Matthew 18:12 Douay-Rheims
What think you? If a man have an hundred sheep, and one of them should go astray: doth he not leave the ninety-nine in the mountains, and go to seek that which is gone astray?
A.D. 367 – 1871 · 10 witnesses · 12 excerpts
Patristic before A.D. 750
-
367
Hilary of Poitiers
PatristicBut by the one sheep is to be understood one man, and under this one man is comprehended the whole human race. He that seeks man is Christ, and the ninety and nine are the host of the heavenly glory which He left.Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 18:10-14
-
407
John Chrysostom
PatristicAnd to this reasoning He adds a parable, in which He sets forth the Father as seeking the salvation of men, and saying, What think you, If a man have a hundred sheep.Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 18:10-14
-
420
Jerome
PatristicOthers think that by the ninety and nine sheep are understood the number of the righteous, and by the one sheep the sinners, according to that said in another place, I am not come to call the righteous but sinners to repentance. (Matt. 9:13.)Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 18:10-14
184 years pass — nothing from this stretch is hosted yet
-
604
Gregory the Great
Patristic(Hom. in Ev. xxxiv. 3.) This refers to the Creator of man Himself; for a hundred is a perfect number, and He had a hundred sheep when He created the substance of Angels and men.Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 18:10-14
(ubi sup.) The Evangelist says they were left on the mountains, to signify that the sheep which were not lost abode on high.Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 18:10-14
-
735
Bede
Patristic(ap. Anselm.) The Lord found the sheep when He restored man, and over that sheep that is found there is more joy in heaven than over the ninety and nine, because there is a greater matter for thanksgiving to God in the restoration of man than in the creation of the Angels. Wonderfully are the Angels made, but more wonderfully man restored.Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 18:10-14
(ap. Anselm.)f; Or, By the ninety-nine sheep, which He left on the mountains, are signified the proud to whom a unit is still wanting for perfection. When then He has found the sinner, He rejoices over him, that is, He makes his own to rejoice over him, rather than over the false righteous.Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 18:10-14
Medieval c. 750 – 1100
-
856
Rabanus Maurus
MedievalNote, that nine wants only one to make it ten, and ninety and nine the same to be a hundred. Thus members which want one only to be perfect, may be larger or smaller, but yet the unit remaining invariable, when it is added makes the rest perfect. And that the number of sheep might be made up perfect in heaven, lost man was sought on earth.Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 18:10-14
400 years pass — nothing from this stretch is hosted yet
Scholastic c. 1100 – 1500
-
1256
Thomas Aquinas
Catholic"What do you think?" Here a comparison is set forth. And first the diligent search is set forth; second, the joy over the sheep found. Hence he says, "What do you think?" Thus it has been said that the Son of Man came to save what had perished, because the shepherd seeks the lost sheep. "If a man has a hundred sheep." By the number one hundred the whole universe of rational creatures is signified: ninety-nine is the same number as nine, but only multiplied, because nine multiplied by ten makes ninety; which number, namely nine, falls short of ten by a unit; hence by these sheep he signifies all rational creatures; John 10:27: "My sheep hear my voice"; Psalm 94:7: "but we are his people and the sheep of his pasture." By the sheep that strayed, the human race is signified. And why did he signify it by the sheep that strayed? Because through one man all strayed; 1 Peter 2:25: "you were like sheep going astray." "Does he not leave the ninety-nine in the mountains?" The text does not read "in the desert," but "in the mountains," as is found in the Greek. This is explained in three ways. First, because these ninety-nine signify the Angels who were left in the mountains, that is, in the heavenly places; Ezekiel 34:13: "I will feed them on the mountains of Israel." Or by the ninety-nine the just are signified, by the lost sheep sinners; and thus he left them in the mountains, that is, in the height of justice; Psalm 35:7: "your righteousness is like the mountains of God." Or by the ninety-nine the proud, by the sheep the humble: hence, "does he not leave the ninety-nine in the mountains," that is, in their pride, and go to seek the one that strayed? Psalm 118:176: "I have strayed like a sheep that is lost; seek your servant, O Lord." Next he deals with the joy: "and if it happens that he finds it," etc. Here too a threefold reason can be assigned. That the Lord rejoices over the good is found in Zephaniah 3:17: "your God will rejoice over you with gladness." If by the ninety-nine the Angels are signified, by the sheep man, the reason is plain, because man was worthy of being restored; Hebrews 2:16: "nowhere did he take hold of the Angels, but he took hold of the seed of Abraham." If by the ninety-nine we understand the just, likewise the reason is plain, because a commander loves more the soldier who falls in battle and afterward always fights manfully, than the one who never fell but always fights half-heartedly. Thus, when someone has sinned, and afterward rises up strongly and always conducts himself manfully, he loves him more; 2 Corinthians 7:9: "I rejoice, because you were made sorrowful unto repentance"; therefore the Lord rejoices more over him, etc., since he is of greater zeal. Yet this is not to be extended to all, because a just man can have so much zeal that he pleases God more than does the penitent. According to the third exposition also the reason is clear, because he rejoices more over the one who acknowledges his sin, as is clear in the case of the publican and the Pharisee. He concludes therefore thus: "It is not the will before your Father who is in heaven that one of these little ones should perish." He says less and signifies more, because his will is that they be saved; 1 Timothy 2:4: "who wills all men to be saved." For if he did not will it, he would not send the Angels. Ezekiel 18:23: "Is it my will that the wicked man should die? says the Lord." "If then your brother sins against you," etc. Here he deals with the forgiving of an offense. And first the order is set forth; second the number, at "then Peter, coming to him," etc. Concerning the first, three things. First he sets forth the secret admonition; second the testimony, at "but if he does not hear you," etc.; third the announcement, at "but if he does not hear them, tell it to the Church." Concerning the first, first he gives his teaching; second he assigns the reason for what was given, at "but if he hears you, you have gained your brother." Thus I have said that the little ones are not to be despised, but what is to be done if someone gives scandal? Here he teaches. "But if your brother sins against you, go and rebuke him between you and him alone." Note first that he says "has sinned": hence he speaks of a sin already perpetrated. Hence one must proceed differently with a sin already perpetrated than with one being perpetrated, because what has been perpetrated cannot become unperpetrated; hence while it is being perpetrated, one must take pains that it not happen; Isaiah 58:6: "undo the bonds of wickedness, loose the bundles that weigh down," etc. Hence while it is being perpetrated it is not necessary that such an order be kept; when it has been perpetrated, it is necessary. Again he says "against you." The Gloss: if he has inflicted an injury or an insult on you. Hence he means to say that we should forgive a sin done against us; but a sin that is done against God we cannot forgive, as the Gloss says. 1 Kings 2:25: "if a man sins against God, who shall pray for him?" Again, you ought especially to attend to injuries done by one who is with you in the same fellowship; of others too care must be had, but not so much. 1 Corinthians 5:12: "what have we to do with judging those who are outside?" "Go and rebuke him between you and him alone." The Lord leads the disciples to perfect solicitude and correction. Above, at 5:23, the Lord had said that if someone offended his brother, he should leave his gift before the altar, etc.; but here he goes further, because it is not only the one who injured, but the one who was injured: hence, "if he sins against you, go," etc.; Psalm 119:7: "with those who hated peace, I was peaceable." And should you forgive first? No; rather you ought first to rebuke: hence he does not command forgiving anyone, but the one who repents. Again he says "rebuke," not "upbraid" or "exasperate," and show it briefly. If he acknowledges it, then you ought to forgive; hence, "instruct them in a spirit of gentleness," Galatians 6:1. But does the one who omits this correction sin? Augustine: if you do not rebuke, you have become worse by keeping silent than he by sinning. But since it is true that all are bound to rebuke, someone might say that it belongs to prelates alone by office, but to others by charity. Sometimes the Lord permits the good to be punished along with the wicked. Why? Because they did not rebuke the wicked. Yet Augustine says that sometimes we ought to desist, if you fear that on account of this correction they will not be amended, but rendered worse. Again, if you fear it may bring on persecution of the Church, you do not sin. But if you desist so as not to be harmed in temporal things, so that no trouble befall you, or the like, you sin; Proverbs 9:8: "reprove a wise man, and he will love you." "Rebuke him between you and him alone." And why? Because this correction is done out of charity; and charity is the love of God and of neighbor. If you love, you ought to cherish his salvation. But in this two things must be attended to, namely conscience and good repute. If therefore you wish to save him, you ought to save his reputation; and this you will do by correcting him between you and him. If you rebuke him before everyone, you take away his reputation; yet conscience is to be preferred to reputation. Yet it frequently happens that when a man sees his sin made public, he becomes so shameless that he exposes himself to every sin; Jeremiah 2:20: "under every leafy tree you lay down, harlot"; Ecclesiasticus 4:25: "there is a shame that brings sin." But against this an objection is raised from 1 Timothy 5:20: "rebuke him that sins, before all." And this is true if the offense is public. For there is someone who sins publicly, and then he must be rebuked publicly; and someone who sins secretly, and then he must be rebuked secretly; and this is clear, because Augustine says that if he has sinned with you alone knowing it, "rebuke him between you and him alone." "But if he hears you, you have gained your brother." To what end does he say this? On account of three things. That you may know for what end you ought to rebuke: because if you rebuke for your own sake, you accomplish nothing, since where the amends sought is private, the correction is not meritorious; but if for God's sake, then it avails. Again, this is what you ought to intend, namely to instill the rebuke and teaching into the mind of the brother. Again, someone might say that it would not be just to lose one's brother. But if that were so, he would not have said, "you have gained your brother." Again, "gained," because he is a fellow-member of yours: and just as a member has fellow-feeling with a member, so too you with your brother. Again, "gained," because you gain salvation for yourself; James 4:11: "he who judges his brother detracts from the law, and judges the law"; hence in the same epistle, 5:20: "he who causes a sinner to be converted from the error of his way saves his soul from death, and covers a multitude of sins." "But if he does not hear you, take with you one or two." Here he brings in the testimony, "take one or two," etc. Deuteronomy 19:15: "in the mouth of two or three witnesses let every word stand." But here is a question: why does he not bring in witnesses right away? It must be said that conscience must be cleansed in such a way that reputation is not harmed: hence if he can correct him first and by himself, well and good; if not, then let him call in witnesses. And Jerome says that first one, and afterward two. And why? That they may be witnesses of the correction made, because if he proceeds further, it is not to be imputed to you. Jerome says it is also for another purpose, namely so that he may be convicted of the sin: because some are so obstinate that they do not acknowledge it, and therefore you ought to bring witnesses, so as to convict him of the deed. Or perhaps he will repeat the injury. Or, according to Augustine, to convict him. But against this seems to be what Augustine says, that before showing it to two, he ought to show it to the superior, and this is to show it to the Church. Therefore it seems to invert the order. I say that it can be shown to the prelate either in a judicial order, or as to a private person. Augustine means, therefore, that it ought to be shown to the superior first as to a private person, so that, as a private person, he may take pains toward the correction. Hence he says, "if he does not hear them, tell it to the Church." Here the denunciation is set forth. And first he denounces; second the sentence is set forth; third the efficacy. The second at "but if he does not hear the Church," etc.; the third at "Amen I say to you," etc. He says, "but if he does not hear them, tell it to the Church," that is, to the whole multitude, that he may be confounded, so that he who was unwilling to be rebuked without confusion may be rebuked with confusion. For there is a shame that brings sin, and there is a shame that brings glory and grace, Ecclesiasticus 4:25. Or "to the Church," that is, to the judges, that he may be corrected; Deuteronomy 21:18: "if a man has a stubborn and defiant son who will not hear the command of his father and mother, and, having been disciplined, refuses to obey, they shall seize him and bring him to the elders of that city, and to the gate of judgment," etc. Then the penalty is added: "if he does not hear the Church, let him be to you as a heathen and a publican." Heathens are the gentiles and unbelievers; publicans are those who collect the tribute, who are public sinners. Hence, as if set apart, let them be excommunicated by the sentence of the Church, because they did not hear the Church. Hence for contumacy alone a man can be excommunicated. "Amen I say to you," etc. Here the efficacy of this sentence is set forth. For someone might say: what do I care if it is told to the Church, and I am excommunicated? Therefore he shows this efficacy: "Amen I say to you, whatever you shall bind on earth shall be bound also in heaven; and whatever you shall loose on earth shall be loosed also in heaven." Above, these things were said to Peter; but here it is said to the whole Church. And he is said to bind, either because he does not absolve, or because he excommunicates. Origen says that here he says "in heaven," whereas when he spoke to Peter, he said "in the heavens," to designate that Peter has universal power. But here he says "in heaven," because their power is not universal, but limited to some place, since he gave universal power to Peter. "Again I say to you," etc. Here he sets forth the efficacy of prayer. And first he does this; second he gives the reason, at "for where there are two," etc. He says, "again I say to you," etc. But you can object, because we ask for many things which we do not obtain. This happens, first, on account of the unworthiness of those asking; hence he says "two of you," namely, who live according to the Gospel. James 4:3: "you ask, and do not receive, because you ask wrongly." Again, it happens because they do not agree together, because they do not have the bond of peace: for it is impossible that the prayers of many not be heard, if out of many prayers there is made, as it were, one; 2 Corinthians 1:11: "so that, from the persons of the many faces, thanks may be given by many on our behalf for the gift that is in us." Again, because they ask for certain things which are not expedient for them unto salvation: for the petition ought to be about something useful; below, 20:22: "you do not know what you ask." "It shall be done for them by my Father," who is in heaven, that is, in the heights: or "in heaven," that is, in us. "For where there are two or three gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them"; in a gathering of the holy, not of the earthly. Psalm 110:1: "great are the works of the Lord, in the council of the just and in the congregation." "Where therefore two or three." Charity is not in one, but in many; hence 1 John 4:16: "he who abides in charity abides in God, and God in him." Therefore, "I am in the midst of them." "Then Peter, coming to him, said: Lord, how often shall my brother sin against me, and I forgive him?" Above he taught in what order forgiveness is to be given, namely after correction and amends; here he deals with the number of times forgiveness is to be given. First, therefore, Peter's question is set forth; second, Christ's response; third, a comparison is applied. The second at "Jesus says to him," etc.; the third at "the kingdom of heaven is likened." He says, therefore, "then, coming." "Then," namely, having heard this saying, "if your brother sins against you," etc., Peter was then moved to ask whether he should forgive once or many times, and he said, "how often shall my brother sin against me," etc., "shall I forgive up to seven times," as if to say: up to seven times is a matter of weakness, but more is a matter of malice. Therefore he asked whether he should forgive up to seven times. Again, he knew that which is said in 4 Kings 5:10, that Elisha commanded Naaman to wash himself seven times in the Jordan; therefore he thought that he ought to forgive seven times. Jesus says to him: "I do not say to you seven times, but seventy times seven." In one way this can be taken, what he says "seven times," cumulatively, so that the sense is: not seven times, but seventy times. Or it can be taken multiplicatively, so that seventy times seven; and thus Jerome expounds it. According to the first exposition, which is Augustine's, it is given to be understood that we ought to forgive entirely, just as Christ forgave everything. Colossians 3:13: "forgiving one another, if anyone has a complaint against another; even as the Lord has forgiven you, so also do you." Or it can be said that a finite number is put for an infinite one, as in the Psalms: "the word which he commanded unto a thousand generations." According to Jerome, the cause is the same; yet a reason for the number is added. For by six perfection is signified; by the hundred, which is multiplied by ten, the Decalogue is signified. The first number that departs from ten is the eleventh. And because by six the totality is signified, therefore the totality of sins is signified; as if he were to say: whatever things your brother has sinned against you, forgive him. Hence, according to Jerome, it seems that he means to say that one can forgive more than the brother could possibly offend.English is machine-translated from the public-domain Latin (Corpus Thomisticum), since no public-domain English translation exists. It is not a scholarly translation. Please report errors.
Source Commentary on Matthew, ch. 18, l2 Read in full ›
515 years pass — nothing from this stretch is hosted yet
Post-Reformation c. 1650 – 1900
-
1771
John Gill
ReformedFor the Son of man is come to seek that which was lost. This is another, and stronger reason, why these little ones should not be despised; because Christ, who is here meant by the Son of man, came into this world to save these persons; who were lost in Adam, and had destroyed themselves by their transgressions, and carries great force in it: for if God had so great a regard to these little ones, as to send his Son to obtain eternal salvation for them, when they were in a miserable and perishing condition; and Christ had so much love for them, as to come into this world, and endure the sorrows, sufferings, and death itself for them, who were not only little, but lost; and that to obtain righteousness and life for them, and save them with an everlasting salvation; then they must, and ought to be, far above the contempt of all mortals; and the utmost care should be taken not to despise, grieve, offend, and injure them in any form or shape whatever; see Rom 14:15. Beza observes, that this whole verse is left out in some Greek copies, but it stands in others, and in all the Oriental versions, and in Munster's Hebrew Gospel; nor can it be omitted; the following parable, which is an exemplification of it, requires it. . Beza observes, that this whole verse is left out in some Greek copies, but it stands in others, and in all the Oriental versions, and in Munster's Hebrew Gospel; nor can it be omitted; the following parable, which is an exemplification of it, requires it. Matthew 18:12 mat 18:12 mat 18:12 mat 18:12How think ye,.... Or, as the Arabic, "what do you think?" what is your opinion of this matter? what is your sense of it? how does it appear to you? It is a Talmudic way of speaking, the same with "what do you think?" what is your judgment? So the Rabbins, after they have discussed a point among themselves, ask (k), , "what is our opinion?" or what do we think upon the whole? Christ here appeals to his disciples, makes them judges themselves in this matter, and illustrates it by a familiar instance of a man's seeking and finding his lost sheep, and rejoicing at it. If a man have an hundred sheep; who is the proprietor of them; not the hireling, who has them under his care, and whose the sheep are not; but the owner of them, to whom they belong, and who must be thought to be most concerned for anyone of them that should go astray: a hundred sheep seem to be the number of a flock; at least flocks of sheep used to be divided into hundreds. In a Maronite's will, a field is thus bequeathed (l); "the north part of it to such an one, and with it , "a hundred sheep", and a hundred vessels; and the south part of it to such an one, and with it , "a hundred sheep", and a hundred vessels; and he died, and the wise men confirmed his words, or his will.'' Such a supposition, or putting such a case as this, is very proper and pertinent. And one of them be gone astray; which sheep are very prone to; see Psa 119:176; doth he not leave the ninety and nine, which are not gone astray, in the place where they are; it is usual so to do: and goeth into the mountains; alluding to the mountains of Israel, where were pastures for sheep, Eze 34:13 and whither sheep are apt to wander, and go from mountain to mountain, Jer 50:6, and therefore these were proper places to go after them, and seek for them in: but the Vulgate Latin version joins the words "in" or "on the mountains", to the preceding clause, and reads, doth he not leave the ninety and nine in the mountains; and so read all the Oriental versions, Syriac, Arabic, Ethiopic, and Persic; and in the same manner Theophylact; and seeketh that which is gone astray? This is usual with men: no man that has a flock of sheep, and though but one strays from it, but takes this method. This parable now may be considered, either as an illustration of the Son of man's coming into this world, to seek, and to save his lost sheep, mentioned in the preceding verse; even the lost sheep of the house of Israel, the little ones that believed in him, who were despised by the Jews. And then by the "ninety and nine", we are not to understand the angels; who never went astray, never sinned, but kept their first estate, whom Christ left in the highest heavens, on the holy mountains of eternity, when he became incarnate, and came down on earth to redeem mankind: for these never go by the name of sheep; nor are they of the same nature and kind with the one that strays, and is sought out; nor is their number, with respect to men, as ninety nine to one; at least it cannot be ascertained; nor were they left by Christ, when he came on earth; for a multitude descended at his birth, and sung glory to God. Nor are the saints in heaven intended, whose state is safe; since it cannot be said of them, as in the following verse, that they went not astray; for they went astray like lost sheep, as others, and were looked up, sought out, and saved by Christ as others; but rather, by them, are meant the body of the Jewish nation, the far greater part of them, the Scribes and Pharisees, who rejected the Messiah, and despised those that believed in him: these were in sheep's clothing, of the flock of the house of Israel, of the Jewish fold; and with respect to the remnant among them, according to the election of grace, were as ninety nine to one: these were left by Christ, and taken no notice of by him, in comparison of the little ones, the lost sheep of the house of Israel he came to save: these he left on the mountains, on the barren pastures of Mount Sinai, feeding on their own works and services; or rather, he went into the mountains, or came leaping and skipping over them, Sol 2:8, encountering with, and surmounting all difficulties that lay in the way of the salvation of his people; such as appearing in the likeness of sinful flesh, bearing, and carrying the griefs and sorrows of his people, obeying the law, satisfying justice, bearing their sins, and undergoing an accursed death, in order to obtain the salvation of his chosen ones, designed by the one sheep "that was gone astray"; who strayed from God, from his law, the rule of their walk, out of his way, into the ways of sin, which are of their own choosing and approving: or, the intention of this parable is, to set forth the great regard God has to persons ever so mean, that believe in Christ, whom he would not have stumbled and offended, and takes special care of them, that they shall not perish; even as the proprietor of a flock of sheep is more concerned for one straying one, than for the other ninety nine that remain. (k) T. Bab. Sanhedrim, fol. 88. 2. (l) T. Bab. Bava Bathra, fol. 156. 2.Source Matthew 18:11–12 Read in full ›
-
1849
George Leo Haydock
CatholicIf a man have a hundred sheep. This is to shew the goodness and mercy of God towards sinners. By the one sheep, some understand all mankind, and by the ninety-nine, the angels in heaven. (Witham) — Jesus Christ manifests his tender regard and solicitude for us poor weak creatures, by becoming himself the Son of man, thus abandoning in some measure the angels who are in heaven. He is come down upon earth to save by his death what was lost, imitating thus, with regard to men, the conduct themselves observe with regard to their sheep. (Bible de Vence) — In the Greek, it is dubious whether the shepherd leaves the ninety-nine in the mountains, or, whether he himself goeth into the mountains in quest of the lost sheep.Source Matthew 18:12
-
1871
Jamieson, Fausset & Brown
ReformedHow think ye? If a man have an hundred sheep, and one of them be gone astray, &c.--This is another of those pregnant sayings which our Lord uttered more than once. See on the delightful parable of the lost sheep in Luk 15:4-7. Only the object there is to show what the good Shepherd will do, when even one of His sheep is lost, to find it; here the object is to show, when found, how reluctant He is to lose it. Accordingly, it is added,Source Matthew 18:12