The interpretation timeline
Psalm 46:5 Douay-Rheims

He hath chosen for us his inheritance the beauty of Jacob which he hath loved.

A.D. 407 – 1871 9 witnesses 10 excerpts

Patristic

before A.D. 750
407
A.D.
John Chrysostom Patristic
A.D. 347–407
“Someone may be bewildered and uncertain, and say, "So how is it that the Jews do not believe today?" … Listen to what follows; he added, "the beauty of Jacob, which he loved." Here in fact he seems to me to be referring to the believers, as Paul indicated in saying, "It is not, however, as though the word of God had failed: not all of Israel belong to Israel; … it is not the children of the flesh who are children of God, but the children of the promise who are counted as descendants." Now, the believers are rightly spoken of as the people's beauty; what could be more appealing, after all, than those who have come to faith?”
Source
430
A.D.
Augustine of Hippo Patristic
A.D. 354–430
“"He has chosen an inheritance for us, the excellency of Jacob, whom He loved" [Psalm 47:4]. A certain beauty of Jacob He has chosen for our inheritance. Esau and Jacob were two brothers; in their mother's womb both struggled, and by this struggle their mother's bowels were shaken; and while they two were yet therein, the younger was elected and preferred to the elder, and it was said, "Two peoples are in your womb, and the elder shall serve the younger." [Genesis 25:23] Among all nations is the elder, among all nations the younger; but the younger is in good Christians, elect, godly, faithful; the elder in the proud, unworthy, sinful, stubborn, defending rather than confessing their sins: as was also the very people of the Jews, "being ignorant of God's righteousness, and going about to establish their own righteousness." [Romans 10:3] But for that it is said, "The elder shall serve the younger;" it is manifest that under the godly are subdued the ungodly, under the humble are subdued the proud. Esau was born first, and Jacob was born last; but he who was last born, was preferred to the first-born, who through gluttony lost his birthright. So you have it written, [Genesis 25:30-34] He longed for the pottage, and his brother said to him, If you will that I give it you, give me your birthright. He loved more that which carnally he desired, than that which spiritually by being born first he had earned: and he laid aside his birthright, that he might eat lentils. But lentils we find to be the food of the Egyptians, for there it abounds in Egypt. Whence is so magnified the lentil of Alexandria, that it comes even to our country, as if here grew no lentil. Therefore by desiring Egyptian food he lost his birthright. So also the people of the Jews, of whom it is said, "in their hearts they turned back again into Egypt." [Acts 7:39] They desired in a manner the lentil, and lost their birthright.”
Source

Scholastic

c. 1100 – 1500
1105
A.D.
Rashi Jewish
1040–1105
“He shall choose...for us and restore us to its midst. Then He will be exalted with the trumpet blast and the sound of the shofar that we will sound before Him over the burnt offerings and the peace offerings, and we will say, “Sing to God, etc.””
1273
A.D.
Thomas Aquinas Catholic
1225–1274
“In the preceding psalms the Psalmist set forth the glory of the king and of the kingdom; but here he exhorts the foreign nations to be converted to God. And first he exhorts them to the praise of God. Second, to having hope in God. Third, he teaches them divine worship. The second begins where it says, "Hear this." The third, where it says, "The God of gods." The title is clear, since it has been explained above: "Unto the end, for the sons of Core, a Psalm of David." Concerning the first part he does two things. First, he exhorts all nations to the praise of God. Second, the matter of the praise is set forth, where it says, "The Lord is great." Concerning the first he does three things. For first he sets forth the invitation to the praise of God. Second, the cause, where it says, "For the Lord is most high." Third, he makes this cause manifest, where it says, "God has ascended." The praise of God ought to proceed from a gladness of heart, just as it is also in the homeland: Isaiah 51: "Joy and gladness shall be found therein." This gladness of heart is shown through an outward sign, of deed or of word. First, therefore, he leads them to praise as regards deeds. Second, as regards words. He says, then, "all nations," as if to say: God has done so many good things for us, therefore praise him in deed, "clap your hands." The clapping of hands is done as a sign of exultation: Jeremiah 5: "the priests clapped with their hands"; as if to say: "clap," that is, show the exultation of your heart through the clapping of your hands. And this happens when a man outwardly performs the services of God with gladness: Psalm 99: "Serve the Lord in gladness"; Isaiah 55: "every tongue of the regions shall clap with the hand," that is, all peoples shall clap. Likewise, praise him in word: hence he says, "shout for joy to God with a voice of exultation," that is, with an outward voice demonstrating an interior affection. The Gloss: jubilation is an ineffable joy, which cannot be kept silent, but cannot be expressed, because it exceeds comprehension. And such is the goodness of God, which cannot be expressed; and if it is expressed, it is nevertheless expressed imperfectly. And therefore Jeremiah said (Jeremiah 1): "Ah, ah, ah, behold I know not how to speak." And the Church signifies this jubilation when, upon the same syllable, she multiplies the notes: Psalm 65: "Shout with joy to God, all the earth; sing a psalm," and so on. "For the Lord." Here the cause of the praise is set forth, and the goods which proceed from the greatness of God. And first the greatness of God is set forth. Second, the sign of that greatness. The greatness of God is commended in two ways. First, through the loftiness of his power. Second, through the majesty of his dominion. He says, then: God is to be praised on account of the loftiness of his nature, because "the Lord is most high": Psalm 112: "The Lord is high above all nations," and so on. And because lofty things are far removed from us, someone might believe that he ought not to be feared, nor that he has providence over us; just as certain fools said, in whose person it is said in Job 22: "He walks about the poles of heaven, and does not consider our affairs." And therefore it was said: "As far as it is in you, you have emptied fear." But it is not so. This one is exalted precisely because he is terrible, because he foresees all things, he punishes all things. Likewise he is to be feared on account of his dominion, because he is "a great king over all the earth": Psalm 23: "the earth is the Lord's," and so on. He is great in the universality of his dominion, because "Great in the universality of dominion, for [it is] a kingdom of all ages, Ps. 144.," Psalm 144. Likewise in duration, because it is forever. Likewise in authority, because he is king of all kings. The sign of the greatness of this king is taken from those things which he has done in us, and these are the benefits of God. First, in the subjection of others. Second, in the conferring of goods. He says, then, "He has subjected peoples to us." These are the words of the Church, to whom even her enemies are subjected temporally. Augustine in the Gloss: "For how many now run to the Church who are not yet Christians; they ask the help of the Church, they wish it to come to their aid temporally, even though they are not yet willing to reign with us for eternity." Likewise, that these may be the words of the apostles: "He has subjected peoples to us," namely of the Jews, "and nations," that is, of the Gentiles, "under our feet": Isaiah 52: "How beautiful upon the mountains are the feet of him that announces and preaches peace." Likewise in the same place, chapter 45: "that I may subject the nations before his face." Or otherwise, "he has subjected peoples to us." Some are converted to the faith, and these are subjected by their own will. Others are not converted, but live as pagans, and these are subjected under the feet, because in the end they will be crushed under our judicial power. "He has chosen for us his inheritance." Here another benefit of the conferring of goods is set forth. Here it should be noted that election implies the acceptance of one thing over another. Now the election of God can be taken in a twofold respect. First, on the part of the goods which are conferred. And thus one should distinguish: because some of those things which are conferred are temporal, some spiritual. But the impious sinners receive temporal things as the portion falling to them: Wisdom 2: "this is our portion." But the just receive God himself as their portion: Psalm 15: "the Lord is the portion of my inheritance." But God has chosen for himself spiritual goods; that is, he has made us choose spiritual goods. "He has chosen for us his inheritance," therefore, as if to say: since there are diverse portions of goods, he has chosen to give us his inheritance. Second, the election of God is taken on the part of those to whom it is given; and thus a distribution is made, because all are condemned in original sin, yet some are saved by God's election. And therefore he says, "he has chosen for us," and so on. And what this inheritance is, he shows: "the beauty of Jacob, whom he has loved." Jerome's text has "the glory," or "the pride of Jacob." And here "pride" is taken for excellence: Isaiah 60: "I will make you into a pride," that is, into an excellence, "of ages." In the same place, "with glory," that is, with beauty, or comeliness: because in that eternal inheritance itself they will be excellent, glorious, and comely: Jeremiah 31: "May the Lord bless you, O beauty of justice." "Whom he has loved." Or, "whom Jacob"; as if to say, this inheritance is the glory of Jacob, that is, of the faithful one, which glory God has loved, because "the Lord loves the gates of Sion." Or, "the beauty of Jacob," that is, that which is represented through Jacob: because there were represented to him the spiritual goods to which we have been chosen, such as the ladder which he saw, and other things of this kind. But the first reading is better. "God has ascended with jubilation." Here he sets forth the cause and the order. He says that he is exalted and a great king, and on this account he is to be praised. But is he indeed so exalted? Indeed he is. And first he shows his excellence. Second, he shows the breadth of his kingdom, where it says, "sing praise." Concerning the first he does two things. First he sets forth his excellence. Second he concludes the exhortation, where it says, "sing praise." I say, then, that he is exalted, because he ascended. But if he is exalted, how did he ascend? Because he descended. Ephesians 4: "he who ascended is the same," and so on. But how did he ascend? "With jubilation." Jubilation is an immense joy, and here jubilation signifies imperfect knowledge. There were two kinds of those singing praise at the ascension of Christ, namely the apostles and the angels. Now the apostles have an imperfect knowledge of divine things, and therefore jubilation over the joy of Christ's ascension with glory belongs to them. Likewise the angels were there, and they had clear knowledge, and jubilation does not belong to them, but a manifest announcement; and therefore he says, "and the Lord with the voice of the multitude." Hence the angels say (Acts 1): "Men of Galilee, why do you stand," and so on. If, then, he is exalted, "sing praise to our God" with the mouth, "sing praise to our king" with the heart: 1 Corinthians 14: "I will sing with the spirit, I will sing also with the understanding." "For the king." Consequently he shows that he is a great king, and he shows this in reverse order. For first he leads them to sing praise to the king. Second, he assigns the cause. Third, he makes it manifest. I say, then, "sing praise to God"; but again, "sing praise to the king," because he is great. And he says "sing praise, sing praise" twice, because we honor the humanity and the divinity in Christ with the same honor, since it is the same supposit: John 5: "that all may honor the Son as they honor the Father." And that praise ought to be sung he shows, because "God is king of all the earth." And therefore you, inhabitants of the earth, should sing praise to him. And he says, "of all the earth," not of Judea only, or of Greece, but of the whole world; but, "sing praise wisely," that is, discreetly. And sing praise not only with the mouth, but with the heart renewed within, because "praise is not comely in the mouth of a sinner," as is said in Ecclesiasticus 15. Likewise not with a troubled mind: James 5: "let him pray with an even mind." Likewise continually: Isaiah 23: "sing well, frequent the song." Consequently he makes manifest how he is king of all the earth. And first he foretells the kingdom of Christ over all nations. Second, over all the princes of the nations; as if to say: I say that he is king of all the earth, because although he now reigns in Judea only, yet he will reign over all nations, because all nations will be converted to God: Psalm 116: "Praise the Lord, all you nations." And the reason for this is: because Christ is God, and now, having ascended, sits at the right hand of the Father, "upon his holy seat," that is, at the right hand of God; and thus nothing remains except that all be subjected to him: Daniel 7: "to him was given the kingdom." Nor are only the nations subjected to him, but also their princes; hence he says, "the princes of the peoples," namely of all of them, "are gathered together with the God of Abraham," through faith and love. And he says "Abraham," because he was the origin of believing, both of the father and of the son: Matthew 3: "Matth. 3: He is able to raise up children of Abraham from these stones.": Psalm 71: "the kings of the Arabians," and so on. And the reason why they are gathered is because "the strong gods of the earth are exceedingly exalted." And this can be understood in two ways. In one way, of the Jews: because they themselves were gods, since they were instructed concerning God: John 10: "he called them gods, to whom the word of God was made." Likewise they were strong, because constant in the faith of the one God; but "of the earth," because their eyes and their affections were always turned toward earthly things. These are "exalted" through pride, "exceedingly," to such a degree that they were unwilling to accept the teaching of Christ. And therefore the apostles went to the nations. In another way, "the strong gods," that is, the apostles. And they are called gods on account of judicial power. And in the Old Testament judges were called gods: Exodus 22: "you shall not speak ill of the gods." Apply this to the gods, that is, to the judges. And they are called strong on account of their constancy in suffering: Romans 8: "Who shall separate us from the charity of Christ?" "Of the earth," that is, still existing among earthly things: 2 Corinthians 4: "we have this treasure in earthen vessels." And they were "exceedingly exalted," through preaching: Mark, last chapter: "but they, going forth, preached everywhere." Likewise through the working of miracles. Likewise through the attaining of glory. Jerome's text has: "for the gods, the shields of the earth," because the apostles were the protectors of all peoples.”

Post-Reformation

c. 1650 – 1900
1714
A.D.
Matthew Henry Reformed
1662–1714
“We are here most earnestly pressed to praise God, and to sing his praises; so backward are we to this duty that we have need to be urged to it by precept upon precept, and line upon line; so we are here (Psa 47:6): Sing praises to God, and again, Sing praises, Sing praises to our King, and again, Sing praises. This intimates that it is a very necessary and excellent duty, that it is a duty we ought to be frequent and abundant in; we may sing praises again and again in the same words, and it is no vain repetition if it be done with new affections. Should not a people praise their God? Dan 5:4. Should not subjects praise their king? God is our God, our King, and therefore we must praise him; we must sing his praises, as those that are pleased with them and that are not ashamed of them. But here is a needful rule subjoined (Psa 47:7): Sing you praises with understanding, with Maschil. 1. "Intelligently; as those that do yourselves understand why and for what reasons you praise God and what is the meaning of the service." This is the gospel-rule (Co1 14:15), to sing with the spirit and with the understanding also; it is only with the heart that we make melody to the Lord, Eph 5:19. It is not an acceptable service if it be not a reasonable service. 2. "Instructively, as those that desire to make others understand God's glorious perfections, and to teach them to praise him." Three things are mentioned in these verses as just matter for our praises, and each of them will admit of a double sense: - I. We must praise God going up (Psa 47:5): God has gone up with a shout, which may refer, 1. To the carrying up of the ark to the hill of Zion, which was done with great solemnity, David himself dancing before it, the priests, it is likely, blowing the trumpets, and the people following with their loud huzzas. The ark being the instituted token of God's special presence with them, when that was brought up by warrant from him he might be said to go up. The emerging of God's ordinances out of obscurity, in order to the more public and solemn administration of them, is a great favour to any people, which they have reason to rejoice in and give thanks for. 2. To the ascension of our Lord Jesus into heaven, when he had finished his work on earth, Act 1:9. Then God went up with a shout, the shout of a King, of a conqueror, as one who, having spoiled principalities and powers, then led captivity captive, Psa 68:18. He went up as a Mediator, typified by the ark and the mercy-seat over it, and was brought as the ark was into the most holy place, into heaven itself; see Heb 9:24. We read not of a shout, or of the sound of a trumpet, at the ascension of Christ, but they were the inhabitants of the upper world, those sons of God, that then shouted for joy, Job 38:7. He shall come again in the same manner as he went (Act 1:11) and we are sure that he shall come again with a shout and the sound of a trumpet. II. We must praise God reigning, Psa 47:7. 8. God is not only our King, and therefore we owe our homage to him, but he is King of all the earth (Psa 47:7), over all the kings of the earth, and therefore in every place the incense of praise is to be offered up to him. Now this may be understood, 1. Of the kingdom of providence. God, as Creator, and the God of nature, reigns over the heathen, disposes of them and all their affairs, as he pleases, though they know him not, nor have any regard to him: He sits upon the throne of his holiness, which he has prepared in the heavens, and there he rules over all, even over the heathen, serving his own purposes by them and upon them. See here the extent of God's government; all are born within his allegiance; even the heathen that serve other gods are ruled by the true God, our God, whether they will or no. See the equity of his government; it is a throne of holiness, on which he sits, whence he gives warrants, orders, and judgment, in which we are sure there is no iniquity. 2. Of the kingdom of the Messiah. Jesus Christ, who is God, and whose throne is for ever and ever reigns over the heathen; not only he is entrusted with the administration of the providential kingdom, but he shall set up the kingdom of his grace in the Gentile world, and rule in the hearts of multitudes that were bred up in heathenism, Eph 2:12, Eph 2:13. This the apostle speaks of as a great mystery that the Gentiles should be fellow-heirs, Eph 3:6. Christ sits upon the throne of his holiness, his throne in the heavens, where all the administrations of his government are intended to show forth God's holiness and to advance holiness among the children of men. III. We must praise God as attended and honoured by the princes of the people, Psa 47:9. This may be understood, 1. Of the congress or convention of the states of Israel, the heads and rulers of the several tribes, at the solemn feasts, or to despatch the public business of the nation. It was the honour of Israel that they were the people of the God of Abraham, as they were Abraham's seed and taken into his covenant; and, thanks be to God, this blessing of Abraham has come upon the isles of the Gentiles, Gal 3:14. It was their happiness that they had a settled government, princes of their people, who were the shields of their land. Magistracy is the shield of a nation, and it is a great mercy to any people to have this shield, especially when their princes, their shields, belong unto the Lord, are devoted to his honour, and their power is employed in his service, for then he is greatly exalted. It is likewise the honour of God that, in another sense, the shields of the earth do belong to him; magistracy is his institution, and he serves his own purposes by it in the government of the world, turning the hearts of kings as the rivers of water, which way soever he pleases. It was well with Israel when the princes of their people were gathered together to consult for the public welfare. The unanimous agreement of the great ones of a nation in the things that belong to its peace is a very happy omen, which promises abundance of blessings. 2. It may be applied to the calling of the Gentiles into the church of Christ, and taken as a prophecy that in the days of the Messiah the kings of the earth and their people should join themselves to the church, and bring their glory and power into the New Jerusalem, that they should all become the people of the God of Abraham, to whom it was promised that he should be the father of many nations. The volunteers of the people (so it may be read); it is the same word that is used in Psa 110:3, Thy people shall be willing; for those that are gathered to Christ are not forced, but made freely willing, to be his. When the shields of the earth, the ensigns of royal dignity ( Kg1 14:27, Kg1 14:28,), are surrendered to the Lord Jesus, as the keys of a city are presented to the conqueror or sovereign, when princes use their power for the advancement of the interests of religion, then Christ is greatly exalted.”
1771
A.D.
John Gill Reformed
1697–1771
“Sing praises to God,.... That is gone up with a shout, Christ Jesus, our ascended Lord and King, as the apostles did at the time of his ascension, Luk 24:52; sing praises; sing praises unto our King, sing praises: who was then made Lord and Christ, declared King of saints, and crowned with glory and honour; the repetition of the phrase sing praises denotes frequency, constancy, fervency, and great devotion in the performance of this service; and that the ascension of Christ, the occasion of it, is of the greatest moment and importance, and requires it to be performed in such a manner.”
Source
1849
A.D.
1774–1849
“Beauty. The temple, Ezechiel xxiv. 21. Both Jews and Gentiles form the Church.”
1863
A.D.
1796–1863
“He hath chosen us for His inheritance : or, He hath chosen an inheritance for us. He has made us His special people, and given us a land to dwell in.”
“The excellent portion assigned to Jacob, whom God specially loved ; whilst to Esau He gave the mountains of Seir.”
1871
A.D.
1871
“God, victorious over His enemies, reascends to heaven, amid the triumphant praises of His people, who celebrate His sovereign dominion. This sovereignty is what the Psalm teaches; hence he adds, sing . . . praises with understanding--literally, "sing and play an instructive (Psalm)." The whole typifies Christ's ascension (compare Psa 68:18).”
Source
Modern · 1953 →

The in-app commentary runs from the Fathers to the early-modern record, then stops — that's where the public-domain sources end, not where the reading does. For the modern reading, follow the sources directly.