How is the faithful city, that was full of judgment, become a harlot? justice dwelt in it, but now murderers.

“a harlot Astray from her God. city which was faithful and full of justice, and righteousness would lodge therein, but now murderers. full of justice Heb. מְלֵאֲתִי מִשְׁפָּט [equivalent to מְלֵאַתמִשְׁפָּט, the ‘yud’ being superfluous,] as in (Lamentations 1:1) רַבָּתִי עָם, “great in population” [equivalent to רַבַּתעָם]. in which righteousness would lodge The daily dawn sacrifice would atone for the sins [committed] at night, and the daily afternoon [sacrifice] would atone for those of the day. Another explanation is that they would allow capital cases to rest overnight when they could find no merit for him, [i.e., for the defendant;] they would not conclude his verdict until the morrow, perhaps they would find a merit for him, and now they have become murderers. [We find in] Pesikta [d’Rav Kahana p. 121a]: Rabbi Menahem bar Oshia [according to Parshandatha,] Rabbi Phinehas in the name of Rabbi Oshia said: Four hundred eighty-one synagogues were in Jerusalem, corresponding to the numerical value of מְלֵאֲתִי. and now murderers They killed Uriah; they killed Zechariah.”

“The prophet has thus reproved the people but they do not listen. How is the faithful city become an harlot. Jerusalem is like a woman that has become faithless to her husband, after having been a faithful wife. מלאתי Full of. The י is paragogic as in גנבתי the theft of (Gen. 31:39.) ילין Was lodging. The future is here used for the imperfect, which has no special form in Hebrew. מרצחים Murderers. Literally, they that cause to murder. It is participle Piel, and has a causative meaning, referring to the judges.”

“How is she become a harlot. Here he shows their sin according to the turning away from justice toward one's neighbor: and concerning this he does three things. First he describes the fault; second he threatens the punishment, at the place, Therefore thus saith the Lord; third, the sequel of the punishment, at the place, And I will restore. Concerning the first, first he reproves the sin of the people; second, the sin of the priest, at thy silver; third, the sin of the prince, at thy princes. In the people he reproves two things, aggravating by comparison to their former state: namely, venality by comparison to their former fidelity: whence, how is she become a harlot? Jer. 2: under every leafy tree and upon every high hill thou didst lie down, a harlot: and cruelty by comparison to justice and judgment, which is the execution of justice. Ps. 93: until justice be turned into judgment. Whence he says: but now murderers. Hosea 4: cursing and lying and killing and theft and adultery have overflowed, and blood hath touched blood. The sin of the priest he reproves in two things. In the corruption of the truth of doctrine: whence he says: thy silver is turned into dross. Ps. 11: the words of the Lord are pure words, silver tried by the fire, proved from the earth, refined seven times. Jer. 5: the prophets have prophesied a lie. Second, in the remission of the severity of discipline, which is signified in the wine: for this is the wine which the Samaritan poured in: Luke 10. Whence he says: thy wine. Ezech. 13: woe to them that sew. Thy princes. Here he reproves the sin of the princes: and first he shows them unfaithful in the execution of their office, in that they carry it out for their own advantage and not that of the people. Amos 6: anointed with the best ointment, drinking wine in bowls. Ezech. 34: woe to the shepherds of Israel, that feed themselves. Should not the flocks be fed by the shepherds? And for this he says, faithless. Second he shows them transgressors in the harboring of evildoers: companions of thieves, by defending them and affording them patronage: Hosea 6: as the throats of robber men, the princes of the priests. Prov. 1: son, walk not with them. Third he shows them corrupted in the receiving of gifts. Below, 5: Woe to you that justify the wicked for gifts, and take away the justice of the just from him. Whence he says: they love gifts — received ones; they follow after — things promised or hoped for. Fourth, he shows them unjust in the repulsion of the poor, saying they judge not for the fatherless. Jer. 5: they have not judged the cause of the widow, they have not directed the cause of the fatherless. Therefore thus saith the Lord. Here he threatens the punishment: and first, of the prelates; second, of the subjects, at and I will turn. Concerning the first he sets down three things. First, the power of the one punishing, in authority, saying, the Lord. Malachi 1: if I be the Lord, where is my fear? saith the Lord. In the multitude of ministers: of hosts. Job 25: is there any numbering of his soldiers? In strength, mighty. Job 9: he is wise in heart and mighty in strength: who hath resisted him, and hath had peace? Second he sets down the will of the one punishing. Ah, namely to them, I will comfort myself, since their punishment will be a consolation. Below, 63: the day of vengeance is in my heart, the year of my recompense is come. Third he sets down the cruelty of the punishment: at and I will take vengeance on my enemies: as if to say: I will punish you as enemies. Deut. 32: I will render vengeance to my enemies, and repay them that hate me. And I will turn. Here he threatens the punishment of the subjects. And first is set down the preparation of the one punishing, at and I will turn my hand upon thee to punish thee, which, in sparing, I had held as it were folded up. Job 19: the hand of the Lord hath touched me. Second, the completion of the punishment: I will melt away, by the fire of tribulation, to the pure, until whatever is to be purged is purged. Matt. 5: thou shalt not go out from thence till thou repay the last farthing. Third, the multitude of punishments: I will take away all thy tin: because for every sin, below, 40: she hath received of the hand of the Lord double for all her sins. And I will restore. Here he sets down the sequel of the punishment: and first, as regards those corrected, renewal; second, as regards the obstinate, consumption, at and he shall crush. For by the same fire (as Augustine says) gold is proved, and straw smokes. Concerning the first he does three things. First he promises renewal as regards the amendment of the prelates; second, as regards the restoration of good name, at after this thou shalt be called; third, as regards the observance of justice, at Zion in judgment. He says therefore: I will restore the judges, as regards the secular princes, whose office it is to judge the people, and thy counsellors, that is, the priests, whose office it is to minister the counsels of God to the peoples: Malachi 2: the lips of the priests keep knowledge, and they seek the law at his mouth: because he is the angel of the Lord of hosts: as they were before, as Moses and Joshua, who pleased God. Jer. 3: I will give you pastors according to my own heart, and they shall feed you with knowledge and doctrine. And thou shalt be called, that is, thou shalt recover thy fame, so that thou art called such as thou wast before, the city of the just, that is, in which justice is kept. Below, 62: thou shalt no more be called Forsaken, neither shalt thou any more be called Desolate; but thou shalt be called My will is in her. Zion in judgment, through the execution of justice, shall be redeemed, from those who wrong her; and they shall bring her back in justice; for judgment is to bring back to equality, in which justice consists. Ps. 71: to judge thy people with justice, and thy poor with judgment. Jer. 23: a king shall reign (...) and shall do justice and judgment in the land. And he shall crush. Here is set down the destruction of the obstinate; and concerning this he does three things. First he foretells the destruction; second, the manner of the destruction, at they shall be confounded; third, he takes away the hope of escape, at and thy strength shall be. And since the punishment is ordered against the fault, therefore concerning the first he touches on the fault in two ways. On the part of turning, as regards the crime of idolatry: whence he says, the wicked; and as regards the sin of pleasure and luxury: whence he says, sinners: because men are most prone to such things; against which he ordains the punishment of crushing, wherein a punishment is marked out to match the wrong inflicted. Jer. 17: crush them with a double destruction; as it were for a double sin. Second, on the part of turning away, because they have forsaken the Lord; against which he ordains the punishment of consumption, saying, they shall be consumed; in which he designates the punishment of desertion: for what is consumed goes into nothing, and all things would fall into nothing, unless the hand of the Lord held them together; as Gregory says. Jer. 17: O Lord, all that forsake thee shall be confounded: they that depart from thee shall be written in the earth: because they have forsaken the vein of living waters, the Lord. They shall be confounded. Here he sets down the manner of the destruction: and first, as regards the confusion of sin; second, as regards the taking away of good, at when you shall be. Concerning the first, against idolatry he ordains confusion, saying: they shall be confounded for the idols, that is, on account of the idols. Ps. 96: let them all be confounded that adore graven things: against pleasure, shame, when he says: you shall be ashamed of the gardens, that is, of the pleasurable places, which you had chosen, of your luxury. Rom. 6: what fruit had you in those things, of which you are now ashamed? For confusion regards more the evil; but shame regards the fault. For carnal sins (as Gregory says) are of lesser fault and greater infamy. And the reason is, that they are according to the baser powers, and most material ones: and yet they are innate and connatural and subject to passion. When you shall be. Here is set down the taking away of good: and first, of that which pertains to protection and adornment, which is signified in the taking away of leaves; second, of that which pertains to fruit, at as a garden without water, barren. And in contrast it is said of the just man, Ps. 1: he shall be as a tree which is planted near the running waters. And it shall be. Here he takes away from them the hope of escape: and he sets down three things. First he takes away from them the support of their own strength: whence he says: thy strength shall be as the ash of tow, which is quickly consumed. Ecclus. 21: the congregation of sinners is like tow heaped together. Second, the help of idols, saying: your work, namely of idols, which your hands have wrought, as a spark, which is of no consequence. Deut. 32: where are their gods, in whom they trusted? And yet it is burnt up: whence follows, and it shall be kindled. Below, 50: walk in the light of your fire. Third, the help of men: and there shall be none to quench it. Ezech. 20: the flame of the kindling shall not be quenched, and every face shall be burnt in it, from the south even to the north; and all flesh shall see.”

“Here, I. The woeful degeneracy of Judah and Jerusalem is sadly lamented. See, 1. What the royal city had been, a faithful city, faithful to God and the interests of his kingdom among men, faithful to the nation and its public interests. It was full of judgment; justice was duly administered upon the thrones of judgment which were set there, the thrones of the house of David, Psa 122:5. Men were generally honest in their dealings, and abhorred to do an unjust thing. Righteousness lodged in it, was constantly resident in their palaces and in all their dwellings, not called in now and then to serve a turn, but at home there. Note, Neither holy cities nor royal ones, neither places where religion is professed nor places where government is administered, are faithful to their trust if religion do not dwell in them. 2. What it had now become. That beauteous virtuous spouse was now debauched, and become an adulteress; righteousness no longer dwelt in Jerusalem (terras Astraea reliquit - Astrea left the earth); even murderers were unpunished and lived undisturbed there; nay, the princes themselves were so cruel and oppressive that they had become no better than murderers; an innocent man might better guard himself against a troop of banditti or assassins than against a bench of such judges. Note, It is a great aggravation of the wickedness of any family or people that their ancestors were famed for virtue and probity; and commonly those that thus degenerate prove the most wicked of all men. Corruptio optimi est pessima - That which was originally the best becomes when corrupted the worst, Luk 11:26; Ecc 3:16; See Jer 22:15-17. The degeneracy of Jerusalem is illustrated, (1.) By similitudes (Isa 1:22): Thy silver has become dross. This degeneracy of the magistrates, whose character is the reverse of that of their predecessors, is a great a reproach and injury to the kingdom as the debasing of their coin would be and the turning of their silver into dross. Righteous princes and righteous cities are as silver for the treasury, but unrighteous ones are as dross for the dunghill. How has the gold become dim! Lam 4:1. Thy wine is mixed with water, and so has become flat and sour. Some understand both these literally: the wine they sold was adulterated, it was half water; the money they paid was counterfeit, and so they cheated all they dealt with. But it is rather to be taken figuratively: justice was perverted by their princes, and religion and the word of God were sophisticated by their priests, and made to serve what turn they pleased. Dross may shine like silver, and the wine that is mixed with water may retain the colour of wine, but neither is worth any thing. Thus they retained a show and pretence of virtue and justice, but had no true sense of either. (2.) By some instances (Isa 1:23): "Thy princes, that should keep others in their allegiance to God and subjection to his law, are themselves rebellious, and set God and his law at defiance." Those that should restrain thieves (proud and rich oppressors, those worst of robbers, and those that designedly cheat their creditors, who are no better), are themselves companions of thieves, connive at them, do as they do, and with greater security and success, because they are princes, and have power in their hands; they share with the thieves they protect in their unlawful gain (Psa 50:18) and cast in their lot among them, Pro 1:13, Pro 1:14. [1.] The profit of their places is all their aim, to make the best hand they can of them, right or wrong. They love gifts, and follow after rewards; they set their hearts upon their salary, the fees and perquisites of their offices, and are greedy of them, and never think they can get enough; nay, they will do any thing, though ever so contrary to law and justice, for a gift in secret. Presents and gratuities will blind their eyes at any time, and make them pervert judgment. These they love and are eager in the pursuit of, Hos 4:18. [2.] The duty of their places is none of their care. They ought to protect those that are injured, and take cognizance of the appeals made to them; why else were they preferred? But they judge not the fatherless, take no care to guard the orphans, nor does the cause of the widow come unto them, because the poor widow has no bribe to give, with which to make way for her and to bring her cause on. Those will have a great deal to answer for who, when they should be the patrons of the oppressed, are their greatest oppressors. II. A resolution is taken up to redress these grievances (Isa 1:24): Therefore saith the Lord, the Lord of hosts, the Mighty One of Israel - who has power to make good what he says, who has hosts at command for the executing of his purposes, and whose power is engaged for his Israel - Ah! I will ease me of my adversaries. Observe, 1. Wicked people, especially wicked rulers that are cruel and oppressive, are God's enemies, his adversaries, and shall so be accounted and so dealt with. If the holy seed corrupt themselves, they are the foes of his own house. 2. They are a burden to the God of heaven, which is implied in his easing himself of them. The Mighty One of Israel, that can bear any thing, nay, that upholds all things, complains of his being wearied with men's iniquities, Isa 43:24. Amo 2:13. 3. God will find out a time and a way to ease himself of this burden, by avenging himself on those that thus bear hard upon his patience. He here speaks as one triumphing in the foresight of it: Ah. I will ease me. He will ease the earth of the burden under which it groans (Rom 8:21, Rom 8:22), will ease his own name of the reproaches with which it is loaded. He will be eased of his adversaries, by taking vengeance on his enemies; he will spue them out of his mouth, and so be eased of them, Rev 3:16. He speaks with pleasure of the day of vengeance being in his heart, Isa 63:4. If God's professing people conform not to his image, as the Holy One of Israel (Isa 1:4), they shall feel the weight of his hand as the Mighty One of Israel: his power, which was wont to be engaged for them, shall be armed against them. In two ways God will ease himself of this grievance: - (1.) By reforming his church, and restoring good judges in the room of those corrupt ones. Though the church has a great deal of dross in it, yet it shall not be thrown away, but refined (Isa 1:25): "I will purely purge away thy dross. I will amend what is amiss. Vice and profaneness shall be suppressed and put out of countenance, oppressors displaced, and deprived of their power to do mischief." When things are ever so bad God can set them to rights, and bring about a complete reformation; when he begins he will make an end, will take away all the tin. Observe, [1.] The reformation of a people is God's own work, and, if ever it be done, it is he that brings it about: "I will turn my hand upon thee; I will do that for the reviving of religion which I did at first for the planting of it." He can do it easily, with the turn of his hand; but he does it effectually, for what opposition can stand before the arm of the Lord revealed? [2.] He does it by blessing them with good magistrates and good ministers of state (Isa 1:26): "I will restore thy judges as at the first, to put the laws in execution against evil-doers, and thy counsellors, to transact public affairs, as at the beginning," either the same persons that had been turned out or others of the same character. [3.] He does it by restoring judgment and righteousness among them (Isa 1:27), by planting in men's minds principles of justice and governing their lives by those principles. Men may do much by external restraints; but God does it effectually by the influences of his Spirit, as a Spirit of judgment, Isa 4:4; Isa 28:6. See Psa 85:10, Psa 85:11. [4.] The reformation of a people will be the redemption of them and their converts, for sin is the worst captivity, the worst slavery, and the great and eternal redemption is that by which Israel is redeemed from all his iniquities (Psa 130:8), and the blessed Redeemer is he that turns away ungodliness from Jacob (Rom 11:26), and saves his people from their sins, Mat 1:21. All the redeemed of the Lord shall be converts, and their conversion is their redemption: "Her converts, or those that return of her (so the margin), shall be redeemed with righteousness." God works deliverance for us by preparing us for it with judgment and righteousness. [5.] The reviving of a people's virtues is the restoring of their honour: Afterwards thou shalt be called the city of righteousness, the faithful city; that is, First, "Thou shalt be so;" the reforming of the magistracy is a good step towards the reforming of the city and the country too. Secondly, "Thou shalt have the praise of being so;" and a greater praise there cannot be to any city than to be called the city of righteousness, and to retrieve the ancient honour which was lost when the faithful city became a harlot, Isa 1:21. (2.) By cutting off those that hate to be reformed, that they may not remain either as snares or as scandals to the faithful city. [1.] it is an utter ruin that is here threatened. They shall be destroyed and consumed, and not chastened and corrected only. The extirpation of them will be necessary to the redemption of Zion. [2.] It is a universal ruin, which will involve the transgressors and the sinners together, that is, the openly profane that have quite cast of all religion, and the hypocrites that live wicked lives under the cloak of a religious profession - they shall both be destroyed together, for they are both alike an abomination to God, both those that contradict religion and those that contradict themselves in their pretensions to it. And those that forsake the Lord, to whom they had formerly joined themselves, shall be consumed, as the water in the conduit-pipe is soon consumed when it is cut off from the fountain. [3.] It is an inevitable ruin; there is no escaping it. First, Their idols shall not be able to help them, the oaks which they have desired, and the gardens which they have chosen; that is, the images, the dunghill-gods, which they had worshipped in their groves and under the green trees, which they were fond of and wedded to, for which they forsook the true God, and which they worshipped privately in their own garden even when idolatry was publicly discountenanced. "This was the practice of the transgressors and the sinners; but they shall be ashamed of it, not with a show of repentance, but of despair, Isa 1:29. They shall have cause to be ashamed of their idols; for, after all the court they have made to them, they shall find no benefit by them; but the idols themselves shall go into captivity," Isa 46:1, Isa 46:2. Note, Those that make creatures their confidence are but preparing confusion for themselves. You were fond of the oaks and the gardens, but you yourselves shall be, 1. "Like an oak without leaves, withered and blasted, and stripped of all its ornaments." Justly do those wear no leaves that bear no fruit; as the fig-tree that Christ cursed. 2. "Like a garden without water, that is neither rained upon nor watered with the foot (Deu 11:10), that had no fountain (Sol 4:15), and consequently is parched, and all the fruits of it gone to decay." Thus shall those be that trust in idols, or in an arm of flesh, Jer 17:5, Jer 17:6. But those that trust in God never find him as a wilderness, or as waters that fail, Jer 2:31. Secondly, They shall not be able to help themselves (Isa 1:31): "Even the strong man shall be as tow not only soon broken and pulled to pieces, but easily catching fire; and his work (so the margin reads it), that by which he hopes to fortify and secure himself, shall be as a spark to his own tow, shall set him on fire, and he and his work shall burn together. His counsels shall be his ruin; his own skin kindles the fire of God's wrath, which shall burn to the lowest hell, and none shall quench it." When the sinner has made himself as tow and stubble, and God makes himself to him as a consuming fore, what can prevent the utter ruin of the sinner? Now all this is applicable, 1. To the blessed work of reformation which was wrought in Hezekiah's time after the abominable corruptions of the reign of Ahaz. Then good men came to be preferred, and the faces of the wicked were filled with shame. 2. To their return out of their captivity in Babylon, which had thoroughly cured them of idolatry. 3. To the gospel-kingdom and the pouring out of the Spirit, by which the New Testament church should be made a new Jerusalem, a city of righteousness. 4. To the second coming of Christ, when he shall thoroughly purge his floor, his field, shall gather the wheat into his barn, into his garner, and burn the chaff, the tares, with unquenchable fire.”

“How is the faithful city become a harlot!.... The city of Jerusalem, in which were the temple, and the pure worship of God, and was in the tribe of Judah, which ruled with God, and was very faithful with the saints when the ten tribes revolted, and fell in with the sin of Jeroboam; but now, in Isaiah's time, was become like a treacherous wife to her husband, unfaithful to the Lord, went after other lovers, committed spiritual adultery, that is, idolatry, with stocks and stones; and in the times of Christ were a wicked and an adulterous generation, corrupting the word and worship of God; see Mat 12:39. it was full of judgment; strict justice was exercised privately between man and man, as well as in the public courts of judicature; righteousness lodged in it; that is, righteous men, who walked in all the commandments of the Lord, and lived soberly, righteously, and godly; see Pe2 3:13. but now murderers: of the prophets whom they stoned, who were sent unto them, and of the Lord Jesus Christ, of whom they were the betrayers and murderers; see Mat 23:37.”

“"How is she become a harlot, the faithful citadel! she, full of right, lodged in righteousness, and now-murderers." It is the keynote of an elegy (kinah) which is sounded here. איכה, and but rarely איך, which is an abbreviated form, is expressive of complaint and amazement. This longer form, like a long-drawn sigh, is a characteristic of the kinah. The kinoth (Lamentations) of Jeremiah commence with it, and receive their title from it; whereas the shorter form is indicative of scornful complaining, and is characteristic of the mâshōl (e.g., Isa 14:4, Isa 14:12; Mic 2:4). From this word, which gives the keynote, the rest all follows, soft, full, monotonous, long drawn out and slow, just in the style of an elegy. We may see clearly enough that forms like מלאתי for מלאת, softened by lengthening, were adapted to elegiac compositions, from the first v. of the Lamentations of Jeremiah, where three of these forms occur. Jerusalem had previously been a faithful city, i.e., one stedfastly adhering to the covenant of Jehovah with her (vid., Psa 78:37). (Note: We have translated the word kiryah "citadel" (Burg), instead of "city;" but Burg also became the name of the town which sprang up around the citadel, and the persons living in and around the Burg or citadel were called burgenses, "burghers." Jerusalem, which was also called Zion, might be called, with quite as much right, a citadel (Burg), as a city.) This covenant was a marriage covenant. And she had broken it, and had thereby become a zonâh (harlot) - a prophetic view, the germs of which had already been given in the Pentateuch, where the worship of idols on the part of Israel is called whoring after them (Deu 31:16; Exo 34:15-16; in all, seven times). It was not, however, merely gross outward idolatry which made the church of God a "harlot," but infidelity of heart, in whatever form it might express itself; so that Jesus described the people of His own time as an "adulterous generation," notwithstanding the pharisaical strictness with which the worship of Jehovah was then observed. For, as the v. before us indicates, this marriage relation was founded upon right and righteousness in the broadest sense: mishpat, "right," i.e., a realization of right answering to the will of God as positively declared; and tzedek, "righteousness," i.e., a righteous state moulded by that will, or a righteous course of conduct regulated according to it (somewhat different, therefore, from the more qualitative tzedâkâh). Jerusalem was once full of such right; and righteousness was not merely there in the form of a hastily passing guest, but had come down from above to take up her permanent abode in Jerusalem: she tarried there day and night as if it were her home. The prophet had in his mind the times of David and Solomon, and also more especially the time of Jehoshaphat (about one hundred and fifty years before Isaiah's appearance), who restored the administration of justice, which had fallen into neglect since the closing years of Solomon's reign and the time of Rehoboam and Abijah, to which Asa's reformation had not extended, and re-organized it entirely in the spirit of the law. It is possible also that Jehoiada, the high priest in the time of Joash, may have revived the institutions of Jehoshaphat, so far as they had fallen into disuse under his three godless successors; but even in the second half of the reign of Joash, the administration of justice fell into the same disgraceful state, at least as compared with the times of David, Solomon, and Jehoshaphat, as that in which Isaiah found it. The glaring contrast between the present and the past is indicated by the expression "and now." In all the correct MSS and editions, mishpat is not accented with zakeph, but with rebia; and bâh, which ought to have zakeph, is accented with tiphchah, on account of the brevity of the following clause. In this way the statement as to the past condition is sufficiently distinguished from that relating to the present. (Note: It is well known that rebia has less force as a disjunctive than tiphchah, and that zakeph is stronger then either. With regard to the law, according to which bâh has rebia instead of zakeph, see Br, Thorath Emeth, p. 70. To the copies enumerated by Luzzatto, as having the correct accentuation (including Brescia 1494, and Venice, by J. B. Chayim, 1526), we may add Plantin (1582), Buxtorf (1618), Nissel (1662), and many others (cf., Dachselt's Biblia accentuata, which is not yet out of date).) Formerly righteousness, now "murderers" (merazzechim), and indeed, as distinguished from rozechim, murderers by profession, who formed a band, like king Ahab and his son (Kg2 6:32). The contrast was as glaring as possible, since murder is the direct opposite, the most crying violation, of righteousness.”