Interpretation & Doctrine

Matthew 19:28 Douay-Rheims

And Jesus said to them: Amen, I say to you, that you, who have followed me, in the regeneration, when the Son of man shall sit on the seat of his majesty, you also shall sit on twelve seats judging the twelve tribes of Israel.

A.D. 367 – 1863 · 10 witnesses · 16 excerpts

‹ Matthew 19 Read Matthew 19 ›

  1. Patristic before A.D. 750

  2. 367

    Hilary of Poitiers

    Patristic
    The disciples had followed Christ in the regeneration, that is, in the laver of baptism, in the sanctification of faith, for this is that regeneration which the Apostles followed, and which the Law could not bestow.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30

    Their following Christ in thus exalting the Apostles to twelve thrones to judge the twelve tribes of Israel, associated them in the glory of the twelve Patriarchs.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30

  3. 407

    John Chrysostom

    Patristic
    He therefore said not the Gentiles and the whole world, but, the tribes of Israel, because the Apostles and the Jews had been brought up under the same laws and customs. So that when the Jews should plead that they could not believe in Christ, because they were hindered by their Law, the disciples will be brought forward, who had the same Law. But some one may say, What great thing is this, when both the Ninevites and the Queen of the South will have the same? He had before and will again promise them the highest rewards; and even now He tacitly conveys something of the same. For of those others He had only said, that they shall sit, and shall condemn this generation; but He now says to the disciples, When the Son of Man shall sit, ye also shall sit. It is clear then that they shall reign with Him, and shall share in that glory; for it is such honour and glory unspeakable that He intends by the thrones. How is this promise fulfilled? Shall Judas sit among them? By no means. For the law was thus ordained of the Lord by Jeremiah the Prophet, I will speak it upon my people, and upon the kingdom, that I may build, and plant it. Bui if it do evil in my sight, then will I repent we of the good which I said I would do to them; (Jer. 18:9.) as much as to say, If they make themselves unworthy of the promise, I will no more perform that I promised. But Judas shewed himself unworthy of the preeminence; wherefore when He gave this promise to His disciples, He did not promise it absolutely, for He said not, Ye shall sit, but, Ye which, have followed me shall sit; at once excluding Judas, and admitting such as should be in after time; for neither was the promise confined to them only, nor yet did it include Judas who had already shewn himself undeserving.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30

    Or; He holds out rewards in the future life to the Apostles, because they were already looking above, and desired nothing of things present; but to others. He promises things present.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30

  4. 420

    Jerome

    Patristic
    Or it may be constructed thus, Ye which have followed me, shall in the regeneration sit, &c.; that is, when the dead shall rise from corruption incorrupt, you also shall sit on thrones of judges, condemning the twelve tribes of Israel, for that they would not believe when you believed.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30

  5. 430

    Augustine of Hippo

    Patristic
    (de Civ. Dei, xx. 5.) Thus our flesh will be regenerated by incorruption, as our soul also shall be regenerated by faith.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30

    (ubi sup.) From this passage we learn that Jesus will judge with His disciples; whence He says in another place to the Jews, Therefore shall they be your judges. (Mat. 12:27.) And whereas He says they shall sit upon twelve thrones, we need not think that twelve persons only shall judge with Him. For by the number twelve is signified the whole number of those that shall judge; and that because the number seven which generally represents completeness contains the two numbers four and three, which multiplied together make twelve. For if it were not so, as Matthias was elected into the place of the traitor Judas, the Apostle Paul who laboured more than they all should not have place to sit to judge; but he shews that he with the rest of the saints pertains to the number of judges, when he says, Know ye not that we shall judge Angels? (1 Cor. 6:3.)

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30

    (Serm. 351. 8.) In the number of judges therefore are included all that have left their all and followed the Lord;

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30

    (de Civ. Dei, xx. 5.) The same holds good, by reason of this number twelve, of those that are to be judged. For when it is said, Judging the twelve tribes, yet is not the tribe of Levi, which is the thirteenth, to be exempt from being judged by them; nor shall they judge this nation alone, and not also other nations.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30

  6. 604

    Gregory the Great

    Patristic
    (Mor. x. 31.) For whosoever, urged by the spur of divine lore, shall forsake what he possesses here, shall without doubt gain there the eminence of judicial authority; and shall appear as judge with the Judge, for that he now in consideration of the judgment chastens himself by a voluntary poverty.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30

  7. Scholastic c. 1100 – 1500

  8. 1256

    Thomas Aquinas

    Catholic
    "The young man says to him: all these I have kept from my youth." After the Lord had handed down the teaching of the common salvation, here he hands down the teaching of perfection. And first he hands down the teaching; second, the necessity of this teaching; third, the reward of its observance. The second is at "Jesus then said to his disciples"; the third at "Peter answering, and so on." And first is set down the occasion for giving the teaching; second, its promulgation; third, its effect. The second is at "Jesus says to him, etc."; the third at "when the young man had heard the word, he went away sad." The occasion for promulgating this teaching is the young man's petition. And first he confesses himself an observer of the legal precepts; second he asks what the perfection is to which he might attain, at "what do I still lack?" He says therefore "all these I have kept from my youth"; and he says "all," because it does not suffice to do one thing only, unless all are kept; James 2:10: "whoever offends in one point has become guilty of all." Likewise he says "from my youth"; Proverbs 22:6: "a young man according to his way, and when he has grown old, he will not depart from it." Whence there was fitting for him what is said in Job 23:12: "I have not departed from the way of my lips." But whether he spoke truly is a question. Jerome says that he lied, which is evident, because immediately before this it had preceded, "you shall love your neighbor as yourself." If he had so loved, he would not have gone away sad, when the Lord said, "go, and sell all that you have, and give to the poor." Chrysostom says that he spoke truly in that he had kept the legal precepts; and this is confirmed by what is found in Mark 10:21, that when Jesus had looked upon him, he loved him, which he would not have done unless he were good. For there is a twofold way. One is sufficient for salvation; and this is the love of God and of neighbor together with one's own benefit, without one's own burden, according to what is had in 1 Corinthians 8:3: "whoever loves God is known by him," and this he had kept. The other is a way of perfection, namely to love one's neighbor with one's own detriment; and this he had not kept; therefore, when it was announced to him, he went away sad. He was not content with the first; therefore he asked "what do I still lack?" Everyone is bound to ask this question, according to what is said: "make known to me, Lord, my end, and what is the number of my days, that I may know what is lacking to me." For he alone knows what is lacking to us. "My imperfection your eyes have seen," Psalm 138:16. Jesus says to him: "if you wish to be perfect, go, and so on." First is set down the endeavor; second, the way; third, since it is difficult, the reward is set down; fourth, the consummation of perfection. He says therefore, "if you wish to be perfect, go, and sell all that you have, and give to the poor." For we ought to strive toward perfection; Hebrews 6:1: "leaving the discourse of the beginning of Christ, let us be carried on to what is perfect." But Origen asks: the perfection of the law is love; but he had said "you shall love your neighbor as yourself"; why then did he say "if you wish to be perfect," when he was already perfect? Some say that in certain books that phrase "you shall love your neighbor as yourself" is not found. And this is evident, because it is not found in Mark. Otherwise it can be said that he did say it, but not in this order, because in the Gospel of the Nazarenes it stands thus: the Lord said, "you shall not commit murder," and so on, up to the matter concerning love. And afterward follows, "all these," etc., and then follows, "you shall love your neighbor, and so on." Nevertheless the solution is plain, because there is a twofold love of neighbor, namely love according to the common way, and love of perfection. Hence he says "go, and sell all," etc., not a part, as Ananias and Sapphira did, as is had in Acts 5:2. And "give to the poor," not to the rich. 1 Corinthians 13:3: "if I should distribute all my goods to feed the poor." Psalm 111:9: "he has scattered abroad, he has given to the poor." And not to one, but to many. But what is this? Would not such a one immediately be perfect? It seems not, because passions are still in him; therefore he is not perfect in virtue. Origen says that he is immediately made perfect, just as those are perfect to whom he distributes his goods. 2 Corinthians 8:14: "let your abundance supply their want, and their abundance may be a supplement to your want." Whence their perfection passes over into him, just as he who receives a prophet in the name of a prophet shall receive a prophet's reward, etc., above, Matthew 10:41. Hence the way of perfection is not "go and sell all that you have," but only what follows, "and give to the poor." The other response is that "if you wish to be perfect" does not mean that you will immediately be perfect, but that you will have a certain beginning of perfection, because, unburdened of these things, you will be able more easily to contemplate heavenly things. Augustine says that vigils and things of this kind are instruments of perfection; but in what follows is the perfection, "and follow me." Whence above, Matthew 4:20: "Peter and Andrew, having left all things, followed him." And so too Matthew above, Matthew 9:9. But when you let go of all these things, the better use is to give to the poor, and in this the neighbor is to be considered. Hence if perfection does not consist in those things, in what does it consist? It must be said that it consists in the perfection of charity; Colossians 3:14: "above all things having charity, which is the bond of perfection." Hence the love of God is perfection, but the letting go of things is the way to perfection. And how? Augustine, in the book of Eighty-Three Questions, says that the increase of charity is the diminishing of cupidity; the perfection of charity is no cupidity at all. He therefore is perfect in charity who loves God even to the contempt of himself and his own. Hence it is difficult and well-nigh impossible that anyone possess riches without being enticed by them: and this is evident in the case of Gregory, of whom it is read that when he had thought he would serve Christ better under a secular guise, so many things began to grow up against him that he was held back not merely in appearance but even in mind. Therefore there is nothing that makes the soul so free as not being occupied about riches: and this is the way of perfection. Hence it is one thing to be perfect, and another to have the state of perfection. Whoever has perfect charity even to the contempt of himself and his own, has perfection. The state of perfection is twofold, of prelates and of religious; but equivocally, because the state of religious is for the acquiring of perfection; hence to such a one it was said, "if you wish to be perfect," and "if you wish to come to the state of perfection." But the state of prelacy is not for acquiring perfection for oneself, but for communicating what one already has; hence the Lord, John 21:17, said to Peter: "Peter, if you love me, feed my sheep"; and he did not say "if you wish to be perfect, etc." Hence the difference between the perfection of religious and of prelates is such as that between a disciple and a master. Hence to the disciple it is said: if you wish to learn, enter the schools that you may learn. To the master it is said: read, and complete your task. Hence the state of religious is more secure, because ignorance is not imputed to them as it is to the prelate. Hence just as it would be ridiculous for a master to know nothing, so too the rest follows. But granted that each does what pertains to him, and uses his office well, I say that there is no comparison, except as between a disciple and a master; hence the prelate is in a more perfect state, even if you should propose Elijah, or anyone whatsoever. But there is a question: if the prelate is perfect, is he not bound to sell all things? I say that this would follow, if perfection consisted in this, namely "go, and sell all that you have"; but it does not, but rather it is the way and the preamble to acquiring perfection; therefore he need not sell what he has. But because it rarely happens that someone has perfection together with riches, it is required of him who comes to perfection that all things be left behind; therefore the Lord gives what is easier. Hence if the prelate were fit, and administered the care well, I say that he would be more perfect; just as someone can say: I wish to enter the schools that I may learn, but it is presumptuous to say, when one knows nothing, that one wishes to be a master. Hence Augustine, in the City of God: a higher state, without which the people cannot be ruled, even if administered fittingly, is nonetheless unfittingly sought after. Likewise it is one thing to be a prelate, and another to be in the state of a prelate. Are parish priests or those with cure of souls in the state of perfection? I say that they are not in that state, because they do not constitute a state. Every state is given with solemnity, as the order of the episcopate and religious life. But when a parish is given, it is not given with solemnity, hence such do not have the state of perfection: which is evident, because to some the care and administration is committed, and if he is not promoted, he can resign and marry, and sometimes he has become a religious. But a bishop would not resign the episcopate, except by leave of a superior; one with cure of souls can enter religious life. But if he were in a more perfect state, he would already be falling from that state, and thus would sin; hence he can have perfection according to act, but not according to state; because a state is not given except with solemnity. "Go therefore and sell all that you have, and give to the poor," because through this you will have a great reward, since reward corresponds to merit. "And you shall have treasure in heaven." In treasure there are two things, stability and abundance. You will have treasure and abundance of spiritual things. Psalm 111:3: "glory and riches are in his house." Isaiah 33:6: "and there shall be faith in your times, riches of salvation, wisdom and knowledge." "And come, follow me." Here is the end of perfection. Hence those are perfect who follow God with their whole heart. Hence Genesis 17:1: "walk before me, and be perfect." And "follow me," that is, imitate the life of Christ; hence above, Matthew 16:24: "if anyone wishes to come after me, let him deny himself." For imitation consists in the solicitude of preaching, teaching, and having care. Hence Chrysostom: it was said to Peter, "follow me," namely in undertaking the care of the whole world. Job 23:11: "my foot has kept his footsteps." "And when the young man had heard this word, he went away sad." His affection is shown, because he went away sad. This happens when we desire something, and cannot have it as we wish; hence this one desired perfection, and heard what he ought to have to attain it. And because he was covetous, he went away sad. And why? "For he had many possessions." Augustine: he who has let go of the will to possess is of great merit, because it is imputed to him what he could have possessed; but it is of greater merit to let go of what one has already acquired, because it is more difficult that things already united be torn away, than things not united. And this is evident, because this man, who possessed, could not be separated from it. "Jesus then said to his disciples." Here is set down the reason for the aforesaid teaching. And first the reason is assigned; second he satisfies the wonder of the disciples, at "and when the disciples had heard this, they wondered greatly." He says therefore "Jesus then said to his disciples, and so on." The occasion for saying this word was that he went away sad, because he had said, "go, sell what you have, and so on." "Because it is difficult for a rich man to enter the kingdom of heaven": he does not say impossible. And he says "rich man," not one who has riches: for some have them, and do not love them, while others have them, and love them, and put their trust in them. Those who have them, and do not love them, can enter the kingdom of heaven. For if this were not so, Paul would not say: "charge the rich of this world not to be highminded, nor to trust in the uncertainty of riches." But he who has and loves, it is difficult, and so on. Above, Matthew 13:22: "the care of this world, and the deceitfulness of riches, choke the word." Proverbs 28:20: "he who hastens to be rich shall not be innocent." Ecclesiasticus 31:8: "blessed is the rich man who is found without blemish, who has not gone after gold, and so on." But this is difficult; therefore there follows: "who is this, and we will praise him? For he has done wonderful things in his life." He adds something which seems to pertain to impossibility; hence he says, "and again I say to you, it is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of heaven." Above the Lord had said that it is difficult for a rich man to enter the kingdom of heaven; here, that it is impossible, just as it is impossible for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle: hence understand by "rich man" the one who has riches and does not love them—for him it is difficult; but for him who loves them, and puts his trust in them, it is impossible to enter the kingdom of heaven. For that a camel cannot enter through the eye of a needle is from nature; but that a rich man who loves riches cannot enter the kingdom of heaven, this is from divine justice; but sooner could all things be overturned than divine justice be changed. Others, such as Jerome, say that impossibility is not designated, but difficulty. In a certain Gloss, whose author is unknown, it is found that at Jerusalem there was a gate called "the eye of the needle," through which laden camels could not pass: thus a rich man cannot enter the kingdom of heaven unless he unburden himself of the affection for riches. But it is easier for a camel to be unburdened than for a rich man to lay down this affection. Chrysostom expounds it mystically: by the camel are signified the Gentiles, who are burdened with the sin of idolatry; by the rich, the Jews; the needle is Christ, and the eye of the needle is his passion. Hence it was easier for the Gentile people to pass through the passion of Christ than for the Jews, because they could not come unless by abandoning the ceremonies of the law, and this they themselves would not do. Hence it was asked of the Demon what is the graver sin, and he said, to have what belongs to another; to which it was answered, you are lying. Rather, he says, because I often lose other sinners, but these I do not lose. Or thus, "it is easier," etc., so that by the rich man we understand the proud man; by the camel, Christ; by the eye of the needle, the passion of Christ: therefore it was easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a proud man to be humbled. "And when the disciples had heard this, they wondered greatly, saying: who then can be saved?" Above the Lord assigned the reason for his teaching; here he satisfies the wonder of the disciples. And first their wonder is set down; second the satisfaction, at "but Jesus looking on them said to them." He says therefore, "and when the disciples had heard this, they wondered greatly, saying: who can be saved?" But here there is a question of the letter. Since more are poor than rich, and it is difficult for the rich to be saved, how do they say "who can be saved?" It is answered that they understood him to mean also the poor who are rich in will; because more are poor who are rich in will. Likewise they themselves had already become solicitous for the whole world; therefore there pressed upon them that solicitude which is had in 2 Corinthians 11:28, so that they were solicitous rulers of all creatures. "But Jesus looking on them said to them: with men this is impossible, and so on." Here he satisfies their wonder, saying: "with men this is impossible, but with God all things are possible." But what does he mean by this? For it seems that free will perishes, if it is impossible with men. It is true that man has of himself the ability to sin; but to rise again, and to perform the works of salvation, this he does not have of himself without the help of the grace of God: for it is God himself who is able to do these things. Romans 9:16: "it is not of him who runs, nor of him who wills, but of God who shows mercy." Hence Job 42:2: "I know that you can do all things, and with you nothing is impossible." Hence according to human power it is impossible for a man to be saved, because human power does not change the will; but it belongs to God alone to change it, as is had in Philippians 2:13: "who works in us both to will and to accomplish." Consequently he determines concerning the reward of the perfect. And first the question is set down; second the response, at "Jesus then said to them." Peter had heard poverty praised, and had heard: "go, and sell all that you have, and give to the poor." He had also heard that it is difficult for the rich to enter the kingdom of heaven; therefore Peter reckoned that he had done something great, because he had let go of all things; hence he says, "then Peter answering said to him: behold, we have left all things." And because he had heard not only "go, and sell," but further, "and follow me, etc."; therefore Peter adds, "and have followed you." To leave all things does not make perfection, but to leave all things and follow Christ, because many philosophers left all things. But Peter had left a boat and a net. But Peter is praised more for his disposition than for what he left, because he let go with such a ready will that he would have let go of everything, if he had had it. Likewise he knew that Christ knew his will, therefore he says, "behold, we, and so on." By which he gave an example, that those who let go of what they had should not be reckoned to have left little, even if they had little. And Jerome says that letting go does not make perfection, but following the Lord. And in many ways one follows God. In mind, through contemplation; Hosea 6:3: "we shall know and we shall follow on, that we may know the Lord." Hence those follow God who have God before their eyes, and know God by way of contemplation. Likewise one follows the Lord through observance of the commandments; John 10:27: "my sheep hear my voice, and follow me." Likewise through imitation of works; Job 23:11: "my foot has followed his steps." Likewise through contempt of self and one's own; above, Matthew 16:24: "if anyone wishes to come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me." Likewise through purity of mind and body; Apocalypse 14:4: "these are they who were not defiled with women; for they are virgins, and follow the Lamb wherever he goes." Voluntary poverty disposes one to this following. "Jesus then said to them, amen I say to you, and so on." Here he treats of the reward of perfection. And first he sets down the reward of the perfection of the apostles; second, the reward of the perfection of others; third, he excludes a certain objection. The second is at "and everyone who has left, etc."; the third at "but many shall be first that are last, and so on." He says therefore, "amen I say to you, and so on." For because he wished it to be certain that he had spoken truly, therefore he professes that he has spoken the truth by saying "amen." And to show that perfection does not consist in this, "go, and sell all that you have," but in this, "follow me"; therefore he says that "you who have followed me, in the regeneration (...) shall sit upon twelve seats, and so on." Regeneration is twofold. One is of the spirit, which happens through grace in Baptism, concerning which 1 Peter 1:3: "he has regenerated us unto a living hope." Likewise there is a regeneration of the body: for just as the spirit is regenerated through grace, so too in the resurrection, he will raise up our bodies. Philippians 3:21: "he will reform the body of our lowliness, made like to the body of his glory." Some expound it of the first regeneration, and punctuate it thus: "you who have followed me in the regeneration," that is, you have been regenerated through grace, "shall sit, and so on." Chrysostom in the same way, but does not punctuate it thus; hence he says that he promised them a reward in the present, thus: "you who have followed me (...) shall sit." The present is the Church of the faith of Christ. In this Church there are diverse states of men. And although all the virtues are necessary for salvation, nevertheless one man is more praiseworthy in the act of one virtue than of another: some in faith, some in chastity, some in charity. And just as it is among diverse believers, so too among the apostles, because Peter was the most fervent zealot of the faith, but John excelled in chastity; thus those who are fervent in faith are the seat of Peter, in chastity the seat of John, and so of the others. But all are the seat of Christ, because all the virtues were in him; therefore he promised them that they would be the future pastors of the Church. Otherwise, according to Augustine, it is taken of regeneration, namely for the resurrection: "amen I say to you, in the regeneration," that is, in the resurrection, when they will be called back according to body and soul, "you shall sit," namely upon the seat of majesty, that is, you shall have judiciary power, "judging the twelve tribes of Israel," because just as God gave judgment to the Son, so it is given also to those who have followed him. But what does he mean by saying "over the tribes of Israel"? Will they not judge others? Why then does he say more, "over the twelve tribes of Israel"? The whole people of the faithful of the whole world is understood, because the Gentile people entered into the richness of the olive tree, and became sharers of the promise made to the fathers. But those who are unfaithful will not be judged: for Gregory says that some are condemned and not judged, as the unfaithful; but some are condemned and judged, as those who believed and were perverted. And, as Jerome puts it, enemies are condemned in one way, those who remained in the faith in another; because enemies are condemned in absence, but the others in presence. Therefore, "you shall judge the twelve tribes of Israel." Because the apostles lived among the Jews; therefore it is said that they will judge the twelve tribes. And how? By comparison, because they had admonished them. They might say: how should we believe that you were God, who were living mortally among us? and so on. But the Lord will say: you were wise in the law, and did not believe; these were fishermen, and believed. Chrysostom asks what great thing was given to the apostles. Was not this also given to the Ninevites and the queen of the South? Above, Matthew 12:41. Chrysostom says that the very manner shows that the authority of judging was given to the apostles, because those who judge by authority judge while sitting, while advocates and accusers condemn while standing; therefore to signify that the apostles will judge by authority, he says "you shall sit." But of the Ninevites he says, "the men of Nineveh shall rise in judgment with this generation, and shall condemn it." But here is a question, because some will be condemned and not judged: thus some will be saved and not judged, as the apostles and apostolic men; but others who are to be saved will be judged, and their merits will be examined. And how will they judge? Some say by comparison. But this does not suffice, because thus even the queen of the South will judge. Some say by the judgment of Christ. But this does not suffice, because thus all the saints would approve. Psalm 57:11: "the just shall rejoice when he shall see the revenge." Likewise some say by a certain venerable justice, because the just will be lifted up in the air to meet Christ, and will be assessors of Christ. But this also does not suffice, because he says "you shall sit, you also judging." Some say that they will judge as a book judges: for it judges, because there are written in it the laws which judge that person; just as the hearts of the apostles and of the just, who kept the commandments of God, will be a book condemning them. "The dead were judged, the books being opened," Apocalypse 20:12. But there is more, because they will exercise another function. Hence in Psalm 149:6: "two-edged swords in their hands." How then will they judge? Consider. There will be a mental judgment, because by divine power it will happen that all one's sins are brought back to memory for each individual. Hence Lactantius was deceived, who supposes the resurrection to occur a thousand years before the judgment. This therefore will be a mental judgment, because by divine power there will be brought back to memory the things which each one has done. But it is not unfitting that someone should receive some light from another, because the Angels receive from God, and men from the Angels; therefore it is no wonder that men will be enlightened by the apostles who will be full; therefore they will not only judge, but the other just will also receive a certain light from them. But Christ and the apostles differ, because Christ judges by authority, but they as promulgators: just as the law was given through Angels, so too the execution of judgment will happen through Angels, because behold Angels are called (Job 36:6: "he will give judgment to the poor") who have followed justice, and have left all things. And why will they judge? One reason is, because sins belong to the world. Hence those who are to judge ought to be from outside the world, and such are the apostles and apostolic men; hence John 15:19: "I have chosen you out of the world." Likewise the Philosopher says that the virtuous man is the judge of all men, just as taste is the judge of all things tastable. Just as therefore he who wishes to taste something gives it to be tasted to one who has a sound taste: so since the virtuous man has a sound taste, therefore he himself is the rule of all acts; therefore perfect men will judge as a rule. Likewise another reason, because they are estranged from the world, therefore they follow Christ more fervently. These therefore ought to judge more, because they grow warm concerning the things to be contemplated; Psalm 38:4: "my heart grew hot within me, and in my meditation a fire shall flame out." Therefore also, because more accustomed, they are more fervent. Likewise because they were poor and more abject, but the merit of abjection is exaltation; therefore they will be exalted. Therefore he says "you shall sit judging, and so on." But will Judas judge? No, because these promises are always under a condition; therefore the Lord says "you who have followed me, and so on." Hence whoever shall have followed, and shall have persevered, will judge, and so on. But if these judge, what will Paul do? If the seats are already full, where then is Paul? Augustine says that by the twelve is signified the universality, which is turned by seven. The number twelve therefore comes from the multitude of seven, because the number seven consists of three and four, and three times four is twelve, or four times three; therefore by this number is signified the universality of the elect. "And everyone who has left house, or brothers, and so on." Having set down the reward of the apostles, here is set down the reward of others: and here there are questions. First, why he promised the apostles nothing temporal, but to others something temporal, because "he shall receive a hundredfold, and so on." And this is evident, because in Mark it is had that the hundredfold is in the present. According to Chrysostom, something temporal was promised to the apostles, because judgment in the Church of God, as was said before. Or otherwise, because each one is enticed according to that to which he is inclined. Hence he who has let go of the world and the things that are in the world, is not enticed by the things that are in the world; but others, who are bound to secular things, are enticed by them. Therefore to the apostles, because they had left everything, he promised nothing temporal; but to others, because they have affection for temporal things, therefore to the apostles he promised judgment. Or, according to Origen, that what was said, "in the regeneration," this is the reward of those who have left all things for Christ. But someone might say: I do not wish to leave all things for you, but I will leave one house, or one field, and so on. I say that if you leave something, you will have something; but if all things, you will be a judge. But there is another question. He said "house," and about this there is no doubt; but he says "father or mother, and so on." Whoever commands that father or mother be left, commands a sin. Likewise he himself commanded that a wife not be left, that parents be honored. It must be said that in these two things are considered: natural affinity, and this is not to be despised, but good is to be done to them if they are in need. But sometimes they draw one back from the service of God: hence then they are like a scandalizing member, and then that member is to be cut off; and therefore he commands these to be left. Likewise another reason, because the Lord foresaw the time of future persecution, when brother would rise up against brother; therefore he wishes man to be separated from them. Another question is when he says "he shall receive a hundredfold, and so on," how it is to be understood. Some said that the saints will rise before the judgment a thousand years, and then Christ will have his kingdom completed: and then he who left a house will have a hundredfold. Jerome disapproves this, because he will not have a hundred fathers, and so on. Likewise baseness is signified, because he will not have a hundred wives. Therefore Augustine says that it is understood as to spiritual things. Hence the Lord has chosen us who are poor in this world, and heirs of the kingdom: hence is understood the grace of God, which outweighs everything that you leave, and infinitely; therefore he puts the finite for the infinite. Hence "he shall receive a hundredfold," that is, something which is worth a hundredfold. Origen says that it is also to be understood according to the letter. You leave a field, by the providence of God it will happen that you will find many for your service; hence there will befit them what is in 2 Corinthians 6:10: "as having nothing, and possessing all things." Likewise you will find brothers, that is, all spiritual men. Likewise, besides this, eternal life; John 10:27: "my sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me, and I give them eternal life." Consequently he introduces incidentally, "but many that are first shall be last, and the last first." Those who leave something for Christ, or all things, if they live negligently, will they have that reward? I say not, because they took it up imperfectly, and they will not be first, but last. Or otherwise, because they might say, "you who have left all things, and so on, we will judge thus." Those who through pride were exalted as first, are last. Origen says that this can be understood of those who come to Christ, and live lukewarmly; afterward others come who are fervent, and by their fervor surpass the others. Or he calls "first" those who were born of Christians, who have become last with respect to others who were from the Gentiles or the Jews. Or it can be referred to men, or to Angels; because those who are first in the order of Angels, have become last through fault; and the last, that is, men, will become first and superior.

    English is machine-translated from the public-domain Latin (Corpus Thomisticum), since no public-domain English translation exists. It is not a scholarly translation. Please report errors.

    Source Commentary on Matthew, ch. 19, l2 Read in full ›

  9. Post-Reformation c. 1650 – 1900

  10. 1771

    John Gill

    Reformed
    And Jesus said unto them,.... To all the disciples whom Peter represented; verily I say unto you: the thing being something very considerable, and of great moment, Christ uses the asseveration he sometimes does in such cases: that ye which have followed me. Christ does not deny that they had forsaken all for his sake, nor does he despise it, because it was but little they left, though he does not repeat it; but only takes notice of their following him, which, including their faith in him, their profession of him, and subjection to him, was a much greater action, and of more importance that the other, and therefore is only mentioned, and which our Lord confirms: in the regeneration. This clause is so placed, that it may be read in connection with the preceding words, and be understood of the disciples following Christ in the regeneration; meaning, not the grace of regeneration, in which they could not be said, with propriety, to follow Christ; and one of them was never a partaker of it: but the new state of things, in the church of God, which was foretold, and is called the time of reformation, or setting all things right, which began upon the sealing up the law, and the prophets, and the ministry of John the Baptist, and of Christ; who both, when they began to preach, declared, that this time, which they call the kingdom of heaven, was at hand, just ushering in. Now the twelve apostles followed Christ herein: they believed, and professed him to be the Messiah; they received, what the Jews called, his new doctrine, and preached it to others; they submitted to the new ordinance of baptism, and followed Christ, and attended him wherever he went, working miracles, preaching the Gospel, and reforming the minds and manners of men. Now this new dispensation is called the regeneration, and which more manifestly took place after our Lord's resurrection, and ascension, and the pouring down of the Spirit; wherefore the phrase may be connected with the following words, when the Son of man shall sit in the throne of his glory in the regeneration; not in the resurrection of the dead, or at the last judgment, but in this new state of things, which now began to appear with another face: for the apostles having a new commission to preach the Gospel to all the world; and being endued with power from on high for such service, in a short time went every where preaching the word, with great success. Gentiles were converted, as well as Jews, and both brought into a Gospel church state; the ceremonies of the old law being abolished, were disused; and the ordinances of baptism, and the Lord's supper, every where practised; old things passed away, and all things became new: agreeably to this the Syriac version renders the phrase, , "in the new world"; and so the Persic. The Arabic reads it, "in the generation", or "age to come"; which the Jews so often call the world, or age to come, the kingdom of the Messiah, the Gospel dispensation. When the Son of man shall sit in the throne of his glory, or glorious throne; as he did when he ascended into heaven, and sat down at the right hand of God; and was then exalted as a prince, and made, or declared to be Lord and Christ; and was crowned in human nature, with honour, and glory, and angels, principalities, and powers, made subject to him: ye also shall sit upon twelve thrones: for though Judas fell from his apostleship, yet Matthias was chosen in his room, and took his place, and made up the number twelve; a metaphorical phrase, setting forth the honour, dignity, and authority of their office and ministry, by which they should be judging the twelve tribes of Israel; doctrinally and practically; by charging them with the sin of crucifying Christ, condemning them for their unbelief, and rejection of him, denouncing the wrath of God, and the heaviest judgments that should fall upon them, as a nation, for their sin; and by turning from them to the Gentiles, under which judgment they continue to this day. So the doctors among the Jews are represented as sitting and judging others: of "the potters", in Ch1 4:23 they say (l), "these are the disciples of the law, or the lawyers, for whose sake the world is created, "who sit in judgment", and establish the world; and build, and perfect the ruins of the house of Israel.'' (l) Targuru in 1 Chron. iv. 23.

    Source Matthew 19:28

  11. 1849

    George Leo Haydock

    Catholic
    In the regeneration. Jesus Christ here calls the general resurrection the regeneration, because there will then be a renovation of the human body, and of the whole world. The promise which is here made to the apostles of sitting on thrones at the general judgment, and passing sentence on the 12 tribes of Israel, must not be understood as limited to the apostles, or to the Jews. For St. Paul says, (1 Corinthians vi. 2. and 3,) that not only he, but also many of the Corinthians to whom he was writing, would judge not merely the 12 tribes, but the whole world, and moreover angels themselves. It is the opinion of many of the Fathers, St. Jerome, St. Augustine, St. Gregory, and others, that all apostolical men, i.e. such as, renouncing the goods of this life, adhere to Christ in mind and affection, and by every possible means promote his reign and the propagation of his gospel, will be so far honoured as to sit in judgment with him at the general resurrection. (Tirinus) — You also shall sit on twelve seats, or thrones, meaning at the general resurrection, when Christ will appear on the throne of his majesty, with his heavenly court, and with his elect, shall condemn the wicked world. (Witham)

    Source Matthew 19:28

  12. 1863

    Francis Patrick Kenrick

    Catholic
    The promise is general, but a condition of faith and devotedness is implied : wherefore Judas is not embraced in the prediction. The apos- tles partake of the judicial attributes of Christ. They will accompany Him in judgment. Their faith will be an occasion of greater condemna- tion to the tribes that rejected Him. Their doctrine will be the stand- ard, by which these tribes shall be judged. Judging may also be taken for governing, as the rulers were called judges. The terms are here used to signify glory and honor, as St. Chrysostom teaches.

    Source Matthew 19:28

  13. Undated date unknown

  14. John Chrysostom (attributed)

    Patristic date unknown
    For it would come to pass, that in the day of judgment the Jews would allege, Lord, we knew Thee not to be the Son of God when Thou wast in the flesh. For who can discern a treasure buried in the ground, or the sun when obscured by a cloud? The disciples therefore will then answer, We also were men, and peasants, obscure among the multitude, but you priests and scribes; but in us a right will became as it were a lamp of our ignorance, but your evil will became to you a blinding of your science.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30

    Or, by that, In the regeneration, Christ designs the period of Christianity that should be after His ascension, in which men were regenerated by baptism; and that is the time in which Christ sate on the throne of His glory. And hereby you may see that He spake not of the time of the judgment to come, but of the calling of the Gentiles, in that He said not, When the Son of Man shall come sitting upon the throne of his majesty; but only, In the regeneration when he shall sit, which was from the time that the Gentiles began to believe on Christ; according to that, God shall reign over the heathen; God sitteth upon his holy throne. (Ps. 47:8.) From that time also the Apostles have sat upon twelve thrones, that is, over all Christians; for every Christian who receives the word of Peter, becomes Peter’s throne, and so of the rest of the Apostles. On these thrones then the Apostles sit, parcelled into twelve divisions, after the variety of minds and hearts, known to God only. For as the Jewish nation was split into twelve tribes, so is the whole Christian people divided into twelve, so as that some souls are numbered with the tribe of Reuben, and so of the rest, according to their several qualities. For all have not all graces alike, one is excellent in this, another in that. And so the Apostles will judge the twelve tribes of Israel, that is, all the Jews, by this, that the Gentiles received the Apostles’ word. The whole body of Christians are indeed twelve thrones for the Apostles, but one throne for Christ. For all excellencies are but one throne for Christ, for He alone is equally perfect in all virtues. But of the Apostles each one is more perfect in some one particuar excellence, as Peter in faith; so Peter tests upon his faith, John on his innocence, and so of the rest. And that Christ spake of reward to be given to the Apostles in this world, is shewn by what follows, And every one that hath forsaken houses, or brethren, or sisters, &c. For if these shall receive an hundred fold in this life, without doubt to the Apostles also was promised a reward in this present life.

    Source as excerpted in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 19:27-30