 'His name shall be called Wonderful, Counselor, God, the Mighty, the Father of the world to come, the Prince of Peace.' He is the Angel of great counsel: this is he to whom we ought to attend with a pure heart. Ecclesiasticus says: 'Before all works let a true word precede you, and before every act a stable counsel.' The true word, which can neither be deceived nor deceive, is the only-begotten Son of God and his doctrine and his life. Let this word precede you and this stable counsel. Stable counsel is none other than that of my God; 'the counsel of the Lord remains forever.'”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Supposing I wanted to know how the Word of God can be the Restorer: Isaiah speaks of it: "A child is born to us, a son is given us; upon His shoulder dominion rests. They name Him Wonder-Counselor, God-Hero, Father-Forever, Prince of Peace." He it is who restored the hierarchy of heaven, and that below heaven which had totally fallen. Hence He must needs have touched both heaven and earth. This Hierarch had to be preeminent, endowed with awareness, acceptable to God, victorious, most generous, and just. He is called "Wonder" because He had to be preeminent in power, showing the miracle of miracles in His own Person, the plurality of natures. He is called "Counselor" because He was the best Counselor and the most wise, and from Him come forth documents of the greatest certainty. He is called "God" because He was acceptable to God, not only because in the form of God, but as God. He is called "Strong" because He overcame the world, despoiled Hades, and restored Paradise. He is called "Father of the age to come" because He is the Principle of those influences by which we will live in the future. He is called "Prince of Peace" because of the manifold character of a justice making infallible inquiries, irreproachable distinctions, and irrevocable judgments.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And Isaiah shows this: "The Lord has sent word against Jacob, it falls upon Israel." He has sent word against Jacob. Jacob is a name of nature, for He was of his seed; but it falls upon Israel: Israel is a spiritual name. We are the sons of Israel and the sons of Abraham according to the promise, for we are the imitators of Abraham's faith.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Finally, He must be supremely just, because of the manifold character of a justice making infallible inquiries, irreproachable distinctions, and irrevocable judgments, handing out retribution to each one according to his deeds. Isaiah writes: "A shoot shall sprout from the stump of Jesse. Justice shall be the band around his waist. Not by appearance shall He judge nor by hearsay shall He decide." Such, then, is God: for if He were mere man, He could not judge otherwise than through witnesses. All the judgments of Scriptures refer to this one judgment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, there is the production of prophets similar to the multiplication of flowers. Flowers appeared when the prophet said: "A shoot shall sprout from the stump of Jesse, and from his roots a bud shall blossom."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Although the gifts of gratuitously given grace are very many, and generally all habits divinely given can not absurdly be called gifts of God, yet specially and appropriately there are seven gifts of the Holy Spirit, which Isaiah enumerates and names, speaking of the flower that proceeded from the root of Jesse, that is, Christ, of whom he says that the Spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him, the spirit of wisdom and understanding, the spirit of counsel and fortitude, the spirit of knowledge and piety, and the spirit of the fear of the Lord shall fill him. In this enumeration he proceeds by descending from the highest and by combining, so that at once the distinction, connection, origin, and order of the gifts may be shown.
The reason for understanding the aforesaid is this: since the restorative principle through supreme liberality gives grace not only for rectifying against the crookedness of vices through the habits of virtues, but also for freeing against the impediments of infirmities through the habits of gifts; therefore the gratuitous gifts must be multiplied according to what is necessary for sufficiency of freedom. Since therefore our soul needs to be freed in a sevenfold manner, hence it is that from a sevenfold cause it is necessary that the gifts of the Holy Spirit be sevenfold.
First, therefore, for most expeditiously repelling the crookedness of vices, there are seven gifts of the Holy Spirit, namely: fear against pride; piety against envy; knowledge against anger, which is as it were a kind of madness; fortitude against sloth, which renders the mind powerless for good; counsel against avarice; understanding against gluttony; and wisdom against lust.
Second, for freeing the natural powers, the gifts of the Holy Spirit must be seven. For the irascible power needs to be freed for good things both in prosperity and in adversity: in prosperity it is freed through fear, in adversity through fortitude. The concupiscible power needs to be freed with respect to affection toward the neighbor, and this is done through piety; and with respect to affection toward God, and this is done through the taste of wisdom. The rational power indeed needs to be freed in the speculation, choice, and execution of truth: through the gift of understanding it is freed for speculating upon the true, through the gift of counsel for choosing the true, through the gift of knowledge for executing what has been chosen.
Third, for the carrying out of the seven offices of the virtues there must be seven gifts of the Holy Spirit. For fear disposes to temperance, since fear transfixes the flesh; piety to true justice; knowledge to prudence; fortitude to fortitude or patience; counsel to hope; understanding to faith; wisdom to charity. Whence, just as charity is the mother and consummation of all the virtues, so wisdom is of the gifts.
Fourth, for readiness in suffering conformably to Christ, there are seven habits of the gifts. Now Christ was moved to suffer by the paternal will, human necessity and the vigor of virtue. The divine will indeed moved him, as known through understanding, as loved through wisdom, as held in reverence through fear. Our necessity also moved him, for the knowing of which knowledge is necessary, and for the pitying of which piety is superadded. The vigor of virtue moved him no less, as provident in choosing through counsel, as vigorous in enduring through fortitude. And thus the gifts must be seven.
Fifth, for readiness in acting, seven gifts are given by the Holy Spirit. For ready action, we must be made ready to turn away from evil, which is done through fear. We must also be made ready to advance in good of a twofold kind: either of necessity, or of supererogation. Regarding the first, we are made ready through knowledge and piety, such that one directs and the other executes; regarding the second, through counsel directing and through fortitude executing. We must also rest in the best, both as regards the understanding of the true and as regards the affection for the good; the first is done through the gift of understanding, the second through the gift of wisdom, in which there is rest.
For readiness in contemplating, the gifts of the Holy Spirit are seven in number. For the hierarchical and contemplative life requires the soul to be purged, illuminated, and perfected. Now it must be purged from concupiscence, from malice, from ignorance, from weakness or impotence: the first is done by fear, the second by piety, the third by knowledge, the fourth by fortitude. Illuminated we also need to be regarding the works of restoration and of the original creation: the first is given by counsel, the second by understanding. Perfected we are to be through approach to the highest, which consists in one, and this through the gift of wisdom; and thus the mystery of contemplation is consummated.
Finally, for readiness in action and contemplation there must be seven gifts of the Holy Spirit. For the contemplative life, on account of its turning toward the Trinity, must have three expediting gifts: with respect to reverence for majesty, fear; with respect to the understanding of truth, understanding; with respect to the savor or taste of goodness, wisdom. The active life, however, which is engaged in doing and enduring, must have four, namely piety for doing and fortitude for enduring; and the directive gifts of these two, namely knowledge and counsel. Whence, because direction is necessary for readiness, there arises a combination of gifts; and more gifts pertain to the intellect, because the light of knowledge greatly avails to direct one's feet into the right path.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The Spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him, the spirit of wisdom and understanding, the spirit of counsel and fortitude, the spirit of knowledge and piety, and the spirit of the fear of the Lord shall fill him." John in the Apocalypse saw in the midst of the throne a Lamb having seven horns and seven eyes, which are the seven spirits of God sent into all the earth. He calls the gifts of the Holy Spirit horns and eyes. There is a certain efficacy of the gifts of the Holy Spirit by which all evils are combated; there is another efficacy of the gifts by which a person is equipped for all good things. And because strength resides in horns, therefore the gifts by which evils are combated he calls horns. And because the power of readiness resides in the eyes, therefore the gifts by which a person is equipped for all good things he calls eyes.
Through the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit, designated by the seven horns, the seven mortal sins are destroyed, and seven virtues are introduced. The gift of fear destroys pride and brings about the good of poverty; the gift of piety destroys envy and introduces meekness; the gift of knowledge destroys wrath and introduces mourning; the gift of fortitude destroys sloth and introduces hunger for justice; the gift of counsel destroys avarice and introduces mercy; the gift of understanding destroys gluttony and introduces purity of heart; the gift of wisdom destroys lust and introduces peace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third ground of the influx of fortitude is from God indwelling. "The Spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him, the spirit of wisdom and understanding, the spirit of counsel and fortitude, the spirit of knowledge and piety"; and he places fortitude in the middle, because Christ does not dwell in us unless we have these two, namely the Spirit of the Lord and fortitude; and therefore he placed fortitude in the middle. Peter denied at the voice of a maidservant, yet stood firm against the emperor, because without the Spirit of the Lord the soul is weak, and with the Spirit of the Lord it is strong. He stood firm against the emperor, because with the Spirit of the Lord he was then strong.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Finally, He must be supremely just, because of the manifold character of a justice making infallible inquiries, irreproachable distinctions, and irrevocable judgments, handing out retribution to each one according to his deeds. Isaiah writes: "A shoot shall sprout from the stump of Jesse. Justice shall be the band around his waist. Not by appearance shall He judge nor by hearsay shall He decide." Such, then, is God: for if He were mere man, He could not judge otherwise than through witnesses. All the judgments of Scriptures refer to this one judgment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Just as "feigned righteousness is not righteousness, but double iniquity," so feigned holiness is not holiness, but rather iniquity. Against such the Apostle says: "In the last times there will be men who are lovers of pleasures, having the appearance of piety, but denying its power." Those having the appearance of piety are hypocrites. For such a one is a son of perdition. Of such a one it is said: "With the breath of his lips he shall strike the impious one," namely him who will have the greatest appearance of piety.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Finally, He must be supremely just, because of the manifold character of a justice making infallible inquiries, irreproachable distinctions, and irrevocable judgments, handing out retribution to each one according to his deeds. Isaiah writes: "A shoot shall sprout from the stump of Jesse. Justice shall be the band around his waist. Not by appearance shall He judge nor by hearsay shall He decide." Such, then, is God: for if He were mere man, He could not judge otherwise than through witnesses. All the judgments of Scriptures refer to this one judgment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Beyond philosophical knowledge, God gave us theological knowledge, which is the pious awareness of credible truth: because the eternal light, namely God, is a light inaccessible to us as long as we are mortal and have the eyes of a bat. Hence Augustine says: "The weak gaze of the mind is not fixed upon so excellent a light unless it is cleansed through the justice of faith." Therefore theological knowledge is founded upon faith: just as the philosophical sciences are founded upon their first principles, so the science of Scripture is founded upon the articles of faith, which are the twelve foundations of the city. Concerning this knowledge it is said in Isaiah: "They shall not hurt nor destroy in all my holy mountain": there follows: "because the earth is filled with the knowledge of the Lord, as the waters of the sea covering it." Sacred Scripture is compared to the water of the sea on account of the profundity of its mysteries, on account of the manifold variety of its senses and on account of the establishment of the Churches.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In relation to the abundantly flowing multiformity of the spiritual meanings, there are many outpourings, of the waters from clouds, rivers, fountains, and all come from the sea. If you ask: How? It is through various detours and motions: this is how the cloud, the river, the fountain answer. Hence, in Isaiah: "The earth shall be filled with knowledge of the Lord, as water covers the sea." And before this: "There shall be no harm or ruin on all my holy mountain."
Now this refers much more directly to the time of the New Testament, when Scripture was made evident, and mostly toward the end, when those Scriptures were understood which had not been understood before. For then there shall be a "mountain," that is, the contemplative Church; then, "there shall be no harm" when the monsters of heresy shall flee on account of the proper use of wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This fortitude is from God redeeming through the incarnation of the divine Word. Whence Isaiah says: "The Lord is my strength and my praise, and he has become my salvation; you shall draw waters with joy from the fountains of the Savior." These are the waters in which the soul is strengthened, purified, redeemed, sanctified, and snatched from the power of demons.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This fortitude is from God redeeming through the incarnation of the divine Word. Whence Isaiah says: "The Lord is my strength and my praise, and he has become my salvation; you shall draw waters with joy from the fountains of the Savior." These are the waters in which the soul is strengthened, purified, redeemed, sanctified, and snatched from the power of demons.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And so, two kinds of water are distinguished. For one knowledge is described as being external, and the more one drinks of it, the more he thirsts; the other, as being internal, of which it is said: "He who believes in Me, as the Scripture says, 'From within Him there shall flow rivers of living water.'" He said this, however, of the Spirit whom they who believed in Him were to receive. And these are the waters from the fountain of salvation, that is, awareness of those graces that sustain souls.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That price is most precious. On account of this Isaiah says: "A man shall be more precious than gold, and a human being than pure gold of Ophir." This he says of Christ, who made us precious.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first among the Angels, Lucifer, presuming upon his private good, sought private excellence, wishing to be raised above the others; and therefore he fell together with the rest who consented to him. Falling, moreover, he became impenitent, obstinate and blinded and excluded from the contemplation of God and disordered in operation, striving with all his effort to subvert man through manifold temptation. Since through the free choice of the will he could tend toward the supreme good or turn toward his private good, Lucifer, aroused by the consideration of his own beauty and loftiness to love himself and his own private good, presumed upon the loftiness he possessed and sought his own excellence, yet not one that was obtained; and by this, in presuming, he made himself his own principle, glorying in himself; and in seeking, he made himself his own supreme good, resting in himself. But since he was neither the supreme principle nor the supreme good, it was necessary that by his disordered ascent he should fall; and by equal reason, all who consented in this. And immediately when he fell into sin, together with the rest who adhered to him, he lost the highest place, namely the empyrean, descending to the lowest, namely the murky air or hell, so that the fall into guilt was through free choice, but the fall into punishment was through divine judgment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For as long as vain, transitory, passing good is loved, man is "passing over." And such passing over Wisdom reproves. This passing over is the cause of every evil. In this way Lucifer passed over, to whom it was said: "Down to the nether world you go, to the recesses of the pit!" He was thrown first by sin, then by the judgment. Adam did the same: after he had given up the tree of life, he hid. Indeed, he saw himself denuded of all good habits. Wherefore he was thrown out of Paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of prophetical revelation, Christ is symbolized by word, which people heard while they could see no one, as they said: "This is the word that the Lord spoke to Moab."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Isaiah had said: The Lord is riding on a swift cloud on His way to Egypt; the idols of Egypt tremble before Him. This came about in Christ. Never was any prophet or philosopher found who could do away with idolatry: yet that is what Christ did through His apostles all over the earth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is fitting that there be a father of fathers, whom we call the Pope, who yet, because of his humility, has four patriarchs: those of Constantinople, Alexandria, Jerusalem, and Antioch. And of these Isaias says: "There shall be five cities in the land of Egypt speaking the language of Chanaan and swearing by the Lord of hosts." But Rome is universal, wherefore "one shall be called 'City of the Sun.'" For while the other four sees have full authority over the neighboring churches, yet, like the sun, Rome in its universality has the fullness of power over them all.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All our merits are rooted in the merit of Christ, whether satisfactory for punishment or meritorious of eternal life, because we are worthy neither to be absolved from offense against the highest good, nor to gain the immensity of the eternal reward, which is God, except through the merit of the God-man, to whom we can and ought to say: All our works you have wrought in us, O Lord.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Whom shall he teach knowledge, and whom shall he make to understand the message? Those weaned from milk and drawn away from the breasts." We dispose ourselves to receive the gift of understanding through holiness of life. Milk signifies the sweetness of carnal delights, by which sweetness the carnal and the infantile are nourished, that is, those who follow infantile impulses. And as long as a man is joined to these carnal consolations, he is called a nursing infant and is not fit to receive the solid food of life and understanding. If we wish to bless God and receive this gift, it is necessary that we be drawn away from these consolations and separate ourselves from the milk of concupiscences.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ is the foundation of this faith. For other foundation no one can lay, but that which has been laid, which is Christ Jesus. For He is the cornerstone of which Isaiah and Peter speak: See, I am laying a stone in Sion, a stone that has been tested, a precious cornerstone as a sure foundation. And the Apostle: You are built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets with Christ Jesus Himself as the chief cornerstone.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Sacred Scripture is compared to the water of the sea on account of the profundity of its mysteries. The sea is deep, nor can a man wade across it: so great is the profundity of the mysteries of sacred Scripture that, however illuminated a man may be and however great his industry, he cannot attain to their depth. Hence Isaiah says: "The vision of all things shall be to you as the words of a sealed book, which when they give to one who knows letters, they will say: Read this; and he will answer: I cannot, for it is sealed. And the book shall be given to one who does not know letters, and it shall be said to him: Read; and he will answer: I do not know letters." Neither the learned nor the unlearned will be able to read it. Who then will read it? I say that he who wishes to enter the sanctuary of God with pride will not be able to, even if he is learned; similarly, if a learned man wishes to enter, he would be foolish. It is necessary, therefore, that one have both learning and the spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this are reproved certain ones who wish to be governed by their own knowledge; of whom Isaiah says: 'Woe to you, deserting children! That you would take counsel and not from me, and would begin a web and not through my Spirit.' They weave spider's webs who cite sacred Scripture for evil purposes. Bernard says: 'You will never understand Paul unless you find the spirit of Paul.'”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture is the mouth of God. Hence Isaiah: "Woe to you who walk to go down into Egypt," that is, to secular sciences, "and have not asked at My mouth," that is, Sacred Scripture. We need not go down to other sciences in order to gain certainty before having had the witness on the mountain, that is, of Christ, Elias and Moses, meaning of the New Testament, of the Prophets and of the Law.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But if you ask how these things come about, ask grace, not doctrine; desire, not understanding; the groaning of prayer, not the study of reading; the Bridegroom, not the master; God, not man; darkness, not clarity; not light, but the fire that wholly inflames and carries into God through ecstatic anointings and most ardent affections. Which fire is indeed God, and his furnace is in Jerusalem, and Christ kindles this in the fervor of his most ardent passion, which only he truly perceives who says: My soul has chosen hanging, and my bones death. Whoever loves this death can see God, because it is indubitably true: No man shall see me and live. Let us die, therefore, and enter into the darkness; let us impose silence upon our cares, concupiscences, and phantasms; let us pass over with Christ crucified from this world to the Father, so that, when the Father is shown to us, we may say with Philip: It suffices us; let us hear with Paul: My grace suffices for you; let us exult with David, saying: My flesh and my heart have failed, God of my heart and God my portion forever. Blessed be the Lord forever, and let all the people say: So be it, so be it. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of the anointing of kings, Christ is symbolized by David, Solomon, Ezechiah and Josiah. Christ is symbolized by Ezechiah: "Once I said, 'In the noontime of life I must depart! To the gates of the nether world I shall be consigned.'"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He who wishes to teach well must put his hand to strong things. In the book of Kings it is said: "Enter, for you are a strong man and one announcing good tidings"; and in Isaiah: "Ascend upon a high mountain, you who bring good tidings to Zion." If the arm is weak, even if the sword be strong and good, the blow will not be good. Some are full of words and have little of works.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Who hath measured the waters in the hollow of his hand and weighed the heavens with his palm? Who hath poised with three fingers the bulk of the earth? This the Word did, through whom all things were made. His hand, by which all things are created, that is, formed or made distinct and adorned, with three fingers lifts and suspends the earth, that is, the ecclesiastic hierarchy which He creates, distinguishes and adorns. This hand measures the waters, this hand holds all things as an object is held in the fist. This is the hand of the eternal Word. This witnessing transcends any judgment by a creature.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And just as all things compared to the divine power can do virtually nothing, so all things compared to the divine essence are virtually the least. Whence in respect to the divine being this entire world is as something minimal. And this is what is said in Wisdom eleven: For as a grain in the balance, so is the whole world before you, and as a drop of morning dew that falls upon the earth: and in Isaiah forty: Behold, the nations are as a drop from a bucket and are accounted as a grain in the balance: and afterward: All nations are as though they were not, so are they before him, and they are accounted as nothing and emptiness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And just as all things compared to the divine power can do virtually nothing, so all things compared to the divine essence are virtually the least. Whence in respect to the divine being this entire world is as something minimal. And this is what is said in Wisdom eleven: For as a grain in the balance, so is the whole world before you, and as a drop of morning dew that falls upon the earth: and in Isaiah forty: Behold, the nations are as a drop from a bucket and are accounted as a grain in the balance: and afterward: All nations are as though they were not, so are they before him, and they are accounted as nothing and emptiness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second disposition for the inflowing of the gift of fortitude is through the imperturbable consolation of hope. "Those who hope in the Lord shall renew their strength: they shall take wings as eagles, they shall run and not labor: they shall walk and not grow faint." A man would gladly bear a great burden for a mark of gold. If a fly refreshes so much, then you ought greatly to be moved to endure for the hope of a future and eternal reward. In God we ought to trust, because he "gives strength to the weary."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The authority of the one commanding ought to move us to observe the commandments of God. He is of great authority, because by His wondrous wisdom He governs us. Whence Isaiah says: "I am the Lord, teaching you profitable things, governing you in the way in which you walk. Would that you had heeded my commandments! Your peace would have been as a river."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The authority of the one commanding ought to move us to observe the commandments of God. He is of great authority, because by His wondrous wisdom He governs us. Whence Isaiah says: "I am the Lord, teaching you profitable things, governing you in the way in which you walk. Would that you had heeded my commandments! Your peace would have been as a river."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The blessed Virgin paid that price as a woman strong and devout with the piety of mercy toward the world, and especially toward the Christian people. Isaiah: "Can a woman forget her infant, so as not to have mercy on the son of her womb? And if she should forget, yet I will not forget you." This is said of Christ. And it can be understood here that the entire Christian people was brought forth from the womb of the glorious Virgin, which is signified to us by the woman formed from the side of the man, who signifies the Church.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Just as the body is adorned by its garment, so the soul is adorned by fortitude; therefore it is called the clothing of the soul; nor is fortitude only the clothing of the soul, or of the glorious Virgin, but indeed of Mother Church. Whence Isaiah says: "Arise, arise, O daughter of Sion; put on the garments of thy glory." The discourse concerns the habit of fortitude, how we may be clothed with it. If we wish to describe fortitude rightly, we must note that it is from heaven.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first thing, then, is that a man possess Scripture, not like a Jew who is content with the rind. For instance, a certain Jew was reading one day this passage from Isaias: "Who would believe what we have heard?" He was reading it literally and was quite unable to relate it to anything nor to make any sense of it, and therefore he cast the book on the ground, begging loudly that God confound Isaias, because it seemed to him that what he said could not stand.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A man sees the slaughter of bodies, he grieves greatly. He therefore who sees the slaughter of souls, how can he restrain himself from tears? I know the infirmities of others: I ought to suffer with them. Isaiah: "We have seen him, a man of sorrows and knowing infirmity." There is no spirit of the knowledge of God in that member when it sees a member of its head wounded and does not grieve with it. David grieved over the death of Absalom, who nevertheless had persecuted him. There is therefore the grief of compunction for oneself, and the grief of compassion for one's neighbors.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ suffered a most universal passion, a most bitter passion, a most ignominious passion, a death-dealing passion, yet one that was life-giving.
He suffered also a most ignominious passion, both on account of the gibbet of the cross, which was the punishment of the worst criminals, and on account of the company of the wicked, namely the thieves, with whom He was reckoned.
Because the swelling of pride sometimes rises inwardly from presumption, and sometimes outwardly from ostentation and the praise of others: therefore, to remedy all pride, Christ suffered both kinds of ignominy, both in himself as the one suffering and in the company he had in his passion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By means of diffusion, as of brightness out of light, of heat out of fire, of a river out of its headspring, of rain out of a full or humid cloud. In the first diffusion, equality is lacking, for brightness is not the same as light. In the second, closeness is lacking, for heat is not close to fire, since it is the principle neither of its form nor of its origin, but is merely an accident. In the third, simultaneity is lacking, for a spring diffuses itself by flowing, and not all at once. In the fourth, fullness is lacking, for not all of the rain is drawn out of a cloud, but only successive drops. Now, join these four conditions to a single diffusion, one of splendor having equality, of heat having closeness and substantiality, of a river or fountain having simultaneity, and of rain having fullness: and in this way, you will have a trace of the eternal generation.
Hence, the Son is sometimes compared to brightness: "Being the brightness of His glory," etc.; at other times, to a flame, as in Moses' bush which represented the person of the Son; or again, as a river or spring: "But a spring rose out of the earth. A river rose in Eden." Again, He is sometimes compared to rain: "For just as from the heavens the rain and snow come down and do not return there till they have watered the earth," etc. And, later: "So shall my word be that goes forth from my mouth," that is, from the Father's heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By means of diffusion, as of brightness out of light, of heat out of fire, of a river out of its headspring, of rain out of a full or humid cloud. In the first diffusion, equality is lacking, for brightness is not the same as light. In the second, closeness is lacking, for heat is not close to fire, since it is the principle neither of its form nor of its origin, but is merely an accident. In the third, simultaneity is lacking, for a spring diffuses itself by flowing, and not all at once. In the fourth, fullness is lacking, for not all of the rain is drawn out of a cloud, but only successive drops. Now, join these four conditions to a single diffusion, one of splendor having equality, of heat having closeness and substantiality, of a river or fountain having simultaneity, and of rain having fullness: and in this way, you will have a trace of the eternal generation.
Hence, the Son is sometimes compared to brightness: "Being the brightness of His glory," etc.; at other times, to a flame, as in Moses' bush which represented the person of the Son; or again, as a river or spring: "But a spring rose out of the earth. A river rose in Eden." Again, He is sometimes compared to rain: "For just as from the heavens the rain and snow come down and do not return there till they have watered the earth," etc. And, later: "So shall my word be that goes forth from my mouth," that is, from the Father's heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Those who bent their knee to drink are those who inclined themselves totally to philosophy: and the same are inclined to an infinite number of errors, and that is how the leaven of error is warmed. They warm the eggs of asps, so that what has been warmed breaks out into a serpent.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is lifted up, so that it may see Jerusalem in a threefold way: as standing in heaven, coming down from heaven, and going up to heaven. In no other way can the soul be contemplative. Isaias speaks of the first: "Rise up in splendor, Jerusalem. No longer shall the sun be your light by day, nor the brightness of the moon shine upon you at night; the Lord shall be your light forever."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Then you shall be radiant at what you see, your heart shall throb and overflow": in contemplation, there is admiration, expansion, a transference and restoration of one's self.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When the soul is lifted up, it must not be idle, but should look around. "Then you shall be radiant at what you see, your heart shall throb and overflow." Then, indeed, the soul must be fixed, and standing, and expecting. Then follows divine induction. When a worthy admission has come about together with a holy perception, then the soul is rapt in God, that is, in the beloved.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is lifted up, so that it may see Jerusalem in a threefold way: as standing in heaven, coming down from heaven, and going up to heaven. In no other way can the soul be contemplative. Isaias speaks of the first: "Rise up in splendor, Jerusalem. No longer shall the sun be your light by day, nor the brightness of the moon shine upon you at night; the Lord shall be your light forever."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Isaiah asks: "Who is this that comes from Edom, in crimson garments, from Bosra? 'It is I who announce vindication, I who am mighty to save.'" For that reason, He is called Strong, and from Him come strong defenses. And so all the wars of Scripture refer to the victory of Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second aspect of the zeal of wisdom is control of the passions, which are the seven affective dispositions of the soul — four principal and three consequent: fear, sorrow, hope and joy; shame and hatred. It is characteristic of these that they go to excess in all matters. But when a child clamors too loudly, he is restrained. Likewise, a man should dominate and restrain these passions with a kind of judicial censure, so that when sorrow comes, he say to himself, "Remain in peace." And the same with the others. And get rid of this childishness and of these infantile dispositions. For children are the pursuers of passions: accursed is the child who is a hundred years old.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first benefit of the fear of God is that the fear of God avails for obtaining the influx of divine grace. Whence Isaiah: "To whom shall I look, except to the poor and contrite of spirit and the one trembling at my words?" However powerful, rich, learned, and strong a man may be, unless he fears God, nothing avails him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Grace makes a man pleasing to God: but he is pleasing to God who recognizes the gift of divine favor and condescension: yet no one recognizes this except one who is attentive to his own unworthiness: and such a one is truly humble: and hence it is that the grace of the Holy Spirit rests upon the humble alone. Whence in the last chapter of Isaiah: Upon whom does My Spirit rest if not upon the humble, etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that which is objected, that the cause of generation and corruption is to be far distant from the First: it must be said that this is not the whole reason. For man, if he had remained in the state of innocence, would never have been corrupted, and yet he would have generated. Whence generation is rather from the supreme perfection and fecundity and actuality of the first principle itself, than it is for the supplementing of the defect of corruption of the productive principle itself. Therefore the Philosopher speaks of the cause of generation according to the state of deficient nature, not generally and according to the mode of that most complete generation, which is the origin of all production. For the generator of the species constituted all these things, and he himself, who bestows generation upon others, cannot be sterile, according to what is said in the last chapter of Isaiah.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To this torment of fire will be joined torment according to all the senses; joined to it will be the punishment of the worm and the deprivation of the vision of God, so that in these punishments there will be variety, and with variety severity, and with severity endlessness.
In every actual mortal sin there is a disordered aversion from the highest light and goodness, and an inordinate conversion to a changeable good, and a disorder of the will against the dictate of right reason: hence it is that all who actually sin and will be damned shall be punished with a threefold punishment: on account of their aversion, the deprivation of the vision of God; on account of their conversion, the punishment of material fire; on account of the conflict between will and reason, the punishment of the worm: so that thus afflicted by this multiplicity of punishments they may be tormented both variously and bitterly and eternally, and the smoke of their torments may ascend forever and ever.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of prophetical revelation, Christ is symbolized especially by means of sight. The prophet saw "a branch of the watching-tree." Christ is symbolized through prophetical visions, and this in different ways: for one saw Christ as "a branch of the watching-tree," another saw Him "seated on a high and lofty throne," while yet another saw Him "dressed."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of prophetical revelation, Christ is symbolized especially by means of sight: the prophet saw "a boiling cauldron" and other things also.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is fitting first to take in Scripture, then to chew it, and finally to assimilate it. What does it serve a man to drink dirty water? "And now what hast thou to do in the way of Egypt, to drink the troubled water?" Drink instead healthy water, that is, wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Know and see that it is evil and bitter that you have forsaken the Lord your God, and that the fear of me is not in you." If you do not fear God, you have lost grace, you have lost justice, and you have lost true wisdom. "See" therefore "how evil and bitter it is that you have forsaken the Lord your God." Where there is no fear, there is neither wisdom nor justice nor grace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the Old Testament it is said that he who swears in the name of God should swear and not perjure himself. For to perjure is the same as to forswear, and this is to take the name of God in vain.
Jeremiah says: "And you shall swear: the Lord lives, in truth and in judgment and in justice;" and the Gloss says there that "an oath ought to have three companions: truth, judgment, and justice."
First, an oath ought to be made with truth; that is, without falsehood. Truth is present in an assertory oath when a man does not deny what is true, nor affirm what is false, nor knowingly assert what is doubtful; for speech is indicative of those things which are in the heart. But do you know what it means when a man testifies to something false by the witness of divine truth? It is to say that he lies and that divine truth lies along with him.
Second, an assertory oath must be made with justice. It is made with justice when it is not made against a commandment of the divine law, nor against a precept of holy Mother Church, nor to the detriment of one's own salvation or that of another. And he who swears against these three swears rashly and sins in a twofold manner: both because he swears and because he keeps the oath.
Third, it is necessary that judgment accompany an assertory oath, so that there be in the mind a discernment of truth and justice, namely, whether the oath is true or false, just or unjust, fruitful or unfruitful. Whence, if I swear without judgment, not discerning among these three, I swear rashly.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That it is the height of folly not to fear, the Lord says in Jeremiah: "Hear, O foolish people, who have no heart: who having eyes, see not, and ears, and hear not. Will you then not fear me, and will you not be grieved at my presence? I who have set the sand as the boundary of the sea, an everlasting decree, which it shall not pass beyond." Do you not fear me?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That it is the height of folly not to fear, the Lord says in Jeremiah: "Hear, O foolish people, who have no heart: who having eyes, see not, and ears, and hear not. Will you then not fear me, and will you not be grieved at my presence? I who have set the sand as the boundary of the sea, an everlasting decree, which it shall not pass beyond." Do you not fear me?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If you glory in wisdom, by that very fact you lose wisdom. "Let not the wise man glory in his wisdom, and let not the strong man glory in his strength." And the cause of this is given in Ezekiel, where it is said: "You, full of wisdom and beauty, were in the delights of the paradise of God: you lost your wisdom on account of your beauty."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of God arises in us from the consideration of divine power. Whence in Jeremiah: "There is none like unto thee, O Lord; thou art great, and thy name is great in might: who would not fear thee, O king of nations?" He sets forth first the magnitude of divine power, when he says: "There is none like unto thee, O Lord"; whence in the book of Wisdom: "As a drop of morning dew, so is the whole world before thee." Therefore who would not fear thee, unless he be impious and foolish?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of God arises in us from the consideration of divine power. "Who would not fear thee, O king of nations? For thine is the glory: among all the wise men of the nations and in all their kingdoms, who is like unto thee?" Therefore who would not fear thee, unless he be impious and foolish? If a man is impious, he is in need of punishment; if he is foolish, he is in need of understanding.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the second word: You shall not make a graven image, all false and superstitious inventions of errors are prohibited. Every error is nothing other than a fiction of the mind. For imagination produces error by clouding reason and making what is not appear to be. All false and superstitious inventions of errors arise either from the wicked audacity of philosophical investigation, or from a perverse understanding of Sacred Scripture, or from a disordered affection of human carnality. Concerning such men, however, who devise, or defend, or imitate these or similar errors, Jeremiah says: Every man has become foolish by his own knowledge, that is, by his own investigation and excessive philosophy; every craftsman has been confounded by his graven image: their works are vain and worthy of ridicule, and in the time of their visitation they shall perish. We must therefore stand upon what the lights of faith dictate, and whatever is opposed to this, we ought to abominate entirely as a graven image.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first brightness, namely that of philosophical knowledge, is great according to the opinion of worldly men: but it is easily eclipsed, unless a man guards himself from the head and tail of the dragon. If anything is interposed between him and the sun of justice, he suffers an eclipse of foolishness. "Every man is made foolish by his knowledge," namely occasioned by it, not caused by it. He who trusts in philosophical knowledge and esteems himself on account of this and believes himself to be better, has been made foolish—namely, when through this knowledge without any further light he believes himself to apprehend the Creator: just as if a man should wish to see the heavens or the body of the sun by candlelight.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"They shall be greatly confounded, because they have not understood everlasting reproach." The second error concerns fatal necessity, as regarding the constellations: if a man is born under such a constellation, he will necessarily be a thief, or evil, or good. This empties free will and merit and reward of meaning: for if a man does of necessity what he does, what is the value of freedom of will? What will he merit? It also follows that God would be the origin of all evils. It is true that some disposition is left by the stars; but nevertheless God alone rules over the rational soul. Those who err thus shall have everlasting reproach.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A figure preceded in the woman and the man, because Jeremiah says: "A woman shall encompass a man." All of this was fulfilled in the glorious Virgin. Whence Bernard says: "What was shown to Moses in the bush and fire, to Aaron in the rod and flower, to Gideon in the fleece and dew: this Solomon clearly foresaw in the strong woman and her price; more clearly Jeremiah foretold concerning the woman and the man; most clearly Isaiah declared concerning the Virgin and her son; and at last Gabriel made it manifest by greeting the Virgin."
The word of Jeremiah concerns the woman and the man: "A new thing," he says, "the Lord will make upon the earth; a woman shall encompass a man." Who brought it about that the Virgin conceived? Certainly the Holy Spirit, who is a love fervent, fruitful, undefiled, virile, incorrupt, and deifying. That he is a virile love is signified to us in the woman and the man, because the "woman encompassed the man," that is, enclosed him on every side.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“God proposes the most direct norms. Hence, the Apostle and Jeremiah say: "I will put my laws into their mind, and upon their hearts I will write them." For He inscribed them first in human nature, then in industry or progress, third in grace, and fourth in glory. In every state, He puts forth His rules: wherefore by necessity He must possess them within Himself.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, there is the production of prophets similar to the multiplication of flowers. The song of the dove was heard when it was said: "How lonely she is now, the once crowded city! Widowed is she who was mistress over nations." For the turtle moans instead of singing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Josiah also represents Christ: he is the king whose death inspired the "Lamentations": "How lonely she is now, the once crowded city! Widowed is she who was mistress over nations; the princess among the provinces has been made a toiling slave."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Everyone who receives the care of souls becomes a prince of the army; and when the prince is not good, then the army is in great danger. Whence Jeremiah laments: "All beauty," he says, "has departed from the daughter of Zion; her princes have become like rams not finding pasture, and they went away without strength before the face of the pursuer."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As the body loses its strength, beauty and health in the absence of food, so the soul without the understanding of truth becomes dark and weak, distorted and unstable in all things; and so it needs to be fed. Hence, the unsettled mind, lacking food, wanders about and is unstable. And so, Jerusalem hath grievously sinned, therefore is she become unstable, and for that reason, having been expelled from paradise, she wanders about, and her people have given all their precious things for food to relieve the soul. And deep suffering follows upon this. Hence there is nothing healthier than that thoughts be stabilized, lest they wander into evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As the body loses its strength, beauty and health in the absence of food, so the soul without the understanding of truth becomes dark and weak, distorted and unstable in all things; and so it needs to be fed. Hence, the unsettled mind, lacking food, wanders about and is unstable. And so, Jerusalem hath grievously sinned, therefore is she become unstable, and for that reason, having been expelled from paradise, she wanders about, and her people have given all their precious things for food to relieve the soul. And deep suffering follows upon this. Hence there is nothing healthier than that thoughts be stabilized, lest they wander into evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In other women there is pain of the body, in her there is pain of the heart; in others there is pain of corruption, in her there is pain of compassion and charity. Whence she invites us to consider her sorrow, in Jeremiah: "All you," she says, "who pass by the way, attend and see if there is any sorrow like my sorrow."
This sorrow ought to pierce through the minds of all. Christ died for you; ought you not to suffer with him? The blessed Virgin suffered with him to the utmost; but on the other hand, it pleased her that he was handed over for us. No one knows how much compassion for Christ avails. There is nothing that so extinguishes temptations and pride as that the mind be kept in compassion for the suffering of Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When the soul does what it can, grace lifts it up easily and God works in it, so that there be a worthy admission, a worthy inspection, and a worthy induction. A worthy admission of divine matters corresponds to the Thrones. And it is in this sense that the passage from Lamentations is understood: "Rise up at the beginning of every watch; pour out your heart like water in the presence of the Lord," that is, pray in the presence of the Lord.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“See to it that each one of you has that ointment, so that he may be devoutly disposed toward God and may repent and guard himself from sin. Some have compassion on their flesh, not on their soul. Whence in Lamentations: "The hands of compassionate women have boiled their own children." Such a one is not like the Virgin nor like Christ. "He boils his children" who has no compassion on his own soul, but exposes it to the fire of concupiscence and of infernal torments.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This refers much more directly to the time of the New Testament, when Scripture was made evident, and mostly toward the end, when those Scriptures were understood which had not been understood before. For then there shall be a "mountain," that is, the contemplative Church; then, "there shall be no harm" when the monsters of heresy shall flee on account of the proper use of wisdom. But today Mount Sion is desolate because of jackals, that is, because of cunning and fetid interpreters.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Ezekiel is describing the judgment: "As I looked, a stormwind came from the North, a huge cloud with flashing fire, enveloped in brightness; from the midst of which, the midst of the fire, something gleamed like electrum." First, as to the disturbance of natural powers shown by the stormwind; second, as to the conflagration of fires shown by the flashing fire; third, as to the examination of consciences or merits shown by the word brightness, for then the consciences will be clear; fourth, as to the assistants to the judges shown by the word enveloped. Christ in His twofold nature is referred to by the word electrum.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Within it were figures resembling four living creatures." The four orders are designated by the four living creatures: the order of pontiffs by the lion, that of martyrs by the ox, that of confessors by the man, that of virgins by the eagle, by reason of contemplation. Thus the separation of the pure from the impure, of the sheep from the goats, will be brought about by Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Ezechiel beheld "within figures resembling four living creatures;" and the first had the face of a man, the second that of a lion, the third that of an ox, and the fourth that of an eagle. And each one had four faces. All agree that the "four living creatures" represent the writers of Sacred Scriptures, mostly the Prophets and the Evangelists. Ezechiel intends to describe these meanings in the order of their importance: therefore he begins with the natural face of a man, which signifies the literal interpretation.
Now, the literal meaning resembles a natural face, that of a man, while the others are symbolical. The lion, being magnificent, points to allegory, or what we should believe; the face of an ox, that pulls the plow and furrows the soil for the harvest, points to tropology, or moral obligation; the eagle that flies on high points to anagogy. The first face, the literal, is open; the second is lifted up on high by magnificence; the third, the tropological, is fruitful; the fourth looks upon the sun almost without flinching.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is a wondrous conformity between the Old and New Testaments, not only in the content of their meanings, but also in the fourfold structure of their parts. As a figure and sign of this, Ezekiel saw wheels with four faces and a wheel within a wheel, because the Old is in the New, and conversely: and in the legal and evangelical books there is the face of a lion on account of the excellence of authority; in the historical books there is the face of an ox on account of the examples of virtue; in the sapiential books there is the face of a man on account of sagacious prudence; in the prophetical books there is the face of an eagle on account of keen understanding.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is a wondrous conformity between the Old and New Testaments, not only in the content of their meanings, but also in the fourfold structure of their parts. As a figure and sign of this, Ezekiel saw wheels with four faces and a wheel within a wheel, because the Old is in the New, and conversely: and in the legal and evangelical books there is the face of a lion on account of the excellence of authority; in the historical books there is the face of an ox on account of the examples of virtue; in the sapiential books there is the face of a man on account of sagacious prudence; in the prophetical books there is the face of an eagle on account of keen understanding.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Ezechiel beheld within figures resembling four living creatures, and later there appeared a wheel within another. Then the Prophet says that "the appearance of the wheels and the work of them was like the appearance of the sea," and that it was "as it were a wheel in the midst of a wheel." According to Gregory, the "two wheels" having "four faces" point to Scripture which has the Old and the New Testaments, the "four faces" being the four principal interpretations, the literal, the figurative, the moral and the anagogical. Their "appearance" is like a vision "of the sea" because of the depth of the spiritual mysteries.
These four meanings are like the appearance of the sea because of the primitive origination, the most profound depth, and the abundantly flowing multiformity of the spiritual meanings. And so, as there are three Persons within the single Essence, there are three meanings beneath the single surface of the letter.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Then the Prophet says that he "heard the sound of their wings, like the roaring of mighty waters, like the voice of the Almighty." The "sound of their wings" is "heard" when the minds are prompted; and "the voice of the Almighty" rings out because all things are from God. Hence, in the Apocalypse: "I heard a voice from heaven like a voice of many waters," because of the great number of possible interpretations; a voice of "harpers" because of the accord of these interpretations, for they agree in such a marvelous way that the resulting harmony is wonderful.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This witnessing of the uncreated Word transcends any judgment by a creature. Hence the living creatures lowered their wings when a voice came from above the firmament. How shall we hear the thunder if we hardly see the lightning of this speech?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Both reason and faith lead to the splendors of exemplarity. But beyond, there is a threefold help for rising to the exemplary principles: the sensible creatures, the rational creatures, and the sacramental scriptures; and this help contains a mystery. As regards the first, the whole world is a shadow, a way, and a trace; a book "with writing front and back." Indeed, in every creature there is a refulgence of the divine exemplar, but mixed with darkness: hence it resembles some kind of opacity combined with light. Also, it is a way leading to the exemplar. As you notice that a ray of light coming in through a window is colored according to the shades of the different panes, so the divine ray shines differently in each creature and in the various properties. Again, it is a trace of God's wisdom. Wherefore the creature exists only as a kind of imitation of God's wisdom, as a certain plastic representation of it. And for all these reasons, it is a kind of book "written without."
And so, when the soul sees these things, it seems to it that it should go through them from shadow to light, from the way to the end, from the trace to truth, from the book to veritable knowledge which is in God. To read this book is the privilege of the highest contemplatives, not of natural philosophers; for the former alone know the essence of things, and do not consider them only as traces.
Another help is that provided by the spiritual creature, which resembles light, a mirror, an image, "a scroll written within." Every spiritual substance is light. At the same time, it is a mirror, for it receives and represents all things; and it has the nature of light, so that it may even pass judgment on things. For the whole world is described in the soul. It is also an image. Since it is both light and mirror containing images of things, it is image too. And hence it is "a scroll written within." And for this reason nothing can penetrate the intimate center of the soul, unless it is simple—meaning that nothing can penetrate its powers. For according to Augustine, the most intimate part of the soul is its summit, and the more a power is interior, the higher it is.
But the third help is that of sacramental Scripture. For the whole of Scripture is the heart of God, the mouth of God, the tongue of God, the pen of God, "a scroll written within and without." Wherefore it is a scroll "written without," because it contains beautiful stories and teaches the properties of things, and also "written within," because it contains mysteries and different possible interpretations.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this consideration, moreover, lies the perfection of the mind's illumination, when, as on the sixth day, it sees man made in the image of God. For if an image is an expressive likeness, when our mind contemplates in Christ the Son of God, who is the image of the invisible God by nature, our humanity so wonderfully exalted, so ineffably united, seeing at once in one the first and the last, the highest and the lowest, the circumference and the center, the Alpha and the Omega, the caused and the cause, the Creator and the creature, the book, that is, written within and without: it has now arrived at a certain perfect reality, so that with God it may reach the perfection of its illuminations in the sixth stage, as on the sixth day; nor does anything further remain except the day of rest, in which through the ecstasy of the mind the keenness of the human mind may rest from every work which it had accomplished.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Next, through the addition of one unit, there is a comparison in relation to the number six. In this sense is understood the measure of the one who carried a rod of six cubits and one palm for the measuring of the temple. Seven, for Gregory, is the number of universality, as found in the major and minor worlds, and in God. This present world accessible to the senses consists in four elements that are receptive to celestial influences, and three spheres that provide influence and power. The minor world is made of the four elements, the four humors, the four temperaments, the four qualities, and the three perfecting vital powers, the vegetative, the sensitive, and the rational. Hence those things that exist in the sensible world, come together with a certain purity in the minor world. Wherefore some people say, and not without reason, that the sphere of the stars has a favorable effect on the reception of the vegetative soul, the crystalline, on the reception of the sensitive soul, and the empyrean, on the reception of the rational soul. And according to Hugh of Saint-Victor, the four-fold series corresponds to the body, the three-fold series, to the spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Of Daniel and his companions, who were continent, it is said that "God gave them knowledge and discipline in every book and wisdom." Delight concerning touch assails the gift of understanding most greatly: drunkenness from the anterior part and lust from the posterior part.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third key is the understanding of the Inspired Word by whom all things are revealed; for there is no revelation except through this Inspired Word. Daniel understood the words: understanding is needed in the case of a vision. For unless the word resound in the ear of the heart, the splendor shine in the eye, the vapor and emanation of the Almighty be perceived as smell and His sweetness as taste, and unless eternity fill the soul, man is not fit to understand visions. "God gave to Daniel the understanding of all visions and dreams." By what means? Through the Inspired Word.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"He gives wisdom to the wise and knowledge to those who understand learning." However much a man may have a good natural judgment and along with this frequency of experience, they do not suffice unless there be illumination through divine influence. He touches upon sapiential, sciential, and intellectual certitude. But whence comes this certitude? Certainly from God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"He reveals deep and hidden things and knows what is established in darkness: and the light is with him." He touches upon sapiential certitude when he says: "He reveals deep things." This light is pure and is with him: no one is illumined with certitude except through him. And Augustine in the fourteenth book of On the Trinity asks whence it comes that the impious sometimes judges well; whence he asks: "Where are those laws of justice written, according to which the impious judges well?" And he responds that "they are written in the book of eternal light, and they descend into the soul not by migrating but by impressing themselves, just as the image of a ring, which is impressed upon wax, does not leave the ring."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Now it came to pass, when I, Daniel, saw the vision and sought understanding: behold, there stood before me as it were the appearance of a man; and he cried out and said: Gabriel, make this one understand the vision." This illumination is aided through the Angels. These visions descended from the Father of lights, and the Angel aids the intellect of Daniel, so that he might grasp the light of God and through it understand. It is true that man is instructed ministerially and supportively through an Angel, as was evident in Daniel: but effectively God alone has power over the rational soul itself, because it is immediately formed by God. The Angel illumines in the way that one who opens a window is said to illuminate a house.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Now it came to pass, when I, Daniel, saw the vision and sought understanding: behold, there stood before me as it were the appearance of a man; and he cried out and said: Gabriel, make this one understand the vision." This illumination is aided through the Angels. These visions descended from the Father of lights, and the Angel aids the intellect of Daniel, so that he might grasp the light of God and through it understand. It is true that man is instructed ministerially and supportively through an Angel, as was evident in Daniel: but effectively God alone has power over the rational soul itself, because it is immediately formed by God. The Angel illumines in the way that one who opens a window is said to illuminate a house.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For no one is in any way disposed to divine contemplations, which lead to mental transports, unless with Daniel he be a man of desires. But desires are inflamed in us in a twofold manner, namely through the cry of prayer, which makes one roar from the groaning of the heart, and through the brilliance of speculation, by which the mind turns itself most directly and most intensely toward the rays of light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The full accord of the witnesses is found in the words of Scriptures. Isaiah says: The virgin shall be with child; and Luke: Thou shalt conceive. One says: Christ shall be slain; and the Evangelist: Put Him to death. Whatever, then, had been foretold by the prophets was fulfilled through Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the fourth mystery, that is, the giving of the law, the Antichrist is symbolized by Balaam, who offered the worst advice, was an idolater, and although he said many good things, yet raised pagan altars and consulted auguries. And in this it is shown that he was the worst idolator and worshiper of evil spirits. "Instead, he shall give glory to the god of strongholds."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The solidity of faith is also called heaven, because it makes understanding lofty through investigation, stable when it establishes the truth, and visible when it fills it with a manifold light. Hence in Daniel: "The wise shall shine brightly like the splendor of the firmament." But no one is wise unless he is taught by God, for "No one comes to the Father but through Me," says the Saviour. No one is taught in matters of faith except through God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Sacred Scripture is compared to the water of the sea on account of the manifold variety of its senses. In the sea there are diverse springs: so in sacred Scripture within a single letter there is a manifold meaning. Hence in Daniel: "But you, Daniel, shut up the words and seal the book until the appointed time: many shall pass through, and knowledge shall be manifold."
Some wonder that in the same Scripture we have so many meanings. Anselm says that in the same earth diverse things can be planted: the earth by divine power produces various sproutings; so by the Holy Spirit within the same letter there are various meanings. Nor is it unfitting to use equivocally what is posited as multiply equivocal. In theology both things and words signify. Therefore, when there are many properties of a thing, then through one thing many things are signified. As many as are the properties of the sun, so many, when the sun signifies the just man, are the properties of the just man.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There follows a reference to seeds and fruits. "The earth brought forth vegetation, every kind of seed-bearing plant." As in the gathering of the waters, there was a symbol of the many forms of intelligent beings, and in the germination of the earth, a symbol of the multiplicity of sacramental images, so also in the seeds is shown a kind of infinity in the heavenly theories that are pointed to by these same seeds. For the principal intelligences and figures exist in certain determined numbers, while the theories are almost infinite. For as the reflection of light-rays and images from a mirror comes about in almost infinite ways, so it is from the mirror of Scriptures. Who can know how many are the intermediate angles between the right and the obtuse, between the obtuse and the acute? Hence, as in the seeds there is multiplication to infinity, so also are the theories multiplied. Wherefore in Daniel: "Many shall pass over, and knowledge shall be manifold," for one man and another look differently into the mirror.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Piety is profitable for knowing truths. God gives His gifts upon every creature: but the knowledge of truth He gives only to those who act piously. It is said in Daniel: "Moreover the impious shall act impiously": revelation shall be closed to the impious. If you wish to be true scholars, it is necessary that you have piety.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against conjugal chastity it is objected: every act and movement that alienates from God is foreign to virtue: but the act of conjugal continence is such: therefore it is foreign to virtue. Proof of the middle term: Hosea 1; the Gloss: "Just as wine intoxicates a man and alienates him from the state of his mind, so the law of marriage alienates a man from the things that are of God."
To this it must be said that something is said to alienate from God in two ways: either simply, or with respect to some act or state. In the first way it cannot be without sin: in the second way it can be through the punishment of sin and also through an act of virtue: just as the exercise of action retards and for a time impedes the act of contemplation, just as also sleep impedes the exercise in virtue.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because the ecclesiastical hierarchy is founded upon Scripture, which is compared to the water of the sea, therefore sentence has been passed against those who do not possess this knowledge. In Hosea: "Because you have rejected knowledge, I will reject you, that you shall not minister to me as priest." He who knows nothing of governance is driven from the helm of the ship and from the rule of the city. If the foundations of the Church consist in the knowledge of sacred Scripture, therefore he who does not know sacred Scripture must be driven from ecclesiastical office and dignity. If a blind man wished to lead another, it would be the greatest folly. A helmsman is not to be chosen by lot or by friendship. And it should be known that knowledge is rejected when a man does not take care to learn it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Counsel disposes to mercy: for there is nothing God counsels more in Scripture than to show mercy, which he esteems above all holocausts.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A man sees the slaughter of bodies, he grieves greatly. He therefore who sees the slaughter of souls, how can he restrain himself from tears? This grief is greatly pleasing to God. The Lord says concerning this knowledge: "I desire mercy and not sacrifice, and the knowledge of God more than holocausts." I know the infirmities of others: I ought to suffer with them.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Those who bent their knee to drink are those who inclined themselves totally to philosophy: and the same are inclined to an infinite number of errors, and that is how the leaven of error is warmed. As Osee writes, "the city rested a little from the mingling of the leaven, till the whole was leavened." They warm the eggs of asps, so that what has been warmed breaks out into a serpent.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In Scripture there is first a fixing of the roots of virtue, as in the Patriarchs. But later, in the establishment of commands and sacrifices, there is a production of green foliage. Hence, in Hosea, "Israel is a luxuriant vine." And because foliage is not to last forever, but is to be followed by flowers, there followed prophecy with both fragrance and beauty.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We have been brought to life in Christ through Christ, because Christ triumphed over death: whence death could not swallow him up, but rather the font of life swallowed up death, according to what was said: "I will be your death, O death." In no other way could we be healed and saved.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In relation to Christ's death, it is said: "The sun shall go down at midday." At midday, the sun falls for the Jews. When Christ was at the highest point of His power, that is, after the resurrection and the ascension, the Jews were blinded.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second element is the form of common life, expressed thus: See thou never do to another what thou wouldst hate to have done to thee by another. This is written in the heart by eternal law. From this natural law come other laws and rules as beautiful sprouts. But why do you refuse to be hung, and hang the thief? The answer: better to hang the thief than to damage the community. As for Jonas, he condemned himself to be thrown into the sea.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of prophetical revelation, Christ is symbolized by occurrence, as with Jonah who was "in the belly of the fish three days," as the Lord was in the tomb three days.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On Jonah 3, upon the text: Let men and beasts be covered with sackcloth: the Gloss says: "Behold, the king of Nineveh rises from his throne; he exchanges purple for sackcloth, ointments for mud, clean things for filth." But this is to abase oneself in the highest degree, not only interiorly but also exteriorly, and through this the wrathful God was appeased: therefore self-abasement is a work most acceptable to God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third ground of the influx of fortitude is from God indwelling. Whence in Micah: "I am filled with the fortitude of the Lord, with judgment and power." The human body, when it does not have a spirit, does not have power, even if it were a gigantic body; so if God is not in the soul, then it does not have power.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If however circumvention occurs with a profane agreement, it is called simony, in which he who buys acquires nothing, nor does he who sells possess anything, but they only handle another's property: and this happens when a spiritual thing is sold as though it were a cheap thing. Against whom the Lord says: "Do not make my Father's house a house of trade." But some make it a den of thieves; whence: "Her princes judged for bribes, and her priests taught for hire, and her prophets divined for money."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These are the mysteries of Scripture. Who can conceive the charm of the mysteries of Sacred Scriptures of which it is said: "Every one under his vine and under his fig tree."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A threefold war is threatening us: domestic, civil, and military. The first is with the flesh, which has many troops. This servant-maid is ever-willing to give access, as did Eve. Hence, Against her who lies in your bosom guard the portals of your mouth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It should be noted that the Church was placed in paradise, like the first man, "to till it," in such a way that no one would say "that anything he possessed" was "his own." For it began in a state of great perfection that is observed today in the religious life, for the love of Christ was still recent, and in those days "a large number also of the priests accepted the faith." This Church, meaning the one that began with the Jews, because they were converted at one time by the three thousand, and at another, by the five thousand, possessed the "tree of life," that is, faith, because "My just one lives by faith." It also had the "tree of knowledge," that is, the Law, which remained with them for seeing and reading, and not for eating. Much more: for "the day you eat of it, you must die." And so you may see the tree of knowledge, but not eat of it, or else you would destroy what Christ had done; and death would necessarily come in, for "the letter kills." Hence Paul says: "I, Paul, tell you that if you be circumcised, Christ will be of no advantage to you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third origin of the fear of the Lord is from the consideration of the severity of divine vengeance. Whence in Habakkuk: "Lord, I have heard your report and was afraid." He says: "I have heard your report and was afraid," namely, that report when it shall be said: "Depart, you cursed, into eternal fire." Not only in the day of tribulation or severity of the last judgment, but of any other judgment whatsoever, because the judgments of God are many.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And so Christ is the center of the two animating spirits, as is the heart. Hence Habakkuk: "In the midst of the two animals Thou shalt make it known." And according to a different translation, "in the midst of the years," as is the Sun: for the sum total of time runs on according to the ten steps in the dial of Achaz. According to the Septuagint, Christ was in between the animated beings that preceded Him and those that followed Him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This fortitude is from God redeeming through the incarnation of the divine Word. By what is the soul redeemed? It is said in Habakkuk: "His splendor shall be as the light; horns are in his hands; there his fortitude is hidden." For "the weakness of God is stronger than men." The Son of God was made weak for our sake.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As indeed a cloud rises aloft in order that it may rain down, so does Christ ascend in order that He may grant His gifts. The sun has been lifted up, and the moon remained in its shelter. For at first He had given the Holy Spirit to the world in a secret way, but He did it manifestly after He had ascended on high, for this Holy Spirit was the cleansing, enlightening, and perfecting Hierarch, and the Holy Spirit came down into the heavenly and sub-heavenly hierarchies.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth anagogy is a reference to the Church Triumphant which is also signified by the sun, in a passage from Habacuc: "The sun and the moon stood still in their habitation," that is, when the soul and the body are glorified. "They go about in the brilliance of many arrows," because of the swiftness of what they do by the lightning-fast power of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third origin of the fear of the Lord is from the consideration of the severity of divine vengeance. Whence in Habakkuk: "Lord, I have heard your report and was afraid. I heard, and my belly was troubled; at the voice my lips trembled. Let rottenness enter into my bones and swarm beneath me, that I may rest in the day of tribulation." He says: "Let rottenness enter into my bones, and let it swarm beneath me, that I may rest in the day of tribulation." Not only in the day of tribulation or severity of the last judgment, but of any other judgment whatsoever, because the judgments of God are many.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Upon the heights he will lead me, the conqueror, singing in psalms." Let us beseech our Lord Jesus Christ, that he through his mercy may deign so to lead and govern us in this mortal life, that we may obtain the gifts of the Holy Spirit and arrive at that ineffable joy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These are the "seven eyes" of the Lamb, and the "seven facets" of the stone mentioned by Zachary, and the seven days that followed upon the first light. These Centers are the "seven golden lamp-stands," and Christ "in the midst of the seven lamp-stands," which are the seven illuminations of wisdom, that is, the metaphysical, the natural, the mathematical, the logical, the ethical, the political, and the theological.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But who will deliver us from these plagues? Certainly there is one alone who came to deliver us, namely Christ, who made ten condescensions against the ten plagues. The first was down to our flesh. The second was down to our mortality. The third, to our neediness, for he suffered hunger, thirst, and cold. The fourth was to our poverty, for "he was made destitute," having no place to which he might turn. The fifth, to our temptation, when he permitted himself to be tempted; and in this he bore our weakness. The Apostle: "We do not have a High Priest who cannot sympathize with our weaknesses, but one tempted in all things." The sixth, to the weariness of body and our toil. The seventh, to our anxiety; whence: "Jesus began to be fearful and distressed and said: My soul is sorrowful even unto death." The eighth was to the cross, and this was wondrous. The ninth was to death. The tenth was to the prison of hell.
These are the ten condescensions by which God condescended to man. But why did he descend to the prison of hell? Certainly, so that in the blood of the covenant he might lead the captives out of prison, those sitting in darkness and the shadow of death. Christ, through the blood of the new covenant, freed us and led us from death to life, and from darkness to light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, in Zechariah thirteen it is said: I am a husbandman, for Adam has been my example from my youth; Gloss: "That I may eat my bread in the sweat of my face, while he showed himself born for this, that in the sweat of his face he might eat bread"; but this most befits one who needs bread and can bear labor and sweat; and such is the able-bodied poor person: therefore he is bound to labor bodily.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If a man is impious, he is in need of punishment; if he is foolish, he is in need of understanding. Wherefore it is also said in Malachi: "The son honoreth the father and the servant his master: if then I be a father, where is my honor? And if I be a master, where is my fear?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That the divine being is immutable is shown thus: First, by authority, Malachi 3: I am God and I do not change: the Gloss says: "He says this lest it be thought that there is any mutability in God."
It must be said that without doubt the divine being is altogether immutable: and this indeed must be maintained, although we cannot perfectly understand it; whence all agree in maintaining it. For all who rightly understand, not only the Saints but also the philosophers, maintain that the divine being is immutable, because it is most simple, immense, and eternal. For inasmuch as it is most simple, it is immutable according to form: inasmuch as it is immense, immutable according to position: inasmuch as it is eternal, immutable according to time: but all motion and change, according to Augustine and Hugh, is reduced to one of the aforesaid differences: and therefore the divine being can in no way admit of change or motion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the allegorical sense, the sun signifies Christ. "The sun rises and the sun goes down." It rises in the nativity, it goes down in death; it orbits through noon in the ascension; it is inclined to the north in the judgment. Malachias refers to the first: "But for you who fear My name, there will arise the Sun of Justice with its healing rays."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This is a lesson that ought to be taught in youth and never abandoned. Whence in Ecclesiasticus: "Keep the fear of the Lord and grow old therein." And in Tobias it is said that Tobias begot a son, "whom from his infancy he taught to fear God." This lesson, therefore, is for all.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second element is the form of common life, expressed thus: See thou never do to another what thou wouldst hate to have done to thee by another. This is written in the heart by eternal law. From this natural law come other laws and rules as beautiful sprouts. But why do you refuse to be hung, and hang the thief? The answer: better to hang the thief than to damage the community. As for Jonas, he condemned himself to be thrown into the sea.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Counsel is regulated according to the dictate of divinely inspired reasons. Concerning this it is said in Tobit: 'At all times bless the Lord and ask of him, that he may direct your ways, and that all your counsels may remain in him.' However much knowledge a man may have of the New and Old Testament, it is still necessary that he consult the Lord: I do not say that he should have a special conversation with him, but it is necessary that the Lord bring forth truth for him as light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But what usefulness is there in fearing God? Tobias says: "Do not fear, my son; we lead indeed a poor life, but we shall have many good things if we fear God." The fear of God avails for three things, namely for obtaining the inflowing of divine grace, for introducing the rectitude of divine justice, and for obtaining the illumination of divine wisdom. In these three all good things are comprehended.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Pray for us, for you are a holy woman." The last word was the word of the priests to Judith: and it can be our word to the most glorious Virgin, who is full of holiness and grace, that she may pray for us to obtain grace and wisdom: wisdom for knowing the truth, and grace for doing the truth. These two things we ought to seek from God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The blessed Virgin possesses this price, because she is strong and valiant, nobly triumphing, which is signified in Judith, where it is said: "One Hebrew woman has brought shame upon the house of Nebuchadnezzar." Judith cut off the head of Holofernes, and all his men fled. In the Gospel it is said: "A sword shall pierce your own soul": and Judith slew Holofernes with his own sword. How then does Judith signify the glorious Virgin? Holy Simeon said: "A sword shall pierce your own soul," that is, a living sorrow. Whence? Surely from the passion of Christ. Who inflicted the passion upon Christ? The Jew, the pagan, Pilate. These were the instruments, but who was moving them to this? Surely the devil was forging the sword by which the soul of the Virgin was pierced, and she herself was healed, and the devil was vanquished. The devil wished to have the bait of Christ's flesh; but the Divinity clung to his throat like a hook; she drove a nail into the temple of Sisera. The one who destroyed the army of the Midianites triumphed nobly.
Therefore, following her example, let us not allow ourselves to be conquered.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He says therefore: Love etc. The Gloss: "Not only do." For the work of justice is not meritorious unless it is done out of love of justice. Gregory: "The branch of good work has no greenness unless it remains in the root of charity." Justice, namely uncreated, which is the rectitude of the divine will; and created, which is the rectitude of the human will, according to Anselm. Love, I say, justice, that you may be conformed to God, because "the Lord is just and has loved justice"; likewise, that with spiritual gladness you may be filled, according to that verse of the Psalm: "You have loved justice, etc.; therefore God, your God, has anointed you with the oil of gladness above your companions"; likewise, that you may be made blessed, according to that verse of Matthew five: "Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for justice."
You who judge the earth: specifically indeed you, prelates, who judge the earth by public judgment: the earth, of the subject people. The Gloss: "To whom the power of judging has been given"; subject, I say, by the merit of sin. For Gregory says: "Where we do not transgress, there we are equals." And therefore he rightly says: the earth, that is, those who love earthly things; not the heavenly, because there is no need: "For the spiritual man judges all things," namely in hope, "and is judged by no one," that is, ought not to be judged, First Corinthians two; but the bestial, according to the Gloss on that verse of Genesis one: "Let him rule over the beasts" of the earth, that is, those living bestially.
Likewise, all of you generally, who judge, by private judgment, the earth, of your own body. The Gloss: that is, who "discreetly restrain the body," so that "your service may be rational," Romans twelve.
It should be noted, moreover, that there is found to be a fourfold earth, namely the upper earth, the earth, I say, of the living, of which in the Psalm: "I believe I shall see the good things of the Lord in the land of the living." The lower earth, namely of the dead: Ezekiel thirty-one: "Behold, you have been brought down with the trees of pleasure to the uttermost earth." The outer earth, namely of the dying, namely the present world: Revelation eight: "Woe, woe, woe to those dwelling upon the earth"! that is, in the world. The inner earth, namely of death, that is, the mortal and earthly body: Ecclesiasticus ten: "Why are you proud, O earth and ashes"?
The first earth is not subject to our judgment, because it is not in our power; and therefore it was rightly said to Peter, Matthew sixteen: "Whatever you shall bind upon earth," not upon heaven.
The second has already been judged and cannot repent: John three: "He who does not believe has already been judged."
The third is to be judged by the judgment of justice, according to that verse of the Psalm: "Judge rightly, O sons of men."
The fourth is to be judged by the judgment of discerning discipline, according to that passage of Ecclesiasticus 33: "Fodder and a rod and a burden for the donkey: bread and discipline and work for the servant," that is, for the body, which must be compelled to serve the spirit, by the example of blessed Martin, who "compelled his limbs, though weakening with fever, to serve the spirit"; likewise by the example of Paul, who says: "I chastise my body and bring it into subjection," into which subjection, namely, it was in the state of innocence; I bring it back, through the power and works of penance. To the aforesaid servant is owed the sustenance of bread, lest it fail; the rod of discipline, lest it grow wanton; and the occupation of holy work, lest it grow sluggish.
Think, that is, rightly esteem, of the Lord in goodness, that is, well, not badly, as heretics do. Moreover, he admonishes us to think well both by the exterior sense, by piously reading the divine Scriptures, and by the interior sense, by piously understanding them. Whence the Gloss: "Read and understand Scripture piously," piously, namely, by devoutly approving and carrying out what you understand, and not by criticizing and despising what you do not understand. And in simplicity of heart seek him, namely, by directing the whole intention of the heart toward him. Whence the Gloss: "Submit yourselves to his will"; which hypocrites do not do, and therefore they are inconstant, according to that passage of James 1: "A double-minded man is inconstant in all his ways"; and on account of this it is said to them in Ecclesiasticus 2: "Woe to the double heart"! The heart is double when its parts are drawn principally toward diverse things, which is the occasion of spiritual death, according to that passage of Hosea 10: "Their heart is divided, now they shall perish." But the heart is simple when all its parts are drawn toward the one most simple being, namely toward God, according to that passage of Ecclesiasticus 30: "Gather your heart in holiness." In simplicity of heart, that is, in the simple unity of the heart. This unity is produced by faith in the rational power, according to that passage of Ephesians 4: "One Lord, one faith," etc.; by charity in the concupiscible power: 1 Corinthians 6: "He who cleaves to the Lord is one spirit"; by peace in the irascible power: Ephesians 4: "Be careful to preserve the unity of the spirit in the bond of peace." The first unity prohibits the division of errors in the intellect; the second, of desires in the affections; the third, of schisms in action.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“General Division. Since, as has been said, princes and prelates, and consequently all people, are urged in this book to the study and love of wisdom; but because wisdom cannot be had without the observance of justice: for into a malevolent soul wisdom will not enter, etc., below in chapter one; likewise Ecclesiasticus chapter one: Son, desiring wisdom, keep justice: therefore according to the Gloss, he first exhorts to justice, namely up to the sixth chapter; second, to wisdom, namely from the sixth chapter to the end.
Part I. Exhortation to Justice. In the first part he does three things according to the three parts of general justice. For first he treats of the justice of man with respect to God, in chapter one; second, of justice with respect to neighbor, in chapters two and three; third, of the justice of man with respect to himself, in chapters four and five.
First, on the threefold justice of man with respect to God. In the first, he first stirs to justice of the heart; second, of the mouth: He is benign; third, of work: Do not be zealous.
The justice of the heart is treated in three ways. In the first, he first sets forth an exhortation to the good of justice; second, the advantage of acquiescing: For it is found; third, the detriment of those who despise: For perverse thoughts, etc.
In the first, first as to right affection, saying: Love justice; second, as to right estimation: Think of the Lord; third, as to right intention: And in simplicity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And well did I say: In simplicity, etc. For he is found, through grace in the present life, according to that passage of Song of Songs 3: "I found him whom my soul loves"; by those who do not tempt him, by displaying one thing outwardly while intending another inwardly, as the Scribes and Pharisees tempting Christ; and this he says against hypocrisy and duplicity: Matthew 22: "Why do you tempt me, you hypocrites?"
But He appears, namely in the future through glory: First John 3: "When He shall appear, we shall be like Him"; and Colossians 3: "But when Christ shall appear, your life, then you also shall appear with Him in glory." To those who have faith in Him: he says this against heresy and unbelief. And note that he says: In Him, because it does not suffice to believe Him or to believe that He is, but to believe in Him, which is the act of formed faith, according to Augustine. Or: He is found, on account of the devotion of the affections; He appears, through the contemplation of the intellect: Psalm: "Taste," by affection; "see," by intellect.
It should be noted, however, that according to Gregory, "to tempt is the same as to craftily test": and accordingly it happens that God is tempted in four ways, namely either by unduly wishing to test His power, as those who, tempting Christ, sought a sign from heaven, Matthew 16; or His wisdom, as the Sadducees, proposing to Him a question about the resurrection that was, according to their judgment, insoluble for those who posit the resurrection, Matthew 22; or His justice, as the Pharisees, by asking about the payment of tribute: "We know that You are truthful," etc.; or His mercy, as the Jews, by questioning about the judgment of the woman caught in adultery, John 8. And because every such tempting comes from distrust, and God is in no way to be distrusted, therefore every such tempting is prohibited; whence Deuteronomy 6: "You shall not tempt the Lord your God"; likewise Ecclesiasticus 18: "Do not be like a man who tempts God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For perverse thoughts etc. Here he touches upon the manifold detriment of those who despise the exhortation to the good of justice, of which the first is exclusion from the fellowship of God: For perverse thoughts: the second, exclusion from the fellowship of wisdom: Because into a malevolent soul: the third, exclusion from the fellowship of the Holy Spirit: For the Holy Spirit. The first pertains to the Father, the second to the Son, the third to the Holy Spirit, whose presence is obtained through the love of justice; whence John 14: "If anyone loves Me, etc., and We will come to him and make Our abode with him"; but their absence or deprivation, through hatred of justice.
For perverse thoughts etc. I rightly said that He appears to those who have faith in Him, and not to others; for perverse thoughts, namely by perversity of faith or of morals, separate from God, with respect to the punishment of loss: Second Corinthians 6: "What fellowship has light with darkness?" Proverbs 17: "He who is perverse of heart shall not find good"; likewise Isaiah 59: "Your iniquities have divided," etc.
But proven etc., as if to say: nor does this suffice for punishment; but stands for "however." Proven virtue, that is "true virtue," according to the Gloss, namely divine virtue: corrects, by punishing: Psalm: "O Lord, do not correct me in your anger." The foolish: the Gloss says "that is, all foolishness"; this he says with regard to the punishment of the senses.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first pillar of the house of wisdom is chastity in the flesh. Why is this the first? Because this is where one must begin: for it is written in the book of Wisdom: "Into a malevolent soul wisdom shall not enter, nor shall she dwell in a body subject to sins." An unchaste body is subject to sins; therefore wisdom cannot dwell in it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For into a malevolent soul etc. I rightly said that they separate etc., for into a malevolent soul, with respect to spiritual sins, wisdom will not enter, by infusing itself into it: wisdom, I say, "which is from above, which is first indeed pure" etc.; although that wisdom may enter which is from below, "namely earthly, animal, diabolical," James 3. Nor will it dwell, by remaining, in a body subject to sins: this he says with regard to carnal sins, which, although they are of lesser guilt, are nevertheless of greater infamy, as Gregory says.
It is objected that all things desire the good: therefore no soul is malevolent, that is, willing evil.
It must be said that no one wills evil per se, but per accidens, because namely he wills that which is evil, namely an evil action, not insofar as it is evil, but insofar as it is delightful and an apparent good.
Again it is doubted: the body cannot be a dwelling place of wisdom nor the subject of sin or foolishness or grace: therefore it supposes something false when it says: Nor will it dwell etc.
To this it must be said that body there does not refer to the bodily part of man only, but by synecdoche, according to which a part is customarily put for the whole, body is taken here for the whole man, insofar as he follows the passions of the body. Hence the Gloss: "He who is subject to sins is body, not spirit." In such a one wisdom does not dwell: hence the Gloss: "In vain do heretics, Pharisees, and false Christians flatter themselves; for only those pure in heart can receive the wisdom of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The holy spirit of discipline will flee from the deceitful and will withdraw from thoughts that are without understanding." God wills that we do all things reasonably. Prudential understanding teaches what is to be carried out, namely every good, according to the way of interior thought and exterior action.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is necessary to ordain our thoughts so that the Holy Spirit be able to enter in the form of wisdom, "for the holy spirit of discipline flees deceit and withdraws from senseless counsel." Hence, there is need for us to use clearly defined materials with which we can be properly concerned.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And I rightly said that he will not dwell etc. For the Holy Spirit of discipline: Gloss: "Who teaches all discipline," according to that passage of John 16: "He will teach you all truth," namely rational, natural, and moral: Psalm: "Teach me goodness and discipline and knowledge." He is called Spirit, insofar as he breathes life: John 6: "It is the Spirit who gives life"; holy, insofar as he purges and renews, according to that passage of the Psalm: "You will send forth your spirit, and they shall be created: and you will renew the face of the earth"; of discipline, insofar as he removes ignorance and bestows wisdom, according to that passage of Isaiah 11: "The spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him, the spirit of wisdom" etc. He will flee, that is, in the present he will flee far from, the deceitful, that is, the sinner, according to that passage of the Psalm: "Salvation is far from sinners," and especially the hypocrite, who is properly called deceitful: Job 13: "No hypocrite shall come into his sight." And he will withdraw himself from thoughts that are without understanding, that is, from false and erroneous thoughts: for understanding pertains only to true things. He will withdraw himself etc.; behold, the punishment of loss: and he will be reproved etc.: behold, the punishment of sense.
Likewise, it should be noted that he is said to withdraw himself because naturally the commission of fault precedes the withdrawal of grace: for God is first in approaching and last in departing. And although he withdraws himself from them, they will not nevertheless remain unpunished: whence he adds: And he will be reproved etc.: correction is done with words, reproof is done with scourges. He will be reproved, I say, namely the deceitful one in the future, that is, he will be punished, by the supervening iniquity, that is, on account of the supervening iniquity: whence the Gloss: "The deceitful one, when the day of retribution comes, will be punished for his iniquity." Supervening, that is, "oppressing," on account of which it is called supervening, just as one who oppresses comes upon another. — Or: He will be reproved, that is, he will be seized together in soul and body unto punishment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The spirit of wisdom is benign, and will not free the evil-speaker from his lips." Good persuadability causes one to esteem and love good things and to consent to them: and the wiser a person is, the more persuadable he is to good things. The malicious person is persuadable to evil, but there is no one who is persuadable to good unless he is benign: and this also accords with wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the justice of speech, the matter is treated in three ways.
For he is kind etc. Here he admonishes toward justice of speech, by drawing back from evil words. And first he removes from evil speech itself the confidence of impunity: second, he foretells their punishment: Therefore he who speaks etc.; third, he admonishes to caution against depraved speech: Guard etc.
In the first part, he first removes the confidence of impunity which might arise from the mercy of the judge: Kind: second, from his ignorance: For of the reins etc.; third, from his powerlessness: For the spirit of the Lord.
He says therefore: For the spirit of wisdom is benign etc. I have rightly said that the dissembler will be reproved etc.: for the spirit of wisdom is benign, namely of uncreated wisdom, namely of the Son, from whom the Holy Spirit is given: or of created wisdom, which he himself gives; below in chapter twelve: "O how good and how sweet is your spirit, O Lord, in all things"! Psalm: "Your good spirit" etc. And yet he will not free the accursed etc., although he is benign: because, as Gregory says, "discipline and mercy are greatly undermined if one is held without the other." Or thus: and because he is benign, he will not free the accursed etc., because benignity is contrary to malice: as the Gloss says: "He will not free, I say, the accursed, that is, the one who curses," who is accursed because he acts against God's commandment, which forbids cursing; Psalm: "Cursed are those who turn aside from your commandments"; behold, a curse in the present. Likewise, Matthew twenty-five: "Depart from me, you cursed, into everlasting fire" etc.: behold, a curse in the future. From his lips, that is, from the sin of his lips, or from the punishment which he merited by the sin of his lips: Matthew twelve: "By your words you shall be condemned"; likewise in the Psalm: "The labor of their lips shall cover them." And it should be noted that the consequent is placed for the antecedent, when he says the accursed for the one who curses.
For of the reins etc., as if to say: he will truly be punished for his sins, even hidden ones: for of his reins, that is, of the affections or "carnal pleasures, whose seat is in the reins," God is a witness, that is, a certain knower, as a witness concerning the matter about which he bears testimony; Jeremiah twenty-nine: "I am the witness and the judge, says the Lord." And of his heart, that is, of the thoughts proceeding from the heart, Matthew fifteen: he is a true searcher, that is, an infallible examiner: whence First Corinthians two: "The Spirit searches all things, even the deep things of God"; likewise Jeremiah seventeen: "I the Lord search the hearts and try the reins"; Psalm: "God, who searches hearts and reins." And of his tongue, that is, of the utterances which are formed by the tongue, a hearer, that is, an immediate knower without the report of another: Psalm: "He who planted the ear, shall he not hear"? as if to say: yes. And it should be noted that he places the instruments for the operations proceeding from them, because, just as the instruments relate more immediately to the soul than their operations do, so God more immediately than anyone else knows all the acts of a person, both interior and exterior.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the Spirit of the Lord etc., as if he were inferring: rightly have I said that the Spirit can do this: for the Spirit of the Lord, intransitively, that is, who is the Lord, according to that saying of Athanasius: "The Father is Lord, the Son is Lord, the Holy Spirit is Lord"; or transitively, that is, the Spirit who is from the Lord, according to that saying of Isaiah sixty-one: "The Spirit of the Lord is upon me" etc.; likewise, John: "The Spirit of truth, who proceeds from the Father." Has filled the whole world, by assisting all things with his presence and containing them: Jeremiah twenty-three: "Do I not fill heaven and earth?" because, according to Gregory, "God is everywhere, within all things yet not enclosed, outside all things yet not excluded, above all things yet not elevated, below all things yet not cast down." And that which contains all things, namely the Holy Spirit containing all things by preserving them through his power. For as Boethius proves in the book On the Consolation, "the world from such diverse and contrary parts would not have come together into one form, and the joined discordant diversity would have torn apart, unless there were one who joined them together and held together what he had woven." Has knowledge of the voice, that is, of all utterances and languages, by knowing all things.
From this it is clear that he can know and punish all things, both deeds on account of his universal presence and words on account of his universal knowledge.
Another exposition, or according to the Gloss: That which contains all things, that is, the Holy Spirit, who contains all things, that is, the Church, outside of which whatever exists is nothing, just as outside the ark of Noah. Has knowledge of the voice, causally speaking, "that is, he grants understanding of Scripture to men"; or formally: Has knowledge of the voice, that is, he has the same knowledge as the voice, that is, as the Word, that is, the Son, of whom John one says: "In the beginning was the Word" etc.
Allegorically, according to the Gloss, it can be expounded concerning the temporal coming of the Holy Spirit. And first is touched upon the person sent, when it says: Spirit; second, his eternal origin: of the Lord; third, the temporal mission: Has filled; fourth, the manifestation of the mission: And that which contains all things.
He says therefore: The Spirit of the Lord has filled: the Gloss says: "with gifts"; the whole world, "that is, the Church spread throughout all lands," as the Gloss says. And that which contains all things: "that is, man, who has a correspondence with every creature," on account of which in Mark at the end he is called every creature, according to Gregory. Has knowledge of the voice: the Gloss says: "Of diverse languages from the Holy Spirit," as is clear from Acts two.
To the orb indeed of the earth the primitive Church is compared, first on account of its expansion, according to that word of the Psalm: "Their sound has gone forth into all the earth." Second, on account of its perfection, which is understood through the roundness of the orb: Song of Songs 6: "One is my dove, my perfect one." Third, on account of its stability: Ecclesiastes 1: "For the earth stands forever."
Fourth, on account of its compression and wearing down: 1 Corinthians 4: "I think that God has set forth us the Apostles last, as men destined to death," etc.; just as the earth is the lowest of bodies, whence it is worn down and trampled upon by all.
Fifth, on account of the sustaining and vivifying of the human race, because it lives from the earth and is sustained by the earth, just as by the primitive Church: Job 9: "Under whom they stoop who bear up the world," namely the Apostles and their followers; nor yet are they broken, because in the Psalm: "I have established its pillars." Sixth, on account of the adornment and production of all virtues, according to that word of Genesis 1: "Let the earth bring forth green herb," etc.
Seventh, on account of the origin of waters, that is, of the wisdom of saving doctrine, according to that word of Genesis 2: "A spring rose up from the earth, watering the whole surface of the earth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On this account, he who speaks, etc. The foolish confidence of impunity having been removed, here he foretells the punishment of evil speech: and first, because it will be brought into judgment; second, because it will be examined by the Judge: "In the thoughts of the ungodly"; third, because it will be made known to all: "For the ear of jealousy."
He says therefore: On this account, because namely the Holy Spirit has knowledge of the voice, that is, of every utterance: he who speaks iniquitous things, like those of whom it is said in the Psalm: "The mouth of those who speak iniquitous things has been stopped"; cannot be hidden, namely from the Holy Spirit in the present; whence Hebrews 4: "All things are naked and open to his eyes"; likewise Proverbs 16: "All the ways of men lie open to his eyes." Nor shall it pass by, namely by dissembling, him, namely the one speaking iniquitous things, correcting, that is, punishing; or correcting, that is, seizing together his body and soul, or all his evil works and words and thoughts; judgment, namely the future judgment: "for all things that are done, God will bring into judgment," as is found in the last chapter of Ecclesiastes.
For in the thoughts of the wicked, that is, concerning the thoughts of the wicked, in which there is less sin than in wicked words, there will be an interrogation, that is, a searching inquiry by the judge and an examination, according to that passage of the Psalm: "The Lord interrogates the just and the wicked"; Job, last chapter: "I know that no thought is hidden from you." And if there will be a searching inquiry concerning thoughts, how much more so concerning words; on account of this he adds: But of his words, etc.; as if to say: not only concerning thoughts. But, used for "however": the hearing of his words, that is, the examination, to God, as to the examiner and judge, will come, and for correction, that is, punishment; of his iniquities, which he committed by speaking wickedly: Genesis eighteen: "The cry of Sodom and Gomorrah is multiplied," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And rightly did I say that it will come, etc.; for the ear of jealousy, of jealousy, I say, of God who is jealous for souls as for brides, hears all things, that is, knows all things, as one who hears all things, namely words both evil and good and indifferent, just as a jealous man carefully hears and notes the words of his spouse and of those speaking with her: Exodus twenty: "I am a mighty God, jealous," etc. And the tumult of murmurings, by which men murmur against God: Ecclesiasticus thirty-three: "The heart of a fool is like a cart wheel." And it is called a tumult, because a man who murmurs makes a tumult, as it were, within his teeth, and does not speak clearly. Shall not be hidden, but shall be made manifest to the whole world; Luke twelve: "Nothing is covered that shall not be revealed, nor hidden that shall not be known"; Exodus sixteen: "I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Guard etc. Here he admonishes to caution against wicked speech, and first he sets forth his exhortation; second, the necessity of the exhortation: For a word, etc.
Now the construction or continuation is as follows: since the tumult shall not be hidden, etc., guard yourselves therefore from murmuring, namely against God, which profits nothing, indeed it greatly harms; whence First Corinthians ten: "Some of them murmured and perished by the destroyer." And from detraction, namely against one's neighbor: Job six: "Why have you detracted from the words of truth?" Spare the tongue; he does not say: spare your neighbor, but the tongue, namely your own, because one who detracts from another first injures himself. Whence detraction is worse than the venom of a serpent: Seneca: "That venom which serpents produce for the destruction of others, they contain without harm to themselves; but detraction itself drinks a portion of its own poison." The Gloss: "Pernicious are murmurings and detractions"; Romans one: "Detractors hateful to God." Detractors, he says in the plural, because detraction occurs in many ways, namely either when a hidden good is denied, or when a manifest good is diminished, or when a hidden evil is made public, or when a manifest evil is further spread abroad.
And I rightly said: Spare your tongue, for obscure speech: The Gloss: "Hidden," as is the word of murmuring: shall not go into the void, that is, it shall not remain without punishment, because not even an idle word: Matthew twelve: "Of every idle word" etc.; therefore much more so of a malicious word. "An idle word, as the Gloss says there, is one that is spoken without benefit to the speaker or the hearer"; Jerome: "Everything that does not edify the hearers turns to the peril of the speakers." But the mouth that lies, namely by slandering, slays the soul: The Gloss: "By the sword of sin, the soul of the liar"; the Psalm: "You will destroy all who speak falsehood." And it should be noted that he speaks here of pernicious lying, which is mortal, not of jocose or officious lying: whence the Gloss: "There is a lie of lighter fault, when someone lies in bestowing a benefit."
But it seems that some lie is good and meritorious, because the midwives who lied merited a reward from the just judge, namely God, who cannot be deceived, as is clear from Exodus one.
But it must be said according to the Gloss that "not the lie was rewarded, but the benevolence of their piety."
But was one and the same deed a sin, and yet possessed the merit of benevolence? And it seems so, for the Gloss says: "God pardons the evil of one and the same deed on account of the good, and rewards the good itself."
It must be said that it was one by connection, not by indivisibility: because the intention to deliver was one thing, and the will to lie was another, although they were conjoined.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the justice of works, the treatment is twofold.
Do not be zealous for etc. Here he exhorts to the justice of works, and first by reasons taken from the side of creation; second, from the side of retribution, at: For justice etc.
From the side of creation, first by a reason taken from the goodness of the Creator: For God; second by a reason taken from the side of the end of creation: He created; third by a reason taken from the side of the condition of the creature: There is not in them.
Do not be zealous for etc., as if to say: because lying kills, do not be zealous for, that is, do not love or desire with affection, death, namely of the soul, which one incurs through fault, according to that saying of Augustine: "True death is that which men do not fear: namely the separation of the soul from God, who is the blessed life of souls, just as bodily death is the separation of the body from the soul." Death, I say, causally established in the error of your lives, according to that passage of Proverbs fourteen: "They err who work evil"; for every wicked person is in error, according to the Philosopher. Nor acquire, in effect, perdition, of eternal punishment, which is in our power, according to that passage of Hosea thirteen: "Your destruction, O Israel; only your help is from me." By the works of your hands, causally, that is, by the merit of your works.
But it is objected that, according to Augustine, all desire life and beatitude: therefore no one desires death or perdition.
It must be said that this is true per se: but per accidens and consequently those are said to desire it who desire the act that is the cause of death and perdition. Whence he posits the consequent for the antecedent, adding: I rightly said that error is the cause of death, and evil works the cause of perdition.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For God, who is the author of all things, according to that saying in John 1: "All things were made through him"; did not make death, namely present death.
But against this: Ecclesiasticus 11: "Life and death, poverty and honor are from God."
It must be said that here he speaks of the death of fault: or if of the death of nature, he speaks with respect to privation, not with respect to the sense of pain. Concerning the death of hell also, with respect to the punishment of loss, what is said here is true: God did not make death.
But against this: Every punishment is just, and everything just is good, and everything good is from God.
It must be said that when it is said: every punishment is just, this is understood per se, namely insofar as it is punishment, not according to what it is: whence it cannot be concluded that it is simply from God, but insofar as it is punishment.
Nor does he rejoice in the perdition of the living, namely their future perdition.
Against this: Proverbs 1: "I also will laugh at your destruction," etc.
It must be said that he does not delight in punishment insofar as it is the perdition of nature, but insofar as it is the effect of justice: whence Isaiah 1: "Ah! I will be consoled over my enemies, and I will be avenged upon my foes." And I rightly said that he does not delight or rejoice in perdition, which is the way to non-being.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For he created, Genesis 1, all things that they might exist: The Gloss: "Not that they might perish": whence he also implanted in all things a natural appetite for existing, that is, gave it inwardly. And because "it is a common conception of the mind, according to Boethius, that everything which exists tends toward the good," and all things tend toward being: he proves that the being of all things is good. And healable, that is, created in spiritual health through innocence and reducible to health through penance, lest they perish: for he does not "will the death of the sinner," etc. Healable, I say, he made the nations of the world, that is, all who are born in the world. Their incurability therefore is from themselves, not from God: Jeremiah 30: "Your fracture is incurable, your wound is grievous."
For there is not in them: The Gloss: "In the nature of those," namely of the nations, a medicine of destruction, "that is, the cup of sin," according to the Gloss, which is the cause of destruction in present death: Baruch 3: "They were destroyed and descended to the underworld." Destruction is called sin, because it places one outside the boundaries of grace: likewise, temporal death, because it places one outside the boundary of natural life: likewise, the death of hell, because it places one outside the boundaries of glory: and he speaks by antiphrasis, as if poison were called a medicine, and as a fishpond is the name for water lacking fish.
But an objection is raised against what he says: There is not in them etc., because Ephesians 2: "We were by nature children of wrath."
But it must be said that here he speaks of actual sin, or of nature as established, that is, before the fall, not deprived through sin, of which the Apostle speaks.
Nor the kingdom of the underworld, that is, eternal perdition, on earth, that is, in man made from the earth: Genesis 2: "God formed man from the slime of the earth." He intends therefore to show that the death of sin and the perdition of eternal punishment are not from nature, but from a perverse will. Concerning the death of sin, this is clear from the Gloss, which says: "We do not sin by necessity, but by a perverse will"; concerning the perdition of punishment, this is clear from another Gloss, which says: "The devil would have harmed man in nothing, had man not consented."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For justice is perpetual etc. Here he admonishes toward justice of work from the consideration of retribution: and first he touches upon the reward of justice: second, the punishment of injustice: But injustice etc.; third, the equity of the punishment or penalty inflicted: But the ungodly etc.
For justice is perpetual etc.; as if to say: I rightly said that death is not from God nor from nature, but from the injustice of a perverse will. For justice is perpetual, by bestowing eternal life, according to that passage in Proverbs 12: "In the paths of justice is life." And immortal, by liberating from perpetual death; whence below in chapter 3: "The souls of the just are in the hand of God, and the torment of death shall not touch them."
But injustice is the acquisition of death, namely both of temporal and eternal death: whence Romans 6: "The wages of sin is death"; likewise Proverbs 12: "The wayward path leads to death."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the ungodly etc. Here he shows the equity of retribution, because namely the ungodly merited this, first, by doing injustice, on account of which he says: But the ungodly with hands etc.: second, by loving it familiarly, there: And esteeming etc.: third, by inseparably adhering to it: And covenants etc.: fourth, by strongly defending it: Because they are worthy of death etc.
But the ungodly etc. I have rightly said that death is not from God, nor from nature: but, for however: the ungodly, against God and neighbor: with hands and words, Gloss: "By deeds and sayings"; they summoned it, as if to say: it did not impose itself, but they themselves called it forth, namely ungodliness and death, as is evident in the first parents, Genesis 3.
And esteeming it a friend, that is, useful and not harmful: Gloss: "Because they think they sin with impunity"; they melted away, that is, they flowed downward, Gloss: "into eternal death"; but first, into the death of guilt, second, into the death of temporal punishment, third, into the death of eternal punishment; Hebrews 2: "We ought to give the more earnest heed to the things which we have heard, lest perhaps we drift away." And they made a covenant with it, that is, an inseparable pact as of betrothal through the impenitence of obstinacy; Gloss: "Lest they be separated"; Isaiah 28: "We have struck a covenant with death, and with hell we have made a pact."
And rightly they melted away into death, for they are worthy of death who are of its party, namely of injustice, by holding and defending it, just as a man defends the party to which he belongs: Romans 1: "Those who do such things are worthy of death."
Moreover, here can be noted the progression in sins, concerning which Ecclesiasticus 20: "There is a progression in evil for the undisciplined man"; for first there is ungodliness in the heart through consent to iniquity; then in the hand through the consummation of the deed; then the word of defense or boasting; then friendship and hope of impunity; afterward the melting away through the repetition of depraved habit; next the covenant through the hardening of the mind; lastly the death of final impenitence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, concerning the justice of man toward his neighbor, the treatment is twofold. For they said etc. Above he treated of the justice of man toward God: here principally of the justice of man toward his neighbor: and first, by drawing back from the likeness of the unjust, namely in this chapter: second, by urging toward the likeness of the just, namely in the third chapter.
First he draws back from the likeness of the unjust by noting three things. In the first part, first on the side of the unjust he sets forth the motivating cause of living unjustly: second he describes the unjust life, at: Come therefore etc.; third he shows that it is not to be imitated, at: These things they thought etc.
In the first part a threefold motivating cause is touched upon: the first on the part of condition; the second on the part of nature: Because we are born of nothing: the third on the part of name or reputation: And our name shall receive oblivion etc.
On the part of condition it is threefold: first, as regards the condition of the world, at: It is short and tedious etc.; second, as regards the condition of paradise: There is no refreshment etc.: third, as regards the condition of hell: And no one is known to have returned from the netherworld.
(Verse 1). For the ungodly said, thinking within themselves not rightly, etc. I have rightly said that "the ungodly by hands and words summoned" injustice and death. For the ungodly said, that is, those lacking piety toward God and neighbor: the Gloss: "It is the voice of the lost, who like brute animals love the things that are present and despise future things, nor do they hope for eternal rest after this life." Within themselves, because "they do not dare openly," according to that passage of the Psalm: "The fool has said in his heart: There is no God"; for if they were to speak openly, they would fear incurring punishment. Thinking not rightly, indeed wickedly. It is short, etc., on account of its brevity, according to that passage of Job chapter fourteen: "The days of man are short." And with weariness, on account of its painfulness: Job chapter fourteen: "Man born of woman, living for a short time, is filled with many miseries." The time of our life: the Gloss: "Of the present," by which, namely, they live for themselves, not for God; therefore he adds: our, against which Second Corinthians chapter five says: "That they who live may no longer live for themselves, but for him who died for them and rose again." And there is no refreshment at the end of man; the Gloss: "That is, rest after death." This, however, is false, because it is said in the Psalm in the person of the Saints: "We have passed through fire and water, and you have brought us out into refreshment"; likewise Jeremiah chapter six: "Ask about the ancient paths, which is the good way, and walk in it; and you shall find refreshment for your souls"; likewise Apocalypse chapter fourteen: "Blessed are the dead who die in the Lord, etc., that they may rest from their labors." And there is no one who is known to have returned from the netherworld. By this they intend to exclude the existence of the netherworld; but by the same reasoning they could say that death does not exist, because no dead person returns to life. Hence their reasoning does not hold, because from privation to possession there is no return according to nature; and therefore from the lower netherworld no one returns according to the common law; hence Job chapter seven: "He who descends to the netherworld shall not ascend." Some, however, are recorded to have returned by a privilege of grace, such as the youth whom John the Evangelist raised, and Trajan, whom Gregory raised. From the upper netherworld, however, Christ returned, and many others raised through him or through his disciples.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because we are born from nothing, etc. Here is set forth the motivating cause on the part of nature: and first, from the consideration of human origin; second, from the consideration of composition, at: Because smoke: third, from the consideration of dissolution: Which being extinguished.
(Verse 2). I have rightly said that there will be neither refreshment nor punishment, because there is no subject capable of receiving such things; because we are born from nothing, by immediate origin as regards the soul and by mediate origin as regards the body; hence Second Maccabees chapter seven: "Understand that God made these things from nothing, and the race of men."
And after this, that is, after this life, we shall be as though we had never been, as if to say: we shall return to nothing, according to that saying of Damascene: "Everything that began from change is subject to change"; likewise Augustine: "It is natural that what is from nothing can be dissolved into nothing"; which is to be understood of the possibility of primary aptitude, not of necessity: because they are held by the hand of the Creator, lest they fall into nothing, as Gregory says.
For smoke, namely with respect to the intrinsic corporeal vital spirit: smoke indeed is a fiery vapor, and the vital spirit is a subtle fiery body; and breath, that is, wind, with respect to the exterior corporeal spirit, which is breathed: James 4: "What is your life? It is a vapor appearing for a little while"; Job 7: "My life is a wind"; Psalm: "My days have vanished like smoke".
In our nostrils, he says this specifically, giving the whole body to be understood from a part, on account of the easy departure, as if it were in the nostrils: likewise, on account of manifestation, because there, by breathing in and breathing out, it is more manifested. And the speech of a spark for moving our heart, "that is, the soul comparable to a spark," as the Gloss says; whence 2 Kings 14: "They seek to extinguish my spark." But the soul is called a word according to the reckoning of the unbelievers, because according to them it is nothing in reality, but only according to name or word: but it is compared to a spark, because according to some philosophers the soul was said to be of a fiery nature. Or better: the soul can be called a word from its effect, because namely it has the power of speaking: but it is compared to a spark on account of the subtlety of its nature and on account of the agility of its motion: whence below in chapter three: "And they shall run about like sparks among the reeds"; likewise, on account of the brevity of its duration, according to the unbelievers: whence the Gloss: "Comparable to a spark, which immediately becomes nothing." For moving our heart, "that is, for enlivening or animating," according to the Gloss: breathing is in our nostrils, that is, in our bodies, so ready to depart from the body, as breath from the nostril.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There follows: Because extinguished etc. I rightly said that the soul is compared to a spark, because it is quickly extinguished, because our body will be extinguished ash, namely after the extinguishing of the soul, which according to the unbelievers is extinguished in death. But the truer reading is: Which having been extinguished etc. Here he touches upon the motivating cause from the consideration of dissolution, and first, from the consideration of dissolution with respect to the body: second, with respect to the spirit, there: And the spirit shall be dispersed: third, with respect to life: And our life shall pass away etc.
(Vers. 3.). He says therefore: Which, namely the soul, being extinguished, according to them, our body will be ashes: Ecclesiasticus seventeen: "All men are earth and ashes"; likewise Genesis eighteen: "I will speak to my Lord, since I am dust and ashes." For through the consumption of the natural moisture by heat, the body is consumed and turned into ashes; and the spirit, the bodily vital spirit, will be dispersed, namely by returning to its component principles, like soft air, that is, easily and invisibly; air is called soft because it does not resist touch. Or: the spirit, the incorporeal spirit, that is the soul, will be dispersed, that is, it will vanish and be dissolved, according to them, according to that verse of the Psalm: "The spirit shall pass through in him and shall not subsist," etc. And our life will pass away, that is, through the annihilation of its principles it will totally cease. And like the trace of a cloud, which does not appear after the dissolution of the cloud: Job thirty: "Like a cloud my well-being has passed away," namely temporal well-being; likewise chapter seven: "As a cloud is consumed and passes away, so he who descends to the netherworld shall not ascend." And it will be dissolved like a mist, which namely is the remnant of a cloud; for a cloud consists of a grosser and lower vapor, but mist of a thinner one. Which, namely the mist, was put to flight by the rays of the sun, the heat of the surrounding air uniting and driving away the parts of the cold vapor, and weighed down by its heat, the same heat driving the cold of the cloud to the interior parts and thus condensing per accidens the parts of that matter and thus weighing them down and afterward dissolving them into water: Job thirty-seven: "Suddenly the air will be gathered into clouds, and the passing wind will drive them away."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And our name, etc. Here is shown the motive cause on the part of fame or name: first the abolition of fame is touched upon; second, the reason for the abolition, at: For the passing of a shadow.
(Vers. 4.). He says therefore: And our name, as if to say: not only will our essence or substance pass into nothing, but also our name, that is, fame as regards the person, will receive oblivion through time, that is, through the length of time: Proverbs ten: "The name of the wicked shall rot." And no one will have memory of our works, as regards life: Job eighteen: "Let his memory perish from the earth"; likewise in the Psalm: "Their memory has perished with a noise"; and on the contrary: "The just shall be in everlasting memory."
But it is objected that the works of many reprobates, namely Cain, Pharaoh, Nero, etc., are still remembered.
It must be said that this statement is the statement of the reprobates, and therefore it is not unfitting to say that it is false. Or it must be said that they are not remembered with a praiseworthy memory or one useful to them; and it is of this kind that he speaks here.
But it is objected that the celebrated and praiseworthy deeds of many reprobates are remembered.
To this it must be said that these were not theirs but God's in them, according to that text of Isaiah twenty-six: "All our works you have wrought in us, O Lord."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 5). For remembering, however, two things are required, namely a strong impression and frequent repetition, and he excludes both when he adds: For shadows etc.; the passing of a shadow, on account of the swiftness of passing, 1 Chronicles twenty-nine: "Our days are like a shadow upon the earth, and there is no delay"; a shadow, I say, of passing is our time, that is, what we spend on doing our own will, not God's; but the Lord will at some time take that very time for himself: Psalm: "When I shall receive the time, I will judge justices." And there is no return of our end, on account of the impossibility of returning: Job ten: "Before I go and do not return" etc. Because it is sealed, namely our return, that is, closed under a seal: the Gloss: "Sealed, as if not appearing, because it does not exist." And no one returns to life, namely according to the common law; Psalm: "Their graves are their homes forever," namely according to their opinion, but according to truth all will at some time rise again through divine power: whence 1 Corinthians fifteen: "Indeed we shall all rise again" etc.
It should be noted, however, that the life and condition of the impious is said to be smoke on account of the blinding of the rational faculty, below in the same chapter: "Their malice has blinded them"; likewise Romans one: "Their foolish heart was darkened." It is likened to a breath on account of the restless disturbance of the irascible faculty, Isaiah fifty-seven: "The impious are like a raging sea"; to a spark, on account of the inflammation of the concupiscible faculty, Ecclesiasticus twenty-three: "A heated soul like a burning fire will not be quenched"; to air, on account of the emptiness of intention; to ashes, on account of the fruitlessness of works, below in chapter three: "Their works are useless"; to a thick cloud, on account of opposition to grace; to a light mist, on account of the elevation or elation of the mind; to a shadow, on account of outward dissimulation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Come therefore etc. Here he describes the unjust life, and first is touched upon the concord of the unjust and their mutual exhortation to the dissolution of their own life; second, the oppression of the just, at: Let us oppress etc. First, therefore, they exhort one another to devote themselves to dissolution: first, swiftly; second, abundantly, at: With costly wine etc.; third, openly, at: Let us crown; fourth, in common or universally, at: Let none of us; fifth, merrily, at: Let us leave everywhere.
(Vers. 6.). Come therefore, as if they were saying: since the present life passes away, and we do not hope for a future one; come therefore etc. Come, they say, because as Seneca says, "the possession of no thing is pleasant without a companion"; and therefore they exhort one another. For this is the invitatory at the matins of the devil. For it should be noted that just as the Church of the just has different invitatories and Venite according to different feasts, so too does the synagogue of sinners. One is of vanity: Genesis 11: "Come, and let us make for ourselves a city and a tower." Another, of iniquity: Genesis 37: "Come, and let us kill him and cast him into an old cistern." The third, of avarice and cupidity: Proverbs 1: "Come with us" etc. The fourth, of pleasure, which is treated here, namely: Come, and let us enjoy the good things that are etc. To these corresponds that saying of Matthew 25: "Depart from me, you cursed, into the fire" etc. Let us enjoy, I say, with loving affection, desiring nothing beyond; "for to enjoy is to cling with love to something for its own sake"; the good things that are, that is, present goods, and let us use, taking delight in the effect: Augustine: "To use is to take something into the power of the will"; Augustine: "The whole evil of man is to enjoy things that should be used and to use things that should be enjoyed." Let us use, I say, the creature, namely with contempt for the Creator: for otherwise it would not be a sin to use the creature. As in youth, that is, as long as we are young: because the senses of the young perceive pleasure more than those of the old: whence 2 Kings 19: "I am eighty years old today; are my senses still vigorous?" etc.; therefore Ecclesiastes 11: "Rejoice, O young man, in your youth." Swiftly: The Gloss: "Lest we and those things pass away before we enjoy them," according to that saying of Isaiah 22: "Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we shall die."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“With costly wine, inwardly as regards taste, arousing warmth from within; and with ointments, outwardly as regards touch, arousing warmth from without: let us fill ourselves, through superfluous and immoderate use; Amos 6: "Drinking wine in bowls and anointed with the finest ointment" etc. And let not the flower of time pass us by, that is, pleasantness as regards sight: Jeremiah 48: "Give a flower to Moab" etc. Such people care nothing for the fruit of the heavenly autumn, but only for the flower of the present spring.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Let us crown ourselves with roses before they wither: Isaiah 40: "The flower has fallen"; and chapter 28: "Woe to the falling flower"! Let us crown ourselves with roses, for delight as regards smell: but "woe to the crown of pride, to the drunkards of Ephraim"; Isaiah 28.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Let no meadow be that our wantonness does not pass through, that is, no pleasant place: this is said as regards the universality of place: Jeremiah 2: "On every high hill and under every leafy tree you lay down, O harlot." Let none of us, this is said as regards the universality of persons. Such was Sodom, in which not even ten just men could be found, as is clear from Genesis 18. Let none, I say, of us be without a share in our wantonness, that is, without a lot, that is, lacking a part or exempt from it. Everywhere let us leave signs of our merriment: this is said as regards universality in deed: Ezekiel 16: "At every head of the way you built a sign of your prostitution." For this, namely such a dissolute life, is our portion, namely on the part of the soul: and of clay is the lot ours, namely on the part of the body. Or: portion and lot are the same in reality, but they differ in concept, because portion is named from the side of the one receiving, lot from the side of the one giving: Isaiah 57: "In the parts of the torrent is your portion, this is your lot." On the contrary, the just man says: "The Lord is the portion of my inheritance"; likewise: "God of my heart, and God is my portion forever."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Let us oppress the just poor man etc. Here he describes the unjust life as regards the oppression of the good, first, because they oppress without reverence for the person: second, because without fear of justice, at the words: But let our strength etc.
(Vers. 10. 11.). Let us oppress: The Gloss: "It is the voice of the lost"; the just poor man, that is, anyone whatsoever: Job 24: "They have equally oppressed the meek of the earth." And let us not spare the widow: Psalm: "They slew the widow and the stranger" etc.; nor let us reverence the grey hairs of the aged of many years, that is, any old man whatsoever; Baruch 4: "They have not reverenced the old man."
Allegorically this is expounded concerning heretics, who do not spare the just poor man, that is, the Christian people; nor the widow, that is, the Church; nor the aged, that is, the Apostles and Prophets.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But let our strength be the law of injustice, that is, let us consider everything lawful, whatever we are able to do: Habakkuk 1: "Judgment has arisen and contention is more powerful." Or: of justice: whence the interlinear gloss: "As if we should have strength in place of justice," that is, what we cannot do through justice, let us do through violence. For what is weak etc., as if to say: let us not oppress only the poor and weak, such as widows and the elderly, but whomever we can; for what is weak, namely in itself, such as the widow, the poor, and the elderly: is found useless, namely to others: whence for such persons little or nothing is to be cared about. Not so did the Lord think, who "chose the weak things of the world to confound the strong, and the ignoble things of the world and the contemptible" etc. Not so Paul, who said that "power is made perfect in weakness," 2 Corinthians 12.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Specifically, the persecution of Christ is described, first with regard to the threefold cause. Let us therefore beset the just man etc. Here he specifically describes the persecution of Christ, and first he touches upon the cause; second, the end, at: Let us see therefore, if his words etc.; third, the manner, at: With insult and torment etc. The cause, on account of which the Jews persecuted Christ, he touches upon in three ways: first, on the part of their works; second, on the part of their thoughts, at: He has become to us; third, on the part of their words, at: As triflers. In the first part, on the part of works, he touches upon a threefold cause, of which the first is the detestation of the works of the Jews; the second, the reproaching and defaming of those transgressions, at: And he reproaches us etc.; the third, the commendation of Christ, at: He promises etc.
(Vers. 12.). Let us therefore ensnare etc. Because I said: Let our strength be the law of injustice, and we cannot do this unless we ensnare the just one: let us therefore ensnare the just one etc., so that, namely, we may freely exercise the law of our strength. Let us ensnare, I say, through deceit, the just one, that is, Christ, who by antonomasia is called the just one: Jeremiah twenty-three: "This is the name by which they shall call him: The Lord our just one"; "because he committed no" actual "sin," First Peter two; nor did he contract original sin in his conception: whence Jeremiah twenty-three: "I will raise up for David a just branch," that is, Christ in the branch, that is, in his conception: Isaiah forty-five: "Let justice spring up together" etc. Or: Let us ensnare etc., can be the voice of any wicked persons against any just person, against which the Apostle warns in First Thessalonians four: "Let no one defraud his brother in business"; just as he himself had not done so; whence Second Corinthians seven: We "have injured no one," namely by deed; "have corrupted no one," namely by evil example; "have defrauded no one," namely by word. Because he is useless to us: The Gloss: "Although they saw his usefulness in all things," according to that passage in Acts ten: "Who went about doing good and healing all who were oppressed by the devil." But they considered him useless to themselves in temporal matters: whence John eleven: "The Romans will come and take away our place and our nation." And he is contrary to our works, namely as good is contrary to evil, according to that passage in Ecclesiasticus thirty-three: "Against evil stands good, and against the just man stands the sinner." And he reproaches us with sins against the Law, that is, because we sin by transgressing the Law: whence John seven: "Did not Moses give you the Law, and none of you keeps the Law"? And he spreads abroad against us, that is, against us, or turning back upon us, the sins of our training, that is, by saying that we sin by teaching our traditions, or by holding them, or by making others hold them; whence Matthew fifteen: "Why do you transgress the commandment of God for the sake of your traditions"?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 13.). He professes to have the knowledge of God: The Gloss: "That is, to know all things as God," and this with respect to essence. And he calls himself the Son of God, "that is, consubstantial and coeternal with God," with respect to person: John five: "He called God his Father, making himself equal to God." Thus any just person has the knowledge of God in the intellect, and is a son of God by grace in the affections; whence in the Psalm: "I said: You are gods," namely knowing good and evil, "and all of you sons of the Most High."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He has become for us an exposer. Here is set forth the moving cause on the part of thoughts, and first is touched upon the manifestation of the thoughts of the Jews through Christ; second, the effect of the manifestation, caused not on the part of Christ, but on the part of the Jews, namely their envy, at: He is grievous etc.
(Verse 14.). He has become for us an exposer, that is, a revealer, of our thoughts: The Gloss: "He brings our thoughts into the light," that is, he leads them out into knowledge; whence Matthew 9: "Why do you think evil in your hearts?" So traducere is understood in Matthew 1, namely as to expose, where it says: "He was not willing to expose her."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 15.). He is grievous for us even to behold, namely on account of the manifestation of their sins; Augustine: "To sick eyes the light is hateful"; John 3: "He who does evil hates the light." But this, that they could not bear to see him, was a sign of envy; whence 1 Kings 18: "Saul did not look upon David with favorable eyes," namely because he envied him. Because his life is unlike that of others, namely his entire outward life or conduct.
On the contrary: Hebrews 2: "He ought to be made like his brethren in all things."
It must be said that the Apostle speaks of likeness in passible nature; here, of likeness in fault.
It should be noted, moreover, that his life or conduct was unlike others both with respect to its beginning, because he was conceived and born without sin: Isaiah 6: "The holy seed shall be that which has stood in her," that is, in Mary; Matthew 1: "That which is born in her is of the Holy Spirit." And with respect to its middle, because he lived without sin: 1 Peter 2: "He committed no sin, nor was deceit found" etc. And with respect to its end, because he died without any debt of death: the Psalm: "What I did not seize, I was then paying back."
And his ways are changed: The Gloss: "They have been made unlike," namely his deeds and his teaching: Isaiah 55: "For my thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are my ways your ways, says the Lord."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As triflers etc. Here is touched upon the moving cause on the part of speech, and first is set forth their reprobation; second, the approbation of others, at: And he prefers the last things etc.; third, his self-commendation, at: And he boasts that he has God for a father.
(Vers. 16.). As therefore we were regarded as triflers by him, that is, doing and saying vain things: Zephaniah 3: "I will gather the triflers, who had departed from the law." And he abstains from our ways: The Gloss: "That is, from our actions and traditions"; as from unclean things, and indeed justly, because they were truly unclean: whence Ezekiel 36: "Their way was made before me like the uncleanness of a menstruous woman." And he prefers the last things of the just, that is, the end, and indeed deservedly, because "the death of sinners is the worst," but the death of the just is precious, according to that verse of the Psalm: "Precious in the sight of the Lord is the death of his Saints"; therefore in Numbers 23 Balaam said: "Let my soul die the death of the just, and let my last end be like theirs." Or according to the Gloss: He prefers the last things of the just, "that is, eternal life to pleasure." And he boasts that he has God for his Father: John 8: "It is my Father who glorifies me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, the persecution of Christ is described with regard to its purpose. Let us see therefore, if the words etc. Here in the person of the Jews he first touches upon the purpose of the persecution of Christ, which was that they wanted to know the truth about Christ; second, it is added how they could know this, at the words: For if he is the true Son of God, etc.
(Vers. 17. 18.). Let us see, etc., as if they were saying: since he so boasts, let us see, as it were from afar, by deliberating about his death: John 11: "The chief priests and Pharisees gathered a council" against Jesus. Let us see, I say, if his words are true, namely, that he is truly the Son of God. This the centurion saw and recognized, who, seeing him expire with a cry and the earthquake and other signs, said in Matthew 27: "Truly this was the Son of God." And let us test him, from close at hand, namely by crucifying him and exposing him to death: what will come upon him, namely whether he will be able to free himself: Matthew 27: "He saved others, he cannot save himself." And we shall know, or: so that we may know, what his last end will be, namely whether he will rise again. And this we shall know by guarding his tomb: whence Matthew 27: "Lord, we have remembered that that deceiver said while he was still living: After three days I will rise again."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For if he is the true Son of God, as he foretold, not through the grace of adoption, as we are, but through the natural property of eternal generation: he will receive him, namely in glory: Isaiah forty-two: "Behold, my servant, I will receive him." And he will deliver him, namely from punishment: and this is what follows: From the hands of adversaries, that is, of those who crucified him, who were his adversaries. God did both for him: for he delivered him from punishment, according to that word of the Psalm: "My deliverer from my wrathful enemies," namely on the very day of the passion, after he endured temporal death: and he raised him up, but not immediately, but on the third day, according to that word of Zephaniah three: "Wait for me on the day of my resurrection"; and he received him with glory on the day of the ascension: whence in the Psalm: "With glory you have received me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, the persecution of Christ is described with respect to the special mode of oppression. Let us examine him with insult and torment, etc. Here he touches upon the special mode of oppression, and first, with respect to those things disposing toward death: second, with respect to death itself: By a most shameful death, etc.
(Vers. 19. 20.). He says therefore: With insult, namely of words: and with torment, namely of blows: Hebrews eleven: "The saints experienced mockeries and beatings"; let us examine him, that is, let us test him. So it was done, as is clear from Matthew twenty-seven and John nineteen, because he was mocked with insulting words and struck with scourges and at last fastened with nails to the gibbet of the cross. That we may know his reverence, that is, the humility with which he reverences God: Hebrews five: "He was heard because of his reverence." And let us test his patience, namely through torments: that is, whether he is truly humble and patient. And truly so, because "when he was reviled, he did not revile in return; when he suffered, he did not threaten," First Peter two. Gregory: "What sort of person each one is within himself, an insult inflicted reveals."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By a most shameful death: The Gloss: "That is, by the death of the cross, which up to the passion of Christ was the punishment of the guilty, but now is the trophy of victory and the glory of the Church"; Augustine: "The cross passed from the punishments of robbers to the foreheads of emperors." And because the death of the cross was most shameful, therefore to show the usefulness of Christ's death the Apostle says in Philippians two: "He humbled himself, etc., even the death of the cross."
Now the death of Christ was most shameful by reason of place, because it was outside the city at the place of Calvary, that is, the place where the heads of the beheaded were cast out, Matthew twenty-seven. By reason of time, because it was on a solemn day and at the greater hour, namely "the sixth hour," John nineteen. By reason of instrument, because it was on the wood of the cross: 1 Peter two: "He bore our sins in his body upon the wood." By reason of company, because it was among thieves, Luke twenty-three. By reason of reproach, because many reproaches were inflicted upon him as he hung, as is evident in Matthew twenty-seven.
Let us condemn him. It should be noted that Pilate condemned him by authority; the Jews, by persuasion. For there shall be regard for him from his words, that is, knowledge of the truth of his words: the Gloss: "We shall see whether after death he is able to raise up his flesh; for he said: 'Destroy this temple, and in three days I will rebuild it,'" John two.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These things they thought, and they erred. Here he shows that the life of such men is to be shunned as erroneous; and first he touches upon the meritorious cause of their error; second, the matter of their error: And they knew not, etc.; third, the author of their error: But by the envy of the devil, etc.
(Vers. 21.). These things, namely the aforesaid, they thought, namely the impious, and they carried them out; and they erred: whence below in chapter five: "Therefore we have erred from the way of truth, and the light of justice has not shone upon us"; likewise Proverbs fourteen: "They err who work evil." For it blinded them, namely their interior eye, their malice: whence in the prayer of Jeremiah: "Woe to us, for we have sinned; therefore our eyes are darkened"; likewise 2 Corinthians four: "The god of this world has blinded the minds of unbelievers."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And they knew not the mysteries of God, that is, the sacred and secret counsels and dispositions concerning the passion and resurrection of Christ; Ephesians three: "The mystery was made known to me, which in other generations was not known." Nor did they hope for the reward of justice; the Gloss: "That is, of the death of Christ," namely his exaltation through death, concerning which, Philippians two: "Wherefore God also exalted him." Nor did they judge: the Gloss: "That is, understand," the honor of holy souls, that is, the salvation of holy souls to be obtained through the death and resurrection of Christ: whence the Gloss: "They did not understand that the death of Christ is the honor and salvation of souls"; the Psalm: "They are exceedingly honored," etc.; likewise 1 Peter two: "To you therefore who believe, honor," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And rightly I said: Honor, because God created man imperishable, that is, having the power not to die, on the part of the body: and to the image, namely on the part of the soul; Genesis 1: "Let us make man to our image and likeness"; to the image, namely in natural endowments: of his likeness, namely in gratuitous gifts: or: to the image, in the cognitive power: to the likeness in the affective power: for image is the principle of knowing, likeness the ground of loving; for "every animal loves its like," Ecclesiasticus 13. He made him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But by the envy of the devil, who envied the happiness of the first parents, death entered into the world.
Against this: Romans 5: "By one man sin entered, and by sin death."
It must be said that death entered through the devil suggesting and through man consenting.
But they imitate him, namely the devil, by envying the just, who are of his party, namely the impious, who are of the party of the devil. "For he himself is the head of all the wicked," as Gregory says.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the first part, on the side of the retribution of the just, there is touched upon first their liberation from evil: second, their reward in good: The just shall shine, etc. In the first, there is touched upon first their liberation from the evil of eternal damnation: second, from the evil of temporal death, at: They seemed in the eyes, etc.; third, from the evil of present vexation or tribulation: And if before men they suffered torments.
(Verse 1). But the souls of the just are in the hand of God, etc. Rabanus continues thus: "In the preceding chapter the sentence of the wicked was expressed, which they brought forth against Christ: now they are condemned for foolishness, because they think the Saints perish, whom they slaughter for his confession." But it can be continued in this way: I rightly said that those "who are on his side" "imitate" the devil. But, standing for "however"; the souls of the just, etc., "that is, of the Martyrs," according to the Gloss: which is also true of other just persons, but Martyrs are called especially just, because "just is he who disregards loss for the sake of a friend," as is found in Proverbs 12: and this the Martyrs do especially, because for Christ they disregard the loss of possessions and of carnal friends and even of their own bodies, as is clear from Hebrews 11. The souls, I say, of the just: he does not say bodies, because "the earth," that is, the body made from earth, "is given into the hands of the wicked," Job 9. He does not say temporal goods: Job 1: "Behold, all that he has is in your hand," etc. But the souls are in the hand of God, that is, in his protection, and therefore they are secure; Psalm: "He who dwells in the aid of the Most High," etc.; John 10: "No one shall snatch them from my hand." And the torment of death shall not touch them, namely "eternal" death, as the Gloss says: whence Job 5: "In six tribulations he will deliver you, and in the seventh no evil shall touch you," that is, the torment of Gehenna. This torment is described in Job 24: "From the waters of snow he shall pass to excessive heat"; likewise in a Psalm: "He shall rain snares upon sinners, fire," etc. By the name of death, taken in its general sense, is understood here eternal death, because that is true death: but temporal death is as it were the shadow of death: for it is a certain passage to life, according to that saying in John 5: "He does not come into judgment," namely of condemnation, "but has passed from death to life."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 2.). They seemed to the eyes etc. It should be noted that the wicked and unbelieving regard the death of the Saints as death in the separation of the conjunction of soul to body, affliction in the pain of the conjoined, destruction in the perdition of the soul, which they regard as perishing with the body; the way of destruction with regard to the subsequent incineration of the body. According to this it is read thus: They seemed, that is the just, in the eyes of the foolish to die, namely by eternal death, when nevertheless they pass over to a better life. Whence Augustine: "God bestowed so great a grace upon the Christian faith that death, which is known to be contrary to life, became an instrument through which one might pass over to life." In the eyes, he says, of the foolish, who "set their eyes to decline toward the earth," that is, who consider only present things and not future things: and therefore to such people they seem utterly to die, but in the eyes of the wise they seem to be born, on account of which the death of the Saints is called a birthday, according to that passage in Job 11: "When you think yourself consumed, you shall rise as the morning star." And it was accounted, namely by the impious, as affliction, namely alone without any benefit, their departure, from the body, when nevertheless it is for them a consolation, according to that passage in Philippians 1: "Having a desire to be dissolved and to be with Christ." Bernard: "The Saints hold death in desire, life in patience." But for the reprobate, there is affliction of departure in their death, and this because, as the same Bernard says, "for them there is pain in departure, horror in passage, shame in the sight of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 3.). And from the just path, that is from the way of justice, they went away into destruction: the Gloss: "That is, in the estimation of the wicked," because "they regard the palm of martyrdom as affliction and destruction," that is, a retreat into nothingness as regards the soul, which they think is reduced to nothing: and repeat: the just went away, in the estimation of the impious, into the way of destruction, that is incineration, as regards the body; which destruction or way of destruction is from us, that is from our first parents: Romans 5: "Through one man death entered the world." Or: destruction he calls temporal death, because it excludes from the present life: way however of destruction he calls eternal death, because it excludes from eternal life: Baruch 3: "They were destroyed and descended to the netherworld." And with this, there one passes or goes from deadly punishment to deadly punishment, according to that passage in Job 24: "From the waters of snow he shall pass to excessive heat." Such people err in thinking thus: whence below in chapter 5: "We fools accounted their life madness and their end without honor." But they are in peace; the Gloss: "Of perpetual rest, now in hope, at last in reality"; Apocalypse 14: "From henceforth now, says the Spirit, that they may rest from their labors." For the end of the just is peace: whence Isaiah 32: "The work of justice shall be peace."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And if before men etc. Here is touched upon the deliverance from the evil of present vexation, and first the deliverance in hope: second in reality, at: Afflicted in few things etc.; third the cause of both, at: For God tested them etc.
(Verses 4, 5). It is said therefore: And if, that is, although, before men: the Gloss: "Because before God is the crown of glory"; they suffered torments, namely various and grievous ones, as is evident in the Martyrs, concerning whom Hebrews eleven says: "They were stoned, they were cut asunder" etc. Their hope, namely of the just, according to that saying of Proverbs fourteen: "The just man hopes in his death": is full of immortality, an immortality, I say, not such as was the immortality of the first parents, namely with the possibility of dying; not such as that of the damned in hell, namely with the perpetual desire of dying: Revelation nine: "They shall desire to die, and death shall flee from them"; not such as that of little children in limbo, namely with the lack of the glorious life, but such as that of the Blessed in heaven: Romans five: "We glory in the hope of the glory of the children of God".
And rightly they hope, because, afflicted in few things, the Gloss: "Bodily"; in many things they shall be well disposed: Matthew twenty-five: "Because you were faithful over a few things, I will set you over many things"; Luke twenty-two: "I dispose to you a kingdom" etc. But what those many things are, is said in Isaiah sixty-four: "Eye has not seen, O God, apart from you, what you have prepared for those who wait for you".
But there is a doubt about what it says: Afflicted in few things etc., because it is said in Hebrews eleven: "They were stoned, they were cut asunder" etc.
It must be said that their torments were many in themselves, but few by comparison: first, by comparison with their own estimation, according to that saying of Genesis twenty-nine: "The days seemed to him," namely to Jacob, "few because of the greatness of his love." Second, by comparison with the Passion of Christ: Lamentations one: "O all you who pass by the way"; likewise in the Psalm: "They were swallowed up, joined to the rock," namely to Christ, "their judges," that is, the Apostles themselves and other Martyrs. Third, by comparison with the future reward: Romans eight: "The sufferings are not worthy" etc.; likewise, Second Corinthians four: "That which is at present momentary and light of our tribulation works for us above measure exceedingly an eternal weight of glory." Fourth, by comparison with eternal affliction: Job six: "He who fears the frost, upon him shall the snow rush." Fifth, by comparison with the debt and the obligation, that is, the punishment owed on account of things omitted and the obligation on account of things committed: the Psalm: "What shall I render to the Lord for all the things that he has rendered to me"?
For God tested them etc. Here the cause of the aforesaid is touched upon, and first, their chastisement: second, their purification, there: As gold in the furnace etc.; third, the future recompense, there: And in the time there will be etc.
I rightly said that they will be well disposed in many things, for God tested them: Gloss: "That is, He chastised them with various tribulations"; 2 Corinthians 6: "As chastised and not put to death."
But to the contrary: "God tempts no one," as is found in James 1.
It must be said that He does not test in order to learn, as a man does: Daniel 1: "Test us, I beseech you" etc.; nor in order to deceive, as the devil does; Matthew 4: "The tempter, approaching, said to Him" etc.; likewise 1 Corinthians 7: "Lest Satan tempt you"; but in order to instruct, as a master instructs a disciple; Psalm: "Prove me, O Lord, and test me" etc.
And He found them worthy of Himself, namely "of the participation of His blessedness," which is acquired through tribulations: whence Acts 14: "Through many tribulations we must enter into the kingdom of heaven"; likewise Tobit 3: "If he shall have been in trial, he shall be crowned."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 6.) As gold in the furnace He tested them, namely on the part of the soul, purifying them through the fire of tribulations but not consuming them: Gloss: "Just as gold in the furnace is not burned up but is tested, so the Martyrs do not fail but are prepared for glory"; Sirach 2: "Gold and silver are tested in fire, but acceptable men in the furnace of humiliation," which, namely, comes through present tribulations: Job 23: "He tested me as gold that passes through fire." And as a victim of holocaust, which is entirely consumed in the sacrifice of the Lord's body: He received them, namely on the part of the body, by approving or accepting their devotion: Romans 12: "Present your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy, pleasing to God." And in the time, namely of retribution: Gloss: "The death of the Saints is not perpetual, but in the day of judgment there is abundant recompense"; there will be regard for them, that is, they will be regarded by God, namely with the eye of mercy, which the Psalmist sought, saying: "Look upon me and have mercy on me." Regard, I say, for them, that is, of the just, who now seem to be abandoned by God, according to that verse of the Psalm: "God, my God, look upon me, why have You forsaken me?"; likewise, to be despised, according to that verse of the Psalm: "Why do You turn Your face away?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The just shall shine etc. After he has treated of deliverance from evil, here he adds concerning reward in good, first, as regards the stole of the body: second, as regards the honor of judicial power, there: They shall judge the nations etc.; third, as regards the glory of divine fruition, there: Those who trust in Him etc.
(Vers. 7.). I said well that there will be in time a regard for them, because the just shall shine, namely by the endowment of clarity in the judgment as regards the substance of the body, according to that passage of Matthew thirteen: "Then the just shall shine as the sun"; but the sun shall shine sevenfold more than it does now: whence Isaiah thirty: "The light of the moon shall be as the light of the sun, and the light of the sun shall be sevenfold." And they shall run about like sparks, that is, they shall be apt for running about through the endowment of agility, and this as regards the operation or motion of the body, according to that passage of Isaiah forty: "They that hope in the Lord shall renew their strength, they shall take wings as eagles"; Augustine: "Where the spirit wills, there immediately shall the body also be." Like sparks, I say, in a bed of reeds, which they set ablaze and consume. A bed of reeds here signifies the assembly of the reprobate, because it is outwardly splendid through pretense, inwardly void of truth, laden with no fruit of good works, continually watered by the swamp of carnal concupiscence, agitated by the wind of pride, fit for eternal burning. In this bed of reeds the Saints are said to run about, trampling them underfoot; Malachi, last chapter: "You shall tread down the wicked." In the spark, moreover, the four endowments of the body can be noted, namely on account of its fiery clarity, subtlety, agility, and active power, through which impassibility can be understood.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 8.). They shall judge nations. This is said specially of the perfect Saints, who shall judge and shall not be judged. For there shall be four orders in the judgment, as the Gloss says on that verse of the Psalm: "The wicked shall not rise in the judgment."
But how shall the Saints judge, since it is written in John five: "The Father has given all judgment to the Son"?
It must be said that there is a judgment of authority, by which the whole Trinity shall judge: of judicial examination, by which Christ alone as man shall judge: of assessorial dignity, by which only the more perfect Saints shall judge: of approbation, by which all the good shall judge: of comparison, by which the good, that is, the less wicked, shall judge: Matthew twelve: "The men of Nineveh shall rise in judgment with this generation and shall condemn it."
And they shall have dominion over peoples, namely after the judgment: Revelation five: "We shall reign upon the earth," that is, over the earthly. Or: they shall have dominion over peoples, after death: Matthew fifteen: "The little dogs eat of the crumbs that fall from the table of their masters," that is, we of the benefits of the Blessed. And He shall reign, with them, or in them, their Lord, namely Christ: Revelation nineteen: "King of kings," etc.: forever: Luke one: "Of His kingdom there shall be no end"; Psalm: "Thy kingdom is a kingdom of all ages."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Who trust in him. Here he touches upon the glory of fruition: and he touches upon this in three respects, namely in the knowledge of truth, in the adherence to goodness, there: And the faithful in love: in the perfection of comprehension, there: For gift and peace is etc.
(Vers. 9.). He says therefore: Who trust etc., as if to say, not only will they judge, but also those who trust in him, namely God, in the present, according to that verse of the Psalm: "Those who trust in the Lord are like Mount Sion"; shall understand the truth, by open vision: First John 3: "We shall see him as he is": Gloss: "According to true confidence, the understanding of truth is given." And the faithful in love, that is, those loving him faithfully and inseparably, as the Apostle, who said: "Who shall separate us from the love of Christ" etc., Romans 8: Ecclesiasticus 6: "To a faithful friend there is no comparison"; shall rest in him: Gloss: "Because in the future they will not be able to be torn from his fellowship, whom here they already held by faith and hope." Therefore rest in God through love will succeed the understanding of faith. For gift: Gloss: "Of eternal satisfaction"; Psalm: "I shall be satisfied when your glory shall appear"; likewise: "They shall be inebriated with the abundance of your house." And peace, "eternal," according to the Gloss: Isaiah 32: "My people shall sit in the beauty of peace": likewise Philippians 4: "And the peace of God, which surpasses all understanding": is for his elect, the Saints, whom God chose from this world: John 15: "You have not chosen me, but I have chosen you from the world." - This can also be expounded concerning present merit, which consists in the knowledge of truth through faith, in the conformity of human and divine will through love, so that gift is referred to the knowledge of faith, and peace to the tranquility of love.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the ungodly, according to what they thought etc. Here he sets forth the reprobation of the opposite state; and first he shows that the error of the ungodly concerning their own impunity is false; second, that their opinion concerning the reward of the continent life is erroneous, there: For blessed is the barren: third, concerning the punishment of incontinence, there: But the children of adulterers etc. In the first part he touches first upon their punishment in themselves: second, the equity of the punishment, there: For wisdom and discipline etc.; third, the overflowing punishment even upon their own, there: Their wives are senseless etc.
(Vers. 10.). There follows therefore: But the ungodly etc. I have rightly said that the just shall be so rewarded: but, for "yet": the ungodly, according to what they have thought, that is, by the desert of their evil thoughts, utterances, and works proceeding from their evil thoughts: shall have correction, "that is, punishment," as the Gloss says, whence it says: "When the just shall enter into rest, the ungodly shall go into eternal punishment." Who have neglected the just, in the neuter, "that is, justice"; or in the masculine, the just one, "that is, God himself," according to the Gloss, and this by omitting the good: Jeremiah 48, according to another reading: "Cursed is he who does the work of the Lord negligently"; Seneca: "Grave is the loss that comes through negligence." And they departed from the Lord, by openly committing evil; Jeremiah 2: "Know and see that it is an evil and bitter thing that you have forsaken your God"; evil, on account of the punishment of loss: bitter, on account of the punishment of sense; the Gloss says: "They depart from the Lord who cast away discipline and wisdom": and this is very evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 11.). For wisdom etc. For, that is, "because": he who casts away, the Gloss says: "By working evil," wisdom, concerning eternal things, discipline, concerning temporal things: or rather: wisdom, of faith, discipline, of morals: is unhappy, namely his person, that is, unworthy of felicity. But on the contrary, "Blessed is the man who finds wisdom," Proverbs 3; and therefore in the same place: "My son, do not cast away the discipline of the Lord"; likewise Hebrews 12: "Do not neglect the discipline of the Lord." And empty is, namely in effect, their hope, the present one: the Gloss says: "By which they thought temporal things would be eternal, and sins would go unpunished": Ecclesiasticus 34: "Vain hope and falsehood to a senseless man." And labors, in enduring, without fruit: the Gloss says: "Of eternal reward"; Ecclesiastes 10: "The labor of fools shall afflict them." On the contrary, to the just one it is said: "You shall eat the labors of your hands; blessed are you, and it shall be well with you." From this it is clear that the life of the ungodly is laborious; whence below in chapter 5: "We have walked difficult ways," but unfruitful; whence Habakkuk 2: "For the peoples shall labor in much fire, and the nations in vain, and they shall fail." And their works are useless, in acting: useless, "because they do not merit the heavenly dwelling," as the Gloss says; Galatians 5: "They who do such things shall not obtain the kingdom of God." — From the foregoing it is clear that such persons shall incur four evils, which are: unhappiness of person, emptiness of hope, fruitlessness of labor, uselessness of work, or demeritorious work.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 12. 13.). Their wives etc., as if to say: not only they themselves, but also their wives, that is, their spouses, are senseless, that is, lacking wisdom; and most wicked are their children, because they are imitators of their father's wickedness—wickedness, I say, against themselves and against their neighbor and against God, and therefore most wicked. — Cursed is their creature, "that is, their handiwork," according to the Gloss; "for the wisdom which God created by blessing does not curse, but shows that the work of the reprobate is worthy of eternal malediction."
According to the Gloss, these things can be expounded allegorically of heretics, so that we say: Wives, "that is, carnal pleasures, or perverse interpretations or doctrines"; and children, "that is, wicked works"; and their creature, that is, their disciples. — Or: cursed is the creature, not simply, but theirs, insofar as it comes to their misuse.
For blessed is the barren etc. Here he shows the reward of the continent life, which the reprobate thought to be nothing; and first he shows this on the part of the feminine sex; second, on the part of the masculine sex: And the eunuch etc.
He says therefore: For etc., as if to say: rightly did I say that their wives and the children begotten from their lust are cursed, because on the contrary blessed is the barren, that is, chaste in body—and he puts the consequent for the antecedent—and undefiled, in mind. Luke twenty-three: "Blessed are the barren and the wombs that have not borne": who has not known, by the knowledge of experience, the bed in transgression, "of adultery," says the Gloss. How great the sin of adultery is, is touched upon in Ecclesiasticus toward the end almost throughout, and in Proverbs six: "It is not a great fault when someone has stolen" etc.; and below: "But he who is an adulterer, through poverty of heart, shall destroy his own soul."
The Gloss also expounds this of spiritual adultery, saying: "Blessed is the chaste and continent soul, which is polluted neither by heresy nor by idolatry." She shall have fruit: the Gloss says: "The fruit of eternal beatitude," namely either thirtyfold, which is owed to the married, or sixtyfold, which is owed to widows, or a hundredfold, which is owed to virgins. Concerning this manifold fruit, it is said in the parable of the seed in Luke eight: "And having sprung up, it bore fruit, some a hundredfold" etc. In the visitation of holy souls: the Gloss says: "On the day of judgment, when God shall look upon holy souls by rewarding them, and they themselves shall look upon him by contemplating him."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the eunuch etc. Here on the part of the masculine sex, there is touched upon first the merit of continence; second, the reward, at: There shall be given etc.; third, the reason for the reward: For the fruits of good labors etc.
(Verse 14.). It follows therefore: And the eunuch, "who namely made himself a eunuch for the sake of the kingdom of heaven," Matthew nineteen. Who has not wrought iniquity with his hands, that is, he has not committed the sin of incontinence in deed, but is clean in body. Nor has he thought most wicked things against God, that is, nor has he sinned by consent or will, but is clean in heart: for both kinds of purity are required: whence Augustine: "Where the Lord in judging shall find corruption of mind, He will condemn even the incorruption of body together with it." Such a eunuch, I say, repeat: is blessed, now in hope, but at last in reality. For there shall be given to him, in the present namely, a chosen gift of faith: of faith, I say, which makes blessed in hope, according to that passage in John twenty: "Blessed are they who have not seen and have believed." A chosen gift he calls the gift of faith, because it is given from divine election and makes men elect: Philippians one: "To you it has been given, not only to believe in Him, but also to suffer for Him." And a lot, that is, a portion in the future, in the temple of God: Gloss: "In heaven": Psalm: "The Lord is in His holy temple; the Lord, His seat is in heaven."
But on the contrary: Because Apocalypse twenty-one: "I saw no temple in it," namely in the heavenly city.
It must be said that there is no material temple there, but a spiritual one.
Most acceptable. It should be noted that a lot is acceptable in the goods of nature, more acceptable in the goods of grace, most acceptable in the goods of glory. This is the "best gift," of which James one speaks.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 15.). For the fruit of good labors is glorious: Gloss: "That is, eternal joy," First Corinthians three: "Each one shall receive his own reward according to his own labor." And the root of wisdom that does not fall, intransitively: "for wisdom is the root of this fruit." This root does not fall, because "it brings forth the fruit of perpetual salvation," according to the Gloss; Ecclesiasticus one: "The root of wisdom is to fear the Lord." This root is known to few; Psalm: "The fear of the Lord is not before their eyes"; Ecclesiasticus one: "To whom has the root of wisdom been revealed?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the children of adulterers etc. Here he determines the punishment of incontinence, which the reprobate thought to be nothing, and first the punishment to be inflicted on them in the future is touched upon; second, that inflicted in this world, at: And if indeed; third, the reason for the punishment, at: Nations etc.
(Vers. 16.). He says therefore: Children etc. I have rightly said that the continent shall be rewarded; but, that is, however; the children of adulterers, namely imitators of paternal incontinence, shall come to destruction, "that is, to eternal destruction," according to the Gloss: Exodus twenty: "Visiting the sins of the fathers upon the children," namely the imitators of paternal wickedness. And from an unlawful bed, namely of adultery, the seed, supply: brought forth, shall be destroyed: The Gloss: "In the future," when namely they shall be cast beyond the borders of the land of the living: whence Baruch three: "They have been destroyed and have descended to the nether regions." The Gloss, however, expounds otherwise concerning children and seed, that is, concerning the disciples of heretics, to whom he here threatens the punishment of sense and the punishment of loss, because they adulterate the word of God. Concerning such it is said in Second Corinthians two: "We are not as many, adulterating the word of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 17.). And if indeed they shall be of long life, namely in this world, they shall be counted as nothing, namely without any value in themselves: Augustine: "Sin is nothing, and men become nothing when they sin." Or: they shall be counted as nothing, according to the Gloss: "That is, their memory shall forever lack blessing." And without honor, namely shown by others, First Kings two: "Those who despise me shall be ignoble." Without honor, I say, shall be the last old age of those, which nevertheless ought to be revered: whence Leviticus nineteen: "Honor the person of the elder"; likewise here below in chapter four: "Old age is venerable, not by length of time nor reckoned by the number of years."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 18. 19.). And if they have died more quickly, that is, overtaken by death, according to that passage of the Psalm: "Men of blood and deceit shall not live out half their days." They shall have no hope, that is, the thing hoped for after death, namely eternal life, because "the hope of the wicked shall perish," Proverbs 10. Nor in the day of recognition, namely the universal one, which will be at the judgment, according to the Gloss. Now the day of judgment is called the day of recognition with respect to the good, because then they will be recognized by God, just as the brothers of Joseph were by him, Genesis 45. Likewise, with respect to the wicked, because their hidden things will be made known; 1 Corinthians 4: "He will illuminate the hidden things of darkness," etc. Likewise, with respect to God himself, because he will be known by the Saints: 1 Corinthians 13: "Then I shall know, even as I am known." Likewise, with respect to Christ as man, because then he will be openly seen by all: Isaiah 40: "All flesh shall see what the mouth of the Lord has spoken"; likewise of the same, 52: "All the ends of the earth shall see the salvation of our God"; likewise Revelation 1: "Every eye shall see him." Likewise, with respect to the world itself, in which then nothing will be hidden or concealed, according to that passage of the Psalm: "The foundations of the world were revealed." Nor in the day, I say, of recognition, repeat: they shall have, an address, that is, a gentle or consolatory one, but a most harsh dismissal: whence Matthew 25: "Depart from me, you cursed," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For wicked nations, that is, doers or imitators of iniquity, are of a dreadful end, that is, conclusion, namely they have harshness of punishment in the end, whatever may be the case regarding the beginning, or regarding the middle, because: The last things do not correspond to the first by the same course; Ecclesiasticus 41: "The inheritance of the children of sinners shall perish, and with their seed shall be a perpetual reproach."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“O how beautiful is the chaste generation with glory! He says this in admiration: beautiful, "with regard to works"; a chaste generation, "with regard to innocence of mind"; with brightness, "with regard to the splendor of virtues," according to the Gloss. Song of Songs 4: "You are all beautiful, my beloved" etc.; likewise Luke 12: "Let your loins be girded," through innocence, "and lamps burning," through the splendor of virtues; "and you yourselves like men waiting for their lord," through solicitude for good works. And I rightly said that it is beautiful, namely with spiritual beauty. For the memory of it is immortal, through happy remembrance: Proverbs 10: "The memory of the just is with praises." For it is known also with God, through approbation: 2 Timothy 2: "The Lord knows who are his." And with men, namely those who use reason and are wise, through praise or the continuation of praise; Sirach 44: "Let the peoples declare the wisdom," namely of the Saints, "and let the Church proclaim their praise."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For when it is present, "namely in the present life," they imitate it, as a most beautiful exemplar; Philippians 3: "Be imitators of me." And they desire it, namely to see the beautiful and chaste generation of the just, namely for imitation: when it has departed, from this life through death: Job 9: "They have passed like ships carrying fruit," which namely leave behind their fragrance after their passage: Song of Songs 1: "We will run after the fragrance of your ointments."
It should be noted that God leads the just out of the present life effectively, according to that verse of the Psalm: "Lead forth from custody," that is, from prison, "my soul." But they themselves lead themselves out by consenting, or by desiring and asking for this: in the Psalm: "My soul has thirsted for God, the living fountain; when shall I come and appear before the face of God?"
And crowned forever, namely with the crown of perpetual life; Apocalypse 2: "Be faithful unto death, and I will give you the crown of life." She triumphs, that is, by triumphing she acquires the prize of undefiled contests, that is, what is owed to undefiled contests, that is, not defiled by a lack of perseverance: the prize, I say, conquering, a prize given for a competitive contest, as the Gloss says, whence 1 Corinthians 9: "They, that they may receive a corruptible crown, but we an incorruptible one." Or: a conquering prize, that is, surpassing the magnitude of persecutions, according to that verse in Romans 8: "The sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared to the future glory that will be revealed in us"; whence the Gloss: "A prize that is greater than those contests and persecutions which they endured in the present."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But of manifold kind etc., as if to say: such is the beautiful and chaste generation of the just. But (in the sense of "however"): the manifold multitude of the impious, etc.; Ecclesiastes 1: "The number of fools is infinite." Here he touches upon a threefold plurality or multitude of the impious in three words, namely because it is scattered through diverse errors with respect to the rational power, against which James 3: "Do not become many masters"; likewise, through diverse appetites with respect to the concupiscible power: Hosea 10: "Their heart is divided, now they shall perish"; likewise, through diverse hatreds with respect to the irascible power: Micah 3: "Jerusalem shall be a heap of stones," that is, without the cement of charity. He touches upon or indicates the first through what he says: Of manifold kind, that is, generating many errors: the second, through what he says: Multitude, as if without the unity or bond of charity: the third, through what he says: Of the impious, in the plural, that is, without piety, but with much cruelty. The manifold, I say, multitude of the impious will not be useful, "indeed harmful," as the Gloss says; Isaiah 30: "They were not for help or for any usefulness, but for confusion and for reproach."
But on the contrary: "Because, as Augustine says, if there were fewer wicked than good, they would not dare to try the good"; but this trial is useful for the good, because Gregory says that "he cannot be Abel whom the malice of Cain does not try." Likewise in the Psalm: "Upon my back sinners have wrought," namely, a perpetual crown for me.
But it must be said that the just will not obtain this benefit from the intention of the wicked, because they do not intend to benefit them, but from their own goodness, or from their own good will, making good use of their evils.
And spurious shoots shall not take deep root, etc. So reads the text of Rabanus and all the ancients; likewise Ambrose in a certain letter says to certain persons: "You are noble shoots," that is, noble plantings. But Augustine says that it would be better said adulterous plantings; and on account of this adulterous plantings remained in the text in the newer Bibles.
It should be noted, however, that shoots are fruitless plants which grow beside the trunk of the vine, whence vitulamen is said from vitis (vine); or according to some it is said from vitulus (calf), because such a plant grows in land plowed by calves or oxen. Spurious, however, means the same as ignoble or degenerate; whence spurious shoots, that is, degenerate or unnatural plantings, and adulterous plantings, that is, impious generations, born from spiritual adultery, namely, multiplied through the propagation of impiety: Matthew 12: "An evil and adulterous generation seeks a sign."
They shall not take deep root, in themselves, that is, thoughts and affections reaching toward heaven, but fixed in the earth. For man according to the Philosopher is an inverted tree; whence he ought to send and fix his roots upward, namely, his intellect and affection; whence in the Psalm: "The meditation of my heart is always in your sight"; likewise: "Our feet were standing in your courts, O Jerusalem"; likewise: "Lord, before you is all my desire"; likewise Colossians 3: "Seek the things that are above," namely, by searching with the intellect; "savor the things that are above," by savoring with the affection; the Psalm: "Taste and see." Nor shall they establish a stable support, or foundation, namely of right faith toward God: for faith is as it were the foundation of the spiritual edifice; whence Hebrews 11: "Faith is the substance of things hoped for," etc.; 1 Corinthians 3: "No one can lay another foundation besides that which has been laid, which is Christ Jesus," that is, faith concerning Christ Jesus.
Otherwise, according to the Gloss, it is expounded concerning heretics and their disciples.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And if in the branches, that is, in exterior goods, etc. Such were the branches of that Babylonian tree, namely Nebuchadnezzar, Daniel chapter four. They budded for a time, that is, for a short time they showed some beginning of good, according to that passage of Isaiah chapter eighteen: "The unripe fruit shall bud forth." Being weakly established, "that is, for an hour," as the Gloss says; or: weakly established, that is, feebly rooted in good, they shall be shaken by the wind, that is, by a lighter temptation, according to that passage of Ezekiel chapter seventeen: "Shall it not wither when the burning wind touches it?" And by the violence of winds, that is, by a more severe persecution, they shall be uprooted: the Gloss: "They shall be utterly torn out"; Matthew chapter fifteen: "Every plant which my heavenly Father has not planted shall be uprooted."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the imperfect branches shall be broken off, namely, without hope of restoration, by the most severe persecution: Job chapter fifteen: "The flame shall wither his branches"; or: for the imperfect branches shall be broken off, that is, their teachings or works lacking the perfection of charity; Colossians chapter three: "Above all things have charity, which is the bond of perfection." And their fruit, namely their own, that is, their evil works, according to that passage of Matthew chapter seven: "A bad tree brings forth bad fruit"; is useless, so as not to nourish: Isaiah chapter fifty-nine: "Their works are useless works." And bitter to eat, so as not to delight but to torment: Deuteronomy chapter thirty-two: "Their grape is a grape of gall, and their cluster most bitter"; Ezekiel chapter eighteen: "The fathers have eaten a sour grape," etc. And fit for nothing, so that they profit in nothing from themselves: Ezekiel chapter fifteen: "When it was whole, it was not fit for any work: how much more, when the fire has devoured it."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From the wicked, etc., as if to say: truly the manifold multitude of the ungodly shall not be profitable, etc. For all children who are born from the wicked, not only by birth of propagation, but also of imitation, concerning which John chapter eight says: "You are of your father the devil." They are witnesses of wickedness against their parents, through the likeness of depravity, in their examination, that is, in the scrutiny of divine judgment, for God the just judge "will examine their works," below in chapter six; likewise their words: Matthew chapter twelve: "Of every idle word," etc.; likewise their thoughts: above in chapter one: "There shall be examination of the thoughts of the ungodly," etc.
Allegorically, the Gloss expounds this concerning heretics, who are a manifold multitude, because they are divided through the diverse sects of diverse heresiarchs: who are useless to the Church, nay rather harmful, because they persecute her. Adulterous plantings are their disciples, who are generated from their erroneous doctrine. They do not put down deep roots, because they are not established in Christ, God and man. Their branches are unstable, because, if they seem to have anything good, in a time of persecution they are uprooted from the Church. Their fruit is useless, because by their doctrines and expositions simple people are poisoned. Their children are witnesses of wickedness against their parents, because from the multiplication of disciples the errors of the master will be more gravely condemned.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the just man, etc., as if to say: thus it is with the wicked: but, standing for however: if the just man shall have been overtaken by death, that is, prevented by death hastened before its time, according to that passage in Isaiah thirty-eight: "While I was yet beginning, he cut me off." He well said: overtaken, because the just man cannot die by sudden death, that is, by unforeseen death, because it is said in the Psalm concerning the person of the just man: "I foresaw the Lord in my sight always," etc.; likewise: "My soul is in my hands always," as if to say: I am prepared to render it up, whenever it shall please God that I die. The just man, I say, if he shall have been overtaken, shall be in refreshment, namely of eternal rest: the Psalm: "We passed through fire and water, and you led us out into refreshment."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For old age etc., as if to say: nor does the being overtaken in age cause harm: for venerable old age etc.: the Gloss: "Not the age of the body, but the maturity of life and the uprightness of morals is praised"; venerable, I say, that is, worthy of veneration before God and the Angels and just men: is not of long duration, by a multitude of days: Job thirty-two: "The wise are not long-lived"; nor reckoned by the number of years, that is, nor by a multitude of years. "For a child of a hundred years shall die, and a sinner of a hundred years shall be accursed," Isaiah sixty-five.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For gray hairs are the understanding of a man, that is, in place of gray hairs: the Gloss: "As if to say: he is well gray-haired who is well endowed with understanding," according to that passage in Daniel thirteen: "God has given you the honor of old age," that is, discretion and wisdom, which is wont to be in the elderly, according to that passage in Job twelve: "In the ancients is wisdom, and in length of time prudence"; likewise Sirach twenty-five: "The crown of the aged is great experience."
And the age of old age, that is, supplying the place of age, an unspotted life, "as if to say: well is the old man who is clean and simple": Proverbs 16: "Old age is a crown of dignity, which shall be found in the ways of justice."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Pleasing God, namely through true faith, according to that passage in Hebrews 11: "Without faith it is impossible to please God": he was made beloved, on account of perfect love, according to that passage in Proverbs 8: "I love those who love me": and living, namely through grace, not dying through sin; among sinners, namely undefiled, which is a very great thing, since it is written in the Psalm: "With the perverse you shall be perverted"; but the just man is as a lily among thorns, because he neither loses the brightness of his purity nor the fragrance of his good name: Song of Songs 2: "As the lily among thorns" etc. He was taken away, from the exile of this world to the heavenly homeland, from death to life, from struggle to the crown.
It should be noted that the transfer is manifold: the first, from sin to grace: 1 John 3: "We know that we have been transferred from death," namely of sin, "to life," of grace, "because we love the brethren." The second, from imperfect grace to perfect grace: 2 Corinthians 3: "We are transformed into the same image from glory to glory, as by the Spirit of the Lord." The third, from perfect grace to glory: of which it speaks here: He was taken away.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He was snatched away, as if to say: he was not only taken away, but snatched away, because he died quickly and was taken up as if by violence beyond nature's due course. Now there is a rapture of the Saints in their life: whence Second Corinthians twelve: "I know a man fourteen years ago caught up" etc.; and in death, concerning which it is said here: He was snatched away etc.; and after death, concerning which First Thessalonians four: "We shall be caught up with them in the clouds to meet Christ in the air." He was snatched away, I say, lest malice, that is, open iniquity, should alter his understanding, by turning him away from the truth and sincerity of faith; or lest deceit, that is, feigned righteousness, concerning which Augustine says: "Feigned righteousness is not righteousness, but a twofold iniquity, because it is both iniquity and pretense." Lest deceit, I say, should deceive, that is, corrupt, his soul, namely by turning his affection away from the love of God: Second Corinthians eleven: "I fear lest, as the serpent seduced Eve by his cunning, so your senses should be corrupted."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the bewitching etc., as if to say: it was indeed necessary for him that he should be thus snatched away etc.; for the bewitching of vanity, from without, that is, trifling and flattering praise, according to which malicious men are said to bewitch children by praising them, obscures good things, namely those of the just, even if it does not destroy them; obscures, I say, because it causes the defects and imperfections of those very goods not to be seen, and through this causes pride in them; Galatians three: "O foolish Galatians! who has bewitched you" etc.; First Corinthians fifteen: "Evil communications corrupt good manners." And the inconstancy of concupiscence, from within, namely of the concupiscible appetite, which makes a man inconstant: James one: "A double-minded man," namely one who partly follows reason, partly sensuality, "is inconstant in all his ways." The inconstancy, I say, of concupiscence, that is, of the concupiscible appetite, perverts, namely from good to evil, the sense that is without malice, that is, one previously good and simple: James one: "Every man is tempted by his own concupiscence, drawn away and enticed."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Being made perfect in a short time, that is, perfected in grace in a brief span of time: Isaiah ten: "A short consummation shall overflow with justice"; he fulfilled a long time, namely by the fulfillment of merit, because he acquired in a short time the merit that others acquire over many ages; or by the fulfillment of reward, because he attained eternity, which in its perfection surpasses many ages.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For his soul was pleasing to God: behold, the cause of consummation, namely divine grace and love. Pleasing, I say, through faith of heart inwardly and gentleness of conduct outwardly: Sirach 1: "Faith and gentleness are well-pleasing to God." Therefore he hastened to lead him out from the midst of iniquities, that is, from the world, which is full of iniquity: 1 John 5: "The whole world is set in wickedness."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the peoples: Gloss: "The persecutors"; seeing, "the punishment," and not understanding, "the future glory," nor laying up in their hearts, that is, inwardly in the heart, although they sometimes hear it preached: Isaiah 57: "The just man perishes, and there is no one who considers it"; such things, namely, which follow: above in chapter 3: "They seemed in the eyes of the foolish to die, but they are in peace."
Because the grace of God, namely for working well: 1 Corinthians 15: "Not I, but the grace of God with me": and mercy is upon his holy ones, for delivering from evils: Sirach last chapter: "You have delivered me according to the multitude of the mercy of your name": and regard is upon his elect, namely for attaining the reward: Gloss: "That is, condign retribution." And note that they are called holy through present justice; elect, through eternal predestination, according to that text in Ephesians 1: "He chose us in him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and immaculate in his sight in charity."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the just man who is dead condemns the living impious: Gloss: "The martyr his persecutors," namely by comparison of a better deed, as the Ninevites, Matthew 12. And youth more quickly consummated, namely of the just man, condemns the long life of the unjust: Gloss: "That is, of the persecutor," because he did more good in a short time than that one in a long time, whence he shall be judged more strictly: Apocalypse 2: "I gave her time to do penance, and she does not wish to repent" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“They shall see etc. Here is set forth a twofold reason for the aforesaid condemnation, namely ignorance and contempt. The first he sets forth saying: For they shall see, namely the impious, the end, "that is, death," as the Gloss says. Of the wise man: the Gloss: "That is, of the Martyr": whence concerning the Martyr is read that passage of Sirach fourteen: "Blessed is the man who shall abide in wisdom." And they shall not understand what God has purposed concerning him, "that is, what He has purposed to give him in the future, according to the Gloss, eternal life"; Proverbs twenty-eight: "Evil men do not consider judgment." And why the Lord has fortified him, namely in the present life: the Gloss: "With the arms of faith," according to that passage in Ephesians six: "In all things taking up the shield of faith"; likewise: "Put on the armor of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Then he sets forth the second reason saying: They shall see him, as if to say: and because they do not understand these things, they shall see him, the Gloss: "Die"; and they shall despise him, whence below in the fifth chapter: "These are they whom we once held in derision" etc.; likewise Job twelve: "The simplicity of the just man is laughed to scorn." Thus the Jews despised Christ in His dying.
But them, namely the impious, the Lord shall deride: the Gloss: "At the judgment," that is, He shall judge them worthy of derision as fools: Psalm: "He who dwells in heaven shall deride them" etc. Not only at the general judgment, but also at the particular judgment, that is, at death: whence Proverbs one: "I also will laugh at your destruction" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And after these things they shall be, namely after the persecution of the good and the Lord's derision, that is, after they have afflicted the good in the present life, and they themselves have been derided by God at death: they shall be falling, that is, falling downward through the fall of death into hell: Psalm: "Even as the green herbs they shall quickly fall." Without honor, that is, of the society of the blessed: and in reproach, namely of the confusion of the reprobate: among the dead: the Gloss: "The damned"; forever, that is, without end: Jeremiah twenty-three: "I will give you over to everlasting reproach and to perpetual shame, which shall never be blotted out by oblivion."
There follows therefore: For he shall break etc. I have rightly said that they shall be falling etc., for he shall break them, "namely the Lord," according to the Gloss: Hosea thirteen: "I will rend the inner parts of their liver." Them, I say, puffed up, with the wind of pride: First Corinthians five: "And you are puffed up, and have not rather mourned." Without voice, "of excuse"; Matthew twenty-two: "But he was struck dumb." And he shall move them from their foundations: Gloss: "He shall overturn their life, which they thought to be stable": Job twenty-two: "Who were taken away before their time, and a flood overturned their foundation." And they shall be laid waste even to the uttermost, that is, to such an extent that they shall lose the highest place, that is, even to this, that they shall be excluded from the loftiness of glory, as the foolish virgins, of whom it is read that "the door was shut," Matthew twenty-five. And they shall be laid waste even to the highest degree, that is, they shall be punished until they pay the last farthing, that is, the penalty for every sin, both great and small: Matthew five: "You shall not go out from there until you pay the last farthing." The first exposition, however, accords more with the aforesaid division. And they shall be groaning: Gloss: "In punishments: because they shall be lifted up by no consolation." And their memory, not any whatsoever, but of happy remembrance, shall perish, before God and men, according to that verse of the Psalm: "The face of the Lord is upon those who do evil, to destroy their memory from the earth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“They shall come at last, namely at the end of the world: whence the Gloss: "To judgment"; for then they shall go out from hell. They shall come, I say, in the thought of their sins, their conscience gnawing at them, fearful, on account of the punishment to be inflicted: below in chapter five: "Seeing this, they shall be troubled with terrible fear." And they shall convict them: Gloss: "Into eternal fire"; from the opposite side: Gloss: "Accusing them," as an adversary accuses his adversary; their own iniquities, that is, sins perpetrated by them in heart, mouth, or deed; Jeremiah two: "Your own wickedness shall reprove you." Sins, moreover, are said to accuse the reprobate, because they shall be the matter of their accusation and damnation: Romans two: "Of thoughts among themselves accusing, or also defending" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, the state of the just is compared to the state of the unjust in the judgment itself with respect to three things.
Then shall the just stand etc. Here he compares the state of the just to the state of the unjust in the judgment itself. And first he touches upon the steadfast accusation of the just: second, the forced confession of the reprobate: Seeing this, they shall be troubled: third, the just retribution of both: But the just shall live forever.
First, concerning the accusation of the just.
(Verse 1). Then shall the just stand etc., as if thus: The impious shall come to judgment fearful: then: The Gloss: "When the peoples shall be judged," namely on the last day: and he says then, indeterminately, because "of that day no one knows," Matthew twenty-four: likewise Acts one: "It is not for you to know the times or moments which the Father has placed in his own power." They shall stand, namely those who in the present had seemed to fall or to lie prostrate: Luke sixteen: "There was a certain beggar named Lazarus, who lay at his gate." On the contrary, the wicked, who now seem to stand, shall then lie prostrate: Proverbs fourteen: "The wicked shall lie prostrate before the good." They shall stand, I say, the just in great constancy, that is, steadfastly and boldly on account of the confidence which they shall have.
The confidence of the Saints in the judgment shall arise from seven things. From the justice of their cause: Job thirteen: "If I shall be judged, I know that I shall be found just"; likewise in the Psalm: "Judge me, O Lord, according to my justice."
Second, from the sufficiency or abundance of proofs: for they shall have proof ready through a written instrument: Job thirty-one: "Let him who judges write the book himself" etc.: likewise Apocalypse twenty: "The dead were judged from those things which were written in the books"; likewise through witnesses: Job sixteen: "Behold, my witness is in heaven," namely God himself; whence Jeremiah twenty-nine: "I am the judge and witness, says the Lord." Third, from the faithfulness of their advocates: First John two: "We have an advocate in heaven, Jesus Christ"; likewise the Holy Spirit: Romans eight: "The Spirit intercedes" etc.: likewise the Blessed Virgin: whence we cry out: "Our Advocate" etc.
Fourth, from the powerlessness of their adversaries, according to that word of the Psalm: "The impious shall not rise in judgment," namely to accuse the just: Apocalypse twelve: "The accuser was cast out" etc.
Fifth, from the friendship and kinship of their judge: Genesis thirty-seven: "He is our flesh and our brother": Bernard: "I think he will not be able to spurn me, bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh."
Sixth, from the benevolence of the assessors, that is, the Apostles: Matthew nineteen: "You also shall sit upon twelve seats, judging" etc.: likewise Job thirty-six: "He grants judgment to the poor."
Seventh, from the familiarity of the officials of the judge, namely the Angels: Matthew thirteen: "The Angels shall go forth and shall separate the wicked from the midst of the just."
Against them: Gloss: "Their persecutors," who distressed them: Gloss: "In martyrdom," afflicting them personally: Hebrews eleven: "Distressed, afflicted," etc. And who took away their labors, bodily, namely despoiling them through violence, although the Saints bore these things joyfully: whence Hebrews ten: "You accepted the plundering of your goods with joy." Or: labors, spiritual, attempting to take away their fruit, namely by provoking them to sin: concerning this fruit above in chapter three: "Glorious is the fruit of good labors." Or: both together, according to the Gloss: "Namely by judging their bodily and spiritual labors vain and foolish."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, concerning the confession of the reprobate in three ways.
Seeing, they shall be troubled, etc. Here he touches upon the forced confession of the reprobate: and first he touches upon the motive for such a confession: second, the matter of the confession: These are they whom once: third, the confirmation of their confession: Such things they said, etc.
A twofold motive for the confession is touched upon, namely affliction over the true happiness of the good, and anxiety over their own unhappiness — Saying within themselves, etc.
(Verse 2). There follows therefore: Seeing: Gloss: "Themselves led from glory to punishment, and their adversaries transferred from punishment to the crown"; they shall be troubled with horrible fear: Exodus fifteen: "Then the princes of Edom were troubled": likewise Ezekiel seven: "Trouble upon trouble shall come," namely the trouble over the affliction of the resumed body upon the trouble previously had over the affliction of the soul previously tormented in the flames of Gehenna. With horrible fear, namely on account of the constancy of their accusers, of whom above in the same chapter. Second, on account of the severity of the divine judgments, according to that passage in Hebrews ten: "It is a horrible thing to fall into the hands of the living God"; likewise below in chapter six: "Horribly and swiftly shall he appear to you." Third, on account of the presence of horrible torturers; Job twenty: "Horrible ones shall go and come upon him." Or thus: They shall be troubled, on account of the gnawing conscience: with fear, on account of the irrevocable sentence of the judge: horrible, on account of the visible presence of the prepared punishments and horrible torturers. And they shall marvel at the suddenness, that is, the sudden attainment, of salvation, namely of the just, unhoped for, that is, not expected by the impious themselves, yet hoped for by the just, according to that passage of the Psalm: "In you our fathers hoped," etc. Groaning, inwardly, from anguish of spirit, from the consideration of that glory and salvation which they lost: First Kings four: "The Philistines groaned, saying: Woe to us," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 3). Saying within themselves, by an interior speech, and they do not engage in exterior speech, perhaps on account of the vehemence of their grief. Doing penance, for the evil that they did: penance, but a late one, like the penance of the rich man, of whom it is said in Luke 16: "Father Abraham, have mercy on me," etc.: doing, or rather suffering. This is the penance of despair, like the penance of Judas, of whom it is read in Matthew 27 that "moved by penance, he returned the thirty pieces of silver." And groaning from the anguish of spirit, on account of the evil of punishment which they incurred: Isaiah 65: "From the sorrow of spirit you shall howl," etc.
These are they whom once etc. Here he sets forth the matter of the confession of the impious confessing their own error, first concerning the life of the just: second concerning their own life: We are wearied etc.
In the first, they first confess their past contempt and mockery of the Saints: second, their rejection of the Saints' state: We fools etc.: third, their then present exaltation: Behold, how they are numbered: fourth, their own error: Therefore we have erred.
(Verse 3). These, namely those worthy of mocking display according to the judgment of the impious, are they whom we once held in derision, by deeds and signs: Job 12: "The simplicity of the just man is laughed to scorn": likewise in the Psalm: "All who saw me mocked me," etc. And as a likeness of reproach, reproaching with words: in the Psalm: "The reproaches of those who reproached you fell upon me." But when a good work is reproached in a man, which is rather matter for praise, it is not a true reproach, but a likeness of reproach: on account of which it is said here: as a likeness of reproach: 2 Corinthians 6: "Through infamy and good fame," etc.; Acts 5: "The Apostles went rejoicing," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 4). We fools etc, living in the manner of foolish children: fools, I say, because we did not perceive things as they were: Ecclesiasticus 16: "In all these things the heart is foolish"; 1 Corinthians 14: "Do not be children in understanding." Their life, that is, their manner of life, which was in poverty, labor, lowliness, fasting, etc.: we esteemed madness. So David was reputed insane by Achish, 1 Kings 21; so also Christ: John 8: "Do we not say well that you are a Samaritan and have a demon?" Likewise John 10: "He has a demon and is mad"; so the messenger of Elisha, 4 Kings 9: "Why did this madman come to you?" Hosea 9: "Know, O Israel, that the prophet is a fool and the spiritual man is mad"; a fool, namely in temporal things, and mad, according to the judgment of the worldly. And their end, that is, death, without honor, namely of any recompense: against which it is said in the Psalm: "Your friends are exceedingly honored, O God"; likewise John 12: "If anyone serves me, my Father will honor him," who is in heaven.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 5). How then are they numbered among the children of God? Through grace: Romans 8: "You have not received again the spirit of bondage in fear, but you have received the spirit of adoption of children," etc.; likewise John 1: "He gave them power to become children of God," etc. And among the Saints their lot is, that is, the portion of glory, of which in the Psalm: "Let my portion, O Lord, be in the land of the living"; likewise Colossians 1: "Who has made us worthy for a share in the lot of the Saints in light." And these things are against the two things which they had said: for they had said that the life of the Saints was foolish and their end disgraceful.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The impious say: "Therefore we have erred from the way of truth and justice: the light has not shone upon us, and the sun of intelligence has not risen upon us." This is the sun that illumines all: from which some go astray. Insofar as God is the reason of understanding, he enters the soul as the sun of intelligence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 6). Therefore we have erred etc. They conclude against themselves: whence that word of the Psalm is verified: "Their tongues have been weakened against them." We have erred, they say: for they approved false things as true: but Augustine says that "to approve false things as true is proper to error": Isaiah 19: "They have caused Egypt to err in all its work, as a drunkard staggers and vomits." From the way of truth: The Gloss: "Of the Gospel of the divine law," with respect to believing; Isaiah 53: "All we like sheep have gone astray: each one has turned aside to his own way." And the light of justice, with respect to acting: the light of justice, taken intransitively, that is, justice which is light, according to that word of the Psalm: "Light has risen for the just"; likewise Proverbs 4: "The path of the just is as a shining light" etc. Has not shone upon us; Isaiah 59: "We waited for light, and behold darkness"! This was the cause of their error, just as a lack of light is the cause of going astray. And the sun of understanding, namely with respect to enkindling: The Gloss: "Christ, the sun of justice, who rises upon those who fear God," as is found in the last chapter of Malachi: has not risen upon us. It should be noted that the deficiency is not on the part of the sun, but on the part of those who lie in darkness and are unwilling to rise and do not seek to open their eyes: the Psalm: "Fire," of envy, "fell upon them, and they did not see the sun," of justice. The material sun indeed rises upon the good and the evil, as is clear from Matthew 5: "Who makes his sun to rise upon the good and the evil," but the sun of understanding rises only upon the good, as is clear here.
But Christ is called the sun, because the sun is so called as if "alone shining" [solus lucens]: but Christ shines singularly, that is, above all others as the light of the world and its eye: John 1: "He was the true light, which enlightens every man coming into this world," even by the illumination of natural knowledge. "For he is the teacher who, having his chair in heaven, teaches the hearts of men on earth," as Augustine says. Likewise John 8: "I am the light of the world." Likewise, because by the illumination of the moon, that is, of the Church: Ecclesiasticus 50: "As the full moon shines in its days," namely from the irradiation of the sun. Likewise, because he is the fountain of all heat, that is, of spiritual love: the Psalm: "In the sun he has set his tabernacle"; and afterward: "There is none who can hide himself from his heat": 2 Maccabees 1: "The time came when the sun shone forth, which before was in a cloud: and a great fire was kindled" etc.: likewise Luke 12: "I have come to cast fire upon the earth," that is, heat.
Likewise, because he is the father of spiritual plants, that is, of all spiritual sprouting: John 15: "He who abides in me, and I in him, bears much fruit, because without me you can do nothing."
But he is called the sun of understanding because his light is apprehended by the eye of understanding alone, because by his ray, namely by the spirit of understanding, the intelligence is illuminated.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We are wearied etc. Here he touches upon the confession of the error of the impious concerning their own life: and first they confess the toilsomeness of their own life; second, the blindness: But the way of the Lord; third, the uselessness: What has profited us etc.; fourth, the instability: They have passed away.
(Verse 7). We are wearied therefore, by our own strength, in the way of iniquity, as regards guilt in the present: Jeremiah 9: "They have labored to act unjustly"; and of perdition, as regards punishment in the future; Proverbs 2: "The impious shall be destroyed from the earth, and those who act unjustly shall be taken away from it." Nor is it a wonder if we are wearied by our own strength, because we have walked difficult ways, by their very nature, namely the ways of sinners, which greatly afflict the soul in the present through the remorse of conscience. For the order of divine justice does not permit that even for a moment there be guilt without punishment.
Whence Augustine: "You have commanded, O Lord, and so it is, that every disordered soul is its own punishment"; Sirach 21: "The way of sinners is paved with stones."
But against this: Matthew 7: "Wide is the gate and broad is the way that leads to perdition."
It must be said that it is easy at the entrance, as if strewn with flowers, namely with the sweetness of present delight and temporal pleasure; but difficult in its progress on account of the remorse of conscience; more difficult at its exit on account of separation from present pleasure; but most difficult after the exit on account of the torment of hell.
But the way of the Lord, namely that by which the Lord comes to us, by which we go to him, namely charity, according to that word of the Apostle, 1 Corinthians 12: "I show you a yet more excellent way"; we have not known, namely with a crass and affected ignorance; whence Job 21: "Who say to God: Depart from us, we desire not the knowledge of your ways." He who is ignorant with such ignorance "shall be ignored," as the Apostle says, 1 Corinthians 14.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 8). What has pride profited us, namely in the excellence of honors, as if to say: nothing; indeed rather it has harmed us, because it is said in the Psalm: "He will repay abundantly those who act with pride"; Proverbs 16: "Pride precedes destruction"; Luke 1: "He has scattered the proud in the conceit of their heart." Or the boasting of riches, namely concerning the abundance of exterior goods, what has it conferred upon us? As if to say: nothing; Ecclesiastes 5: "He who loves riches shall reap no fruit from them"; likewise Luke 6: "Woe to you who are rich!" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“They passed away etc. Here he touches on the confession of the instability of the state of the reprobate under a manifold metaphor: first under the metaphor of a shadow; second, of a messenger: As a messenger; third, of a ship: And as a ship; fourth, of a bird: Or a bird; fifth, of an arrow: Or as an arrow.
(Verses 9, 10). All those things passed away, namely riches, pleasures, and honors of secular power: whence 1 John 2: "Everything that is in the world" etc., and in the same place below: "The world passes away and its concupiscence": that is, the concupiscible things that are in it, namely as regards the outward form, not as regards substance: whence 1 Corinthians 7: "The form of this world passes away." As a shadow, namely by darkening the mind: Ecclesiasticus 34: "As one who grasps at a shadow and pursues the wind, so is he who attends to lying visions," because the soul, by its turning toward earthly things, is darkened and eclipsed by the interposition of the earth between it and the true sun.
And as a messenger running ahead, by its passing removing the mind: Job 9: "My days were swifter than a runner." And as a ship that passes through the surging water, by enduring many tribulations: Luke 10: "You are troubled about many things." Of which, when it has passed, no trace is to be found, namely in the water: Proverbs 30: "Three things are difficult for me, etc., the way of a ship in the midst of the sea." Nor the path of its keel in the waves, that is, of the small boat, which usually accompanies the larger ship for escape from danger. Or: keel can be said to be the middle part or the middle place of the ship, according to those verses:
The prow is the front part of the ship, the stern the last part. Call the side the hull, call the belly the keel.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verses 11, 12). Or a bird, namely, by exalting the heart into pride and wantonness: Proverbs 10: "He who relies on lies feeds the winds: and the same pursues birds in flight." Which flies across through the air, namely swiftly, of which no evidence is found, namely no certain sign, of the passage of that one: but only a sound is heard, a sound, I say, of wings beating the light wind, that is, the moved air, according to that saying of Damascene: "Wind is moved air": and cutting, that is, dividing, by the force of its passage the air, namely the still air. So the light sound of fame accompanies the wicked, according to that saying of the Psalm: "They called their names upon their lands": Isaiah 18: "Woe to the land of the cymbal of wings," etc. And with wings set in motion, it flew across, namely to another place: Hosea 9: "Ephraim flew away like a bird." And after this no sign, that is, no certain indication, is found of its passage: Proverbs 30: "Three things are difficult for me, etc., the way of the eagle in the sky"; likewise Job 28: "The bird knew not the path, nor did the eye of the vulture behold it." Or as an arrow, namely, by wounding the heart fatally; shot toward its appointed place, by the archer: Proverbs 7: "Until the arrow pierces his liver." The divided air, namely by the motion of the arrow, immediately closed back upon itself, so that its passage might be unknown. The Gloss: "Because it left no traces of itself."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 13). So we also, having been born, immediately ceased to exist, that is, quickly after birth; or: immediately we ceased, that is, we began to cease, according to that saying of Augustine: "What is our life but a continuous course toward death?" The Gloss: "So also the course of this life is uncertain and unstable"; Job 14: "Man born of woman, etc., and flees like a shadow." Or: we cease to exist continually, through the acceleration of sinning. And indeed we were unable to show any sign of virtue, namely in our life through good conduct: Mark, last chapter: "These signs shall follow those who believe"; Galatians, last chapter: "I bear the marks of the Lord Jesus in my body." In our wickedness for we were consumed, through final impenitence; Job 13: "I who am to be consumed like rottenness": John 8: "You shall die in your sin."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such things they said, etc. Behold, the confirmation of their confession through fitting examples, first, through the example of down: second, of foam: And as foam: third, of smoke: And as smoke: fourth, of a guest: And as the memory of a guest.
(Verse 14). Such things therefore said in hell those who sinned: they said, I say, by interior speech through the remorse of conscience, even if not perhaps by exterior speech, since they are in hell without bodies until the day of judgment and without bodily organs, although not without the powers of the organs: Luke 16: "Lifting up his eyes," that is, the power of sight, which had used the organs of the eyes in the present life.
In hell etc. How did this author know that they thus said in hell? Since he had never been there, nor had another come from there who had reported it to him: whence above in chapter two: "No one has been recognized who has returned from the underworld."
It can be said that he knew this through the revelation of the Holy Spirit, because, according to Ambrose, every truth, by whomever it is spoken, is uttered at the dictation of the Holy Spirit: likewise 2 Peter 1: "Holy men of God spoke, inspired by the Holy Spirit." Or: They said, that is, they were able to say.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 15). Because etc., as if to say: and they spoke truly, because the hope of the ungodly, that is, temporal prosperity, in which the ungodly place their hope: Isaiah twenty-eight: "We have made falsehood our hope"; is like down, that is, the flower of the thistle, with respect to the fragility of the flesh: which is carried away by the wind, that is, by a slight breeze: the Gloss: "Down expresses the fragility of the flesh, which is quickly carried away by the wind of sickness or trouble"; Isaiah forty: "All flesh is grass." And rightly is the fragility of the flesh compared to the flower of the thistle, because the flesh generates thorns and thistles of temptations: whence Genesis three: "Thorns and thistles shall it bring forth to you." And like thin foam, generated from the agitation of waters, which is scattered by the storm. Like foam etc., he speaks with respect to the vanity of boasting: whence the Gloss: "This is the appetite for human favor and popular boasting, which is scattered by the storm of tribulation and of some present or eternal adversity": Hosea ten: "Samaria has caused her king to pass away, as foam passes over the face of the water"; likewise Jeremiah twenty-three: "Behold, the whirlwind of the Lord's indignation shall go forth, and a tempest shall burst upon the head of the ungodly." And like smoke, which is dispersed by the wind, with respect to the brevity of life: James four: "What is your life? It is a vapor appearing for a little while"; dispersed by the wind: for when it is lifted on high, it is forced to vanish, according to that saying of the Psalm: "As soon as they are honored and exalted, failing they shall fail like smoke"; the Gloss: "Just as smoke is dissolved by the wind, so is human life by the change of times." And like the memory of a guest of one day passing through, with respect to the brief duration of fame: Job thirteen: "Your memory shall be compared to ashes." He compares man existing in this life to a guest, because we are pilgrims and guests as if in another's house, according to that saying of the Psalm: "I am a sojourner with you and a pilgrim, as all my fathers were": likewise Hebrews eleven: "Confessing that they are pilgrims" etc. Passing through, because we pass from life to death: Lamentations one: "O all you who pass by the way" etc.; likewise Ecclesiastes one: "A generation passes away" etc. Of one day, because we remain here but a short time; whence Hebrews thirteen: "We have not here a lasting city" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If long and healthful life: there is sound eternity and eternal soundness, because the just shall live forever, and: The salvation of the just is from the Lord. If fullness: they shall be satisfied, when the glory of God shall appear. If inebriation: they shall be inebriated with the plenty of the house of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, concerning the retribution of the just and the reprobate, in two ways.
But the just forever. Here he sets forth the fitting retribution of the just and the reprobate, and first, the reward of the just; second, the punishment of the reprobate: And he shall take up armor.
He touches upon a twofold reward of the just: first, for the doing of good; and second, for the victory over evil: Therefore they shall receive etc.
(Verse 16). But the just etc., as if to say: such is the life and death of the impious: but, that is, "however." The just, on the contrary, shall live forever: The Gloss: "They shall live with eternal life," of which John 17: "This is eternal life" etc. And with the Lord, that is, in the Lord himself through hope, according to the Gloss: in the Psalm: "But it is good for me to adhere to God," namely through charity, "it is good to place my hope in the Lord God"; is their reward: The Gloss: "The recompense of labor": for he himself is the reward of the Saints: Genesis 15: "I am your protector and your reward exceedingly great": likewise Numbers 18: "I am your portion and your inheritance in the midst of the children of Israel." And their thought etc., as if to say: and deservedly with the Lord is their reward, because their thought, that is, their whole solicitude and intention through faith, is with the Most High, according to that passage of the Psalm: "Cast your thought upon the Lord" etc. Or: thought, that is, the knowledge of their understanding, is with the Most High alone: for the just think only about God, or about those things which contribute to possessing him, according to that passage of 1 Corinthians 7: "The unmarried woman thinks about the things of the Lord."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 17). And because they are such in the present, therefore they shall receive the kingdom of glory, that is, a glorious kingdom with respect to the golden crown or the essential reward; Matthew 5: "Blessed are the poor" etc. And the crown of beauty, that is, a beautiful one: The Gloss: "The enemy having been conquered"—and this with respect to the aureole or with respect to the accidental reward: 2 Timothy 4: "There is laid up for me a crown of justice." Concerning both, Exodus 25. From the hand of God, or of the Lord; The Gloss: "That is, from Christ, who is called the hand and arm and right hand of God the Father." For he is the hand by working: "For all things were made through him," John 1: the arm by protecting, according to that passage of the Psalm: "My arm shall strengthen him"; the right hand by rewarding: Matthew 25: "He shall set the sheep on his right hand." For his right hand shall cover them: The Gloss: "Here and in the future," from the wrath of the supreme Judge: Isaiah 49: "In the shadow of his hand he protected me": Sirach 34: "A shelter from the heat and a shade from the noonday." And with his holy arm, that is, of his holy power, he shall defend them, namely from every attack of the adversary, according to that passage of the Psalm: "The Lord is the defender of my life, of whom shall I be afraid?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he shall take armor etc. Here he touches upon the punishment of the reprobate under the metaphor of a king taking up arms against his adversaries. And first he describes the king's purpose: second, his equipment: He shall put on etc.: third, the battle: They shall go forth directly: fourth, the effect of the battle: And he shall bring to desolation: fifth, the remedy for the battle: Better is wisdom.
(Verse 18). And he shall take armor, namely against adversaries, his zeal: Proverbs six: "The zeal and fury of a man will not spare in the day of vengeance." "His arms, however, are truth, justice, and judgment," according to the Gloss. And he will arm the creature, namely as his army, according to that passage below in chapter sixteen: "The creature serving you its Maker burns against the unjust"; for the vengeance upon enemies: Psalm: "God of vengeances" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He shall put on justice for a breastplate: justice is compared to a coat of mail or breastplate, because, just as a coat of mail protects the whole body, so justice protects the soul on every side: whence Second Corinthians six: "By the armor of justice on the right hand and on the left"; Isaiah fifty-nine: "He put on justice as a breastplate." And he shall take sure judgment for a helmet, or certain: right judgment, that is, discernment, and it is compared to a helmet, which is the defense of the head, that is, of reason: Proverbs sixteen: "Divination is on the lips of the king; in judgment his mouth shall not err."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He shall take equity for an invincible shield: to a shield, which defends the coat of mail, equity is compared, because it renders justice irreproachable: Isaiah eleven: "He shall reprove in equity for the meek of the earth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since justice necessarily requires that the human being, who merited or demerited not in soul alone nor in body alone, but in soul and body together, be punished or rewarded in both; the reformation of grace also requires that the whole body be conformed to Christ the Head, whose dead body necessarily had to rise, since it was inseparably united to the Divinity; and the completion of nature requires that the human being consist simultaneously of body and soul as of matter and form, which have a mutual appetite and mutual inclination: it is necessary that the resurrection be future, since the constitution of nature, the infusion of grace, and the retribution of justice demand this, according to which the whole universe is governed. And therefore from these three all things cry out that the human being must be raised, so that every excuse may be taken away from those who are deaf to this truth of faith, and deservedly against such people the whole world fights.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And he shall sharpen his fierce wrath; he says fierce to distinguish it from the light wrath with which he is now angry; for a spear: the wrath of God is compared to a spear, because it will reach even whatever is remote and will penetrate: Ezekiel twenty-one: "The sword is sharpened" etc.; likewise Exodus fifteen: "You sent forth your wrath, which devoured them as stubble." And the whole world shall fight with him against the senseless: Gregory: "When the Creator is offended, every creature is offended"; the Gloss: "The Creator through the creature subject to him corrects the offenders." That battle shall be terrible, concerning which Job forty: "Remember the battle, and speak no more."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He therefore who is not illumined by such great splendors of created things is blind; he who is not awakened by such great cries is deaf; he who does not praise God on account of all these effects is mute; he who from such great signs does not advert to the first principle is a fool. Open therefore your eyes, bring near your spiritual ears, loose your lips, and apply your heart, that in all creatures you may see, hear, praise, love, and worship, magnify and honor your God, lest perchance the whole world rise up against you. For on this account the whole world shall fight against the senseless, and conversely for the wise it shall be matter of glory, who according to the Prophet can say: Thou hast given me delight, O Lord, in thy making, and in the works of thy hands I shall rejoice. How great are thy works, O Lord! Thou hast made all things in wisdom, the earth is filled with thy possession.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“They shall go directly etc. Here he describes the last battle according to the diverse battle lines of creatures. And first he introduces fire warring against and conquering the impious; second, the air: And from the stony: third, water: And it shall grow white-hot: fourth, wind or whirlwind proceeding from the earth: Against them shall stand the spirit of power.
(Verse 22). They shall go, therefore, namely against them, directly the bolts of lightning: Gloss: "At will, that is, according to the will of the commander": Ecclesiasticus 43: "He hastens to send forth the flashings of his judgment"; likewise in the Psalm: "Flash forth lightning, and you shall scatter them." And as from a well-curved bow of the clouds, that is, as the curved lines of the rainbow, when the sun comes upon them, the impious shall be destroyed: as if to say: just as quickly and easily the heavenly bow is dissolved, so the impious shall quickly and easily be destroyed, that is, they shall be placed outside the boundaries of present and eternal life: Baruch 3: "They were destroyed and descended to the netherworld"; in the Psalm: "He has bent his bow" etc. And they shall leap to a certain place, namely against the wicked only, so that they shall not touch the good: chapter 3 above: "The torment of death shall not touch them." To a certain place: Gloss: "Wherever it may be necessary; for that which divine wisdom has ordered cannot be confused": whence Exodus 9: "In Egypt the land of Goshen suffered no evil from the plagues inflicted upon Egypt."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 23). And from stony wrath: stony is said of that wrath on account of its effect, because it will manifest itself through rocks, or because it is unbreakable and hard like rock, or because it will be inflicted by Christ, who is called the rock in 1 Corinthians 10: "And the rock was Christ." Full hailstones shall be sent, that is, thick and great; or: fully, that is, completely or abundantly: Psalm: "Fire, hail, snow, ice" etc.; Job 38: "Have you entered the storehouses of snow?" Revelation 16: "Great hail like a talent in weight descended from heaven upon men." But the Greeks have it thus: And as from a well-curved bow of clouds they shall leap to a sure mark, and from a hurled stone, full wrath. This reading is clearer and seems truer, since this book appears to have been compiled in Greek. And it shall grow hot, that is, it shall boil, upon them, that is, against them, the water of the sea: for it shall become boiling, turbid, and foaming: Luke 21: "On earth, distress of nations from the confusion of the sound of the sea and the waves." For it shall be one of the fifteen signs, according to Jerome, that the sea shall raise itself above the height of the mountains. And rivers, that is, of fresh waters, shall rush together harshly, that is, forcefully: Exodus 15: "They sank like lead in mighty waters." Or: The water of the sea, that is, the bitterness of hell, shall grow hot against them, that is, it shall hiss and boil like water by the casting in of hot iron: Isaiah 14: "Hell beneath is disturbed." And rivers, namely of anguish, shall rush together harshly, because there shall be grief over goods lost, shame over evils committed, fear over present punishments.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 24). Against them shall stand the spirit of power, that is, a strong wind, according to that passage of Exodus 15: "Your spirit blew" etc., proceeding from the caverns of the earth, according to that passage of the Psalm: "Who brings forth winds from his storehouses"; likewise in the Psalm: "With a vehement wind you shall shatter the ships of Tarshish"; likewise Job 1: "A vehement wind rushed from the region of the desert." This is the "spirit of storms," of which the Psalm speaks. And as: as is expressive of truth, not a mark of similitude: a whirlwind, that is, a blast composed of contrary winds mixed with dust, shall divide them etc. Or: spirit can be called the sentence of the judge, according to that passage of Isaiah 11: "With the spirit of his mouth he shall slay the wicked." And then the term as is a mark of similitude, not expressive of truth, when it is said: And as a whirlwind shall divide them, namely from the good: Job 27: "A burning wind shall take him up, and as a whirlwind shall snatch him from his place"; the last chapter of Isaiah: "Behold, the Lord shall come in fire, and his chariots as a whirlwind." And to a wasteland, that is, a horrible and barren place, lacking every good: concerning such a place, Deuteronomy 32: "In a place of horror and vast solitude."
All the earth, that is, earthly ones, their iniquity will lead them through, that is, their own iniquity, not another's, will be the cause why they are led there, according to that passage of Isaiah 50: "Walk in the flames which you have kindled for yourselves." Or according to another reading: he says the land of their iniquity, because according to the Psalm: "Fire shall go before the judge himself," which will burn the surface of the earth on which their iniquities were committed and render it dry. And malice, which they practiced, which connotes something worse, will overthrow, that is, will be the cause of overthrowing, the thrones of the powerful, that is, kingdoms, cities and strongholds, towers and tribunals: Sirach 10: "God has destroyed the thrones of proud rulers." The Gloss expounds the preceding differently, namely, concerning the present overthrow of the impious, the unfaithful, and heretics by Christ and the Church: by the flashing of miracles, by the hail of rebukes, by the cleansing of tribulations, by the whirlwind of persecutions, by the subversion and removal of possessions, by the casting down of the powerful.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wisdom is better etc., as if to say: since the powerful who lack understanding are treated in this way, better, that is, more useful, is wisdom, concerning divine things, which, according to the Gloss, "always rightly governs the soul"; than the strength of the body, which often casts one headlong into sins: Ecclesiastes 9: "I said that wisdom is better than strength." And a prudent man, in human affairs, according to the Gloss, not only in eloquence: more than a strong man: Gloss: "In body." Whence one ought not to glory in such strength, according to that saying from Jeremiah 9: "Let not the strong man glory in his strength."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hear therefore, etc., as if to say: since wisdom is so useful, hear therefore, with the outward hearing, O kings: Gloss: "Prelates"; and understand, with the inward hearing: Proverbs 1: "A wise man hearing shall be yet wiser, and he that understandeth shall possess governance": Matthew 13: "He that hath ears to hear, let him hear." Learn, O judges of the ends of the earth, that is, of distinct lands or provinces. Kings are called prelates by directing toward the good; judges, by discerning between good and evil. Learn, I say, wisdom, because it is necessary for judges: whence Deuteronomy 1: "Give from among you wise and knowledgeable men."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Give ear, namely both the outward and inward ear, you who restrain, by holding back from evil, the multitudes of peoples committed to your care: Proverbs 14: "In the multitude of the people is the dignity of the king." And you delight in yourselves among the throngs of nations, that is, you glory in your prelacies: against which Gregory says in the Pastoral Rule: "As often as a prelate delights in ruling over men, so often does he fall into the crime of apostasy."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And you ought to listen, because power was given to you by the Lord: whence Romans thirteen: "There is no power except from God": power: Gloss: "Judiciary on earth," namely as regards the definition of the sentence: John nineteen: "You would have no power against me at all, unless it had been given to you from above." And strength: Gloss: "Of punishing," as regards the execution of the sentence. Or: power in civil cases, strength in criminal cases. From the Most High, namely God established above us: Psalm: "You, Lord, are most high over all the earth." Who will examine: Gloss: "In judgment"; Luke sixteen: "Render an account of your stewardship." Your works, namely exterior ones: Ecclesiastes, last chapter: "All things that are done, God will bring into judgment," etc. For he did not so give power that he would not demand an account; therefore Sirach eighteen: "Before judgment examine yourself, and before God you will find propitiation." And he will search out thoughts, that is, interior works: Gloss: "As one about to judge concerning all things"; above, chapter one: "There will be an inquisition into the thoughts of the ungodly." He will search out: Zephaniah one: "I will search Jerusalem with lamps"; nor will he only search out, but he will also make manifest: whence First Corinthians four: "He will illuminate the hidden things of darkness and will make manifest the counsels of hearts."
It should be noted, moreover, that a threefold examination will be made of the prelate: first, how he entered: Matthew twenty-two: "Friend, how did you enter here," etc. Second, how he lived: Isaiah twenty-two: "What are you doing here? Or as who are you here?" Third, how he ruled and guarded the flock entrusted to him: Jeremiah thirteen: "Where is the flock that was given to you, your glorious cattle?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“I have rightly said that he will examine etc.: and deservedly so, since, when you were ministers, not lords, of his kingdom, that is, of the Church Militant: 1 Peter 5: "Not as lording it over the clergy, but being made a pattern of the flock from the heart"; likewise 1 Corinthians 4: "Let a man so account of us as ministers of Christ" etc. You did not judge rightly, namely others: whence Isaiah 1: "They do not judge for the orphan, and the cause of the widow does not come before them"; likewise Jeremiah 5: "They did not judge the cause of the widow, they did not direct the cause of the orphan." Neither did you keep the law of justice, namely in yourselves: in the Psalm: "They did not keep the covenant of God, and in his law they refused to walk"; Isaiah 59: "Judgment is turned backward, and justice has stood afar off"; likewise Jeremiah 5: "These have rather broken the yoke, they have burst the bonds." Neither did you walk according to the will of God, sinning against God: Jeremiah 7: "They went after the pleasures and the depravity of their evil heart."
Or it can be said that he touches upon the threefold manner in which a sentence is called unjust: first, from the cause, namely when no just cause underlies it; second, from the procedure, as when the order of law is not observed; third, from the intention, as when one proceeds against someone with a corrupt intention: against which it is said in Deuteronomy 16: "You shall justly pursue what is just."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Dreadfully, that is, terribly: Hebrews 10: "It is a dreadful thing to fall into the hands of the living God": and swiftly he will appear to you: whence Zephaniah 1: "Near is the great day of the Lord, and exceedingly swift." And although the day of the general judgment be far off, yet the day of the particular judgment, that is, of death, is near: whence Ecclesiasticus 38: "Remember my judgment, for so also shall yours be: yesterday for me and today for you." And truly he will appear dreadfully to you prelates, for a most severe judgment shall be upon those who are set over others. Hard indeed, because they entered badly; harder, because they undertook badly; hardest, because they ruled badly. Or: hard on account of the sins of their subjects; harder on account of the sins of their ministers; hardest on account of the multitude and enormity of their own sins.
Prelates will be punished more harshly than others, first by reason of what was entrusted, according to that of Luke 12: "To whom they have entrusted more, more will they demand from him." By reason of sin, because, other things being equal, the sin of a prelate is graver than that of a subject: Jeremiah 5: "These have broken the yoke all the more" etc. By reason of harm, because namely they corrupt others by their example: Gregory: "When the pastor walks through steep places, it is necessary that the flock follow into the precipice." By reason of scandal, because they scandalize the Church: whence Malachi 2: "You have scandalized very many in the law." By reason of judgment, because namely they are not judged here, according to that of the Psalm: "Against you alone have I sinned" etc.; and therefore in the future they will be judged more harshly both all at once and totally, according to that of 2 Maccabees 6: "For the Lord does not wait patiently, as with other nations, so that when the day of judgment has come, he may punish them in the fullness of their sins." By reason of office, because they also sin by exercising their office unworthily: Romans 2: "In that you judge another, you condemn yourself."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For to the little one, that is, to the weak and humble: whence the Gloss: "To those who have sinned through ignorance, or frailty, or necessity, and have blotted it out by humble penance": mercy is granted: Gloss: "The remission of sins," as regards punishment, whether wholly or in part, here or in the future: Isaiah, last chapter: "To whom shall I look but to the poor little one" etc. But the mighty, that is, those who have abused their power unto sin, shall suffer torments mightily, that is, strongly inflicted, on account of sins, because for their own sins and those of their subjects: whence Numbers 25: "Take all the princes and hang them up on gibbets against the sun"; likewise 3 Kings 20: "Guard this man, who if he shall have escaped, your life shall be for his life"; likewise Ezekiel 32: "The mightiest of the strong shall speak to him from the midst of hell."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the Lord will not withdraw, namely from punishment and torment, the person of anyone, namely of the small or the great, out of private affection: Ezekiel eighteen: "I will judge each one according to his ways, O house of Israel, says the Lord." "God is not a respecter of persons," Acts ten. Then he gives the reason, saying: Who is, that is, because He is, the ruler of all; Revelation nineteen: "King of kings and Lord of lords." Nor will He fear the greatness of anyone, namely out of fear, because He Himself is "the great Lord and a great king above all gods," as is said in the Psalm, and again: "Of His greatness there is no end"; whence He surpasses beyond all proportion every other greatness. Because He Himself made the small and the great: Malachi two: "Is there not one father of us all? Has not one God created us?" And because He created all, therefore He will judge all, the small as well as the great, as His creatures: Revelation twenty: "I saw the dead, great and small, standing in the sight of the throne." And He has equal care of all.
Against this: First Corinthians nine: "Does God have care for oxen?" as if to say: no.
It must be said that the care of discipline belongs to God only with respect to rational creatures; but the care of providence belongs to Him with respect to all things.
But if His care of providence is equal with respect to the good and the wicked, then it makes no difference to Him whether one is good or evil.
I respond: it must be said that he speaks of natural providence, not of gratuitous providence. Or: equally, that is, similarly.
And although His care of all things is equal, nevertheless He will not punish all equally.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“However, in the sense of "but." For the stronger, in evil, a stronger torment awaits, in punishment, as is evident in Lucifer and the other demons.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because a stronger torment awaits the stronger, to you therefore, O kings etc: Gloss: "Having finished the discourse to the mighty, he turns his exhortation to the rulers of the Church": Gloss: "O kings, that is, rulers of the Church, or all those to whom the governance of their souls has been entrusted". To you are these my words, namely concerning the pursuit and love of wisdom: whence it follows: that you may learn wisdom: Gloss: "Divine", not worldly: concerning both, First Corinthians chapter three: "If anyone among you seems to be wise in this age, let him become a fool, that he may be wise". These words, to be heard and retained and fulfilled in deed, according to that passage of Jeremiah chapter fifteen: "Your words were found, and I ate them". And do not fall away, namely from justice "through transgression of the commandments of God", according to the Gloss. For wisdom is the salt that preserves from the corruption of sin: but neglect of wisdom causes one to fall into sin: whence Proverbs chapter seventeen: "He who avoids learning will fall into evils", that is, into the evil of guilt and into the evil of punishment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And rightly did I say: that you may learn wisdom, lest you fall away from justice: for they who have kept justice, which is the way to wisdom, according to that passage of Ecclesiasticus chapter one: "Son, if you desire wisdom, keep justice"; shall be justly judged, Gloss: "They shall receive the reward of their justice", namely in good: whence Isaiah chapter three: "Say to the just man that it is well: for he shall eat the fruit of his doings"; likewise Ezekiel chapter eighteen: "The justice of the just shall be upon him"; Luke chapter six: "With what measure you shall measure" etc. And they who shall have learned, namely through wisdom, just things: Gloss: "Right faith and works": shall find what to answer, namely at the judgment concerning sins charged against them: Habakkuk chapter two: "I will stand upon my watch etc., and I will contemplate, that I may see what is said to me, and what I may answer to him who reproves me".”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Desire therefore etc. Since wisdom is so useful that it causes one not to fall from justice, etc.: desire therefore my words, to be heard concerning wisdom: Ecclesiasticus twenty-four: "Come over to me, all you who desire me." And love them, namely those already heard, according to that word of the Psalm: "I have loved your commandments above gold and topaz," etc. And you shall have discipline, namely through my very words: the Gloss: "He who loves wisdom preserves discipline in his conduct," according to that word of John fourteen: "If you love me, keep my commandments."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Resplendent and unfading is wisdom—with whom there is no change, no shadow of alteration—and she is readily perceived by those who love her, and found by those who seek her. She hastens to make herself known in anticipation of man's desire." And so, she appears unchanging in the rules of divine Law that bind us. These rules filling the rational mind with splendid light are all the ways by which the mind knows and judges that which could not be otherwise, the fact that the supreme Principle must be supremely venerated, that the supreme Truth must be supremely believed in and assented to, and that the supreme Good must be supremely desired and loved. And in these wisdom is seen, for they are so certain that they could not be otherwise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She is bright. Here he shows the ease of acquiring wisdom: first by this, that she is bright for seeing; second, because she is ready to show herself: She anticipates; third, because she is near for approaching: He who watches for her at dawn, etc.
She is bright, etc., as if to say: you ought to desire her, because wisdom is bright: namely by her own beauty and self-evidence, because she is light: whence below in chapter seven: "I purposed to have her for my light." And she never fades, that is, she never falls from her beauty: whence the Gloss: "The beauty of wisdom is unfading." For she is not subject to time, but is above time, as divine wisdom. And easily, etc., as if to say: nor should one despair of acquiring her, because she is easily seen, namely by the eye of the intellect, by those who love her, namely with affection: whence John fourteen: "He who loves me shall be loved by my Father, and I will love him and will manifest myself to him." For love purges and illuminates the interior eye for seeing: whence Ecclesiasticus two: "You who fear the Lord, love him, and your hearts shall be illuminated." And she is found by those who seek her, in effect: Luke eleven: "Seek, and you shall find," namely if she is sought where she ought to be sought. For she "is not found in the land of those who live pleasantly," Job twenty-eight, but in the harshness of sustenance and penance; whence Daniel found wisdom by the merit of his abstinence, as is clear from Daniel one.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Resplendent and unfading is wisdom, and she is readily perceived by those who love her, and found by those who seek her. She hastens to make herself known in anticipation of man's desire." And so, she appears unchanging in the rules of divine Law that bind us. These rules are beyond error, doubt, and judgment, for judgment is by them, and not of them. Hence such wisdom is clear. They are also beyond change, restriction, and cancellation; hence such wisdom never wastes away. For these rules are so certain that they cannot be contradicted in any way. For they are rooted in Eternal Light and lead to it. And indeed such wisdom irradiates the soul: "sitting by his gate, she hastens to make herself known by anticipation."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She anticipates, namely before she is found by the zeal of the seeker: the Gloss: "Offering herself freely: for she herself is the way, the truth, and the life, whence through her one goes to her and arrives." She anticipates, I say, that is, she goes before those who desire her, so that she may first show herself to them: because they would not come before her unless they were first come before and illuminated by her, just as the light of the sun illuminates in order to be seen itself: Bernard: "True wisdom, which is Christ, can be found, but cannot be anticipated."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Who from the light etc. I have rightly said that she is found by those who seek her, because who from the light, that is, as soon as the light rises for him: Gloss: "From the beginning of the shining of faith," not from the night, as sinners always remaining in the night, but as the just, of whom Proverbs 4: "The path of the just is as a shining light" etc.: First Thessalonians 5: "You are all children of the light." Shall have watched for her, against negligence: Proverbs 8: "They who watch for me in the morning shall find me." Shall not labor, because the sweetness of the thing sought and found will alleviate the labor: Sirach 6: "In her work you shall labor but little, and soon you shall eat of her fruits." For sitting etc., that is, in quiet and without motion ready to enter, just as the ray of the sun sits at a closed window. Sitting, I say, at his doors, namely the spiritual ones, namely the intellect and the affections: he shall find her: Revelation 3: "I stand at the door and knock" etc. She herself also has doors through which one enters to her: whence Proverbs 8: "Blessed is the man who hears me and watches at my doors daily": which are faith and charity: through faith the intellect enters to her, through charity the affections.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The benefit in the present is shown to be fourfold: first, understanding in the rational faculty; second, security in the irascible faculty; third, gladness in the concupiscible faculty; and fourth, foresight of future things.
To think therefore upon her: as if to say: she is given not only to one who watches and seeks, but even to think upon her, not with a simple thought, but an affective one: whence the Gloss: "With the desire of divine contemplation": Sirach 14: "Blessed is the man who shall dwell in wisdom, etc., and in his understanding shall think upon the circumspection of God": is perfect understanding, that is, complete, because wisdom perfects the understanding of man, because, according to Hugh of Saint Victor, "wisdom is that in which the form of the perfect good consists." Or: To think upon her is perfect understanding, that is, then the understanding is perfectly ordered when it devotes itself to wisdom, according to that saying of Augustine: "The end of man on the way is to seek truth perfectly." And he who shall have watched: Gloss: "With intention of mind," on account of her, to acquire or to guard her, shall quickly be secure, namely from evil: "because the attainment of her is true security," according to the Gloss: Proverbs 11: "He who guards against snares shall be secure." This is the good security, of which Proverbs 15: "A secure mind is like a continual feast."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The whole world is a way leading to the exemplar. As you notice that a ray of light coming in through a window is colored according to the shades of the different panes, so the divine ray shines differently in each creature and in the various properties. Hence, in Wisdom: "She appears to them in the ways." Again, it is a trace of God's wisdom. Wherefore the creature exists only as a kind of imitation of God's wisdom, as a certain plastic representation of it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For those worthy of herself: as if to say: I have rightly said that he will quickly be free from care, for those worthy of herself, namely those clean of heart and body: whence above in the first chapter: "Into a malevolent soul wisdom will not enter" etc. She goes about seeking, that is, from every side continuously offering herself and unceasingly: which unceasingness and continuity is given to be understood through what it says: she goes about: for rectilinear motion cannot be continued in the way that circular motion can. Thus incarnate Wisdom went about through the villages, as is evident from Mark 6. And in their ways, namely in precepts and counsels observed: concerning which, Proverbs 3: "Her ways are beautiful ways, and her paths are peaceful": she shows herself to them, according to that word of the Psalm: "From your commandments I have understood": cheerfully, gladdening them, namely in this, that she gives herself to them freely: 2 Corinthians 9: "God loves a cheerful giver," as does man also: whence Seneca: "The more delay you add, the more you subtract from the favor." And in all providence, concerning future things, perfectly providing for them the things necessary for salvation: she meets them; the Gloss: "As helper," just as incarnate Wisdom, rising again, met the women, as is recorded in Matthew 28.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The manner in which such wisdom is obtained is clearly seen from authority and through examples. As to the former, the Book of Wisdom reads: "For the first step toward discipline is a very earnest desire for her; then, care for discipline is love of her; love means the keeping of her laws; to observe her laws is the basis for incorruptibility; and incorruptibility makes one close to God; thus the desire for Wisdom leads up to a kingdom. If, then, you find pleasure in throne and scepter, you princes of the peoples, honor Wisdom, that you may reign forever." But discipline is twofold: scholastic and personal, the latter concerning ethics. And scholastic discipline without personal discipline is insufficient for wisdom: for a man becomes wise not merely by listening: he must also conform. A sick man is not healed by listening to a physician: he must follow his prescription. But few walk along that way of wisdom, hence few ever reach it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Here are touched upon the steps of glory to be acquired through wisdom. The first step, that is, the beginning of wisdom, is the desire for discipline; from the desire for discipline, love; from love, the keeping of the law of God; from the keeping of the divine law, incorruption of mind and nearness to the divine likeness; from the divine likeness, the glory of the heavenly kingdom: therefore from the first, from the desire for wisdom, heavenly glory is obtained.
For the beginning of it, namely of wisdom: as if to say: thus wisdom meets and shows herself. Nor is her showing and meeting useless. For, in the sense of because: the beginning of it, namely that by which a man begins to become wise: "for no one suddenly becomes the highest," as the Gloss says: is the truest for discipline, that is, for wisdom, desire. Concerning this desire it is said in the Psalm: "My soul has longed to desire" etc. For the desire for wisdom is itself a certain part of wisdom, according to that word of Sirach 6: "If you love to listen, you will be wise."
But it seems that fear, and not love, is the beginning of wisdom, because it is said in Sirach 1: "The beginning of wisdom is the fear of the Lord."
It must be said that fear is the first beginning, but love is the proximate beginning; or: fear is the extrinsic beginning, love the intrinsic beginning.
Most true: but the desire is called here in contrast to the threefold vain desire, of which it is said in First John 2: "All that is in the world is either the desire of the flesh" etc., which arises from the threefold vanity, of which Ecclesiastes 1 says: "Vanity of vanities" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Care therefore, as if to say: since it is the case that the desire for discipline is the beginning of wisdom, therefore care for discipline, that is, the desire for discipline, is love, that is, the cause of love for wisdom itself: for what we desire, we love when we possess it. And note that he calls wisdom and discipline the same thing, because they are the same in reality, although they differ in concept, because it is called wisdom insofar as it delightfully affects the mind inwardly; discipline, insofar as it orders and arranges outward actions. Or thus: desire etc. is love, that is, the cause of divine love: below in chapter seven: "God loves no one except him who dwells with wisdom": Hebrews 12: "But if you are without discipline, then you are not sons but illegitimate." And love is the keeping of her laws, that is, the cause of keeping them: Romans 13: "The fullness of the law is love," that is, the cause of the fulfillment of the divine law: First Timothy 1: "The end of the commandment is charity"; of laws, namely the natural, Mosaic, and evangelical: concerning which Isaiah 24: "They have transgressed the laws, changed the ordinance, broken the everlasting covenant."
But the keeping of the laws is the consummation of incorruption, that is, the cause of consummated spiritual incorruption, namely of both mind and body in the present; or: of incorruption, "that is, of immortality" in the future, according to the Gloss: Proverbs 3: "Keep my law and my counsel, and it shall be life to your soul."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But incorruption makes one to be near to God: whence it is sung of virgins that "they follow the Lamb wherever he goes," Revelation 14.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore the desire for wisdom, which is its beginning, will lead to an everlasting kingdom: the Gloss: "Which consists in the knowledge of the Divinity," according to that saying in John 17: "This is eternal life, that they may know you, the true God" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If therefore you delight etc., as if to say: since he gives an everlasting kingdom, therefore if you delight in thrones and scepters: The Gloss: "He admonishes kings to love wisdom, without which they cannot reign: for the commonwealth is well governed when philosophers reign and kings philosophize. Rightly therefore the rulers of the Church are assiduous in the meditation of the divine law: for whoever follows it by learning, teaching, and practicing will attain the crown of the heavenly kingdom." If therefore you delight in thrones, of judicial power, and scepters, of royal dignity, according to that passage in Matthew twenty-three: "They love the chief seats," etc.; another reading has senses, with respect to discernment, and crowns, with respect to dignity: if you delight, I say, O kings of the people, that is, the greater rulers and prelates, both secular and ecclesiastical: love wisdom, that you may reign forever: Proverbs eight: "By me kings reign."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Love the light of wisdom, for the illumination of souls: below in chapter seven: "Compared to light she is found to be prior": because she illuminates spiritual things, which is greater than to illuminate corporeal things. All you who rule over peoples, that is, you also who are lesser princes and prelates.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“General Introduction. Love the light of wisdom, all you who lead peoples, Wisdom 6. Since a thing must be formed and what has been deformed reformed by the same principle, and all things are read to have been made through wisdom, according to that verse of the Psalm: You have made all things in wisdom: it is necessary that all things be reformed through wisdom. Therefore the image of the rational soul, which "is read to have been made after the likeness of all wisdom" in the book On the Spirit and the Soul, but afterward deformed through sin to such an extent that it may rightly be asked: Whose is this image and inscription? must necessarily be reformed through wisdom. Likewise, because two things are necessary for its reformation, namely the expulsion of malice and the introduction of perfect good, so that it may be informed by it and expressly conformed to him whose image it is: wisdom, however, is expulsive of malice, whence Wisdom 7: Wisdom overcomes malice: likewise it is introductive of perfect good, because "wisdom is that in which the form of perfect good consists," as Hugh says in the book On the Origin of the Arts. And since the divine image, deformed through sin in the soul, needs reformation according to all three of its parts, which according to Augustine are understanding, memory, and will: therefore the Wise Man draws and invites to wisdom in a threefold manner, namely to the studious acquisition of wisdom, and this with regard to understanding; to the firm retention of acquired wisdom, and this with regard to memory; to the love of acquired and memorially retained wisdom, and this with regard to will.
To the studious acquisition of wisdom: Proverbs 27: Study wisdom, my son. He calls son whomever he instructs with paternal affection, whether young or old. Augustine: "No age can seem too late to me for learning what is needful: because, even if it is more fitting for the old to teach than to be taught, yet it is more fitting for them to learn than to be ignorant of what they should teach." Study, he says, and this suggests that vehement diligence must be applied to the acquisition of wisdom. "For study, as Cicero says, is the vehement application of the mind with the greatest pleasure to accomplishing something." This vehement application of the mind, however, requires freedom from external occupations. "For he who with a confused mind is divided among many things is rendered unequal to each one," as Gregory says. On account of which, Ecclesiasticus 38: Write wisdom in a time of leisure, that is, of freedom from external work: for he who is less occupied in action, namely external action, will receive wisdom, as it says in the same place.
For the firm retention of wisdom: Ecclesiasticus fourteenth, where it says: Blessed is the man who shall abide in wisdom: likewise Proverbs third: Inscribe her upon the tablets of your heart, that is, in the three parts of the divine image, and especially in the memory, by retaining her firmly. For which reason he says: Inscribe, for what is written is retained more firmly and for a longer time: Proverbs twenty-second: Behold, I have described her to you in threefold manner, that is, in the understanding through diligent acquisition, in the memory through firm retention, in the will through love: to which he exhorts in the words set forth, saying: Love the light of wisdom, etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On the fourfold cause of this book. In these words four causes of this work are indicated to us, namely the efficient cause from the person who speaks, saying: Love: the formal, that is, the manner of proceeding, is indicated by light: the material is expressed by the name wisdom; the final can be understood from the relation or comparison of the speaker to the person to whom the discourse is directed, when it is said: All you who rule over peoples.
Concerning the first, it should be noted that the efficient cause of this book is threefold: the first by way of inspiring, namely God: whence Job thirty-second: The inspiration of the Almighty gives understanding: likewise Ecclesiasticus first: All wisdom is from the Lord God, just as all essence is from his essence, and from his truth all truth, and from his goodness all goodness. "For the first in any genus is the cause of those things which come after it": and every perfect thing is caused by a perfect thing, according to Boethius.
The second efficient cause, by way of discovering, is Solomon himself: whence in the ecclesiastical history, "the whole chorus of the ancients declared the book which is entitled Wisdom to be Solomon's." Whence the book itself is inscribed the Wisdom of Solomon, and according to ecclesiastical custom, the readings taken from this book are prefaced with: "Solomon said to the children of Israel," because, namely, this book was compiled from his sayings. The proximate efficient cause, by way of compiling, was Philo, the most learned of the Jews, who lived in the times of the Apostles, as the ecclesiastical history relates: who from his love of wisdom was not undeservedly called Philo. Rabanus also asserts that this book was rather written not by Solomon, as is supposed, but by Philo, the most learned of the Jews, that is, compiled.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The formal cause, that is, the mode of proceeding, as has been said, is indicated through light, because, just as light has the concealment of its radical origin, a clear manifestation in its going forth, and a continuation in its flowing: so also this book of Wisdom has in its sentences a profound difficulty and concealment of origin, according to that passage in Job twenty-eight: Wisdom is drawn from hidden things; in its discourses a clear manifestation, Wisdom six: Bright is wisdom, which never fades, bright, I say, through the beauty of eloquence; "for the style of this book, according to Jerome, has the fragrance of Greek eloquence"; and in the progression of its arguments a consequent and ordered continuation, Ecclesiasticus twenty-one: The knowledge of the wise shall abound like a flood, flowing continuously, not dripping; and his counsel remains like a fountain of life.
The material cause is expressed by the name wisdom. "Wisdom, according to Augustine, is the knowledge of divine things": and divine things are God's power, wisdom, and goodness, which are treated in this book, although wisdom is principally intended. It makes known God's power in the punishment of the rebellious, as is evident in the first, second, third, fourth, and fifth chapters; wisdom in the illumination of the humble, as is evident in the sixth, seventh, eighth, and ninth chapters; goodness in the bestowal of benefits upon both groups, as is evident from the tenth chapter onward. Moreover, here it treats not only of uncreated wisdom, dwelling upon its praises, but also of created wisdom, showing its benefits; whence below in chapter six: What wisdom is, that is, what it is like, namely uncreated; and how it was made, namely created, I shall relate, etc.; although that whole passage can be understood of uncreated wisdom as its subject. Rightly therefore is it entitled the Book of Wisdom, because in it wisdom is principally treated as its subject or as its matter, just as the book On the Soul, because in it the soul is principally discussed.
The final cause can be understood from the relation of the person speaking to those to whom the discourse is directed, who are indicated there: All you who rule over peoples. For just as in angelic illuminations, the ray of divine light, according to blessed Dionysius, is first received by the angels of the first hierarchy, secondly by those of the middle, and lastly by those of the lowest — "for the law, as he himself says, has been divinely promulgated to lead back the last through the middle, and the middle through the first" — whence in the Psalm: You shine wonderfully from the eternal mountains, that is, the superior angels illuminating the inferior ones; just as we also see in bodily illuminations, because first the illumination of the sun is derived to higher places nearer to heaven, then to the middle ones, and lastly to the lowest, Ecclesiasticus forty-three: For the sun, burning the mountains in three ways, breathes forth rays, namely into the valleys: so also it ought to be in human illuminations, that first into the highest, that is into prelates, then into the middle ones, that is into their ministers, thirdly into the lowest, that is their subjects, the light of wisdom is diffused, according to that of the Psalm: Let the mountains receive peace for the people, etc. For this is the procession of wisdom. For it reaches from one end, namely the highest, to the other end, the lowest, and disposes all things, namely the middle things, sweetly, below in chapter eight. On account of this Plato used to say, "commonwealths would be blessed or good if wise men ruled them, or if their rulers devoted themselves to wisdom," as Boethius says in the book On Consolation. For according to the judge of the people, so are his ministers: and as the ruler of the city is, such also are its inhabitants: where he touches upon three orders, namely of judges, ministers, and subjects. On account of the aforesaid, this author first and principally intends to diffuse the light of wisdom into high places, that is into superiors and through them into inferiors. Whence it is clear that the final cause of this teaching is the exhortation or provocation of princes and prelates, and consequently of all, to the pursuit and love of wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Prologue of St. Jerome to the Book of Wisdom. The Book of Wisdom is nowhere found among the Hebrews. Whence its very style savors more of Greek eloquence. The Jews affirm this to be the work of Philo: which is accordingly called Wisdom, because in it the coming of Christ, who is the Wisdom of the Father, and His passion are clearly expressed.
Exposition of the Prologue. The Book of Wisdom etc. This is the prologue which Jerome prefixes to the Book of Wisdom: and first he shows the origin of this book, saying: The Book of Wisdom is nowhere found among the Hebrews. Whence its very style, that is, the composition itself, namely, because it is so elegant, savors more of Greek eloquence, that is, has the flavor of Greek rather than Hebrew. For the Greeks are more eloquent and more profound in their judgments than the Hebrews. Whence since this book has a most elegant style and the greatest profundity of judgments, it is clear that it was handed down in the Greek language rather than the Hebrew.
Second, he names its author, saying: This, namely the Book of Wisdom, the Jews affirm to be of Philo, namely as its compiler, but to be of Solomon as its originator, as has been said. This Philo, although he was a Jew, was nevertheless very skilled in the Greek language. Concerning him, Jerome says in the book On Illustrious Men that "he was a Jew, Alexandrian by nation, of priestly lineage." Third, he assigns the reason for the title, saying: Which book, namely of Wisdom, is therefore named Wisdom, because in it the coming of Christ, who is the Wisdom of the Father, and his passion are evidently, that is, carefully, expressed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But what is wisdom, as if to say: thus I have invited you to wisdom, and that you may assent, I will relate, etc. Or it may be continued thus: up to this point I have admonished you to wisdom: but, standing for "however": from now on I will relate what wisdom is, etc. Behold, a great promise; "for she is hidden from the eyes of all the living," Job twenty-eight; nevertheless she can be known by the revelation of the Holy Spirit. What is, I say, wisdom, uncreated, that is, of what quality: for concerning her it cannot be known or said what she is, namely according to essence, but of what quality, since she is good, eternal, omnipotent, etc. But concerning created wisdom it can be known and said what it is: whence Augustine says: "Wisdom is the knowledge of divine things." And how she was made, that is, how she was begotten from the Father, namely the eternal Wisdom, who is the Son of God: First Corinthians one: "Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God." Or: how she was made, that is, created, if it is expounded of created wisdom: Ecclesiasticus one: "Wisdom was created before all things": likewise in the same book, chapter twenty-four: "From the beginning and before the ages I was created," that is, disposed to be created. And I will not hide from you the mysteries of God, that is, the sacred and secret works of the wisdom of God.
To the contrary: Tobit 12: "It is good to hide the secret of a king."
It must be said that it should be hidden from tempters but revealed to lovers; whence John 15: "But I have called you friends, because all things whatsoever I have heard from my Father, I have made known to you." Likewise, it must be hidden from the proudly wise, but revealed to humble little ones: whence Matthew 11: "You have hidden these things from the wise and the prudent, and have revealed them to little ones," that is, the humble. Likewise, not to the gluttonous, but to the abstinent, as is clear from Daniel 1.
But from the beginning of birth, that is, of human birth, or of wisdom itself; I will search out, by showing that she proceeds from God the Father. And I will bring to light, namely the light of manifestation, the knowledge of her, by teaching clearly: Sirach 24: "Those who elucidate me shall have eternal life." And I will not pass over the truth, by mixing in falsehoods: Sirach 37: "Before all works, let a truthful word precede you"; Augustine: "It is the distinguished mark of good minds to love the truth in words, not the words themselves."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Nor with wasting envy, that is, envy that causes wasting: Proverbs 14: "Envy is the rotting of the bones"; likewise in the Psalm: "The sinner shall see and shall be angry, he shall gnash his teeth and waste away." Will I travel, because she is the worst companion, for she devours a man like a wild beast: Genesis 37: "A most evil wild beast has devoured him, a beast has consumed Joseph." Such was Moses, that is, not envious, for he said: "Who would grant me that all the people might prophesy, and that the Lord would give them his spirit?" Numbers 11. Because such a man, namely the envious, will not be a partaker of wisdom: whence above, chapter 1: "Into a malevolent soul," etc.; Sirach 14: "To an envious man," that is, one full of envy, "what good is gold?" that is, wisdom, which is called gold on account of its preciousness: Proverbs 3: "For she is more precious than all riches."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But a multitude etc., as if to say: and you ought to listen; but, meaning because; because a multitude of the wise: the Gloss: "The assembly of preachers"; is the health of the world, that is, the cause of health: Proverbs 11: "Where there is no governor, the people shall fall; but there is safety where there are many counsels." Whoever therefore opposes the multiplication or multitude of the wise opposes the salvation of the world, and therefore such a one ought to be hated by the whole world. Such were those of whom the Apostle speaks in 1 Thessalonians 2: "They do not please God and are adversaries to all men." And a wise king is the stability of the people: Sirach 10: "A wise judge shall judge his people, and the government of a prudent man shall be stable." But this applies most especially to Christ, in whose person it is said: "I am the salvation of the people."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And because wisdom is so useful, therefore receive discipline, that is, wisdom, through my words, excitatively or occasionally, but through divine inspiration effectively and causally: whence Ecclesiasticus 1: "All wisdom is from the Lord God." And it will profit you, because it is said in the last chapter of Ecclesiastes: "The words of the wise are as goads," namely by provoking to good, "and as nails fastened deep," preserving from falling into evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, he takes a reason for exhorting to wisdom from his own example. For I myself am etc. Above he admonished rulers to acquire and love wisdom through a reason taken from the danger of their office; here from his own example. And first he shows how he received wisdom, namely in this chapter; second, how much he loved it, namely in the eighth chapter; third, how devoutly he sought it from the Lord, namely in the ninth chapter. First he shows how he received wisdom. In the first part, in order to descend to his purpose, first he describes the misery of human frailty; second, he shows that this occasion provoked him to acquire wisdom: Therefore I wished etc.; third, he shows by whom he was instructed: But to me. First, on the misery of human frailty. In the first, first he touches on the defectibility of human nature; second, the vileness of human conception: And in the womb; third, the condition of birth: And I; fourth, the labor of upbringing: In swaddling clothes; fifth, the commonality of misery: For no one etc.
(Verse 1.). For I myself am etc. Thus I admonished you to receive the discipline of wisdom "through my words": and this you can do not only through my words, but also by my example, because I myself also am: indeed, that is, certainly: a mortal man, just as you are: mortal, I say, that is, able to die from the first condition, but having the necessity of dying from the first transgression; for man, according to Boethius, is a rational, mortal animal; likewise Romans 8: "The body indeed is dead because of sin," that is, subjected to the necessity of dying. Like all others in this condition of mortality; 2 Kings 14: "We all die, and like waters slip away into the earth, which do not return." And of the race of that earthly one, namely Adam the transgressor, who was first made, from the earth namely; whence Genesis 2: "God formed man from the slime of the earth"; likewise 1 Corinthians 15: "The first man was of the earth, earthly"; likewise in the same place: "As was the earthly one, such also are the earthly ones." And in the womb of my mother I was formed into flesh. For according to Augustine in the book of Eighty-three Questions, in the first six days the seed is like milk; in the remaining nine the milk is converted into blood; in the remaining twelve it is formed into flesh; in the remaining eighteen it is formed into an organic body. And then around the forty-fifth or forty-sixth day the soul is infused into the body. And during the entire remaining time after the infusion of the soul, the body is nourished and grows.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 2.). In the time of ten months I was compacted in blood from the seed of a man, according to the natural philosophers, as the Gloss says: "The seed of the woman is sanguineous, the seed of the man is white: from the commingling of these, the one as passive and the other as active, coagulation occurs": Job 10: "Did you not pour me out like milk, and curdle me like cheese"? This coagulation occurs in the first part of the ten months: but the entire duration of formation itself is a period of nine months.
But to the contrary: Because the common time of formation is nine months: whence 2 Maccabees 7: "Have pity on me, my son, who bore you nine months in my womb."
I respond: As the Gloss says, "some are born in the seventh month, some in the eighth, some in the ninth: but those born in the tenth are said to be more perfect, healthier, and more vigorous." But Christ, according to the Gloss, was in His mother's womb "nine months and six days": whence what he says, ten months, is taken synecdochically: "for it was from the eighth of the Kalends of April to the eighth of the Kalends of January."
And with the pleasure of sleep concurring, or of concurring [sleep], that is, by the pleasurable act of the common sleeping together of a man with a woman. This pleasure is compared to the pleasure of sleep, because it binds reason and quickly passes, just as the pleasure of sleep.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 3.). And being born I received the common air, for the necessity of breathing: Ecclesiastes 3: "All things breathe alike." And in like manner I fell, from the womb of my mother, upon the earth that was made, namely by God, Genesis 1: and this with respect to the necessity of life and sustenance. And the first voice, like all others, namely those being born, I uttered, crying. Augustine says that "a child from his crying begins to be a prophet of his own calamity"; "but they report, that is, they say, that Zoroaster alone, king of the Bactrians, laughed when he was born." John the Baptist alone also, contrary to the law of those being born, anticipated his own birth with joy and exultation; Luke 1: "The infant leaped for joy in my womb."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 4. 5. 6.). In swaddling clothes, namely of cloths, I was nurtured: Luke 2: "She wrapped him in swaddling clothes." And with great cares: 2 Maccabees 7: "For three years I gave you milk and brought you up to this age."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For no one among kings had a different beginning of birth, because in natural things there is no difference between kings and subjects, but only in the goods of fortune.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore there is one entrance into life for all, namely through temporal birth so lowly, as has been said: and a similar departure, namely through death so harsh, as is described in the last chapter of Ecclesiastes. Likewise, there is one entrance, namely through a poor birth; and a similar departure, namely through a most impoverished death: Job 1: "Naked I came forth from my mother's womb, and naked shall I return thither": Ecclesiastes 5: "A most wretched infirmity: as he came, so shall he return."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Holiness is an immediate disposition toward wisdom: hence a yearning and a strong desire are the door to wisdom. "Therefore I prayed, and prudence was given me; I pleaded, and the spirit of Wisdom came to me. I preferred her to scepter and throne, and deemed riches nothing in comparison with her. Nor did I liken any priceless gem to her; because all gold, in view of her, is a little sand, and before her, silver is to be accounted mire. Beyond health and comeliness I loved her, and I chose to have her rather than the light, because the splendor of her never yields to sleep. And I rejoiced in them all, because Wisdom is their leader, though I had not known that she is the mother of these." But the author says that he came to this Wisdom through prayer and pleading. For if She is the supreme good, She must be loved supremely; and if She is all good, She must be desired universally and above anything else.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, he shows that, prompted by this occasion toward wisdom, he says. For this reason I desired, etc. Here he shows that this occasion prompted him to acquire wisdom: and first he touches on the attainment of the desired wisdom; second, the estimation of what was attained: And I preferred her; third, the love of what was esteemed: Above health; fourth, the communication of what was possessed and loved: Which I learned without pretense.
(Verses 7-8). For this reason, that is, struck by the consideration of the aforementioned miseries, I desired, namely wisdom. And understanding was given to me, that is, wisdom: Proverbs 10: "The desire of the just shall be granted." And I called upon, the Gloss says: "the Lord"; James 1: "If any of you lacks wisdom, let him ask of God." And there came into me, as I called upon him, the spirit of wisdom, according to that verse of the Psalm: "I opened my mouth," namely in prayer, "and drew in the spirit"; likewise Ecclesiasticus 15: "In the midst of the church he opened his mouth, and the Lord filled him with the spirit of wisdom."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Of wisdom the Wise Man says: "Her I loved and preferred to kingdoms and thrones, and I deemed riches nothing in comparison with her; above health and beauty I loved her. And all good things came to me together with her, and innumerable riches through her hands; and I rejoiced in all things, because this wisdom went before me." The Philosopher says that wisdom has the greatest delights. If it is a great thing to be illuminated by wisdom, it is a greater thing to be gladdened, insofar as one loves one's principle.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Holiness is an immediate disposition toward wisdom: hence a yearning and a strong desire are the door to wisdom. "Therefore I prayed, and prudence was given me; I pleaded, and the spirit of Wisdom came to me. I preferred her to scepter and throne, and deemed riches nothing in comparison with her." But the author says that he came to this Wisdom through prayer and pleading. For if She is the supreme good, She must be loved supremely; and if She is all good, She must be desired universally and above anything else.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And I preferred her, namely in estimation of value, to kingdoms, that is, to the dignities of kings, and to thrones, that is, to the dignities of judges: and rightly so, because she says: "By me kings reign," Proverbs 8. And I counted riches as nothing in comparison with her: Proverbs 3: "She is more precious than all riches." "For what does it profit a fool to have riches, when he cannot purchase wisdom?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 9). Nor did I compare to her, that is, to her price or power, any precious stone: in the Psalm: "I have loved your commandments above gold and topaz"; likewise Job 28: "It shall not be compared with the dyed colors of India, nor with the most precious sardonyx stone, or the sapphire." "Neither shall the topaz of Ethiopia be equal to it." For, etc., as if to say: and rightly so, because all gold, that is, all the gold that is in the world, in comparison with her is sand, that is, unfruitful earth: Bernard says: "What is gold but red earth"? of small account, that is, of little weight: Job 28: "Fine gold shall not be given for it." And as clay, that is, of no value, shall silver be esteemed in her sight: Job 28: "Silver shall not be weighed in exchange for it": Proverbs 3: "The gaining of her is better than the trading of gold and silver," etc.
But silver is compared to clay because it stains the hands and the soul: Habakkuk 2: "How long does he heap up against himself thick clay?"
It should be noted that wisdom is preferred to silver and gold and every worldly treasure, first by reason of origin, because worldly treasure is from the earth: Job 28: "Silver has the beginnings of its veins, and there is a place for gold where it is refined," indeed "it is earth," according to blessed Bernard: but wisdom is from heaven, as is clear from James 3.
Second, by reason of nature, because worldly treasure is a corporeal thing, but wisdom is a spiritual thing: whence Isaiah 11: "The spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him, the spirit of wisdom," etc.
Third, by reason of power, because treasure is finite, but wisdom is infinite: whence below in this same chapter: "She is an infinite treasure to men, which they that use are made partakers of the friendship of God."
Fourth, by reason of operation, because treasure can accomplish few things, but she accomplishes all things: whence below in chapter 8: "What is richer than wisdom, which works all things?"
Fifth, by reason of estimation, because treasure falls under estimation, but she does not: Job 28: "It shall not be compared with the dyed colors of India," etc.
Sixth, by reason of utility, because wisdom without riches profits, but riches without wisdom do not profit, but rather harm: whence Ecclesiastes 5: "Riches kept to the hurt of their owner."
Seventh, by reason of duration, because "wisdom is glorious, and never fades away," above in chapter 6; but riches are corrupted: whence James 5: "Your riches are corrupted"; likewise James 1: "The rich man shall wither away in his journeys."
Eighth, by reason of inclination, because wisdom, since it is from above, elevates upward, but gold and silver drag downward, namely toward the earth: whence Baruch 3: "They that hoarded up silver and gold, in which men trust, have been cut off and have descended to the netherworld."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Above health etc. Here he shows the love of esteemed wisdom. And first he shows the greatness of this love; second, its reason: But all good things came to me etc.
(Verse 10). Above health: the Gloss says: "Of the body," namely interior health; the Psalm: "For vain is the salvation of man"; and beauty, the Gloss says: "Of corporeal things," namely exterior beauty, because, Proverbs 31, "favor is deceitful, and beauty is vain"; I loved her, namely wisdom, because insofar as the spirit is better than the body and more dearly to be loved, so much more are spiritual things better than corporeal things and more to be loved. And I loved her so greatly that I purposed to have her for my light, which light, I say, is the most beautiful and most delightful and best among corporeal things, according to Augustine: so wisdom among spiritual things is the light of the soul; Sirach, the last chapter: "In his wisdom my soul shone, and he illuminated my ignorances"; below in the same chapter: "She is more beautiful than the sun." There follows: For her light is inextinguishable, namely as far as it is in itself; below in the same chapter: "Being compared with light, she is found before it, for night succeeds that light."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the carrying out of the seven offices of the virtues there must be seven gifts of the Holy Spirit. For fear disposes to temperance, since fear transfixes the flesh; piety to true justice; knowledge to prudence; fortitude to fortitude or patience; counsel to hope; understanding to faith; wisdom to charity. Whence, just as charity is the mother and consummation of all the virtues, so wisdom is of the gifts, such that the Wise Man truly says: All good things came to me together with her, and innumerable honor through her hands.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"And I rejoiced in them all, because Wisdom is their leader, though I had not known that she is the mother of these." But the author says that he came to this Wisdom through prayer and pleading. For if She is the supreme good, She must be loved supremely; and if She is all good, She must be desired universally and above anything else.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the second place, it is lifted up to the vision of the city coming down from heaven, that is, of the assumed humanity. Indeed, the Son of God descended to our humanity, and this, for Jerusalem, is to come down. But the souls do not come down. He said: "I am the bread that has come down from heaven," and with Him [came down] all the charismatic graces. Wisdom says: "All good things together came to me in her company." And so, when the soul is lifted up by an influx into it of divine strength, light, and warmth, it worships piously, sees clearly, and enjoys holily, and through this it comprehends the marvelous origin, the marvelous fall, the marvelous ascent or ascending, the marvelous return. Then it has the four sides of the city coming down from heaven. I mean there is a marvelous origin in the nativity, a marvelous fall in the crucifixion, a marvelous ascent in the resurrection and ascension, and [there will be] a marvelous return at the time of the judgment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 11.). All good things came to me, namely of graces, within me absolutely: together with her, namely with uncreated wisdom, that is, the Son of God: whence Romans 8: "He who did not spare His own Son, but delivered Him up for us all, how shall He not also with Him give us all things?" The Gloss: "Whoever receives the knowledge of Christ equally has the grace of all virtues and in the future eternal life." Or: with her, that is, with created wisdom, because she herself is the most perfect of gifts. "Solomon experienced this, to whom when he asked for wisdom the Lord added riches and glory." And innumerable honor, outwardly in comparison to others: through the hands, that is, the works, of her, supply: came to me: whence below in chapter 10: "She honored him in his labors," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 12.). And I rejoiced, filled with joy, in all things, namely the gifts of wisdom: Sirach, the last chapter: "My heart rejoiced in her." For this wisdom went before me, namely by directing my steps: Sirach 4: "She receives those who seek her and goes before them in the way of justice." This is the pillar of fire and cloud going before the children of Israel by night and by day, Exodus 13. And I did not know, namely before I possessed her: The Gloss: "By the progress of meditation he understands that he has advanced so much that, comparing his former knowledge with the latter, he considers it ignorance." I did not know, I say, that she is the mother of all these things, namely of goods: Sirach 24: "I am the mother of fair love and of fear," etc.; likewise in the same place: "In me is all grace," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Which without pretense etc. Here first is touched upon the liberality of the communication of wisdom; second, the reason for communicating: For it is an infinite treasure.
(Vers. 13.). Which without pretense, that is, with my whole heart, I learned, knowing that "the Holy Spirit of discipline will flee from the deceitful," above in chapter 1; likewise Proverbs 2: "If you seek her as money, and dig for her as for treasures," etc. And without envy I communicate, namely not withholding useful things, above in chapter 6: "Neither will I journey with consuming envy"; likewise Proverbs 5: "Let your fountains flow abroad." And her honor, that is, her beauty, I do not hide, by veiling with obscure words: Sirach 4: "Do not hide your wisdom in her beauty"; likewise Sirach 20: "Hidden wisdom and an unseen treasure, what profit is in either?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 14.). For she is an infinite treasure in herself, to men: whence she is also inexhaustible through communication; and therefore Cicero says that knowledge is a noble treasure of the soul, which when distributed receives increase and disdains the avaricious possessor: unless it is made public, it slips away. Augustine: "Every good which does not diminish by giving, if it is possessed and not given, is not yet possessed as it ought to be possessed"; Ecclesiasticus 1: "He will fill her whole house from his generations, and her storehouses from his treasures." Those who have used this, namely the treasure of wisdom, governing themselves according to her, have been made partakers of the friendship of God: whence below in the same chapter: "She makes friends of God and prophets." On account of the gifts of discipline, that is, of wisdom, gifts which they possess not through their own industry, but through the distribution of the Holy Spirit, according to that passage in 1 Corinthians 12: "All these things," namely the gifts of graces, "one and the same Spirit works, dividing to each one as He wills." Commended, that is, made commendable, namely to God and to men: 2 Corinthians 10: "For not he who commends himself is approved, but he whom God commends."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, he shows from whom he learned wisdom. But God gave me to speak, etc. Here he shows from whom he learned wisdom: and first he shows who taught him; second, what things he taught: For He Himself gave me, etc.; third, through what medium he taught him: For the artificer of all things, etc.
First, who taught him.
(Verse 15). But to me etc. I have rightly said: Those who have used etc.: but I have used: but, in place of 'because': God gave me to speak, that is, not only to know, but also to teach: Isaiah 50: "The Lord gave me a learned tongue, that I might know how to sustain with a word him who has fallen." To speak, I say, according to judgment, that is, with firm determination: Proverbs 12: "The lip of truth shall be established forever": the Psalm: "The mouth of the just shall meditate wisdom, and his tongue shall speak judgment," that is, a firm judgment. And to presume. It should be noted that there is a presumption of arrogance, concerning which Judith 6: "Those presuming in themselves and glorying in their own strength you humble." And there is a presumption of confidence in divine power and mercy, concerning which in the same place: "You do not forsake those who presume in you" etc.; likewise Judith 9: "Hear me, wretched and presuming upon your mercy." And to presume, that is, to act confidently, things worthy, namely works, of those things which are given to me, that is, to perform vigorous and fitting works according to the gifts bestowed upon me: "For to whom more is committed, more shall be required of him." For he himself, namely God, is the guide of wisdom: Gloss: "That is, the author": Ecclesiasticus 1: "All wisdom is from the Lord God." Likewise the giver: James 1: "If any of you lacks wisdom, let him ask of God" etc. And the amender of the wise, that is, the corrector: Revelation 3: "Those whom I love, I rebuke" etc., namely if it happens that they err in something.
Sometimes even good Homer nods.
Likewise Augustine: I may err, but I shall never be a heretic.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"For God has given me to speak according to judgment and to conceive thoughts worthy of those things that are given to me. In his hand are both we and our words." It is impossible that wisdom should become doctrine except through speech. But speech is not sufficient for teaching unless it is full of meaning. And a man does not speak meaningfully unless his speech is analytical, inquisitive, and persuasive, namely, that he have speech powerful enough to express everything that can be apprehended or known, or toward which the affections can be inclined. Moreover, he fittingly expresses what he says through grammar, rationally investigates through the science of logic, and effectively persuades through rhetoric. This therefore is a part of philosophy, namely the science of discourse, which is threefold, as is evident, which Solomon attained.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 16). For in his hand etc. I have rightly said that he is the guide and amender of the wise: for in the hand of him: Gloss: "That is, in his power"; are both we, who possess wisdom: Jeremiah 18: "As clay in the hand of the potter, so also are you in my hand"; likewise Proverbs 21: "As the divisions of waters, so is the heart of the king in the hand of the Lord." And our words: Proverbs 16: "It is for man to prepare his mind, but for the Lord to govern the tongue"; Matthew 10: "It is not you who speak, but the Spirit of your Father" etc. And all wisdom, which namely is the knowledge of divine things, and of works, namely human, the discipline of knowledge; Isaiah 26: "All our works you have wrought in us, O Lord."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Solomon says that he attained the other part of philosophy, namely that which concerns the truth of things. Whence he says in the book of Wisdom: "God gave me true knowledge of the things that are, that I might know the disposition of the whole world and the powers of the elements." It is certain that the knowledge of the truth of things is threefold, according as there are concrete forms, abstract forms, and separate forms. The natural philosopher considers concrete forms, the mathematician abstract forms, and the metaphysician separate forms. Whence he says: "God gave me the knowledge of the things that are," that is, of beings principally, which are truly beings, with respect to metaphysical science; "that I might know the disposition of the whole world," with respect to mathematics; "and the powers of the elements," with respect to natural philosophy. Solomon knew the course of the year from the disposition of the stars, the natures of animals, and the powers of roots; Solomon taught all things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, what sort of things he taught. For he himself gave me. Here he shows what things and what sort of things God taught him, and first, that he taught him the knowledge of temporal causes; second, of temporal changes: The beginning and the end; third, of temporal effects: The natures of animals.
(Vers. 17.). For he himself, namely God, who alone teaches hearts, according to that saying of Augustine: "He who teaches hearts on earth has his chair in heaven": gave me, of the things that are, that is, of existing things, because there is no knowledge of non-existing things: whence the Philosopher says: "What does not exist cannot be known." "For each thing, as it is related to being, so it is related to truth," as he himself says. True knowledge, that is, certain cognition unmixed with any falsehood: 3 Kings 4: "God gave Solomon wisdom and exceedingly great prudence." That I might know the disposition of the whole world, that is, of the heaven encompassing the entire world: Ecclesiasticus 24: "I alone have compassed the circuit of heaven": and the virtues of the elements, that is, the qualities and seminal reasons and mixtures or connections and temperaments of the elements: Proverbs 8: "When he prepared the heavens, I was present: when with a certain law and compass he enclosed the depths."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 18.). The beginning and the end and the middle of times, namely of the four seasons or parts of the year, which are caused by the motion of the sun, according to the four quadrants of the zodiac: the alternating changes, that is, of the successions of days and nights, by which the quality of the air is changed, namely from brightness to darkness and conversely: and the consummation of times, that is, of months both solar and lunar. Some add here: the changes of customs and the divisions of times: the changes of customs, that is, of human habits, according to the diverse states of men: the divisions of times, that is, of the ages of the world or of man.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 19. 20.). The course of the year, that is, the time caused by the motion of the sun through the entire zodiac: Genesis 1: "That they may be for signs and for seasons and for days and years." And of the stars, namely of those other than the sun, the dispositions, with respect to the quality of nights: in the Psalm: "The moon and the stars to rule the night."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The natures of animals, namely of tame ones, and the rages of beasts, that is, the impulses of fierce animals, such as the lion and the like. And it should be noted that he says: the natures of animals and the rages of beasts, with respect to sensible substances. Then he adds with respect to things inanimate: the force of winds, which are twelve, four principal and eight collateral: and they are of great power, as is clear in Job 1 and Exodus 14, in the drying up of the sea, and in many other places. And the thoughts of men.
Against this: God alone knows the hearts of men: whence 1 Corinthians 2: "For what man knows the things of a man, save the spirit of man which is in him?" as if to say: no one except God.
It must be said that here he speaks of the knowledge of conjecture, not of certitude. Or it must be said that through the revelation of Wisdom they can be known by man, not through nature or one's own industry.
The differences of shrubs, that is, of plants, and the powers of roots, namely, of herbs: 3 Kings 4: "He discoursed on all trees from the cedar of Lebanon to the hyssop," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because this wisdom is attained only through grace, a wise writer attributes all hidden and unforeseeable things to the Holy Spirit and to the Word Himself, as having to be revealed by them. Hence he says: "And all such things as are hid and not foreseen, I have learned: for Wisdom, which is the worker of all things, taught me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 21.). And whatever things are hidden, or concealed, from their causes, and unforeseen by men, I learned: Ecclesiastes 7: "I surveyed all things with my mind, that I might know and consider and seek wisdom."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, through what medium he was taught. For the artificer of all things etc. Here he shows through what medium he was taught, namely, through uncreated Wisdom, begotten of the Father; and that she was able to teach, knew how, and willed to do so, he shows first through the Holy Spirit, who is from her; second, through the nature and power that is in her: For more mobile than all things, etc. In the first part, he first touches upon the procession of the Holy Spirit from uncreated Wisdom; second, his manifold effect in us: Holy, manifold, etc.; third, his goodness in his own nature: Undefiled; fourth, his universal sufficiency: Having all power. He touches upon his effect in us, first interior, second exterior: Modest. He touches upon a fourfold interior effect, namely, the amendment of fault, when he says: Holy; the multiplication of grace, when he says: Manifold; the unity of concord, when he says: One; the subtlety of understanding, when he says: Subtle. A threefold exterior effect, namely, modesty, when he says: Modest; eloquence, when he says: Eloquent; obedience, when he says: Mobile.
(Vers. 21.). The artificer of all things is shown, namely, of things above, things in the middle, and things below, namely, God, Hebrews 11. Wisdom taught me, that is, through Wisdom: the Gloss: "Because through her the knowledge of truth is given," because man can teach outwardly, but not inwardly; whence Gregory: "Unless there is one within who teaches, the tongue of the teacher labors in vain outwardly."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because this wisdom is attained only through grace, a wise writer attributes all hidden and unforeseeable things to the Holy Spirit and to the Word Himself, as having to be revealed by them. Hence he says: "And all such things as are hid and not foreseen, I have learned: for Wisdom, which is the worker of all things, taught me." And he says the same as Paul. "For in her is a spirit intelligent, holy, unique, manifold, subtle," etc. This spirit lifts up the soul and teaches unforeseen things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 22.). For there is in her etc., as if to say: and well was she able to teach me: for there is in her, namely in wisdom, a Spirit etc., in her, namely according to humanity, by dwelling: Isaiah 11: "The Spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him"; in her according to Divinity by emanating from her. A Spirit, I say, of understanding, [its] giver: Job 32: "The inspiration of the Almighty gives understanding." Holy: the Gloss: "Sanctifying all things": above, chapter 1: "The holy Spirit of discipline," etc. Manifold: the Gloss: "Giving manifold graces": 1 Corinthians 12: "There are divisions of graces, etc. But all these things one and the same Spirit works, dividing to each one as he wills." One: the Gloss: "Uniting the good"; Ephesians 4: "Careful to preserve the unity of the spirit in the bond of peace." Subtle, that is, causing hidden things to be penetrated: 1 Corinthians 2: "The Spirit searches all things," that is, causes all things to be searched, "even the deep things of God." Likewise, subtle, that is, producing subtlety or furnishing keenness of understanding: whence he is called "the spirit of understanding," Isaiah 11. Modest, that is, teaching to maintain measure in all things: Philippians 4: "Let your moderation be known to all men." Eloquent, that is, making others eloquent: below, chapter 10: "He made the tongues of infants eloquent." Mobile, that is, making others mobile through obedience: Ezekiel 1: "Wherever the spirit went, the wheels likewise were lifted up, following him. For the spirit of life was in the wheels."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Undefiled etc. Here he describes his goodness in his own nature and first his absolute goodness in himself: second, his goodness in comparison to us: Loving the good: third, the immutability of both: Steadfast. He touches upon absolute goodness in three respects, namely in purity, when he says: Undefiled: in truth: Sure: in tranquility, when he says: Sweet.
(Verse 22.). He says therefore undefiled: the Gloss: "That is, without stain," whence he also cleanses stains in baptism: John 3: "Unless one is born again of water and the Spirit," etc.; likewise Titus 3: "Through the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit," etc. Sure: the Gloss: "He neither deceives nor is deceived"; whence it is said, John 16: "The Spirit of truth." Sweet, that is, tranquil, having nothing of harshness: the Gloss: "Gentle and merciful"; below, chapter 12: "O how good and sweet is your Spirit in us, O Lord!"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Loving the good etc. Here he shows his goodness in comparison to us, first, in the love of the good; second, in its promotion: Who nothing [hinders]; third, in the communication of himself or communion: Humane: fourth, in the communication of his own, there: Kind.
He says therefore: Loving the good, in act; 1 Corinthians 13: "It does not rejoice over iniquity, but rejoices with the truth": who in no way hinders doing good, indeed he assists; Romans 8: "The Spirit helps our weakness"; Proverbs 3: "Do not forbid doing good," etc.
(Vers. 23.). Humane: The Gloss: "Common to all"; Acts 10: "In truth I have found that God is no respecter of persons." Or: humane, that is, compassionate, the sign of which is what is said in Romans 8: "The Spirit intercedes for us with unspeakable groanings." Or: humane, that is, willingly dwelling among men; Proverbs 8: "My delights are to be with the sons of men." Kind: that is, generous "by innate goodness"; above, chapter 1: "The spirit of wisdom is kind," etc.; likewise: Kind, by forgiving evils, giving good things, directing toward the homeland; whence kindness is said to be a fruit of the Spirit, Galatians 5. Steadfast, namely in himself, according to that saying of Boethius: "And remaining steadfast," etc.; likewise, giving steadfastness in his promised gifts. Nor is it surprising if here he is called steadfast and above in the same passage mobile, because here it is said with respect to diverse effects, concerning which the Psalm says: "He set my feet upon a rock and directed my steps." Or: mobile in active things, steadfast in contemplative things; or: steadfast in Christ, mobile in other Saints; John 1: "Upon whom you shall see the Spirit remaining." Or thus: steadfast, in the good; sure, that is, constant in the true; secure, from evil, according to that saying of the Psalm: "No evil shall approach you." And just as in himself he is steadfast and sure and secure, so also those whom he inhabits he makes steadfast in the good, sure in the true, secure from evil; Colossians 1: "Grounded in faith and steadfast and immovable from the hope of the Gospel."
Having every virtue. Here he shows its universal sufficiency, first, in goodness; second, in wisdom: Overseeing all things; third, in power: And who comprehends all intelligible spirits.
He says therefore: Having every virtue; in the Psalm: "By the Spirit of his mouth is all their virtue."
But to the contrary: Because he does not have faith, since faith is enigmatic knowledge and an imperfect virtue.
It must be said that he speaks of every virtue, not any whatsoever, but perfect virtue.
Beholding all things: Job 37: "He beholds above all the heavens, and his light is over all the ends of the earth"; likewise Hebrews 4: "All things are naked and open to his eyes." And who apprehends all spirits, namely the angelic ones, "because they run within him, wherever they may be sent," according to Bede on that passage in Luke 1: "I am Gabriel, who stand before God." Spirits Angels are called with respect to their substance or nature; intelligible, with respect to their power, or because they are by nature not uniteable to bodies. Or: apprehends, that is, causes to apprehend, all spirits, that is, all the gifts of the Holy Spirit, concerning which Isaiah 11: "The spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him, the spirit of wisdom and understanding," etc. Pure, namely through the purity of innocence: for Angels are, according to Dionysius, "pure and most brilliant mirrors"; and he adds: pure, to distinguish them from unclean spirits, that is, demons. Subtle, through the keenness of understanding; or: subtle, through wisdom; Gregory: "What is there that they do not see, who see him who sees all things?" Some books have pure, subtle: pure the spirit of wisdom is, because without the dregs of matter; subtle, because it is pure form. But the first reading is more correct, because thus Rabanus has it in the text and in the exposition. Or: pure the spirit of wisdom is called, because it cleanses from past sins and preserves from future ones; or because in the present it purges from guilt, in the future from punishment; undefiled, because it can contract no impurity either from itself or from another; subtle, because it penetrates all things, or because it works in us subtlety of affection with respect to the gift of wisdom, and of understanding with respect to the gift of intelligence or understanding.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For more mobile than all mobile things. Here he shows that wisdom, through its nature and through the power that is in it, was able to be the medium by which he was instructed. And to demonstrate this he first adduces its mobility; second, its purity: But she reaches; third, its power: And being but one; fourth, its beauty: For she is more beautiful.
(Verse 24). I have rightly said that in her there is a spirit, etc. For more mobile than all mobile things, by whatever kind of motion, namely whether in substance, or in quality, or in quantity, or in place, wisdom is more mobile, that is, swifter in working; the Gloss: "Nothing is more subtle and mobile than wisdom, which created, governs, and orders all things"; more mobile, I say, not because it is moved, but because it moves all things while remaining itself immobile, according to that saying of Boethius:
And remaining stable, you give all things to be moved.
Likewise Acts 17: "In him we live and move and have our being."
But she reaches, etc. Here he shows her purity, first through this, that she proceeds, or emanates, from the most pure fountain; second, because she represents in herself the brightness of the fountain: She is the brightness, etc.
Thus I said, that wisdom is more mobile than all mobile things: and not only so; moreover, standing for "but": but what is more, it reaches everywhere, that is, from the limit of the highest creature to the lowest creature: Ambrose in the Hexaemeron: "Divine wisdom has penetrated even to the locust."
But against this: Job 28: "The abyss says: It is not in me; the sea says: It is not with me."
The response is that there he speaks not of creatures, but of the defects of creatures. Or better it should be said that God is not in the abyss or in the sea by containment, since he can be contained by nothing, but he is there by presence, according to that Psalm: "If I ascend into heaven, you are there; if I descend into hell, you are present."
On account of its purity, that is, its abstraction from all material dregs: for because it is entirely immobile, therefore it is uncircumscribable, according to Damascene.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wisdom 7: Wisdom is more mobile than all mobile things: it is clear that he speaks of uncreated wisdom: therefore if wisdom itself is most mobile, it seems that the divine being is most mutable among all mutable things.
To this it must be said that something is called mobile in three ways: either through efficient causality, or through representative exemplarity, or through inherent variation. In the first and second ways wisdom is called most mobile, because this pertains to perfection: but not in the third, because this pertains to incompleteness.
Or it can be said that because a mobile thing according to position is made present to many places by its very motion, and that which is moved more swiftly is more swiftly presented to more places; hence it is that since divine wisdom is most present to all things, it is called most mobile among all mobile things, not because it passes from one thing to another, but because it is present to all things. And this is what Dionysius says in On the Divine Names, chapter nine: "That God is moved must be devoutly understood not according to conveyance, or mutation, or alteration, or modal or local motion, not rectilinear, not circular, not from both combined, not intelligible, not animate, not natural, but that God acts upon substance and contains all things and provides for all things totally, and that he is present to all things by encompassing all and by provident processions and operations toward all existing things."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is said of the virtues in the Book of Wisdom: For "she is an aura of the might of God and a pure effusion of the glory of the Almighty." Later, "she is the refulgence of eternal light," referring to purity or moderation; the "mirror," referring to prudence; "she reaches from end to end mightily," referring to fortitude; "and governs all things well," referring to justice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First to appear, then, in the eternal light, are the exemplary virtues, or the exemplars of the virtues, that is, the height of purity, the beauty of clarity, the strength of power and the straightness of diffusion. "Vapor is from the power of God and is a certain pure emanation from the clarity of the omnipotent God; and therefore nothing sullied is found in it." Behold, the height of purity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 25). For it is the vapor of the power of God, that is, emanating from God the Father, as vapor from heat: the Gloss: "That is, to warm the cold of our unbelief": Sirach 24: "Like an uncut Lebanon I sent forth vapor in my dwelling." And it is a certain emanation of the brightness of almighty God, that is, emanating from God the Father, as splendor from light, namely to illuminate the darkness of our intellect: Hebrews 1: "Who being the splendor of glory" etc.; likewise Isaiah 62: "Until his just one goes forth as splendor." Pure, without admixture of darkness: 1 John 1: "God is light, and in him there is no darkness at all." Moreover this procession is without diminution of the paternal substance, or separation, but with personal distinction, according to that of Athanasius: "Neither confounding the persons, nor separating the substance." And because it proceeds as light, which cannot be contaminated, therefore nothing defiled, by defilement either culpable or even natural, falls upon it, namely uncreated wisdom: the Gloss: "Evil does not approach the highest good."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That wisdom is a light descending to illuminate our intellective power is evident, because it is written in the book of Wisdom that "she is the brightness of eternal light, the unspotted mirror of God's majesty, and the image of his goodness. And being one, she can do all things, and remaining in herself, she renews all things, and through nations transfers herself into holy souls and constitutes friends of God and prophets. For God loves none but him who dwells with wisdom. For she is more beautiful than the sun and above every arrangement of the stars; compared to light, she is found to be prior." Rightly is wisdom called the seat of God, and the soul so described, which is more beautiful than heaven, indeed than the whole universe, is the seat of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Observing justice helps to obtain wisdom, as the tendency of matter inclines to the form and makes it able to be joined to the form through the medium of dispositions. And so keeping justice brings forth wisdom. Hence, "she is the refulgence of the eternal light, the spotless mirror of the power of God, the image of His goodness. And she, who is one, can do all things, and renews everything while herself perduring; and passing into holy souls from age to age."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is said of the virtues in the Book of Wisdom: "She is the refulgence of eternal light," referring to purity or moderation; the "mirror," referring to prudence; "she reaches from end to end mightily," referring to fortitude; "and governs all things well," referring to justice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Brightness is from eternal light, a spotless mirror of God's majesty and an image of His goodness." And: "This light, then, is more beautiful than the sun, and its brilliance is incomparably superior to any pattern of stars." Behold, the beauty of clarity. But where there is a mirror and an image and brightness, there is necessarily representation and beauty. "Beauty is nothing else but harmonious proportion." And here, there are proportionate relationships retraced to unity. And because this light is most beautiful, it reaches everywhere on account of its purity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second mode of generation is by means of expression: as in the case of the species coming out of the object, the imprint out of the seal, the speech out of the speaker, or the concept or thought out of the mind. And in these, there is deficiency. In the first, the reality of the object is lacking, for the species in the eye or in the soul is not the reality of the thing. In the second, simplicity is lacking, for the image or figure does not consist in a point or in something simple, but has parts. In the third, permanence is lacking, for speech passes away and does not remain. In the fourth, substance is lacking, for the concept of the mind is neither a substance nor a hypostasis. Take away such defects, and suppose an expression like the species deriving from the object but having reality, like the imprint produced by the seal but having simplicity, like the word coming forth from the speaker but having permanence, like the concept proceeding from the mind but having substance: and then you have the first part of the mirror.
The Psalm refers to the first manner of expression: "My heart overflows with a goodly theme." And there follows: "Fairer in beauty are you than the sons of men." Wisdom refers to the second: "For she is the refulgence of eternal light, the spotless mirror of the power of God, the image of His goodness." And the Apostle: "He is the image of the invisible God." Job refers to the third: "God speaketh once, and repeateth not the selfsame thing the second time." Understand this as meaning "in the Son," in the sense that He always is, and will never cease to be nor even be changed. In the fourth manner of expression, suppose substantiality, for the concept of the eternal mind is a hypostasis, and this mental concept is most noble and perfect. Hence, in Proverbs: "When there were no depths I was brought forth." And so He is sometimes called the Word, the Species, the Image, the Word remaining forever, the Concept—not as existing within a mind, but as being substantial: a hypostasis. And in this way we have the other part of the mirror.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 26). And truly nothing defiled falls upon it. For it is the brightness of eternal light, that is, the purest light from eternal light, namely proceeding from the Father; whence it is sung: "Light from light you appeared, O Christ." In this light the eternal light is seen, according to that Psalm: "In your light we shall see light"; likewise John 14: "He who sees me sees the Father also." It is therefore the brightness of eternal light, with respect to the representation of wisdom, and the spotless mirror of the majesty of God, with respect to the representation of divine majesty and power, according to that of John 5: "For whatever things he," namely the Father, "has done, these the Son likewise does." Without spot, I say, of sin, because "he did not commit sin" etc., 1 Peter 2. And the image of his goodness: the Gloss: "That is, the full representation of his goodness": Colossians 1: "Who is the image of the invisible God."
It should be noted that the mirror is the Son of God, immaculate in act and in potency. The mirror is also the Angel, according to Dionysius, pure and most clear, and although immaculate in act, yet stained in potency, at least remotely. The mirror is also the human spirit, in which the divine image shines forth, Genesis 1, stained in act and in potency. The mirror is also said to be every creature, because through it, as through its vestige, the invisible things of God are represented: Romans 1: "The invisible things of God are clearly seen from the creation of the world, being understood through the things that have been made": likewise 1 Corinthians 13: "We see now through a mirror in an enigma." The mirror is also Sacred Scripture: James 1: "He is compared to a man considering the countenance of his birth in a mirror."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Observing justice helps to obtain wisdom, as the tendency of matter inclines to the form and makes it able to be joined to the form through the medium of dispositions. Not that these dispositions perish, or even less, that they are fulfilled either in the human bodies or in others. And so keeping justice brings forth wisdom. Hence, "she is the refulgence of the eternal light, the spotless mirror of the power of God, the image of His goodness. And she, who is one, can do all things, and renews everything while herself perduring; and passing into holy souls from age to age."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But as soon as the soul has been made to resemble God, it enters into that Wisdom, because "She is the refulgence of eternal light, the spotless mirror of the power of God." And consequently, "she passes into holy souls from age to age." Without holiness, a man cannot be wise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 27). And being one, namely in essence with the Father, according to that saying of John 10: "I and the Father are one"; she can do all things, that is, she has the same power as the Father; whence below, chapter 18: "Your almighty word, O Lord, came from the royal throne."
But, if she can do all things, then she can lie or die: which is false.
It must be said that she can do all things that do not contradict her goodness, or those things which to be able to do is some power, not impotence.
And remaining in herself, namely unchangeable, according to that saying of James 1: "With whom there is no change" etc.: she renews all things, namely temporal things through continuous generation; Ecclesiastes 1: "A generation passes away, a generation comes": and spiritual things through spiritual regeneration: 2 Corinthians 5: "If any be a new creature in Christ, the old things have passed away": Revelation 21: "Behold, I make all things new." And through nations, carnal, or rather spiritual, of which John 3: "Unless one be born again of water" etc. Into holy souls, that is, those cleansed from sin, she conveys herself, through the spiritual coming of grace into the mind: John 14: "We will come to him" etc. It should be noted that to convey herself is said not through a new position or by changing place, but through a new effect: whence it follows: Friends of God, through the enkindling of the affections, and prophets she constitutes, through the illumination of the intellect: John 15: "I will no longer call you servants, but friends, because all things whatsoever I have heard from my Father, I have made known to you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 28). For God loves no one except him who dwells with wisdom, namely by remaining with him "who shall meditate on the law of the Lord day and night," according to the Gloss: Proverbs 8: "I, wisdom, dwell in counsel and am present among learned thoughts." And if God loves no one except him who dwells with wisdom: "blessed therefore is the man who shall abide in wisdom," Ecclesiasticus 14.
God loves no one etc. - On the contrary: Below in chapter 11: "You love all things that are," and yet not all things dwell with wisdom.
But it must be said that there he speaks of natural love, here of gratuitous love.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Brightness is from eternal light, a spotless mirror of God's majesty and an image of His goodness." And: "This light, then, is more beautiful than the sun, and its brilliance is incomparably superior to any pattern of stars." Behold, the beauty of clarity. But where there is a mirror and an image and brightness, there is necessarily representation and beauty. "Beauty is nothing else but harmonious proportion." And here, there are proportionate relationships retraced to unity. And because this light is most beautiful, it reaches everywhere on account of its purity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because He is illuminating light: For she is "fairer than the sun and surpasses every constellation of the stars." For although the sun possesses the means by which it can radiate, it yet does not have the species described within itself. Wherefore more beautiful is this Exemplar which has light and also the clear species of light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the wisdom of the Exemplar, there is in the seventh chapter of Wisdom: "For she is fairer than the sun and surpasses every constellation of the stars." It is indeed a beautiful wisdom, because it is light, but it is more beautiful than the sun, since the sun is unable to give birth to its radiance within itself, while the Eternal Sun begets the most beautiful Radiance within Himself. Likewise, eternal wisdom exerts its influence over all things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, the fruit of wisdom is born of the last four by contrast. Corresponding to this fruit, there are four acts, for wisdom is comforting, struggling, contemplating, and extolling. It is also contemplating the Supreme Good: "For she is fairer than the sun." Wisdom makes the soul taste the Supreme Good and be united to it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For she is more beautiful etc. Here he treats of the beauty of wisdom, preferring it to the beauty of the sun, and first he sets forth the comparison; second, the proof of the comparison: For night succeeds it.
(Verse 29.) I have rightly said that God loves him who dwells with wisdom, and deservedly so. For she, namely wisdom, is more beautiful than the sun, because spiritual beauty surpasses corporeal beauty: above in the same chapter: "Above health and beauty I loved her"; than the sun, namely the material sun, because she is the beauty of the sun of justice, of which Malachi 4 says: "The sun of justice shall arise for you who fear my name." And above every arrangement of the stars, it must be repeated: she is more beautiful. For she herself made the stars, Genesis 1, and it is certain that she retained more beauty for herself than she gave to the stars; therefore above in chapter 4: "O how beautiful is the chaste generation with brightness!" namely, of wisdom. Compared to light, namely both of the sun and of the stars, she is found to be prior, namely in eternity, dignity, and causality; whence Sirach 24: "I caused an unfailing light to rise in the heavens"; the Gloss: "Corporeal light, which now sets, now rises, compared to spiritual light, appears as a spark. Christ also far transcends the brightness of the saints."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From this it follows that the eternal light is also the most powerful. Hence, it is said: "Wickedness prevails not over Wisdom. Indeed, she reaches from end to end mightily." Behold, the strength of power. It reaches from the summit or the supreme unto the infinite, from the intrinsic unto the extrinsic, from the first unto the last, for the center of its might is everywhere: and that is the very reason why its power is infinite.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 30.) For night succeeds it, namely corporeal light, according to that passage in Genesis 8: "Night and day shall not cease"; likewise Isaiah 21: "Morning comes and also night." But night does not succeed spiritual light; whence it follows: But malice, which is spiritual darkness, does not overcome wisdom, which is spiritual light, according to John Damascene; whence John 1: "The light shines in the darkness."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is said of the virtues in the Book of Wisdom: "She reaches from end to end mightily," referring to fortitude; "and governs all things well," referring to justice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From this it follows that the eternal light is also the most powerful. Hence, it is said: "Wickedness prevails not over Wisdom. Indeed, she reaches from end to end mightily." Behold, the strength of power. It reaches from the summit or the supreme unto the infinite, from the intrinsic unto the extrinsic, from the first unto the last, for the center of its might is everywhere: and that is the very reason why its power is infinite.
And because of this, it enjoys straightness of diffusion. Behold, justice. Hence, it is written that it "governs all things well."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, he shows in three ways how much he loved wisdom.
She reaches therefore etc. Having shown how he acquired wisdom, here it is shown how much he loved it: and this he shows from three things: first, from the desire of having; second, from the purpose of acquiring: I purposed therefore; third, from the zeal of finding: Thinking upon these things etc.
First, concerning the twofold desire of having her.
In the first he shows the desire of having caused in himself, first from her absolute value; second, from her comparative value: And if riches.
He shows her absolute value first from her power; second, from her beauty: Her I loved etc.; third, from her nobility: Her noble birth; fourth, from her usefulness: For she is a teacher.
(Vers. 1.). Therefore, because wisdom is such as has been said, she reaches, by virtual contact, not corporeal, according to that passage of 1 Kings 10: "Whose hearts God had touched": from end to end: The Gloss: "From eternity unto eternity"; or: "from the beginning of the world unto the coming of Christ": Romans 10: "The end of the law is Christ" etc. Mightily: The Gloss: "Because she is the power of God": 1 Corinthians 1: "Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God." And she orders all things, namely the highest, the middle, and the lowest: sweetly: The Gloss: "Because she is the wisdom of God." She orders all things mightily through justice, and sweetly through mercy; the Psalmist: "All the ways of the Lord are mercy and truth," namely of justice: the same: "The mercy of the Lord is from eternity, and unto eternity upon those who fear him. And his justice unto children's children" etc.
It should be noted that Wisdom, that is the Son of God, reaches mightily those things which are in heaven, by expelling the proud devil with his companions: Job 26: "His prudence struck the proud one": Ezekiel 28: "You have sinned, and I cast you out from the mountain of God and destroyed you, O Cherub"! those things which are in the world, by overcoming and casting out the prince of the world: John 12: "Now shall the prince of this world be cast out": those things which are in hell, by carrying off the spoils of hell, according to the Gloss on Zechariah 9: "You also by the blood of your covenant have sent forth your prisoners out of the pit, wherein is no water."
He disposes moreover sweetly those things which are in heaven, by confirming the Angels standing in grace: in the Psalm: "By the word of the Lord the heavens were established": those things which are in the world, by redeeming the human race with his own blood: First Peter 1: "You were not redeemed with corruptible gold or silver etc., but with precious blood" etc.: those things which are in hell, by leading the souls of the Saints out of limbo, according to that of Zechariah 9: "You also by the blood of your covenant have sent forth your prisoners out of the pit" etc.: likewise in the Psalm: "You have ascended on high, you have led captivity captive" etc. — Or thus: since uncreated Wisdom is the middle Person in the Trinity, it can be said that she reaches from end to end, that is, from the Father to the Holy Spirit, namely through identity of substance, so that no local distance is understood, but personal distinction; mightily with respect to the Father, to whom power is attributed: and she disposes all things sweetly, with respect to the Holy Spirit, to whom benignity is attributed. — Or: she reaches from end to end, that is, from Divinity to humanity, namely in the Incarnation, in which the lowest things are united to the highest: mightily, that is, through infinite power: in the Psalm: "Stir up your power and come": the Gloss: "You yourself into flesh." And she disposed all things sweetly, in the procurement of human redemption: Matthew 11: "Learn from me, for I am meek and humble of heart." He was meek in the nature of the humanity assumed: for man is an animal gentle by nature, discerning by reason, upright in stature. In his manner of life: whence John the Baptist, seeing him walking one day, said: "Behold, the Lamb of God" etc., John 1. In his preaching: Matthew 4: "Do penance" etc.: likewise John 6: "You have the words of eternal life"; Matthew 11: "Come to me, all you who labor and are burdened, and I will give you rest." In the forgiveness of sins: John 8: "Go, and sin no more"; likewise Luke 6: "Forgive, and you shall be forgiven." In his Passion: whence Isaiah 53: "He shall be led as a sheep to the slaughter" etc.: likewise Jeremiah 11: "I was like a gentle lamb that is carried to the victim."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such a desire extinguishes all others, and makes man to be lifted up from the world. Hence he writes: "Her I loved and sought after from my youth; I sought to take her for my bride and was enamored of her beauty."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And since the author expresses himself as a philosopher and as a lover of Wisdom, he writes: "Her I loved and sought after from my youth; I sought to take her for my bride and was enamored of her beauty" — not only in itself, but also because, coming from her, similar properties are flowering in me.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From the second foursome, let us take wise, for it contains the other three. If He is wise, He is therefore living; and if living, He is powerful; and if powerful, beautiful also, for wisdom is the most beautiful form: wherefore "I was enamored of her beauty." Out of the third foursome, let us take one attribute: happy, which contains within itself the other three. For if He is a happy Spirit, therefore He is good, and hence just, and also holy. And so, in these three attributes, eternal, wise, and happy, the whole Trinity shines forth, for eternity is appropriated to the Father, wisdom to the Son, and happiness to the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Do not love the harlot and dismiss your wife: "Her I loved and sought after from my youth." Do not take in the acorns and pods of the swine, lest with Absalom you be hung by the hair, that is, by your dispositions. The teachings of the ages are like the oak: lofty, noble, inflexible. Do not choose to eat the pumpkins of Egypt and the leeks and the garlic, but "bread from heaven." And do not be disgusted with that food, do not be carnal as were the sons of Israel. For these found but one flavor, while others, spiritual men, found the sweetness of every taste.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 2.). There follows: Her, namely wisdom, because she is of such great power, I loved, namely with the affection of the heart: whence above in the seventh chapter: "Beyond health and beauty I loved her." And I sought her out, that is, I sought outside myself, by the effect of good work, according to that passage of First John 3: "Let us not love in word nor in tongue, but in deed and in truth." From my youth, as if to say: in the flower of my age: Proverbs 8: "They who in the morning," namely of youth, "watch for me, shall find me": therefore Sirach 6: "Son, from your youth receive instruction." And I sought, namely by the zeal of reading and prayer: Luke 11: "Seek, and you shall find": to take her to myself as a bride. He says bride by reason of love: Proverbs 7: "Say to wisdom: You are my sister, and call prudence your friend." Likewise, by reason of delight: Proverbs 5: "Rejoice with the wife of your youth." By reason of inseparability: Matthew 19: "For it is not lawful to dismiss a bride except for the cause of fornication": but this has no place in wisdom: "for nothing defiled enters into her," above in the seventh chapter. By reason of generation:
Sirach 24: "Come over to me, all you who desire me, and be filled from my generations." And I became a lover of her form, that is, of the beauty of wisdom, and this by perseverance and the love of fervent affection, converting it as it were into a habit: Zechariah 9: "What is his good and what is his beauty but the grain of the elect and the wine that makes virgins to bud forth"? that is, but wisdom, which restores the affection and makes chaste or purifies the intellect from the corruption of error.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 3.). Her nobility etc. Thus I loved wisdom etc., and deservedly, because uncreated wisdom, having companionship, that is, partnership and cohabitation, with God: the Gloss: "Of the Father, because she is coeternal with him": John 14: "I am in the Father, and the Father is in me": likewise John 1: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God": glorifies his nobility, "that is, represents the nobility of the Father," according to the Gloss. For the Son of God himself represents in himself the glory of the Father, because he is "the brightness of glory and the figure of his substance," as is found in Hebrews 1: likewise Proverbs 10, according to another reading: "A wise son is the glory of his father." Likewise his glory he manifests to the world: whence John 8: "I do not seek my own glory, but I honor" etc. But also the Lord of all things, namely the Father, of whom it is said in the Psalm: "The Lord said to me: You are my Son" etc.: loved her: "The Father loves the Son," John 5.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 4.). And rightly so: for she is the teacher of the discipline of God: Baruch 3: "He found out all the way of discipline," etc. Discipline is twofold, namely of deeds and of words: whence in the Psalm: "Thy discipline hath corrected me unto the end, and thy discipline itself shall teach me." On account of this he says: Teacher, etc., namely in words. And note that the discipline of God is formed faith, which makes disciples of God: Acts 9: "Saul, yet breathing out threatenings and slaughter against the disciples of the Lord," that is, against the faithful. And the chooser of His works, that is, of discipline which is in deeds: the chooser of His works, that is, teaching to choose the works of the discipline of faith, "For faith without works is dead," James 2.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And if riches are desired. Here he shows the desire caused by the comparative value of wisdom, and first in comparison to money, which is the perfection of fortune; second, in comparison to industry, which is the perfection of nature: But if understanding: third, in comparison to virtue, which is the perfection of grace: And if justice: fourth, in comparison to knowledge, which is the perfection of intelligence: And if multitude.
(Vers. 5.). And if riches are desired, although they ought not to be desired — "for they who wish to become rich fall into temptation and into the snare of the devil," 1 Timothy 6; likewise in the Psalm: "If riches abound, set not your heart upon them" — in life, namely the present life, for its sustenance and sufficiency. What is richer than wisdom, which works all things? John 5: "My Father worketh until now, and I work": I, namely uncreated wisdom; nor can he be poor who works all things. For he knows how to make silver and gold and things of this kind; therefore Proverbs 8 says: "With me are riches and glory, stately wealth"; Augustine: "Exceedingly rich is the Christian religion, to which it has been given to possess all things in the possessor of all things."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 6.). But if understanding, that is, natural or acquired industry, works, because "art imitates nature" in working, according to the Philosopher: who among all things that exist is a greater artisan than she? As if to say: no one; whence in the Psalm: "Thou hast made all things in wisdom." The Lord filled Bezalel with wisdom, so that he might know how to make the works of the tabernacle, as is found in Exodus 31.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"For she teaches moderation and prudence, justice and fortitude, and nothing in life is more useful for men than these." These are impressed upon the soul by the said exemplary light, and they go down into the cognitive, the affective and the operative faculties. The sincerity of temperance is marked by the height of purity; the serenity of prudence, by the beauty of clarity; the stability of constancy, by the strength of power; the sweetness of justice, by the straightness of diffusion. These are the four exemplary virtues with which the whole of Scriptures is concerned; and Aristotle felt nothing about them, in contrast with ancient and noble philosophers.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 7.). And if one loves justice, namely general justice, that is, the rectitude of human life, concerning which above in chapter one: "Love justice," etc. The labors of this one, namely of wisdom, by which one labors to obtain her: and he says labors in the plural, because to obtain her one must labor greatly. Second Corinthians 11: "In labors most abundant"; have great virtues, that is, they acquire them. The Gloss: "Nothing idle, nothing slothful in her works." Sobriety indeed, etc. The Gloss: "He sets forth four principal virtues": sobriety, "that is, temperance," in avoiding superfluous evil. Below in chapter nine: "She will lead me in my works soberly." And she teaches wisdom, in discerning and loving the good. And justice, in rendering what is due. And virtue, "that is, fortitude," to which the name virtue more properly belongs, as though protecting by force, in enduring what is difficult and undertaking what is arduous. Concerning these three, Proverbs eight: "Mine is equity, mine is prudence, mine is fortitude." The Gloss: "No one has had these virtues except he to whom the origin of all virtues, God, bestowed them, in whatever time, under whatever law, in whatever nation. Yet certain ones, having the appearance of piety, were ignorant of virtue."
But did the philosophers have virtue? And it seems so, because according to the Philosopher, virtue is had through acquisition.
It must be said that they did not have perfect virtues but imperfect ones, because they were without merit and unformed. Or they had them from God through gratuitously given grace, though not through sanctifying grace.
Than which nothing is more useful in the life of men, that is, in the human life of man in relation to man.
But are the theological virtues not more useful and better?
It must be said that, as has been touched upon, he speaks of the human life of man in comparison to man, not to God, for he presupposes this. Now nothing is more useful to men than these, because they benefit man in acting and in suffering: in acting, because through prudence there is right choice of things to be done, and through justice right execution: in suffering, because through temperance we rightly dispose ourselves toward effeminate passions, and through fortitude toward unstable passions. Therefore the Gloss says: "He who is temperate, prudent, brave, and just—what does he lack?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 8.). And if a multitude of knowledge etc. Some have: And a likeness of knowledge, but that reading is false, although the present knowledge of man can more rightly be called a likeness of knowledge than knowledge, because it is mixed with much mutability and much ignorance. If, a multitude, I say, of knowledge, namely speculative knowledge, anyone desires, according to that saying of the Philosopher: "All men by nature desire to know"—it knows things past, namely wisdom itself, and judges of future things, with certainty, although they are hidden by the condition of time, because past things have already passed away and future things have not yet come to pass. It knows, I say, things past etc.: whence Moses, taught by it, prophesied concerning things past—Genesis 1: "In the beginning God created heaven and earth"; likewise concerning things future, Deuteronomy 18: "The Lord shall raise up a Prophet from your nation and from your brethren." It knows the subtleties of speeches, that is, the obscure cunning of simple propositions, such as riddles, and not only the subtleties of simple propositions, but also of composite ones; whence there follows: And the solutions of arguments, that is, of reasonings, which nevertheless lie hidden due to the more perplexing nature of human cunning: Sirach 39: "He shall seek out the hidden meanings of proverbs, namely the wise man, "and shall be conversant in the hidden things of parables." Whence Christ, "in whom were hidden the treasures of wisdom and knowledge," could not be caught in speech, as is evident in Matthew 22; and no word of the Queen of Sheba could be hidden from Solomon, who was taught by wisdom, as is evident in 3 Kings 10. Signs, namely lesser ones, which occur beyond nature, and wonders, which occur against the common course of nature, it knows before they happen, just as well as when they have already occurred. Concerning these two, John 4: "Unless you see signs and wonders, you do not believe." These things are likewise hidden by reason of natural difficulty, because "a miracle, according to Augustine, is a work arduous and unusual, surpassing the hope and capacity of the one who marvels." And the events of times, that is, of those things which come to pass in the present time, and of ages, that is, of those that follow, which come to pass in eternity and in the future. To know these things, however, is not given to man: whence Acts 1: "It is not for you to know the times or moments which the Father has placed in His own power": these things, however, are hidden by reason of a hidden cause.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Secondly, this is shown from the resolve to acquire it.
I resolved therefore etc. Above he showed how much he loved wisdom, and this from his desire of possessing it: here from his resolve to acquire it, and this on account of the goods which come forth from it, and first on account of goods pertaining commonly to both lives: secondly, on account of those pertaining to the active life: I shall have through her: thirdly, on account of those pertaining especially to the contemplative life: Entering into my house.
First, on account of goods pertaining to both lives.
(Vers. 9.). Therefore, because she is such, I purposed, that is, I firmly resolved in my heart: her, namely divine wisdom, not another adulterous one, such as the poetic disciplines, which Boethius in the Consolation calls "meretricious": to bring to myself, not only to another, against those who only teach others but do not teach themselves, whom the Apostle reproves, saying in Romans 2: "You who teach another, do you not teach yourself?" To feast together, that is, to refresh, namely the affection, not only to illuminate the intellect, as many who are in no way moved by sacred Scripture: Fourth Kings 7: "You shall see it with your eyes, but you shall not eat of it": likewise to feast together, he says, that is, to be refreshed in common and together: because in the goods of wisdom we are fed and refreshed: whence Proverbs 9: "Eat my bread, and drink the wine that I have mingled for you": and she in our goods: whence Proverbs 8: "My delights are to be with the children of men." We ought to serve her the first course, as if from herbs prepared, from the lilies of uprightness: Song of Songs 2: "He who feeds among the lilies, until the day breaks," etc. The second, of kid's flesh, that is, the detestation of all sin and iniquity, both carnal and spiritual: on these two kids she willingly feasts, as did Isaac, Genesis 27. The third, of roasted fish of patience and tribulation: "They offered him a piece of roasted fish," Luke 24. The last, of the fruit of the spirit, that is, of the works of devotion: Song of Songs 5: "Let my beloved come into his garden, and eat the fruit of his apple trees." Knowing that she will share with me of goods, namely her own. This is the symbolic invitation of Revelation 3: "I will sup with him, and he with me": and he says: of goods, in the plural, because both of present and future goods. And there shall be comfort: Gloss: "That is, alleviation": of thought, that is, of affliction in thinking, as regards the intellect, according to that passage of Ecclesiastes, last chapter: "Frequent meditation is an affliction of the flesh." And of my weariness, in working, and this as regards the affection: Second Corinthians 1: "We were pressed out of measure above our strength, so that we were weary even of living."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, on account of the goods pertaining to the active life.
I shall have etc. Here he touches upon the goods pertaining to the active life, especially those necessary for prelates, and first, as regards the act of judging: second, as regards the act of teaching: When I am silent etc.: third, as regards the act of associating: Moreover I shall have etc.: fourth, as regards the act of governing: I shall set peoples in order.
As regards the act of judging he touches upon two things: first, authority: second, discernment: Young and keen etc.
(Vers. 10.). Through this I shall have, namely through wisdom, which "is bright," as is stated above in chapter six, renown, namely of fame: Matthew 5: "Let your light shine" etc.; likewise Philippians 2: "Among whom you shine as luminaries in the firmament" etc. Before the multitudes, that is, before those of lower rank: and honor, namely of reverence, before the elders, that is, before those of higher rank: Job 29: "The young men saw me and hid themselves, and the aged rising up stood." From these two things a man becomes of great authority, namely from the esteem of those below and the reverence of those above. Though young, that is, vigorous and diligent in investigating.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 11.). And keen, that is, subtle in penetrating and discovering, I shall be found in judgment,- the Gloss: "Judging all things according to the laws": such was Daniel, as is clear from Daniel 13. And, supply: therefore, and in the sight of the powerful, that is, of lesser prelates, I shall be admirable, and the faces of princes, that is, of greater prelates, shall wonder at me. This was literally true of Solomon, as is clear from 3 Kings 10, where it is said that "the queen of Sheba, having heard the fame of Solomon" etc., said: "The wisdom that I have found is greater than the report that I heard." This was also true of our Savior: whence Matthew 14: "The tetrarch heard the fame of Jesus and said to his servants" etc. This is also true of the perfectly wise man: Sirach 24: "In the midst of his people he shall be exalted, and in the holy fullness he shall be admired."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 12.). When I am silent, that is, what I am to teach, they shall premeditate: in the Psalm: "The mouth of the just shall meditate wisdom." They shall wait, that is, they shall wait in silence, "not daring to speak," according to the Gloss: Job 29: "They waited for me as for rain, and they opened their mouth as for the latter rain." And when I speak etc., he rightly placed silence before speech, because, according to Jerome, "the teaching of Pythagoras was to be silent for five years and afterward to speak as learned men." And when I speak they shall look upon me, namely attentively, and this as a sign of attention: Job 29: "Attentive, they were silent at my counsel." And when I discourse at greater length, but not superfluously or excessively, because "in much speaking," or in superfluity of words, "sin shall not be wanting," Proverbs 10. Note that plurality is constituted by two or three, but not multitude. They shall lay their hands upon their mouth: the Gloss: "Not daring to resist me": Job 29: "The princes ceased to speak, and laid their finger upon their mouth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 13.). Moreover through her, namely through wisdom, I shall have immortality, namely of eternal glory in heaven: Proverbs 3: "She is a tree of life to those who lay hold of her." And a remembrance: Gloss: "Of my works and virtues," eternal, that is, perpetual, as long as the world shall endure: I shall leave to those who shall come after me: Proverbs 10: "The memory of the just is with praises": in the Psalm: "The just shall be in eternal memory."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“I shall govern etc. Here are touched upon the goods had through wisdom with respect to the act of governing, and first with respect to subjects: second, with respect to outsiders: They shall fear etc.
(Vers. 14.). He says therefore: I shall govern: Gloss: "I shall instruct," namely by ruling and governing, peoples, having the Law. For a people is a multitude of men living under one law, as the Jews under the law of Moses. And nations, that is, gentiles not having the Law, and they are called nations, because not reborn, but remaining in the uncircumcision and vice of their birth: in the Psalm: "He subjected peoples to us and nations under our feet": Isaiah 55: "Behold, I have given him as a witness to peoples, a leader and commander to nations." Nations, I say, shall be subject to me through obedience.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 15.). Hearing me, dreadful kings shall fear me, that is, tyrants and the impious: whence all the kings round about became tributaries of Solomon, 3 Kings 9: likewise Isaiah 60: "The sons of those who humiliated you shall come to you bowed down." And in the multitude, "namely of the faithful," I shall appear good, "that is, benign," and in war, "namely of adversaries," valiant. All these things spiritually, according to the Gloss, were fulfilled in Christ and can be expounded of him, as is clear to one examining the Glosses.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, on account of goods pertaining to the contemplative life.
(Vers. 16.). Entering into my house, that is, my conscience, namely by returning from exterior care to interior care, just as the "disciples" after preaching "returned to the Lord with joy," as is found in Luke 10. He placed action before contemplation by reason of time, not by reason of dignity, just as Leah before Rachel, Genesis 29. I shall rest with her, that is, I shall rest together in her, and she with me or in me: Sirach 32: "Run ahead first to your house, and there withdraw and there play," etc. Well did I say: I shall rest with her: for it has no bitterness, of exterior disturbance, her conversation, that is, cohabitation: Sirach 24: "My spirit is sweeter than honey"; nor weariness, namely of interior affliction, her company: ibid.: "Those who eat me shall still hunger," against disgust. These two, namely the bitterness of exterior disturbance and the weariness of interior affliction, are contrary to rest. And therefore she removes them, adding two opposites, when she says: But gladness, namely interiorly, and joy, namely exteriorly: Sirach 1: "She will give delight and joy"; likewise Sirach 15: "The Lord filled her with the spirit of wisdom," etc.; likewise ibid.: "Delight and exultation," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, the same is shown from the zeal of seeking wisdom in a threefold manner.
Thinking upon these things, etc. Here third he shows how much he loved wisdom, and this from the zeal of seeking her. And concerning this, first he shows the diligence of seeking: second, the aptitude for receiving: But I was a boy: third, the confidence of obtaining: And as I knew
First, the diligence of seeking wisdom is shown.
In the first part he sets forth three causes moving one to seek knowledge: first, the effect of wisdom in the heart: second, the effect in work: And in works: third, the effect in speech: And in the contest of speech.
(Vers. 17.). These things, namely the foregoing, pondering within myself, frequently meditating on them, and recalling in my heart, namely the following things, bringing them back to memory lest I forget: for the animal that "chews the cud and divides the hoof," namely by remembering and discerning, is clean, Leviticus 11: Luke 2: "Mary kept all these words," etc. That she is immortal, namely by nature, or by the effect of the immortality which she confers: whence above in the same book: "Through her I shall have immortality." In the thought of wisdom, that is, in the understanding: the Gloss: "Whatever is known of her nature, the whole is found to be immortal and ever living": below in chapter 15: "To know your justice and your power is the root of immortality."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 18.). And in friendship with her, namely when she is loved, good delight, namely in the affection: good he says as opposed to the delight of sin, which is evil, because it leads to eternal torment, according to that saying of Gregory: "What delights is momentary, what torments is eternal"; likewise the Gloss: "Bodily pleasures weigh down the body, but spiritual pleasures uplift the mind; and the more they are consumed, the more they are hungered for. In the former, the appetite pleases but the experience displeases; but spiritual delights increase desire, and the more they are partaken of, the more eagerly they are loved." And in the works of her hands, that is, in good works, which are done through her hands, that is, by her power and might: John fifteen: "Without me you can do nothing"; honor without failing, that is, perfect honor: for virtue and the work of virtue belong to the genus of the honorable: below in chapter ten: "She honored him in his labors"; likewise above in chapter seven: "Innumerable honor through her hands." And in the contest of her discourse, namely that which takes the form of disputation, in which there is a certain contest between the one objecting and the one responding: wisdom, that is, knowledge; supply: is acquired: Sirach, last chapter: "My soul wrestled with her." And renown, that is, the evidence of illustrious virtue, in the sharing of her words, which namely are shared by way of simple conference: Sirach 24: "Those who elucidate me shall have eternal life"; likewise Daniel 12: "Those who instruct many unto justice shall be as stars for perpetual eternities." I went about: the Gloss: "Diligently and studiously": Song of Songs three: "I will arise and go about the city": seeking, like the woman of whom Luke fifteen says: "Who lights a lamp and sweeps the house, seeking diligently until she finds it." That I might take her to myself, namely as a bride: whence above in the same chapter: "I sought to take her as my bride."
In the aforesaid text, eight things useful to the preacher or teacher concerning the learning of wisdom or concerning the acquisition of wisdom are touched upon: reflection upon her through investigation, recollection through frequent practice, delight through love, action through fulfillment, contention through disputation, communication through conference, going about through questioning, taking up through incorporation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, the aptitude for receiving her.
Now I was a child etc. Here he touches on the aptitude for receiving, first on the part of natural ability, because as a child I was of good natural talent: second on the part of grace, because I obtained a good soul: third on the part of purity, because, since I was more good, I came to an undefiled body.
(Vers. 19. 20.). He says therefore: Now I was an ingenious child: note that he speaks in the person of Solomon. Ingenious by natural industry: Proverbs 20: "A child is known by his pursuits, whether his works be clean and right." And I obtained, that is, attained by the lot of divine election: Acts 1: "The lot fell upon Matthias"; a good soul, namely through grace: 3 Kings 3: "Solomon loved the Lord, walking in the precepts of David, his father."
And since I was more good, namely from superadded grace, than I was previously from natural industry, I came etc. For according to Augustine, temporal goods are the lowest goods, natural goods the middle, gratuitous goods the highest. I came, I say, by the resolution and zeal of the mind, to an undefiled body, supply: to have and preserve through purity.
But the Gloss objects that this can scarcely be understood literally of Solomon, because "he loved women, even foreign ones," as is evident from 3 Kings 11.
But the solution is clear through a distinction of times: in youth he loved purity, but in old age, lust. Nevertheless, these things can be better understood of Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, the confidence of obtaining it.
(Vers. 21.). And as I knew, namely by the most certain cognition of faith and reason, that otherwise I cannot be continent unless God grant it. "For every best gift and every perfect gift is from above" etc., James 1; but continence is a most perfect gift: Sirach 26: "No weight is worthy of a continent soul." And this itself was wisdom, that is, a certain effect of wisdom in me, namely to know whose this gift was; above in the same: "She is the instructress of the discipline of God." As I knew, I say, etc., I went to the Lord, by the intention of the mind, not by the steps of the body. In the Psalm: "Come to him, and be enlightened." And I besought him, namely by the word of vocal prayer: James 1: "If any of you lack wisdom, let him ask of God." And I said from all my inmost heart, namely with the fervor of devotion, according to that word of Isaiah 26: "Yea, with my spirit in the morning within my inmost heart I will watch for thee"; in the Psalm: "I cried with my whole heart: hear me, O Lord."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, he shows how devoutly he sought wisdom from God.
O God of my fathers, etc. After he has shown how he received wisdom and how greatly he loved what he received, here he shows how devoutly he sought it from God. And first he touches upon the form of the petition; second, the reason for being heard: But you have chosen; third, the end of the petition: Send her; fourth, the difficulty of the end: For who, etc.
First, the form of the petition is touched upon.
In the first part, he first praises the beauty; second, specifies the gift: Give me [the wisdom] of your throne; third, humbles himself: For I am your servant; fourth, intimates his need: And if anyone, etc.
(Vers. 1.). O God of my fathers, namely through the grace of election: of the fathers, namely the ancient ones: Exodus 3: "I am the God of your father, the God of Abraham," etc. Or: O God of my fathers, that is, who made my fathers and chose them and sanctified them. And Lord of mercy, that is, merciful Lord, so that it is an intransitive construction; or: Lord of mercy, that is, author [of mercy], so that it is a transitive construction: in the Psalm: "The Lord is compassionate and merciful." Lord, I say, of mercy, namely through the effect of the remission of sins and of justification; for mercy regards misery: Proverbs 14: "Sin makes peoples wretched." Who made all things, namely through the work of creation, as is evident in Genesis 1: in the Psalm: "He spoke, and they were made": by your Word, that is, through your Son: John 1: "In the beginning was the Word," etc., and afterward: "All things were made through him."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 2.). And by your wisdom, that is, by the same Son of yours, according to that verse of the Psalm: "You made all things in wisdom"; you established, that is, you composed from very diverse parts, namely from a rational spirit and earthly clay: man: Sirach 17: "God created man from the earth." And it should be noted that the other things he says were made by the Word alone, but man by wisdom, as if a nobler work, because he is capable of wisdom both created and uncreated, and therefore as if a work requiring greater deliberation; on account of which the Lord, as if deliberating, says in Genesis 1: "Let us make man in our image," etc. That he might have dominion over the creature that was made by you, over the creature, namely not the spiritual or angelic, but the corporeal, and this through power: Genesis 1: "Have dominion over the fish of the sea," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 3.). That he may order the world: namely through wisdom: for man is placed in this world as a king in a kingdom. In equity, that is, mercy, and justice: for these two ought to be joined together in governing: Gregory: "Discipline and mercy are greatly weakened if one is maintained without the other." And in the uprightness of heart, namely through goodness, and this through a right intention toward God: in the Psalm: "I will praise you in the uprightness of heart": Job chapter thirty-four: "If he direct his heart to God, he will draw his spirit and breath to himself": let him judge judgment, namely over his subjects. By the name of judgment simply spoken, he understands a "true" or just judgment. For just as a painted or dead man is not a man, so a false or unjust judgment is not a judgment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 4.). Give me, "from whom is every best gift," James chapter one: wisdom, namely understanding, the attendant of your thrones, that is, the indweller of holy souls: above in chapter seven: "She passes into holy souls throughout the nations." Holy souls are called the thrones of God, because in them God sits and rests, presiding over and commanding all their movements and affections: Isaiah, the last chapter: "Heaven is my throne"; the Gloss: "The soul of the just is the throne of wisdom." And do not reject me, giving me goodness and grace in my affection: do not, I say, reject me, as those of whom it is said in Romans chapter one: "He gave them over to a reprobate mind": Jeremiah chapter six: "Call them rejected silver." From among your children, namely by excluding me from the number and fellowship of your children, of whom Isaiah chapter eight says: "Behold, I and my children," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 5.). Because etc., as if to say: therefore I ask that you give me wisdom, because I am your servant, that is, prepared to serve you: in the Psalm: "I am your servant, give me understanding": Third Kings, chapter ten: "Blessed are your servants, who hear your wisdom". And the son of your handmaid, that is, of the synagogue, concerning which Galatians chapter four says: "It is written that Abraham had two sons". According to the Gloss, these words are "of the Son to the Father", inasmuch as he is a man seeking wisdom for his members, alleging himself to be his servant according to his humanity, not his Son: Isaiah chapter forty-nine: "You are my servant, Israel, because in you I will be glorified". And the son of your handmaid, that is, of the Virgin Mary, according to that passage in Luke chapter one: "Behold, the handmaid of the Lord". A weak man, on the part of the body, on account of the body's frailty: in the Psalm: "Have mercy on me, O Lord, for I am weak". And of short time, on account of the brevity of life: Job chapter fourteen: "Man born of woman, living for a short time"; and lesser, on the part of the soul, that is, insufficient by natural power, for the understanding: the Gloss says: "For perceiving": of judgment, that is, of your judgments, by whose example one must judge: and of laws, namely your eternal laws, by whose regulation one must judge: Romans chapter eleven: "O the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God, how incomprehensible are his judgments, and unsearchable his ways".”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 6.). And if anyone etc., in this charity is intimated, he will be consummate, that is, perfect: the Gloss says: "In judgment"; among the sons of men, who are born, namely, from man and woman, in distinction from the Son of Man, that is, of the Virgin alone, concerning whom Matthew chapter sixteen says: "Whom do men say the Son of Man is"? And he says: consummate among the sons of men, because one can be a mere man by nature. If from him it shall have fled or departed, namely as from one unworthy and a sinner, according to that passage above, chapter one: "Into a malevolent soul wisdom will not enter": your wisdom: the Gloss says: "Divine", not worldly. For worldly wisdom does not flee on account of sin: Jeremiah chapter four: "They are wise to do evil". As nothing, namely of morals, not of nature, he will be reckoned, namely before God and his Saints: below, chapter thirteen: "Vain are all men in whom there is not the knowledge of God": for by grace a man is what he is with respect to moral being: whence First Corinthians chapter fifteen: "By the grace of God I am what I am"; likewise, without charity a man is nothing, as is clear from First Corinthians chapter thirteen: and according to Augustine, a sinner is nothing, namely insofar as he is such.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, the twofold reason for being heard.
But you have chosen etc. Here he adds the manifold reason for being heard, of which the first is the enjoined office of the kingdom: the second is the command to build the temple: And you said etc.
(Vers. 7.). But you etc., as if to say: thus I am by myself insufficient without wisdom. But, standing for "however": nevertheless you have chosen me: The Gloss: "Solomon, or Christ." As king over your people, that is, over those believing in you: in the Psalm: "But I have been established as king by him over Sion" etc.: and judge of your sons and daughters, namely yours, that is, of the faithful, according to that passage in John chapter one: "He gave them the power to become sons of God, to those who believe in his name." The office of a king is to exercise his judgment also in other affairs of the kingdom; but that of a judge is specifically in the cases of the people.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 8.). And you said: The Gloss: "You commanded"; for David, who was a man of blood, was not permitted to build the temple, but Solomon the peaceful was chosen for this, as is clear from 2 Kings chapter seven and 1 Chronicles chapter twenty-nine. And you said, I say, that I should build a temple on your holy mountain, that is, on Mount Moriah, where you willed holy things to be done; and in the city of your dwelling, namely Jerusalem, where he was said to dwell because there he was worshipped more excellently; an altar, namely of burnt offerings, of burnt offerings, I say, to distinguish it from the bronze altar, which was in the court before the temple in the open air. A likeness of your holy tabernacle, that is, according to its exemplar, of which Exodus chapter twenty-five speaks, which was made according to the exemplar of the heavenly tabernacle; whence in the same place: "Look and make it according to the exemplar that was shown to you on the mountain." Which you prepared: The Gloss: "Through Moses"; from the beginning, not of creation, but of the giving of the Law; whence the Gloss: "When you were leading the children of Israel out of Egypt." The tabernacle in the desert, as the Gloss says, signified the Church Militant, but the temple in Jerusalem the Church Triumphant. The reason for this is that the tabernacle in the desert was movable, but the temple in Jerusalem was immovable.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 9.). And with you, namely prepared it, your wisdom, namely uncreated, "that is, your Son," of whom 1 Corinthians chapter one says: "Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God." Who knows your works, as the co-worker of all things, according to that passage of the Psalm: "You have made all things in wisdom." Who was present, with you, then, namely when you made the world: Proverbs chapter eight: "When he was laying the foundations of the earth, I was with him composing all things"; and in the same: "I was delighted with him every day, playing in the world." And she knew that it was pleasing in your eyes, namely as regards counsels; in your eyes, namely of your intellect and your affection, that is, of your mercy and your truth, "for in every work of God there is mercy and truth"; Sirach chapter forty-two: "She found grace before the eyes of the Lord," according to another translation. And what was right: The Gloss: "That is, upright and just"; in your precepts: in the Psalm: "The justices of the Lord are right, gladdening hearts."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, the end of the petition is touched upon in two ways.
Send her, etc. Here he shows the end of the petition, that is, for what purpose he sought wisdom: and first he asks for wisdom in order to know and do the will of God. Second, he shows that it avails for the attainment of such an end: For she knows.
(Vers. 10.). He says therefore: Send her, namely wisdom, etc. It should be noted that there is a twofold sending of Wisdom, namely one visible into the flesh, concerning which John 10: "Whom the Father sanctified and sent into the world"; the other into the mind, which he asks for here. From your holy heavens, that is, from yourself, who are heaven by containing all things; in the Psalm: "From the highest heaven is his going forth," likewise James 3: "The wisdom that is from above is first indeed pure," etc. He says from the heavens in the plural on account of the multitude of things contained and of effects in the things contained, just as the days of eternity are spoken of in the plural: Micah 5: "And his going forth is as from the beginning of the days of eternity." And from the throne of your greatness: The Gloss: "From yourself, who sitting and at rest, govern all things"; Isaiah 18: "I will be at rest and will consider in my place, as the noonday light is clear."
And it should be noted that uncreated Wisdom is sometimes said to be in the bosom of the Father, as John 1: "The Only-begotten, who is in the bosom of the Father, has declared to us"; sometimes to be begotten from the womb, in the Psalm: "From the womb before the daystar I begot you"; sometimes to proceed from the mouth of the Father, Sirach 24: "I came forth from the mouth of the Most High, the firstborn before every creature"; sometimes to be sent from heaven, as here; sometimes to sit in holy souls, whence above in the same place: "Give me the wisdom that attends your thrones," etc. The first on account of concealment, the second on account of consubstantiality, the third on account of manifestation, the fourth on account of illumination, the fifth on account of tranquility.
That she may be with me, namely within, in the essence of the soul, both by dwelling through grace and by informing: Sirach 24: "Dwell in Jacob," etc. And may labor with me, the motive power of the soul for action by perfecting: Sirach, the last chapter: "I remembered your mercy, O Lord, and your work, which are from of old." That I may know, that is, that you may make me know, the cognitive power of my soul by illuminating, what is acceptable before you, or in your sight; in the Psalm: "Teach me to do your will."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 11.). For she knows all those things, namely all things pertaining to the knowledge of reason, such as lower things: and understands, namely all things pertaining to the understanding of the intellect, as are higher things, above in chapter seven: "Beholding all things." And she will guide me soberly in my works: Gloss: "Lest I offend," by directing in good work: above in chapter eight: "She teaches sobriety," etc. And she will guard me in her power: Gloss: "From adversaries," by protecting: in the Psalm: "Unless the Lord guard the city," etc.: likewise: "Behold, he shall neither slumber nor sleep," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 12.). And my works will be acceptable: Gloss: "Before God," as done purely out of love for him. And I shall govern your people justly, namely by rightly governing subjects: whence above in chapter eight: "I shall govern peoples and nations." And I shall be worthy of the thrones of my father, by imitating him: he says thrones in the plural, because there is the throne of the present kingdom, according to that passage in Proverbs eight: "By me kings reign": and of the future: Gloss: "By the recompense of the heavenly kingdom."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fourth, the difficulty of this end is shown in two ways.
For what man, etc. Here he shows the difficulty of the end, first showing that the will of God cannot be known without wisdom: second, that it can be known only through her: But your meaning.
That it cannot be known without her, he shows first from the profundity of the divine mind: second, from the imperfection of the human mind: For the thoughts: third, from comparison with sensible things, there: And we judge with difficulty, etc.
(Vers. 13.). Rightly I said: Send her forth, etc.: for what man, namely a mere man, will be able to know, namely without your wisdom, the counsel of God? which consists in foreseeing and disposing things to be done: Isaiah forty: "Who has helped the spirit of the Lord, or who has been his counselor?" Or who will be able to think, that is, to know by thinking, what God wills? namely by carrying out what has been foreseen, as if to say: no one: whence Romans eleven: "O the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 14.). For the thoughts of mortals, namely as long as we are in the state of mortality, are fearful: Gloss: "That is, fragile": and this with regard to those things which are above reason. And our foresight is uncertain: Gloss: "Because the soul is changeable, and the flesh is corruptible," and this with regard to those things which are beneath reason and the contemplation of truth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The body, which is corrupted, weighs down the soul." The human intellect has the character of apprehending and judging, the possible and the agent intellect: nor can this intellect be sufficiently illuminated without the aid of a higher and loftier light. The Philosopher says: "As the eye of the bat is related to the light of the sun, so is our intellect related to the things most manifest in nature."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 15.). For the body, which is corrupted, that is, which is subject to continual corruption, on account of which it is compared to rottenness; Job twenty-five: "Man is rottenness, and the son of man a worm." Weighs down the soul, namely by drawing back its affection from heavenly things: Galatians five: "The flesh lusts against the spirit."
The body, which is corrupted, weighs down the soul. It should be noted that the body stains the soul with original sin: Job 14: "Who can make clean what is conceived of unclean seed?" Likewise, it binds to the necessity of venial sin: Romans 7: "The evil that I hate, that I do." Likewise, it inclines to mortal sin: Genesis 8: "The senses are prone, and the thought of the human heart is prone to evil from youth." Likewise, it clouds the intellect from the contemplation of truth: above, chapter 2: "Our time is the passing of a shadow," namely by the interposition of an opaque body between the soul and the sun of justice. Likewise, it retards the affection from the love of heavenly things, as here: "The body, which is corrupted, weighs down the soul." Likewise, it hinders and binds the motive powers from good: in the Psalm: "Bring forth from custody, or from prison," "my soul"; likewise Romans 7: "The good that I will, that I do not." Likewise, it stirs up continual war against the spirit: Galatians 5: "The flesh lusts against the spirit." Likewise, care for itself makes the spirit anxious, against which Matthew 6: "Be not anxious," etc. Likewise, it disturbs the soul with its troubles: Daniel 13: "Distresses are upon me from every side." Likewise, by its mutability it disturbs and unsettles the soul's repose: Job 14: "And never remains in the same state."
And the earthly habitation presses down, that is, presses downward by drawing back from the contemplation of eternal things, that is, by inclining toward earthly things: the sense, that is, the human intellect: Genesis 8: "The sense and thought of the human heart are prone to evil from youth": therefore Romans 7: "Unhappy" etc. The sense, I say, that thinks on many things, that is, temporal things, which are many, not eternal things, which are one, according to that of Luke 10: "You are troubled about many things, but one thing is necessary."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 16.). And with difficulty etc., as if to say: And this is evident, because we judge with difficulty, that is, we know estimatively, not with certitude: Ecclesiastes 1: "All things are difficult": the things that are on earth, that is, lower sensible things. And the things that are in sight, "that is, in the open," such as the natures of higher sensible things: we find with labor: Ecclesiastes 8: "There is a man who day and night takes no sleep with his eyes: and I understood that of all the works of God, man can find no reason." The Philosopher: "As the eye of the owl relates to the light of the sun, so our intellect relates to the most manifest things of nature." But the things that are in the heavens, who shall search out? since they are so remote from us: Sirach 3: "Seek not things higher than yourself": Ecclesiastes 5: "God is in heaven and you are upon the earth: therefore let your words be few."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But your sense etc. Here he shows that the divine will can be known only through wisdom. He shows this by attributing to it a threefold effect, namely the effect of instructing the intelligence, correcting fault: And thus were corrected: healing nature, there: For through wisdom etc.
(Vers. 17.). But your sense, that is, your counsel and will, who shall know it? as if to say: no one. Unless you had given wisdom, illuminating the intellect: Sirach 1: "According to his gift he bestows it upon those who love him": James 1: "He gives to all abundantly": Daniel 2: "He gives wisdom to the wise and knowledge to those who understand learning." And had sent your Holy Spirit, inflaming the affection, as if to say: no one. For just as no one "knows the things of a man, except the spirit of man which is in him," as is found in 1 Corinthians 2, "so neither does anyone know the things of God, except God, and him to whom he wills to reveal them." From the most high, that is, from you, who are most high, and from the Son, who is most high, and I say most high adjectivally, not substantively.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 18.). And thus, namely through the gift of wisdom and the sending of the Holy Spirit, the paths were corrected, that is, the operations, of those who are on earth, that is, of men, and this through recall from evil: John 16: "He will convict the world of sin"; and he well says: The paths of those who are on earth, that is, of those sinning on earth: for the paths of sinning angels cannot be corrected. And men learned the things that please you, through formation in the good: John 14: "The Paraclete Spirit etc., will teach you all things."
(Vers. 19.). For through wisdom etc. I well said: And thus were corrected etc.: for through wisdom they were healed, namely from blindness of intellect and corruption of affection; Sirach 24: "I am like the river Dorix," which is interpreted as medicine of generation. Whoever pleased you, Lord, from the beginning, "namely of the world," according to the Gloss: below in chapter 16: "For neither herb nor poultice healed them" etc.: in the Psalm: "He sent his word and healed them": Proverbs 3: "She is a tree of life to those who lay hold of her." Hence it is that spiritual dogs, that is, doctors and preachers of wisdom, have medicinal tongues: and he says all, because, according to Augustine, the same faith of the Mediator saved the ancients which saves us also.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She protected him etc. In the preceding chapters he admonished rulers specifically to acquire wisdom, and this by reasons taken from the peril of the office of those whom he admonishes, namely in chapter six; secondly, by reasons taken from the example of him who admonishes, in chapters seven, eight, and nine. Here thirdly he exhorts them to the same by reasons taken from the many effects and benefits of wisdom, to which he urges them. Now wisdom is beneficent by advancing the wise, namely her friends, and by punishing the foolish, the adversaries of the wise. Therefore he treats first of the benefits pertaining to the advancement of the friends of God, namely in this chapter; secondly, of those pertaining principally to the punishment of adversaries, namely in chapter eleven and thereafter.
Thirdly he exhorts to acquiring wisdom by reasons taken from its effects, and first from the benefits pertaining to the advancement of the friends of God. In the first part he first sets forth the benefits conferred upon individual persons; secondly, the benefits bestowed upon one people: She protected the just people.
In the first part he shows the benefits of wisdom in six individual persons among the ancient Patriarchs: first, in the person of Adam, when he says: She protected him, who was first etc.; secondly, in the person of Noah, there: From her when he departed; thirdly, in the person of Abraham: She also, in the conspiracy of pride; fourthly, in the person of Lot: She delivered the just man from those perishing; fifthly, in the person of Jacob: She moreover the fugitive etc.; sixthly, in the person of Joseph: She the just man who was sold. In the first, concerning Adam, he shows the benefit first of grace, secondly of nature.
She protected him. I have rightly said that through wisdom all were healed, which is evident through examples. She indeed, namely wisdom, him, namely Adam, who first, of all men, was formed by God, namely immediately; Job 10: "Your hands have made me" etc. The father of the world, that is, who was to be the father of the whole human race; Malachi 2: "Is there not one father of us all"? When he had been created alone, namely before the formation of the woman; Genesis 2: "It is not good for man to be alone." It should be noted that formed is said with respect to the body; hence Genesis 2: "God therefore formed man from the slime of the earth"; and created, with respect to the soul; Genesis 1: "God created man in his image and likeness" etc. When alone, I say, he had been created, she protected him, namely from sin in the earthly paradise in the state of innocence. "For he placed him in paradise, to work and to guard it," Genesis 2.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And she led him out, namely, the woman having already been made, him who had become a transgressor, Genesis 3, from his transgression, namely through the infusion of penitence and the remission of fault. And it should be noted that here the penitence of Adam is expressed more explicitly than elsewhere.
And she led him out of the slime of the earth, namely on the part of the body: Ecclesiasticus 17: "God created man from the earth." And gave him power, that is, authority, to contain all things, by ruling all things and having dominion over all, and this on the part of the soul, namely through reason, according to that passage in Genesis 1: "Have dominion over the fish of the sea," etc.; likewise in the Psalm: "You have subjected all things under his feet."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From this, etc. Here he shows the benefit of wisdom specially bestowed upon Noah and upon those who were with him in the ark, when it delivered him from the flood and destroyed the wicked. And first he touches upon the first cause of the destruction of the wicked; second, the first cause of the deliverance of the good.
He says therefore: From this, namely wisdom, when he departed: Proverbs 1: "Fools despise wisdom and doctrine"; for by this, that one departs from wisdom, one departs from God: above, chapter 1: "Perverse thoughts separate from God": the unjust one, namely Cain, who is called unjust antonomastically, because he was the head and exemplar of the unjust: in his wrath, by which he was wrathful against his brother Abel: Genesis 4: "Why are you wrathful," etc. Through the wrath of murder, that is, which wrath was spiritual murder, according to that passage in 1 John 3: "He who hates his brother is a murderer"; or transitively, so that the sense would be: Through the wrath of murder, that is, which was the cause of corporeal murder: whence Genesis 4: "Cain rose up against Abel his brother and slew him." Brotherhood perished, that is, the fellowship of brotherhood, Abel having died corporally and Cain spiritually.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On account of which etc., namely sin: for that sin was the first cause of the corruption of Cain's posterity, from which corruption spread even to a great part of Seth's posterity: and that was fulfilled in Genesis 6, where it says: "All flesh had corrupted its way." When the water destroyed the earth, destroying, namely, earthly man from the surface of the earth: Genesis 6: "I will destroy man, whom I created, from the face of the earth." For all perished who were written in the earth, namely the wicked, of whom Jeremiah 17: "Those who depart from you shall be written in the earth"; destroying also all flesh living on the earth according to Genesis 7: "All flesh was consumed that moved upon the earth." Wisdom healed again, namely the world, just as she had previously healed Adam: she healed, I say, the world, namely by purging it of wicked men: through a contemptible wood "that is, through the ark," contemptible in its material and despised by those who believed it was being built in vain, the just one, "namely Noah," of whom Genesis 6: "Noah was a just man" etc.: governing, namely delivering him from drowning amid the floods of waters: 2 Peter 2: "He preserved Noah, the eighth, a preacher of justice, bringing a flood upon the world." Now that wood signified the cross, because it is contemptible to unbelievers, although to the faithful it is venerable; whence 1 Corinthians 1: "For the word of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing" etc.: likewise in the same place: "We preach Christ crucified, to the Jews indeed a stumbling block" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She also in the agreement etc. Here he touches upon the benefit of wisdom conferred in the person of Abraham, first with respect to himself: second, in his posterity.
He says therefore: This one, namely wisdom, and, also, when the nations, that is, the people of that time persisting in the vice of their birth, had exalted themselves, that is, had carried themselves beyond their measure by elation of heart and striving of work, against which it is said in the Psalm: "Lord, my heart is not exalted," etc. In the consent of pride, that is, coming from pride, by which consent, or which pride, they wished to build a tower reaching up to heaven and to make their name famous: both of which were pride, Genesis eleven. When, I say, the nations had exalted themselves etc.; she knew, namely wisdom, by approving and choosing and separating from the wicked: Second Timothy two: "The Lord knows who are his"; on the contrary, to the wicked it is said, Matthew seven: "I never knew you": the just one, namely Abraham, who is called the just one par excellence. And she preserved him without blame before God, "in the midst of a depraved and perverse nation," which was difficult: Luke one: "They were both without blame." And in his children, that is, his descendants, she kept strong mercy, namely by multiplying them out of his mercy and strongly defending them from adversaries and finally conferring upon them the land of promise, as he had promised, Genesis thirteen and fifteen and seventeen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This one the just from the perishing etc. Here he shows the benefit of wisdom conferred in the person of Lot, who was freed from the destruction of Sodom, and first he touches on the liberation of Lot: second, the punishment of the others; third, the equity of the punishment.
This one, namely wisdom, the just one, "namely Lot," as the Gloss says; likewise Second Peter two says of him: "In sight and hearing he was just": from the perishing impious, namely from the company of the perishing impious, that is, of the Sodomites: she freed him as he fled, both from the fellowship of guilt, according to that passage in the same place: "He rescued the just Lot, oppressed by the injury and wanton conduct of the wicked": and from the fellowship of punishment: concerning both liberations, it is found in Genesis nineteen. When fire descended, from heaven, not sent from the earth; in the same place: "The Lord rained upon Sodom and Gomorrah sulphur and fire" etc.; upon the Pentapolis: the Gloss: "That is, upon the region of the five cities," namely Sodom, Gomorrah, Segor, Seboim, and Adamah.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To whom, namely those perishing, as a testimony of wickedness, namely of burning and foul lust, smoking, that is, emitting smoke from itself; whence in the Psalm: "Smoke ascended in his wrath": the desolate land stands, namely desolate of plants and trees: Job twenty-eight: "The land from which bread arose in its place was consumed by fire": likewise in the Psalm: "A fruitful land into saltness, from the wickedness of those dwelling in it." And at a certain, namely determined, time, trees bearing fruit, useless, as is said, because it is reported that fruits grow there outwardly beautiful, but inwardly ashy and full of cinders: the Gloss: "They show that without the fruit of penance, damned souls will burn in hell for eternity." And a figure, that is, a statue, of salt, for seasoning all who hear and see with the salt of wisdom against the corruption of carnal concupiscence or foolishness: a figure, I say, standing as a memorial, that is, a remembrance: Luke seventeen: "Remember the wife of Lot"; a memorial, I say, of an unbelieving soul, that is, of the unbelief of Lot's wife, who looked back, refusing to believe the Angel who forbade it, as is evident in Genesis nineteen.
It should be noted, moreover, that the desolate land testifies to their uselessness for good works; the smoke, their blinding by carnal concupiscence; the useless fruits, their evil manner of life; the statue of salt, their dissolution and corrupting putrefaction through carnal concupiscence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For wisdom etc., as if to say: and deservedly they were thus punished: for passing over wisdom, that is, the Sodomites casting it aside, and therefore wretched; whence above in chapter three: "He who casts aside wisdom and discipline is wretched": therefore also they perished, according to that passage in Baruch three: "Because they did not have wisdom, they perished on account of their foolishness": nor did they only perish because they passed over wisdom, but they also left a memorial of their foolishness. And this is what he adds: Not only etc. Passing over wisdom, I say, not only did they fall into this, that they should be ignorant, namely with the ignorance of which First Corinthians fourteen says: "If anyone is ignorant, he shall be ignored": of good things, namely those pertaining to their own life and salvation. But also of their foolishness, because "they were compared to foolish beasts and made like unto them": they left a memorial to men, as regards evil fame, namely thus, so that in those things in which they sinned, that is, so that in those sins which they committed, they could not even be hidden, because they did not wish to be hidden, but sinned publicly: Isaiah three: "They proclaimed their sin as Sodom and did not hide it." And therefore the Lord willed that their sins be made known to the whole world through public punishment.
Sin lies hidden by the cunning of sinning: 2 Kings 12: "You did it in secret, but I will do this thing in the sight of all Israel." By the pretense of holiness: Matthew 23: "You are like whitewashed sepulchres," etc. Of dignity or of prelacy by the authority, according to that saying of Gregory: "No one does more harm in the Church than he who, acting perversely, holds the name or rank of holiness; for no one presumes to rebuke such a one, and the fault spreads powerfully as an example, when the sinner is honored out of reverence for his rank."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But Wisdom, as if to say: just as those unjust ones were punished for their contempt of wisdom: but, meaning on the contrary, wisdom those who her, namely wisdom, observe, that is, who diligently keep her in heart, word, and deed: delivered from sorrows, namely of eternal punishments, concerning which Isaiah 50 says: "You shall sleep in sorrows"; likewise in the Psalm: "The sorrows of death surrounded me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore it is necessary to have another brightness, namely that of gratuitous knowledge, which is the form of the two preceding brightnesses. You fail in the third sign if you do not have this knowledge. This knowledge is of truth as believable and lovable, a holy awareness. Of this knowledge it is said in the book of Wisdom: "The Lord led the just one through right ways and showed him the kingdom of God, He honored him in his labors and gave him the knowledge of the Saints." Gratuitous knowledge is called the knowledge of the Saints for a threefold reason.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But she conducted the fugitive etc. Here he touches upon the manifold benefit of wisdom bestowed upon the person of Jacob, of which the first was his advancement in good: the second, his preservation from evil: the third, assistance in triumph.
She, namely wisdom, the fugitive from the wrath of his brother, namely the one fleeing and turning away from the wrath of his brother, or from his angered brother: Genesis twenty-seven: "Behold, Esau your brother threatens to kill you. Now therefore, my son, hear my voice, and arise and flee to Laban, my brother." The just one, namely Jacob, according to that passage in Genesis thirty: "My justice shall answer for me tomorrow": she guided through straight paths: The Gloss: "Through Mesopotamia": Deuteronomy thirty-two: "The Lord alone was his guide." Straight, he says, because "the path of the just is straight," as is found in Isaiah twenty-six. And she showed him, namely on the way through an imaginative vision, the kingdom of God, because "he saw a ladder reaching up to heaven," Genesis twenty-eight. But the devil shows the kingdom of the world: whence Matthew four: "He showed him all the kingdoms of the world." And she gave him the knowledge of the saints, that is, the understanding of sacred things, because "understanding is needed in a vision," as is found in Daniel ten: of sacred things, I say, which he had seen, she gave him understanding, that is, so that he might understand what the ladder which he had seen signified, and the ascent and descent of the Angels. For the ladder is obedience, through which the Angels ascend to attend upon God and descend to minister to us: Daniel seven: "Thousands of thousands ministered to him, and ten thousand times a hundred thousand stood before him." She made him honorable: The Gloss: "That is, she enriched him," according to that passage in Ecclesiasticus eleven: "It is easy in the eyes of the Lord to suddenly make a poor man honorable": and he speaks according to human custom, which is accustomed to regard the wealthy as honorable persons. In his labors, that is, on account of his labors, not through injustice and plunder, as many enrich themselves. But such riches do not make one honorable nor blessed, but rather one's own labors, or riches acquired from just labors: in the Psalm: "For you shall eat the labors of your hands, blessed are you," etc. And she brought to completion, that is, she led to the desired end, namely by bringing him back to his father in the land of Canaan: his labors: The Gloss: "Which he endured in tending sheep," concerning which, Genesis thirty-one: "Day and night I was scorched by heat and frost."
She the fugitive etc. From this place up to: In the fraud of those circumventing, there is touched upon the manifold benefit that the Lord bestows upon His Saints, of which the first is justification at the beginning of their conversion: Romans 8: "Those whom He called, them He also justified": and this is touched upon when it says: The just one. The second is guidance in the progress of one's way of life: She guided him etc.: in the Psalm: "Your good Spirit will guide me into the right land." The third is the showing of the kingdom in grace or in the secret of contemplation: She showed him: Exodus 33: "I will show you all good." The fourth, instruction in the knowledge of the divine will: And she gave him the knowledge of holy things: Baruch 4: "Blessed are we, O Israel, for the things that are pleasing to God are made known to us." The fifth is ennoblement, that is, enrichment in the abundance of merit and virtue: She enriched him etc.: Job 5: "You shall enter the grave in abundance, as a heap of wheat is brought in at its time." The sixth, completion in reward: And she completed etc.; above in chapter four: "Being made perfect in a short time, he fulfilled long times, for his soul was pleasing to God": likewise above in chapter three: "The fruit of good labors is glorious."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the fraud of those circumventing him, that is, of those wishing to circumvent him, "Laban and his sons," as the Gloss says: she stood by him, namely by guarding him, lest he be deceived or harmed: Genesis 31: "Your father has circumvented me and changed my wages ten times." And she made him honorable, the Lord, that is, wealthy: Genesis 31: "Jacob has taken away all that was our father's, and enriched from his possessions, he has become illustrious."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, the fruit of wisdom is born of the last four by contrast. Corresponding to this fruit, there are four acts, for wisdom is comforting, struggling, contemplating, and extolling. It is also struggling, against evil: "Better is wisdom than weapons of war." Again, Wisdom "gave him a strong conflict, that he might overcome and know that wisdom is mightier than all." It is also contemplating the Supreme Good: "For she is fairer than the sun." Wisdom makes the soul taste the Supreme Good and be united to it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She guarded him from enemies, namely from Laban and his sons who were pursuing him and wishing to despoil him: Genesis thirty-one: "Unless the God of my father had been with me, perhaps you would have sent me away empty." And from deceivers she protected him, namely from Esau and his men, who perhaps intended to seize him when they were coming to meet him. But the Lord changed the heart of Esau through the offering of gifts which Jacob sent ahead to him, as is clear from Genesis thirty-two. And she gave him a strong contest, the Gloss explains this of the contest against Laban and his sons, Genesis thirty-one, or against Esau: or more truly it can be understood of the contest in which he wrestled with the Angel, Genesis thirty-two: with the Angel, I say, stronger than himself. For if a wicked angel is so strong that "there is no power on earth that can be compared to him," as is found in Job forty-one: how much more a good Angel? So that he might conquer, namely the contest itself: Hosea twelve: "In his strength he was directed with the Angel and prevailed," etc. So that he might conquer, I say, and know, namely by obtaining the victory, through wisdom, that is: that wisdom is mightier than all things, because she is powerful to deliver from any evil man: whence Genesis thirty-two: "If you have been strong against God, how much more shall you prevail against men"?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She the just one who was sold. Here he shows the benefit of wisdom bestowed upon the person of Joseph, and first in his deliverance: second, in the exaltation of the one delivered.
She, namely wisdom, the just one, "that is, Joseph"; for out of justice he accused his brothers of their crimes before his father: Genesis thirty-seven: "He accused his brothers before his father of a most wicked crime"; the one sold, "namely by his brothers," who "sold him to passing Ishmaelites," in the same place: did not abandon, namely by withdrawing from him: in the Psalm: "The Lord will not abandon his Saints forever." But she delivered him from sinners, from the wife of Potiphar and his servants, "when he was accused of adultery," Genesis thirty-nine. And she descended with him into the pit: the Gloss: "Of the prison": for he was handed over into the prison in which "the king's prisoners were kept," where wisdom descended with him, which was evident because "she gave him favor with the chief of the prison," Genesis thirty-nine.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And in the chains of the prison she did not abandon him, because through the wise interpretation of dreams she freed him from his chains, Genesis forty-one. Until she brought him the scepter of the kingdom, that is, the principate over all of Egypt after Pharaoh: whence in the same place: "You shall be over my house," etc.: and power, namely of judging or of vindicating himself, if he had willed, against those who were oppressing him: that is, against his brothers, who had oppressed him, upon whom he struck great terror, as is clear from Genesis forty-two. And she showed those who had stained him to be liars, namely with the stain of infamy, namely the wife of Potiphar and his servants: Job thirteen: "First showing you to be fabricators of lies and cultivators of perverse doctrines." For through his divine exaltation it was shown and believed that the whole thing was a lie, with even the woman herself perhaps acknowledging this afterward. Concerning this stain of infamy, Ecclesiasticus forty-seven: "You placed a stain upon your glory." And gave him eternal renown, namely of perpetual fame, according to that word of the Psalm: "The just shall be in everlasting remembrance": or of eternal glory, namely when Christ led him together with the other Patriarchs from hell into glory. "Ascending on high, you led captivity captive."
It should be noted that in the aforesaid six persons six ways are touched upon by which wisdom delivers the saints, according to that word of Job five: "In six tribulations he will deliver you, and in the seventh evil shall not touch you." For she delivers from the temptation of the enemy, as with Adam; from the temptation of the corruption of concupiscence, as with Noah, while the rest perished on account of the corruption of the flesh; likewise, from the temptation of pride and interior haughtiness, as Abraham from the pride of the giants which might be imitated, or from the imitation of pride; likewise, from exterior temptation, namely of wicked example and corrupt conduct, as with Lot; likewise, from the temptation of human deceit and circumvention, as with Jacob; likewise, from the temptation of worldly adversity, as with Joseph.
Likewise it should be noted that there are three enemies of ours, namely the devil, the flesh, and the world, signified by the three enemies of Solomon, concerning which see 3 Kings eleven. Now the temptation of the demon is twofold, namely exterior and visible, interior and invisible. Deliverance from the first is signified in the deliverance of Adam; from the second, in the deliverance of Abraham. The temptation of the flesh is likewise twofold, namely according to nature and against nature. Deliverance from the first was signified in the deliverance of Noah; from the second, in the deliverance of Lot. The temptation of the world is likewise twofold, namely through fraud and violence. Deliverance from the first is signified in the deliverance of Jacob; from the second, in the deliverance of Joseph.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She delivered a just people. After he has shown the benefits of wisdom conferred upon individual persons, here he shows the benefit bestowed upon one people: and first the general benefit is touched upon, second the special benefit, third the thanksgiving for both.
This, namely wisdom, a just people, "namely the Israelite people," justified through faith, according to that passage in Romans 5: "Justified by faith": or: just, through the working of good; and a blameless seed, namely through the avoidance of evil: seed, "namely of the Patriarchs," as the Gloss says: likewise Tobit 2: "We are the children of the Saints": delivered etc. Of this deliverance he set forth a twofold cause, namely the goodness of the people, when he says: A just people: secondly, the holiness of the Fathers, when he says: And a blameless seed she delivered from the nations, "that is, from the Egyptians," remaining in the vice of their birth. Who oppressed him, that is, vexed them, "namely in clay and brick" and straw, as is evident from Exodus 1. And note that through this oppression or vexation can be understood the vexation of the devil, by which he vexes his servants in the works of the clay of lust and the brick of avarice and the straw of pride: Exodus 3: "Seeing I have seen the affliction of my people" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She entered etc. Here he touches upon special benefits, first those done in Egypt: secondly, after the departure from Egypt: thirdly, in the departure itself.
She entered, that is, wisdom herself, into the soul of the servant of God: Gloss: "That is, of Moses," above in chapter 7: "Through nations she transfers herself into holy souls": likewise Exodus 4: "I will be in your mouth and will teach you what you shall say." And she stood, namely steadfastly: whence Exodus 9: "Moses stood before Pharaoh": she stood, I say, against dreadful kings: Gloss: "Pharaoh and other princes": in wonders, that is, in greater miracles, and in signs, lesser ones, "which she worked in Egypt"; whence Exodus 7: "I will multiply my signs and portents in the land of Egypt"; Ecclesiasticus 45: "He magnified him in the sight of kings": above in chapter 8: "Dreadful kings shall fear me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And she rendered to the just: Gloss: "Of the Israelite people": the reward of their labors: Gloss: "The promised land," which he had previously promised to them: Genesis 12: "To your seed I will give this land." And she led them, namely to the aforesaid land, by a wonderful way: Gloss: "Through the desert": in the Psalm: "In a desert land, pathless and waterless." This way, moreover, was wonderful, because it was in no way passable for so great a host without many miracles. Whence it follows: And she was to them a covering by day, that is, from the heat of day, namely "through a pillar of cloud": and in the light of stars by night, that is, in place of the light of stars, and this "through a pillar of fire," as the Gloss says: Exodus 13: "Never was the pillar of cloud lacking by day nor the pillar of fire by night"; likewise Isaiah 4: "The Lord will create over every place of Mount Sion etc., a cloud by day" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And she brought them across etc., namely in the departure from Egypt, through the Red Sea: Exodus fourteen: "The water was divided, and the children of Israel entered through the midst of the dry sea." Now it is called the Red Sea from the color which it derives from the adjacent red earth. And she carried them across through the exceeding water, namely of the sea itself, whose waters were for them as a wall on the right and on the left, in the same place. And note that he says through the Red Sea with respect to quality, through the exceeding water with respect to quantity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But their enemies, namely the Egyptians, she submerged in the sea: Exodus fifteen: "The chariots of Pharaoh and his army he cast into the sea": likewise: "They sank as lead," etc. And from the height, that is, the depth, of the nether regions, "that is, of unspeakable afflictions," as the Gloss says: she brought forth them, namely the children of Israel, in this, namely, that their enemies, who wished to kill them by sending them thither, he sent or cast thither: Ecclesiasticus, the last chapter: "From the depth of the belly of hell and from a defiled tongue and from a lying word." Therefore the just, namely because wisdom was with them: the just, namely the children of Israel, carried off the spoils of the ungodly: the Gloss: "The golden and silver vessels of the Egyptians," as is clear from Exodus twelve: Proverbs thirteen: "The substance of the sinner is kept for the just." Note that he does not say they stole, because they did these things by the command of a superior, namely God: and therefore they did not commit theft or robbery, at least those who did these things not out of greed but with the intention of obeying God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And they sang forth, that is, they sang devoutly, namely after the crossing of the Red Sea: O Lord, thy holy name: Exodus fifteen: "Let us sing to the Lord, etc., the Lord is as a man of war, almighty is his name": thus they sang forth for their deliverance. And thy victorious hand, that is, thy power, they praised together, that is, at the same time, namely for the overthrow of their adversaries: whence in the same place: "Thy right hand, O Lord, is magnified in strength."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because wisdom etc., as if to say: and rightly did they sing and praise etc.: because wisdom, namely delivering them, opened, namely unto the praise of the divine name, the mouth of the mute, previously struck dumb by fear; Exodus 14: "The children of Israel saw the Egyptians behind them and feared greatly." And the tongues of infants, that is, of those unable to speak, she made eloquent, that is, fluent in speech, perhaps literally, the tongues of the Hebrew children, according to that passage of Psalm 8: "Out of the mouth of infants and sucklings" etc. Or: of infants, that is, of the unskilled, those not knowing how to speak after the manner of infants, according to that passage of Jeremiah 1: "I know not how to speak, for I am a child"; Luke 21: "I will give you a mouth and wisdom" etc.; Exodus 4: "Who made the mouth of man?" The Gloss: "Without the wisdom of God the human mind can neither think anything nor worthily utter it. From Him therefore both wisdom and eloquence must be sought."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She directed their works. Here he treats of the benefits pertaining to the punishment of adversaries, and first of those pertaining to punishment through lighter penalties, ordained for their correction, namely in this chapter and in the twelfth chapter; second, of those pertaining to punishment through heavier penalties, ordained for condemnation, namely in the thirteenth chapter and thereafter.
First, the punishment through lighter penalties is treated in two ways. In the first part, he treats principally of the punishment of the Egyptians who were unjustly oppressing the Israelites; second, of the punishment of the Canaanites who were unjustly holding their land, namely in the twelfth chapter.
First, concerning the punishment of the Egyptians for a twofold sin, first for unjust oppression. In the first part, the punishment of the Egyptians is treated first on account of the unjust oppression of the children of Israel; second, on account of idolatry: For some who were erring.
In the first part, there is first shown toward the children of Israel, whom they wished to hold captive, the mercy of God; second, against the Egyptians wishing to unjustly hold them, the justice of God: For by what things. In the first part, there is first touched upon the direction of the Israelites on the way; second, the clearing away or removal of impediments occurring on the way: They stood; third, their refreshment on the way: They thirsted.
He says therefore: She directed, as if to say: not only did wisdom bestow the aforementioned benefits upon the Israelite people, but she also directed their works: The Gloss: "of the Israelites," namely after their departure from Egypt: in the hands, that is, in the power and governance, of a holy Prophet: The Gloss: "Moses," who was a prophet as regards doctrine: Deuteronomy 18: "The Lord will raise up for you a Prophet like me": holy as regards life: Exodus 33: "You have found grace before me." He taught and governed them not only by words, because he was a prophet, but also by examples, because he was holy, so that there could be said of him that word of Luke 24: "He was a prophet mighty in work and in word."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“They made a journey: Gloss: "Hastening to the promised land": through deserts, that is, through many places abandoned, namely by cultivators: which were not inhabited, namely by human inhabitants. And this was done with wisdom directing them through the hand of Moses, according to that passage of the Psalm: "You led your people like sheep by the hand of Moses and Aaron." Which many did not acknowledge; whence Jeremiah 2: "They did not say: Where is the Lord, who brought us through the desert, through an uninhabitable and pathless land?" And in desert places they made huts: Gloss: "Tabernacles," that is, poor little dwellings, and they are called huts from "falling," because they can easily fall down: similarly it is read of Abraham that he dwelt "in tents," Hebrews 11. And they did this through forty-two encampments, which are specified in Numbers 33.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“They stood against enemies, namely against the Amalekites, fighting with them, as is found in Exodus 17, and against the Midianites, Numbers 31. And against their foes, namely the Amalekites, they avenged themselves, namely by triumphing and slaying them, and this through the prayer of Moses and the raising of his hands, as is clear from Exodus 17.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“They thirsted, namely on the part of the body because of a scarcity of water, as is clear from Exodus 17 and Numbers 20, and they called upon you, namely on the part of the soul, and this by themselves or through Moses: whence Numbers 20: "Lord God, hear the cry of this people"; in the Psalm: "They cried out to the Lord when they were in distress." And water was given to them from a most high rock, that is, from a lofty crag: Exodus 17: "You shall strike the rock," etc.; likewise Numbers 20: "Speak to the rock, and it will give you waters." And the quenching of thirst, that is, the allaying of thirst through the drinking of water, from the hard stone, supply: was given to them: in the Psalm: "He struck the rock, and waters flowed"; likewise Numbers 20: "Most abundant waters came forth, so that the people and the beasts drank." Moreover, it is called a most high rock, that is, very high, or most high by reason of what it signifies, namely because it signified Christ; whence 1 Corinthians 10: "And the rock was Christ." From this rock come forth the spiritual waters of graces: John 4: "Whoever drinks of the water that I shall give him," etc.; likewise John 7: "If anyone thirsts, let him come to me and drink."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For by the very things. Here is shown the effect of divine justice against the Egyptians, who wished to detain the Israelites. And first is touched upon, through the failure of water, the punishment of the Egyptians: second, the fittingness of the punishment: For instead of a fountain: third, the intention of the one punishing: When they were diminished: fourth, the gravity of the punishment: These indeed: fifth, the effect upon those punished: For when they heard.
By which things etc.: Gloss: "Having recalled the benefits given to the earlier people, the punishment of the enemies is narrated." For by which things etc., as if to say: To the Israelites was given an abundance of waters: for, meaning "because": by which things their enemies suffered punishments, namely the Egyptians, from the lack of their drink, namely all the water of Egypt was turned into blood, so that they could not drink from it, as is clear from Exodus 7. And in these things, when they abounded, the children of Israel, namely in the waters which abounded in the land of Goshen, or according to the Gloss: "Which had flowed from the rock," Numbers 20: rejoiced.
By these things, namely by the waters, when they were lacking to them, namely the waters, Gloss: "To the Israelites," it was dealt well with them, because that lack was supplied through a miracle.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For instead of a fountain etc., as if to say: fittingly and appropriately a lack of water was given to the Egyptians, but an abundance of waters was conferred upon the Israelites: for instead of a fountain indeed, certainly, of an everlasting river, that is, the Nile flowing continuously from the beginning of the world — for it is one of the rivers of paradise: human blood, that is, the appearance of human blood, you gave to the unjust, that is, to the Egyptians, since, according to the Gloss, "their waters were turned into blood," as is clear from Exodus 7.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Who, namely the children of Israel, when they were being diminished by the exposure of the slain infants, that is, by the public exposure and slaying of infants, which was done lest the people should multiply but rather be diminished, as is clear from Exodus 1: you gave them, namely the children of Israel, abundant water unexpectedly, "that is, unforeseen," because in the desert and flowing from a rock through a miracle in the desert. "A miracle is a difficult and unusual work existing beyond the hope and capacity of the one who marvels at it." Human blood etc., as if he wished to say, according to the Gloss: To the Egyptians instead of water you gave blood, to the Israelites instead of the shed blood of the children you gave water.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Showing, O Lord, through the thirst which then was, namely in Egypt to the Egyptians and in the desert to the Israelites: how you would exalt your own, namely in the future, when "you will give them to drink from the torrent of your pleasure": in this, namely, that so wondrously you gave them drink in the present. And would slay their adversaries; Gloss: "With eternal thirst," as the rich banqueter, of whom Luke 16 speaks: likewise Isaiah 65: "Behold, my servants shall drink, you shall thirst." Or according to the literal sense, by this was prefigured that the Egyptians were to be slain in the Red Sea and the Israelites to be delivered.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For when they were tried, namely the children of Israel in the desert by many trials and plagues: the Gloss says: "God corrected the sinning Israelites with fitting plagues and consoled them when they repented." Whence it follows: And indeed, that is, certainly, they received discipline with mercy; in the Psalm: "You were angry and you had mercy on us": with mercy, namely consoling, discipline, correcting: or: a merciful and light correction or scourging for their faults, and therefore they ought not to have cast it off: Proverbs 3: "My son, do not reject the discipline of the Lord": Hebrews 12: "But if you are without discipline, you are illegitimate and not sons." They knew, namely through experience, how with wrath, that is, how harshly — which the Prophet feared, saying: "Lord, do not rebuke me in your fury, nor correct me in your wrath"; the impious, being judged, namely in the present, would suffer torments, namely incomparably graver ones in the future: "For he shall rain snares upon sinners," etc. They knew, I say, through experience and in this, that they were so harshly corrected: Luke 23: "If they do this in the green wood, what shall be done in the dry?" Likewise Proverbs 11: "If the just man receives his due on earth, how much more the impious and the sinner"?
Likewise Jeremiah 25: "Behold, in the city in which my name has been invoked, I shall begin to afflict: and shall you be as though innocent and exempt?" As if to say: no.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These indeed: the Gloss says: "the Israelites"; as a father admonishing, namely unto greater progress or unto advancing to what is better, you tested, that is, by admonishing through their correction you rendered them proven. "For the Lord scourges every son whom he receives," Hebrews 12: and Proverbs 3: "Whom the Lord loves he corrects, and as a father in his son he delights"; likewise above in chapter 3: "As gold in the furnace he tested them." But those: the Gloss says: "the Egyptians, or the Canaanites"; as a harsh king, through the effect of punishment, namely, you who in your nature are benign: examining, namely with punishments and examinations of torments, just as robbers and thieves and malefactors are put to examination and tortured: Gregory says: "Punishment examines whether one loves the truth when at peace." You condemned, because through scourges they were not amended but made worse: Ezekiel 24: "Much labor was sweated, and its excessive rust did not come out of it, not even by fire"; likewise Jeremiah 6: "Call them rejected silver, because the Lord has cast them away."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For those who were absent etc., as if to say: rightly I said that you harshly condemned them. For those who were absent, namely the Egyptians from the presence of Moses and Pharaoh, or from the children of Israel, and those who were present, namely those expressly consenting to the malice of Pharaoh: or also, according to the Gloss, the Canaanites, whether those who were slain by Israel or those who heard of the victory of the others: were similarly tormented, because the plagues were "in all the land of Egypt," as is clear concerning the plague of blood, Exodus 7. Or: those present were tormented in body, those absent, who heard of this, were tormented in mind.
But then it is asked: how then were they similarly tormented, namely those absent in mind, but those present in body? It must be said that they were similarly tormented in genus, namely insofar as both these and those were tormented, but not similarly in species or mode.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For a twofold weariness had seized them, namely as if taking possession of them, weariness, that is, affliction, according to that passage of the Psalm: "Let them be clothed with their confusion as with a double cloak"; Jeremiah 17: "Destroy them with a double destruction." Twofold, I say: and, in place of 'that is': groaning, over the onset of present evils: with the memory of past things, that is, with the grief they had from the recollection of past evils, seeing that plagues succeeded upon plagues. The Gloss: "Twofold weariness, that is, the recollection of past evils and the storm of present ones."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For when they heard etc. Here is shown the punishment's effect upon those punished, first on the part of the Israelites; second, on the part of the Egyptians: For him whom etc.; third, on the part of both: Not similarly.
As if to say: truly you tested these and condemned those. For when they heard, namely the children of Israel, with Moses proclaiming this; that through their torments things were going well for them, that is, profitably, namely unto their salvation, according to that passage in Romans 8: "For those who love God all things work together for good"; they remembered the Lord, whom, namely, they had as it were consigned to oblivion: who, despairing: in the Psalm: "They did not remember his hand" etc.; likewise: "They forgot his benefits and his wonders, which he showed them"; but afterward, afflicted, they remembered him: "For the eyes which guilt closes, punishment opens," as Gregory says; in the Psalm: "And they remembered that God is their helper." Marveling, namely at the power and mercy of God, at the end of the outcome, that is, after the end of the outcome of the matter: for from the end depends right judgment. "For the outcome proves the deeds"; whence also Peter followed Christ "to see the end," Matthew 26.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whom indeed etc., as if to say: and truly it is so: whom, namely the Israelite people or Moses, cast forth in wicked exposure, that is, evilly and dangerously cast into the river, they mocked, namely the Egyptians, as though he would perish in the river, notwithstanding the basket. At the end of the event they marveled, that is, after the outcome of the matter, seeing, namely, Moses so exalted by miracles: whence Exodus 11: "And so Moses was a very great man before the servants of Pharaoh and all the people." Or: at the end they marveled, namely at the people miraculously liberated: Exodus 14: "Let us flee from Israel; for the Lord fights for them against us." Thus the impious err, not considering the end of the just, but only their present affliction: above in chapter 5: "We fools esteemed their life madness and their end without honor." Not similarly etc., as if to say: thus you condemned the impious and liberated the just; you, I say, not dealing similarly with the just; the Gloss: "As with the unjust," because Proverbs 16: "The just man falls seven times a day and rises again, but the impious shall fall into evil." The reason for the diversity, however, is not on the part of God, since "he is no respecter of persons," Acts 10, but on the part of the unjust.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whence it follows: For their thoughts moreover: I said well: not similarly: moreover, for but rather: for their senseless thoughts, that is, hardened in evil, their iniquities, namely the exterior ones, as if to say: on account of their evil thoughts they are permitted to fall into evil works: whence the Gloss: "Iniquitous works proceed from thoughts," because the reprobate do not change their heart amid the scourges of the Lord: Romans 2: "According to your hardness and impenitent heart you treasure up for yourself wrath on the day of wrath" etc.: Revelation 22: "He who is filthy, let him be filthy still."
Second, concerning the punishment of the Egyptians on account of idolatry. That certain ones erring etc. Here is touched upon the punishment of the Egyptians on account of idolatry, and this through the sending of flies. And the fittingness of this punishment is shown first on the part of the one sinning; second, on the part of the judge punishing, at: For not.
Because certain ones etc., as if to say: thus they were punished for the oppression of the Israelites: because, standing for "since": certain ones, of the Egyptians, wandering, namely from the faith: Proverbs 14: "They err who work evil." They worshipped mute serpents: mute he says to distinguish from the serpent who spoke to Eve in the earthly paradise, Genesis 3: and worthless beasts, that is, useless for worship: for the Egyptians worshipped Aesculapius under the form of a serpent, Mercury under the form of a dog, Jupiter under the form of a ram, Apis under the form of an ox: Romans 1: "They changed the likeness of the incorruptible God into the likeness of corruptible man and of birds and of four-footed beasts and of serpents." You sent upon them a multitude of dumb animals for vengeance, namely frogs and flies, gnats and locusts, according to that verse of the Psalm: "He sent among them the dog-fly, and it devoured them, and the frog, and it destroyed them; and he gave their fruits to the mildew and their labors to the locust."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That they might know that by what things, that is, by what sort of things, a man sins, by these, that is, by similar things, also, that is, even, he is tormented: the Gloss: "That from the likeness of the punishment they might recognize the quality of the fault," just as "Haman was hanged on the gallows which he had prepared for Mordecai," Esther 7; and Goliath was slain by his own sword, 1 Kings 17; and Holofernes was slain by his own dagger by the woman whom he had wickedly desired, Judith 13.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For not impossible etc. Here is shown the fittingness of the punishment on the part of the judge who punishes, who prefers to use mercy rather than power. And first it is shown that this light punishment was not from powerlessness; second, that it was from mercy: But all things; third, there is added the proof of power: For greatly; fourth, the proof of mercy: And you have mercy. In the first he shows that he could have punished them otherwise, namely either through an instrument of vengeance already created, or through another to be newly created, at the words: Or of a new kind; or immediately by himself: For even without these.
He says therefore: For not etc. I have rightly said that you punished them through those things by which they had sinned, and this on account of the fittingness of the punishment to the fault, not on account of your powerlessness. For not impossible was, that is, greatly powerless, your hand, "that is, your Son," according to that verse of the Psalm: "Send forth your hand from on high": almighty: whence below in chapter 18: "Your almighty word, O Lord" etc. Which created, that is, formed, the world: for to create is to make something from nothing, to form however, is from pre-existing matter. But the world was from pre-existing matter, yet previously created formless: whence it follows: From unseen matter, that is, from prime matter, which was unseen, that is, invisible at that time, both on the part of itself, because it lacked distinct form, and on the part of the agent, because light was lacking, which is necessary for reducing the sense of sight from potency to act; whence Genesis 1: "The earth was void and empty," namely as to the first defect: "and darkness was upon the face of the deep," as to the second. To send upon them, namely for vengeance, a multitude of bears, or bold lions, which are strong and rapacious animals: on account of which David glories in overcoming them in 1 Kings 17: "I have slain a lion and a bear." To send, I say, lions etc., as he did when he sent lions into the land of Samaria, which devoured the peoples transferred there, because they did not worship God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Or beasts of a new kind, full of rage and unknown, and therefore more terrible: Deuteronomy 32: "I will send the teeth of beasts upon them, with the fury of those that drag upon the ground" etc. Or a fiery vapor, or of fires, breathing out, namely for destruction: or sending forth the smell of smoke, namely for the infection of the air, or shooting horrible sparks from their eyes, for terror.
Of which not only the harm, made namely by striking, could exterminate them, that is, place them beyond the boundaries of life: but even the sight, by seeing, could kill through fear, namely the unjust and the wicked: for of the just it is said in the Psalm: "You shall walk upon the asp and the basilisk, and you shall trample the lion and the dragon."
It should be noted, moreover, that through the various aforementioned beasts, six kinds of sins can be understood: through the bear, the vice of gluttony: through the lion, pride; through beasts full of rage, wrath; through those breathing out fiery vapor, lust; through those sending forth the smell of smoke, avarice; through those shooting sparks from their eyes, envy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The whole of the world-machine was produced into being in time and from nothing by one first, sole, and supreme principle: whose power, although it is immense, nevertheless disposed all things in a certain weight, number, and measure. The creature is the effect of the creating Trinity under a threefold genus of causality: efficient, from which there is in the creature unity, mode, and measure; exemplary, from which there is in the creature truth, species, and number: final, from which there is in the creature goodness, order, and weight. Which indeed are found in all creatures as a vestige of the Creator, whether corporeal, or spiritual, or composed of both. Every creature is established in being by the efficient cause, is conformed to the exemplar, and is ordered to the end: and through this it is one, true, good: modified, beautiful, ordered: measured, distinct, and weighted: for weight is an ordinative inclination.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is a certain order in these things. For God creates all essences "by measure and number and weight." And by giving these, He gives mode, species, and order. Mode is that by which a thing exists; species, that by which it is distinct; order, that by which it is fitting. For there is no creature that is not endowed with measure, quantity, and inclination. And in this a trace may be seen, and wisdom is manifested, as the foot is shown by the trace. And this trace leads to that Wisdom in whom there is mode without qualification, number without quantity, and order without ordination.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For even without these etc. Nor could you punish them only in this way, for even without these, that is, without the aid of these beasts, they could have been killed by a single breath: Gloss: "That is, by a single indignation or command." So breath is understood where it is said in Genesis 6: "My spirit shall not remain in man," that is, my indignation, etc. Or: by a single angelic breath, as happened to Sennacherib and his army, as is clear from Isaiah 37. Having suffered persecution, namely as from a meritorious cause, from their own deeds, so that they would be destroyed by their own works, just as a viper perishes by its own offspring: Luke 3: "Offspring of vipers," etc.; in the Psalm: "Render to them according to the works of their hands." And scattered, namely through diverse places outside their own land, by the spirit of your power. This can be understood intransitively, and then it is understood of the uncreated Spirit; or transitively, that is, effectively, and then it can be understood of a created spirit: Job 4: "I saw those who work iniquity perish by the blast of God, and be consumed by the spirit of his wrath."
But all things etc. Here he shows that he punished out of mercy and punished less than he could have: and first by this, that he did not punish beyond what the magnitude of the fault required, because in measure; second by this, that he did not punish beyond what the multiplicity of the fault required, because in number; third, because not beyond what the condition or quality of the sinner required, because in weight.
I have rightly said that you do not punish according to the immensity of your power, that is, to the extent that you could; but all things etc., as if to say: not only the creatures themselves, but also their retributions and penalties or punishments, you have disposed in measure, so that they do not exceed the magnitude of the fault; and in number, so that they do not exceed the multiplicity of the fault; and in weight, so that they do not exceed the condition of the sinner or the circumstance of the sin. That he punishes according to measure: Revelation 18: "As much as she glorified herself in delights, so much give her torment and mourning"; likewise Isaiah 27: "In measure against measure, when she shall be cast off, you shall judge her"; likewise Luke 6: "With what measure you measure, it shall be measured back to you." That according to number: Revelation 18: "Double unto her double according to her works"; likewise Isaiah 40: "She has received from the hand of the Lord double for all her sins," that is, a twofold punishment, namely the punishment of loss and the punishment of sense, or exterior bodily punishment and interior spiritual punishment, that is, the remorse of conscience. That according to weight is clear from above, chapter 6: "To the little one mercy is granted, but the mighty shall suffer torments mightily."
Otherwise it can be explained thus: all things, namely corporeal things with respect to their nature, you have disposed in measure, number, and weight, because the measure of all corporeal things is the four elements, which have number, weight, and measure, as is evident.
Or otherwise: weight refers to the power of the one operating; number to the wisdom of the one ordering; measure to the clemency of the one preserving; Romans 11: "From whom are all things," with respect to the power of the Father; "through whom are all things," with regard to the wisdom of the Son; "in whom are all things," with regard to the clemency of the Holy Spirit. According to the Gloss of Rabanus: "In measure, quality; in number, quantity; in weight, reason."
According to Augustine, the measure of a creature is its determinate quantity by which it is called great or small or middling; number, a determinate quality by which it is distinguished from another; weight, the property by which it rests in its own place; whence according to Augustine, measure is the same as mode; species is the same as number; order is the same as weight. "These three," namely mode, species, and order, "where they are great, are great goods; where small, small; where none, none," as he himself says.
Or this can be explained concerning measure, number, and weight in uncreated things thus: in measure, that is, in you measuring all things, that is, prefixing a mode to each thing; in number, that is, in you numbering all things, that is, bestowing upon each thing its proper species; in weight, that is, in you weighing all things, that is, assigning to all things their proper and certain order. With this agrees a certain exposition of Augustine, who says: "In measure, that is, in yourself, who are measure without measure, prefixing a mode to each thing; number without number, furnishing a species to every thing; weight without weight, drawing every thing to stability." The first in the nature of the efficient cause, the second in the nature of the exemplar, the third in the nature of the final cause.
Morally thus: In measure, against the vice of superfluity; in number, against the vice of singularity; in weight, against the vice of levity.
But it is objected: if he disposed all things in measure, number, and weight, then he disposed measure in measure, etc., and so on to infinity. It can be said that, speaking of number, weight, and measure in uncreated things, the distribution is universal; but speaking of created things, the distribution is accommodated, namely such that the distribution is understood to be made for things measured, numbered, and weighed. Or: All things, that is, complete beings, not concreated in another. But measure, number, and weight are not such things; rather they are concreated in other things, since they are not beings subsisting by themselves and complete.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the first mode, the gaze of the one contemplating, considering things in themselves, sees in them weight, number, and measure: weight with respect to the position toward which they incline, number, by which they are distinguished, and measure, by which they are limited. And thereby it sees in them mode, species, and order, as well as substance, power, and operation. From which one can rise as from a vestige to understanding the immense power, wisdom, and goodness of the Creator.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Every created thing is disposed in a certain weight, number, and measure. Therefore the soul of Christ and its wisdom have a certain number and measure; therefore it does not extend to infinite things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For much etc. Here is set forth the proof of divine power, first through its magnitude in itself; second, through the smallness of the creature: For as etc.
For much indeed etc., as if to say: it is well evident that it was not from lack of power, because he punished them thus: for to avail much, that is, to be greatly powerful, belongs to you alone, and without the help of another, was always at hand, namely on account of the infinity of your power. "For the infinite is that of which, for one taking parts or quantity, there is always something beyond to take"; Luke 1: "No word shall be impossible with God"; always, that is, at all times or for eternity, according to that passage of Daniel 7: "His power is an everlasting power." And the strength, that is, the perfect power, because, according to the Philosopher, "strength is the ultimate degree of power in a thing"; of your arm, according to that passage of Isaiah 51: "Put on strength, O arm of the Lord"; who shall resist? As if to say: no one can; and this is because he is not acted upon by anyone.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He sets forth first the magnitude of divine power: "There is none like unto thee, O Lord; thou art great, and thy name is great in might." Whence in the book of Wisdom: "As a drop of morning dew, so is the whole world before thee." Therefore who would not fear thee, unless he be impious and foolish?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For etc., as if to say: truly it is so: for the whole world, that is, the totality of creatures, is thus before you, that is, in your disposition, or in comparison with you, as the turning of a balance, that is, that small amount by which the balance is inclined this way or that; whence it is called momentum from "moving," or because, just as it is easily and as if in a moment moved this way or that, so by divine power the world is moved at the nod of God; whence Isaiah 40: "Behold, the nations are as a drop from a bucket and are accounted as the turning of a balance"; and as a drop of the morning dew, that is, falling before the light, which descends upon the earth, which is easily dissolved by the face of the sun and cannot resist it. And it should be noted that he says the creature is as the turning of a balance etc., in respect to God as regards the ease of acting upon it; and as a drop of dew etc., as regards the impossibility of being acted upon by it; Isaiah 40: "All nations are as though they were not, so are they before him."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And just as all things compared to the divine power can do virtually nothing, so all things compared to the divine essence are virtually the least. Whence in respect to the divine being this entire world is as something minimal. And this is what is said in Wisdom eleven: For as a grain in the balance, so is the whole world before you, and as a drop of morning dew that falls upon the earth: and in Isaiah forty: Behold, the nations are as a drop from a bucket and are accounted as a grain in the balance: and afterward: All nations are as though they were not, so are they before him, and they are accounted as nothing and emptiness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And you have mercy on all etc. Here is set forth the proof of divine mercy; and first he proves it through the effect of overlooking; second, through the effect of love: For you love; third, through the effect of preservation: But how could etc.; fourth, through the effect of pardon: But you spare.
And you have mercy on all, that is, in all things you exercise the effect of mercy, according to that passage of the Psalm: "His mercies are over all his works"; likewise: "All the ways of the Lord are mercy and truth"; likewise: "The earth is full of the mercy of the Lord". For you can do all things: whence all things are your handiwork and your works, according to that passage of the Psalm: "Who made heaven and earth, the sea, and all things that are in them". And you overlook, that is, for a time not punishing, the sins of men; he does not say of angels, because the sin of the angels was immediately punished: whence Isaiah 14: "How have you fallen, O Lucifer, from heaven, you who rose in the morning"? On account of repentance; whence Romans 2: "Do you not know that the kindness of God leads you to repentance"? Ezekiel 18: "If the wicked man shall do penance from all his sins, etc., he shall live and shall not die".”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For you love all things that exist, namely by approving and preserving their goods: whence Genesis 1: "God saw all things that he had made, and they were very good": the Gloss: "A good craftsman loves his own work"; but God did not make sin: whence John 1: "Without him was made nothing," that is, "sin," according to Augustine. And therefore he does not love sin but hates it, according to that passage of the Psalm: "You have loved justice and hated iniquity". And you hate nothing of those things which you have made, that is, rejecting none of them.
Against which it is said in the Psalm: "I have hated the unjust"; likewise: "You have hated all who work iniquity"; likewise Ecclesiasticus 12: "The Most High hates sinners". But it must be said that he does not hate his handiwork, but the defect of his handiwork, just as a craftsman loves the statue which he has made, and yet hates some knot existing in it on the part of the material.
For neither hating, that is, unwillingly, did you establish anything, namely by creating it from nothing, or make it, by forming it from pre-existing matter: whence Boethius: Whom no external causes drove to fashion the work of fluctuating matter, but rather the inborn form of the highest good, etc. Whence Proverbs 16: "The Lord has wrought all things for himself".”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But how could anything, that is, any creature, endure, namely in its being: unless you had willed it, that is, unless you voluntarily preserved it by your goodness? as if to say: in no way: whence Gregory: "All things that exist would tend toward nothingness, unless they were sustained or held by the hand of the Creator". Or what had not been called by you, that is, unless you approved it by beholding it with your wisdom: Romans 4: "Who calls those things that are not," etc., would be preserved? as if to say: nothing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But you spare all, namely human beings, who are called every creature, according to that passage in Mark, last chapter: "Preach the Gospel to every creature"; you spare, I say, because it is proper to you according to that passage: "O God, whose property it is always to have mercy and to spare." Because they are yours, O Lord: Ezekiel 18: "All souls are mine"; who love souls: which is evident, because you laid down your soul for them; John 15: "Greater love than this no one has," etc.; whence Bernard: "You had a greater love, laying it down for your enemies."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, concerning the punishment of the Canaanites and Amorites.
O how good etc. After he treated of the benefits shown to the children of Israel in the affliction or punishment of the Egyptians principally, here he treats of the benefits shown to the same in the affliction of the Canaanites and Amorites who principally inhabited the land of promise.
In the first part, first is shown the just punishment of those peoples; second, the mercy shown in the manner of punishing: But also to these: third, the instruction of the people of God in both: But you, O ruler: fourth, the condemnation of incorrigible adversaries through both: Whence also to those.
First, concerning the just punishment of these peoples in two ways.
In the first part, first the pious intention of the one punishing is touched upon; second, the equity of the punishment: For those.
Of the pious intention, he first shows the cause, second the sign: And therefore etc.; third the end: That having abandoned wickedness etc.
(Verse 1). O how good etc. It is an exclamation suggesting the insufficiency of the speaker to express the goodness of the Creator; for the sense is: O how etc., as if to say: I am unable to express how great, and this on account of the infinity of your goodness. Good, namely by communicating your good things: "for the good is diffusive of itself," according to Dionysius; Matthew 19: "None is good but God alone"; for God alone communicates what is his own, every creature communicates what belongs to another, because it has nothing of its own; whence 1 Corinthians 4: "What have you that you have not received"? And your spirit is sweet, O Lord, in all things, namely by sparing our evils: in the Psalm: "Taste and see that the Lord is sweet"; your spirit, I say, in us, namely, all things, the Gloss: "Because the love of God is the font of all good." In all things, especially in those in which the mercy of God appears more: in the Psalm: "The Lord is sweet to all."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 2). And therefore, because You are good and gentle, those who go astray, that is, who wander outside the way of truth in faith or in morals, as those of whom Isaiah fifty-three says: "All we like sheep have gone astray"; likewise Lamentations four: "The blind have wandered in the streets"; You correct in parts, that is, sending punishments by parts, not all at once, but successively, according to Exodus twenty-three: "I will not cast them out from before your face in one year," but "little by little I will drive them out"; Job thirty-five: "For now He does not bring His fury, nor does He avenge wickedness greatly," but moderately: You correct, I say, either by Yourself, or "through others, whom You fill with the Holy Spirit," according to the Gloss: John sixteen: "He will convict the world of sin." And concerning the things in which they sin, that is, concerning the sins by which they sin: You admonish them, namely by promising pardon, according to Matthew four: "Do penance," etc.; likewise Isaiah forty-five: "Turn to Me, and you shall be saved," etc.; the Gloss: "Blessed are those who hear the voice of the one admonishing"; Isaiah thirty: "Your ears shall hear the word of one admonishing from behind." And You address them, that is, by threatening punishment: Isaiah one: "If you hear Me, you shall eat the good things of the land; but if you will not hear, the sword shall devour you"; so that, having abandoned malice, namely of sin, or of unbelief, they may believe in You, Lord, namely with formed faith: in You, I say, not merely You, or to You only: Isaiah fifty-five: "Let the wicked forsake his way," etc. For the movement of penance is contrary to the movement of malice, because, just as the latter is from good to evil, so the former is from evil to good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For those, etc. Here is touched upon the equity of punishment, and first from consideration of the fault itself; second, from consideration of the punishment: You willed to destroy.
(Verse 3). For those etc. I rightly said: You correct, etc., which is clear from the example. For those ancient inhabitants, namely the Canaanites and the Amorites and others of this kind, inhabitants of Your holy land, that is, the land promised to Your Saints, namely Abraham, Genesis fifteen; Isaac, twenty-six; Jacob, twenty-eight: whom You abhorred, so much so that You willed Your people neither be joined to them nor mixed with them, according to Deuteronomy seven: "You shall not enter into a covenant with them, nor shall you join in marriages, nor shall you show mercy to them."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verses 4-5). Because they were doing works hateful to You, namely enormous sins, below, chapter fourteen: "Alike hateful to God are the impious man and his impiety"; through sorceries, namely of poisoners, and unjust sacrifices, of idols, and this against God. There were, however, also just sacrifices, which were offered to God, as Noah offered, Genesis eight.
And slayers of their own children, and this against the neighbor, without mercy, that is, without compassion, because in the sacrifices of demons they immolated them with great devotion, according to that passage of the Psalm: "And they sacrificed their sons and their daughters to demons." Against which, Deuteronomy 18: "Do not desire to imitate the abominations of those nations, nor let there be found among you one who purifies a son or daughter by leading them through fire." And eaters of the entrails of men, this is not read to have happened, but it must be believed to have been possible, just as during the siege of Samaria it is read to have occurred, 4 Kings 6; and Lamentations 4: "The hands of compassionate women cooked their own children"; and devourers of blood, human blood, against that passage of Genesis 9: "You shall not eat flesh with blood."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 6.). And authors, that is, shedders of blood, parents, that is, although they were parents of the blood that was shed, which is more grievous: of the blood, I say, of souls, that is, of human beings; for he puts the part for the whole, and it is a synecdoche, as in Exodus 1, where it is said: "All the souls that entered with Jacob into Egypt"; helpless; The Gloss: "That is, of those who could not defend themselves, or whom they were unwilling to help," namely their own little infants, of whose blood they themselves were the begetters and shedders in sacrifice and eaters by eating of the sacrificed. Slayers, I say, of their own children, etc., you willed to destroy, that is, to expel, from the midst by your sacrament, that is, from the holy land of promise; and the land of promise is called holy or a sacrament on account of its signification of a sacred reality, that is, of the land of the living, and on account of the completion of the sacraments of our salvation in it, and on account of the institution of the Sacraments of the Church in it, such as the Eucharist and Baptism, and on account of the future dwelling of holy men in it, such as the Patriarchs, Prophets, and Apostles, and on account of the shedding and sprinkling of the blood of Christ in it, and on account of the dissolution of the sacred bodies and dust in it, namely of the ancient Fathers buried there; likewise on account of the building of a sacred place in it, namely the Temple, and on account of the birth and life of the Holy of Holies. Through the hands of our parents, namely those who entered the promised land with Joshua.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 7.). That they might receive a worthy, namely our forefathers, sojourning, that is, a land of sojourning, of the children of God, namely the Patriarchs, concerning whom in Hebrews 11: "Confessing that they are pilgrims and strangers upon the earth." Which, namely the land of sojourning, is to you a land dearer than all, namely than all lands, that is, than all lands, namely on account of the salvation of the human race to be procured there, according to that passage of the Psalm: "He wrought salvation in the midst of the earth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, the mercy shown in the manner of punishment is demonstrated in two ways.
But even to these etc. Here the mercy shown in the manner of punishment is demonstrated: and of that manner he first removes the false cause; second, he introduces the true one: When therefore.
In the first part he first shows that that manner of punishing was not from impotence; second, that neither from ignorance: But in parts; third, that neither from fear: Nor fearing; fourth, that neither from injustice: For neither.
(Verse 8.). But even to these etc. Although some read this concerning the Fathers who were to be introduced, whose enemies the Lord first mercifully terrified, not wishing to expose them as mortal men to the sudden dangers of wars, nevertheless it seems more fittingly to be expounded concerning the Canaanite nations to be cast out from before them. He says therefore: But even to these, although, that is, they had sinned so enormously, you spared, that is, by not expelling all of them immediately and at once, as human beings, clothed in fragile flesh, and therefore more prone to sinning. "For the sense and thought of the human heart are prone to evil from its youth," Genesis 8. The Lord himself alleges this reason in Genesis 6: "My spirit shall not remain in man, because he is flesh." And you sent wasps as forerunners of your army, that is, a kind of fly that stings severely; the Gloss says: "The sharpest fears, by which the hearts of the nations were stung." These are the hornets, concerning which Deuteronomy 7: "The Lord your God will send hornets among them, until he destroys and scatters them all"; Exodus 23: "I will send my terror before you"; and afterward: "Sending hornets first, which will put the Hivite to flight" etc. So that those, namely the Canaanites, they might destroy little by little, that is, place or drive them beyond the boundaries of the promised land, or beyond the boundaries of the present life, or beyond the boundaries of the land of the living; whence Baruch 3: "They were driven out and descended to the netherworld," excluded, that is, from the land of the living.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 9.). Not because you were unable in war to subject the impious to the just, according to that of the Psalm: "You have girded me with strength for war, and you have subdued those who rise against me beneath me"; or by savage beasts, that is, or through cruel beasts, according to that of Jeremiah 5: "The wolf at evening laid them waste and the leopard watching over their cities"; above in chapter 11: "For your almighty hand was not unable" etc. Or by a harsh word, that is, through a severe word, to destroy them all at once, according to that of Jeremiah 23: "Are not my words as fire and as a hammer that breaks rocks?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 10.). But by parts etc. Here he shows that he did not do this out of ignorance, namely of their actual or original fault, saying: But by parts etc. I have rightly said that not because he was powerless etc. ; but by parts, "that is, little by little or by portions" and successively, judging, that is, justly punishing; Deuteronomy 7: "He will consume these nations in your sight little by little and by parts, lest perhaps the beasts of the earth multiply against you"; you gave a place of repentance, so that, with some punished, others might be corrected; Job 24: "God gave him a place of repentance, and he abuses it in pride." Not being ignorant, because ignorance does not fall upon God, just as neither do shadows upon light: whence 1 John 1: "God is light, and in him there is no darkness at all." Because their nation is wicked, through the malice of fault, because the children of wicked fathers are wicked: whence above in chapter 4: "All who are born from the wicked are witnesses of their iniquity"; and their malice is natural, that is, similar to what is natural through the practice of evil habit. "For habit is a second nature"; for just as those things which are from nature can with difficulty or never be cast off, so neither can those things which are from habit: whence Jeremiah 13: "If the Ethiopian can change his skin, or the leopard its spots, then you also will be able to do good, when you have learned evil"; Gregory: "He rises with difficulty whom the weight of habit presses down." And their malice is natural: The Gloss: "Abiding, ingrained," namely through the practice of evil habit. And because their thought could not be changed forever, namely on account of the obstinacy of their perverse will: The Gloss: "Hardened by their own wickedness"; Lamentations 1: "He has delivered me into a hand from which I cannot rise."
But to the contrary: It is within the freedom of choice to sin and after sin to repent.
I respond: It could not, that is, it could scarcely; or it could not by itself alone, but only by God's inspiration. For man is "a spirit that goes forth," namely through fault, "and does not return," namely except through grace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 11.). For their seed was cursed from the beginning, that is, in the first parent of their race, namely in Canaan: Genesis 9: "Cursed be Canaan." Or according to the Gloss: From the beginning, "that is, in the foreknowledge of God," or according to the Gloss: From the beginning, because "from the time they existed, a certain depraved quality was in them worthy of a curse."
Neither fearing. Here he excludes fear from God by a fourfold reason: first, because no one can examine his judgment; second, because neither can anyone resist him: Or who shall stand; third, because neither can anyone take vengeance: Or who in the sight; fourth, because neither can anyone reprove: Or who to you.
(Vers. 11.). He says therefore: Neither fearing anyone did you grant pardon to their sins. Neither fearing anyone, namely, as though someone more powerful than you: Ecclesiasticus 3: "Great is the power of God alone"; Isaiah 51: "Who are you, that you should fear a mortal man"? Likewise Job 22: "Will he, fearing, reprove you"? as if to say: no: indeed even "the pillars of heaven tremble and are terrified at his nod," Job 26: how much more the pillars of the earth?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 12.). For who will say to you, that is, would dare to say, or could reasonably say: What have you done, namely, by examining the reason for your deed, as if to say: no one: whence Romans 9: "Does the thing formed say to him who formed it: Why have you made me thus"? Isaiah 45: "Does the clay say to the potter: What are you doing"? Or who will stand against your judgment? namely, by resisting your sentence: Job 9: "God, whose wrath no one can resist"; and later: "If the equity of judgment is sought, no one dares to bear witness on my behalf." Or who will come before your sight, that is, will dare to appear, as an avenger indeed of wicked men? that is, wishing to avenge the wicked by punishing you, as though you had done them an injustice by condemning them: as if to say: no one, because Deuteronomy 32: "Vengeance is mine," etc.: likewise in the same place: "See that I alone am, and there is none who can deliver from my hand." Or who will charge you, namely, by convicting you of fault, as if to say: no one: whence John 8: "Which of you will convict me of sin"? Who, I say, will charge you, if the nations which you made have perished? Have perished, through their own fault, which you made, with respect to their nature: the Gloss: "It is not the fault of the Creator if they perish, but the defect of nature"; Job 12: "If he destroys, there is no one who can build up."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 13.). For neither, etc. Well have I said: who will do any of the aforesaid things against your judgment? For neither is there any other God than you, according to that passage of Isaiah 45: "Am I not the Lord, and there is no further God besides me"? Than you, I say, who have care for all things: above in chapter 6: "You have equal care for all things."
But to the contrary: 1 Corinthians 9: "Does God have care for oxen"?
It must be said that the care of providence is his for all things, but the care of discipline is for rational creatures alone.
So that, namely through this, you might show that you do not judge unjustly the judgment of the punishment of the wicked: in the Psalm: "You are just, O Lord, and your judgment is right."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 14.). Neither a king etc., as if to say: you judge so rightly that neither a king, who governs his own well and according to justice, nor a tyrant, who namely governs badly and through injustice: will inquire in your sight concerning those whom you have destroyed: Gloss: "Whether you have justly destroyed them," according to that passage in Job 9: "Who can say, why do you act thus?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since therefore etc. Here he shows the true cause why God showed mercy in the aforesaid manner of punishing, and this first by showing that God exercises justice in all things; second, that he nonetheless shows mercy: And because of this; third, that to unbelievers he sometimes shows power: Your strength etc.
(Vers. 15.). Since therefore you are just, namely in your nature, you dispose all things justly, namely in creation, namely "justly punishing a son" in the present, so that in the future you may spare him; Hebrews 12: "He scourges every son whom he receives"; Tobit 3: "You are just, O Lord, and all your judgments are just"; likewise in the Psalm: "The judgments of the Lord are true, justified in themselves." Him also who ought not to be punished, that is, corrected by temporal punishment, you condemn; Gloss: "With eternal punishment, sparing him in the present, so that in the future you may punish": whence Ezekiel 16: "My jealousy shall be taken away from me, and I shall rest and be angry no more." And you esteem as foreign from your strength: Gloss: "That is, alien and unworthy of divine compassion." For the strength of God is compassion, according to that saying of Gregory: "O God, whose property it is always to have mercy and to spare," therefore in the Psalm: "In your strength," that is, in your compassion, "judge me." Or thus: and him who ought not to be punished, namely eternally, you condemn, namely according to the estimation of the reprobate, because you correct him in the present: and you esteem, that is, you cause others to esteem, such a one to be foreign, namely, from your strength, that is, alien and unworthy of your compassion, just as the friends of Job esteemed him unworthy of your compassion, because you punished him so grievously.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 16.). For your strength, that is, mercy. For the work of justice is said to be foreign to God, Isaiah 28, but the work of mercy is proper to him. And this is because he has mercy on us from his own goodness, but he exercises justice upon us from our own cause, namely on account of our fault. Your strength, I say, that is, mercy, is the beginning of justice, namely ours, that is, of our justification, according to that saying of the Apostle in Titus 3: "Not by works of justice which we have done, but according to his mercy he saved us"; likewise Romans 3: "Justified freely by his grace." And because you are Lord of all, namely by power, you make yourself to spare all, by mercy: whence the Gloss: "So that you who preside by power may be gentle by nature": above in chapter 11: "You have mercy on all, because you can do all things."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 17). For you show your strength, that is, power in punishing, you who are not believed, namely by those who err, to be consummate in power, that is, perfect: Job twenty-two: "They esteemed him as though the Almighty could do nothing." And those who know you not, namely the unfaithful, you convict in boldness, that is, you boldly lead to punishment, and this by the merit of their iniquities, above, chapter four: "Their iniquities shall convict them to their face."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, the instruction of the people of God in both is shown.
But you, ruler, etc. Having shown the punishment of adversaries and the mercy of the judge in punishing, here he shows the instruction of the people of God in both, and first he touches upon the example by which he instructs; second, the mercy concerning which he instructs: You have taught; third, the manner by which he instructs: For if enemies; fourth, the end on account of which he instructs: When therefore to us.
(Verse 18). But you, etc. I have rightly said that you show your strength and power to the incorrigible; autem stands for "but": you, master of power, etc. This can be understood intransitively, so that the sense is: you, master of power, that is, powerful; or transitively, thus: master of power, that is, Lord of all powers, namely both angelic and human: in the Psalm: "The Lord of hosts, he is the King of glory." You judge with tranquility, that is, without disturbance of intellect or affection; James one: "With whom there is no change"; Isaiah forty-two: "He shall bring forth judgment in truth; he shall not be sad nor troubled." And with great reverence, in effect, that is, with great moderation, you govern us, not like that judge "who neither feared God nor regarded man," Luke eighteen. For power is at hand to you, whenever you will: behold, the cause of tranquility in judging and of reverence in governing or in executing, namely because he is omnipotent: in the Psalm: "Whatsoever he willed, he did."
But it is objected that according to the order of understanding, power precedes will, not will power. Therefore it ought to say: willing is at hand to you when you are able, not being able when you will.
It must be said that power precedes in being, but will in acting: whence he is able to do many things which he does not do, because he does not will them.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 19). For you have taught your people: but others are not taught, whence Sirach twenty-one: "He who is not wise in good will not be instructed"; through such works, namely of justice and mercy together. Because it is necessary to be just, because you are just, and humane, that is, gentle, because man is by nature a gentle animal: and this, because you are merciful, not only just; whence in the Psalm: "Mercy and judgment I will sing to you, O Lord"; likewise: "The Lord is merciful and compassionate and just." And if the Lord, therefore also the servant; whence Matthew eighteen: "Should you not also have had mercy on your fellow servant, just as I also had mercy on you?" Ecclesiastes seven: "Do not be excessively just," namely to such a degree that you exclude mercy from your justice: for the Samaritan poured upon the wounded man not only wine, but also oil together. And you have made your children of good hope, that is, concerning the obtaining of pardon, your faithful ones, who are your children: whence John one: "He gave them the power to become children of God, to those who believe in his name." This is the good hope, concerning which in the Psalm: "Hope in him, all you assembly of the people"; likewise: "In God my heart has hoped, and I have been helped"; First Peter one: "Hope in the grace that is offered to you." Because judging, that is, punishing sinners, you give a place of repentance amid sins, that is, to those remaining in sins, namely by waiting for them unto repentance; Isaiah thirty: "Therefore the Lord waits, that he may have mercy on you." The place of repentance is this world: for after departure from this world there remains no place of repentance: on account of which Ecclesiastes eleven: "Wherever the tree falls, whether to the south or to the north, there it shall be." Chrysostom: "Then there will be no place of repentance, nor time for making satisfaction, nor power of restitution"; therefore Ecclesiastes nine: "Whatever your hand is able to do, work at it earnestly, because neither work nor reason nor knowledge nor wisdom will be in the netherworld, to which you hasten."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 20.). For if the enemies of your servants, as regards sin against neighbor, to which servants, I say, it is said in Luke 10: "He who hears you hears me, and he who despises you despises me"; and those deserving of death, as regards sin against God, who is the life of souls, according to Augustine: deserving, I say, of death, according to that passage in Romans 1: "Not only those who do such things are worthy of death," etc. You tormented with such great deliberation, namely not all at once, but by punishing in parts and successively, as is evident in the plagues of Egypt; and you delivered, namely them from these, namely from temporal torments, because, when Moses prayed, they were delivered from each torment: a similar thing also happened with the Canaanites. Giving time and place, through which they might be changed from malice: time, namely the span of life, and place, namely the exile of this world: concerning time, Apocalypse 2: "I gave her time, that she might do penance"; concerning place, Job 24: "God gave him a place of penance, and he abuses it in pride."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 21.). With how great diligence you judged your sons etc., as if to say: with great diligence and care, according to what the Psalmist sought, saying: "Rise up and attend to my judgment, my God and my Lord, to my cause." In a figure of this it is read in Genesis 3 that God, about to judge the sin of Adam, was walking about, etc. Your sons, namely the Saints, above in chapter 5: "Behold, how they are counted among the sons of God, and among the Saints is their lot." Or: your sons, that is, your faithful, according to that passage in John 1: "He gave them power to become sons of God, to those who believe in his name." Whose, namely of the sons, parents, that is, the Patriarchs, such as Abraham, Genesis 15 and 22; Isaac, Genesis 26; Jacob, Genesis 28: you gave oaths and covenants, that is, sworn covenants. Note that a covenant is a simple promise, whereas an oath is a promise with the attestation of a sacred thing; Hebrews 6: "That by two immutable things, in which it is impossible for God to lie, we might have the strongest consolation," etc. Of good promises, namely concerning the promised land and concerning the blessing of the seed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Verse 22). When therefore etc., as if to say: you are so beneficent and merciful to adversaries: when therefore you give us discipline, that is, corrective punishment, which is not to be rejected, according to that passage in Proverbs 3: "The discipline of the Lord, my son, do not reject," because it instructs; whence in the Psalm: "Your discipline has corrected me unto the end," etc. Our enemies, namely those who hate us, although they are loved by us, according to what the Lord admonishes in Matthew 5: "Love your enemies"; in manifold ways you scourge, namely inwardly and outwardly, according to that passage of the Psalm: "Many are the scourges of the sinner"; the Gloss: "There is a great distance between the judgment of the elect and of the reprobate: for the former he corrects, that he may amend them; the latter pay the penalties of pride and faithlessness." That your goodness, namely in the present, we may consider when judging, namely others, whom we see scourged by you: the Gloss: "Happy is the judge who always looks upon the goodness and mercy of his Judge," namely so that, having beheld the mercy of God who judges, he may learn to have mercy when he judges others: in the Psalm: "How good is the God of Israel to those who are upright of heart": Nahum 1: "The Lord is good and strengthening in the day of tribulation and knows those who hope in him." And when we are judged, namely through the sending of present tribulations, we may hope for your mercy, namely in the future, namely the reward of eternal life: James 1: "Count it all joy, brethren, when you fall into various trials," etc.: Romans 5: "Glory in tribulations, knowing that tribulation works patience, and patience hope," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fourth, concerning the condemnation of incorrigible adversaries on account of contempt, six points are touched upon.
Whence also to those. Here is touched upon the condemnation of incorrigible adversaries on account of contempt of both, namely of divine justice and mercy: and first is touched upon the scourge by which they ought to have been corrected; second, the fittingness of the scourge: For indeed etc.; third, the incorrigibility of those scourged: But those who etc.; fourth, the manifestation of incorrigibility: For in these things; fifth, the reason on account of which they ought to have been corrected: Through those things which they thought; sixth, the finality of condemnation, because they were not corrected, there: On account of which etc.
(Verse 23). Whence etc., as if to say: thus you give discipline to your own; whence, namely by contrast; and, meaning also: to those who in their life lived senselessly and unjustly, with respect to error in faith; or: in their life, that is, in which they lived for themselves, not for God; and unjustly, with respect to error in morals; through those things which they worshipped, namely through brute animals, you gave the greatest, that is, exceedingly great, torments, such as through frogs and flies and locusts and wasps and things of this kind. Through these things etc.; namely in kind and without number or species.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 24.). For indeed they themselves went astray, not for a short time, but for a long while, which aggravates their sin, because, as Gregory says, "sins are so much the worse, the longer they hold the unhappy soul bound." In the pathless way of error, that is, of unbelief, which is called error par excellence. Concerning this way it is said in Proverbs sixteen: "There is a way that seems right to a man, and its end leads to death." Esteeming as gods those things which are superfluous among living creatures, that is, animals artificially carved, not natural ones. Artificial animals are called superfluous, because they are useless; but all natural ones have some usefulness, as Damascene says. Esteeming them as gods, etc.; Romans one: "They changed the glory of the incorruptible God into the likeness of the image of corruptible man"; likewise in the Psalm: "They changed their glory into the likeness of a calf eating hay." Note that he does not say "into a calf," but into the likeness of a calf, which is less and counts for the worse. Living after the manner of senseless children, as regards sins in morals: First Corinthians fourteen: "Do not become children in understanding"; likewise First Peter two: "As newborn babes, rational," not senseless. In this indeed they lived after the manner of senseless children, because, like children, they made and worshipped images, just as Ishmael is read in Genesis twenty-one to have played with Isaac, compelling him to worship clay images, as the Hebrews say.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 25.). Therefore, as to senseless children, you gave a judgment in derision, that is, a punishment in which they were mocked, because they were afflicted by frogs and flies and such small and contemptible animals, not by greater and nobler ones, such as lions and bears, as is clear from Exodus seven through twelve.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 26.). But those who by mockeries and rebukes, that is, rebukes full of mockery, were not corrected, namely from unbelief and perverse conduct, experienced a worthy judgment of God, namely of condemnation and death. From this he seems to imply that some were corrected amid the scourges; whence also some of the Egyptians went with the Israelites, as is clear from Exodus twelve, and the Gibeonites were confederated with them, as is clear from Joshua nine.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For in these things etc., as if to say: and deservedly; for in these things which they suffered, namely in the divine scourges, they bore it grievously, by carrying them impatiently. For in those things suffering, that is, enduring, so that suffering is said from passion, not from patience: they were indignant, namely by murmuring against God; Sirach thirty-three: "The heart of a fool is like a cart wheel." Through those things which they thought were gods, namely brute animals, in them, that is, through them, when they were destroyed, that is, punished; Baruch three: "They were destroyed and descended to the underworld"; seeing him, that is, God, as if perceiving by sensible experience; for in himself he cannot be seen; First John four: "No one has ever seen God." Whom formerly, namely in prosperity, they denied that they knew, according to that text in Exodus five: "I do not know the Lord, and I will not let Israel go." The true God, to be, supply: they acknowledged, by belief not voluntary, but extorted through punishments; such is the faith of demons; James two: "The demons believe" etc.; Isaiah twenty-six: "Lord, in distress they sought you." "For the eyes which guilt closes, punishment opens," as Gregory says. The text is to be construed thus: Seeing, namely the Egyptians and Canaanites, him whom formerly they denied that they knew, they acknowledged the true God, to be, supply: they acknowledged, I say, through those things which they thought were gods, that is, through brute animals; and this happened when they were destroyed through them. On account of which, namely, because they acknowledged God, yet did not glorify him, according to that text in Romans one: "Who, although they had known God, did not glorify him as God" etc.; and the end of their condemnation, that is, their final condemnation, of which Matthew twenty-five says: "Depart from me, you cursed, into eternal fire." The beginning of condemnation is in the separation of the soul from the body; the middle, in the torment of the separated soul; but the end, in the resurrection, when one will be tormented in hell with the resumed body; the end, I say, of their condemnation, who in the present life refused to be corrected, shall come etc.; Gregory: "Those whom scourges do not correct in the present, they transmit to future ones"; upon them, because from heaven for their oppression, so that they cannot resist, as though overwhelmed or crushed; in the Psalm: "He shall rain upon sinners snares, fire and brimstone" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, concerning punishment through graver penalties ordained for condemnation, it is determined in two ways.
But vain etc. Above he determined concerning the punishment of adversaries through lighter penalties ordained for correction, but here concerning their punishment through graver penalties ordained for condemnation. And first he determines concerning the desert of their fault, namely up to the sixteenth chapter; second, concerning the torment of their punishment, namely from the sixteenth chapter onward.
First, the demerit of fault is determined in three ways.
The desert of fault with respect to their condemnatory punishment was idolatry, by which they transferred divine honor to a creature or exhibited it to a creature. And therefore first the manifold error of idolaters is touched upon, namely in this chapter; second, the detestation of idols, namely in the fourteenth chapter; third, the commendation of the true God, namely in the fifteenth chapter.
First, the error of idolaters is treated.
The error of idolaters is touched upon as twofold: the first, of those worshipping God's creatures; the second, of those worshipping their own fabrications: But unhappy.
Their first error.
In the first part, there is first touched upon in them the cause of so great an error, namely ignorance of God: second, the effect of the aforesaid cause, namely the worship of creatures: But either fire: third, of both the greater inexcusability: If by their beauty: fourth, in comparison to other idolaters: Yet nevertheless. — In the first part a twofold ignorance is touched upon, namely that they neither acknowledged by faith God nor knew by reason Him: And from those things which are seen.
He says therefore: Vain, etc. Thus it has been said that some knew God amid afflictions, but did not worship Him: however, for but: vain are all men, etc.; Ecclesiastes 1: "Vanity of vanities," etc. "For they walked after the vanity of the creature and became vain," as is found in Jeremiah 2: vain, I say, with the vanity of thought: whence Romans 1: "They became vain in their thoughts," etc.: likewise in the Psalm: "The Lord knows the thoughts of men, that they are vain." Likewise, with the vanity of speech: whence in the Psalm: "They have spoken vain things every one to his neighbor," etc. Likewise, with the vanity of action: whence Jeremiah 51: "Their works are vain and worthy of derision." In whom there is not the knowledge of God, that is, knowledge of God through faith. Augustine: "Nor do I attribute to this knowledge, namely divine knowledge, whatever can be known by man in human affairs, where there is a great deal of superfluous vanity and harmful curiosity: but only that by which the most salutary faith is begotten, nourished, defended, and strengthened, in which knowledge they do not excel," etc. And from those things which are seen to be good, namely openly: they could not, namely an inability following upon the will, not preceding it: whence the Gloss: "They could not understand, etc., the blindness of sin standing in the way," according to that above in chapter 2: "Their malice blinded them"; in the Psalm: "He would not understand, that he might do well"; understand, that is, know by the intellect: for God cannot be known by the senses: 1 John 4: "No man has seen God at any time"; Him who is, that is, God, for whom being is substantial, not accidental: whence Hilary: "Being is not an accident in God, but subsistent truth." Likewise, for whom being is always present, never past or future. For God, according to Augustine, always is, neither was nor will be, because He does not know, namely through experience, past or future. Likewise, whose being is pure, because whatever is in Him, He Himself is: Augustine: "Whatever is in God is God." Likewise, whose being is not from another, is immutable: whence Jerome to Marcella: "God, who alone has no beginning, held the name of true essence, because in comparison with Him, who truly is, because He is unchangeable, those things which are changeable, as it were, are not," as are all creatures, according to that of the Psalm: "As a covering You shall change them, and they shall be changed: but You are the selfsame," etc.: likewise Malachi 3: "I am," God, or "the Lord, and I change not." For the aforesaid reasons, to Moses asking His name He said in Exodus 3: "I am who I am. He said: Thus shall you say to the children of Israel: He who is has sent me to you." Nor attending to the works, which He Himself made, did they recognize who was the maker, namely of these things, and yet they could easily have known: Romans 1: "For the invisible things of God, from the creation of the world, are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But either fire, namely Vulcan, as the Chaldeans worshipping fire: or spirit, that is, the ether, namely the upper part of the air, which some understood by Jupiter the thunderer; or the swift air, that is, the lower part of the air, which they called Juno: or the circle of the stars, that is, the starry heaven, as those who worshipped the host of heaven, of whom it is said in Deuteronomy 17: "That they go and serve strange gods, and adore them: the sun and the moon and all the host of heaven"; or the great water, which they called Neptune; or the sun, which they called Phoebus or Apollo, which the Babylonians worshipped: or the moon, which they called Diana, or "the queen of heaven," of which in Jeremiah 44. They supposed them to be gods that rule the world, on account of certain of their effects necessary to the world.
Note that they ought not to have supposed creatures to be gods, first on account of the corporeality of their nature, because God is a spirit; John 4: "God is a spirit." Likewise on account of position and determination of figure: for God is everywhere wholly present: likewise He is unfigurable according to the Godhead. Likewise on account of the determination and limitation of power to certain effects: for God is omnipotent: above in chapter 11: "You have mercy on all, because You can do all things." Likewise on account of the necessity and inevitability of natural effects; for God is of free will. Likewise on account of local motion: because God is immovable, since He is the principle of all motion; Boethius: Remaining stable, You give all things to be moved. Likewise on account of deficiency of eternity: for God is eternal, but eternity is lacking or wanting to creatures.
According to the spiritual sense, the lustful worship fire; the proud, spirit: the wrathful and impetuous, the swift air; the curious in knowledge, the circle of the stars: the voluptuous, the great water; the covetous, the sun which begets these lower things: the slothful and acedious, the moon.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If by their beauty. Here is shown their inexcusability, because they were able to know the Creator either through the beauty of creatures, or through their power: which is shown there: Or if their power etc.; or through both together, which is shown there: From the greatness etc.
He says therefore: If delighted by their appearance, that is, by their beauty — Daniel thirteen: "Beauty has deceived you," etc. — they thought them to be gods, supply: that they themselves were gods; they thought, I say, by a false and erroneous opinion, since there is but one God — Deuteronomy six: "Your God is one." Let them know how much the ruler over them, namely their Creator, governor, preserver, and possessor, according to that passage in Judith nine: "God of the heavens, creator of the waters, king of all your creation"; is more beautiful than these, namely he who made such beautiful things; more beautiful, I say, by an infinite distance, because God is beautiful through his essence, but creatures through participation — above in chapter seven: "He is more beautiful than the sun." For the begetter of beauty, of the beauty, namely, of creatures through their production, according to that passage of Boethius: He himself most beautiful, bearing the beautiful world in his mind and forming it in a like image. Or: of beauty, uncreated, that is, of the Son through eternal generation. He established all these things, namely the higher, the middle, and the lower.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Or if the power, that is, the greatness of their might, and their works, that is, the effects proceeding from their power, they marveled at, namely so much so that they believed them to be gods, let them understand from these things, that is, from the consideration of them, according to that passage in Job twelve: "Ask the beasts, and they will teach you"; that he who made these things, namely God, is stronger than they, that is, more powerful — whence Ecclesiasticus forty-three: "He himself is almighty above all his works and exceedingly great"; likewise Job nine: "If strength is sought, he is the most mighty."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For from the greatness of the beauty that is, of the loveliness, and of the creature, that is, of the power of creatures, knowably, not sensibly, that is, by the intellectual eye, not the sensible one, the Creator of these things can be seen. Augustine: "All things cry out: God made me"; for the whole world is like a certain book in which the Creator can be known through his power, wisdom, and goodness, shining forth in creatures — whence Ecclesiasticus twenty-four: "All these things are the book of life"; Isidore: "The Creator is praised through his creature, and how excellent he is, is shown from the condition of his work."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since therefore one must first ascend before descending on the ladder of Jacob, let us place the first step of ascent at the bottom, setting this entire sensible world before us as a mirror, through which we may pass over to God, the supreme Artificer, so that we may be true Hebrews passing over from Egypt to the land promised to the Fathers, and also Christians passing over with Christ from this world to the Father, and also lovers of wisdom, who calls and says: Pass over to me, all you who desire me, and be filled from my generations. For from the greatness of the beauty and of the creature, the Creator of these things can be knowably seen.
Now the supreme power, wisdom, and benevolence of the Creator shines forth in created things, inasmuch as the bodily sense announces this in a threefold manner to the interior sense. For the bodily sense serves the intellect either rationally investigating, or faithfully believing, or intellectually contemplating. The one contemplating considers the actual existence of things; the one believing, the habitual course of things; the one reasoning, the potential excellence of things.
In the first mode, the gaze of the one contemplating, considering things in themselves, sees in them weight, number, and measure: weight with respect to the position toward which they incline, number, by which they are distinguished, and measure, by which they are limited. And thereby it sees in them mode, species, and order, as well as substance, power, and operation. From which one can rise as from a vestige to understanding the immense power, wisdom, and goodness of the Creator.
In the second mode, the gaze of the faithful, considering this world, attends to its origin, course, and end. For by faith we believe that the ages were fashioned by the Word of life; by faith we believe that the times of the three laws, namely of nature, of Scripture, and of grace, succeed one another and have run their course in most perfect order; by faith we believe that the world is to be brought to an end through the final judgment: perceiving in the first the power, in the second the providence, and in the third the justice of the supreme Principle.
In the third mode, the gaze of one rationally investigating sees that certain things merely exist, certain things however exist and live, and certain things indeed exist, live, and discern: and the first are indeed lesser, the second intermediate, the third better. — It sees again that certain things are only corporeal, certain things partly corporeal, partly spiritual: from which it perceives that some things are purely spiritual as being better and more worthy than both. It sees nonetheless that certain things are mutable and corruptible, as terrestrial things; certain things mutable and incorruptible, as celestial things; from which it perceives that certain things are immutable and incorruptible, as supercelestial things. From these visible things, therefore, one rises to considering the power, wisdom, and goodness of God as being, living, and intelligent, purely spiritual and incorruptible and unchangeable.
Now this consideration is expanded according to the sevenfold condition of creatures, which is a sevenfold testimony to the divine power, wisdom, and goodness, if one considers the origin, magnitude, multitude, beauty, fullness, operation, and order of all things. — For the origin of things according to creation, distinction, and adornment, with respect to the works of the six days, proclaims the divine power producing all things from nothing, the wisdom lucidly distinguishing all things, and the goodness lavishly adorning all things. — The magnitude of things, however, according to the mass of their length, breadth, and depth; according to the excellence of a power extending itself far, wide, and deep, as is evident in the diffusion of light; according to the efficacy of an operation that is intimate, continuous, and diffused, as is evident in the operation of fire, manifestly indicates the immensity of the power, wisdom, and goodness of the triune God, who exists in all things through power, presence, and essence, uncircumscribed. The multitude of things, according to their general, specific, and individual diversity in substance, in form or figure, and in efficacy, beyond all human estimation, manifestly intimates and shows the immensity of the three aforesaid conditions in God. The beauty of things, according to the variety of lights, figures, and colors in simple, mixed, and even complexioned bodies, as in celestial bodies and minerals, as in stones and metals, plants and animals, evidently proclaims the three aforesaid. The fullness of things, inasmuch as matter is full of forms according to seminal reasons; form is full of power according to active potency; power is full of effects according to efficiency, manifestly declares the same. Operation, which is manifold, inasmuch as it is natural, inasmuch as it is artificial, inasmuch as it is moral, by its most manifold variety shows the immensity of that power, art, and goodness which is indeed for all things "the cause of being, the ground of understanding, and the rule of living." — Order, moreover, according to the measure of duration, position, and influence, namely through prior and posterior, higher and lower, nobler and less noble, in the book of creation manifestly intimates the primacy, sublimity, and dignity of the first principle with respect to the infinity of power; the order of divine laws, precepts, and judgments in the book of Scripture intimates the immensity of wisdom; and the order of divine Sacraments, benefits, and retributions in the body of the Church intimates the immensity of goodness; so that order itself most evidently leads us by the hand to the first and highest, the most powerful, the most wise, and the best.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But yet etc. Here he shows the fault of those who worship creatures in comparison to other idolaters; and first they are shown to be in some way excusable in comparison to those others; second, it is shown that nevertheless they are simply inexcusable: But again.
But yet etc., as if to say: thus do they err; but yet still in these, namely those who err in this way, the complaint is less, that is, the ground for complaint, than in those who worship graven images, because, as it is said in the last chapter of Baruch, "they will not shine like the sun, nor give light like the moon," namely the graven images themselves. For these also, namely those who worship creatures, perhaps err: "perhaps" is here a mark of free will, not a mark of doubt. Seeking God, namely with a certain curiosity, according to that passage in Acts 17: "He made from one every nation of men to dwell upon the whole face of the earth, etc., to seek God, if perhaps they might grope after him, or find him." And wishing to find him, namely by the intention of the affections: Song of Songs 3: "I will rise and go about the city," that is, the entirety of creatures. For according to Boethius in the Consolation, "there is implanted in the minds of men a desire for the true and the good."
But it is objected: because in Luke 11 it is said: "Everyone who seeks, finds": therefore these people find the true God.
It must be said that that passage is understood of those who seek piously, not curiously.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For when they are occupied with his works, namely by disputing about them as regards the intellect, according to that passage in Ecclesiastes 3: "He delivered the world to their disputation"; and by using them, namely as regards the affections and their effect, because Matthew 5: "He makes his sun to rise upon the good and the evil." They search, namely by reasoning, and they are persuaded, namely by judging: that the things which are seen are good: Genesis 1: "God saw all that he had made, and they were very good." In this these people are better, or less evil, than the Manicheans themselves, who say that these visible things are evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But again, neither should these be pardoned. For simple ignorance merits pardon; whence 1 Timothy 1: "I obtained mercy, because I did it ignorantly"; but crass and supine ignorance does not: whence 1 Corinthians 14: "If anyone is ignorant, he shall be ignored."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"For if they were able to know so much as to make a judgment of the world, how did they not more easily find out the Lord thereof?" Philosophical knowledge is a way to the other sciences: but he who wishes to remain there falls into darkness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For if they were able to know so much as to be able to appraise the world, that is, to know the natures of worldly things: how did they not more easily find the Lord of this, namely of the world? As if to say: they could have known God more easily.
But to the contrary: Above, chapter 9: "With difficulty do we judge the things that are on earth; and who shall search out the things that are in the heavens?"
It must be said that it does not mean to say that they could more easily know God to be the author of these things absolutely, but rather that he is God, rather than those things which they worshipped.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Their second error concerns two things.
But unhappy etc. Here is set forth the error of those who worship their own handiwork, first, their own handiwork in metallic material; second, in wooden material: Or if someone.
He says therefore: But unhappy are they, namely through the privation of the happiness of the way, concerning which above in chapter three: "He who rejects wisdom and discipline is unhappy." And among the dead, namely by eternal death, is their hope, that is, their expectation: hope however is here taken improperly, because hope properly so called pertains only to what is good. Among the dead, I say, is their hope, through the privation of eternal happiness, according to that verse of the Psalm: "Like the wounded sleeping in the sepulchres, whom you remember no more, and they are cast off from your hand," from the hand, namely, of saving mercy, not from the hand of punishing justice. Or the first refers to the punishment of loss in the future, the second to the punishment of sense. Of those, I say, who have called gods, etc. And he rightly says called: for they are gods by name only, not by nature. The works of the hands of men, according to that verse of the Psalm: "The idols of the nations are silver and gold, the works of the hands of men"; Isaiah chapter two: "They have adored the work of their own hands, which their fingers have made"; gold and silver, that is, made of gold and silver as regards the matter, according to that verse of Hosea chapter two: "I multiplied their silver and gold, which they made unto Baal"; according to that verse of Isaiah chapter two: "The land is filled with gold and silver, and there is no end to its treasures, and its land is filled with idols." An invention of art, that is, some figure devised by art, and this as regards the form. And likenesses of animals, not the animals themselves, but their image or likeness: against which it is said in Deuteronomy chapter four: "You shall not make a likeness of any animals that are on the earth." Or a useless stone, namely as to the usefulness which idolaters believe to be in it, although it is useful as regards natural use, because there is nothing superfluous in the works of God, of which kind are creatures; Deuteronomy chapter thirty-two: "The works of God are perfect," neither superfluous nor diminished. The work of an ancient hand, that is, of the hand of an ancient craftsman, because "in the ancients is wisdom," Job chapter twelve. Against all these things it is said in Acts chapter seventeen: "Being therefore the offspring of God, we ought not to think that the divine is like unto gold, or silver, or stone, the graving of art and the device of man."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Or if anyone. Here is set forth the error of those who worship their own handiwork in wooden material: and first their error in fashioning or carpentry is touched upon; second, in worshipping: And of the substance. In the first, he first touches upon the matter; second, the form: And through knowledge; third, the placement: And let him make for it, etc.; fourth, the impotence: An image, etc.
Or if some craftsman, a worker: worker here is taken broadly for a craftsman in whatever material, whether wooden or other, not only iron: has cut a straight piece of wood from the forest: Isaiah forty-four: "He cuts down cedars, he took the holm oak," etc. And of this, namely the wood, skillfully scrapes off all the bark, namely the outer bark; and employing his skill, diligently fashions a useful vessel: The Gloss: "Very useful," for the conduct of life, namely human life: Second Timothy two: "For in a great house there are vessels of wood and of earthenware," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the remnants of this work, that is, of the aforesaid wood, he uses up for the preparation of food, that is, he uses them, according to that passage of Isaiah forty-four: "He took from them and was warmed, he kindled a fire and baked bread."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the remainder of these, namely of those things which have been put to human uses: which for no use, namely human use, avails, that is, is of any worth; I say that very crooked wood, namely in itself, and with knots, that is, nodes, full, namely on the outside; he carves diligently, namely by removing the knottiness, through his idleness, because however much he labors there, all his labor is reckoned as idleness, since he labors there uselessly. And by the knowledge of his art he shapes it, namely by external delineation, and this with respect to form: and makes it like the image of a man, namely by the representation of the limbs. And note that he does not say makes it like a man, but the image of a man, because this configuration can exist in external features and not in internal ones.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Or compares it to some animal, that is, likens it: Romans 1: "Into the likeness of the image of corruptible man and of birds and of four-footed beasts," etc.; likewise in the Psalm: "They exchanged their glory for the likeness of a calf eating hay." Smearing over, that is, on the outside, with red ochre, that is, with a rule or a line drawn in red color, by which a marking is made. For rubrica is said to mean red earth and the color that is made from it, and the rule or line by which it is made, and the dye itself, and the middle syllable must always be lengthened. And making the color of it red with paint: fucus is called an unnatural and, as it were, counterfeit color. Likewise it should be noted that fucus is called an animal similar to a bee, which does not make honey but devours honey; likewise, a certain herb that dyes; likewise, any counterfeit color; likewise, falsehood or fraud and deceit, according to Papias. And smearing over every blemish that is in it, namely in the wood, with earth. — And he makes a worthy dwelling for it: whence Baruch, last chapter: "When they are set up in a house, their eyes are full of dust from the feet of those entering." And setting it in a wall, namely so that it may be more visible, and fastening it with iron, that is, with iron nails, lest perhaps it fall; Isaiah 41: "He fastened it with nails, lest it be moved"; looking out for it, that is, foreseeing and taking precaution; knowing that it cannot help itself, namely by itself: whence in the Psalm: "They have hands, and they shall not handle; they have feet, and they shall not walk," etc. Nor is this a wonder, for it is an image, that is, a likeness of a thing, not the thing itself, and it needs help, namely human help: Baruch, last chapter: "If they fall to the ground, they do not rise up by themselves," as was evident concerning Dagon, 1 Kings 5; likewise Jeremiah 10: "They must be carried and borne, because they cannot walk."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And concerning his substance, that is, concerning his outward possession, and concerning his children, that is, concerning the welfare of his children, and concerning marriages, namely those to be contracted, making a vow, namely to it, he inquires, namely from it, so as to seek what is necessary for himself and his children, although one ought not to make vows except to God, according to that word of the Psalm, "Vow and render unto the Lord your God," etc.; likewise Isaiah 19: "They shall vow vows unto the Lord and fulfill them." He is not ashamed to speak, namely he himself having a soul, with that which, namely the false god, is without a soul: Baruch, last chapter: "When they hear that a mute cannot speak, they bring it to Bel"; in the Psalm: "They have a mouth, and they shall not speak."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And for health, that is, his own or of his own, he entreats one who is infirm, that is, altogether powerless, indeed, that is, certainly, and for life he asks one who is dead, that is, altogether lacking life, so that dead is understood negatively, not privatively, because, if privatively, then it would be understood that he once had life, but was afterwards deprived of it: which would be false. And he calls upon one useless for help, that is, one unable to help himself or another: whence Baruch, last chapter: "He has a sword in his hand, and does not deliver himself from robbers."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And for a journey, that is, direction on a journey, he asks of him who cannot walk, according to that of the Psalm: "They have feet, and they shall not walk," etc.; Baruch, last chapter: "Without feet they are carried on shoulders." And concerning acquiring, namely through commerce, and concerning working, namely through the mechanical arts, and concerning the outcome of all things, in general, he asks of him who is useless in all things; Isaiah forty-four: "He fashioned a god and cast a graven image, useful for nothing."
But it seems that the same objection could be raised against Christians who adore images.
But it must be said that it is not the same: because idolaters adored images as things, thinking that something living was in them; but Christians adore them only as pieces of wood, and insofar as they lead to those realities of which they are signs.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, it treats of the detestation of idols in a fourfold manner. Again another thinking to sail etc. After he described the manifold errors of idol-worshippers, here he touches upon the detestation of idols, and first, from the uselessness of the idols themselves; second, from the offense to the Creator: But in like manner they are hateful; third, from the novelty and manner of their invention: For they were not etc.; fourth, from the effect of human corruption: And it was not enough to have erred.
First, he detests idols on account of their uselessness.
He shows the uselessness of idols in the first part by the example of those sailing on the sea, whom the idols, when invoked, cannot help. He shows that this impotence is to be detested, first from the fragility of the idol that has no power; second, from the power of God who saves even without a ship: But thy etc.; third, from the usefulness of the ship itself: But that they might not be; fourth, by the example of Noah's ark preserving the human race: But also from the beginning.
He says therefore: Again another etc., as if to say: not only do men uselessly seek help from idols on land, but again, on water, because another, namely a man, thinking to sail, namely by intention, and through fierce waves, that is, dangerous ones: whence in the Psalm: "Wonderful are the surges of the sea"; likewise Sirach forty-three: "They that sail the sea tell of the dangers thereof." Beginning to make a journey, namely by the execution of his intention, calls upon a wood more fragile than the wood that carries him: he calls upon, namely for help, a wood, namely an idol, more fragile than the wood carrying him, that is, the ship.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For that, namely the wood of the idol, the desire of acquiring devised: whence in Ephesians five it is said "covetousness is the service of idols." And the craftsman fashioned it by his wisdom: his own, he says, as if to say: not divine, "but earthly, sensual, devilish," James three; Isaiah forty-five: "The makers of errors have gone into confusion"; and Job thirteen: "Showing you to be makers of lies"; the Gloss: "Since the maker is greater than what is made, to adore one's own handiwork is madness."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But thy, O Father, as if to say: there they invoke the idol in the governance of their journey: but, meaning however; thy, O Father, by creation; Isaiah sixty-four: "And now, O Lord, thou art our father, and we indeed are clay" etc.; likewise by provision; whence Matthew six: "Our Father etc., our bread" etc. Thou governest, namely all things, by providence, which, according to Damascene, "is the care of God for things"; concerning which Judith nine: "Thou hast placed thy judgments in thy providence."
From what has been said, it is clear that nothing in the world happens by chance and fortune, because, as Plato says, "nothing exists whose origin was not preceded by a legitimate cause." That the world is administered by providence, Cicero proves in the Rhetoric thus: "Things done by providence are better administered than those done by chance; but the world is administered in the best way; therefore," etc.
For etc., as if to say: this is clear, that you govern all things by providence; for you have given, namely to the children of Israel, a way in the sea, leading them out of Egypt through the midst of the dry sea, as is clear from Exodus fourteen: and among the waves, namely of the river Jordan, a most firm path, Joshua three. Of both it is said in the Psalm: "Your way is in the sea, and your paths in many waters"; the Gloss: "Divine power led the Israelites through the Red Sea with dry footstep and divided the waters of the Jordan."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Showing, namely by this, that you are powerful from all things, namely perils and misfortunes, to heal, or better according to another reading, to save, even if without a raft, that is, a ship, someone should go to sea: Isaiah forty-three: "When you pass through the waters, I will be with you, and the rivers shall not cover you"; whence "He raised up Peter walking on the waves, lest he be submerged," as is clear from Matthew fourteen: "He freed Paul, shipwrecked for the third time, from the depth of the sea," as is clear from Second Corinthians eleven.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But that they might not be empty, but rather necessary for human use, the works of your wisdom, that is, devised through your wisdom; in the Psalm: "You have made all things in wisdom." For this reason also to a small piece of wood, namely a small ship, men entrust their souls, that is, their bodily life: and crossing the sea, in which nevertheless there are innumerable perils, they have been delivered by a raft: the Gloss: "The Creator gave to his creature knowledge by which it might provide for itself in the present and serve his will."
Allegorically, the small piece of wood can be called the cross of Christ on account of its abjection and lowliness; First Corinthians one: "We preach Christ crucified, to the Jews indeed a stumbling block, and to the Gentiles foolishness." To this men entrust their souls, namely by believing in Christ crucified and adoring him in whom they have believed. And thus crossing the sea of this world, namely by the power and imitation of the cross, by the raft they are delivered and arrive at the port of eternal salvation. Whence Damascene: "The cross is the resurrection of those who sleep, the staff of the infirm, the rod of pastors, the aid of those being converted, the perfection of those advancing, the salvation of soul and body, the aversion of all evils, the teacher of all good things, the destruction of sin, the tree of resurrection, the wood of eternal life." In these words, however, To a small piece of wood, etc., the humility of the cross is first intimated, when it says: By a small piece of wood; second, its veneration and dignity, when it says: Men trust their souls, rational men, that is, as blessed Andrew said: "Receive me from men"; third, necessity, when it says: And those crossing the sea, namely of this world, concerning which the Psalm says: "This great sea" etc.; fourth, its power and usefulness, when it says: They were delivered by a raft: First Corinthians 1: "We preach Christ" etc.; likewise: "The word of the cross to those who are perishing etc., but to us" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But also from the beginning. Here the usefulness of Noah's ark is first shown; second, it is praised, at: For blessed is the wood etc.; third, the idol and its maker are condemned: But by the hands etc.
But also from the beginning etc., as if to say: it not only delivers from the peril of the sea, but also from the flood, and this is what it says: But also from the beginning, namely in the beginning of the second age, namely in the time of Noah, Genesis 6. When there perished, namely in the flood, the proud giants, concerning whom it is found in Genesis 6: the hope of the world, namely of the future world: the Gloss says: "The seedbed of the human race," namely the eight persons, concerning whom it is said in First Peter 3: "In which a few souls were saved through water"; fleeing to a raft, that is, an ark made in the manner of a raft, because its length was greater than its width, Genesis 6, bequeathed to the age, namely the future age after the flood, the seed of birth, namely of both men and animals, as is evident in Genesis 6. Which, namely the ark, by your hand: the Gloss says: "By power, or by the Son," according to that verse of the Psalm: "Send forth your hand from on high" etc.; was governed, because it had no helmsman except God or his Angel, since all men existing outside were dead, and those existing within were enclosed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For blessed is the wood, namely of Noah's ark, through which justice is wrought, namely the deliverance of the just, while the wicked were drowned, which was just. Concerning this wood, above in chapter 10: "When water destroyed the earth, wisdom healed it again, governing the just man by a contemptible piece of wood."
Now this wood allegorically can be called the wood of the cross, of which it is said in First Peter, chapter two: "He bore our sins in His own body upon the tree." Through that wood justice was accomplished, because "to each was rendered what was his own." For through that wood sin was destroyed, according to that which the Church sings: "Death then died, when life died upon the wood"; Hosea, chapter thirteen: "O death, I will be your death," etc. Likewise, through it the devil was conquered, according to that saying of Gregory: "He who conquered through wood would also be conquered through wood." Likewise, through it man was reconciled; Colossians, chapter two: "Blotting out the handwriting of the decree that was against us, nailing it to the cross"; likewise Colossians, chapter one: "Making peace through the blood of the cross." Likewise, hell was despoiled; Colossians, chapter two: "Despoiling principalities and powers," etc. Likewise, heaven was opened: whence it was said to the thief: "Today you shall be with Me in paradise," Luke, chapter twenty-three; Isaiah, chapter twenty-two: "I will give the key of the house of David." Likewise, Christ was exalted: whence Philippians, chapter two: "Wherefore God also exalted Him," etc. This was the scepter of Ahasuerus shown or extended to man as a sign of clemency, Esther, chapter fifteen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And rightly I said that blessed is the wood by which justice is done: now, standing for "but": the idol, which is made by hands, namely of craftsmen, is accursed, both it, namely the idol, and he who made it, namely the craftsman.
But the idol, since it is an inanimate thing, how is it accursed? Because this curse is understood either by reason of fault, which does not befall the idol, or by reason of punishment, which is to be inflicted by reason of fault.
It must be said that in the idol two things are to be considered, namely the presiding spirit and the figure of the wood. The malign spirit itself is accursed with the curse of fault and punishment; but the wood, with the curse of detestation and infamy, as a kind of punishment — not because it is a subject of fault, by reason of which punishment is to be inflicted, but because it is the matter or occasion of fault. Whence the Gloss: "For the devil will be punished because he usurps divine honor for himself; and man, who honors a creature in place of the Creator."
Because he indeed fashioned it, namely the idol, whence he is rightly accursed: Isaiah, chapter forty-four: "Behold, all its partakers shall be confounded." But that thing, namely the idol, since it was fragile, because made of fragile material, was named a god, namely by appellation alone, not by the truth of the thing: on account of which it is rightly accursed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Secondly, he detests idols on account of the offense to the Creator.
But likewise etc. Here he touches on the second cause of the detestation of idols, taken from the offense against the Creator: and first he touches on the sign of the offense, namely the idol, and the punishment of the idolater; second, the irremissibility of the punishment: For this reason etc.; third, the cause on the part of the idol: Because creatures; fourth, the cause on the part of the idolater: For the beginning etc.
I have rightly said that both are accursed etc.: but, meaning because: likewise hateful to God is the ungodly one, namely the idolater, because he denies the piety of divine worship, and his ungodliness, that is, the matter of his ungodliness, namely the idol, that is, the demon presiding over the idol; Sirach 12: "The Most High hates sinners." And it should be noted that the hatred of God does not denote or signify an affection in Him, but an effect in the one whom He hates.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For indeed that which was made, namely the idol, together with him who made it, that is, with the idolatrous craftsman, shall suffer torments.
Concerning the idolater this is clear: but concerning the idol, how can it be true, namely that it suffers torment, since it is an inanimate thing?
It must be said that he speaks of the idol by reason of the malign spirit presiding in it, not on the part of the figure or matter of the idol itself.
But to the contrary: The idolater does not make the malign spirit that presides.
It must be said that although he does not make it in itself, he nevertheless causes it to preside in the idol; just as we are said to exalt and magnify God, not in Himself, but in ourselves; in the Psalm: "Magnify the Lord with me" etc. Both therefore shall be punished: Sirach 14: "Every corruptible work shall fail in the end, and he who works it shall go with it"; and 27: "The offense shall be crushed together with the offender."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For this reason, namely because they are hateful to God, and, that is also, upon the idols of the nations, that is, upon the demons presiding in the idols of the gentiles, of which it is said in the Psalm: "All the gods of the nations are demons" etc.; there shall be no regard, namely of clemency: which is against Origen, who said that Christ would suffer for the demons in the air at the end, and that thus they would be saved; against which it is said here and in Sirach 39: "There are spirits who were created for vengeance, and in their fury they have confirmed their torments." Because etc.: and deservedly, because creatures of God, that is, made by God, such as gold and silver: whence Hosea 2: "I multiplied silver and gold for them" etc.; were made into an object of hatred, namely of the irascible power, so that men might hate God, like the demons, concerning whom in the Psalm: "The pride of those who hate you ascends always." And into a temptation of the souls of men, that is, of the concupiscible power, so that men might freely subject themselves to whatever powers according to the will or suggestion of their gods. And into a snare, that is, a deception of the rational power, and a mousetrap is called an instrument by which mice are caught: for the feet, namely the interior ones, that is, of the soul, not the exterior ones, namely of the body: of the foolish, that is, of the unbelieving: Job 18: "His snare is hidden in the ground"; likewise Jeremiah 5: "Wicked men are found among my people, lying in wait like fowlers, setting snares and traps to catch men."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the beginning etc. I said well that the creatures of God etc.: for the beginning of fornication, namely spiritual fornication, which consists in withdrawing from God, is etc.; whence the Gloss: "The worst kind of fornication is that by which the soul withdraws from God and fornicates with idols"; whence Jeremiah 3: "She committed adultery with wood and stone." Such are destroyed or ruined by God, according to that word of the Psalm: "You have destroyed all who fornicate from you." For the beginning, I say, of fornication, the aforesaid, is the seeking out of idols.
But to the contrary: Ecclesiasticus 10: "The beginning of all sin is pride."
I respond: He does not speak here of fornication which consists in any withdrawal whatsoever from God, as occurs in any mortal sin, but of that by which one withdraws from God by a complete withdrawal, namely even to the subversion of faith, which is the foundation of the entire spiritual edifice; Hebrews 11: "Faith is the substance of things hoped for" etc.; likewise 1 Corinthians 3: "No one can lay another foundation" etc.
And the devising of them is the corruption of life, namely with respect to morals: Romans 1: "For which reason God delivered them over to the desires of their heart, to uncleanness"; in the Psalm: "Give them according to their works and according to the wickedness of their devices."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, he detests idols on account of the novelty and manner of their invention.
For they were not. Here the third reason for the detestation of those idols is touched upon, namely from the novelty and manner of their devising. He touches upon several causes of this devising and worship: first, the curious idleness of men; second, the affection of parents toward deceased children: For with bitter grief; third, the fear of tyrants: Then etc.; fourth, the reverence and honor toward princes: Those whom; fifth, the diligence and solicitude of artisans: Moreover it advanced etc.; sixth, he sets forth a recapitulation of the principal causes: And this was of life.
I have rightly said: The seeking out of idols and the invention etc.; for they were not from the beginning, namely idols, which is evident, because they are not the Creator: whence Jeremiah 10: "The gods who did not make heaven and earth shall perish from the earth"; nor even a creature, because every creature is from God, but idols are not from God, but are a fiction of men: on account of which it is said in 1 Corinthians 8: "An idol is nothing in the world," namely with respect to the divine being which is believed by idolaters to belong to it. Nor shall they exist forever, rather they shall be destroyed, when men are converted to the worship of the one God; Isaiah 19: "The Lord shall ascend upon a light cloud and shall enter Egypt, and the idols of Egypt shall be moved at his presence."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the vanity, that is, the idleness, of men devised these things etc.: Sirach 33: "Idleness has taught much wickedness," namely to the idle, who were unwilling to labor to seek the one true God and to worship Him worthily; upon the earth, for in heaven no such error ever existed. And therefore, namely because they did not always exist, a swift end for them was found, namely among the wise. For they were quickly abandoned by the children of Israel in the time of Moses and by the Christian people in the time of Christ or of the new law; Jeremiah 10: "Every craftsman is confounded by his graven image: their works are vain and worthy of ridicule; in the time of their visitation they shall perish."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For a father, grieving with bitter mourning, namely over the death of his son, as David grieved over the death of Absalom, 2 Kings 18, or over the death of the child whom he first had from Bathsheba, 2 Kings 12, of a son swiftly snatched from him, that is, seized by the violence of death, made an image: The Gloss: "Men fashioned for themselves images of their deceased friends, in the contemplation of which they found some consolation." And him who then, namely recently, had died as a man, whose property it is to be mortal, according to that passage of 2 Kings 14: "We all die" etc.; now, that is, a little later, which is all the more inexcusable, he began to worship as God: The Gloss: "And advancing further, through love of the deceased they began to cultivate their memory." And he established among his servants, who obeyed him out of fear, not reason, sacred rites, namely offerings of incense and praises, and sacrifices, namely the immolation of animals. Moreover, the first to do this, as Isidore says on that passage of Luke 11: "By Beelzebub, the prince of demons" etc., was Ninus, king of the Assyrians, who made an image of his dead father Belus, which he honored with such great veneration that he even spared criminals who fled to it for refuge: on account of which unlearned men began to worship the statue of Belus as God and to multiply statues. Of whom some called that idol Bel, some Baal, some Baalim, some Beelzebub.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Then with the passage of time, that is, a delay of time, as the wicked custom grew strong, which ought rather to be uprooted than maintained, because length of time does not diminish sin, but rather increases it: this error, namely, of worshipping idols, as though it were a law, that is, under a precept, was observed: Jeremiah 10: "The laws of the peoples are vain"; likewise Isaiah 10: "Woe to those who enact wicked laws"! And by the command of tyrants, that is, of wicked rulers, figments were worshipped: whence Antiochus compelled the Jews to the worship of the nations, 1 Maccabees 1; and Nebuchadnezzar forced them to adore his statue, Daniel 3.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Those whom men could not honor openly, that is, in their presence, on this account, namely, because they were far away, from afar, namely, from a distant place, their likeness having been brought, namely, in a painting, a visible image, namely, a sculpted image, I say, of the king whom they wished to honor, they made, namely, bestowing divine honor upon men. Cicero: "Moreover, the life of men and common custom undertook to raise to the heavens by fame and goodwill men who excelled in benefits." So that him, namely, the king, who was absent, that is, he was away, yet still living, they might worship as though present through their devotion. The Gloss: "On account of the foolishness and depravity of men, who lived a rustic life without any ruler, they exalted the king himself and the whole nation with the highest praises, so that they even called them gods either for their distinguished virtue, or for their benefits, or out of flattery." Those whom etc. The text is to be construed thus: Men made a visible image which they wished to honor, their likeness having been brought from afar: those whom they could not honor openly, that is, in person, on this account, supply, because they were far away: they made, I say, so that him who was absent, etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Moreover, it advanced to the worship of these, namely, of idols, worship, and, that is, even, those who were ignorant, that is, the ignorant and unlearned, the extraordinary, that is, the greatest, diligence of the craftsman: of the craftsman, I say, diligently and elaborately fashioning the idol and adorning it, according to that passage in Jeremiah 10: "He adorned it with silver and gold"; likewise Isaiah 44: "He made the image of a man, like a beautiful man dwelling in a house."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For he, the craftsman, wishing to please him who engaged him, that is, hired him, namely, to make an idol; this is a wicked pleasing, of which it is said in the Psalm: "God has scattered the bones of those who please men"; likewise Galatians 1: "If I were pleasing men, I would not be a servant of Christ." He labored with his art, so that the likeness, that is, the image, he might fashion more finely, that is, in the best manner he could: Isaiah 44: "The ironsmith has wrought with a file"; Baruch 6: "As for a maiden who loves ornaments, so having received gold they are fashioned."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the multitude of men, namely of the foolish; Ecclesiastes 1: "The number of fools is infinite"; led astray, namely from the truth, by the appearance of the work, that is, by its beauty; Proverbs, last chapter: "Grace is deceitful, and beauty is vain"; Daniel 13: "Beauty has deceived you"; him who before a time, supply: a short time, had been honored as a man, namely with the honor of dulia; they now esteemed as a God, honoring him with the honor of latria.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And this was the deception of human life, that is, the cause of deception, a cause, I say, that is twofold, as it were a twofold gate of death, namely love and fear, according to the Gloss on that verse of the Psalm: "Set on fire and dug up," etc. For because to their affection, namely their own in the honoring of friends, or to kings, in the veneration of the powerful: the Gloss: "Thus through peoples and regions," namely out of flattery, or out of fear, "various sacred rites were taken up, while men desire to be pleasing to their princes"; serving, that is, devotedly serving, men, against that passage of 1 Corinthians 7: "Do not become slaves of men." The incommunicable name: the Gloss: "of God almighty," because namely the form from which that name God was imposed is incommunicable to creatures, yet communicable to the divine persons: they imposed upon stones and wood, against that precept, Exodus 20: "You shall not take the name of your God in vain."
But to the contrary: Exodus 7: "Behold, I have made you a god to Pharaoh"; likewise in the Psalm: "I said: you are gods," etc.: therefore the name of God is communicable to creatures.
It must be said that God is spoken of in three ways: by nature, by adoption, by appellation. In the first way it is incommunicable; in the second and third ways it is not.
But to the contrary: Because the divine name was communicated to Christ as man: whence Philippians 2: "He gave him the name which is above every name."
But it must be said that it was not communicated to one not having it before, but otherwise than before, because this name belongs to the person, not to the nature, namely the human nature, but nevertheless to one having a human nature.
To that which is objected: He gave him the name, etc.; it must be said that giving is taken there for manifestation. Or: he gave it to him in the human nature, who previously had it in the divine.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fourth, he detests idols on account of the twofold effect of human corruption.
And it was not enough. Here is touched upon the last cause for the detestation of idols, taken from the effect of human corruption: and first is touched upon in idolaters the blinding of the mind; second, the corruption of works: For either sons; third, the reasonableness of the blinding and corruption: And all things; fourth, the cause of both: For of unspeakable things.
He says therefore: And it was not enough for them to have erred: The Gloss: "With false religion they subjected themselves to all vices"; to have erred, I say, namely concerning the knowledge of God, that is, faith; above in the thirteenth chapter: "Vain are all men in whom there is not the knowledge of God." But living also in a great war of ignorance, that is, of unbelief, war, through which unbelief, namely, they wage war against God: whence Job 24: "They were rebels against the light." So many, namely as to number, and so great, as to intensity, or as to the quantity of duration, evils, as to deformity: so many, I say, and so great evils, in which, namely, they live, they call peace, according to that passage in Job 30: "And they counted it a delight to be under thorns"; Jeremiah 6: "Saying: Peace, peace: and there was no peace"; the Gloss: "Under the reign of the devil, subjected to diverse vices, they could not have true peace."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For either etc. Here he enumerates the evils by which they were corrupted in deed: first, the evil specially committed against God; second, specially committed against themselves and against the neighbor: Neither life.
He says therefore: For either sacrificing their own children, according to that passage of the Psalm: "And they sacrificed their sons and their daughters to demons": Ezekiel 16: "Is your fornication a small thing? You have sacrificed my children and given them up, consecrating them to those," because, as the Gloss says, "in the rites of Saturn, on account of hatred of Jupiter, without regard for piety they sacrificed their little ones." Or performing obscure sacrifices, obscure, that is, nocturnal, as was done, according to the Gloss, "in the rites of Egyptian Isis and Ceres, which rites were celebrated with the brandishing of burning torches." Or keeping vigils full of madness, for in the rites of Bacchus and Cybele, mother of the gods, "after the example of the gods, who being sated at the festival spent the whole night in revelries, they themselves reveled," as the Gloss says. Against this it is said in the Psalm: "Blessed is the man whose hope is the name of the Lord, and who has not regarded vanities and false madnesses."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Neither do they keep life, namely their own life, pure, because "God gave them up to uncleanness," Romans 1. Nor do they any longer keep their marriages pure, against which Hebrews 13: "Marriage is honorable, and the bed undefiled"; any longer do they keep etc.; because, as the Gloss says, "they thought to please their gods through lust and uncleanness," and the more wicked anyone was, the more he thought he pleased his god. But also one kills another through envy, namely in his own person, as Cain killed Abel, Genesis 4; and the Jews killed Christ, Matthew 27. Or the adulterer grieves, namely in the person joined to him: he says grieves, because the violation of the marriage bed is a great cause of sorrow; whence also according to the civil laws the husband was given license to kill the adulterer and adulteress found in the very act of adultery.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And all things, namely vices, are mixed together: whence Hosea 4: "Cursing and lying and murder and theft and adultery have overflowed."
Blood. Here he touches first upon certain spiritual sins; second, upon certain carnal sins: Of souls etc. In the first, first certain evils of deed; second, certain evils of the heart: Corruption; third, certain evils of speech: And perjury. He touches upon four evils of deed, namely wounding, when he says: Blood; slaying, when he says: Murder; theft, when he says: Theft; fraud, when he says: And deceit.
Rightly I said: And all things are mixed together, namely blood, by mutual wounding; whence Isaiah 1: "Your hands are full of blood"; likewise Hosea 4: "Blood has touched blood." Murder: whence Micah 7: "A man hunts his brother to death." Theft, Isaiah 1: "Your princes are faithless, companions of thieves"; in the Psalm: "If you saw a thief, you ran with him." And deceit, that is, guile: "For guile is when one thing is done, and another is pretended or feigned."
Corruption. Here he touches upon the sins of the heart, namely of the concupiscible power; in the Psalm: "They are corrupt and have become abominable" etc. And unfaithfulness, namely of the rational power; whence Jeremiah 7: "Faith has perished and has been taken from their mouth." Disturbance, namely of the irascible power; whence Isaiah 57: "There is no peace for the wicked, says the Lord." These are the three evils of the heart.
Then he touches upon three evils of speech, saying: And perjury, namely either assertory, as occurs in false testimonies, or promissory, as in false promises, against which Leviticus 19 says: "You shall not swear falsely." Uproar, namely in contentions and discords; whence Isaiah 3: "The youth shall rise up tumultuously against the elder."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And forgetfulness of the good things of God, that is, ingratitude, because they do not praise God for his benefits; whence Luke 17: "There was none found who returned to give glory to God" etc.; in the Psalm: "I am forgotten as one dead from the heart." These are the three evils of speech: the first against God and neighbor; the second against the neighbor; the third against God, namely by omission.
The defilement of souls etc. Here he touches upon carnal sins, first, sins of interior lust; second, of unnatural intercourse, at: The changing of birth etc.; third, of bigamy: The inconstancy of marriages etc.; fourth, of adultery: The disorder etc.; fifth, of fornication: And immodesty etc.
He says therefore: The defilement of souls, namely through interior lust; whence Matthew 5: "He has already committed adultery in his heart"; Jeremiah 4: "Wash your heart from wickedness, O Jerusalem" etc.; Titus 1: "Both their mind and conscience are defiled." The changing of birth, that is, of nature or of natural use; Romans 1: "Their women changed the natural use" etc. The inconstancy of marriages, namely taking and repudiating wives at will, when nevertheless they ought to be "two in one flesh," Genesis 2; likewise Matthew 19: "What God has joined together, let not man separate." The disorder of unchastity, that is, of adultery, against the order of matrimony, against which Exodus 20: "You shall not commit adultery." And immodesty, that is, of fornication, against which Romans 13: "Not in debauchery and immodesty."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Of unspeakable things etc. Here it is shown that idolatry is the cause of this corruption: and first he shows how idolatry is the cause of all evils in idolaters; second, on account of what, namely on account of the hope of impunity: For while they trust etc.; third, he shows that this very thing is for them the cause of punishment: Both etc.; fourth, he shows what that punishment is, namely the fall and headlong rush into other sins: For not etc.
Of unspeakable things etc. Thus I have said that idolaters commit so many and such great evils; for of unspeakable idols, that is, of abominable ones, that is, of those unworthy of being named, according to that saying of the Psalm: "Nor will I be mindful of their names upon my lips." Of unspeakable, I say, idols, the worship is the cause of all evil, namely through the blinding of the intellect and the subversion of the will; and the beginning, namely through the inception of the work; and the end, through its completion, just as faith and the worship of God is the cause of all good, as the Apostle proves in Hebrews 11, where he says: "Faith is the substance of things hoped for."
But to the contrary: Ecclesiasticus 10: "The beginning of all sin is pride"; likewise 1 Timothy 6: "The root of all evils is covetousness"; therefore it is wrongly said here that the beginning of all evils is infidelity.
It must be said that it is not unfitting for there to be many beginnings of evils according to different respects, just as of one thing there are four causes, namely efficient, material, etc., and yet only one in each genus, because on the part of the rational power there is unbelief, on the part of the concupiscible power there is covetousness, on the part of the irascible power there is pride.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For either while they rejoice, they are mad: The Gloss: "In feasts and games," and this with respect to the evil in affection: they are mad, he says, because irrational joy is madness, like the laughter of the frenzied: Hosea 9: "Madness in the house of his God." Or indeed they prophesy falsehoods, namely by prophesying false things, and this with respect to the evil of thought: 3 Kings, last chapter: "I will be a lying spirit in the mouth of all the prophets." Or they live unjustly, and this with respect to the evil of conduct: Ecclesiastes 7: "The impious man lives a long time in his wickedness." Or they commit perjury, or forswear themselves, and this with respect to the sin of speech: quickly, that is, easily, on account of their evil habit: on account of which Ecclesiasticus 23: "Let not your mouth become accustomed to swearing, for there are many falls therein."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For while they trust in idols, which are without soul, as regards life: swearing wickedly, namely on the part of the thing by which they swear, because by an idol, and on the part of the thing for which they swear, because it is false, against that saying of Jeremiah 4: "You shall swear: The Lord lives, in truth and in judgment and in justice." They do not expect to be harmed, that is, they do not fear.
But how do they not fear, since they believe them to be true gods?
It must be said that although they worship them as gods, they nevertheless do not think omnipotence to be in them; or they do not believe that they punish the sins of men. And in truth they cannot harm them, on account of which Jeremiah 10: "Do not fear them," namely the idols, "for they can do neither evil nor good"; but nevertheless they will be punished by God for the sin of perjury.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whence follows: Both things therefore will come upon them, namely the evil of guilt, because they are permitted to swear wickedly, and the evil of punishment, because they will be punished for this: they will come upon them, I say, deservedly, namely according to their merits: Apocalypse, last chapter: "He who is filthy, let him be filthy still." Because they thought wrongly of God by attending to idols, that is, by attributing divine worship to idols, while they swear by an idol. And they swore unjustly by an idol, despising justice, namely by swearing what is unlawful or what is false, and thus they err or sin in a twofold way, namely, because they swear by what they ought not, and because they swear that which they ought not: Exodus 23: "You shall not swear by the name of foreign gods."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For not, as if to say: and truly they sin by swearing thus: for not of those who swear, namely in this way, is the virtue, that is, a virtuous or meritorious work; but the punishment of those who sin, that is, the sin itself, which is also the punishment of preceding sins and guilt in itself. It always walks about, namely from bad to worse, in the transgression of the just, that is, of just things, namely of God's commandments; Gregory: "For a sin which is not washed away through penance, by its own weight soon drags one to another": for in the Psalm: "Let their way be darkness and slippery" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, it treats of the commendation of the true God.
But you, our God etc. After he showed the error of idolaters and the detestation of idols, here he adds the commendation of the true God. He shows the true God to be commendable, first from his own goodness: second, from the remuneration of those believing in him: For if we have sinned etc.; third, from the vileness of idols: But also the potter: fourth, from the reproach of idolaters: For all.
God is commended first from his own goodness.
But you etc., as if to say: such are idols; but, in place of "however"; you, our God: God, I say, by creation, according to that of Genesis 1: "In the beginning God created"; likewise by governance and preservation: according to Damascene, God is called theos apo tou theein, that is, to dispose or to govern. The first effect is of power, the second of wisdom, the third of goodness. Our, namely by appropriation of worship, because only "God is known in Judah," as is said in the Psalm. Sweet, namely to the affections, according to that of the Psalm: "O taste and see, that the Lord is sweet"; above in chapter twelve: "O how good and how sweet is your spirit in us"! sweet, I say: the Gloss: "Of inestimable charity"; Gregory: "O inestimable love of charity, to redeem a servant, you delivered up the Son"! And you are true, namely to the contemplating intellect; the Gloss: "Because he neither deceives nor is deceived"; likewise Romans 3: "But God is truthful, and every man a liar"; both of the aforesaid, however, refer to the good; and patient, namely by overlooking the evils of fault, namely with regard to the wicked: whence the Gloss: "Patient, that is, long enduring sinners"; Joel 2: "Patient and ready to relent concerning malice"; in the Psalm: "God is a just judge, strong and patient." And disposing all things in mercy, with regard to all, namely remitting all evils of punishment: in the Psalm: "His mercies are over all his works"; Matthew 5: "And he makes his sun to rise upon the good and the bad."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, he is commended from the remuneration of those believing in him.
For indeed etc. Here he is shown to be commendable from the remuneration of believers: and first he shows that those sinning are subject to God. Second, that those not sinning are acceptable to God: And if we have not sinned etc. Third, he shows what the reason for this is, namely the knowledge and worship of God: For to know you. Fourth, he shows who are worthy of such a benefit: For not into error. Fifth, who are unworthy: Lovers of evil things.
For indeed if etc., as if to say: and truly you are such: for indeed if we have sinned, namely by mortal sin, and especially by the sin of unbelief, which is called sin par excellence: whence John 16: "He will convict the world of sin"; and he speaks specifically of this here. If we have sinned, I say, we are yours, that is, established in your power and governance: Gloss: "We cannot escape, because we are your creature"; whence in the Psalm: "If I ascend into heaven, you are there; if I descend into hell, you are present"; likewise Deuteronomy 32: "There is none who can deliver from my hand." Knowing your greatness, greatness, I say, not of mass, but of power, containing all things and able to destroy all things: whence in the Psalm: "Great is God and great is his power." And if we have not sinned, namely by mortal sin, which is sin absolutely speaking, and especially the sin of unbelief, which is sin par excellence. For we cannot be free from venial sin, or if we can, yet not for long: whence 1 John 1: "If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us." If we have not sinned, I say: we know, namely through faith, that we are accounted with you: Gloss: "With whom the number of good works is known or preserved"; in the Psalm: "I shall count them, and they shall be multiplied beyond the sand." And not only numbered, but also inscribed by name: Luke 10: "Rejoice that your names are written in heaven." Now the good are said to be accounted as beloved and elect: and they can well be counted, because they are few, according to that of Matthew 20: "Many are called, but few are chosen." The wicked, however, are not counted by God, just as no one counts rejected coin: for they themselves are rejected coin, according to that of Jeremiah 6: "Call them rejected silver"; likewise, because they are infinite in number, according to that of Ecclesiastes 1: "The number of fools is infinite." This, however, is not from any inability of God who counts, but rather from their unworthiness. For the sinner is unworthy of the bread he eats, as Augustine says: likewise below in the same book: "His life is viler than mud"; but no one would count mud.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the last knowledge, namely concerning glorious knowledge, I shall say one word. It is said of it in the book of Wisdom: "To know you is supreme justice"; it follows: "and is the root of immortality." This knowledge is initiated in those who contemplate, perpetuated in those who sleep, and consummated in those who rise again.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For to know etc. I have rightly said: if we have not sinned, and especially with the sin of unbelief, because we are accounted with you: for to know you, namely through formed faith, is consummate justice, that is, the perfection of justice in the present life; and this is to be understood causally, so that the sense is: to know you through faith is consummate justice, that is, the cause of consummate justice: for faith justifies, whence Romans 5: "Being justified therefore by faith" etc.: likewise there, chapter 4: "Abraham believed God, and it was reputed to him unto justice"; and to know, namely through formed faith, your justice and your power, Warfare, namely of goodness, and power, of might: or: power, that is, Christ, who is "the power and wisdom of God", 1 Corinthians 1; is the root of immortality, that is, the principle and cause of eternal beatitude in the future: whence John 17: "This is eternal life, that they may know you, the only true God" etc.
The root, that is, of the spiritual tree, that is, of the life of the just person, who is like "a tree planted near running waters" etc.: the root is faith, as is said here. The foot, humility, just as conversely the foot of the ungodly is pride, according to that passage of the Psalm: "Let not the foot of pride come to me". The trunk, rising up on high, is hope: Colossians 3: "Seek the things that are above". The interior moisture and verdure of this tree is the grace of interior devotion: Job 8: "Can the rush be green without moisture"? The directing heat is the virtue of charity: Luke 12: "I have come to cast fire upon the earth" etc. Exterior irrigation, spiritual teaching: whence Wisdom says in Ecclesiasticus 24: "I will water the garden of my plantings".
The branches, the multiplication of good works: Ezekiel 36: "Mountains of Israel, spread forth your branches". The flowers, the manners of virtuous conduct: whence Song of Songs 2: "The flowers have appeared in our land". The leaves, the words of discreet speech, according to that passage of the Psalm: "And his leaf shall not fall off". The fruit, the reward of eternal recompense: above, chapter 3: "Glorious is the fruit of good labors".”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Not for etc. I have well said: because we are accounted with you, we, and not others, namely idolaters: not for into error, namely of idolatry, which is the chief error, did lead us, namely as it did others, concerning whom above in the fourteenth chapter: "Moreover, the exquisite diligence of the craftsman promoted even those who were ignorant to the worship of these things"; of men, namely those fabricating idols, etc., the invention of evil art, that is, of art leading to evil through the gods that are fashioned by it. The art itself, however, is good in itself, but the abuse is evil: for every knowledge is of the genus of goods, namely with respect to the habit itself, since it is from God: Ecclesiasticus 1: "All wisdom is from the Lord God." And it should be known that he touches upon two things, inducing, that is, provoking to idolatry, namely the diligence of art, when he says: the invention of evil art, and the beauty of the idol, when he adds: nor the shadow of a painting, that is, not even a painting overshadowing the appearance of wood: Ecclesiasticus 38: "His constant practice varies the painting"; the labor, namely of the craftsman, without fruit, namely of usefulness: above in the third chapter: "Their hope is vain, and their labors without fruit"; an effigy, that is, an image, carved with various colors, distinguishing the parts of the sculpture: above in the thirteenth chapter: "Making its color red with paint."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whose appearance to the senseless one, that is, to the unbeliever, gives desire, namely by occasioning incitement to evil: Ecclesiasticus 34: "Vain hope and falsehood to the senseless man." And he loves the effigy of a dead image without a soul: he loves, I say, the effigy, that is, the figure, worshiping it as God, of a dead image, that is, one lacking the act of life, and this is a lack by way of negation, not of privation; without a soul, that is, lacking the power of giving life. "For the soul is the act of a natural, organic body having the potency of life," as is found in the second book of On the Soul.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Of evils etc., and deservedly, he did not lead us, because lovers of evil things, namely of idols and of sins arising from idols, are worthy of death, namely eternal and temporal: Romans 1: "Those who do such things are worthy of death." Who have hope in such things, namely idols, namely by invoking their help: Isaiah 42: "Let those who trust in a graven image be confounded with confusion"; and who make them, namely by fabricating gods of this kind: in the Psalm: "Let those who make them become like them"; and who love them, namely by affection, having devotion to idols: above in the same chapter: "He loves the effigy of a dead image," etc.; and who worship them, by effect, adoring outwardly: in the Psalm: "Let all who adore graven images be confounded"; Deuteronomy 5: "You shall not adore foreign gods nor worship them."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Third, God is commended from the vileness of idols in two ways.
But also the potter. Here it is shown that the true God is commendable from the vileness of idols: this vileness he shows first from the vileness of the material; second, from the vileness of the craftsman: And with labor.
And that, namely the vileness of the craftsman, he shows there, first from the fragility of his condition: second, from the vanity of the motivating intention: But his care is: third, from ignorance of the Creator: For he is ashes: fourth, from the error of his way of life: But they also esteemed: fifth, from a comparison of iniquity: For this one knows etc.
But also the potter: thus I have said that lovers of evil things are worthy of death, namely those who worship idols or who make them: but also the potter, that is, the maker of earthen vessels, supply: is of their number: the potter, I say, laboriously pressing soft earth: Ecclesiasticus 38: "The potter sitting at his work and turning the wheel with his feet," who is always set in anxiety on account of his work. He fashions each vessel for our uses: "for in a great house there are not only vessels of gold and silver, but also of wood and of earth," Second Timothy two. And from the same clay he fashions those which are clean for uses, honorable and clean: and likewise those which are contrary to these, as are those which are assigned to unclean uses: whence in the same place: "Some unto honor, some unto dishonor"; Romans nine: "Has not the potter power over the clay, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honor, and another unto dishonor"? But what the use of these vessels may be, namely clean or unclean, the potter is the judge, as their superior and maker, not the vessels themselves: in the same place: "Does the clay say to the potter: Why have you made me thus"?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And with vain labor, that is, fruitless; Jeremiah 51: "Their works are vain and worthy of derision"; he fashions a god from the same clay: a similar thing is said in Isaiah 44 concerning wooden idols, that part is burned for human uses, and part is worshipped as a god. That potter, namely, who a little before had been made from earth, through earthly birth: Genesis 2: "God formed man from the slime of the earth"; and after a little while, namely, of time: Job 14: "The days of man are short"; likewise: "Living for a brief time"; he returns, by the desert of his sins, namely into death: above, chapter 1: "The ungodly summoned it with hands and words", after death and through death: whence he was taken, that is, into the earth, from which he had been taken as regards the body, according to that passage in Genesis 3: "Until you return to the earth from which you were taken"; Ecclesiastes 3: "All things that were made from the earth shall equally return to the earth". Summoned to repay the debt of the soul, which, namely, the soul, he had, namely, as a debt, something borrowed, so that he might return it with interest: not something given, as that rich man to whom it was said in Luke 12: "Fool, this night they demand your soul from you"; Matthew 18: "Seizing him, he choked him, saying: Pay what you owe", namely, the debt of the soul.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But he has a care, although, namely, his labor is vain, not because he is going to labor, and in vain, about which he ought rather to be concerned; he is going to labor even wickedly, according to that passage in Jeremiah 9: "They labored to act wickedly". Nor because his life is short, although all the more he ought to be concerned to spend it usefully; James 4: "What is your life? It is a vapor appearing for a little while". But he strives with goldsmiths and silversmiths, endeavoring to make the beauty and subtlety of his work resemble theirs; and he also imitates the workers in bronze. It should be noted that he calls goldsmiths the artisans who make gods from gold; silversmiths, those from silver; workers in bronze, those from bronze: Isaiah 46: "You bring forth silver from the purse and weigh gold in the balance, hiring an artisan to make a god". And he prefers glory, supply: vain glory, to his labor or to the brevity of life. "Glory is widespread fame with praise"; glory, that is, by glorifying himself in this, in which one ought not to glory. Because superfluous things, that is, useless things, namely, idols, he fashions, namely, he makes them from clay material; Hosea 4: "I will change their glory into shame"; likewise, Philippians 3: "Whose glory is in their confusion, who mind earthly things".”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For ashes is etc., as if to say: thus he glories: for, in place of "but"; or thus: thus he glories, which nevertheless he ought not to do; for, in place of "because": ashes, that is, a vile thing, is, as it were, ashes is his heart, that is, his thought, because in ash and dust, from which he fashions his god, he sets his heart: Ecclesiasticus 10, "Why does earth and ashes pride itself?" And superfluous earth, that is, useless, is his hope, that is, his desire and affection, because namely he places it in an earthen idol: above, chapter three: "Empty is their hope"; for such an idol is empty earth and nothing, concerning which Jeremiah 4: "I looked upon the earth, and behold, it was empty and nothing." And his life, that is, his conduct, is viler than clay, because namely he occupies his life in making and worshipping a clay idol; in the Psalm: "Like the clay of the streets I shall destroy them." Now the clay of guilt is viler than the clay of nature: whence the Gloss: "His life is more sordid than filth"; 2 Peter 2: "The sow that was washed returns to wallowing in the mire."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because he did not know, namely with that ignorance concerning which 1 Corinthians 14: "He who is ignorant shall be ignored"; him who formed him, that is, God, who made him from the clay of the earth as regards the body: in the Psalm: "He himself knew our formation"; and who breathed into him a soul, according to that passage in Genesis 2: "He breathed into his face the breath of life"; and he loves, namely more than God, the things he works, namely idols. And who breathed into him a vital spirit, one must supply again: he did not know, and he now speaks of the bodily spirit, when he says: vital spirit: Isaiah 57: "The spirit shall go forth from my face, and breaths I shall make"; in the Psalm: "His spirit shall go forth and he shall return to his earth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But they also reckoned: thus I said, that they did not know God, but rather they reckoned, namely the fabricators of idols, our life, namely natural life, to be a game, namely of wantonness, like those concerning whom Exodus 32: "The people sat down to eat and drink"; Job 21: "He holds the timbrel and the harp." To be a game etc., he says this because to make and worship idols seems similar to the play of children, and thus those who make images of clay and adore them. And the conduct of life, namely moral life, ordered, that is, arranged, toward gain, namely of avarice, and not only gain, but unlawful gain, whence he adds: and that one must acquire from everywhere, even from evil, that is, from an unlawful craft or business: against which Ecclesiasticus 5: "Be not anxious for unjust riches. For they shall not profit you in the day of affliction" or of vengeance "and vindication." These are "riches kept to the hurt of their owner."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For he etc., as if to say: and truly those who make idols acquire from evil; for he knows that he, above all others, namely the other makers of idols, offends: he, I say, who from earthly material, which is of lesser worth, fashions fragile vessels on the one hand, and graven images, that is, idols, on the other hand from his material. Whence from the comparison of these he better understands, or can understand, the worthlessness of idols.
But how can he know this, namely that he offends or sins above all others, when he is ignorant of God, as has been said?
It must be said that he knows this or can know it by the habit of the natural law written in his heart. But actually he does not know this, namely because he does not wish to investigate this, although he could; or if he cannot do so fully or easily, this is because he has been blinded by the desert of his unbelief.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fourth, God is commended from the foolishness of idolaters.
For all. Here it is shown that the true God is commendable from the foolishness of idolaters, and first, from the foolishness of idolaters who worship inanimate things, namely statues; second, of those who worship animate things: But also animals.
In the first part, he first shows and rebukes them as foolish, because idols are the cause of many evils to their worshippers; second, because they are also in themselves useless to man: For all idols; third, because they were made by man: For a man; fourth, because they are inferior to man: For better is.
For all etc. I have rightly said that this one, who makes an idol from clay material, knows that he sins beyond all other craftsmen: for all are foolish: Gloss: "Who consider idols to be gods"; for this is great foolishness: Jeremiah 4: "The children are foolish and senseless." Foolish, I say, through a defect of wisdom or faith with respect to the intellect, and unhappy, with respect to the affections; and this on account of the defect of grace, which makes one happy; above, chapter thirteen: "Unhappy are those who called the works of their hands gods." Beyond the measure of their soul, that is, of their nature, they are proud, namely against God, and this by fashioning for themselves idols as gods: Isaiah 16: "We have heard of the pride of Moab, he is exceedingly proud: his pride and his arrogance are greater than his strength." Or: unhappy beyond measure, because with infinite unhappiness, because "their worm shall not die, and their fire shall not be quenched," Isaiah, last chapter. Enemies of your people, namely by persecuting those who believe in God; enemies, I say, with respect to affection, and persecuting in deeds: Esther 14: "It is not enough that they oppress us with the harshest servitude; but attributing the strength of their hands to the power of idols, they wish to change your promises"; and reproaching him, namely in words: in the Psalm: "The reproaches of those who reproached you fell upon me"; just as certain ones from Ephraim and Manasseh mocked the messengers of Hezekiah, who wished to call them back to the worship of God, as is clear from 2 Chronicles 30.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because all the idols etc., as if to say: this whole thing is evil, because all etc. Or thus: I have rightly said that foolish and unhappy, proud beyond the measure of their soul etc.: because all the idols of the nations, that is, of the gentiles not reborn through faith, but remaining in the vice of their birth, they esteemed as gods: thus did the Romans, namely by bringing all the idols of the subjugated gentiles to Rome and worshipping and guarding them: which, namely the idols, have neither sight of the eyes for seeing, according to that verse of the Psalm: "They have eyes, and they shall not see"; nor ears for hearing, according to that passage in the same place: "They have ears, and they shall not hear." Nor nostrils for perceiving breath: in the same place: "They have nostrils, and they shall not smell." Nor fingers of hands for handling, that is, for touching anything: whence in the same place: "They have hands, and they shall not feel." But also their feet are sluggish, that is, immovable, for walking, in the same place: "They have feet, and they shall not walk." Therefore it is said in Baruch 6: "The beasts are better than they, which can flee under a roof and be of use to themselves."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For a man, whose it is not to give sense and motion, made them, he did not beget them from his own substance, but fashioned them from extrinsic matter; and he who has borrowed a spirit, namely one to be returned to God, whenever it shall please Him; Ecclesiastes, last chapter: "And the spirit shall return to God, who gave it." he fashioned them, that is, he made them from clay. For no one etc., as if to say: and truly they are thus without sense and motion; for no man will be able to fashion a god like himself, like, namely with a likeness of equality, by which a man is like another man, although like with a likeness of some exterior representation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For since he is mortal, having a mortal life, a dead thing, that is, one lacking life, he fashions with wicked hands: in the Psalm: "In whose hands are iniquities." But mortal is better than dead, according to that saying of Ecclesiastes 9: "A living dog is better than a dead lion." And I said well that no one can make something like himself etc.: for he himself is better, namely man, than those whom he worships. But God ought to be the highest good of man, according to Augustine, since He is his beatitude. Because he indeed lived, at some time, namely man, when he was mortal, for what does not live is not mortal: but they never, namely the false gods. But rightly living things are preferred to non-living things, sentient things to non-sentient things, according to Augustine.
But an objection is raised: Because above in the same book it is said: "His life is viler than clay."
It must be said that above he speaks of the moral life, here of the natural life.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But even animals etc. Here is shown the reproof of those who worship animate things: and first they are shown to be miserable in themselves: second, somewhat excusable in comparison to the preceding: Senseless etc.: third, simply inexcusable: But neither in appearance etc. And there they are shown to be inexcusable, first by the fact that they worship irrational creatures: second, because they have fled from the true God: They have fled etc.
But even animals: The Gloss: "Not only the likeness of men," but also the image of animals, as the Egyptians worshipped Isis in the form of a cow, the Babylonians a dragon, as is clear from Daniel fourteen: most wretched, they worship; Proverbs fourteen: "Sin makes peoples miserable." They are indeed miserable all the impious and sinners, but more wretched all the unbelievers, but most wretched of all those who worship idols. On account of this I rightly said: But they worship even the most wretched animals; in the Psalm: "They exchanged their glory for the likeness of a calf that eats hay." For senseless things: for, in place of but: senseless things, that is, statues, compared to these, namely animals, are worse than them, because, according to Augustine, that which lives is better than that which does not live, and that which senses is better than that which does not sense; whence the Gloss: "In truth, living things are better than dead things, and sensible things than insensible things, and rational things than irrational things. But it was fitting that those who were ignorant of the Creator should not know the distinction among creatures."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But not even by sight etc. Thus it has been said that idols neither hear nor see anything nor know anything: and not only do they see nothing, but not even by sight can any of these animals discern good things. But not even by sight, as if to say: not only in absence through imagination, but not even in presence through sense: any of these animals, which they worship, can discern good things, that is, know good things by beholding them: and this is to be understood of honorable goods, which are goods simply, such as virtues and the like: not of useful goods, or pleasurable goods, which are goods in a qualified sense. But they have fled etc., as if to say: thus the most wretched worship animals: but, in place of however, they have fled etc. Or: but, that is, certainly by worshipping animals, they have fled from the praise of God and his blessing, as if to say: they neither praised God himself nor blessed him: praise for his goodness in himself, and blessing for his beneficence toward us. Against which two things it is said in the Psalm: "Give thanks to the Lord, for he is good," namely in himself, "for his mercy endures forever," that is, because the beneficence of his mercy extends itself to all: and he says they have fled, not only not praising and not blessing inwardly in heart, but not even confessing with the mouth, against which it is said in Romans 10: "With the heart one believes unto justice, but with the mouth confession is made unto salvation."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On account of these things, namely because most wretched people worshipped idols, or on account of the sins of idolatry, and things similar to these, that is, on account of other sins similar to the aforesaid idolatry, they suffered torments deservedly: Ephesians 5: "On account of these things the wrath of God comes upon the sons of unbelief"; Deuteronomy 25: "According to the measure of the sin, so also shall be the manner of the stripes." For there ought not to be the disgrace of fault without the beauty of justice or of vengeance, according to Augustine. And by a multitude of beasts, namely devastating their land, such as flies, locusts, and frogs and the like; they were destroyed, that is, grievously afflicted, and perhaps some of them were killed: above, chapter 12: "Through the things they worshipped, you gave them the utmost torments"; Deuteronomy 32: "I will send the teeth of beasts upon them."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Instead of which torments, that is, in place of which torments, as if by contrast: you dealt well with your people, namely the Israelite people, who were his "peculiar people," as is found in Deuteronomy 7. To whom, that is, to which people, you gave the desire of their delight, that is, a desirable thing longed for: "for desire, if it is fulfilled, delights the soul," as is found in Proverbs 13. A new flavor, into food of a new flavor, preparing for them quail as food, and that bird, namely the quail, is called ortygometra, as they say from the land of Ortygia, in which it was first seen and from there brought away; or preparing foods etc.: and then according to some the plural is used here for the singular, when it says: preparing foods for them, the quail, that is, the quail, according to that verse of the Psalm: "They asked, and the quail came" etc.: Exodus 16: "It came to pass in the evening, and the quail coming up covered the camp"; likewise Numbers 11: "But a wind going out from the Lord, snatching up quails, brought them across the sea" etc. But it is not necessary that the plural be used for the singular, because it can be glossed thus: foods, that is, in place of foods.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“So that those indeed, namely the children of Israel, desiring food, namely the meats of Egypt, Exodus 16, on account of those things, namely the quails, which were shown to them, namely to be desired, and sent, namely to be eaten, even from a necessary desire, that is, a very pressing one, might be turned away, that is, so that they would no longer desire the meats of Egypt and a return to Egypt: in the Psalm: "They desired with desire in the desert"; likewise Numbers 11: "The people burned with desire for meats," although it is said in Sirach 18: "Go not after your desires, and turn away from your own will." But these, namely the children of Israel, having been made destitute in a short time, that is, for a little time, because their want lasted but briefly: for God quickly came to their aid, according to that verse of Isaiah 65: "Before they cry out, I will hear them"; destitute, that is, lacking food: had tasted a new food, that is, an unusual food, or of unusual birds.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For it was fitting etc., as if to say: and rightly was it so done; for it was fitting, that is, it was opportune, for them, namely the Egyptians, without any excuse indeed, namely of the fault for which they were being punished: Romans 1: "So that they are without excuse"; likewise ibid. 2: "Therefore you are without excuse, O man": that destruction should come upon them, namely the torment of death-dealing punishment from the supreme Judge for their crushing; Job 18: "Let confidence be torn from his tent, and let destruction tread upon him like a king"; likewise Proverbs 29: "For a man who despises the one who corrects him with a stiff neck, sudden destruction shall come upon him." For them, I say the Egyptians, exercising tyranny, that is, cruel dominion over the children of Israel, oppressing them with harsh labors, as is clear from Exodus 1 and 5, and by drowning their boys in the river, as is clear from Exodus 1. But for these, namely the Israelites, only to show, supply: it was fitting: in what manner their enemies would be destroyed, so that thus, having seen their punishment, they might be corrected, according to that passage of Proverbs 19: "When the pestilent man is scourged, the fool will become wiser"; likewise ibid. 21: "When the pestilent man is punished, the little one will become wiser."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He says therefore: For indeed, as if to say: I have rightly said: but for these only to show etc.; for indeed, that is, because: when upon them, namely the children of Israel, there came the fierce wrath of beasts, namely from the displeasure of the heavenly Judge, whom they had offended by murmuring against him, as is clear from Numbers 21: "The Lord sent fiery serpents among the people." By the bites of perverse serpents, because they were effective for harming, they were being destroyed, namely some of them: whence 1 Corinthians 10: "Do not murmur, as some of them murmured and perished by serpents."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But not forever, that is, without end, such that eternal punishment would be joined to temporal punishment, as in Herod, Acts 12. Your wrath, that is, the effect of your wrath, not the emotion of your mind, according to that saying: "I am the Lord, and I am not angered"; remained, namely in the children of Israel: Habakkuk 3: "When you are angered, you will remember mercy." But for correction, not for condemnation, in a short time, that is, for a brief period, they were troubled, that is, afflicted, namely outwardly, and from that troubled, inwardly: Isaiah 54: "For a brief moment I forsook you, etc., and in a moment of indignation I hid my face briefly from you, and in everlasting mercy I have had compassion on you"; Jeremiah 30: "But I will not make a complete end of you, but I will chastise you in judgment, lest you seem innocent to yourself." Having a sign of salvation; The Gloss: "The bronze serpent set up as a sign, by the sight of which they were healed," as is clear from Numbers 21. For a remembrance of the commandment of your law, namely, to be kept, according to that saying of the Psalm: "And they are mindful of his commandments, to do them," just as a negligent boy is whipped so that he may repeat and fix his lesson.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And I rightly said: having a sign, not a cause: for he who turned, namely either inwardly through repentance toward God, or outwardly toward the bronze serpent to look upon it: not through that which was seen, namely by the bodily eye, was healed, that is, not through the bronze serpent; but through you, the Savior of all, signified through the said serpent: John 3: "As Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, so must the Son of Man be lifted up"; just as also a dead man could not be raised by the staff of Elisha, which did not obey him in this, but through him personally, as is found in 4 Kings 4.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this moreover, namely in the affliction of the Egyptians and the easy liberation of the Israelites, you showed, that is, you willed to show, although they did not see; whence they cannot complain except about the blindness of their own eyes, just as if the shining sun were shown to someone with bleary eyes and he did not see it, according to Augustine: to our enemies, namely the Egyptians; for the wicked are enemies of the just, namely actively, not passively, because they hate the just, although they are loved by them; you showed, I say, that you are, namely the only one, who delivers from all evil: in the Psalm: "Many are the tribulations of the just, and from all these the Lord will deliver them."
On the contrary: Why are many not delivered from evil?
It must be said that this is to be understood thus: he delivers all who are delivered, just as that passage in John 1, "He enlightens every man," etc., namely, who is enlightened.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For those, namely the Egyptians who did not worship you, the bites of locusts and flies killed: of locusts, Exodus 10, and of flies, Exodus 8: killed, literally some of them, although it is not read there expressly. And no healing was found for their life, namely of the Egyptians, as for the children of Israel from the serpents; in the Psalm: "There is no health in my flesh because of your wrath," etc.; Jeremiah 30: "Your wound is incurable, your affliction is grievous." Because they were worthy, namely as their merits demanded, by such things, namely by vile animals, to be destroyed: whence Augustine on John: "The Lord could have subdued the proud people of Pharaoh with bears and lions, but he sent flies and the vilest creatures, so that their pride might be tamed." For the same reason men are also afflicted by fleas: whence Augustine: "Why do you puff yourself up, human pride? Resist the fleas, so that you may sleep."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But your sons, that is, the Israelites; Exodus 4: "Israel is my firstborn" — sons, I say, your sons, by faith, according to that passage in John 1: "He gave them power to become sons of God, to those who believe in his name"; nor did the teeth of venomous serpents overcome them, that is, of fiery serpents; Deuteronomy 8: "Your guide was in the great and terrible wilderness, in which there were serpents burning with their breath, and scorpions, and the dipsas snake." He speaks here of the good, who are sons of God, not of the wicked.
I said well: but your sons, that is, the Israelites, the teeth of venomous serpents, that is, the bites of fiery serpents, did not overcome them: for your mercy, that is, the effect of your mercy, coming upon them, healed them: in the Psalm: "If I said: My foot has slipped: your mercy, O Lord, helped me"; Jeremiah 33: "I will close up your scar and give you health"; "for he wounds and he heals," Job 5.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For in the remembrance of your words, that is, through the recompense of your commandments, they were being destroyed, some of them, namely, and they were quickly healed, or saved, namely others who were penitent, having seen the death or punishment of others; according to that verse of the Psalm: "When he slew them," that is, some of them, "they sought him," that is, others who were penitent. Or: the same ones were being destroyed, that is, severely punished, and were quickly healed, lest falling into deep, that is, profound, falling, that is, falling inwardly, forgetfulness, namely of despair; namely on account of the delay of help and remedy; they might not be able to make use of your help, that is, of your liberating grace, they, I say, having been made unworthy of your mercy on account of despair; Proverbs 18: "The wicked man, when he has come into the depth of sins, shows contempt"; in the Psalm: "They forgot God, who saved them," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, they did not know the Physician. Since the disease had come from a crime against sovereignty, the punishment had to be very heavy. No one, then, could heal, unless he were God and man: He alone would have the power of satisfaction, in whom there would be no concupiscence, and who would have been born, not through the law of nature, but from the Virgin. That He indeed was the Physician, He demonstrated through examples of virtue, documents of truth, incitements to love, and saving remedies. This Physician heals all things: For indeed, neither herb nor application cured them, but Your all-healing Word, O Lord! the Word who was incarnate and crucified and who suffered, and later sent the Holy Spirit into the depths of our hearts.
This, then, is the medicine: the grace of the Holy Spirit. Philosophy is unable to grasp such a Physician and such a grace. Why should you glory, you whose science is unable to know your disease, or its cause, or its Physician, or its remedy?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is no salvation except through wisdom. For "indeed, neither herb nor application cured them, but Your all-healing word, O Lord!" But wisdom is neither disclosed nor obtained except through faith.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And I said rightly: in the remembrance of your words: for indeed, meaning "because"; neither herb, that is, a potion made from herbs, which is taken internally by drinking; nor poultice, that is, a plaster, which is applied externally upon the place of pain; healed them, namely from the bites of serpents. But your word, O Lord, that is, the command concerning the making and gazing upon the bronze serpent, Numbers 21; which, namely the word, heals all things, namely those things which are healed: whence here there is an accommodated distribution: in the Psalm: "He sent his word and healed them." Or: the Word, uncreated, that is, the Son, of whom John 1 says: "In the beginning was the Word"; this Word, according to the Gloss, "heals bodies and saves souls from spiritual beasts"; Matthew 4: "Healing every disease and every infirmity."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For you are, O Lord. I said rightly that your word heals all things: for you are, O Lord, namely the Creator of all things, who have power over life and death, that is, of giving life and putting to death, according to that passage of 1 Kings 2: "The Lord kills and makes alive," etc.; likewise Ecclesiasticus 11: "Death and life are from God."
But to the contrary: Because it is said above in chapter 1: "God did not make death."
I respond: it must be said that although God is not the meritorious or efficient cause of death, nevertheless with respect to the privation itself he has power over death, because, although he is not the cause of evils, he nevertheless has power over evils, because from them he knows how to and is able to bring forth good.
To that which is objected, that death is not from God: it must be said that in death there is a privation of life, which is nothing, and therefore does not have an efficient cause, but rather a deficient one: likewise, there is therein a penal affliction, which is something and is from God, who justly inflicts it upon sinners by the merit of their sins.
And you lead down to the gates of death, that is, to the final extremity of life, and you lead back, namely by healing, as is evident in the case of Hezekiah, Isaiah 38.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But man etc., as if to say: thus you can put to death and give life: but, for "however": man can kill himself but not give life, and this is what it says: but man, namely the sinner, called man from the earth: indeed kills, that is, certainly, through the malice of sin, his own soul, on account of which it is said in the Psalm: "He who loves iniquity hates his own soul"; for he is a murderer of himself: for sin is a two-edged sword, for it kills both body and soul: Sirach twenty-one: "All iniquity is like a two-edged broadsword." And when the spirit has departed, namely from the body through death, it will not return, namely to the body in the present age; Job ten: "Before I go, and return not, to the land of darkness" etc.; likewise 2 Kings fourteen: "We all die, and like waters we flow down upon the earth, which do not return."
But to the contrary: Because it is said in the Psalm: "His spirit shall go forth, and he shall return to his earth."
It must be said that this is understood of the return to the earth of one's natural habitation and body by nature: but that Psalm passage [speaks] of the return to one's earth according to the justice of retribution, and this by divine power.
Nor will he call back, namely man, the soul, separated from the body, which has been received, in its place, namely in glory or in punishment; Sirach eleven: "Wherever the tree falls, whether to the south or to the north, there it shall be."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But your hand, that is, your power, both in the present and in the future, both in life and in death: it is impossible to escape: Job ten: "There is no one who can deliver from your hand"; therefore it is said in the Psalm: "Where shall I go from your spirit, and where shall I flee from your face?" "For the hand of the Lord is not shortened," nay rather it is most far-reaching and contains all things, according to that Psalm: "In your hand, O Lord, are all the ends of the earth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For denying etc. I rightly said: it is impossible to escape your hand: for the ungodly who denied knowing you, that is, the Egyptians, namely Pharaoh with his servants: denying, I say, by word, whence Exodus 5: "I know not the Lord, and I will not let Israel go"; and in deed those of whom it is said in Titus 1: "They profess to know God, but in their deeds they deny him." By the strength of your arm, that is, by your mighty power: Exodus 15: "Who is like you among the mighty, O Lord?" etc.; they were scourged: Exodus 6: "I will bring them out from the prison of the Egyptians with an outstretched arm"; Exodus 15: "Your right hand has struck the enemy"; with strange waters: and, in place of "that is": with hailstones, for hail is like frozen water, and rains, which are like flowing waters, they suffered persecution; Exodus 9: "Pharaoh seeing that the rain and hail had ceased"; and by fire, that is, falling simultaneously, they were consumed: Exodus 9: "Hail and fire mingled together were carried"; likewise in the Psalm: "He turned their rains into hail, burning fire in their land."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“I rightly said: by fire with hailstones: for what was wonderful: namely, that a contrary was not destroyed by its contrary, although it is written in Sirach 3: "Water extinguishes a burning fire"; whence it follows: In water, which extinguishes all things, namely things set ablaze, fire prevailed the more, that is, it acted more powerfully together with water. For the whole world is an avenger, that is, an instrument of vengeance: an avenger, I say, the whole world of the just, that is, avenging the just: whence above in chapter 5: "The whole world shall fight for him against the senseless." Through the aforesaid text he indicates that the punishment of the Egyptians was carried out not according to the order of nature, but according to the order of divine justice avenging the Israelites against the Egyptians, who had oppressed them, Exodus 1; the Gloss: "It is not surprising that hail and fire are carried mingled together, because all things consent to the will of the Creator."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For at a certain time, as if to say: it did not always act uniformly: for, in place of "but": at a certain time the fire was made gentle, namely until the animals of those who feared the words of Moses were called back or brought in from the fields: Exodus nine: "Send and gather your livestock and all that you have in the fields," or field: and afterwards: "He who feared the word of the Lord among the servants of Pharaoh made his servants and livestock flee into the houses." It was made gentle, I say, lest the animals that had been sent to the ungodly be burned, that is, the livestock divinely given to them. Nor only for this reason, but also, so that they themselves, seeing the aforesaid interruption, might know, namely through it, that by the judgment of God, not by natural occurrence, they suffer persecution. Likewise, according to the Gloss, "that they might recognize that every creature is prepared to avenge the injury done to the Creator"; in the Psalm: "The Lord shall be known executing judgments," who, as Bernard says, is not known when suffering injuries. And it should be noted that the Lord punished the Sodomites by fire, Genesis nineteen, without gentleness, and this because there were no good people among them; but the Egyptians by fire with gentleness, because the children of Israel were in Egypt, who were good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And at a certain time, namely when the animals had been called back, in water beyond its power, its natural power, namely, because by a miracle, the fire blazed forth on every side, namely throughout the whole land of Egypt, so as to destroy the wicked nation of the land, that is, the Egyptians, who were an earthly nation, not a heavenly one; against which, First Corinthians fifteen: "As we have borne the image of the earthly, let us bear the image of the heavenly."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Instead of which evils, that is, in place of which evils, contrariwise, with the food of Angels, that is, manna, which was prepared by the Angels, you nourished your people, etc.; whence in the Psalm: "Man ate the bread of Angels"; or because it prefigured the food of Angels, namely "the living bread that came down from heaven," John six. You nourished, I say, your people, namely the children of Israel: for with this food he nourished them "until they reached the borders of the promised land," as is found in Exodus sixteen. And ready bread, that is, refreshment, from heaven, namely descending from the airy heaven, according to that verse of the Psalm: "He rained down manna upon them to eat, and gave them the bread of heaven"; you furnished to them without labor.
On the contrary: Because it is said in Numbers eleven: "The people went about and, gathering it, ground it in a mill or crushed it in a mortar, cooking it in a pot and making from it cakes as it were of the taste of bread made with oil."
I respond: without labor of acquiring through agriculture, but not without labor of preparing. We indeed have labor in acquiring and preparing: Genesis 3: "In the sweat of your face."
Having in itself every delight, that is, the effect of every delightful food, producing a similar delight in the one eating: and the sweetness of every taste, that is, every pleasant taste: for it tasted to each person just as he wished, as Gregory says in the sixth book of the Morals.
But against this: It is said in Numbers 11 that it had the taste "as of bread made with oil."
It must be said that by its own nature it had a determined and most sweet taste, namely like the taste "of fine flour with honey"; but by divine grace it had diverse tastes, namely according to the diversity of desires, as the Gloss touches upon on that passage of 1 Corinthians 10: "They all ate the same spiritual food."
But against this: Because if it had the taste desired by anyone, then they would not have desired the meats of Egypt, nor would their soul have been nauseated over the manna as over a most light food, yet the opposite is read in Numbers 21.
It must be said, according to the Gloss: The good found the best taste therein, but the wicked were disgusted. Or it must be said that they required in food not only the delight of taste with respect to the palate, but also of color with respect to sight, and of odor with respect to smell. Jerome: Birds are cooked before the rich in their own vapors, so that they may be refreshed by sight and aroma, just as the luxurious are with wine, yet it is said in Proverbs 23: "Do not gaze upon wine when it turns yellow, when it sparkles in the glass," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For your substance, that is, your power of sustaining, and your sweetness, that is, your power of delighting, which you have toward your children, namely sustaining them through the substance of the food and delighting them through the taste of the same food, you showed etc.; in the Psalm: "You prepared in your sweetness for the poor, O God"; you showed, I say, by bestowing upon them the aforesaid food that sustains and delights. And serving, namely the aforesaid food or bread, the will of each one, namely of those eating, it was turned to what each one wished, that is, to whatever taste: for it had, as was said, one determined taste by nature, but various tastes by divine grace.
Mystically, by the manna Christ was fittingly signified under the Sacrament of the altar, first because he himself is the bread of angels, namely of priests, according to that passage of Malachi 2: "He is the angel of the Lord of hosts."
Second, because it is prepared from heaven, that is, because it is confected by heavenly power; John 6: "I am the living bread, who came down from heaven"; in the Psalm: "You prepared their food, for thus is its preparation."
Third, because those eating from it according to their desire, that is, their devotion, are refreshed, according to that word of the Psalm: "You have granted him the desire of his soul"; likewise in the Psalm: "He brought them their desire, they were not defrauded of their desire."
Fourth, because with it the dew of grace descends and is given, just as dew also descended with the manna, as is found in Numbers eleven. And therefore this bread is called eucharist: eucharist is interpreted as good grace.
Fifth, because, just as the manna appeared like "white coriander seed," so also Christ is received under a white cloud: Apocalypse fourteen: "Behold, a white cloud, and upon the cloud one sitting like the Son of Man."
Sixth, because it was gathered on six days and not on the Sabbath, so Christ is received under the Sacrament in the present, but in the future Sabbath, of which Isaiah sixty-six says: "There shall be Sabbath after Sabbath," He will be seen openly: First Corinthians thirteen: "But then face to face"; likewise First John three: "We shall see Him as He is." Seventh, because they were nourished by that food in the desert for forty years until the entrance into the promised land, so until the end of the world in the desert of this world the faithful of the Church are nourished, according to that word of Matthew twenty-eight: "Behold, I am with you all days even to the consummation of the age."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He says therefore: But snow etc. It has been said that fire prevailed more in water: but snow and ice, that is, hail, sustained the force of fire, that is, heat, which is its quality of active power. And they did not melt, that is, they did not liquefy; whence Exodus nine: "The Lord rained hail upon the land of Egypt; and hail and fire were carried mingled together"; so that they might know, namely the Israelites, that the fruits of the enemies, that is, of the Egyptians, burning fire was destroying, namely by heat: flashing in hail and rain, namely by splendor. "The flax and the barley were damaged, because the barley was green and the flax was already putting forth pods," Exodus nine.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But this again etc. It should be known that the word this can be of the ablative case, so that it is expounded thus: this, for this reason; or of the nominative, so that it is read thus: but this again, supply: was done, so that the just might be nourished, namely the children of Israel. The fire also forgot its own power, namely by not destroying the fruits of the land of the just, as is clear from Exodus nine, where it is read that "only in the land of Goshen, where the children of Israel were, the hail did not fall." So also the fire forgot the force of its power when it did not harm the three just youths in the furnace, as is clear from Daniel three.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For your creature, namely whatsoever creature, serving you its maker, that is, your will, by which you made all things, according to that verse of the Psalm: "Whatsoever he willed, he did": grows fierce, that is, is vehemently moved and stirred up, unto torment, of punishment, against the unjust, that is, your enemies. And is made milder, that is, harmless or innocuous, to do good for those who trust in you, that is, for the just: for creatures obey those who obey God, as is clear in Joshua 10, where it is read how the sun stood still at the command of Joshua, and they rebel against those who rebel: whence above in chapter five: "The whole world shall fight for him against the senseless."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For this reason, namely because the creature serves the Creator, and then, namely when the children of Israel were fed with manna in the desert, into all things, that is, into the flavor of all desired things, was transfigured, namely that creature itself, namely the manna: your grace, the nurse of all, that is, your gratuitous good will, so that it is understood of uncreated grace: Baruch 4: "You have saddened your nurse, Jerusalem"; they served, that is, they obeyed: The Gloss: "Let sinners be confounded here, because while all other creatures serve their Maker, they themselves resist. Whence they are scourged by the concord of all creatures." They served, I say, according to the will, to be fulfilled, namely, of those who were desired by you, namely, beloved with a special love, as the children of Israel: Deuteronomy 7: "The Lord your God has chosen you, that you might be his peculiar people from among all the peoples that are upon the earth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That your sons might know, namely the Israelites, according to that passage of Exodus 4: "Israel is my firstborn"; Isaiah 1: "I have nourished sons"; whom you loved, O Lord, namely with eternal and temporal love: Malachi 1: "I have loved you, says the Lord." Might know, I say, that it is not the fruits of birth, that is, not natural fruits, born from the earth, according to that passage of Genesis 1: "Let the earth bring forth," etc., that nourish men, namely insofar as they are men, that is, according to that by which they differ from beasts, namely according to the rational power or part of the soul. But your word, that is, the created word, that is, your commandment: Matthew 4: "Man does not live by bread alone," etc. Or: the Word, uncreated, that is, the Son, of whom John 17 says: "Your word is truth"; ibid. 14: "I am the way and the truth and the life"; preserves those who have believed in you: Deuteronomy 8: "The Lord gave you manna as food, which neither you nor your fathers knew, to show you that man does not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceeds from the mouth of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For that which could not be destroyed by fire, namely the manna, because it hardened at fire, so that small cakes were made from it, as is clear from Numbers 11; when warmed by even a faint ray of the sun, immediately melted away, that is, it liquefied, as is clear from Exodus 16. Hence it was necessary that it be gathered in the morning.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That it might be known to all, namely through this sign, that one must rise before the sun, that is, before the rising of the sun, for your blessing, supply: to be obtained, that is, to receive and gather the manna, lest after the rising of the sun it be liquefied by the heat of the sun: thus, to obtain the blessing of grace, one must rise before the sun by keeping vigil in the morning, according to that passage of Proverbs 8: "Those who watch for me in the morning will find me"; in the Psalm: "In the morning I will stand before you and I will see," etc. And at the rising of the light, that is, as soon as the light rises, or toward the east, where the light rises, to adore you, namely for the reception of the manna itself: toward the east, I say, because, as Damascene says, everything that is better must be attributed to God; whence, because the east is the nobler part of the sky, therefore one must worship toward the east, according to that passage of the Psalm: "He who ascends above the heaven of heavens toward the east."
It should be noted, moreover, that in the fact that the manna melted at the rising of the sun, it was signified, according to the Gloss, that at the rising of Christ the old sacrament would cease, because "Christ is the end of the Law," Romans 10.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the hope of the ungrateful etc. Thus I said that it wasted away by the heat of the sun, and this as a sign of this, because the hope of the ungrateful will waste away etc. Or thus: I rightly said that it is necessary to worship at the rising of the light etc. for the reception of the aforesaid benefit, and this to avoid ingratitude, which is greatly harmful. For the hope of the ungrateful, namely of any impious person, or specifically "of the Jewish people," according to the Gloss, like winter ice: The Gloss: "Constricted by the cold of unbelief," according to that passage of Ecclesiasticus forty-three: "The cold north wind has blown, and ice has frozen from the water"; will waste away, that is, will be liquefied, that is, will be dissolved by the heat of the sun of justice on the day of judgment, whether particular or universal: in the Psalm: "As wax melts before the face of fire, so let sinners perish before the face of God." It will waste away, I say, as regards the punishment of loss, namely by losing all goods, whatsoever he had or hoped for, namely the goods of grace and glory; and will perish utterly, that is, will perish in a twofold manner, that is, will suffer torment in body and soul, and this as regards the punishment of sense. It will perish utterly, I say, like superfluous water, that is, useless water, which is poured out or cast upon the ground: so also the ungrateful one, as useless, will be cast into hell, according to that passage of Matthew twenty-five: "Cast the unprofitable servant into the outer darkness." The hope of the ungrateful therefore will waste away and perish utterly etc.; whence above in chapter five: "The hope of the impious is like down which is carried away by the wind"; likewise Bernard: "Ingratitude is a scorching wind, drying up the fountain of piety, the dew of mercy, the streams of grace."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, on the punishment of loss.
For great are etc. After he treated the punishment of sense, here he treats the punishment of loss, that is, the withdrawal of light: and first is touched upon the equity of the punishment of the Egyptians, namely because they were punished according to their merits: second, the irremediability, namely because without interruption: For neither that which contained: third, the universality, because all, there: But those who the powerless: fourth, the singularity, because they alone, namely the Egyptians: For every.
The equity, moreover, is shown from the meritorious cause of their sins, first of sin against God: second, against neighbor: For while persuaded: third, against themselves: And while they think.
For great are etc. Well have I said that the Egyptians were punished, but the Israelites consoled: for great are your judgments, O Lord: Gloss: "By which you govern all creation"; in the Psalm: "Your judgments are a great deep." And your words are unspeakable, namely by which you instruct the rational creature; unspeakable, I say, in full: Romans 11: "O the depth of the riches of the wisdom of God" etc. On account of this: Gloss: "Because they refused to believe and understand their Creator," undisciplined souls, that is, incorrigible regarding their sins: Sirach 20: "And a procession into evil for an undisciplined man"; likewise Jeremiah 5: "You have struck them, and they have not grieved; you have crushed them, and they have refused to receive discipline"; in the Psalm: "But you have hated discipline"; they went astray, from the way of truth: above in chapter five: "Therefore we have strayed from the way of truth," concerning which John 14: "I am the way and the truth and the life": the way in example, the truth in promise, the life in reward.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For when etc. I have rightly said that they erred; for when the wicked, namely the Egyptians, called wicked on account of the wicked oppression of the Israelites and the drowning of their infants, Exodus chapter one: were persuaded, that is, believed, that they could dominate the holy nation, that is, the children of Israel, who are called a holy nation, because they were children of the Saints, according to that saying in Tobit chapter two: "We are the children of the Saints"; likewise, because they were sanctified through circumcision, concerning which sanctification is found in Genesis chapter seventeen; thirdly, because they were to be sanctified through their manner of life, according to that saying in Leviticus chapter eleven: "Be holy, because I am holy." Bound in the chains of darkness, namely palpable darkness, which occurred in Egypt, Exodus chapter ten, and of a long night, that is, of a dark period, as if it were night: which time was long, because for three days no one saw his neighbor, as is evident in the same place: fettered, namely by a likeness of effect, because they could not move, as if they were fettered: whence in the same place: "For three days no one moved from the place where he was"; shut up under their roofs, namely of their houses, not daring to go out: fugitives from eternal providence, namely as far as it was in their power, because they thought to impede the liberation of the Israelites foreseen by God. Or: fugitives etc., that is, wishing to escape the providence of God: which could not be, since it is said above in chapter sixteen: "It is impossible to escape your hand." They lay hidden, that is, they thought themselves hidden, according to that saying in Proverbs chapter fourteen: "The wicked shall lie prostrate before the good"; or they were pleased, namely in punishment, who were displeasing in guilt, because through punishment the reordering is accomplished of those who had been disordered through guilt.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And while they thought themselves hidden, namely from God the punisher, although "all things are naked and open to his eyes," Hebrews chapter four. Hidden, I say, in obscure sins, that is, enormous sins, which are chiefly committed in darkness: Ephesians chapter five: "For it is shameful even to speak of what is done by them in secret," because "he who does evil hates the light," John chapter three: on account of this, sins are called "works of darkness," Romans chapter thirteen. By the dark veil of forgetfulness, that is, the gloom of darkness veiling them and casting forgetfulness upon others, while they could not help themselves: they were scattered, namely one from another, fearfully terrified, that is, with horrible fear, namely on account of the darkness. And disturbed with exceeding wonder, namely on account of the unaccustomed novelty of the thing: above, chapter five: "Seeing this, they shall be troubled with terrible fear, and shall be amazed" etc.; Job chapter eighteen: "On his day the last shall be astonished, and horror shall seize the first."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For neither did the cave that held them etc. Here is shown the irremediability of the punishment, first from the place; second from the contrary: And fire; third from artifice: And the magical arts etc.
For neither etc. I have rightly said: trembling horribly etc.: for neither did the cave, which contained them, those namely who had fled there on account of the hail and rain and fire. And note that he uses the singular for the plural, when he says cave, because they had not fled to one cave only, but to many, and they thought to hide in diverse places: was guarding them without fear: The Gloss: "Because horror always accompanies darkness, and the less one discerns what things are around him, the more he fears." Since a sound descending, namely into that pit, a sound, I say, either of heavenly thunders or of diabolical illusions, was disturbing, that is, was thoroughly disturbing, them; Job 15: "The sound of terror is always in his ears." And sorrowful figures appearing to them.
But how did they appear in such great darkness?
It can be said that they did not appear to the sense, but to the imagination.
Were furnishing them with dread, because, as the Gloss says, "it could be that demons thrust upon them certain terrible phantasms, which would terrify them unto an increase of their punishments," according to that passage in Job 7: "You will terrify me through dreams, and through visions You will shake me with horror."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And indeed fire etc. Here is shown the irremediability of the punishment, and this from the side of the contrary, namely fire: first, because it did not furnish aid: second, because it rather furnished harm: But it appeared to them.
He says therefore: And indeed no power of fire could furnish them light: whence illumination was failing them from the lower part: and he says: no power, because there are three species of fire, according to the Philosopher, namely light, flame, and ember. Nor of the heavenly bodies, that is, of the stars, the bright flames, that is, the emitted rays, could illuminate that horrendous night: whence it is evident that light was failing them from the upper part, although the stars are placed above to illuminate the night, Genesis 1. And deservedly was light lacking to them, because namely they were rebels against spiritual light: Job 24: "They themselves were rebels against the light," and therefore the sun of justice did not rise for them: whence above in chapter 5: "The sun of understanding did not rise for us, and the light of justice did not shine for us."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But there appeared to them, namely the Egyptians, a sudden fire, namely of heavenly flashes, full of fear, namely on account of the aspect of terrible visions, namely of lightnings: "for the graver the pains, the greater the terrors that are feared." And struck with fear, on account of the vision of imagined evils, of that face which was not seen, that is, of a phantasm not seen outwardly but imagined inwardly, which the devil sent in to terrify them further: they judged the things that were seen to be worse, supply: than they were according to the truth of the matter; Job 18: "Terrors shall frighten him on every side and shall entangle his feet."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And of the magical etc. Here is shown the irremediability from the craft, namely of the magical art; and first is shown the confusion of the magicians: second, the matter of the confusion, namely fear: For those; third, the cause outwardly producing fear: For even if nothing: fourth, the disposition inwardly increasing fear: Frequently etc. And there three things that increase fear are touched upon, of which the first is the remorse of conscience; the second is the disturbance following upon remorse: For always: the third is the distrust of help following upon both: For fear is nothing etc.
And of the magical art, that is, of the magicians themselves, were set forth, namely against the aforesaid evils, derisions, in this, namely, that they attempted to expel these evils and could not; whence they themselves also feared vehemently; Exodus 8: "This is the finger of God." And the glory of wisdom, that is, the glory of the magicians concerning their own wisdom, a rebuke with disgrace, supply: was, that is, the cause of disgraceful correction; Proverbs 11: "Where pride has been, there shall be disgrace"; Jeremiah 9: "Let not the wise man glory in his wisdom."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And rightly did I say that their rebuke was with disgrace to themselves; for those, namely the magicians, who promised, fears, namely interior ones, and disturbances, namely exterior ones, to expel, namely by their magical art, from the languishing soul, namely on account of fear and disturbance: these with derision, inflicted by others, full of fear, in themselves, were languishing. Whence to any one of them could be said that word of Luke 4: "Physician, heal thyself"; Proverbs 25: "Clouds and wind and rains that do not follow, a boastful man who does not fulfill his promises."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For even if nothing from the portents, that is, from appearing phantasms, or from the miracles of Moses, disturbed them, because, namely, they were accustomed to portents, just as Balaam did not fear the speech of the ass, as is clear from Numbers twenty-two. Yet by the passing of animals, namely sudden and violent, namely of bears and lions and the like, and by the hissing of serpents or of serpents, which, namely, they could not see, shaken, namely inwardly, trembling, namely outwardly, they were perishing, namely failing on account of the aforesaid things; Deuteronomy twenty-eight: "The Lord shall give you a trembling heart and failing eyes and a soul consumed with sorrow, and you shall fear night and day." And, that is, even, the air, which no one could by any means escape, namely on account of the necessity of breathing in and breathing out, denying that they could see, on account of the palpable darkness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For frequently they anticipate, namely by thinking and expecting before the event, the worst things, namely punishments to be inflicted for sins: the worst he says, because there are evil things in life, worse things in death, and the worst things after death; or: evils that are inborn, worse evils inflicted by man, but the worst evils inflicted by God; on account of which, Hebrews ten: "It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God." With conscience reproving them, according to that passage of Jeremiah two: "Your own wickedness shall reprove you." For since wickedness is timid, that is, having fear attached to it, because the evil of guilt is always followed by or accompanied by the evil of punishment; whence, just as "perfect love casts out fear," as is said in First John four, so iniquity causes or induces it; in the Psalm: "They trembled with fear where there was no fear"; likewise Leviticus twenty-six: "The sound of a flying leaf shall terrify them"; it gives testimony of condemnation, namely against its own agent; whence, Romans two: "Their conscience bearing witness"; testimony, I say, of condemnation, namely of its agent, that is, it testifies that he is worthy of condemnation; whence, above, chapter five: "We fools," etc.; likewise Genesis forty-two: "We deservedly suffer these things, because we sinned against our brother." Others have: it is given for the condemnation of all. For it always presumes, that is, before they come to pass, it suspects, cruel things, that is, harsh things to befall it, a troubled conscience, namely troubled by sin or by the remorse of sin; whence Cain says, Genesis four: "Everyone who finds me shall kill me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For it is nothing. Note that here a causal predication, not an essential one, is had: for fear is not presumption, but is caused by presumption, that is, by a presumed suspicion of future evil. Whence he describes fear here in two ways: first, by its cause, which is the presumption of future evil; second, by its effect, which is the betrayal or manifestation of the thought of failing help. For fear is nothing but a help of presumption, that is, a presumption or suspicion of future or coming evil aiding toward fearing, and a betrayal of the thought of helps, namely of failing ones, that is, a thought betraying the lack of help both to the one fearing himself and to others, namely those who perceive by his fear that help is failing him. Whence such fear makes one cry out seeking help, as is clear in Peter, who, when he had begun to sink, cried out and said: "Lord, save me," Matthew fourteen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And while from within, namely in the mind, the expectation is less, that is, hope or confidence, because it lacks justice, which makes the just confident and secure, according to that passage of Proverbs twenty-eight: "The just man, confident as a lion, shall be without terror." He thinks the power greater, that is, they reckon the force for harming greater, of its cause, namely the terrible thing, from which the torment presses, that is, it threatens him, because the lack of greater hope and confidence increases the fear that makes one suspect the evil that threatens is greater than it actually is.
Otherwise it seems it can be expounded according to the Gloss from that passage: For it always presumes savage things etc.; as if to say: deservedly wickedness gives testimony of condemnation: for it always presumes savage things, that is, it presumptuously exalts itself to inflict savage things on others: a disturbed conscience, that is, an angered conscience, not a tranquil one; for, in place of "but." For fear is nothing but a help of presumption, that is, a remedy, namely by repressing the movement of this presumption, and a betrayal, that is, a manifestation, of the thought of helps, that is, of a weak thought, which previously exalted itself by presuming that it did not need help. And while from within the expectation is less, that is, less is expected the power of harming of the thing by which one is punished, namely from without: he thinks the power greater, that is, the force for harming him, than it is according to truth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But those etc. Here is shown the generality of punishment, first on the part of time; second, on the part of afflicted persons: Then, if anyone; third, on the part of causes: Or a hissing spirit.
As if to say: thus the magicians were terrified; but those, namely the Egyptians, who the overpowering truly night, that is, a powerful one, because very dark and long and unable to be illuminated by any remedy; and from the lowest depths, namely by the rising of vapors and gross fumes darkening the air; and from the highest places, namely by the failure of the irradiation of the celestial bodies, coming upon them, that is, coming over them, the same sleep, that is, a common one, sleeping, because as one slept, so did another, no better.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Sometimes they were driven by fear of monsters, that is, of monstrous phantasms appearing to them in dreams; Job 7: "You will terrify me through dreams and shake me with horror through visions." Sometimes their souls failed from the passage, that is, as if the departure from the body were imminent, and this while waking, when they had already been roused: because, as the Gloss says, "neither waking nor sleeping could they rest, because they were surrounded by horrifying monsters and visions and excessive terror." For sudden, that is, unexpected, and unhoped for, that is, unforeseen, because quickly and without warning, fear had come upon them, that is, from above, from the divine judgment: Isaiah 47: "Misery shall come upon you suddenly, which you shall not know."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Then, namely besides the aforementioned evils, if anyone of them, namely of the Egyptians, had fallen, namely into a pit or something of this kind, he was kept in a prison, that is, in the place where he had fallen, unable to get out from there, shut in without iron, that is, without iron chains, because all were shackled by the bond of darkness, as is evident above in the same book.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For if anyone was a countryman, that is, a cultivator of the field, or a shepherd, of animals, or a laborer of the works of the field, such as a reaper or a vintager, were overtaken, namely by those darknesses outside his house: he endured an inescapable necessity, namely want and affliction, because no one moved himself for three days from the place where he was, as is evident from Exodus 10.
For by one, that is, a common, chain of darkness, namely of exterior darknesses, all were bound together, that is, bound at once. And not only by the chain of exterior darknesses, but of interior ones, namely of unbelief and sins: whence Proverbs 5: "Each one is bound by the cords of his own sins"; likewise in the Psalm: "The cords of sinners have encompassed me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whether indeed a spirit etc. I have rightly said that they endured necessity, for whether indeed a spirit to itself whistling, that is, "the whistling of a gentle breeze," 3 Kings 19: or among the thick branches of trees the sound of birds, that is, the song, sweet, insofar as it was of itself suited to delight rather than to terrify: or the force of water running down exceedingly, that is, rushing impetuously, as the waters of torrents run.
Or the mighty sound of stones rushing down, that is, falling impetuously from high places, or the unseen course of playing animals, namely, on account of the density of the darkness, animals, namely, gentle ones, such as beasts of burden; or the mighty voice of roaring beasts, that is, of wild animals, or bears, or lions, or the like; or the echo resounding from the highest mountains, that is, the reproduction of the voice of animals due to the reverberation from mountains or rocks; made them faint with fear, namely, all the things mentioned above; whence the Gloss: "On every side the wretches were tormented; for whatever they perceived with their ears, or eyes, or any sense whatsoever, they dreaded as dangerous."
Now it should be noted that the aforesaid chain, morally speaking, signifies the progression and connection of sins, concerning which Isaiah 58: "If you take away the chain from your midst." The hissing spirit signifies the hidden suggestion of the devil; Revelation 16: "I saw coming from the mouth of the dragon and from the mouth of the beast and from the mouth of the false prophet three unclean spirits in the form of frogs." The sweet sound of birds, the delight of thoughts; Zephaniah 2: "The voice of one singing in the window." Running water, consent to the perpetration of sin, against which Sirach 25: "Do not give your water any outlet, not even a small one." The sound of falling stones, the outward operation of sin; Job 14: "A mountain falling crumbles away, and a rock is removed from its place." The course of playing animals, depraved habit; Job 40: "All the beasts of the field play there." The mighty voice of roaring beasts, open boasting about sin committed; against which in the Psalm: "Why do you glory in malice?" The resounding echo, the delightful remembrance of sin; Numbers 11: "We remember the fish that we ate in Egypt."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For all etc. Here is touched upon the singularity of the punishment; and because "opposites placed next to each other shine forth more clearly," first is touched upon the illumination of others; second, the darkening of the Egyptians: But to them alone etc.; third, the merit of the darkening: They therefore.
I have rightly said: the Egyptians were fettered with the bonds of darkness and not others: for the whole world, namely, with the exception of the region of Egypt, with clear "that is, bright," was illuminated with light, namely, of the sun and the heavenly luminaries, although elsewhere there were many sinners in the world; Matthew 5: "He makes His sun to rise upon the good and the bad." And was maintained unhindered, that is, was preserved, with works unimpeded, of the luminaries by the density of darkness; or in another way: with works unimpeded, of other men apart from the Egyptians on account of the lack of light, since elsewhere there was the brightness of light which is required for working; whence John 9: "Work while it is day; for the night comes, when no one can work."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But upon them alone, namely the Egyptians, there was laid, namely by God, a heavy night, because darker than usual and longer: Job thirty-seven: "For we are wrapped in darkness." A night, I say, being an image, that is, an express representation, of the darkness, namely eternal; which namely image of darkness, that is, the prefigured darkness, was going to come upon them, namely in hell: whence Matthew twenty-five: "Cast the unprofitable servant into the outer darkness"; likewise Job ten: "A land of misery and darkness," etc. And because they were suffering such heavy darkness, and not undeservedly: they themselves therefore were to themselves heavier darkness, that is, the cause of heavier darkness, supply: than what they were suffering, that is, of that which was going to come upon them in hell: whence Job thirty-four: "He knows their works, and therefore He will bring night, and they shall be crushed." Or: they themselves were heavier darkness, that is, more dangerous through the blinding of the heart: "for their malice blinded them," above, chapter two; Ephesians five: "You were once darkness"; some books have: heavier than the darkness, namely the exterior darkness, on account of the remorse of conscience.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“With the Egyptians was the densest darkness, but with Your saints was the greatest light. All those who properly followed the Law of Nature, the patriarchs, the prophets, and the philosophers, were the sons of light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But to your holy ones etc. Thus the Egyptians were in darkness; but, in the sense of however; to your holy ones: namely the Israelites, according to that passage of Leviticus 11: "Be holy"; there was the greatest light, because there was exterior bodily light; whence Exodus 10: "Wherever the children of Israel dwelt, there was light"; likewise interior spiritual light; whence the Gloss: "To your holy ones, that is the Israelites, whom faith and purity of conscience illumined"; 1 Thessalonians 5: "You are all children of light"; likewise superior heavenly light; John 1: "There was the true light, which enlightens every man" etc.; likewise Malachi 4: "To you who fear my name, the sun of justice shall arise." And indeed of these, namely the holy ones, the enemies heard the voice, whether of human conversation or of divine praise, namely the Egyptians; but they did not see their form, namely on account of the hindering darkness.
But to the contrary: Because one who is in darkness can see him who is in the light, and not conversely.
It must be said that this is true, unless there be an impediment in his eye, or in the medium itself. But there the impediment was in the eye of those seeing, because they had been struck with a kind of blindness, and in the medium, because the darkness there was dense and palpable.
And because not also, that is even, they themselves, namely the holy ones, had suffered through the same things, "that is, the same plagues," according to the Gloss, they magnified you, namely by praising; Luke 1: "My soul magnifies the Lord"; Ecclesiasticus 43: "Who shall magnify him, as he is from the beginning"?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And those who before had been harmed, namely by Pharaoh oppressing and scourging them, as is clear from Exodus 1. Because they were not harmed, namely by the plagues inflicted by God, they gave thanks to you: Isaiah 51: "Joy and gladness shall be found therein, thanksgiving and the voice of praise." And that there might be a distinction, namely between themselves and the Egyptians; they sought you, O God, or: they prayed to you, O God, according to that verse of the Psalm: "Judge me, O God, and distinguish my cause from an unholy nation," just as Abraham also asked that the just man not be destroyed like the impious: Genesis 18. Or: distinction, namely distance: this was granted to the Israelites when "the Angel, lifting himself up, stood between the camp of the Egyptians and the camp of Israel," as is clear from Exodus 14.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On account of which, namely because they were grateful for the benefit bestowed, praying by offering thanks: they had a burning column of fire, namely by night, as is clear from Exodus 13; as a guide on an unknown way, namely through the desert, and a sun without harm, along the way; a sun, I say, of good lodging, supply: a guide to the end of the journey; you provided; without harm, I say, by day, and this because the column of cloud tempered the heat of the sun, as is clear from the same place and above in chapter 10: "It was for them a covering by day and a light of stars by night," so that they came to a place where they could suitably find lodging and pitch their tents: Isaiah 4: "The Lord will create over every place of Mount Zion, and where he has been invoked, a cloud by day"; and afterward: "and it shall be a shade by day from the heat."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Worthy indeed were those, namely the Egyptians, supply: to lack light, with regard to the privation of sense, and to suffer the prison of darkness, with regard to the privation of movement: who kept them enclosed etc., not permitting them to go out from the land of Egypt; Exodus 5: "I know not the Lord, and I will not let Israel go." Your holy sons, namely the Israelites believing in you: John 1: "He gave them power to become sons of God, to those who believe in his name"; through whom was beginning, namely through the preparation of that people and the reception of the Law, because it had not yet been given: the incorrupt light of the law to be given to the world. It should be noted that the law is sometimes called a light, because it illuminates the intellect: Proverbs 6: "The commandment is a lamp, and the law is a light"; incorrupt, because it purifies or preserves the affections from corruption, according to that verse of the Psalm: "The word of the Lord, tested by fire, proven to the earth, purified seven times."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When they thought, namely the Egyptians, of the just, that is, of the Hebrews, to kill the infants, not only by simple thought, but also progressively toward the deed, as is clear from Exodus 1. And one son, namely Moses, being exposed, namely by his mother, and delivered, namely by the daughter of Pharaoh, as is clear from Exodus 2. For the reproof of them, that is, the punishment of the Egyptians, or: for the leading forth of them, that is, of the Hebrews, that is, so that he might lead them out of Egypt through Moses who had been delivered. You took away a multitude of children, that is, the totality of the firstborn, Exodus 12. And at the same time, that is, simultaneously, them, namely the Egyptian parents of those children, you destroyed in a mighty water, namely by drowning them in the Red Sea, Exodus 14: "Not even one of them survived," and chapter 15: "They sank like lead in the mighty waters."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For that: for, stands for but: night, namely the night on which the firstborn were slain, was known beforehand by our fathers, namely Abraham and others: whence Genesis 15: "Know assuredly that your seed shall be a stranger in a land not its own" etc.; or by the Israelites themselves in Egypt, with Moses foretelling it to them, as is clear from Exodus 12. So that truly, that is, with certainty, knowing in what oaths they trusted, that is, how firm were God's promises; Genesis 22: "By myself I have sworn, says the Lord"; likewise Hebrews 6: "That by two immutable things" etc.; they might be of better courage, namely in awaiting the fulfillment of the oath.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But there was received etc., namely on that night, or according to the Gloss: "the law of the Passover," on that night, as if for a great benefit, by your people, namely the Israelite people, as is clear from Exodus 12, where it is said: "And they did" etc.; the salvation indeed of the just, for by it the Israelites were saved from the destroying Angel, as is clear from Exodus 12; but of the unjust, namely the Egyptians, destruction, that is, slaying by the destroying Angel, in the same place.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For as you struck our adversaries, namely by slaying them on account of their sins, so also urging us on, supply: to better things, namely to faith and the reception of the Law; Deuteronomy 32: "As an eagle stirring up to fly" etc., you magnified us, namely by magnificently delivering us from that destruction.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For in secret, namely on account of fear of the Egyptians, according to the Gloss; they sacrificed, namely by immolating the Passover, as is clear from Exodus 12. The just children, namely the sons, of the good, namely of the Israelites, together with their fathers themselves, on account of which they merited to be freed, the firstborn of the Egyptians having been slain. And the law of justice, namely the one given, in the same place, concerning the immolation of the Passover, which was just, because it signified the justification to be accomplished through the death of Christ; likewise it was called a law, because it bound to its observance for its own time. They disposed in concord, that is, they harmoniously received it and proposed to fulfill it and did fulfill it: whence in the Psalm: "Gather to him his Saints, who order his covenant upon sacrifices." Likewise, that is, with equanimity, good and evil, that is, prosperity and adversity, the just about to receive, namely themselves: repeat: they disposed, whatever God might wish to inflict: Job 2: "If we have received good things from the hand of the Lord, why then should we not endure evil things?" Likewise Luke 16: "You received good things in your life, and Lazarus likewise evil things." Ancestral praises, that is, established and celebrated by the fathers, singing forth, that is, devoutly singing, namely praising God both for evils, namely of punishment, and for goods, namely of grace, or of fortune, or of nature; in the Psalm: "His praise is always in my mouth"; always, that is, not only in prosperity, but also in adversity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Thus I said, that ancestral praises were being sung forth; but there resounded, namely loudly throughout the whole land of Egypt, the discordant voice of the enemies, that is, the voice of the Egyptians, horrible to hear: Exodus 12: "There arose a great cry in Egypt"; and there was heard a lamentable wailing, that is, weeping with lamentation: for there was a cry of the voice and weeping of the eyes and wailing of the hands: a lamentable, I say, wailing of those mourning children, that is, concerning the children or for the children, whom they were mourning, according to that of Jeremiah 6: "Make for yourself the mourning of an only child, a bitter lamentation."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But with a similar punishment, that is, by the loss of his firstborn, the servant was afflicted together with the master, in one house: and the common man suffered similar things to the king, namely in the whole kingdom of Egypt, Exodus 12: "He struck every firstborn in the land of Egypt, from the firstborn of Pharaoh, who sat on his throne, even to the firstborn of the captive woman, who was in the prison"; Isaiah 24: "As the people, so also the priest: and as the servant, so his master."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Similarly therefore all, that is, the greater and the lesser and the middling, namely King Pharaoh and the other lords and their servants: had innumerable dead, all the firstborn, dead, I say, by one manner of death, namely by one kind, because it was a divine plague. And he well says: all, because "there was no house in which there did not lie one dead," as is found in Exodus twelve. For neither etc. And I well said: innumerable: for neither for burying, namely the dead, did the living suffice: Jeremiah sixteen: "The small and the great shall die, and they shall not be buried" etc. Since in one moment, namely in one hour of the night, that which was the more noble offspring of theirs, that is, the whole body of the firstborn, who surpass the remaining sons in dignity: was destroyed, that is, slain by the destroying Angel, as is clear from Exodus twelve.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For concerning all, as if to say: and rightly were the firstborn thus slain: for concerning all, that is, on account of all the plagues previously inflicted, not believing, namely the Egyptians, on account of the benefits, namely those done to them in the relaxation of each of the plagues, as is clear from Exodus seven, eight, nine, ten, and twelve. Then when first there was the destruction of the firstborn, namely in the last plague, they pledged that they were the people of God, that is, they promised to carry out God's command, which was concerning the release of the children of Israel: for then they released them, as is clear from Exodus twelve. Or: they pledged etc., that is, they promised to believe in the God of the Hebrews, if they were delivered: Isaiah twenty-six: "Lord, in distress they sought you"; in the Psalm: "When he slew them, they sought him."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The day of the repose of sabbath, the time of the intermediate repose, and the time of final repose: The time of the intermediate repose occurred when the prophets ceased to write. "For when peaceful stillness compassed everything and the night in its swift course was half spent, Your all-powerful word from heaven's royal throne bounded," etc. Then there was the silence of the prophets, intermediate between the first and the last. There was also repose, for at that time the whole world was in complete peace: for then, and twelve years hence, the Temple of Peace in Rome was closed until the coming of Christ. That temple was always open in times of war and closed in times of peace. The doors even became rusted. Then also the Emperor commanded that a census be taken of the whole world, and God placed this very thought in the heart of a pagan, in order that the Virgin would travel to Bethlehem, and once there, that she would give birth in the inn. And very often he insisted that such things and others of the same kind were not placed in Scriptures as a result of chance or fortune, but for a very high reason and as a very high mystery, and that anyone who failed to consider them understood nothing. There was also "night in its swift course," for that was the high point of idolatry.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“I well said: Then when first there was the destruction: for, in the sense of because: when quiet silence held all things: silence, namely of the night, which was given for resting, just as the day for working: whence First Thessalonians five: "Those who sleep, sleep at night." And the night in its course had reached its midpoint, that is, when it was the middle of the night: whence Exodus twelve: "And it came to pass in the middle of the night"; and this on account of their lack of foresight.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Allegorically however, the coming of Christ in the flesh is described here, who is called the almighty word of God through eternal generation, according to that passage in John 1: "In the beginning was the Word"; but is said to have come from heaven, from the royal thrones, through the temporal assumption of flesh: in the Psalm: "His going forth is from the highest heaven"; in the silence of midnight, on account of the opportuneness of the time: Galatians 4: "But when the fullness of time came," etc. The first silence was under the law of nature, and this on account of ignorance of infirmity; the second, under the law of Moses, and this on account of despair of healing; the third, under the law of grace, and this on account of the attainment of salvation. As a fierce warrior etc., namely on account of the vanquishing of demons; Luke 11: "When a strong man armed guards his court, all things that he possesses are in peace; but if a stronger one than he comes upon him," etc. Into the midst of the land of destruction, that is, into the midst of the world, on account of the position of the land in which he was born: in the Psalm: "He has worked salvation in the midst of the earth." He carried the dominion of God with him, on account of his Divinity co-omnipotent with the Father: John 1: "And the Word was God," namely, of whom he afterwards adds: "And the Word was made flesh"; likewise the last chapter of Matthew: "All power is given to me," etc. He filled all things with death, on account of the consummation of all things in his death, according to that passage in John 19: "It is consummated." Standing on earth, he touched heaven, because his soul in the state of a wayfarer had continual enjoyment of God; John 3: "No one has ascended into heaven, except he who descended from heaven, the Son of Man, who is in heaven."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The day of the repose of sabbath, the time of the intermediate repose, and the time of final repose: The time of the intermediate repose occurred when the prophets ceased to write. "For when peaceful stillness compassed everything and the night in its swift course was half spent, Your all-powerful word from heaven's royal throne bounded," etc. Then there was the silence of the prophets, intermediate between the first and the last. There was also repose, for at that time the whole world was in complete peace: for then, and twelve years hence, the Temple of Peace in Rome was closed until the coming of Christ. That temple was always open in times of war and closed in times of peace. The doors even became rusted. Then also the Emperor commanded that a census be taken of the whole world, and God placed this very thought in the heart of a pagan, in order that the Virgin would travel to Bethlehem, and once there, that she would give birth in the inn. And very often he insisted that such things and others of the same kind were not placed in Scriptures as a result of chance or fortune, but for a very high reason and as a very high mystery, and that anyone who failed to consider them understood nothing. There was also "night in its swift course," for that was the high point of idolatry.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Your almighty word, O Lord, that is, your ordinance and command: whence Hebrews 4: "The word of God is living and effective," namely because of the impossibility of resisting, leaping from heaven, leaping he says because of the swiftness, from heaven, that is, in the destroying Angel, from the royal thrones, namely yours, that is, from the company of Angels, among whom you reign and sit enthroned: in the Psalm: "You who sit upon the Cherubim." Or: leaping from heaven, namely sent by you, who sit enthroned in heaven: "For they are all ministering spirits sent forth for service on behalf of those who shall inherit salvation," Hebrews 1: came harsh, that is, implacable, a warrior, namely against the Egyptians because of their obstinacy; into the midst of the land of destruction, that is, into the land of Egypt to be destroyed by the death of the firstborn; he leaped forth, namely suddenly.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A sharp sword, that is, about to fulfill the office of a sharp sword through the slaying of the firstborn: Hebrews 4: "The word of God is living and effective and more piercing than any two-edged sword"; likewise Ephesians 6: "The sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God." A sword, therefore, sharp, because of the ready facility for harming, bearing your unfeigned command, that is, not a fictitious but a true command and power of yours, because "there is no power except from God," Romans 13. Unfeigned therefore command is said because of the divine authority, and standing, because of the immovability of the sentence. He filled all things with death, that is, the whole land of Egypt with dead firstborn. "For there was no house in which there did not lie one dead," as is clear from Exodus 12. He says therefore: He filled all things etc., because of the universality of this plague.
But an objection is raised, because in Exodus 12 it is said: "I will pass through the land of Egypt that night and I will strike every firstborn" etc.; therefore he was not standing: therefore it is poorly said here: And standing etc.
But it must be said that this standing, of which he speaks here, is opposed to departure from the land of Egypt, not to movement through the land itself. Whence he means to say that the Angel, executing the word or command given concerning the slaying of the firstborn, stood in the land of Egypt, so that outside Egypt no one was slain: but he does not mean to say that he did not pass through Egypt from house to house.
And he reached even to heaven while standing on earth, that is, he seemed to reach, namely because of the inevitability, namely lest anyone should escape; in the Psalm: "If I ascend into heaven, you are there." Or: even to heaven etc., he says this because that Angel was contemplating in heaven while ministering on earth, according to that saying of Bede: "They run within God, wherever they are sent"; likewise Matthew 18: "Their Angels," namely the ministers, "in heaven always behold," through contemplation, "the face of my Father" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Then immediately, namely at the very hour of the slaying, visions of evil dreams, that is, of terrible ones, disturbed them, namely those sleeping: the Gloss: "So that neither to those awake nor to those sleeping was rest given." And unforeseen fears, that is, sudden ones, came upon them, namely upon them: Job 7: "You will terrify me through dreams, and shake me with horror through visions"; Job 4: "In the horror of a nocturnal vision, when deep sleep is wont to seize men, dread took hold of me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And one here, another there, namely than the other, cast down half-dead, that is, at the extremity of his life; he showed the cause of death on account of which he was dying, namely by indicating to others, as he was able, namely on account of the hardness of heart rebelling against the God of the Hebrews and against Moses, his servant: Romans 2: "According to your hardness and impenitent heart."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The visions indeed, of dreams, namely, which disturbed them, forewarned these things, namely the cause of their death. Lest they perish unknowing why they suffered evils, and thus be excused on account of ignorance from impenitence: Isaiah 28: "Vexation will give understanding to the hearing"; Gregory: "The eyes which guilt closes, punishment opens."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But it touched etc. Thus the Egyptians were punished, and not only they: but, for "however": it touched then: then, is taken broadly, so that the sense is: Then, namely at that time when, having gone out of Egypt, they were journeying through the desert, it touched even the just, namely the children of Israel. It touched, he says, because it did not long remain nor was it in all, a trial of death, that is, leading to death. And a commotion of the multitude was made in the desert, namely against Moses and Aaron, so that they fled to the tabernacle of the Lord, as is clear from Numbers 16. But your wrath did not long remain: Habakkuk: "When you are angry, you will remember mercies."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He says therefore: For hastening etc. I have rightly said that your wrath did not long remain: for hastening, a man without reproach, namely Aaron: whence Numbers 16: "When Aaron had heard this and had run into the midst of the multitude, which the conflagration was already devastating" etc.; hastening, in this is intimated the fervor of heart; without reproach, the holiness of conduct; to entreat for the peoples etc. For God hears such a one and not sinners: whence John 9: "God does not hear sinners"; Gregory: "When one who is displeasing is sent to intercede, the mind of the one angered is provoked to worse things"; to entreat for the peoples: entreaty properly concerns the removal of evils, while prayer concerns the obtaining of goods, but commonly one is put for the other. Bringing forth the shield of his service, prayer etc. Prayer is called a shield by reason of protection: Ezekiel 20: "I sought among them a man who would set up a hedge and stand opposed against me." Of his service is said because he was bound to this service by reason of the pontifical office; whence Hebrews 5: "For every high priest, taken from among men, is appointed for men"; and afterward follows: "He ought, just as for the people, so also for himself to offer for sins."
It should be noted that the shield can spiritually be called faith: whence Ephesians 6: "In all things taking up the shield of faith." Likewise, the word of God: whence Proverbs 30: "Every word" of the Lord, or "of God, is a fiery shield to those who hope in him." Likewise, prayer: whence here: Bringing forth the shield of his service, prayer. Likewise, equity; whence above in chapter 5: "He will take up the impregnable shield, equity." Likewise, almsgiving: whence Ecclesiasticus 29: "Above the shield of the mighty and above the lance, it will fight against your enemy." Likewise, patience: 2 Kings 1: "There the shield of the mighty was cast away," etc. Likewise, obedience, concerning which, 1 Maccabees 14: "This is the golden shield of Simon, of a thousand minas."
And through incense, that is, the offering of incense, presenting a supplication, that is, bringing forward by way of plea: Numbers 16: "He offered incense and standing between the dead and the living, he made supplication for the people." And it should be noted that prayer is set down for the remission of sin, supplication for the removal of the scourge, incense for the reconciliation of the offended judge. Hastening, I say, the man, etc., he withstood the wrath, that is, the divine chastisement. And he put an end to the distress, that is, to the inevitable human affliction. Showing, namely by deed, not only by word, that he is your servant, according to that passage in John 10: "The good shepherd lays down his life for his sheep"; Ecclesiasticus 45: "He chose him from among all the living to offer sacrifice to God, incense," etc. On the contrary, the Lord complains about wicked prelates in Ezekiel 13: "You have not gone up against the enemy, nor have you set up a wall for the house of Israel."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But he overcame the throngs, that is, the troubled people, by dividing and penetrating through them, not by the strength of the body, as Samson overcame the Philistines, Judges 15; nor by the armor of power, namely powerful and strong armor, as David overcame Goliath, 1 Kings 17: 1 Maccabees 3: "Not in the multitude of the army is the victory of war." But by the word, namely of devout prayer, he subdued him who was tormenting him, namely the Angel destroying the people, which he reckoned as his own torment, according to that passage: "Who is weak, and I am not weak?" etc., 2 Corinthians 11. The oaths of the Fathers and the covenant, that is, the promise made to the Fathers concerning giving them the land of promise as an inheritance; Genesis 12: "To your seed I will give this land"; recalling them, namely in his prayer.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For when etc., as if to say: rightly did I say that he overcame the multitudes etc.: for when the dead had already fallen in heaps upon one another, that is, when the dead lay in heaps one upon another: he stood between, that is, he stood between the living and the dead: whence Numbers sixteen: "He stood between the dead and the living." And he cut off the assault, namely of the fire consuming them; Hebrews eleven: "They quenched the violence of fire"; and he divided the way that led to the living, namely by placing himself against the fire in the middle of the way, lest the fire should pass from the dead to the living.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the adornment of the High Priest, there were four rows of stones. "For on his full-length robe was the whole world, and the glories of the fathers were carved in four rows upon the stones." And in these are the fourfold orders of the mysteries: and it is in this order that the Scriptures are planted.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For in the robe etc., as if to say: therefore he was able to do the aforesaid things: for in the robe reaching to the feet, that is, the ankle-length hyacinth-colored tunic, "on the hem of which were bells and pomegranates," Exodus twenty-eight. Or according to Josephus, the whole pontifical vestment, both interior and exterior, is the poderis, a linen garment descending to the feet, whence it is named from podos in Greek, which means foot in Latin, whence poderis as if clinging to the feet.
In the robe reaching to the feet is understood, which seems truer from what follows. In the robe, I say, reaching to the feet, which he wore, namely Aaron, the whole world was depicted, namely in symbol, because, as the Gloss says, "the Hebrews assign fine linen to the earth, because it is produced from the earth: purple to the sea, because it is dyed from its shellfish: hyacinth to the air on account of the likeness of color: scarlet to fire and the ether, namely so that the High Priest might pray for the whole world; since the world consists of earth, water, fire, and air."
But according as it is expounded of the hyacinth-colored tunic alone, the question arises: how was the whole world depicted in it? For since it was entirely of hyacinth, no part of the world seems to be depicted in it except the air alone.
But it must be said that, although the body of the tunic was of hyacinth, nevertheless at its borders there were some things of purple and fine linen and hyacinth and scarlet, such as pomegranates and the like.
The belt represented the ocean, because it encircles the whole earth. The ephod and the two stones, which were above covering each shoulder, represented the two hemispheres, or the sun and the moon. The pomegranates and bells placed below represented lightning and thunder: the twelve stones of the breastplate represented the twelve months, or the twelve parts of the zodiac. The breastplate represented divine providence and disposition. The miter with its hyacinth-colored ribbon represented the heavens. The plate on the forehead of the High Priest and the name of God written thereon represented that all things which exist are governed by the will of God.
And the great deeds of the fathers, that is, names of great authority, were engraved in four rows of stones: for on the breastplate there were four rows of precious stones: on each were inscribed the individual names of the twelve Patriarchs, as is clear from Exodus twenty-eight, just as also in the foundations of Jerusalem are said to be inscribed the names of the twelve Apostles, Apocalypse twenty-one. And your magnificence was engraved on the diadem of his head, that is, the magnificent name of God, the tetragrammaton, that is, of four letters, which are: Yod, He, Vau, He, which signify the principle of the life and passion of Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To these, however, namely the sacred vestments, the one who was destroying yielded, namely the Angel or the fire, yielding not on account of those vestments themselves, but on account of what they signified, namely on account of the future adornment, that is, the sacrifice of the supreme Pontiff, namely Christ, according to what the Gloss touches upon. And he feared these things, that is, he acted as if he feared, namely by withdrawing; and well did I say: To these he yielded, etc.; for it was only a trial of wrath, that is, a beginning, not a consummation, sufficient namely for the correction of the people, namely with the intercession of the Priest.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On the punishment of the Egyptians through their own death.
But to the impious even to the end. After he has treated the punishment of the Egyptians through the death of the firstborn, here he treats their punishment through their own death, namely when they were drowned in the Red Sea. And first is touched upon the drowning of the Egyptians; second, the liberation of the Hebrews: For every creature; third, the giving of thanks for both: Seeing your; fourth, the obedience of creatures in both: For the elements in themselves.
First, the drowning of the Egyptians.
In the first part, first is touched upon the gravity of the punishment; second, the reason on the part of the one punishing: He foreknew; third, the desert on the part of the punished: For still; fourth, the fittingness of the penalty: For he led.
(Vers. 1.). But to the impious etc., as if to say: thus the Israelites were freed from the fire: but, standing for "however": to the impious, namely the Egyptians, lacking the piety of religion toward God and of compassion toward neighbor, because they both despised God and oppressed his people: even to the end, that is, finally: Proverbs 5: "Her end is bitter as wormwood"; wrath came upon them without mercy. Without mercy, namely not relenting, but delivering without mercy, and this because they were impious and without mercy: James 2: "Judgment without mercy to him who has not shown mercy." Wrath, that is, the vengeance of sin, which is a sign of anger; came upon them, that is, by the heavenly judgment of God it came to their destruction: Job 21: "The lamp of the wicked shall be extinguished, and a flood shall come upon them"; Proverbs 1: "When tribulation and distress shall come upon you." And deservedly it came upon them etc.; for he foreknew, namely God, and, that is also, their future deeds, namely their sins, before they came to be: Hebrews 4: "All things are naked and open to his eyes"; likewise in the Psalm: "You have understood my thoughts from afar"; likewise Ecclesiasticus 23: "To the Lord our God, before all things were created, they are known" etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 2.). For when they themselves, namely the Egyptians, had returned, namely to their heart, according to what Isaiah admonishes, saying: "Return to your heart, you transgressors," Isaiah forty-six. Had returned, I say, to their heart, outside of which they had been on account of fear: in the Psalm: "My heart has forsaken me." And had permitted, namely previously, that they should lead them away, that is, that the children of Israel should lead them apart from their land; whence Exodus eleven: "Go forth, you and all the people who are subject to you." And with great solicitude, that is, urgency, had sent them forth, namely by compelling them to go out; whence Exodus twelve: "The Egyptians urged the people to go out of the land quickly." There followed upon them, namely the Egyptians, when they had done this, the driving of repentance, that is, grief over their departure—grief, I say, in the heart, and confession on the lips, and the manifestation of both in the work of pursuit: Exodus fourteen: "The heart of Pharaoh and of his servants was changed regarding the people, and they said: What did we intend to do, that we should let Israel go?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 3.). And I rightly said that there followed etc. For while still having mourning in their hands, that is, the matter of mourning, namely the dead firstborn, or: mourning, that is, the signs of mourning; and bewailing, that is, weeping greatly, or weeping from the heart, or: bewailing, that is, weeping over the death of the firstborn. Rightly there follows: At the tombs of the dead, namely of the firstborn, they took up another thought, etc. Rightly he says: They took up, etc., because an evil thought is from man, but a good one from God; Second Corinthians three: "Not that we are sufficient to think anything of ourselves," etc. A thought, I say, of ignorance, that is, of foolishness. For every evildoer errs: Proverbs fourteen: "They err who work evil." The prior thought had been foolish, by which they had thought to detain them by force; the other also was foolish, by which they had thought to recall or bring them back by force. And those whom, entreating, they had cast out, namely by compelling the children of Israel to go out, as is clear from Exodus twelve; these, as though fugitives, that is, as though departing without their permission, which was false, they pursued, as is clear from Exodus fourteen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 4.). There led etc., as if to say: and fittingly, for a worthy necessity led them to this end, namely of obstinacy and drowning, a worthy necessity, not of fortune or fate, but of divine justice.
But to the contrary: Because they tended toward this voluntarily, therefore not by necessity.
It must be said that it was not a necessity of coercion, but of immutability.
But to the contrary: Because they could have repented and thus avoided that punishment.
It must be said that they could have, but they did not will to. Whence that necessity was consequent upon the will, not antecedent to it. Or: they could not do so fully of themselves, nor did they will to seek the help of God.
And of those things which had happened, namely the many plagues inflicted for the retention of the children of Israel, Exodus seven, eight, nine, ten, and twelve, they lost the remembrance, that is, they were losing it, if not in disposition, nevertheless in act; or in deed, if not in heart: Hosea thirteen: "They lifted up their heart and forgot me." So that what was lacking to the torments, namely the preceding ones, for they had not yet been sufficiently punished, the punishment might supply, namely the following one, and the word so that is placed consecutively, not causally.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 5.). And indeed your people, namely the Israelite people, might pass through wondrously, namely through the Red Sea with dry footstep: whence Exodus fifteen: "The children of Israel walked through the dry land in the midst of it." But those, namely the Egyptians, might find a new death, namely a new manner of dying, namely through miraculous drowning: in the same place: "The horseman, that is the cavalry, entered"—"of Pharaoh," in the genitive case—"with chariots and horsemen into the sea, and the Lord brought back the waters of the sea upon them."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second, the liberation of the Hebrews.
For every etc. Here is touched upon the liberation of the Hebrews, and first in general; second, in particular: For the cloud.
(Vers. 6.). For every etc., as if to say thus: The Egyptians were drowned, and the Israelites were freed: for every creature, that is, all the elements, to its own kind from the beginning, namely the disposition it had, was being refashioned, that is, was again made like what it was, in this namely, that it did not harm the good, just as neither did it in the state of innocence; whence Isidore: "If man had not sinned, water would not drown, fire would not burn, nor would the pricks of thorns wound." The creature itself, I say, serving your commands, that is, your ordinance and will; in the Psalm: "He established them forever and for ages of ages; he set a decree, and it shall not pass away"; likewise Jeremiah five: "Who placed the sand as the boundary of the sea, an everlasting decree, which it shall not pass beyond." So that your children, namely the Hebrews subject to you: Isaiah eight: "Behold, I and my children"; might be kept unharmed; Proverbs two: "He will guard the salvation of the righteous and protect those who walk in simplicity."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 7.). For the cloud, namely given by God through the ministry of an Angel, their camp, namely of the Hebrews, overshadowed, "standing between their camp and the camp of the Egyptians, so that throughout the whole night they were unable to approach them," as is clear from Exodus fourteen. And from water, that is, after the water, just as when it is said: from morning comes midday, that is, after. From water, I say, which was there before, in the place through which they crossed, dry land appeared, namely dried by the blast of the wind, as is clear from Exodus fourteen. And in the Red Sea, namely divided, as is clear there; likewise in the Psalm: "Who divided the Red Sea into divisions"; a way namely appeared, without impediment, namely of water or mud, according to that word of the Psalm: "In the sea is your way," etc.; Habakkuk three: "You made a way in the sea for your horses"; likewise Isaiah fifty-one: (You made the depth of the sea a way, that the redeemed might cross over). And a sprouting field, that is, a level and delightful way, as through a sprouting field, from the exceeding deep, that is, after the exceeding depth of water previously existing there.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 8.). Through which, namely the field, the whole nation, namely of the Hebrews, crossed over, or might cross over, with the Egyptians pursuing. Which was covered, that is, protected, by your hand, that is, by your power: Isaiah forty-nine: "In the shadow of his hand he protected me," or by your Son, as in the Psalm: "Send forth your hand from on high," etc.
Third, the thanksgiving.
Seeing, etc. Here is subjoined the thanksgiving, first for the liberation of the Hebrews; second, for the punishment of the Egyptians or their drowning: And the vexations.
In the first part is touched upon the leading of the Hebrews out of Egypt; second, the wonders done for them in Egypt: For remembering; third, their refreshment in the desert: But at last.
Seeing your things, as if to say: not only hearing but also seeing; First John one: "What we have seen, what we have heard," etc. Your wonders and portents: wonders, namely lesser ones, and portents, namely greater ones; or: wonders, in their liberation, portents, in the overthrow of the Egyptians. For a portent is called not only something wondrous but also something terrible.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 9.). Seeing, I say etc: for, that is certainly, they fed upon food, namely in the overthrow or destruction of their adversaries. Or he says this inasmuch as they delighted in the destruction of those, just as horses when they eat or feed upon food. Like horses, upon which namely the Lord was riding, according to that passage in Habakkuk 3: "You made a way in the sea for your horses." Like horses, namely neighing at the overcoming of their enemies, according to that passage in Isaiah 24: "These shall lift up their voice and shall praise. When the Lord shall be glorified, they shall neigh from the sea." And like lambs, namely simple and meek: in the Psalm: "The mountains skipped like rams, and the hills like lambs of the flock," that is, both the greater and the lesser among them: they exulted, not only inwardly in heart, but also outwardly in rejoicing. Magnifying you, O Lord, that is, proclaiming you as great or praising you magnificently: Exodus 15: "Let us sing to the Lord, for he has been gloriously magnified." Who delivered them, namely by leading them through the sea; Isaiah 63: "Who led them out through the depths, like a horse in the desert that does not stumble, and like an animal in the field"; and rightly they magnified you.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 10.). For they were still mindful of those things, namely the signs, which had been done during their sojourning, that is, when they were still inhabitants of Egypt. Just as in place of the generation of animals, that is, instead of the production of natural animals, the earth brought forth flies, and this miraculously, as is clear from Exodus 8; likewise in the Psalm: "He spoke, and the dog-fly came, and gnats," etc. And in place of fish, that is, instead of fish, the river poured forth, namely the Nile, a multitude of frogs; for frogs ascended from the aforesaid river, as is found in Exodus 8. Nor is this contrary to what is said in the Psalm: "Their land brought forth frogs," etc., because in the Psalm the container is put for the contained, namely the channel of the earth for the water of the river.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 11.). But lastly, that is, after the aforesaid things: new indeed, or first, had been the striking of Egypt; newer still the leading out of the Hebrews from Egypt; but newest of all, their refreshment in the desert. They saw, namely with their own eyes, a new creature of birds, namely quails, Exodus 16 and Numbers 11.
But to the contrary: Because in Genesis 2 it is said: "God completed on the seventh day his work which he had made, and he rested from all the work which he had done," that is, from creating new genera or species of creatures, according to Augustine; likewise Ecclesiastes 1: "Nothing is new under the sun": therefore it says wrongly here: They saw a new creature.
It must be said that it was not simply new, but new to them, because previously unseen by them; likewise, new in that place, namely in the desert; and new in so great a multitude, which birds are not accustomed to approach, but rather to flee from.
When led away, that is, led far from God, by concupiscence: James 1: "Each one is tempted by his own concupiscence, drawn away and enticed." Concerning the concupiscence of these people it is said in the Psalm: "They desired a concupiscence in the desert"; whence "that place was called the burial-place of concupiscence," Numbers 11. They demanded, namely from Moses, foods of feasting, that is, delicate and superfluous foods, not of necessity or sustenance.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 12.). For in the speaking of desires, that is, in consolation and mitigation, there came up for them, namely the Hebrews, from the sea. Or thus: For in the speaking of desire, or of desires, while on account of their desire for meat they were speaking, namely words of murmuring: there came up for them from the sea, he does not say this because they drew their origin from the sea, but because they were brought from beyond the sea or from some island of the sea, according to that passage in Numbers 11: "A wind going forth from the Lord carried quails snatched from across the sea and dropped them into the camp," or released them, the ortygometra, that is, the quail. Now it is called ortygometra from orthos, which means "straight," and gogos, which means "leading," and metros, which means "measure," as if food rightly brought to them in measure; or, as was said above in chapter sixteen, ortygometra is named from the island of Ortygia, on which such birds are thought to have first existed, according to Isidore. "It should be noted that, as the Gloss says, for the enemies of God the earth produces flies and the river frogs; but for the worshippers of God the earth gives fruit and the sea the nourishment of flesh."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the vexations. Here is touched upon the thanksgiving for the vexation of the Egyptians, or their punishment; and first their punishment is touched upon; second, the justice of the punishment: For justly; third, the blindness of those punished: They were struck.
The justice of the punishment is evident from this, that they behaved badly toward the strangers dwelling with them, or wishing to dwell with them, namely toward the children of Israel, and this either by in no way receiving them, or by reducing those received into servitude: But others etc.; or by receiving them unwillingly: And not only: or, those receiving them with joy, by grievously afflicting them: But those who etc.
And vexations etc., as if to say: not only were the aforementioned good things done for the Hebrews, but also vexations, that is, afflictions of body and soul, came upon sinners etc., according to that verse of the Psalm: "Many are the scourges of the sinner." Upon sinners, I say, that is, the Egyptians, who are here called sinners by antonomasia, and this on account of the sin of idolatry, which flourished there more than elsewhere, so much so that Cicero said that Egypt was the temple of the entire world. They came upon them, I say, that is, they came in addition to those things which they had suffered in Egypt; whence it follows: Not without those things, indeed with those things and beyond them; which before had been done with proofs, that is, with signs manifesting the divine power and their hardness of heart, according to that passage in Ephesians 5: "All that is reproved is made manifest by the light." Which, I say, had been done, that is, in Egypt, by the force of rivers, namely when they were turned into blood, and when the frogs ascended from the river. Or thus: they came upon them, I say, by the force of rivers, that is, by the rush of the waters gathered in the Red Sea, returning upon them and drowning them: Exodus 15: "They sank like lead in the mighty waters." And deservedly: for they justly suffered this, namely because it was according to the merits of their sins; whence he adds: According to their wickedness, that is, the merits of their wickedness; Deuteronomy 25: "According to the measure of the sin shall be the manner of the stripes."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 13.). For indeed, meaning because, a more detestable, namely than others, they established, that is, they maintained as though it were an established practice, inhospitality, against that passage in Hebrews 13: "Do not forget hospitality"; likewise 1 Peter 4: "Be hospitable to one another without murmuring." So hold Rabanus and Augustine. But some read indetestable or in more detestable, that is, exceedingly detestable, so that the prefix denotes augmentation or intensification: and he says: Inhospitality, either because they did not receive guests, or because they received them badly. Some indeed, namely among them, did not receive unknown strangers, against which Job acted, chapter 31: "The stranger did not remain outside." Similar to these were those of Gibeah of Benjamin, who refused to receive the Levite with his wife into their lodging, Judges 19. Others, however, having received good guests, reduced them to servitude, or received them, as they did the children of Israel, oppressing them with the servitude "of clay and brick," Exodus 1.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 14.). And not only these things, supply: did they do, but there was also another regard of theirs, that is, their intention was perverse, since they received strangers unwillingly, although they ought to have been entreated, by the example of Abraham saying: "Lord, if I have found favor in your eyes, do not pass by your servant," Genesis eighteen. Nor only ought they to have been entreated, but even compelled, by the example of the two disciples, of whom Luke last chapter: "And they compelled him"; upon which Gregory says: "That strangers are not only to be invited to lodging, but even to be drawn in."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 15.). But those who with gladness received those who had practiced the same customs, afflicted them with the most savage pains: the text is to be construed thus: I have said that some received strangers, but unwillingly: but, standing for "however": who had practiced the same customs, of detestable inhospitality, as also the preceding ones: afflicted them with the most savage pains, he says "most savage," because savage is the pain from evil inflicted upon an extrinsic possession; more savage in a connected person, namely in a wife; most savage in one's own person. They afflicted those whom they had received with gladness, namely guests, as the Sodomites themselves wished to afflict Lot, as is clear from Genesis nineteen, and the Benjaminites that old man, of whom Judges nineteen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 16.). But they were struck, namely the Egyptians, with blindness, namely corporeal, through the plague of darkness, of which Exodus ten; and spiritual, through the blinding of the mind, so that amid the scourges they became worse: Exodus seven: "The heart of Pharaoh was hardened," etc. As those, namely the unspeakable Sodomites, on account of their unspeakable sin, which they themselves committed: Romans one: "God delivered them over to shameful passions." At the doors of the just man, namely Lot, of whom Second Peter two: "In sight and hearing he was just." They, I say, when they were covered with sudden darkness, namely aorasia, or non-seeing, struck by the Angel, each one, namely of them, the passage of his door, namely Lot's, sought, and could not find it: whence Genesis nineteen: "Those who were outside they struck with blindness, from the least to the greatest, so that they could not find the door."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The obedience of creatures.
For the elements in themselves. Here, after the punishment of the Egyptians and the consolation of the Hebrews and the giving of thanks for both, he shows the obedience of creatures in the aforementioned matters, and first he sets forth the commendation of this obedience; second, its manifestation through examples: As in an instrument; third, the exaltation of God's people through this: In all things.
He sets forth examples first in the lower elements; second, in the higher element, namely in fire, there: Fire in water etc.; third, in composite bodies: Flames on the contrary.
(Vers. 17.). For in themselves. Thus I have said that through the lower creatures the Egyptians were afflicted and the Hebrews consoled: while the elements are changed, that is, pass over, one into the force and power or office and mode of another, and this miraculously: the sound of quality, that is, the quality of sound, is altered, namely in act, that is, the natural consonance in its effects is changed for a time according to the will and command of God who moves. As in an organ, that is, as in any musical instrument, which is what is understood here by organ, the quality of sound is changed in act according to the will of the one moving it; sometimes, however, organ is taken for a specific instrument, as in the Psalm: "Praise Him with strings and organ." And all things, that is, the individual elements and things composed of elements, their own sound, that is, their natural harmony and order, preserve, in habit: similarly, the individual strings in an organ preserve their own sound, and yet the sound of the organ is changed according to the will of the one moving it: whence the Gloss: "Just as in an organ diverse sounds agree by tempering to the concord of melody, so the discordant elements, with the law of nature preserved, are bent to the will of the Creator. For He did not establish a creature contrary to Himself, but in all things consonant with His will." Whence that is, from which thing, it can be judged, that is, known, from the very certain sight, namely by beholding the metaphor of the organ and the truth of the thing done among the people of God,”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 18.). For land creatures, namely animals, were changed into aquatic ones, that is, into the mode of aquatic ones, namely when "men and beasts, as the Gloss says, crossed the depths of the Red Sea with dry footstep." And whatever things were swimming, such as frogs, passed over to land, namely by walking about on the land, Exodus 8: "The frogs came up," namely from the river, "and covered the land of Egypt."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 19.). Fire prevailed in water, that is, it acted powerfully, beyond its own, namely natural, power, which is such that it is extinguished in water, according to that saying of Ecclesiasticus 3: "Water extinguishes a burning fire." And water forgot its extinguishing nature, namely of extinguishing fire, because "hail and fire mingled together were carried along," as is found in Exodus 9; likewise above in chapter sixteen: "In water, which extinguishes all things, fire prevailed the more."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 20.). The flames, namely those that were in the pillar of fire, on the contrary, supply: than their nature would require, did not torment the flesh, namely by burning: the flesh, I say, of corruptible living beings, namely of men and beasts, walking together with the flames themselves. He says this because when the pillar of fire accompanied the Hebrews by night, they were not afflicted nor burned, as is evident from Exodus thirteen. Nor did it dissolve, namely those flames, that good food, which was easily dissolved, namely by the heat of the sun: like ice, namely is dissolved by the heat of the sun, above in chapter sixteen: "For what could not be destroyed by fire" etc. Good food he calls manna, because it represented the goodness of any foods whatsoever: in the same place: "Serving the will of each one."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“(Vers. 21.). For in all things, namely the aforementioned miracles, you magnified your people, O Lord, namely the Israelite people, by casting down their adversaries. And you honored them, by exalting them with many benefits; John twelve: "If anyone serves me, my Father will honor him" etc.; likewise First Kings two: "If anyone honors me, I will honor him." And you did not despise them, namely by abandoning them in their tribulations: in the Psalm: "Many are the tribulations of the just, and the Lord delivered them from all of these"; Ecclesiasticus two: "Who called upon him, and he despised him?" as if to say: no one. At all times, namely of prosperity and adversity: Matthew last chapter: "Behold, I am with you all days"; and therefore at all times he is to be blessed, according to that word of the Psalm: "I will bless the Lord at all times"; and in every place, namely both safe and dangerous: standing by them, as though ready to help: Isaiah forty-three: "When you pass through the waters, I will be with you." It should be noted, moreover, that the Lord magnifies his Saints in manifold ways: in the first way, by conferring his grace, according to that word of Romans eight: "Those whom he justified, he also magnified." Second, by making them illustrious through miracles, according to that word of Ecclesiasticus forty-eight: "Thus was Elijah magnified in his wonders"; likewise Exodus eleven: "Moses was a very great man in the land of Egypt before the servants of Pharaoh and all the people." Third, by elevating them to ecclesiastical dignities: whence the Church sings: "Behold, the great Priest"; Third Kings ten: "King Solomon was magnified above all the kings of the earth in riches and wisdom." Fourth, by leading them to the glory of the heavenly kingdom, according to what the Church sings: "He magnified him in the sight of kings," namely of the Angels, "and gave him a crown of glory"; in the Psalm: "Great is his glory in your salvation" etc. So great is the magnitude of this glory that the least of that kingdom is greater than the greatest of this world; whence Matthew eleven: "There has not risen among those born of women one greater than John the Baptist. Yet he who is least in the kingdom of heaven is greater than he." May Jesus Christ our Lord lead us to this greatness, who is blessed forever and ever. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is objected that the soul of Christ was wise by uncreated wisdom only, thus: Sirach 1: All wisdom is from the Lord God and was always with Him and is before all time; but everything that is before all time is eternal: therefore all wisdom is eternal: therefore if the soul of Christ is not wise except by some wisdom, it is not wise except by eternal wisdom.
If you say that wisdom is said to have been with God as in its cause: by the same reasoning this could be said of any creature, and this does not greatly render wisdom itself praiseworthy.
If you say that all wisdom, that is, perfect wisdom: the following text does not agree with this, because it speaks of that wisdom to the acquisition of which it invites, as is clearly gathered from what follows.
To the first objection, that all wisdom is from the Lord God, it must be said that wisdom there is not taken as the habit by which the soul of the wise is informed and by which it is disposed for knowing, but as the unchangeable ground of knowing. Now every such ground is in the divine art, because it is sempiternal, and without it there cannot be created wisdom, as was shown above. Hence from that authority it cannot be concluded that created wisdom ought not to be posited.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The loftiness of faith consists in two things: the extreme of altitude and the extreme of depth. Concerning the first, Ecclesiasticus says: "Heaven's height, earth's breadth, the depth of the abyss: who can explore these?" As if he were saying, above all human reason there is the understanding of this: faith's loftiness, love's expansion, and the veneration brought about by the fear of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third face of wisdom has every form in the traces of divine works. Hence in Ecclesiasticus: "To whom hath the root of wisdom been revealed; and who hath known her wise counsels? To whom hath the discipline of wisdom been revealed and made manifest? And who hath understood the multiplicity of her steps? There is one most high Creator, Almighty." And below: "He created her in the Holy Ghost, and saw her, and numbered her, and measured her. And He poured her out upon all His works." This wisdom has been made manifest, hence "wisdom cries aloud in the street, in the open squares she raises her voice." And yet we do not find her, resembling the unlettered man who owns a book and has no concern for it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"To whom hath the root of wisdom been revealed; and who hath known her wise counsels? There is one most high Creator, Almighty. He created her in the Holy Ghost, and saw her, and numbered her, and measured her. And He poured her out upon all His works." This wisdom is spread out among all things. For everything possesses a rule of wisdom and displays divine wisdom by reason of some characteristic; and the man who would know all characteristics would clearly see this wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore the fear of God ought to be perfect, because "it shall be well with those who fear God," because they shall come to the blessing of glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of God avails for obtaining the illumination of divine wisdom, because "the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom." For the fear of the Lord is the extrinsic principle of wisdom and the intrinsic principle and the complement of wisdom; because there is servile fear, and this is the initiator of wisdom, because, just as the needle introduces the thread and does not remain with the thread, so servile fear introduces wisdom and does not remain with wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of the Lord is the extrinsic principle of wisdom and the intrinsic principle and the complement of wisdom. The third is the fear of filial reverence: and this is the complement of wisdom, because "the fullness of wisdom is to fear God." Fear produces these three things in us, because "the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom," and "the root of wisdom is to fear God," and "the fullness of wisdom is to fear God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The preacher does as a man who is in a meadow and gathers flowers: he cannot gather them all, but he gathers some and makes from them a garland. It is said in Ecclesiasticus: "The crown of wisdom is to fear the Lord." I wish to make for you a garland from the flowers that I have gathered. It seems to me that the fear of the Lord is a most beautiful tree planted in the heart of the holy man, which God waters continually: and when the tree is brought to perfection, then the man is worthy of eternal glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Another is the fear of punishment and of offending God; and this is the intrinsic beginning of wisdom and "the root of wisdom." Fear produces these three things in us, because "the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom," and "the root of wisdom is to fear God," and "the fullness of wisdom is to fear God": Job: "Behold, the fear of the Lord, that itself is wisdom." He who does not fear God knows nothing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of God avails for introducing the rectitude of divine justice. Whence Ecclesiasticus: "The fear of the Lord drives out sin. For he who is without fear cannot be justified." Injustice does not enter the soul except through sin: but the first justification of the soul is that it be subject to the divine majesty. Once this fear is destroyed, it is necessary that what follows be destroyed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"In the treasures of wisdom is understanding." This is to say that the hidden treasures of knowledge either consist in the knowledge of the highest causes, or of conclusions, or of principles. And one must dig through the study of truth so that a person may arrive at this treasure. This understanding, which is the gateway of scientific considerations, is partly from the dictate of nature, that is, from the interior light; partly from the frequency of experience, as from the exterior light; and partly from the illumination of the eternal light, as from the superior light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Son, desiring wisdom, preserve justice, and God will bestow it upon you." This gift is from God; but if you wish to have it, you must desire wisdom, because wisdom does not enter a soul unless it is borne toward it with great affection, nor is it denied to a soul that desires it. Along with the desire for wisdom, justice must be preserved, because wisdom does not accord with iniquity. Among other things, this is the highest justice, that a man not be ungrateful to God, but pour back the gifts conferred upon him to the Giver.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Son, if thou desire wisdom, keep justice: and God will give her to thee." Observing justice helps to obtain wisdom, as the tendency of matter inclines to the form and makes it able to be joined to the form through the medium of dispositions. Not that these dispositions perish, or even less, that they are fulfilled either in the human bodies or in others. And so keeping justice brings forth wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first justification of the soul is that it be subject to the divine majesty. Once this fear is destroyed, it is necessary that what follows be destroyed. On account of this it is said in Ecclesiasticus: "Son, coming to the service of God, stand in justice and fear, and prepare your soul for temptation."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The gift of piety arises first from the uncreated Trinity, namely from God the Father. Although God possesses all the most noble properties, He is nevertheless most excellent in this property, namely that of piety; whence it is said in the prayer: "O God, whose property it is always to have mercy and to spare." And in Ecclesiasticus: "Pious and merciful is God, and in the time of tribulation He forgives sins and is a protector to all who seek Him in truth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And how shall we perfect sanctification? It is said in Ecclesiasticus: "Those who fear the Lord will prepare their hearts, and in his sight will sanctify their souls, saying: if we do not do penance, we shall fall into the hands of the Lord and not into the hands of men." "Those who fear the Lord will prepare their hearts," that is, they will abstain and cease from sins. Let us therefore approach the cleansing of conscience. It is a wonder how a man can remain in mortal sin. When a man enters his dwelling, he enters a tomb. I have seen of spiritual men that when they had a slight venial sin, they could scarcely sleep. If I had a lion bound with me, how could I sleep? The enemy holds you bound if you are in mortal sin. Rise therefore and sanctify your soul. Do not halve your confession, but confess most perfectly and most completely. Let the fear of the Lord lead you to this.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To the one who honors his father with the honor of obedience is granted a joyful life; whence in Ecclesiasticus: He who honors his father shall find joy in his children, and in the day of his prayer he shall be heard. He who honors his father shall live a longer life; and he who obeys his father shall bring comfort to his mother. The highest joy is that a man not be rebellious toward his superior; because he who is rebellious toward his superior will find his inferior rebellious toward him, and the despiser of higher powers will be despised by those beneath him: just as Adam, when he was disobedient to his superior, found all the lower creatures which had been subject to him turned against him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To the one who honors his father with the honor of obedience is granted a joyful life; whence in Ecclesiasticus: He who honors his father shall find joy in his children, and in the day of his prayer he shall be heard. He who honors his father shall live a longer life; and he who obeys his father shall bring comfort to his mother. The highest joy is that a man not be rebellious toward his superior; because he who is rebellious toward his superior will find his inferior rebellious toward him, and the despiser of higher powers will be despised by those beneath him: just as Adam, when he was disobedient to his superior, found all the lower creatures which had been subject to him turned against him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To the father, insofar as he holds the character of origin, the honor of reverence is owed; whence in Ecclesiasticus: He who fears God will honor his father and his mother, and will serve as masters those who begot him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To the one who honors his father with the honor of beneficence is granted an abundant life; whence in Ecclesiasticus: Honor your father and your mother, and blessing shall come upon you, and your blessing shall remain to the last. This blessing is called the multiplication of goods.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To the one who honors his father with the honor of reverence is granted a glorious or honorable life; whence in Ecclesiasticus: The glory of a man is from the honor of his father; likewise in the same place: Glory not in the dishonor of your father, for his shame is not glory to you. For it is natural that a son should love his father most ardently, and that he should be indignant when someone does injury to his father.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To the one who honors his father with the honor of reverence is granted a glorious or honorable life; whence in Ecclesiasticus: The glory of a man is from the honor of his father; likewise in the same place: Glory not in the dishonor of your father, for his shame is not glory to you. For it is natural that a son should love his father most ardently, and that he should be indignant when someone does injury to his father.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The honor of beneficence is owed to the father, because he holds the character of benefactor: whence in Ecclesiasticus: Son, support your father in his old age, and do not grieve him in his life.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For this reason it is said in Ecclesiasticus: "The greater you are, humble yourself in all things." You are an archbishop or a bishop: do you wish to find grace? Humble yourself. Otherwise we are thieves, unless we humble ourselves. If a king had enriched someone, and that person refused to acknowledge that he had received his goods from him, he would be most unfaithful and would deserve to be stoned.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From Christ, indeed, is the fruit of grace. This fruit of grace is fourfold: it consists in steadying the soul through faith, blessing it through divine love, lifting it up through hope, curbing it through divine fear. The fourth is indicated in Ecclesiasticus: "The greater thou art, the more humble thyself in all things."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It belongs to justice to "render to each one what is his own," both to God and to oneself and to one's neighbor. But to God is principally owed honor and reverence; and humility especially disposes one to render this, according to that passage in Ecclesiasticus three: How great is the power of God alone, and He is honored by the humble. Since, therefore, the beginning of all justice is the worship and honor of God, and this is rendered to God by the humble: hence it is that the root and foundation of all justice is humility.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“What God hath commanded thee, think upon always, and in many of his works be not curious. These last words are spoken especially to the learned; in which Ecclesiasticus teaches to think on useful things and to avoid curious things. Useful things indeed direct us in the way of salvation; but curious things distract us from the way of salvation and dissipate our understanding. A great part of understanding is lost on account of curiosity; and yet nothing in us is more precious than understanding. We grieve greatly when we lose gold; we ought to grieve much more if we lose understanding, because nothing is so dear as the act of understanding.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence, meditation on the Law is supremely necessary. The Psalm reads: Happy the man who follows not the counsel of the wicked, but delights in the Law of the Lord. He is like a tree planted near running water. And Ecclesiasticus: The things that God hath commanded thee, think on them always, and in many of His works be not curious.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“What God hath commanded thee, think upon always, and in many of his works be not curious. These last words are spoken especially to the learned; in which Ecclesiasticus teaches to think on useful things and to avoid curious things. Useful things indeed direct us in the way of salvation; but curious things distract us from the way of salvation and dissipate our understanding. A great part of understanding is lost on account of curiosity; and yet nothing in us is more precious than understanding. We grieve greatly when we lose gold; we ought to grieve much more if we lose understanding, because nothing is so dear as the act of understanding.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“You are the image of God; and image is called, as it were, imitage: therefore, if you are truly the image of God, you ought to conform yourself to God in piety. Whence in Ecclesiasticus: "In judging, be merciful to orphans as a father, and as a husband to their mother; and you will be as an obedient son of the Most High, and He will have mercy on you."
"In judging," that is, in fostering justice, "be merciful to orphans," namely so that you may truly be a son of the Most High. When the glorious God has compassion on the wretched, why do you not imitate Him? If there were some fountain that caused withered plants to grow green, it would be greatly prized. The soul without piety has withered plants. The river of divine mercy pours itself out most abundantly and causes dead plants to grow green. Is it not necessary that you introduce that river into your soul? But you cannot introduce it except through piety. The first original influence of piety, therefore, is from the uncreated Trinity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the same manner, there are four acts of justice: to do good, to flee evil, to beware of prosperity, and to withstand misfortune. The fourth is referred to in Proverbs: "The just man, like a lion, feels sure of himself." There is also this: "Blessed are they who suffer persecution for justice' sake." And again: "Strive for justice for thy soul, and even unto death fight for justice."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Be meek to hear the word, that you may understand." A man is disposed to receive the gift of understanding through the docility of meekness. Concupiscence clouds the understanding, and fury impedes intelligence, "because anger impedes the mind, so that it cannot discern the truth." The Philosopher says that "by being at rest the soul becomes prudent and knowing." When water is still, then a man sees his face well in it; but when it is disturbed, then he can see nothing in it. So, when a man is in anger, then he does not see the truth. The contentious impede understanding in themselves and in others. The angry man also pertinaciously defends what is false. A tractable man learns and becomes gentle.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"If you have understanding, answer your neighbor; if not, let your hand be over your mouth." Prudential understanding teaches what is to be carried out, namely every good, according to the way of interior thought and exterior action. God wills that we do all things reasonably. And blessed Ambrose says that we ought neither to do nor to speak anything about that for which we cannot give a reason.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But who is the good counselor? Certainly that one of whom Ecclesiasticus says: 'Let many be at peace with you, but let one out of a thousand be your counselor.' One counselor, that is, Christ, of whom Isaiah says: 'His name shall be called Wonderful, Counselor, God, the Mighty, the Father of the world to come, the Prince of Peace.' He is the Angel of great counsel: this is he to whom we ought to attend with a pure heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence in Ecclesiasticus: 'Put your foot into her fetters and your neck into her chains. And her shackles shall be to you a protection of strength and a foundation of virtue, and her chains a robe of glory. For the beauty of life is in her, and her bonds are a binding of salvation.' You will say: 'To give a purgative medicine without a preparatory one is foolish.' I say that religious life has both purgative and preparatory medicine, because it tempers itself according to the capacity of those who receive it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence in Ecclesiasticus: 'Put your foot into her fetters and your neck into her chains. And her shackles shall be to you a protection of strength and a foundation of virtue, and her chains a robe of glory. For the beauty of life is in her, and her bonds are a binding of salvation.' I say that religious life has both purgative and preparatory medicine, because it tempers itself according to the capacity of those who receive it. Hence Augustine says: 'Let food and clothing be distributed to each of you by your superior, not equally to all, because you are not all equally well, but rather to each one as he shall have need.'”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From the second consideration comes forth that fruit of justice which consists in fleeing evil, that is, by means of distinguishing judgments. As Ecclesiasticus says: "Sow not in the furrows of injustice, lest you harvest it sevenfold." No one, indeed, wants to reap cockle or tares, for as it is said in Deuteronomy: "According to the measure of the sin shall the measure also of the stripes be." Thus the consideration of the judgments will make one flee from evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She is a net to those who lust and consent. Whence in Ecclesiasticus: "On account of the beauty of a woman many have perished." It is difficult "to carry fire in one's bosom without one's garments being burned."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Do you know what happens through sin? The most precious becomes the most worthless. Whence in Ecclesiasticus: "A fornicating woman shall be trodden underfoot as dung in the road." What then is a fornicating cleric and priest? Certainly an abomination to the Lord. Flee therefore from lusts and follow the Virgin, who believed the Archangel Gabriel, not the woman who believed the serpent.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“She is a snare to those who look upon her; whence it is written: "Many, having admired the beauty of a strange woman, have become reprobate." It is read of blessed Bernard that his sister came to see him, adorned with the most beautiful finery; he spat in her face and fled from her. She, indignant, asked why he did this; he answered: "because you come in the adornment of a harlot to capture souls and carry the devil with you." Therefore he says: "She is the snare of hunters," that is, of the devil, who through her captures souls.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The sixth column of the house of wisdom is maturity in judgment. Maturity is in judgment when a man does not judge rashly. "A wise judge shall judge his people," namely, over whom he has authority. But if he exceeds his authority, he is not a wise judge, but his judgment is rash. If he judges without authority, what is it? Certainly nothing. It is also necessary that the judgment of a wise man have rectitude of zeal and clarity of knowledge.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The ninth plague was of darkness, by which the covetous and avaricious are struck, because nothing so blinds a man as covetousness. Solomon: "Nothing is more wicked than the avaricious man. For he has even his own soul for sale, because in his life he has cast away his inmost parts."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Of actual sins there is one beginning, a twofold root, a threefold fuel, and a sevenfold head or capital sin. There is one beginning, namely pride, according to what is written: The beginning of all sin is pride. Since mortal sin is an actual departure from the First Principle, and departure from the First Principle cannot occur except through contempt of Him, either in Himself or in His commandment, and contempt of the First Principle is pride: it is therefore necessary that every mortal fault or offense take its beginning from pride. But because no one despises the Supreme Principle, or His commandment in itself, except by reason of something else that he either wishes to acquire or fears to lose: hence it is necessary that every actual sin draw its origin from a twofold root, namely fear and love; which are roots of evils, though not equally primary. For every fear has its origin from love: for no one fears to lose something unless he loves to have it; and therefore fear is nourished by those things by which love too is nourished. Now disordered love regards a changeable good: and since that is threefold—interior, namely excellence; exterior, money; inferior, carnal wantonness—hence it is necessary that there be three radical fuels of actual sins, toward which when the soul is carried in a disordered manner, all actual sins arise.
And because this happens according to a sevenfold manner, therefore there are seven capital sins, from which the universality of vices is generated. For our will is either disordered because it desires what is not to be desired, or because it shuns what is not to be shunned. If one desires what is not to be desired, namely a good as of now, or a changeable or apparent good: it is either interior, and thus it is private excellence, which pride loves; or it is exterior, and thus it is sufficiency, which avarice loves; or inferior, and thus either delectable because it serves the conservation of the individual, and thus it is nourishment, which is delectable according to taste and is desired by gluttony; or because it serves the conservation of the species, and thus it is sexual union, which is delectable according to touch and is desired by lust. If, however, the will is disordered because it flees what is not to be fled, this can occur in three ways: for it either flees according to the perverse instinct of the rational power, and thus it is envy; or according to the instinct of the irascible power, and thus it is wrath; or according to the instinct of the concupiscible power, and thus it is sloth. Whence, because there are four principal objects of desire and three powers according to whose instinct there is flight, therefore the capital sins are seven in number.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First there must be food, not drink. Unless man is trained in the gift of understanding, he cannot proceed to the drink of wisdom, which makes a river flow in the soul. The gift of understanding is solid food, like bread which, as Blessed Francis used to say, is obtained through much labor. First the seed is sown, then it grows, then the grain is collected, then brought to the mill, then baked. There are many such steps. And so it is with the gift of understanding: to prepare understanding is a difficult task in itself. Likewise, wisdom is not obtained except by the man who thirsts.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"In the midst of the Church she shall open his mouth, and shall fill him with the spirit of wisdom and understanding, and shall clothe him with a robe of glory." It has been shown above to whom a doctor should direct his speech and whence he should begin. It remains now to see where he must end it: and that is in the fullness of wisdom and understanding. Concerning wisdom, four points are to be noted: its origin, its dwelling, its door, and its beauty.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"In the midst of the Church the Lord shall open his mouth, and shall fill him with the spirit of wisdom and understanding and shall clothe him with a robe of glory." In these words the Holy Spirit teaches the prudent man to whom he should address his speech, from where he should begin it, and finally where he should end it. First, to whom he should address it, that is, to the Church: for what is holy should not be given to dogs nor should pearls be thrown to the swine. Second, from where to begin, that is, from the center, which is Christ: for if this Medium is overlooked, no result is obtained. Third, where he should end, that is, in fullness, in the complete fulfilling of the spirit of wisdom and understanding.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whatever is said of wisdom, must be said of understanding of which it was explained in the Collations on the Gifts that it is the rule of moral definition, the door to learned thought, and the key to heavenly contemplation. And such understanding is indeed a gift. A beginning must be made from understanding in order to reach wisdom. First there must be food, not drink. Unless man is trained in the gift of understanding, he cannot proceed to the drink of wisdom, which makes a river flow in the soul. The gift of understanding is solid food, like bread which, as Blessed Francis used to say, is obtained through much labor. First the seed is sown, then it grows, then the grain is collected, then brought to the mill, then baked. There are many such steps. And so it is with the gift of understanding: to prepare understanding is a difficult task in itself.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"God created man from the earth," namely as regards the body, "and made him according to His own image," namely as regards the soul. He gives us to understand that the human soul has three operations, according to its power and operation. "Every noble soul has three operations," by which it turns itself upon its own body, upon itself, and toward divine things. Sometimes it turns itself upon the body: it has the tongue for speaking, ears for hearing; sometimes it turns itself upon itself; sometimes toward understanding and knowing God. And this is according to the threefold consideration of the soul; for the soul is considered as the form and perfection of the body, as a this-something, and as an image.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Counsel and a tongue and eyes and ears and a heart He gave them for thinking, and He filled them with the discipline of understanding." He gives us to understand that the human soul has three operations, by which it turns itself upon its own body, upon itself, and toward divine things. That this understanding is partly from the dictate of nature is evident in Adam, because he imposed names upon all things. But that God "filled him with the discipline of understanding," this was his privilege; hence it is not in us. But our soul has signed upon it a certain light of nature, through which it is apt for knowing first principles; but that alone does not suffice, because, according to the Philosopher, "we know principles insofar as we know terms." For when I know what a whole is, what a part is, I immediately know that "every whole is greater than its part."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All things, although God could have made them in an instant, He nevertheless preferred to make them through a succession of times: partly for the sake of a distinct and clear representation of power, wisdom, and goodness; partly for the sake of a fitting correspondence of days or times and works; and partly also so that, just as in the first creation of the world there were to be made the seminal principles of works yet to be done, so also there would be made prefigurations of future times. If, however, it were said in another manner, that all things were made simultaneously, then all these seven days are referred to angelic contemplation. Nevertheless, the first manner of speaking is more consonant with Scripture and with the authorities of the Saints, both those who preceded and also those who followed the blessed Augustine.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Thus is to be understood that which is said: "He who lives forever created all things simultaneously": not because He created them in a chaos of every kind of confusion, as the poets imagined, since He brought forth this threefold nature, the highest in the highest place, the middle in the middle, and the lowest in the lowest: nor indeed into a being of every kind of distinction, since heaven was perfect, and the earth unformed, and the middle nature, as it were holding a middle position, had not yet been brought to perfect distinction.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Jurists are concerned with judgments of money, we with the judgment of ourselves. Hence, "before you are judged, seek merit for yourself."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Wine and women make the wise to fall away and will reprove the sensible." You have a ready example in that Solomon, who fell away on account of women even to the worship of idolatry, who nevertheless was filled with wisdom like a river. I believe that the eternal God, by the most high dispensation of his counsel, permitted Solomon to fall, so that he might teach all men to flee from women.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third column of the house of wisdom is moderation in speech. Above all things, moderation is required in speech: "A wise man will be silent until the time, but the wanton and imprudent will not observe the time. For every matter there is a time and opportunity." Is it not the height of foolishness that a man should pierce both himself and his neighbor with the same sword? An evil word kills both the hearer and the speaker. You cannot detract from your neighbor without slaying yourself with the same sword.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The grace of God therefore descends to us through the Word incarnate, through the Word crucified, and through the Word inspired. Man assails this most noble influence through sin. For all the things in the world, man ought not to commit sin. It is said in Ecclesiasticus: "Flee from sin as from the face of a serpent." As a serpent pouring out venom kills, so sin kills the life of grace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third aspect of the zeal of wisdom is the ordaining of thoughts. "A fool will peep through the window into the house." And in this regard, there is great difficulty in containing our imagination so well that in church we think of nothing but the office, and likewise in other circumstances. And it is necessary to ordain such thoughts so that the Holy Spirit be able to enter in the form of wisdom, "for the holy spirit of discipline flees deceit and withdraws from senseless counsel." Hence, there is need for us to use clearly defined materials with which we can be properly concerned.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A promissory oath is made for entering into mutual peace: and in this is understood the restraint of all mortal sins; because "every true oath is dangerous, a false one is pernicious, and no oath is safe." And for this reason it is said in Ecclesiasticus: "Let not your mouth become accustomed to swearing."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The commandments of God are irreproachable, because they contain nothing burdensome, but rather they are sweet. Whence it is said in Ecclesiasticus: "Nothing is better than the fear of God, and nothing is sweeter than to look upon the commandments of the Lord."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the height and depth of faith, Ecclesiasticus says: "In the highest heavens did I dwell, my throne on a pillar of cloud." The height of faith consists in understanding the eternal God, its depth, in knowing God made man. The words "in the highest heavens" indicate the teaching of faith that God is eternal. The words, God's "throne on a pillar of clouds," refer to the teaching about God made man.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I dwelt in the highest places, and My throne is in a pillar of a cloud. I alone have compassed the circuit of heaven, and have penetrated into the bottom of the deep, and have walked in the waves of the sea." This is what incarnate Wisdom says: "I dwelt in the highest heavens," in the creation; "My throne is in a pillar of cloud," in the incarnation; "I have walked in the waves of the sea," in the passion; "I have penetrated into the bottom of the deep," in the penetration of Scriptures, for after He arose, "He opened their minds, that they might understand the Scriptures." By faith in the cross, Peter walked on the sea.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I dwelt in the highest places, and My throne is in a pillar of a cloud. I alone have compassed the circuit of heaven, and have penetrated into the bottom of the deep, and have walked in the waves of the sea." This is what incarnate Wisdom says: "I dwelt in the highest heavens," in the creation; "My throne is in a pillar of cloud," in the incarnation; "I have walked in the waves of the sea," in the passion; "I have penetrated into the bottom of the deep," in the penetration of Scriptures, for after He arose, "He opened their minds, that they might understand the Scriptures." By faith in the cross, Peter walked on the sea.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“I made that in the heavens there should rise light that never faileth. That is, in heavenly men, a firm light of faith. The threefold heavens refer to a threefold vision: purely intellectual, intellectual combined with imaginary, and intellectual combined with manifest bodily vision. The first is found in the minds of angels, the second in the minds of prophets, and the third in the minds of the apostles. The certainty of Scriptures consists in the concurrence of these visions.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I dwelt in the highest places, and My throne is in a pillar of a cloud. I alone have compassed the circuit of heaven, and have penetrated into the bottom of the deep, and have walked in the waves of the sea." This is what incarnate Wisdom says: "I dwelt in the highest heavens," in the creation; "My throne is in a pillar of cloud," in the incarnation; "I have walked in the waves of the sea," in the passion; "I have penetrated into the bottom of the deep," in the penetration of Scriptures, for after He arose, "He opened their minds, that they might understand the Scriptures." By faith in the cross, Peter walked on the sea.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In reference to the first stage, the Father says to Incarnate Wisdom in Ecclesiasticus: "Take root in My elect. — And I took root in an honorable people." This is the production of a tree that is good for food.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We have spoken of the fruits of Holy Scripture. It is to these fruits that Holy Wisdom invites us. "I bud forth delights like the vine, My blossoms become fruit fair and rich. Come to Me, all you that yearn for Me, and be filled with My fruits." If we want to come over, we must be the sons of Israel who passed over from Egypt. But the Egyptians did not pass over: they were drowned. Those alone come over who focus their whole attention on how to pass from vanity to the country of truth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whence in Ecclesiasticus uncreated Wisdom says: "I am the mother of fair love and of fear and of knowledge and of holy hope: in me is all grace of the way and of truth: in me is all hope of life and of virtue: come over to me, all you who desire me, and be filled from my fruits." Do you wish to be full of grace and virtue? Come over to me, that is, to Christ. And how? We cannot do this unless we are raised above ourselves: but certain things hinder us from being raised above ourselves: therefore it is necessary that we rise up against those things which hinder us. No one is established in this fullness of grace unless he rises up against himself and is raised above himself and loves God above all things and his enemy as himself; because by the name of neighbor every person is understood. Full justice, therefore, is to love God above all things, and this means to love every person, therefore both friend and enemy. But what will bring it about that a person is lifted up against himself and above himself? Surely grace; I say, the grace of the way and of truth. It is difficult for anyone to love his enemy except through grace. A stone cannot give heat of itself: but if it is placed next to a burning furnace, it can afterward give heat.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We have spoken of the fruits of Holy Scripture. It is to these fruits that Holy Wisdom invites us. "I bud forth delights like the vine, My blossoms become fruit fair and rich. Come to Me, all you that yearn for Me, and be filled with My fruits." If we want to come over, we must be the sons of Israel who passed over from Egypt. But the Egyptians did not pass over: they were drowned. Those alone come over who focus their whole attention on how to pass from vanity to the country of truth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since therefore one must first ascend before descending on the ladder of Jacob, let us place the first step of ascent at the bottom, setting this entire sensible world before us as a mirror, through which we may pass over to God, the supreme Artificer, so that we may be true Hebrews passing over from Egypt to the land promised to the Fathers, and also Christians passing over with Christ from this world to the Father, and also lovers of wisdom, who calls and says: Pass over to me, all you who desire me, and be filled from my generations. For from the greatness of the beauty and of the creature, the Creator of these things can be knowably seen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the soul is a paradise in which Scripture is planted, and it has marvelous aspects of sweetness and beauty. Hence in the Canticle: My sister, my spouse is a garden enclosed, a garden enclosed, a fountain sealed up. Thy plants are a paradise of pomegranates. The soul is a garden in which there are sacramental mysteries and spiritual meanings, where a fountain of spiritual outpourings gushes forth, but it is enclosed, and the fountain is sealed up, for they are not visible to the impure, but to those whom God knows to be His. Eternal wisdom loves this garden and dwells around it. Hence in Ecclesiasticus: I, like the river Doryx, flowed out of paradise. This garden is watered by the One who plants all things: and whatever he did not plant will be rooted up. "Every plant that My heavenly Father has not planted will be rooted up." And consequently, I said: I will water my garden of plants, and I will water abundantly the fruits of my meadow. For He waters by means of blood, with which He sprinkled the book and all the people; He also waters through the Holy Spirit flowing from Him. The Scripture has this flow and we find it there. Such are the trees beautiful to behold and sweet to feed upon because of the beauty and flavor of their fruits.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the soul is a paradise in which Scripture is planted, and it has marvelous aspects of sweetness and beauty. Hence in the Canticle: My sister, my spouse is a garden enclosed, a garden enclosed, a fountain sealed up. Thy plants are a paradise of pomegranates. The soul is a garden in which there are sacramental mysteries and spiritual meanings, where a fountain of spiritual outpourings gushes forth, but it is enclosed, and the fountain is sealed up, for they are not visible to the impure, but to those whom God knows to be His. Eternal wisdom loves this garden and dwells around it. Hence in Ecclesiasticus: I, like the river Doryx, flowed out of paradise. This garden is watered by the One who plants all things: and whatever he did not plant will be rooted up. "Every plant that My heavenly Father has not planted will be rooted up." And consequently, I said: I will water my garden of plants, and I will water abundantly the fruits of my meadow. For He waters by means of blood, with which He sprinkled the book and all the people; He also waters through the Holy Spirit flowing from Him. The Scripture has this flow and we find it there. Such are the trees beautiful to behold and sweet to feed upon because of the beauty and flavor of their fruits.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The blessed Virgin brought forth that price as strong and holy with the holiness of uncorrupted modesty. Whence in Ecclesiasticus: "Grace upon grace is a holy and modest woman"; and the Angel said: "Hail, full of grace," because she was holy and modest: holy in flesh and modest in mind.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third allegory, pointing to the Church, is indicated in Ecclesiasticus: "Like the sun rising in the Lord's heavens, the beauty of a virtuous wife is the radiance of her home." This wife or house is the Church: a wife, in that it is active; a house of God, in that it is contemplative. This woman is Martha who received Christ and was concerned with many things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The blessed Virgin brought forth that price as strong and holy with the holiness of prompt obedience. Whence in Ecclesiasticus: "Everlasting foundations upon a solid rock, and the commandments of God in the heart of a holy woman." The Church had to be founded: therefore it was necessary to lay the foundations, namely the commandments of God, and it was necessary that they be placed in some person. This could not be except in the glorious Virgin. He says: "The commandments of God in the heart of a holy woman," that is, of the glorious Virgin. She was not idle, she was not one who knew and did not act, but she was obedient. Therefore in her heart these commandments of God were founded.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture tends to lead back to the first beginning by means of reformation, or it describes eternal things, as in the Laws and Gospels. Hence in the Psalm: "He gave them a duty which shall not pass away." And in Ecclesiasticus: "As everlasting foundations upon a solid rock, so the commandments of God in the heart of a holy woman." This woman is the Church. For it is not to be understood that the Law or the Commandments will pass away, but rather that they will be better served in the fatherland. For they are not served in the same manner under the Old Testament and under the New Testament: they are served better under the New Testament, and yet better still in the fatherland. God indeed lives by these very Laws which He Himself has given.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Ecclesiasticus twenty-seven: On account of want, many have sinned; but nothing that is a way of leading into fault pertains to evangelical perfection: therefore etc.
To that, therefore, which is first objected to the contrary concerning want, that it draws one to sin, and concerning destitution, which causes one to commit perjury, it must be said that want is twofold: one kind is voluntary, and another involuntary. Involuntary want induces a defect of mind and a proneness and occasion to sin. But voluntary want or poverty has sufficiency joined to it, according to that passage of Second Corinthians six: As having nothing, etc. And this disposes one to perfect justice, because it makes the mind fit for every good, just as conversely the root of all evils is avarice. And this is what Chrysostom says, in the forty-seventh homily on Matthew: "If you wish to see the soul of one who loves gold, just as a garment consumed by ten thousand worms and having nothing sound, so will you find it pierced on every side by anxieties and putrefied by sins and full of rust. But the soul of one voluntarily poor is not such, but it shines indeed like gold, and gleams like a pearl, and blooms like a rose. There is no moth there, there is no thief there, there is no anxiety of the affairs of this life, but like an Angel, so does he live. He is not subject to demons, he does not attend upon kings, but attends upon God; he does not wage war with men, but with Angels; he does not have the earth as his treasure, but heaven; he has no need of servants, but rather he has as servants the passions and thoughts that lord over kings. What then is better than this poor man? For his pavement is heaven. But if the pavement is such, imagine the roof. But he does not have horses and a chariot? Yet what need has he of these, who is to be carried upon a cloud and to be with Christ?" From these things it is apparent that in voluntary poverty there is great sufficiency, great nobility, which makes one transcend all earthly things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And Ecclesiasticus says: "If you do not hold yourself steadfastly in the fear of the Lord, your house will quickly be overturned." Consider David, who says: "Serve the Lord in fear, and rejoice in him with trembling."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But as soon as the soul has been made to resemble God, it enters into that Wisdom, because "She is the refulgence of eternal light, the spotless mirror of the power of God." And consequently, "she passes into holy souls from age to age." Without holiness, a man cannot be wise. "A holy man continueth in wisdom as the sun: but a fool is changed as the moon." Holiness is an immediate disposition toward wisdom: hence a yearning and a strong desire are the door to wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The sun represents spiritual life, as in Ecclesiasticus: "A holy man continueth in wisdom as the sun; but a fool is changed as the moon." For the sun goes directly through the ecliptic, without ever turning back or stopping.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“O, how few there are who guard the piety of religion! It is said in Ecclesiasticus: "Have mercy on your own soul, pleasing God; and gather and restrain your heart in holiness."
"Have pity on your soul," that is, have piety toward your soul; "pleasing God," namely, that you strive to please God. And how? "Gather and contain your heart in holiness."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Listen in silence, and for your reverence good grace will come to you." The Wise Man exhorts the good hearer to listen silently and with reverence to the word of God; for silence and reverence are not unprofitable to him, because through these good grace will come to him. What is good grace? Good is the grace that makes a man good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"A man experienced in many things will know many things." Understanding which is the gateway of scientific considerations is partly from the frequency of experience. From many sensations arises one memory; from many memories arises one experience; from many experiences arises one universal, which is the principle of art and science.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because it is difficult for a man to be instructed by himself, therefore there is required a counsel by which one is regulated according to the dictate of divinely inspired men. Concerning evil counselors it is written: 'Guard your soul from a counselor. Do not attend to these in every counsel. But be constant with a holy man, whomever you know to observe the fear of God: whose soul is according to your soul.' He gives the reason: because the soul of a holy man at times declares true things more than seven watchmen sitting on high to keep watch, and he sees more than you. We gather from this that one point of counsel consists in this, that a man should not place counsel in himself alone; but he ought to seek counsel from another. Nor does it consist only in this, but also in this, that he know how to discern a counselor and choose the good and flee the evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because it is difficult for a man to be instructed by himself, therefore there is required a counsel by which one is regulated according to the dictate of divinely inspired men. Concerning evil counselors it is written: 'Guard your soul from a counselor. Do not attend to these in every counsel. But be constant with a holy man, whomever you know to observe the fear of God: whose soul is according to your soul.' He gives the reason: because the soul of a holy man at times declares true things more than seven watchmen sitting on high to keep watch, and he sees more than you. We gather from this that one point of counsel consists in this, that a man should not place counsel in himself alone; but he ought to seek counsel from another. Nor does it consist only in this, but also in this, that he know how to discern a counselor and choose the good and flee the evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because it is difficult for a man to be instructed by himself, therefore there is required a counsel by which one is regulated according to the dictate of divinely inspired men. Concerning evil counselors it is written: 'Guard your soul from a counselor. Do not attend to these in every counsel. But be constant with a holy man, whomever you know to observe the fear of God: whose soul is according to your soul.' He gives the reason: because the soul of a holy man at times declares true things more than seven watchmen sitting on high to keep watch, and he sees more than you. We gather from this that one point of counsel consists in this, that a man should not place counsel in himself alone; but he ought to seek counsel from another. Nor does it consist only in this, but also in this, that he know how to discern a counselor and choose the good and flee the evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because it is difficult for a man to be instructed by himself, therefore there is required a counsel by which one is regulated according to the dictate of divinely inspired men. Concerning which it is written: 'Establish with yourself a heart of good counsel.' We gather from this that one point of counsel consists in this, that a man should not place counsel in himself alone; but he ought to seek counsel from another. Nor does it consist only in this, but also in this, that he know how to discern a counselor and choose the good and flee the evil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because it is difficult for a man to be instructed by himself, therefore there is required a counsel by which one is regulated according to the dictate of divinely inspired men. Be constant with a holy man, whomever you know to observe the fear of God: whose soul is according to your soul. He gives the reason: because 'the soul of a holy man at times declares true things more than seven watchmen sitting on high to keep watch,' and he sees more than you. We gather from this that one point of counsel consists in this, that a man should not place counsel in himself alone; but he ought to seek counsel from another.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Ecclesiasticus says: 'Before all works let a true word precede you, and before every act a stable counsel.' The true word, which can neither be deceived nor deceive, is the only-begotten Son of God and his doctrine and his life. Let this word precede you and this stable counsel. Stable counsel is none other than that of my God; 'the counsel of the Lord remains forever.'”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wisdom descends from above as a light to gladden our affective power. "Wine and music gladden the heart, and above both is the love of wisdom." Wine and music gladden the heart, namely from without and according to impressed species, which are not truth itself, but a certain likeness of the thing, nor do they fill the soul, and they gladden not truly but phantastically. But where there is union according to truth, there is delight, where truth flows into the soul and fills it and gladdens it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The figures of Scripture are not arid, since they produce lively growths in us. And in Ecclesiasticus: "Charm and beauty delight the eye, but better than either, the flowers of the field."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is a counsel by which we are raised up to choose what is lawful, what is fitting, and what is expedient according to the resolution of a good will. Whence in Ecclesiasticus: 'Gold and silver are the establishing of the feet, and above both is counsel well-pleasing.' By gold is signified sacred Scripture, by silver the knowledge of philosophy. Each is either speculative or practical. Sacred Scripture is about faith and morals, partly speculative and partly practical. By these sciences the feet are made firm, because the heart is made firm through theological and philosophical teachings; yet counsel makes it more firm.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because the fear of the Lord avails for these three things, namely for obtaining the influx of divine grace, for introducing the rectitude of divine justice, and for attaining the illumination of divine wisdom; therefore Ecclesiasticus says: "The fear of the Lord is like a paradise of blessing."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Sirach 40: My son, in your life do not be in need: for it is better to die than to be in need: therefore it is better to be dead than a beggar.
To that which is objected from Sirach: Son, in your life do not be in want: it must be said that, according to the distinction given above, that word is to be understood of spiritual want with respect to grace, not of bodily want with respect to the sustenance of nature. And that this is true appears from the Gloss: "Do not be in want," says the Gloss, "of virtues or good morals."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"From a garment comes the moth, and from a woman the iniquity of a man."
If we wish to be most precious, we must cling to the price of the most valiant woman, the incorrupt, most obedient, and most loving Virgin. That woman, namely Eve, expels us from paradise and sells us; this one leads us back and redeems us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Some have compassion on their flesh, not on their soul. "The hands of compassionate women have boiled their own children." Such a one is not like the Virgin nor like Christ. "He boils his children" who has no compassion on his own soul, but exposes it to the fire of concupiscence and of infernal torments. Of such a woman it is said: "Better is the iniquity of a man than a woman doing good": you cannot afflict the body too much. Let us not give our body to sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Then, because mercy without emulating rectitude is worthless, there follows: "Of the tribe of Levi, twelve thousand sealed." Levi is understood to mean "added." Levi received the priesthood on account of his zeal, wherefore he killed his idolatrous brother-priests. Phineas likewise obtained the priesthood because of zeal, and Mathathias and his descendants, because of zeal, obtained the priesthood and leadership, and they lasted until Herod. Levi signifies "prelates" who must have the spirit of severity and piety, as did Moses who, in spite of his extreme meekness, broke the tablets. By contrast, Heli, who was remiss, died together with his sons. Hence greater damage comes from a prelate who is merciful and rejects all rigor of discipline than from another who is rigidly merciless. In this sense is the passage of Ecclesiasticus understood: "Better a man's harshness than a woman's indulgence."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Let us take an example in the sun, which signifies in turn the Trinity, the wisdom of the Exemplar, the angelical order, and the Church Triumphant. The reference to the Trinity is found in Ecclesiasticus: "As the rising sun is clear to all, so the glory of the Lord shines upon all His works." The sun has substance, brilliance, and heat: likewise God has the originating principle, the Father; the brilliance, the Son; and the heat, the Holy Spirit. Yet it is the same sun in the sky as regards substance, in the eye as regards light, and in the body as regards heat. This is how a certain blind man was convinced who at one time had seen the sun and stood in the sun, and yet could not understand the Trinity of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In Ecclesiasticus it is written: "The firmament on high is His beauty, the beauty of heaven with its glorious shew." And here, three things are touched upon: loftiness, stability, and beauty. For this vision of faith is lofty, stable and beautiful. This faith is most noble, most solid and most splendid.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And so, first of all there is the heavenly form. For Scripture makes use of all the heavens and the stars. Hence the Psalm: The heavens declare the glory of God, and the firmament proclaims His handiwork. And Ecclesiasticus: The clear vault of the sky shines forth like heaven itself, a vision of glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the second allegory, about the blessed Virgin Mary, it is said in the Psalm: "He has pitched a tent there for the sun." Wherefore she is "as beautiful as the moon, as resplendent as the sun, as awe-inspiring as bannered troops." Hence she is a vessel able to contain light: "The sun, an admirable instrument, the work of the most High — shining gloriously in the firmament of heaven."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, this light sends out three primary radiations, hence in Ecclesiasticus: The sun, three times as much, burneth the mountains. There is, indeed, a truth of things, a truth of signs or words and a truth of behavior. The truth of things is indivision between existence and essence, the truth of words is equality between expression and understanding, the truth of behavior is the rectitude of a morally good life. And these three are the three parts of philosophy which the philosophers did not invent, since they are: but because they already existed in the order of truth, they became the concern of the soul, as Augustine explains.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third anagogy is that the sun represents the loftiness of angels. Hence in Ecclesiasticus: "The sun, three times as much, burneth the mountains, breathing out fiery vapors: and shining with his beams, he blindeth the eyes." For the selfsame and unique divine radiance, received in a threefold manner, brings forth three hierarchies.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such are the three hierarchies which this Sun enlightens in a threefold manner. Hence, the sun, three times as much, burneth the mountains. These are the mountains of Bether, as explained in the Canticle: My lover, like a gazelle or a young stag, upon the mountains of Bether. And it is upon those very mountains that this Sun is sending out its first illuminations.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Sirach says: "Behold the rainbow! Then bless its Maker." The rainbow has several natures and colors. As the sun goes down according to the ten divisions of the clock of Achaz, so does the Incarnate Word through the nine choirs of angels down to man, who is counted tenth. This is the greatest miracle, that God be man, that the first be the last; wherefore all miracles are related to this one.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Piety is profitable for knowing truths, namely salutary truths: whence in Ecclesiasticus: "The Lord made all things, and to those who act piously He gave wisdom." God gives His gifts upon every creature: but the knowledge of truth He gives only to those who act piously. How could one attain to originated things who does not attain to the origin of truth? How would one know the origin of truth who opposes the origin of truth?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second firmness of faith comes from the outstanding reputation of the witnesses. This consists in three things: the high reputation of their merits, miracles and martyrdom. The high reputation of merits belonged to the patriarchs. Hence in Ecclesiasticus: Let us now praise men of renown. The patriarchs did not perform miracles, but they were famous for their merits. They were the beginning of Scriptures which are concerned with the apparitions that occurred to them.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third exercise of the gift of piety is in the abundance of interior compassion. Of this it is said in Ecclesiasticus: "These are men of mercy, whose acts of piety have not failed; with their seed good things endure."
Dearest ones! You ought to run through the lives of the holy Fathers, and you will see that these are men of mercy, namely Noah, Abraham, Moses, Joseph, and Samuel. What was the piety of Noah! For a hundred years he did nothing but build the ark, so that he might save the human race. How great was the piety in the most sacred Abraham! God descended to strike the cities in which there were abominations of sin; and Abraham interceded with the Lord for them and wrested from the Lord that if He should find ten just men in the cities, the Lord would spare them. How great was the piety of Joseph! Who, sold by his brothers — indeed his brothers wanted to kill him — yet he guarded his brothers, governed and enriched them and their sons; and he had piety toward preserving the whole world by gathering and storing grain. How great was the piety of Moses! Who loved the people provoking the Lord and prayed to the Lord for them saying: "Hear me, Lord, this people has sinned: either forgive this people this offense, or if you do not, blot me out of your book which you have written." Bernard gives the example of a woman who has her little child and is outside the house. If it were said to her: leave your little child outside the house, and you enter the house; she would not want to enter the house, such that the child would remain outside. So Moses willed that the Lord would forgive the people their sin, or that He would blot him from the book of life. So it was with Samuel, when the people sought a king; afterwards the people recognized that Samuel had governed the people well, and when the people had sinned, they feared that Samuel would not want to pray to the Lord for them. And the people asked him to pray for them, and Samuel said: "Far be it from me that I should cease to pray for you." Of how great piety was David, king of Israel! Saul was seeking to kill him, and David had Saul in his hand: he could have killed him, with God not prohibiting it, because God said to him: "I will deliver him into your hands." He could have killed him, with no man prohibiting it, nor the law prohibiting it; and yet he spared him and his house. These therefore are men of mercy, whose acts of piety did not fail.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There were two to whom the Lord gave fortitude, namely Caleb and Joshua. And it is said of Joshua that he became "mighty in war." Joshua is interpreted as "salvation." These men, for the salvation of others, went about to explore the promised land.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There were two to whom the Lord gave fortitude, namely Caleb and Joshua. Of Caleb it is said: "The Lord gave fortitude to Caleb himself, and even unto old age his strength remained with him, that he might ascend to the high place of the land." Caleb is interpreted as "whole heart." These men, for the salvation of others, went about to explore the promised land.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The exercise of piety consists first in the reverence of divine veneration. Whence in Ecclesiasticus it is said of Josiah that he took away the abominations of impiety and governed his heart unto the Lord, and in the days of sinners he strengthened piety. It is certain that before the coming of Christ, the worship of God did not flourish except among the Israelite people, and it did not flourish in the whole people, because the ten tribes in the time of Jeroboam worshiped idols, namely the golden calf; nor did the worship of God flourish even throughout the whole time in the two tribes, because David was the best worshiper of God, but afterward came Manasseh, the worst, who made the people commit idolatry; but after him came Josiah, who began to reign in his eighth year and took away all idolatry, and in the days of sinners he strengthened piety, that is, divine worship.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The foundation of virtue is faith, and we place it as a center. Faith is "as the morning star in the midst of a cloud." To this star the Christian rises after being lifted up from the waters of baptism. He enters darkness, and this darkness of faith is accompanied by a mysterious light. Now this foundation is that by which Christ is established in us. Through it faith goes forward by rising to the practical virtues, as if reaching the foot of the mountain where Moses offered twelve sacrifices; then it proceeds to the cleansing virtues as if at mid-slope, and finally to the virtues of the cleansed soul as at the mountain's top, a place well suited to the contemplation of the exemplary virtues.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Transgressors of the commandments plunge into abominable crimes: whence in Baruch: "We have not obeyed the voice of the Lord, that we should walk in His commandments, and we have gone away each one into the sense of his own malicious heart."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“No one rightly walks the path of virtue unless he renders the honor due to God: but he who vilifies himself for God's sake is the one who honors God. This is proved by what is said in Ecclesiasticus 3: Great is the power of God alone, and He is honored by the humble: and Baruch 2: The soul that is sorrowful over the greatness of evil and goes bowed down and feeble, and the failing eyes, and the hungering soul gives You glory and justice, O Lord.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Learn where prudence is, where virtue is, where understanding is, so that you may know at the same time where length of life and sustenance is, where the light of the eyes and peace is." Prudential understanding instructs what is to be awaited, namely the highest good. "Length of days is in her right hand," and "With you is the fountain of life." If you have the light of the eyes, you will act prudently.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This virtue gives nobility to the soul. But because at times a man may be indignant at another, there is need for gentleness, which is the remedy against irascibility and anger—not that man should never be angry at all, but that he should be so only in the right circumstances of place and time. Hence, he must have both the face of a man and the face of a lion. At times, however, you believe a man to be kind when he remains silent while knowing of another's sin. Such is not kindness. Listen, therefore: it is said of Jesus that He was troubled, and that He made a kind of whip. Hence, in the First Book of the Machabees, it is written: Woe is me! Wherefore was I born to see the ruin of my people and the ruin of the holy city? Jesus is the Lamb and the Lion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This fortitude ought to be in every Christian and especially in the leader of the army of the Christian people. It is written in the book of Maccabees that "Judas, strong in might from his youth, let him be your prince of the army, and he shall wage the war of the people." Everyone who receives the care of souls becomes a prince of the army; and when the prince is not good, then the army is in great danger.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If we wish to describe fortitude rightly, we must note that it is from heaven. Whence in the book of Machabees: "The victory of war is not in the multitude of the army, but strength is from heaven." Therefore fortitude is a gift of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is said in the book of Maccabees: "When the holy city was inhabited in peace, and the laws were very well kept because of the piety of Onias and the souls that held evil in hatred: it came to pass that kings and pontiffs held the place in reverence and honored it with many gifts." Afterwards Menelaus and his men entered the temple, and Antiochus contaminated the temple. I believe that the impediment was that the Holy Spirit was not among the people, because the impediment was in the pastor.
The oil of piety ought to be especially in the hearts of pontiffs. Whence pontiffs are anointed on the head, and once anointed, they ought afterwards to purify all of the people.
Blessed Gregory was noble and wealthy: he founded and endowed seven monasteries, and in the seventh in the city of Rome he became a monk, afterwards a cardinal, and finally Pope. Blessed Gregory was accustomed, when he was Pope, to have twelve poor persons who ate before him. One day there was among those twelve one who sometimes appeared as a young man, sometimes with venerable white hair. After the meal Blessed Gregory arose and led him into his chamber and asked who he was. He answered: I am that shipwrecked man to whom you showed mercy near the seaport. I said that my ship had been imperiled, and I asked alms from you, by which I might sustain myself. You had fifty gold coins given to me, and afterwards all the silver dishes that were in your house: and then I knew that the eternal God had disposed you for this honor, and that by dispensation you came to this dignity, so that you might give much for God. And Blessed Gregory said: who are you? He answered: I am His Angel. And Blessed Gregory was terrified, because he saw an Angel: and thus he was consoled, because works of piety are so pleasing to God. Martin and Nicholas, because they were men of mercy, therefore from their tombs oil flows.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The gift of fortitude is given for enduring worldly tribulations. Whence it is said in the book of Maccabees that Eleazar, when he departed from life, leaving behind an example of fortitude for the young and the old, said: "Gladly for love of you do I suffer these things." He could have been freed if he had pretended to have eaten pork; but he refused, nay rather he chose to die and to leave behind an example of fortitude for others.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third grief is that of zeal for the divine honor. Whence in the book of Maccabees: "Thou, O Lord, who hast knowledge, knowest that whereas I might be delivered from death, I endure hard pains of body; but according to the soul, on account of thy fear, I willingly suffer these things." Eleazar spoke these words when he preferred to die rather than to make a pretense of eating swine's flesh. Philosophy does not teach this, that for the sake of a conclusion I should expose myself to death.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The gift of fortitude is given for enduring worldly tribulations. Whence it is said in the book of Maccabees that Eleazar, when he departed from life, leaving behind an example of fortitude for the young and the old, said: "Gladly for love of you do I suffer these things." He could have been freed if he had pretended to have eaten pork; but he refused, nay rather he chose to die and to leave behind an example of fortitude for others.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is certain that God created all things. And therefore that good woman said to her son in the book of Maccabees that he should look upon all things, "because God created them from nothing." For God is the cause of all things in whole; therefore he produces them not from himself, not from something else, because nothing else exists; therefore from nothing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third benefit of the gift of piety is that it makes one attain every good. Whence it is said in the book of Maccabees that Judas considered "that those who had fallen asleep with piety carried away the finest grace."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Scriptures in the New Testament are either legal as in the Gospels where commands are established, or historical as in the Acts of the Apostles, or sapiential as in the Epistles of Paul to which should be added the Canonical Letters, or prophetical as in the Apocalypse. Although the Epistles are placed after the Gospels, the Acts of the Apostles follow the Gospels immediately. "In the former book, O Theophilus, I spoke of all that Jesus did and taught."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In order to raise us to hope, he ascended to the heavenly glory which we hope for. But because hope does not arise except from faith in future immortality, therefore he did not ascend immediately, but with an interval of forty days interposed, in which through many signs and proofs he established the true resurrection, by which the mind might be strengthened in faith and lifted up to hope for heavenly glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And this is the reasoning Christ used, during forty days appearing to them. "Did not the Christ have to suffer these things before entering into His glory?" Concerning this central position, John writes: "When it was late, Jesus came and stood in their midst and said to them, 'Peace be to you!'" He is showing two things here, the loftiness of the state of glory, in that, being impassible and immortal, He entered as God while the doors were closed; later, He showed them His hands and side and forced Thomas to confess: "My Lord and my God!"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Before the sending of the Holy Spirit, there was neither the full gift of the Holy Spirit for confirmation and public confession of the name of Christ, nor the plenary anointing of the mind for departure; therefore Christ only initiated and intimated these two Sacraments, namely confirmation and extreme unction. Confirmation he initiated by laying his hand on the little ones and by foretelling that the disciples would be baptized with the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ was such a Center in His ascension. Hence it is written in Acts: "A cloud took Him out of their sight." Likewise the Christian must rise "from strength to strength," and not stand still at the terminal point of virtue, for by so doing he would cease to be virtuous.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“At first He had given the Holy Spirit to the world in a secret way, but He did it manifestly after He had ascended on high, for this Holy Spirit was the cleansing, enlightening, and perfecting Hierarch, and the Holy Spirit came down into the heavenly and sub-heavenly hierarchies. And so, "suddenly there came a sound from heaven, as of a violent wind." The Holy Spirit came down as a means of cleansing: hence, the "violent wind"; as a means of instruction, hence "there appeared to them parted tongues as of fire"; as a means of perfection, hence the tongues of fire "settled upon each of them." From Him come forth the free gifts of grace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To appear denotes a sensible effect with express signification, as the Holy Spirit appeared in a dove. And since, just as the divine persons are distinct, so they can be distinctly signified both by signs and by names, therefore any person can appear by itself, and apparition can belong to all, whether together or to any one by itself. Whence that the Holy Spirit is said to have appeared in tongues of fire and in a dove, this is not on account of a new bond or a special effect, but on account of the union which exists between the thing signified and the sign specially and by manner and origin assigned to it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“After an interval of ten days, He sent upon the Apostles the promised Holy Spirit, through whom the Church of the nations was gathered together and ordered according to the diverse distributions of offices and graces.
In order to inflame to charity, he sent the fire of the Holy Spirit on the day of Pentecost. And because no one is filled with this fire unless he asks, seeks, and knocks with an urgent and importunate desire of hope: therefore he did not send it immediately after the ascension, but with an interval of ten days interposed, in which the disciples, fasting, praying, and groaning, disposed themselves for the reception of the Holy Spirit. And through this, just as he observed the due hour in suffering, so also in rising, so in ascending into heaven, so in sending the Holy Spirit, both on account of the foundation of the three aforesaid virtues and on account of the many mysteries that are implied in these times.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“At first He had given the Holy Spirit to the world in a secret way, but He did it manifestly after He had ascended on high, for this Holy Spirit was the cleansing, enlightening, and perfecting Hierarch, and the Holy Spirit came down into the heavenly and sub-heavenly hierarchies. And so, "suddenly there came a sound from heaven, as of a violent wind." The Holy Spirit came down as a means of cleansing: hence, the "violent wind"; as a means of instruction, hence "there appeared to them parted tongues as of fire"; as a means of perfection, hence the tongues of fire "settled upon each of them." From Him come forth the free gifts of grace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the power that restores us is the power of the whole Trinity, which holy mother Church believes in the mind, confesses in word, and professes in sign, under the distinction and property, order and natural origin of the three persons: hence it is that for the expression of these things in the Sacrament which is the first of all Sacraments, and in which this power operates firstly and principally, there ought to be an expression of the Trinity in a distinct, proper, and ordered naming, as regards the common form, although in the time of the primitive Church it could be done in the name of Christ, in which the understanding of the Trinity is enclosed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It should be noted that the Church was placed in paradise, like the first man, "to till it," in such a way that no one would say "that anything he possessed" was "his own." For it began in a state of great perfection that is observed today in the religious life, for the love of Christ was still recent, and in those days "a large number also of the priests accepted the faith." This Church, meaning the one that began with the Jews, because they were converted at one time by the three thousand, and at another, by the five thousand, possessed the "tree of life," that is, faith, because "My just one lives by faith." It also had the "tree of knowledge," that is, the Law, which remained with them for seeing and reading, and not for eating. Much more: for "the day you eat of it, you must die." And so you may see the tree of knowledge, but not eat of it, or else you would destroy what Christ had done; and death would necessarily come in, for "the letter kills." Hence Paul says: "I, Paul, tell you that if you be circumcised, Christ will be of no advantage to you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Those who are placed in charge of governing others ought to have mercy. "Consider therefore, brethren, from among you men of good testimony, full of the Holy Spirit and wisdom, whom we may appoint over this work" of distribution. He would not be a wise steward who would steal the goods of God. If something were given to you to distribute to a household, and you were to steal it and put it in your purse: do you not believe that the household of the lord would cry out against you and call you the worst steward, and the lord would say: "Cast the unprofitable servant into the outer darkness"? The greatest wisdom that can exist is that the steward fruitfully expend what he has to distribute, and what has been entrusted to him for distribution. Such were blessed Stephen and Lawrence. The supreme pontiffs in the primitive Church did not occupy themselves with these earthly things: now there is concern for having temporal goods, not for distributing them.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It should be noted that the Church was placed in paradise, like the first man, "to till it," in such a way that no one would say "that anything he possessed" was "his own." For it began in a state of great perfection that is observed today in the religious life, for the love of Christ was still recent, and in those days "a large number also of the priests accepted the faith." This Church, meaning the one that began with the Jews, because they were converted at one time by the three thousand, and at another, by the five thousand, possessed the "tree of life," that is, faith, because "My just one lives by faith." It also had the "tree of knowledge," that is, the Law, which remained with them for seeing and reading, and not for eating. Much more: for "the day you eat of it, you must die." And so you may see the tree of knowledge, but not eat of it, or else you would destroy what Christ had done; and death would necessarily come in, for "the letter kills." Hence Paul says: "I, Paul, tell you that if you be circumcised, Christ will be of no advantage to you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third high reputation concerns merits, miracles and martyrdom. And this certainty of truth appears when a man wills to die for the truth he preaches, such as Isaiah who was cut up, Ezechiel who was killed, Jeremiah and also the other prophets. Which of the prophets have not your fathers persecuted? If heretics claim they too died for the truth and gained merits, yet they do not have the third requirement, miracles. For it was never heard that a heretic performed a miracle either before, after, or at the time of his death.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If you take a straight look at the leaders of the city, the foremost chief is Christ. In terms of the fight, although the angels and the saints help, yet the principal contender is Christ. Hence, in the Psalm: "I set the Lord ever before me; with Him at my right hand I shall not be disturbed." And again, in the Acts: "Behold, I see the heavens opened, and the Son of Man standing at the right hand of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Only a wretched man sells the grace bestowed upon him. Whence did this selling first enter? Surely from Simon the magician, to whom the Apostle Peter said: "May your money perish with you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such cupidity must be tamed by munificence, which includes generosity and magnificence. It is the fountain which pours out water: for the fountain does not keep water within. According to the Philosopher, it is hard to be completely cured from cupidity, for cupidity is delightful in that it makes a man imagine himself to be great, and makes others believe that he is. If a man indulges in excesses, his brain suffers: but a man rejoices in riches because they lead to presumption and reputation. And so, such cupidity infected Giezi, and he became a leper because he ran after Naaman. Even today those who practice simony consider it quite the right thing. Simon came to Peter and said to him: "Accept some money: I have enough. Grant that I may give the Holy Spirit through the laying of hands." But Peter did not consider it right, nor did he have any patience: "Thy money," he said, "go to destruction with thee."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third certainty derives from an intellectual vision combined with bodily vision. This occurred in the minds of the apostles. What was from the beginning, what we have heard, what we have seen with our eyes, what we have looked upon and our hands have handled, the Word of Life. And we announce to you nothing else than what we have seen. And in the Acts: He charged us to testify. And the blessed Virgin Mary, the teacher of the Apostles and Evangelists, came in contact with this Word in her womb and on her lap.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This faith is most noble, most solid and most splendid. Many possess it, however, without knowing it, for the face of faith is covered: it wears a kind of dark veil. It turns sinful souls into the most exalted. Hence, in the Acts, "He cleansed their hearts by faith."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Few indeed are those who know that they attain those reasons: indeed, what is more, few are those who are willing to believe this, because it seems difficult to an intellect not yet elevated to contemplate eternal things that it should have God so present and so near, even though Paul says in Acts, chapter seventeen, *that He is not far from each one of us.*”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"In him we live and move and have our being." Augustine says that the Apostle does not speak there of corporeal life, but of intellectual life. Whence he speaks there of God, according as he is for all things "the cause of being, the reason of understanding, and the order of living." He is the cause of being, immediately producing all perpetual things, and mediately temporal things, yet immediately through elemental powers. He is the reason of understanding, because through him intelligences are made certain beyond the mutability of nature. If all creatures were to assail, God is nonetheless to be loved: nor can God bring it about that he is not to be loved. Though all things be corrupted, the certitude of truth remains. God is also the order of living: unless the gift of the Holy Spirit dwells in a man, he will not be governed according to the rule of upright life. Insofar as God is the cause of being, he enters the soul as its principle; but insofar as he is the order of living, he enters the soul as an infused gift: insofar as he is the reason of understanding, he enters the soul as the sun of intelligence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Acts 20: It is more blessed to give than to receive: but giving alms does not make a man attain evangelical perfection: therefore much less does receiving.
To the objection that it is more blessed to give than to receive: it must be said that this is true when the acceptance of alms comes from the necessity of nature; but not when it comes from the supererogation of justice, according to the distinction made in the principal solution. And that this is true appears from what is said in the book On Ecclesiastical Dogmas: "It is good to distribute one's resources to the poor with careful dispensation, but it is better, for the intention of following the Lord, to give all at once and, freed from anxiety, to be in want with Christ." Augustine himself says this in the book On the Good of Marriage, as was cited in the preceding question.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A promissory oath is made in three ways, namely for promoting good, for preserving fidelity, and for entering into mutual peace. In the first way, inferiors swear to superiors; in the second way, equals to equals; in the third way, superiors to inferiors. By the first oath the Apostle swore, saying: "God is my witness, whom I serve in my spirit." From this first oath a threefold benefit results: faith in the intellect, love in the affections, and peace in effect.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If, now, it is considered as fulfilling or perfecting, this again is threefold: it may be seen as vital food for the militant and triumphant Church, as the punishment of crimes, and as the final reward. It is fitting that God be first; hence He is credible and understandable, and this in terms of influence by reason of the laws of mercy, justice and peace; in relation to the first, as Virtue; in relation to the second, as Truth; in relation to the third, as Equity. These are the twelve gates that are mentioned in the psalm: "Open to me the gates of justice," for "He who is just lives by faith."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“They did not know the disease because they were unaware of its cause. If, indeed, as the philosophers say, the soul is naturally united to the body, it does not contract a disease—otherwise God would be wasting beings instead of preserving them. But this comes about through sin, from the first principle, that is, Adam. But the fact that Adam ate of the forbidden tree cannot be known through reason, but only by hearing: and so faith is necessary. Wherefore, they did not reach the cause of the disease because they did not believe the prophets. As Augustine says in the thirteenth book, nineteenth chapter, of his work "On the Trinity," "These are the foremost philosophers of the Gentiles, who could see God's invisible attributes, being understood through the things that are made. Yet, because they philosophized without the Mediator, that is, without the man Christ, whom they did not accept as the One who was to come to the prophets and who did come to the apostles, in wickedness they hold back the truth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These are the nine luminaries enlightening the soul, to wit, the truth of things, words and actions: of things, that is, of essences, of figures, and of natures: in their "suchness" referring to hidden differences, in their quantity referring to manifest proportions, in their nature referring to mixed properties. The truth of words is threefold, in regard to expressions, arguments, and persuasions: first, in regard to expressions concerning mental concepts; second, in regard to arguments drawing rational agreement; third, in regard to persuasions producing inclinations of the heart. The first is the object of grammar, the second of logic, and the third of rhetoric. The truth of actions is threefold: in regard to proprieties, activities, and lawful relationships. Proprieties are concerned with the observance of conventions; activities depend upon intellectual speculations; relationships are based on civil law. Philosophers offered these nine sciences and gave examples of them. But God has manifested it to them. Later, they sought to reach wisdom, and truth was leading them: and they promised to procure wisdom, that is, beatitude, that is, an intellect having attained its goal. They promised it, I mean, to those who would follow them.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Although God is simple and uniform in himself, nevertheless in a certain way he is hidden and in a certain way is manifest, as the Apostle intimates in Romans 1: What is known of God is manifest in them. For to some the trinity of appropriated attributes is manifest, to whom the trinity of persons is not manifest; and to someone the unity of essence is manifest, to whom the trinity of appropriated attributes is not manifest; and to someone the very trinity of God is manifest, to whom the very unity of essence is not manifest. But this is what is first manifest concerning God, namely his very entity, and in this respect it does not lie hidden but lies open; and therefore it is not doubtable but indubitable.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As the Apostle says in Romans, chapter one, *that which is known of God is manifest in them:* although God is simple and uniform, nevertheless that eternal light and that exemplar represents certain things as it were *exteriorly* and *openly,* but certain things more *profoundly* and *hiddenly.* The first are those things which come about according to the necessary ordering of the divine art; but the second are those which come about according to the disposition of the hidden will. And that which is called a *voluntary* mirror — this is not with respect to exemplified things in the first way, but in the second: and therefore in the eternal reasons, natural things are known by the natural judgment of reason, but supernatural and future things only by the gift of supernal revelation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since it is fitting that these invisible things of God be manifested through works, therefore God, originating this sensible world, so produced, so governs, so restores, so rewards and consummates it, that in production supreme power is manifested, in governance wisdom, in restoration clemency, and in retribution consummated justice. Therefore, that power might be manifested, he produced all things from nothing for his own praise, glory, and honor, making something close to nothing, namely corporeal matter, and something close to himself, namely spiritual substance, and joining these together in one man in the unity of nature and person, namely the rational soul and corporeal matter. That wisdom might be manifested, he indeed governs all things most providently and in order. For he himself rules the highest part of man through himself, namely the mind, which he illumines, and the lowest part, namely the body, through the free choice of the will, so that the body and bodily things as regards governance may be subject to the spirit, and the spirit to God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For "since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen—His everlasting power also and divinity—being understood through the things that are made": God's "everlasting power" and His "divinity" are understood through their effect, since God is the Cause of all things, and all things are made by this power of His. And this is contrary to the theory of the philosophers who deny that things endowed with many forms can proceed from one and the same Being, that temporal things can proceed from the Eternal, possible things from the most Actual, changing things from the most Stable, composite things from the most Simple, lowly things from the supremely High: since the effect reflects the cause, and the opposite is true in these cases.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“They did not know the disease because they were unaware of its cause. If, indeed, as the philosophers say, the soul is naturally united to the body, it does not contract a disease—otherwise God would be wasting beings instead of preserving them. But this comes about through sin, from the first principle, that is, Adam. But the fact that Adam ate of the forbidden tree cannot be known through reason, but only by hearing: and so faith is necessary. Wherefore, they did not reach the cause of the disease because they did not believe the prophets. As Augustine says in the thirteenth book, nineteenth chapter, of his work "On the Trinity," "These are the foremost philosophers of the Gentiles, who could see God's invisible attributes, being understood through the things that are made. Yet, because they philosophized without the Mediator, that is, without the man Christ, whom they did not accept as the One who was to come to the prophets and who did come to the apostles, in wickedness they hold back the truth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From all of which it is gathered that the invisible things of God, from the creation of the world, being understood through those things which have been made, are clearly seen: so that those who are unwilling to attend to these things and to know, bless, and love God in all of them are without excuse, since they are unwilling to be transferred from darkness into the admirable light of God. But thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord, who from darkness has transferred us into His admirable light, while through these lights given outwardly to the mirror of our mind, in which divine things shine forth, we are disposed to re-enter.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That the divine being is eternal, the authority of Scripture demonstrates this, Exodus 15: The Lord shall reign forever and ever; and Romans 1: His eternal power also and divinity. The truth of the faith also demonstrates this: "Eternal the Father," it says in the Athanasian Creed, "eternal the Son, eternal the Holy Spirit." Likewise, the necessity of reason concludes this same thing. For everything that is its own being is eternal; for being cannot not be, therefore it can neither begin nor cease, and thus it lacks a beginning and an end: if therefore God, since he is most simple, is his own being, indeed is simply being itself; therefore he is altogether eternal.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Grant that a man possess natural and metaphysical knowledge, which extends itself to the highest substances, and that a man arrive there so as to rest there: it is impossible that he not fall into error, unless he be aided by the light of faith—namely, that a man believe God to be triune and one, most powerful and most good according to the ultimate outpouring of goodness. If you believe otherwise, you are mad concerning God: what is proper to God you attribute to another, you blaspheme and are an idolater, just as if a man should attribute the simplicity of God or things of this kind to another.
Therefore this knowledge cast down and darkened the philosophers, because they did not have the light of faith. Whence the Apostle: "Who, when they had known God, did not glorify him as God, or give thanks: but became vain in their thoughts, and their foolish heart was darkened: professing themselves to be wise, they became fools."
Philosophical knowledge is a way to the other sciences: but he who wishes to remain there falls into darkness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The philosophers have offered nine sciences and promised a tenth: contemplation. But many philosophers, while attempting to avoid the darkness of error, have themselves become involved in major errors. While professing to be wise, they have become fools. Because they boasted of their knowledge, these philosophers have become the likes of Lucifer.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Everything that is adored other than God is either an intellectual creature, such as angels and demons; or a corporeal creature, such as heaven and earth and water and the like; or it is a figment of the human mind. Concerning idolatry with respect to corporeal nature, the Apostle says: Who exchanged the glory of the incorruptible God — and it follows: And they served the creature rather than the Creator. Behold, the true adoration of God is here implied, and all idolatry is prohibited.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Everything that is adored other than God is either an intellectual creature, such as angels and demons; or a corporeal creature, such as heaven and earth and water and the like; or it is a figment of the human mind. Concerning idolatry with respect to corporeal nature, the Apostle says: Who exchanged the glory of the incorruptible God — and it follows: And they served the creature rather than the Creator. Behold, the true adoration of God is here implied, and all idolatry is prohibited.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the first word: You shall not have strange gods before me, all profane pacts with demons are prohibited, whether they be made through incantations of words, or through inscriptions of characters or images, or through immolations of sacrifices. In these three consist all the parts of the magical art. And thus by prohibiting these three, all things are prohibited from which all profane pacts with demons arise, whether they be made for the transmutation of natures, as the magicians of Pharaoh did; or for the deception of the senses, as illusionists do; or for the investigation of future contingencies. All these Augustine calls pacts with demons, because in such things there is attributed to the creature what ought to be attributed to the Creator. Concerning such persons it is said: They provoked him with strange gods, and stirred him to anger with him who was not God. Whence such persons fall into the hands of demons; the Apostle: God delivered them up to shameful passions, that is, he permitted them to be delivered up, their sins demanding it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Certain things are sins in such a way that they are also the punishment of sin. In a special manner, those are called sins and punishments of sin which have joined to them sorrow and sadness, such as envy, sloth, and the like. Less specially, those are so called which have joined to them either the mere depravation of nature or disgrace, as are those with respect to which the sinner is said to be given over to a reprobate mind. But generally, sins which are between the first apostasy and the final punishment of hell can be called both sins and the punishment of sin, according to what Gregory says, that crimes are punished by crimes. Although the same thing may be called both sin and the punishment of sin, it must nevertheless be held that every punishment insofar as it is punishment is just and from God; but no fault is just nor from God, but only from the free choice of the will.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Apostle to the Romans: "Do you not know that the kindness of God leads you to repentance? But according to your hardness and impenitent heart, you treasure up for yourself wrath on the day of wrath and of the revelation of the just judgment of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Through piety the incarnate Son of God assumed flesh, ascended the cross, was raised from the dead, sent the Holy Spirit upon the earth, called the Church to himself, and freed all the worthy from misery through piety. The Apostle to the Romans says: "Do you despise the riches of his goodness and patience and longsuffering? Do you not know that the kindness of God leads you to repentance? But according to your hardness and impenitent heart, you treasure up for yourself wrath in the day of wrath and of the revelation of the just judgment of God." The Son of God offered a holocaust, namely himself for us: this is the great sacrament of piety.
This sacrament is repeated daily upon the altar. For these reasons he gave us the Sacrament of the altar, so that, mindful of the sacrament of piety, we might put on the bowels of piety. Cruel is the heart that is not softened by these things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Apostle to the Romans: "Do you not know that the kindness of God leads you to repentance? But according to your hardness and impenitent heart, you treasure up for yourself wrath on the day of wrath and of the revelation of the just judgment of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second benefit of keeping the commandments of God is the understanding of the sacred Scriptures. Gregory says that "by hearing God's precepts the disciples were not illuminated, but by doing them they were illuminated"; because "not the hearers of the law only, but the doers shall be justified." On account of this James says: "Be doers of the word of God and not hearers only, deceiving yourselves." When a man hears the word of God, it seems to him that he understands it well, but it immediately departs; but when he puts it to experience by working well, then he understands it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Scripture shut up all things under sin, the first through ignorance, the second through weakness, and the third through malice, so that when Christ came, He could have mercy on them all. And the Apostle wonders at this, and quotes the authority of the Psalm: "All alike have gone astray; they have become perverse; there is not one that does good, not even one."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Where there is no fear, there is neither wisdom nor justice nor grace. "Their throat is an open sepulchre, the poison of asps is under their lips, with their tongues they acted deceitfully, their feet are swift to shed blood: whose mouth is full of cursing and bitterness, destruction and unhappiness are in their ways"; "there is no fear of God before their eyes." When a man does not have the fear of God, then his sense is turned to malice and goes forth like the poison of asps. There follows iniquity in deed: whence he says: "With their tongues they acted deceitfully, their feet are swift to shed blood." When a man is disordered in affection with respect to thought, in speech with respect to utterance, and in deed with respect to effect; then he has nothing good. Whence he says: "Their feet are swift to shed blood. Destruction and unhappiness are in their ways, and the way of peace they have not known," namely the way of the grace of the Holy Spirit. And why? Because "there is no fear of God before their eyes."
If you wish to strive to have grace, justice, and wisdom, and these cannot be had without fear: therefore the fear of God is necessary for you. Likewise, where there is no fear, there is foolishness, malice, and iniquity, destruction and unhappiness: but these are to be fled as the worst things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since from the beginning Christ was most holy, he could not advance in holiness for himself. He merited, however, for us, who by his merit are justified through grace, advance in justice, and are crowned with eternal glory.
And through this, all our merits are rooted in the merit of Christ, whether satisfactory for punishment or meritorious of eternal life, because we are worthy neither to be absolved from offense against the highest good, nor to gain the immensity of the eternal reward, which is God, except through the merit of the God-man.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first fruit of grace is the remission of guilt. Whence the Apostle to the Romans: "Justified by faith, let us have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom also we have access by faith into this grace, in which we stand and glory in the hope of the glory of the sons of God." As the Philosopher holds, one is not changed from viciousness to virtues except through habituation to the contrary habit; so guilt will never be remitted except through grace. The Philosopher considers vice insofar as it denotes a certain disorder; when I have knowledge of God, I judge concerning sin, that it is an offense against God; for "by transgression of the law you dishonor God;" whence it is necessary that you be subject to the vengeance of God. He who is disordered in guilt must necessarily be subject to punishment. Sin is subject to divine vengeance; therefore the punishment must be eternal, because the offense is infinite. For the offense is as great as he who is offended; but God is immeasurable, and his majesty is infinite: therefore the offense too is infinite: therefore the punishment too is infinite, not intensively, but processively: because it is impossible for a created active power to be infinite. It is necessary, therefore, that an eternal power operate: but God is infinite: therefore if he himself changes the soul, this must be done through some influx of grace. Likewise, hell is not remitted except through grace. See therefore how grace liberates from the servitude of sin and of the devil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The first fruit of grace is the remission of guilt. Whence the Apostle to the Romans: "Justified by faith, let us have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom also we have access by faith into this grace, in which we stand and glory in the hope of the glory of the sons of God." As the Philosopher holds, one is not changed from viciousness to virtues except through habituation to the contrary habit; so guilt will never be remitted except through grace. The Philosopher considers vice insofar as it denotes a certain disorder; when I have knowledge of God, I judge concerning sin, that it is an offense against God; for "by transgression of the law you dishonor God;" whence it is necessary that you be subject to the vengeance of God. He who is disordered in guilt must necessarily be subject to punishment. Sin is subject to divine vengeance; therefore the punishment must be eternal, because the offense is infinite. For the offense is as great as he who is offended; but God is immeasurable, and his majesty is infinite: therefore the offense too is infinite: therefore the punishment too is infinite, not intensively, but processively: because it is impossible for a created active power to be infinite. It is necessary, therefore, that an eternal power operate: but God is infinite: therefore if he himself changes the soul, this must be done through some influx of grace. Likewise, hell is not remitted except through grace. See therefore how grace liberates from the servitude of sin and of the devil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But it is fitting that the seal of truth be impressed upon the soul, by which also the soul becomes "an enclosed garden, a fountain sealed." The first seal consists in its having the indissoluble bond of charity, which occurs when the soul loves in such a way that it says: "Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? Shall tribulation, or distress, or persecution, or hunger," etc. Not that man could never fall away from charity, but when he does, that he never think of sinning. The second [seal] consists in this, that [the soul] has the irrevocable gift of divine charity, so that it loves everything God loves, both friends and enemies, both strangers and neighbors. Hence, "the charity of God is poured forth in our hearts." Through these means, then, the soul diffuses itself in order that it may love every good, and nothing but good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When our mind has been filled with all these intellectual lights, it is inhabited by the divine Wisdom as a house of God, having been made a daughter of God, a spouse and friend; having been made a member of Christ the Head, a sister and co-heir; having been made no less a temple of the Holy Spirit, founded through faith, elevated through hope, and dedicated to God through holiness of mind and body. All of which the most sincere charity of Christ accomplishes, which is poured forth in our hearts through the Holy Spirit, who has been given to us, without which Spirit we cannot know the secrets of God. For just as the things of a man no one can know except the spirit of man which is in him, so also the things of God no one knows except the Spirit of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We therefore must also rise to a new life, so that, just as "Christ rose from the dead, so we too might walk in newness of life." Christ has freed us at this time from the hand of Pharaoh and has led us into the promised land; and as a sign of this the Passover is now eaten, because we have now been set free. We too must make the passage and begin a new life and not return to Egypt. Three things are necessary for any penitent, namely, that sin should displease him, and that he should be prepared to guard himself from sin with the help of God and the Holy Spirit, and that he should wish to make satisfaction according to the measure of his ability, and resolve never to repeat sin. And this is the consummation of these words: we must always be conformed to Christ and be refreshed with him, so that we may arrive at the eternal refreshment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third fruit of grace is the attainment of eternal beatitude. Whence the Apostle to the Romans: "The wages of sin is death: but the grace of God is life eternal." You have the planting of life and of death. The grace of God is life eternal. But what is sin? Surely nothing other than the tree of death. Here is the tree of death, and here is the tree of life; place yourself in the garden where the tree of life is. Foolish would he be who plants the tree of death: if you planted a tree on which you were to be hanged, you would be foolish. The wicked therefore plant that tree of sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“At a later point, the illuminating Law was given, and yet their infirmities were multiplied, and there was an opportunity for a greater transgression of the Law, for "sin, having thus found an occasion, worked in me by means of the commandment all manner of lust." And therefore man had to be convicted of weakness or impotency.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The commandments of God are irreproachable, because they contain nothing unjust: whence the Apostle: "The law indeed is holy, and the commandment holy and just and good."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second appropriation is made to the Eternal Sun insofar as it is the medium that governs all things. In this regard, three [attributes] are appropriated, to wit, piety, truth, and holiness, for all [rightful] governing and law-giving is pious, true, and holy. As it is said in Romans: The law indeed is holy and the commandment holy and just and good. Out of these three come forth three laws, and there cannot be more; that is, [the laws] of nature, of Scripture, and of grace. The law of nature is appropriated to the Father, the law of Scripture to the Word, and the law of grace to the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The law of nature is the law of piety. Now piety is found to exist within every nature, even insensible. Indeed, the root sends to the branches everything it receives; the wellspring pours out to the brooks everything it draws. Likewise, in animals, piety is seen in the relationship between parents and offspring, for whatever they taste and eat that is beyond their need — and even within their need — they convert into milk and food for their young. The law of Scripture is the law of truth, for it consists in a sense in the pronouncement of a true promise. The law of holiness is the law of grace. As it is written in Romans: The law of the Spirit of the life in Christ Jesus has delivered me from the law of sin and of death.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against conjugal chastity it is objected: Romans 8: Those who are in the flesh cannot please God: but by the fact that they exercise the carnal act they are said to be in the flesh: therefore such persons cannot please God: therefore conjugal continence is repugnant to the law of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that which is objected, that those who are in the flesh cannot please God, it must be said that to be in the flesh can denote a relation of matter or of end; insofar as it denotes a relation of matter, it is not reprehensible to be in the flesh, and thus it accords with conjugal chastity and its use; insofar as it denotes a relation of end, as when someone performs carnal works for the sake of the flesh, thus it is culpable: and in this way the Apostle understands it, and in this way it does not arise from conjugal chastity, but rather is against it. Whence Augustine, in the book On the Good of Marriage: "Marriages have this good, that carnal or youthful incontinence, even if it is vicious, is directed to the honorableness of propagating offspring, so that from the evil of lust the conjugal union may produce something good; then, because carnal concupiscence is restrained and in a certain way burns more modestly, being tempered by parental affection. For a certain gravity intervenes in fervent pleasure, when in the very act by which man and woman cleave to one another, they nevertheless consider becoming father and mother." From which it is gathered that marriage is of such great power that it directs the carnal act to spiritual honorableness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If honor and riches: God shall set His good and faithful servants over many things, indeed sons of God and gods they shall be called and shall be, and where His Son shall be, there shall they be also, heirs indeed of God, and co-heirs with Christ. If true security: surely they shall be as certain that these things, or rather this good, shall never and in no way be lacking to them, as they shall be certain that they shall not lose it of their own accord, nor that God who loves them shall take it from His lovers against their will, nor that anything more powerful than God shall separate God and them against their will.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The affective dispositions once ordained must be straightened by these same virtues. These dispositions are four in number: fear, sorrow, joy, and trust. And they are not straightened unless fear is holy, sorrow just, joy true, and trust assured. For if fear is prideful, sorrow unfounded, joy inappropriate, and trust presumptuous, then the affections are distorted. Now these affections cannot be straightened by themselves. Indeed, trust, or hope, is concerned with things unseen, such as the life of beatitude; but this life is given only to those who deserve it; and no one deserves it unless he has sufficient merit. Such things cannot be obtained through the powers of free will: they require God's condescension, that is, grace. The sufferings of the present time are not worthy to be compared to the glory to come.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Although God is most generous and more ready to give than we are to receive, nevertheless He wills to be prayed to by us, so that He may have occasion to bestow the gifts of the grace of the Holy Spirit.
Moreover, He wills to be prayed to not only by mental prayer, which is "the ascent of the intellect to God," but also by vocal prayer, which is "the petition of fitting things from God," not only through ourselves, but also through the Saints as through helpers divinely given to us, so that what we are less worthy to obtain through ourselves we may be able to obtain through the Saints.
And because we know not what we should pray for as we ought, lest we wander in uncertainty, He handed down to us a form in the prayer which He composed, in which under the sevenfold number of petitions the universality of things to be sought is comprehended.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because He ought to have restored while preserving the freedom of the will, He restored by giving a most efficacious example; and that example is most efficacious which invites and instructs toward the summit of the virtues. Now nothing more instructs a person toward virtue than the example of enduring death for the sake of justice and divine obedience—death, I say, not of just any kind, but of the most painful sort. Nothing indeed more invites than such great kindness, by which for us the most high Son of God, without any merits on our part—nay, with many demerits on our part—laid down His life; which kindness is shown to be all the greater, the more grievous and abject the things He endured or willed to suffer for us. For God spared not His own Son, but delivered Him up for us all: how shall He not with Him also freely give us all things? From which we are invited to love Him and to imitate the One we love.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Thoughts about God must be the highest in the order of goodness, because He is the Best, and out of this Goodness He supremely pours Himself and loves. Wherefore He has not spared even His own Son, and by giving Him to us, He gave us all that He knew, all that He could give. The Son said: All things that the Father has are mine. The Father gave us a Son born of us, He gave us One who suffered for us and rose again for our sake, by reason of His very great love wherewith He has loved us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A person is disposed to the influx of the gift of fortitude through the inextinguishable fire of charity. "Love is strong as death": death conquers all, and likewise love conquers all things. Paul, what do you say about charity? "Who," he says, "shall separate me from the charity of God?" He answers: "Tribulation? or distress? or hunger? or nakedness? or danger? or persecution? or the sword?" And he says: "I am certain that neither death nor life nor things present nor things to come shall be able to separate me from the charity which is in Christ Jesus." Chrysostom says that Paul enumerates all creatures and says: "Nor shall any other creature be able to separate me from the charity which is in Christ Jesus": that is, if a creature could be made anew, it could not separate me. This charity draws us to a celestial nature and does not permit any foreign impression upon us: of itself, it is perpetual; unless I give a bill of divorce, God will not take away his charity from us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the summit of faith, which is love, the Apostle says: Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? Shall tribulation, or distress—all the way to the words, which is in Christ Jesus our Lord. And, in another passage, being rooted and grounded in love. That is the firmament of heaven. The heavens proclaim your wonders, that is, the marvels of the soul which they feel within them. Such experiences make faith most secure.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But it is fitting that the seal of truth be impressed upon the soul, by which also the soul becomes "an enclosed garden, a fountain sealed." The first seal consists in its having the indissoluble bond of charity, which occurs when the soul loves in such a way that it says: "Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? Shall tribulation, or distress, or persecution, or hunger," etc. Not that man could never fall away from charity, but when he does, that he never think of sinning. The second [seal] consists in this, that [the soul] has the irrevocable gift of divine charity, so that it loves everything God loves, both friends and enemies, both strangers and neighbors. Hence, "the charity of God is poured forth in our hearts." Through these means, then, the soul diffuses itself in order that it may love every good, and nothing but good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Paul, what do you say about charity? "Who," he says, "shall separate me from the charity of God?" He answers: "Tribulation? or distress? or hunger? or nakedness? or danger? or persecution? or the sword?" And he says: "I am certain that neither death nor life nor things present nor things to come shall be able to separate me from the charity which is in Christ Jesus." Chrysostom says that Paul enumerates all creatures and says: "Nor shall any other creature be able to separate me from the charity which is in Christ Jesus": that is, if a creature could be made anew, it could not separate me. This charity draws us to a celestial nature and does not permit any foreign impression upon us: of itself, it is perpetual; unless I give a bill of divorce, God will not take away his charity from us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Chrysostom says that Paul enumerates all creatures and says: "Nor shall any other creature be able to separate me from the charity which is in Christ Jesus": that is, if a creature could be made anew, it could not separate me. This charity draws us to a celestial nature and does not permit any foreign impression upon us: of itself, it is perpetual; unless I give a bill of divorce, God will not take away his charity from us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since a mean for reconciling is not suitable unless he has in himself both natures, namely the superior and the inferior, the adorable and the adoring; and this can in no way come about except through a supremely condescending and gratuitous union; therefore it is necessary to posit in Christ a grace above every grace, to be venerated with every manner of reverence, which we call the grace of union, by reason of which Christ as man is God blessed above all things, and therefore to be venerated with the worship of latria.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is therefore true what Augustine says, that "He who created you without you will not justify you without you." It is also true that it is not of him who wills nor of him who runs, but of God who has mercy. It is also true that no one can boast of merits, because God crowns nothing in us except his own gifts. For God has reserved to himself the gifts of grace to be freely bestowed, so that man may learn not to be ungrateful nor to glory in himself as though he had not received, but to glory in the Lord.
It is also true that, although free choice cannot of itself fulfill the law nor produce grace within itself, it is nevertheless inexcusable if it does not do what it can, because grace freely given is always at hand for admonition, with the aid of which it can do what lies within itself: which having been done, it may have grace making acceptable: which having been obtained, it may fulfill the divine law and do the will of God: which having been done, it may at last arrive at eternal beatitude on account of meritorious works, which are wholly from grace, and wholly also from free choice, although principally from grace: because, as Augustine says, "grace is compared to free choice as a rider to a horse," which rider indeed directs, leads, and conducts free choice to the harbor of eternal felicity, exercising us in the works of perfect virtue according to the gift of sevenfold grace itself.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fact that the Jews will be converted is certain because of Isaiah and the Apostle who teaches authoritatively: "Though the number of the children of Israel are as the sands of the sea, the remnant shall be saved." And again: "A partial blindness only has befallen Israel, until the full number of the Gentiles should enter." The Jews oppose to the fact that none of the prophesied peace has come about as yet. But the prophet is not speaking of the first advent nor of the first calling, but of the last, when "the Lord will have His day against all that is arrogant." Nor should it be understood that in so doing, the Lord is dismissing these branches.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second key is the understanding of the Incarnate Word, through whom all things are restored. "All things must be fulfilled that are written in the Law of Moses and the Prophets and the Psalms concerning Me. Then He opened their minds, that they might understand the Scriptures." Hence, in the Epistle to the Romans: "Christ is the consummation of the Law unto justice for everyone who believes."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"With the heart a man believes unto justice." Now faith consists more precisely in the confession of truth than in the communication of light. Hence, "with the mouth profession of faith is made unto salvation." Therefore in a certain sense faith sees, and in another it does not see. The merit of faith is founded on non-seeing, the light of faith on believing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is not said, God saw the firmament, but called it, because the solidity of faith consists rather in belief than in contemplation. For belief is through the ear, because, as the Apostle wrote to the Romans, "faith depends on hearing."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fact that the Jews will be converted is certain because of Isaiah and the Apostle who teaches authoritatively: "Though the number of the children of Israel are as the sands of the sea, the remnant shall be saved." And again: "A partial blindness only has befallen Israel, until the full number of the Gentiles should enter." The Jews oppose to the fact that none of the prophesied peace has come about as yet. But the prophet is not speaking of the first advent nor of the first calling, but of the last, when "the Lord will have His day against all that is arrogant." Nor should it be understood that in so doing, the Lord is dismissing these branches.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore when it condemns and reprobates, it operates according to justice: but when it predestines, according to grace and mercy, which does not exclude justice. Because therefore all, insofar as they were of the mass of perdition, deserved to be condemned: therefore more are reprobated than chosen, so that it may be shown that salvation is according to special grace, but damnation according to common justice. Therefore no one can complain about the divine will, because it does all things most rightly; indeed in all things we ought to give thanks and honor the governance of divine providence. But if anyone should ask why it bestows the gift of grace on one sinner rather than another, here it is necessary to impose silence on human loquacity and to exclaim with the Apostle: O the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God, how incomprehensible are his judgments, and unsearchable his ways! For who has known the mind of the Lord, or who has been his counselor, or who has first given to him, and it shall be repaid to him? For from him and through him and in him are all things. To him be glory forever and ever. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“About the height of faith in understanding the eternal God and the depth in knowing God made man, the Apostle writes to the Romans: "Oh, the depth of the riches of the wisdom and of the knowledge of God! How incomprehensible are His judgments and how unsearchable His ways!" Wisdom refers to the understanding of the eternal God, knowledge to the knowing of God made man.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“O the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How incomprehensible are His judgments, and unsearchable His ways! From which it is gathered that those things which pertain to divine wisdom are more comprehensible than the divine judgments; but in John 5 it is said that the Father has given all judgment to the Son, because He is the Son of man; from which it is gathered that the soul of Christ comprehends the divine judgments: therefore if those are less comprehensible than the others, much more strongly does He comprehend all the others.
To that which is objected, that the soul of Christ comprehends all the divine judgments: it can be said that those things are said of the assumed man on account of the communication of idioms; or certainly they are said of those things which are, were, and will be, which indeed can be comprehended by the soul of Christ; but it is not true with respect to all things that the divine wisdom understands, since it knows infinite things, as is clear from what has been determined above.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore when it condemns and reprobates, it operates according to justice: but when it predestines, according to grace and mercy, which does not exclude justice. Because therefore all, insofar as they were of the mass of perdition, deserved to be condemned: therefore more are reprobated than chosen, so that it may be shown that salvation is according to special grace, but damnation according to common justice. Therefore no one can complain about the divine will, because it does all things most rightly; indeed in all things we ought to give thanks and honor the governance of divine providence. But if anyone should ask why it bestows the gift of grace on one sinner rather than another, here it is necessary to impose silence on human loquacity and to exclaim with the Apostle: O the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God, how incomprehensible are his judgments, and unsearchable his ways! For who has known the mind of the Lord, or who has been his counselor, or who has first given to him, and it shall be repaid to him? For from him and through him and in him are all things. To him be glory forever and ever. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore when it condemns and reprobates, it operates according to justice: but when it predestines, according to grace and mercy, which does not exclude justice. Because therefore all, insofar as they were of the mass of perdition, deserved to be condemned: therefore more are reprobated than chosen, so that it may be shown that salvation is according to special grace, but damnation according to common justice. Therefore no one can complain about the divine will, because it does all things most rightly; indeed in all things we ought to give thanks and honor the governance of divine providence. But if anyone should ask why it bestows the gift of grace on one sinner rather than another, here it is necessary to impose silence on human loquacity and to exclaim with the Apostle: O the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God, how incomprehensible are his judgments, and unsearchable his ways! For who has known the mind of the Lord, or who has been his counselor, or who has first given to him, and it shall be repaid to him? For from him and through him and in him are all things. To him be glory forever and ever. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore when it condemns and reprobates, it operates according to justice: but when it predestines, according to grace and mercy, which does not exclude justice. Because therefore all, insofar as they were of the mass of perdition, deserved to be condemned: therefore more are reprobated than chosen, so that it may be shown that salvation is according to special grace, but damnation according to common justice. Therefore no one can complain about the divine will, because it does all things most rightly; indeed in all things we ought to give thanks and honor the governance of divine providence. But if anyone should ask why it bestows the gift of grace on one sinner rather than another, here it is necessary to impose silence on human loquacity and to exclaim with the Apostle: O the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God, how incomprehensible are his judgments, and unsearchable his ways! For who has known the mind of the Lord, or who has been his counselor, or who has first given to him, and it shall be repaid to him? For from him and through him and in him are all things. To him be glory forever and ever. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This threefold radiation may be considered from the viewpoint of the originating principle, from that of the receiving subject, and from that of the object in which it terminates. For it concerns the originating principles in terms of the three causes: the primary (efficient), the exemplar (formal), and the final: For from Him and through Him and unto Him are all things. Hence truth indicates that our mind is carried by a natural inclination to the supreme Truth in that it is the cause of being, the reason of understanding and the norm of life. From the cause of being comes forth the truth of things; from the reason of understanding, the truth of words; from the norm of life, the truth of moral behavior.
On the part of the soul, every radiation of truth over our power of understanding comes about in one of three ways: it shines upon it absolutely, and then refers to things to be seen; or in relation to the interpretative faculty, and then consists in the truth of words; or in relation to the affective or motive faculty, and then it is the truth of things to be done.
It is the same as regards the object. Everything that exists depends upon essence, reason, or will. The first leads to the knowledge of things, the second to the knowledge of words, and the third to the knowledge of behavior. Hence, in relation to the principle, to the subject, and to the object, there is in the soul a threefold radiation of truth through which the soul may be lifted up to eternal matters and also to the cause of all. But if the spice of faith is added, things become easier: the cause of being is then attributed to the Father, the reason of understanding to the Son, and the norm of life to the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, this seven-fold series, either in the sensible world or in the minor world, arises out of the archetypal world, where causal principles exist in a seven-fold series. For God exists by reason of a triple-formed cause, original, exemplary, and final, and He cannot exist in any other mode. Hence the Apostle says: For "from Him and through Him and unto Him are all things." But the principle of causality is dependent upon four things: height of power, depth of wisdom, breadth of benevolence, and length of eternity, so that, as the Apostle says, "you may be able to comprehend with all the saints what is the breadth and length and height and depth." Power creates, wisdom governs, benevolence achieves, and eternity preserves.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Turning back again, let us say: because therefore the most pure and absolute being, which is simply being, is the first and the last, therefore it is the origin and consummating end of all things.
Because eternal and most present, therefore it encompasses and enters all durations, existing as it were simultaneously as their center and circumference.
Because most simple and greatest, therefore it is wholly within all things and wholly beyond all things, and therefore "it is an intelligible sphere whose center is everywhere and whose circumference is nowhere."
Because most actual and most immutable, therefore "remaining stable, it gives motion to all things."
Because most perfect and immense, therefore it is within all things, not enclosed; beyond all things, not excluded; above all things, not elevated; below all things, not cast down.
Because indeed it is supremely one and all-encompassing, therefore it is all things in all, although all things are many and it itself is nothing but one; and this because through most simple unity, most serene truth, and most sincere goodness there is in it all power, all exemplarity, and all communicability; and therefore from him and through him and in him are all things, and this because he is omnipotent, omniscient, and in every way good, which to see perfectly is to be blessed, as was said to Moses: I will show you all good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But because from itself, therefore it lacks a producer and creator: therefore it can neither depend nor begin; and through this it has the highest and most perfect necessity, which excludes all mutability and dependence, inevitability and indigence, coercion and violence, which denote a diminished necessity: and conversely it posits the highest permanence and stability, the highest sufficiency and freedom. For because it is through itself, therefore it is permanent and most stable: because indeed for its own sake, therefore most generous and most sufficient: because indeed it is through itself and for its own sake, therefore it is the alpha and the omega: and therefore all other things are from it, and all other things for the sake of it, whether necessary or contingent. For just as all movable things flow from one first immovable being and are reduced to it; so all contingent things flow from the necessary being and are reduced to it. Therefore the necessity of the divine being is the origin and completion of all being, living and understanding; and all things proclaim that the first principle is necessary, whether they be necessary or contingent.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That widowed continence according to the evangelical law ought to be vowed is shown by authority, as follows. Romans 12: I beseech you to present your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy, pleasing to God; but this is done most especially when the flesh is dedicated to God through the vow of continence: therefore to vow continence is pleasing to God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In another way, that is called right which conforms itself to the one directing it. And according to this, in the consideration of rectitude the order of living is discerned. For he lives rightly who is directed according to the rules of divine law. And this is when the will of man assents to necessary precepts, salutary admonitions, and perfect counsels, so that man may prove what is the good and acceptable and perfect will of God. And then there is a right order of living, in which no crookedness can be found.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Exterior humiliation ought to proceed from interior humility according to the dictate and rule of the divine gift; and this can be done according to the law of divine precept, or of divine good pleasure, or of divine counsel. Precept regards all universally: good pleasure regards those to whom the divine will is specially inspired: counsel indeed regards those who ascend to the summit of perfection. And concerning these three it is said to the Romans: that you may prove what is the good, well-pleasing, and perfect will of God. Rightly therefore does he humble himself who conforms himself to the divine will according to any one of these three modes, according to which the spirit of true humility inclines different persons to different kinds of humiliations.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Faith itself is the basis of all supernatural illuminations as long as we are pilgrims from the Lord, both the foundation that stabilizes, the lamp that directs, and the gate that introduces; and according to its measure the wisdom divinely given to us must also be measured, lest anyone be wise beyond what is fitting to be wise, but unto sobriety, and to each one as God has divided the measure of faith.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This wisdom results from many mysteries of the Scriptures, as out of many mirrors there results a multiplication of light rays and fires. This wisdom is given according to the measure of faith, "according as God has apportioned to each one the measure of faith." For in the measure in which a man seizes the mind, in that measure does he become wiser—and faith is obtained through humility.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wisdom is neither disclosed nor obtained except through faith. For you should not "be more wise than it behooveth to be wise,... according as God hath divided to every one the measure of faith." For faith is not had except through the grace of the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth need is good measure, so that a man seek not to savor beyond his means, but that he do so according to moderation. Do not extend yourself beyond the point your intelligence can reach; but neither remain short of it. Wherefore, in order to make this point, as Dionysius says, the Seraphim flew with their intermediate wings, showing that man should not remain short of his possibilities nor rise beyond them. Likewise, those who sing beyond their range never produce harmony. And Augustine says that those who do not order their studies properly are like colts gamboling hither and thither, while the mare with a steady step goes just where it is good for her to go. This example may be applied to a man of slow intelligence who is able to organize his studies well, as opposed to a man of brilliant intelligence who studies in a disorderly manner.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the father is understood the notion of friendliness: and in this we understand that by reason of origin every person is lovable and ought to be loved, and every person is bound to honor another. Whence the Apostle: In honor anticipating one another; and again: Render to all what is owed; to whom honor, honor. Owe no one anything, except to love one another. For a person ought to love another, willing good to each one with respect to affection, with respect to deed, and with respect to outward expression.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Although diverse persons are bound to diverse others by many bonds to the subjection of obedience, according to what the Apostle says: Let every soul be subject to the higher powers, Romans 13, and this according to the diversity of ranks, offices, and powers: nevertheless all this variety must be reduced to one supreme and first person, in whom the universal sovereignty over all principally resides: not only to God himself and Christ, the mediator of God and men, but also to his Vicar; and this not by human statute, but by divine statute, by which Christ established Peter as the prince of the Apostles.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is necessary to have a just intention, so that the man who is the minister of the law slays a man by law, not from the desire for vengeance, but from the love of justice. Whence the Apostle to the Romans, speaking to rulers, says that "the ruler does not bear the sword without cause. For he is the minister of God, an avenger unto wrath against him who does evil."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the father is understood the notion of friendliness: and in this we understand that by reason of origin every person is lovable and ought to be loved, and every person is bound to honor another. Whence the Apostle: In honor anticipating one another; and again: Render to all what is owed; to whom honor, honor. Owe no one anything, except to love one another. For a person ought to love another, willing good to each one with respect to affection, with respect to deed, and with respect to outward expression.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the father is understood the notion of friendliness: and in this we understand that by reason of origin every person is lovable and ought to be loved, and every person is bound to honor another. Whence the Apostle: In honor anticipating one another; and again: Render to all what is owed; to whom honor, honor. Owe no one anything, except to love one another. For a person ought to love another, willing good to each one with respect to affection, with respect to deed, and with respect to outward expression.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Church is a union of rational men united in harmonious and uniform adherence to divine peace. For the Church in return loves itself. And love is born of obedience to the Law. And the Law itself commands love: Now "the purpose of this charge is charity, from a pure heart and a good conscience and faith unfeigned." And again, "he who loves his neighbor has fulfilled the Law." And this can be proved in the Saviour's own words: "On these two commandments depend the whole Law and the Prophets." And so it is fitting that those who obey the Law be loving also.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To the objection that it belongs to perfection to serve freely and to flee obligations: it must be said that there is an obligation arising from the guilt of fault and from the affection of perfect charity. The first obligation is to be avoided, but the second is to be embraced, according to what is said in Romans 13: Owe no man anything, except to love one another. For the Lord praises the friendship of spiritual men, which is made from the mammon of iniquity; and it pertains to the perfection of the mystical body of Christ that the members share with one another according to the principle of giving and receiving, so that mutual need may be supplied in turn.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For sacred Scripture is principally concerned with the works of reparation. Whence it treats chiefly of faith, hope, and charity, through which virtues the soul must be reformed, and most especially of charity. Of which the Apostle says that it is the end of the commandment, insofar as it proceeds from a pure heart and a good conscience and faith unfeigned. It is the fullness of the Law, as the same Apostle says. And our Savior asserts that the whole Law and the Prophets depend on the two precepts of the same, namely the love of God and of neighbor; which two are intimated in the one Spouse of the Church, Jesus Christ, who is at once neighbor and God, at once brother and lord, at once also king and friend, at once the uncreated and incarnate Word, our maker and remaker, as the Alpha and the Omega; who is also the supreme hierarch, purging and illuminating and perfecting the spouse, namely the whole Church and every holy soul.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And so, these virtues without form or clothing are those of the philosophers, while ours are clothed. But they must be clothed with the gold of love, for all the walls of the temple were covered with gold. Also, with the oil of unction, because all the vessels were sanctified by the oil of unction. And so, they are not divided. The night is far advanced; the day is at hand. Let us therefore put on the armor of light, that is, the four virtues originated by faith, lifted up by hope, and fulfilled by charity. These four virtues, clothed in such a manner, are symbolized by the four rivers of paradise, the four sides of the city, and the four ornaments of the tabernacle, in so far as they are originated, endowed with form, and stabilized.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"I will destroy the wisdom of the wise, and the prudence of the prudent I will reject." That is the wisdom of which Jeremiah says: "They are wise to do evil, but to do good they know not." To scatter this wisdom Christ died, made poor, afflicted, and humble, so that he might teach us to beware of it. Has not God made foolish the wisdom of this world? — when on the cross he chose the contraries of worldly wisdom. It pleased God through the foolishness of preaching to save those who believe.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture was handed down for the disclosing of wisdom which is found in it alone. Hence: "For since, in God's wisdom, the world did not come to know God by 'wisdom,' it pleased God, by the foolishness of our preaching, to save those who believe."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Our restorative principle, Christ the Lord, the incarnate Word, since He is the power and wisdom of God and our mercy, must so powerfully, so wisely, so mercifully, so fittingly institute His Sacraments in the law of grace that nothing whatsoever is lacking for our healing, insofar as befits the state of the present life. For the perfect healing of sickness, these three things concur, namely: the expulsion of the sickness, the introduction of health, and the preservation of the health that has been introduced.
Since for perfect healing a perfect and universal expulsion of the disease is required, and the disease is sevenfold—threefold as to guilt, namely original sin, mortal sins, and venial sin; and fourfold as to penalty, namely ignorance, malice, weakness, and concupiscence—hence it was necessary that a sevenfold remedy be applied against these to expel more fully this sevenfold disease, namely, against original sin, baptism; against mortal sin, penance; against venial sin, extreme unction; against ignorance, holy orders; against malice, the Eucharist; against weakness, confirmation; and against concupiscence, matrimony, which tempers and excuses it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“You esteem the abundance of riches, and Christ chose poverty; you esteem the experience of sensual delights, and Christ chose the bitterness of suffering; you esteem the ambition of worldly pomps, and Christ willed to be despised and put to shame. And the wisdom of God prevailed; therefore the Apostle says: "The foolishness of God is wiser than men." To scatter the false wisdom of the world Christ died, made poor, afflicted, and humble, so that he might teach us to beware of it. When on the cross he chose the contraries of worldly wisdom, God made foolish the wisdom of this world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"When a strong man armed guards his court, those things which he possesses are in peace; but if a stronger one than he comes upon him and overcomes him, he will take away all his armor in which he trusted, and will distribute his spoils." This stronger one is God, because "the weakness of God is stronger than men." The Son of God was made weak for our sake.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All of which comes about through Jesus Christ, who was made for us by God wisdom and justice and sanctification and redemption. Who, since He is the power of God and the wisdom of God, and is the incarnate Word full of grace and truth, brought about grace and truth: He poured in the grace, namely, of charity, which, since it proceeds from a pure heart and a good conscience and an unfeigned faith, rectifies the whole soul according to its threefold aspect mentioned above; and He taught the knowledge of truth according to the threefold mode of theology, namely symbolic, proper, and mystical, so that through symbolic theology we might rightly use sensible things, through proper theology we might rightly use intelligible things, and through mystical theology we might be rapt to supermental ecstasies.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth face of wisdom is the most difficult, for it is without form. Thus would it seem to destroy the preceding faces, and yet it does not. The Apostle speaks of it in the First Epistle to the Corinthians: "Wisdom, however, we speak among those who are mature, yet not a wisdom of this world. But we speak the wisdom of God, mysterious, hidden, which eye has not seen nor ear heard, nor has it entered into the heart of man. But to us God has revealed it through His Spirit. For the Spirit searches all things, even the deep things of God." Paul taught this wisdom to Dionysius and Timothy and other perfect men, but he kept it hidden from others. It is up to us, then, to be perfect in order to reach it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third fruit of wisdom consists in contemplating the supreme good which arises from a close consideration of the gifts of grace. For grace can be so great that a man living in it would be existing as it were in paradise. He would have an insight into his inner self, like blessed Paul who says: "Wisdom, however, we speak among those who are mature." And later: "But to us God has revealed them through His Spirit. For who among men knows the things of a man save the spirit of the man which is in him? Even so, the things of God we do not know, unless the Spirit of God goes into us."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth face of wisdom is the most difficult, for it is without form. Thus would it seem to destroy the preceding faces, and yet it does not. The Apostle speaks of it in the First Epistle to the Corinthians: "Wisdom, however, we speak among those who are mature, yet not a wisdom of this world. But we speak the wisdom of God, mysterious, hidden, which eye has not seen nor ear heard, nor has it entered into the heart of man. But to us God has revealed it through His Spirit. For the Spirit searches all things, even the deep things of God." Paul taught this wisdom to Dionysius and Timothy and other perfect men, but he kept it hidden from others. It is up to us, then, to be perfect in order to reach it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Rouse yourself now, O my soul, and lift up your whole understanding and think, as much as you can, of what kind and how great that good is. For if individual goods are delightful, think intently how delightful is that good which contains the joyfulness of all goods, not such as we have experienced in created things, but differing as much as the Creator differs from the creature. For if created life is good, how good is the creative life? If wrought salvation is joyful, how joyful is the salvation that makes all salvation? If wisdom in the knowledge of created things is lovable, how lovable is the wisdom that created all things from nothing? In short, if there are many and great delights in delightful things, of what kind and how great is the delight in him who made those very delightful things?
Who will enjoy this good, what shall be his, and what shall not be his? Surely whatever he wills shall be, and what he does not will shall not be. There indeed shall be goods of body and soul, such as eye has not seen, nor ear heard, nor the heart of man conceived. Why then do you wander through many things, O little man, seeking the goods of your soul and your body? Love the one good, in which are all goods, and it suffices. Desire the simple good, which is every good, and it is enough.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth face of wisdom is the most difficult, for it is without form. Thus would it seem to destroy the preceding faces, and yet it does not. The Apostle speaks of it: "Wisdom, however, we speak among those who are mature, yet not a wisdom of this world. But we speak the wisdom of God, mysterious, hidden, which eye has not seen nor ear heard, nor has it entered into the heart of man. But to us God has revealed it through His Spirit. For the Spirit searches all things, even the deep things of God." Paul taught this wisdom to Dionysius and Timothy and other perfect men, but he kept it hidden from others. It is up to us, then, to be perfect in order to reach it. "Forgetting what is behind, I strain forward to what is before," hoping that I may understand.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"But to us God has revealed it through His Spirit. For the Spirit searches all things, even the deep things of God." Paul taught this wisdom to Dionysius and Timothy and other perfect men, but he kept it hidden from others. It is up to us, then, to be perfect in order to reach it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third fruit of wisdom consists in contemplating the supreme good which arises from a close consideration of the gifts of grace. For grace can be so great that a man living in it would be existing as it were in paradise. He would have an insight into his inner self, like blessed Paul who says: "Wisdom, however, we speak among those who are mature." And later: "But to us God has revealed them through His Spirit. For who among men knows the things of a man save the spirit of the man which is in him? Even so, the things of God we do not know, unless the Spirit of God goes into us."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this passing over, however, if it is to be perfect, it is necessary that all intellectual operations be relinquished, and that the summit of affection be wholly transferred and transformed into God. This, however, is mystical and most secret, which no one knows unless he receives it, nor does anyone receive it unless he desires it, nor does anyone desire it unless the fire of the Holy Spirit inflames him to the marrow, which fire Christ sent upon the earth. And therefore the Apostle says that this mystical wisdom has been revealed through the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When our mind has been filled with all these intellectual lights, it is inhabited by the divine Wisdom as a house of God, having been made a daughter of God, a spouse and friend; having been made a member of Christ the Head, a sister and co-heir; having been made no less a temple of the Holy Spirit, founded through faith, elevated through hope, and dedicated to God through holiness of mind and body. All of which the most sincere charity of Christ accomplishes, which is poured forth in our hearts through the Holy Spirit, who has been given to us, without which Spirit we cannot know the secrets of God. For just as the things of a man no one can know except the spirit of man which is in him, so also the things of God no one knows except the Spirit of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Gratuitous knowledge is called the knowledge of the Saints first because it is given by the Holy Spirit moving the soul, inspiring and informing it unto holiness. I say by the Holy Spirit inspiring unto the awareness of holiness, unto the delight in holiness, and unto the guardianship of holiness. Whence the Apostle to the Corinthians: "We have not received the spirit of this world, but the Spirit who is from God, that we might know the things that have been given to us by God": and in what manner? If we know, we guard and approve the things inspired through the Holy Spirit unto the awareness of holiness, unto the delight in holiness, and its guardianship.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The seventh and last column of wisdom is simplicity in intention. Christ is the fountain of wisdom; He Himself is the foundation and completion of this gift. The Apostle, as a wise architect, says: "No one can lay another foundation besides that which has been laid, which is Christ Jesus." As a certain Gloss says, man is related to a tree in the opposite manner with respect to the root: for a tree has its root below, but man above; and a spiritual building has its foundation above, but a corporeal one below. Christ therefore is the foundation of this gift.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ is the foundation of this faith. For other foundation no one can lay, but that which has been laid, which is Christ Jesus. For He is the cornerstone of which Isaiah and Peter speak: See, I am laying a stone in Sion, a stone that has been tested, a precious cornerstone as a sure foundation. And the Apostle: You are built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets with Christ Jesus Himself as the chief cornerstone.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The purgatorial fire is a corporeal fire, by which nevertheless the spirits of the just, who in this life did not fulfill condign penance and satisfaction, are afflicted to a greater or lesser degree, according as they carried with them from this life more or less of what is combustible.
They are afflicted, however, less gravely than in hell, and more gravely than in this world; yet not so gravely that they do not always hope and know that they are not in hell. By this affliction inflicted by corporeal fire, spirits are purged from guilt and dross and also from the remnants of sins; and when these have been sufficiently purged away, they immediately fly forth and are introduced into the glory of paradise.
And because just men, who are in grace, are worthy of nothing but transitory punishment: and they are worthy of so much greater punishment as they committed greater sins and performed lesser penance: hence it is that they are punished by material fire temporally, some however for a longer time, some indeed for a shorter, some more harshly, some more lightly, according as the guilt of their offenses requires. For one is purged with so much more difficulty as the love of worldly things had clung more intimately to the marrow of one's heart.
Since that punishment ought to be purgative, and that purgation is spiritual: the very power of grace dwelling within, aided by the extrinsic punishment, purges the soul itself—already punished for its offenses and relieved of the burden of its guilt—with a sufficient purgation, so that no dissimilitude to glory may remain. And since such spirits are disposed in the highest degree to receive in themselves the deiformity of glory: when the gate is opened and purgation is consummated, it is necessary that those spirits fly upward, in whom is the fire of charity lifting them upward, and nothing holding them back on the part of the soul's impurity or guilt.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is also true that no one can boast of merits, because God crowns nothing in us except his own gifts. For God has reserved to himself the gifts of grace to be freely bestowed, so that man may learn not to be ungrateful nor to glory in himself as though he had not received, but to glory in the Lord.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A man is instructed by the gift of counsel to discern what is lawful, what is fitting, and what is expedient according to the judgment of right reason. First a man ought to consider whether it is lawful, whether it is fitting: many things are lawful that are not fitting. Afterward he ought to consider whether it is expedient, because the Apostle says: 'All things are lawful for me, but not all things are expedient.' Once this threefold consideration has been attained, thoughts are instructed, and wisdom dwells in the counsel of man.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To approach Christ is through faith, or through the Sacrament of faith; and the faith of Christ is the same in past, present, and future: therefore the ground of influencing is posited in Christ with respect to all, past as well as present as well as future, who believe in Christ and are reborn in Christ, who through faith are joined to Christ and through inflowing grace become members of Christ and temples of the Holy Spirit, and thereby children of God the Father, connected to one another through the indivisible bond of charity. Which just as it is not divided by distance of places, so neither is it separated by length of times; and thereby all the just, wherever they may be and whenever they may have been, constitute one mystical body of Christ, receiving sense and motion from the one influencing head, according to the fontal, radical, and original fullness of all grace dwelling in Christ as in a fountain.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When a worthy admission has come about together with a holy perception, then the soul is rapt in God, that is, in the beloved. "My Lover belongs to me and I to Him; He browses among the lilies," for the soul already feels the union and is made one spirit with God: "he that is joined unto the Lord is one spirit." And this is the highest thing in the soul: it makes it abide in heaven.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To approach Christ is through faith, or through the Sacrament of faith; and the faith of Christ is the same in past, present, and future: therefore the ground of influencing is posited in Christ with respect to all, past as well as present as well as future, who believe in Christ and are reborn in Christ, who through faith are joined to Christ and through inflowing grace become members of Christ and temples of the Holy Spirit, and thereby children of God the Father, connected to one another through the indivisible bond of charity. Which just as it is not divided by distance of places, so neither is it separated by length of times; and thereby all the just, wherever they may be and whenever they may have been, constitute one mystical body of Christ, receiving sense and motion from the one influencing head, according to the fontal, radical, and original fullness of all grace dwelling in Christ as in a fountain.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This is the price of which the Apostle says: "You have been bought with a great price; bear and glorify God in your body." That the price is great, the Apostle Peter says: "You were redeemed not with corruptible gold or silver from your vain manner of life received by tradition from your fathers, but with the precious blood as of a Lamb unspotted and undefiled." This had to be a great price, by which the whole world and the entire human race was to be redeemed; because man could not make satisfaction, since no single man could be worth all men, nor could any creature. Nothing was sufficient to redeem the entire human race unless it possessed human nature and a nature above every creature; therefore it was necessary that it possess both a divine and a human nature.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Let us not give our body to sin. "We have been bought at a great price. Do not become servants of men" nor of demons nor of sins. If I had redeemed some servant, I would not give him away for nothing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The hands of a woman are bonds to those who touch her, because she holds so tightly that a man cannot be separated from her. Whence the Apostle: "It is good for a man not to touch a woman."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That widowed continence according to the evangelical law ought to be vowed is shown by authority, as follows. 1 Corinthians 7: It is good for a man not to touch a woman: therefore by equal reasoning it is good for a woman not to touch a man: but this is not a good of precept, but of counsel; and counsels are to be vowed: therefore not to touch a woman is to be vowed. But this is a vow of continence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against the vowing of widowed continence it is objected: 1 Corinthians 7: On account of fornication let each man have his own wife, and each woman her own husband: but that is not a counsel, since it is not a work of perfection nor of supererogation: therefore it is a precept: therefore whoever vows continence acts against this precept.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that which is objected from the word of the Apostle, who says: On account of fornication, let each man have his own wife; it must be said that the following text determines this: But I say this by way of concession, not by way of command. Whence the Gloss on the aforementioned word: "The Apostle says this in order to exclude fornication, not to close the way to those striving toward a better life." And because the Apostle had said: Let each man have his own wife, and each woman her own husband, and come together again; namely, lest he should seem to have said this by way of precept, he adds: But I say this by way of concession, not by way of command. And therefore he does not sin who acts otherwise, that is, who practices continence; rather, he who acts thus sins, because there is some fault there, but a light one.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That conjugal chastity is to be approved according to the evangelical law is shown by authority, as follows. 1 Corinthians 7: Let the husband render to the wife the debt owed, and the wife to the husband. The husband does not have power over his own body, but the wife does: therefore for the husband to render the debt to the wife is consonant with the law of God: but this is done according to the conjugal act: therefore the conjugal act is consonant with the law of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against conjugal chastity it is objected: 1 Corinthians 7: Return together again: but this I say by way of indulgence, not by way of commandment: but no act of virtue requires indulgence: therefore the act of conjugal continence is not an act of virtue.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that objection that the act of marriage is by way of indulgence: it must be said that this is not said of marriage itself and of the nuptial act that is performed for the procreation of children, but of that which is performed for the restraining of incontinence, because this has venial fault joined to it. Hence Augustine, in the book On the Good of Marriage: "If you have taken a wife, you have not sinned: and if a virgin marries, she does not sin. From this it is no longer permissible to doubt that marriage is not a sin; therefore the Apostle does not grant marriage by way of pardon. For who would hesitate to say that it is most absurd to say that those to whom pardon is given have not sinned? But he grants that intercourse by way of pardon which takes place on account of incontinence, not solely for the sake of procreating, but also sometimes with no purpose of procreating; which marriage does not compel to happen, but obtains pardon for, provided however that it is not so excessive as to impede the times that ought to be set aside for prayer, nor changed into that use which is against nature."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That widowed continence according to the evangelical law ought to be vowed is shown by authority, as follows. 1 Corinthians 7: I wish all men to be as I myself: but he himself was entirely continent and bound to continence: therefore he wished that all be bound to continence. But this is done through the vow of continence: therefore widowed continence is to be vowed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That widowed continence according to the evangelical law ought to be vowed is shown by authority, as follows. 1 Corinthians 7: But I say to the unmarried and to widows: it is good for them, if they so remain: therefore according to the Apostle it is good to remain in widowed continence; but this good is a counsel: therefore someone can licitly vow widowed continence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Let us not give our body to sin. "We have been bought at a great price. Do not become servants of men" nor of demons nor of sins. If I had redeemed some servant, I would not give him away for nothing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This counselor, namely Christ, has many counselors, to whom he imparts his counsel. And the Apostle himself says: 'In this I give counsel, but I have no precept.' Augustine says that 'Christ became poor to such an extent that he does not have what the foxes have, because foxes have holes, but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head; understand: Christ became poor so that we might imitate his poverty.' The Master says that we should imitate him in giving alms, in humility, in poverty, and in obedience.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As to the excellence of virtue, it attests to the highest virtue that someone in mortal flesh should lead a life not human but heavenly, should extinguish heat in fire, and in nature should surpass the force of nature: and this virginity does. Hence Jerome to the virgin Demetrias: "Just as in the furnace the fourth one, having the appearance as it were of the Son of man, tempered the immense flames and amid the conflagration of the raging furnace taught the flames to lose their heat and to threaten one thing to the eyes and present another to the touch: so also in the virginal soul, by the heavenly dew and the cold of fasting, youthful heat is extinguished and the manner of life of angels is obtained for the human body. Wherefore also the vessel of election says of virgins that he does not have a precept of the Lord, because it is against nature, nay rather beyond nature, not to exercise that for which you were born, to kill your root within you and to pluck only the fruits of virginity, to know no stranger's bed, to shudder at all intimacy with men, and to live in the body without the body."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That conjugal chastity is to be approved according to the evangelical law is shown by authority, as follows. 1 Corinthians 7: If you have taken a wife, you have not sinned: and if a virgin shall have married, she does not sin: therefore if one was previously continent without a wife, it seems that one will also be continent with a wife.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that objection that the act of marriage is by way of indulgence: it must be said that this is not said of marriage itself and of the nuptial act that is performed for the procreation of children, but of that which is performed for the restraining of incontinence, because this has venial fault joined to it. Hence Augustine, in the book On the Good of Marriage: "If you have taken a wife, you have not sinned: and if a virgin marries, she does not sin. From this it is no longer permissible to doubt that marriage is not a sin; therefore the Apostle does not grant marriage by way of pardon. For who would hesitate to say that it is most absurd to say that those to whom pardon is given have not sinned? But he grants that intercourse by way of pardon which takes place on account of incontinence, not solely for the sake of procreating, but also sometimes with no purpose of procreating; which marriage does not compel to happen, but obtains pardon for, provided however that it is not so excessive as to impede the times that ought to be set aside for prayer, nor changed into that use which is against nature."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against conjugal chastity it is objected: 1 Corinthians 7: Let those who have wives be as though not having them; but he who does not have a wife does not use her: therefore he who has one should not use her. But this is contrary to the act of conjugal continence: therefore conjugal continence is repugnant to the law of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that objection that those who have wives ought to be as though not using them: it must be said that the Apostle does not there prohibit every use of worldly things; for then it would be necessary for man to go out of the world, and thus no one in this world would be just and good; but he shows there that one's intention must not be fixed on this world, nor should it be loved as an end, but as a way to the end. This is clear from what he adds: For the figure of this world passes away. Hence from this it is not established that one should not use a wife, but that one should not rest in love of her and use of her, since she is not a stable good, but one transitory and perishable.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now the figure of this world is said to pass away, not as regards the total destruction of this sensible world, but because through the action of that fire all flammable elementary things will be consumed, plants and animals; the elements will be purged and renewed, especially air and earth; the just will be purged and the reprobate will be burned; and when these things have been accomplished, the motion of the heavens will also cease, so that, with the number of the elect completed, there may come about a certain renewal and rewarding of worldly bodies.
Since God according to His most orderly wisdom made this entire sensible and greater world for the sake of the lesser world, namely man, who is placed in the middle between God and these lower things: hence it is that, so that all things may be congruent with one another, and the dwelling may have harmony with the dweller, when man was well established, this world ought to have been established in a good and peaceful state; when man fell, this world also ought to have deteriorated; when man was disturbed, it ought to have been disturbed; when man was purged, it ought to have been purged; when man was renewed, it ought to have been renewed; and when man was consummated, it ought to have been brought to rest.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that objection that those who have wives ought to be as though not using them: it must be said that the Apostle does not there prohibit every use of worldly things; for then it would be necessary for man to go out of the world, and thus no one in this world would be just and good; but he shows there that one's intention must not be fixed on this world, nor should it be loved as an end, but as a way to the end. This is clear from what he adds: For the figure of this world passes away. Hence from this it is not established that one should not use a wife, but that one should not rest in love of her and use of her, since she is not a stable good, but one transitory and perishable.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against conjugal chastity it is objected: 1 Corinthians 7: He who is with a wife is solicitous for the things of the world, and how he may please his wife: but solicitude for and complacency in this world is condemned and is contrary to the law of God: therefore so also is conjugal continence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that objection, that he who has a wife is anxious, etc.: it must be said that solicitude is twofold: one kind is under God, and this is called distracting and occupying solicitude; the other kind leads to forgetfulness of God, and this is suffocating solicitude: similarly a distinction must be made concerning friendship as well. The Apostle, however, speaks of the first kind, and the argument proceeds from the second.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The blessed Virgin brought forth that price as strong and holy with the holiness of uncorrupted modesty. Whence in Ecclesiasticus: "Grace upon grace is a holy and modest woman"; and the Angel said: "Hail, full of grace," because she was holy and modest: holy in flesh and modest in mind. The Apostle: "The unmarried woman and the virgin thinks on the things of the Lord, that she may be holy in body and in spirit."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since widowed continence has more in itself of the nature of the honorable on account of purity, more of the nature of the advantageous on account of the removal of impediment, more of the nature of the delightful on account of the removal of burdens which follow upon the law of marriage: hence it is that widowed continence is counseled to all who are unbound; and those who wish to adhere to this counsel according to the dictate of evangelical perfection are not to be restrained but rather encouraged, that is, not only in old age but also in youth. For one is persuaded to abstain from marriage or to be continent, both by the Lord and by the Apostle himself, 1 Corinthians 7: She shall be happier if she so remain, according to my counsel. And the reason for this he himself states beforehand: Moreover, this I say for your profit, not that I may cast a snare upon you, but for that which is honorable, and which may afford the opportunity of beseeching the Lord without hindrance.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That virginal continence is to be preferred to all others is shown by authority, as follows. 1 Corinthians 7: He who gives his virgin in marriage does well, and he who does not give her in marriage does better: therefore virginal continence is to be preferred to the other differences of continence, according to the authority of the Apostle.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This counselor, namely Christ, has many counselors, to whom he imparts his counsel. Paul said: 'She will be more blessed if she so remains according to my counsel; but I think that I also have the Spirit of God.' Whence to the Corinthians: 'You know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though he was rich, for your sake he became poor.' And the Apostle himself says: 'In this I give counsel, but I have no precept.' Augustine says that 'Christ became poor to such an extent that he does not have what the foxes have, because foxes have holes, but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head; understand: Christ became poor so that we might imitate his poverty.' The Master says that we should imitate him in giving alms, in humility, in poverty, and in obedience.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That widowed continence according to the evangelical law ought to be vowed is shown by authority, as follows. 1 Corinthians 7: If the husband shall have died, the woman is freed from the law of the husband; but she will be more blessed if she so remains: but what is more blessed can be licitly vowed: and this is through the vow of widowed continence: therefore widowed continence is to be vowed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On that word Augustine says, in On Widowhood: "What I say to one widowed woman I say to every widow: She will be more blessed if she so remains": therefore this is proposed to all widows: therefore it is licit for anyone to vow continence according to the evangelical law.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because marriage has something attached which diminishes both honor and utility and spiritual joy, no one is compelled to it against his will, because rather one is persuaded to abstain from it or to be continent, both by the Lord and by the Apostle himself, 1 Corinthians 7: If her husband be dead, the woman is loosed from the law of her husband; let her marry whom she will, only in the Lord; but she shall be happier if she so remain, according to my counsel. And the reason for this he himself states beforehand: Moreover, this I say for your profit, not that I may cast a snare upon you, but for that which is honorable, and which may afford the opportunity of beseeching the Lord without hindrance.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Knowledge puffs up, but charity edifies"; therefore it is necessary to join charity with knowledge, so that a man may have knowledge and charity together, so that what the Apostle says may be fulfilled: "Rooted and founded in charity, that you may be able to comprehend with all the Saints what is the length, and breadth, and height, and depth, and to know also the charity of Christ which surpasseth knowledge." This is the knowledge which is a gift of the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Gratuitous knowledge teaches to know and the manner of knowing. Whence, upon that saying of the Apostle: "If any man think that he knoweth anything, he hath not yet known how he ought to know": Bernard says: "You see that the Apostle does not approve him who knows many things, but the manner of knowing: see that he places all the fruit and utility of knowledge in the manner of knowing. What does he call the manner of knowing? To know in what order, with what zeal, and to what end each one learns: in what order, so that one may first learn that which is more conducive to salvation; with what zeal, so that one may more ardently pursue that which more powerfully draws to the love of God; to what end, so that one may learn not for vainglory or curiosity, but for the edification of oneself and one's neighbor. There are those who wish to know only for the sake of knowing, and this is base curiosity. There are those who learn and wish to know in order to be known, and this is base vanity. And there are those who wish to know in order to sell their knowledge for money or honors, and this is base profit. There are those who wish to know in order to edify others, and this is charity. And there are those who wish to know in order to be edified, and this is prudence."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“An idol is nothing, as is said in First Corinthians, chapter eight: therefore to think that God is an idol and that God does not exist is the same thing: but it is thinkable and is sometimes thought that God is an idol: therefore it is thinkable that God is nothing.
The reason a pagan thinks that God is an idol is that his apprehension of God is defective: for he does not apprehend Him as the highest and best, but as something powerful that man cannot be; and hence there arises in him the error of deception and the wavering of doubt, into which error he casts himself by his own obstinacy, so that he becomes utterly inexcusable. Nor yet is he entirely deprived of the knowledge of God, because, although out of his own perversity he wills to worship an idol, he nonetheless has a natural instinct to worship God, against which he fights by casting himself into voluntary error.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On that passage in 1 Corinthians 9: Who serves as a soldier, etc.; the Gloss says: "As the Lord ordained, those living from the Gospel ate bread freely given, received from those to whom they preached grace freely given"; but it is called bread freely given because it was not acquired through bodily labor: therefore those exercising the work of preaching are not bound to bodily labor.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First Corinthians nine: Do you not know that those who work in the sanctuary eat what belongs to the sanctuary, and those who serve at the altar share with the altar? The Gloss: "Natural reason dictates that one should live from where he labors." If therefore the faithful person who is intent upon spiritual occupations is worthy of being sustained, and such a person is not idle: therefore neither for the sake of avoiding idleness nor even for acquiring sustenance is he bound to work manually.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that which is objected, that such men are imitators of Gehazi, who minister spiritual things for temporal ones: to this the Gloss responds sufficiently enough on that passage of 1 Corinthians 9: A dispensation is entrusted to me: "We ought not to preach the Gospel in order that we may eat, but rather to eat in order that we may preach the Gospel, so that food is not a good which is sought after, but a necessity which is added; so that that saying may be fulfilled: Seek first the kingdom of God and his justice, and all these things shall be added unto you." Hence if someone were to make a temporal thing the end in preaching the word of God, without doubt he would be perverse, because he would make the means into the end, and he would be like Gehazi and Balaam, who loved the reward of iniquity. But if they seek sustenance as a means ordered to the preaching of the Gospel, then they proceed rightly and imitate the Apostles, nor do they depart from the path of truth in any respect.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the allegory of the Head, Paul writes: "I would not have you ignorant, brethren, that our fathers were all under the cloud, and all passed through the sea, and all were baptized in Moses, in the cloud and in the sea. And all ate the same spiritual food, and all drank the same spiritual drink (for they drank from the spiritual rock which followed them, and the rock was Christ)."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the allegory of the Head, Paul writes: "I would not have you ignorant, brethren, that our fathers were all under the cloud, and all passed through the sea, and all were baptized in Moses, in the cloud and in the sea. And all ate the same spiritual food, and all drank the same spiritual drink (for they drank from the spiritual rock which followed them, and the rock was Christ)."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because humility is the dwelling place of grace, the grace of the Holy Spirit rests upon the humble alone. Whence Augustine, in the third book of On Christian Doctrine: "For this reason the sins of great men were written down, so that that apostolic saying might everywhere be feared: Wherefore let him who seems to stand take heed lest he fall. For there is no page of the holy books in which it does not resound: God resists the proud, but to the humble He gives grace."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Scriptures call Christ sometimes the Center, sometimes the Head. He is called the Head because all the senses and spiritual motions and charismatic graces flow from Him. This He pours in as being united to the members. For "the head of Christ is God," that is, in so far as He is God; but "the head of every man is Christ," in so far as He is God and man. Hence He pours the Holy Spirit into the members of the Church united to Him, not separated from Him. And since in the human body there is no diffusion from the head to the members unless the members are united to the head, so it is with the Mystical Body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the species of bread and wine Christ is set before us as food, which whoever receives worthily, not only sacramentally, but also eating spiritually through faith and charity, is more fully incorporated into the mystical body of Christ and is in himself refreshed and purified; but whoever approaches unworthily eats and drinks judgment to himself, not discerning the most holy body of Christ.
Since our capacity to receive Christ efficaciously is not in the flesh, but in the spirit, not in the belly, but in the mind: and the mind does not attain Christ except through knowledge and love, through faith and charity, such that faith illuminates unto meditation, and charity enkindles unto devotion: therefore, in order that one may approach worthily, it is necessary that one eat spiritually, so that through the meditation of faith one may chew, and through the devotion of love one may receive: through which one does not transform Christ into oneself, but rather one is transferred into His mystical body. On account of which it is manifestly gathered that he who approaches tepidly, without devotion, and without consideration eats and drinks judgment to himself, because he does insult to so great a Sacrament. And therefore the counsel is for those who feel themselves less clean in mind or in flesh, or even without devotion, that they defer until, prepared for the eating of the true Lamb, they approach clean, devout, and circumspect.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the Holy Spirit, who is charity and is possessed through charity, is the origin of all charisms: therefore, when the Holy Spirit descended, the fullness of charisms was poured forth for the perfecting of the mystical body of Christ. And because there must be diverse members in a perfect body, and diverse offices and functions of diverse members, and diverse charisms for diverse offices: hence it is that to one is given through the Spirit the word of wisdom, to another the word of knowledge, to another faith, to another the grace of healing, to another the working of miracles, to another prophecy, to another the discernment of spirits, to another kinds of tongues, to another the interpretation of words; all these things one and the same Spirit works, dividing to each one as he wills, according to his most generous providence and most provident generosity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The origin of Scripture is not through human investigation, but through divine revelation, which flows from the Father of lights, from whom all paternity in heaven and on earth is named, from whom through his Son, Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit flows into us, and through the Holy Spirit, dividing and distributing gifts to each one as he wills, faith is given, and through faith Christ dwells in our hearts.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It has been said how the intellect is enlightened by these theories, in order that it may go on to the tasting of its fruit. And this is necessary. As Gregory says, "He who labors only to find out what to say and how, remains empty inside and is devoid of inner devotion," for as the Apostle says, he has become as sounding brass or a tinkling cymbal.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From the foregoing it is gathered that, although from the primary division the light descending from above is fourfold, there are nevertheless six differences of it: namely, the light of sacred Scripture, the light of sensitive cognition, the light of mechanical art, the light of rational philosophy, the light of natural philosophy, and the light of moral philosophy. And therefore there are six illuminations in this life, and they have an evening, because all knowledge shall be destroyed; and therefore the seventh day of rest succeeds them, which has no evening, namely, the illumination of glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In heavenly glory there is a substantial, consubstantial, and accidental reward. The substantial reward consists in the vision, fruition, and possession of the one highest good, namely God, whom the Blessed will see face to face, that is, nakedly and without veil; whom they will enjoy eagerly and delightfully; whom they will also hold for all eternity.
The supreme light, which darkened eyes cannot see, cannot be seen face to face without deiformity of mind and joy of heart. Because a mere creature does not have supreme authority, from which there can be no appeal, hence it is necessary that our judge be both God, so that he may judge by supreme authority, and man, so that he may be seen and contend with sinners in a human likeness.
The rational spirit can be rewarded and fulfilled by nothing less than God, nor can its capacity be bounded: therefore as a reward there is given to it the deiformity of glory, through which, made conformed to God, it may see him clearly by reason and love him fully by will and retain him forever by memory: so that the whole soul may live, the whole soul may be endowed in the three powers of the soul, the whole soul may be configured to God, the whole soul may be united to him, the whole soul may rest in him, finding in him as in every good peace, light, and eternal sufficiency.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Augustine explains the Apostle's words: "But we all, with faces unveiled, reflecting as in a mirror the glory of the Lord:" Not "as in mirrors," that is, from afar, but "as in a mirror." But we still see through this mirror in an obscure manner, for a man who sees clearly is in the state of beatitude.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since, however, the two aforementioned steps, leading us toward God through His vestiges, through which He shines forth in all creatures, have led us by the hand to this point: that we should re-enter into ourselves, namely into our mind, in which the divine image shines forth: hence it is that now in the third place, entering into ourselves and as it were leaving the outer court behind, in the holy place, namely the anterior part of the tabernacle, we ought to endeavor to see God through a mirror; where, after the manner of a candelabrum, the light of truth shines forth in the face of our mind, in which, namely, the image of the most blessed Trinity resplends.
Enter therefore into yourself and see that your mind most fervently loves itself; nor could it love itself unless it knew itself; nor would it know itself unless it remembered itself, because we grasp nothing through the intellect that is not present in our memory; and from this you perceive that your soul has a threefold power, not with the eye of the flesh, but with the eye of reason. Consider therefore the operations and dispositions of these three powers, and you will be able to see God through yourself as through an image, which is to see through a mirror in an enigma.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is objected: Everything whose contrary created nature displays is incredible to reason; but every created nature displays the contrary of this, namely that one thing is multiplied in supposits without the form being multiplied: for in any created nature, when the supposit is multiplied, the form is multiplied: therefore if our intellect is led by the hand through creatures to knowing God whether He exists, as is said in First Corinthians thirteen: We see now through a glass in an enigma: since every created nature has a contrary indication to this truth, that God is triune: it is necessary that this be an incredible truth.
To that which is objected, that everything whose contrary all created nature exhibits is incredible: it must be said that created nature can exhibit something in two ways: either in itself, or in its cause. For created nature exhibits that it is temporal and mutable and composite, but that its cause is eternal and immutable and most simple. In this same way, although in a creature the unity of form cannot stand together with a trinity of supposits, since supposits in a creature are distinguished by matter and by form appropriated to matter itself; in the Creator, in whom there is absolutely no matter and there is true fecundity, while one form and substance remains, there is distinction in supposits by reason of origin. Therefore, since the creature does not universally exhibit the contrary of this, namely that God is trine, but rather rightly and conformably exhibits the very same: it is therefore more credible than incredible.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But how does Paul "announce the good tidings of the unfathomable riches of Christ?" This is how: "So there abide faith, hope and charity, these three." There shines forth a threefold signification in Scriptures, teaching what to believe, what to expect, and what to do. What to believe, in terms of faith; what to expect, in terms of hope; what to do, in terms of charity, which consists in action, and not only in affective dispositions. "If anyone love Me, he will keep My word."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Church is a union of rational men united in harmonious and uniform adherence to divine peace. For the Church in return loves itself. And love is born of obedience to the Law. And so it is fitting that those who obey the Law be loving also. "By this will all men know that you are My disciples, if you have love for one another." And the Apostle writes: "For God is a God of peace, not of disorder."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On the third day He rose from the dead, resuming the body which He had previously vivified, yet not such a body as it had been before: for before it was passible and mortal, but after He rose, it was impassible and immortal, living perpetually.
In order to build up faith, by which we believe Christ to be true man and true God, and by which we also believe that he willed to redeem us through death and was able to restore us to life through resurrection: for this reason he willed to rise again to immortal life, yet with a due interval of time interposed, namely thirty-six hours, in which it is shown that he was truly dead. Nor ought he to have hastened more, lest, if he had risen sooner, it would be believed that he had not truly died but had feigned himself dead. Nor ought he to have delayed longer, lest, if he had remained forever in death, he would be believed powerless and unable to recall anyone to life. And therefore he rose on the third day.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the power that restores us is the power of the whole Trinity and also the power of the passion of Christ, who died and was buried and rose again on the third day: hence it is that in the Sacrament of baptism there ought to be a proper and ordered pronouncing of the baptizing word with a triple immersion for the expression of the death of Christ and his burial and resurrection accomplished after three days. And because both powers operate simultaneously and in the one Christ the Savior, both of these ought to be done by one and the same person simultaneously and at the same time, for the sake of preserving unity in the Sacrament and signifying unity in our Mediator.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These three concurrent visions or certainties, the angelic, the prophetic, and the apostolic, provide the certainty of faith and Scriptures. Paul had all three, for he saw Christ bodily: And last of all, he writes, as by one born out of due time, He was seen also by me. And he was also lifted up to the intermediate and to the highest visions, that is, to the intellectual.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Apostle, when he said: "By the grace of God I am what I am," adds: "I have labored more abundantly than all of them." Do you then praise yourself, O Apostle? No; whence he adds: "Not I, but the grace of God with me." It is a noble example that some recognize their virtue and do not grow proud of it. How virtuously some act with the grace of the Holy Spirit!”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Nature dictates jurisdictional obedience according to the state of nature as reparable or repaired, and this in the state of the wayfarer, according to that passage in First Corinthians fifteen: When he shall have brought to nothing all principality, etc.; the Gloss: "As long as the world endures, Angels will preside over Angels, and men over men for the benefit of the living: but when all have been gathered together, then all prelacy will cease, because it will not be necessary." For what nature dictates absolutely has perpetual duration; but it is not so of what nature dictates for a particular state: just as in the state of innocence it dictated that all things should be held in common, which indeed it does not dictate in corrupted nature.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This unity is now begun on the way, but is consummated in eternal glory, according to what the Lord prays, that they may be one, as we also are one: and I in them, and thou in me, that they may be made perfect in one: when this unity is consummated through the bond of charity, God will be all in all in certain eternity and perfect peace, and all things will be common through love, ordered in communion and connected in ordering and indissolubly bound in connection.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When these have been possessed, the soul, entering into itself, enters into the supernal Jerusalem, where, considering the orders of Angels, it sees God in them, who, dwelling in them, works all their operations. Whence Bernard says to Eugenius that "God in the Seraphim loves as charity, in the Cherubim knows as truth, in the Thrones sits as equity, in the Dominations rules as majesty, in the Principalities governs as principle, in the Powers protects as salvation, in the Virtues works as power, in the Archangels reveals as light, in the Angels assists as piety." From all of which God is seen to be all in all through the contemplation of Him in minds in which He dwells through the gifts of most abundant charity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Turning back again, let us say: because therefore the most pure and absolute being, which is simply being, is the first and the last, therefore it is the origin and consummating end of all things.
Because eternal and most present, therefore it encompasses and enters all durations, existing as it were simultaneously as their center and circumference.
Because most simple and greatest, therefore it is wholly within all things and wholly beyond all things, and therefore "it is an intelligible sphere whose center is everywhere and whose circumference is nowhere."
Because most actual and most immutable, therefore "remaining stable, it gives motion to all things."
Because most perfect and immense, therefore it is within all things, not enclosed; beyond all things, not excluded; above all things, not elevated; below all things, not cast down.
Because indeed it is supremely one and all-encompassing, therefore it is all things in all, although all things are many and it itself is nothing but one; and this because through most simple unity, most serene truth, and most sincere goodness there is in it all power, all exemplarity, and all communicability; and therefore from him and through him and in him are all things, and this because he is omnipotent, omniscient, and in every way good, which to see perfectly is to be blessed, as was said to Moses: I will show you all good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is in this way that men enter into contemplation, nor can anyone in the world attain the visions of the Apocalypse unless he understands such things as these. Since, then, according to the Apostle, "there is one glory of the sun, and another glory of the moon, and another of the stars," we, lifted up through faith, are being transformed from glory to glory, and this, with faces unveiled, so that in a sense we are made to become similar to the twelve stars and to the twelve pearls. There are twelve thoughts we have received through faith: these are the notions that God is the First, that He is triune, that He is the Exemplar of things, the Creator of the world, the One who gave form to the soul, and the Giver of life; that God united to the flesh was crucified, that He is the Remedy of the minds, the Retribution of crimes and the eternal Reward.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The consubstantial reward consists in the glory of the body, which is called the second stole: which being resumed, the blessed soul tends more perfectly toward the highest heaven. And this stole consists in a fourfold dowry of the body, namely in the dowry of clarity, subtlety, agility, and impassibility: which will be in greater or lesser degree, according to the lesser or greater charity previously possessed.
Since the spirit is glorified by the vision of eternal light, there must result in its body the greatest clarity of light. Because indeed by the love of that supreme Spirit it is made supremely spiritual, it must have in the body a corresponding subtlety and spirituality. Because by the possession of eternity it is made altogether impassible, there must be in its body complete impassibility both within and without. Because indeed from all these things the spirit is most ready to tend toward God, in the glorified body there must be found supreme agility. Since therefore through these four properties the body is made conformed to the spirit and also subject to it, hence it is that in these four it is said to be especially endowed, by reason of which it has the aptitude to follow the spirit and to be placed in the celestial region, which is the region of the Blessed. For in these properties it is made like to the celestial bodies, and thus the fourfold dowry of bodies renders the body both perfect in itself and conformed to the celestial habitation and to the blessed Spirit, through whom from the supreme head, God, even unto the hem of the garment, namely the body, the fullness of sweetness and the inebriation of beatitude overflows and, insofar as is possible, is derived.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the death of Christ the separation of the soul from the flesh was so accomplished that nevertheless the unity of the person was preserved, and the union of both the flesh and the soul with the Deity.
And because the union of the soul with the body makes a man and makes him living: hence it is that Christ was not a man during that triduum, although the soul and the flesh were united with the Word. Whence, because death in the human nature could not induce death in the person, who was always living; therefore death died in life, and through the death of Christ death was swallowed up in victory, and the prince of death was vanquished, and through this man was liberated from death and the cause of death through the merit of Christ's death as through the most efficacious means.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To attribute sufficiency to one's own virtues and free will is a matter of presumption with respect to however small a good, since the Apostle says in Second Corinthians 3: Not that we are sufficient, etc. But to attribute this to divine grace, which one hopes will not be lacking to oneself on account of divine munificence, is not a matter of presumption, but of confidence and of the certainty of hope, by which we believe that God is a helper to the man who wills to adhere to His counsels. On account of which the same Apostle immediately after the aforementioned word adds: Our sufficiency is from God; and the same, in the last chapter of Philippians: I can do all things in Him who strengthens me; and by this hope ought he to be sustained who, inspired by the divine Spirit, not only proposes the perfection of the evangelical counsels, but also promises it by vowing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It should be noted that the Church was placed in paradise, like the first man, "to till it," in such a way that no one would say "that anything he possessed" was "his own." For it began in a state of great perfection that is observed today in the religious life, for the love of Christ was still recent, and in those days "a large number also of the priests accepted the faith." This Church, meaning the one that began with the Jews, because they were converted at one time by the three thousand, and at another, by the five thousand, possessed the "tree of life," that is, faith, because "My just one lives by faith." It also had the "tree of knowledge," that is, the Law, which remained with them for seeing and reading, and not for eating. Much more: for "the day you eat of it, you must die." And so you may see the tree of knowledge, but not eat of it, or else you would destroy what Christ had done; and death would necessarily come in, for "the letter kills." Hence Paul says: "I, Paul, tell you that if you be circumcised, Christ will be of no advantage to you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Apostle gives us to understand that the soul possesses a manifold clarity and ascends from one to another. Whence the Apostle to the Corinthians: "But we all, beholding the glory of the Lord with unveiled face, are transformed into the same image from clarity to clarity, as by the Spirit of the Lord." The clarity of the soul is knowledge; on the contrary, the darkness of the soul is ignorance. He says: "we are transformed from clarity to clarity."
Here it must be noted that there is a clarity of philosophical knowledge, of theological knowledge, of gratuitous knowledge, and a clarity of glorious knowledge. The clarity of philosophical knowledge is great according to the opinion of worldly men, yet it is small in comparison to the clarity of Christian knowledge. The clarity of theological knowledge indeed seems small according to the opinion of worldly men, but according to truth it is great. The clarity of gratuitous knowledge is greater, but the clarity of glorious knowledge is the greatest: there lies the final state.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This wisdom results from many mysteries of the Scriptures, as out of many mirrors there results a multiplication of light rays and fires. These are the "mirrors of the women" out of which "the bronze laver" was made; this is Scriptures, "with faces unveiled, reflecting as in a mirror the glory of the Lord, being transformed into His very image from glory to glory": from the clarity of allegory to the clarity of anagogy, and again to that of tropology. This wisdom is given according to the measure of faith, "according as God has apportioned to each one the measure of faith." For in the measure in which a man seizes the mind, in that measure does he become wiser—and faith is obtained through humility.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is in this way that men enter into contemplation, nor can anyone in the world attain the visions of the Apocalypse unless he understands such things as these. Since, then, according to the Apostle, "there is one glory of the sun, and another glory of the moon, and another of the stars," we, lifted up through faith, are being transformed from glory to glory, and this, with faces unveiled, so that in a sense we are made to become similar to the twelve stars and to the twelve pearls. There are twelve thoughts we have received through faith: these are the notions that God is the First, that He is triune, that He is the Exemplar of things, the Creator of the world, the One who gave form to the soul, and the Giver of life; that God united to the flesh was crucified, that He is the Remedy of the minds, the Retribution of crimes and the eternal Reward.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Augustine explains this power as follows: "But we all, with faces unveiled, reflecting as in a mirror the glory of the Lord:" Not "as in mirrors," that is, from afar, but "as in a mirror." But we still see through this mirror in an obscure manner, for a man who sees clearly is in the state of beatitude. Augustine indicates the form of this mirror in the fifteenth book of his work "On the Trinity," chapter four, where he seeks to show both God's unity and trinity. This is what he says: "It is not only the authority of the divine books that proclaims that God is one: everything around us, including ourselves because of the universal nature of things, manifests the fact that it has a most outstanding Creator, who gave us a mind and natural reason through which we see that the living beings are superior to the non-living, the sensible to the senseless, the intelligent to the non-intelligent, the immortal to the mortal, the powerful to the weak, the just to the unjust, the beautiful to the deformed, the good to the wicked, the incorruptible to the corruptible, the invisible to the visible, the bodiless to the bodily, the blessed to the wretched. And because of the fact that, without any doubt, we place the Creator above created things, it is fitting that we profess that He is supremely living, that He perceives and knows all things, that He is free from death, corruption, and change, that He is not a body but a Spirit, the most powerful, just, beautiful, good, and happy of them all."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This consideration of the theories exists between the two mirrors of the two Cherubim, that is, of the two Testaments, that shed light on each other, so that man be "transformed from glory to glory." But this germination of the seeds procures the understanding of the different theories through adaptation to the different times; and the man who overlooks the times cannot know the theories. For one who ignores the past cannot know the future. If, indeed, I do not know from which tree a seed comes, I cannot know what tree is to grow from it. Hence the knowledge of future events depends on the knowledge of those of the past. Moses, indeed, in his prophecies concerning the future, was telling about the past through revelation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This word is written in the second Epistle to the Corinthians, in which the Apostle Paul, the great doctor, explains the gift of knowledge itself; and he explains the gift itself with respect to its antecedents and consequents. Two things precede the gift of knowledge: one is like an innate light, and the other is like an infused light. The innate light is the light of the natural judicatory or of reason; the superinfused light is the light of faith. With respect to the first he says: "God, who commanded light to shine," that is, he impressed the light of the natural judicatory upon the rational creature, that is, not only the possible intellect, but also the agent intellect. With respect to the superinfused light of faith he says: "He has shone in our hearts," namely through the infusion of the light of faith. God established the rational nature and superadded grace. Therefore there are two antecedents.
The consequents are also two, namely clear knowledge of the Creator, and revealed knowledge of the Savior. With respect to the antecedents he says: "God, who commanded," etc.; with respect to the consequents he says: "For the illumination of the knowledge of the glory of God," where clear knowledge of the Creator is touched upon; "in the face of Christ Jesus," where revealed knowledge of the Savior is touched upon.
The Apostle gives us to understand that the soul possesses a manifold clarity and ascends from one to another.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"He has shone in our hearts for the illumination of the knowledge of the glory of God." However much a man may have a good natural judgment and along with this frequency of experience, they do not suffice unless there be illumination through divine influence. This light is pure and is with him: no one is illumined with certitude except through him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But grace which lifts up is obtained through hope. The Psalm reads: "For what have I in heaven? And besides Thee what do I desire upon earth?" And elsewhere: "I say, You are my refuge, my portion in the land of the living," so that a man be kept whole in view of this fatherland. Therefore "our present light affliction which is for the moment, prepares for us an eternal weight of glory." For the Lord rejoices in the right. "The delights at your right hand forever." At the left are passing riches, glories and consolations. We must indeed adhere to the right. Hence the rewards dispose towards the third act of grace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is indubitably true that we are the end of all things that exist, and all corporeal things were made for human service, so that from all of them man might be kindled to love and praise the Maker of all things, by whose providence all things are disposed. This sensible framework of corporeal things is therefore like a certain house fashioned for man by the supreme Artificer, until he should come to the house not made with hands in the heavens; so that, just as the soul, by reason of the body and the state of merit, is now on earth, so at some time the body, by reason of the soul and the state of reward, may be in the heavens.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens from above by means of divine promises, for its teaching is concerned with things above. Hence the Apostle writes: For we know that if the earthly house in which we dwell be destroyed, we have a building from God, a house not made by human hands, eternal in the heavens. And: "In My Father's house there are many mansions," says the Lord. In the Psalms, it is said: The children of men take refuge in the shadow of Your wings. They have their fill of the prime gifts of Your house; from Your delightful stream You give them to drink. For with You is the fountain of life, and in Your light we see light. And in the Apocalypse: For the Lamb who is in the midst of the throne will shepherd them, and will guide them to the fountains of the waters of life. And in a Psalm: The delights at Your right hand forever. And so Scripture offers us the divine promises.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Grace is more necessary for us than the Law; to receive which grace fruitfully, our mother the Church and the Apostle Paul exhort us. The Apostle Paul in this brief word rouses us to receive divine grace, to guard the grace received, and to multiply the grace received and guarded. He exhorts us not to receive the grace of God in vain, but to receive it fruitfully: therefore he means to say that we should be ready to receive, guard, and multiply the grace of God. But in order that this exhortation may be fulfilled in us, three things present themselves here for our consideration: first, what is the origin of grace; second, what is the use of grace; and third, what is the fruit of grace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The perfection of the fear of God consists in three things, namely in perfect sanctification and cleansing of conscience, in perfect promptitude of obedience, and in perfect firmness of confidence. First, the perfection of the fear of God consists in perfect sanctification or cleansing of conscience. Hence the Apostle to the Corinthians: "Let us cleanse ourselves from all defilement of flesh and spirit, perfecting sanctification in the fear of God." And how shall we perfect sanctification? It is said in Ecclesiasticus: "Those who fear the Lord will prepare their hearts, and in his sight will sanctify their souls, saying: if we do not do penance, we shall fall into the hands of the Lord and not into the hands of men."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This counselor, namely Christ, has many counselors, to whom he imparts his counsel. Paul said: 'She will be more blessed if she so remains according to my counsel; but I think that I also have the Spirit of God.' Whence to the Corinthians: 'You know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though he was rich, for your sake he became poor.' Augustine says that 'Christ became poor to such an extent that he does not have what the foxes have, because foxes have holes, but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head; understand: Christ became poor so that we might imitate his poverty.' The Master says that we should imitate him in giving alms, in humility, in poverty, and in obedience.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, 2 Corinthians 8: You know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that for your sake He became poor, though He was rich, so that by His poverty etc.: therefore whoever so renounces that he becomes destitute conforms himself more to Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On 2 Corinthians 8, on the verse: That by His poverty you might be made rich: the Gloss says: "Let no one despise himself: the poor man in his cell, rich in conscience, sleeps more securely on the ground than the man rich in gold upon purple. Therefore do not be afraid to approach with your beggary Him who was clothed with our poverty: where He made Himself poor, He enriched us." Therefore beggary disposes one toward, and does not withdraw one from, divine approach: it is established therefore that it is not a sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, on what follows in the same place: In this I give counsel; Augustine in the original: "He was made poor to such an extent that He did not have what foxes have; and in this I give counsel, that is to say, that you imitate His poverty"; but whoever renounces all things imitates His poverty: therefore etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, Second Corinthians eight: If the willing mind is ready according to what one has: the Gloss says: "Let him retain what is necessary, not giving beyond his means": therefore he acts wrongly who so distributes that he reserves absolutely nothing for himself.
To that which is objected from the Gloss on Second Corinthians eight: If the will is ready etc.; Gloss: "that he may retain what is necessary"; it must be said that that Gloss is truncated, because immediately it follows: "This is not said as though it would not be better, namely to give all: but he fears for the weak, whom he so advises to give that they may not suffer want." From which it appears that that Gloss rather makes for the contrary than for the proposition, if it be examined with a sound and right eye.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, 2 Corinthians 8: Let your abundance supply their want, so that their abundance also may be a supplement to your want. The Gloss: "Let your abundance of earthly things supply their want, so that conversely the abundance of their spiritual merits, who are devoted to divine things, may be a supplement to your want." If, therefore, it pertains to the perfection of the Lord's body that its members share with one another in the manner of giving and receiving: it contributes to the perfection of the Church and of the Gospel that the just poor seek and receive sustenance from the worldly and imperfect rich. If you say that they can receive but not ask: this amounts to nothing, because the worldly rich can ask for the prayers of spiritual men to relieve the want of their merits: therefore conversely the spiritual poor can ask for corporal alms for the sustenance of their bodies.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since truth is to be believed, and a greater truth is to be believed more, and consequently the supreme truth is to be believed supremely; and the truth of the first principle is infinitely greater than every created truth and more luminous than every light of our intellect: hence it is that, in order that our intellect may be rightly ordered in things to be believed, it is necessary that it believe the supreme truth more than itself, and that it bring itself into the obedience of Christ; and through this, that it believe not only those things which are according to reason, but also those which are above reason and contrary to the experience of the senses: for if it refuses, it does not exhibit due reverence to the supreme truth, since it prefers the judgment of its own industry to the dictate of the eternal light; which cannot be without the swelling of pride and blameworthy elation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Bringing into captivity the understanding unto the obedience of Christ." He who wishes to search sacred Scripture according to the light of his own intelligence thinks the most false errors. In this life we are little ones, and "the learner must believe." For it is necessary to believe God, and especially in sublime matters that transcend our understanding. The first Angel erred because he presumed upon himself. The disordered concupiscible power impedes the gift of understanding; likewise also the irascible, when it is disordered; but when the rational power is disordered, it most greatly impedes this gift. It is necessary therefore that we bring our intellect into captivity, if we wish to receive this gift. He who despises all things is raging mad: he is not disposed to receive this gift, nor is the presumptuous one.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The sixth vision is that of understanding absorbed by rapture in God. Hence, the Epistle to the Corinthians: "I know a man in Christ who fourteen years ago—whether in the body or out of the body I do not know, God knows—such a one was caught up" in this way. This lifting up makes the soul as similar to God as is possible in the state of pilgrimage. Ecstasy and rapture are not the same, wherefore it is said that they do not have merely a disposition toward glory, but the very act. And as the one vision consists in the common boundary between the way and the fatherland, so the other consists in the common boundary between union and separation from the body. Hence the Apostle writes: "Whether in the body or out of the body I do not know." Why, then, would a man presume to determine what Paul himself did not know?”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“I know a man who was caught up to the third heaven and heard secret words, that is, assured knowledge by means of ascent to the third heaven, and again, by means of descent to the first through representations of all the heavens. The threefold heavens refer to a threefold vision: purely intellectual, intellectual combined with imaginary, and intellectual combined with manifest bodily vision. The first is found in the minds of angels, the second in the minds of prophets, and the third in the minds of the apostles. The certainty of Scriptures consists in the concurrence of these visions.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The soil is Scripture which brings forth all kinds of trees pleasant to the sight, as regards the intellect, and good for food as regards the affective dispositions, that is, the manifold theories both delighting and sustaining. In the heavenly paradise, there is no planting, except of eternal reasons, and although there is sustainment in the fact of the predestination of all the saints, I will rejoice rather over my own. And this is what the Lord suggests: "Rejoice rather in this, that your names are written in heaven." Paul could speak of the heavenly paradise, because he was caught up to the third heaven. We do not know, but we speak of the earthly paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, the fourth seal consists in this, that the soul perceives an incomprehensible consolation that grows so much within it that it is unable both to comprehend it and to explain it to others. The Canticle says of this: "Eat, friends; drink! Drink freely of love!" And this inebriated soul says: The king "brought me into the cellar of wine." And earlier: "The king hath brought me into his storerooms." This occurs when the soul is beside itself, like a drunken man who does not know what he is doing. Hence, Paul did not know whether he was in the body or out of the body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the way is none other than through the most burning love of the Crucified, who so transformed Paul, caught up to the third heaven, into Christ, that he said: I have been crucified with Christ; yet I live, now not I; but Christ lives in me; who also so absorbed the mind of Francis that his mind was made manifest in his flesh, when he bore the most sacred stigmata of the Passion in his body for two years before his death.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this union the mind is joined to God, wherefore in a certain sense it sleeps, while in another it keeps vigil: "I was sleeping, but my heart kept vigil." Only the affective power keeps vigil and imposes silence upon all the other powers; then man becomes foreign to his senses: he is in ecstasy and hears "secret words that man may not repeat," because they are only in the heart. Hence, because nothing can be expressed unless it is conceived, or conceived unless it is understood, and here the intelligence does not speak: it follows that a man can hardly speak or explain anything.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And it must be so, for had he been proud, he could have lost grace and fallen into a reprobate sense. And so it is not without reason that the Apostle was given "a thorn for the flesh"; and he explains: "Lest the greatness of the revelation puff me up." And I say that a man who has attained such a state may order and command other men as did Paul, and also Dionysius, who ordered the Church according to the exemplar shown to him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But if you ask how these things come about, ask grace, not doctrine; desire, not understanding; the groaning of prayer, not the study of reading; the Bridegroom, not the master; God, not man; darkness, not clarity; not light, but the fire that wholly inflames and carries into God through ecstatic anointings and most ardent affections. Which fire is indeed God, and his furnace is in Jerusalem, and Christ kindles this in the fervor of his most ardent passion, which only he truly perceives who says: My soul has chosen hanging, and my bones death. Whoever loves this death can see God, because it is indubitably true: No man shall see me and live. Let us die, therefore, and enter into the darkness; let us impose silence upon our cares, concupiscences, and phantasms; let us pass over with Christ crucified from this world to the Father, so that, when the Father is shown to us, we may say with Philip: It suffices us; let us hear with Paul: My grace suffices for you; let us exult with David, saying: My flesh and my heart have failed, God of my heart and God my portion forever. Blessed be the Lord forever, and let all the people say: So be it, so be it. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whence the Apostle: "The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, and the charity of God, and the communion of the Holy Spirit, be with you all. Amen." If you wish to have the love of the Son and of the original Principle and of the Gift of the Holy Spirit, dispose yourself to grace. Grace arises from the Father of lights through the Word incarnate, through the Word crucified, and through the Word inspired. A noble influence, which has its origin from God incarnate. This grace ought to be guarded most carefully: but you lose it through sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The use of grace ought to be faithful with respect to God. Whence the Apostle: "But when it pleased him who separated me from my mother's womb and called me by his grace, I did not immediately acquiesce to flesh and blood." Faithful is he who does not diminish the gift which he receives on behalf of another. But when you seek something more principally than God, you are not faithful. Therefore the Apostle says: "I did not acquiesce to flesh and blood," that is, I did not seek carnal glory, but only divine glory. The experts in optics say that if a ray falls perpendicularly upon a smooth and polished body, it must necessarily be reflected back along the same path. The influx of grace is like a perpendicular ray — I speak of sanctifying grace, because gratuitous grace is like a ray of incidence; it is therefore necessary that whoever truly receives the grace of God should render glory back to God. Whence if you preach for your own glory, it profits you nothing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The use of grace ought to be faithful with respect to God. Whence the Apostle: "But when it pleased him who separated me from my mother's womb and called me by his grace, I did not immediately acquiesce to flesh and blood." Faithful is he who does not diminish the gift which he receives on behalf of another. But when you seek something more principally than God, you are not faithful. Therefore the Apostle says: "I did not acquiesce to flesh and blood," that is, I did not seek carnal glory, but only divine glory. The experts in optics say that if a ray falls perpendicularly upon a smooth and polished body, it must necessarily be reflected back along the same path. The influx of grace is like a perpendicular ray — I speak of sanctifying grace, because gratuitous grace is like a ray of incidence; it is therefore necessary that whoever truly receives the grace of God should render glory back to God. Whence if you preach for your own glory, it profits you nothing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In Galatians 2 he says that Peter and James gave to me and Barnabas the right hand of fellowship, that we should go to the Gentiles, and they to the circumcision, only that we should be mindful of the poor: the Gloss: "Of the poor, who had laid the price of their goods sold at the feet of the Apostles, we should be mindful, by making collections for their support." If therefore the Apostle was not simoniacal in this, that he sought collections and sent disciples for this purpose, that they might seek alms from those among whom he had sown spiritual things, for the poor who were in Jerusalem: if the Supreme Pontiff establishes Orders of poor men who sow spiritual things and live from the freely given alms, whether sought or spontaneously offered, of those whom they edify by word and example: he in no way whatsoever disagrees with the Apostle, but rather agrees.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Galatians two: I withstood him to the face: the Gloss says: "as an equal." "For he would not have dared to do this unless he knew himself not to be unequal." To this it must be said that the authority of the apostolate has a twofold comparison, namely to him by whom it is conferred, and to those over whom it is conferred: because an apostle is called one sent by someone and to some persons. According to the first comparison, the Gloss says that Paul is made equal to Peter, because each was immediately sent by Christ. Whence Paul also says that he is an Apostle, not from man nor through man, but through Jesus Christ. But according to the second comparison, he is not made equal to him; for Peter is called the prince of the Apostles, which is never said of Paul, because according to this comparison he was inferior to Peter. Whence the Gloss also says there: "Peter himself furnished an example to posterity, so that the greater ones would not disdain, if perchance they had departed from the path of rectitude, to be corrected even by their inferiors."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the way is none other than through the most burning love of the Crucified, who so transformed Paul, caught up to the third heaven, into Christ, that he said: I have been crucified with Christ; yet I live, now not I; but Christ lives in me; who also so absorbed the mind of Francis that his mind was made manifest in his flesh, when he bore the most sacred stigmata of the Passion in his body for two years before his death.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whence the Apostle to the Galatians: "I do not cast aside the grace of God; for if justice is through the Law, then Christ died in vain:" but Christ died that he might raise the dead to the reception of life and grace: therefore grace flows into us through the Word incarnate and through the Word crucified. And the blessed Virgin received this Word full of grace; and a river of graces went forth from his side, which has the efficacy of healing us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The purely intellectual vision existed in the minds of the angels and of the Lawmaker. For the Law was delivered by angels. Angels gave it forth, composed it, for they could see the pure truth in the eternal light. Moses was raised up to this vision more completely than any other prophet.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We are also led by the hand through the reformed powers of the soul itself, and this by gratuitous virtues, spiritual senses, and mental ecstasies, as is evident from the fourth step. We are led by the hand no less through hierarchical operations, namely of purgation, illumination, and perfection of human minds, through the hierarchical revelations of sacred Scriptures given to us through Angels, according to that saying of the Apostle, that the Law was given through Angels by the hand of a Mediator.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And they killed the prophets, and their followers too, and they received false prophets, thus revealing their malice. And so the Scripture shut up all things under sin, the first through ignorance, the second through weakness, and the third through malice, so that when Christ came, He could have mercy on them all.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Although God could have become incarnate from the beginning, He nevertheless willed not to do so until the end of the ages, after the law of nature and the law of figure had preceded, after the Patriarchs and the Prophets, to whom and through whom the Incarnation was promised. After these He deigned to become incarnate as at the end of times and in their fullness, according to what the Apostle says: "But when the fullness of time had come, God sent His Son, made of a woman, made under the Law, that He might redeem those who were under the Law."
The Incarnation is the work of the first principle restoring, according to what is fitting and suitable with respect to the freedom of the will, with respect to the sublimity of the remedy, and with respect to the integrity of the universe.
Since freedom of the will requires that it be drawn to nothing against its will, God ought to have restored the human race in such a way that he who wished to seek the Savior would find salvation, while he who did not wish to seek the Savior would consequently not find salvation either. Now no one seeks a physician unless he recognizes his disease; no one seeks a teacher unless he recognizes himself to be ignorant; no one seeks a helper unless he recognizes himself to be powerless. Since, therefore, man at the beginning of his fall was still proud of his knowledge and strength, God first allowed the time of the law of nature, in which he would be convicted of ignorance; and afterwards, when ignorance was recognized but pride in his own strength remained, He added the Law, instructing through moral precepts and burdening through ceremonial ones, so that, having obtained knowledge and having recognized his powerlessness, man might take refuge in divine mercy and petition for grace, which was given to us in the coming of Christ.
Since the integrity and perfection of the universe requires that all things be ordered with respect to places and times, and this work of the incarnation was the most perfect among all divine works, and the process must be from the imperfect to the perfect, and not the reverse: hence it is that this work had to be accomplished in the end of times, so that, just as the first man, who was the adornment of the entire sensible world, had been created last, namely on the sixth day, for the completion of the whole world, so the second man, the complement of the entire restored world, in whom the first principle is joined with the last, namely "God with clay," would come to be in the end of times, that is, in the sixth age.
In the coming of the Son of God there is said to be the fullness of times, not because time comes to an end in his coming, but because the temporal mysteries are fulfilled.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Let us see, therefore, how the other illuminations of knowledge are to be reduced to the light of sacred Scripture. And first let us consider the illumination of sensitive cognition, which is wholly concerned with the cognition of sensible things, where three things are to be considered: the medium of cognition, the exercise of cognition, and the delight of cognition.
If we consider the medium of cognition, we shall behold therein the Word eternally generated and incarnate in time. For no sensible thing moves the cognitive power except through a likeness which proceeds from the object, as offspring from a parent; and this is necessary, whether generally, really, or exemplarily, in every sense. But that likeness does not bring about the completion of the act of sensing unless it is united with the organ and the power: and when it is united, a new perception arises, and through that perception a reduction to the object is effected by means of that likeness. And although the object is not always sensed, nevertheless it always, insofar as it is in itself, generates a likeness, when it is in its completeness.
In this same way understand that from the supreme Mind, which is knowable by the interior senses of our mind, there eternally emanated a Likeness, Image, and Offspring: and He afterwards, when the fullness of time came, was united to a mind and flesh and received the form of man, which He had never been before: and through Him all our minds which receive that Likeness of the Father through faith in the heart are reduced to God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For if you are a Cherub contemplating the essential attributes of God, and you wonder that the divine being is at once the first and the last, eternal and most present, most simple and greatest, that is, uncircumscribed, wholly everywhere and nowhere comprehended, most actual and never moved, most perfect and having nothing superfluous nor diminished, and yet immense and infinite without limit, supremely one, and yet all-inclusive, as having all things in itself, as all power, all truth, all good: look upon the mercy seat and wonder that in it the first beginning is joined with the last, God with man formed on the sixth day, the eternal is joined with temporal man, born of the Virgin in the fullness of time, the most simple with the supremely composite, the most actual with one who supremely suffered and died, the most perfect and immense with the small, the supremely one and all-inclusive with a composite individual distinct from all others, namely the man Jesus Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Although God could have become incarnate from the beginning, He nevertheless willed not to do so until the end of the ages. After these He deigned to become incarnate as at the end of times and in their fullness, according to what the Apostle says: "But when the fullness of time had come, God sent His Son, made of a woman, made under the Law, that He might redeem those who were under the Law."
Since freedom of the will requires that it be drawn to nothing against its will, God ought to have restored the human race in such a way that he who wished to seek the Savior would find salvation. Now no one seeks a physician unless he recognizes his disease; no one seeks a teacher unless he recognizes himself to be ignorant; no one seeks a helper unless he recognizes himself to be powerless. Since, therefore, man at the beginning of his fall was still proud of his knowledge and strength, God first allowed the time of the law of nature, in which he would be convicted of ignorance; and afterwards, when ignorance was recognized but pride in his own strength remained, He added the Law, instructing through moral precepts and burdening through ceremonial ones, so that, having obtained knowledge and having recognized his powerlessness, man might take refuge in divine mercy and petition for grace, which was given to us in the coming of Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And concerning the allegory of the body: "It is written that Abraham had two sons, the one by a slave-girl and the other by a free woman. And the son of the slave-girl was born according to the flesh, but the son of the free woman in virtue of the promise. This is said by way of allegory. For these are the two covenants." There is no need for further explanations, for two peoples are understood here.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And concerning the allegory of the body: "It is written that Abraham had two sons, the one by a slave-girl and the other by a free woman. And the son of the slave-girl was born according to the flesh, but the son of the free woman in virtue of the promise. This is said by way of allegory. For these are the two covenants." There is no need for further explanations, for two peoples are understood here.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As the moon is the daughter of the sun and receives its light from it, likewise the Church Militant receives hers from that Jerusalem which is above. Wherefore the Apostle calls her our mother, for she is the mother of those influences by which we are made to be the sons of God. The heavenly hierarchy is a model of the Church Militant. It is fitting, then, that the Church Militant have orders corresponding to the model hierarchy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The image of our mind must therefore be clothed with the three theological virtues, by which the soul is purified, illuminated, and perfected, and thus the image is reformed and made conformable to the supernal Jerusalem and becomes a part of the Church militant, which is the offspring, according to the Apostle, of the heavenly Jerusalem. For he says: That Jerusalem which is above is free, which is our mother.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It should be noted that the Church was placed in paradise, like the first man, "to till it," in such a way that no one would say "that anything he possessed" was "his own." For it began in a state of great perfection that is observed today in the religious life, for the love of Christ was still recent, and in those days "a large number also of the priests accepted the faith." This Church, meaning the one that began with the Jews, because they were converted at one time by the three thousand, and at another, by the five thousand, possessed the "tree of life," that is, faith, because "My just one lives by faith." It also had the "tree of knowledge," that is, the Law, which remained with them for seeing and reading, and not for eating. Much more: for "the day you eat of it, you must die." And so you may see the tree of knowledge, but not eat of it, or else you would destroy what Christ had done; and death would necessarily come in, for "the letter kills." Hence Paul says: "I, Paul, tell you that if you be circumcised, Christ will be of no advantage to you."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From what has been said, therefore, it is clearly gathered that the habits of the virtues principally dispose one to the exercise of the active life; the habits, however, of the gifts to the repose of the contemplative life: while the habits of the beatitudes dispose to the perfection of both. The fruits of the Spirit, however, which are charity, joy, peace, patience, longanimity, goodness, benignity, mildness, faith, modesty, continence, chastity, denote the delights consequent upon perfect works.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, flowing down from charity, there are the twelve charismatic gifts, the fruits which the Apostle enumerates in his Epistle to the Galatians: "But the fruit of the Spirit is charity, joy, peace, patience, benignity, goodness, longanimity, mildness, faith, modesty, continency, chastity." For grace and righteousness and wisdom cannot exist without charity. Indeed, fruit comes from the Latin frui which means "to cleave to something because of its intrinsic value." Wherefore neither acts of justice nor miracles nor the understanding of mysteries are of any use without charity. And this is the opinion of all the doctors and saints. And so for instance, a little old woman who owns a small garden, if she has nothing but charity, will bring forth a better fruit than a great master who owns an enormous garden and knows the mysteries and natures of things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“No one arrives at full knowledge of God except through true and right knowledge of oneself; nor does he rightly know himself who does not attend to his own nothingness; for he who thinks himself to be something, when he is nothing, deceives himself, as the Apostle says in the last chapter of Galatians; but to know one's own nothingness is to humble oneself: therefore humility is the gateway of wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"What a man shall sow, that also shall he reap." If a lord were to give his servant grain to sow his field, and that servant were to put the grain in a sack and not sow it: the land would bear fruit poorly, indeed it would cry out against him. Just as mercy is a friend of wisdom, so avarice is its enemy. The avaricious deride all who do not love money.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against conjugal chastity it is objected: Galatians 6: He who sows in the flesh shall of the flesh reap corruption: but sowing in the flesh is done through the act of conjugal continence: therefore conjugal continence is contrary to the law of God.
To this it must be said, as to the foregoing objection concerning being in the flesh, that to be in the flesh can denote a relation of matter or of end; insofar as it denotes a relation of matter, it is not reprehensible, and thus it accords with conjugal chastity; insofar as it denotes a relation of end, as when someone performs carnal works for the sake of the flesh, thus it is culpable, and in this way it does not arise from conjugal chastity, but rather is against it. Whence Augustine, in the book On the Good of Marriage: "Marriages have this good, that carnal or youthful incontinence, even if it is vicious, is directed to the honorableness of propagating offspring, so that from the evil of lust the conjugal union may produce something good." For marriage is of such great power that it directs the carnal act to spiritual honorableness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And Paul says of it: "You too, were sealed with the Holy Spirit of the promise." Through this seal, the friends are distinguished from the enemies, free men from slaves, heavenly men from the earthly. This seal is imprinted on the forehead of the contemplative soul and on the foreheads of the elect. This seal was imprinted on those standing upon Mount Sion. In the Second Epistle to Timothy, it is written: "The sure foundation of God stands firm." This is the seal by which "the Lord knows who are His." He knows through an express seal through which the soul calls upon the name of the Lord out of its inner depths.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the beginning I call upon the first principle, from whom all illuminations descend as from the Father of lights, from whom is every good gift and every perfect gift, namely the eternal Father, through his Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, that by the intercession of the most holy Virgin Mary, mother of the same God and our Lord Jesus Christ, and of blessed Francis, our leader and father, he may give the enlightened eyes of our mind to direct our feet in the way of that peace which surpasses all understanding; which peace our Lord Jesus Christ proclaimed and gave.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Everyone begotten through intercourse is born by nature a child of wrath, because deprived of the rectitude of original justice; on account of whose absence we incur with respect to the soul a fourfold penalty, namely weakness, ignorance, malice, and concupiscence; which four are inflicted on account of original sin: which spiritual penalties are indeed accompanied in the body by manifold suffering, manifold deficiency, manifold toil, manifold disease, and manifold pain. To these penalties follows the penalty of death and reduction to ashes, the penalty of the lack of the vision of God and the loss of heavenly glory.
If God had from the beginning created man in such great miseries, there would be neither mercy nor justice, namely that he would oppress his own work with such great misery, with no preceding fault. Similarly, if he were to fill us with such great miseries, or permit us to be filled, without fault, divine providence would govern us neither mercifully nor justly. If therefore it is most certain that the first principle is most upright and most clement both in producing and in providing: it is necessary that he so made the human race that from the beginning there was in it neither fault nor misery; it is also necessary that he so governs that he does not permit misery to be in us except on account of some preceding fault. Since therefore it is most certain that from our origin we contract manifold misery of punishment, it is certain that we are all born by nature children of wrath, and thereby deprived of the rectitude of original justice, which privation we call original fault.
And because every fault denotes a withdrawal from the unchangeable good and an approach toward the changeable good: and to withdraw from the unchangeable good is to withdraw from the highest power, truth, and goodness: but to approach the changeable good is to tend toward it through love more than is due: hence it is that one who loses original justice incurs weakness, ignorance, malice, and concupiscence.
Again, because one who abandons the unchangeable good for the sake of a changeable good becomes unworthy of both: hence it is that by reason of the lack of original justice, the soul loses temporal rest in the body through manifold corruption and death, and at last is separated from the vision of eternal light, losing the felicity of glory both in soul and in body.
Finally, because the lack of this justice in those being born is not through a movement of their own will nor through actual delight: hence it is that to original sin there is not owed after this life a punishment of sense in hell, for the reason that divine justice, which is always accompanied by superabundant mercy, does not punish above what is deserved, but below it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Not only were we unfit to receive grace on account of ignorance of the divine precepts, but indeed also on account of our infirmity and powerlessness and concupiscence of earthly things: therefore the Lord willed to set up supports. That he might heal our languors, he descended into us through the Word crucified. Whence the Apostle to the Ephesians: "God, who is rich in mercy, on account of his exceeding charity with which he loved us, when we were dead in sins, brought us to life together with Christ, by whose grace you are saved." We have been brought to life in Christ through Christ, because Christ triumphed over death: whence death could not swallow him up, but rather the font of life swallowed up death.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“God's inner goodness is the very reason why He loved to the highest possible degree and was filled with the deepest possible mercy. The Father gave us a Son born of us, He gave us One who suffered for us and rose again for our sake, by reason of His very great love wherewith He has loved us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Not only were we unfit to receive grace on account of ignorance of the divine precepts, but indeed also on account of our infirmity and powerlessness and concupiscence of earthly things: therefore the Lord willed to set up supports. That he might heal our languors, he descended into us through the Word crucified. Whence the Apostle to the Ephesians: "God, who is rich in mercy, on account of his exceeding charity with which he loved us, when we were dead in sins, brought us to life together with Christ, by whose grace you are saved." We have been brought to life in Christ through Christ, because Christ triumphed over death: whence death could not swallow him up, but rather the font of life swallowed up death.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ is the foundation of this faith. For other foundation no one can lay, but that which has been laid, which is Christ Jesus. For He is the cornerstone of which Isaiah and Peter speak: See, I am laying a stone in Sion, a stone that has been tested, a precious cornerstone as a sure foundation. And the Apostle: You are built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets with Christ Jesus Himself as the chief cornerstone.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There are, in the Church, three fundamental ranks: the patriarchal, the prophetical, and the apostolical. "Therefore, you are now no longer strangers. You are built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets." The patriarchs were the ancestors of the apostles according to the flesh and according to the promise. This order corresponds to the Father as He is in Himself. The prophetical order corresponds to the Father as He is in the Son, and the apostolical order, to the Father as He is in the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wisdom appears as manifold in the mysteries of divine Scriptures. This multiformity of the mysteries is shown in the Apostle's letter to the Ephesians: "To me, the very least of all saints, there was given this grace, to announce among the Gentiles the good tidings of the unfathomable riches of Christ, and to enlighten all men as to what is the dispensation of the mystery which has been hidden from all eternity in God, who created all things; in order that through the Church there be made known to the Principalities and the Powers in the heavens the manifold wisdom of God." And so this wisdom is called manifold because there are many ways of expressing it. Hence it was necessary that wisdom be shown under many figures, many sacraments, many signs, in order also that it be hidden to the proud and revealed to the humble.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wisdom appears as manifold in the mysteries of divine Scriptures. This multiformity of the mysteries is shown in the Apostle's letter to the Ephesians: "To me, the very least of all saints, there was given this grace, to announce among the Gentiles the good tidings of the unfathomable riches of Christ, and to enlighten all men as to what is the dispensation of the mystery which has been hidden from all eternity in God, who created all things; in order that through the Church there be made known to the Principalities and the Powers in the heavens the manifold wisdom of God." And so this wisdom is called manifold because there are many ways of expressing it. Hence it was necessary that wisdom be shown under many figures, many sacraments, many signs, in order also that it be hidden to the proud and revealed to the humble. These veils cover Christ, hiding wisdom from the wise and impure.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And thus it is clear how the manifold wisdom of God, which is clearly handed down in sacred Scripture, lies hidden in all knowledge and in all nature. It is also clear how all branches of knowledge serve theology; and therefore theology itself takes up examples and uses terms pertaining to every kind of knowledge. It is also clear how broad the illuminative way is, and how in every thing that is sensed or that is known, God Himself lies hidden within.
And this is the fruit of all the sciences: that in all things faith may be built up, God may be honored, morals may be ordered, consolations may be drawn, which are found in the union of the bridegroom and the bride, which union is indeed brought about through charity, to which the entire intention of Sacred Scripture is directed, and consequently every illumination descending from above, and without which all knowledge is vain, because one never arrives at the Son except through the Holy Spirit, who teaches us all truth: who is blessed forever and ever. Amen.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The great teacher of the nations and preacher of truth, filled with the divine Spirit as a chosen and sanctified vessel, in this word discloses the origin, progress, and state of sacred Scripture, which is called theology: intimating that the origin of Scripture is to be understood according to the influence of the most blessed Trinity, its progress, however, according to the requirement of human capacity, and its state or fruit, according to the superabundance of the most overflowing felicity. And so that we may arrive at this fruit and goal by a right progress through the way of the right journey of the Scriptures, we must begin from the beginning, that is, that with pure faith we approach the Father of lights, bending the knees of our heart, so that He Himself through His Son in the Holy Spirit may give us true knowledge of Jesus Christ and with that knowledge love of Him, so that thus knowing and loving Him, and as it were established in faith and rooted in charity, we may come to know the breadth, length, height, and depth of Sacred Scripture itself, and through this knowledge arrive at the most complete knowledge and surpassing love of the most blessed Trinity, toward which the desires of the Saints tend, in which is the end-state and fulfillment of all truth and goodness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the origin is not through human investigation, but through divine revelation, which flows from the Father of lights, from whom all paternity in heaven and on earth is named, from whom through his Son, Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit flows into us, and through the Holy Spirit, dividing and distributing gifts to each one as he wills, faith is given, and through faith Christ dwells in our hearts.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the origin is not through human investigation, but through divine revelation, which flows from the Father of lights, from whom all paternity in heaven and on earth is named, from whom through his Son, Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit flows into us, and through the Holy Spirit, dividing and distributing gifts to each one as he wills, faith is given, and through faith Christ dwells in our hearts. This is the knowledge of Jesus Christ, from which originally flows the firmness and understanding of all sacred Scripture.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Through faith Christ dwells in our hearts. This is the knowledge of Jesus Christ, from which originally flows the firmness and understanding of all sacred Scripture. Whence it is also impossible that anyone should enter into knowing it unless he first has the faith of Christ infused in him, as the lamp and gate and also foundation of all Scripture. For faith itself is the basis of all supernatural illuminations as long as we are pilgrims from the Lord, both the foundation that stabilizes, the lamp that directs, and the gate that introduces; and according to its measure the wisdom divinely given to us must also be measured. Therefore through the mediation of this faith, the knowledge of sacred Scripture is given to us according to the influence of the blessed Trinity, just as the Apostle expressly intimates in the first part of the authority previously introduced.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Knowledge puffs up, but charity edifies"; therefore it is necessary to join charity with knowledge, so that a man may have knowledge and charity together, so that what the Apostle says may be fulfilled: "Rooted and founded in charity, that you may be able to comprehend with all the Saints what is the length, and breadth, and height, and depth, and to know also the charity of Christ which surpasseth knowledge." This is the knowledge which is a gift of the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This contemplation comes about through grace, and yet personal effort is helpful, for it separates self from anything that is not God, and if possible, from itself. And that is the supreme union of love. And the Apostle says that it comes about through love alone: "So that, being rooted and grounded in love, you may be able to comprehend with all the saints what is the breadth and length and height and depth." Such love transcends every intellect and every science.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the summit of faith, which is love, the Apostle says: Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? Shall tribulation, or distress—all the way to the words, which is in Christ Jesus our Lord. And, in another passage, being rooted and grounded in love. That is the firmament of heaven.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the third place, for the soul to be hierarchized, it is necessary that it see the city going up into heaven. And that is when, through infusion into it of divine strength, light and warmth by the eternal Sun, it piously venerates, clearly speculates, and holily enjoys, and in so doing, comprehends the indissoluble bond of divine charity, the irrevocable gift of divine charity, the incomparable fire of divine charity, and the incomprehensible consolation of divine charity. Then it sees the city of God as it were in itself, and it has four sides, of which [Paul writes] to the Ephesians: "Being rooted and grounded in love, you may be able to comprehend with all the saints what is the breadth and length and height and depth," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This excess is indeed the ultimate and most noble mode of knowing, which Dionysius praises in all his books, and especially in the book On Mystical Theology. Concerning which also, mystically, almost all of divine Scripture speaks; because this mode of knowing one scarcely or never understands unless one has experienced it, nor does one experience it unless one is rooted and grounded in charity, so that one may comprehend with all the Saints what is the length, the breadth, etc.; in which also experiential and true wisdom consists, which is begun on the way and consummated in the fatherland: for the circumlocution of which negations are more fitting than affirmations, and supereminent expressions than positive predications; for the experience of which interior silence avails more than the exterior word.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The progress of Sacred Scripture is not confined to the laws of reasoning, definitions, and divisions according to the manner of other sciences, nor is it confined to a part of the universe; but rather, since it proceeds according to supernatural light to give man the wayfarer sufficient knowledge of things, as is expedient for salvation, partly through plain words and partly through mystical ones, it describes the containment of the entire universe as in a certain summary, in which its breadth is observed; it describes its course, in which its length is observed; it describes the excellence of those who are finally to be saved, in which its sublimity is observed; it describes the misery of those who are to be damned, in which the depth consists not only of the universe itself, but also of the divine judgment. And thus it describes the whole universe, insofar as it is expedient to have knowledge of it for salvation, according to its breadth, length, height, and depth. Now its breadth consists in the multitude of its parts, its length in the description of times and ages, its height in the description of hierarchies arranged in gradual order, and its depth in the multitude of mystical senses and meanings.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Knowledge puffs up, but charity edifies"; therefore it is necessary to join charity with knowledge, so that a man may have knowledge and charity together, so that what the Apostle says may be fulfilled: "Rooted and founded in charity, that you may be able to comprehend with all the Saints what is the length, and breadth, and height, and depth, and to know also the charity of Christ which surpasseth knowledge." This is the knowledge which is a gift of the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This contemplation comes about through grace, and yet personal effort is helpful, for it separates self from anything that is not God, and if possible, from itself. And that is the supreme union of love. And the Apostle says that it comes about through love alone: "So that, being rooted and grounded in love, you may be able to comprehend with all the saints what is the breadth and length and height and depth." Such love transcends every intellect and every science.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The loftiness of faith consists in two things: the extreme of altitude and the extreme of depth. And although in bodies height and depth are the same, they are distinguished by reason. The Apostle makes this distinction when he writes: "You may be able to comprehend what is the breadth and length and height and depth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, this seven-fold series, either in the sensible world or in the minor world, arises out of the archetypal world, where causal principles exist in a seven-fold series. For God exists by reason of a triple-formed cause, original, exemplary, and final, and He cannot exist in any other mode. Hence the Apostle says: For "from Him and through Him and unto Him are all things." But the principle of causality is dependent upon four things: height of power, depth of wisdom, breadth of benevolence, and length of eternity, so that, as the Apostle says, "you may be able to comprehend with all the saints what is the breadth and length and height and depth." Power creates, wisdom governs, benevolence achieves, and eternity preserves.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the third place, for the soul to be hierarchized, it is necessary that it see the city going up into heaven. And that is when, through infusion into it of divine strength, light and warmth by the eternal Sun, it piously venerates, clearly speculates, and holily enjoys, and in so doing, comprehends the indissoluble bond of divine charity, the irrevocable gift of divine charity, the incomparable fire of divine charity, and the incomprehensible consolation of divine charity. Then it sees the city of God as it were in itself, and it has four sides, of which [Paul writes] to the Ephesians: "Being rooted and grounded in love, you may be able to comprehend with all the saints what is the breadth and length and height and depth," etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In charity, therefore, let us be rooted and grounded, that we may be able to comprehend with all the Saints what is the length of eternity, what the breadth of liberality, what the height of majesty, and what the depth of judging wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This excess is indeed the ultimate and most noble mode of knowing, which Dionysius praises in all his books, and especially in the book On Mystical Theology. Concerning which also, mystically, almost all of divine Scripture speaks; because this mode of knowing one scarcely or never understands unless one has experienced it, nor does one experience it unless one is rooted and grounded in charity, so that one may comprehend with all the Saints what is the length, the breadth, etc.; in which also experiential and true wisdom consists, which is begun on the way and consummated in the fatherland: for the circumlocution of which negations are more fitting than affirmations, and supereminent expressions than positive predications; for the experience of which interior silence avails more than the exterior word.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The end-state, however, or fruit of Sacred Scripture is not just anything, but the fullness of eternal happiness. For this is the Scripture in which are the words of eternal life, which was therefore written not only that we might believe, but also that we might possess eternal life, in which indeed we shall see, we shall love, and our desires shall be universally fulfilled; and when these are fulfilled, we shall then truly know the charity that surpasses knowledge, and thus we shall be filled unto all the fullness of God. To which fullness indeed the divine Scripture strives to lead us, according to the truth of the aforementioned apostolic statement. Therefore, with this end and with this intention, Sacred Scripture is to be searched out, taught, and also heard.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Knowledge puffs up, but charity edifies"; therefore it is necessary to join charity with knowledge, so that a man may have knowledge and charity together, so that what the Apostle says may be fulfilled: "Rooted and founded in charity, that you may be able to comprehend with all the Saints what is the length, and breadth, and height, and depth, and to know also the charity of Christ which surpasseth knowledge." This is the knowledge which is a gift of the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This contemplation comes about through grace, and yet personal effort is helpful, for it separates self from anything that is not God, and if possible, from itself. And that is the supreme union of love. And the Apostle says that it comes about through love alone: "So that, being rooted and grounded in love, you may be able to comprehend with all the saints what is the breadth and length and height and depth." Such love transcends every intellect and every science. But if it transcends every science, how can this wisdom be seen? That is why the Apostle continues: "Now, to him who is able to accomplish all things in a measure far beyond what we ask or conceive." For it does not belong to anyone, but to the man to whom God reveals it. Hence the same Apostle writes: "But to us God has revealed it through His spirit."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such love transcends every intellect and every science. But if it transcends every science, how can this wisdom be seen? That is why the Apostle continues: "Now, to him who is able to accomplish all things in a measure far beyond what we ask or conceive." For it does not belong to anyone, but to the man to whom God reveals it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Our Hierarch must be most generous in the amount of what He gives out. As written in the Epistle to the Ephesians, "to each one of us grace was given according to the measure of Christ's bestowal. Thus it says, 'Ascending on high, He led away captives; He gave gifts to men.'" As indeed a cloud rises aloft in order that it may rain down, so does Christ ascend in order that He may grant His gifts.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Just as Christ insofar as He is the uncreated Word most perfectly formed all things, so insofar as He is incarnate He ought to have most perfectly reformed all things. Because the remedy of the passion was most sufficient, it therefore extended itself to celestial, terrestrial, and infernal things. Through Christ infernal things were recovered, terrestrial things remedied, and celestial things restored to wholeness—such that the first of these He accomplished through pardon, the second through grace, and the third through glory: therefore after the passion His soul descended to the nether regions to free those detained in hell; then He rose from the dead to vivify those dead in sins; He ascended into the heavens, leading captivity captive, to restore the heavenly Jerusalem to wholeness; and He sent the Holy Spirit to build up the earthly Jerusalem. All of which necessarily follow and are required for the sufficiency of human restoration.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Our Hierarch must be most generous in the amount of what He gives out. As written in the Epistle to the Ephesians, "to each one of us grace was given according to the measure of Christ's bestowal. Thus it says, 'Ascending on high, He led away captives; He gave gifts to men.'" As indeed a cloud rises aloft in order that it may rain down, so does Christ ascend in order that He may grant His gifts.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The bodies of all human beings will rise in the general resurrection, with no difference among them as to the order of time, but a great difference as to the order of dignity. For the wicked will rise with their deformities and punishments, miseries and defects, which they had in the state of wayfare. But in the good, nature will be preserved, and defects will be removed, and all will rise with a whole body and full age and due measure of members; so that all the Saints may attain to the perfect man, to the measure of the age of the fullness of Christ.
Because the resurrection must be in accordance with the demand of the consummation of grace, and perfect grace makes us conformed to Christ, our head, in whom there was no defect of members, but perfect age and due stature and beautiful form: it is fitting that the good be raised in the best conditions; and through this it is necessary that in them defects be removed and nature be preserved. It is also fitting that, if any member was lacking, it be supplied; if there was any superfluity, it be removed; if there was any disorder of the members, it be corrected; if one was a child, he be brought by divine power to the measure of the age of Christ which he had at the resurrection; if decrepit, he be restored to the same age; if a giant, if a dwarf, he be limited to a fitting measure; so that thus all, whole and perfect, may attain to the perfect man, to the measure of the age of the fullness of Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The sixth judgment of God is the judgment of despair, namely when the Lord takes away hope from man, and man believes himself to be deprived of eternal glory. Of such it is said: "Despairing, they gave themselves over to lasciviousness, unto the working of all uncleanness, unto covetousness." This is the most terrible judgment. Into this judgment Judas fell; and this judgment is the greatest, such that in the present life no greater can be given.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But we cannot possess these three in relation to others unless we have them first in relation to ourselves. Wherefore there are three more commandments: one that straightens all deeds, another that straightens all speech, and yet another that straightens all affective dispositions. That which straightens speech is as follows: You shall not bear false witness, which prohibits all falsity either in oneself or in relation to another. Speak truth each one with his neighbor.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But we cannot possess these three in relation to others unless we have them first in relation to ourselves. Wherefore there are three more commandments: one that straightens all deeds, another that straightens all speech, and yet another that straightens all affective dispositions. That which straightens deeds is as follows: You shall not steal, which not only prohibits stealing from others, but commands to give from one's own goods. And this is how the Apostle understands it: He who was wont to steal, let him steal no longer; but rather let him labor, working with his hands, that he may have something to share with him who suffers need.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Ephesians four: He who was stealing, let him steal no more, but rather let him labor, working with his hands, etc. This he says in order to avoid idleness and to remove sloth, which is the bilge of desires and the fuel of sins. From this, therefore, it is evident that labor is not commanded to all; and thereby mendicancy is not prohibited, except that which comes from idleness and cupidity, as the texts and Glosses indicate.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He commands imitation of himself. Concerning this imitation the Apostle says: Be imitators of God, as most beloved children. Now there are six works of mercy, namely: feeding the hungry, giving drink to the thirsty, clothing the naked, gathering in strangers, visiting the sick, and ransoming captives. Moreover, the work of perfect virtue cannot exist unless the creature is conformed to Christ in these things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because it accords with the time of grace that the Sacrament of communion and love should not merely signify communion and love, but also inflame unto the same, so that it may effect what it figures; and because that which most inflames us to mutual love and most unites the members is the unity of the Head, from whom through the diffusive, unitive, and transformative power of love mutual love flows into us: hence it is that in this Sacrament is contained the true body of Christ and immaculate flesh, as diffusing itself to us and uniting us to one another and transforming us into itself through the most ardent charity, by which he gave himself to us and offered himself for us and restored himself to us and remains with us even unto the end of the world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These philosophers had the wings of ostriches, for their affective powers were not cleansed or ordained or straightened: for this can be obtained only through faith. Hence they proposed a false circle of beatitude, second a false sufficiency of merits in the present world, third an eternal soundness of internal powers. In these three instances, they fell into darkness.
But faith, brushing away these obscurities, indicates the disease, its cause, Physician, and medicine; it heals the soul by placing the roots of merits in God who must be satisfied. And so the soul goes forth through faith into assured hope by means of the merits of Christ, and not in a presumptuous fashion. And so faith heals, straightens and ordains: in this manner the soul may be changed, straightened and ordained. The philosophers did not know these roots. Faith alone, then, divides the light from the darkness. Hence, the Apostle says: You were once darkness, but now you are light in the Lord. For faith, that has hope and charity together with good works, heals the soul, and once it has been healed, cleanses and lifts it up and makes it into the likeness of God. Now we are in the true light: not like those who sleep and take the false for the true, an idol for God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because it accords with the time of grace that the Sacrament of communion and love should not merely signify communion and love, but also inflame unto the same, so that it may effect what it figures; and because that which most inflames us to mutual love and most unites the members is the unity of the Head, from whom through the diffusive, unitive, and transformative power of love mutual love flows into us: hence it is that in this Sacrament is contained the true body of Christ and immaculate flesh, as diffusing itself to us and uniting us to one another and transforming us into itself through the most ardent charity, by which he gave himself to us and offered himself for us and restored himself to us and remains with us even unto the end of the world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That conjugal chastity is to be approved according to the evangelical law is shown by authority, as follows. Ephesians 5: Husbands, love your wives, just as Christ also loved the Church: but the union of Christ with the Church is according to the most chaste love: therefore the union of man with woman is also according to chaste love. But chaste love is consonant with the law of God: therefore also its act.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since each of the spiritual unions signified in the Sacrament of matrimony is a union of one as agent and infuser, and of the other as patient and receiver; and this by the bond of love, which proceeds from pure will: hence it is that matrimony must be a joining of two persons, differing according to the relation of agent and patient, namely of the male sex and the female, and this from the pure consent of the will. And because consent before commingling does not make a full union, because they are not yet one flesh: hence it is that by words regarding the future, matrimony is said to be initiated, by words regarding the present confirmed, but in carnal union consummated, because then they are one flesh and become one body: and through this it fully signifies that union which is between us and Christ. For then the body of one is fully transferred to the body of the other according to the power of one's spouse for the procreation of offspring.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Matrimony, because it renews the multitude in the being of nature, which is the foundation of all, was therefore first introduced before all others: although, on account of the disease of concupiscence attached to it, and because it is the least sanctifying, even though in signification it is a great Sacrament, it is placed last among the spiritual remedies and assigned the final place.
God from the beginning instituted that propagation should take place through a conjunction of male and female that is undivided and singular, which would signify before sin the conjunction of God and the soul, or of God and the subcelestial hierarchy, but after sin the conjunction of God and human nature, or of Christ and the Church; and therefore in both cases it is a Sacrament, namely before and after, although in different ways, with respect to signification and use. For since it was a Sacrament before the disease supervened, the concupiscence which supervened through sin is rather to be excused through matrimony than it is able to vitiate it: because the disease does not corrupt the medicine, but the medicine has the power to cure the disease.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"The Lord cast a deep sleep upon Adam, and when he had fallen asleep, he took one of his ribs" and made a woman "and brought her to Adam." And the Lord said: "For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and shall cleave to his wife." And the Apostle said: "This is a great sacrament; but I speak in Christ and in the Church."
And why, while he slept, did He take one of his ribs? Could He not have done this while he was awake? This is mystical. Was not the Church formed from the side of Christ, when Christ fell asleep on the cross? And from His side flowed forth blood and water, that is, the Sacraments, through which the Church is reborn. From the rib of Adam, Eve was formed, who was joined to him in marriage. Just as man was formed from virgin earth, so Christ from the glorious Virgin. And just as from the side of the sleeping Adam woman was formed, so the Church from Christ hanging on the cross. And just as from Adam and Eve, Abel and his successors were formed, so from Christ and the Church the whole Christian people.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Everything that accords with the evangelical Sacraments is good and praiseworthy: but conjugal continence is of this kind: therefore it is good and praiseworthy. The major is evident; the minor is proved: Ephesians 5: This Sacrament is a great one, etc.: therefore conjugal continence is consonant with the law of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By reason of governance, the honor of obedience is owed to the father; whence the Apostle to the Ephesians: Children, obey your parents, for this is just. Honor your father and your mother: which is the first commandment with a promise, that it may be well with you, and that you may be long-lived upon the earth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the law of grace considers the origin, fall, and remedy of nature, it belongs to it to approve the threefold mode and distinction of obedience. For it approves filial obedience, Ephesians 6: Children, obey your parents in the Lord: for this is just. Fatherhood and sonship are most consonant with natural law: therefore also that children obey parents; and this is done through the service of obedience.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By reason of governance, the honor of obedience is owed to the father; whence the Apostle to the Ephesians: Children, obey your parents, for this is just. Honor your father and your mother: which is the first commandment with a promise, that it may be well with you, and that you may be long-lived upon the earth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By reason of governance, the honor of obedience is owed to the father; whence the Apostle to the Ephesians: Children, obey your parents, for this is just. Honor your father and your mother: which is the first commandment with a promise, that it may be well with you, and that you may be long-lived upon the earth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The soul is disposed to the gift of fortitude through the unconquerable shield of faith. "In all things taking up the shield of faith, by which you may be able to extinguish all the fiery darts of the most wicked one." The devil draws man to the concupiscence of the flesh, to the concupiscence of the eyes, and to the pride of life. What is the means of resisting these? Through truth. "His truth shall encompass you with a shield," namely through faith dwelling within. And blessed Peter said: "Your adversary as a roaring lion goes about seeking whom he may devour: whom resist, strong in faith." If we loved truth, we would not fear the devil, because it is written: "The eyes of the Lord behold the whole earth and give fortitude to those who believe in him with a perfect heart."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The very truth of the divine law dictates that each person ought to think more humbly of himself than of another, and on this account ought to regard himself as more vile than others—not because he is certain that he is such, but because he is more certain of his own vanity or vileness than of another's. Therefore, as is said in the Gloss on Philippians 2: In humility esteeming one another as superior to themselves, "we ought not so to esteem this that we pretend to esteem it, but truly esteem that there can be something hidden in another by which he is superior to us, even if our own good, by which we seem superior to him, is not hidden." And thus it is apparent that self-abasement is not founded upon falsehood but upon truth, namely according to experiential knowledge of one's own defect, which each person has, as it were, singularly with respect to another.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Philippians 2: Let this mind be in you, which was also in Christ Jesus, who being in the form, etc.: but to empty oneself is nothing other than to abase oneself: if therefore we ought to imitate Christ in this, self-emptying and self-abasement belong to evangelical perfection.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since therefore Christ Jesus, insofar as he was God, was equal to the Father in the form of God; insofar as he was an innocent man, he was in no way a debtor of death: when he emptied himself and became obedient unto death, he paid back to God what he had not stolen through the homage of perfect satisfaction, and offered a sacrifice of supreme sweetness for the perfect placation of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“What is more benevolent than that the Lord should take on the form of a servant for the salvation of the servant? Indeed, this is of such great kindness that nothing more merciful, nothing more kind, nothing more loving can be conceived. This mode was therefore most suitable for God the restorer, for the commending of the divine power, wisdom, and benevolence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since therefore Christ Jesus, insofar as he was God, was equal to the Father in the form of God; insofar as he was an innocent man, he was in no way a debtor of death: when he emptied himself and became obedient unto death, he paid back to God what he had not stolen through the homage of perfect satisfaction, and offered a sacrifice of supreme sweetness for the perfect placation of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On that passage Bernard says in a sermon on the Nativity of the Lord: "What necessity was there for the God of majesty to so empty himself, so humble himself, so diminish himself, unless that you should do likewise? Already he cries out by example what he will preach by word." And shortly after: "It is intolerable impudence that, where majesty emptied itself, a little worm should puff itself up and swell with pride." If therefore we ought to imitate Christ in such self-emptying, it remains that to be abased belongs to the perfection of virtue.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since therefore Christ Jesus, insofar as he was God, was equal to the Father in the form of God; insofar as he was an innocent man, he was in no way a debtor of death: when he emptied himself and became obedient unto death, he paid back to God what he had not stolen through the homage of perfect satisfaction, and offered a sacrifice of supreme sweetness for the perfect placation of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“I have heard that there was a certain conjurer of demons. One day, when he was invoking a demon in the midst of certain persons who wished to obtain something from the demon, a certain priest passed by carrying the Body of Christ, and immediately the demon bowed down before him, and likewise on his return. And the conjurer said: whence is this? You have forbidden me to adore Christ, and yet you adore him? The demon replied: I did so unwillingly. Is it not written: "At the name of Jesus every knee should bow, of those in heaven, on earth, and under the earth?"”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He, then, is the Strong One. That is why "at the name of Jesus every knee should bend of those in heaven, on earth and under the earth." And so all the wars of Scripture refer to the victory of Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of God avails for obtaining the influx of divine grace. "Work out your salvation with fear and trembling. For it is God who works in you both to will and to accomplish according to his good will." We cannot have the grace of God except through the fear of God, because "the mercy of the Lord is from eternity and unto eternity upon those who fear him." No one receives the grace of God unless he fears God. Bernard says: "In truth I have learned that nothing is equally efficacious for meriting, preserving, and multiplying the grace of God as if at all times you are found before God not to be wise in lofty things, but to fear. Fear, therefore, when grace has smiled upon you: fear, when it has departed: fear, when it returns again." He who does not have grace ought to fear greatly for himself; likewise, if the Lord restores to a man the grace he had lost, he ought to fear greatly for himself, lest he lose it and become ungrateful, and the last state of that man becomes worse than the first.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fear of God avails for obtaining the influx of divine grace. "Work out your salvation with fear and trembling. For it is God who works in you both to will and to accomplish according to his good will." We cannot have the grace of God except through the fear of God, because "the mercy of the Lord is from eternity and unto eternity upon those who fear him." No one receives the grace of God unless he fears God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The rational power indeed needs to be freed in the speculation, choice, and execution of truth: through the gift of understanding it is freed for speculating upon the true, through the gift of counsel for choosing the true, through the gift of knowledge for executing what has been chosen; for through the gift of knowledge we rightly conduct ourselves in the midst of a crooked and perverse nation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is an order of levels intended for enlightenment, that of acolytes, subdeacons, and deacons. And these orders are for the sake of enlightenment. Now, enlightenment is at times through external example, at others, through writings of secondary importance, at others again, through writings of primary importance. The second enlighten by word and example: "guileless, children of God without blemish in the midst of a depraved and perverse generation... among these shining like stars in the world, holding fast the word of life," as are the subdeacons who hold fast the words of the Epistles.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is an order of levels intended for enlightenment, that of acolytes, subdeacons, and deacons. And these orders are for the sake of enlightenment. The second enlighten by word and example: "guileless, children of God without blemish in the midst of a depraved and perverse generation... among these shining like stars in the world, holding fast the word of life," as are the subdeacons who hold fast the words of the Epistles.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There is perfection with respect to merit and with respect to state. To profess oneself perfect with respect to merit is a matter of presumption, not of perfection, since Paul says in Philippians 3: Not that I am already perfect. But to profess oneself perfect with respect to state is not a matter of presumption, because this places the praise not upon the person in herself, who can be culpable through her own merits, but upon the common life and the manner of living approved by the counsel of Christ's own mouth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Paul taught this wisdom to Dionysius and Timothy and other perfect men, but he kept it hidden from others. It is up to us, then, to be perfect in order to reach it. "Forgetting what is behind, I strain forward to what is before," hoping that I may understand.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fourth aspect of the zeal of wisdom is the elevation of desire. This gives worth to other endeavors, so that "forgetting what is behind, we strain forward to what is before." "The wise man has eyes in his head. — The heart of a wise man is in his right hand." Now, the zeal of wisdom consists in this, that our endeavor be directed toward nothing but God who is "all delight."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All perverse valuations of worldly natures are prohibited. Now every perverse valuation of creatures proceeds either by reason of sublimity, or by reason of sufficiency, or by reason of delight. In the first way it is the idolatry of the proud; in the second way it is the idolatry of the avaricious; in the third way it is the idolatry of the lascivious. Against the third the Apostle says: Whose god is their belly.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Many walk, of whom I often told you, and now tell you even weeping, that they are enemies of the cross of Christ, whose end is destruction, whose god is their belly," on account of sensual wisdom; "and whose glory is in their shame," on account of diabolical wisdom; "who mind earthly things," namely on account of earthly wisdom. For the false wisdom which is from below makes a person solicitous to delight in the abundance of riches (earthly), in the experience of sensual delights (sensual), and in the eminence and ambition of worldly pomps (diabolical).”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For the perfection of interior sanctity, there is necessarily required purity of conscience and tranquility of the whole soul through the peace of God surpassing all human understanding.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the beginning I call upon the first principle, from whom all illuminations descend as from the Father of lights, from whom is every good gift and every perfect gift, namely the eternal Father, through his Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, that by the intercession of the most holy Virgin Mary, mother of the same God and our Lord Jesus Christ, and of blessed Francis, our leader and father, he may give the enlightened eyes of our mind to direct our feet in the way of that peace which surpasses all understanding; which peace our Lord Jesus Christ proclaimed and gave.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Samson with his hair was the strongest of all: his strength went beyond nature. And why was his strength in seven locks of hair? I say that by the seven locks is signified the sevenfold grace of the Holy Spirit, through whom his strength is made firm. But when he lay in the lap of Delilah and no longer had his hair, he became in strength like other men. Give me one person without grace who could endure what blessed Lawrence endured. For man can do nothing without grace, and nothing is so hard that man cannot endure it with grace. Whence the Apostle: "I can do all things in him who strengthens me."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To attribute sufficiency to divine grace, which one hopes will not be lacking to oneself on account of divine munificence, is not a matter of presumption, but of confidence and of the certainty of hope, by which we believe that God is a helper to the man who wills to adhere to His counsels. On account of which the Apostle says: Our sufficiency is from God; and the same, in the last chapter of Philippians: I can do all things in Him who strengthens me; and by this hope ought he to be sustained who, inspired by the divine Spirit, not only proposes the perfection of the evangelical counsels, but also promises it by vowing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second mode of generation is by means of expression: as in the case of the species coming out of the object, the imprint out of the seal, the speech out of the speaker, or the concept or thought out of the mind. And in these, there is deficiency. In the first, the reality of the object is lacking, for the species in the eye or in the soul is not the reality of the thing. In the second, simplicity is lacking, for the image or figure does not consist in a point or in something simple, but has parts. In the third, permanence is lacking, for speech passes away and does not remain. In the fourth, substance is lacking, for the concept of the mind is neither a substance nor a hypostasis. Take away such defects, and suppose an expression like the species deriving from the object but having reality, like the imprint produced by the seal but having simplicity, like the word coming forth from the speaker but having permanence, like the concept proceeding from the mind but having substance: and then you have the first part of the mirror.
The Psalm refers to the first manner of expression: "My heart overflows with a goodly theme." And there follows: "Fairer in beauty are you than the sons of men." Wisdom refers to the second: "For she is the refulgence of eternal light, the spotless mirror of the power of God, the image of His goodness." And the Apostle: "He is the image of the invisible God." Job refers to the third: "God speaketh once, and repeateth not the selfsame thing the second time." Understand this as meaning "in the Son," in the sense that He always is, and will never cease to be nor even be changed. In the fourth manner of expression, suppose substantiality, for the concept of the eternal mind is a hypostasis, and this mental concept is most noble and perfect. Hence, in Proverbs: "When there were no depths I was brought forth." And so He is sometimes called the Word, the Species, the Image, the Word remaining forever, the Concept—not as existing within a mind, but as being substantial: a hypostasis. And in this way we have the other part of the mirror.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For since the apprehended species is a likeness generated in the medium and then impressed upon the organ itself, and through that impression leads to its principle, namely to the object to be known; it manifestly suggests that that eternal light generates from itself a likeness or splendor coequal, consubstantial, and coeternal; and that he who is the image of the invisible God and the splendor of glory and the figure of his substance, who is everywhere through his primary generation, just as an object generates its likeness throughout the entire medium, is united through the grace of union, as a species to a bodily organ, to an individual of rational nature, so that through that union he might lead us back to the Father as to the fontal principle and object. If therefore all knowable things have to generate a species of themselves, they manifestly proclaim that in them as in mirrors can be seen the eternal generation of the Word, the Image, and the Son, eternally emanating from God the Father.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this consideration, moreover, lies the perfection of the mind's illumination, when, as on the sixth day, it sees man made in the image of God. For if an image is an expressive likeness, when our mind contemplates in Christ the Son of God, who is the image of the invisible God by nature, our humanity so wonderfully exalted, so ineffably united, seeing at once in one the first and the last, the highest and the lowest, the circumference and the center, the Alpha and the Omega, the caused and the cause, the Creator and the creature, the book, that is, written within and without: it has now arrived at a certain perfect reality, so that with God it may reach the perfection of its illuminations in the sixth stage, as on the sixth day; nor does anything further remain except the day of rest, in which through the ecstasy of the mind the keenness of the human mind may rest from every work which it had accomplished.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He, then, who is supremely alive, supremely luminous, and supremely warm, He alone is the First — He who is the principle of production, the means of government, and the end of beatification, having the first place in all things. But in order that He be a true Monarch, He must exert power to the supreme degree, preside with supreme fortitude, and guide His flock with supreme sweetness.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is objected that the soul of Christ was wise by uncreated wisdom only, thus: Where there is fullness of wisdom, it is superfluous to posit what is partial. But in Christ there is fullness of wisdom, because in him it pleased all fullness to dwell, Colossians 1. Therefore, if all created wisdom is partial, it is superfluous to posit created wisdom in Christ or in his soul.
To the objection that where there is fullness of wisdom, it is superfluous to posit what is partial: it must be said that this is true in the same subject and according to the same respect. But when it is said that Christ had the fullness of wisdom, this is according to His uncreated nature, if it is understood of fullness simply and beyond any genus; if however it is understood of fullness within a genus, then it can belong to the created nature, and this is in a certain way partial (ex parte) in relation to fullness simply speaking; nor is it superfluous, because it is more proportioned to the soul itself, since the soul by itself could not nakedly grasp that immensity of uncreated wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These six considerations having therefore been traversed, as if they were the six steps of the throne of the true Solomon, by which one arrives at peace, where the true peaceful one rests in a peaceful mind as in an interior Jerusalem; and as if also the six wings of the Cherub, by which the mind of the true contemplative, filled with the illumination of supernal wisdom, may be borne upward; and as if also the first six days, in which the mind must be exercised, so that it may at last arrive at the sabbath of rest; after our mind has contemplated God outside itself through vestiges and in the vestiges, within itself through the image and in the image, above itself through the similitude of the divine light shining upon us and in that light itself, insofar as is possible according to the state of wayfaring and the exercise of our mind; when at last in the sixth step it has arrived at this point, that it contemplates in the first and highest principle and the mediator of God and men, Jesus Christ, those things whose likenesses can in no way be found in creatures, and which exceed all keenness of the human intellect: it remains that, in contemplating these things, it should transcend and pass beyond not only this sensible world, but also itself; in which passing over, Christ is the way and the door, Christ is the ladder and the vehicle, as it were the mercy seat placed upon the ark of God and the mystery hidden from the ages.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ is also the completion of this gift, because in Him "are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge." In Him the house of wisdom is brought to perfection.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Our intent, then, is to show that in Christ "are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge," and that He Himself is the central point of all understanding. He is the central point in a sevenfold sense, in terms of essence, nature, distance, doctrine, moderation, justice and concord. The first is in the metaphysical order, the second in the physical, the third in the mathematical, the fourth in the logical, the fifth in the ethical, the sixth in the political or juridical, and the seventh in the theological. The first Center is first by eternal origin, the second is most strong through the diffusion of power, the third is most deep because of the centrality of position, the fourth is most clear by rational proof, the fifth is most important because of the choice of moral good, the sixth is outstanding because of the retribution of justice, the seventh is at peace through universal conciliation. Christ was the first center by His eternal generation, the second by His incarnation, the third by His passion, the fourth by His resurrection, the fifth by His ascension, the sixth by the judgment to come, the seventh by the eternal retribution or beatification.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These are the forty-eight boards of the dwelling — twenty on one side, and twenty on the other, and eight in the back — within which is placed the Ark, that is, Christ, containing in Himself "all the treasures of wisdom and of knowledge," upon whom the Cherubim gaze. And these are the twelve trees around the Tree of Life.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Damascene, in the third book: "We affirm that Christ as man knows all things, for in Christ are all the treasures of wisdom." If you say that this is understood according to the divine nature: to the contrary: no one knows anything that his soul is ignorant of: therefore if Christ comprehends all things, it is necessary that His soul also comprehend them.
That which is objected, that no one can know something that his soul is ignorant of: this holds true when someone knows nothing except through the soul, as is the case with a mere man. But in Christ, who knows not only through the soul but also through the divine nature, that proposition does not hold.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Once more, the Hierarch must be totally victorious by the number of His triumphs and victories. Hence, in the Epistle to the Colossians: "And you, when you were dead by reason of your sins and the uncircumcision of your flesh"; and later: "Disarming the Principalities and Powers, He displayed them openly, leading them away in triumph by force of it." Indeed, He overcame the world, despoiled Hades, and restored Paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Once more, the Hierarch must be totally victorious by the number of His triumphs and victories. Hence, in the Epistle to the Colossians: "And you, when you were dead by reason of your sins and the uncircumcision of your flesh"; and later: "Disarming the Principalities and Powers, He displayed them openly, leading them away in triumph by force of it." Indeed, He overcame the world, despoiled Hades, and restored Paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Those Sacraments of the first time, as Hugh says, were like a shadow of the truth, those of the middle time like a figure or image, and those of the last time, namely of grace, like the body, because they contain within themselves the truth and healing grace which they present, and they confer in present reality what they promise.
Since when truth arrives the shadow ceases, and the prefiguring figure attains its intended end, which once obtained, its use and exercise ought to cease: hence it is that with the arrival of grace, the old Sacraments and signs were at once fulfilled and removed, because they were prognostic signs of future things and, as it were, announcing from afar; and new ones were nevertheless instituted as demonstrative of present grace and in a certain way commemorative of the Lord's passion, which is the font and origin of curative grace. On account of which, those former Sacraments prepared and led to these, as a way to its terminus, as a sign to what it signifies, as a figure to the truth, and as the imperfect leads back and prepares for the perfect.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The holy Apostle exhorts us to attain true wisdom and to flee vain wisdom. He touches on the first when he says: "If you have risen with Christ, seek the things that are above." He gives us to understand that just as there is a twofold gaze of the soul, so there is a twofold desire of it. One gaze of the soul is toward heavenly and invisible things, the other is toward earthly and corruptible things: so also there is a twofold desire of the soul: one is for eternal things, and the other is for temporal things. So also there is a wisdom which is from above, and another which is from below. He exhorts us to the first.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But where is Christ? Certainly, above in heaven; the Apostle says: "Seek the things that are above." Therefore Christ and life are in heaven. Christ is the fountain of wisdom; He Himself is the foundation and completion of this gift.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Do not set your mind on the things that are upon the earth, for Christ was crucified to make void this wisdom; and just as Christ died to make void and destroy vain wisdom, so he rose again and ascended to teach true wisdom and to establish it in our hearts. On the cross he taught us to spurn the wisdom of the world, and going into heaven he taught us to desire the wisdom of God and to love the fountain of life. All the wisdom of the world is to spurn these things. But the greatest foolishness is to make void the death of Christ, which those do who mind the things that are upon the earth; therefore it is necessary to make void this wisdom and to desire the wisdom that is from above.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All perverse valuations of worldly natures are prohibited. Now every perverse valuation of creatures proceeds either by reason of sublimity, or by reason of sufficiency, or by reason of delight. In the first way it is the idolatry of the proud; in the second way it is the idolatry of the avaricious; in the third way it is the idolatry of the lascivious. Against the second the Apostle says: Avarice is the servitude of idols.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First Thessalonians four: Work with your hands, as we commanded you, and that you may walk honestly toward those who are outside, and that you may desire nothing of anyone's: Gloss: "Much less ask for it, or take it." But this especially regards the poor: therefore, etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First Thessalonians chapter four: We beseech you, brethren, that you endeavor to be quiet and that you work with your hands, as we have commanded you: the Gloss: "Work, which helps you to be quiet. For that evil comes from idleness." From this it is evident that he says this in order to avoid idleness and to remove sloth, which is the bilge of desires and the fuel of sins.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First Thessalonians 4: That you desire nothing of anyone: the Gloss says: "That you desire nothing of anyone, much less ask for or take anything." If therefore it is more to ask or petition than to desire, and the first is prohibited as unlawful by the Apostle, namely to desire or covet what belongs to another: therefore much more so to petition.
To that which is objected from the Gloss on 1 Thessalonians 4, that one should desire nothing of anyone nor ask for anything: it must be said that someone can ask something from another in two ways: either out of desire for another's property, or out of desire for another's salvation. The first the Apostle prohibits as evil and as prohibited in the Law, where it is said: Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's goods. But the second he does not prohibit, because the law of charity grants this, which is to be nourished by mutual benefits and causes the burden of one to be borne by another. For what is so absurd as to believe that the Apostle denied that anyone should ask from another either benefit or aid or the solace of mercy and fraternal piety? And that this is true appears from what the Apostle says at the end of Philippians about himself, thanking them for the benefit conferred: I do not seek the gift, but I seek the fruit that abounds to your account. For according to what Augustine expounds in the thirteenth book of the Confessions, he seeks the gift who delights principally in the thing received; he seeks the fruit who delights in the salvation of another.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The time of the clear doctrine extended from Hadrian. But how long it lasted, who is able to say, and who has said? It is certain that we are living in it; it is certain also that it will last until the downfall of the beast that comes up from the sea, when Babylon will be confounded and destroyed, and peace will be given. But first, tribulation must come to pass. And here no boundary can be set, for no one knows how long this time of major peace is to last, "for when they shall say, 'Peace and security,' even then sudden destruction will come upon them."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First Thessalonians 5: We beseech you that you acknowledge those who labor among you and are over you in the Lord; the Gloss says: "Just as riches beget negligence of salvation, so want, while it desires to be satisfied, turns aside from justice"; but what makes one turn aside from justice does not pertain to evangelical perfection: therefore, etc.
To that which is objected from the Gloss on 1 Thessalonians 5, that want causes one to turn aside from justice: it must be said that just as riches are not at fault, but the cupidity of riches, so want is not at fault, but the impatience of want; and whoever has this turns aside from justice, since in fleeing want he goes after money; and whoever pursues it easily turns aside from justice: for they that will be rich fall into temptations and into the snare of the devil and many hurtful desires. And just as such want is evil, so also begging arising from such want is blameworthy. But when penury pleases more than abundance, and a man out of love of poverty despises the abundance of earthly things, such a one has no occasion of turning aside from justice on account of such want; and such is the poverty and begging that pertains to evangelical perfection. And that this response is correct is clear from the Gloss itself, in which it is said that "want, when it desires to be satisfied, turns aside from justice." For the needy person who desires to be satisfied is the needy person who does not love poverty but satiety, not penury but abundance. And such a one is not the evangelical and heavenly poor man, who begs out of the supererogation of justice; but rather the covetous and earthly man, who begs out of the viciousness of fault.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the second mystery, that of the punishment of crimes, the Antichrist is represented by Nemrod who was the first to make himself emperor, and under whose command a tower was built that was to reach up to heaven. By this it may be seen that the Antichrist would be filled with the greatest pride, to the point of being "exalted above all that is called God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third flow from the light of faith consists in the rapture of love: at such times, the soul always perceives inner joy even in the face of insults and hardships. And it is at its highest when the burning soul feels that the Lord makes it taste the children's bread. Now this is the highest point of faith, the summit: to be inebriated by actual experience and to have no desire for the world. This will be the defense of such a soul in the time of the Antichrist: God sends them a misleading influence that they may believe falsehood.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This same thing is apparent through the apostolic example, Second Thessalonians three: You yourselves know how you ought to imitate us, for we were not disorderly among you, nor did we eat bread from anyone without paying, but in labor and toil, etc.; Gloss: "The Apostle was a model for those who were of slender means among the people, that they might learn not to lose their freedom. For he who frequently comes to another's table, given to idleness, must necessarily flatter the one who feeds him, since our religion calls man to freedom": therefore this is against the Christian religion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Second Thessalonians 3: If anyone does not wish to work, let him not eat: the Gloss says: "The Apostle wills that servants of God work bodily, so that they may have the means to live and not be compelled by want to beg for necessities"; but this is the way of mendicants: therefore it is not for servants of God to beg, according to the Apostle.
To the objection drawn from the Gloss on 2 Thessalonians 3, that the Apostle wills the servants of God to labor bodily, etc.: it must be said that that willing is either not a willing of precept but of admonition; or if it is a willing of precept, it does not extend to all, but to those who wish to be in want; or if it extends to those who wish to be in want for Christ's sake, it extends only to those who cannot engage in greater works. And from this it is not concluded that the life of the poor who eat and do not labor with their own hands is evil, if they are occupied with better and more salutary exercises. For if that word, He who will not work, let him not eat, were simply a precept, then all would be in an evil state who do not seek their sustenance with their own hands when they are able; and this would be to condemn the whole world. That again it does not extend to voluntary and perfect poor, is apparent from the Gloss itself, which says, "lest they be compelled by want to beg for necessities." For such persons do not beg as those compelled by necessity, but as those led by love of perfection. Lastly, that it does not extend except to those who are not occupied with greater things is apparent from the text itself of 2 Thessalonians 3: We have heard that certain among you walk disorderly, working nothing, but being busybodies: now them that are such we command, that with quietness they work and eat their own bread.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Granted that the Apostle commands manual labor of this kind — which I have never denied — yet he does not command this universally to the servants of Christ, except perhaps in a moment of necessity in which no lawful way of obtaining sustenance is available except through the labor of the hands — but he commands it to determinate persons, as is apparent from the text: We have heard that certain ones among you are walking disorderly, doing no work, but acting as busybodies. Now to those who are of this sort, we command and beseech in the Lord Jesus Christ that they work in silence and eat their own bread. And a little before: We command that you withdraw yourselves etc.; the Gloss: "He begins here concerning the busybodies and the idle, admonishing that they be corrected." It is therefore evident from the sequence of the text and from the Gloss that that command extends to the busybodies and the idle. From this, therefore, it is evident that labor is not commanded to all; and thereby mendicancy is not prohibited, except that which comes from idleness and cupidity, as the texts and Glosses indicate.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The incarnate Word restores no one unless he both conceives it by believing in his heart and brings forth outwardly what is believed by confessing with due confession; of this kind is truthful confession full of truth, which is not only speculative truth but also practical. This moreover is that in which the whole person is conformed to truth according to the understanding of reason, according to the delight of the will, and according to the adherence of virtue, so that it may be with the whole heart, the whole soul, and the whole mind, and may be from a pure heart, a good conscience, and an unfeigned faith: and such is a confession that is whole, pleasing, and intrepid: so that it may be whole by reason of Him of whom it is; pleasing by reason of Him before whom it is made; intrepid by reason of him by whom that confession must be made. Since therefore the fainthearted person is not fit for this unless he is confirmed by the hand of grace from above, therefore for this purpose the Sacrament of confirmation was divinely instituted as immediately following baptism.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Church is a union of rational men united in harmonious and uniform adherence to divine peace. For the Church in return loves itself. And love is born of obedience to the Law. And the Law itself commands love: Now "the purpose of this charge is charity, from a pure heart and a good conscience and faith unfeigned." And again, "he who loves his neighbor has fulfilled the Law." And this can be proved in the Saviour's own words: "On these two commandments depend the whole Law and the Prophets." And so it is fitting that those who obey the Law be loving also. "By this will all men know that you are My disciples, if you have love for one another." And the Apostle writes: "For God is a God of peace, not of disorder."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The eager desire for discipline gives birth to love. Hence the proper attention to discipline is love. For if you love discipline, you love virtue in yourself and in others and in its very Source. Discipline, however, does not have to be servile: it may be free, so that it loves the one who imposes it, and acts out of love, not out of fear. If you are poor as a result of discipline, you must love poverty. And the same applies to the other perfections. But love is observance of the laws. If, then, you love what is good, you keep the law, because "the purpose of this charge is charity, from a pure heart." When you keep the law, you are sanctified and filled with the Holy Spirit; and in this you are drawn away from any love that is not God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It should be noted that charity alone heals the affective dispositions. For, according to Augustine in "The City of God," love is the root of all affections. Wherefore love must be healed, otherwise all affections are distorted; but it can be healed only by divine love, which divine love is pure, provident, devoted, and perpetual: pure in regard to temperance, provident in regard to prudence, devoted in regard to justice, and perpetual in regard to fortitude. Charity, then, is the end and form of all the virtues and is from a pure heart and a good conscience and faith unfeigned.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And in this commandment consists the consummation of God's precepts, whether the world accepts it or not — this, indeed, he asserted — that is, in the abdication of all cupidity. And so, as a ninefold series is completed and made perfect by the addition of a single unit, so the nine commandments are made perfect through the abdication of cupidity, which consists in private love and disregard for the common good. Wherefore, as charity is the end and perfection of all the commandments, likewise abdicating cupidity which is opposed to charity is the perfection of the commandments.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For sacred Scripture is principally concerned with the works of reparation. Whence it treats chiefly of faith, hope, and charity, through which virtues the soul must be reformed, and most especially of charity. Of which the Apostle says that it is the end of the commandment, insofar as it proceeds from a pure heart and a good conscience and faith unfeigned. It is the fullness of the Law, as the same Apostle says. And our Savior asserts that the whole Law and the Prophets depend on the two precepts of the same, namely the love of God and of neighbor; which two are intimated in the one Spouse of the Church, Jesus Christ, who is at once neighbor and God, at once brother and lord, at once also king and friend, at once the uncreated and incarnate Word, our maker and remaker, as the Alpha and the Omega; who is also the supreme hierarch, purging and illuminating and perfecting the spouse, namely the whole Church and every holy soul.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second exercise of the gift of piety consists in the custody of intrinsic sanctification; concerning which the Apostle says: "I beseech first of all that supplications, entreaties, prayers, and thanksgivings be made for all"; there follows: "that we may lead a quiet life in all piety and chastity." You ought to understand that the summit of the Christian religion consists in piety and purity. For a man can never be piously disposed toward himself unless he has peace. This is the Christian religion, which consists in these two things. The tranquility of peace exists only in the tranquility of conscience. And conscience is not holy unless it is good and pious, namely that it prefers the life of virtue and grace to the life of nature. Consider well: if a man were more attached to his shoe than to his foot, he would not love his foot much. He who would expose his foot to breaking for the sake of a shoe, would he love his foot much and be much attached to his foot? Certainly not. He who for a small thing would expose himself to hanging would not love his own life much. Must not a man guard his soul in holiness? Certainly so. But he exposes his soul to confusion who does not guard himself from sin.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the restorative principle in reconciling necessarily has the office of mediator, therefore it is necessary that it have conformity with both extremes, not only with respect to nature, but also with respect to those things which pertain to nature. Since therefore God is just and blessed, impassible and immortal, but fallen man is a sinner and wretched, passible and mortal, it was necessary that the mediator of God and men, in order to be able to lead man back to God, share with God in justice and beatitude, but with man in passibility and mortality; so that thus, by having "a passing mortality and a permanent beatitude," he might lead man back from present misery to the blessed life; just as conversely the evil angel, by having immortality with misery and injustice, was a mediator causing the fall into guilt and misery through his suggestion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since therefore the deformation of the image and the destruction of grace is as it were an annihilation in the being of moral life and gratuitous life; since the offense against God is to be weighed as great as He Himself is; since the liability to eternal punishment holds the character of the infinite: it is impossible for man to rise from guilt unless he is recreated in gratuitous life, unless the offense is remitted, and the eternal punishment released. He alone, therefore, who was the creative principle is also the recreative principle, namely the eternal Word of the Father, which is Christ Jesus, the mediator of God and men, who because He creates all things from nothing, therefore creates by Himself alone without any intermediary.
But because He recreates, reforming what was deformed through the vice of guilt by the habit of grace and justice, absolving what was bound to punishment through condign satisfaction; hence it is that He restores us, by sustaining punishment for us in the assumed nature and by infusing reformative grace, which, since it joins us to its origin, makes us members of Christ; and through this makes the sinful soul, which had been an enemy of God, a brothel of the devil, and a slave of sin, into a bride of Christ, a temple of the Holy Spirit, and a daughter of the eternal Father: all of which comes about through the gratuitous and condescending infusion of the gratuitous gift.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Our restorative principle, namely the incarnate Word, restores us insofar as He is the mediator of God and men, the man Christ Jesus: and insofar as He is Jesus, He has the power to save; but insofar as He is Christ, the Anointed, He has the power to channel the grace of anointing to others: hence it belongs to Him in His Sacraments to bestow upon His members a saving anointing. Since, moreover, the soul, in order to be perfectly healed, needs a threefold kind of health, namely for the vigor of action, for the sweetness of contemplation, and for the happiness of comprehension: and the first belongs to those entering into the battle line of the Church, the second to those presiding in the same, whose office it is to instruct others, and the third to those departing from the same through death: hence it is that the Lord instituted not only a sacramental anointing in confirmation, but also a middle one in the pontifical order and a last one, when the danger of death is imminent.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Note that a beginning should be made from the center, that is, from Christ. For He Himself is the "Mediator between God and men," holding the central position in all things. Hence it is necessary to start from Him if a man wants to reach Christian wisdom, as it is proved in Matthew: for no one knows the Son except the Father; nor does anyone know the Father except the Son, and him to whom the Son chooses to reveal Him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“According to the aforesaid modes, one can find in the illumination of moral philosophy the light of sacred Scripture: since the intention of moral philosophy is principally concerned with rectitude: for it is concerned with general justice, which, as Anselm says, "is rectitude of the will." Now the right can be defined in three ways, and according to this the three aforementioned things shine forth in the consideration of rectitude. In one way, that is called "right whose middle does not depart from the extremes." If therefore in God there is supreme rectitude both in Himself, and insofar as He is the principle, and insofar as He is the end of all things: it is necessary to posit in God a middle Person in Himself, so that one Person only produces, another is only produced, and the middle one both produces and is produced. It is also necessary to posit a middle in the egress and return of things; but the middle in egress must hold more to the side of the one producing, while the middle in return holds more to the side of the one returning: just as therefore things went forth from God through the Word of God, so for a complete return it is necessary that the Mediator of God and men be not only God, but also man, so that He might lead men back to God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These six considerations having therefore been traversed, as if they were the six steps of the throne of the true Solomon, by which one arrives at peace, where the true peaceful one rests in a peaceful mind as in an interior Jerusalem; and as if also the six wings of the Cherub, by which the mind of the true contemplative, filled with the illumination of supernal wisdom, may be borne upward; and as if also the first six days, in which the mind must be exercised, so that it may at last arrive at the sabbath of rest; after our mind has contemplated God outside itself through vestiges and in the vestiges, within itself through the image and in the image, above itself through the similitude of the divine light shining upon us and in that light itself, insofar as is possible according to the state of wayfaring and the exercise of our mind; when at last in the sixth step it has arrived at this point, that it contemplates in the first and highest principle and the mediator of God and men, Jesus Christ, those things whose likenesses can in no way be found in creatures, and which exceed all keenness of the human intellect: it remains that, in contemplating these things, it should transcend and pass beyond not only this sensible world, but also itself; in which passing over, Christ is the way and the door, Christ is the ladder and the vehicle, as it were the mercy seat placed upon the ark of God and the mystery hidden from the ages.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The transgression of the precept was common to both, although from different causes, for it was not the man, but the woman who was deceived; in both, however, namely in the man and the woman, there was a disordering from the highest to the lowest, because first in the mind or in reason, then in sensuality, and lastly in deed. For each was prostrated through disobedience and enticed through gluttony, because each was raised up in pride: the woman indeed by desiring and pursuing what she had not yet received, the man by excessively loving and prizing what he already had; whence the woman believed she would be exalted by eating, but Adam, thinking himself something great and dear to God, believed he would be punished less severely. For he had not yet experienced the rigor of divine severity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That conjugal chastity is to be approved according to the evangelical law is shown by authority, as follows. 1 Timothy 2, it is said of woman: She shall be saved through the bearing of children, if she shall have continued in faith and love with sanctification: but in the conjugal act there is the bearing of children, and that is consonant with the law of God: therefore the conjugal act is consonant with the law of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The earth which the Spirit has filled is the ecclesiastical hierarchy; he "who weighs the mass of the earth with three fingers," because he founded the holy Church upon the divine utterances. The sacred utterances are for its stability. The Apostle says to Timothy: "I write to you, Timothy, that you may know how you ought to conduct yourself in the house of God, which is the Church of the living God, the pillar and ground of truth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning observance of divine Law, St. Paul writes: "I write these things to thee, my son Timothy, in order that thou mayest know how to conduct thyself in the house of God, which is the Church of the living God, the pillar and mainstay of the truth." The Church is called pillar and mainstay because it both enlightens the mind and strengthens virtue. Those who come to it are enlightened by faith and strengthened by the constancy of virtue. And divine Law brings about these two effects. Hence it is the column of the sons of Israel, whose motion indicated clearly how they were to act and how to rest. For on this point all Churches are in agreement, on how to observe God's Law, as in olden days the whole people kept their eyes on the moving column. He who does not look upon it does not belong to the unity of the Church, for instance if he does not understand this Law, or understanding it, refuses to obey it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second original influence of piety itself is from incarnate Wisdom. Whence the Apostle to Timothy: "Manifestly great is the sacrament of piety, which was manifested in the flesh, justified in the spirit, appeared to Angels, was preached to the nations, was believed in the world, was taken up in glory." The mystery of human redemption accomplished through the incarnate and crucified Word is the great sacrament of piety.
He says that it was manifested in the flesh, through the incarnation; was justified in the spirit, on the gibbet of the cross; appeared to Angels, in the glorification; was preached to the nations, in the mission of the Holy Spirit; was believed in the world, through the spread of the faith; was taken up in glory, through the examination of the final judgment. I say that the incarnate Son of God assumed our poverty. What brought this about? Certainly piety. "Whence he ought in all things to be made like unto his brethren, that he might become a merciful and faithful high priest before God, to make propitiation for the sins of the people." Through piety he assumed flesh, ascended the cross, was raised from the dead, sent the Holy Spirit upon the earth, called the Church to himself, and freed all the worthy from misery through piety. The Apostle to the Romans says: "Do you despise the riches of his goodness and patience and longsuffering? Do you not know that the kindness of God leads you to repentance? But according to your hardness and impenitent heart, you treasure up for yourself wrath in the day of wrath and of the revelation of the just judgment of God." The Son of God offered a holocaust, namely himself for us: this is the great sacrament of piety.
This sacrament is repeated daily upon the altar. For these reasons he gave us the Sacrament of the altar, so that, mindful of the sacrament of piety, we might put on the bowels of piety. Cruel is the heart that is not softened by these things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These words are in the first Epistle to Timothy, in which the Apostle shows that there is a twofold exercise befitting man: one bodily, and another spiritual; and he shows that spiritual exercise is to be preferred to bodily as being a nobler exercise and a more useful one. For bodily exercise has little utility; whence he says: "Bodily exercise profiteth little"; but spiritual exercise has the greatest utility. Whence spiritual exercise is to be preferred to bodily: as much as spiritual things are to be preferred to bodily, eternal to temporal, and invisible to visible, so much is that spiritual exercise to be preferred to bodily. Therefore, if anyone is wise, he ought to seek spiritual exercise more than bodily, because bodily exercise profiteth little, for it is useful for the comfort of the body, but sometimes it is the cause and occasion of the contrary. Someone believes he is going to sport, and he goes to war; he seeks pleasure, and finds sorrow. Whence Seneca says: "I have found many exercising the body, but few exercising their minds." Foolish would he be who could dig for gold and wished to dig in mud. Spiritual exercise surpasses bodily more than gold surpasses mud. Of this spiritual exercise, insofar as it is ordered to piety, we must speak.
The Apostle Paul, as a good teacher, arouses the concern of our minds and intellects toward the good use of the divine gift. And having presupposed the influx of piety, he invites us to the exercise of piety and sets forth the benefit of piety. If you have received the gift of God, exercise yourself unto piety, lest you fall from the gift; if you do not have the gift of God, exercise yourself to obtain piety. He assigns the reason for this when he adds: "Piety is profitable for all things." Therefore he shows that concerning this gift of piety, three things are to be considered by us, namely the exercise of piety, the benefit of piety, and the original principle of piety. If it is a gift, then it is necessary to know how it is given; if it is a noble gift, it is necessary to know how we may advance in it and exercise ourselves; if it is a useful gift, let us see what fruit we may obtain from it.
See, my whole intention is that you conceive the gift of piety in your soul and learn what it is to be pious.
The exercise of piety consists in a threefold act, namely in the reverence of divine veneration, in the custody of intrinsic sanctification, and in the superabundance of interior compassion. The first two modes of piety are more deeply rooted than the third.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But what is the usefulness of the gift of piety? He says: "Piety is profitable for all things, having the promise of the life that now is and of the life to come." I do not know what more to add. Do you have temporal goods? Piety is profitable for those; and likewise for spiritual goods. Those who have suffered the slipperiness of the flesh have sometimes been freed through the gift of piety, and afterwards they obtained mercy. For piety is profitable for all things: it is profitable for knowing truths, for avoiding all evils, and for obtaining all goods.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Someone will say: 'Do you commend to me that I should follow the counsels and enter the religious order?' He says: 'The order is fictitious, newly established, it has outward signs.' Further he says: 'It is a small thing to despise temporal goods; we cannot give them up. Why should we give up these few goods? What is the worth of bare feet? Bodily exercise is profitable for a little, but godliness is profitable for all things.' However much the order may be fictitious and new, it is nevertheless good. And as to what he says, that bodily exercise is profitable for a little, and that it is a small thing to give up temporal goods; I say that these are the greatest sacrifices. Christ did not come for a small thing. It is the greatest thing to live in chastity and poverty. These are the greatest, highest, and noblest sacrifices, and you reckon the counsel of God as nothing, you despise the counsel of God in yourself and in others.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against the vowing of widowed continence it is objected: 1 Timothy 5: Let a widow be chosen not less than sixty years of age; and in the same place: Avoid the younger widows: therefore it does not seem that widowed chastity should be undertaken except in elderly women, nor this for any other reason than on account of the danger: therefore it does not seem safe to make a vow of continence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that which is objected: Let a widow be chosen not less than sixty years old: it must be said that this is not understood with respect to the vow of continence, but with respect to the ministry that was to be rendered to the Saints, who also were to be sustained from ecclesiastical goods. Hence in the Gloss: "Let a widow be chosen not less than sixty years old, who is to be nourished by the sustenance of the Church." Hence what he adds: Avoid younger widows: is understood in the same sense. Hence the Gloss there: "Avoid younger widows, that is, do not so greatly concern yourself with their vows of chastity as to undertake to sustain them with the sustenance of the Church." But that he does not intend to prohibit continence or the vow of continence for them is apparent from what Ambrose says in the book On Virginity: "We ought not to regard the virtue of age, but the age of virtue; nor should you marvel at profession in young girls, when you read of passion in little children." Hence also blessed Agnes in her legend, which Ambrose composed: "Do not, she said to the prefect, so despise bodily youth in me as to think that I wish to have you favorable: for faith is found not in years but in understanding, and almighty God approves minds more than ages."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against the vowing of widowed continence it is objected: 1 Timothy 5: Let a widow be chosen not less than sixty years of age; and in the same place: Avoid the younger widows: therefore it does not seem that widowed chastity should be undertaken except in elderly women, nor this for any other reason than on account of the danger: therefore it does not seem safe to make a vow of continence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that which is objected: Let a widow be chosen not less than sixty years old: it must be said that this is not understood with respect to the vow of continence, but with respect to the ministry that was to be rendered to the Saints, who also were to be sustained from ecclesiastical goods. Hence in the Gloss: "Let a widow be chosen not less than sixty years old, who is to be nourished by the sustenance of the Church." Hence what he adds: Avoid younger widows: is understood in the same sense. Hence the Gloss there: "Avoid younger widows, that is, do not so greatly concern yourself with their vows of chastity as to undertake to sustain them with the sustenance of the Church." But that he does not intend to prohibit continence or the vow of continence for them is apparent from what Ambrose says in the book On Virginity: "We ought not to regard the virtue of age, but the age of virtue; nor should you marvel at profession in young girls, when you read of passion in little children." Hence also blessed Agnes in her legend, which Ambrose composed: "Do not, she said to the prefect, so despise bodily youth in me as to think that I wish to have you favorable: for faith is found not in years but in understanding, and almighty God approves minds more than ages."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Against the vowing of widowed continence it is objected: 1 Timothy 5: I wish the younger women to marry, to bear children: but the vow of continence is contrary to this: therefore the Apostle wished the contrary of the vow of continence: therefore continence is not to be vowed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that which is objected from the word of the Apostle: I will that the younger women marry, etc.: it must be said that neither is this a precept, but it is permissive, just as the preceding one; and therefore it does not follow that to vow continence is reprehensible. Whence Augustine, in the book On Widowhood: "What the Apostle says: I will that the younger women marry, bear children, commends the good of marriage with apostolic authority and sobriety; he does not impose the duty of procreation upon those who embrace the good of continence, as though it were an obligation of law." And later: "To devote oneself to the procreation of children in the honorable order of marriage is not a disposition to be condemned in a person; yet the Christian mind that thinks on heavenly things more laudably transcends and overcomes this. But since, as the Lord says, not all receive this word, let her who can receive it, receive it; and let her who does not contain herself marry; let her who has not begun deliberate, and let her who has undertaken it persevere; let no occasion be given to the adversary, let no offering be withdrawn from Christ."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the law of grace considers the origin, fall, and remedy of nature, it belongs to it to approve the threefold mode and distinction of obedience. For it approves filial obedience, Ephesians 6: Children, obey your parents in the Lord: for this is just. It also approves servile obedience, 1 Timothy 6: Whoever are under the yoke of servitude, let them consider their masters worthy of all honor. It also praises jurisdictional obedience, Hebrews last chapter: Obey your superiors and be subject to them: for they keep watch, etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Piety is profitable for knowing truths. God gives His gifts upon every creature: but the knowledge of truth He gives only to those who act piously. How could one attain to originated things who does not attain to the origin of truth? How would one know the origin of truth who opposes the origin of truth? The Apostle says to Timothy: "If anyone teaches otherwise and does not consent to the sound words of our Lord Jesus Christ and to the doctrine which is according to piety, he is proud and knows nothing, and is sick about questions and disputes of words." It is necessary that a man assent to the doctrine which is according to piety. If you wish to be true scholars, it is necessary that you have piety.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Moreover, nature itself especially makes the way to this, whether instituted or fallen. For man was formed naked, and if he had remained in that state, he would have appropriated absolutely nothing to himself; but fallen man is born naked and dies naked. And therefore this is the most direct way: that, not turning aside from these extremes, one should walk poor and naked, as far as nature can endure. And this is what is said in 1 Timothy 6: We brought nothing into this world, and without doubt we can carry nothing out. And from this he concludes: Having food and covering, let us be content with these. Now this is nothing stricter or poorer than to be content with simple food and covering; which the Apostle urges from the teaching of nature as good and perfect.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To that which is objected from the Gloss on First Timothy six: Having food etc., where it is said that temporal things are not to be entirely cast away: it must be said that it understands the casting away of temporal things with respect to use, not with respect to ownership. For the use of temporal things is necessary for human life, which nevertheless can be had without ownership and property, as is evident in the poor, who have nothing of property. And that this is the meaning is evident from what follows immediately in the Gloss, where it adds that "having food and that with which we may be covered, let us be content with these things; he who reaches beyond finds evil." To be content, therefore, with the use of covering and food is the mode of perfect virtue. And thus the Gloss ought to be understood, nor does this conflict with the highest poverty. But whoever would so wish to cast away temporal things that he would neither wish to receive food nor have covering would not act perfectly, but foolishly. And this is what that Gloss intends to suggest.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fear causes one to withdraw from evil and from the occasion of evil; and because the root of all evils is cupidity, therefore fear disposes to poverty of spirit, in which humility is joined together with poverty, so that the perfect man may thus be distanced from the fount of all fault, namely from pride and cupidity. And hence it is that poverty of spirit is the foundation of all evangelical perfection.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In these two commandments: "You shall not covet your neighbor's goods, nor shall you desire his wife," the illicit interior act is prohibited, and here the concupiscence of the eyes, or covetousness, is prohibited, which "is the root of all evils"; the concupiscence of the flesh is also prohibited, which is the kindling of all sins. Through this twofold concupiscence occurs the transmission of all evils and sins; and therefore the divine law prohibits it, and in this prohibits all evils and all sins.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The commandments of God are irreproachable, because they contain nothing unjust. "I command you before God, who gives life to all things, that you keep the commandment without stain, irreproachable."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Such light is beyond reach and is yet the closest to the soul, even more than it is to itself. It is also unconfinable, and yet supremely intimate. This can be seen by none but a man suspended beyond himself in a lofty vision; and when we wish to see by means of simple intuition how such art is one and yet manifold, we cannot conceive how infinite it is, except in terms of extension, because the imagination interferes: and so we cannot see by simple intuition, except through reasoning.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the last chapter of First Timothy it is said of God: *Who alone has immortality and dwells in inaccessible light, whom no man has seen, nor can see.* But everything by which or in which we know is accessible to the knower: therefore that by which or in which we know cannot be the light of eternal reason or truth. — To this it must be said that he speaks of that approach which is to that light in the fullness and splendor of its clarity, in which way one does not approach it through the power of a creature, but through the deiformity of glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We must speak first of the sustainment of the intellect. But, as the Apostle says, the farmer who toils must be the first to partake of the fruit. For the preacher himself must first be filled and sweetened before offering anything to others. Yet, there are many who want to be considered prophets and to be heard as prophets, and their bread or food is tasteless and improperly cooked and cold, and they hold the people, but to little avail.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It belongs to those having principal authority to receive support authoritatively, as the Gloss says on Second Timothy 2: The laboring farmer ought to be the first to partake of the fruits: there the Gloss says: "To take for himself what is necessary from those among whom he serves God and whom he tends as a cultivator of the vineyard, or feeds as a flock, is not begging but authority": so to those to whom sub-principal authority belongs, it belongs to them to receive by way of supplication. This the Holy Spirit disposed for the benefit of the Church, so that they might build up not only by the word of preaching, but also equally by the word and the example of humility.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the first principle, by the very fact that it is first, is supreme, whatever it has it has in the highest degree; therefore it is necessary that it be most righteous. Since therefore in rendering retribution it acts according to righteousness—just as it cannot act against itself, nor deny itself, nor assail its own justice—so necessarily, its righteousness requiring it, sin must be punished according to the magnitude of the fault, especially in those who, despising the law of mercy, have through impenitence struck against the severity of justice. Since therefore it belongs to the severity of justice to consider fault not only with respect to the root, but also with respect to the aggravating circumstances, it is most fitting that the just judge exact the due punishments from the impious down to the last farthing, so that the disgrace of sin may not remain without the beauty of justice; and just as power is manifest in creating and wisdom in governing and clemency in restoring, so may supreme justice be made manifest in punishing.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From the observance of the law a man becomes reverent, faithful, devout, pious, meek, chaste, generous, truthful, content with his own possessions — that is, liberal in heart and undefiled in mind. On the contrary, from the transgression of the law a man becomes an idolater, a blasphemer, undevout, impious, a murderer, an adulterer, a thief, a liar, covetous, and carnal. Therefore the transgressor of the law and the observer are more distant from one another than hell is from paradise, because the one is at the center and the other is at the circumference; nor can the God of heaven do otherwise, because He is just and "cannot deny Himself."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And Paul says of it: "You too, were sealed with the Holy Spirit of the promise." Through this seal, the friends are distinguished from the enemies, free men from slaves, heavenly men from the earthly. This seal is imprinted on the forehead of the contemplative soul and on the foreheads of the elect. This seal was imprinted on those standing upon Mount Sion. In the Second Epistle to Timothy, it is written: "The sure foundation of God stands firm." This is the seal by which "the Lord knows who are His." He knows through an express seal through which the soul calls upon the name of the Lord out of its inner depths.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Some are content to have exterior holiness, namely in word and gesture and outward conduct; but this is to adorn holiness outwardly, like a man who whitewashes himself outwardly and makes a sepulcher of the dead, which outwardly is whitewashed. But just as "feigned righteousness is not righteousness, but double iniquity," so feigned holiness is not holiness, but rather iniquity. Against such the Apostle says: "In the last times there will be men who are lovers of pleasures, having the appearance of piety, but denying its power."
"Having the appearance of piety," "that is, of religion," says the Gloss. Those having the appearance of piety are hypocrites.
For such a one is a son of perdition. Of such a one it is said: "With the breath of his lips he shall strike the impious one," namely him who will have the greatest appearance of piety. Therefore the second exercise of the gift of piety is through the custody of interior holiness. But some have no mercy on their soul; indeed, they do the worst they can to their soul. They supremely hate their soul; they could not do worse to it than they do, because they do everything the devil suggests to them. "Have pity on your soul!" And some under the appearance of piety take up things that are against their soul. They say: I will go to baseness under the appearance of piety. What piety is this? Certainly none.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There are three orders: the priestly, corresponding to the Thrones; the episcopal, corresponding to the Cherubim; and the patriarchal, corresponding to the Seraphim--not properly speaking on account of the imposition of some new character, since there is no level above the priesthood, but because of eminence and power. It is fitting that the bishop "be holding fast the faithful word." But the Pope must be the most perfect of them all. And if the interior ordination corresponded to the exterior, that would be the best.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We take up the name of God in vain through frustration of a Sacrament received; and according to this there is a threefold degree of taking the name of God in vain. The first is when someone does not believe in the Sacrament, like a heretic. Second, when one believes but does not dispose himself for the Sacrament, like a usurer. Third, when someone does not preserve the grace received in the Sacrament, like one who afterward sins. Hear, you who are marked with the Christian name: the character is then imprinted upon you through the power of the name of God; and when you afterward sin, you empty out the power of the Sacrament. Of such persons the Apostle says to Titus: "They profess to know God, but by their deeds they deny Him."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second fruit of grace is the fullness of justice, which consists in this, that a man be just in himself and with respect to God and with respect to his neighbor, namely that a man avoid evil and work good. And how? The Apostle says to Titus: "The grace of God our Savior has appeared to all men, instructing us, that denying ungodliness and worldly desires, we should live soberly, justly, and piously in this world, awaiting the blessed hope and the coming of the glory of the great God." This is the grace which expels all evils and bestows all goods: therefore in grace is the fullness of justice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second fruit of grace is the fullness of justice, which consists in this, that a man be just in himself and with respect to God and with respect to his neighbor, namely that a man avoid evil and work good. And how? The Apostle says to Titus: "The grace of God our Savior has appeared to all men, instructing us, that denying ungodliness and worldly desires, we should live soberly, justly, and piously in this world, awaiting the blessed hope and the coming of the glory of the great God." This is the grace which expels all evils and bestows all goods: therefore in grace is the fullness of justice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third original influence of the gift of piety is from holy mother Church, sanctified through the Holy Spirit, who possesses the pledge of the Holy Spirit. Holy mother Church has enjoined piety upon all. Those who are born from one father and one mother love one another more than those who are born from one father alone, or from one mother alone. The Holy Spirit makes us children of one father and one mother and members of one body. The Apostle: "The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, our Savior, has appeared to all men, instructing us that, denying impiety and worldly desires, we should live soberly and justly and piously in this world."
See whether your piety is that of brother toward brother, and of a brother from the same womb toward a brother from the same womb! Who is our father? Certainly God. Who is our mother? It is the Church, who from her womb bore us through the Holy Spirit and will bring us forth when we shall be presented in eternal light. Do you not see that just as one member suffers with another member, so also we ought to suffer with one another? We are all members of one body, we are nourished with one food, we are brought forth from the same womb, we tend toward the same inheritance: and our inheritance will be magnified the more numerous we shall be, not diminished. We are one body; we ought to be piously disposed toward one another. Come to the father, the father receives you, or the mother; if holy mother Church stands by, even flagitious sinners will be compelled to return. We ought therefore to suffer with one another.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And the Apostle demonstrates these three things in his Epistle to Titus: We may live temperately and justly and piously in this world. Temperately, that is, in a holy manner; piously, which stands [in the Apostle's text]; justly, that is, truly. God, therefore, gives the laws, not by will, but by the greatest reason.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Grace arises in us through the Word inspired. However much God sent His Son into the flesh, unless you believe Him crucified, you will not have grace. Whence the Apostle to Titus: "Not by works of justice which we have done, but according to His mercy He saved us, through the laver of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit, whom He poured out abundantly upon us through Jesus Christ, our Savior." It is the Holy Spirit who is the giver of graces and the love proceeding from the Father and the Son. Whatever therefore the Father does and the Son suffers, without the Holy Spirit it is nothing. For He Himself joins us to the Father and the Son.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Grace arises in us through the Word inspired. However much God sent His Son into the flesh, unless you believe Him crucified, you will not have grace. Whence the Apostle to Titus: "Not by works of justice which we have done, but according to His mercy He saved us, through the laver of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit, whom He poured out abundantly upon us through Jesus Christ, our Savior." It is the Holy Spirit who is the giver of graces and the love proceeding from the Father and the Son. Whatever therefore the Father does and the Son suffers, without the Holy Spirit it is nothing. For He Himself joins us to the Father and the Son.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From Christ is the fruit of grace. This fruit of grace is fourfold: it consists in steadying the soul through faith, blessing it through divine love, lifting it up through hope, curbing it through divine fear. The third is mentioned in the Epistle to Titus: "Justified by His grace, we are heirs in the hope of life everlasting."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First, then, the only being able to save would have to be preeminent in power. Hence, in the Epistle to the Hebrews: "God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spoke in times past to the fathers by the prophets, last of all in these days has spoken to us by His Son, whom He appointed heir of all things, by whom also He made the world; who, being the brightness of His glory and the image of His substance, and upholding all things by the Word of His power, has effected man's purgation from sin and taken His seat at the right hand of the Majesty on high, having become so much superior to the angels as He has inherited a more excellent name than they." From Him, indeed, miracles come forth, and hence it was necessary that He show the miracle of miracles in His own Person, that is, the plurality of natures: for He possesses corporeal, spiritual, and divine natures—the temporal, the aeviternal, and the eternal. Hence again it belongs to Him to bind the lowest with the highest.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Holy Spirit radiated in the hearts of the preachers so that they could preach and write all the truth. God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spoke in times past to the fathers by the prophets, last of all in these days has spoken to us by His Son. And this threefold firmness of faith is explained: first, as expressed through the Uncreated Word, when He says, at sundry times, etc., and, being the brightness of His glory. Second, as expressed through the Incarnate Word, in the passage: He has effected man's purgation from sin. Third, as expressed through the Inspired Word, in the passage: For it was first announced by the Lord.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First, then, the only being able to save would have to be preeminent in power. Hence, in the Epistle to the Hebrews: "God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spoke in times past to the fathers by the prophets, last of all in these days has spoken to us by His Son, whom He appointed heir of all things, by whom also He made the world; who, being the brightness of His glory and the image of His substance, and upholding all things by the Word of His power, has effected man's purgation from sin and taken His seat at the right hand of the Majesty on high, having become so much superior to the angels as He has inherited a more excellent name than they." From Him, indeed, miracles come forth, and hence it was necessary that He show the miracle of miracles in His own Person, that is, the plurality of natures: for He possesses corporeal, spiritual, and divine natures—the temporal, the aeviternal, and the eternal. Hence again it belongs to Him to bind the lowest with the highest.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Holy Spirit radiated in the hearts of the preachers so that they could preach and write all the truth. God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spoke in times past to the fathers by the prophets, last of all in these days has spoken to us by His Son. And this threefold firmness of faith is explained: first, as expressed through the Uncreated Word, when He says, at sundry times, etc., and, being the brightness of His glory. Second, as expressed through the Incarnate Word, in the passage: He has effected man's purgation from sin. Third, as expressed through the Inspired Word, in the passage: For it was first announced by the Lord.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First, then, the only being able to save would have to be preeminent in power. Hence, in the Epistle to the Hebrews: "God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spoke in times past to the fathers by the prophets, last of all in these days has spoken to us by His Son, whom He appointed heir of all things, by whom also He made the world; who, being the brightness of His glory and the image of His substance, and upholding all things by the Word of His power, has effected man's purgation from sin and taken His seat at the right hand of the Majesty on high, having become so much superior to the angels as He has inherited a more excellent name than they." From Him, indeed, miracles come forth, and hence it was necessary that He show the miracle of miracles in His own Person, that is, the plurality of natures: for He possesses corporeal, spiritual, and divine natures—the temporal, the aeviternal, and the eternal. Hence again it belongs to Him to bind the lowest with the highest.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And this threefold firmness of faith is explained: first, as expressed through the Uncreated Word, when He says, at sundry times, etc., and, being the brightness of His glory. Second, as expressed through the Incarnate Word, in the passage: He has effected man's purgation from sin. Third, as expressed through the Inspired Word, in the passage: For it was first announced by the Lord.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“By means of diffusion, as of brightness out of light, of heat out of fire, of a river out of its headspring, of rain out of a full or humid cloud. In the first diffusion, equality is lacking, for brightness is not the same as light. In the second, closeness is lacking, for heat is not close to fire, since it is the principle neither of its form nor of its origin, but is merely an accident. In the third, simultaneity is lacking, for a spring diffuses itself by flowing, and not all at once. In the fourth, fullness is lacking, for not all of the rain is drawn out of a cloud, but only successive drops. Now, join these four conditions to a single diffusion, one of splendor having equality, of heat having closeness and substantiality, of a river or fountain having simultaneity, and of rain having fullness: and in this way, you will have a trace of the eternal generation.
Hence, the Son is sometimes compared to brightness: "Being the brightness of His glory," etc.; at other times, to a flame, as in Moses' bush which represented the person of the Son; or again, as a river or spring: "But a spring rose out of the earth. A river rose in Eden." Again, He is sometimes compared to rain: "For just as from the heavens the rain and snow come down and do not return there till they have watered the earth," etc. And, later: "So shall my word be that goes forth from my mouth," that is, from the Father's heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For since the apprehended species is a likeness generated in the medium and then impressed upon the organ itself, and through that impression leads to its principle, namely to the object to be known; it manifestly suggests that that eternal light generates from itself a likeness or splendor coequal, consubstantial, and coeternal; and that he who is the image of the invisible God and the splendor of glory and the figure of his substance, who is everywhere through his primary generation, just as an object generates its likeness throughout the entire medium, is united through the grace of union, as a species to a bodily organ, to an individual of rational nature, so that through that union he might lead us back to the Father as to the fontal principle and object. If therefore all knowable things have to generate a species of themselves, they manifestly proclaim that in them as in mirrors can be seen the eternal generation of the Word, the Image, and the Son, eternally emanating from God the Father.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If indeed we consider speech by reason of its end, it is for expressing, for instructing, and for moving; but it never expresses anything except by means of a species, never teaches except by means of a demonstrative light, never moves except by means of a power: and it is clear that this does not happen except through a species, a light, and a power that are intrinsic, intrinsically united to the soul: and therefore Augustine concludes that he alone is the true teacher who can impress a species, infuse a light, and give power to the heart of the hearer. And hence it is that "he who inwardly teaches hearts has his chair in heaven."
Just as, therefore, nothing is perfectly known through speech except by means of a power, light, and species united to the soul; so in order that the soul may be instructed unto the knowledge of God through his internal speech, it is necessary that it be united to him who is the splendor of glory and the figure of his substance, upholding all things by the word of his power.
From this it is clear how wondrous is this contemplation, through which Augustine in many books leads by the hand to divine wisdom.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“First, then, the only being able to save would have to be preeminent in power. Hence, in the Epistle to the Hebrews: "God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spoke in times past to the fathers by the prophets, last of all in these days has spoken to us by His Son, whom He appointed heir of all things, by whom also He made the world; who, being the brightness of His glory and the image of His substance, and upholding all things by the Word of His power, has effected man's purgation from sin and taken His seat at the right hand of the Majesty on high, having become so much superior to the angels as He has inherited a more excellent name than they." From Him, indeed, miracles come forth, and hence it was necessary that He show the miracle of miracles in His own Person, that is, the plurality of natures: for He possesses corporeal, spiritual, and divine natures—the temporal, the aeviternal, and the eternal. Hence again it belongs to Him to bind the lowest with the highest.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, the same distinction is had in relation to action, which is the lowest, in which [function] are all those spirits that are sent for service, for "the highest ones never recede from the intimate." Wherefore Dionysius raises the question of the Seraph sent to Isaias, but he does not solve it. But it seems better to be of the opinion that it was another angel, receiving his fire from an angel of that particular order, and thus named after him. Now, this action has three functions, to cleanse, enlighten, and perfect. Perfecting is greater than enlightening, and the latter is greater than cleansing. Cleansing befits the Angels, enlightening, the Archangels, and perfecting, the Principalities.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Those governing both the former and the latter are spiritual substances, either entirely conjoined, as are the souls of brutes, or separably conjoined, as are rational spirits, or entirely separate, as are celestial spirits, whom the philosophers call Intelligences, and we call Angels. To whom, according to the philosophers, it belongs to move the celestial bodies, and through this the administration of the universe is attributed to them, receiving from the first cause, namely God, the influx of power, which they pour back according to the work of governance, which regards the natural subsistence of things. But according to the theologians, the governance of the universe is attributed to the same according to the command of the supreme God with respect to the works of reparation, according to which they are called ministering spirits, sent for the sake of those who receive the inheritance of salvation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Holy Spirit radiated in the hearts of the preachers so that they could preach and write all the truth. God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spoke in times past to the fathers by the prophets, last of all in these days has spoken to us by His Son. And later it is said: For if the word spoken by angels proved to be valid; and still later: For it was first announced by the Lord and was confirmed unto us by those who heard Him; God also, according to His own will, bearing them witness by signs and wonders, and by manifold powers, and by impartings of the Holy Spirit. And this threefold firmness of faith is explained: first, as expressed through the Uncreated Word, when He says, at sundry times, etc., and, being the brightness of His glory. Second, as expressed through the Incarnate Word, in the passage: He has effected man's purgation from sin. Third, as expressed through the Inspired Word, in the passage: For it was first announced by the Lord.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Holy Spirit radiated in the hearts of the preachers so that they could preach and write all the truth. God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spoke in times past to the fathers by the prophets, last of all in these days has spoken to us by His Son. And later it is said: For if the word spoken by angels proved to be valid; and still later: For it was first announced by the Lord and was confirmed unto us by those who heard Him; God also, according to His own will, bearing them witness by signs and wonders, and by manifold powers, and by impartings of the Holy Spirit. And this threefold firmness of faith is explained: first, as expressed through the Uncreated Word, when He says, at sundry times, etc., and, being the brightness of His glory. Second, as expressed through the Incarnate Word, in the passage: He has effected man's purgation from sin. Third, as expressed through the Inspired Word, in the passage: For it was first announced by the Lord.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since before His coming they were not bound to believe in the Trinity except implicitly, now after the promulgation of the New Testament all are bound to believe it explicitly, so that it is now not only credible because worthy of belief, or fitting from the testimony of creation, but also obligatory through the promulgation of evangelical truth, whose promulgation had its beginning from the Savior, as is said in Hebrews 2, where the Apostle, speaking of the Christian faith, says thus: Having received its beginning to be declared through the Lord, it was confirmed unto us by those who heard, with signs and wonders and various powers and distributions of the Holy Spirit according to His will.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Holy Spirit radiated in the hearts of the preachers so that they could preach and write all the truth. God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spoke in times past to the fathers by the prophets, last of all in these days has spoken to us by His Son. And later it is said: For if the word spoken by angels proved to be valid; and still later: For it was first announced by the Lord and was confirmed unto us by those who heard Him; God also, according to His own will, bearing them witness by signs and wonders, and by manifold powers, and by impartings of the Holy Spirit. And this threefold firmness of faith is explained: first, as expressed through the Uncreated Word, when He says, at sundry times, etc., and, being the brightness of His glory. Second, as expressed through the Incarnate Word, in the passage: He has effected man's purgation from sin. Third, as expressed through the Inspired Word, in the passage: For it was first announced by the Lord.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the New Testament, after the universal scripture and the course of time, Christ was formed, as was man on the sixth day, that He may "have dominion over the fish of the sea," and "the birds of the air." As the Psalm says, "what is man that You should be mindful of him, or the son of man that You should care for him? You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor. You have given him rule over the works of your hands, putting all things under his feet: all sheep and oxen, yes, and the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, the fishes of the sea," etc. And in order that it be understood of Christ, the Apostle says: "You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor." And there follows: "But we do see Him who was made 'a little lower than the angels,' namely, Jesus, crowned with glory and honor because of His having suffered death." Man was created out of a virgin soil that had never received blood, which signifies Christ born of the Virgin; and as Eve was formed out of Adam's side, so also the Church, out of the side of Christ. But since Christ never sinned, how can Adam's transgression correspond to Him? There must be transference from the head to the body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the New Testament, after the universal scripture and the course of time, Christ was formed, as was man on the sixth day, that He may "have dominion over the fish of the sea," and "the birds of the air." As the Psalm says, "what is man that You should be mindful of him, or the son of man that You should care for him? You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor. You have given him rule over the works of your hands, putting all things under his feet: all sheep and oxen, yes, and the beasts of the field, the birds of the air, the fishes of the sea," etc. And in order that it be understood of Christ, the Apostle says: "You have made him little less than the angels, and crowned him with glory and honor." And there follows: "But we do see Him who was made 'a little lower than the angels,' namely, Jesus, crowned with glory and honor because of His having suffered death." Man was created out of a virgin soil that had never received blood, which signifies Christ born of the Virgin; and as Eve was formed out of Adam's side, so also the Church, out of the side of Christ. But since Christ never sinned, how can Adam's transgression correspond to Him? There must be transference from the head to the body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The mystery of human redemption accomplished through the incarnate and crucified Word is the great sacrament of piety. I say that the incarnate Son of God assumed our poverty. What brought this about? Certainly piety. "Whence he ought in all things to be made like unto his brethren, that he might become a merciful and faithful high priest before God, to make propitiation for the sins of the people." Through piety he assumed flesh, ascended the cross, was raised from the dead, sent the Holy Spirit upon the earth, called the Church to himself, and freed all the worthy from misery through piety.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It was necessary that our Hierarch be endowed with awareness, in regard to the threefold wisdom within Him: the innate, that is, the wisdom of angels and of the first man, the infused, and the eternal. Through the first, He knows all things which we are able to know by means of the proper disposition; through the second, He comprehends gloriously and infinitely, because "to His wisdom there is no limit"; through the third, He comprehends all things. For the One who was to restore the whole universe had to know the conditions of the whole universe. Hence, in the Epistle to the Hebrews: "The Word of God is living and efficient." And later: "All things are naked and open to the eyes of Him to whom we have to give account." Hence, it was necessary not only that He be powerful, but also that He be aware.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It was necessary that our Hierarch be endowed with awareness, in regard to the threefold wisdom within Him: the innate, that is, the wisdom of angels and of the first man, the infused, and the eternal. Through the first, He knows all things which we are able to know by means of the proper disposition; through the second, He comprehends gloriously and infinitely, because "to His wisdom there is no limit"; through the third, He comprehends all things. For the One who was to restore the whole universe had to know the conditions of the whole universe. Hence, in the Epistle to the Hebrews: "The Word of God is living and efficient." And later: "All things are naked and open to the eyes of Him to whom we have to give account." Hence, it was necessary not only that He be powerful, but also that He be aware.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But who will deliver us from these plagues? Certainly there is one alone who came to deliver us, namely Christ, who made ten condescensions against the ten plagues. The first was down to our flesh. The second was down to our mortality. The third, to our neediness, for he suffered hunger, thirst, and cold. The fourth was to our poverty, for "he was made destitute," having no place to which he might turn. The fifth, to our temptation, when he permitted himself to be tempted; and in this he bore our weakness. The Apostle: "We do not have a High Priest who cannot sympathize with our weaknesses, but one tempted in all things." The sixth, to the weariness of body and our toil. The seventh, to our anxiety; whence: "Jesus began to be fearful and distressed and said: My soul is sorrowful even unto death." The eighth was to the cross, and this was wondrous. The ninth was to death. The tenth was to the prison of hell.
These are the ten condescensions by which God condescended to man. But why did he descend to the prison of hell? Certainly, so that in the blood of the covenant he might lead the captives out of prison, those sitting in darkness and the shadow of death. Christ, through the blood of the new covenant, freed us and led us from death to life, and from darkness to light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But if you ask, "What need was there for Him to have wisdom besides the divine?" I will answer: in order that He might have experience. As it is written in the Epistle to the Hebrews, "we have not a High Priest that cannot have compassion on our infirmities, but one tried as we are in all things except sin." For He stands both as our Advocate and our Judge; and He it is who was the best Counselor and the most wise: hence all other sages were nothing but figures and imitations of this Wise One. From Him come forth documents of the greatest certainty and celebrity by which we need to be taught; and that is why He is called Counselor.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The Apostle Paul urges those wishing to obtain grace to approach the throne of grace, that is, the glorious Virgin. "Let us approach," he says, "with confidence to the throne of his grace."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The clerical order is both active and contemplative, which must both feed and contemplate so that its members be intermediates between God and the people. For "every high priest taken from among men is appointed for men in the things pertaining to God, that he may offer gifts and sacrifices for sins." And among these, there are three orders, the ministerial, the sacerdotal, and the pontifical. All are reduced to these, for they are either ministering, and they are the first six; or they are sanctifying through words; or again, they rule through eminence.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In Christ there was the fullness of all wisdom not only with respect to things known, but also with regard to the modes and differences of knowing. For in Christ there was sempiternal cognition on the part of the Deity, sensible cognition on the part of the sensuality and the flesh, scientific cognition on the part of the mind and spirit—and this was threefold: one namely through nature, one through grace, and one through glory. Whence He had wisdom both as God and as man, as comprehensor and as wayfarer, as one illuminated through grace and as one rightly formed through nature; and thus in all there were in Christ five modes of knowing.
The fifth mode of knowing is according to sensible experience: and in this mode He knew those things that come to the organs of the senses, according to which mode it is said that He learned obedience from the things which He suffered.
Because sense is not perceptive of things except in the presence of the object, it follows that according to sensitive cognition, he did not know all things simultaneously, but now these, now those, according as it was opportune for accomplishing the reparation of the human race.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The time of Christ's passion comes, and some "again are crucifying to themselves the Son of God," namely so far as it lies within them. The supreme cruelty of Christian iniquity is this: that you who are wholly of the blood of Christ, by sinning crucify him again, so far as it lies within you.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A promissory oath is made for preserving fidelity, and this is done in three ways, namely for restraining malice, for settling controversy, and for clearing away infamy. First, it is made for restraining malice, so that a man may neither deny the true nor affirm the false; and this is the reason for the usefulness of the oath. Second, it is made for settling controversy. Whence the Apostle says to the Hebrews: "The end of all controversy is an oath." Third, it is made for clearing away infamy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second disposition for the inflowing of the gift of fortitude is through the imperturbable consolation of hope. Hence the Apostle to the Hebrews: "We have the strongest consolation, we who have fled to hold fast the hope set before us."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This Hierarch is acceptable to God, for we need a most sacred Reconciler. Hence the Epistle to the Hebrews: "It was fitting that we should have such a High Priest, holy, innocent, undefiled, set apart from sinners, and become higher than the heavens," in order that He be entirely in the form of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“God proposes the most direct norms. Hence, the Apostle and Jeremiah say: "I will put my laws into their mind, and upon their hearts I will write them." For He inscribed them first in human nature, then in industry or progress, third in grace, and fourth in glory. In every state, He puts forth His rules: wherefore by necessity He must possess them within Himself.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since it is possible to contemplate God not only outside us and within us, but also above us: outside through his vestige, within through his image, and above through the light that is sealed upon our mind, which is the light of eternal Truth, since "our mind itself is immediately formed by Truth itself"; those who have been exercised in the first mode have already entered into the court before the tabernacle; those in the second have entered into the holy place: but those in the third enter with the High Priest into the holy of holies; where above the ark are the Cherubim of glory overshadowing the mercy seat; by which we understand two modes or degrees of contemplating the invisible and eternal things of God, of which one is concerned with the essential attributes of God, and the other with what is proper to the persons.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ instituted the seven Sacraments of the law of grace as the mediator of the new testament and the chief lawgiver, in which law he called to the promises eternal, gave directing precepts, and instituted sanctifying Sacraments.
Our restorative principle is Christ crucified, namely the incarnate Word, which because it is the Word coequal and consubstantial with the Father, is the Word of supreme power, supreme truth, and supreme goodness, and thereby also of supreme authority; and therefore it properly belongs to him to introduce the new testament, and it also belongs to him to give a law that is complete and sufficient according to the demand of his supreme power and truth and goodness. By reason therefore of supreme goodness, he set forth beatifying promises; by reason of supreme truth, he gave directing precepts; but by reason of supreme power, he established assisting Sacraments: so that through the Sacraments power might be restored for fulfilling the directing precepts, and through the directive precepts one might arrive at the eternal promises.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Those Sacraments of the first time, as Hugh says, were like a shadow of the truth, those of the middle time like a figure or image, and those of the last time, namely of grace, like the body, because they contain within themselves the truth and healing grace which they present, and they confer in present reality what they promise.
Since when truth arrives the shadow ceases, and the prefiguring figure attains its intended end, which once obtained, its use and exercise ought to cease: hence it is that with the arrival of grace, the old Sacraments and signs were at once fulfilled and removed, because they were prognostic signs of future things and, as it were, announcing from afar; and new ones were nevertheless instituted as demonstrative of present grace and in a certain way commemorative of the Lord's passion, which is the font and origin of curative grace. On account of which, those former Sacraments prepared and led to these, as a way to its terminus, as a sign to what it signifies, as a figure to the truth, and as the imperfect leads back and prepares for the perfect.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The seventh judgment is in death, namely the judgment of condemnation. When a man dies in mortal sin, he is separated perpetually from eternal glory, and his soul is condemned to eternal fire until the end of the world, and then he will be punished also in body. Whence the Apostle says: "The expectation of judgment is terrible."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When someone is worthy of eternal life, through sin he makes himself worthy of eternal death. Such a one must be greatly punished. Whence the Apostle to the Hebrews: "He who makes void the Law of Moses dies without any mercy on the testimony of two or three witnesses. How much more, do you think, does he deserve worse punishments, who has trampled upon the Son of God and has regarded the blood of the covenant as defiled, by which he was sanctified, and has done outrage to the Spirit of grace?" If a man sins, he tramples upon the Son of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hear, you who are marked with the Christian name: the character is then imprinted upon you through the power of the name of God; and when you afterward sin, you empty out the power of the Sacrament. Of such persons the Apostle says: "They profess to know God, but by their deeds they deny Him;" and thus "you trample upon the Son of God" and "treat as polluted the blood" of the covenant, you who were washed in the blood of Christ!”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When someone is worthy of eternal life, through sin he makes himself worthy of eternal death. Such a one must be greatly punished. Whence the Apostle to the Hebrews: "He who makes void the Law of Moses dies without any mercy on the testimony of two or three witnesses. How much more, do you think, does he deserve worse punishments, who has trampled upon the Son of God and has regarded the blood of the covenant as defiled, by which he was sanctified, and has done outrage to the Spirit of grace?" If a man sins, he tramples upon the Son of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Do not fear those who kill the body and after this have nothing more that they can do; but I will show you whom you should fear: fear him who, after he has killed, has power to cast into gehenna." I would prefer to be in the greatest punishment of this world for seven thousand years than to endure the least eternal punishment. "It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God," because God afflicts for eternity. Consider the sublimity of divine power, the perspicacity of divine wisdom, and the severity of divine vengeance, that you may fear God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In a certain sense faith sees, and in another it does not see. The merit of faith is founded on non-seeing, the light of faith on believing. There exists therefore a firmament-heaven, "the substance of things to be hoped for." And it consists in light, because it is "the evidence of things that are not seen." Wherefore it has both light and clouds.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The door to all this is the understanding of the Uncreated Word who is the root of the understanding of all things; hence a man who does not have this door cannot go in. But philosophers consider impossible some things that are supremely true, for the door is closed to them. How these matters are to be understood is explained in the Epistle to the Hebrews: "By faith we understand that the world was fashioned by the Word of God; and thus things visible were made out of things invisible." For it is impossible for the supreme Spirit not to understand itself; and since the understanding is equated with the one who understands, He understands whatever is and whatever can be: hence also the reason of understanding is equated to understanding itself, for it is its likeness. Now this likeness is the Word because, according to Augustine and Anselm, the likeness of the mind returning upon itself, which is at the fine point of intelligence, is the word. If then this likeness is equal, it follows that it is God, and, having originated from God, it represents the Originating One and whatever the Father is able to do: hence it represents many things. Again, since it represents the Father's power, it represents a power that is absolutely one; but "the more a power is one, the more it is infinite." Hence this likeness properly represents infinite things; and therefore it is necessary that many things proceed from one. If, then, you understand the Word, you understand all understandable things.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the second mode, the gaze of the faithful, considering this world, attends to its origin, course, and end. For by faith we believe that the ages were fashioned by the Word of life; by faith we believe that the times of the three laws, namely of nature, of Scripture, and of grace, succeed one another and have run their course in most perfect order; by faith we believe that the world is to be brought to an end through the final judgment: perceiving in the first the power, in the second the providence, and in the third the justice of the supreme Principle.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The manner in which sacrifice was introduced is seen in the fact that Abel offered a sacrifice by faith, and so did Noah, of whose offering it is said: The Lord smelled the sweet odor. And these sacrifices represented that which Christ offered on the cross. Hence it is said, the Lord smelled: God was appeased by the death of His only Son. By contrast, the demons, because of their pride, seek to be worshiped as God Himself, in order to obtain on earth the honor they could not have in heaven, and because men are farthest removed from God. A man who makes such sacrifices offers the blood of Christ, in that it was shed in order to appease the Father.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If there could be no doubt concerning this truth, that God exists, there would be no merit in believing it: but this is the principle of all merit, to believe that God exists, because it is said in Hebrews 11: He who approaches must believe that He exists.
To believe that God exists, considered in itself, is not meritorious except insofar as it is subordinated to the belief that God is triune, or to other articles of faith, since these are founded upon it; and by reason of those articles it can become meritorious, because if it is believed nakedly by itself, it is not efficacious for meriting. The Apostle, moreover, speaks of the belief that God exists insofar as it is the foundation of other things to be believed; and this foundation is implanted in man by nature, lest, if the human intellect knew nothing of God from its own nature, it could excuse itself through ignorance. And this is what Master Hugh says: "Therefore God from the beginning of nature willed to be neither wholly manifest to human conscience nor wholly hidden, lest, if He were wholly manifest, faith would have no merit, nor would infidelity have any place: for infidelity would be convicted by what is manifest, and faith would not be exercised concerning what is hidden. But if He were wholly hidden, faith would not be aided by knowledge, and infidelity would be excused by ignorance."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The soul is disposed to the gift of fortitude through the unconquerable shield of faith. Hence the Apostle to the Hebrews: "Who through faith conquered kingdoms; they were made strong in battle."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The soul is disposed to the gift of fortitude through the unconquerable shield of faith. Hence the Apostle to the Hebrews: "Who through faith conquered kingdoms; they were made strong in battle."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens from the left by means of benign punishments. Wherefore the Lord permitted the most just Abel to be murdered. Behold Noah who took a hundred years to build the Ark and placed in it everything he had: and the whole world was making fun of him. It is the same with Abraham, Isaac and Jacob who were pilgrims, and with Joseph who could not be exalted before having been sold, imprisoned and humiliated. See Moses, whom God was to place at the head of the whole world, how he was humbled: he tended the sheep of a priest for forty years. Likewise, David: as long as he suffered, he was very good, and he came to reign by means of sufferings. But later, living in prosperity, he committed many sins. Likewise, Ezechias in his weakness was very humble, but later he became proud at the time of the coming of the Babylonian envoys. Behold Elias, the poor little one who had nothing to eat but what the crow and the poor little widow brought to him: and who yet closed the heavens. Behold John the Baptist who stayed seven years in the desert and lay there on a bed of pebbles. Likewise, Paul says: They were stoned, they were sawed asunder, they were tempted, they were put to death by the sword. They went about in sheepskins, etc. Punishments, therefore, are most sweet. And so, either God punishes or He does not. For whom the Lord loves, He chastises. This is proved by particular instances. Hence it must be inferred to apply universally.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In Hebrews 11 it is said in praise of the Saints: They wandered about in sheepskins, in goatskins, destitute, etc.; but to wander about in such a manner is to beg: therefore etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens from the left by means of benign punishments. Wherefore the Lord permitted the most just Abel to be murdered. Behold Noah who took a hundred years to build the Ark and placed in it everything he had: and the whole world was making fun of him. It is the same with Abraham, Isaac and Jacob who were pilgrims, and with Joseph who could not be exalted before having been sold, imprisoned and humiliated. See Moses, whom God was to place at the head of the whole world, how he was humbled: he tended the sheep of a priest for forty years. Likewise, David: as long as he suffered, he was very good, and he came to reign by means of sufferings. But later, living in prosperity, he committed many sins. Likewise, Ezechias in his weakness was very humble, but later he became proud at the time of the coming of the Babylonian envoys. Behold Elias, the poor little one who had nothing to eat but what the crow and the poor little widow brought to him: and who yet closed the heavens. Behold John the Baptist who stayed seven years in the desert and lay there on a bed of pebbles. Likewise, Paul says: They were stoned, they were sawed asunder, they were tempted, they were put to death by the sword. They went about in sheepskins, etc. Punishments, therefore, are most sweet. And so, either God punishes or He does not. For whom the Lord loves, He chastises. This is proved by particular instances. Hence it must be inferred to apply universally.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The tenth plague was the death of the firstborn, by which the carnal are struck, like Esau. For the Apostle says: "Lest anyone among you be a fornicator, like Esau, and lose his birthright." Carnal concupiscence took from us our noble generation, by which we would all be born innocent and heirs of paradise, and it makes us be born in death and guilt and the loss of the birthright.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That perfect men ought to conform themselves to the Apostles, of whom it is said in Second Corinthians chapter four: We are in want, but not forsaken: Gloss: "We are in want, that is, we are so poor that necessities are lacking; but we are not forsaken by God entirely, because God feeds us." And that this extends not only to the Apostles, but also to their imitators, is apparent from what is said in Hebrews, the last chapter: Let your ways be without avarice, content with what is at hand. For he himself said: I will not desert you nor forsake you; there the Gloss says: "The Lord Almighty himself said to Joshua: I will not desert you, that is, I will not fail to give necessities; nor will I forsake you, forsaken would be he who perished from hunger; but because this does not happen, the greedy man should not say so. This he said to Joshua after the death of Moses; this he also says to everyone hoping in him, as Joshua did. For these things he promises to us, if we place our hope in him — not to the grasping, not to the greedy, but to those hoping in him. And because it could seem to them that this promise was made only to Joshua, the Apostle responds to this saying that he will help us just as he helped him, as if to say: there is no reason to doubt the promise, because Jesus Christ, who yesterday, that is in the past, helped Joshua, he himself today, that is in the present, helps us and other faithful, and will help in the future forever, that is without end."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The use of grace ought to be manly in itself. Whence the Apostle to the Hebrews: "It is best to establish the heart with grace," he does not say the stomach. At other times you have labored to strengthen your bodies. He who wishes to have strong arms must exercise himself in works of strength. Similarly, he who wishes to have stabilizing grace must exercise himself in works of virtue.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From Christ, indeed, is the fruit of grace. This fruit of grace is fourfold: it consists in steadying the soul through faith, blessing it through divine love, lifting it up through hope, curbing it through divine fear. The Apostle speaks of the first: "It is good to make steadfast the heart by grace, not by foods." The Jews steadied themselves with foods.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He who presides over political or ecclesiastical affairs is called father by reason of authority. And we ought to honor him according to what the ecclesiastical ordering requires, and the people ought to obey him: whence the Apostle to the Hebrews: Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they keep watch as those who will render an account for your souls.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The law of grace praises jurisdictional obedience, Hebrews last chapter: Obey your superiors and be subject to them: for they keep watch, etc. From what has been said it is manifestly gathered that the obedience of man to man is consonant with the law of grace and the written law and the law of nature.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence, if charity is patient, long-suffering and good, then it "shall suck as milk the abundance of the sea." In this way did Lawrence rejoice over the glowing embers as if they had been flowers. These fruits are in the spirit, not in the flesh. Hence in James: "Esteem it all joy, my brethren, when you fall into various trials."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"If any of you is wanting in wisdom, let him ask it of God, who gives abundantly to all men, and does not reproach; and it will be given to him. But let him ask with faith, without hesitation." For one who hesitates is not disciplined. This, then is the door. Such a desire extinguishes all others, and makes man to be lifted up from the world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"If any of you is wanting in wisdom, let him ask it of God, who gives abundantly to all men, and does not reproach; and it will be given to him. But let him ask with faith, without hesitation." For one who hesitates is not disciplined. This, then is the door. Such a desire extinguishes all others, and makes man to be lifted up from the world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Of such a one it is said: 'A man double in mind is inconstant in all his ways.' A man ought to follow the counsels of Saints Benedict and the others. He ought not to bring in new counselors, but follow the counsel of Christ, whose life is the certain form of living. If a religious says: 'There is no salvation except with us,' he speaks badly. He ought not to praise his own holy order in such a way that he condemns others. He can stand for his own religious order, provided that he does not go to excess in his manner of speaking and persuading.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the allegorical sense, the sun signifies Christ. It rises in the nativity, it goes down in death; it orbits through noon in the ascension; it is inclined to the north in the judgment. Concerning the judgment, James says: "For the sun rises with a burning heat and parches the grass, and its flower falls."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"A great sign appeared in heaven; a woman clothed with the sun, and the moon under her feet, and on her head a crown of twelve stars." We shall have this crown if we wish to imitate the glorious Virgin. Whence it is written: "Blessed is the man who endures temptation, for when he has been proved, he shall receive the crown of life."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Actual sin draws its origin from the free will of each person through suggestion, delight, consent, and action, according to that passage in James: Each one is tempted, being drawn away and enticed by his own concupiscence. If, however, suggestion and delight stop short of consent, it is a venial sin. But if consent and action follow in those things which are prohibited by divine law, the sin is a consummated mortal sin. Since sin denotes a withdrawal of the will from the First Principle, insofar as the will is made to be moved by Him, according to Him, and for His sake, every sin is a disorder of the mind or will, around which virtue and vice are naturally found. Actual sin, therefore, is an actual disorder of the will. Now this disorder is either so great that it destroys the order of justice—and in this way it is called mortal sin, because it is apt to take away life, by separating the soul from God, through whom the just soul is given life—or it is so slight that it does not destroy that order, but disturbs it in some respect, and then it is called venial sin, because from it we can quickly obtain pardon, since through it grace is not taken away, nor is divine enmity incurred.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concupiscence, when it has conceived, brings forth sin; and sin, when it is consummated, begets death. If, however, suggestion and delight stop short of consent, it is a venial sin. But if consent and action follow in those things which are prohibited by divine law, the sin is a consummated mortal sin. But if it happens in a middle way, such that there is consent without action, either because one wills to proceed to action but cannot—then the will is reckoned as the deed, nor is one less culpable than if one were caught in the very act; or because one does not will to proceed to action, but wills to take inward pleasure in the delight—and then the woman eats, but not the man: and although the sin is not fully consummated, it is nevertheless to be counted among mortal sins, because when the woman eats, the whole man deserves to be condemned.
Because reason is not compelled to consent to these things, if after the sense of delight there is consent to the deed: then there is full consent, and thereby sin is consummated, because it has reached the man, that is, the supreme part of reason, upon which the fullness of consent depends. But because there is consent not only to the deed, but also to the delight, in which the inferior portion follows sensuality: therefore, if in sensual delight reason succumbs to sensuality, the woman obeys the serpent, and thereby there occurs a subversion of right order, and thus a subversion of justice; on account of which mortal sin is committed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning grace, therefore, insofar as it is a gift divinely given, the following must be held: that it is a gift which is immediately given and infused by God. For indeed, with it and in it the Holy Spirit is given, who is the uncreated gift, the best and perfect gift, which descends from the Father of lights through the incarnate Word.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The origin of Scripture is not through human investigation, but through divine revelation, which flows from the Father of lights, from whom all paternity in heaven and on earth is named. And so that we may arrive at the fruit and goal of Scripture by a right progress, we must begin from the beginning, that is, that with pure faith we approach the Father of lights, bending the knees of our heart, so that He Himself through His Son in the Holy Spirit may give us true knowledge of Jesus Christ and with that knowledge love of Him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If we consider the origin of grace, I ask what is the original principle of grace. It is certain that grace is the best gift and the perfect gift, descending from above from the Father of lights. I set forth the universal affirmative major premise thus: "Every best gift and every perfect gift is from above, descending from the Father of lights, with whom there is no change nor shadow of alteration:" but grace is the best gift and the perfect gift: therefore it descends from above from the Father of lights.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“As to the origin of grace I said that grace is nothing other than "an excellent gift and a perfect endowment, descending from the Father of lights" through the Word incarnate, through the Word crucified, and through the Word inspired. And that Word leads us back to the highest principle. And from this the following description of grace is given: that grace is the best endowment and the perfect gift, descending from the Father of lights, healing from evil, strengthening in good, and consummating in glory.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Wisdom is light: light, I say, "descending from above from the Father of lights, from whom is every best gift and every perfect gift." This light descends to illuminate our cognitive power, to gladden our affective power, and to strengthen our operative power. It descends from the most high God into the intellect, from the intellect into the affection, and even to the lowest, namely operation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning wisdom, four points are to be noted: its origin, its dwelling, its door, and its beauty. As to the origin, it was said that wisdom was a light "coming down from the Father of Lights" within the soul, and that by radiating through it, made it in the form of God, and the house of God. This descending light makes the intellective power beautiful, the affective power delightful, and the operative power strong.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He is called the Father of the age to come, for He Himself is the Principle of those influences by which we will live in the future. As James writes: "Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of Lights." And later: "Of His own will He has begotten us by the word of truth, that we might be, as it were, the first-fruits of His creatures." We are now the beginning of creatures, but then we shall be creatures in full.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is good to have the sign of Zabulon, which is "a dwelling of fortitude," which implies the first stability. "Because Thou, O Lord, art my hope." Hence, "the name of the Lord is a strong tower; the just man runs to it and is safe." He alone is at peace who fixes himself upon that "with which there is no change, no shadow of alteration." Hence, "in Thee, O Lord, have I hoped, let me never be confounded."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Every best gift and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights, James in the first chapter of his Epistle. In this word is touched the origin of every illumination, and together with this is intimated the generous emanation of manifold light from that fontal light. Although, however, every illumination of knowledge is internal, we can nevertheless reasonably distinguish, so that we may say that there is a light that is exterior, namely the light of mechanical art; a light that is inferior, namely the light of sensitive knowledge; a light that is interior, namely the light of philosophical knowledge; a light that is superior, namely the light of grace and Sacred Scripture. The first light illuminates with respect to artificial form, the second with respect to natural form, the third with respect to intellectual truth, the fourth and last with respect to salvific truth.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the beginning I call upon the first principle, from whom all illuminations descend as from the Father of lights, from whom is every good gift and every perfect gift, namely the eternal Father, through his Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, that by the intercession of the most holy Virgin Mary, mother of the same God and our Lord Jesus Christ, and of blessed Francis, our leader and father, he may give the enlightened eyes of our mind to direct our feet in the way of that peace which surpasses all understanding; which peace our Lord Jesus Christ proclaimed and gave.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is said in the Epistle of James: "Of his own will he begot us by the Word of truth, that we might be a certain firstfruits of his creatures." Through the Word incarnate there descends to us an abundance of graces.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He is called the Father of the age to come, for He Himself is the Principle of those influences by which we will live in the future. As James writes: "Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of Lights." And later: "Of His own will He has begotten us by the word of truth, that we might be, as it were, the first-fruits of His creatures." We are now the beginning of creatures, but then we shall be creatures in full.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second benefit of keeping the commandments of God is the understanding of the sacred Scriptures. Gregory says that "by hearing God's precepts the disciples were not illuminated, but by doing them they were illuminated"; because not the hearers of the law only, but the doers shall be justified. On account of this James says in his canonical epistle: "Be doers of the word of God and not hearers only, deceiving yourselves: because if anyone is a hearer of the word of God only and not a doer, he shall be compared to a man considering the countenance of his birth in a mirror." If a man sees his own face ten times in a mirror, he still will not know it well; but if he sees the face of another man outside of a mirror, he knows it well: and this is because of the strong impression of the species upon the organ of sight along a straight line, but in a mirror there is no true intuition. Similarly, when a man hears the word of God, it seems to him that he understands it well, but it immediately departs; but when he puts it to experience by working well, then he understands it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second benefit of keeping the commandments of God is the understanding of the sacred Scriptures. Gregory says that "by hearing God's precepts the disciples were not illuminated, but by doing them they were illuminated"; because not the hearers of the law only, but the doers shall be justified. On account of this James says in his canonical epistle: "Be doers of the word of God and not hearers only, deceiving yourselves: because if anyone is a hearer of the word of God only and not a doer, he shall be compared to a man considering the countenance of his birth in a mirror." If a man sees his own face ten times in a mirror, he still will not know it well; but if he sees the face of another man outside of a mirror, he knows it well: and this is because of the strong impression of the species upon the organ of sight along a straight line, but in a mirror there is no true intuition. Similarly, when a man hears the word of God, it seems to him that he understands it well, but it immediately departs; but when he puts it to experience by working well, then he understands it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the third place, a saint's life must be religious, closed as a vineyard wall. And so, it is good that a man restrain his taste, his tongue and his other senses: for "if anyone thinks himself to be religious, not restraining his tongue but deceiving his own heart, that man's religion is vain." Our life must not be given to discourse, but to tears.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, on that passage of James: Has not God chosen the poor; the Gloss says: "He chose poor parents, by whose service He would be raised"; but the destitution of Christ's parents was very great, according to that passage of Luke 2: She wrapped Him in swaddling clothes and laid Him in a manger: therefore Christ loved poverty not only in Himself, but also in others.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"Whoever shall keep the whole law, yet offend in one point, is become guilty of all": not that for one transgression he is punished with as much punishment of sense as for the transgression of all; but he will be punished with as much punishment of loss, yet not as severely for one as for all. Therefore, if anyone wishes to attain to true life, it is necessary that he have regard to all the commandments of God in heart, mouth, and deed.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“You must always fear God, because he who "keeps the whole law but offends in one point has become guilty of all." And in Deuteronomy it is said: "And now, Israel, what does the Lord your God ask of you, except that you fear him and keep all his commandments and walk in his ways?" And Solomon says: "Fear God and observe his commandments: this is the whole man," that is, the perfect man. Therefore if you wish to be perfect, fear God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the second petition, the consummation of human salvation is sought, which is not obtained except through the gift of piety: "Judgment without mercy shall be done to him who has not shown mercy." This gift is touched upon when he says: "Thy kingdom come."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second pillar of the house of wisdom is innocence in the mind. Augustine says that "peace is the tranquility of order," namely, when one humbly subjects himself to a superior, conducts himself equably toward an equal, and discreetly governs an inferior. All who are children of wisdom maintain this order. He who disturbs this peace destroys the house of wisdom. "He who is patient is governed by much wisdom; he who is impatient exalts his own folly." Blessed James says: "Who is wise and instructed among you? Let him show by his good conduct his work in the meekness of wisdom."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That wisdom which is from below, blessed James describes, saying: "This is not wisdom descending from above, but is earthly, sensual, diabolical." This wisdom with all solicitude seeks to delight in every pleasure, in the abundance of worldly riches, in the experience of sensual delights, and in the eminence or ambition of worldly pomps. Insofar as it makes a person solicitous to delight in the abundance of riches, it is earthly: insofar as it makes a person solicitous to delight in the experience of sensual delights, it is sensual: but insofar as it makes a person solicitous to delight in the eminence and ambition of worldly pomps, it is diabolical: because pride is the root of all evils, and it is principally condemned in the diabolical king.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“What are the seven pillars of the house of wisdom? Sacred Scripture explains them sufficiently. Blessed James, describing the wisdom that is from above, sets down its seven conditions, saying: "First indeed it is chaste, then peaceable, modest, persuadable, consenting to the good, full of mercy and good fruits, not judging, without dissimulation." These pillars are nothing other than certain steps toward wisdom. The first is chastity in the flesh; the second is innocence in the mind; the third is moderation in speech; the fourth is persuadability in affection; the fifth is liberality in effect; the sixth is maturity in judgment; and the seventh is simplicity in intention. Through these the house of wisdom is established.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This dwelling of wisdom is built with seven columns which blessed James clearly touched upon: "But the wisdom that is from above is first of all chaste, then peaceable, moderate, docile, in harmony with good things, full of mercy and good fruits, without dissimulation." It is of this house that Matthew writes: "Everyone therefore who hears these My words and acts upon them, shall be likened to a wise man who built his house on rock."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Humility preserves this return and connection, and pride dissolves it. Whence in the Epistle of James: "God resists the proud, but gives grace to the humble." And what is the reason? Certainly, he who is humble attributes all the goods he has to his original principle; but the proud man attributes all things to himself. The humble man remains in continuity with his origin, but the proud man is severed from it and as it were says: this I did not receive from you. And therefore Lucifer became dark, because he withdrew from his original principle; but Christ led himself back to his original principle through humility, and therefore he was radiant.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because humility is the dwelling place of grace, the grace of the Holy Spirit rests upon the humble alone. Whence Augustine, in the third book of On Christian Doctrine: "For this reason the sins of great men were written down, so that that apostolic saying might everywhere be feared: Wherefore let him who seems to stand take heed lest he fall. For there is no page of the holy books in which it does not resound: God resists the proud, but to the humble He gives grace."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"To him who knows the good and does it not, it is sin," as blessed James says. From knowledge, guilt is increased and also punishment.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If you come to exemplars, the supreme Exemplar of all virtues is in Christ. Compared to the patience of Job, the patience of Christ is greater. "You have heard of the patience of Job, and you have seen the purpose of the Lord," says James. For stars are nothing when compared to the sun.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Extreme unction is the Sacrament of those departing from this life, preparing and disposing them for perfect health; it avails also for the removal of venial sins and for the recovery of present health, if it be expedient for the sick person.
This Sacrament has efficacy both for arousing devotion and for remitting venial sins and for more easily removing the dross of sins. And because for many of the sick it is still expedient to live for the accumulation of their merits: hence it is that this Sacrament, both by invigorating the soul in good and by unburdening it from evil, frequently also alleviates from disease. And this is what blessed James says, that the prayer of faith shall save the sick person, and if he be in sins, they shall be forgiven him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From Christ is the fruit of grace. This fruit of grace is fourfold: it consists in steadying the soul through faith, blessing it through divine love, lifting it up through hope, curbing it through divine fear. And in the First Epistle of Peter: "Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who according to His great mercy hath regenerated us unto a lively hope."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And in these degrees consists the ladder of Jacob, whose summit reaches heaven: and the throne of Solomon, upon which sits the most wise King, truly peaceful and loving as the most beautiful bridegroom and wholly desirable: upon whom the Angels desire to gaze, and toward whom the desire of holy souls sighs, as the hart longs for the fountains of waters. By which most fervent desire, in the manner of fire, our spirit is not only made agile for ascent, but also by a certain learned ignorance is rapt above itself into darkness and ecstasy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From Christ is the fruit of grace. This fruit of grace is fourfold: it consists in steadying the soul through faith, blessing it through divine love, lifting it up through hope, curbing it through divine fear. Peter speaks of the second: "Therefore, having girded up the loins of your understanding, be sober and set your hope completely on that grace which is brought to you in the revelation of Jesus Christ." For sanctification consists in this, that virtues, which are the loins of the mind, are transformed in God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This is the price of which the Apostle says: "You have been bought with a great price; bear and glorify God in your body." That the price is great, the Apostle Peter says: "You were redeemed not with corruptible gold or silver from your vain manner of life received by tradition from your fathers, but with the precious blood as of a Lamb unspotted and undefiled." This had to be a great price, by which the whole world and the entire human race was to be redeemed; because man could not make satisfaction, since no single man could be worth all men, nor could any creature. Nothing was sufficient to redeem the entire human race unless it possessed human nature and a nature above every creature; therefore it was necessary that it possess both a divine and a human nature.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This is the price of which the Apostle says: "You have been bought with a great price; bear and glorify God in your body." That the price is great, the Apostle Peter says: "You were redeemed not with corruptible gold or silver from your vain manner of life received by tradition from your fathers, but with the precious blood as of a Lamb unspotted and undefiled." This had to be a great price, by which the whole world and the entire human race was to be redeemed; because man could not make satisfaction, since no single man could be worth all men, nor could any creature. Nothing was sufficient to redeem the entire human race unless it possessed human nature and a nature above every creature; therefore it was necessary that it possess both a divine and a human nature.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The blessed Virgin on account of her sanctity, piety, and sublimity had a crown of precious stone. Who is this stone? Certainly Christ. Whence blessed Peter: "Behold, I shall place in the foundation a precious stone." The blessed Virgin was crowned with this stone in the flesh: seeing in the flesh the glorified body of Christ, seeing in spirit his glorified soul, and in mind his Divinity. Christ was crowned first, and she afterward.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ is the foundation of this faith. For He is the cornerstone of which Isaiah and Peter speak: See, I am laying a stone in Sion, a stone that has been tested, a precious cornerstone as a sure foundation. And the Apostle: You are built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets with Christ Jesus Himself as the chief cornerstone.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But whatever Aristotle's opinion, other enlightened philosophers presupposed the existence of ideas: they were the worshipers of a single God, who placed all good in the supremely good God, and believed in the existence of exemplary virtues from which the cardinal virtues flowed, first into the cognitive power, and thence into the affective, and finally into the operative, according to the phrase "knowledge, will and definitive action," as established by the most noble Plotinus in regard to the school of Plato, and Tullius of the Academic school. And so these were seen to be enlightened and to be capable of enjoying happiness as such. Yet, these men lived in darkness, since they did not have the light of faith; we by contrast do have that light. Hence, in the First Epistle of Peter: You, however, are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a purchased people; that you may proclaim the perfections of Him who has called you out of darkness into his marvellous light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From all of which it is gathered that the invisible things of God, from the creation of the world, being understood through those things which have been made, are clearly seen: so that those who are unwilling to attend to these things and to know, bless, and love God in all of them are without excuse, since they are unwilling to be transferred from darkness into the admirable light of God. But thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord, who from darkness has transferred us into His admirable light, while through these lights given outwardly to the mirror of our mind, in which divine things shine forth, we are disposed to re-enter.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“1 Peter 2: Be subject to every human creature for the sake of God: therefore the more efficaciously one does this, the more perfectly one acts; but he who subjects himself to another by vow does this most efficaciously: therefore such a person acts most perfectly. Whence Bernard, Homily 42 on the Song of Songs: "It is a small thing to be subject to God unless you are also subject to every human creature for the sake of God: subject yourself to equals, subject yourself to inferiors: for thus it befits us to fulfill all justice"; but this is done most especially by binding oneself by vow to obey another.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the father there is authority: and in this commandment a precept is given that the father be obeyed, because he has authority. Moreover, everyone who presides over public affairs, or political affairs, or monastic affairs has authority. He who presides over public affairs is called father by reason of authority, such as a prince, baron, count, and the like, and is called father by guardianship or defense; and we ought to honor him as a father. Whence blessed Peter: Fear God, honor the king.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, Christ was most imitable according to the state He had on the cross, according to that passage of 1 Peter 2: Christ suffered for us, leaving an example, that you should follow His steps; but on the cross He was entirely naked; whence Jerome to Hedibia: "Do you wish to be perfect and to stand at the highest summit of dignity? Do what the Apostles did: sell all that you have, and give to the poor, and follow the Savior, and follow the naked and solitary cross with naked and solitary virtue": therefore etc.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That conjugal chastity is to be approved according to the evangelical law is shown by authority, as follows. 1 Peter 3: Husbands, dwelling together according to knowledge, bestowing honor on the woman as on a weaker vessel; but this is according to the conjugal act: therefore the conjugal act is consonant with the law of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That the Lord commands sanctification, that is, rest for the sake of loving, this is a purely moral precept. Whence blessed Peter says: But sanctify the Lord Christ in your hearts, that is, love him. For he sanctifies or makes holy the Sabbath who loves God above all things for his own sake, not for the sake of something else.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The soul of Christ after the passion descended to hell, that is, to limbo, for the liberation not of all, but of those who had departed as members of Christ through living faith, or through the Sacraments of faith.
Because the remedy of the passion was most sufficient, it extended itself to celestial, terrestrial, and infernal things. Through Christ infernal things were recovered, terrestrial things remedied, and celestial things restored to wholeness—such that the first of these He accomplished through pardon, the second through grace, and the third through glory: therefore after the passion His soul descended to the nether regions to free those detained in hell.
Because that remedy was most efficacious both upon those who preceded the coming of Christ and upon those who follow, who nevertheless approached and approach Christ Himself and were and are His members—and such are those who cling to Him through faith, hope, and charity—therefore that remedy ought to have had efficacy first upon those who believed in Christ, and by believing hoped, and by hoping loved; and on this account He ought to have descended to the nether regions immediately for their liberation. Whence, when the gate of heaven was opened through the passion of Christ—who by making satisfaction removed the flaming sword, by changing the divine sentence—He snatched from hell all His members.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise in the time after the cleansing of sin, there were three divisions: the building of the Ark, the showing of the rainbow, and the separation of tongues. For a hundred years, Noah worked on the Ark in which he was saved together with seven souls. And, as Peter says, baptism is the type of this — of water, of desire and of blood. In the New Testament, Clement was saved in this Ark, for a marble temple was prepared for him in the sea by angel hands, while the others were submerged. And out of this there came about a great miracle, that for so many years the sea remained open, until pirates and robbers removed his body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The chief of the Apostles, blessed Peter, says: "Each one, as he has received grace, ministering it to one another, as good stewards of the manifold grace of God." Dionysius determines for us the use of grace in the angelic and celestial hierarchy and says that if the higher Angels were to contain themselves and were unwilling to flow into the lower Angels, then they would close off for themselves the way of God's influence. If the good that you have from God you deny to another, and you see one who is poor in life or in merit, you are not worthy of eternal life, and your life is most wretched and swinish.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because humility is the dwelling place of grace, the grace of the Holy Spirit rests upon the humble alone. Whence Augustine, in the third book of On Christian Doctrine: "For this reason the sins of great men were written down, so that that apostolic saying might everywhere be feared: Wherefore let him who seems to stand take heed lest he fall. For there is no page of the holy books in which it does not resound: God resists the proud, but to the humble He gives grace."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The soul is disposed to the gift of fortitude through the unconquerable shield of faith. The devil draws man to the concupiscence of the flesh, to the concupiscence of the eyes, and to the pride of life. What is the means of resisting these? Through truth. "His truth shall encompass you with a shield," namely through faith dwelling within. And blessed Peter said: "Your adversary as a roaring lion goes about seeking whom he may devour: whom resist, strong in faith." If we loved truth, we would not fear the devil, because it is written: "The eyes of the Lord behold the whole earth and give fortitude to those who believe in him with a perfect heart."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The soul is disposed to the gift of fortitude through the unconquerable shield of faith. The devil draws man to the concupiscence of the flesh, to the concupiscence of the eyes, and to the pride of life. What is the means of resisting these? Through truth. "His truth shall encompass you with a shield," namely through faith dwelling within. And blessed Peter said: "Your adversary as a roaring lion goes about seeking whom he may devour: whom resist, strong in faith." If we loved truth, we would not fear the devil, because it is written: "The eyes of the Lord behold the whole earth and give fortitude to those who believe in him with a perfect heart."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“To this piety blessed Peter invites us, who was the other Apostle, in his second Canonical epistle saying: "Supply in faith virtue, in virtue knowledge, in knowledge abstinence, in abstinence patience, in patience piety, in piety brotherly love, and in brotherly love charity." What does he mean? He places piety in the middle of two, namely between patience and charity. He says piety is a purple garment, and patience and charity he says are a royal garment. Whoever wishes to be pious toward his neighbor, it is necessary that he bear with him patiently and love him charitably. David bore himself patiently and charitably toward his enemy; so it is necessary that a man bear himself toward his neighbor.
Where is piety today? There is no mean, because God has taken away the extremes; so great is the cruelty today that man cannot be satisfied with vengeance; today impatience and wrath reign; man judges badly; even if a man does not offend me, I will nevertheless judge badly of him. Whence comes this? Surely, because I do not have charity. Blessed Peter well knows how to say how I may have charity, because if I have patience on the one hand and charity on the other: behold, the exercise of piety.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The second certainty existed in the minds of prophets. We have the word of prophecy, surer still, to which you do well to attend, as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts. This, then, you must understand first of all, that no prophecy of Scripture is made by private interpretation. For not by will of man was prophecy brought at any time; but holy men of God spoke as they were moved by the Holy Spirit. Yet, the visions of the prophets were imaginary, as was the case with Isaiah and Daniel.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Piety avails for avoiding all evils. Whence blessed Peter says: "The Lord knows how to deliver the pious from temptation, but to reserve the impious for torment unto the day of judgment." The impious are those who do not acknowledge divine piety.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Blessed Peter says: 'It is better not to know the way of justice than, after knowing it, to turn back.' You will say: 'Many fall.' You ought not to fall with those who fall, but to stand with those who stand.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Fire will precede the face of the Judge, by which the face of the earth will be burned up, so that the figure of this world will perish by the conflagration of worldly fires, just as the flood came about by the inundation of waters.
Just as the world was previously destroyed and in a certain way purged by the element of water, which is cold, against the heat and filth of lust; so the final world will be purged by fire on account of the cooling of charity and the coldness of malice and avarice, which will reign at the end as if in the old age of the world itself. Because these are of the greatest adherence, it is necessary that the purging agent be of intimate, violent and accelerated action; which is not found in any other element than fire. And therefore, just as the flood was brought about by an inundation of waters, so by the action of fire the face of this sensible world will be burned up.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Through the action of that fire all flammable elementary things will be consumed, plants and animals; the elements will be purged and renewed, especially air and earth; the just will be purged and the reprobate will be burned; and when these things have been accomplished, the motion of the heavens will also cease, so that, with the number of the elect completed, there may come about a certain renewal and rewarding of worldly bodies.
Since fire has especially the power of expelling an extraneous form, and also has a refining power akin to celestial nature: therefore through it there ought to occur purgation and renewal at once, such that, since it has a twofold efficacy, with respect to the one it precedes the coming of the Judge, but with respect to the other it must follow. And since the renewal is toward a newness that no longer returns to oldness—and thus toward an incorruptible newness, which it is not in the power of any creature to bestow—hence it is that, although in that purgation and renewal fire accomplishes something by its natural power, such as igniting, purging, rarefying, and refining, nevertheless it is necessary that together with that natural power there be a power operating above nature, by whose command the beginning of the conflagration will occur, and by whose power the completion will likewise be brought about.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third certainty derives from an intellectual vision combined with bodily vision. This occurred in the minds of the apostles. What was from the beginning, what we have heard, what we have seen with our eyes, what we have looked upon and our hands have handled, the Word of Life. And we announce to you nothing else than what we have seen. Wherefore Thomas wanted to touch, and was told: "Because thou hast seen Me, thou hast believed." And the blessed Virgin Mary, the teacher of the Apostles and Evangelists, came in contact with this Word in her womb and on her lap.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The gift of the Holy Spirit is given for overthrowing the powers of the air. Whence in John: "I write to you, young men, because you are strong, and the word of God abides in you, and you have overcome the evil one." This fortitude ought to be in every Christian and especially in the leader of the army of the Christian people.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The devil enticed the woman through a threefold desirable object, namely through knowledge, which is desirable to the rational power; through excellence after the manner of God, which is desirable to the irascible power; through the sweetness of the tree, which is desirable to the concupiscible power. And thus he tempted everything that was temptable in the woman, through everything by which she could be led into temptation, which is the threefold desirable object of the world, namely the concupiscence of the flesh, the concupiscence of the eyes, and the pride of life; according to which three things the origin of every temptation is discerned, whether from the world, or from the flesh, or from the devil.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Of actual sins there is one beginning, a twofold root, a threefold fuel, and a sevenfold head or capital sin. There is one beginning, namely pride; a twofold root, namely fear wrongly humbling and love wrongly inflaming; a threefold fuel, according to the three things that are in the world, namely the concupiscence of the flesh, the concupiscence of the eyes, and the pride of life; and a sevenfold head, namely pride, envy, wrath, sloth, avarice, gluttony, and lust. Among which the five preceding are spiritual sins, while the last two are carnal. For every fear has its origin from love: for no one fears to lose something unless he loves to have it; and therefore fear is nourished by those things by which love too is nourished. Now disordered love regards a changeable good: and since that is threefold—interior, namely excellence; exterior, money; inferior, carnal wantonness—hence it is necessary that there be three radical fuels of actual sins, toward which when the soul is carried in a disordered manner, all actual sins arise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since justice arrives at perfection when it perfectly distances itself from evil both as to worship and as to cause: and all evil arises from a threefold root, namely the concupiscence of the flesh, the concupiscence of the eyes, and the pride of life: hence it is that there are three evangelical counsels, perfectly distancing us from the aforesaid threefold root. Which are therefore counsels because, in order that they may perfectly cause one to withdraw from evil, they separate not only from illicit things, but also from licit and permitted things which can be an occasion of evil: and through this they contain not only sufficient, but also abundant justice, according to what befits the perfection of the evangelical law and the exercise of perfecting grace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That which most distances us from the world is most consonant with evangelical perfection; but to bind oneself by vow to obey a man most distances us from the world, because all that is in the world is either the concupiscence of the flesh, or the concupiscence of the eyes, or the pride of life, from which we are most distanced by the vow of obedience: therefore to bind oneself by vow to obey another is most consonant with evangelical perfection.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise homicide is committed interpretively, and this occurs in three ways: first, by omitting in deed: whence Ambrose says: "Feed the one dying of hunger: if you have not fed him, you have killed him." In the second way it occurs when someone kills another by counseling, or accusing, or disparaging, when he does this from malice of spirit. In the third way homicide is committed interpretively by hating in the soul: whence in the epistle of John: "He who hates his brother is a murderer."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Nothing more instructs a person toward virtue than the example of enduring death for the sake of justice and divine obedience—death, I say, not of just any kind, but of the most painful sort. Nothing indeed more invites than such great kindness, by which for us the most high Son of God, without any merits on our part—nay, with many demerits on our part—laid down His life; which kindness is shown to be all the greater, the more grievous and abject the things He endured or willed to suffer for us. For God spared not His own Son, but delivered Him up for us all: how shall He not with Him also freely give us all things? From which we are invited to love Him and to imitate the One we love.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The door to wisdom is a yearning for it and a powerful desire. That is the road by which wisdom comes within me, by which I go into wisdom, and wisdom comes into me, and likewise charity. Hence "God is love, and he who abides in love abides in God, and God in him." Such wisdom cannot be obtained without supreme mutual pleasure, but where there is supreme mutual pleasure, supreme yearning must have come first.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If we consider the fruit, we shall find the union of God and the soul. For every artisan who makes some work either makes it so that through it he may be praised, or so that through it something may be procured or gained for himself, or so that he may delight in it, according to the three things that are among desirable goods, namely the honorable good, the useful, and the delectable. For these three reasons God made the rational soul: that it might praise Him, that it might serve Him, that it might delight and rest in Him; and this is through charity, in which he who abides, abides in God, and God in him, so that there is a certain wondrous union, and from that union a wondrous delight; for, as it is said in Proverbs, my delights are to be with the children of men. Behold how the illumination of mechanical art is a path to the illumination of Sacred Scripture, and there is nothing in it that does not proclaim true wisdom. And therefore Sacred Scripture quite rightly makes frequent use of such similitudes.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The commandments of God are irreproachable, because they contain nothing impossible: whence in First John: "This is the love of God, that we keep his commandments, and his commandments are not burdensome." He premises: "this is the love of God": for to one having charity the commandments of God are easy and sweet, but to one not having charity they seem difficult. And Augustine gives the example of a bird having feathers and a bird without feathers: and he says that for a bird having feathers it is easy to fly, but for a bird not having feathers it is difficult. Similarly, to a man of perverse will the commandments seem difficult, which to one having charity are easy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The third firmness of faith is that which proceeds from the witness of truth as expressed through the inspired word: and this occurred with all the prophets. And we have heard this Word, for it is the Spirit that bears witness that Christ is the truth. Some have actually seen Him in the flesh.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For there are three that bear witness in heaven: the Father, the Word and the Holy Spirit; and these three are one. Witness is given by the Three, but it is expressed through the Word, for the Word expresses the Father, and Itself, and the Spirit, and all other things besides.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There are two Seraphim established in us through faith, and each one makes the triple exclamation, but refers only once to the Lord God. For the understanding of God is the understanding of three Persons with unity of essence. Wherefore "there are three that bear witness in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Spirit; and these three are one." And so the intellect is made to resemble a Seraph, that is, it is enlightened and inflamed through faith, and cries out "Holy" three times.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The words also testify to this same thing, among which, although many there be, that one statement is express which the friend of the Bridegroom wrote in First John five: There are three who give testimony in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Spirit, and these three are one. Now this testimony is so efficacious and express that it not only makes the aforesaid truth credible, that is, fitting to be believed, but also makes it obligatory, inasmuch as it binds and constrains us to believing it.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“1 John 5: Three are they who give testimony in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Spirit, and these three are one; I say one absolutely, which I say with no addition: therefore they are one absolutely: therefore the trinity does not take away unity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The incarnation cannot be known unless one is aware of the distinction of Persons. For if you do not know the Trinity, the Father could have been incarnated and have suffered as well as the Son: and this is Sabellianism and Patripassianism. Likewise, if you suppose the Trinity and not the incarnation, you have a witnessing in heaven, but you do not receive it on earth. Yet, since "there are three that bear witness on earth: the Spirit and the water and the blood." The spirit refers to the Godhead, the water to the body, and the blood, wherein is the life of the soul, to the soul. Through blood, indeed, Christ united the Spirit with the water, for by means of the soul, the Godhead was joined to a body.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fifth middle way is kindness, either in the form of the re-establishment of justice or in that of friendship, which has nothing of malice, but through which a man seeks someone else's good; and here it is necessary that reason be guided. Although the Philosopher says it is fitting to do good to friends and evil to enemies, Christ recommends that every man be loved, and that all men be given things that are useful to them, and not damaging. If I love you and grant you some favor or freedom which you will misuse as soon as you receive it, I am not being kind, but rather malicious: and so, in order to be kind, I will not give it to you. I have a friend, and I have an enemy: the friend will badly use some position of power or some dignity, damaging both himself and the common good. If I give them to him, I am not kind. On the contrary, my enemy will use it well: I will give it to him and turn his wickedness into good. A father does not flatter his son, nor does he speak to him in sweet words, lest he become proud. The world in our days is ignorant of this form of kindness, hence the whole world is in the power of the evil one, for man loves nothing but his own personal good.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“According to this same mode also, one may find in the illumination of natural philosophy, whose principal intention turns upon formal reasons in matter, in the soul, and in divine wisdom. These may be considered in three ways, namely according to the relation of proportion, according to the effect of causality, and according to the medium of union: and according to these three the three aforesaid are to be found.
If we consider them according to the relation of proportion, we shall see in them the eternal Word and the Word incarnate. Intellectual and abstract reasons are, as it were, intermediate between seminal and ideal reasons. But seminal reasons cannot exist in matter without there being in it a generation and production of form; similarly, neither can intellectual reasons exist in the soul without there being a generation of a word in the mind; therefore, neither can ideal reasons exist in God without there being a production of the Word from the Father according to a right proportion; for this pertains to dignity, and if it befits the creature, much more strongly can it be inferred of the Creator. On account of which Augustine said that the Son of God is "the art of the Father." Again, the appetite that is in matter is ordered to intellectual reasons, so that in no way is generation perfect unless the rational soul is united to corporeal matter. By a similar reasoning, therefore, it can be argued that the highest and most noble perfection in the universe cannot exist unless the nature in which seminal reasons reside, and the nature in which intellectual reasons reside, and the nature in which ideal reasons reside, come together simultaneously in the unity of one person, which was accomplished in the incarnation of the Son of God. Therefore all natural philosophy, through the relation of proportion, proclaims the Word of God begotten and incarnate, so that the same is the Alpha and Omega, begotten, namely, in the beginning and before all ages, but incarnate at the end of the ages.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For sacred Scripture is principally concerned with the works of reparation. Whence it treats chiefly of faith, hope, and charity, through which virtues the soul must be reformed, and most especially of charity. Of which the Apostle says that it is the end of the commandment, insofar as it proceeds from a pure heart and a good conscience and faith unfeigned. It is the fullness of the Law, as the same Apostle says. And our Savior asserts that the whole Law and the Prophets depend on the two precepts of the same, namely the love of God and of neighbor; which two are intimated in the one Spouse of the Church, Jesus Christ, who is at once neighbor and God, at once brother and lord, at once also king and friend, at once the uncreated and incarnate Word, our maker and remaker, as the Alpha and the Omega; who is also the supreme hierarch, purging and illuminating and perfecting the spouse, namely the whole Church and every holy soul.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this consideration, moreover, lies the perfection of the mind's illumination, when, as on the sixth day, it sees man made in the image of God. For if an image is an expressive likeness, when our mind contemplates in Christ the Son of God, who is the image of the invisible God by nature, our humanity so wonderfully exalted, so ineffably united, seeing at once in one the first and the last, the highest and the lowest, the circumference and the center, the Alpha and the Omega, the caused and the cause, the Creator and the creature, the book, that is, written within and without: it has now arrived at a certain perfect reality, so that with God it may reach the perfection of its illuminations in the sixth stage, as on the sixth day; nor does anything further remain except the day of rest, in which through the ecstasy of the mind the keenness of the human mind may rest from every work which it had accomplished.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These Centers are the "seven golden lamp-stands," and Christ "in the midst of the seven lamp-stands," which are the seven illuminations of wisdom, that is, the metaphysical, the natural, the mathematical, the logical, the ethical, the political, and the theological. These are the "seven eyes" of the Lamb, and the seven days that followed upon the first light.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of the disclosing of Scriptures, Christ is pointed to through the symbol of the One presiding, as is clearly shown through the "son of man... in the midst of the seven lamp stands" that have "seven stars," which are the "Seven Churches."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Because the truth to the belief of which we are bound by faith, and which sacred Scripture principally treats, is not just any truth, but divine truth, either as it is in its own nature or as it is in the assumed nature — for in the knowledge of this truth consists both the reward of the fatherland and the merit of the way —: hence it is that the articles of faith, which are the foundations of faith, pertain either to the Divinity or to the humanity. And since the Divinity is to be considered in three persons, namely the Father begetting, the Son begotten, and the Holy Spirit proceeding, and in a fourfold operation, namely creation in the being of nature, recreation in the being of grace, resurrection in the restoration of life, and glorification in the bestowal of glory: hence it is that the articles pertaining to the Divinity are seven.
Similarly, because Christ's humanity is to be considered as conceived of the Holy Spirit, as born of the Virgin, as suffering on the cross, as descending into hell, as rising from the dead, as ascending into heaven, as coming to the final judgment; hence it is that there are seven articles of the humanity, and thus fourteen in all, after the manner of the seven stars and the seven golden lampstands, in the midst of which the Son of Man walked.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Therefore, however much one may be illuminated by the light of nature and acquired knowledge, one cannot enter into oneself so as within oneself to delight in the Lord, except through the mediation of Christ, who says: I am the door. If anyone enters through me, he shall be saved, and shall go in and go out, and shall find pastures. But to this door we do not draw near unless we believe in him, hope in him, and love him. It is necessary, therefore, if we wish to re-enter into the enjoyment of Truth as into paradise, that we enter through faith, hope, and charity in the mediator of God and men, Jesus Christ, who is as the tree of life in the midst of paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“We shall have this crown if we wish to imitate the glorious Virgin. Whence it is written: "Blessed is the man who endures temptation, for when he has been proved, he shall receive the crown of life"; and in the Apocalypse: "Be faithful unto death, and I will give you the crown of life."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These seals, then, are found in a twofold perfection: a series of twelve, which is a number of abundance, and of a thousand, which derives from a multiplication of ten by itself in a perfect way. Indeed, ten times ten are a hundred, and ten times a hundred are a thousand. No one receives this signification, unless he is the one who has the "pebble, and upon the pebble a new name written, which no one knows except him who receives it." This is "the tree of life": there man enjoys life. Hence, "blessed are they who wash their robes that they may have the right to the tree of life." And he said: I have wanted to lead you to this "tree of life." "King Solomon hath made him a litter of the wood of Libanus. The pillars thereof he made of silver, the seat of gold, the going up of purple: the midst he covered with charity." The seat of gold is contemplative wisdom. And this no one has, except one who has the pillars of silver, which are the virtues buttressing the soul. The going up of purple is charity which makes [the soul] go up to the higher things and down to the lower.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When these senses have been recovered, while the soul sees and hears, smells, tastes, and embraces its spouse, it can sing as a bride the Song of Songs, which was composed for the exercise of contemplation according to this fourth degree, which no one grasps unless he receives it, because it consists more in affective experience than in rational consideration. For in this degree, when the interior senses have been restored to sense the supremely beautiful, to hear the supremely harmonious, to smell the supremely fragrant, to taste the supremely sweet, to apprehend the supremely delightful, the soul is disposed to mental transports, namely through devotion, admiration, and exultation, according to those three exclamations which are made in the Song of Songs. The first of these arises from the abundance of devotion, through which the soul becomes like a column of smoke from the aromatics of myrrh and frankincense; the second from the excellence of admiration, through which the soul becomes like the dawn, the moon, and the sun, according to the progression of illuminations that suspend the soul in admiration of the spouse contemplated; the third from the superabundance of exultation, through which the soul of most sweet pleasure, flowing with delights, leans entirely upon her beloved.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Whoever looks upon this mercy seat with full turning of the countenance, gazing upon him who hangs upon the cross through faith, hope, and charity, devotion, admiration, exultation, appreciation, praise, and jubilation, makes the Passover, that is, the passing over, with him, so as to pass through the Red Sea by the rod of the cross, entering the desert from Egypt, where he may taste the hidden manna, and may rest with Christ in the tomb as though outwardly dead, yet sensing, insofar as is possible according to the state of wayfaring, what was said on the cross to the thief clinging to Christ: Today you shall be with me in paradise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this passing over, however, if it is to be perfect, it is necessary that all intellectual operations be relinquished, and that the summit of affection be wholly transferred and transformed into God. This, however, is mystical and most secret, which no one knows unless he receives it, nor does anyone receive it unless he desires it, nor does anyone desire it unless the fire of the Holy Spirit inflames him to the marrow, which fire Christ sent upon the earth. And therefore the Apostle says that this mystical wisdom has been revealed through the Holy Spirit.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This excess is indeed the ultimate and most noble mode of knowing, which Dionysius praises in all his books, and especially in the book On Mystical Theology. Concerning which also, mystically, almost all of divine Scripture speaks, and concerning which Apocalypse 2: I will give him a stone, and on the stone a new name written, which no one knows except he who receives it: because this mode of knowing one scarcely or never understands unless one has experienced it, nor does one experience it unless one is rooted and grounded in charity, so that one may comprehend with all the Saints what is the length, the breadth, etc.; in which also experiential and true wisdom consists, which is begun on the way and consummated in the fatherland.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“All the judgments of Scriptures refer to this one judgment; hence, He is called the Prince of Peace. Wherefore just rewards come forth from Him. He, then, "has the key of David, He who opens and no one shuts." And such a key is the mystery of union.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This is the Key of David which the Inspired Word is teaching, this Word, who is uncreated in the bosom of the Father, incarnate in the Virgin's womb, inspired in your heart by faith. He penetrates angelic and human minds, and coming into them, He makes them understand these visions, because He is pure understanding and spirit; but He does so in different degrees, for there are different depths in the penetration by which the soul is intimately led to Him.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And it was said to the Angel of Philadelphia, who was the sixth, "Thus says the holy one, the true one, he who has the key of David, he who opens and no one shuts, and who shuts and no one opens: I know thy works. Behold, I have caused a door to be opened before thee." And he said that now for the first time the understanding of Scripture would be given, either as revelation or as the key of David, to a single person or to a great number of people; and I believe rather that it would be given to a great number.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And it was said to the Angel of Philadelphia, who was the sixth, "Thus says the holy one, the true one, he who has the key of David, he who opens and no one shuts, and who shuts and no one opens: I know thy works. Behold, I have caused a door to be opened before thee." And he said that now for the first time the understanding of Scripture would be given, either as revelation or as the key of David, to a single person or to a great number of people; and I believe rather that it would be given to a great number.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This passage establishes that it was those who were upon Mount Sion who were sealed; also, that one of the angels who were to pour out the bowls — and, fittingly, it was the sixth — showed him the city the measure of which was a hundred and forty-four cubits. Toward the beginning of the Apocalypse, it is said of the sixth angel, that of Philadelphia: "He who overcomes, I will make him a pillar in the temple of my God. And I will write upon him the name of my God, and the name of the city, the new Jerusalem," which is mentioned only in the end. There are six times, of which the sixth has three periods and repose. And as Christ came in the sixth time, so it is fitting that the contemplative Church be born at the end. For the contemplative Church and the soul do not differ, except that the soul has within itself that which the Church has within many. For any contemplative soul has some measure of perfection through which to see the visions of God.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Furthermore, these twelve virtues, doubled in prosperity and adversity, are represented by the twenty-four hours, twelve in the night of adversity and twelve in the day of prosperity. Likewise, they are doubled in the active and the contemplative life: in that sense they are represented by the twenty-four elders who turned sometimes to action and at other times to contemplation, for they do what is sensible and mature. Once more, the twelve virtues are doubled through practical and speculative contemplation: and in this they are revealed by the twenty-four wings of the four animals, each one of which had six wings. And here ends the First Vision and the work of the First Day.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These are the true witnesses of Scriptures: the prophets and the apostles. Nor can it be said that the apostles bribed the prophets so that their prophecies would accord with what eventually came about in Christ. If they had lived at the same time, there could have been some suspicion: but the prophets came before the apostles. And so this truth is infallible. The Old and the New Testament agree, standing as they do in major conformity and harmony; and they are like the twenty-four elders around the throne of Christ, so that there be no doubt.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“John says in the Apocalypse that the four living creatures stood around God's throne, and that the first had the face of a lion, the second that of an ox, the third that of a man, and the fourth that of an eagle: but he does not say that each one had four faces. While Ezechiel says that the living creatures "moved," John says that they "stood." Ezechiel says that the first living creature had the face of a man; John, that it had the face of a lion. Wherefore John seems to comprise the visions both of Isaiah and of Ezechiel.
John intends to describe the four meanings, not in the order of importance, but according to the four faces which represent four meanings, that is, the literal or the allegorical or the tropological or the anagogical within any one of the four. The legal books correspond to the lion, because of its magnificence and authority; the historical to the ox who pulls the plow, because of its simplicity, and because it furrows the earth; the sapiential to man; and the prophetical to the face of an eagle.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Furthermore, these twelve virtues, doubled in prosperity and adversity, are represented by the twenty-four hours, twelve in the night of adversity and twelve in the day of prosperity. Likewise, they are doubled in the active and the contemplative life: in that sense they are represented by the twenty-four elders who turned sometimes to action and at other times to contemplation, for they do what is sensible and mature. Once more, the twelve virtues are doubled through practical and speculative contemplation: and in this they are revealed by the twenty-four wings of the four animals, each one of which had six wings. And here ends the First Vision and the work of the First Day.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The First Principle made this sensible world to manifest Himself, namely so that through it, as through a mirror and a vestige, man might be led back to God the Maker, to love and praise Him. And accordingly there is a twofold book: one written within, which is the eternal art and wisdom of God; and another written without, namely the sensible world. And because in Christ the eternal Wisdom and its work come together simultaneously in one person, He is therefore called the book written within and without for the restoration of the world.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“It is not without reason that the scroll was sealed with seven seals. "Behold," said one of the Elders, "the Lion of the tribe of Juda, the Root of David, has overcome to open the scroll and its seven seals." These are the seven Centers. By their significance, Christ opened the tomb, and this represents the opening of the scroll, and He removed the shroud, and this represents the manifestation of mysteries. This is our logic, this is our reasoning which must be used against the devil who constantly argues with us.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This virtue gives nobility to the soul. But because at times a man may be indignant at another, there is need for gentleness, which is the remedy against irascibility and anger—not that man should never be angry at all, but that he should be so only in the right circumstances of place and time. Hence, he must have both the face of a man and the face of a lion. At times, however, you believe a man to be kind when he remains silent while knowing of another's sin. Such is not kindness. Listen, therefore: it is said of Jesus that He was troubled, and that He made a kind of whip. Hence, in the First Book of the Machabees, it is written: Woe is me! Wherefore was I born to see the ruin of my people and the ruin of the holy city? Jesus is the Lamb and the Lion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“John in the Apocalypse saw in the midst of the throne and of the four living creatures a Lamb having seven horns and seven eyes, which are the seven spirits of God sent into all the earth. John sets forth a visionary image and expresses the truth. He calls the gifts of the Holy Spirit horns and eyes. And why? You must understand that there is a certain efficacy of the gifts of the Holy Spirit by which all evils are combated; there is another efficacy of the gifts by which a person is equipped for all good things. And because strength resides in horns, therefore the gifts by which evils are combated he calls horns. And because the power of readiness resides in the eyes, therefore the gifts by which a person is equipped for all good things he calls eyes.
Through the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit, designated by the seven horns, the seven mortal sins are destroyed, and seven virtues are introduced. The gift of fear destroys pride and brings about the good of poverty; the gift of piety destroys envy and introduces meekness or gentleness of spirit; the gift of knowledge destroys wrath and introduces the gift of mourning; the gift of fortitude destroys sloth and introduces hunger for justice; the gift of counsel destroys avarice and introduces mercy; the gift of understanding destroys gluttony and introduces purity of heart; the gift of wisdom destroys lust and introduces peace. Whence through the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit all evils are destroyed, and all goods are introduced.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This virtue gives nobility to the soul. But because at times a man may be indignant at another, there is need for gentleness, which is the remedy against irascibility and anger—not that man should never be angry at all, but that he should be so only in the right circumstances of place and time. Hence, he must have both the face of a man and the face of a lion. At times, however, you believe a man to be kind when he remains silent while knowing of another's sin. Such is not kindness. Listen, therefore: it is said of Jesus that He was troubled, and that He made a kind of whip. Hence, in the First Book of the Machabees, it is written: Woe is me! Wherefore was I born to see the ruin of my people and the ruin of the holy city? Jesus is the Lamb and the Lion.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Apocalypse 5: Worthy is the Lamb who was slain to receive wisdom; the Gloss: "The knowledge of all things, just as the Word united to Him"; but the united Word comprehends whatever it knows: therefore so does the soul of Christ.
To that which is objected, that the soul of Christ has all knowledge just as the Word united to it has: it can be said that those things are said of the assumed man on account of the communication of idioms; or certainly they are said of those things which are, were, and will be, which indeed can be comprehended by the soul of Christ; but it is not true with respect to all things that the divine wisdom understands, since it knows infinite things, as is clear from what has been determined above.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The sun signifies spiritual combat. In this regard, "the sun will be darkened, and the moon will not give her light." When the fight will be between Christ and Antichrist, between the teaching of truth and that of falsity, then "the sun" will become "black as sackcloth of hair," and a certain teacher of truth or superior in truth shall be obscured by errors, while others will stand firm, although they may seem to be darkened in their reputation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the martyrs, the Church was slightly obscured, for the moon became as blood; but it was cleansed, and returned to a greater growth. Hence, the Church was enlarged through the martyr's blood. Likewise, in the days of the confessors, it was attacked by heretics; but later, heresy was destroyed in the councils, and the faith of the Church was explained better. Once again, in the days of the virgins, when men had been turned to the flesh, the Holy Spirit impelled the minds of a few to love and serve chastity.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The day of the formation of man, the time of the prophetical voice, and the time of the clear doctrine, in which the prophesized life would come: for it was necessary that in this time there come a single order, that is, a prophetical disposition similar to the order of Jesus Christ, and of which the head would be an "angel ascending from the rising of the sun, having the seal of the living God," and conforming to Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And it is certain that one of them wanted to exterminate the Church. But an "angel ascending from the rising of the sun cried to the four angels: 'Do not harm the earth or the sea till we have sealed the servants of our God on their foreheads.'" Wherefore the Church's tribulations are lasting until now.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“How can this be? See what is said toward the end of the Apocalypse. Toward the middle, it is said: "I saw the Lamb standing upon Mount Sion, and with Him a hundred and forty-four thousand having His name and the name of His Father written on their foreheads." But at the opening of the sixth seal, it is said in the Apocalypse: "And I saw another angel ascending from the rising of the sun, having the seal of the living God; and he cried with a loud voice to the four angels, who had it in their power to harm the earth and the sea, saying, 'Do not harm the earth or the sea or the trees, till we have sealed the servants of our God on their foreheads.' And I heard the number of those who were sealed, out of every tribe of the children of Israel; of the tribe of Juda, twelve thousand sealed," etc. The tribe of Dan is not counted, but Manasses is counted instead of Dan, and Joseph instead of Ephraim. In Deuteronomy, Simeon is omitted.
This is how the contemplative soul is sealed by God. Hence, in reference to the sixth angel, it is said that an angel appeared, "having the seal of the living God." That was when Jerusalem was shown as standing in heaven. And to this angel appeared an expressive seal, as regards the manner of living in conformity with this seal, which is what was sealed: "Of the tribe of Juda, twelve thousand sealed," etc. And that is, that everyone who possesses this thrice-uplifting light must have a threefold perfection corresponding to love. Hence, to seal in this manner is to bind [oneself] to this through a promise and to impress a seal that would correspond to this seal of love.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And it is certain that one of them wanted to exterminate the Church. But an "angel ascending from the rising of the sun cried to the four angels: 'Do not harm the earth or the sea till we have sealed the servants of our God on their foreheads.'" Wherefore the Church's tribulations are lasting until now.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“How can this be? See what is said toward the end of the Apocalypse. Toward the middle, it is said: "I saw the Lamb standing upon Mount Sion, and with Him a hundred and forty-four thousand having His name and the name of His Father written on their foreheads." But at the opening of the sixth seal, it is said in the Apocalypse: "And I saw another angel ascending from the rising of the sun, having the seal of the living God; and he cried with a loud voice to the four angels, who had it in their power to harm the earth and the sea, saying, 'Do not harm the earth or the sea or the trees, till we have sealed the servants of our God on their foreheads.' And I heard the number of those who were sealed, out of every tribe of the children of Israel; of the tribe of Juda, twelve thousand sealed," etc. The tribe of Dan is not counted, but Manasses is counted instead of Dan, and Joseph instead of Ephraim. In Deuteronomy, Simeon is omitted.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, this perfection consists in the description of the city, that is, that the soul have within itself a divine worship of God, a divine bond with God, a divine zeal for God, and a divine sense of God. The worship is in the east, the bond in the south, the zeal in the north, and the sense in the west. And there are three doors to the east, three to the west, three to the south, and three to the north. Worship has two companions, one that comes before, the other after. For perfect worship, three things are necessary: a veridical profession of eternal truth, a humble veneration of the supreme majesty, and a manly preservation of inner holiness. Wherefore three doors are placed to the east.
"Of the tribe of Juda, twelve thousand sealed." For these were ranked, not in relation to carnal generation, for Juda was not the first son, but according to spiritual generation. Juda, indeed, is understood to mean "profession," and this is the foundation, for the spiritual foundation is faith, upon which the Church is built. This, then, is primary: that with you there be an integral profession of perfect belief and assent.
Second, there is needed humble veneration of the supreme majesty, and that occurs when a man considers the hugeness of his crimes and the immensity of God's severity. Wherefore there follows: "Of the tribe of Ruben, twelve thousand sealed." Ruben is understood to mean "son of vision."
Third, there is needed manly preservation of inner holiness, so that man be so girded in advance, girded against everything, that he be in control of all outpourings. Hence, also, priests were forbidden to drink wine or any inebriating liquid when they entered the temple for service. The same is evident also from the prescription concerning cleanliness. Now, this cleanliness is of the heart. Wherefore there follows: "Of the tribe of Gad, twelve thousand sealed." Gad is understood to mean "girded."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But true worship is insufficient without perfect bond, for charity teaches the worship and the love of God. And this comes about when the soul despises lowly things, tends to supreme values, and expands on the intermediate level, in such a way that it has sublimation in the highest things, separation from the lowest, and expansion on the intermediate level. And this consists in the foremost desire for eternal beatitude, an expanded disposition toward heavenly love, and a perfective contempt for worldly prosperity or possessions. These three are understood through the three next [groups of those who were] sealed.
Hence, there must be in the soul a true contempt in order that the longing for beatitude be in the first place. Wherefore there follows: "Of the tribe of Aser, twelve thousand sealed." Aser is understood to mean "happy," that is, rich with food, providing dainties for kings. But happy is the man who is transported by love into supreme beatitude.
Then, there follows an expanded disposition toward heavenly love, wherefore there comes next: "Of the tribe of Nephthali, twelve thousand sealed." Nephthali is understood to mean "breadth," and it means that all those who want to have the bond of charity must have their affective powers well disposed toward all. But this they cannot have as long as they are lovers of their own private good.
Hence, it is fitting that there be contempt for all things. Wherefore there follows: "Of the tribe of Manasses, twelve thousand sealed." Manasses is understood to mean "oblivion." For some men despise earthly things, but do not give them up. Others give them up, but do not despise them. Others again despise them and give them up, but do not forget them. When the soul gives up and forgets, then there is perfection, and this is indicated in the sixth place. "Forget your people and your father's house." As Augustine writes, "He loves you less if, besides You, he loves something else not on account of You." Manasses, then, is in the sixth place. He was the son of Joseph who [in turn] was the twelfth son of Jacob. And so, it is not without mystery that he is in the sixth place.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the third place, there must be in the contemplative soul perfect zeal, so as to love in such a way that it rejects all evil. Now, there are two companions to the zeal of charity, piety that comes before, and patience that follows. For some men are pious zealots, and later they turn to the fury of impatience. Then, there will be three doors to the north, the affective condescension of kindly mercy, the emulating rectitude of severe control, and the victorious bearing of cruel or human tribulations. In this manner the city is defended against the north wind.
And hence, there follow three [groups of those who were] sealed. The first: "Of the tribe of Simeon, twelve thousand sealed." Simeon is understood to mean "listening to sorrow," and signifies mercy toward the neighbor. This Simeon is "just and devout," receiving Christ in his arms. Unless a man be merciful, he is unworthy of receiving the One who came down from heaven for mercy's sake.
Then, because mercy without emulating rectitude is worthless, there follows: "Of the tribe of Levi, twelve thousand sealed." Levi is understood to mean "added." Levi received the priesthood on account of his zeal, wherefore he killed his idolatrous brother-priests. Phineas likewise obtained the priesthood because of zeal, and Mathathias and his descendants, because of zeal, obtained the priesthood and leadership, and they lasted until Herod. Levi signifies "prelates" who must have the spirit of severity and piety, as did Moses who, in spite of his extreme meekness, broke the tablets. By contrast, Heli, who was remiss, died together with his sons. Hence greater damage comes from a prelate who is merciful and rejects all rigor of discipline than from another who is rigidly merciless. In this sense is the passage of Ecclesiasticus understood: "Better a man's harshness than a woman's indulgence."
In the third place, it is fitting that there be a victorious bearing of worldly tribulations. Indeed, the man who assumes them must prepare himself for suffering. Wherefore Christ overturned the tables in His zeal. Later, when they sought Him, He showed Himself. Hence, "the patient man shows much good sense." There is no doubt that those whose tables He overturned were then clamoring: "Crucify Him!" Wherefore there follows: "Of the tribe of Issachar, twelve thousand sealed." Issachar is understood to mean "sturdy ass," and actually an ass bears a cross on its shoulders. It must always be ready to bear this cross. But the [true] interpretation is not "sturdy ass," but "reward," and it represents a man armed with love of the reward. Hence, in Matthew: "Blessed are you when men reproach you, and persecute you, and, speaking falsely, say all manner of evil against you, for My sake. Rejoice and exult, because your reward is great in heaven." And he said that once he was speaking with Brother Aegidius, who told him that we are not wise compared to Francis, the wise merchant: but we waste our substance, for we should pay a denarius to a man for him to strike us. And we do not even have the wisdom of the ass that bears its burden, and the more blows and insults it receives, the better it carries its load. And so, the obedient man should not let go any [potential] good. On the contrary, he should do better on account of any kind of tribulation, otherwise he is not a contemplative.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On the western side [of the city], there is a perfect sense of God. And this sense makes us contemplate, and as companions, it has the stability of repose and the excess of joy. For in repose there can be stability together with thinking and contemplating, that is, in the west, where there is repose, conciliation, darkness or entering into darkness. For this sense, there is need of the peaceful stability of the sublime mansion, the clear view of wise judgment, and the ecstatic excess of sweet consolation.
It is good to have the sign of Zabulon, which is "a dwelling of fortitude," which implies the first stability. "Because Thou, O Lord, art my hope." Hence, "the name of the Lord is a strong tower; the just man runs to it and is safe." He alone is at peace who fixes himself upon that "with which there is no change, no shadow of alteration." Hence, "in Thee, O Lord, have I hoped, let me never be confounded."
Second, there must be the clear view of wise judgment, so that, as the dove staying over water can see the bird of prey, man too may see in Scriptures. And this pertains to Joseph, which is understood to mean "growing." "Joseph is a growing son," a most handsome son, the savior of Egypt, the leader of his brothers, meaning that he has that judgment by which a man is guide and instructor to others: and this pertains to wisdom. And he is in the eleventh place, so that he can gather the wheat, not the leaves, but the documents of truth in Holy Scripture, and that he can pour it out again later for the salvation of the people. This is the sixth angel, [the one] of Philadelphia, "saving the inheritance." This one provides wheat against future famine.
Finally, there is the ecstatic taste of sweet contemplation. It is written: "Of the tribe of Benjamin, twelve thousand sealed." Benjamin, "the son of the right hand, the son of pain," in giving birth to whom Rachel died, and yet, Benjamin, "the best beloved of the Lord, as in a bride chamber shall he abide all the day." And this signifies the ecstatic excess of contemplation. The son of Jacob is not born to anything beyond this. Here is sleep with excess. No one attains this sealing unless he has gone through all the preceding ones.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Christ is this Center in eternal beatitude. The theologian deals with the salvation of the soul, how it starts with faith, moves forward through the virtues, and is consummated in the gifts. Hence in the Apocalypse: "They shall neither hunger nor thirst any more, neither shall the sun strike them nor any heat. For the Lamb who is in the midst of the throne will shepherd them and will guide them to the fountains of the waters of life." And there will be no inner defect, since "they shall neither hunger nor thirst" through lack of sustainment by which life is lost; "neither shall the sun strike them" through any external harm.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“"For the Lamb who is in the midst of the throne will shepherd them and will guide them to the fountains of the waters of life." The Lamb in the midst of the waters is the Son of God, the Son who is the central Person, and from whom all happiness comes forth. For the Lamb of God leads us, so that seeing the body and the soul and the divinity, we may find pastures either by going in or by going out. Here the beatifying Center sheds its light on body and soul.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Scripture enlightens from above by means of divine promises, for its teaching is concerned with things above. Hence the Apostle writes: For we know that if the earthly house in which we dwell be destroyed, we have a building from God, a house not made by human hands, eternal in the heavens. And: "In My Father's house there are many mansions," says the Lord. In the Psalms, it is said: The children of men take refuge in the shadow of Your wings. They have their fill of the prime gifts of Your house; from Your delightful stream You give them to drink. For with You is the fountain of life, and in Your light we see light. And in the Apocalypse: For the Lamb who is in the midst of the throne will shepherd them, and will guide them to the fountains of the waters of life. And in a Psalm: The delights at Your right hand forever. And so Scripture offers us the divine promises.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the seventh time, that of rest, starts with the angel swearing "by Him who lives forever, that there shall be delay no longer; but that in the days of the voice of the seventh angel, the mystery of God will be accomplished."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But the seventh time, that of rest, starts with the angel swearing "by Him who lives forever, that there shall be delay no longer; but that in the days of the voice of the seventh angel, the mystery of God will be accomplished."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The fifth time, at the end, is that of the restoration of ruins, for "Elias indeed is to come and to restore all things," and with him Henoch will come too. For "the beast will conquer them." And so, it is necessary that they fail, so that there be first a ruin and then a restoration; and there will be so great a "tribulation as to lead astray, if possible, even the elect."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the Apocalypse: "A great sign appeared in heaven; a woman clothed with the sun, and the moon under her feet, and on her head a crown of twelve stars." We shall have this crown if we wish to imitate the glorious Virgin. Whence it is written: "Blessed is the man who endures temptation, for when he has been proved, he shall receive the crown of life"; and in the Apocalypse: "Be faithful unto death, and I will give you the crown of life."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“A man who does not have contemplation cannot yet enjoy the adornment of sun, moon and stars. For there is need of the apparition of "a woman clothed with the sun, and having the moon under her feet, and upon her head a crown of twelve stars." Contemplation of the super-heavenly hierarchy is represented by the sun, contemplation of the sub-heavenly hierarchy, by the moon, and contemplation of the heavenly hierarchy, by the stars.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning the consideration of the heavenly Monarchy, it has been said that it is understood through the solar light, as being a Sun alive, lighting and heating, so that there come together in the soul nine lights from the viewpoints of divine excellence, divine influence, and divine primacy; and in what manner the divine Hierarchy is shown forth by this Sun, and hierarchized by reason of conformity to the Sun, of the disposition of the full hierarchy, and of its manifold aspects.
It remains, then, to speak of the moon. For as the contemplative soul is a good woman, clothed with the sun, so also the moon is under her feet. Hence, as the moon is the daughter of the sun and receives its light from it, likewise the Church Militant receives hers from that Jerusalem which is above. Wherefore the Apostle calls her our mother, for she is the mother of those influences by which we are made to be the sons of God. The heavenly hierarchy is a model of the Church Militant. It is fitting, then, that the Church Militant have orders corresponding to the model hierarchy. They are distinguished in three different ways: the first, according as they proceed in different ways, the second, as regards their manner of ascent, and the third, as regards their manner of exercise.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And so the soul is a woman clothed with the sun, and the moon under her feet, and upon her head a crown of twelve stars, for it is full of lights and never turns its eyes away from light.
And because in this life we cannot remain intent upon any one object, therefore the soul has twelve matters like twelve stars around which it always moves as in a circle, as the sun runs through the twelve constellations, that is, the twelve signs of the zodiac and never goes outside of them. These considerations adorn the soul, wherefore they are like a crown of twelve stars, to wit, the considerations of bodily natures, spiritual substances, intellectual notions, affective virtues, divinely instituted laws, divinely infused graces, irrevocable judgments, incomprehensible mercies, merits worthy of reward, rewarding gifts, periods of time, eternal reasons. In such matters, then, the contemplative soul must at all times be intent upon one of these lights, as the sun is always in one of the zodiac signs.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, Scripture also has trees for food. It enlightens by means of those things that are from the opposite side. For it shows us an endless army arrayed against us, either through the seven princes, through a single war, or through several wars. That war began on the day when Michael and his angels battled with the dragon. A threefold war is threatening us: domestic, civil, and military. The first is with the flesh, which has many troops. This servant-maid is ever-willing to give access, as did Eve. Hence, Against her who lies in your bosom guard the portals of your mouth.
Again, civil war is the temptation of the world. Indeed, every creature is a trap. Hence the saying: Vanity of vanities! All things are vanity! What profit has man from all the labor which he toils at under the sun? Vain and worthless is anything of which nothing remains to man after death: wherefore all things are vanity. The Psalm reads: Turn away my eyes from seeing what is vain.
Once more, there is military war, a conflict with demons which threaten by night and by day, at times by exaggerating so that we become presumptuous, at times by thoughts of knowledge, at times by thoughts of sanctity. At times they make a man angry, and thus devilish and filled with a spirit of malice; and they make him fall into sadness and despair, and it is the same with other means. Scripture teaches to flee from this. But what kind of knowledge teaches to flee from adverse powers? None!”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Three errors are to be guarded against in the sciences, which destroy sacred Scripture and the Christian faith and all wisdom: one against the cause of being, another against the reason of understanding, and the third against the order of living. These errors are signified in the Apocalypse in the number of the name of the beast. It is said there that it had a name whose number is six hundred sixty-six, which is a cyclical number. The first group base themselves upon the circle of motion and time; the second, upon the motion of the stars; the third, upon one Intelligence, saying that it enters into and exits from the body. The first error concerns the eternity of the world; the second concerns fatal necessity; the third concerns the unity of the human intellect. All of this is heretical.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“How can this be? See what is said toward the end of the Apocalypse. Toward the middle, it is said: "I saw the Lamb standing upon Mount Sion, and with Him a hundred and forty-four thousand having His name and the name of His Father written on their foreheads." But at the opening of the sixth seal, it is said in the Apocalypse: "And I saw another angel ascending from the rising of the sun, having the seal of the living God; and he cried with a loud voice to the four angels, who had it in their power to harm the earth and the sea, saying, 'Do not harm the earth or the sea or the trees, till we have sealed the servants of our God on their foreheads.' And I heard the number of those who were sealed, out of every tribe of the children of Israel; of the tribe of Juda, twelve thousand sealed," etc. The tribe of Dan is not counted, but Manasses is counted instead of Dan, and Joseph instead of Ephraim. In Deuteronomy, Simeon is omitted.
This passage establishes that it was those who were upon Mount Sion who were sealed; also, that one of the angels who were to pour out the bowls — and, fittingly, it was the sixth — showed him the city the measure of which was a hundred and forty-four cubits.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Hence, in the Apocalypse: "I heard a voice from heaven like a voice of many waters," because of the great number of possible interpretations; a voice of "harpers" because of the accord of these interpretations, for they agree in such a marvelous way that the resulting harmony is wonderful.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On account of the prerogative of dignity, by which to follow Christ wherever he goes and to sing the new song is proper to virgins, there will be a singular glory among virgins, according to what blessed John says in the fourteenth chapter of the Apocalypse. Whence Augustine, in the book On Virginity: "Go forward, holy ones of God, boys and girls, men and women, celibates and unmarried, go forward perseveringly unto the end. Praise the Lord more sweetly, whom you contemplate more richly; hope more happily, whom you serve more urgently; please him more attentively: with loins girded and lamps burning, await the Lord when he comes from the wedding: you bring to the wedding of the Lamb a new song, which you will sing on your harps, not indeed such as all the earth sings, to which it is said: Sing to the Lord, all the earth: but such as no one will be able to say except you, and because you follow the Lamb wherever he goes, as he who was beloved by the Lamb above the rest wrote concerning you. Where do we think he goes, this Lamb, where no one dares or is able to follow him except you? Where do we think he goes, into what glades or meadows? Where, I believe, there are twofold joys, not the vain joys of this world, lying madnesses, nor joys such as in the very kingdom of God belong to the rest who are not virgins; but distinct from the lot of all the rest: joys of the virgins of Christ, concerning Christ, in Christ, with Christ, after Christ, through Christ, on account of Christ. In this you follow the Lamb, because the flesh of the Lamb is indeed virgin: for he retained this in himself which, conceived and born, he did not take away from his Mother."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“That virginal continence is to be preferred to all others is shown by reason, as follows. That which most greatly makes us follow Christ is most greatly to be preferred; but virginity most greatly makes one follow Christ, Apocalypse fourteen: For they are virgins and follow the Lamb wherever He goes: therefore virginal continence is to be preferred.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On account of the prerogative of dignity, by which to follow Christ wherever he goes and to sing the new song is proper to virgins, there will be a singular glory among virgins, according to what blessed John says in the fourteenth chapter of the Apocalypse. Whence Augustine, in the book On Virginity: "Go forward, holy ones of God, boys and girls, men and women, celibates and unmarried, go forward perseveringly unto the end. Praise the Lord more sweetly, whom you contemplate more richly; hope more happily, whom you serve more urgently; please him more attentively: with loins girded and lamps burning, await the Lord when he comes from the wedding: you bring to the wedding of the Lamb a new song, which you will sing on your harps, not indeed such as all the earth sings, to which it is said: Sing to the Lord, all the earth: but such as no one will be able to say except you, and because you follow the Lamb wherever he goes, as he who was beloved by the Lamb above the rest wrote concerning you. Where do we think he goes, this Lamb, where no one dares or is able to follow him except you? Where do we think he goes, into what glades or meadows? Where, I believe, there are twofold joys, not the vain joys of this world, lying madnesses, nor joys such as in the very kingdom of God belong to the rest who are not virgins; but distinct from the lot of all the rest: joys of the virgins of Christ, concerning Christ, in Christ, with Christ, after Christ, through Christ, on account of Christ. In this you follow the Lamb, because the flesh of the Lamb is indeed virgin: for he retained this in himself which, conceived and born, he did not take away from his Mother."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Since the punishment for lustful disorder must be afflictive, because delight is punished through contrary sorrow: and the rational spirit in sinning turns itself to its own good and to what is present and partial, loving it lustfully, and from this despises the divine command and dominion: hence it is that, in order that that wicked delight be perfectly punished, in which there is simultaneously delight with contempt, it is necessary that for the punishment of that contempt and delight the sinner, whether man or spirit, be cast down into the lowest place and most distant from the state of glory, that is, into the deepest hell.
It is also necessary that the one to be afflicted there be exposed to the lowest nature, and thereby suffer not from a spiritual substance, but from a corporeal and lowest one, that is, from the dregs of worldly bodies, so that he may be fixed in the dregs and burned with fire and brimstone. And since the spirit, which by nature is set over the body and has the power to influence and move it, has perverted the dignity of nature through fault and subjected itself in a certain way to the vileness and nothingness of sin: hence it is that according to the order of justice it must be ordained that both the sinning spirit and man be bound to corporeal fire, not so as to flow life into it, but so as to receive punishment by divine decree. For since he is inseparably bound to a thing which he dreads through divinely sent fear and which he perceives through the power of natural sensation: it is necessary that he be sharply tormented.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“The punishment of hell is in a corporeal place below, in which all the reprobate, both men and evil spirits, will be eternally tormented. They will be tormented by the same corporeal fire, which will burn and torment both spirits and bodies—yet it will not consume those bodies, but will always torment them, some more, some less, according to the measure of their merits. Moreover, to this torment of fire will be joined torment according to all the senses; joined to it will be the punishment of the worm and the deprivation of the vision of God, so that in these punishments there will be variety, and with variety severity, and with severity endlessness, so that for the punishment of the reprobate the smoke of their torments shall ascend forever and ever.
Since divine justice must punish the impious sinner according to the measure of his fault, and mortal fault, upon which final impenitence follows, has the character of a perpetual disordering, a concupiscent disordering, and a manifold disordering, it is necessary that it be punished with the eternity, severity, and multiformity of punishments. The punishment for perpetual disorder must be perpetual, because the sin which one commits and for which one never repents endures perpetually in the soul and separates from perpetual life, namely God, and proceeds from a will that would wish to delight perpetually in sin. And although that passing delight is momentary, yet because the disorder holds the character of perpetuity, the punishment corresponding to the disorder must have no end; so that, just as man in his own perpetuity set no end by withdrawing from sin, so God in His own perpetuity does not cease from punishing; and just as he sinned against the Infinite, so let him have infinite punishment: and because he cannot have punishment infinite in intensity, let him have it at least in duration: and just as his will after death always clings to evil without the reception of repentance, so let God always afflict without change of sentence.
In every actual mortal sin there is a disordered aversion from the highest light and goodness, and an inordinate conversion to a changeable good, and a disorder of the will against the dictate of right reason: hence it is that all who actually sin and will be damned shall be punished with a threefold punishment: on account of their aversion, the deprivation of the vision of God; on account of their conversion, the punishment of material fire; on account of the conflict between will and reason, the punishment of the worm: so that thus afflicted by this multiplicity of punishments they may be tormented both variously and bitterly and eternally, and the smoke of their torments may ascend forever and ever.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, Scripture enlightens from below by showing forth the torments of hell. In the Psalm: He rains upon the wicked fiery coals and brimstone; a burning blast is their allotted cup. In the Apocalypse: Their portion shall be in the pool that burns with fire and brimstone. And the smoke of their torments goes up forever and ever. Scripture proposes this from the very beginning where it is said that darkness covered the abyss, until the end. And so Scripture offers internal spectacles, external examples, heavenly promises, and the tortures of hell.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“From these three idolatries proceed all falsities and disordered states of sin, by which the wretched soul is subjected to demons; which is well signified in Revelation, where it is said: "I saw coming out of the mouth of the dragon and out of the mouth of the beast and out of the mouth of the false prophet three unclean spirits in the form of frogs." By the dragon are signified pacts with demons, by the false prophet the superstitious inventions of errors, by the beast the perverse valuations of creatures. And all these things are prohibited in the first commandment. And just as God in the first creation of things in a certain manner produced all things, so also in the first commandment he prohibits all evils, although for greater explanation he sets forth multiple commandments.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For unless you understand the order and origin of restoration, you cannot understand Scriptures. Now, in the Apocalypse the name of the Restorer is the Word of God: "And He is clothed in a garment sprinkled with blood, and His name is called the Word of God."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In this judgment, moreover, there will be an opening of the books, namely of consciences, by which the merits and demerits of all will become known both to themselves and to others, this being accomplished by the power of that book of life, namely the incarnate Word; who in the form of Divinity will be seen only by the good, but in the form of humanity, in which he will also promulgate the sentence, will be seen by the good as well as by the evil, although in that same form he will appear terrible to the reprobate and gentle to the just.
Because the open declaration of merits requires that there appear simultaneously what ought to have been done and what was done or omitted by the freedom of the human will according to the variety of circumstances, hence it is that both the books of consciences will be opened, so that merits may appear, and the book of life, so that justice itself may appear, according to which those merits are to be approved or rejected. And since that book of life is the book in which all things are written simultaneously and most lucidly, and in consciences they are written truthfully, therefore from the concurrence of the opening of these books there will be an open declaration of all merits, so that the hidden things of each one's heart may become known both to himself and to all others.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“He is a judge who judges by His own power. "Scrolls were opened. And another scroll was opened, which is the book of life," and the book of the conscience. Through the power of the book of life, the soul lives and is open to judgment; and if the book of the conscience coincides with the book of life, it is approved; but if they differ, it is reproved.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“In the mystery of the disclosing of Scriptures, Christ is pointed to through the One who brings about eternal beatitude, for he saw "a new heaven and a new earth."
These, then, are the mysteries concerned with the Tree of Life, that is, Holy Scripture, because it begins with eternity and ends in the direction of eternity. Hence, "in the beginning God created the heavens and the earth"; and at the end, "I saw a new heaven and a new earth."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This Holy Spirit, acting in the minds of the chosen, brings about Scriptures and gives firmness to the Christian faith. And because it acts more specially in the apostles, they are said to be the twelve foundation stones. The Apocalypse reads: And I saw the Holy City, New Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God. And it is said that the twelve names of the apostles were written on these foundation stones; not only the witnessing of the apostles, but also various witnessings of the Holy Spirit on many topics, among which are the twelve reasons for the firmness of faith, which are the twelve foundations. For through the concurrence of divers witnessings, the Holy Spirit strengthened this faith so that it would not be smitten.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“When these things have been attained, our spirit becomes hierarchical for ascending upward according to its conformity to that supernal Jerusalem, into which no one enters unless it first descends into the heart through grace, as John saw in his Apocalypse. It descends into the heart, then, when through the reformation of the image, through the theological virtues, and through the delights of the spiritual senses and the suspensions of ecstasy, our spirit becomes hierarchical, that is, purged, illuminated, and perfected.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There alone is the most perfect order, where there is perfect reduction to the supreme, which is the supreme absolutely, of which kind is God; and this is in the heavenly Jerusalem, where there is full justice. But where there is reduction to the supreme in the genus of men, of which kind is the Vicar of Christ the Supreme Pontiff, there is a perfect order, insofar as befits the perfection of the present Church, which is formed after the likeness of the heavenly Jerusalem. Hence Bernard, in the third book to Eugenius: "Do not consider this form, which is on earth, to be base: it has its form in heaven. He who said the following had seen this: I saw the holy city descending from heaven, prepared by God. For I consider it said on account of the likeness, that, just as there the Cherubim and Seraphim and all the rest down to the Archangels and Angels are ordered under one head, God: so here also under one Supreme Pontiff the primates or patriarchs, archbishops, bishops, priests or abbots and the rest are arranged in this manner. It is not to be made little of that it has God as its author and draws its origin from heaven."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Likewise, Scripture enlightens from below by showing forth the torments of hell. In the Psalm: He rains upon the wicked fiery coals and brimstone; a burning blast is their allotted cup. In the Apocalypse: Their portion shall be in the pool that burns with fire and brimstone. And the smoke of their torments goes up forever and ever. Scripture proposes this from the very beginning where it is said that darkness covered the abyss, until the end. And so Scripture offers internal spectacles, external examples, heavenly promises, and the tortures of hell.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, the great number of thoughts arising out of faith transcend in clarity the light of the stars. Hence, in the Apocalypse: "He took me up in spirit to a mountain, great and high, and showed me the holy city Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven." And I saw that it had twelve gates, and over each gate a pearl, so that each gate was of a single pearl.
These thoughts of faith are compared to the stars and also to twelve pearls. Although these stars are countless, there are twelve signs through which the sun runs its course. These twelve signs are merely clusters of stars which have divers influences because of their different configurations and lights. And the sun, in combination with these, affects the course of life on earth at different times and according to the different influences. These thoughts also, arising from the considerations of faith, are compared to the clarity of pearls because they are bright, vivifying and joyful in the manner of pearls. For pearls have brightness or refulgence, while they also comfort through their efficacy, and rejoice the heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For if they are led twelve by twelve, they will be a hundred and forty-four, that is, the number of the City of Jerusalem. And so, a soul hierarchized in this way is a city in which God lives and is seen. John says of this: "He took me up in spirit to a mountain great and high, and showed me the holy city Jerusalem." And in the same chapter, he says that it was measured "to twelve thousand stadia." And, later, that "the length and the height and the breadth of it are equal." And that the measure of the wall was "a hundred and forty-four cubits."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, the great number of thoughts arising out of faith transcend in clarity the light of the stars. Hence, in the Apocalypse: "He took me up in spirit to a mountain, great and high, and showed me the holy city Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven." And I saw that it had twelve gates, and over each gate a pearl, so that each gate was of a single pearl.
These thoughts of faith are compared to the stars and also to twelve pearls. Although these stars are countless, there are twelve signs through which the sun runs its course. These twelve signs are merely clusters of stars which have divers influences because of their different configurations and lights. And the sun, in combination with these, affects the course of life on earth at different times and according to the different influences. These thoughts also, arising from the considerations of faith, are compared to the clarity of pearls because they are bright, vivifying and joyful in the manner of pearls. For pearls have brightness or refulgence, while they also comfort through their efficacy, and rejoice the heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Again, you can multiply the four cardinal virtues by the three theological, and then there are twelve: for prudence must be faithful, trusting, and loving; and so it is with the others. And they are represented by the twelve springs, the twelve gems in the High Priest's vestment, and the twelve doors of the City. First, the twelve springs, for as they flow into each other, they make the soul clean. Second, the twelve gems, for they adorn the soul with all the virtues carried in the heart, as these gems were carried on the High Priest's chest. Third, the twelve doors, in so far as they lead in: for in the east, there is the sincerity of temperance; in the south, the serenity of prudence; in the north, the stability of constancy; and in the west, the sweetness of justice.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This Holy Spirit, acting in the minds of the chosen, brings about Scriptures and gives firmness to the Christian faith. And because it acts more specially in the apostles, they are said to be the twelve foundation stones. And it is said that the twelve names of the apostles were written on these foundation stones; not only the witnessing of the apostles, but also various witnessings of the Holy Spirit on many topics, among which are the twelve reasons for the firmness of faith, which are the twelve foundations. For through the concurrence of divers witnessings, the Holy Spirit strengthened this faith so that it would not be smitten; although this firmness was shaken violently in the beginning when the martyrs were crucified by idolaters. It was also shaken in intermediate times by different heresies. It will be shaken most violently at the end of the time of the Church through torment, argument, and the working of miracles.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For if they are led twelve by twelve, they will be a hundred and forty-four, that is, the number of the City of Jerusalem. And so, a soul hierarchized in this way is a city in which God lives and is seen. John says of this: "He took me up in spirit to a mountain great and high, and showed me the holy city Jerusalem." And in the same chapter, he says that it was measured "to twelve thousand stadia." And, later, that "the length and the height and the breadth of it are equal." And that the measure of the wall was "a hundred and forty-four cubits."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“For if they are led twelve by twelve, they will be a hundred and forty-four, that is, the number of the City of Jerusalem. And so, a soul hierarchized in this way is a city in which God lives and is seen. John says of this: "He took me up in spirit to a mountain great and high, and showed me the holy city Jerusalem." And in the same chapter, he says that it was measured "to twelve thousand stadia." And, later, that "the length and the height and the breadth of it are equal." And that the measure of the wall was "a hundred and forty-four cubits."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Now, the great number of thoughts arising out of faith transcend in clarity the light of the stars. Hence, in the Apocalypse: "He took me up in spirit to a mountain, great and high, and showed me the holy city Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven." And I saw that it had twelve gates, and over each gate a pearl, so that each gate was of a single pearl.
These thoughts of faith are compared to the stars and also to twelve pearls. Although these stars are countless, there are twelve signs through which the sun runs its course. These twelve signs are merely clusters of stars which have divers influences because of their different configurations and lights. And the sun, in combination with these, affects the course of life on earth at different times and according to the different influences. These thoughts also, arising from the considerations of faith, are compared to the clarity of pearls because they are bright, vivifying and joyful in the manner of pearls. For pearls have brightness or refulgence, while they also comfort through their efficacy, and rejoice the heart.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And by the twelve gates, each one made of a single pearl, may be understood the twelve principal ideas to which the others may then be retraced, and according to which the others are ruled and directed: and these twelve principal ideas are bright, vivifying, and joyful. The first of these ideas was to consider God as the first Being; the second, to consider Him as triune. Both the saints and the doctors deal with them, but the saints by means of intellectual vision and the doctors by means of investigation.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“Concerning grace, therefore, insofar as it is a gift divinely given, the following must be held: that it is a gift which is immediately given and infused by God. For indeed, with it and in it the Holy Spirit is given, who is the uncreated gift, the best and perfect gift, which descends from the Father of lights through the incarnate Word, according to what John in Revelation saw a river, shining like crystal, proceeding from the throne of God and of the Lamb.
It is nonetheless a gift through which the soul is perfected and made the bride of Christ, the daughter of the eternal Father, and the temple of the Holy Spirit: which in no way comes about except from the dignifying condescension and condescending dignity of the eternal Majesty through the gift of His grace.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“John indeed beheld "a river in the midst of the city streets coming forth from the throne of God and of the Lamb." For the Lamb of God leads us, so that seeing the body and the soul and the divinity, we may find pastures either by going in or by going out. Here the beatifying Center sheds its light on body and soul. "There is a stream whose runlets gladden the city of God," that is, the one "coming forth from the throne of God and of the Lamb," the Holy Spirit. And there will be no inner defect, since "they shall neither hunger nor thirst" through lack of sustainment by which life is lost; "neither shall the sun strike them" through any external harm.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If you are concerned with grace, all such things proceed from the throne of God and of the Lamb. Behold, says John, "a river coming forth from the throne of God and of the Lamb." If you consider the prophetic signs, all refer to Christ and are obscure unless their meaning is solved through Christ. Hence all considerations return to Christ.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“And so, in descending order, out of charity which is an ointment flowing from the head over the beard upon the collar of the robe, there is the cleaving to God, to self, to the neighbor and to one's body. Hence, as there are twelve fruits in the twelve examples of ascent towards charity, so also there are twelve fruits in the descent. And this is what is said in the Apocalypse: "On both sides of the river, was the tree of life, bearing twelve fruits, yielding its fruit according to each month." On the one side of the river, the intellectual fruits; on the other, the affective; or on the one side the ascending fruits, and on the other the descending.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But you have that by which you may be raised up in wonder. For being itself is first and last, is eternal and most present, is most simple and greatest, is most actual and most immutable, is most perfect and immense, is supremely one and yet all-encompassing.
If you wonder at these things with a pure mind, you will be flooded with a greater light, while you see further that it is last, because it is first. For because it is first, it works all things for its own sake: and therefore it is necessary that it be the ultimate end, the beginning and the consummation, the Alpha and the Omega.
Therefore it is most present, because it is eternal. For because it is eternal, it does not flow from another nor fail from itself nor pass from one thing to another: therefore it has neither past nor future, but only present being alone.
Therefore greatest, because most simple. For because it is most simple in essence, therefore it is greatest in power, because power, the more it is united, the more it is infinite. — Therefore most immutable, because most actual. For because it is most actual, therefore it is pure act; and what is such acquires nothing new, loses nothing it possesses, and therefore cannot be changed. — Therefore immense, because most perfect. For because it is most perfect, nothing can be thought beyond it that is better, nobler, or more worthy, and therefore nothing greater; and everything such is immense.
Therefore all-encompassing, because supremely one. For what is supremely one is the universal principle of all multitude; and therefore it is the universal efficient, exemplary, and final cause of all things, as "the cause of being, the ground of understanding, and the order of living." It is therefore all-encompassing not as the essence of all things, but as the most superexcellent, most universal, and most sufficient cause of all essences, whose power, because supremely united in essence, is therefore supremely most infinite and most manifold in efficacy.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“But because from itself, therefore it lacks a producer and creator: therefore it can neither depend nor begin; and through this it has the highest and most perfect necessity, which excludes all mutability and dependence, inevitability and indigence, coercion and violence, which denote a diminished necessity: and conversely it posits the highest permanence and stability, the highest sufficiency and freedom. For because it is through itself, therefore it is permanent and most stable: because indeed for its own sake, therefore most generous and most sufficient: because indeed it is through itself and for its own sake, therefore it is the alpha and the omega: and therefore all other things are from it, and all other things for the sake of it, whether necessary or contingent. For just as all movable things flow from one first immovable being and are reduced to it; so all contingent things flow from the necessary being and are reduced to it. Therefore the necessity of the divine being is the origin and completion of all being, living and understanding; and all things proclaim that the first principle is necessary, whether they be necessary or contingent.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“If we consider the modes of the divine conditions, the divine being, by the very fact that it is first, is most simple. For by the very fact that it is first, all things flow from it, and by the very fact that they flow from it, they return and are led back to it as to the ultimate end, and from this it has that it is the Alpha and the Omega, the First and the Last, the Beginning and the End. Because therefore these things, which seem most distant, come together into what is in every way one, it is necessary that the divine being itself be most perfect, as a kind of intelligible circle: it is also necessary that it be most simple.
For something falls short of supreme simplicity in three ways: either because it is composed from others, or because it is composed with another, or because it is composable in aptitude. But the divine being, from the fact that it is first, is not composed from others, for it has nothing prior before itself; from the fact that it is most perfect, it is not composed with another, for what is perfect does not come to the constitution of a third: from the fact, moreover, that it is ultimate, all other things are ordered to it as to a quieting terminus: and thus it is most absolute, and through this it not only lacks actual composition, but also possible composition, and thus to be most simple belongs to God truly and properly, for these three cannot be found together in anything else.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“This indeed is the fruit of Scripture: charity. It is for its sake that there are mysteries, interpretations, and theories. Hence towards the end of the Apocalypse: "Blessed are those who wash their robes that by the gates they may enter into the city." And he said: I imagine those twelve first examples as going up which flow from God and end in God and run through all of Scripture. I imagine as it were twelve circles, so that whatever circle the soul enters, it finds a forest and the amenity of trees and an abundance of fruits.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“These seals, then, are found in a twofold perfection: a series of twelve, which is a number of abundance, and of a thousand, which derives from a multiplication of ten by itself in a perfect way. Indeed, ten times ten are a hundred, and ten times a hundred are a thousand. No one receives this signification, unless he is the one who has the "pebble, and upon the pebble a new name written, which no one knows except him who receives it." This is "the tree of life": there man enjoys life. Hence, "blessed are they who wash their robes that they may have the right to the tree of life." And he said: I have wanted to lead you to this "tree of life."”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“On account of which John says in the Revelation: Blessed are they who wash their robes in the blood of the Lamb, that their power may be over the tree of life, and that they may enter through the gates into the city; as if to say that one cannot enter the heavenly Jerusalem through contemplation unless one enters through the blood of the Lamb as through a gate.”
Bonaventure · c. A.D. 1221–1274 1274
“There must be a discerning investigation, so that the world be considered discriminately by the soul. It is fitting that there be great discernment in the guarding of the house, lest all have access to these powers. May nothing useless be announced to the king and the queen. For a robber should not be introduced before the king, except perhaps to be condemned. Eve, wretched and imprudent as she was, introduced the serpent's eloquence, and doubted; and many today are corrupted by this eloquence. Wherefore nothing filthy should come in through those doors. "Outside are the dogs, and the sorcerers, and the fornicators."”