And we charge you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you withdraw yourselves from every brother walking disorderly, and not according to the tradition which they have received of us.

“To which course many nations of those barbarians who believe in Christ do assent, having salvation written in their hearts by the Spirit, without paper or ink, and, carefully preserving the ancient tradition, believing in one God, the Creator of heaven and earth, and all things therein, by means of Christ Jesus, the Son of God; who, because of His surpassing love towards His creation, condescended to be born of the virgin, He Himself uniting man through Himself to God, and having suffered under Pontius Pilate, and rising again, and having been received up in splendour, shall come in glory, the Saviour of those who are saved, and the Judge of those who are judged, and sending into eternal fire those who transform the truth, and despise His Father and His advent. Those who, in the absence of written documents, have believed this faith, are barbarians, so far as regards our language; but as regards doctrine, manner, and tenor of life, they are, because of faith, very wise indeed; and they do please God, ordering their conversation in all righteousness, chastity, and wisdom. If any one were to preach to these men the inventions of the heretics, speaking to them in their own language, they would at once stop their ears, and flee as far off as possible, not enduring even to listen to the blasphemous address. Thus, by means of that ancient tradition of the apostles, they do not suffer their mind to conceive anything of the [doctrines suggested by the] portentous language of these teachers, among whom neither Church nor doctrine has ever been established.”

“Again, they say the same apostle has left a precept, according to his own example, "That each one work with his own hands for a living." If this precept is maintained in respect to all hands, I believe even the bath-thieves live by their hands, and robbers themselves gain the means to live by their hands; forgers, again, execute their evil handwritings, not of course with their feet, but hands; actors, however, achieve a livelihood not with hands alone, but with their entire limbs.”

“The words of the apostle's testimony are, "We command you in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ that you withdraw from all brothers who are living disorderly lives and not according to the tradition which they received from us." And again he says, "Let no one deceive you with empty words; for because of these things the wrath of God comes on the children of disobedience. Don't be, therefore, partakers with them." We must withdraw, indeed flee from those who fall away, lest, while one is joined with them while they walk wickedly, passing over the paths of error and crime, wandering apart from the way of the true road, he himself also be caught in a similar crime. God is one and Christ one and his church one and the faith one and the people one, all joined together by the tie of concord into a solid unity of body. The unity cannot be torn apart, nor can the one body be separated by a division of its structure, nor torn into bits by the lacerating of its entrails. Whoever departs from the root of the parent body will not be able to breathe and live apart. By departing one loses the substance of health.”

“"And now there remain faith, hope, charity, these three; but the greatest of these is charity." In view of such declarations on the part of our Lord and the apostle, I marvel, I say, how it is that men display such zeal and such intense absorption in the pursuit of goods that will come to an end and be destroyed but have no regard for that which will remain, especially charity, the greatest of all goods, the distinguishing mark of the Christian. And not only this, but they show hostility to those who are zealous in its practice, and in fighting against them they fulfill the words of the Lord, namely, that they themselves do not enter in and those that are entering in they hinder. I beg and implore you, therefore, to be content with the words of the saints and of the Lord himself. Desist from curious inquiry and unseemly controversies. Think on those things that are worthy of your heavenly calling. Live in a manner befitting the gospel of Christ, relying on the hope of eternal life and the heavenly kingdom prepared for all those who keep the commandments of God the Father, according to the gospel of Jesus Christ our Lord in the Holy Spirit and in truth.”

“"Now we command you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye withdraw yourselves from every brother that walketh disorderly and not after the tradition which they received of us." That is, it is not we that say these things, but Christ, for that is the meaning of "in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ"; equivalent to "through Christ." Showing the fearfulness of the message, he says, through Christ. Christ therefore commanded us in no case to be idle. "That ye withdraw yourselves," he says, "from every brother." Tell me not of the rich, tell me not of the poor, tell me not of the holy. This is disorder. "That walketh," he says, that is, liveth. "And not after the tradition which they received from me." Tradition, he says, which is through works. And this he always calls properly tradition.”

“Lastly, those very people [the Thessalonians] whom in his first epistle Paul had treated with the gentle application of his words, he endeavors in his second epistle to heal with severer and sterner remedies, as those who had not profited from any more gentle treatment. And he no longer applies the treatment of gentle words, no mild and kindly expressions such as, "But we ask you, brothers." Rather he says, "We command you, brothers, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you withdraw from every brother that lives in a disorderly fashion." In the first letter Paul asks; in the second he commands. In the first we see the kindness of one who is persuading; in the second the sternness of one protesting and threatening. "We command you, brothers," because, when we first asked you, you scorned our words. Now at least obey our threats. Paul renders this commandment severe, not by his bare word but by the imprecation of the name of our Lord Jesus Christ. He is concerned that they might again scorn his teaching as merely a human word, considering it of little importance. And so quite directly, like a well-skilled physician operating on infected limbs to which he could not apply the remedy of a mild treatment, Paul attempts to cure by an incision with a spiritual knife.… He bids them withdraw from those who will not make time for work and to cut them off like limbs tainted with the festering sores of leisure. This is so that the malady of idleness, like some deadly contagion, might not infect even the healthy portion of their limbs by the gradual advance of infection.”

“Above he instructed them concerning the things to come at the last times; here he instructs them concerning certain matters which they were to carry out in particular. Here first the instruction is set down; second, the conclusion of the epistle, at the place, but he himself, the God of peace. Likewise, first he admonishes them how they should conduct themselves toward him; second, he shows what confidence he himself has concerning them, at the place, but faithful is God; third, how they should conduct themselves toward others who walk disorderly, at the place, but we declare to you. Concerning the first, first he sets down the prayer; second, what is to be asked in the prayer, at the place, that the word. He says therefore, as for the rest, namely because you are sufficiently instructed, pray for us. Rom. XV, 30: I beseech you therefore, brothers, by our Lord Jesus Christ and by the charity of the Holy Spirit, that you help me in your prayers for me to God. And this is owed as a debt, because those who are cared for have a care for the good of the flock. Hebr. XIII, 7: remember your prelates, who have spoken to you the word of God, et cetera. Second, he shows what is to be asked, namely that the impediments to preaching be removed; and therefore he says that the word of God may run, because it cannot be totally impeded, but only delayed. Therefore he says, may it run. Col. IV, 3: praying at the same time also for us, that the Lord may open to us a door of speech, to speak the mystery of Christ. Likewise, that it may be made clear, namely through a clear and lucid exposition, among the unlearned and the wise, just as also among you. Rom. I, 14: I am a debtor to the wise and to the unwise. Prov. XIV, v. 6: the teaching of the prudent is easy. Likewise through miracles, which are demonstrations of the faith. For every science is made clear through demonstrations, and this is to be prayed for. Act. IV, 29: grant to your servants to speak your word with all confidence, et cetera. Likewise, second, prayer must be made for the preachers, that they be freed from troublesome and evil men, namely the false apostles, who are troublesome in disputing, evil in seducing. Or from persecutors who have devised iniquity in their heart. And the reason for the petition is that not all have faith, because although they may seem to have it, they do not however have the true faith. Is. LIII, v. 1: Lord, who has believed our report? Rom. X, 16: not all obey the Gospel. Then, when he says, but faithful, etc., he sets down the confidence which he has concerning them. And first he does this; second, he prays for them, at the place, but the Lord, et cetera. Now confidence depends on him who gives grace, and on men who are of free will, that they be directed in grace. He says, first, on the part of God: I trust that you will pray, and you will be heard, because the Lord is faithful, who will confirm you in the good things which he has worked in you. I Petr., last chapter: he will perfect, confirm, and establish, et cetera. And he will guard against evil, both of fault and of punishment. If however they should fall into the evils of punishment, it is for their good, because to those who love God all things work together unto good, as is said in Rom. VIII, 28. Second, on their part he says, but we trust concerning you, brothers, namely from the grace which you have received, but in the Lord, not in your own strength. Hebr. VI, 9: but we trust of you, most beloved, better things, and nearer to salvation, et cetera. Because whatever we command, etc., that is, because you will persevere. Ex. XXIV, 7: all the words which the Lord has spoken, we will do. Then, when he says, but the Lord, etc., he prays for them, saying, but may the Lord direct, namely that you may arrive. Now it belongs to man to prepare the soul, and to the Lord to govern the tongue, as is said in Prov. XVI, 1. And a little after: the heart of man disposes his way, but it belongs to the Lord to direct his steps, namely to the appointed prize. And therefore he says, may he direct our hearts, not only our outward works; and this in the charity of God. Now there are two things by which we advance on the way of salvation, namely the good things which we do, and the evils which we endure. But works are not good, unless directed to the end of charity. I Tim. c. I, 5: the end of the commandment is charity, et cetera. Likewise neither is patience good, except through Christ. Lc. XXI, 19: in your patience you will possess your souls. Matth. V, 11: blessed will you be, when men shall curse you. And therefore he says, and the patience of Christ, that is, the endurance of evils on account of Christ, or after his example. I Petr. II, 21: Christ suffered for us, leaving you an example, et cetera. Then, when he says, but we declare, etc., he shows how they should conduct themselves toward disorderly men. And first he sets forth the edict; second, he expounds it, at the place, for you yourselves, etc.; third, he shows the necessity of setting forth the edict, at the place, we have heard. He says therefore: thus you live, and thus I trust; but because there are certain evil men among you, we declare, etc., namely to the perfect, in the name, et cetera. For this belongs to the prelate. Is. LVIII, 1: declare to my people their wicked deeds, and to the house of Jacob their sins, et cetera. Ez. III, 18: I will require his blood at your hand. And the edict follows, saying that you withdraw, et cetera. From this it was introduced into the Church that evil men be avoided, and this lest the weaker be defiled by association with them. Eccli. XIII, 1: he who touches pitch will be defiled by it. I Cor. c. V, 6: a little leaven corrupts the whole lump. Likewise for the healing of the sinner, that shame may turn to his salvation. Eccli. IV, 25: there is a shame that brings sin, and there is a shame that brings glory. Nor should this be done indiscriminately, but with deliberation and maturity. I Cor. V, 4: you being gathered together, and my spirit, with the power of the Lord Jesus, to deliver such a man to Satan for destruction, et cetera. And thus here it is said, that you withdraw, et cetera. Nor should excommunication be made, except for some sin, because here it is said, disorderly, et cetera. And this is when something is evil in itself, and against the order of natural law, as the Gloss expounds. I Cor. XIV, 40: that all things be done honestly and according to order among you. Rom. XIII, 1: all things that are, are ordained by God. Or because it is forbidden, and against the teaching of the Church. Hence he says, and not according to the tradition, et cetera. Above, in the second chapter of this epistle: hold the traditions which you have learned, whether by word, or by our epistle. Then, when he says, for you yourselves, etc., he expounds with respect to the last thing he had said, namely, according to the traditions, showing what this tradition is, and how they received it from him. Now this tradition is that they should not be idle, or meddlesome. And first he shows how they received it by example; second, how by word. Likewise, first he shows that he avoided restlessness; second, how; third, he assigns the reason. He says therefore, concerning the tradition which they received, you know, etc., because prelates are to be imitated not in all things, but in those things which are according to the rule of Christ. I Cor. IV, 16 and c. XI, 1: be imitators of me, as I also am of Christ. And in what? Because we were not restless among you. For the Thessalonians were very generous. I Thess. IV, 9: concerning brotherly charity we have no need to write to you, for you yourselves have learned, et cetera. And for this reason the poor lived idly, and out of idleness gave themselves to undue works, not pertaining to them. And this was restlessness. And therefore he says, because we were not restless, et cetera. I Thess. IV, v. 11: give your effort, that you may be quiet, et cetera. Likewise, neither did we eat bread for nothing, etc., because he worked with the works of his hands. Act. XX, 34 it is said: you yourselves know that these hands ministered to my necessities, and to those who are with me. And Prov., last chapter: she does not eat the bread of idleness. Num. XVI, 15: you know that I have not even taken so much as an ass from them, et cetera. But in labor and weariness. Not a little, but night and day, that is, continually, because at times he had to preach and teach, and he spent the remainder in labor, lest we should burden any of you. II Cor. XII, 13: what is it in which you had less than the rest, except that I did not burden you? Then, when he says, not as though, etc., he assigns the reason for his manual labor. Where he first excludes a false cause, second sets down the true one. A false cause indeed would be if someone were to say that it was not lawful for him to accept support from them. And therefore he says, not as though we did not have, rather we did have, the power of living from the support of the faithful. I Cor. IX, 13: those who serve the altar, partake with the altar. Matth. X, v. 10: the laborer is worthy of his food. I Cor. c. IX, 14: so also the Lord has ordained for those who preach the Gospel, to live from the Gospel. And thus from the Gospel there are two kinds of men having the power to live from the support of others, namely those who serve the altar, and preachers. Then, when he says, but that you, etc., he sets down the true cause. For we find a twofold cause why the apostle labored with his hands: one among the Corinthians; another here. For those were avaricious, and would have taken it hard, as is said there. But the cause why he labored here was the idleness of these. And therefore he says, that we might give a pattern, etc., namely of laboring. I Tim. IV, 12: be an example to the faithful in word, in conduct, in charity, in faith, in chastity. I Petr. V, 3: made a pattern of the flock. Another cause is given in the Gloss, I Cor. IV, namely when we do not find one who gives to us, and then he labored. A fourth cause was, that like the monks of Egypt they should not be idle. Eccli. XXXIII, 29: idleness has taught much evil. Hence those who have no employment in duty, or study, or reading, live idly at great peril.”

“The apostle having commended their obedience for the time past, and mentioned his confidence in their obedience for the time to come, proceeds to give them commands and directions to some who were faulty, correcting some things that were amiss among them. Observe, The best society of Christians may have some faulty persons among them, and some things that ought to be reformed. Perfection is not to be found on this side heaven: but evil manners beget good laws; the disorders that Paul heard of as existing among the Thessalonians occasioned the good laws we find in these verses, which are of constant use to us, and all others whom they may concern. Observe, I. That which was amiss among the Thessalonians, which is expressed, 1. More generally. There were some who walked disorderly, not after the tradition they received from the apostle, Th2 3:6. Some of the brethren were guilty of this disorderly walking; they did not live regularly, nor govern themselves according to the rules of Christianity, nor agreeably to their profession of religion; not according to the precepts delivered by the apostle, which they had received, and pretended to pay a regard to. Note, It is required of those who have received the gospel, and who profess a subjection to it, that they live according to the gospel. If they do not, they are to be counted disorderly persons. 2. In particular, there were among them some idle persons and busy-bodies, Th2 3:11. This the apostle was so credibly informed of that he had sufficient reason to give commands and directions with relation to such persons, how they ought to behave, and how the church should act towards them. (1.) There were some among them who were idle, not working at all, or doing nothing. It does not appear that they were gluttons or drunkards, but idle, and therefore disorderly people. It is not enough for any to say they do no hurt; for it is required of all persons that they do good in the places and relations in which Providence has placed them. It is probable that these persons had a notion (by misunderstanding some passages in the former epistle) concerning the near approach of the coming of Christ, which served them for a pretence to leave off the work of their callings, and live in idleness. Note, It is a great error, or abuse of religion, to make it a cloak for idleness or any other sin. If we were sure that the day of judgment were ever so near, we must, notwithstanding, do the work of the day in its day, that when our Lord comes he may find us doing. The servant who waits for the coming of his Lord aright must be working as his Lord has commanded, that all may be ready when he comes. Or, it may be, these disorderly persons pretended that the liberty wherewith Christ had made them free discharged them from the services and business of their particular callings and employments in the world: whereas they were to abide in the same calling wherein they were called of God, and therein abide with God, Co1 7:20, Co1 7:24. Industry in our particular callings as men is a duty required of us by our general calling as Christians. Or perhaps the general charity there was then among Christians to their poor brethren encouraged some to live in idleness, as knowing the church would maintain them: whatever was the cause, they were much to blame. (2.) There were busy-bodies among them: and it should seem, by the connection, that the same persons who were idle were busy-bodies also. This may seem to be a contradiction; but so it is, that most commonly those persons who have no business of their own to do, or who neglect it, busy themselves in other men's matters. If we are idle, the devil and a corrupt heart will soon find us something to do. The mind of man is a busy thing; if it be not employed in doing good, it will be doing evil. Note, Busy-bodies are disorderly walkers, such as are guilty of vain curiosity, and impertinent meddling with things that do not concern them, and troubling themselves and others with other men's matters. The apostle warns Timothy (Ti1 5:13) to beware of such as learn to be idle, wandering about from house to house, and are not only idle, but tatlers also, and busy-bodies, speaking things which they ought not. II. The good laws which were occasioned by these evil manners, concerning which we may take notice, 1. Whose laws they are: they are commands of the apostles of our Lord, given in the name of their Lord and ours, that is, the commands of our Lord himself. We command you, brethren, in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, Th2 3:6. Again, We command and exhort you by our Lord Jesus Christ, Th2 3:12. The apostle uses words of authority and entreaty: and, where disorders are to be rectified or prevented, there is need of both. The authority of Christ should awe our minds to obedience, and his grace and goodness should allure us. 2. What the good laws and rules are. The apostle gives directions to the whole church, commands to those disorderly persons, and an exhortation to those in particular who did well among them. (1.) His commands and directions to the whole church regard, [1.] Their behaviour towards the disorderly persons who were among them, which is thus expressed (Th2 3:6), to withdraw themselves from such, and afterwards to mark that man, and have no company with him, that he may be ashamed; yet not to count him as an enemy, but to admonish him as a brother. The directions of the apostle are carefully to be observed in our conduct towards disorderly persons. We must be very cautious in church-censures and church-discipline. We must, First, Note that man who is suspected or charged with not obeying the word of God, or walking contrary thereto, that is, we must have sufficient proof of his fault before we proceed further. We must, Secondly, Admonish him in a friendly manner; we must put him in mind of his sin, and of his duty; and this should be done privately (Mat 18:15); then, if he will not hear, we must, Thirdly, Withdraw from him, and not keep company with him, that is, we must avoid familiar converse and society with such, for two reasons, namely, that we may not learn his evil ways; for he who follows vain and idle persons, and keeps company with such, is in danger of becoming like them. Another reason is for the shaming, and so the reforming, of those that offend, that when idle and disorderly persons see how their loose practices are disliked by all wise and good people they may be ashamed of them, and walk more orderly. Love therefore to the persons of our offending brethren, even when we hate their vices, should be the motive of our withdrawing from them; and even those who are under the censures of the church must not be accounted as enemies (Th2 3:15); for, if they be reclaimed and reformed by these censures, they will recover their credit and comfort, and right to church-privileges as brethren. [2.] Their general conduct and behaviour ought to be according to the good example the apostle and those who were with him had given them: Yourselves know how you ought to follow us, Th2 3:7. Those who planted religion among them had set a good example before them; and the ministers of the gospel should be ensamples to the flock. It is the duty of Christians not only to walk according to the traditions of the apostles, and the doctrines they preached, but also according to the good example they set before them, to be followers of them so far as they were followers of Christ. The particular good example the apostle mentions was their diligence, which was so different from what was found in the disorderly walkers he takes notice of: "We behaved not ourselves disorderly among you (Th2 3:7), we did not spend our time idly, in idle visits, idle talk, idle sports." They took pains in their ministry, in preaching the gospel, and in getting their own living. Neither did we eat any man's bread for nought, Th2 3:8. Though he might justly have demanded a maintenance, because those who preach the gospel may of right expect to live by the gospel. This is a just debt that people owe to their ministers, and the apostle had power or authority to have demanded this (Th2 3:9); but he waived his right from affection to them, and for the sake of the gospel, and that he might be an example for them to follow (Th2 3:9), that they might learn how to fill up time, and always be employed in something that would turn to good account. (2.) He commands and directs those that live idle lives to reform, and set themselves to their business. He had given commandments to this purport, as well as a good example of this, when he was among them: Even when we were with you, this we commanded you, that if any man would not work neither should he eat, Th2 3:10. It was a proverbial speech among the Jews, He who does not labour does not deserve to eat. The labourer is worthy of his meat; but what is the loiterer worthy of? It is the will of God that every man should have a calling, and mind his calling, and make a business of it, and that none should live like useless drones in the world. Such persons do what in them lies to defeat the sentence, In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat thy bread. It was not the mere humour of the apostle, who was an active stirring man himself and therefore would have every body else to be so too, but it was the command of our Lord Jesus Christ, that with quietness we work, and eat our own bread, Th2 3:12. Men ought some way or other to earn their own living, otherwise they do not eat their own bread. Observe, There must be work or labour, in opposition to idleness; and there must be quietness, in opposition to being busy-bodies in other men's matters. We must study to be quiet, and do our own business. This is an excellent but rare composition, to be of an active yet quiet spirit, active in our own business and yet quiet as to other people's. (3.) He exhorts those that did well not to be weary in well-doing (Th2 3:13); as if he had said, "Go on and prosper. The Lord is with you while you are with him. See that whatever you do, that is good, you persevere therein. Hold on your way, and hold out to the end. You must never give over, nor tire in your work. It will be time enough to rest when you come to heaven, that everlasting rest which remains for the people of God."”

“Now we command you, brethren,.... The apostle is now come to the main thing itself he has in view in this part of the epistle, which is to encourage a regard to the discipline of God's house; and to exhort this church to excommunicate, or remove from communion, all disorderly persons; and those who are to do this he points out, and calls upon, and even commands; and these are the fraternity, the "brethren", the society of believers, all the members of the church; for to them to whom belongs the power of receiving members, to them only belongs the power of excluding offenders: the executive power lies in the hands of the elders or pastors of churches; they are the persons by whom the church receives or casts out members; but the power of judgment, or of determining who shall be received into, or who shall be removed from communion, lies in the church, and not in the pastors and elders only; whoever therefore take upon them to receive, or refuse, or cast out members of themselves, and at their own pleasure, act the part of Diotrephes, Jo3 1:9. The authority for removing disorderly persons from communion is an apostolical command, "we command you"; who are the apostles of Christ, immediately sent by him, who had their mission and commission from him, and which were confirmed by miracles; these had a greater power and authority than the ordinary ministers of the word; they were the ambassadors of Christ, stood in his stead, represented him, and acted in his name; what they said, he spake by them; and it was all one as if he had spoke it himself: and that this might appear not to be of them, but of him, it is added, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ; that is, by his power and authority, if they had any regard to that, or to his honour and glory: that ye withdraw yourselves from every brother that walketh disorderly; by a brother is meant, not one in a natural or civil sense, who is so by blood, or by neighbourhood, by being of the same country, or of the same human species, since all are of one blood; but one in an ecclesiastical sense, a church member, who is called a brother, though he may not be really a child of God, one of the brethren of Christ, or born of the Spirit; yet being a fellow citizen with the saints, and of the household of God externally, he bears this character; and such an one only is cognizable by a church, who have nothing to do to judge them that are without, only them that are within: and "every brother" in this sense falls under their notice; everyone that is a member, whether male or female, for this word includes both; and as the sisters, as well as the brethren, stand in the same relation, are in the same church state, partake of the same ordinances, and enjoy the same privileges, they are obliged to regard the same rules of the Gospel, and duties of religion, and, in case of disorder, to be withdrawn from: and this also regards every brother, of whatsoever state or condition, bond or free, high or low, rich or poor; no partiality is to be used, no preference to be given to one above the other; a poor member in a disorder is not to be bore hard upon, while a rich one is winked and connived at: and it also respects the brethren, whether private members, or officers of the church; for not only the former, but also the latter, when they walk disorderly, whether in the discharge of their office, or in any other part of their conduct, are liable to the notice and censure of the church: and which is only to be done when any of them "walk disorderly"; not for every disorder they are guilty of; there is no man lives without sin; and church members have their infirmities, and will have, as long as they are in the flesh, or in the body; and they are not to be made offenders for a word, or for a single disorder, or for the common infirmities of life; nor are the just to be set aside for a thing of nought, or a small offence, and that not continued in: it is one thing to be guilty of a disorder, and another thing to walk disorderly; which denotes a way, a course, a series of disorder, and proceeding on in it, a going from evil to evil, an increasing to more ungodliness; for walking is a progressive action, and disorderly persons do not stop, but grow worse and worse; for they take pleasure in their disorders; they choose their own ways, and delight in their abominations; the paths of sin are pleasant paths to them: and they are disorderly walkers, who pertinaciously and stubbornly continue in their disorders, notwithstanding the admonitions of private persons, and of the whole church; and of this sort there are such that walk disorderly in the world, in the commission of notorious and scandalous sins, such as uncleanness, intemperance, covetousness, &c. and that walk disorderly in families; as husbands that are not affectionate to their wives, and provide not for their household; and wives that are not in subjection to their husbands; parents that provoke their children to wrath; and children that are disobedient to their parents; masters who give not that which is fit and equal to their servants; and servants that despise their masters because they are brethren, when they should serve them the more cheerfully, because faithful and beloved: and also that walk disorderly in churches, that fill not up their places, but neglect attendance with the church, on the word and ordinances; and who are contentious and quarrelsome, and will not submit to the sentiments of those who are superior to them in number and sense; and likewise such who entertain bad notions and principles, derogatory to the grace of God, the person and offices of Christ, and the operations of the Spirit; who walk, not in the truth, nor according to the standard of the word of God; and especially such are designed here, who are busy bodies, and idle persons, who work not at all, but live at the tables, and upon the substance of others, as appears from Th2 3:11. These act contrary to the order and decorum of nations, towns, and families, and to that which God has fixed among mankind; and to the example of God, and Christ as God, who work hither to and jointly together in Providence, and in the government of the world; and to the example which Christ, as man, has set, and to the example of the apostles, and to their commands: wherefore it follows, and not after the tradition which he received of us; meaning either the Gospel of Christ, which being, preached was received, but the walk and conversation of some was not agreeably to it; or the ordinances of the Gospel, and the precepts of religion which the apostles delivered, and were received, and yet due attendance to them was not given; See Gill on Th2 2:15, or rather that particular injunction concerning quietness, and doing their own business, and working with their own hands, Th1 4:11. The Vulgate Latin version reads, "which they received of us": the sense is the same; and the Ethiopic version, "and not according to the constitution we appointed them". Now what is commanded to be done to such disorderly persons, by the church, even the whole fraternity, is to "withdraw" themselves from them; by which is meant, not only to distinguish themselves from them by an orderly and regular conversation, and a strict observance of Gospel discipline, which to do is very right; nor barely to curb and restrain the affections towards such persons, lest by carrying it as heretofore, in a kind, tender, and affectionate manner, they should take encouragement from hence to continue in their disorders, as tender parents keep in their affections, and from showing them to their children, when in disorder, and under their corrections, that they might not seem to countenance them in that which is evil, though this is also very proper; nor also merely to contract or shut up the hand to such persons, and refuse to distribute to then, living such an idle life, and in such a disorderly way, though this is what ought to be done; nor does this phrase only intend a forbidding such persons their houses and their tables, not suffering them to sit at the one, nor even to come into the other, not allowing any company and conversation with them, that they may have no opportunity of indulging their laziness and tale bearing, though so to serve them is highly just and reasonable; nor does it design only a suspension, or a debarring of them from the Lord's table, which ought not to be done to any persons, while they continue in relation to the church, and members of it; but a removal of them from church communion, or an excommunication of them; which is sometimes expressed by rejecting persons, casting them out of the church, and putting them away, and here by withdrawing from them; which are all synonymous phrases, and intend exclusion from the communion of the church. And so the Ethiopic version here renders it, "that ye remove every brother", &c. From this passage we learn who they are that are to be excommunicated or removed from the communion of churches, all disorderly walkers; what the act of excommunication is, it is a withdrawing from them, a separating them from the church, and its communion; and who they are that have the power to do it, the whole fraternity or body of the church; and also the authority for it, an apostolical command, in the name of Christ.”

“That ye withdraw yourselves - Have no fellowship with those who will not submit to proper discipline; who do not keep their place; ατακτως, such as are out of their rank, and act according to their own wills and caprices; and particularly such as are idle and busybodies. These he had ordered, Th1 4:11, Th1 4:12, that they should study to be quiet, mind their own business, and work with their hands; but it appears that they had paid no attention to this order, and now he desires the Church to exclude such from their communion. And not after the tradition - This evidently refers to the orders contained in the first epistle; and that first epistle was the tradition which they had received from him. It was, therefore, no unwritten word, no uncertain saying, handed about from one to another; but a part of the revelation which God had given, and which they found in the body of his epistle. These are the only traditions which the Church of God is called to regard.”

“Charge, or declare; or by the Greek, we command. — In the name of our Lord. This may signify a separation by excommunication. (Witham) — That you withdraw, &c. St. Chrysostom upon this place, St. Augustine, Theophylactus, and others understand St. Paul as speaking of a kind of excommunication. But St. Chrysostom on ver. 13. and 14. seems to restrain its meaning to a prohibition for the guilty to speak to any body, unless they spoke to him, if their conversation tended to exhort him to repentance. Theophylactus likewise remarks that this punishment was formerly much dreaded, though now not in use.”

“we command you--Hereby he puts to a particular test their obedience in general to his commands, which obedience he had recognized in Th2 3:4. withdraw--literally, "to furl the sails"; as we say, to steer clear of (compare Th2 3:14). Some had given up labor as though the Lord's day was immediately coming. He had enjoined mild censure of such in Th1 5:14, "Warn . . . the unruly"; but now that the mischief had become more confirmed, he enjoins stricter discipline, namely, withdrawal from their company (compare Co1 5:11; Jo2 1:10-11): not a formal sentence of excommunication, such as was subsequently passed on more heinous offenders (as in Co1 5:5; Ti1 1:20). He says "brother," that is, professing Christian; for in the case of unprofessing heathen, believers needed not be so strict (Co1 5:10-13). disorderly--Paul plainly would not have sanctioned the order of Mendicant Friars, who reduce such a "disorderly" and lazy life to a system. Call it not an order, but a burden to the community (BENGEL, alluding to the Greek, Th2 3:8, for "be chargeable," literally, "be a burden"). the tradition--the oral instruction which he had given to them when present (Th2 3:10), and subsequently committed to writing (Th1 4:11-12). which he received of us--Some oldest manuscripts read, "ye received"; others, "they received." The English Version reading has no very old authority.”