The interpretation timeline
Isaiah 56:9 Douay-Rheims

All ye beasts of the field come to devour, all ye beasts of the forest.

1105 – 1875 8 witnesses

Scholastic

c. 1100 – 1500
1105
A.D.
Rashi Jewish
1040–1105
“All the beasts of the field All the proselytes of the heathens ([Mss. and K’li Paz:] All the nations) come and draw near to Me, and you shall devour all the beasts in the forest, the mighty of the heathens ([Mss. and K’li Paz:] the mighty of the nations) who hardened their heart and refrained from converting. the beasts of the field [The beast of the field is not as strong as the beast of the forest.] The beast of the field is weaker and of weaker strength than the beast of the forest. Since he stated, “I will yet gather others to him,” he stated this verse.”
Source
1167
A.D.
Ibn Ezra Jewish
1089–1167
“All ye beasts of the field, etc. The idea connecting the following with the preceding verses is, that the righteous Israelites and the proselytes will return, but those that persevere in the worship of idols will not return. אתיו Come. It is imperative (comp. 21:12) of אתה to come; comp. ואתה, and He came (Deut. 33:2). God summons the idolatrous wicked nations, to come and devour the wicked of Israel, like wild beasts that devour each other.”
Source
1256
A.D.
Thomas Aquinas Catholic
1225–1274
“Thus says the Lord. Here, after he had promised liberation from evils, he begins to promise salvation in the conferring of goods. And it is divided into three parts. In the first is set down the preparation for salvation; in the second, the promise of salvation, chapter 60: Arise, be enlightened; in the third, the great discernment of the salvation conferred, chapter 63: Who is this. The first into two. In the first is set down the preparation on the part of the one receiving salvation; in the second, on the part of the one saving, chapter 59: Behold, it is not shortened. The first into two. In the first he gives the wholesome counsel of preparation; in the second he excludes the vain remedy, chapter 58: Cry, cease not. The first into two. In the first he sets down the diversity of those who receive the counsel, as regards the establishment of rewards; in the second, as regards the escape from dangers, chapter 57: the just man perishes. The first into three. In the first he sets down the counsel; in the second, the fruit of the counsel in those who receive it, Blessed is the man who does; in the third, the failure of salvation in those who despise it, all you beasts. Concerning the first he does two things. First he counsels the due preparation: keep judgment, you prelates, whose office it is to judge; do justice, you subjects, that is, every virtue, according as one is conformed to another by the precepts of the law. Micah 6: I will show you, O man, what is good. Second he promises the nearness of salvation: for near, that is, close, is my salvation, because you will be saved by me after the captivity, and my justice, as regards the enemies of whom I will avenge you. Above, 46: I have brought my justice near. Blessed is the man. Here he sets down the fruit of the counsel in those who receive it: and first he sets down its usefulness, setting down the fruit of fulfillment: blessed is the man who does, fulfilling in deed, who lays hold, vigorously undertaking. Psalm 111: blessed is the man who fears the Lord; and the manner of fulfilling, as regards ceremonial matters, keeping the sabbath: for the observance of the sabbath was moral as regards this, that rest is placed in God, and that one is at some time free for divine things by abstaining from other things; but it was ceremonial as regards the determination of the time. Now the seventh day was determined for them on account of the work of creation, than which nothing more worthy had yet preceded. For us, the first day, or the eighth, on account of the mystery of the resurrection, by which nature once founded is repaired for the better. Exodus 20: remember to keep holy the sabbath day. Jeremiah 17: keep your souls. And as regards moral matters, keeping the hands. Psalm 25: I will wash my hands among the innocent. Second he sets down the universality of its usefulness, and let him not say: and first he excludes the despair of certain ones who seemed unworthy, whether on account of a defect of lineage, because they were not of the race of Israel. Who adheres, keeping his precepts. By separation, not making me a partaker of the salvation promised to them. Romans 10: for there is no distinction of Jew and Greek: for the same is Lord of all. Or on account of a defect of the generative power: and let not the eunuch say: a dry tree, powerless to beget, as a dry tree is powerless to sprout. Proverbs 11: the just, like a flourishing leaf. Second he sets down the promise: for thus says the Lord. And first to them specially, as regards the eunuchs: they shall have kept, as regards the worship of religion; they shall have chosen, as regards obedience to the law; they shall have held fast, as regards the observance of the promise of abstaining from evils: within the walls, that is, a dwelling within the walls of my city; a better name, in that they shall be called my servants and holy ones; and than sons, as if they had begotten many sons. Wisdom 3: the eunuch who has not wrought. And as regards the strangers: and to sons, that is, I will give the privileges in which the Jews glory, that they may worship, as regards special worship, and love, as sons, that they may be as servants, and glory in his dominion. Above, 19: they shall worship the Lord. And these things indeed were fulfilled in the return of the people from the captivity; but more fully in the conversion of the nations to the faith of Christ, as the Gloss explains. Second, as regards all in general: every one who keeps. And concerning this he does two things. First he sets down the promise, by which he promises the restoration of the sacred place: to the holy mountain. Namely, as above, 1: come, let us go up to the mountain of the Lord. And as regards the acceptance of sacrifices: holocausts. Malachi 3: the sacrifice of Judah and Jerusalem shall be pleasing to God. Second he sets down the order of fulfillment: and first as regards the veneration of the temple: for my house. 2 Maccabees 3: the temple throughout the whole. John 2 and Matthew 21: my house shall be called a house of prayer. Second, as regards the gathering of the people: says the Lord, to him; he gathers Israel, the nations adhering to him. Psalm 146: the Lord, building up Jerusalem, will gather the dispersions of Israel. Note on that word, and I will give a better name, that the saints have a name, first from predestination. Above, 49: the Lord has called me from the womb; second, from divine attainment. 1 John 3: behold what manner of love or charity God the Father has given us, that we should be called, and should be, sons of God. Third, from the infusion of grace. Apocalypse 2: you have a name, and you hold my name. Fourth, from the renewal of the mind. In the same place, Apocalypse 2: I will give a stone. Also note, that the name of God is to be loved: first, because it is great, so as to be feared. Malachi 1: my name is great among the nations, says the Lord. Second, because it is holy, so as to be venerated. Luke 1: he who is mighty has done great things for me, and holy is his name. Third, because it is sweet, so as to be meditated upon. Above, 26: your name and your memorial are in the desire of the soul. Fourth, because it is abundant, so as to show mercy. Canticle 1: your name is oil poured out. Fifth, because it is efficacious, so as to obtain. John 15: whatsoever you shall ask the Father in my name, he will give you. Sixth, because it is powerful, so as to save. Acts 4: there is no other name under heaven whereby we must be saved. Seventh, because it is hidden, so as to be known. Proverbs 30: what is his name. All you beasts of the field. Here he threatens those who despise it with the failure of salvation: and first he designates the punishment of slaughter: all beasts, to devour, their corpses. Ezekiel 39: speak to every bird, to all. Second he sets down the fault: and first, of the prelates, as regards their failure in government and in foreseeing dangers. Watchmen: for prelates are set up to guard the people from dangers, as a watchman guards against enemies: they have not known, to foresee dangers. Matthew 15: let them alone: they are blind leaders of the blind. In the correction of vices, all of them dogs. To bark, against vices. Psalm 37: but I, as a deaf man, heard not, and as a dumb man, not opening his mouth. In the admonition of things to be done, seeing vain things, promising them prosperous things when adverse things were imminent; and thus nourishing them in sins. Ezekiel 22: her prophets daubed them. In the plundering of goods, and most shameless dogs; as if, without any restraint of shame, despoiling their subjects of their goods, and never satisfied. Psalm 58: they shall suffer hunger like dogs. And as regards their failure in the perfection of knowledge: they, the shepherds, understanding, of the law and the prophets. Proverbs 1: the intelligent man shall possess the helm. Psalm 81: they have not known nor understood; they walk on in darkness. Second, the fault of the subjects, or of all in common: and first, as regards their own will, which pertains to pride: all, into his own way. Jeremiah 16: every one walks. Second, as regards their covetousness, which pertains to avarice: every one. Jeremiah 6: from the least even to the greatest, all are given to avarice. Third, as regards pleasure, which pertains to the concupiscence of the flesh: come. And it shall be; that is, if today we rejoice in such things, tomorrow much more. Above, 22: and behold joy and gladness, killing calves and slaying rams, eating flesh and drinking wine.”

Post-Reformation

c. 1650 – 1900
1714
A.D.
Matthew Henry Reformed
1662–1714
“From words of comfort the prophet here, by a very sudden change of his style, passes to words of reproof and conviction, and goes on in that strain, for the most part, in the three following chapters; and therefore some here begin a new sermon. He had assured the people that in due time God would deliver them out of captivity, which was designed for the comfort of those that should live when God would do this. Now here he shows what their sins and provocations were, for which God would send them into captivity, and this was designed for the conviction of those that lived in his own time, nearly a hundred years before the captivity, who were now filling up the measure of the nation's sin, and to justify God in what he brought upon them. God will lay them waste by the fierceness of their enemies, for the falseness of their friends. I. Desolating judgments are here summoned, Isa 56:9. The sheep of God's pasture are now to be made the sheep of his slaughter, to fall as victims to his justice, and therefore the beasts of the field and the forest are called to come and devour. They are beasts of prey, and do it from their own ravenous disposition; but God permits them to do it, nay, he employs them as his servants in doing it, the ministers of his justice, though they mean not so, neither does their heart think so. If this refers primarily to the descent made upon them by the Babylonians, and their devouring them, yet it may look further, to the destruction of Jerusalem and the Jewish nation by the Romans, after these outcasts of them (mentioned Isa 56:8) were gathered in to the Christian church. The Roman armies came upon them as beasts of the forest to devour them, and they quite took away their place and nation. Note, When God has bloody work to do he has beasts of prey within call, to be employed in doing it. II. The reason of these judgments is here given. The shepherds, who should have been the watchmen of the flock, to discover the approaches of the beasts of prey, to keep them off, and protect the sheep, were treacherous and careless, minded not their business, nor made any conscience of the trust reposed in them, and so the sheep became an easy prey to the wild beasts. Now this may refer to the false prophets that lived in Isaiah's, Jeremiah's, and Ezekiel's time (who flattered the people in their wicked ways, and told them they should have peace though they went on) and to the priests that bore rule by their means. Or it may refer to the wicked princes, the sons of Josiah, that did evil in the sight of the Lord, and other wicked magistrates under them, who betrayed their trust, were vicious and profane, and, instead of making up the breach at which the judgments of God were breaking in upon them, made it wider, and augmented the fierce anger of the Lord instead of doing any thing to turn it away. They should have kept judgment and justice (v. 1), but they abandoned both, Jer 5:1. Or it may refer to those who were the nation's watchmen in our Saviour's time, the chief priests and the scribes, who should have discerned the signs of the times and have given notice to the people of the approach of the Messiah, but who, instead of that, opposed him, and did all they could to keep people from coming to the knowledge of him and to prejudice them against him. It is a very sad character that is here given of these watchmen. Woe unto thee, O land! when thy guides are such. 1. They had no sense or knowledge of their business. They were wretchedly ignorant of their work, and very unfit to teach, being so ill-taught themselves: His watchmen are blind, and therefore utterly unfit to be watchmen. If the seers see not, who shall see for us? If the light that is in us be darkness, how great is that darkness! Christ describes the Pharisees to be blind leaders of the blind, Mat 15:14. The beasts of the field come to devour, and the watchmen are blind, and are not aware of them. They are all ignorant (Isa 56:10), shepherds that cannot understand (Isa 56:11), that know not what is to be done about the sheep, nor can feed them with understanding, Jer 3:15. 2. What little knowledge they had they made no use of it; no one was the better for it. As they were blind watchmen, that could not discern the danger, so they were dumb dogs, that would not give warning of it. And why are the dogs set to guard the sheep if they cannot bark to waken the shepherd and frighten the wolf? Such were these; those that had the charge of souls never reproved men for their faults, nor told them what would be in the end thereof, never gave them notice of the judgments of God that were breaking in upon them. They barked at God's prophets, and bit them too, and worried the sheep, but made no opposition to the wolf or thief. 3. They were very lazy, and would take no pains. They loved their ease, and hated business, were always sleeping, lying down and loving to slumber. They were not overcome and overpowered by sleep, as the disciples, through grief and fatigue, but they lay down on purpose to invite sleep, and said, Soul, take thy ease. Yet a little sleep. It is bad with a people when their shepherds slumber (Nah 3:18), and it is well for God's people that their shepherd, the keeper of Israel, neither slumbers nor sleeps. 4. They were very covetous and eager after the world - greedy dogs that can never have enough. If they had ever so much, they would think it too little. They so love silver as never to be satisfied with silver, Ecc 5:10. All their enquiry is what they shall get, not what they shall do. Let them have the wages, and they care not whether the work be done or no; they feed not the flock, but fleece it. They are every one looking to his own way, minding his own private interests, and have no regard at all to the public welfare. It was St. Paul's complaint of the watchmen in his time (Phi 2:21), All seek their own, not the things that are Jesus Christ's. Every one is for propagating his own opinion, advancing his own party, raising his own family, and having every thing to his own mind, while the common concerns of the public are wretchedly neglected and postponed. They look every one to his gain from his quarter, from his end or part of the work. They are for fain from every quarter (Rem rem quocunque modo rem - Money, money, by fair means or by foul we must have money), but especially from their own quarter, where they will be sure to take care that they lose nothing, nor miss any thing that is to be got. If any one put not into their mouths they not only will do him no service, but they prepare war against him, Mic 3:5. 5. They were perfect epicures, given to their pleasures, never so much in their element as in their drunken revels (Isa 56:12): Come (say they), I will fetch wine (they have that at command; their cellars are better furnished than their closets) and we will fill ourselves, or be drunk, with strong drink. They were often drunk, not overseen (as we say) or overtaken in drink, but designedly. The watchmen did thus invite and encourage one another to drink to excess, or they courted the people to sit and drink with them, and so confirmed those in their wicked ways, and hardened their hearts, whom they should have reproved. How could they think it any harm to be drunk when the watchmen themselves joined with them and led them to it! 6. They were very secure and confident of the continuance of their prosperity and ease; they said, "Tomorrow shall be as this day and much more abundant; we shall have as much to spend upon our lusts tomorrow as we have today." They had no thought at all of their own frailty and mortality, though they were shortening their days and hastening their deaths by their excesses. They had no dread of the judgments of God, though they were daily provoking him and making themselves liable to his wrath and curse. They never considered the uncertainty of all the delights and enjoyments of sense, how they perish in the using and pass away with the lusts of them. They resolved to continue in this wicked course, whatever their consciences said to the contrary, to be as merry tomorrow as they are today. But boast not thyself of tomorrow when perhaps this night thy soul shall be required of thee.”
1771
A.D.
John Gill Reformed
1697–1771
“All ye beasts of the field, come to devour,.... Which may be understood either literally of savage beasts being called to devour the slain, signifying a great slaughter that should be made, like that in Rev 19:17 to which the fowls of the heaven are invited, as to a supper; and so Kimchi interprets it of such creatures being called to feed upon the carcasses in the camp of Gog and Magog, agreeably to Eze 39:17, but it seems better to understand it figuratively of people and nations, comparable to the beasts of the field for their strength, cruelty, and voraciousness. The Targum of the whole is, "all the kings of the people that shall be gathered to oppress thee, O Jerusalem, shall be cast in the midst of thee; they shall be for food to the beast of the field, the beast of the forest shall be satisfied with them.'' Though it seems most correct to interpret these beasts of the kings of the people themselves; by whom some understand the Chaldeans, Babylonians, and other nations along with them, and under them, who spoiled the people of the Jews, and carried them captive; but rather the Romans are intended. And so the prophet, after he had foretold the gathering in of the remnant, according to the election of grace, among the Jews, and the addition to them from among the Gentiles, proceeds to give an account what should become of the rest of the Jewish nation that rejected the Messiah and his Gospel; that the Romans should be brought in upon them, who should devour them; which destruction would be owing to the following sins abounding among their principal men. But I am inclined to the opinion of Cocceius and Vitringa, that the barbarous nations of the Goths and Vandals, and others, coming into the Roman empire, become Christian, though greatly corrupted, are here meant (t); since this seems to be a prophecy of what should happen between the first gathering of the Jews and Gentiles to Christ in the first times of the Gospel, and the later gathering of them in the latter day; and the following words aptly describe the ignorance, stupidity, avarice, and intemperance of the priests of the apostate church of Rome; and the following chapter, which is a continuance of this prophecy, better agrees with the idolatry of the church of Rome than with the Jews, who, especially at the time of their destruction by the Romans, were not given to idolatry. Yea, all the beasts in the forest: a herd of them, which, like an inundation, ran over the Roman empire, and tore it to pieces, and spread ignorance and corruption every where, next described; for now the beast of Rome arose with his ten heads. Some think that a new chapter should begin here. (t) Agreeably to which, the words, according to the accents, are thus rendered by Reinbeck, De Accent. Heb. p. 427. "all ye beasts of the field; come ye, to devour all the beasts in the forest"; so Munster; one sort of beasts are called upon to devour another sort.”
Source
1849
A.D.
1774–1849
“Beasts. Here a fresh discourse begins to chap. lxi. The Chaldeans and Romans are invited to punish God’s people for their sins, committed before the captivity, Zacharias xiv. 2. (Calmet) — The prophet foresees the negligence of some pastors, and denounces their rigorous chastisement. (Worthington)”
1871
A.D.
1871
“beasts--Gentile idolatrous nations hostile to the Jews, summoned by God to chastise them (Jer 12:7-9; Jer 50:17; Eze 34:5): the Chaldeans and subsequently the Romans. The mention of the "outcasts of Israel" (Isa 56:8) brings in view the outcasting, caused by the sins of their rulers (Isa 56:10-12). to devour--namely, Israel.”
Source
1875
A.D.
Keil & Delitzsch Lutheran
1861–1875
“It is a question whether Isa 56:9 forms the commencement of a fresh prophecy, or merely the second half of the prophecy contained in Isa 56:1-8. We decide, for our part, in favour of the former. If Isa 56:9. formed an antithetical second half to the promising first half in Isa 56:1-8, we should expect to find the prophets and leaders of Israel, whose licentiousness and want of principle are here so severely condemned, threatened with destruction in the heathen land, whilst true proselytes and even eunuchs were brought to the holy mountain. But we meet with this antithesis for the first time in Isa 57:13, where we evidently find ourselves in the midst of another prophetic address. And where can that address commence, if not at Isa 56:9, from which point onwards we have that hard, dull, sharp, and concise language of strong indignation, which recals to mind psalms written "in a thundering style" (Psalter, i. 80) and the reproachful addresses of Jeremiah, and which passes again in Isa 57:11. into the lofty crystalline language peculiar to our prophet's "book of consolation?" The new prophetic address commences, like Isa 55:1, with a summons. "All ye beasts of the field, come near! To devour, all ye beasts in the forest!" According to the accentuation before us (לכל mercha, כלח־יתו tiphchah), the beasts of the field are summoned to devour the beasts in the forest. This accentuation, however, is false, and must be exchanged for another which is supported by some MSS, viz., לכל tiphchah, כלח־יתו mercha, and ביער Beth raphatum. It is true that even with these accents we might still adhere to the view favoured by Jewish commentators, viz., that the beasts of the field are to be devoured by the beasts of the forest, if this view yielded any admissible sense (compare, for example, that supported by Meyer, "Ye enemies, devour the scattered ones of my congregation"), and had not against it the synonymous parallelism of שדי חיתו and ביער חיתו (Isa 43:20; Psa 104:11, Psa 104:20; cf., Gen 3:14). But there remains another view, according to which ביער כל־חיתו is a second vocative answering to שׂדי כל־חיתו. According to the Targum, what is to be devoured is the great body of heathen kings attacking Jerusalem; according to Jerome, Cyril, Stier, etc., the pasture and food provided by the grace of God. But what follows teaches us something different from this. Israel has prophets and shepherds, who are blind to every coming danger, and therefore fail to give warning of its approach, because they are sunken in selfishness and debauchery. It resembles a flock with a keeper, and therefore an easy prey (Eze 34:5); and the meaning of the appeal, which is certainly addressed to the nations of the world, the enemies of the people of God, is this: "Ye have only to draw near; ye can feed undisturbed, and devour as much as ye please." This is the explanation adopted by most of the more modern commentators. In Jer 12:9, which is founded upon this ("Assemble all ye beasts of the field, bring them hither to devour"), it is also Jerusalem which is assigned as food to the heathen. The parallel in Isa 56:9 is both synonymous and progressive. The writer seeks for rare forms, because he is about to depict a rare inversion of the proper state of things. חיתו (with the first syllable loosely closed) is the antiquated form of connection, which was admissible even with ביּער following (cf., Isa 5:11; Isa 9:1-2; Sa2 1:21). On אתיוּ (= אתוּ), see at Isa 21:12 (cf., Isa 21:14).”
Source
Modern · 1953 →

The in-app commentary runs from the Fathers to the early-modern record, then stops — that's where the public-domain sources end, not where the reading does. For the modern reading, follow the sources directly.