The interpretation timeline
2 Timothy 4:16 Douay-Rheims

At my first answer no man stood with me, but all forsook me: may it not be laid to their charge.

A.D. 407 – 1871 9 witnesses

Patristic

before A.D. 750
407
A.D.
John Chrysostom Patristic
A.D. 347–407
“"At my first answer," he says, "no man stood with me, but all men forsook me: I pray God that it may not be laid to their charge." Do you see how he spares his friends, notwithstanding it was a grievous thing they had done? For it is not the same thing to be despised by aliens, as by our own friends. Do you see his intense dejection? It cannot be said, that I was assailed by those without, but had comfort in the attention and support of my friends; for these also betrayed me. "All men," he says, "forsook me." And this was no light offense. For if he that in war abandons one who is exposed to danger, and shrinks from meeting the hands of his enemies, is justly smitten by his friends, as having utterly betrayed their cause, much more in the case of the Gospel. But what "first answer," does he speak of? He had stood before Nero, and had escaped. But afterwards, because he had converted his cup-bearer, he was beheaded. And here again is encouragement for his disciple in what follows.”
Source
430
A.D.
Augustine of Hippo Patristic
A.D. 354–430
“For we owe "fruits" to those who minister spiritual doctrine to us through their understanding of the divine mysteries. We owe these to them as men. We owe these fruits also to "the living souls" since they offer themselves as examples for us in their own continence.”
749
A.D.

Scholastic

c. 1100 – 1500
1273
A.D.
Thomas Aquinas Catholic
1225–1274
“He asks to be visited, and first he calls him to himself; second he indicates his own condition, at "Alexander"; third he concludes the epistolary greeting, at "they greet you." Again, first he commands that he come; second he assigns him a companion, at "take Mark"; third he shows what he should bring, at "the cloak." Concerning the first he does two things, for first he calls him; second he assigns the cause of the calling, at "Demas." He says therefore: because I am soon to depart from the world, hasten to come to me quickly. And this, that they might console one another, and that he might help him in the preaching of the Gospel, for which he was anxious, being in chains. Prov. 18:19: A brother who is helped by a brother is like a strong city. The cause of the calling is that he was deprived of the fellowship due to him. And first by one who had departed on account of his own fault; second, because he had sent certain ones to preach. He says therefore "for Demas," etc., that is, he preferred the love of this age to love of me. 1 John 2:15: If anyone loves the world, the charity of the Father is not in him. Crescens, a certain disciple, went into Galatia, sent by the apostle. Titus also, sent by him, went into Dalmatia, where in the end he is said to have been bishop. Job 38:35: Will you send lightnings, and will they go? "Luke alone is with me" — this one he retained in the preaching of the Gospel, in which he was gracious. 2 Cor. 8:18: whose praise is in the Gospel throughout all the Churches. Then when he says "Take Mark, and bring him," he assigns him a companion; and concerning this he does two things. First he assigns him a companion; second, the reason for this. This Mark is called by another name John, and is the cousin of Barnabas. Acts 15:37f. it is said that Barnabas wanted to take Mark, but Paul was unwilling. And on account of this a dissension arose between them, so that he departed from them. Col., last chapter: Mark, the cousin of Barnabas. The reason is, "because he is useful to me," etc. Then when he says "the cloak," etc., he says what he should carry. Carpus is a certain saint. The "penula" according to Jerome was a scroll of the law, which they had on paper in the manner of a roll, and this he calls the "penula." Or "penula" is said to be some garment; but, according to Chrysostom, it was a common garment. And because the apostle at Rome was poor, not receiving from others, therefore he wanted a garment to be brought to him. Haymo says that it was a special garment as a sign of nobility. Hence in Acts 22:25, Paul said that he was a Roman citizen. For Paul's father served the Romans at Tarsus of Cilicia; and from this he was made a Roman citizen: and the "penula" was a garment as a sign of the consul. And perhaps his father was consul there. Or "penula" is said to be a satchel where the books were, which seems to be the case, because there follows "and the books." But what need had the apostle, full of the Holy Spirit, of books? Again, his dissolution was at hand. I respond. It must be said that it was on account of two things. First, that in reading he might have comfort. 1 Macc. 12:9: having the holy books for comfort. For in books there is a remedy against tribulations. Or he says this lest they be lost, but might remain for the faithful. Again, the more he was approaching death, the more he pressed on with the service of the Scriptures; just as it is said of Ambrose that up to his last illness he did not cease to write; hence, while writing that Ps. 47:2: "Great is the Lord, and greatly to be praised," etc., he died. "But especially the parchments." Parchments are unwritten papers, or leaflets, where he had written his letters, or his sermons. Then when he says "Alexander," etc., he shows what things were with him, and what things are with him. And first on the part of men; second on the part of God, at "but the Lord stood by me." Again the first is divided into two; for first he tells him about a certain one who was against him; second about the negligence of those who did not help him, at "in my first defense," etc. Again, first he sets forth the fault of the one wickedly attacking; second he shows his future punishment, at "the Lord will repay him," etc.; third he shows how he is also to be punished according to the Church, at "whom you also avoid." It seems that this Alexander was a coppersmith, or a keeper of the treasury; and he was one of those who said that the legal observances were to be kept as necessary for salvation. 1 Tim. 1:19: concerning the faith they have made shipwreck, of whom is Hymenaeus and Alexander. And some say that this is the one about whom it is said in Acts 19:24, because he stirred up a sedition against the apostle; but the name disagrees, because that one was Demetrius, this one Alexander, and Luke; because that one was at Ephesus, this one at Rome. And he adds "he showed me many evils." And note that he does not say "he did," but that "he showed," because the wicked can show their intent against the just, but do not always carry it out, Jer. 1:19. Jer. 15:20: They will fight against you, and will not prevail, because I am with you. Job 5:12: who scatters the thoughts of the malicious, so that their hands cannot accomplish what they have begun. Who catches the wise in their own cunning, and scatters the counsel of the wicked. Then when he says "the Lord will repay him," etc., he sets down his future punishment. But note that he does not put the optative verb, "may he repay," but says "he will repay"; because it is signified that the punishment has been prepared by God, which the apostle foresaw from his obstinacy. Ps. 61:13: because you will repay each one according to his works. Yet, together with the fact that punishment is reserved for him in the future, the Church ought also to punish him by excommunicating him. Hence he adds "whom you also avoid," namely as a heretic. Titus 3:10: A heretical man, after one and a second correction, avoid. Of this saying he also gives the reason, saying "for he greatly withstood our words." Acts 7:51: You have always resisted the Holy Spirit. Consequently he sets down the negligence of those not helping him; and first he reproves their fault; second he asks pardon for them, at "may it not be imputed to them." He says therefore "in my first," etc. The Gloss says that the apostle often fought against Alexander who taught wrongly, and in person no one stood by him. But this does not seem to be his meaning here, because this Alexander was not so great that the apostle needed others to dispute with him. But it must be said that, as it is said in Acts 25:21: "Paul, appealing, was sent to Rome," and therefore it was necessary that he be presented to Caesar, that the cause of his mission be examined, and the Jews came against him. And this the apostle calls his first defense. In which the disciples were absent to him, fearing lest they be punished by the cruel Nero. Ecclus. 51:10: I was looking for the help of men, and there was none. Is. 63:3: I have trodden the winepress alone, and of the nations there is no man with me. But it could be said that this was because from the beginning no one knew. But this is false; rather, they withdrew out of a certain faintheartedness. Ps. 87:19: You have put far from me friend and neighbor, and my acquaintances, because of misery. Job 6:15: My brothers have passed by me, etc. But because they did it out of weakness, he prays for them, and does not excommunicate, saying "may it not be imputed to them." Luke 6:28: Pray for those who slander you. Then when he says "but the Lord," he shows what is done concerning him on the part of God, whose help he first sets down; second, the effect of this, at "and let them hear." He says therefore: all have forsaken me, but where man is lacking, God offers himself. Ps. 24: for my father and my mother have forsaken me, but the Lord has taken me up. Hence he says "the Lord stood by me," namely to help me. Jer. 20:11: The Lord is with me like a mighty warrior. Ps. 15:8: I foresaw the Lord always in my sight, because he is at my right hand, that I be not moved. And how? "And he strengthened me," giving fortitude of soul, so that I would not be stunned before Caesar. Ezek. 3:14: the hand of the Lord was with me, strengthening me. And this "that through me," etc., which is fulfilled when it is spread to many, and when what is said by mouth is fulfilled by deed. Acts 9:15: a vessel of election, etc. Then when he says "and let them hear," the effect of the divine help is set down. And first as to the past; second as to the future; third he gives thanks. But the benefit regarding the past is twofold, namely deliverance from fault and from punishment. He says therefore: the Lord stood by me, and therefore in that summons I was delivered, because I was not condemned by Caesar; but it was permitted to me that I might go where I wished. And therefore he says "and let all the nations hear," namely that others might be encouraged along with him to come. Ps. 95:5: Declare his glory among the nations. And that the insult of the Jews might be put down. And he adds "I was delivered from the mouth of the lion," that is, from the cruelty of Nero. Prov. 19:12: As the roaring of lions, so is the wrath of a king. Prov. 28:15: A roaring lion and a hungry bear is a wicked prince over a poor people. Second, he was delivered from fault; hence he says "the Lord delivered me from every evil work." But some are delivered from punishment, falling into the fault of denial of the faith. Ps. 17:18: He rescued me from my most powerful enemies, and from those who hated me, etc. And this through God. Wis. 8:21: I cannot be continent unless God grants it. "In the future he will save me." Is. 45:17: Israel is saved in the Lord with an eternal salvation. And he says "into the heavenly kingdom." Luke 22:29: I dispose to you, as my Father has disposed to me, a kingdom. Matt. 5:12: your reward is abundant in heaven. And therefore he gives thanks, "to whom be glory." 1 Tim. 1:17: to the king of ages. Then when he says "greet," etc., he enjoins on him the greeting of others; second he greets him on the part of others; third on his own part. Again, concerning the first, first he enjoins the greeting of others; second he determines the time of coming. He says therefore "greet Prisca," namely who is the woman, "and Aquila," the husband of Prisca, whom he puts first because perhaps they were more devout, "and the household of Onesiphorus." But why not him, but the household? Because perhaps he was dead, and therefore he greets the family; or perhaps because he was with him at Rome. Determining the time of coming, first he shows the necessity; second he pursues his purpose. The necessity is on account of others remaining in other places. Again, on account of the disturbance of the sea. Then he sets down the persons greeting, as is evident. And in the usual manner, lest the letter be corrupted, he writes in his own hand: "Grace be with you. Amen."”

Post-Reformation

c. 1650 – 1900
1714
A.D.
Matthew Henry Reformed
1662–1714
“Here, I. He gives Timothy an account of his own present circumstances. 1. He had lately been called to appear before the emperor, upon his appeal to Caesar; and then no man stood with him (Ti2 4:16), to plead his cause, to bear testimony for him, or so much as to keep him in countenance, but all men forsook him. This was strange, that so good a man as Paul should have nobody to own him, even at Rome, where there were many Christians, whose faith was spoken of throughout the world, Rom 1:8. But men are but men. The Christians at Rome were forward to go and meet him (Acts 28); but when it came to the pinch, and they would be in danger of suffering with him, then they all forsook him. He prays that God would not lay it to their charge, intimating that it was a great fault, and God might justly be angry with them, but he prays God to forgive them. See what a distinction is put between sins of presumption and sins of infirmity. Alexander the coppersmith, who maliciously withstood Paul, he prays against: The Lord reward him according to his works; but respecting these Christians, who through weakness shrunk from Paul in time of trial, he says, The Lord lay it not to their charge. Observe, (1.) Paul had his trials in his friends' forsaking him in a time of danger as well as in the opposition made by enemies: all forsook him. (2.) It was their sin not to appear for the good apostle, especially at his first answer; but it was a sin of weakness, and therefore the more excusable. Yet, (3.) God might lay it to their charge, but Paul endeavours to prevent it by his earnest prayers: Let it not be laid to their charge. 2. Notwithstanding this God stood by him (Ti2 4:17), gave him extraordinary wisdom and courage, to enable him to speak so much the better himself. When he had nobody to keep him in countenance, God made his face to shine. - That by me the preaching might be fully known, that is, "God brought me out from that difficulty that I might preach the gospel, which is my business." Nay, it should seem, that he might preach the gospel at that time; for Paul knew how to preach at the bar as well as in the pulpit. And that all the Gentiles might hear; the emperor himself and the great men who would never have heard Paul preach if he had not been brought before them. And I was delivered out of the mouth of the lion, that is, of Nero (as some think) or some other judge. Some understand it only as a proverbial form of speech, to signify that he was in imminent danger. And the Lord shall deliver me from every evil work. See how Paul improved his experiences: "He that delivered doth deliver, and we trust he will yet deliver, will deliver me from every evil work, from any ill done to me by others. And shall preserve me to his heavenly kingdom." And for this he gives glory to God, rejoicing in hope of the glory of God. Observe, (1.) If the Lord stand by us, he will strengthen us, in a time of difficulty and danger, and his presence will more than supply every one's absence. (2.) When the Lord preserves his servants from great and imminent danger, it is for eminent work and service. Paul was preserved that by him the preaching might be fully known, etc. (3.) Former deliverances should encourage future hopes. (4.) There is a heavenly kingdom, to which the Lord will preserve his faithful witnessing or suffering servants. (5.) We ought to give God the glory of all past, present, and future deliverances: To whom be glory for ever and ever. Amen. II. He sends salutations to Aquila, and Priscilla, and the household of Onesiphorus, Ti2 4:19. He mentions his leaving Trophimus sick at Miletum (Ti2 4:20), by which it appears that though the apostles healed all manner of diseases miraculously, for the confirmation of their doctrine, yet they did not exert that power upon their own friends, lest it should have looked like a collusion. III. He hastens Timothy to come to him before winter (Ti2 4:21), because he longed to see him, and because in the winter the journey or voyage would be more dangerous. IV. He sends commendations to him from Eubulus, Pudens, Linus, Claudia, and all the brethren. One of the heathen writers at this time mentions one Pudens and his wife Claudia, and says the Claudia was a Briton, whence some have gathered that it was this Pudens, and that Claudia here was his wife, and that they were eminent Christians at Rome. V. He concludes with a prayer, that the Lord Jesus would be with his spirit. We need no more to make us happy than to have the Lord Jesus Christ with our spirits; for in him all spiritual blessings are summed up. And it is the best prayer we can put up for our friends, that the Lord Jesus Christ may be with their spirits, to sanctify and save them, and at last to receive them to himself; as Stephen the proto-martyr prayed, Lord Jesus, receive my spirit, Act 7:59. "Lord Jesus, receive that spirit which thou hast been with while it was united to the body; do not now leave it in its separate state." Grace be with you. Amen. This was our apostle's token in every epistle; so he wrote. The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you all. Amen, Th2 3:17, Th2 3:18. And if grace be with us here to convert and change us, to make us holy, to keep us humble, and to enable us to persevere to the end, glory will crown us hereafter: for the Lord is a sun, and a shield; the Lord will give grace and glory, and no good thing will he withhold from those that walk uprightly. O Lord of hosts, blessed is the man that trusteth in thee, Psa 84:11, Psa 84:12. Now unto the King eternal, immortal, invisible, the only wise God our Saviour, be honour and glory for ever and ever. Amen.”
Source
1771
A.D.
John Gill Reformed
1697–1771
“And the Lord shall deliver me from every evil work,.... From wicked and unreasonable men, and all their attempts upon him, and from all afflictions by them; not but that he expected afflictions as long as he was in the world, but he knew that God would support him under them; and in his own time and way deliver out of them; and at last entirely by death, when he should be no more attended with them; and from all the temptations of Satan, and his evil designs upon him, and from sin and iniquity; not that he expected to live free of Satan's temptations, or without sin, but he believed that he should be kept from sinking under the former, and from being under the dominion of the latter; and should not be left to deny his Lord, desert his cause, blaspheme his name, and apostatize from him: and will preserve me unto his heavenly kingdom, the ultimate glory and happiness of the saints in heaven; so called, both because of its nature and place, and to distinguish it from the church, which is Christ's kingdom in this world, though it is not of it; and from his personal reign with his saints on earth, for the space of a thousand years; whereas this will be for ever: and unto this the apostle believed he should be preserved, as all the saints will be, notwithstanding the persecutions of the world, the temptations of Satan, and their own corruptions; for they are secured in an everlasting covenant, and in the hands of Christ; and have not only angels to encamp about them, and salvation, as walls and bulwarks to them, but God himself is a wall of fire around them, and they are kept by his power unto salvation: and besides, this heavenly kingdom is prepared for them, and given to them; they are chosen to be heirs and possessors of it; they are called unto it, and Christ is gone to receive it in their name, to prepare it for them, and will come again and introduce them into it: to whom be glory for ever and ever, Amen: of the present deliverance, and of all others he had, or should receive, as well as of the provision of the heavenly kingdom for him, and of his preservation to it.”
Source
1832
A.D.
Adam Clarke Methodist
1762–1832
“At my first answer - Εν τῃ τρωτῃ μου απολογιᾳ· At my first apology; this word properly signifies a defense or vindication. To his is the meaning of what we call the apologies of the primitive fathers; they were vindications or defences of Christianity. It is generally allowed that, when St. Paul had been taken this second time by the Romans, he was examined immediately, and required to account for his conduct; and that, so odious was Christianity through the tyranny of Nero, he could procure no person to plead for him. Nero, who had himself set fire to Rome, charged it on the Christians, and they were in consequence persecuted in the most cruel manner; he caused them to be wrapped up in pitched clothes, and then, chaining them to a stake, he ordered them to be set on fire to give light in the streets after night! Tormenti genus! To this Juvenal appears to allude. Sat. i. v. 155. Pone Tigellinum, taeda lucebis in illa Qua stantes ardent, qui fixo gulture fumant. "If into rogues omnipotent you rake, Death is your doom, impaled upon a stake; Smear'd o'er with wax, and set on blaze to light The streets, and make a dreadful fire by night." Dryden. I pray God that it may not be laid to their charge - How much more simple, elegant, and expressive are the apostle's own words: Μη αυτοις λογισθειη· let it not be placed to their account! Let them not have to reckon for it with the supreme Judge at the great day!”
Source
1849
A.D.
1774–1849
“At my first defence, or trial, when I appeared before Nero and my judges, no man stood with me; all, or almost all, abandoned me in that danger: may it not be laid to their charge. (Witham)”
1871
A.D.
1871
“At my first answer--that is, "defense" in court, at my first public examination. Timothy knew nothing of this, it is plain, till Paul now informs him. But during his former imprisonment at Rome, Timothy was with him (Phi 1:1, Phi 1:7). This must have been, therefore, a second imprisonment. He must have been set free before the persecution in A.D. 64, when the Christians were accused of causing the conflagration in Rome; for, had he been a prisoner then, he certainly would not have been spared. The tradition [EUSEBIUS, Ecclesiastical History, 2.251] that he was finally beheaded, accords with his not having been put to death in the persecution, A.D. 64, when burning to death was the mode by which the Christians were executed, but subsequently to it. His "first" trial in his second imprisonment seems to have been on the charge of complicity in the conflagration; his absence from Rome may have been the ground of his acquittal on that charge; his final condemnation was probably on the charge of introducing a new and unlawful religion into Rome. stood with me--Greek, "came forward with me" [ALFORD] as a friend and advocate. may it not be laid to their charge--The position of "their," in the Greek, is emphatic. "May it not be laid to THEIR charge," for they were intimidated; their drawing back from me was not from bad disposition so much as from fear; it is sure to be laid to the charge of those who intimidated them. Still Paul, like Stephen, would doubtless have offered the same prayer for his persecutors themselves (Act 7:60).”
Source
Modern · 1953 →

The in-app commentary runs from the Fathers to the early-modern record, then stops — that's where the public-domain sources end, not where the reading does. For the modern reading, follow the sources directly.