But avoid foolish questions, and genealogies, and contentions, and strivings about the law. For they are unprofitable and vain.

“Unhappy Aristotle! who invented for these men dialectics, the art of building up and pulling down; an art so evasive in its propositions, so far-fetched in its conjectures, so harsh, in its arguments, so productive of contentions-embarrassing even to itself, retracting everything, and really treating of nothing! Whence spring those "fables and endless genealogies," and "unprofitable questions," and "words which spread like a cancer? " From all these, when the apostle would restrain us, he expressly names philosophy as that which he would have us be on our guard against.”

“Blessed is that servant [Paul] who can say: "I have fed you with milk and not with meat; for until now you were not able to bear it." … Yet he—being so great a man and chosen by Christ for the care of his flock in order to strengthen the weak and to heal the sick—rejects immediately after a single admonition a heretic from the fold entrusted to him. This he does for fear that the taint of one erring sheep might infect the whole flock with a spreading sore. He further bids that foolish questions and contentions be avoided.”

“"But avoid foolish questions, and genealogies, and contentions, and strivings about the law, for they are unprofitable and vain." What do these "genealogies" mean? For in his Epistle to Timothy he mentions "fables and endless genealogies." (1 Tim. i. 4.) Perhaps both here and there glancing at the Jews, who, priding themselves on having Abraham for their forefather, neglected their own part. On this account he calls them both "foolish and unprofitable"; for it is the part of folly to confide in things unprofitable. "Contentions," he means, with heretics, in which he would not have us labor to no purpose, where nothing is to be gained, for they end in nothing. For when a man is perverted and predetermined not to change his mind, whatever may happen, why shouldest thou labor in vain, sowing upon a rock, when thou shouldest spend thy honorable toil upon thy own people, in discoursing with them upon almsgiving and every other virtue?”

“Above, the Apostle taught Titus what things he should propose for the instruction of the people; now he shows what he should avoid in teaching. And first he does this; second he writes certain personal matters, at the point 'when I shall send.' Likewise the first part is divided into two: first he shows how he should avoid useless and foreign doctrines; second, how he should avoid heretics, at 'a heretic.' Concerning the first he does two things: first he shows what is to be avoided in his teaching; second he assigns the reason, at 'for they are.' Now it must be noted concerning the first that it belongs to one who professes the teaching of some science, first, to satisfy the questions that are raised within it; second, to treat certain things of himself; third, to dispute with those who resist; and fourth, to teach what is to be avoided concerning it. But in other sciences no wise man answers just any question, but only those that pertain to his own science. So the teacher of the truth ought not to answer just any question. For folly is opposed to wisdom. But this teaching is a teaching of wisdom. Deut. 4:6: "for this is your wisdom and understanding in the sight of the peoples." Therefore he says 'foolish questions.' Questions, therefore, that are opposed to the intentions of this teaching, are foolish. Now those things are opposed to it which are undisciplinable. Job 34:35: "But Job has spoken foolishly, and his words do not sound of discipline." Likewise when something manifest is proposed as doubtful, namely whatever anyone ought to hold of himself in the science. And these are the things that pertain to the instruction of the faith and the education of morals. And there are certain things that he ought to avoid. Hence he says 'genealogies.' For genealogies are set down in the Scriptures on account of mysteries, and on account of the historical understanding. In resisting those who attack, he ought to avoid 'contentions and fights.' For when there is disputation for the inquiry of the truth, it is praiseworthy; but when there is contention for the purpose of showing what is to be held and what is to be avoided, such are to be avoided. Prov. 20:3: "It is an honor for a man to separate himself from contentions." II Tim. 2:14: "Do not contend with words." The 'fights of the law' are those which arise not from a fault of the disputants, but which arise from a contrariety in Scripture, or from contrary reasons. But are such things always to be avoided? It must be said: in sacred Scripture, according to truth, nothing is contrary. But if something appears contrary, either it is because it is not understood, or because they have been corrupted by the fault of the scribes, which is especially evident in numbers and genealogies. And therefore these things, because they cannot be determined, he wishes to be avoided. And this for the reason that they are 'useless.' And a teacher ought to attend to two things, namely to usefulness, and to truth. Prov. 8:7: "My throat shall meditate truth," etc. Isaiah 48:17: "I am the Lord your God, teaching you useful things." One ought not, therefore, to meddle with useless things, and things that do not have solid truth. For to know particulars, such as genealogies are, is not for the perfection of the intellect, nor for the instruction of morals, nor of faith. And they are 'vain,' because they do not have solid truth. Then when he says 'a heretic,' he shows who among men are to be avoided; and first he shows that heretics [are to be avoided]; second he shows the reason for this, at 'knowing that.' He says, therefore, 'a heretical man.' Where it must be noted what makes one to be a heretic, and the first meaning of this name 'heretic' must be taken. For it is not said from division, but from choice, as Jerome says; for in Greek 'haeresis' means 'choice.' Hence 'heretic,' that is, 'one who chooses,' as it were pertinaciously adhering to some sect which he has chosen. Hence it must be known that every heretic is one who errs, and not the converse, for two reasons. First on the part of the matter concerning which he errs, for instance if it is not concerning the end of human life, or concerning that which pertains to the faith and good morals. For one so erring is not a heretic. But if he should err concerning those things that are for the end of human life, he is always a heretic. And I say 'the end of human life,' because among the ancients there were sects positing a different end, as is evident concerning the Stoics and the Epicureans. Or concerning the faith; and thus if someone should say that God is not triune and one, and that fornication is not a sin, he is a heretic. Second on the part of the choosing, because one who chooses, if he is not obstinate, but is ready to be corrected according to the determination of the Church, and thus [errs] not from malice, but from ignorance, is not a heretic. Him, therefore, 'avoid,' on account of danger. II Tim. 2:17: "Their speech creeps like a cancer." Likewise let no one share in their sins, lest he seem to consent to them. II John, the only chapter: "If anyone comes to you and does not bring this teaching," etc. Likewise on account of punishment. Num. 16:26: "Depart from the tents of these wicked men, and touch nothing that belongs to them," etc. Yet he wishes that he be admonished, and if he does not desist, then he is a heretic and to be avoided. And he says 'after the first and second reproof.' For thus it is done in the Church in excommunications. And the reason is that the number of every thing has a beginning, a middle, and an end. Therefore it is taken as sufficient for all things. II Cor., last chapter, v. 1: "Behold, this is now the third time I am coming to you," etc. Likewise on account of the perfection of the number three. But the reason for the avoidance is that one must deal with the one erring from the beginning, so that he may be corrected. Matt. 9:12: "Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick." And therefore he is not to be given up until it is seen whether he can be cured; but if he cannot be healed, then he is to be given up. Luke 19:22: "Out of your own mouth I judge you, wicked servant." Then when he says 'when I shall send,' he writes certain personal matters. And first certain things to be arranged concerning him; second he ends the epistle with a greeting. He says, therefore, 'when I shall send,' etc. These two were disciples of the Apostle. He sent others because he wanted Titus to come to him, and he does not fix a time for him, but a place; for he had need of him for the help of preaching. Yet he wished Artemas to be sent ahead, and he shows what he arranges concerning them; second he answers an objection, at 'and let ours also learn.' This Apollo, of whom Acts 19:1 speaks, was bishop of the Corinthians, on account of whose fault he left them, and went to Crete to Titus, but, the Corinthians having been corrected, the Apostle recalls him. But he calls Zenas a lawyer, although Apollo also was very learned, because he had this dignity in Judaism. But the reason why he wishes these to be sent ahead, and not Titus, is that Titus was necessary at Crete on account of the episcopate, but these did not have any charge. And he says 'that nothing may be lacking to them,' as if he were to say: if you do not have it, let your subjects provide it. And therefore he adds thus: 'let ours also learn,' namely the faithful, to provide, just as the Jews do. And he says 'ours,' namely his subjects, let them learn to excel the Jews, and others from Asia, who provide for their preachers and for those in need. And he says 'for necessary uses,' that is, in cases of necessity. I Tim. 6:8: "Having food, and that with which we may be covered, let us be content with these." But the reason why they preside is that they may not be unfruitful. I Cor. 9:7: "Who plants a vineyard, and does not eat of its fruit?" etc. The people, therefore, if they are like the vineyard of the Lord, ought to bear fruit, not only spiritual, but also temporal, so that from it the cultivators may be sustained; otherwise they would be unfruitful. Matt. 7:19: "Every tree that does not make good fruit will be cut down." Then he greets them, first on the part of others; second he asks that they greet others; third he sets down his own. As to the first he says 'they greet,' etc., that is, they wish them well. Second he says, 'Greet those who love us in the faith,' being Christ's, because there is no agreement of the faithful with the unfaithful. II Paralipomenon 19:2: "You give help to the impious, and you are joined in friendship to those who hate the Lord." Or 'who love us in faith,' that is, with a faithful affection. Ecclesiasticus 6:15: "There is no comparison to a faithful friend." 'The grace of God,' namely which is the principle of all goods. Rom. 3:24: "Justified freely through his grace." And he says 'to you,' because he does not write to one for his usefulness alone, but for the whole Church. Thanks be to God.”

“Here is the fifth and last thing in the matter of the epistle: what Titus should avoid in teaching; how he should deal with a heretic; with some other directions. Observe, I. That the apostle's meaning might be more clear and full, and especially fitted to the time and state of things in Crete, and the many judaizers among them, he tells Titus what, in teaching, he should shun, Tit 3:9. There are needful questions to be discussed and cleared, such as make for improvement in useful knowledge; but idle and foolish enquiries, tending neither to God's glory nor the edification of men, must be shunned. Some may have a show of wisdom, but are vain, as many among the Jewish doctors, as well as of later schoolmen, who abound with questions of no moment or use to faith or practice; avoid these. - And genealogies (of the gods, say some, that the heathen poets made such noise about; or rather those that the Jews were so curious in): some lawful and useful enquiries might be made into these things, to see the fulfilling of the scriptures in some cases, and especially in the descent of Christ the Messiah; but all that served to pomp only, and to feed vanity, in boasting of a long pedigree, and much more such as the Jewish teachers were ready to busy themselves in and trouble their hearers with, even since Christ had come, and that distinction of families and tribes had been taken away, as if they would build again that policy which now is abolished, these Titus must withstand as foolish and vain. - And contentious, and strivings about the law. There were those who were for the Mosaic rites and ceremonies, and would have them continued in the church, though by the gospel and the coming of Christ they were superseded and done away. Titus must give no countenance to these, but avoid and oppose them; for they are unprofitable and vain: this is to be referred to all those foolish questions and genealogies, as well as those strivings about the law. They are so far from instructing and building up in godliness, that they are hindrances of it rather: the Christian religion, and good works, which are to be maintained, will hereby be weakened and prejudiced, the peace of the church disturbed, and the progress of the gospel hindered. Observe, Ministers must not only teach things good and useful, but shun and oppose the contrary, what would corrupt the faith, and hinder godliness and good works; nor should people have itching ears, but love and embrace sound doctrine, which tends most to the use of edifying. II. But because, after all, there will be heresies and heretics in the church, the apostle next directs Titus what to do in such a case, and how to deal with such, Tit 3:10. He who forsakes the truth as it is in Christ Jesus, who broaches false doctrines and propagates them to the corrupting of the faith in weighty and momentous points, and breaks the peace of the church about them, after due means used to reclaim him, must be rejected. "Admonish him once and again, that, if possible, he may be brought back, and thou mayest gain thy brother; but, if this will not reduce him, that others be not hurt, cast him out of the communion, and warn all Christians to avoid him." - Knowing that he that is such is subverted (turned off from the foundation) and sinneth grievously, being self-condemned. Those who will not be reclaimed by admonitions, but are obstinate in their sins and errors, are subverted and self-condemned; they inflict that punishment upon themselves which the governors of the church should inflict upon them: they throw themselves out of the church, and throw off its communion, and so are self-condemned. Observe, 1. How great an evil real heresy is, not lightly therefore to be charged upon any, though greatly to be taken heed of by all. Such a one is subverted or perverted - a metaphor from a building so ruined as to render it difficult if not impossible to repair and raise it up again. Real heretics have seldom been recovered to the true faith: not so much defect of judgment, as perverseness of the will, being in the case, through pride, or ambition, or self-willedness, or covetousness, or such like corruption, which therefore must be taken heed of: "Be humble, love the truth and practise it, and damning heresy will be escaped." 2. Pains and patience must be used about those that err most grievously. They are not easily and soon to be given up and cast off, but competent time and means must be tried for their recovery. 3. The church's means even with heretics are persuasive and rational. They must be admonished, instructed, and warned; so much nouthesia imports. 4. Upon continued obstinacy and irreclaimableness, the church has power, and is obliged, to preserve its own purity, by severing such a corrupt member which discipline may by God's blessing become effectual to reform the offender, or if not it will leave him the more inexcusable in his condemnation. III. The apostle subjoins some further directions, Tit 3:12, Tit 3:13. Here are two personal things enjoined: - 1. That Titus should hold himself ready to come to Paul at Nicopolis (a city of Thrace, as is reckoned, on the borders of Macedonia), as soon as Artemas or Tychicus should be sent to Crete, to supply his place, and take care of the churches there when he should leave them. The apostle would not have them in their young and weak state be without one or other of chief sufficiency, to guide and help them. Titus, it seems, was not their ordinary fixed bishop or pastor, but an evangelist, otherwise Paul would not have called him so much from his charge. Of Artemas we read little, but Tychicus is mentioned on many occasions with respect. Paul calls him a beloved brother, and faithful minister, and fellow-servant in the Lord: one fit therefore for the service intimated. When Paul says to Titus, Be diligent to come to me to Nicopolis, for I have determined there to winter, it is plain that the epistle was not written from Nicopolis, as the postcript would have it, for then he would have said, I determined here, not there, to winter. 2. The other personal charge to Titus is that he would bring two of his friends on their journey diligently, and see them furnished, so that nothing should be wanting to them. This was to be done, not as a piece of common civility only, but of Christian piety, out of respect both to them and the work they were sent about, which probably was to preach the gospel, or to be in some way serviceable to the churches. Zenas is styled the lawyer, whether in reference to the Roman or the Mosaic law, as having some time been his profession, is doubtful. Apollos was an eminent and faithful minister. Accompanying such persons part of their way, and accommodating them for their work and journeys, was a pious and needful service; and to further this, and lay in for it, what the apostle had before exhorted Titus to teach (Tit 3:8) he repeats here: Let ours also learn to maintain good works for necessary uses, that they be not unfruitful, Tit 3:14. Let Christians, those who have believed in God, learn to maintain good works, especially such as these, supporting ministers in their work of preaching and spreading the gospel, hereby becoming fellow-helpers to the truth, Jo3 1:5-8. That they be not unfruitful. Christianity is not a fruitless profession; the professors of it must be filled with the fruits of righteousness, which are by Jesus Christ, to the glory and praise of God. It is not enough that they be harmless, but they must be profitable, doing good, as well as eschewing evil. - "Let ours set up and maintain some honest labour and employment, to provide for themselves and their families, that they be not unprofitable burdens on the earth;" so some understand it. Let them not think that Christianity gives them a writ of ease; no, it lays an obligation upon them to seek some honest work and calling, and therein to abide with God. This is of good report, will credit religion and be good to mankind; they will not be unprofitable members of the body, not burdensome and chargeable to others, but enabled to be helpful to those in want. To maintain good works for necessary uses; not living like drones on the labours of others, but themselves fruitful to the common benefit. IV. The apostle concludes with salutations and benedictions, Tit 3:5. Though perhaps not personally known (some of them at least), yet all by Paul testify their love and good wishes to Titus, owning him thereby in his work, and stimulating him to go on therein. Great comfort and encouragement it is to have the heart and prayers of other Christians with and for us. Greet those that love us in the faith, or for the faith, who are our loving fellow-christians. Holiness, or the image of God in any, is the great endearing thing that gives strength to all other bonds, and is itself the best. Grace be with you all. Amen. This is the closing benediction, not to Titus alone, but to all the faithful with him, which shows that though the epistle bears the single name of Titus in the inscription, yet it was for the use of the churches there, and they were in the eye, and upon the heart, of the apostle, in the writing of it. "Grace be with you all, the love and favour of God, with the fruits and effects thereof, according to need, spiritual ones especially, and the increase and feeling of them more and more in your souls." This is the apostle's wish and prayer, showing his affection to them, his desire of their good, and a means of obtaining for them, and bringing down upon them, the thing requested. Observe, Grace is the chief thing to be wished and begged for, with respect to ourselves or others; it is, summarily, all good. Amen shuts up the prayer, expressing desire and hope, that so it may, and so it shall be.”

“But avoid foolish questions,.... Such as were started in the schools of the Jews; see Ti2 2:23 and genealogies; of their elders, Rabbins, and doctors, by whom their traditions are handed down from one to another, in fixing which they greatly laboured; see Ti1 1:4 and contentions and strivings about the law; the rites and ceremonies of it, and about the sense of it, and its various precepts, as litigated in the schools of Hillell and Shammai, the one giving it one way, and the other another; and what one declared to be free according to the law, the other declared forbidden; which occasioned great contentions and quarrels between the followers of the one, and of the other, as both the Misna and Talmud show: and agreeably to this sense, the Syriac version renders it, "the contentions and strifes of the scribes"; the Jewish doctors, who were some on the side of Hillell, and others on the side of Shammai; as well as went into parties and strifes among themselves, and oftentimes about mere trifles; things of no manner of importance; wherefore it follows, for they are unprofitable and vain; empty things, of no manner of use, to inform the judgment, improve the mind, or influence the life and conversation.”

“Avoid foolish questions, and genealogies - In these the Jews particularly delighted; they abounded in the most frivolous questions; and, as they had little piety themselves, they were solicitous to show that they had descended from godly ancestors. Of their frivolous questions, and the answers given to them by the wisest and most reputable of their rabbins, the following is a specimen: - Rabbi Hillel was asked: Why have the Babylonians round heads? To which he answered: This is a difficult question, but I will tell the reason: Their heads are round because they have but little wit. Q. Why are the eyes of the Tarmudians so soft? A. Because they inhabit a sandy country. Q. Why have the Africans broad feet? A. Because they inhabit a marshy country. See more in Schoettgen. But ridiculous and trifling as these are, they are little in comparison to those solemnly proposed and most gravely answered by those who are called the schoolmen. Here is a specimen, which I leave the reader to translate: - Utrum essent excrementa in Paradiso? Utrum sancti resurgent cum intestinis? Utrum, si deipara fuisset vir, potuisset esse naturalis parens Christi? These, with many thousands of others, of equal use to religion and common sense, may be found in their writings. See the Summa of Thomas Aquinas, passim. Might not the Spirit have these religious triflers in view, rather than the less ridiculous Jews? See the notes on Ti1 1:4; Ti2 2:23 (note). Contentions, and strivings about the law - Of legal contentions, and different and conflicting decisions about the meaning of particular rites and ceremonies, the Talmud is full.”

“avoid--stand aloof from. Same Greek, as in Ti2 2:16; see on Ti2 2:16. foolish--Greek, "insipid"; producing no moral fruit. "Vain talkers." genealogies--akin to the "fables" (see on Ti1 1:4). Not so much direct heresy as yet is here referred to, as profitless discussions about genealogies of aeons, &c., which ultimately led to Gnosticism. Synagogue discourses were termed daraschoth, that is, "discussions." Compare "disputer of this world (Greek, 'dispensation')." strivings about the law--about the authority of the "commandments of men," which they sought to confirm by the law (Tit 1:14; see on Ti1 1:7), and about the mystical meaning of the various parts of the law in connection with the "genealogies."”