The interpretation timeline
Isaiah 60:19 Douay-Rheims

Thou shalt no more have the sun for thy light by day, neither shall the brightness of the moon enlighten thee: but the Lord shall be unto thee for an everlasting light, and thy God for thy glory.

1105 – 1875 7 witnesses

Scholastic

c. 1100 – 1500
1105
A.D.
Rashi Jewish
1040–1105
“You shall no longer have You shall not require the light of the sun.”
1167
A.D.
Ibn Ezra Jewish
1089–1167
“The sun shall be no more, etc. Thou wilt not want the light of the sun, because of the light of God. An everlasting light, that shines day and night.”
1256
A.D.
Thomas Aquinas Catholic
1225–1274
“Arise, be enlightened. Here he begins to set forth the promise of salvation: and first as to prosperity; second as to joy, chapter 61: The spirit of the Lord; third as to the honor of glory, chapter 62: For Sion's sake. Concerning the first, two things. First he sets forth consolation in general under the metaphor of light, setting forth the rising of that light: Arise — from your former misery; be enlightened — shine with the light of his consolation. The glory of the Lord — the benefits in which he appears glorious. Baruch 4: Walk by the way toward his splendor, facing his light. Or, Jerusalem is the Church; the light, the Son of God. Setting forth the judgment of discernment in perceiving the light: for behold darkness — the peoples of tribulation, of Babylon, and other enemies; but upon thee shall it rise, as a sun enlightening thee. Wisdom 17: Upon them alone was heavy night imposed, and an image of darkness. Or, darkness — of unbelief and of sins; peoples — the unbelievers. It shall rise — as the sun of justice: or, according to the letter, his glory — his miracles. He also sets forth the effect of the light: And the nations shall walk — to the knowledge and devotion of God, seeing the benefits given to thee by God — in the splendor of thy rising, as it were rising, glowing like a star. 2 Maccabees 3: When the holy city. Or, in the light — in the faith of Christ. Apocalypse 21: The nations shall walk. Second, he carries out the consolation part by part: and first he promises manifold prosperity; second, the observance of justice, And I will appoint. Concerning the first, two things. First he sets forth the state of prosperity; second, the manner of restitution, namely, by what means they will be restored in prosperity — Who are these. Concerning the first, three things. First he promises prosperity as to the gathering of the sons, who had first been scattered into diverse parts through captivity. Lift up round about (...) from the side — from the regions bordering the sides. Baruch 5: Arise, Jerusalem, and stand on high, and look about toward the east, and see thy sons gathered from the rising of the sun even to its setting. Or it is to be referred to the gathering of the diverse nations under the unity of the Church. Sons — the stronger in faith; daughters — the weaker; from the side — of Christ opened on the cross, whence the sacraments of salvation flowed forth. Or, they shall suck milk — of a more elementary teaching. Second, as to the service of the peoples: Then shalt thou see (...) when converted, serving thee in trade — the multitude of the sea, namely the merchants of the sea; the strength — kings and princes, ministering peace to thee, and gifts. Or, concerning the conversion of the nations to the Church. Job 22: Then shalt thou abound in delights over the Almighty. Third, as to the abundance of riches: and first as to trade, setting forth the beasts of burden: The flood — that is, abundance after the likeness of water — of camels, by which merchandise used to be carried; by which, mystically, are meant the rich who are converted to the faith, who bear the burden of riches and the hump of sin: above, chapter 30: bearing upon their shoulders; the dromedaries — an animal smaller than the camel, but swifter — by which are meant the nations swiftly converted to the faith: Midian and Ephah — regions beyond the sea abounding in such. He also sets forth precious merchandise: all from Saba — a city in the farthest parts of Ethiopia. Which also was fulfilled in the time of Christ: Matthew 2. Psalm 71: The kings of Tharsis and the islands shall offer gifts. Second, as to the clean animals, according as they served for use as food: All the flocks of Cedar — the son of Ishmael, from whom the land has its name, abounding in flocks; Nabajoth, another son — they shall minister, yielding to thy use, sold to the people that is in thee. And according as they served for the use of sacrifices: they shall be offered upon that which is acceptable, that is, that in which I am well-pleased. By the altar is signified faith; by the rams, the leaders of the flock — the apostles and the prelates of the Churches; by the flock, the simple faithful. Haggai 2: I will fill this house. Note on that word, Be enlightened, Jerusalem, that the Church is enlightened with light: first, of sacred doctrine. Proverbs 6: The commandment is a lamp, and the law a light. Second, of spiritual understanding. 2 Corinthians 4: God, who said that light should shine in darkness. Third, of grace. 1 John 1: But if we walk in the light, as he also is in the light, we have fellowship one with another. Fourth, of glory. Psalm 35: In thy light we shall see light. Fifth, of gladness. Tobit 5: What manner of joy is it to me, who sit in darkness, and do not see the light of heaven? Sixth, of the divine substance. 1 Timothy, the last chapter: Who alone has immortality, and inhabits light inaccessible. Who are these. Here he shows the manner of coming into the said prosperity: and first as to the restoration of the city; second as to the subjection of the foreign peoples, And they shall come to thee; third as to the multiplication of riches: For brass I will bring gold. Concerning the first, two things. First he (sets forth) the restoration of the city as to the uniting of its inhabitants, setting forth the manner of their coming under a note of wonder. As clouds — because swiftly, without hindrance; and as doves to their windows — that is, to their own openings — for the same reason. Or it is to be referred to the nations which were swiftly converted to the faith. Psalm 54: Who will give wings like a dove, and I will fly away, that I may rest. Setting forth also the help toward their coming, which they had from the nations: For me the islands — the diverse nations near the sea, and also the distant ones — shall wait, as subject to the judgment of my will, from the beginning — of the place in which the captives were held: because perhaps some returned by sea, or the Lord was able to bring them back in this way. Or, mystically, the islands — the diverse nations; the ships — the Churches; in the beginning — of the faith. Above, chapter 42: his law, the islands. Setting forth also the treasure of those who come, which they brought with them: silver. To the name — that is, for the glory and the service of the name. Psalm 104: He brought them out with silver and gold. Mystically, silver — the eloquence; gold — the wisdom of those converted to the faith. Second, he sets forth the restoration of the city as to the building of the walls, And they shall build: and first as to the buildings of the city; second as to the buildings of the temple, The glory of Lebanon. Concerning the first, two things. First he sets forth the rebuilding of the city: And they shall build — by giving help — kings — Cyrus and Darius — by providing the expenses, and the license to build. Mystically, the Gentiles build the Churches of God, and kings serve the Church. Above, chapter 49: Kings shall see. And he adds the reason from the divine mercy: In my indignation I struck — I took captive; I have had mercy — by setting free. Mystically, struck — through the blinding of the Jews, or through tribulations; had mercy — through the conversion of the nations, or through the Churches restored in peace. Above, chapter 54: In a moment of indignation I hid my face for a little while. Second, he shows the security of the rebuilt city, And they shall be opened — the fear of enemies ceasing, and because of the need of those coming to worship in Jerusalem; and this is that there may be brought. Mystically, the gates — the ministers who bring others into the faith and the Church, ready in prosperity and adversity to receive those converted to the faith. Apocalypse 21: Its gates shall not be shut. And he assigns the reason: For the nation. This does not seem to be fulfilled according to the letter, unless it be understood that those were Jews who acknowledged its dominion, and were therefore venerated by the people of God; but the mystical sense is plain. Jeremiah 27: The nation and the kingdom. The glory of Lebanon. Here he sets forth the rebuilding of the buildings of the temple: The glory of Lebanon, which is the fir tree; the place — namely, the temple; of my feet — in which I am adored, as kings are at the feet. Ezekiel 43: The place of my throne. Mystically, by the place is meant the Church; by the diverse trees, the diverse faithful among those converted to the faith. And they shall come. Here he shows the manner of attaining the said prosperity as to the subjection of the peoples: and first he sets forth the subjection itself, And they shall come to thee: which was fulfilled in the times of the Maccabees, who subjugated many of the neighboring enemies. Mystically, the sons of the tyrants who once persecuted the Church now serve the Church. Psalm 109: Until I make thy enemies thy footstool. Above, chapter 1: After this thou shalt be called. Second, he sets forth the reason for the subjection: For that thou wast — it is just that after distress thou shouldst be consoled — for pride, height — of ages, throughout many ages: which also mystically befits the Church. Tobit 3: After the storm he makes a calm. Third, he sets forth the usefulness of the subjection: And thou shalt suck; that is, the fatness of the earth shall be brought to thee in trade, and in offerings; the breast — defense; in help — of kings; of Tyre. Daniel 4. By milk, mystically, is meant the teaching of the simple; by kings, the apostles. Above, chapter 49: Kings shall be thy nursing fathers. For brass. Here he sets forth the manner of restoration as to the restoration of riches: because much greater things shall be offered to the temple by kings than were taken away by Nebuchadnezzar. Mystically, those who before were vile become precious in the Church. Above, chapter 55: Instead of the shrub shall come up. And I will appoint. Here he promises the observance of justice: and first in the prelates; second in the subjects, And they shall be fulfilled. Concerning the first, two things. First he consoles them from the rectitude of the prelates, touching upon the justice of the prelates: visitation — visitors and correctors. Mystically, concerning Christ and the apostles. Jeremiah 3: I will give thee pastors. Setting forth also the effect of justice as to the absence of malice: Iniquity shall not be heard, because for a certain time the laws were observed most excellently: 2 Maccabees 3: or, iniquity — idolatry. Mystically, as to the state of future beatitude. Psalm 102: As far as the rising is from the setting, so far has he removed our iniquities from us. And as to the absence of misery: wasting — as to things; ruin — as to men so crushed by enemies; gates — in which the people used to gather for judgments. This too, mystically, as to the state of future beatitude, when, although the sun shall be much brighter than now, and the moon: yet not for the saints, because they have no need of their splendor. Apocalypse 21: Then they shall have no need of the splendor of the sun. He also sets forth the eternity of him who governs: The sun shall not go down — who is God. Psalm 101: But thou art always the selfsame, and thy years shall not fail. And they shall be fulfilled. This as to the state of the subjects: and first he sets forth the cessation of sorrow: And the mourning shall be fulfilled — captivity. Mystically, in future beatitude. Apocalypse 21: God shall wipe away every tear from the eyes of the saints. Above, chapter 25: He shall take away the tear. Second, he sets forth the observance of justice: But the people; that they may glorify me. Above, chapter 43: everyone that calls upon my name. Forever — as long as they remain in justice. But mystically it is plain, concerning the blessed saints. Third, the multiplication of the seed: the least — that is, from one so many shall be born through succession, just as from Abraham one nation. Mystically, one from the Church shall be set over a nation as prelate. Psalm: The saints shall judge among the nations. In its time — that is, of Christ; or, at the time appointed. Suddenly — as though unforeseen, all this that has been said. Note on that word, Who are these that are as clouds, and as doves, that the apostles are called clouds: first, on account of the fertility of the earth, namely from the rain. Job 37: The clouds desire the grain. Second, on account of the diffusion of light. The same: the clouds scatter their light. Third, on account of the swiftness of motion, the same: which range over all things round about. Fourth, on account of the fulfillment of the divine will. The same: whithersoever the will of him that governs shall lead them. Likewise they are called doves: first, on account of compunction of heart. Nahum 2: moaning like doves. Second, on account of simplicity of life. Matthew 10: Be ye wise as serpents, and simple as doves. Third, on account of the height, or swiftness, of contemplation. Psalm 54: Who has given me wings like a dove, and I will fly away, and be at rest. Fourth, on account of purity of conscience. Canticle 5: Thy eyes are as doves. Canticle 4: Thy eyes, doves'.”

Post-Reformation

c. 1650 – 1900
1771
A.D.
John Gill Reformed
1697–1771
“The sun shall be no more thy light by day,.... Here begins the account of the sinless, pure, and perfect state of the church in the personal reign of Christ, even the New Jerusalem church state, as appears from the use of these very words, in the description of that state, Rev 21:23 where it is read, "and the city had no need of the sun, neither of the moon to shine in it: for the glory of God did lighten it, and the Lamb is the light thereof"; and in like manner the Targum renders these words, "and ye shall have no need any more of the light of the sun by day, nor even of the light of the moon by night;'' and so both Aben Ezra and Jarchi interpret it, "ye shall have no need of the light of the sun;'' and the former adds, because of the light of the Shechinah; and which seems to be the meaning of the next clause: neither for brightness shall the moon give light unto thee; that is, because of the exceeding brightness, splendour, and lustre of the divine majesty of Christ, who will appear personally among his people, neither sun nor moon will be able to give any light: as the light of a candle is made useless and unnecessary by the light of the sun, so the light of the sun and moon will be made useless and unnecessary by the vastly superior light and glory of Christ; see Isa 24:23, though the sun and moon may be understood here mystically, not of civil magistrates, who are sometimes signified by these luminaries; and who also will be no more used when this dispensation or personal reign of Christ shall take place; see Isa 13:10, but rather of the Gospel and Gospel ordinances, which the church will no more stand in need of to enlighten, teach, and instruct them, refresh and comfort them, having the immediate presence of Christ with them, as follows: but the Lord shall be unto thee an everlasting light; that is, the Lord Jesus Christ, the Lamb of God, as it is interpreted in the above cited place in the Revelation; who, as he is the author of the light of nature, and of the light of grace, so of the light of glory in this state, and to all eternity; then will the saints in this light behold the face of God, which is not to be seen now; they shall see Christ in all his glory, in the glory of his Father, and of his holy angels; all the glorious forms, the angels of heaven, and all the saints, those spirits of just then made perfect, that shall come with Christ, and be clothed with glorious bodies; even the New Jerusalem descending from heaven, having the glory of God upon her; likewise all the doctrines of grace, now not so clearly understood; and all the mysteries of Providence, which will be laid open, and made manifest; and this clear light will continue for ever; there will be no more night, but one everlasting day: and thy God thy glory; it is the saints' glory that God is their God; and it will be their glory in this state to have the God-man Jesus Christ personally with them; the tabernacle of God will be among them; God himself shall be with them, and be their God; and his glory shall lighten them, Rev 21:3.”
Source
1849
A.D.
1774–1849
“Thou shalt, &c. In this latter part of the chapter, the prophet passes from the illustrious promises made to the Church militant on earth, to the glory of the Church triumphant in heaven. (Challoner) — Glory. St. John seems to have copied this, Apocalypse xviii., &c.”
1871
A.D.
1871
“The sun and moon, the brightest objects by day and night, shall be eclipsed by the surpassing glory of God manifesting Himself to thee (Isa 30:26; Zac 2:5; Rev 21:23; Rev 22:5).”
1875
A.D.
Keil & Delitzsch Lutheran
1861–1875
“The fifth turn celebrates the glorifying of Jerusalem, through the shining of Jehovah as its everlasting light and through the form of its ever-growing membership, which is so well-pleasing to God. The prophecy returns to the thought with which it set out, and by which the whole is regulated, viz., that Jerusalem will be light. This leading thought is now unfolded in the most majestic manner, and opened up in all its eschatological depth. "The sun will be no more thy light by day, neither for brightness will the moon shine upon thee: Jehovah will be to thee an everlasting light, and thy God thy glory. Thy sun will no more go down, and thy moon will not be withdrawn; for Jehovah will be to thee an everlasting light, and the days of thy mourning will be fulfilled." Although, in the prophet's view, the Jerusalem of the period of glory in this world and the Jerusalem of the eternal glory beyond flow into one another; the meaning of this prophecy is not that the sun and moon will no longer exist. Even of the Jerusalem which is not to be built by Israel with the help of converted heathen, but which comes down from heaven to earth, the seer in Rev 21:23 merely says, that the city needs neither the shining of the sun nor of the moon (as the Targum renders the passage before us, "thou wilt not need the shining of the sun by day"), for the glory of God lightens it, and the Lamb is the light thereof, i.e., God Himself is instead of a sun to her, and the Lamb instead of a moon. Consequently we do not agree with Stier, who infers from this passage that "there is a final new creation approaching, when there will be no more turning round into the shadow (Jam 1:17), when the whole planetary system, including the earth, will be changed, and when the earth itself will become a sun, yea, will become even more than that, in the direct and primary light which streams down upon it from God Himself." We rather agree with Hofmann, that "there will still be both sun and moon, but the Holy Place will be illuminated without interruption by the manifestation of the presence of God, which outshines all besides." The prophet has here found the most complete expression, for that which has already been hinted at in such prophecies in Isa 4:5; Isa 30:26; Isa 24:23. As the city receives its light neither from the sun nor from the moon, this implies, what Rev 21:25 distinctly affirms, that there will be no more night there. The prophet intentionally avoids a לילה לאור parallel to יומם לאור. We must not render the second clause in Isa 60:19, "and it will not become light to thee with the shining of the moon," for האיר never means to get light; nor "and as for the shining of the moon, it does not give the light," as Hitzig and Knobel propose, for וּלנגהּ is used alone, and not היּרח וּלנגהּ as the antithesis to יומם לאור, in the sense of "to light up the night" (compare נגהּ as applied to the shining of the moon in Isa 13:10, and נגהּ to the glittering of the stars in Joe 2:10), and even the use of הלילה is avoided. The true rendering is either, "and for lighting, the moon will not shine upon thee" (Stier, Hahn, etc.); or, what is more in accordance with the accentuation, which would have given ולנגה tifchah and not tsakeph gadol, if it had been intended to indicate the object, "and as for the lighting" (ל as in Isa 32:1). The glory of Jehovah, which soars above Jerusalem, and has come down into her, is henceforth her sun and her moon - a sun that never sets, a moon יאסף לא which is not taken in towards morning, like a lamp that has been hung out at night (compare נאסף, Isa 16:10, withdrawn, disappeared). The triumph of light over darkness, which is the object of the world's history, is concentrated in the new Jerusalem. How this is to be understood, is explained in the closing clause of Isa 60:20. The sum of the days of mourning allotted to the church is complete. The darkness of the corruption of sin and state of punishment is overcome, and the church is nothing but holy blessed joy without change or disturbance; for it walks no longer in sidereal light, but in the eternally unchangeable light of Jehovah, which with its peaceful gentleness and perfect purity illumines within as well as without. The seer of the Apocalypse also mentions the Lamb. The Lamb is also known to our prophet; for the "Servant of Jehovah" is the Lamb. But the light of transfiguration, in which he sees this exalted Lamb, is not great enough to admit of its being combined with the light of the Divine Nature itself.”
Source
Modern · 1953 →

The in-app commentary runs from the Fathers to the early-modern record, then stops — that's where the public-domain sources end, not where the reading does. For the modern reading, follow the sources directly.