God forbid. For we that are dead to sin, how shall we live any longer therein?

“What does "we are dead" mean? Does it mean that as for that, and as far as it goes, we have all received the sentence of death? or, that we became dead to it by believing and being enlightened. This is what one should rather say, since the sequel makes this clearly right. But what is becoming dead to it? The not obeying it in anything any more. For this baptism effected once for all, it made us dead to it. But this must of our own earnestness thenceforth continually be maintained, so that, although sin issue countless commands to us, we may never again obey it, but abide unmovable as a dead man doth. And indeed he elsewhere saith that sin itself is dead. But there he sets that down as wishing to show that virtue is easy, But here, as he earnestly desires to rouse the hearer, he puts the death on his side. Next, since what was said was obscure, he again explains, using what he had said also in the way of reproof.”

“Here Paul makes the point that past sins have been forgiven and that in this pardon grace so superabounded that earlier sins were remitted as well. Thus whoever tries to increase sin in order to feel an increase of grace does not understand that he is behaving in such a way that grace can do nothing in him. For the work of grace is that we should die to sin.”

“After the Apostle has shown that through the grace of Christ we are freed from past sin — both the sin introduced through the first man, and that which abounded through the law — here he shows that through the grace of Christ the power to resist future sins is given to us. And concerning this he does two things. First, he raises a question arising from what has gone before; second, he resolves it, at the place, "God forbid. For if," and so on. Now he had said above that where sin abounded, grace abounded still more; which someone could indeed wrongly understand, as though the abundance of sin were the cause of the superabundance of graces. And therefore he introduces the question, saying: "What shall we say, then? Shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound?" Which indeed it would be necessary to say, if the abundance of sin were the cause of abounding grace, and not merely the occasion, as was said above. Whence also above, in Romans 3:8, the Apostle says: "as we are slandered, and as some affirm that we say, Let us do evil, that good may come." Jeremiah 12:1: "It is well with all that transgress and do wickedly." Then, when he says, "God forbid," etc., he resolves the question raised. And first he assigns the reason why we ought not to remain under sin; second, he draws the intended exhortation, at the place, "Let not sin therefore reign," and so on. Concerning the first he does two things. First he assigns the reason why one should not remain in sin; second he shows that we possess the capacity for this, that we should not remain under sin, at the place, "Knowing this," and so on. Concerning the first he sets forth this reasoning: if we are dead to sin, we ought not to live in it; but we are dead to sin; therefore we ought not to live in sin. Concerning this, then, he does four things. First he sets forth the conditional; second he proves the antecedent, at the place, "Know you not," etc.; third he draws the consequent, at the place, "that as Christ," etc.; fourth he proves the necessity of the inference, at the place, "For if we have been planted together," and so on. He says therefore first, "God forbid" — namely, that with this intention one should remain in sin, that grace may abound — because, as is said in Ecclesiasticus 15:21, "God hath commanded no man to do wickedly." And the reason for this is: for if we are dead to sin — namely, by this, that sin has been put to death in us — how shall we still live in it? For the natural order of things does not allow that one should return from death to life. Isaiah 24:14: "they that die shall not live," and so on. Canticle 5:3: "I have washed my feet, how shall I defile them?" Then, when he says, "Know you not," etc., he proves the antecedent, namely, that the faithful are dead to sin. And first he proposes the middle term to show his proposition; second he makes clear the middle term he has introduced, at the place, "For we are buried together with him," and so on. He says therefore first, "Know you not," as if to say: what is to be proposed to you is so manifest that it is not permitted for you to be ignorant of it — 1 Corinthians 14:38: "if any man know not, he shall not be known" — "that all we who are baptized in Christ Jesus": which is understood in three ways. In one way, according to the institution of Jesus Christ, Matthew, last chapter: "teach ye all nations, baptizing them," and so on. Second, through the invocation of Jesus Christ, Acts 8:12: "men and women were baptized in the name of Jesus Christ." Third, in Christ Jesus, that is, in a certain conformity to Christ Jesus — Galatians 3:27: "as many of you as have been baptized in Christ Jesus have put on Christ." Thus, then, we are configured to his death, into the likeness of his death, as it were representing the very death of Christ in ourselves. 2 Corinthians 4:10: "always bearing about in our body the mortification of Jesus." Galatians, last chapter: "I bear the marks of Jesus in my body." Or, "in his death," that is, through the power of his death. Apocalypse 1:5: "he hath washed us from our sins." Whence from the side of Christ hanging on the cross, after death, there flowed blood and water, as is said in John 19:34. Just as, therefore, we are configured to his death, insofar as we die to sin, so he himself died to mortal life, in which there was a likeness of sin, although sin itself was not there. Therefore all of us who have been baptized are dead to sin. Then, when he says, "For we are buried together," etc., he proves the middle term he had proposed, namely, that we are all baptized in conformity to the death of Christ, saying: "For we are buried together with him by baptism into death." As if to say: burial is owed only to the dead. Matthew 8:22: "let the dead bury their dead." Now through baptism men are buried with Christ, that is, they are conformed to his burial. For just as one who is buried is placed beneath the earth, so one who is baptized is immersed beneath the water. Whence also in baptism a threefold immersion is made, not only on account of faith in the Trinity, but also to represent the three days of Christ's burial. And just as the three days of burial make only one burial, so the threefold immersion makes only one baptism. And from this it is also the case that on Holy Saturday solemn baptism is celebrated in the Church, when the burial of Christ is commemorated, just as also on the vigil of Pentecost, when solemnity is kept for the Holy Spirit, from whose power the water of baptism receives its cleansing force, as is said in John 3:5: "unless a man be born again of water and the Holy Spirit," and so on. It must be considered, however, that bodily someone first dies and afterward is buried; but spiritually the burial of baptism causes the death of sin, because a sacrament of the new law effects what it signifies. Whence, since the burial that is effected through baptism is a sign of the death of sin, it effects death in the one baptized. And this is what he says, that we are "buried into death," so that by this very fact, that we receive in ourselves the sign of the burial of Christ, we obtain the death of sin. Then, when he says, "that as Christ," he infers the consequent, namely, that we ought not to live in sin. For this indeed he introduces a likeness drawn from the resurrection of Christ, saying, "that as Christ rose from the dead by the glory of the Father" — that is, by the power of the Father, from which the Father himself is glorified, according to that word of Psalm 56:8: "arise, my glory" — "so we also may walk in newness of life," that is, that we may proceed by the good works of life. For the life of sin has oldness, because it leads us into corruption. Hebrews 8:13: "that which decayeth and groweth old is near its end." Whence also it is said in Baruch 3:10: "How happeneth it, that thou art in thy enemies' land, thou art grown old in a strange country?" and so on. Whence also it is called newness of life, by which someone returns to integrity, namely, so as to be without sin. Psalm 102:5: "thy youth shall be renewed like the eagle's." Ephesians 4:23: "be renewed in the spirit of your mind." Then, when he says, "For if," he proves the necessity of the inference. For Christ, after he was dead, rose again; whence it is fitting that those who are conformed to Christ as to his death in baptism should also be conformed to his resurrection through innocence of life. And this is what he says: "For if we have been planted together in the likeness of his death" — that is, if we take up in ourselves the likeness of his death, so that we are incorporated into him as a branch that is grafted onto a plant, so that we are, as it were, grafted into the very passion of Christ — "we shall be also in the likeness of his resurrection," namely, planted together with the likeness of it, so that, that is, in the present we may live innocently, and in the future we may arrive at a like glory. Philippians 3:21: "he will reform the body of our lowness, made like to the body of his glory." 2 Timothy 2:11: "if we be dead with him, we shall live also with him." Thus, therefore, just as the Apostle, through the likeness of the death of Christ, proved that we are dead to sin — which he had set forth beforehand as it were the antecedent — so, through the likeness of his resurrection, he proved that we ought not to live in sin; which he had introduced above as it were the consequent.”

“God forbid,.... By which he expresses his abhorrence of such a practice, and that this was a consequence which did not follow from the premises, and was far enough from his thoughts, and which he had in the greatest detestation: and he further argues against it by asking, how shall we that are dead to sin, live any longer therein? There is a death for sin, a death in sin, and a death to sin; the latter is here mentioned, and persons may be said to be "dead to sin", both as justified and sanctified: justified persons are dead to sin, inasmuch as that is not imputed to them to condemnation and death; they are discharged from it; it cannot hurt them, or exert its damning power over them; it is crucified, abolished, and made an end of by Christ: sanctified persons are dead to sin; sin is not made their business, it is not their course of life; it is no longer a pleasure to them, but is loathsome and abominable; it is looked upon, not as a friend, but an enemy; it does not reign, it has not the dominion over them; it is subdued in them, and its power weakened; and as to the members of the flesh, and deeds of the body, it is mortified: to live in sin, is to live after the dictates of corrupt nature; and persons may be said to live in it, when they give up themselves to it, are bent upon it; when sin is their life, they delight in it, make it their work and business, and the whole course of their life is sinful: now those who are dead to sin, cannot thus live in it, though sin may live in them; they may fall into sin, and lie in it some time, yet they cannot live in it: living in sin, is not only unbecoming the grace of God revealed in the Gospel, but is contrary to it; it is detestable to gracious minds, yea, it seems impossible they should live in it; which is suggested by this question, "how shall we?" &c. The thing is impracticable: for, for a gracious soul to live in sin, would be to die again, to become dead in sin, which cannot be; he that lives and believes in Christ shall never die, spiritually or eternally.”

“God forbid - Μη γενοιτο, Let it not be; by no means; far from it; let not such a thing be mentioned! - Any of these is the meaning of the Greek phrase, which is a strong expression of surprise and disapprobation: and is not properly rendered by our God forbid! for, though this may express the same thing, yet it is not proper to make the sacred Name So familiar on such occasions. How shall we, that are dead to sin - The phraseology of this verse is common among Hebrews, Greeks, and Latins. To Die to a thing or person, is to have nothing to do with it or him; to be totally separated from them: and to live to a thing or person is to be wholly given up to them; to have the most intimate connection with them. So Plautus, Clitell. iii. 1, 16: Nihil mecum tibi, Mortuus Tibi Sum. I have nothing to do with thee; I am Dead to thee. Persa, i. 1, 20: Mihi quidem tu jam Mortuus Eras, quia te non visitavi. Thou wast Dead to me because I visited thee not. So Aelian, Var. Hist. iii. 13: Ὁτι φιλοινοτατον εθνος το των Ταπυρων, τοσουτον, ὡστε ζῃν αυτους εν οινῳ, και το πλειστον του βιου εν τῃ προς αυτον ὁμιλιᾳ καταναλισκειν· "The Tapyrians are such lovers of wine, that they Live in wine; and the principal part of their Life is Devoted to it." They live to wine; they are insatiable drunkards. See more examples in Wetstein and Rosenmuller.”

“Dead to sin, &c. We are then dead to sin when we neither live in sin by serving it, nor sin lives in us by reigning; in this case, how can we still live in it by yielding to its desires? St. Augustine (chap. vi. de spiritu et litera) thus explains the passage: when grace has caused us to die to sin; if we live again in it, we must be exceedingly ungrateful to grace. (Estius)”