The interpretation timeline
Matthew 3:16 Douay-Rheims

And Jesus being baptized, forthwith came out of the water: and lo, the heavens were opened to him: and he saw the Spirit of God descending as a dove, and coming upon him.

A.D. 397 – 1871 13 witnesses 22 excerpts

Patristic

before A.D. 750
397
A.D.
Ambrose of Milan Patristic
A.D. 339–397
“(Ambrosiaster. Serm. xii. 4.) For, as we have said, when the Saviour was washed, then the water was cleansed for our baptism, that a laver might be ministered to the people who were to come. Moreover, it behoved that in Christ’s baptism should be signified those things which the faithful obtain by baptism.”
407
A.D.
John Chrysostom Patristic
A.D. 347–407
“But though you see it not, be not therefore unbelieving, for in the beginnings of spiritual matters sensible visions are always offered, for their sakes who can form no idea of things that have no body; which if they occur not in later times, yet faith may be established by those wonders once wrought.”
“It is moreover an allusion to ancient history; for in the deluge this creature appeared bearing an olive-branch, and tidings of rest to the world. All which things were a type of things to come. For now also a dove appears pointing out to us our liberator, and for an olive-branch bringing the adoption of the human race.”
Source
420
A.D.
Jerome Patristic
c. A.D. 347–420
“Not by an actual cleaving of the visible element, but to the spiritual eye, as Ezekiel also in the beginning of his book relates that he saw them.”
“It sate on the head of Jesus, that none might suppose the voice of the Father spoken to John, and not to the Lord.”
430
A.D.
Augustine of Hippo Patristic
A.D. 354–430
“(App. Serm. 135. 1.) Christ after He had been once born among men, is born a second time in the sacraments, that as we adore Him then born of a pure mother, so we may now receive Him immersed in pure water. His mother brought forth her Son, and is yet virgin; the wave washed Christ, and is holy. Lastly, that Holy Spirit which was present to Him in the womb, now shone round Him in the water, He who then made Mary pure, now sanctifies the waters.”
Source
“(de Trin. ii. 5.) It is easy to understand how the Holy Ghost should be said to be sent, when as it were a dove in visible shape descended on the Lord; that is, there was created a certain appearance for the time in which the Holy Spirit might be visibly shewn. And this operation thus made visible and offered to mortal view, is called the mission of the Holy Spirit, not that His invisible substance was seen, but that the hearts of men might be roused by the external appearance to contemplate the unseen eternity. Yet this creature in the shape of which the Spirit appeared, was not taken into unity of person, as was that human shape taken of the Virgin. For neither did the Spirit bless the dove, nor unite it with Himself for all eternity, in unity of person. Further, though that dove is called the Spirit, so far as to shew that in this dove was a manifestation of the Spirit, yet can we not say of the Holy Spirit that He is God and dove, as we say of the Son that He is God and man; and yet it is not as we say of the Son that He is the Lamb of God, as not only has John Baptist declared, but as John the Evangelist saw the vision of the Lamb slain in the Apocalypse. For this was a prophetic vision, not put before the bodily eyes in bodily shape, but seen in the Spirit in spiritual images. But concerning this dove none ever doubted that it was seen with the bodily eye; not that we say the Spirit is a dove as we say Christ is a Rock; (for that Rock was Christ.) (1 Cor. 10:4.) For that Rock already existed as a creature, and from the resemblance of its operation was called by the name of Christ, (whom it figured;) not so this dove, which was created at the moment for this single purpose. It seems to me to be more like the flame which appeared to Moses in the bush, or that which the people followed in the wilderness, or to the thunderings and lightnings which were when the Law was given from the mount. For all these were visible objects intended to signify something, and then to pass away. For that such forms have been from time to time seen, the Holy Spirit is said to have been sent; but these bodily forms appeared for the time to shew what was required, and then ceased to be.”
Source

Medieval

c. 750 – 1100
856
A.D.
Rabanus Maurus Medieval
c. A.D. 780–856
“As by the immersion of His body He dedicated the laver of baptism, He has shewn that to us also after baptism received the entrance to heaven is open, and the Holy Spirit is given, as it follows, and the heavens were opened.”
“(ap. Anselm.) Seven excellencies in the baptized are figured by the dove. The dove has her abode near the rivers, that when the hawk is seen, she may dive under water and escape; she chooses the better grains of corn; she feeds the young of other birds; she does not tear with her beak; she lacks a gall; she has her rest in the caverns of the rocks; for her song she has a plaint. Thus the saints dwell beside the streams of Divine Scripture, that they may escape the assaults of the Devil; they choose wholesome doctrine, and not heretical for their food; they nourish by teaching and example, men who have been the children of the Devil, i. e. the imitators; they do not pervert good doctrine by tearing it to pieces as the heretics do; they are without hate irreconcileable; they build their nest in the wounds of Christ’s death, which is to them a firm rock, that is their refuge and hope; as others delight in song, so do they in groaning for their sin.”
Source
908
A.D.
c. A.D. 841–908
“But was this then the first time that the heavens were opened to Him according to His human nature? The faith of the Church both believes and holds that the heavens were no less open to Him before than after. It is therefore said here, that the heavens were opened, because to all them who are born again the door of the kingdom of heaven is opened.”
Source
“As to all those who by baptism are born again, the door of the kingdom of heaven is opened, so all in baptism receive the gifts of the Holy Spirit.”

Scholastic

c. 1100 – 1500
1256
A.D.
Thomas Aquinas Catholic
1225–1274
“Above, the Evangelist introduced John baptizing; now he introduces Christ coming to the baptism of John. And concerning this he does two things. First he sets down the things that preceded the baptism; second, the things that followed upon the baptism, at the words but Jesus, having been baptized. Concerning the first, four things are set down. First, Christ's wondrous humility; second, the admiration at that humility; third, Christ's satisfaction given to that admiration; fourth, John's consent to that satisfaction. The second is at but John was preventing him; the third at but Jesus, answering; the fourth at then he permitted him. Concerning the first, four things are set down: the time, the persons, the places, and the office. The time, when he says then, namely, while John still had his own light. For just as the sun rises while Lucifer still appears, so did Christ while John was preaching and baptizing, Luke 3:21. Job 38:32: "Canst thou bring forth Lucifer in its time, and make the evening star to rise upon the children of the earth?" Or then, when Christ was in his thirtieth year, Luke 3:23, so as to give one to understand that no one ought to take up the office of preaching and of prelacy before a mature age. Or then, when according to the course of others he could have committed many sins. Hence he did not wish to be baptized at once, but for a long time kept the law, as one placed under the law, and so that the Jews might have no occasion for scandal, since he did not come to dissolve the law, below 5:17. But it might seem to someone that Christ delayed being baptized because he could not have fulfilled the law; and this is why he wished to observe it for so long, and why he was not baptized so quickly. The persons are set down when it is said Jesus came to John — the Lord to the servant, the Creator to the creature; below 11:29: "Learn from me, because I am meek and humble of heart." The places, from Galilee. These things agree mystically with the baptized, because Galilee signifies a passing-over: for it is fitting that the baptized pass over from vices to virtues; 1 Peter 2:1: "Laying away all malice, and all guile, and dissimulations, and envies, and all detractions." Likewise, into the Jordan. Jordan is interpreted as descent, and signifies the humility that ought to be present in the one being baptized so that grace may be received; James 4:6: "But to the humble he giveth grace." The office is set down, that he might be baptized. God willed to be baptized by John for four reasons. First, so that the baptism of John might be preserved in honor, because some were disparaging it, below 21:24. Second, so that by his touch he might consecrate all water; and therefore baptism is said to be made from the fountains of the savior; Isaiah 12:3: "You shall draw waters with joy out of the saviour's fountains." Third, so that he might demonstrate in himself the true condition of man, because just as he was in the likeness of sinful flesh, Romans 8:3, so he willed to be cleansed as though a sinner. Fourth, so that he might impose upon others the necessity of being baptized: for he wished first to keep what he imposed; Acts 1:1: "Jesus began to do and to teach," against those of whom it is said below, 23:4: "They bind heavy and insupportable burdens, and lay them on men's shoulders: but with a finger of their own they will not move them." Next the admiration is set down. And note three things. For first John refuses the honor offered to him; second he confesses his own humility; third his own weakness. The second is at but John was preventing him; Ecclesiasticus 7:4: "Seek not of man the leadership, nor of a king the seat of honor." The third is at I ought to be baptized by thee. For he knew that Christ baptized inwardly; and therefore he speaks of being baptized, that is, cleansed from original sin — so says the Gloss. But against this, one might object, since John was sanctified in the womb. But it must be said that before the coming of Christ some were in a certain way cleansed as to the infection of the person, through circumcision and the like; but as to guilt and the infection of the whole nature, no one was cleansed before the passion of Christ. And comest thou to me? Psalm 138:6: "Thy knowledge is become wonderful to me: it is high, and I cannot reach to it." Next Christ's satisfaction is set down. Note that John had done one thing, in that he was preventing him; and he had said two things: I ought to be baptized by thee, and comest thou to me? And yet Christ did not answer to the one, namely to this: I by thee; but he answered to that which he was preventing, whence: suffer it to be so now. And he says now, because, according to Chrysostom, John was afterward baptized by Christ, not only with the baptism of the spirit, but also of water. Or suffer it to be so now, he says this because John was afterward baptized with the baptism of the Holy Spirit. Or suffer it to be so now, that I may be baptized with the baptism of water, because I have another baptism with which to be baptized, namely the baptism of the passion; Luke 12:50: "I have a baptism wherewith I am to be baptized: and how am I straitened until it be accomplished?" And with this baptism too John was baptized by Christ, inasmuch as he died for justice, which is the same as to die for Christ. Or suffer it to be so now, meaning: while I bear the form of a servant, let me fulfill the office of humility; because when I shall appear glorious, then I will baptize thee with the baptism of glory. Next Christ answers the admiration, and says thus: for so it becometh us to fulfil all justice. Which is expounded in three ways. First, thus it becometh us to fulfil all justice, namely through baptism: for it was to come to pass that Christ would fulfill all justice, both of the law and of nature; but he willed to fulfill it by this way, because without baptism it is not fulfilled; John 3:3: "Unless a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God," etc. Remigius expounds it thus: thus it becometh us to fulfil all justice — it becomes me to give an example of this sacrament, in which the fullness of all justice is given, because the fullness of grace and of the other virtues is given; Psalm 64:10: "The river of God is filled with water," namely of graces. Or thus: thus it becometh us etc., that is, it becomes me to have perfect humility. The first degree is not to prefer oneself to an equal, and to subject oneself to a greater, which indeed is a matter of necessity. The second, when one subjects oneself to an equal. But the perfect degree is when a superior subjects himself to an inferior: and this is thus it becometh us etc., that is, to fulfill perfect humility. But since there was such a contest of wills between them, Christ prevailed. Hence then he permitted him, etc., that is, he permitted that he be baptized by him. The Gloss: true humility is that which obedience does not forsake; for to resist stubbornly belongs to pride. 1 Kings 15:23: "As the sin of witchcraft, is to rebel," that is, to refuse to acquiesce; for thus are Jeremiah and Moses praised, who in the end gave their consent. Next, when it says but Jesus, having been baptized, forthwith came out of the water, four things consequent upon the baptism are set down. And it should be known that just as Christ in his own baptism gave an example of baptizing for others, so in the things following upon the baptism he gave us to understand what we should follow after. Now there are four consequent things, namely the ascent of Christ, the opening of heaven, the appearance of the Holy Spirit, and the declaration of the Father. The first is at but Jesus, having been baptized, forthwith came out of the water. And to the letter this is said because the river had deep channels. In this, however, it is signified that those who are baptized ascend by good works. And he says forthwith, because those baptized immediately put on Christ in Christ; Galatians 3:27: "For as many of you as have been baptized in Christ, have put on Christ." Likewise they obtain a heavenly inheritance; 1 Peter 1:3: "He hath regenerated us unto a lively hope... unto an inheritance incorruptible": and this is and the heavens were opened. This is not to be understood corporeally, but by an imaginary vision. And the heavens were opened to him. And this signifies that heaven had been closed to the human race through sin; Genesis 3:24: "And he placed before the paradise of pleasure Cherubims, and a flaming sword, turning every way, to keep the way of the tree of life." It is said that he placed the Seraphim, but it was opened through Christ. But it is asked, why were the heavens opened to him, since they had always been open to him? And it must be said, according to Chrysostom, that the Evangelist speaks according to the common manner of speaking, because by the merit of his baptism the heavens were opened to us: just as a king, when a friend of his asks a favor on behalf of another, says: I grant this to you. And it should be known that there are three kinds of men who fly straight to heaven immediately after death: those baptized, as here; martyrs, whence Acts 7:56: "Behold, I see the heavens opened, and the Son of man standing on the right hand of God"; and those who have completed penance, of whom it is said, Acts 10:19, that to Peter praying heaven was opened. Next the appearance of the Holy Spirit is set down; hence: and he saw the Spirit of God descending as a dove, and coming upon him. This is what is fitting for the baptized, who receive the Holy Spirit into themselves; John 3:6: "That which is born of the Spirit, is spirit," that is, is spiritual. And he saw — not by an imaginary vision, otherwise he alone would have seen it — the Spirit of God, that is, the dove. And it should be known that nothing corporeal is said of God according to his substance, but either through an imaginary vision, Isaiah 6:1: "I saw the Lord sitting upon a throne high and elevated," etc., or through signification, 1 Corinthians 10:4: "And the rock was Christ," or through assumption into the unity of the person, John 1:14: "The Word was made flesh." But in none of these ways is the Holy Spirit called a dove. That it is not by an imaginary vision is clear, because it was seen commonly by all. Not by signification, because it had not previously existed as such. Not by assumption into the unity of the person. And therefore there is a fourth way, which is when some species is newly formed for the representation of divine effects, as in Exodus 3:2 the Lord appeared in fire and a bush; and in the giving of the law, in lightning and thunder, Exodus 19:16. Hence the dove served to represent the influence of the Holy Spirit: and this is and he saw the Spirit of God descending. Now he appeared in the form of a dove for four reasons. First, on account of charity; for the dove is a loving animal. Chrysostom: "Even the servant of the devil has, in pretense, other gifts which the servant of God has in truth: only the charity of the Holy Spirit can the unclean spirit not imitate." Song of Songs 5:2: "Open to me, my sister, my love, my dove, my undefiled." Second, on account of innocence and simplicity; below 10:16: "Be ye therefore wise as serpents, and simple as doves." Third, because it has a moaning in place of song; and man, sanctified through the Holy Spirit, ought to groan for his sins; Nahum 2:7: "And her handmaids led her away mourning, as doves." Fourth, on account of fecundity. Whence also it was commanded in the law that they should offer a dove: and this befits the baptized, because, as John 3:6 says, "that which is born of the Spirit, is spirit." Descending as a dove. The emanation of divine gifts from God into any creature whatsoever is always by way of descent, because a creature cannot receive except by a descent into it; James 1:17: "Every best gift, and every perfect gift, is from above, coming down from the Father of lights." And coming upon him. Note: a visible mission is always a sign of an invisible mission, and it signifies either grace newly received or an increase of grace: just as in the apostles, when the Holy Spirit appeared in tongues, it signified an increase of grace. Likewise such a mission signifies either grace then made, or grace made before. In Christ, however, it did not signify a new effect, because from the instant of his conception he was full of grace and truth; but the grace which then rested upon him was so inasmuch as he was man, not inasmuch as he was God. Next, when it says and behold a voice from heaven, saying, the declaration of the Father is set down: this is my beloved Son. Note that baptism makes men not only spiritual, but also sons of God; John 1:12: "He gave them power to be made the sons of God." And it should be known that this voice, as it were, expresses that which the dove signified. Beloved — not as other creatures are, Wisdom 2:13, but as a natural son; John 5:20: "For the Father loveth the Son, and sheweth him all things which himself doth: and greater works than these will he shew him, that you may wonder." This is also signified by Psalm 2:7: "The Lord hath said to me: Thou art my son, this day have I begotten thee." But because the saints too are loved by him, he adds Son, by which he distinguishes the Son, according to one understanding, from the others. In whom I am well pleased. For in whomever the good of someone shines forth, in that one something is pleasing to himself, just as a craftsman is pleased with himself in his own beautiful work, and as when a man sees his own beautiful image in a mirror. The divine goodness is present in every particular creature; but it is never wholly perfect except in the Son and the Holy Spirit; and therefore the whole is not pleasing to himself except in the Son, who has as much of goodness as the Father: and this is in whom, that is, I am well pleased in myself in him; John 3:35: "The Father loveth the Son: and he hath given all things into his hand." But note that a certain contrariety seems to exist between this Evangelist and the others, because Mark 1:11 and Luke 3:22 say, "Thou art my beloved son"; but Matthew says, "This is my beloved son," and, "in whom." But the meaning is the same, because what is said, thou art, seemed to be said directly to Christ; but he said it on account of others, because Christ was certain of the Father's love. And therefore Matthew expressed the intention of the one speaking, and says this is, etc. Hence he shows it to have been said, as it were, to others; thus said Augustine. Likewise it is asked, why do Matthew and Mark say in whom I am, while Luke says in thee? Augustine says that the Father is pleased in the Son both in himself and for the sake of men. On account of this, therefore, what is said, in whom, signifies that he is pleased in men. Hence, that he may please others through me, that is, to my honor, because some, seeing the Son, glorified the Father. Or according to both senses: in whom I am well pleased, that is, my pleasure was to fulfill the salvation of men: and this is in thee, that is, through thee. And note that in this baptism there is represented not only the end and the fruit, but also the form of baptism, which is, in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit, below. For the Son was in the flesh, the Father in the voice, the Holy Spirit in the form of a dove. And note that this — that they occurred separately — does not pertain to a division of the operation of the persons of the Trinity, since, just as there is a common essence, so too there is a common operation; but this is said on account of a certain appropriation, because the whole Trinity both created that dove and created the flesh; but these things are referred to the different persons.”

Post-Reformation

c. 1650 – 1900
1771
A.D.
John Gill Reformed
1697–1771
“And Jesus, when he was baptized,.... Christ, when he was baptized by John in the river Jordan, the place where he was baptizing, went up straightway out of the water. One would be at a loss at first sight for a reason why the Evangelist should relate this circumstance; for after the ordinance was administered, why should he stay in the water? what should he do there? Everyone would naturally and reasonably conclude, without the mention of such a circumstance, that as soon as his baptism was over, he would immediately come up out of the water. However, we learn this from it, that since it is said, that he came up out of the water, he must first have gone down into it; must have been in it, and was baptized in it; a circumstance strongly in favour of baptism by immersion: for that Christ should go down into the river, more or less deep, to the ankles, or up to the knees, in order that John should sprinkle water on his face, or pour it on his head, as is ridiculously represented in the prints, can hardly obtain any credit with persons of thought and sense. But the chief view of the Evangelist in relating this circumstance, is with respect to what follows; and to show, that as soon as Christ was baptized, and before he had well got out of the water, lo the heavens were opened: and some indeed read the word "straightway", in connection with this phrase, and not with the words "went up": but there is no need of supposing such a trajection, for the whole may be rendered thus; and Jesus, when he was baptized, was scarcely come up out of the water, but lo, immediately, directly, as soon as he was out, or rather before, the heavens were opened to him; the airy heaven was materially and really opened, parted, rent, or cloven asunder, as in Mar 1:10 which made way for the visible descent of the Holy Ghost in a bodily shape. A difficulty arises here, whether the words, "to him", are to be referred to Christ, or to John; no doubt but the opening of the heavens was seen by them both: but to me it seems that John is particularly designed, since this vision was upon his account, and for his sake, and to him the following words belong; "and he", that is, John, saw the Spirit of God descending like a dove, and lighting upon him: for this is what was promised to John, as a sign, which should confirm his faith in Jesus, as the true Messiah, and which he himself says he saw, and upon which he based the record and testimony he bore to Christ, as the Son of God; see Joh 1:32 not but that the descent of the Holy Ghost in this manner might be seen by Christ, as well as John, according to Mar 1:10. The Spirit of God, here said to descend and light on Christ, is the same, which in the first creation moved upon the face of the waters; and now comes down on Christ, just as he was coming up out of the waters of Jordan, where he had been baptized; and which the Jews (r) so often call , "the Spirit of the king Messiah, and the spirit of the Messiah". The descent of him was in a "bodily shape", as Luke says in Luk 3:22 either in the shape of a dove, which is a very fit emblem of the Spirit of God who descended, and the fruits thereof, such as simplicity, meekness, love, &c. and also of the dove-like innocence, humility, and affection of Christ, on whom he lighted; or it was in some other visible form, not expressed, which pretty much resembled the hovering and lighting of a dove upon anything: for it does not necessarily follow from any of the accounts the Evangelists give of this matter, that the holy Spirit assumed, or appeared in, the form of a dove; only that his visible descent and lighting on Christ was , as a dove descends, hovers and lights; which does not necessarily design the form of the creature, but the manner of its motion. However, who can read this account without thinking of Noah's dove, which brought in its mouth the olive leaf, a token of peace and reconciliation, when the waters were abated from off the earth? Give me leave to transcribe a passage I have met with in the book of Zohar (s); "a door shall be opened, and out of it shall come forth the dove which Noah sent out in the days of the flood, as it is written, "and he sent forth the dove", that famous dove; but the ancients speak not of it, for they knew not what it was, only from whence it came, and did its message; as it is written, "it returned not again unto him any more": no man knows whither it went, but it returned to its place, and was hid within this door; and it shall take a crown in its mouth, and put it upon the head of the king Messiah.'' And a little after, the dove is said to abide upon his head, and he to receive glory from it. Whether this is the remains of some ancient tradition, these men studiously conceal, concerning the opening of the heavens, and the descent of the Spirit of God, as a dove, upon the Messiah; or whether it is hammered out of the evangelic history, let the reader judge. (r) Bereshit Rabba, fol. 2. 4. & 6. 3. Vajikra Rabba, fol. 156. 4. Zohar in Gen. fol. 107. 3. & 128. 3. Baal Hatturim in Gen. i. 2. Caphtor Uperah, fol. 113. 2. (s) In Num. fol. 68. 3, 4.”
Source
1849
A.D.
1774–1849
“He . . . went up, &c. Christ was in the river when he was baptized. As soon as he went out, and was praying, says St. Luke, (iii. 21,) the heavens were opened to him, or in favour of him; and he saw the Spirit of God descending: i.e. Christ himself saw the shape of the dove, which was also seen by the Baptist, as we find, John i. 33. And it was perhaps seen by all that were present. — As a dove, or like a dove in a bodily shape. The dove was an emblem of Christ’s meekness and innocence. (Witham) — Calmet supposes that it was St. John that saw the Spirit of God descend thus upon Jesus Christ. The Greek text is favourable to this interpretation. But the Vulgate supposes it was Jesus Christ himself. St. John declares that he saw the Spirit; (John i. 32,) but this apparent disagreement is easily cleared, by supposing that both saw the shape of the dove, and also the surrounding crowd, and that they all heard the voice of the Father, as it was heard by the disciples in the transfiguration on Mount Thabor, (chap. xvii,) and by the crowd in the temple. John xii. (Tirinus)”
Source
1863
A.D.
“It is generally thought that the Holy Spirit assumed the shape of a dove, although some explain it of His descent on our Lord in some sen- sible way, as if a dove descended, since her manner is peculiar.”
1871
A.D.
1871
“And Jesus when he was baptized, went up straightway out of the water--rather, "from the water." Mark has "out of the water" (Mar 1:10). "and"--adds Luke (Luk 3:21), "while He was praying"; a grand piece of information. Can there be a doubt about the burden of that prayer; a prayer sent up, probably, while yet in the water--His blessed head suffused with the baptismal element; a prayer continued likely as He stepped out of the stream, and again stood upon the dry ground; the work before Him, the needed and expected Spirit to rest upon Him for it, and the glory He would then put upon the Father that sent Him--would not these fill His breast, and find silent vent in such form as this?--"Lo, I come; I delight to do Thy will, O God. Father, glorify Thy name. Show Me a token for good. Let the Spirit of the Lord God come upon Me, and I will preach the Gospel to the poor, and heal the broken-hearted, and send forth judgment unto victory." While He was yet speaking-- lo, the heavens were opened--Mark says, sublimely, "He saw the heavens cleaving" (Mar 1:10). and he saw the Spirit of God descending--that is, He only, with the exception of His honored servant, as he tells us himself (Joh 1:32-34); the by-standers apparently seeing nothing. like a dove, and lighting upon him--Luke says, "in a bodily shape" (Luk 3:22); that is, the blessed Spirit, assuming the corporeal form of a dove, descended thus upon His sacred head. But why in this form? The Scripture use of this emblem will be our best guide here. "My dove, my undefiled is one," says the Song of Solomon (Sol 6:9). This is chaste purity. Again, "Be ye harmless as doves," says Christ Himself (Mat 10:16). This is the same thing, in the form of inoffensiveness towards men. "A conscience void of offense toward God and toward men" (Act 24:16) expresses both. Further, when we read in the Song of Solomon (Sol 2:14), "O my dove, that art in the clefts of the rocks, in the secret places of the stairs (see Isa 60:8), let me see thy countenance, let me hear thy voice; for sweet is thy voice, and thy countenance is comely"--it is shrinking modesty, meekness, gentleness, that is thus charmingly depicted. In a word--not to allude to the historical emblem of the dove that flew back to the ark, bearing in its mouth the olive leaf of peace (Gen 8:11) --when we read (Psa 68:13), "Ye shall be as the wings of a dove covered with silver, and her feathers with yellow gold," it is beauteousness that is thus held forth. And was not such that "holy, harmless, undefiled One," the "separate from sinners?" "Thou art fairer than the children of men; grace is poured into Thy lips; therefore God hath blessed Thee for ever!" But the fourth Gospel gives us one more piece of information here, on the authority of one who saw and testified of it: "John bare record, saying, I saw the Spirit descending from heaven like a dove, and IT ABODE UPON HIM." And lest we should think that this was an accidental thing, he adds that this last particular was expressly given him as part of the sign by which he was to recognize and identify Him as the Son of God: "And I knew Him not: but He that sent me to baptize with water, the same said unto me, Upon whom thou shalt see the Spirit descending AND REMAINING ON HIM, the same is He which baptizeth with the Holy Ghost. And I saw and bare record that this is the Son of God" (Joh 1:32-34). And when with this we compare the predicted descent of the Spirit upon Messiah (Isa 11:2), "And the Spirit of the Lord shall rest upon Him," we cannot doubt that it was this permanent and perfect resting of the Holy Ghost upon the Son of God--now and henceforward in His official capacity--that was here visibly manifested.”
Source

Undated

date unknown
date
unknown
“This action of Christ’s has a figurative meaning pertaining to all who were after Him to be baptized; and therefore he says, straightway He ascended, and not simply He ascended, for all who are worthily baptized in Christ, straightway ascend from the water; that is, make progress in virtues, and are carried on towards a heavenly dignity. They who had gone down to the water carnal and sinful sons of Adam, straightway ascend from the water spiritual sons of God. But if some by their own faults make no progress after baptism, what is that to the baptism?”
Source
“For had the actual creation of the heavens been opened, he would not have said were opened to Him, for a physical opening would have been open to all. But some one will say, What, are the heavens then closed to the eye of the Son of God, who even when on earth is present in heaven? But it must be known, that as He was baptized according to the ordinance of humanity that He had taken on Him, so the heavens were opened to His sight as to His human nature, though as to His divine He was in heaven.”
Source
“Perhaps there were before some unseen obstacles which hindered the souls of the dead from entering the skies. I suppose that since Adam’s sin no soul had mounted the skies, but the heavens were continually closed. When, lo! on Christ’s baptism they were again opened; after He had overcome by the Cross the great tyrant death, henceforward the heaven, never more to be closed, needed not gates, so that the Angels say not, ‘Open ye gates,’ for they were open, but take away the gates. (Ps. 24:7.) Or the heavens are opened to the baptized, and they see those things which are in heaven, not by seeing them with the bodily eye, but by believing with the spiritual eye of faith. Or thus; The heavens are the divine Scriptures, which all read but all do not understand, except they who have been so baptized as to receive the Holy Spirit. Thus the Scriptures of the Prophets were at the first sealed to the Apostles, but after they had received the Holy Spirit, all Scripture was opened to them. However, in whatever way we interpret, the heavens were opened to Him, that is to all, on His account; as if the Emperor were to say to any one preferring a petition for another, This boon I grant not to him but to you; that is, to him, for your sake.”
Source
date
unknown
Glossa Ordinaria Medieval
“(non occ.) Or, so bright a glory shone round about Christ, that the blue concave seemed to be actually cloven.”
date
unknown
“The Holy Ghost took the likeness of a dove, as being more than other animals susceptible of love. All other forms of righteousness which the servants of God have in truth and verity, the servants of the Devil have in spurious imitation; the love of the Holy Spirit alone an unclean spirit cannot imitate. And the Holy Ghost has therefore reserved to Himself this special manifestation of love, because by no testimony is it so clearly seen where He dwells as by the grace of love.”
Source
Modern · 1953 →

The in-app commentary runs from the Fathers to the early-modern record, then stops — that's where the public-domain sources end, not where the reading does. For the modern reading, follow the sources directly.